ML20199G939

Discusses Aspects of Facility Reactor Operator Requalification Program That Will Be Examined During Wk of 840213.Supporting Documentation Encl

ML20199G939
Person / Time
Site:	Trojan File:Portland General Electric icon.png
Issue date:	02/10/1984
From:	Andrea Johnson NRC OFFICE OF INSPECTION & ENFORCEMENT (IE REGION V)
To:	Faulkenberry B NRC OFFICE OF INSPECTION & ENFORCEMENT (IE REGION V)
Shared Package
ML20151H981	List: IA-84-656, Advises That Util Identified Individual Who Had Notes Available to Him During Recent Requalification Exam.Requests Ofc of Investigation Participation in Review of Situation ML20151H979 ML20151H993 ML20151J018 ML20151K296 ML20151K372 ML20199G784 ML20199G819 ML20199G847 ML20199G854 ML20199G870 ML20199G895 ML20199G911 ML20199G939 ML20199H011 ML20199H028 ML20199H058 ML20199H089 ML20199H096 ML20199H119 ML20199H132 ML20199H235 ML20199H249 ML20199H258 ML20199K451
References
FOIA-84-656 NUDOCS 8604090272
Download: ML20199G939 (9)

Text

,

g, [)Af [Lv

' [, %o, UNITED STATES y ,.(

g NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION

e '

l REGloN V 0, 4 1450 MARIA L ANE, SulTE 210

% *4/ ,[ WALNUT CREEK, CALIFORNIA 945%

, . FEB 101984 MEMORANDUM FOR: B. H. Faulkenberry, Deputy Regional Administrator FROM: A. D. Johnson, Enforcement Officer

SUBJECT:

TROJAN REQUALIFICATION PROGRAM I intend to examine the following aspects of the Trojan reactor operator requalification program during the week of February 13, 1984.

1. Examine the Trojan Reactor Operator Training, Testing and Requalification Program for compliance with 10 CFR 55 Appendix A, the NRC approved requalification program, and good operating practices,

a. Schedul'es

b. Lectures - The Training Aids - Lesson Plans

c. On-The-Job-Training

d. Evaluations

e. Records ,

f. Alternate Training Programs i

2. Examine qualifications of instructors over the past three years.

a. Education

b. Experience

c. Licenses

3. Examine the process for development of written examinations and all examinations given over the past three years.

a. Source of Question

b. Topic Areas

c. Control of Exam Questions

d. Number of Questions in Bank

e. Potential Conflict of Interests Between Trainer and Test Writer

f. Availability and Use of Answer Keys i

g. Control of Answer Keys

i. Standardization and Control of Level of Difficulty of Questions and Subsequent Grading .

4. Examine procedures and process for administering written examinations.

l.-

a. Number of Proctors

b. Instructions to Proctors

c. Instructions to Operator Candidates N

8604090272 860213 PDR FOIA -

BELL 844-656 PDR ~

[L

FEB 1o n;4

5. Management Audit and Involvement in Program.

a. Management Oversight ,

b. Management

• Attendance at Lectures and Exams

c. Management Review of Exams and Individual Results

d. Management Commitment (1) Funding (2) Staffing (3) Physical Facilities (4) Writt.n Policy Statements Basic information regarding the above will be available for discussion at the SALP meeting on February 17, 1984. Subsequent to this meeting, a final inspection will be prepared.

I A. D. Johp' son n ad Enforcemd t Officer

/

cc: L. Miller v' e

~

q l

CONVERSATION $ CORD )"fyg,(f*'d' /

O visit O CONFERENCE W HONE p

@:#NK1 MING h Locat;on of Visit / Conference:

NAM C PERSONIS) CONTACTED OR IN CONTACT joRGANIZATION (OMice. dept bureau.

O OUTGOING TELEPNONE NO:

[g '~

h #

/d f su b fb h /f fl -

• *"?

7'r,h s, : As i 4'm -Edi/ h,iu $pg

, - wv - - jr ,

nym hk/JAs k/k1 n hb . .

A "

is>7 A h/W '

A ~

'~

WAAM -

//~ f {

ll{IIIT k

g. vw <- v

.bk/

c -

3 /$ T s/ A/>r YYJ1 M i r L ~

• D A>,-, A/2~An, +

d' ^ + 2 2 o' JAM ' ~

LiiM w A MU Y b /T a ,M2,s Af,e,/,N M m W & -

i I

ACTION REQUIRED

['

M y /p (Nh5$584-009,>

y NAME OF PERSON CUMENTING CONVERSATION SIGNATURE bJ ACTION tap

/ds'a/ /b E '

/

d 1/W21 '

[ '

SIGNATURE TITLE DATE 5o272-201 e so i sus o - mi-s2s cnm CONVERSATION RECORD $80,NAL ORW 2 cp jg)

.A g- l e s L . J

G i

. - _.. f u ru V- 0 /AP ~'C _ A r_.-. Y. to,1A f -

UA . . _ & eh$# W k 4--ll Anal _Yjr u re.facsr!an. ..cxys Am. 'i.) .- /3- .apturou on__)ds-2,_I179 ._ . _ . _ . - . . - - -

bL - th E d 4, Aff o se opmr.se Te .,,>_E. B b s x s _ _ /]p .rrs o

- - - n_cm,..a_ u s>>,,, _

d) - . h,4 4-m Q, J 9$'{ 0 D To f& .h/_( O i es c_o on d o'

})_ Dw_fla 9, nts ~Pd is s> <o + i ,, r,.re,_c.>.,I.c r> _ 2 _ N 7

we u Ja -tu.tL._._DJT__Aso dLL_0;voras l<s n ~'

. - . -- - e') . 0 L . M c's f ,. D E y hejueoe &_07- ?eter.cq4ra-,. fua .AJ -fa._.--__

._ Slus,uern . m .0T_ via.nu. -.- .- ----.-- .---- - - --

. . . -.- 0 On El+ -fa ifN hV 6< hem ..% *t e L.y . L / v . All& So,. bwun i ELb_b L.ebu, ..,4 She_%s, y Pages _ G . % .. ( 0 1-)..tey e 1 H- c e n cu rw.n . o !- Dee, s .r.,- _M ar._

n _.. y a c r.e.p s re , -__ .- .

+- 4 . w*ma- - -

e+=--hew eem - ee e em m. .sh. w -s -e m. --e- ,_ e e-ens . m >. .-9. * * **"

• es- - . -

• ene ww.m ew w- e. .. .e e ee m,e . emme . 4 ma 6 *- * *

• gm eeO. ee_e mum - ' -+ 6 D +- . -

• D e .

e a w M m e e e -e ew - Gm - geeh a e e *' -8 " " ' ' * * ' " "'

e 'n.- 6a e se m-e e e . eew. ..g - m ,4 ,, , 4  % emes si=* + 8 " * ^8 m -,w hw

• 4 en -- +- - em+ y a.. p

>m eaw wee 56e@ 6 $e esiw ee ,e e dem a- _ mg a , mmi .g. -g am . e 4m e . ese . + . e-.h 8' '""

J _ - - .. .- .. -- -- .- - - - -

- n b ),

. . .V . 4

" ~

J k g u sapu,pw 4.y 0 g

4 ,(,,d ,a cuadd g iuf J issa s./ cU k Y+

pa/& pG/m,J yvsJs ad % w i Q. n-rassa.s e - aa z ,- s , _ m ..- __

, w u s, is,elc e 4<J

'PeeE0 c t.__Gx sm. -. e r.0->,

}. Ecr_ -h -_0 J-c.t_

. A so_ _ma,, . ts e, Ts s.- s _,

tv.1-,__s. ao_

SCSisll b N? AS3s44 VA Ls D_.. .Et n ~ Res L6..

n)_fy,etusrc___o7ra4rve, ~yg,,.ag____'7ec4a.,,__{n

, insLu O e '. 'Tj?e__&._bej u *-~y_D F 14A -. -e_,._fa ** L.k1.ea 4su of . -, s +~c 4s n , rpe._s_Acs aus _ o e man.+s .. 3

--,-. , ,n

.-p _4__2 q o ,1. . et. ma 3 ,_ _>___p I.,.c , __ o_^

_i37

._ . . _ . . _ . . . . _ _ [u~, c.L am _ c re_._ __ _ _ _ _ _ ._._ _ __ _

J.) E~/A Lunsrl_ Teoc t.4 ~<_ _ D F_ ZYA m ., caw , s _. . I n e L- u. e_

- _ _ - . _. Rey u e Ldac ., ra s -,Evs --, s . _ ra _ sact u r>e : ..laoe._.c.y. -

. .. . _ . - .- . .- aest a s., -b A.s d s_ _ 4 ko ) exams A if. - 'ueo*C p c9 , - .

-- - _ _ . . . _ iloa. A u E es , ._..y ue> r s s __ Os.dratlao_ (p< e_e.sa.4 -

__ _ __.__ .p. 6.o ,

,3_._m.3c.__ h _~u.4c _ 4 .,ot,,L,, _ot 7, e , t3 .,,_

.. . _ _ _ _ - - . . v o e.}.,_jio u . sa. _.srs-3. c.uca.. sea _ -10 3o<<* -

_. ._ _( As t_soos _ c0,. ric t.s_ .igzte ,s.irso , e re .) , _ As s _ . -

. pie 7 W OS . f.s1 Play te ~T0 . C o-p of <t A.<s .s en .Ya ..

.. .- - .- . .._ _ -. . _ -._ -. - r. ra a-a. ._ b u _ f. a L..,< . ly_, e }c. ._, _ &&.srsif asp e

_. . - - .. - .. A .n,L .ua t _ os_sa ,esr.. s . o1 _,,,s ri croat . ,., so t ,a- z~r

-- . . . /M Cd/Ariks'.. ot, _ ms dane . tvs , . /es-Lh IOat. Caon.

. - _. - - . . . . . . . - . 3h . $UAL u.* TE .. . de AD.He . . J1x0_ .g'ys%s Resu L TS .. .. --

. . &J Al u4TLU-s__)lDC/35. . ~7's _ Jos cf.u D/_ :._ ffLl A4Su.) E y .

Affs__Ava.l.ts.LL..Axoban fr.>LlrJ_,__'Does A._ 3ugu Os.sor-.. -

__. ._.re.vnesa...d<mpL 1 ..Of ex,,-s n f,tss.u.* rs .

D

- '91)tDurt Acwu p t_'y H .c u L - Ao

- _e_

STA & 4 b.L3 ' r2 n -s,s.a

)

we--- - h w . h e w-**wer-=e auRh M r - __e. _ _---

6

+ - e-N -

.w w - h 9

-==- - .ee

._. . e_ es--- . e.- -

'=+4D a 6 -*M- +eup we- ,=-M-e*-w enen.w- -h*

• ee m== e ex m me en.w* , -we em w a w w +e w-+- m- >-=e'emp h" *****"''*'*'*" ***

=66 ** * '"* N meewge* . - . w w s mup-n-wem.m_m ,m new, .,gesp.m N ew "6 9

. mem , - e w - -- . .. e---e-- -e- ee.m-e = , _ _ , . ,_e . ,e

.. , _,, ,.,._e e . =me.- -e. . . e em es. .- - - *m se- * * * *

• e- e- h e-*.r --. . -.- m . e .m, , . , . --* em =*6- T' N h NN h - w- h **

e_ w we e pww h gmumm w ==Wem N N O e ---e,e---= ~ .. ee eme -e -e. e - - - ,. ,._e - .. _e _e _ ._,,_ _ _ .._,e- _ .e ,m ee.e _ e .---e .e. ., em e-====

• • h m-6hh-+-w-e--. h eO - . - . - --.a w.e- eh emp ==-ee e m - .m., .me,e., e e m eeemise-e aw m emum - ausea- - ei6- e*M'* N6 Damp - @ *ehee -h-eee ,o_ em . e e-+em e ..wsimpw espe--, ,,,,.. . r, ,, e *,.,, m- p. - ee- we -- e e === *" " '*

hw--m - -h** - =e=e - M em = ewe _ e >+- e es, mum e-w+ * **"

,,,, ,m. . _,ae w- , ,e e e em whenemim**- maximuum = .. m a e e. m-e.. mw. h-eh aem-+ eme,. " ""

..-- ,,. , , , e, e e m we -m . m h. eg== -* - - - **h me. N - *

• eus- awsun- W

--ee ==mmium-m== w e -e y .ee e- p .e- m aame- e e. *

• h e + y-,.,, -e ee e e%w-. gase e =wm . go w g s e on-a r y e o - -  % "*' *

• === = em - = e- ==ee -.--. + e-+ me - -.e- == e-- . e -w e- e e- = = w eu=- e * * *" * **~ ** " * * *

. -* -=mine w e .- ee-+ == m.*e ma

e. .: -e. .e.__ ee _.. - __ _ . .e. e. __ ..e-i L . e. er e . e .e _e_. = _. . _ . - _ e. __ -. 6. ._ e e - - -

+6 -h *e==uem mp -M w wm emumm> 6 h hemiemm eM &

=$ e w ,ai em .e en e em- e.e. -

M =em- . w e eme e== 4 me m usum "'sh h .m om ewe e * *

%e

g O

8, h M h,0 _, ,d% ...

- ERtm to-Lh -

)_00aenaus_. D -Of.1.< .an- a I -10 0.y ec -  ?CE -

to_ _.d.uk N fum nn MAav -

= ~

_Af h$Y *

• _ . / . .

k p d d M# >

h[k 8%ff 3W N 1

4,0 , ....---._

. g nA_AL,

- Lfdm mw -- -

e- 9*= m- = - - - -* we-se - ,-+ a., w w - ees. g,._,w w.,,,,,,,. .... , . . . _ ,, e =w+9**'

w. ,,, ._..gm, ,, _ --

em 6w -4 -e.y e O= mh w -e hm we ee .,m ,,e 4 .., ,, , , , ,, .,, __ e , , , e e-

"N w e- e e.e,e u W 6*@

h he **N*** * *'"N NNN 6- 3.m,w__. w . mun e-e= w .eM 6-ap.MM i

h

---

- *+ eme-= .=m--= .e = - .  % ..- . , , , .. . . . . . , , , . . m , -. .~4

& a r Wm. . g . ,se, . _ em, e p .,m,,. .,,,4 .m , ,, ,, , , . , , , , _ , _ , , ,,,,,

D

.e. e e .=m-*w ww w. - m .- w .w . . .,,,-e .,

w _, ,,. , ,_. , , , , .m , , , _ _ ,, , . . , . . O g

• ** + - - - a.6 6 mm== e. ese w - ese = w-m- e.gn e *- *@ m . -- 6 -- =

4e ae m& * - N - w * '

.w-- _.-- - . - . ...u ..,,,_ ...__ . ... _ ._ __ . . _, , 1 . _ , . . _ ..._

-; @- _ ._ .. _ . . . , _ . . __ _.,_ ._;. .h ;J _. -

• • • = m h

. _ ew e - *a==s-='" e - ~ ' ** * **""

• N h M eh -e -em d. e- p . @ & ,@. p w 6 N * *

• be

O 9

t 4

l e .. _ _ N m .

luie_.I - %.1_.imay,p'~~~ , _A ue.,, 't_.,,._Ath

((Lb.__ -. ~i'~doelei,~, ,

She bo dit - ~L_1eems_jka_To yaa -

h5- hue f5aase.,_0 we-._ SP w re-N 6 W *-

>e *- . _ , - ,_ .

w-=

• en's _e N *_e e.es mui 6 -* _e ---_ow _ wwwe -6.* NM*

• hM_ . __ ,# O . _. b _

M _.O)_8, _ eI *W E "*_ 00 - - . . . - -

OJ?._ CAv t/ /a swsr der iet JpLard._ . sis  ! n o !s

• b _ . .__ .. _ . _ _. . . -

.- .. . . - - i *t hl

• v . c M _ , C lC . - _. _. . _ . _ -. _ _ . . . _ _ _ - - -

.A *E W _ E_ C___ J.n A. __ - a 1 e i* * * . 'Tu TfM LA *tM -

._ - - .. - - _ - 1.cu,< oe_2 s w . .- _ _ _ _ ___--

,.c._

. .. _ - - Au a . w.w . g., pc, _at _ns . , . m ,__ _ o -u. ,_ .. _ _ _ _ .

b e v el ._ v k </_ _ c a.fA _ _ v. m l.cs.s.__o n d .ea {.y _ o t _ __ _ _ __ _

_.- _. ~3 e . -.3 _ ,~t et w .ck e. sper.).. . . - . . . _ . . _ ._ . .. . -

__ _ _ . _. - . . _L & r eepu tun _ ro __% e. .e-vue A a

- _ _ . - . . ... .. . .de t. 44.04. mm.L. . . . _ . _ . . . - - _

. _ . _ . & wQ . Qto act *&A -,:fras u no.s .'D.. _ g<tlic /02.] .

. ... . . ... ... . ._ - . . Aee p . _0-s.0,e v . e,e. . in k ,< W _ -Hre o 4 . . .- _ - . .

____ . . _,._._ __ _ __ _ __ u p & <d.o 1 3. c F__ _ ){ ._ _ . , _, _ _ _ __ . _ , _ _ . _ . _ _ .

0 S_ te4 9 _ ns ._o .__ C to m ac _ acr _ L_Quaan ._C n _.

. __.._ile.prosec=Teo. _ _ . _ ._. . _.. . _

~

I L i FJe s rure nea hunuiea, ac,ccown,Rv QF M407 7 03M- @kaL On kidad O M~. .s/n/rf kJk. 2/JJ 'q ($3-380)p ,. p 9

&: 3Ro,l bad 4 5 4 khsk. Lo,Uk Rui A LO fN$4 Hi? bb0$ S A

n lis(bh J~ un fleyk.(RV] #*

~ % W He s-e ygn ;., 6 +.}$ de Jdtf ~u aub he la w ! s k . h 3 , w .

~ %L% 4ht k ow sh wait <e d % L~ ~Lta.d LihM st Tr,3u. h ku reya fk %.16da a s ;~ dQG ,

~ L., cJ sam squcas ksaa tl k4b Lia nte J s. cua spha as NR.e A sdb km enpuuks wN b6 . N a LUN

,t Tn, ~

Of$

LI _

j- f7 G5-64-009-014 b