ML18347B180: Difference between revisions
StriderTol (talk | contribs) (Created page by program invented by StriderTol) |
StriderTol (talk | contribs) (StriderTol Bot change) |
||
(2 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown) | |||
Line 23: | Line 23: | ||
* Attached is Licensee Event Report 78-008 for the Palisades Plant as required by Technical Specification 6.9.2(a).2. | * Attached is Licensee Event Report 78-008 for the Palisades Plant as required by Technical Specification 6.9.2(a).2. | ||
David P Hoffman Assistant Nuclear Licensing Administrator CC: Director, Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation Director, Office of Inspection and Enforcement | David P Hoffman Assistant Nuclear Licensing Administrator CC: Director, Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation Director, Office of Inspection and Enforcement | ||
* Palisades NRCFORM366 U.S. NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION 17-771 LICENSEE EVENT REPORT CONTROL BLOCK: I IQ (PLEASE PRINT OR TYPE ALL REQUIRED INFORMATION) 1 6 | |||
* Palisades | |||
[ilI] I MI r I P I AI L I i l@I o I oI o I o Io I o lo I o 101OIOIG)l411l1l1l 1l©I 7 8 9 LICENSEE CODE 14 ,5 LICENSE NUMBER 25 26 . LICENSE TYPE 30 I | [ilI] I MI r I P I AI L I i l@I o I oI o I o Io I o lo I o 101OIOIG)l411l1l1l 1l©I 7 8 9 LICENSEE CODE 14 ,5 LICENSE NUMBER 25 26 . LICENSE TYPE 30 I | ||
57 CAT 58 10 CON'T | 57 CAT 58 10 CON'T | ||
Line 33: | Line 31: | ||
DOCKET NUMBER 6B 69 EVENT DATE 74 75 REPORT DATE 80 EVENT DESCRIPTION ANO PROBABLE CONSEQUENCES@ | DOCKET NUMBER 6B 69 EVENT DATE 74 75 REPORT DATE 80 EVENT DESCRIPTION ANO PROBABLE CONSEQUENCES@ | ||
1 | 1 | ||
( | ()))) I Reanalysis of the cycle 2 core axial power distribution has shown that | ||
(]J:!] I the power distribution limits of TS 3.10.3 were exceeded by approximately | (]J:!] I the power distribution limits of TS 3.10.3 were exceeded by approximately | ||
[]JI] I 12 percent for steady state operation during Clcle 2. The limits were | []JI] I 12 percent for steady state operation during Clcle 2. The limits were | ||
[ | [)))) I exceeded only in the upper portion of the core. This condition was dis-III)) covered through the use of an improved incore. analysis (INCA) computer ITlI] code. | ||
[]: | []:))] | ||
1 a g so SYSTEM CAUSE CAUSE COMP. VALVE CODE CODE SUBCOOE COMPONENT CODE SUSCODE SUBCODE | 1 a g so SYSTEM CAUSE CAUSE COMP. VALVE CODE CODE SUBCOOE COMPONENT CODE SUSCODE SUBCODE | ||
[ill) IR I Cl@ 1..!J@ W@ IZ I ZIZ I Z IZ IZ I@ l!..J@) ~@ | [ill) IR I Cl@ 1..!J@ W@ IZ I ZIZ I Z IZ IZ I@ l!..J@) ~@ | ||
1 a 9 10 11 12 13 18 19 20 SEQUENTIAL OCCURRENCE REPORT REVISION* | 1 a 9 10 11 12 13 18 19 20 SEQUENTIAL OCCURRENCE REPORT REVISION* | ||
r.::... REPORT NO. COOE TYPE | r.::... REPORT NO. COOE TYPE LEA/RO LVENT YEAR NO. | ||
LEA/RO LVENT YEAR NO. | |||
v..:.; REPORT NUMBER 17 18 I 21 I I Io I o 18 I 1......-1 10 11 I l!.J 1=:J ~ | v..:.; REPORT NUMBER 17 18 I 21 I I Io I o 18 I 1......-1 10 11 I l!.J 1=:J ~ | ||
ACTION FUTURE TAKEN ACTION 22 EFFECT ON PLANT 23 SHUTDOWN METHOD 24 26 HOURS | ACTION FUTURE TAKEN ACTION 22 EFFECT ON PLANT 23 SHUTDOWN METHOD 24 26 HOURS | ||
Line 54: | Line 50: | ||
35 L!l 36 I 010 I 01 I l!_J@ t!J L:J@ I LJ* l'.::I I '.: I I '.::11@) | 35 L!l 36 I 010 I 01 I l!_J@ t!J L:J@ I LJ* l'.::I I '.: I I '.::11@) | ||
37 40 41 42 43 44 47 CAUSE DESCRIPTION ANO CORREC'rlVE ACTIONS @ | 37 40 41 42 43 44 47 CAUSE DESCRIPTION ANO CORREC'rlVE ACTIONS @ | ||
((((] I The incore analysis (INCA) code used during cycle 2 yielded a poor rep-II1J] resentatj OP Of t,be axj a] poye"l" aj5trjbution in the CO"l"e region above the CI:ILl topmost incore detectors. A revised form of the INCA code gives a better | |||
[IIlJ I representation of core ;power pear the top of the core, and will be used OJil I for cycle 3 operation. | [IIlJ I representation of core ;power pear the top of the core, and will be used OJil I for cycle 3 operation. | ||
7 8 9 80 FACILITY l3c)\ METHOD OF (.;.:;\ | 7 8 9 80 FACILITY l3c)\ METHOD OF (.;.:;\ | ||
Line 62: | Line 58: | ||
* 12 13 44 45* 45** SD ACTIVITY CONTENT* . , ~ | * 12 13 44 45* 45** SD ACTIVITY CONTENT* . , ~ | ||
RELEASED OF RELEASE N/A AMOUNT OF ACTIVITY I N/A..** LOCATION OF RELEASE @ | RELEASED OF RELEASE N/A AMOUNT OF ACTIVITY I N/A..** LOCATION OF RELEASE @ | ||
OJ | OJ))~ ~@I . | ||
* I 1 a 9 10 11 44 45 80 PERSONNEL EXPOSURES C\ | * I 1 a 9 10 11 44 45 80 PERSONNEL EXPOSURES C\ | ||
NUMBER (.;:;\TYPE DESCRIPTION | NUMBER (.;:;\TYPE DESCRIPTION | ||
Line 70: | Line 66: | ||
lo I olo l@)~~~r~A-=----------------------------'80 9 11 12 LOSS OF OR DAMAGE TO FACILITY f43\ | lo I olo l@)~~~r~A-=----------------------------'80 9 11 12 LOSS OF OR DAMAGE TO FACILITY f43\ | ||
-=.::; | -=.::; | ||
TYPE DESCRIPTION lJII] L&J@)!'::--_N/~A ___________________ ..;......___________. | TYPE DESCRIPTION lJII] L&J@)!'::--_N/~A ___________________ ..;......___________. | ||
1 a 9* 10 80 PUBLICITY (.;;\ | 1 a 9* 10 80 PUBLICITY (.;;\ | ||
Line 76: | Line 71: | ||
ITEi L.!Jei ___N"""'/A_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ ____. I '! I I I ! I I I I I I I 7 8 9 10 68 69 80 | ITEi L.!Jei ___N"""'/A_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ ____. I '! I I I ! I I I I I I I 7 8 9 10 68 69 80 | ||
~ | ~ | ||
Attachment to LER 78-008 Consumers Power Company Palisades Nuclear Plant Docket 050-255 Discussion | Attachment to LER 78-008 Consumers Power Company Palisades Nuclear Plant Docket 050-255 Discussion Recent revisions to the Incore Analysis (INCA) computer code have been made in order to more accurately determine the core axial power distributions. | ||
As a result of the improved code, the discovery was made that the axial power distribution limits of Technical Specification 3.10.3 were exceeded by approxi-mately 12 percent for steady state conditions during Cycle 2. During transient conditions such as Xenon oscillations, the limits may have been exceeded by a greater amount. The attached figure shows the computed axial power distribution using both the old and revised INCA codes. | As a result of the improved code, the discovery was made that the axial power distribution limits of Technical Specification 3.10.3 were exceeded by approxi-mately 12 percent for steady state conditions during Cycle 2. During transient conditions such as Xenon oscillations, the limits may have been exceeded by a greater amount. The attached figure shows the computed axial power distribution using both the old and revised INCA codes. | ||
Cause This condition was caused by the use of an INCA code which did not give a good representation of the axial power distribution in the core region above the uppermost detector. | Cause This condition was caused by the use of an INCA code which did not give a good representation of the axial power distribution in the core region above the uppermost detector. | ||
Corrective Action Use of the improved INCA code during Cycle 3 is expected to prevent recurrence | Corrective Action Use of the improved INCA code during Cycle 3 is expected to prevent recurrence of this condition. | ||
*~ | *~ | ||
Attachment to LER 78-008 Consumers Power Company Palisades Nuclear Plant (._ | Attachment to LER 78-008 Consumers Power Company Palisades Nuclear Plant (._ | ||
Docket 050-255 Discussion Recent revisions to the Incore Analysis (INCA) computer code have been made in order to more accurately determine the core axial power distributions . | Docket 050-255 Discussion Recent revisions to the Incore Analysis (INCA) computer code have been made in order to more accurately determine the core axial power distributions . | ||
Line 109: | Line 99: | ||
* I. * . ** . . . . * . l-Lrf.11l I .*. : -I - ~ * .I ".t.1 . , >. * ** | * I. * . ** . . . . * . l-Lrf.11l I .*. : -I - ~ * .I ".t.1 . , >. * ** | ||
.l+L' r.~ I *If I 1** j . I 1I . , . , ~ .J. , I 0. tt~ I I>, . I, , ; , I It I 1. , * ', ',;, * , .* , , .. : | .l+L' r.~ I *If I 1** j . I 1I . , . , ~ .J. , I 0. tt~ I I>, . I, , ; , I It I 1. , * ', ',;, * , .* , , .. : | ||
~-,,::q~~~- ::*:: ;:t*~ *; :.~-~~ r.*:~. :'.*~'. .Y ~*-:*i*~:~---4~: .:~'. !*:r:~ ;.*.*'. ~ -~ *~-~';*~: . : ~:i~ :::-i :~t-~ i!:l .:!:. :*!::: .'.~. *:~~- ;: ; r.~:-~ *:!~~ :*:;; :*:~: :*. :~ i~::/ i'.~* **:~:: '., .: )J+ ::::; ~:*:: ~~'.-~ ::: ~:~: ~: µ:~ ~:::;~~ | ~-,,::q~~~- ::*:: ;:t*~ *; :.~-~~ r.*:~. :'.*~'. .Y ~*-:*i*~:~---4~: .:~'. !*:r:~ ;.*.*'. ~ -~ *~-~';*~: . : ~:i~ :::-i :~t-~ i!:l .:!:. :*!::: .'.~. *:~~- ;: ; r.~:-~ *:!~~ :*:;; :*:~: :*. :~ i~::/ i'.~* **:~:: '., .: )J+ ::::; ~:*:: ~~'.-~ ::: ~:~: ~: µ:~ ~:::;~~ | ||
\::-c1*i*- .... , .... "* *1'1 'l*t I' "'"I *"I"' l-1\ I.ti *"r* 1~1 "'1 lmL ..1.1., .* t,, | \::-c1*i*- .... , .... "* *1'1 'l*t I' "'"I *"I"' l-1\ I.ti *"r* 1~1 "'1 lmL ..1.1., .* t,, | ||
Line 120: | Line 109: | ||
.,* ..; ti,' 1 * "I' | .,* ..; ti,' 1 * "I' | ||
* I * ' ,;-r, I ' ,,* ' 'I'*..,.'' I.':;t' | * I * ' ,;-r, I ' ,,* ' 'I'*..,.'' I.':;t' | ||
'1.t~ Utl | '1.t~ Utl | ||
"'"I r, I ltt!J, I I- t* 'H+ll | "'"I r, I ltt!J, I I- t* 'H+ll | ||
,I\ 'l'ti j J. I *'*' | ,I\ 'l'ti j J. I *'*' | ||
Line 128: | Line 115: | ||
1 ** | 1 ** | ||
* It t* *I- | * It t* *I- | ||
+t 1 | +t 1 | ||
*I 'II I * "'*I I'**1*1 *I'. I l tit!1 | *I 'II I * "'*I I'**1*1 *I'. I l tit!1 | ||
Line 146: | Line 132: | ||
* ijt | * ijt | ||
\ | \ | ||
*;,j l.J: | |||
*;,j | |||
* t*" | * t*" | ||
I I I | I I I | ||
Line 162: | Line 145: | ||
J.l\.'"'""' | J.l\.'"'""' | ||
rW 1"'" | rW 1"'" | ||
~~i~ | ~~i~ | ||
l*"J*.lt:'H1, | l*"J*.lt:'H1, | ||
'to! | 'to! | ||
Line 187: | Line 168: | ||
,ti | ,ti | ||
.~I IJ '' l 1 | .~I IJ '' l 1 | ||
.M.. | .M.. | ||
, ~II f +'i' 1**-*** | , ~II f +'i' 1**-*** | ||
Line 193: | Line 173: | ||
* i., u:* 'llifl 1g1 1 | * i., u:* 'llifl 1g1 1 | ||
., 1" '* * ... | ., 1" '* * ... | ||
t | t | ||
:_~J*1111~ | :_~J*1111~ | ||
Line 211: | Line 189: | ||
.i, 11~ .,, | .i, 11~ .,, | ||
1., ... | 1., ... | ||
, .* ,~,, | , .* ,~,, | ||
" ' 111**' | " ' 111**' | ||
Line 218: | Line 195: | ||
Tl*' ......,.. , .. ,........ | Tl*' ......,.. , .. ,........ | ||
......,, .. ,1 :Ii* . . . . . . . . . . . . . . | ......,, .. ,1 :Ii* . . . . . . . . . . . . . . | ||
I.... .. ' ' | I.... .. ' ' | ||
* | * | ||
* 11~1 * * **U. I.~£* Ji **t 1**1 11IJj"'-'*..11'' | * 11~1 * * **U. I.~£* Ji **t 1**1 11IJj"'-'*..11'' | ||
Line 230: | Line 204: | ||
6J . * .- - " ' * ,,..,,. , .,.. | 6J . * .- - " ' * ,,..,,. , .,.. | ||
I* i"lll * | I* i"lll * | ||
-I* | -I* | ||
11 . . | 11 . . | ||
Line 251: | Line 223: | ||
ltl! | ltl! | ||
*1*** | *1*** | ||
.,,. _,,_,i. -* | .,,. _,,_,i. -* | ||
: l. I. | : l. I. | ||
ijll 1 .. | ijll 1 .. | ||
Line 261: | Line 229: | ||
.i .... ***. | .i .... ***. | ||
I 11 | I 11 | ||
,1. . . | ,1. . . | ||
.1,, | .1,, | ||
** I... | ** I... | ||
.. ,,' .... "'' .... 1... . | .. ,,' .... "'' .... 1... . | ||
1 . . . . . .. | 1 . . . . . .. | ||
l t~iQ | l t~iQ | ||
'"''it+,''* ;iJl)W" ,~1::: 1,:: 1.1.I u~: *'.:~ 1H"J .:1 '1-~;:i'-' | '"''it+,''* ;iJl)W" ,~1::: 1,:: 1.1.I u~: *'.:~ 1H"J .:1 '1-~;:i'-' | ||
Line 288: | Line 247: | ||
1: | 1: | ||
!.U' . '~.!II *tH .,, . * ,_ *** ***'-I* ;.: . . .... . *~u. .U.1 .i,l.!.. ~* *. ~ ..*. l***:: ~*n ~*** . . . ..... . . . .*I*:. ,, .*... *" | !.U' . '~.!II *tH .,, . * ,_ *** ***'-I* ;.: . . .... . *~u. .U.1 .i,l.!.. ~* *. ~ ..*. l***:: ~*n ~*** . . . ..... . . . .*I*:. ,, .*... *" | ||
Vi I !v-..fr*I*.i ;:11 .;:,~.!_.*w: | Vi I !v-..fr*I*.i ;:11 .;:,~.!_.*w: | ||
!**r | !**r | ||
, 11; 1: JlO 11;* . | , 11; 1: JlO 11;* . | ||
~ | ~ | ||
. 1 | . 1 | ||
* h ~ | |||
h ~ | |||
111 (,\-:-Im* | 111 (,\-:-Im* | ||
Ti_.!I .. 11\"' | Ti_.!I .. 11\"' | ||
Line 303: | Line 260: | ||
t | t | ||
. "1 l\.;L. | . "1 l\.;L. | ||
tl*l r1 | tl*l r1 Ll l'I w* | ||
Ll l'I w* | |||
.. L!.*, , | .. L!.*, , | ||
1 | 1 | ||
* -It.. q | * -It.. q l. | ||
l | |||
t n | t n | ||
. . .11:-Mt1 | . . .11:-Mt1 | ||
Line 320: | Line 271: | ||
!q., | !q., | ||
:1. , 1 1 l~ | :1. , 1 1 l~ | ||
1 1 | |||
r : | r : | ||
..;d '-1**~ | ..;d '-1**~ | ||
1111 | 1111 | ||
.4:.:. :11:. | .4:.:. :11:. | ||
-~~**!. | -~~**!. | ||
i:ti', 1 | i:ti', 1 | ||
+1.1:1jL .. ,. ... *J.!t~ | +1.1:1jL .. ,. ... *J.!t~ | ||
Line 337: | Line 285: | ||
1 1 1: ll'.! ;::: 1:11 :11! ::., :::: | 1 1 1: ll'.! ;::: 1:11 :11! ::., :::: | ||
~-** | ~-** | ||
1 | 1 | ||
****: **-IUH'' | ****: **-IUH'' | ||
' * | ' * | ||
Line 351: | Line 297: | ||
* .I* .L-t t'1tt.~I ** I***Ii*** | * .I* .L-t t'1tt.~I ** I***Ii*** | ||
!I 'l | !I 'l | ||
*1 jil. t I' *l 'I I!*I - * * * | *1 jil. t I' *l 'I I!*I - * * | ||
* 1 If!. 'I 1+ | |||
1 If!. 'I 1+ | |||
* L . ..i I"'*1 11* *I* .. , I"'"~,,,,, 11 *I .11 j 1*11*I '* i'*"* ", !' I lllil; 11rn**I 1 11'I **f' **!I 1 '1 | * L . ..i I"'*1 11* *I* .. , I"'"~,,,,, 11 *I .11 j 1*11*I '* i'*"* ", !' I lllil; 11rn**I 1 11'I **f' **!I 1 '1 | ||
".i I!,* '"I | ".i I!,* '"I 11*'* !* ..! 11',,"I'*" | ||
11*'* !* ..! 11',,"I'*" | |||
IL** * * * * 'I'' | IL** * * * * 'I'' | ||
8 :.::.:.. . | 8 :.::.:.. . | ||
~ffi *;; iNr~ ~-mi !ff!, ~-** | ~ffi *;; iNr~ ~-mi !ff!, ~-** | ||
11"I*! :.''...!... '* ** | 11"I*! :.''...!... '* ** | ||
1t Ur.;*''* | 1t Ur.;*''* | ||
* | * | ||
Line 396: | Line 332: | ||
* 1 * ,., 1 1,. I, *** ... ,,. | * 1 * ,., 1 1,. I, *** ... ,,. | ||
* I, , I,, I * , . . , , ! . , . , .* , . , .. , | * I, , I,, I * , . . , , ! . , . , .* , . , .. , | ||
H-J !~;-~ :'f:.'.::.:;~i :;i:lf. :1*~ :;:':,:.~. :~ ~~.H17l''j ;~ii~~f~:,::1 t-'*~j H.. ~ t* ... :~t*;tt~~:i*~ll:;**: '::: j-_;j_**.:j*;; ;:;.:. ~i ~;-:1.'.1*~; .;;:~; ;; :.;.*;.: 1 ~1 ~;!*; ~i;.; ;;;; ;~*;~ :*:;: :;;; ;;;: ;;;~ ;:;; ;*;:; ;~;; ;;:: ;;;: ;:~; | H-J !~;-~ :'f:.'.::.:;~i :;i:lf. :1*~ :;:':,:.~. :~ ~~.H17l''j ;~ii~~f~:,::1 t-'*~j H.. ~ t* ... :~t*;tt~~:i*~ll:;**: '::: j-_;j_**.:j*;; ;:;.:. ~i ~;-:1.'.1*~; .;;:~; ;; :.;.*;.: 1 ~1 ~;!*; ~i;.; ;;;; ;~*;~ :*:;: :;;; ;;;: ;;;~ ;:;; ;*;:; ;~;; ;;:: ;;;: ;:~; | ||
0 ::1 ;.. 1 1 1 | 0 ::1 ;.. 1 1 1 | ||
Line 403: | Line 338: | ||
fY:.;.b 1* | fY:.;.b 1* | ||
~p * .. :[J~Y.~ *=:~'.:;.:. :**.~ . i .. ; *:.:.* *,::* ~t:.~~: *;.. ~u ... 1-* .:*,. J:l~ 1 _..i _~i**;. 1.Jd+/-f.Hrrr t ,.~ ~ .* 1 ***!: ..: ,.''. --~~j :;~ *~:;, ;::-;k{+~~-;f !"t+!~*;-;-~~_i-:-7 :-:-r-+:-:-:- :~-::--:+;.~i*~~.:.;.:- ;:.;c r *l*"r1 1**' 1** L11:1t 1 '1t tdl fr;_:. jtiJ *~1-l 1*rtl t~ -~t11- fft*1-~ "-1t J.l~.u L"J l*LLJJ11 .ti.,,., .I,~ ,,.1. ..1,, '"' | ~p * .. :[J~Y.~ *=:~'.:;.:. :**.~ . i .. ; *:.:.* *,::* ~t:.~~: *;.. ~u ... 1-* .:*,. J:l~ 1 _..i _~i**;. 1.Jd+/-f.Hrrr t ,.~ ~ .* 1 ***!: ..: ,.''. --~~j :;~ *~:;, ;::-;k{+~~-;f !"t+!~*;-;-~~_i-:-7 :-:-r-+:-:-:- :~-::--:+;.~i*~~.:.;.:- ;:.;c r *l*"r1 1**' 1** L11:1t 1 '1t tdl fr;_:. jtiJ *~1-l 1*rtl t~ -~t11- fft*1-~ "-1t J.l~.u L"J l*LLJJ11 .ti.,,., .I,~ ,,.1. ..1,, '"' | ||
r:;;.:. rd t*.: :*:~, tt,~t ~tli | r:;;.:. rd t*.: :*:~, tt,~t ~tli | ||
,.* 1. *;i., .;_v'~ ** *\l:J ltt+/-tl J-.i-j' _ ,:flt,t . . ._ | ,.* 1. *;i., .;_v'~ ** *\l:J ltt+/-tl J-.i-j' _ ,:flt,t . . ._ | ||
Line 430: | Line 364: | ||
I .* , IJii *"* '*" i"'* ''" *'" .... : *" ... | I .* , IJii *"* '*" i"'* ''" *'" .... : *" ... | ||
.. * * * ... ..... * ** * '" ****~-* * *" .... * "**1 ,.... .. . - | .. * * * ... ..... * ** * '" ****~-* * *" .... * "**1 ,.... .. . - | ||
~~;... ;q; ;,.: l~;I; 'i-'.-1, t~t' i '!';1 t 1'.!!l' i1~ t +,~;;, 'IJ'! .. Ill il'j ,, 1.1"11'11:1i *1:'1' 1 ~i1 1'1'' IL' '[~i ~iLi ~itf I~: :1rt~;;; ;~:; :::: ;;:~~~: ;:;: :~~ ~~ r~: ::::F:~ | ~~;... ;q; ;,.: l~;I; 'i-'.-1, t~t' i '!';1 t 1'.!!l' i1~ t +,~;;, 'IJ'! .. Ill il'j ,, 1.1"11'11:1i *1:'1' 1 ~i1 1'1'' IL' '[~i ~iLi ~itf I~: :1rt~;;; ;~:; :::: ;;:~~~: ;:;: :~~ ~~ r~: ::::F:~ | ||
L | L | ||
~l,;.~1:in : 1~,~~'i\.:.: r\1 :*: :11 It : ;'1* | ~l,;.~1:in : 1~,~~'i\.:.: r\1 :*: :11 It : ;'1* | ||
!1 t !tr :*u ..f * | !1 t !tr :*u ..f * | ||
Line 440: | Line 372: | ||
::+; | ::+; | ||
'::: !; 1; d:: :::; *::: :::: ;:;; ;;,!::.:~J::::_ | '::: !; 1; d:: :::; *::: :::: ;:;; ;;,!::.:~J::::_ | ||
*:.-.u,.. titi*J*"' :~ *:*11:. . l i'i rL l*t*~ ' '.' :1:1. ':~ti :\:l:'* ..1-rt .:1.1*: i'IJJL~*11:1 1*'-' ;::: *w i'~ .~.lHr\! *I' | *:.-.u,.. titi*J*"' :~ *:*11:. . l i'i rL l*t*~ ' '.' :1:1. ':~ti :\:l:'* ..1-rt .:1.1*: i'IJJL~*11:1 1*'-' ;::: *w i'~ .~.lHr\! *I' | ||
'\l"-''1' hi ltd!/,: HI+ | '\l"-''1' hi ltd!/,: HI+ | ||
Line 463: | Line 394: | ||
1 | 1 | ||
!Cl: ~14; ft! +10 t .. ,,, 1i1 1 l +1 ntt ,.,, 'i' 1 tl 't"tl J* '-1~**.r* t., -L'lJ t *+ ' ,, r l 1* 1::t*1*'" ITh rtn '*i]* ttiJ *rr! l:i"*' 1hr*Jr ... *~ '"-:1' ,!+; :1** .,.,,, *-**' "" ., ..... ,, ,.. , '"' ,,,, *'*' """ ''" .... , "" ,... | !Cl: ~14; ft! +10 t .. ,,, 1i1 1 l +1 ntt ,.,, 'i' 1 tl 't"tl J* '-1~**.r* t., -L'lJ t *+ ' ,, r l 1* 1::t*1*'" ITh rtn '*i]* ttiJ *rr! l:i"*' 1hr*Jr ... *~ '"-:1' ,!+; :1** .,.,,, *-**' "" ., ..... ,, ,.. , '"' ,,,, *'*' """ ''" .... , "" ,... | ||
~ µ,.:.( .~ 1 ... '. i 1 -t*l :;.t.urj ~ .... 1i ~ ~,. . Lu.~..... , ..... _. !-f ... ri., .. ~n ti.: .* 111. q~ .1.~ **~1. '- ' .J.l:l..!. ~~~*:*:.;~: ;.:....:....:.~:.::~!.;...r...:..;..:...:...i~~ .:.....:..:...!..;.:._:_: _: .... ~ | ~ µ,.:.( .~ 1 ... '. i 1 -t*l :;.t.urj ~ .... 1i ~ ~,. . Lu.~..... , ..... _. !-f ... ri., .. ~n ti.: .* 111. q~ .1.~ **~1. '- ' .J.l:l..!. ~~~*:*:.;~: ;.:....:....:.~:.::~!.;...r...:..;..:...:...i~~ .:.....:..:...!..;.:._:_: _: .... ~ | ||
L- . . . , , ; | L- . . . , , ; | ||
\.- | \.- | ||
j; | j; | ||
.. , ""' *"'*t*'' .... \]"' r''l ''"'*1*1 IT***1~ d1 11tLIC\" *11iil 1 i; 1' r~. !Ll* -i' iT.'..i | .. , ""' *"'*t*'' .... \]"' r''l ''"'*1*1 IT***1~ d1 11tLIC\" *11iil 1 i; 1' r~. !Ll* -i' iT.'..i | ||
- ....,:. * | - ....,:. * | ||
Line 480: | Line 406: | ||
Jf ** | Jf ** | ||
I *.f.* | I *.f.* | ||
, 111** 1*1****, I**~ti | , 111** 1*1****, I**~ti | ||
. * . ** . --1 I l *ijll'l!.!.'*-.11 1' ! , **1* ~I 1... I '"' 111*1* | . * . ** . --1 I l *ijll'l!.!.'*-.11 1' ! , **1* ~I 1... I '"' 111*1* | ||
Line 493: | Line 418: | ||
L:~:.I. t: '.**,;,:.!:** *l .. | L:~:.I. t: '.**,;,:.!:** *l .. | ||
* 11:;,:**' 1 ~ *~,: !iL. l-._',*!I .: . .._"I.**.*:., ~ ::*.,*!::** .: ~:: t .. *: l**:;'!lll-;I: *:.~ ** 1 :*,;:*:: ;*,~~,.;*::.;l::;*;~.;~:::::*::::t::::::!:::::::::: .. * :::::*:er- r | * 11:;,:**' 1 ~ *~,: !iL. l-._',*!I .: . .._"I.**.*:., ~ ::*.,*!::** .: ~:: t .. *: l**:;'!lll-;I: *:.~ ** 1 :*,;:*:: ;*,~~,.;*::.;l::;*;~.;~:::::*::::t::::::!:::::::::: .. * :::::*:er- r | ||
\.., trd ,:j, 1 t :-- * :ti! ;t!: 1.l!j t.1iti4.tJ'f*I 1.11 ~.!I.ill~ .. , 1l11 tf:;1 t" r*.; 1+ :0 1 1.11''ilt "'_ , ii 1 | \.., trd ,:j, 1 t :-- * :ti! ;t!: 1.l!j t.1iti4.tJ'f*I 1.11 ~.!I.ill~ .. , 1l11 tf:;1 t" r*.; 1+ :0 1 1.11''ilt "'_ , ii 1 | ||
: i. ll1 1L l t1 fhl[L1 t 1 .,.d.t.I .q. , t-11H-1 .~ . . . .ll [. 1Ltl.H:.. l'~ -'HJ.. l.f:i.1. i4-i . :*1'!t ~: !t ;.tlJ ~ .. Lil; l~**!*!1H 1:11:1'11 -r. -!tlf.:. ..ll:! .I ::t 11.:; ! ~-, !* dtt rid 1ur i!.t1 ::~: ;*!1: ;:~: :: : : :::: 1:::: ::*: ::;......... | : i. ll1 1L l t1 fhl[L1 t 1 .,.d.t.I .q. , t-11H-1 .~ . . . .ll [. 1Ltl.H:.. l'~ -'HJ.. l.f:i.1. i4-i . :*1'!t ~: !t ;.tlJ ~ .. Lil; l~**!*!1H 1:11:1'11 -r. -!tlf.:. ..ll:! .I ::t 11.:; ! ~-, !* dtt rid 1ur i!.t1 ::~: ;*!1: ;:~: :: : : :::: 1:::: ::*: ::;......... | ||
Line 517: | Line 441: | ||
* 1**11. 1.*.11 :1 t * . . . . * * :. 1. | * 1**11. 1.*.11 :1 t * . . . . * * :. 1. | ||
1 1 *11* r,11x: rt:c~1r ff" '"lii *t t - .. ** t1i | 1 1 *11* r,11x: rt:c~1r ff" '"lii *t t - .. ** t1i | ||
*, .. *J1 ** | *, .. *J1 ** | ||
~t:t* | ~t:t* | ||
Line 532: | Line 455: | ||
,t, I -I I ' I> :*1' * *1 "di'11 *t- 1111:*11* 'I it* ., IJt \l1l_' illl' lil11l.i' ., !i11 ;;I: !!~,l~lil!lli** | ,t, I -I I ' I> :*1' * *1 "di'11 *t- 1111:*11* 'I it* ., IJt \l1l_' illl' lil11l.i' ., !i11 ;;I: !!~,l~lil!lli** | ||
1 ii 't;:: I::: iii!;;;:*;;; 11*: :::I!::!:*:::*:: ,t,, 111* ::*1; ''I' ,;:;::!:I"""' | 1 ii 't;:: I::: iii!;;;:*;;; 11*: :::I!::!:*:::*:: ,t,, 111* ::*1; ''I' ,;:;::!:I"""' | ||
\.:.} | \.:.} | ||
_. T***r1*** | _. T***r1*** | ||
Line 541: | Line 462: | ||
r**1.*t pt*t 1 | r**1.*t pt*t 1 | ||
:U J . .L~{''[~I' | :U J . .L~{''[~I' | ||
* 1 | * 1 | ||
!"t-J*~.:L-m | !"t-J*~.:L-m 1' | ||
1' | |||
~j.*~* | ~j.*~* | ||
t ., ,, | t ., ,, | ||
*l | *l | ||
'"L ~*L *r 'li'1'JL*11r1**!11i | '"L ~*L *r 'li'1'JL*11r1**!11i | ||
.1. * **. | .1. * **. | ||
Line 563: | Line 478: | ||
*"' , .. , ~ | *"' , .. , ~ | ||
. . 1, .11. | . . 1, .11. | ||
!*v 'j~ ~' !"'' *1 * . 11 . . . . . | !*v 'j~ ~' !"'' *1 * . 11 . . . . . | ||
\\\ | \\\ | ||
~ | ~ | ||
\.L l 'I" "!' 't1iA'*"1 11111* "'I I I "IL., .... 11t* ' *t* *tr.1 ' [111'11'' *t t! l' ' I 'f' II tll'' r: 1*u:*I'>*\! l'I''1 t *''J'. l'I" l**'t ''I *rnt* t*' -*1''''''' .... ;,,I,,,,,,-.,,"" I':, .... :., .. "'", .. :,,, ***4*,',;*'."'.7'.'"'.'7:';*.IJ ~ | \.L l 'I" "!' 't1iA'*"1 11111* "'I I I "IL., .... 11t* ' *t* *tr.1 ' [111'11'' *t t! l' ' I 'f' II tll'' r: 1*u:*I'>*\! l'I''1 t *''J'. l'I" l**'t ''I *rnt* t*' -*1''''''' .... ;,,I,,,,,,-.,,"" I':, .... :., .. "'", .. :,,, ***4*,',;*'."'.7'.'"'.'7:';*.IJ ~ | ||
~*.* ii:J f'Y:' 1 * *.flt *I Ii I I l I~,, I ** ! | ~*.* ii:J f'Y:' 1 * *.flt *I Ii I I l I~,, I ** ! | ||
I~ ~ lj ~* | I~ ~ lj ~* | ||
Line 578: | Line 490: | ||
ttl fii | ttl fii | ||
**fll ,,, ) | **fll ,,, ) | ||
-~-:_1.! | -~-:_1.! | ||
I- | I- | ||
-'!*HI_ LI l :t' l | |||
-'!*HI_ LI | |||
. | . | ||
* I | * I | ||
** 1 . | ** 1 . | ||
...''I ' I.Id | ...''I ' I.Id Ii* ,,,Iii 11~-1 LI | ||
11~-1 | |||
LI | |||
* H I | * H I | ||
JI'' | JI'' | ||
Line 603: | Line 503: | ||
,.L:; | ,.L:; | ||
*1 II | *1 II | ||
*!11 I | *!11 I I | ||
I | |||
,11.. ' | ,11.. ' | ||
* 11!1 ''!' | * 11!1 ''!' | ||
Line 611: | Line 509: | ||
1,' | 1,' | ||
1'*1 'I j , | 1'*1 'I j , | ||
1. | |||
I '1.1 | I '1.1 | ||
* * * * * * *I | * * * * * * *I | ||
_:!_~i..:..:...:...; .... | _:!_~i..:..:...:...; .... | ||
*I: I | *I: I | ||
"::1 | "::1 | ||
_:_:;.:..Ll~' | _:_:;.:..Ll~' | ||
_:_~__: " ' '.... ~ | _:_~__: " ' '.... ~ | ||
, I,. | , I,. | ||
Line 665: | Line 553: | ||
.* l.I | .* l.I | ||
't ~ | 't ~ | ||
i! 1-IH | i! 1-IH 1 . . .*ti* | ||
1 . . .*ti* | |||
,.i 1\~ | ,.i 1\~ | ||
w.. . I~-' !1!: | w.. . I~-' !1!: | ||
Line 675: | Line 561: | ||
tt ' . | tt ' . | ||
~ , L 1 . | ~ , L 1 . | ||
t l l' . . l H'' I l1 ' | t l l' . . l H'' I l1 ' | ||
.I | .I | ||
*I II. | *I II. | ||
Line 687: | Line 570: | ||
I*!* | I*!* | ||
+I I | +I I | ||
1 | 1 j{j, | ||
,,!11' ,,,,. | ,,!11' ,,,,. | ||
t-11.l ill l.11 I ' | t-11.l ill l.11 I ' | ||
Line 694: | Line 576: | ||
I II li I ' I * ! II I I | I II li I ' I * ! II I I | ||
'j l I" | 'j l I" | ||
~I i1 ' I ' l '1* ' .. * ' | ~I i1 ' I ' l '1* ' .. * ' | ||
i::1 ni.::1:11: | i::1 ni.::1:11: | ||
IHll1' *** I d * " " | IHll1' *** I d * " " | ||
" I ''" | " I ''" | ||
;;:: 1;1; ;::: I :;1 I' ' " ' | ;;:: 1;1; ;::: I :;1 I' ' " ' | ||
"O | "O | ||
' I' | ' I' | ||
~::: :!'- | ~::: :!'- | ||
" ' l*..j | " ' l*..j | ||
, _:_~:+..:.:....:.: | , _:_~:+..:.:....:.: | ||
.. *: :!:: lJl | .. *: :!:: lJl | ||
.**Hr-1"**. | .**Hr-1"**. | ||
~i'!r'!*;,: *~'.**1li;--** | ~i'!r'!*;,: *~'.**1li;--** | ||
Line 725: | Line 593: | ||
**t> . +r **+*el' H Ll1 *1* ,,* J * | **t> . +r **+*el' H Ll1 *1* ,,* J * | ||
'*i | '*i | ||
" ' '** 11* '' J1 ** t I i'' *t***r1* * . . . ** | " ' '** 11* '' J1 ** t I i'' *t***r1* * . . . ** | ||
*I | *I | ||
".ll ... 1****t* --~ II' I!' | ".ll ... 1****t* --~ II' I!' | ||
'I' . * | 'I' . * | ||
Line 737: | Line 602: | ||
' . | ' . | ||
* r1 *1;'*t | * r1 *1;'*t | ||
***.'t'::->-;;;, | ***.'t'::->-;;;, | ||
1 '' .,i, ........ -:-:-:* . ....... | 1 '' .,i, ........ -:-:-:* . ....... | ||
I ' " " ' " Lj' !* **'1'>*' *;I 1 | I ' " " ' " Lj' !* **'1'>*' *;I 1 | ||
:~"'.-::::- | :~"'.-::::- | ||
l:1 '~-~ *t'I :iJ. ij ~ t*j i -~ :. * .IJ' * .:~ ft~ ;j r: ...1*1 1~ j* .. ; *1 tl ~: :t;*t .;fl :'.1'1' '.,ii;;;:;:::;;:::'.~. | l:1 '~-~ *t'I :iJ. ij ~ t*j i -~ :. * .IJ' * .:~ ft~ ;j r: ...1*1 1~ j* .. ; *1 tl ~: :t;*t .;fl :'.1'1' '.,ii;;;:;:::;;:::'.~. | ||
ffi' l**t /*,;Jt 'j:' 11 t ** " .t<: 1*1**'*: j;;:*;.J;;: j:.:: .. :. ;::; J-H rl' t.t* ti ..1*..~:*1 1. .1 11 :\' t d IJ I* | ffi' l**t /*,;Jt 'j:' 11 t ** " .t<: 1*1**'*: j;;:*;.J;;: j:.:: .. :. ;::; J-H rl' t.t* ti ..1*..~:*1 1. .1 11 :\' t d IJ I* | ||
Line 754: | Line 616: | ||
it 1.qJ**H** | it 1.qJ**H** | ||
**.- :L~.:** trtl' i...i *. t~-l. :*:1.I .. ll. .*~ | **.- :L~.:** trtl' i...i *. t~-l. :*:1.I .. ll. .*~ | ||
tj' !!::: 1 | tj' !!::: 1 | ||
**. '~~:'.. *_ *_ | **. '~~:'.. *_ *_ | ||
Line 802: | Line 663: | ||
:Y | :Y | ||
.. '1*** .. ,. **1*1 '" :1,htH11 | .. '1*** .. ,. **1*1 '" :1,htH11 | ||
:I:: !:I :!d !I;!!!:! | :I:: !:I :!d !I;!!!:! | ||
* | * | ||
Line 812: | Line 672: | ||
!fLJ .:i: I dt I I | !fLJ .:i: I dt I I | ||
:!l : 1, 11+h1 I * ' I l.i: | :!l : 1, 11+h1 I * ' I l.i: | ||
' ! JJ ti l I - | ' ! JJ ti l I - | ||
I 'lJ | I 'lJ | ||
Line 821: | Line 680: | ||
j L! 1t!lI .:!: 1:;: ::!! *::! iii! 1!11 L!! 1:1! | j L! 1t!lI .:!: 1:;: ::!! *::! iii! 1!11 L!! 1:1! | ||
* I : ' ! I " I I . I I " * | * I : ' ! I " I I . I I " * | ||
:!!: ~ t::! 1::: :!:: !11 1 1!f: | :!!: ~ t::! 1::: :!:: !11 1 1!f: | ||
I * * ' | I * * ' | ||
: I I ti" 1**1 '"' ! 1*11; | : I I ti" 1**1 '"' ! 1*11; | ||
' I | ' I | ||
* I ' .. | * I ' .. | ||
1111*: * ,.,, | 1111*: * ,.,, | ||
1!;: :: 1 ::*; ,**<.:... | 1!;: :: 1 ::*; ,**<.:... | ||
' 1' .......... "' | ' 1' .......... "' | ||
! : ' I " | ! : ' I " | ||
* TT"' ... | * TT"' ... | ||
'C i'~'.''I"' | 'C i'~'.''I"' | ||
:. '*-'**f '***1 !r'I 'I' ~*,1 I"'''' | :. '*-'**f '***1 !r'I 'I' ~*,1 I"'''' | ||
11 | 11 141** 'I'', tjll ''" I !' titt* *1''f'1 t;**11*1**; l: t l I 1111 '**q.; *1*1 I'[It ti ' I j'!'' 'I''"I'I 11' 11I,,,, | ||
141** 'I'', tjll ''" I !' titt* *1''f'1 t;**11*1**; l: t l I 1111 '**q.; *1*1 I'[It ti ' I j'!'' 'I''"I'I 11' 11I,,,, | |||
1 :1 .. 1d1.1 1>i1. r:1. il:itii. nt..i1 ~*1,1*i:.!~*:t!~.J~;::1~Jl!-~J...!:.:Jl: .. :.il~UU!l': 1 :i;ilii..l!...:lL!lL~'.-:...:...~*:~.L~.:~.:.:~~~:.:~-~- t.\.... :. f:.:.: | 1 :1 .. 1d1.1 1>i1. r:1. il:itii. nt..i1 ~*1,1*i:.!~*:t!~.J~;::1~Jl!-~J...!:.:Jl: .. :.il~UU!l': 1 :i;ilii..l!...:lL!lL~'.-:...:...~*:~.L~.:~.:.:~~~:.:~-~- t.\.... :. f:.:.: | ||
' I''' L*1* . t"I .,, '*I*'; " !... ' ' ' *1** | ' I''' L*1* . t"I .,, '*I*'; " !... ' ' ' *1** | ||
Line 848: | Line 698: | ||
.~. .~ti 1 | .~. .~ti 1 | ||
1r11;*11tt 7 | 1r11;*11tt 7 | ||
'-*. J:t;mi~ | '-*. J:t;mi~ | ||
*" "r l"t ...1 ,,,. **,*1 *** 1 " !*** 1111 1 l* *11 * * *;II 1 1 1 *' "'*1j ,,_,1 1*.1t* 11i * * ' ttH r.:. *1 ; H++ 1 1**1711* 1 ***1 ... i ... , ,, ....... *1I * ,, ,,,, | *" "r l"t ...1 ,,,. **,*1 *** 1 " !*** 1111 1 l* *11 * * *;II 1 1 1 *' "'*1j ,,_,1 1*.1t* 11i * * ' ttH r.:. *1 ; H++ 1 1**1711* 1 ***1 ... i ... , ,, ....... *1I * ,, ,,,, | ||
Line 855: | Line 704: | ||
* O,. \;. . | * O,. \;. . | ||
j0 | j0 | ||
~ I* ' I | ~ I* ' I | ||
: i h !*** ... ~..... ,. ilt; | : i h !*** ... ~..... ,. ilt; | ||
Line 862: | Line 710: | ||
. l *rr | . l *rr | ||
* I l | * I l | ||
* 1** 1i., | * 1** 1i., | ||
I | I | ||
* I I | * I I | ||
.1. 11'" *;'" .,J, 11 ~I . | .1. 11'" *;'" .,J, 11 ~I . | ||
Line 872: | Line 717: | ||
* II- | * II- | ||
* I I~* | * I I~* | ||
I I | |||
1J 1* [ 111.. 1-+ :i)I ._ | |||
I | |||
i-ld-~i-u* | i-ld-~i-u* | ||
.,ltl .~"'" | .,ltl .~"'" | ||
1* I | 1* I | ||
Line 886: | Line 726: | ||
,r11*.*.Ii, I ~ I | ,r11*.*.Ii, I ~ I | ||
*' l,i. ,,., ;* 1. i1l1;1*** | *' l,i. ,,., ;* 1. i1l1;1*** | ||
it1* | |||
I o. | I o. | ||
I , 11 I I t. | I , 11 I I t. | ||
,.1. | ,.1. | ||
I * , , | I * , , | ||
, | , | ||
* I ' | * I ' | ||
* 1 | * 1 | ||
. I , , 1 1"' .,., | . I , , 1 1"' .,., | ||
1., I . | 1., I . | ||
l*1* | l*1* | ||
1 11 | 1 11 | ||
, I . | , I . | ||
' * , 1 | ' * , 1 | ||
*I** | *I** | ||
* | * | ||
* i " *~** | * i " *~** | ||
1 tvt. O *_L:...:.........:. .. , * | |||
1 | |||
. 1 , , | . 1 , , | ||
-i | -i | ||
* u Ot919P | * u Ot919P | ||
--*--*---*-- -,,._~--~--,.--*--*-,.....---,.........---:------*----*---.--*---~---...------------,--------------*~- .---*--*-*".-.--.~---......_ __:. ______ ~.---~-----.---~****c-<i-::---:c"-:l".....,..,...,_.~--~--;** --:---.:_:-_:~**-***-*-*-** *---*- --~---~ ..-----r-~~**~----*---* * 'l'l:J 5?. X Bl | --*--*---*-- -,,._~--~--,.--*--*-,.....---,.........---:------*----*---.--*---~---...------------,--------------*~- .---*--*-*".-.--.~---......_ __:. ______ ~.---~-----.---~****c-<i-::---:c"-:l".....,..,...,_.~--~--;** --:---.:_:-_:~**-***-*-*-** *---*- --~---~ ..-----r-~~**~----*---* * 'l'l:J 5?. X Bl |
Latest revision as of 03:47, 17 March 2020
ML18347B180 | |
Person / Time | |
---|---|
Site: | Palisades |
Issue date: | 04/19/1978 |
From: | Hoffman D Consumers Power Co |
To: | James Keppler NRC/RGN-III |
References | |
LER 1978-008-00 | |
Download: ML18347B180 (5) | |
Text
t/
~-..,
- e consumers
- Area Code 517 788-0550 April 19, 1978 Mr James G Keppler Office of Inspection and Enforcement Region III US Nuclear Regulatory Commission 799 Roosevelt Road Glen Ellyn, IL 60137 DOCKET 50-255 - LICENSE DPR PALISADES PLANT - LICENSEE EVENT REPORT 78-008
- Attached is Licensee Event Report 78-008 for the Palisades Plant as required by Technical Specification 6.9.2(a).2.
David P Hoffman Assistant Nuclear Licensing Administrator CC: Director, Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation Director, Office of Inspection and Enforcement
- Palisades NRCFORM366 U.S. NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION 17-771 LICENSEE EVENT REPORT CONTROL BLOCK: I IQ (PLEASE PRINT OR TYPE ALL REQUIRED INFORMATION) 1 6
[ilI] I MI r I P I AI L I i l@I o I oI o I o Io I o lo I o 101OIOIG)l411l1l1l 1l©I 7 8 9 LICENSEE CODE 14 ,5 LICENSE NUMBER 25 26 . LICENSE TYPE 30 I
57 CAT 58 10 CON'T
[ITJ]
1 a
- ~~~ LlJ©IO 60 61 15 1010IO1215 15 l(?)lo j 4!o 151 7181@10141119 17 18 IG)
DOCKET NUMBER 6B 69 EVENT DATE 74 75 REPORT DATE 80 EVENT DESCRIPTION ANO PROBABLE CONSEQUENCES@
1
()))) I Reanalysis of the cycle 2 core axial power distribution has shown that
(]J:!] I the power distribution limits of TS 3.10.3 were exceeded by approximately
[]JI] I 12 percent for steady state operation during Clcle 2. The limits were
[)))) I exceeded only in the upper portion of the core. This condition was dis-III)) covered through the use of an improved incore. analysis (INCA) computer ITlI] code.
[]:))]
1 a g so SYSTEM CAUSE CAUSE COMP. VALVE CODE CODE SUBCOOE COMPONENT CODE SUSCODE SUBCODE
[ill) IR I Cl@ 1..!J@ W@ IZ I ZIZ I Z IZ IZ I@ l!..J@) ~@
1 a 9 10 11 12 13 18 19 20 SEQUENTIAL OCCURRENCE REPORT REVISION*
r.::... REPORT NO. COOE TYPE LEA/RO LVENT YEAR NO.
v..:.; REPORT NUMBER 17 18 I 21 I I Io I o 18 I 1......-1 10 11 I l!.J 1=:J ~
ACTION FUTURE TAKEN ACTION 22 EFFECT ON PLANT 23 SHUTDOWN METHOD 24 26 HOURS
@ 27 28 ATTACHMENT SUBMITTED
- 29 NPRD-4 FORM l>UB.
30 PRIME COMP.
suPz-IER 31 32 COMPONENT l:dAN)IFACPJRE""'
W@W@r 33 34
~@
35 L!l 36 I 010 I 01 I l!_J@ t!J L:J@ I LJ* l'.::I I '.: I I '.::11@)
37 40 41 42 43 44 47 CAUSE DESCRIPTION ANO CORREC'rlVE ACTIONS @
((((] I The incore analysis (INCA) code used during cycle 2 yielded a poor rep-II1J] resentatj OP Of t,be axj a] poye"l" aj5trjbution in the CO"l"e region above the CI:ILl topmost incore detectors. A revised form of the INCA code gives a better
[IIlJ I representation of core ;power pear the top of the core, and will be used OJil I for cycle 3 operation.
7 8 9 80 FACILITY l3c)\ METHOD OF (.;.:;\
STATUS . %POWER OTHERSTATUS \:::::; DISCOVERY plSCOYEFJY* .D~S,l:RIPTIO.t-1 ~
[ill] L...Ql@ I o Io I o l@,_I_N_/A_ _ _ ___. ~~I Use of revised ~~GA code I 1 a 9
- 10
- 12 13 44 45* 45** SD ACTIVITY CONTENT* . , ~
RELEASED OF RELEASE N/A AMOUNT OF ACTIVITY I N/A..** LOCATION OF RELEASE @
OJ))~ ~@I .
- I 1 a 9 10 11 44 45 80 PERSONNEL EXPOSURES C\
NUMBER (.;:;\TYPE DESCRIPTION
[ITIJ 7 8 lo I ala l~LzJ@)~--------------------------~
9 11 12 13 80 PERSONNEL INJURIES I.:".;\
NUMBER DESCRIPTION6 1II!Ja 1
lo I olo l@)~~~r~A-=----------------------------'80 9 11 12 LOSS OF OR DAMAGE TO FACILITY f43\
-=.::;
TYPE DESCRIPTION lJII] L&J@)!'::--_N/~A ___________________ ..;......___________.
1 a 9* 10 80 PUBLICITY (.;;\
NRC USE ONLY ISSUED(,'.;\ DESCRIPT. ION~
ITEi L.!Jei ___N"""'/A_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ ____. I '! I I I ! I I I I I I I 7 8 9 10 68 69 80
~
Attachment to LER 78-008 Consumers Power Company Palisades Nuclear Plant Docket 050-255 Discussion Recent revisions to the Incore Analysis (INCA) computer code have been made in order to more accurately determine the core axial power distributions.
As a result of the improved code, the discovery was made that the axial power distribution limits of Technical Specification 3.10.3 were exceeded by approxi-mately 12 percent for steady state conditions during Cycle 2. During transient conditions such as Xenon oscillations, the limits may have been exceeded by a greater amount. The attached figure shows the computed axial power distribution using both the old and revised INCA codes.
Cause This condition was caused by the use of an INCA code which did not give a good representation of the axial power distribution in the core region above the uppermost detector.
Corrective Action Use of the improved INCA code during Cycle 3 is expected to prevent recurrence of this condition.
- ~
Attachment to LER 78-008 Consumers Power Company Palisades Nuclear Plant (._
Docket 050-255 Discussion Recent revisions to the Incore Analysis (INCA) computer code have been made in order to more accurately determine the core axial power distributions .
.As a result of the improved code*, the discovery was made that the axial power distribution limits of Technical Specification 3.10.3 were exceeded by approxi-
- mately 12 percent for steady state conditions during Cycle 2. During transient conditions such as Xenon oscillations, the limits may have been exceeded by a greater amount. The attached figure shows the computed axial power distribution using both the old and revised INCA codes.
Cause This condition was caused by the use of an INCA code which did not give a good representation of the axial power distribution in the core region above the uppermost detector.
Corrective Action Use of the improved INCA code during Cycle 3 is expected to prevent recurrence of this condition.
!iii' t: i:"- rmnm i:: 41!1'*:.Lil* 1q, ~u:l_L! 11111I 111ti (IP lfll j'lll' l~I 1m**LL 1111 -I.fl 111 m1 . t11_1 l .iI Mlli'i I 1111111111111:~ I * '*t'
- 11111111 1
- *II JI:iJIJ 111' j*ll :u.1.\lj:), !lj! filt'i Iii! ![II @.Ufil!tl H'o t:tllli..,.;, ., 1 _..ill 1111 lli*.I l,1411;.1,1.
1 ljll :~.:l 1!i:! u;: 'i!! !~::.' ~-;~;.:.~.!.:.:~
.,J~1lljt:!l T~:':l'~'_::-:--8: ..... :.:c:.: .. ~ :l JI ijl!tjif- 'f~l
- 111 ,)f *I*!* ill Wt h'IW/ 1{J ti 1lfl ,L '.W 1ff * *J ~*11 ttt~ t~l' l*tl 1*\ "l* l**I ***11 mt !11* *'1* ti*! 1** .ell iq 1 'T Ml 1 **Ji Jtttt[f* !<IT *1"** r+tl .,,. l. 11 * ...... , ........ **
I ;
>:<tllUit:,;.L."
1 * * *' *I 1I I
- 11 \
- I *
- I I .* * -~ . *
- I. * . ** . . . . * . l-Lrf.11l I .*. : -I - ~ * .I ".t.1 . , >. * **
.l+L' r.~ I *If I 1** j . I 1I . , . , ~ .J. , I 0. tt~ I I>, . I, , ; , I It I 1. , * ', ',;, * , .* , , .. :
~-,,::q~~~- ::*:: ;:t*~ *; :.~-~~ r.*:~. :'.*~'. .Y ~*-:*i*~:~---4~: .:~'. !*:r:~ ;.*.*'. ~ -~ *~-~';*~: . : ~:i~ :::-i :~t-~ i!:l .:!:. :*!::: .'.~. *:~~- ;: ; r.~:-~ *:!~~ :*:;; :*:~: :*. :~ i~::/ i'.~* **:~:: '., .: )J+ ::::; ~:*:: ~~'.-~ ::: ~:~: ~: µ:~ ~:::;~~
\::-c1*i*- .... , .... "* *1'1 'l*t I' "'"I *"I"' l-1\ I.ti *"r* 1~1 "'1 lmL ..1.1., .* t,,
..;.0.:. ~}::; l!i.;_ 1~;.* l~I: -1.i.L JJ. i. L;. i:i
- lrl~ .LW ttt il.J l _* ~i. J: *,tJ1t. _u. *! *'
I lli't I -11+ tr" .ol, .; ..l..'i " *. ,J " " I'll '"' l,l, l .. ,.r Liq +i** 1..,. m'I
-lLiiJ.l ~i*\ t i :*;~ LW J~ .ilJ:~l i:*µ * ., ... l1:in ***n .. J, '"I" ........ , ..... ,.
~1-~1 ;! ! i :-l-i] *';: :* U~_;:~*2+Ht~ Lt *i .. r1i~ 11 ;n *f"l 1:1. ~JllL: . !_:_!_!Ji_ :.~~: .i_':. -~: ~LiL~ :..~_:_\.: __ :_..~:.:)_.~:.:
' .. L ' . '* ..
.,* ..; ti,' 1 * "I'
- I * ' ,;-r, I ' ,,* ' 'I'*..,. I.':;t'
'1.t~ Utl
"'"I r, I ltt!J, I I- t* 'H+ll
,I\ 'l'ti j J. I *'*'
'~*~ll* * ;~
1 **
- It t* *I-
+t 1
- I 'II I * "'*I I'**1*1 *I'. I l tit!1
, I- 'T:TI
.,[.., 1* . .J -~lttI
- It+l * -1 j*r1**t **-1-1 11 1 *".
1\:1
- ' ,, " "' r.;-:T '"'*Pl'
1 I j
- I .. I ! * . 1 * ! ,
.tl'* *1.1.
- t I I I 1 *'I' "' ' 1 'I 1 I 1111 l* 1t '1 1 1 I'" i111 ,,., ,,,,
I*" *]*' li,I 'r'!
I *
- I I.
- j,i. I
- ijt
\
- ,j l.J
- t*"
I I I
- I
- I
- I 1 ,r, I I' .... ' ' " '"' ,,
...,, '"t !'"'** **, . .' ....,. i*
~ . . I , . . * . , 1* * *
"td"'" *
- . . . , , , 1 . ,
- Ii<\
J.l\.'"'""'
rW 1"'"
~~i~
l*"J*.lt:'H1,
'to!
- .... *!" .. 11 ~'*~ .;_ ,, I ,1
- '*1* ...:,1 ;~* 11:* ITJ],tii'l
- . i: i~J, I' tl
- i.r**
" ' **i ill.!.U_:u: **LL~l-1., t 1 1. i!i!.t .... /~. ~- ~;c i:~ :1:i L i*** .,.,,
q1**1 I.... ,* * *
- 1*1 **'** *11*>1111 I I
.*ii 1I**
- +1i I ' 1-J r'"' **o
- t;1-l*:t.
I
- .n I**'~*-*
i ~I 'ii
.lfl
- ii .~I ,t;,
.1*.....
I It~-'**~-~*
- 'I* L'
,ti
.~I IJ l 1
.M..
, ~II f +'i' 1**-***
- l' I*
- i., u:* 'llifl 1g1 1
., 1" '* * ...
t
- _~J*1111~
- 4*
lt. ll\j I
+l!J
.1 U"t I' *-" !t*
- .I._."*'*-*~~
.\*\*I* !111 ***1 r* I ' ' "
t ! * , !-1
- 1~ I'.*
JIJ, 1*1* "1**111*" ,,L,.* ,,, '*1* p., L*1* d:; "*'!I .,1.f. fjl, I' .. 1.. 1 l.q I~ .... lo.I.*'
- l **I"~
~1 _! i1 *: *;t* :. ~11~,~~*:.-'.1t 11u.~~.Ji2-l:!it. ;l~i I.ft! -~n.t t:1_;LLUJ.LUl~ i:.t ;.J~ i:'.!.*~!~ ~.:1~;:._; ~~L~ ::L: ~:~~.
- 1! :.1 q
.i, 11~ .,,
1., ...
, .* ,~,,
" ' 111**'
1:* i~*
-11 ...- ,,, I*********
Tl*' ......,.. , .. ,........
......,, .. ,1 :Ii* . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
I.... .. ' '
- 11~1 * * **U. I.~£* Ji **t 1**1 11IJj"'-'*..11
1*-L* *1--1 1,ll ***1*1 ,_, *1**t-* *t>** .. ,1 ... , .,,.ti , ... ,.,., ,,,, "" 7'1T loll~.r.rll f'-L tt! ... ,, '1** **1* *r" ... ,~*** ... , ....... '*"["" .......
....... -' I 'I . jl;~ ti 'I; ~,,*ti. t~ 1.* .11.-* * -l'ii I*** ' ) , rI,\~ l Ii I i*****t<'
1
- tt" 1**1 ' 1"' .i,L, 1i 11 , ..!*, *1*' I'.,
6J . * .- - " ' * ,,..,,. , .,..
I* i"lll *
-I*
11 . .
I 1'*'"' I""'
~--1.*1 *'**1i*) ,,.,, ' t!,;*.
- l*r,.'. ., ,,.,.,., ., . ; "1*. j,_ .* ,~ ....1."- .'
- I*
- I .l. .
l--
- i--. pt*
- I cl.,.* !1.
I.
- f**1'*,' f-~ 1*111* 11 *' **l:t t ... *1.1*** ........
I .. I.
I .. * * , , . , ,
I *. 4 . J .
I I*
II***!'
ltl!
- 1***
.,,. _,,_,i. -*
- l. I.
ijll 1 ..
..,111' .o
.i .... ***.
I 11
,1. . .
.1,,
- I...
.. ,,' .... " .... 1... .
1 . . . . . ..
l t~iQ
'"it+,* ;iJl)W" ,~1::: 1,:: 1.1.I u~: *'.:~ 1H"J .:1 '1-~;:i'-'
]l'ill ~J** ~--1 .. 1* *: J'"t I[-~* : .. t:'*ffl 1'.. .'t*H*[~!:. .. .
11 . ij. !1-1
'1--L' '*fJ-~l'*t "I . .'~1:.. *t *:.:t'fl wti I.- '! "I t'J_ 1'*t. ;11 tLtt
,. '"' j:ilt *1*!*" Ljl; 1'Lil "t+**'t 41':1~ l~-t't*'*j.I.*tl*fj*#f:t1**t::
. ..J,:.1, 1~;J
.1t*!Pi!u1111 ':lt 1'.l1';lliJ!':ll'
'. .,I"***.' l*.*.:! :.i;;.'",: :1.! I*" :::; ;.::rn*1::: :.:;,8;:;1 1 , , l f
- I - i :- --;--"". r.1.Tt .,r,-* .1"': 1....... ~- .
!Ji.:~ !.-;, .~<! :.Ir~ 1~'1 1~: rt1,, 11:* **: . "
1:
!.U' . '~.!II *tH .,, . * ,_ *** ***'-I* ;.: . . .... . *~u. .U.1 .i,l.!.. ~* *. ~ ..*. l***:: ~*n ~*** . . . ..... . . . .*I*:. ,, .*... *"
Vi I !v-..fr*I*.i ;:11 .;:,~.!_.*w:
!**r
, 11; 1: JlO 11;* .
~
. 1
- h ~
111 (,\-:-Im*
Ti_.!I .. 11\"'
111 \'.. I.*
i . . 1 -
~
t
. "1 l\.;L.
tl*l r1 Ll l'I w*
.. L!.*, ,
1
- -It.. q l.
t n
. . .11:-Mt1
- I P , t - l i 1*******"
11.1 . , 1 11;'
.. 1
!q.,
- 1. , 1 1 l~
1 1
r :
..;d '-1**~
1111
.4:.:. :11:.
-~~**!.
i:ti', 1
+1.1:1jL .. ,. ... *J.!t~
- r*
", ,flt1.. .*
- rt,, 11 J.11* ::.!!
"'"7., ** 1;1il,r:*.,r;.t-;-7:-il1t-t"-::*~ .--:*;.7: ....
1 1 1: ll'.! ;::: 1:11 :11! ::., ::::
~-**
1
- **-IUH
' *
- 1 I l, * *;*~
I 1,1.1.
~Q'
- IGV*
'* * ' 1*I ~*-*'I' 1 *11*1 l'* Il41i! . "1,, I:~' l\ .... , I' tll'
~vi l Ul' tl' **111 j"'L I j ,,
- .I* .L-t t'1tt.~I ** I***Ii***
!I 'l
- 1 jil. t I' *l 'I I!*I - * *
- 1 If!. 'I 1+
- L . ..i I"'*1 11* *I* .. , I"'"~,,,,, 11 *I .11 j 1*11*I '* i'*"* ", !' I lllil; 11rn**I 1 11'I **f' **!I 1 '1
".i I!,* '"I 11*'* !* ..! 11',,"I'*"
IL** * * * * 'I
8 :.::.:.. .
~ffi *;; iNr~ ~-mi !ff!, ~-**
11"I*! :....!... '* **
1t Ur.;**
- j
- ! l*' * *I !
- t 1 1 t !* * , * *
- i;. * * **' ' ' " * * * *. , ..*
I ' un l1 *fu ** l*:i< .l-t ** ..j* 'i* j*1-ir 1* ,1111 t*tl \' *'1'11 11' "" *1" !* !"" ** '"'"'Iii*. 'I**, ... ,,.,,, ... . .:., .... * .. , ... ** * * *
- TI2
_:__ ~:.~ ~ t *t*'*. l:ti 4- uu.1.!;J.i.!l.U~ 1 11
I _1_ Ii**~~-!..!..:..~Ll-u.L:..:...:..r:l.H14.L..'....LLl.L::..: 11111 -.~-..:.:.:..:..:..:..::.:...:..~**...;
1 1 1
- 1. * .... * *** * ....... *i *1*111
- ': .i
- I* . * . r*,,c-,, I 1. f 'I *1** 11~ *t**** .. I -.~ 1. , *. LI !* ... ,.... 1.. J_J 11.f*** 1--j.LI ~ .1*-H LI I. 11rl'Ti'1' * * *, ...i .. I ~**! ***~* ~,;,. **~1* **-i* **i*: **Ir ; , * , , ,, ,. , **.* ****1*: ........ ..
1 t..,+ .!Ht., Ji., ** 1 * .111 tlti *!1; "1 1 1o,; ** ,, 11,. i 1J 1*** ii** ..*.
~.
mq@.Jil l"J *J** IL< I :!1 1 *lfa :Hi.!. wl f*.I t 111*111J H J,.t 1ttt *I*.rH iT' 1'
- -* * ' '* I '
- I ;"Iii I *
- t I I I i 11 -' * * *'
- 1 I* I* - .l
- I * * * .1
- I * *
- Ii-! f*l.I I I+** ..;.*.
- 1. . I, **** I * , Ii .L t , t , , t
- 1 * ,., 1 1,. I, *** ... ,,.
- I, , I,, I * , . . , , ! . , . , .* , . , .. ,
H-J !~;-~ :'f:.'.::.:;~i :;i:lf. :1*~ :;:':,:.~. :~ ~~.H17lj ;~ii~~f~:,::1 t-'*~j H.. ~ t* ... :~t*;tt~~:i*~ll:;**: '::: j-_;j_**.:j*;; ;:;.:. ~i ~;-:1.'.1*~; .;;:~; ;; :.;.*;.: 1 ~1 ~;!*; ~i;.; ;;;; ;~*;~ :*:;: :;;; ;;;: ;;;~ ;:;; ;*;:; ;~;; ;;:: ;;;: ;:~;
0 ::1 ;.. 1 1 1
H* ~:~ *111 ;:"') :J:'. **~ q~ 1 1 'li!; ,,(.. !4.diW .I~' I :i:rEli'i ttt! 1 flit' n It t. 1 t. Lldl:jtr+l
- t i. ii 1"*1iltt1*ll l,l1 ifl' 11~* 'II',. I tll, Ii** 1"' .. ,. "I " "' , .. , : .,,, *"' ,,,, .. " '" ..
fY:.;.b 1*
~p * .. :[J~Y.~ *=:~'.:;.:. :**.~ . i .. ; *:.:.* *,::* ~t:.~~: *;.. ~u ... 1-* .:*,. J:l~ 1 _..i _~i**;. 1.Jd+/-f.Hrrr t ,.~ ~ .* 1 ***!: ..: ,.. --~~j :;~ *~:;, ;::-;k{+~~-;f !"t+!~*;-;-~~_i-:-7 :-:-r-+:-:-:- :~-::--:+;.~i*~~.:.;.:- ;:.;c r *l*"r1 1**' 1** L11:1t 1 '1t tdl fr;_:. jtiJ *~1-l 1*rtl t~ -~t11- fft*1-~ "-1t J.l~.u L"J l*LLJJ11 .ti.,,., .I,~ ,,.1. ..1,, '"'
r:;;.:. rd t*.: :*:~, tt,~t ~tli
,.* 1. *;i., .;_v'~ ** *\l:J ltt+/-tl J-.i-j' _ ,:flt,t . . ._
- H1* 1**! 1l1....* 1111 ... ,. 1*;* , .. , .11, i .. t ,.. , :*** ,,,, , ....... ,,,, -~*: ........
1 *.~ 1*~, J t~~*iJ7:':-o -~* IP-1--*H*I* HI ***-t- **** ll1*
i'-\ 1 .1- ** :
1 +., I-!** 1q1 .... **I*!"* .. 1 .**** " " * - ! I I " " , . . . . 1 . . . . . . . . . . . , .. '.l'.'
. '* .u *. .'"'*,, ~,._~-.'* I~*.*~-*\*. ' "!1 I*f1J* IIJ+/-;.-
- t**1* jf l;.;, ~ *1*1
- .. , 1* T'i '11'It
'...* * 'm**-H1 '*[I' AA_.,illI* 11**111
.* * * "C:..
',, * *..11 **."'i"':1'. II' t'r*:u*H, * 't'* 1J * ***11 I ~.!**4' *1*1*1
+>- ti'* ' :t1.* *t
- i*1 **. *~,.1* t~lt
...h<*t :;.\ "'*1***,..'r l'IJ*1
- l't"*1.H1*1
'l ' 1 1 :ff '*t 'l
- tl* "I*.*"! **
- 1
- tt*r I '*! ! l'
....l i* 11* ":1*
ii !' ., I:i ....
t',, '..1,".......... ,,, 1* ';"*1_...........
I"* *, ... '* '* * .. * ,"* ....* 1***~
I .* , IJii *"* '*" i"'* " *'" .... : *" ...
.. * * * ... ..... * ** * '" ****~-* * *" .... * "**1 ,.... .. . -
~~;... ;q; ;,.: l~;I; 'i-'.-1, t~t' i '!';1 t 1'.!!l' i1~ t +,~;;, 'IJ'! .. Ill il'j ,, 1.1"11'11:1i *1:'1' 1 ~i1 1'1 IL' '[~i ~iLi ~itf I~: :1rt~;;; ;~:; :::: ;;:~~~: ;:;: :~~ ~~ r~: ::::F:~
L
~l,;.~1:in : 1~,~~'i\.:.: r\1 :*: :11 It : ;'1*
!1 t !tr :*u ..f *
'itt '1 Ii ;j, [. t1*1tt*
- I.rt lit' fj ti Jt 1:t1'.' Ii.I lli It. i II ilrl I*, Hti**. 11![1l11;t;; 1 *i; !ii :_!t* ;:i* *1*:: :::*
- +;
'::: !; 1; d:: :::; *::: :::: ;:;; ;;,!::.:~J::::_
- .-.u,.. titi*J*"' :~ *:*11:. . l i'i rL l*t*~ ' '.' :1:1. ':~ti :\:l:'* ..1-rt .:1.1*: i'IJJL~*11:1 1*'-' ;::: *w i'~ .~.lHr\! *I'
'\l"-1' hi ltd!/,: HI+
i!! ti!
- .jrf1t tr 1 u *
- t * ~ti :1H 1
- r tt:1+/-1H1 1 1h w dti 111 u 1 t.tt tl't .lt':I*' ftrl
- u !htt" IJt* 11* ;:*;:I!~'
1::1: "! r::: *t*: 1**:; ;:1: ::*: *:*:: :::: ;::: :;:: :*;:; ~:.:*: :;:;*::::1-
... , .,.t "
- 1*1. ...... , .. ;,, * . *" . . *" ; ...
Gri 11~'1:1i 1 :.;.; :l!I II: rfA 1 ~; :* 111/. f t..f 't'* : t ,:*,,[ :lL; .L' 't,l.U:. ~ '1-1u.1lT::l'L,1.,,. *1: r.11~;';*~-;~.J :~I bill ;tl[,;.;::; ;;;;
- f*J.Jtt!lti lff' * .V..J1 bili1v.:I tl11 Jt;! l
- 1tfJi: ** 1 :r1 * --H 1
- 1r h, L t 11:11 Fh1t I ~f! riLn Ji 1b' +t!c L ... ,. *I *Cl*
A' 1 ::-1 *'
- i~;
111*
- 1: :::r~f~ih~f:'Si :f: :~~~:
..... , .. ., ...... "'* ** 1 ,, ' ** * *" ....
~£~*t7i-<i ~~~t*r.~-. 1'~.;~I* ~~i~.*:*ttJ~~ ttt* 1~:1*-t*:*:*~1.!... :. ~i+/-~t~;"-. :~t ::t.i +/- . :-+ *J*~t+~*.1::: i11.l._ .*i-~~-~~tLtititLi;~:!Ttt;:'.~ti~::~~.t*~~t~.;~~f:;:;{f.Q.;.~;;:;.j~*i*;~*;; :~~~ ;;;~.;:;;~ ;_;;: ~-~;.;;.:;~ ~~;;.:;~~~
1
!Cl: ~14; ft! +10 t .. ,,, 1i1 1 l +1 ntt ,.,, 'i' 1 tl 't"tl J* '-1~**.r* t., -L'lJ t *+ ' ,, r l 1* 1::t*1*'" ITh rtn '*i]* ttiJ *rr! l:i"*' 1hr*Jr ... *~ '"-:1' ,!+; :1** .,.,,, *-**' "" ., ..... ,, ,.. , '"' ,,,, *'*' """ " .... , "" ,...
~ µ,.:.( .~ 1 ... '. i 1 -t*l :;.t.urj ~ .... 1i ~ ~,. . Lu.~..... , ..... _. !-f ... ri., .. ~n ti.: .* 111. q~ .1.~ **~1. '- ' .J.l:l..!. ~~~*:*:.;~: ;.:....:....:.~:.::~!.;...r...:..;..:...:...i~~ .:.....:..:...!..;.:._:_: _: .... ~
L- . . . , , ;
\.-
j;
.. , ""' *"'*t* .... \]"' rl "'*1*1 IT***1~ d1 11tLIC\" *11iil 1 i; 1' r~. !Ll* -i' iT.'..i
- ....,:. *
- i...f" * . I *"1 !*1"' t*"t l l :1 ..;.l I , l 1*~*[1t*t H11*11**** '1* -~
. L ti
- 1 ' ti-:. H
- 1 . . . Il . -
Jf **
I *.f.*
, 111** 1*1****, I**~ti
. * . ** . --1 I l *ijll'l!.!.'*-.11 1' ! , **1* ~I 1... I '"' 111*1*
bt .. IT' 1*' 1 *** ,, 1*-1 l fl-!-i':i **I* n* 1t 1*11t 1 j*:~1; ii* "*'i '*'111" .... ,t,,, .. ,, .... ***" *** ............. * .... ...
" . . , ~
- IL.
- . 1.,
- c,r1,
.j":.i I !'"111 *1*** ...... ~ ,,. ...<,', ... , ............................
. I I\-! l l 1 I** t * * '. 1 * * * * * * * * , * * . 1. I I.,* I* .. ~. , *.*.. * , .. . .
1__
L:~:.I. t: '.**,;,:.!:** *l ..
- 11:;,:**' 1 ~ *~,: !iL. l-._',*!I .: . .._"I.**.*:., ~ ::*.,*!::** .: ~:: t .. *: l**:;'!lll-;I: *:.~ ** 1 :*,;:*:: ;*,~~,.;*::.;l::;*;~.;~:::::*::::t::::::!:::::::::: .. * :::::*:er- r
\.., trd ,:j, 1 t :-- * :ti! ;t!: 1.l!j t.1iti4.tJ'f*I 1.11 ~.!I.ill~ .. , 1l11 tf:;1 t" r*.; 1+ :0 1 1.11ilt "'_ , ii 1
- i. ll1 1L l t1 fhl[L1 t 1 .,.d.t.I .q. , t-11H-1 .~ . . . .ll [. 1Ltl.H:.. l'~ -'HJ.. l.f:i.1. i4-i . :*1'!t ~: !t ;.tlJ ~ .. Lil; l~**!*!1H 1:11:1'11 -r. -!tlf.:. ..ll:! .I ::t 11.:; ! ~-, !* dtt rid 1ur i!.t1 ::~: ;*!1: ;:~: :: : : :::: 1:::: ::*: ::;.........
t**1* **'1* .;.~~ '*-****1 .** ~ *. ~t~1.,1.+it *. ~; 11-1. ****l..J....'.~:....:....:.:.: 1:...:...:....:...****
- : ::: :: . : ~~. .: ::1 * : l..J...
'I!
tl.;.. ..
t ~;-, I "1J J*I, r :1j'.ltr!t: L 1 !1 i r!J: 11 y i I! I ' Jt j {*'
~'.:*l~ *:h;:"~:*::~ijj~1,111;,:1_j' ,!~1.+I: *:f:~r!!. ~:
l -;t tt-. t.: 1 ..l '.t! ' *rfH** ]: I 11'* rt, iJ; Lj*1: t.! .i t'* *t-~r1.: 1;;:1 J ;*.'Ii: ~-i:; ; Iii i' t "1IJ1* '*~. r: u l; \! : : : : : : i: 0 ' : : : : : : : : : : : : ; : ': :I:~ : : : : . : .. : ' ........_,,
_I,
- Ei .~ u11:L. _ !l~ 1::it~~t1tL 1~t~1: :!!:.~~:r11:;'.'.J!f.*_:u~UL1;::*:;;:;:;;i:;:;::::::::::::::::::~::::;:~::::1:::'.Ko 5 1
- _L
\U !ill r]i1 .. r!Jrn* 1:1 :.. Ii-~. . H ll {1 {Tit llfr ~I l!1\~Jfl 1 1
"' ;.; ,. .JI t[I1 1,i*1 ,, .I 11* o .t' .1,It :;I m*-1_1* 1l. .L. *!: '* J*1 * . I 1:.
I
.; -i- lj!ijlll -II-fl tit
, L*ll j t\'I ll;l*1"+ff d. l Iii Lit. ill! ;IT.t 'l1it '.Hi l!it; rl.*: t;J; :I;-: 1::: :::; :1:: ;ii:*.::::*:::[,:::
I. :::.LLll:.:wli~~!.!.:.Jl;..'..'..!.LH.:.JJlLC:.:::,4;.: ,_:.:.*:.:.c ~
~
J ii.*!*
ntt u 1t lf!I q:t*. r.Jt. ill' .
- 1**11. 1.*.11 :1 t * . . . . * * :. 1.
1 1 *11* r,11x: rt:c~1r ff" '"lii *t t - .. ** t1i
- , .. *J1 **
~t:t*
- t .. 1
.J* . *I i- *1 f .;*j:J. -~L ,,:1 1*1-11 J; ~111 1 ., tu, JU 'IH!
- -1 1*_ . 1 .. ~1 1 ~1 *!1::11 l i.1rn1:t1-1 t .. 1n1* 1*a ti.I -~1 i;.:1 *1:.:
tlu u *1 11**1: *:*;: :;:; :;*:: :'!--'; *i!! ::;: :::* ;::: :;i: ::::
!:i: :;'.! ::i:o'.'b_~ 1;:: :::! :.:;: :::: *: ..
. :111 1[1 r111' ".I*
1!*
1
! I' 1*,r*," **ticl .ii, 11'111111 I,. ;*'* 'I
- I' i'I l!l 1rn11** I' ..'t .. -1 j .I *p*
,t, I -I I ' I> :*1' * *1 "di'11 *t- 1111:*11* 'I it* ., IJt \l1l_' illl' lil11l.i' ., !i11 ;;I: !!~,l~lil!lli**
1 ii 't;:: I::: iii!;;;:*;;; 11*: :::I!::!:*:::*:: ,t,, 111* ::*1; I' ,;:;::!:I"""'
\.:.}
_. T***r1***
- ;q11
!.H fi:.:t:*t;.:J*.L*ur.tt 1 ~*j ****c-
!/*pi+\J' l\J'll:H 1 * .1.
r**1.*t pt*t 1
- U J . .L~{[~I'
- 1
!"t-J*~.:L-m 1'
~j.*~*
t ., ,,
- l
'"L ~*L *r 'li'1'JL*11r1**!11i
.1. * **.
- ,.. *H* ii, .1.
- J :i.1*:1 i .,l*!* f *1r**.1:*J*-Hli ... (1< .. -t.t*tH1. ::t1tU.:.iH:.t.ldih 1 .!*1n.1:!:/:"!fi~i!li!f~!11.J.:~1~::!:::'.i1*'.::;;.;::::
- It-!* 11 . . JJJ.
- , +, '", !*" 1
" ' tf"
[U* **1r:i'Ji.:"*l**1""t'**~~ .. ,.,i".:7T.1*;., .. ::-:-:-:-:-~~~:.~
!*!* ,,.i
- "' , .. , ~
. . 1, .11.
!*v 'j~ ~' !" *1 * . 11 . . . . .
\\\
~
\.L l 'I" "!' 't1iA'*"1 11111* "'I I I "IL., .... 11t* ' *t* *tr.1 ' [111'11 *t t! l' ' I 'f' II tll r: 1*u:*I'>*\! l'I1 t *J'. l'I" l**'t I *rnt* t*' -*1'' .... ;,,I,,,,,,-.,,"" I':, .... :., .. "'", .. :,,, ***4*,',;*'."'.7'.'"'.'7:';*.IJ ~
~*.* ii:J f'Y:' 1 * *.flt *I Ii I I l I~,, I ** !
I~ ~ lj ~*
11.! !I I .
1 *l l 1
[.ft,Lil .
- 11 1!
ttl fii
- fll ,,, )
-~-:_1.!
I-
-'!*HI_ LI l :t' l
.
- I
- 1 .
...I ' I.Id Ii* ,,,Iii 11~-1 LI
- H I
JI
11 I
- . I
,.L:;
- 1 II
- !11 I I
,11.. '
- 11!1 !'
1*
1,'
1'*1 'I j ,
1.
I '1.1
- * * * * * *I
_:!_~i..:..:...:...; ....
- I: I
"::1
_:_:;.:..Ll~'
_:_~__: " ' '.... ~
, I,.
.... (\
ii 11 '1'1* r1itr'U lI I 11' j11fi 'll1*
- :*;.: i**ltl1 * .1 *t! H *rl .. " * "' **1 * * *** " "_.
i,tl\i 'I' I
ti::::'.* '. r: n:~.. ;;,,'I
.!,1: " r.. i['U .11 * '1.1 I i :ii I 4
'iffl ,*.111"' t~-1 j:;,,, *r~*' 01,:l'l'!i~;.. 'l1t 11 ' 1'
! ' I;, I' [j;; ,., ' r ' 1*1r1
" l1I Ut:*tt.i:
i'I; I .. 'I '.!J'1: ,,.,, ' i:*, I'11: fli'1 I .. , I. I ;;tJ , *111.;;;1' I'. ::;:I ..... .:'! I ' ::;:
.... "t: ' " :;t . ',I ()'.. !.::!\*:.:: . .. ,' '. .~::
' '.'." .. ' ("\ v
\..._
- ~*"
..I'1;1it1*
li '1*1 *11*
Lo
" ... ,, ;11 ii* I l l iJH~
1*1;:,,*,r
- 1 '('
- Yllt
!' 11i1
~*I~
- ft,I' I!"
II'"
LI.!
µH,tf'-' I' I: l ' 1* J.I'*.,,.!I' t I'ti**"
II
- !*l' H*.
lit!" 0
'i; fl
- ill ti-I!
I* !
.* l.I
't ~
i! 1-IH 1 . . .*ti*
,.i 1\~
w.. . I~-' !1!:
l*!I
' I..
. 1.
tt ' .
~ , L 1 .
t l l' . . l H I l1 '
.I
- I II.
.I
~!t "nlj
- llit.H.[I l L11 I',
..~
I*!*
+I I
1 j{j,
,,!11' ,,,,.
t-11.l ill l.11 I '
llOl.f tj I[ij' i:~ 11' i 1 'i!
I II li I ' I * ! II I I
'j l I"
~I i1 ' I ' l '1* ' .. * '
i::1 ni.::1:11:
IHll1' *** I d * " "
" I "
- 1;1; ;
- : I :;1 I' ' " '
"O
' I'
~::: :!'-
" ' l*..j
, _:_~:+..:.:....:.:
.. *: :!:: lJl
.**Hr-1"**.
~i'!r'!*;,: *~'.**1li;--**
- i1r 1 .,
b11-n 'Ii r* 1.j. .t'l.ll. .ti"*, , .*1"l:J
- t> . +r **+*el' H Ll1 *1* ,,* J *
'*i
" ' '** 11* J1 ** t I i *t***r1* * . . . **
- I
".ll ... 1****t* --~ II' I!'
'I' . *
- J' 1li'*'t'"l1::*
1 '*' l*rr: *
"' 'JI 111**'""*t .... r "ii'-i' r***'I 1"*"*11'""""'"'1'1"'1"'""'
' .
- r1 *1;'*t
- .'t'::->-;;;,
1 .,i, ........ -:-:-:* . .......
I ' " " ' " Lj' !* **'1'>*' *;I 1
- ~"'.-::::-
l:1 '~-~ *t'I :iJ. ij ~ t*j i -~ :. * .IJ' * .:~ ft~ ;j r: ...1*1 1~ j* .. ; *1 tl ~: :t;*t .;fl :'.1'1' '.,ii;;;:;:::;;:::'.~.
ffi' l**t /*,;Jt 'j:' 11 t ** " .t<: 1*1**'*: j;;:*;.J;;: j:.:: .. :. ;::; J-H rl' t.t* ti ..1*..~:*1 1. .1 11 :\' t d IJ I*
- r 1
- t i
- 1 1l:U t r h' I t: I 1J11 IT* 1 11' 11 11 .. ;11 *iil ::tj il*I i1 11 :~I 1i!i i!~! iii!
~f l*',* - .....~.~ .* . . -, * .. ! * . - _:--I*~.--. 1. . :1. **.:.. * ". . . ,** ,:***+'~+-~*~t+~;;'. ~,:,:'".'~:'.'..::~.;~
L t~ !:*!* 1nj
- ~~
- n.-:*:*::
it 1.qJ**H**
- .- :L~.:** trtl' i...i *. t~-l. :*:1.I .. ll. .*~
tj' !!::: 1
- . '~~:'.. *_ *_
~ t ~I fl
.~:111_*:t:, ,_fl..
rJ I ' *. II L1 II' ' II d ,_ *1r~~- :.1 .:'*. !*!.~_. . t _ l l rn*.. llJj . ... 1 11u1
- 1 fl q-1~* .t *+.. r~ t
- ~J ;~:
~1:1 ~t' .fl
~t~ .'. ;;~ ::*:: ::j~
1L11 1, .. *ill I"'
- !
- : 1**111, .. ,Iii tit* I.!"' .1 ..
,~;1 ~:::*'.:*~~ :::;~:~: :;:'.+4irJ)
[:/,t I.,.'
lf~t! tlli i*tltt ..i.~r..J.t Hi ll]. !ti, I i*t ITr.1HlliH.~1rtJl.
- l *1 *
- .._~..
iJL tr!
- 1 ~1
.:rL
- ~:1 1 . *iJ, l:J 11 " 111-1 t*. Ii I 1- t*. J !lr~ .i*t 1*1*1 .. 11111- *1 [lll tt1111:. j.l.,l1'*1 .. ut,,:111 f'** *ii* *_*I* **ti.,,~,,., t....... ,.,.,, ...
t
- li1 .. J-*~-H, J-t .i~u.:-t-l *~~** : ~!* 1 :.1i~.1 _.... l~J~1 :U1 .;'"f .. tf:t~~1J~11*t..~**w.tli:1 :!.*11~i! : 1,l ;l:I: ~i.:: Q:: :*1; ::..::
llt1'11't.'t1Jn1fi" r:H pr111q *:r 1:1J** lr . . .lit .. ! *'-* 00 i~ili~. ti H rltthlJ *l tli1lw11:111~11 :;~'::':,) ~rnm
- .
- :t*~ :, .. :;:.1 i1:** ; .* : *~*.* ,,:~~q
'H t : fl Li
- ~
I 'rt. n ' ~.:~*,** -~. ~.
I HJ-t It
-.. . 1.1 1 .:~. 'tr tJ J Ji ti* i 11 i
/:;I"*': ;~t*:*:-i-: ;:':-~.. ',*/:,. :::~j tifj !
- .;*:.1 ...... *~.. ~~**I*** :;~._j*:-~ 1.1~*'.~":.11:'.: :::~ :;.: '.::: :::::.:::::-~ill~:'.: ::::N IJli rtj ::::i:::! :1!! ;-:;-;-
.1 ;.1::* ..
"I' " , ,
1 ililJ.l.*
1
"" *0 1 11!*1 '*i' w I**"
t.. f!t ,,;: i 1J.ltiti 1
1 l*llftti'l ['j' fil'1!1*f lil i"*.
l*ftl L11!i,. '~dt1 1 Li' **11* I,, t1:L*-1I 11 1***1-IL" "fl *I" .;I, 1l'lt hi:
L* *~I!
... : l **
J t * * ~~~;LI t,. 'fil' 1.J+fmllj::j:c:_U,Lllil.;.i:.ililll.i_ .. :~_: 1 1:1: 11.1 ;,, !_Ji .;1: ! ...I .,1: ::: . .'...'..:.'.~~~.:~:.:~ .:.:: :.0.'."1 c::i'..:.:.:
' 1' *I' .t.I .. ,. t.1* 11* 111 ' *1***~,
- u' lttt I"' II*;'1 .,.t ,.J-!J*l11l1-l11., t1l1* II i *.*1* ""I"'**.* .. '
' fi *\ !+~ :lJ ~ **~! .:.:.:L: Jj.:_v-~L:_:.~ ! *O .. I .. .
jL¢ L I
- Y
.. '1*** .. ,. **1*1 '" :1,htH11
- I:: !:I :!d !I;!!!:!
- l *
. '!" llilt illl t;* . ,.
'
- iI . '. !t ,, I Ill I 1lt.
I
!fLJ .:i: I dt I I
- !l : 1, 11+h1 I * ' I l.i:
' ! JJ ti l I -
I 'lJ
- I 1**
J!Jl .
H1: .
I l l t*
j L! 1t!lI .:!: 1:;: ::!! *::! iii! 1!11 L!! 1:1!
- I : ' ! I " I I . I I " *
- !!: ~ t::! 1::: :!:: !11 1 1!f:
I * * '
- I I ti" 1**1 '"' ! 1*11;
' I
- I ' ..
1111*: * ,.,,
1!;: :: 1 ::*; ,**<.:...
' 1' .......... "'
! : ' I "
- TT"' ...
'C i'~'.I"'
- . '*-'**f '***1 !r'I 'I' ~*,1 I"'
11 141** 'I, tjll " I !' titt* *1f'1 t;**11*1**; l: t l I 1111 '**q.; *1*1 I'[It ti ' I j'! 'I"I'I 11' 11I,,,,
1 :1 .. 1d1.1 1>i1. r:1. il:itii. nt..i1 ~*1,1*i:.!~*:t!~.J~;::1~Jl!-~J...!:.:Jl: .. :.il~UU!l': 1 :i;ilii..l!...:lL!lL~'.-:...:...~*:~.L~.:~.:.:~~~:.:~-~- t.\.... :. f:.:.:
' I L*1* . t"I .,, '*I*'; " !... ' ' ' *1**
' " ,'"I .. I'" '"***I,.' t**' 1*11 t'*' ,,,, ,,,, ... .... ,,, '1,,,,I'"' 1' .'; ' .. ' '"'_. , ..... f' ' 'n1 1**j . " ',, " 1111*.!.ll L4.z.'*iLlJJJ_Ji.
.~. .~ti 1
1r11;*11tt 7
'-*. J:t;mi~
- " "r l"t ...1 ,,,. **,*1 *** 1 " !*** 1111 1 l* *11 * * *;II 1 1 1 *' "'*1j ,,_,1 1*.1t* 11i * * ' ttH r.:. *1 ; H++ 1 1**1711* 1 ***1 ... i ... , ,, ....... *1I * ,, ,,,,
tr,, *1* .,., 11** *'*' *1*1 *1;*1 i1*1* **** L.... ,.. ,,1. "* * **i
,,,, ... ,,,........ * ... *I* .. * * *
- O,. \;. .
j0
~ I* ' I
- i h !*** ... ~..... ,. ilt;
! I I
- I I
. l *rr
- I l
- 1** 1i.,
I
- I I
.1. 11'" *;'" .,J, 11 ~I .
t * **
- II-
- I I~*
I I
1J 1* [ 111.. 1-+ :i)I ._
i-ld-~i-u*
.,ltl .~"'"
1* I
"' 1lj1..*.*. 1*'rii* 111.* iii*.. [ll1 I I ii 111:: ,_;i~
I ,
,r11*.*.Ii, I ~ I
- ' l,i. ,,., ;* 1. i1l1;1***
it1*
I o.
I , 11 I I t.
,.1.
I * , ,
,
- I '
- 1
. I , , 1 1"' .,.,
1., I .
l*1*
1 11
, I .
' * , 1
- I**
- i " *~**
1 tvt. O *_L:...:.........:. .. , *
. 1 , ,
-i
- u Ot919P
--*--*---*-- -,,._~--~--,.--*--*-,.....---,.........---:------*----*---.--*---~---...------------,--------------*~- .---*--*-*".-.--.~---......_ __:. ______ ~.---~-----.---~****c-<i-::---:c"-:l".....,..,...,_.~--~--;** --:---.:_:-_:~**-***-*-*-** *---*- --~---~ ..-----r-~~**~----*---* * 'l'l:J 5?. X Bl
.. *y*s n NI lOYW '0:'.) U3SS3
~3J.3W IJlN3::l 3fU O.t 01 X 01
- ig ,3.!f.:ln3>4 ~
- '},'""n!
u
\fi(IJ