ML19327A323: Difference between revisions
StriderTol (talk | contribs) (Created page by program invented by StriderTol) |
StriderTol (talk | contribs) (StriderTol Bot change) |
||
(One intermediate revision by the same user not shown) | |||
Line 17: | Line 17: | ||
=Text= | =Text= | ||
{{#Wiki_filter:o & | {{#Wiki_filter:o & | ||
W's . | W's . | ||
.e | .e | ||
% ') | % ') | ||
. : ,s. | . : ,s. | ||
/,, , ~ . - | /,, , ~ . - | ||
h | h | ||
, ,.e= , . - ~ -2.'.*e - ,. | , ,.e= , . - ~ -2.'.*e - ,. | ||
Line 30: | Line 27: | ||
. _ . s r - -. =. | . _ . s r - -. =. | ||
~,=, | ~,=, | ||
s..- | s..- | ||
. . . . . - . - - - - . . . . , , , , - , . -m - | . . . . . - . - - - - . . . . , , , , - , . -m - | ||
Line 39: | Line 32: | ||
, , , . w -~ T l .9 ..- .. 4 7 r | , , , . w -~ T l .9 ..- .. 4 7 r | ||
., A | ., A | ||
_,m, . s = == } | _,m, . s = == } | ||
.. s ; | .. s ; | ||
0 k,4s g ..S. | 0 k,4s g ..S. | ||
t | t | ||
/ | / | ||
... 2 ./. .=. 2. | ... 2 ./. .=. 2. | ||
,i ' sg~- '. '~ ND*+,". , | ,i ' sg~- '. '~ ND*+,". , | ||
s, | s, | ||
.k e | .k e | ||
.. b. a, '.' .4 . . w .4 2 . ....-..-.2.;. .es ..7.'2,,.,.._4- .. w / | .. b. a, '.' .4 . . w .4 2 . ....-..-.2.;. .es ..7.'2,,.,.._4- .. w / | ||
1 | 1 | ||
..C w X 3. | ..C w X 3. | ||
. =?V . | . =?V . | ||
'i * .,2 w | 'i * .,2 w | ||
.'.s.,, | .'.s.,, | ||
-...y,..., .; 2. ., | -...y,..., .; 2. ., | ||
_. .) | _. .) | ||
s | s | ||
'?,,* | '?,,* | ||
s' *e1.3 . .*;. . ~4._...a._- : - _1 1.- D | s' *e1.3 . .*;. . ~4._...a._- : - _1 1.- D | ||
.. s ,.W e .. | .. s ,.W e .. | ||
/ | / | ||
-w4w . | -w4w . | ||
-. 4. | -. 4. | ||
Line 82: | Line 59: | ||
.** .t . 4 L. e . s O,. n.'s b ,11.% .w _ .78 .17. l'O. i L 7. O n 4. 2..~..-*. | .** .t . 4 L. e . s O,. n.'s b ,11.% .w _ .78 .17. l'O. i L 7. O n 4. 2..~..-*. | ||
O L J.v.......--.-O | O L J.v.......--.-O | ||
.c. | .c. | ||
s.--.s m f s. _n .' | s.--.s m f s. _n .' | ||
n .~g . . au | n .~g . . au | ||
. .,.m o_ | . .,.m o_ | ||
,,v.. | ,,v.. | ||
Line 93: | Line 67: | ||
~~...r3 | ~~...r3 | ||
-..t..su..; | -..t..su..; | ||
.o _. 2 1. 4 ... 4 . . 2. _ f. - ._ . _ = . . . .= . . - | .o _. 2 1. 4 ... 4 . . 2. _ f. - ._ . _ = . . . .= . . - | ||
3 a ....w2,. 3 7.C. - ., . -. . - | 3 a ....w2,. 3 7.C. - ., . -. . - | ||
3 | 3 | ||
..- w . a. k.. 3. .' _e .,s.3 | ..- w . a. k.. 3. .' _e .,s.3 | ||
. 3. 2 ,.. . %. 4 . -:3.. 4. 4. . . . . | . 3. 2 ,.. . %. 4 . -:3.. 4. 4. . . . . | ||
_1 2 2 ...a. . . , | _1 2 2 ...a. . . , | ||
.w _4 . . . .2.. ., .,. 2. . .3 4,. _w4. .- -, ,C u g:-.y fw ...- | .w _4 . . . .2.. ., .,. 2. . .3 4,. _w4. .- -, ,C u g:-.y fw ...- | ||
Line 109: | Line 77: | ||
.a | .a | ||
- _2_ 4 _7 _4.; , r. w. | - _2_ 4 _7 _4.; , r. w. | ||
.s . -..a. | .s . -..a. | ||
2- | 2- | ||
..4 -3. A 7 s. _. 4 . s-,. , m- _,. | ..4 -3. A 7 s. _. 4 . s-,. , m- _,. | ||
. . ,c-..._4 - | . . ,c-..._4 - | ||
.o . | .o . | ||
: e. .m ..X.w. 21.,..c. -- .. a , w ., S ...C \. m. C | : e. .m ..X.w. 21.,..c. -- .. a , w ., S ...C \. m. C | ||
: e. , _ | : e. , _ | ||
. w, | . w, | ||
_w . . s. 2 -- | _w . . s. 2 -- | ||
A _4 e .. 4 o,, n -s w . 2. ; e 4--. _4 ,., . . 3. _i , . _4w.. ,, ,, s.. . , _, . r. m .a.K.4. 2 ,w, S -s _- | A _4 e .. 4 o,, n -s w . 2. ; e 4--. _4 ,., . . 3. _i , . _4w.. ,, ,, s.. . , _, . r. m .a.K.4. 2 ,w, S -s _- | ||
.- ,n C o--A e .e | .- ,n C o--A e .e | ||
_m u. .s _. ..u. m- . . E,a, c...._C s i .. . .a- _- 2 1. 2 . .2 O ..2.~a_--a | _m u. .s _. ..u. m- . . E,a, c...._C s i .. . .a- _- 2 1. 2 . .2 O ..2.~a_--a | ||
. - 4..b 4 c b. . | . - 4..b 4 c b. . | ||
.a. gy m . 2..-=,.s-,; ~.a. | .a. gy m . 2..-=,.s-,; ~.a. | ||
-c . - | -c . - | ||
_ .n. _ s e c. 2. . -i | _ .n. _ s e c. 2. . -i | ||
- ..2..- e .m. ,. _e_ o- .,gG | - ..2..- e .m. ,. _e_ o- .,gG | ||
"''._'a~ | "''._'a~ | ||
^ - ' ' " | ^ - ' ' " | ||
* * *.C o a d .i ."." ~~.. V. | * * *.C o a d .i ."." ~~.. V. | ||
fw w" .". w w.' . e .# .". ~. o- '~'<'G .". "- " , .' 1 # -u | fw w" .". w w.' . e .# .". ~. o- '~'<'G .". "- " , .' 1 # -u | ||
" ~'' _4 V " _7 _'-;"" O .CWe" . .U"C;'3"~ | " ~'' _4 V " _7 _'-;"" O .CWe" . .U"C;'3"~ | ||
(nw/ =. e n | (nw/ =. e n | ||
.. . . .J. a -37 aC - 2 C .4 -s- | .. . . .J. a -37 aC - 2 C .4 -s- | ||
Line 155: | Line 107: | ||
.- .=. e c, K' o<- | .- .=. e c, K' o<- | ||
. ,w. - .i. 4. --3 4g . m. | . ,w. - .i. 4. --3 4g . m. | ||
w _4 m e v~.,. ij.. w eC*uSG C# ' s s~ v'' ' .' .= _ _# ."4 3" ^,, ^. S '' S " _4."'. ' b. a | w _4 m e v~.,. ij.. w eC*uSG C# ' s s~ v'' ' .' .= _ _# ."4 3" ^,, ^. S '' S " _4."'. ' b. a | ||
% , w, -..a s ,_-, , ,.-~. 4 w., n O .a s u.a. e. 4 .~..~..G | % , w, -..a s ,_-, , ,.-~. 4 w., n O .a s u.a. e. 4 .~..~..G | ||
. .,.. -, C .4 _4 _4 _ y. ., _ u., | . .,.. -, C .4 _4 _4 _ y. ., _ u., | ||
s 4a A, 4 : _:_4 , , . -_1 a,.. | s 4a A, 4 : _:_4 , , . -_1 a,.. | ||
_O | _O | ||
_y _ , , | _y _ , , | ||
v- w ..w. a _4ye 9 a--a-a - :-w- ..'.,c | v- w ..w. a _4ye 9 a--a-a - :-w- ..'.,c | ||
Line 171: | Line 119: | ||
-, y..a.,ge | -, y..a.,ge | ||
.- w | .- w | ||
..eu_,y . y _o:.__-.A -- . , c. . , . ._4 ~.,. g . | ..eu_,y . y _o:.__-.A -- . , c. . , . ._4 ~.,. g . | ||
_. _=..e., cw | _. _=..e., cw c.g4A- e _ 4-..c. | ||
c.g4A- e _ 4-..c | |||
~ y _ ., __n_e_., _4.v . _ ,- . ,- 4 .,.. | ~ y _ ., __n_e_., _4.v . _ ,- . ,- 4 .,.. | ||
-- .w - - - - - , w_= - b.e | -- .w - - - - - , w_= - b.e | ||
- c v- .m _4 . . _4 ~.. ' - _u _' a_ s C . . | - c v- .m _4 . . _4 ~.. ' - _u _' a_ s C . . | ||
, , _ __4.- ., A - ,_ | , , _ __4.- ., A - ,_ | ||
m~. . m-. , _4 ~.,.g .3--,_,_4 w...-.. ., n. _ .o- _4 .- -w | m~. . m-. , _4 ~.,.g .3--,_,_4 w...-.. ., n. _ .o- _4 .- -w | ||
Line 193: | Line 133: | ||
-- # e _" w^ ". | -- # e _" w^ ". | ||
* b.e C. " e S ' _#u ^ n C .# | * b.e C. " e S ' _#u ^ n C .# | ||
_. w | _. w | ||
.. .y._,..., e. -.ege - ... -- ..,.. - . . . . | .. .y._,..., e. -.ege - ... -- ..,.. - . . . . | ||
j '---~------- -~ ' | j '---~------- -~ ' | ||
THIS DOCUMENT CONTAINS | THIS DOCUMENT CONTAINS | ||
Line 204: | Line 141: | ||
i 8008060 m b0 / - | i 8008060 m b0 / - | ||
1 | 1 | ||
.S , | .S , | ||
l l | l l | ||
Line 220: | Line 154: | ||
. -4.m w.._ 4.w.. . | . -4.m w.._ 4.w.. . | ||
w ...a- u.,_. ws-- a m _, | w ...a- u.,_. ws-- a m _, | ||
. .%a.c. 1g----_, 2- | . .%a.c. 1g----_, 2-u- .. .. 4., a.a-w - 4 r. ( n o.. c.swco me n. ww n- 4 a _1_4w-. -a n.g _4 ..n c g a _4 ..gc , _ u. g | ||
u- .. .. 4., a.a-w - 4 r. ( n o.. c.swco | |||
me n. ww n- 4 a _1_4w-. -a n.g _4 ..n c g a _4 ..gc , _ u. g | |||
-- sa-- | -- sa-- | ||
.m..._4 - - 4 4.,. ") ; y . | .m..._4 - - 4 4.,. ") ; y . | ||
.a .n s my .. a - . _- | .a .n s my .. a - . _- | ||
e.x.a.. . . . | e.x.a.. . . . | ||
'_".a. # 4 .". _= ".C .4a .i ~ .- | '_".a. # 4 .". _= ".C .4a .i ~ .- | ||
__ ". a _i _d _# _4.-- = _ _4 ^.".S ^ | __ ". a _i _d _# _4.-- = _ _4 ^.".S ^ | ||
w _# ". a. = "r y" _1 _4w-^ = .". . = | w _# ". a. = "r y" _1 _4w-^ = .". . = | ||
-_"=. | -_"=. | ||
_4 .".vo _' ", a. d. . ". .'~. e .# a~ S "w e v^.# . .' .". = .". C .d = - _i ","w = .' .' _# _4 . = . _4 6.". w S, _4 .". ' . " - _ " " . . , | _4 .".vo _' ", a. d. . ". .'~. e .# a~ S "w e v^.# . .' .". = .". C .d = - _i ","w = .' .' _# _4 . = . _4 6.". w S, _4 .". ' . " - _ " " . . , | ||
was raised by MVPP in 1975- Dr. FankhauSer has damonScrated , | was raised by MVPP in 1975- Dr. FankhauSer has damonScrated , | ||
nothing wh1Cn wou_3C Crovi,e CCCd CauSe C # new Contentions aC | nothing wh1Cn wou_3C Crovi,e CCCd CauSe C # new Contentions aC | ||
: b. _4 a - | : b. _4 a - | ||
: 1. s._ .s -m.g _i ;. . 7a'" AS.c.' -- . | : 1. s._ .s -m.g _i ;. . 7a'" AS.c.' -- . | ||
# S"- | # S"- | ||
Line 253: | Line 175: | ||
.41y , | .41y , | ||
a c, 3- _4 . s e %. 4 .7 . | a c, 3- _4 . s e %. 4 .7 . | ||
T. | T. | ||
_ .w.e o. | _ .w.e o. | ||
--m wyvs eA. c. w .. .. 2.. _._4w.4 . S | --m wyvs eA. c. w .. .. 2.. _._4w.4 . S | ||
.*wa | .*wa | ||
+ - ~ **4 h _ .. .bru._v yo ,4 | + - ~ **4 h _ .. .bru._v yo ,4 3 | ||
3 | |||
. e. y Spd. Cw..sa .. r._4mna- w ' (' s ) | . e. y Spd. Cw..sa .. r._4mna- w ' (' s ) | ||
(% | (% | ||
so) a.. A. 9 ,S a e _v. . .. _ %. s .. _..%. - - | so) a.. A. 9 ,S a e _v. . .. _ %. s .. _..%. - - | ||
- - .S . .- | - - .S . .- | ||
ww. ... wC . _4 w n , C r e . s u_ _: O., . ... a _4 . . . n . . .2 . - . -.. | ww. ... wC . _4 w n , C r e . s u_ _: O., . ... a _4 . . . n . . .2 . - . -.. | ||
2 A | 2 A 2 | ||
we Cwi...- | |||
4 m a _4 ,n.4 - | 4 m a _4 ,n.4 - | ||
3 | 3 C# w S~oo~ C# "#~~.e" u *** "'^w^ w *.._ | ||
C# w S~oo~ C# "#~~.e" u *** "'^w^ w *.._ | |||
* ~;. * . " -. **. C' _"g"-_"_. | * ~;. * . " -. **. C' _"g"-_"_. | ||
'_* | '_* | ||
* v _' =_ w C# _ ' '~. e | * v _' =_ w C# _ ' '~. e C w^ .c a ' / ", e ".. a. .#. .# . $ | ||
C w^ .c a ' / ", e ".. a. .#. .# . $ | |||
m.7 a.' v S .#S | m.7 a.' v S .#S | ||
, _ ' . " .'..b. e '.s _' .~. ~. 8 .". | , _ ' . " .'..b. e '.s _' .~. ~. 8 .". | ||
Line 290: | Line 200: | ||
--- .r. C W e V a_ _* , _'~.- a S e "y_" w*"y C S e d w^ w ^ .".. ' = .". w ..#..^ | --- .r. C W e V a_ _* , _'~.- a S e "y_" w*"y C S e d w^ w ^ .".. ' = .". w ..#..^ | ||
* S y"e " | * S y"e " | ||
ur- ,Ce.. | ur- ,Ce.. | ||
h ... ,2. _1 e,A3..*. | h ... ,2. _1 e,A3..*. | ||
=.a .4 . . s . w w m_4C Co nS _4Ce . a_._4w4..S 4.._4 -w .m._. a _4 . _4._. r.4 RC | =.a .4 . . s . w w m_4C Co nS _4Ce . a_._4w4..S 4.._4 -w .m._. a _4 . _4._. r.4 RC | ||
Line 299: | Line 207: | ||
. ' " . " . " a~*..". C .a .. **r.^,gn.'..'.*A uhn aw .d'n e u.G C.- ..O *w nC,C14 u_- 7 C%. o. _* | . ' " . " . " a~*..". C .a .. **r.^,gn.'..'.*A uhn aw .d'n e u.G C.- ..O *w nC,C14 u_- 7 C%. o. _* | ||
4-a _78 - | 4-a _78 - | ||
-.C S *. 1_ _:_ = _4 r _4 a. .n. . m v E CCnC m .'- *~ ~ *~*.*.S .#C" . S " "yy" _7V .# .".C, m. _i s_ C .* .' ". " ' S e _" ". #. " *- 's. ^ -' C ._d _' _i ."y ' .S 1 | |||
-.C S *. 1_ _:_ = _4 r _4 a. .n. . m v E CCnC m .'- *~ ~ *~*.*.S .#C" . S " "yy" _7V .# .".C, m. _i s_ C .* .' ". " ' S e _" ". #. " *- 's. ^ -' C ._d _' _i ."y ' .S | |||
1 | |||
.. #~ __. / | .. #~ __. / | ||
w S *. *.". e ." S -a C u 'o o~ #-- #a _4 ".a~ ."* C, U.' a '.C _"Y, s4 " _" _' S d #w" .#w... ^* | w S *. *.". e ." S -a C u 'o o~ #-- #a _4 ".a~ ."* C, U.' a '.C _"Y, s4 " _" _' S d #w" .#w... ^* | ||
s fC.e '".a--" 0 " *** *w *. . ''".e "" .* a* w.'. | s fC.e '".a--" 0 " *** *w *. . ''".e "" .* a* w.'. | ||
~*"*- | ~*"*- | ||
-_3=d'^ . n' "yC, _l _4C '.". '. ' .c "" | -_3=d'^ . n' "yC, _l _4C '.". '. ' .c "" | ||
Line 314: | Line 218: | ||
As a u*.b. s , S *..= . a. ." a a. a.k .i .". g ." =. "g "- .' ." =...e .". . a- | As a u*.b. s , S *..= . a. ." a a. a.k .i .". g ." =. "g "- .' ." =...e .". . a- | ||
- " a--" a_ ", ev_ C .". A. [ '". a,. | - " a--" a_ ", ev_ C .". A. [ '". a,. | ||
1/' m..k. e S .we n a . ,u. . 4SSt,e O.e .a.b.e . _ w.o . | 1/' m..k. e S .we n a . ,u. . 4SSt,e O.e .a.b.e . _ w.o . | ||
-- u..h. e a*..,C .1_4 2.. u. _ia- .. a 4 .,. 2 n_ | -- u..h. e a*..,C .1_4 2.. u. _ia- .. a 4 .,. 2 n_ | ||
: c. 4 .a .l l,y C,ua.l .d .#.4 ed *.C C"".S*_*""*. . w .'.".d . y" e _"..'..". a a "CCiea." | : c. 4 .a .l l,y C,ua.l .d .#.4 ed *.C C"".S*_*""*. . w .'.".d . y" e _"..'..". a a "CCiea." | ||
raci3.ty | raci3.ty | ||
. . . . C | . . . . C | ||
. i . 15 anot.ner matCer, wh1Cn 15 CISCuSSec Ce3 Cw. | . i . 15 anot.ner matCer, wh1Cn 15 CISCuSSec Ce3 Cw. | ||
h* | h* | ||
_ _m _ | |||
-.. ,.e - | -.. ,.e - | ||
_ 3_ | _ 3_ | ||
e 'ol - | e 'ol - | ||
.k =-.".. " | .k =-.".. " | ||
"..C .- ..wb.a _- ".. 3 ..*. - = S . " w e " #ww... y .= . . "f v.4..c. ( ". v . w-. . a. .. . a .- ; "; | "..C .- ..wb.a _- ".. 3 ..*. - = S . " w e " #ww... y .= . . "f v.4..c. ( ". v . w-. . a. .. . a .- ; "; | ||
: 3. 3 . .V. ', T.* . _4 . 1}, _ 1,-7 1] _ '' :w t M,9 * | : 3. 3 . .V. ', T.* . _4 . 1}, _ 1,-7 1] _ '' :w t M,9 * | ||
, ". sO. .r.' } " 9. ,, | , ". sO. .r.' } " 9. ,, | ||
. /. (' ', | . /. (' ', | ||
- Q , g } ,. L .? ^ | - Q , g } ,. L .? ^ | ||
m y s. .' a. .. | m y s. .' a. .. | ||
- . C' | - . C' | ||
? ? s r ..._4 - ? _? _* s_.a _4 .e.e n . s.y- .*m. | ? ? s r ..._4 - ? _? _* s_.a _4 .e.e n . s.y- .*m. | ||
- - -. ow -g. | - - -. ow -g. | ||
? 2 1. .j . | ? 2 1. .j . | ||
% %. w e .11 .1 2 e. a. .s. _. 3 _7 _1 . . .. , ". ...a | % %. w e .11 .1 2 e. a. .s. _. 3 _7 _1 . . .. , ". ...a | ||
. . 4 . | . . 4 . | ||
9%)-, ~Tm e * | |||
(TQ-=% | (TQ-=% | ||
u | u | ||
- . A.e .M _ 's=s .1 , .; v. e .%c. ~*1, | - . A.e .M _ 's=s .1 , .; v. e .%c. ~*1, | ||
/n_ **3 Im \. t 6 / . m..w%. . , a , _..%.w a %ne w. m..m.._4a. _ | /n_ **3 Im \. t 6 / . m..w%. . , a , _..%.w a %ne w. m..m.._4a. _ | ||
a _4 . . .-.w2A | a _4 . . .-.w2A | ||
_4.a _. =c2-4. --a %.* "v2. | _4.a _. =c2-4. --a %.* "v2. | ||
"*Ca s .".~. .' ': '." .a._l d s..k. e s | "*Ca s .".~. .' ': '." .a._l d s..k. e s | ||
w - | w - | ||
Line 364: | Line 255: | ||
: m _.u.o ; at . co,-__= | : m _.u.o ; at . co,-__= | ||
~_ n 3 3 -3 g.41_4 .,y 2'*"ya*2 ** *_ | ~_ n 3 3 -3 g.41_4 .,y 2'*"ya*2 ** *_ | ||
4-a ... ** .#.".S u _# _# .# 2" 4 ..*.".w baa4 S _#C* . 4.".".*"- | 4-a ... ** .#.".S u _# _# .# 2" 4 ..*.".w baa4 S _#C* . 4.".".*"- | ||
ye.n. _4w.*-, -4 . v. 4 .C .'. _#Can3.4 c,. y _em.,C e e C' .4 . c, 3 . | ye.n. _4w.*-, -4 . v. 4 .C .'. _#Can3.4 c,. y _em.,C e e C' .4 . c, 3 . | ||
.c e e c_ e n a-- "a _ _ V_ 3C ** | .c e e c_ e n a-- "a _ _ V_ 3C ** | ||
'' _ ' ~" ". w# | '' _ ' ~" ". w# | ||
c :-. | c :-. | ||
: w. a. a_.__i e _' s c . _4 . C o. ..y 2 | : w. a. a_.__i e _' s c . _4 . C o. ..y 2 | ||
_ - ._ .... (o. m. .w k. .i e. -y__4 | _ - ._ .... (o. m. .w k. .i e. -y__4 | ||
.; c .*t. L.wm _is. .m .- 3_7m . - .., | .; c .*t. L.wm _is. .m .- 3_7m . - .., | ||
L.ni S ,- anC . | L.ni S ,- anC . | ||
.), | .), | ||
4 | 4 ca. | ||
ca. | |||
.n | .n | ||
/0-44, | /0-44, n | ||
n | |||
yRC | yRC | ||
.4 o.,p., , | .4 o.,p., , | ||
o _, ,, ( .3y/. ..g). - | o _, ,, ( .3y/. ..g). - | ||
Jee 1_SC | Jee 1_SC | ||
.A. . g 3 __ w.. e . .._: . ._ _. 4 .. . a.- 0....a.e " " .*w~.."y . a u" V_ t' a' _' _' s_ .*. S "w."=^..>s ". C a., . . _l a .* .* | .A. . g 3 __ w.. e . .._: . ._ _. 4 .. . a.- 0....a.e " " .*w~.."y . a u" V_ t' a' _' _' s_ .*. S "w."=^..>s ". C a., . . _l a .* .* | ||
u-a e _ .;- wcu _s._4 _ 4 .. , ~ -rmm, _:. an | u-a e _ .;- wcu _s._4 _ 4 .. , ~ -rmm, _:. an | ||
. s. | . s. | ||
. . . . _4.. 1), . u.at | . . . . _4.. 1), . u.at | ||
. c, _1 _7 $.Io. w.c . 9. .3 c. , o ,, 3 ,.. ;. | . c, _1 _7 $.Io. w.c . 9. .3 c. , o ,, 3 ,.. ;. | ||
I-( .1 ..4 3 0 ) ,. c.. w i _a | I-( .1 ..4 3 0 ) ,. c.. w i _a | ||
. - - . ca | . - - . ca | ||
- -_ i_4 r.e L"w.ay a .f.. w _a C'x- _7 2.w.C m m fo_isCx | - -_ i_4 r.e L"w.ay a .f.. w _a C'x- _7 2.w.C m m fo_isCx | ||
~ - | ~ - | ||
.T w x o*,._43, - . | .T w x o*,._43, - . | ||
Ls.,. 4. | Ls.,. 4. | ||
* S _i -C s. 9), .!_?mnm _10 .. ,, : sIeC _17* s .1 , *_ *~ | * S _i -C s. 9), .!_?mnm _10 .. ,, : sIeC _17* s .1 , *_ *~ | ||
Line 415: | Line 289: | ||
. c~ "m* " 4 .^.". , N..". _# " S . | . c~ "m* " 4 .^.". , N..". _# " S . | ||
' "".d 9_ ) , .Gt - | ' "".d 9_ ) , .Gt - | ||
;.%nn, :. . .1- | ;.%nn, :. . .1- | ||
: o. c i e | : o. c i e | ||
Line 421: | Line 294: | ||
i.a . . . --.3 r | i.a . . . --.3 r | ||
\_c: . -s. | \_c: . -s. | ||
1; | 1; aC- ,.A .- ._4 C .1.., | ||
aC- ,.A .- ._4 C .1.., | |||
_s y_wyCSS. | _s y_wyCSS. | ||
.... A Ce . -4... . a .n. u._4w.. r. _ * (w r) _4a. _J..y. ..e wy LG c. = ,a. s .J e. --s-_4 a. e S | .... A Ce . -4... . a .n. u._4w.. r. _ * (w r) _4a. _J..y. ..e wy LG c. = ,a. s .J e. --s-_4 a. e S y g.m_1V, - ..C n .# a.d e -" * ' " a *.*. * ."S W.# "w.b.4 .". "b.e d " | ||
y g.m_1V, - ..C | |||
d " | |||
;u._4-d_4".'w_4C7 a . C-# " b.. o. | ;u._4-d_4".'w_4C7 a . C-# " b.. o. | ||
s | s sta"e .CChlic utla,itV. CCamiSSion. | ||
sta"e .CChlic utla,itV. CCamiSSion. | |||
t | t | ||
; c .4 3.413 .1.fi - y wy ..CSec w on.e.n.._4C.i. | ; c .4 3.413 .1.fi - y wy ..CSec w on.e.n.._4C.i. | ||
o | o | ||
. 2C, . | . 2C, . | ||
4 ,a . . _1 ( a) , .O | 4 ,a . . _1 ( a) , .O | ||
. f | . f | ||
Line 452: | Line 312: | ||
S SSCCd=~*d W.4"". " | S SSCCd=~*d W.4"". " | ||
C C S 'o s~ -- ._ #."..~ e ." ". ". " b.e C._w" " "w E. d a- ' .. ' * . * * - b.eV . a .~ a_ | C C S 'o s~ -- ._ #."..~ e ." ". ". " b.e C._w" " "w E. d a- ' .. ' * . * * - b.eV . a .~ a_ | ||
4 "tCC hic.h" Cr have been inadecuatelv. evaluated under the | 4 "tCC hic.h" Cr have been inadecuatelv. evaluated under the C*S*/b~ | ||
C*S*/b~ | |||
w e.ne_#.4 +- a.a.a _' v. a _iS ." =.c, "-_d ." = A- b ,v "ba | w e.ne_#.4 +- a.a.a _' v. a _iS ." =.c, "-_d ." = A- b ,v "ba | ||
- - - '.'a'. 4 C.*.a _' T 4 - v.' _"C.ar..e.n * = L' | - - - '.'a'. 4 C.*.a _' T 4 - v.' _"C.ar..e.n * = L' | ||
-ce | -ce w .l _4C ,f A C *- , ,i -2 L+ . g . C . 2 3.732 ( n y.r.c.a.n .. ) anc .10 C.7.R. on_._ -- . | ||
w .l _4C ,f A C *- , ,i -2 L+ . g . C . 2 3.732 ( n y.r.c.a.n .. ) anc .10 C.7.R. on_._ -- . | |||
21 a."e C'e#8 C "._dVE. *.. ".V _d _""w ".a7 * .*. t * '-w"" S 'wa" , | 21 a."e C'e#8 C "._dVE. *.. ".V _d _""w ".a7 * .*. t * '-w"" S 'wa" , | ||
; C".. _' V, w" .".d | ; C".. _' V, w" .".d | ||
- . ". C *. ec."C.CD_4 . "w | - . ". C *. ec."C.CD_4 . "w i | ||
i | |||
[ | [ | ||
, _ m . - . ~ | , _ m . - . ~ | ||
.__ - ._ _ . - - - = | .__ - ._ _ . - - - = | ||
. . s | . . s 4 - | ||
4 - | |||
C** S ~* a~ r 7 .''] . b e "--.* ".S .#----- | C** S ~* a~ r 7 .''] . b e "--.* ".S .#----- | ||
~ #3"*d -a" " " *--* S . " ' # .$. ^ . C _* | ~ #3"*d -a" " " *--* S . " ' # .$. ^ . C _* | ||
Line 485: | Line 333: | ||
*^~ | *^~ | ||
..w. | ..w. | ||
.2, | .2, | ||
..k.e - .. _4 .a . b. a. e. . . ..N_4as - .4 ..m a.-- .+ | ..k.e - .. _4 .a . b. a. e. . . ..N_4as - .4 ..m a.-- .+ | ||
Line 491: | Line 338: | ||
. h. o *..b. a. - | . h. o *..b. a. - | ||
* b.. a. 1.-y y _7 _4.w- m .. 6 | * b.. a. 1.-y y _7 _4.w- m .. 6 | ||
.b. a S ' C.'*.C S e.". " | .b. a S ' C.'*.C S e.". " | ||
* e w".b.a. " y* e S | * e w".b.a. " y* e S | ||
Line 507: | Line 353: | ||
.w s. - | .w s. - | ||
"we ._4*a *- | "we ._4*a *- | ||
.' .s..a. C' s.1, - i 1*S L2 _ .:09 , . 1.1 M. | .' .s..a. C' s.1, - i 1*S L2 _ .:09 , . 1.1 M. | ||
.. O.F. 127, es | .. O.F. 127, es | ||
-e .: O" _ s O | -e .: O" _ s O | ||
^ | ^ | ||
Line 520: | Line 363: | ||
m o. . | m o. . | ||
.;.y y . 2.=. .i. _C'*# .".^ . .a d _4 .". .' .' _7 _4.*.^ w a.4. - 0 ".W a .* w. . ^^~..".-*.".V, /s C _' _4 .". ~. ^. ". A 0"We." | .;.y y . 2.=. .i. _C'*# .".^ . .a d _4 .". .' .' _7 _4.*.^ w a.4. - 0 ".W a .* w. . ^^~..".-*.".V, /s C _' _4 .". ~. ^. ". A 0"We." | ||
- a * , <- | - a * , <- | ||
- .3. .. 4 e .,. , r. . 4 . .a. C o . T | - .3. .. 4 e .,. , r. . 4 . .a. C o . T | ||
Line 534: | Line 375: | ||
. . -2 7 e.a. .-.. 2 . 4 . <.e o O _i c .i . j. C .m. *..k.a. | . . -2 7 e.a. .-.. 2 . 4 . <.e o O _i c .i . j. C .m. *..k.a. | ||
haSiS Of iOS eConC=iC CCSOS. | haSiS Of iOS eConC=iC CCSOS. | ||
: m. .%.a t is a yuSineSS u 7UCgment s WniCn 1S Cuts 1;G the Scope of Cur NISA review. See. | |||
: m. .%.a t is | |||
a yuSineSS u 7UCgment s WniCn 1S Cuts 1;G the Scope of Cur NISA review. See. | |||
3IC.- k.e.-,. s p a u.m S t.- owe- Ce. (o_2 4 4m a | 3IC.- k.e.-,. s p a u.m S t.- owe- Ce. (o_2 4 4m a | ||
_m- - , , | _m- - , , | ||
nd .5L,C.,ea_- | nd .5L,C.,ea_- | ||
4 ce s .n. a _. , . _. . . ; _2 -7. , ...f r . 4 . a- . | 4 ce s .n. a _. , . _. . . ; _2 -7. , ...f r . 4 . a- . | ||
_7 -.e.n .7. ) r 2 s - | _7 -.e.n .7. ) r 2 s - | ||
Line 548: | Line 384: | ||
.ssi :. 7. , | .ssi :. 7. , | ||
( _7 0, 4). O.n..l y 4 .*.S C # ' " "S 3. .".V _4 _" O | ( _7 0, 4). O.n..l y 4 .*.S C # ' " "S 3. .".V _4 _" O | ||
- .. ".~..e .". ." _' | - .. ".~..e .". ." _' | ||
_4me " | _4me " | ||
Line 556: | Line 391: | ||
= C .a.".*..' | = C .a.".*..' | ||
- v. , | - v. , | ||
* h- e * .* -C = "-uS .4 .".c. .'Ca # S *. .= '. a- d, 4 .". *>c uS | * h- e * .* -C = "-uS .4 .".c. .'Ca # S *. .= '. a- d, 4 .". *>c uS Lightinc & ?CWer CCmpany (AllenS Creek Nuclear Generating | ||
Lightinc & ?CWer CCmpany (AllenS Creek Nuclear Generating | |||
- .c . . . _4 C., r ._4 | - .c . . . _4 C., r ._4 | ||
... . . . _), n O.-a-e _- R., , ; .g oy o.. ... a .-,/ ~a .n -._4 n. =. a. u. 4 . _4 n ,S n | ... . . . _), n O.-a-e _- R., , ; .g oy o.. ... a .-,/ ~a .n -._4 n. =. a. u. 4 . _4 n ,S n r. | ||
r. | |||
.- . wi. | .- . wi. | ||
' " C.V. a. . ".sC . 3 0 - J. 0' 0' | ' " C.V. a. . ".sC . 3 0 - J. 0' 0' | ||
-. ( .T aa" .-"- = _ f 9 , ' 9 ~/ . 9 ) (s S _1_4 "y C". y =. 3) f . - = . - | -. ( .T aa" .-"- = _ f 9 , ' 9 ~/ . 9 ) (s S _1_4 "y C". y =. 3) f . - = . - | ||
4 g e C e. 4 ..c y a Ce .w.. - . e n.a 4w On 64.2 w Ce w a.7 _4. 4 . ed y .7 a.w.u.a. a _- a. p.e.4e _- s _k _t e _ | 4 g e C e. 4 ..c y a Ce .w.. - . e n.a 4w On 64.2 w Ce w a.7 _4. 4 . ed y .7 a.w.u.a. a _- a. p.e.4e _- s _k _t e _ | ||
CVer nuC3 Gar ZaC1.3.tleS: | CVer nuC3 Gar ZaC1.3.tleS: | ||
. i . | . i . | ||
We rejeC- this ContentiCn. It iS | We rejeC- this ContentiCn. It iS | ||
-predCainantly based Cn eConCmic costs of Coal v. nuclear .clantS. It a.ceearS . | -predCainantly based Cn eConCmic costs of Coal v. nuclear .clantS. It a.ceearS . | ||
to ' assume that the utilit*f is prCmCtinc. | to ' assume that the utilit*f is prCmCtinc. | ||
. u. s.. --...e v m_ | . u. s.. --...e v m_ | ||
y | y | ||
Line 593: | Line 413: | ||
, .=- s. | , .=- s. | ||
s ".w 4- . | s ".w 4- . | ||
N. a- a _- a_ .. C . "'_''=d - - " "y o ". . e- | N. a- a _- a_ .. C . "'_''=d - - " "y o ". . e- | ||
. a""- | . a""- | ||
a.-.,.m-C L, , ;..4 .- . 3. .,. _. _- -. .-. - - w;_ r. _w | |||
a.-.,.m- | |||
C L, , ;..4 .- . 3. .,. _. _- -. .-. - - w;_ r. _w | |||
- .. . s - | - .. . s - | ||
_1- 4 _ 7, -..A 4_- | _1- 4 _ 7, -..A 4_- | ||
._.- _. - -ge,-3 | ._.- _. - -ge,-3 | ||
... 4 m - - . . - | ... 4 m - - . . - | ||
2_ g. , | 2_ g. , | ||
Line 609: | Line 424: | ||
: 1. .s.. | : 1. .s.. | ||
. w oy. - ww n s. . ~.a_.-- aa . . | . w oy. - ww n s. . ~.a_.-- aa . . | ||
,a. .s-- - a .. . :. . .a ..n; _. .u.. =. | ,a. .s-- - a .. . :. . .a ..n; _. .u.. =. | ||
~...C s ~. - t .. , .,. n-_t .,. _1 1 .f .,. A . . m .. _,n : | ~...C s ~. - t .. , .,. n-_t .,. _1 1 .f .,. A . . m .. _,n : | ||
y a. c,. L.a- 4; | y a. c,. L.a- 4; a u*..' .i .i .v. -- a "ug y .' v, --a w""s ~~e_a' .".a. a -d | ||
a u*..' .i .i .v. -- a "ug y .' v, --a w""s ~~e_a' .".a. a -d | |||
-^ - - 4-- ^~ - | -^ - - 4-- ^~ - | ||
3 0 .- y C% d _" . 2. " W e v a_ _ , '.' .". d a. ." .T | 3 0 .- y C% d _" . 2. " W e v a_ _ , '.' .". d a. ." .T | ||
Line 624: | Line 434: | ||
a r.C 7. C, a's i b_'a ----_..--_d"ses | a r.C 7. C, a's i b_'a ----_..--_d"ses | ||
-- - #C_- a .e a- ' _# ."."y ycwe.e | -- - #C_- a .e a- ' _# ."."y ycwe.e | ||
.n.e -- aAs. .M.e.* -a C^ s '- "a _' a.".C 4 *- C, _4a- | .n.e -- aAs. .M.e.* -a C^ s '- "a _' a.".C 4 *- C, _4a- | ||
_i .m y C _-*. = .". *.w ^ r.iv, *r we *"a | _i .m y C _-*. = .". *.w ^ r.iv, *r we *"a | ||
--- e.x . a. .". *. -.4* - -=su..a ''- | --- e.x . a. .". *. -.4* - -=su..a ''- | ||
_4 .". a.". e .n.v _4 _-.^ " ~..e .". '. ' _' _' v_ a u a- | _4 .". a.". e .n.v _4 _-.^ " ~..e .". '. ' _' _' v_ a u a-y - - _4C _ = .' '. a _-. . a - | ||
y - - _4C _ = .' '. a _-. . a - | |||
-4 | -4 | ||
- ve. ad"ad ; | - ve. ad"ad ; | ||
: i. r...y .~ . = a _* a- - ---.. | : i. r...y .~ . = a _* a- - ---.. | ||
. ay--, a- .- , - -e. e .--A ---..".a- :"-- | . ay--, a- .- , - -e. e .--A ---..".a- :"-- | ||
.-.4 ,- | .-.4 ,- | ||
-a .- u. | -a .- u. | ||
s_x e C " -- .d a d .' .. u~ ~.a". ur..e _-- | s_x e C " -- .d a d .' .. u~ ~.a". ur..e _-- | ||
a Cwer CCm:any (Midland Plant, "nics 1 and 2) , ALA3-453, 7 | a Cwer CCm:any (Midland Plant, "nics 1 and 2) , ALA3-453, 7 | ||
.i .sv _, Ac,-ca (. _, ,s /.p ) : | .i .sv _, Ac,-ca (. _, ,s /.p ) : | ||
, - u. e | , - u. e | ||
Line 648: | Line 451: | ||
2 a., | 2 a., | ||
,n C ,.n- .;__ ,sa-d44 DCt 'a.k= | ,n C ,.n- .;__ ,sa-d44 DCt 'a.k= | ||
"4- a " " e..Cv. | "4- a " " e..Cv. | ||
-; " .-n s y- C.". d _d-.'^ '. s | -; " .-n s y- C.". d _d-.'^ '. s | ||
_30_" a s s e s a .4 ."."; w'.="-.'".a__- .- _= y_-yCaed- ..uC'a"- | _30_" a s s e s a .4 ."."; w'.="-.'".a__- .- _= y_-yCaed- ..uC'a"- | ||
--~~ - | --~~ - | ||
y l a.".~ '4C u' u# "a -- - -".e ~C * *s #_ 4 .". * .".-- C 4-;" ' '" ad-Va.".*.*.CeCus wa" # C* | y l a.".~ '4C u' u# "a -- - -".e ~C * *s #_ 4 .". * .".-- C 4-;" ' '" ad-Va.".*.*.CeCus wa" # C* | ||
* u' _4 1_* '."; -^ - -- s a '- _4s.#7 4*s . m.,sw-ow -m e_-8 a ..m. -- e A .Cw& y C.a.e.e . q m uw.b. | * u' _4 1_* '."; -^ - -- s a '- _4s.#7 4*s . m.,sw-ow -m e_-8 a ..m. -- e A .Cw& y C.a.e.e . q m uw.b. | ||
a m u.- s a- - -.2 - _4 2 . . e A ..u.e y - ,*._4 ..C. e C .: ..w. -a g.---4 1_4 s, *v a." # . | a m u.- s a- - -.2 - _4 2 . . e A ..u.e y - ,*._4 ..C. e C .: ..w. -a g.---4 1_4 s, *v a." # . | ||
V' s _4 .".C, C"'"a | V' s _4 .".C, C"'"a | ||
- s- s - _SC,"- | - s- s - _SC,"- | ||
1 ato.-.f C-~.~a_a wa. s.4 w...- | 1 ato.-.f C-~.~a_a wa. s.4 w...- | ||
a a '-y-aen , n *_w .- w | a a '-y-aen , n *_w .- w | ||
_4 , . s s*.a 4ua_s o o One s4 4e, w Cu._ .J ..,IC 1 Vc m..a. .n... -.. 4 44.nu | _4 , . s s*.a 4ua_s o o One s4 4e, w Cu._ .J ..,IC 1 Vc m..a. .n... -.. 4 44.nu s ._ | ||
s ._ | |||
C _,. , m .._e e. .da s _1_,.mi . _. | C _,. , m .._e e. .da s _1_,.mi . _. | ||
o c..._... -.- . | o c..._... -.- . | ||
n- .g wh e *-.' .e , _4 _# we .14 C -a .r.s e '..".e c i a .7'. , "".e C ~ ~ya.nv . w.i.11 -be ab_'a ' o b u- _d _' d a..d "" a .n. - ,. | |||
n- .g wh e *-.' .e , _4 _# we .14 C -a .r.s e '..".e c i a .7'. , "".e | |||
C ~ ~ya.nv . w.i.11 -be ab_'a ' o b u- _d _' d a..d "" a .n. - ,. | |||
'o | 'o | ||
- C ye.a'a _i '. wd ".^eu. Cvmo__-wmi a 4"3 | - C ye.a'a _i '. wd ".^eu. Cvmo__-wmi a 4"3 sa:ety .ceCause Cf pressing financial | ||
sa:ety .ceCause Cf pressing financial | |||
..eas | ..eas | ||
--a . | --a . | ||
The passage Cf the NatiCnal Environ-mental PClicy ACt increased our concern w.i'". 'he er.onCm4w s C_# .".u"-_=- - 'a | The passage Cf the NatiCnal Environ-mental PClicy ACt increased our concern w.i'". 'he er.onCm4w s C_# .".u"-_=- - 'a yCwe y.'=n*ma, b u'w C.7.' V. -4 . " . a 1' 4 ".. 4 - a ".h* a' C '- _-=- | ||
yCwe y.'=n*ma, b u'w C.7.' V. -4 . " . a 1' 4 ".. 4 - a ".h* a' C '- _-=- | |||
quires us to cons'. .cer d waV. , | quires us to cons'. .cer d waV. , | ||
wnetn. er tn.'w ere are aa.vd | |||
wnetn. er tn.'w | |||
ere are aa.vd | |||
-. Crne.".'=_'7 7_ .,c _-a _#--a--ab i a_ = .' "-a - .-. a '- v a s i | -. Crne.".'=_'7 7_ .,c _-a _#--a--ab i a_ = .' "-a - .-. a '- v a s i | ||
_ :. :nere are r | _ :. :nere are r co tne .DrocCsa =e:Cre us. . x we must take the steps we Can to see | ||
co tne .DrocCsa =e:Cre us. . x we must take the steps we Can to see | |||
'..." a * *.' .ev a_* = ino .' e." =-.".t a d _4 _# ' '". a C = .". | '..." a * *.' .ev a_* = ino .' e." =-.".t a d _4 _# ' '". a C = .". | ||
be accomplished at a reasCnable Cost,- | be accomplished at a reasCnable Cost,- | ||
_4 . a . , Cn.e | _4 . a . , Cn.e | ||
Line 708: | Line 484: | ||
c=> | c=> | ||
6-mu. | 6-mu. | ||
4.: .u.e -a -- a_-a. ..o y _- a : e _,u, | 4.: .u.e -a -- a_-a. ..o y _- a : e _,u, | ||
-- -- .a- a..,..._4-,.- . - - . | -- -- .a- a..,..._4-,.- . - - . | ||
'nental alternatives, such Cost-benefit h a l =-u " C.i .".g ' dC E S . .o *. - = .' *. G "y .' = C a . u'J- m.q .4 : e e . .i. v , | 'nental alternatives, such Cost-benefit h a l =-u " C.i .".g ' dC E S . .o *. - = .' *. G "y .' = C a . u'J- m.q .4 : e e . .i. v , | ||
.".C * "..# .d. C _4 .. . ' F.' . . | .".C * "..# .d. C _4 .. . ' F.' . . | ||
. , = _' ' a- ~ . . ' a- "o a 4 # . | . , = _' ' a- ~ . . ' a- "o a 4 # . | ||
%..., ." u C. .". a...v4_ w_- . ".e..t.= _' _' "; _4 . .---v _# = 4 .. ='~ - =, _ - | %..., ." u C. .". a...v4_ w_- . ".e..t.= _' _' "; _4 . .---v _# = 4 .. ='~ - =, _ - | ||
.. a w. 4 ,<,e s- _., | .. a w. 4 ,<,e s- _., | ||
. 4 4 nc a w.L.a.a y s- ( w u,w. .. -4 _4 .- | . 4 4 nc a w.L.a.a y s- ( w u,w. .. -4 _4 .- | ||
* _4e.-) | * _4e.-) | ||
way C .# 'a..=".di4..C, t.h. e "..a . . *- * = | way C .# 'a..=".di4..C, t.h. e "..a . . *- * = | ||
. - . .h..=..d - . J" . . " . | . - . .h..=..d - . J" . . " . | ||
the scheme of things, we leave such | the scheme of things, we leave such | ||
. a * *. a. .. a- o *.uka ow,S4..ess ;4A4 . -gn a .n. *. o_4 - | . a * *. a. .. a- o *.uka ow,S4..ess ;4A4 . -gn a .n. *. o_4 - | ||
ww. y a.._as s..c .n. .%a A | ww. y a.._as s..c .n. .%a A | ||
_.. %.e u..-4 _1_,ys., -nn ; | _.. %.e u..-4 _1_,ys., -nn ; | ||
.4 | .4 | ||
.-a uca o# *he w c~ .a a ..C"w'=~~-v, | .-a uca o# *he w c~ .a a ..C"w'=~~-v, | ||
** = C, =-." C -4 a s--~ * - | ** = C, =-." C -4 a s--~ * - | ||
5 y C n s .4 h _' *_ _#C* S w . U *. 4 .". 4 . .4 y."." *he y-"- O'v | 5 y C n s .4 h _' *_ _#C* S w . U *. 4 .". 4 . .4 y."." *he y-"- O'v eCOnCmic aspeCO3 of prCPCsals to build new C.eneratinC facilities. - In short, r e.s. _4s- ww-- .C a -..a c , w s *. 4 a-a s .2, _- . .a. S .v4-. -- - | ||
eCOnCmic aspeCO3 of prCPCsals to build new C.eneratinC facilities. - In short, r e.s. _4s- ww-- .C a -..a c , w s *. 4 a- | |||
a s .2, _- . .a. S .v4-. -- - | |||
: 4. y o .- . a.. . -..._' "g '-".a. .w a_.x .r a. . 4. _-=- | : 4. y o .- . a.. . -..._' "g '-".a. .w a_.x .r a. . 4. _-=- | ||
. S ul .a- -.. 4 | . S ul .a- -.. 4 | ||
=.=. a .". - _# _- w ..m e."..= .' _' v, m- uy e. .4. o _- | =.=. a .". - _# _- w ..m e."..= .' _' v, m- uy e. .4. o _- | ||
Line 760: | Line 514: | ||
.. m. .' .%.e .. w_4 s es s e, . %..s . _4 _ 4.s w.%.e sy - 4 s-h a.-dw .' .v _4... :. | .. m. .' .%.e .. w_4 s es s e, . %..s . _4 _ 4.s w.%.e sy - 4 s-h a.-dw .' .v _4... :. | ||
. .* = S a .4 v e . [T.m- y ".= s _i s .4... o .. _4 _4 . . = _' ,- | . .* = S a .4 v e . [T.m- y ".= s _i s .4... o .. _4 _4 . . = _' ,- | ||
_anCw t..C u.a s- wm_4 -- | _anCw t..C u.a s- wm_4 -- | ||
. . a A . ]' | . . a A . ]' | ||
-o-oy"Csed w - -- - .".~. .".* _4C .". _' ( "_ ) _45 ^ | -o-oy"Csed w - -- - .".~. .".* _4C .". _' ( "_ ) _45 ^ | ||
. . - =C~ ~*"y *. = h ' | . . - =C~ ~*"y *. = h ' | ||
Line 771: | Line 523: | ||
- - a cc l_i - = ..*.s as s * .= ~.= d | - - a cc l_i - = ..*.s as s * .= ~.= d | ||
, - _i.n *he 7_4..a' ?.n v _4 _. w . e n a _' -=.=._.e... | , - _i.n *he 7_4..a' ?.n v _4 _. w . e n a _' -=.=._.e... | ||
c" " | c" " | ||
. : .- , 4 .,. . a _ , | . : .- , 4 .,. . a _ , | ||
Line 779: | Line 530: | ||
.._ __4_,,.a__ | .._ __4_,,.a__ | ||
2 y_, | 2 y_, | ||
4 _4.,.,onse . -an _4_._3 D. r- ,-.. x .w.a ,.,_e e = | 4 _4.,.,onse . -an _4_._3 D. r- ,-.. x .w.a ,.,_e e = | ||
_ _, _4 ., m- | _ _, _4 ., m- | ||
-- , _%,. _w | -- , _%,. _w | ||
_ -- ..o t .a - - - . . . a. | _ -- ..o t .a - - - . . . a. | ||
applicant was granted sunmary disposition en MV?? "need for | applicant was granted sunmary disposition en MV?? "need for ycwe_" C^.n'an._4 w r. '' hv ~54 s Sca." 4.. | ||
. _4 ".s- .' -..=.h =- = . _4 . .g u~ 6. . .#-= _- =- ..w-- a Orc.er or v.une 4, 19_<9. --2/ Dr. ,anx.hauser | |||
ycwe_" C^.n'an._4 | |||
w r. '' hv ~54 s Sca." 4.. | |||
. _4 ".s- .' -..=.h =- = . _4 . .g u~ 6. . .#-= _- =- ..w-- a Orc.er or v.une | |||
4, 19_<9. --2/ Dr. ,anx.hauser | |||
: .nas . . | : .nas . . | ||
allec. to naxe. | allec. to naxe. | ||
"a s w o .g a.k.cw_d ..C. | "a s w o .g a.k.cw_d ..C. | ||
. . . 5 = ._ "m".- a _* =. = x _ds .s- a = _4 :u - .4 .# _4 .= .. | . . . 5 = ._ "m".- a _* =. = x _ds .s- a = _4 :u - .4 .# _4 .= .. | ||
3.k.3 A 1ssue wnicn .nac not crev. o u s ., v. ceen acequate3v . | 3.k.3 A 1ssue wnicn .nac not crev. o u s ., v. ceen acequate3v . | ||
. Cen- | . Cen- | ||
- s _4c' e. ed o _ . s 4 .._i 3 _# _i w a..' u ew i .n #o ..i = '._icr. w"4 | - s _4c' e. ed o _ . s 4 .._i 3 _# _i w a..' u ew i .n #o ..i = '._icr. w"4 | ||
- u c.". ". = d c' =". a _' c y e d | - u c.". ". = d c' =". a _' c y e d a_# e.* 'u"a- -- w-r.s---" c. 4 c. . e e--- | ||
a_# e.* 'u"a- -- w-r.s---" c. 4 c. . e e--- | |||
-- 4 ' - | -- 4 ' - | ||
avdaw."__3/..n | avdaw."__3/..n | ||
_# a c ~ , D.. | _# a c ~ , D.. | ||
--2/ In this regard, we note that while 10 C.T.R. 52. 7A 9 | --2/ In this regard, we note that while 10 C.T.R. 52. 7A 9 ye_- | ||
ye_ | |||
''- a..v. c a _-* v, " | ''- a..v. c a _-* v, " | ||
_--o , oy-yose a - o'_'. w . .o sur-.a_-v, .._s- | _--o , oy-yose a - o'_'. w . .o sur-.a_-v, .._s-y c S4 _4 ^ ". ,' D.*.. | ||
y c S4 _4 ^ ". ,' D.*.. | |||
- -. .T anV....= Us e _" .#- 4 1 ed ..o *.n' _4 ..g . | - -. .T anV....= Us e _" .#- 4 1 ed ..o *.n' _4 ..g . | ||
,/. | ,/. | ||
n, e . wn i ~. = d_4s c.,. u. _.. | n, e . wn i ~. = d_4s c.,. u. _.. | ||
. - a..,_ ( .=u _ _4-- ,,_ = e _- ,._4 n,u. .n 4 - 2owa-Plant, Uni 2) , L3P-79-1, 9 NRC 7 3, 36 (1979). | |||
. - a..,_ ( .=u _ _4-- ,,_ = e _- ,._4 n,u. .n 4 - 2owa- | |||
Plant, Uni 2) , L3P-79-1, 9 NRC 7 3, 36 (1979). | |||
4 i | 4 i | ||
#. -- -e,, ' | #. -- -e,, ' | ||
1 R | 1 R | ||
1 4 | 1 4 | ||
1 73.. <w.a,se_ o. . .s | 1 73.. <w.a,se_ o. . .s | ||
. . ..a- . . m. d 4 .. en- _.m..a . _4o.. 2 . _2 _1 1 . m.. k.n s ..b. e _. m. _4a- | . . ..a- . . m. d 4 .. en- _.m..a . _4o.. 2 . _2 _1 1 . m.. k.n s ..b. e _. m. _4a- | ||
. .o . h.4 | . .o . h.4 | ||
Line 844: | Line 565: | ||
. ^ - * " _ . " . = - ', o a # Wh_4u #.*. *a *o ue ' d 4 .".# | . ^ - * " _ . " . = - ', o a # Wh_4u #.*. *a *o ue ' d 4 .".# | ||
- w -- _4 -- =..= "'.w=. ..'.o. | - w -- _4 -- =..= "'.w=. ..'.o. | ||
c s./'e.e~'_i | c s./'e.e~'_i | ||
=..a_lvs4-a. "..a.d e _ '..' ~o A .".a a- "- ea - r. s ub s - * .". ._4 =- _' _';" | =..a_lvs4-a. "..a.d e _ '..' ~o A .".a a- "- ea - r. s ub s - * .". ._4 =- _' _';" | ||
a "' | a "' | ||
l e-=d. .v.o .- =. o v e-- , _4 . k. = s ' -e a. n. -^ ~. | l e-=d. .v.o .- =. o v e-- , _4 . k. = s ' -e a. n. -^ ~. | ||
s s =- . . - _v. _-=c -.4 i | s s =- . . - _v. _-=c -.4 i | ||
c..- ed ' ' .a *. | c..- ed ' ' .a *. | ||
e _, o.x_; w 4 1_4 | e _, o.x_; w 4 1_4 | ||
- - . ., 4 .,. .w 4 - | - - . ., 4 .,. .w 4 - | ||
.- a y _..c4-. | .- a y _..c4-. | ||
w _43. _4a- .m, _4. | w _43. _4a- .m, _4. | ||
c wy . | c wy . | ||
_w. | _w. | ||
w u--e,__ | w u--e,__ | ||
.4 .3 uncertainty in load forecasting. As the Appeal Board stated | .4 .3 uncertainty in load forecasting. As the Appeal Board stated | ||
Line 869: | Line 583: | ||
_4 ., - | _4 ., - | ||
f .- m_ a_ _4 - - m_ c ;~ =_ = _ ^ # ..=_=_d '979 "<s. | f .- m_ a_ _4 - - m_ c ;~ =_ = _ ^ # ..=_=_d '979 "<s. | ||
_198' - a s- =~._4m . | _198' - a s- =~._4m . | ||
_4--- = _' _' v. -.e = .n_i ..3_ u l dis-tinction. If there was one thing agreed uron 4.. . . " . = :-- " e _i c w ,4--- i s --=. " | _4--- = _' _' v. -.e = .n_i ..3_ u l dis-tinction. If there was one thing agreed uron 4.. . . " . = :-- " e _i c w ,4--- i s --=. " | ||
- - - c = = d 4 .. c. | - - - c = = d 4 .. c. | ||
4 .,.p. e _._. . . 4 .,. -. 2 .y _:--=c=.- | 4 .,.p. e _._. . . 4 .,. -. 2 .y _:--=c=.- | ||
- - o' "".-_-= eiec- _ | - - o' "".-_-= eiec- _ | ||
tric pcwer demand is a substantial margin ' | tric pcwer demand is a substantial margin ' | ||
o u,.c ...e ". ds o# | o u,.c ...e ". ds o# | ||
Line 883: | Line 593: | ||
. . 2. --..... .; . .s=- w4 k. .os f ed 4- - .4. 3 -".e"".."_-=, | . . 2. --..... .; . .s=- w4 k. .os f ed 4- - .4. 3 -".e"".."_-=, | ||
~ | ~ | ||
cad ."o ec=st_i.c. | cad ."o ec=st_i.c. | ||
involves at least as much art as science. | involves at least as much art as science. | ||
m..u.e .,a _ 3- _4.. | m..u.e .,a _ 3- _4.. | ||
o a . --. ..- | o a . --. ..- | ||
4.,y&_4 , | 4.,y&_4 , | ||
Line 896: | Line 603: | ||
-u.a. 4.. u. e _-. ,a..o o r .o : en,ssos. | -u.a. 4.. u. e _-. ,a..o o r .o : en,ssos. | ||
- -- m..u.e an yy _1_4 - | - -- m..u.e an yy _1_4 - | ||
cant's choice of the earliest of the | cant's choice of the earliest of the possible " years of need" is readily understandable. Seing_ legally obligated to meet reserve margin requirements, any utility company must be expected-to fore-cast' load demands conservatively, i.e., | ||
favor the high side of such predictions to insure that it is always crecared . . | favor the high side of such predictions to insure that it is always crecared . . | ||
for unexpectedly hic.h demands. . ._4_. ' | for unexpectedly hic.h demands. . ._4_. ' | ||
Line 905: | Line 611: | ||
i C2N | i C2N | ||
- Q 9: a | |||
- Q | |||
9: a | |||
: w. a u. 0. . 4 .,. . | : w. a u. 0. . 4 .,. . | ||
* n ~1_4 .w. 4 ~a~. _w .s. . 4 s .w. (' b .'. _4 .m. O. | * n ~1_4 .w. 4 ~a~. _w .s. . 4 s .w. (' b .'. _4 .m. O. | ||
.. c. a. A s _. . . s. 2. - . . 01 | .. c. a. A s _. . . s. 2. - . . 01 3 | ||
3 | |||
.f | .f | ||
.) * * - | .) * * - | ||
w . ~I <~_ | w . ~I <~_ | ||
f | f | ||
_7wi 7 _1 9F - O" "/ - | |||
v.4.Tw f -4 "t, gJ/ | v.4.Tw f -4 "t, gJ/ | ||
/7n=Q'. #) . .u.- a ..- ; | /7n=Q'. #) . .u.- a ..- ; | ||
yy p.=- -w--- | yy p.=- -w--- | ||
-3 4 4 .,. *..k _' _4-- | -3 4 4 .,. *..k _' _4-- | ||
30 .,4ma | |||
. _ - o*. . a.e.y C: T .m. A _4 .s .%. 3. , T... | . _ - o*. . a.e.y C: T .m. A _4 .s .%. 3. , T... | ||
: w. _ | : w. _ | ||
Line 938: | Line 634: | ||
** 3 _ ,' . 0 , " * | ** 3 _ ,' . 0 , " * | ||
* 7.e. . ... | * 7.e. . ... | ||
-,O, , -7 ,0, : | -,O, , -7 ,0, : | ||
, ( 7 Q- "J Q" ' .). | , ( 7 Q- "J Q" ' .). | ||
Line 946: | Line 641: | ||
*^ * | *^ * | ||
* v.4.e Ae.m g.m. A a a - -v- m_ y cyg 4 =- e :- __w m. ' .. .m g - | * v.4.e Ae.m g.m. A a a - -v- m_ y cyg 4 =- e :- __w m. ' .. .m g - | ||
".C .hC C_" , w " V ~.^. - d * "j r . " . " #. - V o. " * #. w^ .- V- S- "-* f 2.n A .w.4 ..k. 4*. *.. u.g " y a. .m .e.1 C " d " *.'s*. . .* v*.b. " . . ' * . * - | |||
".C .hC C_" , w " V ~.^. - d * "j r . " . " #. - V o. " * #. w^ .- V- S- "-* f | |||
2.n A .w.4 ..k. 4*. *.. u.g " y a. .m .e.1 C " d " *.'s*. . .* v*.b. " . . ' * . * - | |||
a l e- c. a. . 4 , 2 *- a,j- a .. -.m.m.. | a l e- c. a. . 4 , 2 *- a,j- a .. -.m.m.. | ||
. ..,,a-. w . a. v3 yaw;s _- G_H n | |||
. ..,,a-. w . a. v3 | |||
yaw;s _- G_H n | |||
. a.a - _4 .; | . a.a - _4 .; | ||
..A- .. _ u. m. 3 a 2. .. ... . | ..A- .. _ u. m. 3 a 2. .. ... . | ||
.. 4. . . n 4. .. . ,- . | .. 4. . . n 4. .. . ,- . | ||
v 2 -, . ,. _-.. -- w; ;,,. | v 2 -, . ,. _-.. -- w; ;,,. | ||
4 . .a. .v. _. a. _.. u. . w - r = - - _~ _4 y . | 4 . .a. .v. _. a. _.. u. . w - r = - - _~ _4 y . | ||
"e y * .k ' C | "e y * .k ' C | ||
* da" .**" . - * . ' 1--.= w^ * = = . . * .:-- | * da" .**" . - * . ' 1--.= w^ * = = . . * .:-- | ||
-- ~ ~ ^ V '..'.~: , | -- ~ ~ ^ V '..'.~: , | ||
.?ws4_ | .?ws4_ | ||
3- | 3- | ||
.._..4- | .._..4- | ||
<- ; - .; _- -.2.: | <- ; - .; _- -.2.: | ||
-.. . .2. , - .3 . _. .,a2_. | -.. . .2. , - .3 . _. .,a2_. | ||
; -- a . | ; -- a . | ||
o .s . ., .. a . =. _.a- - Aa_a_. | o .s . ., .. a . =. _.a- - Aa_a_. | ||
. - . 4 ...=. ..4..a. | . - . 4 ...=. ..4..a. | ||
-- .. . u. . ; , ,. _ a. | -- .. . u. . ; , ,. _ a. | ||
.3. - . -- 2..__.. - . . w- g . | .3. - . -- 2..__.. - . . w- g . | ||
--2 32 _1 s .ea- ; | --2 32 _1 s .ea- ; | ||
.. . : 3 | .. . : 3 T e C ...m . a 6.r | ||
T e C ...m . a 6.r | |||
~ | ~ | ||
w v~ a 4 _ . = A . .~ | w v~ a 4 _ . = A . .~ | ||
--. mu.a | --. mu.a | ||
.. - 2. _s,,goaa5 L. . ._.=,....4, . ..: .z.u.e n..?. A | .. - 2. _s,,goaa5 L. . ._.=,....4, . ..: .z.u.e n..?. A n7 S C. -.e ..~c.- Jag . . . .; . . _. _4 . 2 7. .:. . | ||
n7 S C. -.e ..~c.- Jag . . . .; . . _. _4 . 2 7. .:. | |||
T .,. a f A 4. | T .,. a f A 4. | ||
- - 4 . .. .nw u, u.a ,,m . o n- C e . .= .u --i ~ .4..; . . , me w. u.a f vy nnoggA. | - - 4 . .. .nw u, u.a ,,m . o n- C e . .= .u --i ~ .4..; . . , me w. u.a f vy nnoggA. | ||
- . . u..a . . . _J . . . a-a ,,__-..=_. ., | |||
- . . u..a . . . _J . . . a- | |||
a ,,__-..=_. ., | |||
- _ - .v r 1- ...u. ,=. y .u..w-- n . . n z--ua -,=-.n..-- os= 2A 1 3 | - _ - .v r 1- ...u. ,=. y .u..w-- n . . n z--ua -,=-.n..-- os= 2A 1 3 | ||
v" C". C# . # ."..a. **#~'".^"*. w_ -* a~ "w b S . =.a. . _4--' -z .b.C'.v* 4 ."."; C.# 3" v" C w# ^*CC*.. .. #.^.* | v" C". C# . # ."..a. **#~'".^"*. w_ -* a~ "w b S . =.a. . _4--' -z .b.C'.v* 4 ."."; C.# 3" v" C w# ^*CC*.. .. #.^.* | ||
v 4 1,. | v 4 1,. | ||
_32 - a_. a. uC 241s. CC * ..4 ..~a | _32 - a_. a. uC 241s. CC * ..4 ..~a | ||
-- , waSeA- w -,.. _b.e m 2 Co w _a- | -- , waSeA- w -,.. _b.e m 2 Co w _a-2 8 u. C,luw _4 . . 7 0 a - | ||
2 8 u. C,luw _4 . . 7 0 a - | |||
. v . v. 3. S.o 7 . ~t 7 4 (> a) , 4 .. 3 dC4-4oC . | . v . v. 3. S.o 7 . ~t 7 4 (> a) , 4 .. 3 dC4-4oC . | ||
.s u..e m . - a um_a- Sy eC4 :-4 eC- 4 1 | |||
.s u..e m . - a um_a- Sy eC4 :-4 eC- 4 | 0 cn .. . a... | ||
cn .. . a... | |||
~7.4i+ | ~7.4i+ | ||
~ s C . | ~ s C . | ||
.On N.Cv=""e.- | .On N.Cv=""e.- | ||
'C | 'C | ||
_ r | _ r 9~Ia r '' .e .'. i ^ a..S * .*.q 3 C a # | ||
9~Ia r '' .e .'. i ^ a..S * .*.q 3 C a # | |||
-- -.4 .". 4 "- d a.' ~i v, | -- -.4 .". 4 "- d a.' ~i v, | ||
;-- =...mA. g.k.a CS e "'a~ | ;-- =...mA. g.k.a CS e "'a~ | ||
g -.- .Ts ,C e | g -.- .Ts ,C e | ||
* _4 ". 4.. ^ ". | * _4 ". 4.. ^ ". | ||
Line 1,039: | Line 692: | ||
* _" V a.*." . _i ^w P. . n' ". | * _" V a.*." . _i ^w P. . n' ". | ||
%.- a a g..~a | %.- a a g..~a | ||
~ 4 .a a , _ u.a.. | ~ 4 .a a , _ u.a.. | ||
-4 a c a.n.g - .t .e.c, .n c a v.A. ; _ , .q . a f u ' .a-y | -4 a c a.n.g - .t .e.c, .n c a v.A. ; _ , .q . a f u ' .a-y | ||
. q +.4 u 4- c.n c :- | . q +.4 u 4- c.n c :- | ||
M4 gg-d Va''*V O,*We "_ 3 *C ;4eC'. ~ '.C .#.".'.*"*<*G.".a. | M4 gg-d Va''*V O,*We "_ 3 *C ;4eC'. ~ '.C .#.".'.*"*<*G.".a. | ||
J- T ' .7.k.". | J- T ' .7.k.". | ||
-- * "- a~ e " | -- * "- a~ e " | ||
.y O | .y O | ||
.O | .O | ||
- - - - = 6. J w$N .N. - O O N y ..$. b O w. | - - - - = 6. J w$N .N. - O O N y ..$. b O w. | ||
M hw .. . g . -. g M. w | M hw .. . g . -. g M. w | ||
Line 1,057: | Line 706: | ||
10~iD. | 10~iD. | ||
a "..".e _' a s . G- ,. . . =..a.*. .* C . rw_# . b. a. | a "..".e _' a s . G- ,. . . =..a.*. .* C . rw_# . b. a. | ||
.T4 =. .o y e .d .4 w r. o aS -=- | .T4 =. .o y e .d .4 w r. o aS -=- | ||
m.*w= b, g .*. -m d 4 .2..*.. A .. .m e. .m a . b.,y | m.*w= b, g .*. -m d 4 .2..*.. A .. .m e. .m a . b.,y | ||
== | == | ||
h b. -a .'3 a g.. A. | h b. -a .'3 a g.. A. | ||
- p a . S . a. g | |||
- p | |||
a . S . a. g | |||
<Sdub. | <Sdub. | ||
_ g- | _ g- | ||
.i .t . m..s. g pe,o--y. | .i .t . m..s. g pe,o--y. | ||
- 4 Sn.e.*. nggA w _4 .7 ".."a. C -. ^ ". m~ ". ""- * - | - 4 Sn.e.*. nggA w _4 .7 ".."a. C -. ^ ". m~ ". ""- * - | ||
.; .7 w | .; .7 w | ||
.4 | .4 | ||
. C .. 3 ..C Cye m*4.._C. . C: _ %.e .. .7 2 .=... .._4 4 -e | . C .. 3 ..C Cye m*4.._C. . C: _ %.e .. .7 2 .=... .._4 4 -e | ||
. f .. | . f .. | ||
excessive _3v Cost.3v anC, 10 e;;eC , OG.VCnd | excessive _3v Cost.3v anC, 10 e;;eC , OG.VCnd | ||
* k.g 4 . 4 ._.a.7C 4 a _' C = D ah .4 .' ' .v. . C - = "y y _' _# " -- | * k.g 4 . 4 ._.a.7C 4 a _' C = D ah .4 .' ' .v. . C - = "y y _' _# " -- | ||
' .". ~. a~ . | ' .". ~. a~ . | ||
d' yo n, ., t e. gn. . . @- g.e a- = _4 ..s e.c _t m | d' yo n, ., t e. gn. . . @- g.e a- = _4 ..s e.c _t m | ||
Line 1,098: | Line 735: | ||
*--ion. =n.d c'e"="._4cny c_# '".e N_- .. . m. ..e_" _3=w~_i | *--ion. =n.d c'e"="._4cny c_# '".e N_- .. . m. ..e_" _3=w~_i | ||
- _1 _4 v_ b=s _'ong "ea.. | - _1 _4 v_ b=s _'ong "ea.. | ||
= | = | ||
contention in this proceeding. If Dr. Fankhauser wished ,to | contention in this proceeding. If Dr. Fankhauser wished ,to | ||
=sse_. su . .k. | =sse_. su . .k. | ||
" = % | " = % | ||
c r.' m.7 '. 4..^ . , ". e " = - _4a- ... ^ | c r.' m.7 '. 4..^ . , ". e " = - _4a- ... ^ | ||
m = a C .". w"..v. "..a. o ". "- i d k ave A. *w* = .' . a- d ur.* _4 _' "..b.4 s a.% *. _"- a." e _' v, .' a . .a C' a . .a ---" dC sC. ^ ~ | |||
n' o ..'"s-a ny_eal c - oC a _" s# a ".a' a d | |||
m = a C .". w"..v. "..a. o ". "- i d | |||
k ave A. *w* = .' . a- d ur.* _4 _' "..b.4 s a.% *. _"- a." e _' v, .' a . .a C' a . .a ---" dC sC. ^ ~ | |||
n' o ..'"s-a | |||
~ | ~ | ||
- _4 .. a..k.e c '.< s c_ 4 . o_--* C 6 a --A _4 ..~2 , : e~~4 4- | - _4 .. a..k.e c '.< s c_ 4 . o_--* C 6 a --A _4 ..~2 , : e~~4 4- | ||
Line 1,118: | Line 747: | ||
-- - ~_4 | -- - ~_4 | ||
. a ~s ".b. -a _#__# ' _# .".C. #_ c. =- d-._'- # ". a k v .".O t m" e _" a_ | . a ~s ".b. -a _#__# ' _# .".C. #_ c. =- d-._'- # ". a k v .".O t m" e _" a_ | ||
b | b | ||
; _' " ". C n*w.s ,- "u bv se"<a"=.' | ; _' " ". C n*w.s ,- "u bv se"<a"=.' | ||
Line 1,124: | Line 752: | ||
j- k. = ", a. | j- k. = ", a. | ||
. . = . " . 3..".""- | . . = . " . 3..".""- | ||
.T C u s .' ,V . h*. = V,V burda" - -a *O | .T C u s .' ,V . h*. = V,V burda" - -a *O | ||
- "u e -a '. , " a s- "y e "- _# =- _' _' v w.".a. ." *. ~_'* a.- _4 .". ". | - "u e -a '. , " a s- "y e "- _# =- _' _' v w.".a. ." *. ~_'* a.- _4 .". ". | ||
, -- s *7 e.". - | , -- s *7 e.". - | ||
u---i ^ ". WC"'# - "=- _' .'.C W " b.c.7. - ' . " . **=Va"se- - ~~3 Cur.d- w'r. . 4 -b. .b.= s a .' ." e .=. d V | u---i ^ ". WC"'# - "=- _' .'.C W " b.c.7. - ' . " . **=Va"se- - ~~3 Cur.d- w'r. . 4 -b. .b.= s a .' ." e .=. d V w | ||
e a- .n. -1 -. ac | |||
. - A. (3 -- 7%e- .4 h. . . C ". *O - | . - A. (3 -- 7%e- .4 h. . . C ". *O - | ||
__/ | __/ | ||
y- - u b. a. _4 _* s a ~._4m. ~ 4 .= c. . _d - .e ,. T . d O. .k.a. | y- - u b. a. _4 _* s a ~._4m. ~ 4 .= c. . _d - .e ,. T . d O. .k.a. | ||
Ameen_1 yy cCa.A . h.a. .. .v a. a A C- ~ a C' .. | Ameen_1 yy cCa.A . h.a. .. .v a. a A C- ~ a C' .. | ||
c.C.re syeC.4 4_4 a.1 1 y , y e,sc,.s y Ouw a n*4 -.77" | c.C.re syeC.4 4_4 a.1 1 y , y e,sc,.s y Ouw a n*4 -.77" | ||
*t 2 | *t 2 a _s.se C -- u. -a s u f, uu.e _,.4c - ns4 .g ,c~._4-. -. u".,.C a _- | ||
a _s.se C -- u. -a s u f, uu.e _,.4c - ns4 .g ,c~._4-. -. u".,.C a _ | |||
scrutiny would be encouraged simply to sit back and Obserte the ccurse of the proceedinc- from the sidelines unless | scrutiny would be encouraged simply to sit back and Obserte the ccurse of the proceedinc- from the sidelines unless | ||
.a..d | .a..d u.".' _* _' 'he.v %ec_= ..e "e_"s"a^ | ||
u.".' _* _' 'he.v %ec_= ..e "e_"s"a^ | |||
. y a -- | . y a -- | ||
A',..*.=~. | A',..*.=~. | ||
Line 1,151: | Line 770: | ||
represented bv the existin3 carties ard . . | represented bv the existin3 carties ard . . | ||
*w,s.u wha. .w.ae.4 _- C .* . . a c . ._4 , a. ( .4 .: w e_- | *w,s.u wha. .w.ae.4 _- C .* . . a c . ._4 , a. ( .4 .: w e_- | ||
,,.,e | ,,.,e | ||
--) | --) | ||
Line 1,164: | Line 782: | ||
12 ..o . | 12 ..o . | ||
med. N | med. N | ||
= - | = - | ||
,q | ,q 3...C ...4.*. 6.. b. a ,d, b. a,. m. 5. , | ||
,3..q.._. ", 4 | ,3..q.._. ", 4 | ||
-. . . . . .. . ..b. 3. _. | -. . . . . .. . ..b. 3. _. | ||
Line 1,177: | Line 790: | ||
. .. . -ba4 n 3,. *.* | . .. . -ba4 n 3,. *.* | ||
.3.=. | .3.=. | ||
.; -,..,3..,. . -; | .; -,..,3..,. . -; | ||
_ ,,. .g.y ,.a ~q,a.. a, m- ..... .., . ..- .. ,,s. -. . | _ ,,. .g.y ,.a ~q,a.. a, m- ..... .., . ..- .. ,,s. -. . | ||
- y _ _ . a .,. | - y _ _ . a .,. | ||
-gw 3 | -gw 3 | ||
~; ,. a . .; . .. | ~; ,. a . .; . .. | ||
L. .wa, s- _ %. 3. . _ .%, . =a. 4. . | L. .wa, s- _ %. 3. . _ .%, . =a. 4. . | ||
Line 1,188: | Line 799: | ||
-w_.., . | -w_.., . | ||
w.'8.. . . % a. * .3. . a 4. s ii e , e .*. .d'. a.... a. .,... w . w ; m | w.'8.. . . % a. * .3. . a 4. s ii e , e .*. .d'. a.... a. .,... w . w ; m | ||
: 4. .Jw ..'s. | : 4. .Jw ..'s. | ||
. s. .:. a. n., _m _. a. . ' e. w* . . ,. .. 4. 2. w. _s .n. - | . s. .:. a. n., _m _. a. . ' e. w* . . ,. .. 4. 2. w. _s .n. - | ||
._. J h. ._. ... 3. 7 .-dw.,.._*=.., - | ._. J h. ._. ... 3. 7 .-dw.,.._*=.., - | ||
.m... w. | .m... w. | ||
b. | b. | ||
.E . ' : | .E . ' : | ||
* * ~ *A 2.-*y**.**.*2e..*.' 2... .?e,.*.*.=..**;* ** ** | * * ~ *A 2.-*y**.**.*2e..*.' 2... .?e,.*.*.=..**;* ** ** | ||
3..**. y . | 3..**. y . | ||
y .. .- | y .. .- | ||
Line 1,211: | Line 813: | ||
.. 2---. | .. 2---. | ||
-.-O;.. | -.-O;.. | ||
.w Cm w .w. . ,a.. 3. ._w 4 a | |||
.w | |||
. i. | . i. | ||
m | m | ||
Line 1,224: | Line 821: | ||
_- _A m .:. %wve _ %. | _- _A m .:. %wve _ %. | ||
v _.. b. a .'_..w..._se w .T.._. a. w mj. . ' _ . . ~ _ | v _.. b. a .'_..w..._se w .T.._. a. w mj. . ' _ . . ~ _ | ||
.m..-. _w.%. a. | .m..-. _w.%. a. | ||
C,. . ,4aa_4m,..I | C,. . ,4aa_4m,..I | ||
Line 1,230: | Line 826: | ||
w | w | ||
, g ,,_I _3 ._. _J - i . . a= . | , g ,,_I _3 ._. _J - i . . a= . | ||
: b. .= . . g .b. | : b. .= . . g .b. | ||
.w- | .w- | ||
.e ,n_a.,- . : 2, gey n .. | .e ,n_a.,- . : 2, gey n .. | ||
. 1 -. n ( ., ) | . 1 -. n ( ., ) | ||
.,. a. | .,. a. | ||
Line 1,250: | Line 841: | ||
;m- | ;m- | ||
: 2. 1- | : 2. 1- | ||
;* .y j | ;* .y j | ||
( t., & ..c. g e. ==.a .c.i u _- a aaa3 | |||
( t., & ..c. g e. ==.a .c.i u _- a | |||
aaa3 | |||
-== w. a - a---.e w .. . a a. . .y | -== w. a - a---.e w .. . a a. . .y | ||
. .y =wawa _ .s. _ w.==. a | . .y =wawa _ .s. _ w.==. a | ||
..a. .m . , .n .- | ..a. .m . , .n .- | ||
a lll. | a lll. | ||
a.O.-, .w. . ._ 1 .% .*.=. -ww- | a.O.-, .w. . ._ 1 .% .*.=. -ww- | ||
-mJ e g .. a=- _ = . .. ..4. . | -mJ e g .. a=- _ = . .. ..4. . | ||
*.'m. J -e . J -A : | *.'m. J -e . J -A : | ||
.. ; aw, A.. .J . 4 . e. . J. .* . . g * ..O _... . O 4 .O _. | .. ; aw, A.. .J . 4 . e. . J. .* . . g * ..O _... . O 4 .O _. | ||
.a . | .a . | ||
,.....a w.. . . _ -. .=. ;......,_.s._ -- s | ,.....a w.. . . _ -. .=. ;......,_.s._ -- s | ||
: y. *.- . <.- a a. . ..; | : y. *.- . <.- a a. . ..; | ||
. __ 3. , . . | . __ 3. , . . | ||
, ,,_.a,. | , ,,_.a,. | ||
.a . . . ,,. 1. e . ..~ . . _ . | .a . . . ,,. 1. e . ..~ . . _ . | ||
a a- _-~= u _n _.- n .u.a.; _ ; .. a- - :-: : | a a- _-~= u _n _.- n .u.a.; _ ; .. a- - :-: : | ||
~ %. a. .. - _. | ~ %. a. .. - _. | ||
.a _,. | .a _,. | ||
..a _- u. t:: | ..a _- u. t:: | ||
e.,,.,. | e.,,.,. | ||
-v-. a , .;. .m. | -v-. a , .;. .m. | ||
- , 2a .~ - _ - . . ,,. _ :. 2a- | - , 2a .~ - _ - . . ,,. _ :. 2a- | ||
,. - .....: a a | ,. - .....: a a | ||
. _a | . _a | ||
~n, - | ~n, - | ||
<1* | <1* | ||
Line 1,313: | Line 873: | ||
y_~., . -. .; ._ %. | y_~., . -. .; ._ %. | ||
. _: .. . a. | . _: .. . a. | ||
.=.m-*-. | .=.m-*-. | ||
%. 2 _ .* .. . a | %. 2 _ .* .. . a | ||
. .3." .'"..^*_ a .C | . .3." .'"..^*_ a .C | ||
. 2 .*.*. a.. ** f*, w * * ^ * | . 2 .*.*. a.. ** f*, w * * ^ * | ||
* w...O...*.*.**.*.*~ae,. '. .S. a* . | * w...O...*.*.**.*.*~ae,. '. .S. a* . | ||
a.""s***.*.S*.^* . . | a.""s***.*.S*.^* . . | ||
.u.a- _. | .u.a- _. | ||
- e. .a a | - e. .a a | ||
.uw., e ga a, n u..a... .n a %y m _ .s. n a .c., ... , .. . | .uw., e ga a, n u..a... .n a %y m _ .s. n a .c., ... , .. . | ||
w .n _.. .v i . _. .. . -.a . n... | w .n _.. .v i . _. .. . -.a . n... | ||
Line 1,335: | Line 887: | ||
-, - ~ | -, - ~ | ||
y #- | y #- | ||
: 2. , | : 2. , | ||
.- a S a _: .,.a --; . . . m. ., | .- a S a _: .,.a --; . . . m. ., | ||
a | a | ||
.a.: _, | .a.: _, | ||
a , u. .= ,a- . = A | a , u. .= ,a- . = A | ||
. 7.0 sIu.,C . .3. . 7. ", .1 .., u..w. e. S _s .a a | . 7.0 sIu.,C . .3. . 7. ", .1 .., u..w. e. S _s .a a | ||
- _.. : _a C ,. _a- u w. a . . - e .3. 7 | - _.. : _a C ,. _a- u w. a . . - e .3. 7 | ||
.~c c ,.a-A -e a- Aw g c 4- n. .. .n n .:-. : _ _ u.g. . .'s | .~c c ,.a-A -e a- Aw g c 4- n. .. .n n .:-. : _ _ u.g. . .'s | ||
: p. a. n _,._ .4 a ., ~ | : p. a. n _,._ .4 a ., ~ | ||
. x ,_ | . x ,_ | ||
Line 1,355: | Line 900: | ||
y .. .. .. _4 u- | y .. .. .. _4 u- | ||
" " # C *~* C .* ". " * * * * " * *. '. C.'..'.a~~.'.".*". ~ *. *** | " " # C *~* C .* ". " * * * * " * *. '. C.'..'.a~~.'.".*". ~ *. *** | ||
y-w | y-w | ||
* y"e"_~..*..". | * y"e"_~..*..". | ||
a..-._.a | a..-._.a | ||
. a ,. , | . a ,. , | ||
s | s | ||
. -.. ~ a t,.,..- .. | . -.. ~ a t,.,..- .. | ||
.w | .w | ||
- . . . _. , w. e. a. .. . .. a. a ~ 3, | - . . . _. , w. e. a. .. . .. a. a ~ 3, | ||
.. c . | .. c . | ||
.~ 3,-." . .* . a~ | .~ 3,-." . .* . a~ | ||
4 3 w --- a C _,. -. . A 3 | 4 3 w --- a C _,. -. . A 3 | ||
- -%. a v.4.e.r- ----- cm: C .,. C a _, _ _4 .. . , . .u. a .. .. 4. | - -%. a v.4.e.r- ----- cm: C .,. C a _, _ _4 .. . , . .u. a .. .. 4. | ||
Line 1,377: | Line 915: | ||
_4 u.a ..w....., .. . . . . ..a- _ u. a. .~. , | _4 u.a ..w....., .. . . . . ..a- _ u. a. .~. , | ||
: a. , | : a. , | ||
- .A. . | - .A. . | ||
e, a--,; . | e, a--,; . | ||
.~ | .~ | ||
_ n../. ., .a < z. | _ n../. ., .a < z. | ||
... o c-a ;_ : n. ., | ... o c-a ;_ : n. ., | ||
L, nw | L, nw | ||
., a nuO g,1. | |||
., a | |||
nuO g,1. | |||
- ,.wa .- w w.. a. CC _aC . . 4.. .aSa- w- , | - ,.wa .- w w.. a. CC _aC . . 4.. .aSa- w- , | ||
..aj | ..aj | ||
-1 l3 1. u 4 2 m. a ww y,A.- | -1 l3 1. u 4 2 m. a ww y,A.- | ||
n . . . . | n . . . . | ||
^-. | ^-. | ||
.". *. C, "w.".*, ** | .". *. C, "w.".*, ** | ||
,C US'w" .S | ,C US'w" .S | ||
."."-.".C, | ."."-.".C, | ||
- _..."ya.~~w"^o"."*.....'".".a . | - _..."ya.~~w"^o"."*.....'".".a . | ||
~ | ~ | ||
4". | 4". | ||
._ ,.* ., _ " '= f* *...' | ._ ,.* ., _ " '= f* *...' | ||
. n '. - ' | . n '. - ' | ||
O J4m | O J4m | ||
"' e ",, y"' e ** .'. '. ' '.' .". *- _'*a, | "' e ",, y"' e ** .'. '. ' '.' .". *- _'*a, | ||
- ."."- -- - ."w . " ** *''.'*''':'.''. | - ."."- -- - ."w . " ** *''.'*''':'.''. | ||
Line 1,420: | Line 943: | ||
u .. | u .. | ||
.z... { .a. w .v a a 'j _3.1. .i. a f _4 .. ..a T p | .z... { .a. w .v a a 'j _3.1. .i. a f _4 .. ..a T p | ||
.a_ae Se.".Se O-. _ S G C " ".' ' "j | .a_ae Se.".Se O-. _ S G C " ".' ' "j | ||
* wV , | * wV , | ||
..~. a y" a "-' - - a .'. ". a ",._ '^,s ". | ..~. a y" a "-' - - a .'. ". a ",._ '^,s ". | ||
. O... | . O... | ||
a.".O *w* .'''. e_ ' y" * .". ' V, j . " . ..*" "e ~ ~ ~ - *C C.".A w - '3C*d e .* a | a.".O *w* .'''. e_ ' y" * .". ' V, j . " . ..*" "e ~ ~ ~ - *C C.".A w - '3C*d e .* a | ||
* ^ | * ^ | ||
. ~ ' . "' . . ' . L' v^ ~..~',2 ". .V_ . | . ~ ' . "' . . ' . L' v^ ~..~',2 ". .V_ . | ||
~(Sk=C,.4.. N.',..'*-.=.- | ~(Sk=C,.4.. N.',..'*-.=.- | ||
w . Cv. -- a " : ". C *Je C w p N... | |||
. . w . a- 1 2..d .'. ) p .' ' n - | . . w . a- 1 2..d .'. ) p .' ' n - | ||
3 .*., _) r . _T 0 V. .T.t.*. .i. , S3 ( _i C, "< 9 ) .. .C. a_- o 2_m,,. | 3 .*., _) r . _T 0 V. .T.t.*. .i. , S3 ( _i C, "< 9 ) .. .C. a_- o 2_m,,. | ||
G n _1_: C- | |||
~ | ~ | ||
3 | 3 | ||
Line 1,442: | Line 962: | ||
-sm | -sm | ||
.t7,, | .t7,, | ||
C ..2 9. | |||
C ..2 | |||
9. | |||
. )s p na n =. 3 ,-s p s'd . .p w / cup _a.O.(p3-i . s_3 s / ) . y: ,I.' < ef. C*4 ef Cw e pa=a a".*/ | . )s p na n =. 3 ,-s p s'd . .p w / cup _a.O.(p3-i . s_3 s / ) . y: ,I.' < ef. C*4 ef Cw e pa=a a".*/ | ||
*-,aN. ''." _I-4*--2 .". f..''"."_#^** | *-,aN. ''." _I-4*--2 .". f..''"."_#^** | ||
,,s-4 | |||
,,s- | |||
4 | |||
( C.' *- " -*''.,.* . . w .. p t o.''..#. a~ .-.p .' a.*.. # .', ) , | ( C.' *- " -*''.,.* . . w .. p t o.''..#. a~ .-.p .' a.*.. # .', ) , | ||
. _s | . _s | ||
.% o.t.B ~ n, -s U r 3 y.s_~.f . v Q ~s t. r onD \q1I). ., | .% o.t.B ~ n, -s U r 3 y.s_~.f . v Q ~s t. r onD \q1I). ., | ||
-: 10 - | -: 10 - | ||
.c- . .4 334 c .. s a- ..a.c. o- -.... _t , . 4 - . a . .i. _t ... C " b. . | .c- . .4 334 c .. s a- ..a.c. o- -.... _t , . 4 - . a . .i. _t ... C " b. . | ||
.c a. c . 4. _. . . , , _, ,( _, ) m. n : . u. . a. a._ | .c a. c . 4. _. . . , , _, ,( _, ) m. n : . u. . a. a._ | ||
. v_ | . v_ | ||
--- .4.., | --- .4.., | ||
.. s _. .- w.. ,s u..w. a. -a- . e _. _= _4 _. ..,. _3 y .o c _. _4 .. m- . | .. s _. .- w.. ,s u..w. a. -a- . e _. _= _4 _. ..,. _3 y .o c _. _4 .. m- . | ||
...2..- | ...2..- | ||
2 . .. ., | 2 . .. ., | ||
,' ". s - _ _# _ ' _= b_ _' v _' _= . =-= f . "_ _' _. _' ^ . a , _'. = = a- "u - | ,' ". s - _ _# _ ' _= b_ _' v _' _= . =-= f . "_ _' _. _' ^ . a , _'. = = a- "u - | ||
= d_ _';" | = d_ _';" | ||
~ | ~ | ||
ane e s _ a_ _s_. , , c . _ha. .nx. , a_ n. , _ _a n -- s.u u , . , __u , | ane e s _ a_ _s_. , , c . _ha. .nx. , a_ n. , _ _a n -- s.u u , . , __u , | ||
y- . | y- . | ||
sent ,emonstrac..le- gccc cause :or no a o _4 . gso,an _4 .- e _4< .._4 2 ,,_,_3 4 | sent ,emonstrac..le- gccc cause :or no a o _4 . gso,an _4 .- e _4< .._4 2 ,,_,_3 4 | ||
...a_.as_aC _4n | ...a_.as_aC _4n | ||
,w...e on - .- w.m.e o.# _= : a_-__* "' . | ,w...e on - .- w.m.e o.# _= : a_-__* "' . | ||
--=- - :- - ~ c==.di.nc. | --=- - :- - ~ c==.di.nc. | ||
w _ _' _' =c. .o ,_w i | w _ _' _' =c. .o ,_w i | ||
+ | + | ||
=v. b._' o- _'...=_-=e..w_d"..b._'.". | =v. b._' o- _'...=_-=e..w_d"..b._'.". | ||
~- | ~- | ||
..w. a. .s_,c,4-wo .. e c | ..w. a. .s_,c,4-wo .. e c | ||
. _4._..e _ _4..._4 . o . _of As the Court stated in Eas:cn Utilities Commission v. | . _4._..e _ _4..._4 . o . _of As the Court stated in Eas:cn Utilities Commission v. | ||
_i _r C ,. 4 *4 *, e.&- ma 3.=2 _l o_ e 0 ) ,f.e . . ,c e m. A_-3o _4 - - -----. | _i _r C ,. 4 *4 *, e.&- ma 3.=2 _l o_ e 0 ) ,f.e . . ,c e m. A_-3o _4 - - -----. | ||
Line 1,501: | Line 998: | ||
4 | 4 | ||
: 2. w.. _4 . . _4 g __ _.__. , _ , . = a C. =..w . " _# =. m- _= ~ =_. . * . * ..-. ^. .. c . _4 "." *. = A "_S.., =..C''.'.".=...*=. | : 2. w.. _4 . . _4 g __ _.__. , _ , . = a C. =..w . " _# =. m- _= ~ =_. . * . * ..-. ^. .. c . _4 "." *. = A "_S.., =..C''.'.".=...*=. | ||
. _. g g . o- .m..c f g i a. A. --.a,= . _- a_ _T =jn _, _ c.a s _4 .. .l ._4 . .'4 . ' . a. | . _. g g . o- .m..c f g i a. A. --.a,= . _- a_ _T =jn _, _ c.a s _4 .. .l ._4 . .'4 . ' . a. | ||
- - . . . . C# | - - . . . . C# | ||
m w_- | m w_- | ||
f C a a C_4 ..n ; _4a- f amonA. s..wn.w sa a_ _ne< _T j .__. . : - .. . . . a. M | f C a a C_4 ..n ; _4a- f amonA. s..wn.w sa a_ _ne< _T j .__. . : - .. . . . a. M | ||
_ a_ ;- c a _n _.j , aX. w ..--m_a5 s,._ | _ a_ ;- c a _n _.j , aX. w ..--m_a5 s,._ | ||
-v.m .a. _. .s .e . .s . . .. .. . - ., . .s. y _? ;o _._.__s_..; | -v.m .a. _. .s .e . .s . . .. .. . - ., . .s. y _? ;o _._.__s_..; | ||
4 ,.4 , | 4 ,.4 , | ||
Line 1,519: | Line 1,010: | ||
_4 . . w. a. .F.i _4-., *m. _i a. a, | _4 . . w. a. .F.i _4-., *m. _i a. a, | ||
. .y_--v.. y _-wc. o. a. C' _' . .3 -. | . .y_--v.. y _-wc. o. a. C' _' . .3 -. | ||
an acministrative hearine woulc. .ce. ~ | an acministrative hearine woulc. .ce. ~ | ||
a meaningless charade if these with 2 2n ,e , o - - c . | a meaningless charade if these with 2 2n ,e , o - - c . | ||
. w: . ,. 4 -; . o --.--2-._4,4-,.. u n_ - . w a. | . w: . ,. 4 -; . o --.--2-._4,4-,.. u n_ - . w a. | ||
.=7'*wed - "^ - s-=.".A- --_44'" "": _ = . .4- ' . = . . , . | .=7'*wed - "^ - s-=.".A- --_44'" "": _ = . .4- ' . = . . , . | ||
..e va_**. .b.e _' a.s s , A=~.sa..d_ | ..e va_**. .b.e _' a.s s , A=~.sa..d_ | ||
_= _- =. _ = v. wP.=. .. | _= _- =. _ = v. wP.=. .. | ||
thev do not like the result. | thev do not like the result. | ||
. _7/ | . _7/ | ||
._ _,ea. | ._ _,ea. | ||
o 10 sIRC. _ . o w.. s a __.e a_ _s _so r. . -=- | o 10 sIRC. _ . o w.. s a __.e a_ _s _so r. . -=- | ||
. w | . w | ||
.e .1.,..e _- | .e .1.,..e _- | ||
3 card's decision at an earlier point in the Skaci:: | 3 card's decision at an earlier point in the Skaci:: | ||
f ecaad_* .c, w h e ~ e .' '. c h. _= s .4 .~ =. 6 = ,e ". _ | f ecaad_* .c, w h e ~ e .' '. c h. _= s .4 .~ =. 6 = ,e ". _ | ||
* c.n a. _- #..- ~. _- _ o - | * c.n a. _- #..- ~. _- _ o - | ||
.. e - =.~. .= u e m--.. *".e | .. e - =.~. .= u e m--.. *".e | ||
'i ^ | 'i ^ | ||
- cy _4 ...i n.ns c 3 ' b. a. r,e e. a.. .e.. c 3- . | - cy _4 ...i n.ns c 3 ' b. a. r,e e. a.. .e.. c 3- . | ||
ai.C .w | ai.C .w | ||
..n. . __4C. . -.e Na..C .ow u.s._e_: C .,. C.m .- 2 _4 .. Co . .a..r._._4 c..s . | ..n. . __4C. . -.e Na..C .ow u.s._e_: C .,. C.m .- 2 _4 .. Co . .a..r._._4 c..s . | ||
as , w~as_a- 2e _-_. 4 .s .no n 4 .,. .. ..re , --_4 c n . as .w.. a. nyre,_ | as , w~as_a- 2e _-_. 4 .s .no n 4 .,. .. ..re , --_4 c n . as .w.. a. nyre,_ | ||
-3 card noted, no party to a NRC proceeding purports n.o. - | -3 card noted, no party to a NRC proceeding purports n.o. - | ||
3w-_.an..ae-w.e Co ..C.,ess -- . Oe _[.4.sj- . | 3w-_.an..ae-w.e Co ..C.,ess -- . Oe _[.4.sj- . | ||
-_w 4m,a .ua. -ev. , . _ | -_w 4m,a .ua. -ev. , . _ | ||
C_l us d ops" * = g a d i .a. "; '- b.e _4my* a ". *. c .# Cvi^ .t =. .".* 4 .^ P.s c ". | C_l us d ops" * = g a d i .a. "; '- b.e _4my* a ". *. c .# Cvi^ .t =. .".* 4 .^ P.s c ". | ||
o t.ner .reta. tioners , and nit is not enou n Icr a c.eti- | |||
. - = | . - = | ||
. . .i u _1 1 =. d .4 .. *. a = | . . .i u _1 1 =. d .4 .. *. a = | ||
"._4 cn.e.-] s .i .c. .' .v ' o = s s e _- . _". a ". ( _4o 6 was] . . | "._4 cn.e.-] s .i .c. .' .v ' o = s s e _- . _". a ". ( _4o 6 was] . . | ||
alse-sense c:. securitv. - t.ne c.articication or | alse-sense c:. securitv. - t.ne c.articication or | ||
.v . | .v . | ||
another carty]." Puc_e: Sound Pcwer & Lic_ht Ccmc_any | another carty]." Puc_e: Sound Pcwer & Lic_ht Ccmc_any t | ||
t | |||
-(Skagit Nuclear Pcwer Pro]ect, Units 1 and 2), ALA3- | -(Skagit Nuclear Pcwer Pro]ect, Units 1 and 2), ALA3- | ||
-552, 10 NRC 1, 8-9 '(1979). | -552, 10 NRC 1, 8-9 '(1979). | ||
~ | ~ | ||
See also Gulf States-Utilities - Ccmpany (River Send Station, Units 1 and 2) , | See also Gulf States-Utilities - Ccmpany (River Send Station, Units 1 and 2) , | ||
ALA3-444,-6 NRC 760, 796 (1977). Duke Power Cc==any | ALA3-444,-6 NRC 760, 796 (1977). Duke Power Cc==any (Cherokee Nuclear Station, Units 1, 2 and 3), ALA3-440, 6 - N R C o, ,, 2 -,_ , o*r (29 , | ||
(Cherokee Nuclear Station, Units 1, 2 and 3), ALA3-440, 6 - N R C o, ,, 2 -,_ , o*r (29 , | |||
es). | es). | ||
7/- Pacific Gas and Electric Company (Diablo Canyon Nuclear Power Plant, Units 1 and 2) , A A3-583, 11 NRC 447, 448 - | 7/- Pacific Gas and Electric Company (Diablo Canyon Nuclear Power Plant, Units 1 and 2) , A A3-583, 11 NRC 447, 448 - | ||
(1980). | (1980). | ||
m | m | ||
-u.,s, : 4.. - 4.: ,a- , . .. | -u.,s, : 4.. - 4.: ,a- , . .. | ||
: n. . . a. . . . -- - =. :.-.=.:-~~~ u =- ,,,, | : n. . . a. . . . -- - =. :.-.=.:-~~~ u =- ,,,, | ||
.. -; . ; 4-.. , - - - - | .. -; . ; 4-.. , - - - - | ||
: e. .: .. -..-..na.-...n.=...n- | : e. .: .. -..-..na.-...n.=...n- | ||
Line 1,594: | Line 1,061: | ||
.,=. :: ., | .,=. :: ., | ||
---.A - . - - . | ---.A - . - - . | ||
-...n....4...=. | -...n....4...=. | ||
4- .u.n ,., . ,- m.u.-..; - . n _..n: , | 4- .u.n ,., . ,- m.u.-..; - . n _..n: , | ||
-.C ,-. . . . . , = . . | -.C ,-. . . . . , = . . | ||
. . . n. -u-==. | . . . n. -u-==. | ||
...= | ...= | ||
u. | u. | ||
w=a ;4-..c., : : ,-a - -=,..a...=;,. : - | w=a ;4-..c., : : ,-a - -=,..a...=;,. : - | ||
:- .u.. a. -_- a.. ,, = .,. a .4 . . .----- . . | :- .u.. a. -_- a.. ,, = .,. a .4 . . .----- . . | ||
, = - | , = - | ||
.-~... ,,...--..,- | .-~... ,,...--..,- | ||
.u ,_, | .u ,_, | ||
2 | 2 | ||
-...n..-- -- c - | -...n..-- -- c - | ||
... , . a u. , uaa ,. | ... , . a u. , uaa ,. | ||
.=. -.u. a. -.e,.. -s --. --u,4n,-4 | .=. -.u. a. -.e,.. -s --. --u,4n,-4 | ||
:------- C,.. n, : | :------- C,.. n, : | ||
s.; c : r g f q .q , o , -J %=C*",ae | s.; c : r g f q .q , o , -J %=C*",ae | ||
. ".s ". .-ao a 3"- | . ".s ". .-ao a 3"- | ||
- , - " . = a " by" = - . = . = _ - C _# | - , - " . = a " by" = - . = . = _ - C _# | ||
e..e. | e..e. | ||
24 % . , . n,. n | 24 % . , . n,. n | ||
: w. e -- .. . m..u . _4C..-a 2.,4- .a . | : w. e -- .. . m..u . _4C..-a 2.,4- .a . | ||
%. m. v.. m. . e- c/ 24 | %. m. v.. m. . e- c/ 24 | ||
-.- m..u. c. - -3 | -.- m..u. c. - -3 | ||
Line 1,646: | Line 1,090: | ||
...s...J | ...s...J | ||
: e. -- | : e. -- | ||
w - .m. b. s. . . . 4 . . . a- | w - .m. b. s. . . . 4 . . . a-W-%.. 4 .- .%. .%..,.*.*3 %.=2C - . . 4 m..C 4*2 | ||
W-%.. 4 .- .%. .%..,.*.*3 %.=2C - . . 4 m..C | |||
4*2 | |||
-==-.h. = | -==-.h. = | ||
*.y. | *.y. | ||
-/ | -/ | ||
, -,, --- -4 a .q N | , -,, --- -4 a .q N | ||
~ | ~ | ||
... . .m . ..%. .:. 2,,=. . a ,. % ;. 2. p . .~~./ | ... . .m . ..%. .:. 2,,=. . a ,. % ;. 2. p . .~~./ | ||
~_~ | ~_~ | ||
..a %. -2 | ..a %. -2 | ||
Line 1,665: | Line 1,102: | ||
- , o-. .3 4 .. ; Q3 A 2 . . ~~. , w a ---p -s? n , % | - , o-. .3 4 .. ; Q3 A 2 . . ~~. , w a ---p -s? n , % | ||
--2 8.m. e. 1. % | --2 8.m. e. 1. % | ||
..w e n- .* A s- .. , .w=;* ~ .4 .w---..m...e | ..w e n- .* A s- .. , .w=;* ~ .4 .w---..m...e | ||
. ,.. . -a S , _9n.s o 47 25 | . ,.. . -a S , _9n.s o 47 25 | ||
-...-..J-.a | -...-..J-.a | ||
-*. m- m | -*. m- m | ||
Line 1,676: | Line 1,111: | ||
J 3..%., .* - -,3 h , , w 4 m. .. | J 3..%., .* - -,3 h , , w 4 m. .. | ||
-. .. .m. o. ..a..- C... | -. .. .m. o. ..a..- C... | ||
w z - .- | w z - .- | ||
-n w | -n w | ||
. .~...a .n.. %. c. . . ..%.a. .w. a- 1 - a. f .v a.gy4o | . .~...a .n.. %. c. . . ..%.a. .w. a- 1 - a. f .v a.gy4o | ||
-- . - 6 g.g *.. | -- . - 6 g.g *.. | ||
5 .. 4. u. | 5 .. 4. u. | ||
.. 15 a .4.... 4 .* .u. .w ~~...2.._ | .. 15 a .4.... 4 .* .u. .w ~~...2.._ | ||
-e d | -e d | ||
. 4 n..~e | . 4 n..~e n~~ | ||
n~~ | |||
Lv CO-. ..k.a. ~4.. ..- S w u.s.n r.,o.:s - , a-. . | Lv CO-. ..k.a. ~4.. ..- S w u.s.n r.,o.:s - , a-. . | ||
. .r .m e.. ,w... .s ., 8 .. | . .r .m e.. ,w... .s ., 8 .. | ||
Line 1,697: | Line 1,124: | ||
-, ru 3. -w4- | -, ru 3. -w4- | ||
-_a | -_a | ||
: 3. . 2 4.,.-..,.. | : 3. . 2 4.,.-..,.. | ||
.s. .e .e c - . u..w.., f ... 4. .*.; : . . _! . .:. .u., /m. . eo e - .- . ...2 . .o | .s. .e .e c - . u..w.., f ... 4. .*.; : . . _! . .:. .u., /m. . eo e - .- . ...2 . .o | ||
. a".'.e 2 ',.' b ;" | . a".'.e 2 ',.' b ;" | ||
* C ' p .W d | * C ' p .W d | ||
Line 1,717: | Line 1,137: | ||
- . -. ".aS .~y"e "_" 1_0 * | - . -. ".aS .~y"e "_" 1_0 * | ||
* 4- ./_ C ".. | * 4- ./_ C ".. | ||
CCOS ..C C ,..Su.a-,,-s w --w. n3CCC - --- - | CCOS ..C C ,..Su.a-,,-s w --w. n3CCC - --- - | ||
3., S e n : | 3., S e n : | ||
0- J.... r 2 n *K.w. 2 ,- . S c _. ea- | 0- J.... r 2 n *K.w. 2 ,- . S c _. ea- | ||
. wa.i. | . wa.i. | ||
y" "*- C . a S '-_4 .".a . 4 C .". 4..". ** | y" "*- C . a S '-_4 .".a . 4 C .". 4..". ** | ||
.#. a .4 ..C. h..# .~.ia" e | .#. a .4 ..C. h..# .~.ia" e | ||
.#. "'".a. .#..:o Ce C.#.' # #..". * .". "- 4 .S. .i | .#. "'".a. .#..:o Ce C.#.' # #..". * .". "- 4 .S. .i | ||
-.s_.4__4 3- a 6._4- p. .. . | -.s_.4__4 3- a 6._4- p. .. . | ||
O 44 - e m A | O 44 - e m A | ||
. .V.o. w..w- w_m C .1 4 e .s... ' .r % a C .n. b.s. i_ m.e a.. V_ r. .h. .w a cn,., .M 4 1 .s TA S .1 s2 .s. v.. | . .V.o. w..w- w_m C .1 4 e .s... ' .r % a C .n. b.s. i_ m.e a.. V_ r. .h. .w a cn,., .M 4 1 .s TA S .1 s2 .s. v.. | ||
.* wmw.7,.p a..w q c-m-,.cp. r n,. p. .~ ~. a"o . aa A.. ) r " .M.e .m..c .~. .n .. d g~.. s qd Q .ge .. | .* wmw.7,.p a..w q c-m-,.cp. r n,. p. .~ ~. a"o . aa A.. ) r " .M.e .m..c .~. .n .. d g~.. s qd Q .ge .. | ||
.=.e 3 n ..t. e.n . | .=.e 3 n ..t. e.n . | ||
ev' won CC .. u. m.n. *. 4 CnS t ,J_- a b, m . . -& wC | ev' won CC .. u. m.n. *. 4 CnS t ,J_- a b, m . . -& wC | ||
.%a ,I.4 a e4 C .f 5. Rt Le G / C 0. | .%a ,I.4 a e4 C .f 5. Rt Le G / C 0. | ||
- - . -- 7 7 %e ] , " | - - . -- 7 7 %e ] , " | ||
DC C.k- = ~. N. C . o0-280 ( t a .~ S ' _* _ '_ ) ( _v a . -". . .3, 1990), S .' 4 e, Cy. | |||
DC C.k- = ~. N. C . o0-280 ( t a .~ S ' _* _ '_ ) ( _v a . -". . .3, | |||
1990), S .' 4 e, Cy. | |||
at 2-3. | at 2-3. | ||
0' -- - | 0' -- - | ||
Line 1,750: | Line 1,159: | ||
a. | a. | ||
_10 ... *. a .. .re ..C .* r . a.a.x w .. s- S ., | _10 ... *. a .. .re ..C .* r . a.a.x w .. s- S ., | ||
e _* ' a- .M.a - ..* 4 Cn u m., 4'.C'.. 4 6- | e _* ' a- .M.a - ..* 4 Cn u m., 4'.C'.. 4 6-ad A 4 *. 4 -- .. 2 . | ||
o Cw n .a..u 4 CnS 3..,. | o Cw n .a..u 4 CnS 3..,. | ||
1 1 | 1 1 | ||
12 - | 12 - | ||
.r ..w-. | .r ..w-. | ||
, . - , a, . .n . s s- ...C . 4-n . | , . - , a, . .n . s s- ...C . 4-n . | ||
,2, 4 .. , | ,2, 4 .. , | ||
..e,4 - -. . .,,. | ..e,4 - -. . .,,. | ||
Line 1,771: | Line 1,173: | ||
* C .'". a - . | * C .'". a - . | ||
_+C"%-=,~.i.."." # .- , -' = e 4 .". '. a. -"< a. .". . 4-." . u.*.#--- * * | _+C"%-=,~.i.."." # .- , -' = e 4 .". '. a. -"< a. .". . 4-." . u.*.#--- * * | ||
...k.. . S 2 C O.n.C- - | ...k.. . S 2 C O.n.C- - | ||
, 1.O C . .r . 0.. . 34.,1_ w' (2w) ( 4 4 s _ ( ,7) . , | , 1.O C . .r . 0.. . 34.,1_ w' (2w) ( 4 4 s _ ( ,7) . , | ||
..o | ..o | ||
.O | .O | ||
. - o_-4_ . .2_.4 ns. _w.- | . - o_-4_ . .2_.4 ns. _w.- | ||
Line 1,783: | Line 1,181: | ||
a.o 4 n&.e -..e.._. 4 C., _w | a.o 4 n&.e -..e.._. 4 C., _w | ||
: w. .- o _ erC.C | : w. .- o _ erC.C | ||
_4s - C 1.s. s - -m 2-uO ww.k. e 3.s.a _4 _1- 3 h _4 | _4s - C 1.s. s - -m 2-uO ww.k. e 3.s.a _4 _1- 3 h _4 | ||
- < . - - - - --7 -; | - < . - - - - --7 -; | ||
Line 1,789: | Line 1,186: | ||
O- Ot..o b - m e , .,.S .v.w | O- Ot..o b - m e , .,.S .v.w | ||
...e- *s'D.. y .ws | ...e- *s'D.. y .ws | ||
-a*4 yo --- | -a*4 yo --- | ||
4 3 .a..t- s 4 .. G O S '.S N. #--7 ' D*. | 4 3 .a..t- s 4 .. G O S '.S N. #--7 ' D*. | ||
Line 1,796: | Line 1,192: | ||
~ | ~ | ||
c.o | c.o | ||
=C - n' a | =C - n' a | ||
..o =C, | ..o =C, | ||
- .V.V3 .. | - .V.V3 .. | ||
Line 1,806: | Line 1,200: | ||
.-a- ' w= ~.a . 'wv^ ""e | .-a- ' w= ~.a . 'wv^ ""e | ||
- .#.4.7a..C.#'_' - | - .#.4.7a..C.#'_' - | ||
_: .w ...e a | _: .w ...e a v s - yu-2 b _4 _1 _4 .; | ||
v s - yu-2 b _4 _1 _4 .; | |||
- ny--y .1 4 C .m .,. _. a . %- | - ny--y .1 4 C .m .,. _. a . %- | ||
s_. v3 4*3s,,Se | s_. v3 4*3s,,Se | ||
. . - uCe- s .w-.r u C4 = | . . - uCe- s .w-.r u C4 = | ||
2 | 2 s --e_,.. | ||
s --e_,.. | |||
yyw 4 .. w. a. ---- | yyw 4 .. w. a. ---- | ||
-m-.- 4- m | -m-.- 4- m | ||
Line 1,825: | Line 1,211: | ||
.. . . -.3.,og. a..b _43 _4 g g Ua - . .._4 | .. . . -.3.,og. a..b _43 _4 g g Ua - . .._4 | ||
;w - m _ g u s .1,7 _4a- e,ne-_4 s ._ - ..sh's.." | ;w - m _ g u s .1,7 _4a- e,ne-_4 s ._ - ..sh's.." | ||
m | m | ||
-< u s.. . , = v.4 . a- a.- n.".C -"- "^"...*."...'.'..S | -< u s.. . , = v.4 . a- a.- n.".C -"- "^"...*."...'.'..S | ||
Line 1,832: | Line 1,216: | ||
-.. .n. . .v, .~ -y. S. V _#w " U S ;' " = C.7.4 ". . * -d 4 | -.. .n. . .v, .~ -y. S. V _#w " U S ;' " = C.7.4 ". . * -d 4 | ||
4 | 4 | ||
-.. u. 4. . . sn. g | -.. u. 4. . . sn. g a wa | ||
a wa | |||
.,anu -- | .,anu -- | ||
,- ,=-, ..v.u. | ,- ,=-, ..v.u. | ||
. 4 .. a A a o n. g ... , . ..., g | . 4 .. a A a o n. g ... , . ..., g | ||
.m.,_. ~ , | .m.,_. ~ , | ||
...,u. ,. v g g _ s s-l ac.k C# =.".',I 3 ~Cv"d v="Se #^- | ...,u. ,. v g g _ s s-l ac.k C# =.".',I 3 ~Cv"d v="Se #^- | ||
: w. # = _4 ' "- --* '.O | : w. # = _4 ' "- --* '.O | ||
_- .# .4 .l a. ^w ".. ". 4 "...e , " =- _' s C ym -ev.4 w dm- S .b.e .14..C.k y-4.w. | _- .# .4 .l a. ^w ".. ". 4 "...e , " =- _' s C ym -ev.4 w dm- S .b.e .14..C.k y-4.w. | ||
- - _am.,w 4 4...A 4 ..g h- h.s | - - _am.,w 4 4...A 4 ..g h- h.s e | ||
am b.e - -3 45 no e rb.o.,. w- | |||
--*- .=. S C .". . . ' . - .=.# | --*- .=. S C .". . . ' . - .=.# | ||
- ~ 4 . . .' .".C, { 'w.". *. .'.=...i * -^"..'.oC',.'^."..S,*" | - ~ 4 . . .' .".C, { 'w.". *. .'.=...i * -^"..'.oC',.'^."..S,*" | ||
-w s ' .=. '/...= " S 3 ' m- | -w s ' .=. '/...= " S 3 ' m-e-=~- e div, e..gn, -e s s ed 3- | ||
e-=~- e div, e..gn, -e s s ed 3- | |||
"b -a.ge. m .i d ed- . - ' | "b -a.ge. m .i d ed- . - ' | ||
_. _4 .._. m-- - e s * ~n _4 _1 _1 | _. _4 .._. m-- - e s * ~n _4 _1 _1 4- --m-- | ||
4- --m-- | |||
- y . o. g e..~.e--A 11/ | - y . o. g e..~.e--A 11/ | ||
CV eX1s tinc. .Oartie s . n-i t | |||
CV eX1s tinc. .Oartie s . n- | |||
i t | |||
y , . . | y , . . | ||
..O:eCVer, in SSSeSSinq 2. e SeCCnc :aC;Or, Cne Boarc. | ..O:eCVer, in SSSeSSinq 2. e SeCCnc :aC;Or, Cne Boarc. | ||
1 g w..ow u_l d w-n . . .a 4 A - e *. " ..C ". C n .' V, W.".a ".e _" | 1 g w..ow u_l d w-n . . .a 4 A - e *. " ..C ". C n .' V, W.".a ".e _" | ||
w.ob y a_".4ag .-- 9. 4 1 | w.ob y a_".4ag .-- 9. 4 1 | ||
-- 1 a deC"-n a1"; | -- 1 a deC"-n a1"; | ||
y- . o *w = C *. .'a.a | y- . o *w = C *. .'a.a | ||
. _4..'.a.-a.s | . _4..'.a.-a.s | ||
Line 1,880: | Line 1,244: | ||
= _- a. o *.". a - *.ae = ..S wh.a -=b'r y e".' -4 C 7 =- - " = .7 | = _- a. o *.". a - *.ae = ..S wh.a -=b'r y e".' -4 C 7 =- - " = .7 | ||
-- , -- hi Se'# y . -w- "o | -- , -- hi Se'# y . -w- "o | ||
= C . ". _45 4 7 | |||
= C . ". _45 | |||
4 7 | |||
_51 | _51 | ||
.a.*. a--- a S ' S . -v.a.C_ =.~.d ar.ic ".." .d - _C_ C --m g anv_ | .a.*. a--- a S ' S . -v.a.C_ =.~.d ar.ic ".." .d - _C_ C --m g anv_ | ||
- (v~e._eSyC-. ".3".C_'==- | - (v~e._eSyC-. ".3".C_'==- | ||
'Cwer StatiCn, Units 1 and 2) , ALA3-292, 2 NRC 631, 647 (1975). _AS noted in the precedinc, d SCuSS1Cn, coSC C: Dr. | 'Cwer StatiCn, Units 1 and 2) , ALA3-292, 2 NRC 631, 647 (1975). _AS noted in the precedinc, d SCuSS1Cn, coSC C: Dr. | ||
11/ | 11/ | ||
_ _- m.. k.. e e. Li _l o | _ _- m.. k.. e e. Li _l o | ||
. - ?.S 1 a..d , Suc 3, - | . - ?.S 1 a..d , Suc 3, - | ||
e1 a - _4 .- on4 .- n _4o.. a e ,*. | e1 a - _4 .- on4 .- n _4o.. a e ,*. | ||
.. -- - + | .. -- - + | ||
13 - | 13 - | ||
: 2. .,.. . >. .u. .o. s . . a i a- -..-,-_..a- ,._.4...,..a._,.. a ,a. _ _4 -< a,. | : 2. .,.. . >. .u. .o. s . . a i a- -..-,-_..a- ,._.4...,..a._,.. a ,a. _ _4 -< a,. | ||
w : .- . ,,.. -. | w : .- . ,,.. -. | ||
,.a, ,4 | ,.a, ,4 | ||
. 2 . | . 2 . | ||
. w- . .m | . w- . .m | ||
- - a- .,.--.74 , u. | - - a- .,.--.74 , u. | ||
Line 1,910: | Line 1,265: | ||
~ . .. "; , , | ~ . .. "; , , | ||
- ....a- | - ....a- | ||
. .*h.._*w.*. | . .*h.._*w.*. | ||
.v. | .v. | ||
--. . .n.. . d sau. av 'u* _l m d hg | --. . .n.. . d sau. av 'u* _l m d hg | ||
;,w ~_,_ | ;,w ~_,_ | ||
_nyy-wy | _nyy-wy | ||
Line 1,921: | Line 1,273: | ||
.;----- gG -a A %a:n-a | .;----- gG -a A %a:n-a | ||
- --_w-w w .- . a -a. c, u n-,--- -- ,y % c w# _' * * * | - --_w-w w .- . a -a. c, u n-,--- -- ,y % c w# _' * * * | ||
~- | ~- | ||
no a.. u. a. _ u. .; _- mA v.c_ :_n- | no a.. u. a. _ u. .; _- mA v.c_ :_n-w- .~,_ a | ||
w- .~,_ a | |||
- n n .. . a.n._ _4w.. | - n n .. . a.n._ _4w.. | ||
: w. - ,s , _ u. a .v. - a,. _4s-Q | : w. - ,s , _ u. a .v. - a,. _4s-Q ac .. _ - . ; | ||
ac .. _ - . ; | |||
.s.u. a- _-,.n.. > u.. . = -, -..... | .s.u. a- _-,.n.. > u.. . = -, -..... | ||
, > u. ., a a,. _- _ u. , _ u.. aa - | , > u. ., a a,. _- _ u. , _ u.. aa - | ||
a.u.n.n_2..: _ . . , - - -; . .. | a.u.n.n_2..: _ . . , - - -; . .. | ||
yw_ . _: _: f g _.-s-, | yw_ . _: _: f g _.-s-, | ||
- - .. m g ,y - - a w..- ,u | - - .. m g ,y - - a w..- ,u | ||
-wa,-- - _1 , y ug _ | -wa,-- - _1 , y ug _ | ||
a. | a. | ||
v ge._.af . _.m g 5 3_4o- -_ _.a | v ge._.af . _.m g 5 3_4o- -_ _.a m C a *# #. | ||
m C a *# #. | |||
. c V 2_ _' ,. ^, _4 ."."; = s~^, L' .".d .- | . c V 2_ _' ,. ^, _4 ."."; = s~^, L' .".d .- | ||
* C w-- o-#. 3. 7 7 _4 ,. a..m.s_ | * C w-- o-#. 3. 7 7 _4 ,. a..m.s_ | ||
Line 1,948: | Line 1,292: | ||
. . s- ya" .d .' _' ' 2 5 _-". _# | . . s- ya" .d .' _' ' 2 5 _-". _# | ||
_ . .". "; ".v'.''*. | _ . .". "; ".v'.''*. | ||
=- : - _ .a _m -za | =- : - _ .a _m -za | ||
- e, g _ a- | - e, g _ a- | ||
.. _ u.= , . _w- . .. s -_-~ c _- 4 . .c , n -y-a _ ,, . _: ._.c. w _- c e. n..n... _a m | .. _ u.= , . _w- . .. s -_-~ c _- 4 . .c , n -y-a _ ,, . _: ._.c. w _- c e. n..n... _a m c .4 . .. : . . c, , | ||
c .4 . .. : . . c, , | |||
... . r i e,, 4__:_y. _...a.,...u. | ... . r i e,, 4__:_y. _...a.,...u. | ||
_ a,. .,. _- __ | _ a,. .,. _- __ | ||
. - -e .s u..u. a. y g __ _ __ _4 r, n.. -- a a t - | . - -e .s u..u. a. y g __ _ __ _4 r, n.. -- a a t - | ||
----_4_y sui 1 | ----_4_y sui 1 | ||
.S. a- 2 <------- | .S. a- 2 <------- | ||
- .. , 7 . . , w i a --ww. . _._ 4 % r | - .. , 7 . . , w i a --ww. . _._ 4 % r | ||
* 2--_c.-- . | * 2--_c.-- . | ||
...2 " "_ -^ ---- | ...2 " "_ -^ ---- | ||
y C a c d 4 .". " _4a- | y C a c d 4 .". " _4a- | ||
Line 1,974: | Line 1,308: | ||
-^ | -^ | ||
-w | -w | ||
. s' _' _' .W # .".": y a _- _* "_ _4 - | . s' _' _' .W # .".": y a _- _* "_ _4 - | ||
y a ___4 v I,. c .n. _ u.e | y a ___4 v I,. c .n. _ u.e f | ||
f | |||
., _ u m_: v w | ., _ u m_: v w | ||
..a i | |||
..a | |||
i | |||
_9 aCX 4 ..ny s_u. s .,.C' _s ..; u .., .. : ._ a,. _e.,. a. . . a. . | _9 aCX 4 ..ny s_u. s .,.C' _s ..; u .., .. : ._ a,. _e.,. a. . . a. . | ||
.s , | .s , | ||
__/ u u. e _- a ;_ ,c cas_:a- _ v _. | __/ u u. e _- a ;_ ,c cas_:a- _ v _. | ||
_i _S | _i _S | ||
._a-, . - c_ _ .a3n.u._ . , n _a .. | ._a-, . - c_ _ .a3n.u._ . , n _a .. | ||
n ye_.- -,_a..g a | n ye_.- -,_a..g a | ||
.3, . a | .3, . a | ||
,...=."._'c..#-- | ,...=."._'c..#-- | ||
^ | ^ | ||
--- W"._'-". . .$ -y a,. _4 _ _# ., .e _ , _' _4 5. =. . _ . ? .$..~ >."._= ".-.=. e _- ". n .~. = , | --- W"._'-". . .$ -y a,. _4 _ _# ., .e _ , _' _4 5. =. . _ . ? .$..~ >."._= ".-.=. e _- ". n .~. = , | ||
"w , e. c _e _ma-aa | "w , e. c _e _ma-aa | ||
. . - . ---- ..c _v.' ._4 ..g ~ eyo n.d .g_4a - b a e a s s e . '. 4.^.". wb._4w" .". . _d.".". | . . - . ---- ..c _v.' ._4 ..g ~ eyo n.d .g_4a - b a e a s s e . '. 4.^.". wb._4w" .". . _d.".". | ||
3 lead [the Scard] to believe that he would be ible to make a | 3 lead [the Scard] to believe that he would be ible to make a | ||
= _4 3 .._4 _2 _2 -- - s .. . w- e n .__."u w 4 c.. '. s "_b.e deve'^e | = _4 3 .._4 _2 _2 -- - s .. . w- e n .__."u w 4 c.. '. s "_b.e deve'^e | ||
- y ,e... c# = . . = " _4c'an | - y ,e... c# = . . = " _4c'an 4=-- | ||
4=-- | |||
v. | v. | ||
_1_3/ | _1_3/ | ||
-acc_-an c. uu.e cnn.e..u_;cns me | -acc_-an c. uu.e cnn.e..u_;cns me | ||
_ . - e . | _ . - e . | ||
Line 2,018: | Line 1,335: | ||
Units 1 and 2) , ALA3-397, 5 NRC-1143, 1145 (1977); | Units 1 and 2) , ALA3-397, 5 NRC-1143, 1145 (1977); | ||
V_4 _ ,~_4 .7_4 .= T _i e c -_ _# . = - 3 c w e - " - .._ a..v_ ( 7u c _- .n' .a .. . = d ~ = ._4 c., | V_4 _ ,~_4 .7_4 .= T _i e c -_ _# . = - 3 c w e - " - .._ a..v_ ( 7u c _- .n' .a .. . = d ~ = ._4 c., | ||
~ | ~ | ||
Units 1 and 2) , ALA3-363, 4 NRC 631, 633 (1976); | Units 1 and 2) , ALA3-363, 4 NRC 631, 633 (1976); | ||
* e "...e s s e a V a _' _' a v_ .A u | * e "...e s s e a V a _' _' a v_ .A u | ||
* k.o _ _4 _ v_ (Wa*..s ma- Nu-_'a=_- 5_ _' _= .n . , | * k.o _ _4 _ v_ (Wa*..s ma- Nu-_'a=_- 5_ _' _= .n . , | ||
Units 1 and 2), ALA3-413, 5 NRC 1418, 1422-23 (1977). | Units 1 and 2), ALA3-413, 5 NRC 1418, 1422-23 (1977). | ||
___3/ =n u, s .-... r _;a nu. ~._; ..c. &o. c.a e _nu n- | ___3/ =n u, s .-... r _;a nu. ~._; ..c. &o. c.a e _nu n- | ||
-w . w m c_ a n.t ( n _, _, ,n s C_ --- a a y n.iuc _,- , , - | -w . w m c_ a n.t ( n _, _, ,n s C_ --- a a y n.iuc _,- , , - | ||
Genera:Ing Station, Uni: 1) , ALA3-582, 11 NRC 239, 244 (1980). | Genera:Ing Station, Uni: 1) , ALA3-582, 11 NRC 239, 244 (1980). | ||
l | l 1 | ||
1 | |||
m.no C_4 a C. - , a a _4 wa. r , SwC.le 31.5 0 a..r -w wW a- _..%. - 3. u | m.no C_4 a C. - , a a _4 wa. r , SwC.le 31.5 0 a..r -w wW a- _..%. - 3. u | ||
.n. | .n. | ||
Line 2,053: | Line 1,358: | ||
a w. a_4 44 m .l y , , | a w. a_4 44 m .l y , , | ||
...%.g.v o - . _43 .o.r w... _ w 4 ..- ; _4.,. n ., . r .=. . .*4.%. .s. . .c . 2. .. r .: _,,m.. .a | ...%.g.v o - . _43 .o.r w... _ w 4 ..- ; _4.,. n ., . r .=. . .*4.%. .s. . .c . 2. .. r .: _,,m.. .a | ||
~ ~ .a. . 4--- . m A 33ae--.4C 47S | ~ ~ .a. . 4--- . m A 33ae--.4C 47S | ||
..w. .;. _. . _4 ; ..-w . 4 .. A 4- C ' ". = .=. "- .'.4 "p" o. .4 .. . o .- a g .. 4. . . 7 4 ...m..g -* - 36 e .'.C | ..w. .;. _. . _4 ; ..-w . 4 .. A 4- C ' ". = .=. "- .'.4 "p" o. .4 .. . o .- a g .. 4. . . 7 4 ...m..g -* - 36 e .'.C | ||
. . - . ^ | . . - . ^ | ||
w "a~ . | w "a~ . | ||
-. . - , . -3AA44 | -. . - , . -3AA44 | ||
--- 4 r. ,. . .,-_4-.. | --- 4 r. ,. . .,-_4-.. | ||
Line 2,070: | Line 1,373: | ||
w 1. k. | w 1. k. | ||
.. e. .2 .. -. 4 s, OC.as. ., | .. e. .2 .. -. 4 s, OC.as. ., | ||
. y 4.. . = . . C "ye " * "- _4 ."A C, | . y 4.. . = . . C "ye " * "- _4 ."A C, | ||
. _' _4 "w . . *. * | . _' _4 "w . . *. * | ||
Line 2,076: | Line 1,378: | ||
=w 4 y . .m m .. a. s. 4 4 .=.3 | =w 4 y . .m m .. a. s. 4 4 .=.3 | ||
~ | ~ | ||
4 m,, | 4 m,, | ||
y d _w _% - - - _1 _3 _ , 4. _..-.a . - =.4< -2 ..v. m w . h. -s -*4as y y - - - -.%. ..f a = | y d _w _% - - - _1 _3 _ , 4. _..-.a . - =.4< -2 ..v. m w . h. -s -*4as y y - - - -.%. ..f a = | ||
- . 4 .,. 3. . . w .J .s .. ~ . , - | - . 4 .,. 3. . . w .J .s .. ~ . , - | ||
3 2. _4_:4. | 3 2. _4_:4. | ||
3 | 3 | ||
.4cn.a- w , e. gg " " C .".y " . . ' * . * - 4 .". .#. 6v.".* a '. .i c. .". a "w.'a. | .4cn.a- w , e. gg " " C .".y " . . ' * . * - 4 .". .#. 6v.".* a '. .i c. .". a "w.'a. | ||
~ | ~ | ||
.".._4 ' | .".._4 ' | ||
* a, -d | * a, -d y -- a w -4. . uw 9 | ||
. g c. . . .% . t o _- . .v, _yy .o . .-_4 g | |||
y -- a w -4. . uw 9 | |||
. g c. . . .% . t o _- . .v, _yy .o . .-_4 | |||
g | |||
: v. m. .w.g 33w---4: _- 2 74 w9 2 | : v. m. .w.g 33w---4: _- 2 74 w9 2 | ||
: 2. a- .w. S _ .1 2 a- u- s. 2 f a.-~. 4 3. :s _1 _4 . _4 -- 2 . _4 ,. . . r. .: | : 2. a- .w. S _ .1 2 a- u- s. 2 f a.-~. 4 3. :s _1 _4 . _4 -- 2 . _4 ,. . . r. .: | ||
y m | y m | ||
,w .m | ,w .m | ||
Line 2,104: | Line 1,396: | ||
, .b.. -o .J. .e. s. s .. s. s .w- s _ 3 .*. . v g, ..'<..b. n o- g e | , .b.. -o .J. .e. s. s .. s. s .w- s _ 3 .*. . v g, ..'<..b. n o- g e | ||
. , . .4... *- h.4. a- | . , . .4... *- h.4. a- | ||
-mes _- . . | -mes _- . . | ||
T m es ,n _' -- . . m. * ;4 . .n J As | T m es ,n _' -- . . m. * ;4 . .n J As | ||
-. = %. | -. = %. | ||
Line 2,114: | Line 1,404: | ||
- . '.b.4 | - . '.b.4 | ||
. a~ 3Ca"# %. . ' S .m .' _"a- a c' V, ";_" ' .*. . c C' "'". | . a~ 3Ca"# %. . ' S .m .' _"a- a c' V, ";_" ' .*. . c C' "'". | ||
. . e | . . e a *y,C u' .i ^..S.."."w ' a~ ." C ". 4 C .". C." S C*w"a."V., d.4c''yCS.4.~.#Cn C". . .V.VU. .U ^^".".*.."."w# Cn ww. | ||
a *y,C u' .i ^..S.."."w ' a~ ." C ". 4 C .". C." S C*w"a."V., d.4c''yCS.4.~.#Cn C". . .V.VU. .U ^^".".*.."."w# Cn ww. | |||
11 *a c, a."# _4 .". ~ | 11 *a c, a."# _4 .". ~ | ||
- ; ~.".e "..^ a d _#w.^ " y" C W e " . .O.--a-"_ " 4 '. "..#. .". " | - ; ~.".e "..^ a d _#w.^ " y" C W e " . .O.--a-"_ " 4 '. "..#. .". " | ||
.".s-. 7. c' .*..T.*s .* L' a~ c~ _~ | .".s-. 7. c' .*..T.*s .* L' a~ c~ _~ | ||
'.^w "*** | '.^w "*** | ||
- wy "e.. ****.. a " * .*. .*^ V, *a *av, v ^_~. | - wy "e.. ****.. a " * .*. .*^ V, *a *av, v ^_~. | ||
. . a 2 | . . a 2 | ||
_ . ". 2 4. ^^"."n.".*..'.w^.". | _ . ". 2 4. ^^"."n.".*..'.w^.". | ||
.. - '..C.**,. | .. - '..C.**,. | ||
. "." . . " . " . a | . "." . . " . " . a | ||
. - _ . a_4 2, | . - _ . a_4 2, | ||
-- u..w. e. e, .- , 3. 3. C .# #4~ | -- u..w. e. e, .- , 3. 3. C .# #4~ | ||
a' C'"~m " _'**;* - m " w'yc'' _# ~_ _' "w .7 'a'_" .' ' ''.''4 | a' C'"~m " _'**;* - m " w'yc'' _# ~_ _' "w .7 'a'_" .' ' ''.''4 w vI w *.d _i ';' | ||
w vI w *.d _i ';' | |||
-an- | -an- | ||
---ae de_iny. | ---ae de_iny. | ||
7 4 .,.g 1_1, y f m y o..n. g _4 ... x. .- a. g y S C . ' w" ~...~~ C S *- _4~S"as a - ""a.5e".~ed y_ . - _4 .". | 7 4 .,.g 1_1, y f m y o..n. g _4 ... x. .- a. g y S C . ' w" ~...~~ C S *- _4~S"as a - ""a.5e".~ed y_ . - _4 .". | ||
a S .w. .- r | a S .w. .- r | ||
Line 2,150: | Line 1,429: | ||
- - w-r w n we.n. .. 4 e.*.S C. | - - w-r w n we.n. .. 4 e.*.S C. | ||
3 | 3 | ||
.s.WO.. c =a *O .e.4 .,m | .s.WO.. c =a *O .e.4 .,m s | ||
4 c. 4u. ,1 C.Ca.1_4 _:_4w a_ | |||
O.. w$ n a , .&.- ,.-&.%...- | O.. w$ n a , .&.- ,.-&.%...- | ||
S v. | S v. | ||
y C. @ | y C. @ | ||
.. w , .&. & S.. | .. w , .&. & S.. | ||
Line 2,163: | Line 1,438: | ||
* OQ c, Q 5..Q g e , | * OQ c, Q 5..Q g e , | ||
--..n'e.-.y e , .+ %. gu--3 C. . %._4 C f"_"" w C andi."."; | --..n'e.-.y e , .+ %. gu--3 C. . %._4 C f"_"" w C andi."."; | ||
^ | ^ | ||
wV | wV | ||
^ | ^ | ||
, _ S""g"m _4 _" _ .".C. -*###" - - - . _# ^w.".S .i | , _ S""g"m _4 _" _ .".C. -*###" - - - . _# ^w.".S .i | ||
, _ -2d.. | , _ -2d.. | ||
4 | 4 | ||
Line 2,176: | Line 1,447: | ||
* M Q. M.U . S_9-,j *. . | * M Q. M.U . S_9-,j *. . | ||
.d. Q | .d. Q | ||
- .M. _W _9.M. F , | - .M. _W _9.M. F , | ||
. - n | . - n | ||
. C .a m S . a Ls m i .i . , 4- | . C .a m S . a Ls m i .i . , 4- | ||
--w. e. 1 | --w. e. 1 | ||
Line 2,189: | Line 1,455: | ||
3 | 3 | ||
... 4 .: .4 a. 3 ...,. t .7 , a. | ... 4 .: .4 a. 3 ...,. t .7 , a. | ||
.r | .r | ||
,-.s . g..we g.e.. c. -e...oAs-ww . . s, . w s u. :n | ,-.s . g..we g.e.. c. -e...oAs-ww . . s, . w s u. :n | ||
.... -e.v ..g - 2 AA4 .4 4.,.3.1 | .... -e.v ..g - 2 AA4 .4 4.,.3.1 A .a .l .".',I WCul# w "e "--2,2.s.d ' . *.* ..'". a .c a, | ||
A .a .l .".',I WCul# w "e "--2,2.s.d ' . *.* ..'". a .c a, | |||
." .**. .W .*^w r. .*""' . . . . C .". S.." .d '...,' i s. .c. .".", | ." .**. .W .*^w r. .*""' . . . . C .". S.." .d '...,' i s. .c. .".", | ||
4 ..f.4 . 3. . 4 o p*- ew .k..s . ,- 43 . .i .4. y. %.... w.4 3 | 4 ..f.4 . 3. . 4 o p*- ew .k..s . ,- 43 . .i .4. y. %.... w.4 3 | ||
%. 4O- .y aw .-.y | %. 4O- .y aw .-.y 1 2. . a. .i .n. . c .* < g n. w.4. | ||
1 2. . a. .i .n. . c .* < g n. w.4. | |||
. . mw.m. an Y.. | . . mw.m. an Y.. | ||
N | |||
*..%.n. g g .m..- m. . . a. w . ~c p %.a. | *..%.n. g g .m..- m. . . a. w . ~c p %.a. | ||
. 4 .. .. a..A. | . 4 .. .. a..A. | ||
Line 2,209: | Line 1,469: | ||
* L. | * L. | ||
1,4 / | 1,4 / | ||
m '~~ w.a.aC eVO ., . . 4. 4 a- aca e A .-S u%OL1A.- - | m '~~ w.a.aC eVO ., . . 4. 4 a- aca e A .-S u%OL1A.- - | ||
e4 A- 4. ? | e4 A- 4. ? | ||
Line 2,221: | Line 1,480: | ||
u-y_--=. | u-y_--=. | ||
--1 .~ ,/ | --1 .~ ,/ | ||
: a. g.w w . ya. - a. ........a. v a.,/ | : a. g.w w . ya. - a. ........a. v a.,/ | ||
-.g..g o .m .. | -.g..g o .m .. | ||
.sw . . . . g.r. .s , | .sw . . . . g.r. .s , | ||
= .q - - aw . .y. . | = .q - - aw . .y. . | ||
a-<a. | a-<a. | ||
Line 2,238: | Line 1,490: | ||
.w ...%.a. -1. 2. a s.. .S | .w ...%.a. -1. 2. a s.. .S | ||
_ C4a c aSaA | _ C4a c aSaA | ||
...C a, .- . 1 1 ;. -.%.C . ,7a, , _w.a. ...r . .4 .,. . | ...C a, .- . 1 1 ;. -.%.C . ,7a, , _w.a. ...r . .4 .,. . | ||
va n | va n | ||
Line 2,246: | Line 1,497: | ||
~ ,. | ~ ,. | ||
.a. .n. s e u.O S L.. %., | .a. .n. s e u.O S L.. %., | ||
. - 4 . s C' C' ; ~, 4 w m n.a n n.nw. ..ae.+w4n . w. .a- | . - 4 . s C' C' ; ~, 4 w m n.a n n.nw. ..ae.+w4n . w. .a-ShCua,C. . Oe Cen'SC. . | ||
ShCua,C. . Oe Cen'SC. . | |||
O.e S ya cw ". #. "-.' ' v .e ub...4 . . s. A , | O.e S ya cw ". #. "-.' ' v .e ub...4 . . s. A , | ||
CCNNER & MCORE | CCNNER & MCORE | ||
\ | \ | ||
Line 2,257: | Line 1,504: | ||
f*?l a . &' | f*?l a . &' | ||
Tro' s .Onner, Jr. | Tro' s .Onner, Jr. | ||
o ne | o ne V ' | ||
V ' | |||
. t< a. .n e u.. .. a .%. , n' .~s | . t< a. .n e u.. .. a .%. , n' .~s | ||
.s.L .. | .s.L .. | ||
C ^ u.. S e .1 .#w.^ - .'sy, | C ^ u.. S e .1 .#w.^ - .'sy, | ||
* o '- ic = u" ". | * o '- ic = u" ". | ||
.a Julv. 31r 1980 14/ | .a Julv. 31r 1980 14/ | ||
Nuclear Tuel SerriceS, Inc. (West Valley Reprocessing Plant), C. .2-to-4, 3 .i R C . a i a , .i . 96 ( ., 9 /2 ..). | |||
Nuclear Tuel SerriceS, Inc. (West Valley Reprocessing | |||
Plant), C. .2-to-4, 3 .i R C . a i a , .i . 96 ( ., 9 /2 ..). | |||
--15/ Denial of Petition for Rulenaking by Cincinnati gas . & | --15/ Denial of Petition for Rulenaking by Cincinnati gas . & | ||
"- .' e c . 4 ~ | "- .' e c . 4 ~ | ||
w Cw-~yanv, m , s'o ? .=.- d . _a c,. _' 'i / O *' , l~s e 0.: ( .'d. = . w'". 10, . . | w Cw-~yanv, m , s'o ? .=.- d . _a c,. _' 'i / O *' , l~s e 0.: ( .'d. = . w'". 10, . . | ||
1 980 . | 1 980 . | ||
1 | 1 | ||
L | L e' | ||
e' | |||
. ,. M.s , s | . ,. M.s , s | ||
,s s. | ,s s. | ||
.N'.,,.. | .N'.,,.. | ||
s, | s, | ||
.x,. | .x,. | ||
fg y g3 Am.en - -e-_ | |||
fg y | |||
g3 Am.en - -e-_ | |||
.n . r.e C.# .'. ' -.'_r.S _'' L.2 ~ | .n . r.e C.# .'. ' -.'_r.S _'' L.2 ~ | ||
'yU . @, ,# 4' - | 'yU . @, ,# 4' - | ||
NCCLEAR RIGULATCRY CC'01:SSICM -a ca -) >- | NCCLEAR RIGULATCRY CC'01:SSICM -a ca -) >- | ||
- .s .i*>.. w | - .s .i*>.. w p&ac i Cse.. ,. | ||
p&ac i | |||
Cse.. ,. | |||
.w. o .st..m . m -- o -. | .w. o .st..m . m -- o -. | ||
r ,) c,s y 'f | r ,) c,s y 'f | ||
,, g.a _i $3 UC C'7 | ,, g.a _i $3 UC C'7 | ||
,3...T. M ,h, | ,3...T. M ,h, | ||
.) ,,6 ... . | .) ,,6 ... . | ||
[ | [ | ||
m.. w. e v _4 | m.. w. e v _4 | ||
. , 4 . .. . .. rwa a | . , 4 . .. . .. rwa a 2- | ||
2 | |||
: r. _* a_ - _ .4 w- | : r. _* a_ - _ .4 w- | ||
), . | ), . | ||
* o. | * o. | ||
. v. . . .=rv s%.: | . v. . . .=rv s%.: | ||
C o m c. a n v , et al. | C o m c. a n v , et al. | ||
. ) | . ) | ||
M*2 | M*2 | ||
) | ) | ||
t r,a.4 _i _7 _4u3 m .u. . 1 4 .....e v.au. , _1.,2 a.,. . | |||
t r,a.4 _i _7 _4u3 m .u. . 1 4 .....e | |||
v.au. , _1.,2 a.,. . | |||
on,.,,a.e _s. J | on,.,,a.e _s. J | ||
.c -. a - C .n. ') J' e | .c -. a - C .n. ') J' e | ||
w .c.o.m. ..= sa | w .c.o.m. ..= sa | ||
_ e. - m. .e c. : -wz. -.r c- e , | _ e. - m. .e c. : -wz. -.r c- e , | ||
T 'r.e _' Ab.,v CS . - ..# "' .a - v^ # " n' c, " .' _4 Car." ' o~ n' .".s'de - | T 'r.e _' Ab.,v CS . - ..# "' .a - v^ # " n' c, " .' _4 Car." ' o~ n' .".s'de - | ||
_#- w^^"y .# e s | _#- w^^"y .# e s | ||
--y c Ac...4 . ACw4e4,n.31 4 | --y c Ac...4 . ACw4e4,n.31 4 c 1n m _... e4 r . | ||
c 1n m _... e4 r . | |||
. - . . .,c _,. r.e. ..s-w.a., . s e _. : s .stc . . - - - , , | . - . . .,c _,. r.e. ..s-w.a., . s e _. : s .stc . . - - - , , | ||
: a. ,,. 4 - r..a , u w.s. A _ m A V . -_7 . . 1., _7 , _4 . . "- . " . = . - = =,--' w^ r* a -- d c ._. . . . . | : a. ,,. 4 - r..a , u w.s. A _ m A V . -_7 . . 1., _7 , _4 . . "- . " . = . - = =,--' w^ r* a -- d c ._. . . . . | ||
j . _1s0-0 0 , | j . _1s0-0 0 , | ||
Line 2,361: | Line 1,567: | ||
g_ V"-. nly, -,C3Q.= | g_ V"-. nly, -,C3Q.= | ||
1 | 1 | ||
%.. _ .g .. .% | %.. _ .g .. .% | ||
* b. 3_ _I g 3 | * b. 3_ _I g 3 | ||
Line 2,376: | Line 1,580: | ||
: 2. .a _ 3 n' e re.= _' _= c a _ - | : 2. .a _ 3 n' e re.= _' _= c a _ - | ||
". 5. N. u c .'. =- = - S.a "- ' a - v, | ". 5. N. u c .'. =- = - S.a "- ' a - v, | ||
. U... 'iu c _' =. .= _- c. a u .' .=. . .^ _ v | . U... 'iu c _' =. .= _- c. a u .' .=. . .^ _ v Commission Commission Washing cn, D.C. 20555 Washington, D.C. 20555 | ||
Commission Commission Washing cn, D.C. 20555 Washington, D.C. 20555 | |||
..m . .. a.* *. | ..m . .. a.* *. | ||
. .=.c c -y e _ , .Nf .- a ..~b e_# C".a_' | . .=.c c -y e _ , .Nf .- a ..~b e_# C".a_' | ||
. _ .a.. , .4"u^.,m.4 c .C a_ # e .v a..c' | . _ .a.. , .4"u^.,m.4 c .C a_ # e .v a..c' | ||
.g w p 4 . .ca .e s. _, f , | .g w p 4 . .ca .e s. _, f , | ||
-..A - | -..A - | ||
_4w-o . . 3 .4 . . ; | _4w-o . . 3 .4 . . ; | ||
.4m - ..,. a. 4 , e, a-,y,,2. | .4m - ..,. a. 4 , e, a-,y,,2. | ||
y . 7 .a.,g2 - ..4 o .= . . , _1 | y . 7 .a.,g2 - ..4 o .= . . , _1 | ||
=ca_w4 | =ca_w4 | ||
. "u . . . ' A'" C' s,.= - | . "u . . . ' A'" C' s,.= - | ||
. .O. c ':-". .' = *. ^, _-~/ , | . .O. c ':-". .' = *. ^, _-~/ , | ||
bCw. Ci ca | bCw. Ci ca | ||
. v. 2. | . v. 2. | ||
L... 2 - ;, , | L... 2 - ;, , | ||
. . a. .e. w- i . , ,.- o s ca,,..... ..4 s s 4 C.. | . . a. .e. w- i . , ,.- o s ca,,..... ..4 s s 4 C.. | ||
u ,._4yo | u ,._4yo | ||
.. -.a- 4-y c: .'.' .4 c. ."._4 ~y= . . | .. -.a- 4-y c: .'.' .4 c. ."._4 ~y= . . | ||
, N, a s .k.d .. c, ,. . , D.C. 20..:.: | , N, a s .k.d .. c, ,. . , D.C. 20..:.: | ||
an | an | ||
. A wc ,.s1_4 -.._3-.. w4 , | . A wc ,.s1_4 -.._3-.. w4 , | ||
,. o. | ,. o. | ||
-,09 Chairman, Atomic Safety . and | -,09 Chairman, Atomic Safety . and 5_. c i e.r. c . m .4 : .w._ , .v.embe_- | ||
5_. c i e.r. c . m .4 : .w._ , .v.embe_- | |||
?. 4 c e.. s.i ..c. | ?. 4 c e.. s.i ..c. | ||
' ca-- -d | ' ca-- -d | ||
:_ =..a' -- | :_ =..a' -- | ||
Line 2,421: | Line 1,609: | ||
Scard Cer:'. mis sion U.S. Nuclear Regulaccrv. Washincten, D.C. 20555 C ~.'.'r. _i m s i ''' .. | Scard Cer:'. mis sion U.S. Nuclear Regulaccrv. Washincten, D.C. 20555 C ~.'.'r. _i m s i ''' .. | ||
Washington, D.C. 20555 Charles A. Barth, Esq. | Washington, D.C. 20555 Charles A. Barth, Esq. | ||
Counsel for the NRC Staff Richard S. Sal man, Esq. Office of the Executive Legal | Counsel for the NRC Staff Richard S. Sal man, Esq. Office of the Executive Legal c." a.d ...a4n , n' ". ^ ca #= .v, = ..d n.i_ec m.. _iw . - _- | ||
Licensing A e. =eal 3 card U.S. Nuclear Rec.ulatorv U.S. Nuclear Regula:crv Cc= mission Ccamiss'cn Wasn..' ne., te n , D.C. 20:... a 00sa | |||
c." a.d ...a4n , n' ". ^ ca #= .v, = ..d n.i_ec | |||
m.. _iw . - _- | |||
Licensing A e. =eal 3 card U.S. Nuclear Rec.ulatorv | |||
U.S. Nuclear Regula:crv | |||
Cc= mission Ccamiss'cn Wasn..' ne., te n , D.C. 20:... a 00sa | |||
..ashington, w D.u, . 4 William J. Moran, Esq. | ..ashington, w D.u, . 4 William J. Moran, Esq. | ||
Dr. Lawrence R. Guarles General Counsel | Dr. Lawrence R. Guarles General Counsel | ||
.4 , r_d- w . c a_"e *v. a_..d . =-..s u.. ~ | .4 , r_d- w . c a_"e *v. a_..d . =-..s u.. ~ | ||
4 C .4 ..c.d ..n. = - 4 - | 4 C .4 ..c.d ..n. = - 4 - | ||
vas = .".ar"__4c | vas = .".ar"__4c Appeal Scard - | ||
Appeal Scard - | |||
Com-any e . | Com-any e . | ||
U.S. Nuclear Regulatcry Post Office Ecx 360 C ...m _4 s o- i .. C .4 .,. c _4 ...,. , _- 4 , C.w._4 c 2. .:, | U.S. Nuclear Regulatcry Post Office Ecx 360 C ...m _4 s o- i .. C .4 .,. c _4 ...,. , _- 4 , C.w._4 c 2. .:, | ||
4 0 ., | 4 0 ., | ||
,a.as hington , - D . C . 20222 | ,a.as hington , - D . C . 20222 | ||
.v-.. | .v-.. | ||
a - | a - | ||
Line 2,458: | Line 1,626: | ||
_. 4 < , _T-ag . | _. 4 < , _T-ag . | ||
.' c c .'< = ".. | .' c c .'< = ".. | ||
..;.- ...=._-,.=.3__=.~..". | ..;.- ...=._-,.=.3__=.~..". | ||
=..4 | =..4 | ||
.'. . . ._. - - .a v a_ _ __=n-m ea_ - | |||
.'. . . ._. - - .a v a_ _ __=n- | |||
m ea_ - | |||
v_ _ _4nas. _.. ' . a. .c a. n. - s._, _ _. . . . s ,e - *34 C w_- ..a _3 _, o. _n _u w. n a | v_ _ _4nas. _.. ' . a. .c a. n. - s._, _ _. . . . s ,e - *34 C w_- ..a _3 _, o. _n _u w. n a | ||
?.? . g . v. | ?.? . g . v. | ||
Line 2,474: | Line 1,637: | ||
. , s.w. _onv3.. :: v'Ch. *. D. 'W C _T _* v e _ , =_ s~ g~ . | . , s.w. _onv3.. :: v'Ch. *. D. 'W C _T _* v e _ , =_ s~ g~ . | ||
C_i e." o..*. C~u...v, c. ..- ..."m.~. _d v | C_i e." o..*. C~u...v, c. ..- ..."m.~. _d v | ||
. .v _4 _1 _7 _4 _2.,.. t. a _. , _. .J. s. _4 _ 2. , _. = g_ . Cno u.. _4 _7 na --s 4a- . _,.. . c v _4 .. _y _ av _1 _4 w~ _4 _ . m. _. OCX _i a i3_ | . .v _4 _1 _7 _4 _2.,.. t. a _. , _. .J. s. _4 _ 2. , _. = g_ . Cno u.. _4 _7 na --s 4a- . _,.. . c v _4 .. _y _ av _1 _4 w~ _4 _ . m. _. OCX _i a i3_ | ||
a4 ~ m ,* , g h._: g *1 vum _ w.y..Si* | a4 ~ m ,* , g h._: g *1 vum _ w.y..Si* | ||
Line 2,481: | Line 1,643: | ||
: c. _4 nC .4 . . ., u._ , | : c. _4 nC .4 . . ., u._ , | ||
ek s ._4 c J. .:707. . sav_4 A | ek s ._4 c J. .:707. . sav_4 A | ||
: s. .v.a_. ._ _4 . , ;as. | : s. .v.a_. ._ _4 . , ;as. | ||
A s s _' = ~ .= . . '. a' '. .e _ .. = v. e er. . = _. _= _1 | A s s _' = ~ .= . . '. a' '. .e _ .. = v. e er. . = _. _= _1 | ||
.u._ s . .M.a_-v, ".~= d_ e _- * | .u._ s . .M.a_-v, ".~= d_ e _- * | ||
.a.c. ._d .ne_ D4_e . - _ _ | .a.c. ._d .ne_ D4_e . - _ _ | ||
B o x _,< v~ D. _4 ./ _4s _4 o n o _=_.; .,,,_4 _. . ....a . . _, _, | B o x _,< v~ D. _4 ./ _4s _4 o n o _=_.; .,,,_4 _. . ....a . . _, _, | ||
m- , .a. | m- , .a. | ||
o^ | o^ | ||
Line 2,505: | Line 1,662: | ||
-; , = | -; , = | ||
. .-_-a.a . . a. . .. . _4n. = w . , =. a g . | . .-_-a.a . . a. . .. . _4n. = w . , =. a g . | ||
m_ | m_ | ||
n..-v_..., , y _2._ . . .a | n..-v_..., , y _2._ . . .a | ||
Line 2,511: | Line 1,667: | ||
. ~ .~. e e | . ~ .~. e e | ||
, 0 0 .v.a _4 .. - : .- = =. . "_-e secu"4.- = | , 0 0 .v.a _4 .. - : .- = =. . "_-e secu"4.- = | ||
3 2. . . . - . = .v 2 | |||
3 2. . . . - . = .v | |||
2 | |||
--._ , _ , v _4 _2 , m.._- -w: . ,.:._es n, C _' a___.c.n . vot ..'."; , u .k. _i . ^ | --._ , _ , v _4 _2 , m.._- -w: . ,.:._es n, C _' a___.c.n . vot ..'."; , u .k. _i . ^ | ||
_1a ,. .u.-_4 , - | _1a ,. .u.-_4 , - | ||
Line 2,520: | Line 1,673: | ||
Batavia, Chio 45103 | Batavia, Chio 45103 | ||
:$ ---f | :$ ---f | ||
.u.atst J . n e _. . _., ... .. ., . | .u.atst J . n e _. . _., ... .. ., . | ||
s | s | ||
. _.}} | . _.}} |
Latest revision as of 17:20, 18 February 2020
ML19327A323 | |
Person / Time | |
---|---|
Site: | Zimmer |
Issue date: | 07/31/1980 |
From: | Conner T, Wetterhahn M CINCINNATI GAS & ELECTRIC CO., CONNER, MOORE & CORBER |
To: | Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel |
References | |
NUDOCS 8008060009 | |
Download: ML19327A323 (18) | |
Text
o &
W's .
.e
% ')
. : ,s.
/,, , ~ . -
h
, ,.e= , . - ~ -2.'.*e - ,.
. -~.. .~.~. ..:-, - :-., - -
. _ . s r - -. =.
~,=,
s..-
. . . . . - . - - - - . . . . , , , , - , . -m -
. 4 w Y_T nt. 74 c ',,, _. . . ' r.1 LLa...----y- a_ O O _ L . . **
, , , . w -~ T l .9 ..- .. 4 7 r
., A
_,m, . s = == }
.. s ;
0 k,4s g ..S.
t
/
... 2 ./. .=. 2.
,i ' sg~- '. '~ ND*+,". ,
s,
.k e
.. b. a, '.' .4 . . w .4 2 . ....-..-.2.;. .es ..7.'2,,.,.._4- .. w /
1
..C w X 3.
. =?V .
'i * .,2 w
.'.s.,,
-...y,..., .; 2. .,
_. .)
s
'?,,*
s' *e1.3 . .*;. . ~4._...a._- : - _1 1.- D
.. s ,.W e ..
/
-w4w .
-. 4.
.~3..,,..r . . . . . - - ._,, . . , , , . . , - . . - -
.** .t . 4 L. e . s O,. n.'s b ,11.% .w _ .78 .17. l'O. i L 7. O n 4. 2..~..-*.
O L J.v.......--.-O
.c.
s.--.s m f s. _n .'
n .~g . . au
. .,.m o_
,,v..
-,.-.u
~~...r3
-..t..su..;
.o _. 2 1. 4 ... 4 . . 2. _ f. - ._ . _ = . . . .= . . -
3 a ....w2,. 3 7.C. - ., . -. . -
3
..- w . a. k.. 3. .' _e .,s.3
. 3. 2 ,.. . %. 4 . -:3.. 4. 4. . . . .
_1 2 2 ...a. . . ,
.w _4 . . . .2.. ., .,. 2. . .3 4,. _w4. .- -, ,C u g:-.y fw ...-
w
.a
- _2_ 4 _7 _4.; , r. w.
.s . -..a.
2-
..4 -3. A 7 s. _. 4 . s-,. , m- _,.
. . ,c-..._4 -
.o .
- e. .m ..X.w. 21.,..c. -- .. a , w ., S ...C \. m. C
- e. , _
. w,
_w . . s. 2 --
A _4 e .. 4 o,, n -s w . 2. ; e 4--. _4 ,., . . 3. _i , . _4w.. ,, ,, s.. . , _, . r. m .a.K.4. 2 ,w, S -s _-
.- ,n C o--A e .e
_m u. .s _. ..u. m- . . E,a, c...._C s i .. . .a- _- 2 1. 2 . .2 O ..2.~a_--a
. - 4..b 4 c b. .
.a. gy m . 2..-=,.s-,; ~.a.
-c . -
_ .n. _ s e c. 2. . -i
- ..2..- e .m. ,. _e_ o- .,gG
"._'a~
^ - ' ' "
- * *.C o a d .i ."." ~~.. V.
fw w" .". w w.' . e .# .". ~. o- '~'<'G .". "- " , .' 1 # -u
" ~ _4 V " _7 _'-;"" O .CWe" . .U"C;'3"~
(nw/ =. e n
.. . . .J. a -37 aC - 2 C .4 -s-
. _..%. 3 *-. +.
,. b.e m. e., nC... 4 -
,. _4 a c- , *.a
- S h.a
.- .=. e c, K' o<-
. ,w. - .i. 4. --3 4g . m.
w _4 m e v~.,. ij.. w eC*uSG C# ' s s~ v ' .' .= _ _# ."4 3" ^,, ^. S S " _4."'. ' b. a
% , w, -..a s ,_-, , ,.-~. 4 w., n O .a s u.a. e. 4 .~..~..G
. .,.. -, C .4 _4 _4 _ y. ., _ u.,
s 4a A, 4 : _:_4 , , . -_1 a,..
_O
_y _ , ,
v- w ..w. a _4ye 9 a--a-a - :-w- ..'.,c
._. ., , 3 w *- ., 3 G
.- --JeC-_4Cn
,. a 4 C_# **,. .
-, y..a.,ge
.- w
..eu_,y . y _o:.__-.A -- . , c. . , . ._4 ~.,. g .
_. _=..e., cw c.g4A- e _ 4-..c.
~ y _ ., __n_e_., _4.v . _ ,- . ,- 4 .,..
-- .w - - - - - , w_= - b.e
- c v- .m _4 . . _4 ~.. ' - _u _' a_ s C . .
, , _ __4.- ., A - ,_
m~. . m-. , _4 ~.,.g .3--,_,_4 w...-.. ., n. _ .o- _4 .- -w
. ..eyc. . e- -.e
_-- , _4 _
= c .4 .Tw-
, w'p. o- .e wa -.*.S C.".a.b l e .'e n ""., w.
- 1# - #4_# _
-- # e _" w^ ".
- b.e C. " e S ' _#u ^ n C .#
_. w
.. .y._,..., e. -.ege - ... -- ..,.. - . . . .
j '---~------- -~ '
THIS DOCUMENT CONTAINS
._ P00R QUAUTY PAGES (, $ g,$
?
i 8008060 m b0 / -
1
.S ,
l l
l
-w
. . . a. S C o .r.Ca.._4w, _4- aa ga-u 34.gA a -
w., . r s.-...g w. .2- . . a c. _" s_"*-
- w;. w. "-,a V C s". C'
-4
- m. e w
- a. g . ,4 . . _. _4a
. -4.m w.._ 4.w.. .
w ...a- u.,_. ws-- a m _,
. .%a.c. 1g----_, 2-u- .. .. 4., a.a-w - 4 r. ( n o.. c.swco me n. ww n- 4 a _1_4w-. -a n.g _4 ..n c g a _4 ..gc , _ u. g
-- sa--
.m..._4 - - 4 4.,. ") ; y .
.a .n s my .. a - . _-
e.x.a.. . . .
'_".a. # 4 .". _= ".C .4a .i ~ .-
__ ". a _i _d _# _4.-- = _ _4 ^.".S ^
w _# ". a. = "r y" _1 _4w-^ = .". . =
-_"=.
_4 .".vo _' ", a. d. . ". .'~. e .# a~ S "w e v^.# . .' .". = .". C .d = - _i ","w = .' .' _# _4 . = . _4 6.". w S, _4 .". ' . " - _ " " . . ,
was raised by MVPP in 1975- Dr. FankhauSer has damonScrated ,
nothing wh1Cn wou_3C Crovi,e CCCd CauSe C # new Contentions aC
- b. _4 a -
- 1. s._ .s -m.g _i ;. . 7a'" AS.c.' -- .
- S"-
.l._'_' ---."s_"a ~
- _ = C, ' " # _4 .".y- . '"* *- -
_4 . . .. n _7 .. . ._Jwe.., . 1 a..m .1. y .v.e
. _4 3 k.. k.m. . 2 <.
.41y ,
a c, 3- _4 . s e %. 4 .7 .
T.
_ .w.e o.
--m wyvs eA. c. w .. .. 2.. _._4w.4 . S
.*wa
+ - ~ **4 h _ .. .bru._v yo ,4 3
. e. y Spd. Cw..sa .. r._4mna- w ' (' s )
(%
so) a.. A. 9 ,S a e _v. . .. _ %. s .. _..%. - -
- - .S . .-
ww. ... wC . _4 w n , C r e . s u_ _: O., . ... a _4 . . . n . . .2 . - . -..
2 A 2
we Cwi...-
4 m a _4 ,n.4 -
3 C# w S~oo~ C# "#~~.e" u *** "'^w^ w *.._
- ~;. * . " -. **. C' _"g"-_"_.
'_*
- v _' =_ w C# _ ' '~. e C w^ .c a ' / ", e ".. a. .#. .# . $
m.7 a.' v S .#S
, _ ' . " .'..b. e '.s _' .~. ~. 8 .".
4 .T_4."."_' T..*."..#"^".~a."...*._'
. w
=*. 3 u.-4a e . e.
w . ('svren}.
--- .r. C W e V a_ _* , _'~.- a S e "y_" w*"y C S e d w^ w ^ .".. ' = .". w ..#..^
- S y"e "
ur- ,Ce..
h ... ,2. _1 e,A3..*.
=.a .4 . . s . w w m_4C Co nS _4Ce . a_._4w4..S 4.._4 -w .m._. a _4 . _4._. r.4 RC
_1 _4vo- a..3 4.".C, y"."w
- C*- -*A_#.*."3 ~a. "..h. e ,.rw*.~..'. .A a~ a~ _AO .". .'.*S *
. ' " . " . " a~*..". C .a .. **r.^,gn.'..'.*A uhn aw .d'n e u.G C.- ..O *w nC,C14 u_- 7 C%. o. _*
4-a _78 -
-.C S *. 1_ _:_ = _4 r _4 a. .n. . m v E CCnC m .'- *~ ~ *~*.*.S .#C" . S " "yy" _7V .# .".C, m. _i s_ C .* .' ". " ' S e _" ". #. " *- 's. ^ -' C ._d _' _i ."y ' .S 1
.. #~ __. /
w S *. *.". e ." S -a C u 'o o~ #-- #a _4 ".a~ ."* C, U.' a '.C _"Y, s4 " _" _' S d #w" .#w... ^*
s fC.e '".a--" 0 " *** *w *. . ".e "" .* a* w.'.
~*"*-
-_3=d'^ . n' "yC, _l _4C '.". '. ' .c ""
w-- "."~a.".~
m a"e y"."CCe." .'"St be, w deC.4ded DV. S ' ' ". a . _
- C, ula'.O "Y, --...w_"_' *"-"* _ _i s_ S .
As a u*.b. s , S *..= . a. ." a a. a.k .i .". g ." =. "g "- .' ." =...e .". . a-
- " a--" a_ ", ev_ C .". A. [ '". a,.
1/' m..k. e S .we n a . ,u. . 4SSt,e O.e .a.b.e . _ w.o .
-- u..h. e a*..,C .1_4 2.. u. _ia- .. a 4 .,. 2 n_
- c. 4 .a .l l,y C,ua.l .d .#.4 ed *.C C"".S*_*""*. . w .'.".d . y" e _"..'..". a a "CCiea."
raci3.ty
. . . . C
. i . 15 anot.ner matCer, wh1Cn 15 CISCuSSec Ce3 Cw.
h*
_ _m _
-.. ,.e -
_ 3_
e 'ol -
.k =-.".. "
"..C .- ..wb.a _- ".. 3 ..*. - = S . " w e " #ww... y .= . . "f v.4..c. ( ". v . w-. . a. .. . a .- ; ";
- 3. 3 . .V. ', T.* . _4 . 1}, _ 1,-7 1] _ :w t M,9 *
, ". sO. .r.' } " 9. ,,
. /. (' ',
- Q , g } ,. L .? ^
m y s. .' a. ..
- . C'
? ? s r ..._4 - ? _? _* s_.a _4 .e.e n . s.y- .*m.
- - -. ow -g.
? 2 1. .j .
% %. w e .11 .1 2 e. a. .s. _. 3 _7 _1 . . .. , ". ...a
. . 4 .
9%)-, ~Tm e *
(TQ-=%
u
- . A.e .M _ 's=s .1 , .; v. e .%c. ~*1,
/n_ **3 Im \. t 6 / . m..w%. . , a , _..%.w a %ne w. m..m.._4a. _
a _4 . . .-.w2A
_4.a _. =c2-4. --a %.* "v2.
"*Ca s .".~. .' ': '." .a._l d s..k. e s
w -
3 m
- m _.u.o ; at . co,-__=
~_ n 3 3 -3 g.41_4 .,y 2'*"ya*2 ** *_
4-a ... ** .#.".S u _# _# .# 2" 4 ..*.".w baa4 S _#C* . 4.".".*"-
ye.n. _4w.*-, -4 . v. 4 .C .'. _#Can3.4 c,. y _em.,C e e C' .4 . c, 3 .
.c e e c_ e n a-- "a _ _ V_ 3C **
_ ' ~" ". w#
c :-.
- w. a. a_.__i e _' s c . _4 . C o. ..y 2
_ - ._ .... (o. m. .w k. .i e. -y__4
.; c .*t. L.wm _is. .m .- 3_7m . - ..,
L.ni S ,- anC .
.),
4 ca.
.n
/0-44, n
yRC
.4 o.,p., ,
o _, ,, ( .3y/. ..g). -
Jee 1_SC
.A. . g 3 __ w.. e . .._: . ._ _. 4 .. . a.- 0....a.e " " .*w~.."y . a u" V_ t' a' _' _' s_ .*. S "w."=^..>s ". C a., . . _l a .* .*
u-a e _ .;- wcu _s._4 _ 4 .. , ~ -rmm, _:. an
. s.
. . . . _4.. 1), . u.at
. c, _1 _7 $.Io. w.c . 9. .3 c. , o ,, 3 ,.. ;.
I-( .1 ..4 3 0 ) ,. c.. w i _a
. - - . ca
- -_ i_4 r.e L"w.ay a .f.. w _a C'x- _7 2.w.C m m fo_isCx
~ -
.T w x o*,._43, - .
Ls.,. 4.
- S _i -C s. 9), .!_?mnm _10 .. ,, : sIeC _17* s .1 , *_ *~
. .. _tst ( .1.c // a - ) ,. G,u,.7.a
-3
- m w e s "w *- .4 _7 _4 ~. 4 m g Co wi .."y a.".V_ (34. Ve " O., en d
. c~ "m* " 4 .^.". , N..". _# " S .
' "".d 9_ ) , .Gt -
- .%nn,
- . . .1-
- o. c i e
- c. u , : -
i.a . . . --.3 r
\_c: . -s.
1; aC- ,.A .- ._4 C .1..,
_s y_wyCSS.
.... A Ce . -4... . a .n. u._4w.. r. _ * (w r) _4a. _J..y. ..e wy LG c. = ,a. s .J e. --s-_4 a. e S y g.m_1V, - ..C n .# a.d e -" * ' " a *.*. * ."S W.# "w.b.4 .". "b.e d "
- u._4-d_4".'w_4C7 a . C-# " b.. o.
s sta"e .CChlic utla,itV. CCamiSSion.
t
- c .4 3.413 .1.fi - y wy ..CSec w on.e.n.._4C.i.
o
. 2C, .
4 ,a . . _1 ( a) , .O
. f
_k.e
.. eX en. uu%.mf, mees' -
u.O 1_4 4yra u.e s k. _3 C2,4*27 y_.. -
2
. A. Crr e .... .. - C.n.
S SSCCd=~*d W.4"". "
C C S 'o s~ -- ._ #."..~ e ." ". ". " b.e C._w" " "w E. d a- ' .. ' * . * * - b.eV . a .~ a_
4 "tCC hic.h" Cr have been inadecuatelv. evaluated under the C*S*/b~
w e.ne_#.4 +- a.a.a _' v. a _iS ." =.c, "-_d ." = A- b ,v "ba
- - - '.'a'. 4 C.*.a _' T 4 - v.' _"C.ar..e.n * = L'
-ce w .l _4C ,f A C *- , ,i -2 L+ . g . C . 2 3.732 ( n y.r.c.a.n .. ) anc .10 C.7.R. on_._ -- .
21 a."e C'e#8 C "._dVE. *.. ".V _d _""w ".a7 * .*. t * '-w"" S 'wa" ,
- C".. _' V, w" .".d
- . ". C *. ec."C.CD_4 . "w i
[
, _ m . - . ~
.__ - ._ _ . - - - =
. . s 4 -
C** S ~* a~ r 7 .] . b e "--.* ".S .#-----
~ #3"*d -a" " " *--* S . " ' # .$. ^ . C _*
- 4 .".
. . . ' * . *.T "i. 0.1 g g u. / % e r.a. .# .4 ". a.*.* _' "j S .4S. **
.u C ".b.e
. " WO "# a~ - , ". . T..U .2 #
CaS-
- ^~
..w.
.2,
..k.e - .. _4 .a . b. a. e. . . ..N_4as - .4 ..m a.-- .+
A--woa . a rm_4 ..m - .a.
. h. o *..b. a. -
- b.. a. 1.-y y _7 _4.w- m .. 6
.b. a S ' C.'*.C S e.". "
- e w".b.a. " y* e S
- Wa'/ '.O y"."^d".".a w - - s .' e ". *. ." 4- " a .' "yC W e ." .
e
- 0. 3 . g o..p. 4*
. . ~ 5 V, 2.X
- a N. .# .".e *.* * *y "y _1 .# ".S w ~. _iw.^ ". C ."._' Y , #.~v~~...
- "..".e *<*#-- "W" y o 4 .". *. O# c..".7 _d _" w* r.m e n w a .l a .' *. * *.". a - _' "< a - S . *V_
- # _* c_ _4 .7_4 =-- T.'*"."._"4* .-
Dm de. Cm m n *u 4. C 64,
.a n.C' -
ese..ii sf 'f ut .4 .C -s.%. .%. . c. Y C _T a n _-
.41. D e v .e.v.
.w s. -
"we ._4*a *-
.' .s..a. C' s.1, - i 1*S L2 _ .:09 , . 1.1 M.
.. O.F. 127, es
-e .: O" _ s O
^
- C
(' _' 3 v 0 *1 .
- a
.s o a.b.
m o. .
.;.y y . 2.=. .i. _C'*# .".^ . .a d _4 .". .' .' _7 _4.*.^ w a.4. - 0 ".W a .* w. . ^^~..".-*.".V, /s C _' _4 .". ~. ^. ". A 0"We."
- a * , <-
- .3. .. 4 e .,. , r. . 4 . .a. C o . T
. . _ .m . . C ), .._ %= _ 7. ,+ 0 , ,
+
we.C 7r,
.i . - ,o (. .7 9 e o sj
.l e n _- a. ..O .s a k. . u. .. nw . 4 . a. A -r .u.mde,<.a w r a.m -
.**. C,"w _# _*.* a.". " "ey" _1 _4 . -*.*.* . "O S C -" c "y ". ** w.
-.e
.a g.C. g 2
. . -2 7 e.a. .-.. 2 . 4 . <.e o O _i c .i . j. C .m. *..k.a.
haSiS Of iOS eConC=iC CCSOS.
- m. .%.a t is a yuSineSS u 7UCgment s WniCn 1S Cuts 1;G the Scope of Cur NISA review. See.
3IC.- k.e.-,. s p a u.m S t.- owe- Ce. (o_2 4 4m a
_m- - , ,
nd .5L,C.,ea_-
4 ce s .n. a _. , . _. . . ; _2 -7. , ...f r . 4 . a- .
_7 -.e.n .7. ) r 2 s -
10_ 7 ,' ,a o 0 .--r- ::=
.ssi :. 7. ,
( _7 0, 4). O.n..l y 4 .*.S C # ' " "S 3. .".V _4 _" O
- .. ".~..e .". ." _'
_4me "
- a " *.S C.# '.*40 al'***.2 . _d".oS ". a _**/ "..a"2, .
.de 4 2 C *o o. a- ._ .4 -3* T ] e c --m.,.C..._4 _- d_4__4e - e. .n.C -a 5 into our evaluatiCn.
.".C.-= -
= C .a.".*..'
- v. ,
- h- e * .* -C = "-uS .4 .".c. .'Ca # S *. .= '. a- d, 4 .". *>c uS Lightinc & ?CWer CCmpany (AllenS Creek Nuclear Generating
- .c . . . _4 C., r ._4
... . . . _), n O.-a-e _- R., , ; .g oy o.. ... a .-,/ ~a .n -._4 n. =. a. u. 4 . _4 n ,S n r.
.- . wi.
' " C.V. a. . ".sC . 3 0 - J. 0' 0'
-. ( .T aa" .-"- = _ f 9 , ' 9 ~/ . 9 ) (s S _1_4 "y C". y =. 3) f . - = . -
4 g e C e. 4 ..c y a Ce .w.. - . e n.a 4w On 64.2 w Ce w a.7 _4. 4 . ed y .7 a.w.u.a. a _- a. p.e.4e _- s _k _t e _
CVer nuC3 Gar ZaC1.3.tleS:
. i .
We rejeC- this ContentiCn. It iS
-predCainantly based Cn eConCmic costs of Coal v. nuclear .clantS. It a.ceearS .
to ' assume that the utilit*f is prCmCtinc.
. u. s.. --...e v m_
y
-- .e. o _1,; . ...e .2 . . a- ( .4. . e . . . . .wC .n a .m. . ')
C .# -
- g mV_4 A # .9- - . -..'".*. - r. w a_ _* ...---- **5*5 "
~; *-- ~-*"~ . . -
-wa
, .=- s.
s ".w 4- .
N. a- a _- a_ .. C . "'_=d - - " "y o ". . e-
. a""-
a.-.,.m-C L, , ;..4 .- . 3. .,. _. _- -. .-. - - w;_ r. _w
- .. . s -
_1- 4 _ 7, -..A 4_-
._.- _. - -ge,-3
... 4 m - - . . -
2_ g. ,
. . -a a- - . - - - - _.s..-
- 1. .s..
. w oy. - ww n s. . ~.a_.-- aa . .
,a. .s-- - a .. . :. . .a ..n; _. .u.. =.
~...C s ~. - t .. , .,. n-_t .,. _1 1 .f .,. A . . m .. _,n :
y a. c,. L.a- 4; a u*..' .i .i .v. -- a "ug y .' v, --a w""s ~~e_a' .".a. a -d
-^ - - 4-- ^~ -
3 0 .- y C% d _" . 2. " W e v a_ _ , '.' .". d a. ." .T
.. "4 U. .A We 2_-a-C h *' _4C,ed "O N. a, 34 .h = ". v d _-^ .. *.
- a.". a ' ~ ^5 -o-
- 27~****"
a r.C 7. C, a's i b_'a ----_..--_d"ses
-- - #C_- a .e a- ' _# ."."y ycwe.e
.n.e -- aAs. .M.e.* -a C^ s '- "a _' a.".C 4 *- C, _4a-
_i .m y C _-*. = .". *.w ^ r.iv, *r we *"a
--- e.x . a. .". *. -.4* - -=su..a -
_4 .". a.". e .n.v _4 _-.^ " ~..e .". '. ' _' _' v_ a u a-y - - _4C _ = .' '. a _-. . a -
-4
- ve. ad"ad ;
- i. r...y .~ . = a _* a- - ---..
. ay--, a- .- , - -e. e .--A ---..".a- :"--
.-.4 ,-
-a .- u.
s_x e C " -- .d a d .' .. u~ ~.a". ur..e _--
a Cwer CCm:any (Midland Plant, "nics 1 and 2) , ALA3-453, 7
.i .sv _, Ac,-ca (. _, ,s /.p ) :
, - u. e
_.. - n, _.w m a-- _=..a_--., -
2 a.,
,n C ,.n- .;__ ,sa-d44 DCt 'a.k=
"4- a " " e..Cv.
-; " .-n s y- C.". d _d-.'^ '. s
_30_" a s s e s a .4 ."."; w'.="-.'".a__- .- _= y_-yCaed- ..uC'a"-
--~~ -
y l a.".~ '4C u' u# "a -- - -".e ~C * *s #_ 4 .". * .".-- C 4-;" ' '" ad-Va.".*.*.CeCus wa" # C*
- u' _4 1_* '."; -^ - -- s a '- _4s.#7 4*s . m.,sw-ow -m e_-8 a ..m. -- e A .Cw& y C.a.e.e . q m uw.b.
a m u.- s a- - -.2 - _4 2 . . e A ..u.e y - ,*._4 ..C. e C .: ..w. -a g.---4 1_4 s, *v a." # .
V' s _4 .".C, C"'"a
- s- s - _SC,"-
1 ato.-.f C-~.~a_a wa. s.4 w...-
a a '-y-aen , n *_w .- w
_4 , . s s*.a 4ua_s o o One s4 4e, w Cu._ .J ..,IC 1 Vc m..a. .n... -.. 4 44.nu s ._
C _,. , m .._e e. .da s _1_,.mi . _.
o c..._... -.- .
n- .g wh e *-.' .e , _4 _# we .14 C -a .r.s e '..".e c i a .7'. , "".e C ~ ~ya.nv . w.i.11 -be ab_'a ' o b u- _d _' d a..d "" a .n. - ,.
'o
- C ye.a'a _i '. wd ".^eu. Cvmo__-wmi a 4"3 sa:ety .ceCause Cf pressing financial
..eas
--a .
The passage Cf the NatiCnal Environ-mental PClicy ACt increased our concern w.i'". 'he er.onCm4w s C_# .".u"-_=- - 'a yCwe y.'=n*ma, b u'w C.7.' V. -4 . " . a 1' 4 ".. 4 - a ".h* a' C '- _-=-
quires us to cons'. .cer d waV. ,
wnetn. er tn.'w ere are aa.vd
-. Crne.".'=_'7 7_ .,c _-a _#--a--ab i a_ = .' "-a - .-. a '- v a s i
_ :. :nere are r co tne .DrocCsa =e:Cre us. . x we must take the steps we Can to see
'..." a * *.' .ev a_* = ino .' e." =-.".t a d _4 _# ' '". a C = .".
be accomplished at a reasCnable Cost,-
_4 . a . , Cn.e
- . . .C*m n
- . u. . C y_wy . --- C .-.;Cn u,
-- .. . u. ,.
envirCnmental advantages to be gained.
c=>
6-mu.
4.: .u.e -a -- a_-a. ..o y _- a : e _,u,
-- -- .a- a..,..._4-,.- . - - .
'nental alternatives, such Cost-benefit h a l =-u " C.i .".g ' dC E S . .o *. - = .' *. G "y .' = C a . u'J- m.q .4 : e e . .i. v ,
.".C * "..# .d. C _4 .. . ' F.' . .
. , = _' ' a- ~ . . ' a- "o a 4 # .
%..., ." u C. .". a...v4_ w_- . ".e..t.= _' _' "; _4 . .---v _# = 4 .. ='~ - =, _ -
.. a w. 4 ,<,e s- _.,
. 4 4 nc a w.L.a.a y s- ( w u,w. .. -4 _4 .-
- _4e.-)
way C .# 'a..=".di4..C, t.h. e "..a . . *- * =
. - . .h..=..d - . J" . . " .
the scheme of things, we leave such
. a * *. a. .. a- o *.uka ow,S4..ess ;4A4 . -gn a .n. *. o_4 -
ww. y a.._as s..c .n. .%a A
_.. %.e u..-4 _1_,ys., -nn ;
.4
.-a uca o# *he w c~ .a a ..C"w'=~~-v,
- = C, =-." C -4 a s--~ * -
5 y C n s .4 h _' *_ _#C* S w . U *. 4 .". 4 . .4 y."." *he y-"- O'v eCOnCmic aspeCO3 of prCPCsals to build new C.eneratinC facilities. - In short, r e.s. _4s- ww-- .C a -..a c , w s *. 4 a-a s .2, _- . .a. S .v4-. -- -
- 4. y o .- . a.. . -..._' "g '-".a. .w a_.x .r a. . 4. _-=-
. S ul .a- -.. 4
=.=. a .". - _# _- w ..m e."..= .' _' v, m- uy e. .4. o _-
- _1 .- . a._-e.
- u
... s _ 4 . ,S . C -o _- a n 4_s ,ac.- a e 2 .
.. u k.a-A
.%.w
.. m. .' .%.e .. w_4 s es s e, . %..s . _4 _ 4.s w.%.e sy - 4 s-h a.-dw .' .v _4... :.
. .* = S a .4 v e . [T.m- y ".= s _i s .4... o .. _4 _4 . . = _' ,-
_anCw t..C u.a s- wm_4 --
. . a A . ]'
-o-oy"Csed w - -- - .".~. .".* _4C .". _' ( "_ ) _45 ^
. . - =C~ ~*"y *. = h '
- b - e" = "- a e = . .Y, a
A 4 _a _ e_ e.n.c e ' e .ya.a.m. ".%.a a c.ec aguaA
-- . - --- , e n .Q _'wn ac' =- -c- - u %.e _..* ._-a-- a
- - a cc l_i - = ..*.s as s * .= ~.= d
, - _i.n *he 7_4..a' ?.n v _4 _. w . e n a _' -=.=._.e...
c" "
. : .- , 4 .,. . a _ ,
-, _ - m--.,.r C- 0 .3. . .. ( u t,.,. . .a _3s- e o- ss, , , -
...c w
_..a. ,,,_-a_.,._
.._ __4_,,.a__
2 y_,
4 _4.,.,onse . -an _4_._3 D. r- ,-.. x .w.a ,.,_e e =
_ _, _4 ., m-
-- , _%,. _w
_ -- ..o t .a - - - . . . a.
applicant was granted sunmary disposition en MV?? "need for ycwe_" C^.n'an._4 w r. hv ~54 s Sca." 4..
. _4 ".s- .' -..=.h =- = . _4 . .g u~ 6. . .#-= _- =- ..w-- a Orc.er or v.une 4, 19_<9. --2/ Dr. ,anx.hauser
- .nas . .
allec. to naxe.
"a s w o .g a.k.cw_d ..C.
. . . 5 = ._ "m".- a _* =. = x _ds .s- a = _4 :u - .4 .# _4 .= ..
3.k.3 A 1ssue wnicn .nac not crev. o u s ., v. ceen acequate3v .
. Cen-
- s _4c' e. ed o _ . s 4 .._i 3 _# _i w a..' u ew i .n #o ..i = '._icr. w"4
- u c.". ". = d c' =". a _' c y e d a_# e.* 'u"a- -- w-r.s---" c. 4 c. . e e---
-- 4 ' -
avdaw."__3/..n
_# a c ~ , D..
--2/ In this regard, we note that while 10 C.T.R. 52. 7A 9 ye_-
- a..v. c a _-* v, "
_--o , oy-yose a - o'_'. w . .o sur-.a_-v, .._s-y c S4 _4 ^ ". ,' D.*..
- -. .T anV....= Us e _" .#- 4 1 ed ..o *.n' _4 ..g .
,/.
n, e . wn i ~. = d_4s c.,. u. _..
. - a..,_ ( .=u _ _4-- ,,_ = e _- ,._4 n,u. .n 4 - 2owa-Plant, Uni 2) , L3P-79-1, 9 NRC 7 3, 36 (1979).
4 i
- . -- -e,, '
1 R
1 4
1 73.. <w.a,se_ o. . .s
. . ..a- . . m. d 4 .. en- _.m..a . _4o.. 2 . _2 _1 1 . m.. k.n s ..b. e _. m. _4a-
. .o . h.4
. ..g b,e # -.
. ^ - * " _ . " . = - ', o a # Wh_4u #.*. *a *o ue ' d 4 .".#
- w -- _4 -- =..= "'.w=. ..'.o.
c s./'e.e~'_i
=..a_lvs4-a. "..a.d e _ '..' ~o A .".a a- "- ea - r. s ub s - * .". ._4 =- _' _';"
a "'
l e-=d. .v.o .- =. o v e-- , _4 . k. = s ' -e a. n. -^ ~.
s s =- . . - _v. _-=c -.4 i
c..- ed ' ' .a *.
e _, o.x_; w 4 1_4
- - . ., 4 .,. .w 4 -
.- a y _..c4-.
w _43. _4a- .m, _4.
c wy .
_w.
w u--e,__
.4 .3 uncertainty in load forecasting. As the Appeal Board stated
_4 .3 -m.w ._ 3. _4 .,e .v--4 , e . o c _e .,. , _ v c e e d 4 ..g .-
[W]e do not consider the difference
_4 ., -
f .- m_ a_ _4 - - m_ c ;~ =_ = _ ^ # ..=_=_d '979 "<s.
_198' - a s- =~._4m .
_4--- = _' _' v. -.e = .n_i ..3_ u l dis-tinction. If there was one thing agreed uron 4.. . . " . = :-- " e _i c w ,4--- i s --=. "
- - - c = = d 4 .. c.
4 .,.p. e _._. . . 4 .,. -. 2 .y _:--=c=.-
- - o' "".-_-= eiec- _
tric pcwer demand is a substantial margin '
o u,.c ...e ". ds o#
4, '
. . 2. --..... .; . .s=- w4 k. .os f ed 4- - .4. 3 -".e"".."_-=,
~
cad ."o ec=st_i.c.
involves at least as much art as science.
m..u.e .,a _ 3- _4..
o a . --. ..-
4.,y&_4 ,
_4u. 4 .. s L,C.s.
...C_4-f.. - _4o.s .4-a a. u 3.2s*. c.
-- a-..:::u.__C_4ent magnitude to encompass the two-year d 4 _# _# e _* =_.. c = ' e . a e- a .n '. " a. a e.c .l .i -- ^ =.. . ' s- .= .. wA
-u.a. 4.. u. e _-. ,a..o o r .o : en,ssos.
- -- m..u.e an yy _1_4 -
cant's choice of the earliest of the possible " years of need" is readily understandable. Seing_ legally obligated to meet reserve margin requirements, any utility company must be expected-to fore-cast' load demands conservatively, i.e.,
favor the high side of such predictions to insure that it is always crecared . .
for unexpectedly hic.h demands. . ._4_. '
Accordinglv.1 the Commission has stated that the Applicant need only shov "that its proiections - of demand are reasonable and that additional or replacement generating capacity is needed to meet that demand. " Energv Research and Develocmen:
__4 /. Niagra Mohawk Power Coro. (Nine' Mile Point Nuclear Station, Unit 2) , ALA3-264, 1 NRC 347, 365-66 (1975)
(footnotes omitted) .
i C2N
- Q 9: a
- w. a u. 0. . 4 .,. .
- n ~1_4 .w. 4 ~a~. _w .s. . 4 s .w. (' b .'. _4 .m. O.
.. c. a. A s _. . . s. 2. - . . 01 3
.f
.) * * -
w . ~I <~_
f
_7wi 7 _1 9F - O" "/ -
v.4.Tw f -4 "t, gJ/
/7n=Q'. #) . .u.- a ..- ;
yy p.=- -w---
-3 4 4 .,. *..k _' _4--
30 .,4ma
. _ - o*. . a.e.y C: T .m. A _4 .s .%. 3. , T...
- w. _
- - _ . .'A. .s _.k . _7 s.
- 4 **
. . _ . '. aS.o m. _i s. .m e"s.e.e e s. - 4 .a.n
- c" e. .s. . 4 m. .m. , 7. .m. .a 4 _ s m.o.C" _7 ,) , -
n-.'%
- 3 _ ,' . 0 , " *
- 7.e. . ...
-,O, , -7 ,0, :
, ( 7 Q- "J Q" ' .).
T
. C "
- C a S - 4 .". C. '..h."..~ ." c a. -d 4 a~ . . ~ . a ..'..*y ' a .
- ^ *
- v.4.e Ae.m g.m. A a a - -v- m_ y cyg 4 =- e :- __w m. ' .. .m g -
".C .hC C_" , w " V ~.^. - d * "j r . " . " #. - V o. " * #. w^ .- V- S- "-* f 2.n A .w.4 ..k. 4*. *.. u.g " y a. .m .e.1 C " d " *.'s*. . .* v*.b. " . . ' * . * -
a l e- c. a. . 4 , 2 *- a,j- a .. -.m.m..
. ..,,a-. w . a. v3 yaw;s _- G_H n
. a.a - _4 .;
..A- .. _ u. m. 3 a 2. .. ... .
.. 4. . . n 4. .. . ,- .
v 2 -, . ,. _-.. -- w; ;,,.
4 . .a. .v. _. a. _.. u. . w - r = - - _~ _4 y .
"e y * .k ' C
- da" .**" . - * . ' 1--.= w^ * = = . . * .:--
-- ~ ~ ^ V '..'.~: ,
.?ws4_
3-
.._..4-
<- ; - .; _- -.2.:
-.. . .2. , - .3 . _. .,a2_.
- -- a .
o .s . ., .. a . =. _.a- - Aa_a_.
. - . 4 ...=. ..4..a.
-- .. . u. . ; , ,. _ a.
.3. - . -- 2..__.. - . . w- g .
--2 32 _1 s .ea- ;
.. . : 3 T e C ...m . a 6.r
~
w v~ a 4 _ . = A . .~
--. mu.a
.. - 2. _s,,goaa5 L. . ._.=,....4, . ..: .z.u.e n..?. A n7 S C. -.e ..~c.- Jag . . . .; . . _. _4 . 2 7. .:. .
T .,. a f A 4.
- - 4 . .. .nw u, u.a ,,m . o n- C e . .= .u --i ~ .4..; . . , me w. u.a f vy nnoggA.
- . . u..a . . . _J . . . a-a ,,__-..=_. .,
- _ - .v r 1- ...u. ,=. y .u..w-- n . . n z--ua -,=-.n..-- os= 2A 1 3
v" C". C# . # ."..a. **#~'".^"*. w_ -* a~ "w b S . =.a. . _4--' -z .b.C'.v* 4 ."."; C.# 3" v" C w# ^*CC*.. .. #.^.*
v 4 1,.
_32 - a_. a. uC 241s. CC * ..4 ..~a
-- , waSeA- w -,.. _b.e m 2 Co w _a-2 8 u. C,luw _4 . . 7 0 a -
. v . v. 3. S.o 7 . ~t 7 4 (> a) , 4 .. 3 dC4-4oC .
.s u..e m . - a um_a- Sy eC4 :-4 eC- 4 1
0 cn .. . a...
~7.4i+
~ s C .
.On N.Cv=""e.-
'C
_ r 9~Ia r .e .'. i ^ a..S * .*.q 3 C a #
-- -.4 .". 4 "- d a.' ~i v,
- -- =...mA. g.k.a CS e "'a~
g -.- .Ts ,C e
- _4 ". 4.. ^ ".
. -4 _#w.^
- 4 .".".
- _" V a.*." . _i ^w P. . n' ".
%.- a a g..~a
~ 4 .a a , _ u.a..
-4 a c a.n.g - .t .e.c, .n c a v.A. ; _ , .q . a f u ' .a-y
. q +.4 u 4- c.n c :-
M4 gg-d Va*V O,*We "_ 3 *C ;4eC'. ~ '.C .#.".'.*"*<*G.".a.
J- T ' .7.k.".
-- * "- a~ e "
.y O
.O
- - - - = 6. J w$N .N. - O O N y ..$. b O w.
M hw .. . g . -. g M. w
@ .M. veggg-- e_ y u,
~
10~iD.
a "..".e _' a s . G- ,. . . =..a.*. .* C . rw_# . b. a.
.T4 =. .o y e .d .4 w r. o aS -=-
m.*w= b, g .*. -m d 4 .2..*.. A .. .m e. .m a . b.,y
==
h b. -a .'3 a g.. A.
- p a . S . a. g
<Sdub.
_ g-
.i .t . m..s. g pe,o--y.
- 4 Sn.e.*. nggA w _4 .7 ".."a. C -. ^ ". m~ ". ""- * -
.; .7 w
.4
. C .. 3 ..C Cye m*4.._C. . C: _ %.e .. .7 2 .=... .._4 4 -e
. f ..
excessive _3v Cost.3v anC, 10 e;;eC , OG.VCnd
- k.g 4 . 4 ._.a.7C 4 a _' C = D ah .4 .' ' .v. . C - = "y y _' _# " --
' .". ~. a~ .
d' yo n, ., t e. gn. . . @- g.e a- = _4 ..s e.c _t m
= - _T _'f- n o.n. w a _1_. _m_ a. -A
- 0 C.ym e .* m h.o
. - *b.a. y_ia m
. h.
b ee.--se O.J st*-
a~ s va 1 7 m -- _4 ..~ 3 CCsts.
m . k.. a.--_- a : C e , ..*w. n. 4 m o-,w, e C a n esv272 4 _----.;.ws.. .- n
_4 . . _..%. .- -
wo .r. a- _-,., C _
- --ion. =n.d c'e"="._4cny c_# '".e N_- .. . m. ..e_" _3=w~_i
- _1 _4 v_ b=s _'ong "ea..
=
contention in this proceeding. If Dr. Fankhauser wished ,to
=sse_. su . .k.
" = %
c r.' m.7 '. 4..^ . , ". e " = - _4a- ... ^
m = a C .". w"..v. "..a. o ". "- i d k ave A. *w* = .' . a- d ur.* _4 _' "..b.4 s a.% *. _"- a." e _' v, .' a . .a C' a . .a ---" dC sC. ^ ~
n' o ..'"s-a ny_eal c - oC a _" s# a ".a' a d
~
- _4 .. a..k.e c '.< s c_ 4 . o_--* C 6 a --A _4 ..~2 , : e~~4 4-
's e a-o *. _4 .3 a ro. e.n.*.4 Cr. "WhC 4 ".e.X""s ab l v,
-- - ~_4
. a ~s ".b. -a _#__# ' _# .".C. #_ c. =- d-._'- # ". a k v .".O t m" e _" a_
b
- _' " ". C n*w.s ,- "u bv se"<a"=.'
, --- " A _= _" s~ ,
j- k. = ", a.
. . = . " . 3..".""-
.T C u s .' ,V . h*. = V,V burda" - -a *O
- "u e -a '. , " a s- "y e "- _# =- _' _' v w.".a. ." *. ~_'* a.- _4 .". ".
, -- s *7 e.". -
u---i ^ ". WC"'# - "=- _' .'.C W " b.c.7. - ' . " . **=Va"se- - ~~3 Cur.d- w'r. . 4 -b. .b.= s a .' ." e .=. d V w
e a- .n. -1 -. ac
. - A. (3 -- 7%e- .4 h. . . C ". *O -
__/
y- - u b. a. _4 _* s a ~._4m. ~ 4 .= c. . _d - .e ,. T . d O. .k.a.
Ameen_1 yy cCa.A . h.a. .. .v a. a A C- ~ a C' ..
c.C.re syeC.4 4_4 a.1 1 y , y e,sc,.s y Ouw a n*4 -.77"
- t 2 a _s.se C -- u. -a s u f, uu.e _,.4c - ns4 .g ,c~._4-. -. u".,.C a _-
scrutiny would be encouraged simply to sit back and Obserte the ccurse of the proceedinc- from the sidelines unless
.a..d u.".' _* _' 'he.v %ec_= ..e "e_"s"a^
. y a --
A',..*.=~.
their interest was not beine adec.uatelv - -
represented bv the existin3 carties ard . .
- w,s.u wha. .w.ae.4 _- C .* . . a c . ._4 , a. ( .4 .: w e_-
,,.,e
--)
involvement was required. No judicia_,
tribunal 1would or. cculd sanction such an approach and it is equally .clain to .
us that it is whollv . .
t.,,.e
. foreie.n to the . .
contemplation or .
.nearin= provisiens of both the Atomic Enerev Act and the -.
__5/ Puget SCund PCwer & Light Com=any (Skagit Nuclear Power Pr0]ect, Units 1 and 2 ) , ALA3-5 5 9 , 10 NP.C 152, tao 3" ,
12 ..o .
med. N
= -
,q 3...C ...4.*. 6.. b. a ,d, b. a,. m. 5. ,
,3..q.._. ", 4
-. . . . . .. . ..b. 3. _.
= b. . a. 4. _w _4 .._ a. _v..a. a- _e
. .. . -ba4 n 3,. *.*
.3.=.
.; -,..,3..,. . -;
_ ,,. .g.y ,.a ~q,a.. a, m- ..... .., . ..- .. ,,s. -. .
- y _ _ . a .,.
-gw 3
~; ,. a . .; . ..
L. .wa, s- _ %. 3. . _ .%, . =a. 4. .
.... 3._4 #
-w_.., .
w.'8.. . . % a. * .3. . a 4. s ii e , e .*. .d'. a.... a. .,... w . w ; m
- 4. .Jw ..'s.
. s. .:. a. n., _m _. a. . ' e. w* . . ,. .. 4. 2. w. _s .n. -
._. J h. ._. ... 3. 7 .-dw.,.._*=.., -
.m... w.
b.
.E . ' :
- * ~ *A 2.-*y**.**.*2e..*.' 2... .?e,.*.*.=..**;* ** **
3..**. y .
y .. .-
9,
.3 6. _3 _J _. a.- W.
..b.w=.*._* ;
.. 2---.
-.-O;..
.w Cm w .w. . ,a.. 3. ._w 4 a
. i.
m
- b. a. '. . a 3. .. _4 .; y.=,..-
_Je =
7 w , =3 w .w
_- _A m .:. %wve _ %.
v _.. b. a .'_..w..._se w .T.._. a. w mj. . ' _ . . ~ _
.m..-. _w.%. a.
C,. . ,4aa_4m,..I
. . = _. -
w
, g ,,_I _3 ._. _J - i . . a= .
- b. .= . . g .b.
.w-
.e ,n_a.,- . : 2, gey n ..
. 1 -. n ( ., )
.,. a.
, ,.,w.: - _ u. a.=. .. ... = . , .
-.em= v .. _ _. ..*. . . . ,..j ,
-.._.,,-.4,.a. .
g...._ .s. ; g. e. .. . . = .
f %. .,. g..4 C2. 4- .s..'n. _?j. . -s.a
- _
a.
s _. 2. _4
- m-
- 2. 1-
- .y j
( t., & ..c. g e. ==.a .c.i u _- a aaa3
-== w. a - a---.e w .. . a a. . .y
. .y =wawa _ .s. _ w.==. a
..a. .m . , .n .-
a lll.
a.O.-, .w. . ._ 1 .% .*.=. -ww-
-mJ e g .. a=- _ = . .. ..4. .
- .'m. J -e . J -A :
.. ; aw, A.. .J . 4 . e. . J. .* . . g * ..O _... . O 4 .O _.
.a .
,.....a w.. . . _ -. .=. ;......,_.s._ -- s
- y. *.- . <.- a a. . ..;
. __ 3. , . .
, ,,_.a,.
.a . . . ,,. 1. e . ..~ . . _ .
a a- _-~= u _n _.- n .u.a.; _ ; .. a- - :-: :
~ %. a. .. - _.
.a _,.
..a _- u. t::
e.,,.,.
-v-. a , .;. .m.
- , 2a .~ - _ - . . ,,. _ :. 2a-
,. - .....: a a
. _a
~n, -
<1*
s- -:'. . " A. - : ,* **,, ~~
. , . t, .~t . r . ev.4. . 1 .~. - ~s ', ,
_ , -, ,.=aA_:
y_~., . -. .; ._ %.
. _: .. . a.
.=.m-*-.
%. 2 _ .* .. . a
. .3." .'"..^*_ a .C
. 2 .*.*. a.. ** f*, w * * ^ *
- w...O...*.*.**.*.*~ae,. '. .S. a* .
a.""s***.*.S*.^* . .
.u.a- _.
- e. .a a
.uw., e ga a, n u..a... .n a %y m _ .s. n a .c., ... , .. .
w .n _.. .v i . _. .. . -.a . n...
. w ._
aapa a r a s,. : =; .. :
-, - ~
y #-
- 2. ,
.- a S a _: .,.a --; . . . m. .,
a
.a.: _,
a , u. .= ,a- . = A
. 7.0 sIu.,C . .3. . 7. ", .1 .., u..w. e. S _s .a a
- _.. : _a C ,. _a- u w. a . . - e .3. 7
.~c c ,.a-A -e a- Aw g c 4- n. .. .n n .:-. : _ _ u.g. . .'s
- p. a. n _,._ .4 a ., ~
. x ,_
.. .a .. ,
y .. .. .. _4 u-
" " # C *~* C .* ". " * * * * " * *. '. C.'..'.a~~.'.".*". ~ *. ***
y-w
- y"e"_~..*..".
a..-._.a
. a ,. ,
s
. -.. ~ a t,.,..- ..
.w
- . . . _. , w. e. a. .. . .. a. a ~ 3,
.. c .
.~ 3,-." . .* . a~
4 3 w --- a C _,. -. . A 3
- -%. a v.4.e.r- ----- cm: C .,. C a _, _ _4 .. . , . .u. a .. .. 4.
- . . . a m S a u aa_4S _w_ :, .,,.,,;a_,,,a._,., ~, 3
_4 u.a ..w....., .. . . . . ..a- _ u. a. .~. ,
- a. ,
- .A. .
e, a--,; .
.~
_ n../. ., .a < z.
... o c-a ;_ : n. .,
L, nw
., a nuO g,1.
- ,.wa .- w w.. a. CC _aC . . 4.. .aSa- w- ,
..aj
-1 l3 1. u 4 2 m. a ww y,A.-
n . . . .
^-.
.". *. C, "w.".*, **
,C US'w" .S
."."-.".C,
- _..."ya.~~w"^o"."*.....'".".a .
~
4".
._ ,.* ., _ " '= f* *...'
. n '. - '
O J4m
"' e ",, y"' e ** .'. '. ' '.' .". *- _'*a,
- ."."- -- - ."w . " ** *.'*:'..
..w . - --
.. .. a. } 3 4 .3..1.;e *, eg .
aagg u u.k..
u ..
.z... { .a. w .v a a 'j _3.1. .i. a f _4 .. ..a T p
.a_ae Se.".Se O-. _ S G C " ".' ' "j
- wV ,
..~. a y" a "-' - - a .'. ". a ",._ '^,s ".
. O...
a.".O *w* .. e_ ' y" * .". ' V, j . " . ..*" "e ~ ~ ~ - *C C.".A w - '3C*d e .* a
- ^
. ~ ' . "' . . ' . L' v^ ~..~',2 ". .V_ .
~(Sk=C,.4.. N.',..'*-.=.-
w . Cv. -- a " : ". C *Je C w p N...
. . w . a- 1 2..d .'. ) p .' ' n -
3 .*., _) r . _T 0 V. .T.t.*. .i. , S3 ( _i C, "< 9 ) .. .C. a_- o 2_m,,.
G n _1_: C-
~
3
.a. S.
g h 4 _1 4. u. 4.o g Cw.r .o. w, .a _.y /\.*t"* 4. y a,. .. . , g . . A- au
'3 .a _. 4.v e . , v.._, S 1 .m . .-A
-sm
.t7,,
C ..2 9.
. )s p na n =. 3 ,-s p s'd . .p w / cup _a.O.(p3-i . s_3 s / ) . y: ,I.' < ef. C*4 ef Cw e pa=a a".*/
- -,aN. ." _I-4*--2 .". f.."."_#^**
,,s-4
( C.' *- " -*.,.* . . w .. p t o...#. a~ .-.p .' a.*.. # .', ) ,
. _s
.% o.t.B ~ n, -s U r 3 y.s_~.f . v Q ~s t. r onD \q1I). .,
-: 10 -
.c- . .4 334 c .. s a- ..a.c. o- -.... _t , . 4 - . a . .i. _t ... C " b. .
.c a. c . 4. _. . . , , _, ,( _, ) m. n : . u. . a. a._
. v_
--- .4..,
.. s _. .- w.. ,s u..w. a. -a- . e _. _= _4 _. ..,. _3 y .o c _. _4 .. m- .
...2..-
2 . .. .,
,' ". s - _ _# _ ' _= b_ _' v _' _= . =-= f . "_ _' _. _' ^ . a , _'. = = a- "u -
= d_ _';"
~
ane e s _ a_ _s_. , , c . _ha. .nx. , a_ n. , _ _a n -- s.u u , . , __u ,
y- .
sent ,emonstrac..le- gccc cause :or no a o _4 . gso,an _4 .- e _4< .._4 2 ,,_,_3 4
...a_.as_aC _4n
,w...e on - .- w.m.e o.# _= : a_-__* "' .
--=- - :- - ~ c==.di.nc.
w _ _' _' =c. .o ,_w i
+
=v. b._' o- _'...=_-=e..w_d"..b._'.".
~-
..w. a. .s_,c,4-wo .. e c
. _4._..e _ _4..._4 . o . _of As the Court stated in Eas:cn Utilities Commission v.
_i _r C ,. 4 *4 *, e.&- ma 3.=2 _l o_ e 0 ) ,f.e . . ,c e m. A_-3o _4 - - -----.
- aw smes
_ 8 ,= =, , ( .n . c. . c. _a _. .
4
- 2. w.. _4 . . _4 g __ _.__. , _ , . = a C. =..w . " _# =. m- _= ~ =_. . * . * ..-. ^. .. c . _4 "." *. = A "_S.., =..C.'.".=...*=.
. _. g g . o- .m..c f g i a. A. --.a,= . _- a_ _T =jn _, _ c.a s _4 .. .l ._4 . .'4 . ' . a.
- - . . . . C#
m w_-
f C a a C_4 ..n ; _4a- f amonA. s..wn.w sa a_ _ne< _T j .__. . : - .. . . . a. M
_ a_ ;- c a _n _.j , aX. w ..--m_a5 s,._
-v.m .a. _. .s .e . .s . . .. .. . - ., . .s. y _? ;o _._.__s_..;
4 ,.4 ,
_2_;-_ c , 7 3 .__. , . : a. -. ." _ _4 .'s..= g _. _c a_ ,
a . . .w. .s
.- - g ., 7 - .o c .m._* -4 '..c: _7 -4 nyy -
_4 . . w. a. .F.i _4-., *m. _i a. a,
. .y_--v.. y _-wc. o. a. C' _' . .3 -.
an acministrative hearine woulc. .ce. ~
a meaningless charade if these with 2 2n ,e , o - - c .
. w: . ,. 4 -; . o --.--2-._4,4-,.. u n_ - . w a.
.=7'*wed - "^ - s-=.".A- --_44'" "": _ = . .4- ' . = . . , .
..e va_**. .b.e _' a.s s , A=~.sa..d_
_= _- =. _ = v. wP.=. ..
thev do not like the result.
. _7/
._ _,ea.
o 10 sIRC. _ . o w.. s a __.e a_ _s _so r. . -=-
. w
.e .1.,..e _-
3 card's decision at an earlier point in the Skaci::
f ecaad_* .c, w h e ~ e .' '. c h. _= s .4 .~ =. 6 = ,e ". _
- c.n a. _- #..- ~. _- _ o -
.. e - =.~. .= u e m--.. *".e
'i ^
- cy _4 ...i n.ns c 3 ' b. a. r,e e. a.. .e.. c 3- .
ai.C .w
..n. . __4C. . -.e Na..C .ow u.s._e_: C .,. C.m .- 2 _4 .. Co . .a..r._._4 c..s .
as , w~as_a- 2e _-_. 4 .s .no n 4 .,. .. ..re , --_4 c n . as .w.. a. nyre,_
-3 card noted, no party to a NRC proceeding purports n.o. -
3w-_.an..ae-w.e Co ..C.,ess -- . Oe _[.4.sj- .
-_w 4m,a .ua. -ev. , . _
C_l us d ops" * = g a d i .a. "; '- b.e _4my* a ". *. c .# Cvi^ .t =. .".* 4 .^ P.s c ".
o t.ner .reta. tioners , and nit is not enou n Icr a c.eti-
. - =
. . .i u _1 1 =. d .4 .. *. a =
"._4 cn.e.-] s .i .c. .' .v ' o = s s e _- . _". a ". ( _4o 6 was] . .
alse-sense c:. securitv. - t.ne c.articication or
.v .
another carty]." Puc_e: Sound Pcwer & Lic_ht Ccmc_any t
-(Skagit Nuclear Pcwer Pro]ect, Units 1 and 2), ALA3-
-552, 10 NRC 1, 8-9 '(1979).
~
See also Gulf States-Utilities - Ccmpany (River Send Station, Units 1 and 2) ,
ALA3-444,-6 NRC 760, 796 (1977). Duke Power Cc==any (Cherokee Nuclear Station, Units 1, 2 and 3), ALA3-440, 6 - N R C o, ,, 2 -,_ , o*r (29 ,
es).
7/- Pacific Gas and Electric Company (Diablo Canyon Nuclear Power Plant, Units 1 and 2) , A A3-583, 11 NRC 447, 448 -
(1980).
m
-u.,s, : 4.. - 4.: ,a- , . ..
- n. . . a. . . . -- - =. :.-.=.:-~~~ u =- ,,,,
.. -; . ; 4-.. , - - - -
- e. .: .. -..-..na.-...n.=...n-
,4 -~
4
.. -- .d .u. . .-.
.,=. :: .,
---.A - . - - .
-...n....4...=.
4- .u.n ,., . ,- m.u.-..; - . n _..n: ,
-.C ,-. . . . . , = . .
. . . n. -u-==.
...=
u.
w=a ;4-..c., : : ,-a - -=,..a...=;,. : -
- - .u.. a. -_- a.. ,, = .,. a .4 . . .----- . .
, = -
.-~... ,,...--..,-
.u ,_,
2
-...n..-- -- c -
... , . a u. , uaa ,.
.=. -.u. a. -.e,.. -s --. --u,4n,-4
- ------- C,.. n, :
s.; c : r g f q .q , o , -J %=C*",ae
. ".s ". .-ao a 3"-
- , - " . = a " by" = - . = . = _ - C _#
e..e.
24 % . , . n,. n
- w. e -- .. . m..u . _4C..-a 2.,4- .a .
%. m. v.. m. . e- c/ 24
-.- m..u. c. - -3
.%. .,. A u - * -**j
- w. %. 2 2 .
. -. .m
...s...J
- e. --
w - .m. b. s. . . . 4 . . . a-W-%.. 4 .- .%. .%..,.*.*3 %.=2C - . . 4 m..C 4*2
-==-.h. =
- .y.
-/
, -,, --- -4 a .q N
~
... . .m . ..%. .:. 2,,=. . a ,. % ;. 2. p . .~~./
~_~
..a %. -2
~4s
- , o-. .3 4 .. ; Q3 A 2 . . ~~. , w a ---p -s? n , %
--2 8.m. e. 1. %
..w e n- .* A s- .. , .w=;* ~ .4 .w---..m...e
. ,.. . -a S , _9n.s o 47 25
-...-..J-.a
-*. m- m
.W-.
4 7. ' w ,
.m . 2* m..e . S -
J 3..%., .* - -,3 h , , w 4 m. ..
-. .. .m. o. ..a..- C...
w z - .-
-n w
. .~...a .n.. %. c. . . ..%.a. .w. a- 1 - a. f .v a.gy4o
-- . - 6 g.g *..
5 .. 4. u.
.. 15 a .4.... 4 .* .u. .w ~~...2.._
-e d
. 4 n..~e n~~
Lv CO-. ..k.a. ~4.. ..- S w u.s.n r.,o.:s - , a-. .
. .r .m e.. ,w... .s ., 8 ..
a . , ... . w-
-, ru 3. -w4-
-_a
- 3. . 2 4.,.-..,..
.s. .e .e c - . u..w.., f ... 4. .*.; : . . _! . .:. .u., /m. . eo e - .- . ...2 . .o
. a".'.e 2 ',.' b ;"
- C ' p .W d
. u.a. -
- 4. . S " C "..' . V, C,"w
- S ..*.*. .". a h .' s ~4.b. s *..b. s .". . . O. .U **4..'..'
n.
1
,7 4;"C "C"wS ' */ _7 _4 ~. 4 C,a's.
, " k o S e " C P. ". *.". . _4$ ^" ".h
- . -. ".aS .~y"e "_" 1_0 *
- 4- ./_ C "..
CCOS ..C C ,..Su.a-,,-s w --w. n3CCC - --- -
3., S e n :
0- J.... r 2 n *K.w. 2 ,- . S c _. ea-
. wa.i.
y" "*- C . a S '-_4 .".a . 4 C .". 4..". **
.#. a .4 ..C. h..# .~.ia" e
.#. "'".a. .#..:o Ce C.#.' # #..". * .". "- 4 .S. .i
-.s_.4__4 3- a 6._4- p. .. .
O 44 - e m A
. .V.o. w..w- w_m C .1 4 e .s... ' .r % a C .n. b.s. i_ m.e a.. V_ r. .h. .w a cn,., .M 4 1 .s TA S .1 s2 .s. v..
.* wmw.7,.p a..w q c-m-,.cp. r n,. p. .~ ~. a"o . aa A.. ) r " .M.e .m..c .~. .n .. d g~.. s qd Q .ge ..
.=.e 3 n ..t. e.n .
ev' won CC .. u. m.n. *. 4 CnS t ,J_- a b, m . . -& wC
.%a ,I.4 a e4 C .f 5. Rt Le G / C 0.
- - . -- 7 7 %e ] , "
DC C.k- = ~. N. C . o0-280 ( t a .~ S ' _* _ '_ ) ( _v a . -". . .3, 1990), S .' 4 e, Cy.
at 2-3.
0' -- -
am g
_ _-f _C. _
a.
_10 ... *. a .. .re ..C .* r . a.a.x w .. s- S .,
e _* ' a- .M.a - ..* 4 Cn u m., 4'.C'.. 4 6-ad A 4 *. 4 -- .. 2 .
o Cw n .a..u 4 CnS 3..,.
1 1
12 -
.r ..w-.
, . - , a, . .n . s s- ...C . 4-n .
,2, 4 .. ,
..e,4 - -. . .,,.
v 4 n-. .S :
-eS w ..C ..
= 4* .a a Sa 4. s #*/ " . " .
- C .'". a - .
_+C"%-=,~.i.."." # .- , -' = e 4 .". '. a. -"< a. .". . 4-." . u.*.#--- * *
...k.. . S 2 C O.n.C- -
, 1.O C . .r . 0.. . 34.,1_ w' (2w) ( 4 4 s _ ( ,7) . ,
..o
.O
. - o_-4_ . .2_.4 ns. _w.-
1 1
a.o 4 n&.e -..e.._. 4 C., _w
- w. .- o _ erC.C
_4s - C 1.s. s - -m 2-uO ww.k. e 3.s.a _4 _1- 3 h _4
- < . - - - - --7 -;
4 ...
O- Ot..o b - m e , .,.S .v.w
...e- *s'D.. y .ws
-a*4 yo ---
4 3 .a..t- s 4 .. G O S '.S N. #--7 ' D*.
=d.
~
~
c.o
=C - n' a
..o =C,
- .V.V3 ..
4-s = _' .- =- = -d v, -' .# "._i3 a ..i ..C, w ."e 4-os ue C _# "e5v*=' = w_# . .~3
^^
w w S *w o* " =S t.h .av .
.-a- ' w= ~.a . 'wv^ ""e
- .#.4.7a..C.#'_' -
_: .w ...e a v s - yu-2 b _4 _1 _4 .;
- ny--y .1 4 C .m .,. _. a . %-
s_. v3 4*3s,,Se
. . - uCe- s .w-.r u C4 =
2 s --e_,..
yyw 4 .. w. a. ----
-m-.- 4- m
_ew- _..%._4 .e -s 3--
a e .- _4 - .~. b. s -- .'.n .v-- O O s o-n 4 .. a.- n _. 4 r. .n. _-
.. . . -.3.,og. a..b _43 _4 g g Ua - . .._4
- w - m _ g u s .1,7 _4a- e,ne-_4 s ._ - ..sh's.."
m
-< u s.. . , = v.4 . a- a.- n.".C -"- "^"...*."...'.'..S
~
-.. .n. . .v, .~ -y. S. V _#w " U S ;' " = C.7.4 ". . * -d 4
4
-.. u. 4. . . sn. g a wa
.,anu --
,- ,=-, ..v.u.
. 4 .. a A a o n. g ... , . ..., g
.m.,_. ~ ,
...,u. ,. v g g _ s s-l ac.k C# =.".',I 3 ~Cv"d v="Se #^-
- w. # = _4 ' "- --* '.O
_- .# .4 .l a. ^w ".. ". 4 "...e , " =- _' s C ym -ev.4 w dm- S .b.e .14..C.k y-4.w.
- - _am.,w 4 4...A 4 ..g h- h.s e
am b.e - -3 45 no e rb.o.,. w-
--*- .=. S C .". . . ' . - .=.#
- ~ 4 . . .' .".C, { 'w.". *. .'.=...i * -^"..'.oC',.'^."..S,*"
-w s ' .=. '/...= " S 3 ' m-e-=~- e div, e..gn, -e s s ed 3-
"b -a.ge. m .i d ed- . - '
_. _4 .._. m-- - e s * ~n _4 _1 _1 4- --m--
- y . o. g e..~.e--A 11/
CV eX1s tinc. .Oartie s . n-i t
y , . .
..O:eCVer, in SSSeSSinq 2. e SeCCnc :aC;Or, Cne Boarc.
1 g w..ow u_l d w-n . . .a 4 A - e *. " ..C ". C n .' V, W.".a ".e _"
w.ob y a_".4ag .-- 9. 4 1
-- 1 a deC"-n a1";
y- . o *w = C *. .'a.a
. _4..'.a.-a.s
- a- o .# ." 2
. y- e " _4 ". 4.C .".a .. , "< u . w".. a. b.e .. ..". a -_* =.
= _- a. o *.". a - *.ae = ..S wh.a -=b'r y e".' -4 C 7 =- - " = .7
-- , -- hi Se'# y . -w- "o
= C . ". _45 4 7
_51
.a.*. a--- a S ' S . -v.a.C_ =.~.d ar.ic ".." .d - _C_ C --m g anv_
- (v~e._eSyC-. ".3".C_'==-
'Cwer StatiCn, Units 1 and 2) , ALA3-292, 2 NRC 631, 647 (1975). _AS noted in the precedinc, d SCuSS1Cn, coSC C: Dr.
11/
_ _- m.. k.. e e. Li _l o
. - ?.S 1 a..d , Suc 3, -
e1 a - _4 .- on4 .- n _4o.. a e ,*.
.. -- - +
13 -
- 2. .,.. . >. .u. .o. s . . a i a- -..-,-_..a- ,._.4...,..a._,.. a ,a. _ _4 -< a,.
w : .- . ,,.. -.
,.a, ,4
. 2 .
. w- . .m
- - a- .,.--.74 , u.
. . _ _,_ a....,.h._4
~ . .. "; , ,
- ....a-
. .*h.._*w.*.
.v.
--. . .n.. . d sau. av 'u* _l m d hg
- ,w ~_,_
_nyy-wy
- - - n _ _ - . a _n - r a A-a
.;----- gG -a A %a:n-a
- --_w-w w .- . a -a. c, u n-,--- -- ,y % c w# _' * * *
~-
no a.. u. a. _ u. .; _- mA v.c_ :_n-w- .~,_ a
- n n .. . a.n._ _4w..
- w. - ,s , _ u. a .v. - a,. _4s-Q ac .. _ - . ;
.s.u. a- _-,.n.. > u.. . = -, -.....
, > u. ., a a,. _- _ u. , _ u.. aa -
a.u.n.n_2..: _ . . , - - -; . ..
yw_ . _: _: f g _.-s-,
- - .. m g ,y - - a w..- ,u
-wa,-- - _1 , y ug _
a.
v ge._.af . _.m g 5 3_4o- -_ _.a m C a *# #.
. c V 2_ _' ,. ^, _4 ."."; = s~^, L' .".d .-
- C w-- o-#. 3. 7 7 _4 ,. a..m.s_
, _4 ._.g - .#.*. y _ - .'.4". k.". a " s e ' o" 4
.'..C._^v.". 4..".#
. . -. . # ^ = ~ 2 s .*.*, 4..'.* ,8 - . _' a~ e .*.^,
. . s- ya" .d .' _' ' 2 5 _-". _#
_ . .". "; ".v'.*.
=- : - _ .a _m -za
- e, g _ a-
.. _ u.= , . _w- . .. s -_-~ c _- 4 . .c , n -y-a _ ,, . _: ._.c. w _- c e. n..n... _a m c .4 . .. : . . c, ,
... . r i e,, 4__:_y. _...a.,...u.
_ a,. .,. _- __
. - -e .s u..u. a. y g __ _ __ _4 r, n.. -- a a t -
_4_y sui 1
.S. a- 2 <-------
- .. , 7 . . , w i a --ww. . _._ 4 % r
- 2--_c.-- .
...2 " "_ -^ ----
y C a c d 4 .". " _4a-
'v----
e - w a..v g _- 5-- C ."."; "."w o~ e # S C.^_s v w's a y y_'_#"A --
-^
-w
. s' _' _' .W # .".": y a _- _* "_ _4 -
y a ___4 v I,. c .n. _ u.e f
., _ u m_: v w
..a i
_9 aCX 4 ..ny s_u. s .,.C' _s ..; u .., .. : ._ a,. _e.,. a. . . a. .
.s ,
__/ u u. e _- a ;_ ,c cas_:a- _ v _.
_i _S
._a-, . - c_ _ .a3n.u._ . , n _a ..
n ye_.- -,_a..g a
.3, . a
,...=."._'c..#--
^
--- W"._'-". . .$ -y a,. _4 _ _# ., .e _ , _' _4 5. =. . _ . ? .$..~ >."._= ".-.=. e _- ". n .~. = ,
"w , e. c _e _ma-aa
. . - . ---- ..c _v.' ._4 ..g ~ eyo n.d .g_4a - b a e a s s e . '. 4.^.". wb._4w" .". . _d.".".
3 lead [the Scard] to believe that he would be ible to make a
= _4 3 .._4 _2 _2 -- - s .. . w- e n .__."u w 4 c.. '. s "_b.e deve'^e
- y ,e... c# = . . = " _4c'an 4=--
v.
_1_3/
-acc_-an c. uu.e cnn.e..u_;cns me
_ . - e .
u y---we vses.
_12/ Sublic Service Cemc.any c# oklahoma (Black Fox Station, _
Units 1 and 2) , ALA3-397, 5 NRC-1143, 1145 (1977);
V_4 _ ,~_4 .7_4 .= T _i e c -_ _# . = - 3 c w e - " - .._ a..v_ ( 7u c _- .n' .a .. . = d ~ = ._4 c.,
~
Units 1 and 2) , ALA3-363, 4 NRC 631, 633 (1976);
- e "...e s s e a V a _' _' a v_ .A u
- k.o _ _4 _ v_ (Wa*..s ma- Nu-_'a=_- 5_ _' _= .n . ,
Units 1 and 2), ALA3-413, 5 NRC 1418, 1422-23 (1977).
___3/ =n u, s .-... r _;a nu. ~._; ..c. &o. c.a e _nu n-
-w . w m c_ a n.t ( n _, _, ,n s C_ --- a a y n.iuc _,- , , -
Genera:Ing Station, Uni: 1) , ALA3-582, 11 NRC 239, 244 (1980).
l 1
m.no C_4 a C. - , a a _4 wa. r , SwC.le 31.5 0 a..r -w wW a- _..%. - 3. u
.n.
a-. .r- m..< ' w . 3, . 5 6. -
- a 4 .. u.a- _- a. g u. e w _4 _1 _7 km
.- ---y- a" #e S e.7'. " -A- " ";
- b. a .. - s.v. _4m~ ". 4 ."."; "ya _"*._# s- S , " . . " . " -
. 4. w% k, .w. ..%.
sa_+- 4..E. -c 13 4
_ww.w- 4 . . = .w.m.. i .n. _i . . ;~ .-
3
... a. .r.. <s. .n. e. 4.m w n. C --.
a w. a_4 44 m .l y , ,
...%.g.v o - . _43 .o.r w... _ w 4 ..- ; _4.,. n ., . r .=. . .*4.%. .s. . .c . 2. .. r .: _,,m.. .a
~ ~ .a. . 4--- . m A 33ae--.4C 47S
..w. .;. _. . _4 ; ..-w . 4 .. A 4- C ' ". = .=. "- .'.4 "p" o. .4 .. . o .- a g .. 4. . . 7 4 ...m..g -* - 36 e .'.C
. . - . ^
w "a~ .
-. . - , . -3AA44
--- 4 r. ,. . .,-_4-..
w .y-. ...w a. :Ca*#
- - N. _4 .' .' -"s"*
- - - _4 "v e ""..de ." .'flO. U. C ^w *. -
---e .n. *. _4w.4 -- .v e. .g g *w- 2:_ .4 s
_1.,* ..b.o. 4
- _1W a v. a~ .". : S "..b. a. C -'" .l _i;"a *w_4w ^ r. ^w .# SS-g .w. . .4.. .~y .w-
.. . a -..w y w-1 __4 .,
w 1. k.
.. e. .2 .. -. 4 s, OC.as. .,
. y 4.. . = . . C "ye " * "- _4 ."A C,
. _' _4 "w . . *. *
. S S
=w 4 y . .m m .. a. s. 4 4 .=.3
~
4 m,,
y d _w _% - - - _1 _3 _ , 4. _..-.a . - =.4< -2 ..v. m w . h. -s -*4as y y - - - -.%. ..f a =
- . 4 .,. 3. . . w .J .s .. ~ . , -
3 2. _4_:4.
3
.4cn.a- w , e. gg " " C .".y " . . ' * . * - 4 .". .#. 6v.".* a '. .i c. .". a "w.'a.
~
.".._4 '
- a, -d y -- a w -4. . uw 9
. g c. . . .% . t o _- . .v, _yy .o . .-_4 g
- v. m. .w.g 33w---4: _- 2 74 w9 2
- 2. a- .w. S _ .1 2 a- u- s. 2 f a.-~. 4 3. :s _1 _4 . _4 -- 2 . _4 ,. . . r. .:
y m
,w .m
... .o.u .a.. m .,. 1 .*) .._4... *
- ada.""S**'V . -- , -**, D, .". 2 S e.". *
, .b.. -o .J. .e. s. s .. s. s .w- s _ 3 .*. . v g, ..'<..b. n o- g e
. , . .4... *- h.4. a-
-mes _- . .
T m es ,n _' -- . . m. * ;4 . .n J As
-. = %.
. a. - .4. .=. 3. _1 _aC_e w- , y C.-a. e.4 k _1 s- -1.=.. g _4.=. b- b. o-
"y "v" C S
- d 4 ."." , WS ". C *. ~ ".a "
- . '.b.4
. a~ 3Ca"# %. . ' S .m .' _"a- a c' V, ";_" ' .*. . c C' "'".
. . e a *y,C u' .i ^..S.."."w ' a~ ." C ". 4 C .". C." S C*w"a."V., d.4cyCS.4.~.#Cn C". . .V.VU. .U ^^".".*.."."w# Cn ww.
11 *a c, a."# _4 .". ~
- ; ~.".e "..^ a d _#w.^ " y" C W e " . .O.--a-"_ " 4 '. "..#. .". "
.".s-. 7. c' .*..T.*s .* L' a~ c~ _~
'.^w "***
- wy "e.. ****.. a " * .*. .*^ V, *a *av, v ^_~.
. . a 2
_ . ". 2 4. ^^"."n.".*..'.w^.".
.. - '..C.**,.
. "." . . " . " . a
. - _ . a_4 2,
-- u..w. e. e, .- , 3. 3. C .# #4~
a' C'"~m " _'**;* - m " w'yc _# ~_ _' "w .7 'a'_" .' ' .4 w vI w *.d _i ';'
-an-
---ae de_iny.
7 4 .,.g 1_1, y f m y o..n. g _4 ... x. .- a. g y S C . ' w" ~...~~ C S *- _4~S"as a - ""a.5e".~ed y_ . - _4 .".
a S .w. .- r
. a.n.X' 4.a b
- b. o e_w Ba- -.9%
e.eW C e w4
. n.= a..m.b.4.r..m.a- .ut
. .b. 4 e. .b. a.w m - o w S om..e - d t.e..m C" o.w e
- k.e e (.4S .-.4 ..
- - w-r w n we.n. .. 4 e.*.S C.
3
.s.WO.. c =a *O .e.4 .,m s
4 c. 4u. ,1 C.Ca.1_4 _:_4w a_
O.. w$ n a , .&.- ,.-&.%...-
S v.
y C. @
.. w , .&. & S..
w a^
- OQ c, Q 5..Q g e ,
--..n'e.-.y e , .+ %. gu--3 C. . %._4 C f"_"" w C andi.".";
^
wV
^
, _ S""g"m _4 _" _ .".C. -*###" - - - . _# ^w.".S .i
, _ -2d..
4
-.9 M. ,o ,. f..- W Q M. .$ _W _94.g oNAMw . ..*--Q - $, .M. M --O, $.T.
- M Q. M.U . S_9-,j *. .
.d. Q
- .M. _W _9.M. F ,
. - n
. C .a m S . a Ls m i .i . , 4-
--w. e. 1
. d y C S n a-- 4 u _n .;. 2,<. - . 4 .A n .n. a . _4 .,._ '.n. . _4 a. .: . - 4._
3
... 4 .: .4 a. 3 ...,. t .7 , a.
.r
,-.s . g..we g.e.. c. -e...oAs-ww . . s, . w s u. :n
.... -e.v ..g - 2 AA4 .4 4.,.3.1 A .a .l .".',I WCul# w "e "--2,2.s.d ' . *.* ..'". a .c a,
." .**. .W .*^w r. .*""' . . . . C .". S.." .d '...,' i s. .c. .".",
4 ..f.4 . 3. . 4 o p*- ew .k..s . ,- 43 . .i .4. y. %.... w.4 3
%. 4O- .y aw .-.y 1 2. . a. .i .n. . c .* < g n. w.4.
. . mw.m. an Y..
N
- ..%.n. g g .m..- m. . . a. w . ~c p %.a.
. 4 .. .. a..A.
. a- . e. .. 1.r. .a ~ %.a. e ve n s.a.5 y..v -- 4 ..e ; 1-
-m j f %. a.
- L.
1,4 /
m '~~ w.a.aC eVO ., . . 4. 4 a- aca e A .-S u%OL1A.- -
e4 A- 4. ?
. .,. *..k.a.
2,,. -
- -. 4 - o -. -. .y ..
L"w e. ~m 4'm..4 r..a.t a- . e.w.C w.n. o e. .w am.6.4 .,. w A e .w s %. 2. .. ..b.e *,w.1 9 aS .J w.
ew 4 .. .1.*.Is .n.e. 4. a. n t.*.m.- A s .* 03-.- - - . 7 . -s..
w ..b.ew_w J. ..o e .' .4 . .1 . . S .4 c. . ; kes.*A-ww- -o *w o
- a. S .w.4.- ~. A..m 1 4 -
u-y_--=.
--1 .~ ,/
- a. g.w w . ya. - a. ........a. v a.,/
-.g..g o .m ..
.sw . . . . g.r. .s ,
= .q - - aw . .y. .
a-<a.
m..
.- .m.AA -- .m. a,. .n. w-e. . . . a, .n. . 4 Cnd. -
ConcluSicn er_.
.w ...%.a. -1. 2. a s.. .S
_ C4a c aSaA
...C a, .- . 1 1 ;. -.%.C . ,7a, , _w.a. ...r . .4 .,. .
va n
m..
w r ,
- w. 's..k. ,L,S O , _C
~ ,.
.a. .n. s e u.O S L.. %.,
. - 4 . s C' C' ; ~, 4 w m n.a n n.nw. ..ae.+w4n . w. .a-ShCua,C. . Oe Cen'SC. .
O.e S ya cw ". #. "-.' ' v .e ub...4 . . s. A ,
CCNNER & MCORE
\
' / \
f*?l a . &'
Tro' s .Onner, Jr.
o ne V '
. t< a. .n e u.. .. a .%. , n' .~s
.s.L ..
C ^ u.. S e .1 .#w.^ - .'sy,
- o '- ic = u" ".
.a Julv. 31r 1980 14/
Nuclear Tuel SerriceS, Inc. (West Valley Reprocessing Plant), C. .2-to-4, 3 .i R C . a i a , .i . 96 ( ., 9 /2 ..).
--15/ Denial of Petition for Rulenaking by Cincinnati gas . &
"- .' e c . 4 ~
w Cw-~yanv, m , s'o ? .=.- d . _a c,. _' 'i / O *' , l~s e 0.: ( .'d. = . w'". 10, . .
1 980 .
1
L e'
. ,. M.s , s
,s s.
.N'.,,..
s,
.x,.
fg y g3 Am.en - -e-_
.n . r.e C.# .'. ' -.'_r.S _ L.2 ~
'yU . @, ,# 4' -
NCCLEAR RIGULATCRY CC'01:SSICM -a ca -) >-
- .s .i*>.. w p&ac i Cse.. ,.
.w. o .st..m . m -- o -.
r ,) c,s y 'f
,, g.a _i $3 UC C'7
,3...T. M ,h,
.) ,,6 ... .
[
m.. w. e v _4
. , 4 . .. . .. rwa a 2-
- r. _* a_ - _ .4 w-
), .
- o.
. v. . . .=rv s%.:
C o m c. a n v , et al.
. )
M*2
)
t r,a.4 _i _7 _4u3 m .u. . 1 4 .....e v.au. , _1.,2 a.,. .
on,.,,a.e _s. J
.c -. a - C .n. ') J' e
w .c.o.m. ..= sa
_ e. - m. .e c. : -wz. -.r c- e ,
T 'r.e _' Ab.,v CS . - ..# "' .a - v^ # " n' c, " .' _4 Car." ' o~ n' .".s'de -
_#- w^^"y .# e s
--y c Ac...4 . ACw4e4,n.31 4 c 1n m _... e4 r .
. - . . .,c _,. r.e. ..s-w.a., . s e _. : s .stc . . - - - , ,
- a. ,,. 4 - r..a , u w.s. A _ m A V . -_7 . . 1., _7 , _4 . . "- . " . = . - = =,--' w^ r* a -- d c ._. . . . .
j . _1s0-0 0 ,
..3. w. e,,
.-- ..'d. s,. _. s. s. -.
e- ,.s
-- 4 .. 7-
.. wh.e em _1
- - _1 -m.g 4 .. 3 - w,y .
As
-y gg 4 - - 4 . h k.e-
- V .. 4. _.. c A .C, _ .- _ a, s . 3 4 .* _ ..h.4 o-
- 1,1 g- e dsy .
g_ V"-. nly, -,C3Q.=
1
%.. _ .g .. .%
- b. 3_ _I g 3
- 2., Cq.b.b.a A.w- #
=__,* --
.sf. .4g.'] 3 a- _T '-
- "2._**_is., -* **-'.
.. . 7. G w. .
. w. .. J u, .
C .". = _" _ ...a . . , n' "~^ .~ _4v- .C a # =,. "; a' -..._"
- - , a.# = .v. .=..A- -_' w = . . s _' . .~.
m r _4 , o . . s. 4 .. - _= c a_ #_ 4
- 2. .a _ 3 n' e re.= _' _= c a _ -
". 5. N. u c .'. =- = - S.a "- ' a - v,
. U... 'iu c _' =. .= _- c. a u .' .=. . .^ _ v Commission Commission Washing cn, D.C. 20555 Washington, D.C. 20555
..m . .. a.* *.
. .=.c c -y e _ , .Nf .- a ..~b e_# C".a_'
. _ .a.. , .4"u^.,m.4 c .C a_ # e .v a..c'
.g w p 4 . .ca .e s. _, f ,
-..A -
_4w-o . . 3 .4 . . ;
.4m - ..,. a. 4 , e, a-,y,,2.
y . 7 .a.,g2 - ..4 o .= . . , _1
=ca_w4
. "u . . . ' A'" C' s,.= -
. .O. c ':-". .' = *. ^, _-~/ ,
bCw. Ci ca
. v. 2.
L... 2 - ;, ,
. . a. .e. w- i . , ,.- o s ca,,..... ..4 s s 4 C..
u ,._4yo
.. -.a- 4-y c: .'.' .4 c. ."._4 ~y= . .
, N, a s .k.d .. c, ,. . , D.C. 20..:.:
an
. A wc ,.s1_4 -.._3-.. w4 ,
,. o.
-,09 Chairman, Atomic Safety . and 5_. c i e.r. c . m .4 : .w._ , .v.embe_-
?. 4 c e.. s.i ..c.
' ca-- -d
- _ =..a' --
a' * . . 4 . S a # = *'- -J a..d - -7 .'.c e ..s .4 .. ~, U.S. N',. . ,_' e a _ .'A e g " _1 = ". - _- "
Scard Cer:'. mis sion U.S. Nuclear Regulaccrv. Washincten, D.C. 20555 C ~.'.'r. _i m s i ..
Washington, D.C. 20555 Charles A. Barth, Esq.
Counsel for the NRC Staff Richard S. Sal man, Esq. Office of the Executive Legal c." a.d ...a4n , n' ". ^ ca #= .v, = ..d n.i_ec m.. _iw . - _-
Licensing A e. =eal 3 card U.S. Nuclear Rec.ulatorv U.S. Nuclear Regula:crv Cc= mission Ccamiss'cn Wasn..' ne., te n , D.C. 20:... a 00sa
..ashington, w D.u, . 4 William J. Moran, Esq.
Dr. Lawrence R. Guarles General Counsel
.4 , r_d- w . c a_"e *v. a_..d . =-..s u.. ~
4 C .4 ..c.d ..n. = - 4 -
vas = .".ar"__4c Appeal Scard -
Com-any e .
U.S. Nuclear Regulatcry Post Office Ecx 360 C ...m _4 s o- i .. C .4 .,. c _4 ...,. , _- 4 , C.w._4 c 2. .:,
4 0 .,
,a.as hington , - D . C . 20222
.v-..
a -
F..b._,a a. , O... O" h. a.n y h..a .,. a- _? e a %. . D. A'n v .q
_. 4 < , _T-ag .
.' c c .'< = "..
..;.- ...=._-,.=.3__=.~..".
=..4
.'. . . ._. - - .a v a_ _ __=n-m ea_ -
v_ _ _4nas. _.. ' . a. .c a. n. - s._, _ _. . . . s ,e - *34 C w_- ..a _3 _, o. _n _u w. n a
?.? . g . v.
- u . _7 s. _, _. .O ;. e. y ,. _? _,. __,A . y c _4.g 4 m _4 . ... .,_. _4 , s .k. _a . ,s_7r
- S_s n -
wwm ..._4 aa - _:. ..-
.qa m- y. 4 ..n ; .- ..
. , s.w. _onv3.. :: v'Ch. *. D. 'W C _T _* v e _ , =_ s~ g~ .
C_i e." o..*. C~u...v, c. ..- ..."m.~. _d v
. .v _4 _1 _7 _4 _2.,.. t. a _. , _. .J. s. _4 _ 2. , _. = g_ . Cno u.. _4 _7 na --s 4a- . _,.. . c v _4 .. _y _ av _1 _4 w~ _4 _ . m. _. OCX _i a i3_
a4 ~ m ,* , g h._: g *1 vum _ w.y..Si*
n _: w _4.w. _4 . ... _, __ _4 --.. _4 _, , . ,3 97.
_w -,
- c. _4 nC .4 . . ., u._ ,
ek s ._4 c J. .:707. . sav_4 A
- s. .v.a_. ._ _4 . , ;as.
A s s _' = ~ .= . . '. a' '. .e _ .. = v. e er. . = _. _= _1
.u._ s . .M.a_-v, ".~= d_ e _- *
.a.c. ._d .ne_ D4_e . - _ _
B o x _,< v~ D. _4 ./ _4s _4 o n o _=_.; .,,,_4 _. . ....a . . _, _,
m- , .a.
o^
-~u - e ' . O_##_4c=
_ c_3 n' +--- -- .. =. .v "a e - = _ ' ' -
,,noe ,
n v _, ,_ _4 __ _- . ._a _, , .s ., . . . . , -
2 _ss .09 de. C_,_,_:_ m. _.. ...
u
.e_._..,e_._.,
...g - - -.
s , n . ._,
. c .'< v. ,' u' c' G i
-; , =
. .-_-a.a . . a. . .. . _4n. = w . , =. a g .
m_
n..-v_..., , y _2._ . . .a
__ o.c ~^ a. - - n' . ~.
. ~ .~. e e
, 0 0 .v.a _4 .. - : .- = =. . "_-e secu"4.- =
3 2. . . . - . = .v 2
--._ , _ , v _4 _2 , m.._- -w: . ,.:._es n, C _' a___.c.n . vot ..'."; , u .k. _i . ^
_1a ,. .u.-_4 , -
. C _. _. c. a. _
Batavia, Chio 45103
- $ ---f
.u.atst J . n e _. . _., ... .. ., .
s
. _.