Text

Tube Burst & Leakage Testing of Intergranular Attack & IGSCC Defects Representative of Those Found in St Lucie Unit One Steam Generators
	ML20238F259
Person / Time
Site:	Saint Lucie
Issue date:	08/31/1986
From:	Frisk R, Heilker W, Walker M; ABB COMBUSTION ENGINEERING NUCLEAR FUEL (FORMERLY
To:	;
Shared Package
ML17221A393	List: ML20238F259;
References
	CENC-1740, NUDOCS 8709160046
	Download: ML20238F259 (110)
	v • d • e

--

i TUBE BURST AND LEAKAGE TESTING OF IGA.AND IGSCC DEFECTS REPRESENTATIVE OF THOSE FOUND IN THE ST. LUCIE, UNIT ONE STEAM GENERATORS CENC-1740 l

BY COMBUSTION ENGINEERING, INC.

W. J. HEILKER R. S. FRISK M. J. WALKER , .

J. F. HALL AUGUST 1986 1

O B709160046 870910 PDR ADOCK 05000335 P PDR

\.

(c TABLE OF CONTENTS l

Page l-

1. INTRODUCTION ........................................ ~1

! '2.

SUMMARY

AND' CONCLUSIONS .............................

! 2

.3. DESCRIPTION OF DAMAGE ............................... 3

4. TEST VESSEL AND TEST PROCEDURE ...................... 4

5. TUBE LEAK TESTING OF IGSCC DEFECTS .................. 7 6.. TUBE BURST TESTING OF IGA DEFECTS.................... 16

7. COMPARISON OF TEST RESULTS WITH PREVIOUS TESTING PERFORMED BY CE AND OTHERS .......................... 20

8. COMPARISON OF TEST RESULTS WITH REGULATORY GUIDE 1.121 ACCEPTANCE CRITERIA ..................... 23 r 9. REFERENCES .......................................... <

APPENDIX A: PREPARATION OF LEAK RATE / BURST PRESSURE TUBE SAMPLES AND. POST TEST EXAMINATION ..... A-1 1

f

~I i

r -

!- 1. INTRODUCTION l

l During the fall 1985 St. Lucie 1 outage, FP&L removed sections j of three tubes from the hot leg of SG. A. Numerous tubes in d.

both steam generators had small volume defect indications l above the tuesheet and at eggcrate locations and. either. dis-torted support signals (DSS) at eggcrate locations or unde-fined signals above the tubesheet. Results of the destructive examination indicated that small volume defects, initially .

presumed to be pits o were either areas of intergranular attack (IGA) or intergranular/transgranular cracks.

Corr.bustion Engineering was contracted by Florida Power andt Light to make and test a series.of' corrosion samples contain-ing induced defects (intergranular attack (IGA) and intergranular stress corrosion cracking (IGSCC)). The defects produced were of types observed in recent steam generator' tube examinations. Defect depth covered variations frcm detectable to throughwall (IGSCC Cracks). '

It was the objective of'this test program, to demonstrate that the flaws found in the St.'Lucie, Unit One Cteam Generators did not pose a safety risk, where a safety risk was defined as

' a strong potential for a large tube leak. In this context, a tube with a high safety margin against bursting due to differ-ential pressure loading is considered safe. Also, a tube which begins leaking at a small rate with gradually increasing leakage is considered safe, although certainly not desirable (i.e., " leak before break").

k$

i 1

i f'

i?

l. p -

2.

SUMMARY

AND CONCLUSIONS 1

Based onH the results of this Burst and Leakage Test Program, ;

significant safety margins exist and have previously existed i for" tube defects found in the St. Lucie 1 steam generators. 1 In Nhe case of IGA deftets, tubes with in excess of 60%

through wall attack have safety margins of greater than three with respect to burst pressure. Specifically, tube sample 14 j (360, circumferential attack), which had 63% through wall i attack, burst at 5550 psi. Three tinies the normal-operating

' differential pressure of 1435 psi is 4305 psi.

In the case of IGsCC defects, a tube will begin leaking gradu-ally at a length considerably shorter than one inch, if not.

, previously detected by ECT examination. As the crack length

c increases, the leak rate will be detectable and the unit can be safely s' nut down, when the tech. spec. leakage limit is

. reached or sooner at Florida P&L's discretion. )

r l

i

/

l l

l

~

r

3. DESCRIPTION OF DAMAGE Based on destructive examination of the three tube segments removed from one of the steam generators, the findings were as follows.

3.1 Tube 120/12 Tube 120/12 defect indications approximately 1.3 inches above the tubesheet were axially oriented crack-like defects which were present over about one inch of tube and extended over about one-half of the circumference.

The individual cracks had an axial length of about one-half inch, were 25-30% throughwall, had multiple branches, and were primarily intergranular. However, the cracks also had limited transgranular components. There was essentially no volumetric IGA and there were no pits present at this location. It was further determined that the defects producing the 82% indication at the #2 eggerate in tube 120/12 were straight deep axially ori-ented cracks with little or no branching. The maximum depth measured to date by destructive metallography is 72% which agrees reasonably well with the ECT indication.

, All cracks originate on the OD at tube contact points.

, 3. 2 Tube 79/91 The undefined signal (UDS) 1.4 inches about the tubesheet in tube 79/91 proved to be intergranular attack. Analy-sis by an 8X1 probe indicated 50% throughwall IGA. The 57% indication 4.4 inches above the tubesheet was also IGA. Destructive metallography, still in progress, has determined a maximum depth of 42% for the IGA which has .

an axial extent of about one inch.

3.3 Tube 59/95 The examination has also confirmed that the DSS at the #1 eggerate of tube 59/95 was a defect. The defect appeared to be series of cracks originating from patches of shal-low IGA. Although this sample has not been etched, the crack paths suggest at least some transgranular cracking.

The shallow IGA from which the cracks originated were located at tube contact points. The deposits / corrosion products in the cracks / IGA were relatively thick.

Based on the above findings, a test program which provid-ed burst data on simulated IGA defects and leakage data on simulated IGSCC defects was deemed appropriate.

/

'4. TEST VESSEL AND TEST PROCEDURE When tube defects are found, the. only obviously conservative basis for establishing a plugging criteria is to assume uni -

form tube wall thinning at the maximum defect depth determined by ECT. This approach can lead to the plugging of 40%

throughwall defects, when a 10% operating allowance is sub-tracted from the ASME Code Section XI recommended value of 50%

throughwall.- This purely analytical approach is often overly conservative, since some types of defects are much less-likely-to rupture than uniform wall . thinning. In addition, . since

.some. crack-like defects are difficult to detect by ECT, it is' .

desirable to demonstrate a " leak before break" . probability.

Burst.and leakage testing of simulated defects can lead to more realistic tube plugging criteria.

4.1 Test Vessel In the test vessel shown in Figure O'.1, CE has leak and burst tested various types of defects, including fret-ting, pitting, This wastage, and various types of cracking.

test facility can test tube . defects under prototypical temperature, pressure and flow conditions

including burst. testing a tube which is leaking at great-er than planc . tech. spec. allowables for ten or - more ;

minutes. Since the loop was specifically designed for l l

tube' leakage and burst testing, sample change out is rapid . and- pressure, temperature and leak . rate data is recorded and displayed continuously via computer.

4.2 Test Procedure for Samples with IGSCC Defects a.

Install specimen in test vessol.

b. Heat and pressurized to " normal operating" condi-tions, i.e., 0 T = 560 F, Py = 2250 psi, P; = 815 psi.

c. Hold conditions and measure leak rate, if any, for 10 1 g minutes while plotting data.

E

d. Simulate a " Main Steam Line Break" accident by de-creasing vessel pressure, P = 650 psi, and/or 2

i l

(, i i

l t

l increasing specimen pressure, P = 2250 psi, P =

1 1600 psi.*

e. Repeat Step C.

f. Return to " Normal Operating" conditions.

g. Repeat Step C.

h. Shutdown Test vessel.

4.3 Test Procedure for IGA Type Tube Defects

a. Install specimen in test vessel,

b. Pressurize specimen with hand pump until rupture occurs. For a single selected specimen:

c. Run a leak test for " Normal Operating" conditions, per Test Plan 4.2, in the case of small tube rup-tures.

Note: In the case of Tube Sample 1 (Section 5.) the test was run as planned. In the case of Tube Sample 2 (Section 5. ) , the significant leak rate from the primary side caused the seccadary pressure to increare and the differential pressure only reached 1476 psi instead of 1600 psi. This effect could have been mitigated, but was not observed while the test was in progress. In the case of Tube Sample 3, the high rate of leakage prevented any increase in differential ;

pressure. '

~

r, h

SCHEfA ATIC of: C E /EP f:4.I TU EEE SURST

_ AMO LEAK,R. ATE _

"T" E S T 7:"AC I L.I T'Y TO CO U C EMSEE.R h !

O t

_M:

~ ~ v--- - -

TEST ;

MODEL f f

PRESSURE LTL T A AMS DUCER

\n TVEE priT n u s , i

-ruea 0 SPECIMEM s:E 3 I; ;

Jr il I i

H i- + 3, i

=:- -, 3)

(, UL i

O Q 'M O '

4 L g

k HokJEO M FLOW ORIFICE PLATE [ 7e rasy i

Loop HEACER

- H E A C E R.

-+-O V FROM TEST' LOOP NEADER ;

FIGURE 0.1 u___ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _

a y

f ~

5. TUBE LEAF. TESTING DF IGSCC DEFECTS-A total of six defected - tubes were ' tested, with axial IGSCC cracks ranging-in size from.0.619 inches in' length to 1.702.

inches in length at the tube O.D. surface. The defected sam-ples . exhibited two types. of behavior. . Those: with cracks of

.1.O inches in- length or shorter : leaked in' a stable. manner, with leak rates ranging-from less than 0.08 GPM to 7.97 GPM at the St. .Lucie, Unit.One normal operating differential pressure across thel tube wall of 1435' psi.

The" tube samples with cracks of longer than 1.0 inches all leaked at rates in- excess of 20 GPM'which is the upper leak measuring limit of the test apparatus. These results are decidedly favorable.

What~ the results demonstrate are that a tube . subjected to IGSCC will begin. leaking gradually at. a length considerably shorter than one. inch if not.previously detected by ECT exami-nation. -As the crack length increases, the leak rate will be.

detectable and the unit . can be sately shutdown to plug the-leaking tube,~either.when:it.is initially detected or when'the

. tech. spec. leakage limit is reached.

(~ .

The cracked tubes which leaked'in excess of 20 GPM will not be obtained in the St.'Lucie, Unit One Steam Generators, because they will be removed from service due to unacceptable 'yet small leakage well before they grow longer than one inch.. "

Note that Samples one and two in Table 'I were resistant to pressure spikes causing significantly greater leakage. Sample three was inadvertently not tested for a pressure spike (see

.Section 4 for an explanation). .

l l

r

? . . .

l

oy g 2 F F ir i ( (

_ tt F .

_ pe ( g k k

_ i m i c c

_ ro k k F a a

_ ce c c ( r r

_ sG a a C C

_ e r r k k

_ Dt C C c c s s c a a u u l e s s r r o o af u u C C u u ce o o n n i D u u s s i i s n n u u t t yf i i o o n n

_ h o t t u u o o

_ P n n n n C C

_ o o i i - -

c c t t i i s s n n m m i i o o e e D D C C S S

)

T P FI 4 6 S A AS 2 7 - - - -

E P 6 4 T m ( 1 1 u

E m G i )

A sxk eM 8 4 K eaatP 0 4 A tMeaG - - - -

E a LR( 2 L S R T

E C k)

B E a5 U F e3 )

T E L4 I 1 7 5 A A A D 1 PS 3 0 3 / / /

R d( AP 4 4 4 N N N O E e ( 1 1 1 T B t r

% A U se ep R T E TO )

N E k eM 8 5 7 E P . atP 0 3 9 0 0 0 G Y meaG 2 2 2 T rLR( < 1 7 > > >

M o '

A C N E C T S S G .

I e 1 rkh) 4 7 7 3 0 7 uct . 2 8 9 3 3 8 E sad n 0 0 1 4 3 7 I ariI 0 0 0 0 0 0 C eCW(

U M L

) 4 2 8 5 8 0

. . . 6 6 7 7 0 9 T n 1 6 7 9 5 0 S ta D.I d 1( 0 0 0 0 1 1 e

r u ) 9 8 0 5 2 2 s . . 1 5 1 5 9 0 n

s a t 0(

h ea tM D.I 6 0

8 0

0 1

3 1

5 1

7 1

g n

e L

. "6 k l v) "6 "6 " 1 c ar . "6 1 1 2 /

a uen "8 1 / / / 1 r ssI / / 1 3 1 1 C ib( 3 5 - - - -

VO 1 1 1 1 1 l

akh) " "

nct . " " 4 2 "8 i agn 2 " 4 / / /

mrnI / 1 / 3 1 5

' oCe( 1 3 - - -

N L 1 1 1 o 1 2 3 4 5 6 N

8 o c .

i

. R

d. ~,

e

+ -

na

+ ..

FIGURE 1 IGSCC SAMPLE NO. 1 - DISCONTINUOUS CRACK ACTUAL LENGTH: AT O.D. - 0.619 IN., AT I.D. - 0.164 IN.

A e 5 . .

/-

a 5

+

p \

s %

W

, o ,

(

FIGURE 2 IGSCC SAMPLE NO. 3 - CONTINUOUS CRACK l ACTUAL LENGTH: AT O.D. - 1.010 IN., AT I.D. - 0.778 IN.

g. .

iy #

1 1 x*

, /

FIGURE 3 IGSCC SAMPLE NO. 5 - SEMI-CONTINUOUS CRACK ACTUAL LENGTH: AT O.D. - 1.592 IN., AT I.D. - 1.508 IN. )

4

)

.i 4

\._ .

g .

f s A .

A FIGURE 4 '

l IGSCC SAMPLE NO. 6 - SEMI-CONTINUOUS CRACK ACTUAL LENGTH: AT O.D. - 1.702 IN., AT I.D. - 1.090 IN.

10 -

f r.

THREE OBSERVED IGSCC CRACK GEOMETRIES C d FC 3

% ~.Y (1) CONTINUOUS (2) SEMI-CONTINUOUS CRACKS (3) DISCONTINUOUS CRACKS CRACKS FIGURE 5

(1) .

A crack with a single initiation site which is propagating along the length of the tube.

(2) A single crack formed by the joining of two or more shorter cracks which initiated separately.

(3) Two or more parallel craens separated by .a ligament of sufficient from linking.

strength to prevent the separately initiated cracks

/ d.

l. _ _ - - - - - - _ - - -

T -

H -

G -

d d

I -

L -

E [

s

- R .

~

U . '

D - .

S -

E '

N -

S E .. R U

A -

R -

S '

P .1 S d R E E d N .

R T E

E .-

P A s)

W - M -

R '

- I .t. L O - C .

E K P - E .-

D A '

- P t O E

- S '

M L

~

A -

~

d(

D -

d I - :E R - 4M O -

% L -

. F -

~

R -

d O - d F -

2

~

S -

~

T -

S -

~

E -

~

d T -

d

...;'...T . ;..' . .' ..._. ' . . . 2 . d E 0 0

0 6

0 2

0 0

T . . .

8 4 0 A 2 i 1 . . .

R 2n.$ -

w F4 w y<W I_.

..;.24a: - l .;. ,:. . ,- . s. .

K A

E . -

L . .

_ .. . : .,: .';..~ .. ... -

_..2 .

0 0 0 0 .

0 0 0 0 0 0 0

. 0 4 8 2 0 0

_ 3 2 1 1 6 .

< H @- WcammWxQ .

N, l

. 5 T -

H - -

6 G -

r.

6 I -

i t

i ._

L - T E 6 4

.S.UR ~-

D -

- i e - E '

N - u S E _

R U

A - i t

r .R S '

T .P S 6 R E E 6

- 1 t N R T :

E -

ME.M P A 6)

W -

t R '

- i. I L '

O -

.C E K ' T P -

s s

.E P

D O

A E

~

U

- .S M L ~

A -

6(

D -

6 I - :E R -

4M I

O -

\ L -

F -

R -

- - 6 O - - 6 F -

2 S -

T -

S -

E

~

6 T <

6

... .~ . ...~ . .d- . . : - .. ' ..2 .. : . - . . . - 6 E 0 0

0 0

T 0 0 . . . .

0 A 1 8 6 4 2 .

R ro.E gF4E x<WJ .

3 .;. . > . 3 .. a ;. ; l . ,.a ,.;~ .,..:. .

K .J a :2a.- .

A E . -

4 L ~ .

t

. . e. i r c :n. .'

i

...T . . : - . : ...2 ... -} ..3 0 0 0 0 .

0 0

0 3

0 4

2 0

8 1

0 2

1 0

0 6

0 0

< s [- r WtamnmEQ t t

,,.,* ;I ;...'.,:..' .:, .- .

\ :T ..-

0

__ 1

~

T -

H -

G -

=. _

d d

I -

L E -

8

u. R - '

_ ,. . U '

_ D -

E '

M N

S-

_ - a S R '

P E U '

S A -

t

- . R S '

r_

P S 6 P R : . E E 6 a4

N R T: M 4 E

= . E .

P A 6) M U .

N - . M R ' S I 2

I O

L E X

- C E K ' T A

M P - E P

D A ' U E O E N ) T S C

- M L ' I C A A

- S R d (M G

D -

d I

( K I - E A R 4M 2 E O

~ '

' T I

NL E E

\ L M F

m ~

I G C R E E A

R -

- d P V O - _ d l

S A F -

a S -

T -

S -

E - _

~

d T -

y ... .

d

.._.. : .: . .. - .. . . .~- .. -

..d E 0 o .

0 0 0 0 T . .

0 0 0 0 0 0 0 A 5 4 3 2 1 .

R

-1a.9 mF4a x4mJ -

a.3. . ;a : , ..; :a K . .. _.la

. .3 ." .;

. . . ] .

A E

L . . .

7... ::...:.:....:....- .: .

. - lJ 0

0 0 0 .

0

_ 0 0 0 0 0 0

_ , 0 4 8 2 0 0 3 2 1 1 6 .

< m 2_ wrammWtDr.

t

- A'

,! l

- 0 1

T -

H -

G -

_0 I -

,0 .

L -

T .

. E 8

- R .

. _ U .

D -

r e

a

. S E .

N - !

r .

S E

R .

A -

1

_. U .

H _ R S - .

T _ P S 0 R - i

_ N E E R T 0

E -

a. E P A 6)

W -

L. .

M I

- L R .

O -

C E K P - i .

i .

E P

D A .

O E

- J S_ M L A -

D -

- d(

d I - ,.E R - _- 4M O - -

. I L -

. F -

R -

0 O -

- 0 F -

2 S -

T -

S -

E -

T .

d d

- . - ~ : ,.: ...;..:..- .... . . . _.:. - 6 E O 0 0 0 0 0 T

0 0 0

0 0 0 0 A 5 4 3 2 1 .

R 1Q$ gF<E 24Wi 1 :.

]i~ ~ 3 a j , : . ;. :.. , .

K . " ] .

. . .,.1,',..

. . :. 3 ..* :

A E

L .

. . _.. .ri.- .'.'

~

- . .. . . - - : ,.: ...: ..: ..;.....2 ..,. .

2 0 0 0 0 .

0 0

A 0

6 0

2 0

0 0

0 3 2 1 1 6

< H @- WE3mmWEa.

, ,m ,

r ~

6. TUBE BURST TESTING OF IGA DEFECTS A total of 14 defected tubes were tested, with general IGA attack extending over a region apgroximgtely ong inch along the axis of the tube by either 90 , 180 or 350 around the circumference of the tube. The samples with a greater circum-

forential extend had marginally lower burst pressures, since

! they more nearly approximated uniform tube thinning. Due to l

the realistic follow through type loading provided by the test facility, at the time of tube rupture, the failed tubes tended to develop large break openings. Appendix A contains photo-graphs of the failed tubes. Seven of the fourteen samples, ranging in depth of attack from 13% to 42% of tube wall, did not fail when pressurized to between 8000 psi and 9600 psi.

All of the tube samples which failed are plotted on Figure 10.

Lower bound values of some of the samples which did not fail are also plotted. For purposes of comparison previous CE tube burst data is also plotted for various types of defects. The figure also contains a theoretical burst pressure line based on actual tube physical properties (yield strength and ulti-mate strength) at temperature, for a uniformly thinned tube.

The distance that the burst sample data point lies above the

theoretical line, represents the amount of reinforcement pro-vided by the unaffected sound tube material. It is apparent that some types of defects receive more reinforcement than others.

It can be observed that the St. Lucie .1 IGA tube samples per-formed better than the Palisades IGA tube samples. This was dueg in part to the Palisades defect configuration, which was 360 circumferential1y and two inches in axial length. Note that the current burst pressure data supports the position -

that tube IGA defects in excess of 60% through wall can with-stand differential pressure greater than three times the oper-ating differential pressure.

t

l ST. LUCIE 1 STEAM GENERATOR TUBE BURST TEST IGA TYPE TUBE DEFECTS '

Circumferential Depth of Attack Burst Sample Extent of Attack Target Measur. Pressure No. (Dearees) (% Wall) (% Wall) (PSI) Coments on Test 1 90 15 18 >9600 Did Not Rupture 0 i 2 90 35 20 >8500 Did Not Rupture 3 90 45 69 6600 See Appendix A, Figure 5 i l

4 90 50 40 >8000 Did Not Rupture 1 0

5 90 65 74 3500 See Appendix A, Figure 9 6 90 85 78 4650 See Appendix A, Figure 11 ;

7 180 20 13 >8500 Did Not Rupture 0

8 180 Did Not Rupture

} 40 42 >8000 <

0 9 180 50 63 6650 See Appendix A, Figure 17 0 '

10 180 90 75 3450 See Appendix A, Figure 19 l 11 360" 25 32 >8500 Did Not Rupture 12 360' 40 17 >8500 Did Not Rupture )

13 360 50 58 5900 See Appendix A, Figure 25 14 360 70 63 5550 See Appendix A, Figure 27 I

l TABLE 2 I l

l l' .

i

D E

N b G

I O e L

A EGE 9

/ g h G 3 ,

S&

GA AT Z g bSAG TSA f O AWI E g N

I RATLnR I

GW N .uM c I

GRTI cC L PUU u EI LI I VWPEcC S

/

T.

6 2 Wm4 -

8O OAOQOE 3

Q g@

Y A E T K A

D.

T C

e e...,

E 8 T

S F

E D

o 8 E

T T g S T 4A #_

0 S 0 g a. D E 1 1 H E T E I_-

B CH L L R E NC E A L I

U G 0 f_

B IN 5

I N N

M I F 0 C u

U 78 A E_ 0 T 0 00 0 5 0 I_ 8

0 6

00, O [ 0 L =

D. = )

04 ,

E M 1 N . R + 2 EL ODg OG n BL C FN g UA TW N

I g T NN S

II ep3 V

I R UN U C

Y L I R A UR H BO 0 2 Tu T I T I E R E F L ~+:b =

M E CE L ~c O T NR C D n E A EU A RS W F :

G M E ESE FEB 2:

RE ERU b HW RPT F 92 0 .

(

D -

1 0

1 e " -

4 _

nM5 a0yw H@g

.E.

7. COMPARISON OF TEST RESULTS WITH PREVIOUS TESTING PERFORMED BY CE AND OTHERS As was discussed in Section 6, the simulated St. Lucie 1 !GA

( samples performed more favorably than previously tested simu-lated palisades IGA samples, which werg chemically attacked over an area 2 inches in length and 360 about the circumfer-ence. Thus the St. Lucie 1 samples were gaining some support fr?.p., adjacent sound material. However, IGA attack over any significant surface area produces defects that perform less favorably than wastage, pitting or wear induced defects, with respect to burst pressure. Figure 10 illustrates this conclu-sion. It would appear that as the IGA surface area increases, burst pressure performance approaches that for uniform wall thinning.

l Other testing, funded by the Nuclear Regulatory Commission, and tested by Battelle Northwest Laboratories is presented in Figures 11 and 12, for purposes of comparison (see References 9.5 and 9.6). From this data it would appear that 1.5 inch axial EDM slots (simulated cracks) ~ perform approximately the same as uniform wall thinning. Both types of defects per-formed, with respect to burst pressure, in a comparable manner

, to the St. Lucie 1 steam generator IGA samples.

S e

Based on work carried out on NRC/RSR program "PWR Steam Generator Tube Integrity Program", NRC Contract Number B2097 for the Metallurgy and Materials Research Branch, Dr. Joseph Muscara, Program Manager.

by -

MILTON VAGINS o

C e-O ,,, o c ;

0 4 I

C e O

m_

j a e 4 33 <

~

(

2

. 9 00 O H <

<f3 4 oO m< c cl: ' '

C' C O W m H _

Vo h Hppo O o w aco a ?n E

a a g j M

g.

C o o*

Q og

@MM' 4N' x f zss-Dere eg

< J Q ~

W oca< N O 2 LD -

f e

C.

g c'C I - I c

. t , , ,

C C h m v m N r o f b CO (IS')l) 380 SS3 kid .l.S8 08 r

L" %" 8 ,8" E A 5 Of= %RnM ng!5

" =2n m $"

E%* ;m 7 ASS ~ gr y qK" =5i- 0l8" 0, g* !S,8~ 3g s

E %3Sm ~ 5@

FEEE E=E.o* &=e* gE4?

a

,e g gE %-

, 2Wd= <E g"

%% %t a H H G o3 TiH T l N O d 9 6g GTT G I 9 NGGN I

N ENN EL LEE N D LLD I I

EDD E H D NEEN E

T TNNNN Cl NNl l

l I

M il I E TiH T F

l i

R E" TT" O o F D 16"84 " /2 I F O # N /// 1 I

U3331 N

U 0o09a i 0

5 0 l x - -

5 h- -

0 9 7 g <

7 1 6 4 3 2 1 0 8 . n

^ uMammt E s m c l

i c -lg im*

- i

7 r

i Ct

~

r,

8. COMPARISON OF TEST RESULTS WITH REGULATORY GUIDE 1.121 ACCEP-

- TANCE CRITERIA e U.S. NRC Regulatory Guide 1.121 requires satisfaction of each -

of several criteria in establishing a maximum allowable degra-dation before tube plugging is mandated. Those criteria are as follows:

(1) Tubes'with cracks should not be stressed beyond the elas-tic range during normal operation.

(2) Defected Tubes should have a factor of safety against bursting of three during normal operation.

(3) Any increase in the ' primary to secondary leakage rate should be gradual to provide time for action.

(4) The safety margin against postulated accidents, such as LOCA, MSLB, and FWLB, should' be consistent with the ASME code allowables-(normally 0.7 S I*

u Based on this test program, criteria (1) and (2) have both

' been met as discussed in Section 6. Also based on the work reported in Chapter 5, criteria (3) has been satisfied. -

Item (4)~ is generally not controlling, but proper analyses must be completed before a tech-spec. change request can be submitted to the NRC as the basis for increased allowable tube degradation. The analyses include LOCA, MSLB and FWLB evalua-tion.

F

/

l' i

k e

9. REFERENCES 9.1 Meeting, between Florida Power and Light and Combustion Engineering, on August 5, 1986, in Miami, Florida, to discuss St. Lucie, Unit Une Steam Generator Longevity.

! 9.2 Letter, C. O. Woody (Florida P&L) to A. C. Thadani (NRC)

L-86-263, dated June 25, 1986, " Supplement to Florida P&L Letter L-86-259, dated June 17, 1986."

9. 3, U.S. NRC Regulatory Guide 1.121, " Bases for Plugging Degraded PWR Steam Generator Tubes," August 1976.

9.4 ASME Boiler and Pressure Vessel Code,Section III for Nuclear Power Plant Components, Subsection NB for Class 1 Components, 1983 Edition.

9.5 NUREG-0359, Steam Generator Tube Integrity Program.

Quarterly Report January 1 -

March 31, 1977, Battelle Pacific Northwest Labs for U.S. NRC.

9.6 Steam Generator Tube Burst and Collapse Predictions by Milton Vagins, Presented at the Sixth Water Reactor Safe-ty Research Information Meeting Held at National Bureau of Standards, Gaithersburg, Mr. yland, November 6-9, 1978 (Based on Work performed per Reference 9.5).

/

l .i l

l

~

r

~

APPENDIX A Preparation of Leak Rate / Burst Pressure Tube Samples and Post Test Examination.

FLORIDA PCWER AND LIGHT ST. LUCIE, UNIT ONE STEAM GENERATORS JULY 1986 R. S. FRISK COMBUSTION ENGINEERING,.INC.

1000 PROSPECT HILL ROAD e

WINDSOK, CONNECTICUT 06095 l

_m._.________.________ _ _ _

1 l

.SECTION 1 INTRODUCTION This Appendix describes procedures for reproducing tube sampics containing chemical Intergranular Attack (IGA) and Intergranular

.. Stress Corrosion Cracking (IGSCC). Also included in this appen--

dix, is a post test metallographic examination, used to determine geometry and/or depth of the various induced defects.

e 9

I A-1

.q J

l

1

. =

Section 2.0 MATERIAL .

1 Nuclear grade Alloy 600 steam generator tubing meeting both the chemical' and mechanical requirements of ASME Specification SB163-80 were used in- the preparation of the defect. standards. The tubing ' was procured in the mill annealed condition, but to facilitate defect initiation, was sensitized by heating for four hours at 1200*F. i Subsequent to sensitization, all material was cleaned with '600 ' grit paper, followed by.a water rinse and then an acetone rinse before defect production.

s 9

i' A-2 b _ _ _ _ .

.f i

- r Section 3.0 PROCEDURES 3.1 Production of Burst Test Samples with Intergranular Attack Defects 3.1.1 Method for Inducing Intergranular Attack. I IGA .satples were made by masking ail' but the desired areas with. heat shrinkable . tape and paraffin and then exposing the tubes to a saturated sulfurous acid solution. The progression of the IGA through the' wall thickness was monitored by eddy current testing. When the desired depth of intergranular attack was reached, the specimens were removed from the test vessel and immersed in lithium hydroxide solution to neutralize the sulfurous C acid.

3.1.2 Specimen Design Test specimens were designed and fabricated to provide defect standards with well defined defect areas of specified size and geometry. Each straight ,,

length of tubing had one distinct IGA band. Outside diametral intergranular attack was induced in one inch wide bands of varying circumferential extent.

The objective was to produce three sets of IGA samples; one set with a 90 defect arc and varying throughwall defects, the second set with a 180* defect arc and varying throughwall defects and the last set with a 360* arc and varying throughwall defects. Each set of IGA samples had defect depths ranging from 13-18% to 63-78% through the wall.

l

[ , A-3

L

'~

3.1.1 Environment to Induce IGA I

Tube segments were placed in a closed vessel and immersed at room temperature in a saturated sulfurous acid solution, i.e. stock solution of 6% S0 2 I" water.- The saturation of the solution was maintained by continuously bubbling sulfur dioxide through the solution.

3.1.4 Specimen Identification Alloy 600 specimens with IGA defects were given the numerical designations IGA 1-14. A list of the specimens together with the corresponding defect depth documentation are given in Table 1 and Figures 1 through 28.

3.1.5 Burst Testing o

Each sample was internally pressurized to determine its burst pressure. Seven of the fourteen IGA samples failed during burst testing. The remaining

' samples expanded in the defected region. The samples that failed durir.g testing are identified in Table 1. The samples that did not fail during burst testing and their corresponding degree of expansion due to testing are listed in Table 2.

3.1.6 Metallographic Examination of Failed Burst Samples ,

IGA burst samples that failed during testing were sectioned naar the fracture surface and that surface was examined using a scanning electron microscope.

IGA was determined by observing the visual difference between the ductile tear region and the individual grains within the IGA region. The defect depth was then determined by measuring the depth of the IGA region and comparing the results to the original wall thickness.

t A-4

L

[

c b i 1

3.1.7 Meta 11ographic Examination of Burst Samples that did not Fail During Testing ]

IGA burst samples that did not fail during testing were cross sectioned in the defect region, metallographically mounted, polished and examined. The defected surface was then etched with orthophosphoric acid prior to photography to enhance the'. IGA defects. A measurement of the deepest defect was made and compared with the thickness of the wall to determine the depth of IGA.

3.2 Method for Inducing IGSCC The IGSCC samples were made by masking the tube with heat shrinkable plastic tubing, cutting out the desired geometry and exposing the tubes to 0.1 Molar sodium tetrathionate at 32*C. The tubes were internally pressurized to provide stress for crack initiation. Stress was maintaund until throughwall defects were present. Upon completion of the exposure to the sodium tetrathionate, the specimens were immersed in lithium hydroxide solution for

' neutralization.

3.2.2 Specimen Design Intergranular stress corrosion cracking (IGSCC) test specimens were designed and fabricated to provide samples with crack defect (s) of specified length in .

the axial direction that originated on the OD and propagated through the wall.

A total of 6 defects were made as indicated.

3.2.4 Environment to Induce IGSCC The designated crack area on the OD surface was exposed to a 0.1 M sodium tetrathionate solution maintained at 32*C. Tubes were internally pressurized to provide the mechanical stress necessary to induce cracking in this environment.

t A-5

F 3.2.5 Specimen Identification Alloy 600 specimens with IGSCC defects were given the designations IGSCC 1 through 6.- A list of the specimens 'with corresponding defects are given'in Table 3.

3.2.6 Meta 11ographic Examination All IGSCC specimens were sectioned for metallographic examination. The internal and external crack lengths were measured and correlated with the leak rates produced by each sample. The metallographic- r'esults are shown in Table 3.

r

/

I A-6

_ = _ - _ _ - _

1 L l

r ;

1 Table 1 1

I IGA DEFECT DEPTH l Circumferential Extent Defect Burst l Sample # (Degrees & % Circum.) Depth Test Results

(%)

1 90' - 25% 18 -

2 90 - 25% 20 -

3 90' - 25% 69 Ruptured 4 90' - 25% 40 -

5- 90' - 25% 74- Ruptured'

/ 6 90' - 25% 78 Ruptured 7 180* - 50% 13 -

8 180* - 50% 42 -

9 180' - 50% 63 Ruptured 10 180* - 50% 75 Ruptured ,

11 360' - 100% 32 -

12 360' - 100% 17 -

13 360' - 100% 58 Ruptured 14 360' - 100% 63 Ruptured

(

A-7

i Table 2 EXPANDED TUBING MEASUREftENTS DUE TO BURST TESTING Defect Circumferential Nominal Maximum Sample # Extent 0.D.(In.) Bulge 0.D.(In.)

1 90 - 25% 0.750 0.796 2 90' - 25% 0.750 0.783 4 90' - 25% 0.750 0.785 7 180 - 50% 0.750 0.815 8 180' - 50% 0.750 0.812 11 360' - 100% 0.750 0.808 12 360* - 100% 0.750 0.830 t

f A-8

-___m_._____.._ 2 _ _ _ _ _

. l

. 1

" 1 Table 3

]

FP&L IGSCC BURST TEST CRACK MEASUREMENTS Sample C-E Windsor Length Length !

I.D. 0.0. I.D. Crack Width Comments l 1 1/2" IGSCC 0.619 0.164 ,0024 Discontinuous crack 2 1" IGSCC 0.858 0.662 .0087 Discontinuous crack 3 3/4" IGSCC 1.010 0.778 .0197 Continuous Crack 4 1 3/4" IGSCC 1.355 0.975 .0433 Continuous Crack 5 1 1/2" IGSCC 1.592 1.508 .033 Semi-Continuous ~ Crack 6 'l 5/8" IGSCC 1.702 1.090 .0787 Semi-Continuous Crack i

/

i e

/

A-9 .

I

- - _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ 1

SAMPLE 1 !

IGA - 25 % CIRC. EXT.

i Neg. #77135 Figure 1: Post Test Photograph of Sample #1 l

..g......

(orthophosphoric acid etch)

Figure 2: Photomicrograph Depicting Depth of IGA in Sample #1 A-10

i f

1 1

SAMPLE 2 IG A - 25 % CIRC. EXT. l

'l 1

Neg. #77134 1 Figure 3: Post Test Photograph of Sample #2 a- : .

'. .l ;,.

(orthophosphoric acid etch)

Figure 4: Photomicrograph Depicting Depth of IGA in Sample #2 A-11

i l

l I

SAMPLE 3 l IGA - 25 % CIRC. EXT. i Neg. #77137 Figure 5: Post Test Photograph of Sample #3 >

I 9 tr ..

3 N.smsg I Wq g- w.

34

. , 3 , , :* ' ,f 3 -: -

h ll,', . .

it p , i: 1 ,

3. .:j ,'; '., + ;)3,f - . a

)O,, p. . c ; .

F.f,A . -

g,,

. ,) e r

'b ,-

/.

/i a i .., ,gp}x

% -lf .

{ ' ;, !' k]l, . f ', <

h}

e<y p, tag.. 7 g,

'f'.;b:,

k b, 'h .k '

04 3 z; gk ; . <f hf.'..? ..,b MDW D@ @

50X Neg. # 77167 Figure 6: Photomicrograph Depicting Depth of IGA in Sample #3 A-12

l SAMPLE 4 IGA - 25 % CIRC. EXT.

Neg. #77136 Figure 7: Post Test Photograph of Sample #4 I

4. -# ,.

g ..

N - -

. 3, s

(orthophosphoric acid etch)

Figure 8: Photomicrograph Depicting Depth of IGA in Sample #4 A-13

SAMPLE 5 IGA - 25 % CIRC. EXT.

Neg. #77139 Figure 9: Post Test Photograph of Sample #5

~

.- .-s. .. c

(;[ ,4 t,

y t

. 3: ..

'4t ,{, ( :,'

.\ i

~

y,, , "

,, ,.L C hsq vy ,c - <, + s .

l Y

< . , r y,, ..

'h Q.s,-' . ,

, .r . ~ . ,

i

+.

..rv'd_f.f.

. cy L{,

'g*J. . p,' 3 F % l;.

'. +L

'; . , - .. . f t,.,y -

.\p,

. , - w'.

, < u./

.,.- i

i

');,j ' .

50X Neg. # 76968 Figure 10: Photomicrograph Depicting Depth of IGA in Sample #5 A-14

SAMPLE 6 IGA - 25 % CIRC. EXT.

Neg. #77138 Figure 11: Post Test Photograph of Sample #6 l ..Q g,

, p? -

_ . '}{'.Q> I ?,$l J, t } % 9T,'r . H f .. . . 27 'L' f , ) q g .

3 N% g .A,3? ? f:l

,' ' t .

.: j;'Mvn.

't . f OjyydQy[ '

,; 9 y - ( .: .

3' ;:, y ; :ew., % . ,

'*J '

,, .N .

$$ ,. f/ c < c. ~. g

'+ 5% 1, . & g?, ;

s' ,. >

.-n- \s t;W z ' +

.. .I

'i

. J% .

'M' t

.['

Y.3, ;-f. ' . ' W 19 ,-

h _

j 50X Neg. # 76969 Figure 12: Photomicrograph Depicting Depth of IGA in Sample #6 A-15

SAMPLE 7 IG A - 50% CIRC. EXT. ;

Neg. #77141 Figure 13: Post Test Photograph of Sample #7

)1 t

f

, ., t .

.;(4,,.sik.)***

1

'7 *** , , % , ~e . ; . .,. . ,

. . , -, o

_a*,. .,..

+.,4. ~ . . . . , , "

a .. ,G:t .

..e;.,., .

1, ,y : ,,.. ' . *

. . V.

, sl

.. .c.

. . c. , \

.:. .. + :. . : r.

. . , . , .e . . . .' \

'. ~ ,-

' ' ' ' . * '_ { , - '

-(orthophosphoric acid etch)

Figure 14: Photomicrograph Depicting Depth of IGA in Sample #7 A-16

SAMPLE 8 IG A - 50% CIRC. EXT.

1 Neg. #77140 Figure 15: Post Test Photograph of Sample #8 )

~4 .' ,

' i

,y ' = ,

, f- -

l l

i (orthophosphoric acid etch)

Figure 16: Photomicrograph Depicting Depth of IGA in Sample #8 A-17 t------_-__---------_---__ J

l i

l SAMPLE 9 ;

IGA - 50% CIRC. EXT.

Neg. #77143 Figure 17: Post Test Photograph of Sample #9

^gh g,.

f. , .[ ,'['. .,,'; .: >, -' . . . : ;. .'.,

( *,.

'y N, ' ' .

' h}I-(

($ .

g t

. s.

,; Y N '4

't:)

}y). .. 1,' .g'f.(. ^'pf.k

' r :

' l, - .

'g ;

, j 5 < ? .'

4 ~ j. i ; i r

,{

1 . ,, -

T " 5;.7 )

y,r

~

.; i .' Q '{;g y :-

g 7 _

r

' /.

fly _% ?'-(.., .

t'

./

. 3- ,

- , 3, - . . . - . 'y

, .c-

_. s - - .

s.

i, . >' d, [;

(_f 4' ' (>

. . f. .. IL h ..

~

t 50X Neg. # 76970 Figure 18: Photomicrograph Depicting Depth of IGA in Sample #9 A-18

SAMPLE 10 IGA .50% CIRC. EXT.

1 1

Neg. #77142 Figure 19: Post Test Photograph of Sample #10 r.

g. -

)<.

Jy., -

f N. . , ^

' A, 4 ,.( .:

i -

.. :. 4 L' ... .

vi ;

','+'jf I

'}/ QJO...' / . ,'h

., Y.

s y,

<. 3- s fr ,w.

{E k?.,' . z '. >% a 7 $ ,fs ' ,

ep

e

~

3

'" * '$.]f:,k' .

%. , i).i.,l:'-3 9 % C

~

g.<

,,

w v . 't .:' ' .. .

' '. hl[ ,' ' , , ' 3 ?j", %.', '

.%f y.y

-' 5

(

{

(" j y d.- 4 7

i: ' .[. f, ..;..s i 50X Neg # 76971 Figure 20: Photomicrograph Depicting Depth of IGA in Sample #10 A-19

SAMPLE 11 IG A - 100% CIRC. EXT.

Neg. #77145 Figure 21: Post Test Photograph of Sample #11

~

1 (orthophosphoric acid etch)

Figure 22: Photomicrograph Depicting Depth of IGA in Sample #11 A-20

l i

SAMPLE 12 IG A - 100% CIRC. EXT.

l l

l Neg #77144 Figure 23: Post Test Photograph of Sample #12 i

l 8'

p. .,

I 4

( . ~4 7> ,

'f M. .

. . . .8/

<. .>g

.r..,

. .- . ?. . .

': .: :-.s. ,e -

,..;,.....'~

C..~.. .g.

~

.. .. ? ., ; - . . -

. . .: . . :. 1 . ->

',,*x..' . . .s *

.,1

, .i .,,.,,. . e .,

~= . .

. . y. . . .

n-4.:?idL. .X 50X Neg. # 77195 (orthophosphoric acid etch)

Figure 24: Photomicrograph Depicting Depth of IGA in Sample #12 A-21

i 1

SAMPLE 13 IG A - 100% CIRC. EXT.

i l Neg. #77146 Figure 25: Post Test Photograph of Sample #13 e

.v i.f f s- ,

p 1

g'y J

' f .-

. ", ';; k s f.

i ,

.* ' N

~k ,' > Jk

- w.

p - )

ps <

, ? . . b , ; '[ ; .,

. ,;7 W:

, .1

, ~; _

j 50X Neg. # 76973 Figure 26: Photomicrograph Depicting Depth of IGA in Sample #13 A-22 i

L. . _ . . . _ . . . . . . _ . . . . . . . . . . l

SAMPLE 14 ;

IG A - 100% CIRC. EXT. .i i

Neg. #77147 Figure 27: Post Test Photograph of Sample #14 k;;'..'. ,

' ~ .: * * '

- - o, ,%

'l ', QN a

.s 4'!.n.

y J ~.

. . . "1M. ' j.; fc

,f.' ,1~'

. ,7 4-

- ~ . _ ; ,,c,.

?l.

.. .j

~

, ' /: % -

7_.

?. A{.J,,.} -,f K _ '-

. ' 'l 1 I

50X Neg. # 76974 Figure 28: Photomicrograph Depicting Depth of IGA in Sample #14 A-23 l l

ATTACHMENT 2 Response to Question 3 Listing of Tubes with Indications in PSL 1 Steam Generators 1987 Outage 4

l

)

MCl2:7

_ = _ - - - . _-- - . _ _ _ _ - - - - _ -_- _-__ __ - _ - _ _ __- - - _ - __. .- _

1 i

CUMULATIVE REPORT 02/87, ST. LUCIE' S/G -

A, UNIT 1 STEAM GENERATORS.A PAGE: 1 0F 11 LOCATION: ALL DATE: e8/20/87 ,

CRITERIA . 1% TO' 19% TIME: 10:58:24 i

l I i i IEXTENT 3. I I I l CURRENT 1 iLINIROWlHEAT#1LEGIREQlTSTlREMlREELlPROBEl LOCATION IVOLTSIMILIDEGl % ICHI I i I -_I___I___I___I___I____I_____I____ _____I_____I___1___I___I__l 1 31 .71000211 C 107H106Hi 1 0011580SD104C+ 22.2 1 2.11 11611 11 11 1; 81 121000221 C IF/LIF/L1 1 0151580SM101C . 0.4 1 0.71 11461 71 11 1 81 341999991 C IF/LIF/Li 1 0141580SMiBW3+ 0. 0 1 1.21 11451 81 il 1, 91 211999991 C IF/LIF/LI i 0151580SM102H+ 0. 4 1 1.81 11511 'il 11-t 9l 271999991 C IF/LIF/LI I 0151580SM101H+ 0. 8 1 0,91 11451 81 11 El 91 431999991 C IF/LIF/L1 1 0151580SM101H+ 0. 5 1 1.61 11431 101 11 1 101 41000601 H 107C106Cl 1 0631580SMl02H+ 0. 3 1 2.41 11431 81 11

.I 101 261999991 C IF/LIF/L1 1 0151580SM103H- 0. 5 1 0.91 11351 191 11 l- l 1 i C IF/LIF/LI I 0151580SM102C- 0. 4 1 1.51 11441 91 11 I ill 411000601 C lF/LIF/LI i 015tS80SM105H+ 0. 2 1 1.91 11381 161 il 1 ill 511999991 C IF/LIF/LI i 0151580SM101H+ 0. 5 1 0.91 11511 il 11 1 131 37199999! C IF/LIF/Lt 1 0161580SMIBW5+ 0. 0 1 0.91 11421 131 11 l'171 291999991 C IF/LIF/Li 1 0171580SF101H+ 0. 4 l 1.71 l1491 41 11 1'171 591000601 C IF/LIF/LI I 0181580SM105H- 0. 3 l 1. 9 I 11471 71 il 1 38l 121000221 C IF/LIF/L1- 1 0181580SM102H+ 0. 5 1 1.11 11521 21 il l- 1 I i C IF/LIF/LI l 018t580SM104H+ 0. 5 i 1.51 11511 31 11 1 191 76000211 H 107C106Cl 1 0631580SMIPW3+ 0. 0 1 1.01 11406 111 11 1 221 221999991 C lF/LIF/Lt 1 0201580SMITSH+ 1. 3 1 0.71 11331 191 il 1 221 321000601 C IF/LIF/LI 1 0201580SMITSH+ 1. 0 1 2.51 11431 91 il I l- 1 I C IF/LIF/LI I 0201580SM104C+ 0. 5 ~1 0.81 11501 21 11 1 1 I I C IF/LIF/LI i 0201580SM102C+ 0. 6 1 0.81 11351 171 11 1 221 341999991 C IF/LIF/LI 'l 0201580SMITSH+ 2.1 1 1.41 11421 101 il i 221 361999991 C IF/LIF/LI l 020;580SMITSH+ 1. 9 l 1.11 11381 151 11

'l 231 51000601 H.107C106C) 1 0631580SM101H+ 1. 8 1 2.41 11351 171 il 1 231 13l000221 C IF/LIF/L1 l 0201580SMl02H- 0. 5 l 1.61 11351 171 11 1 231 171000601 C IF/LIF/LI I 0201580SMITSC+ 4. 6 1 1.01 I1491 31 il i 231-191000431 C IF/LIF/LI i 0201580SMITSC+ 5.1 1 1.81 1148l 41 il i 231 231999991 C IF/LIF/Li I 0201580SMITSH+ 1. 4 1 1.71 11371 161 16 1 231 271000601 C IF/LIF/LI 1 0201580SMITSH+ 1. 9 1 0.41 11371 161 11 1 I I I C IF/LIF/LI i 020tS80SMITSH+ 4. 7 1 2.21 11401 121 11 I I I I C IF/LIF/LI i 0201580SMllSC+ 1. 3 1 1.01 11481 46 il 1 231 291999991 C IF/LIF/Li 1 0201580SMITSH+ 1. 5 1 1.01 11451 71 11 1 231 471999991 C IF/LIF/LI 1 0201580SMIBW3+ 0. 0 1 0.51 11331 191 il 1 241 681999991 C IF/LIF/Lt 1 0211580SM102H+ 0. 8 1 0.51 11451 111 11 1 251 291000601 C IF/LIF/Li 1 0211580SMITSH+ 1. 2 l 2.01 11461 101 11

-1 251 471999991 C IF/LtF/Li 1 0211580SMITSH+ 0. 6 1 1.31 11431 131 11 1 251 53l999991 C IF/LIF/Lt 1 0211580SM103C+ B. 5 1 0.7I 11531 11 il 1 261 221000601 C IF/LIF/Li 1 022tS80SMITSH+ 0. 3 1 2.61 11371 151 il i 261 521000601 C IF/LIF/LI I 0221580SMITSH+ 1. 4 1 1.31 11441 71 11 1 261 941000411 C IF/LIF/Lt 1 0221580SM109C+ 0. 0 l 1.41 11401 111 il i 271 471999991 C IF/LIF/LI i 0221580SM101H+ 0. 5 1 0.71 11351 171 il 1 271 491999991 C IF/LIF/Lt 1 0221580SMiTSH+ 1. 0 1 1.11 11351 171 il i 271 591999991 C (F/LIF/LI I 02315GOSMITSH+ 0. 6 1 1.11 11461 8, il i i i i C IF/LIF/LI i 0231580SM101H+ 9. 3 1 0.71 11441 101 it l_

i 271 651999991 C IF/LIF/Li 1 0231580SM101H+ 0. 5 1 0.91 11441 101 11 i i i i i i i_._i___i_____i___i___i___i___i____i_____i FLORIDA POWER & LIGHT COMPANY

CUMULATIVE REPORT

02/87, ST. LUCIE S/3 A, UNIT 1

. STEAM GENERATOR: A PAGEs- 2 OF 11 LOCATION: ALL DATE: 08/20/87 CRITERIA: 1% TO 19% TIME: 10:58:24

~~~~~~ ~ ~~

l ~~~i"~~i~ l IEXTENT i 5~~~l I l CUER5 i i I LIN I RDW l HEAT # 1 LEG I REQ l T ST l REM I REEL I P ROBE l : LOCATION IVOLTSIMILIDEGI % ICHI I l' l_____l___I I I I I l. _z _____ _ l _____ I ___ I ___ I _ __ l . I I 271 691999991 C IF/LIF/Li 1 0231580SMl03H-- 0. 6 1 0.51 11371 161 11 1 271 931000411 C lF/LIF/LI I 0231580SM101H+ 0. 7 1 1.11 11251 41 S i i 1 -1 1 C IF/LIF/LI I 0231580SMl09H+ 0. 0 1 0.81 11501 4.1'11 I l. I I C IF/LIF/LI l 0231580SM109C+ 0. 0 1 0.81 11471 7.1 11 ;

I 281"141000221 C IF/LIF/LI I 0231580SMIO1H+ 0. 8 1 1.11 11491 51 11 1 28l 241000601 C IF/LIF/LI I 023l580SMITSH+ 3. 8 l 1.36 11461 81 il 1 281 301999991 C IF/LIF/LI 1 0231580SM104H+ 0. 0 1 1.31 11531 11 11 1 281 341999991 C IF/LIF/LI i 0231580SMl02H- 0. 2 1 0.81 11481 61 11 l 281 361000601 C lF/LIF/LI i 0231580SMITSH+ 1. 3 1 1.74 11461 81 il 1 281 381999991 C IF/LIF/Li' I 0231580SMITSH+ 1. 3 1 1.81 11341 191 11 1 281 481999991 C IF/LIF/L1 1 0231580SMITSH+ 3.1 1 0.71 11371 161 il i 281 501999991 C IF/LIF/L1 1 0231580SMITSH+ 0. 6 1 2.21 11411 131 11 1 0231580SMITSH+ 0. 8 1,71 11431 111 il 1 281.521000601 C IF/LIF/LI 1 1 i i i C IF/LIF/L1 1 0231580SMITSH+ 2.1 1 1.01 11451' 91 il i 281 601000601 C IF/LIF/LI i 0231580SMITSH+ 1. 3 1 1.21 11491 51 11 1 281 801000411 C IF/LIF/LI I 023I580SMl08H+ 0. 2 1 0.81 1150l 41 11 1.281 961000421 C'IF/LIF/LI 1 0231580SM109H+ 0. 0 1 1. 4 l 11411 131 il i 281-981000421 C IF/LIF/LI i 0231580SMIO9H+ 0. 0 1 1.51 11391 151 il i 1 1 l C IF/LIF/LI i 0231580SM109C+ 0. 0 1 0.51 11421 121 il i 2811001000421 C lF/LIF/LI i 0231580SM103H+ 36.8 I 0.91 1152l 21 il 1.291 131000221 C IF/LIF/Li 1 0231580SM103H+ 0. 6 1 0.81 11521 21 11 1 291 231999991 C lF/LIF/LI i 0231580SM105H- 0. 5 1 0.71 11351 181 11 1 291 311999991 C IF/LIF/LI i 0236580SMITSH+ 0. 8 l 1.61 11451 91 il i 291 611000601 C IF/LIF/L1 1 0241580SF105H- 0. 5 1 1.51 11521 21 11-1 321 981000421 C IF/LIF/LI ! 0251580SFl09H+ 0. 0 1 1.71 11411 121 11 l 331 391000606 C IF/LIF/LI i 0261580SMl05H+' O. 4 1 1.31 11421 161 11 1 331 491000601 C IF/LIF/LI I 0261580SMl04H+ 0. 5 1 1. 31 11401 181 11 1 341 141000221 C IF/LIF/LI I 0271580SM102H+ 0. 4 1 1.01 1151I 41 il i 351 691000501 C IF/LIF/LI i 0271580SM103H+ 0. 5 1 0.51 11401 171 11 1 36l 321000601 C IF/LIF/LI 1 0281580SMITSH+ 1.1 1 2.41 11501 41 il 1 361 341000601 C IF/LIF/LI I 0281580SMITSH+ 1. 0 1 0.91 11211 81 51 1 361 961000431 C IF/LIF/L1 1 0281580SM109C+ 0. 0 1 1.31 11371 191 11 1 371 331000601 C IF/LIF/Lt 1 0281580SM101C+ 0. 4 1 0.71 !1371 191 il 1 371 411000601 C IF/LIF/Lt 1 0281580SMl06H+ 2. 0 1 1.11 11421 131 11 I I I I C IF/LIF/LI i 0281530SM106C+ 2.1 1 1.21 11401 161 11 1 371 75I000601 C IF/LIF/LI i 0281580SMl01C- 0. 5 1 1.81 11421 131 11 1 3711071000431 C IF/LIF/LI I 0291580SM101C+ 17.3 1 1.11 11481 71-11 l

L I 381 70100050t C IF/LIF/Lt t 0291580SMITSC+ 0. 6 1 0.71 11461 91 11 l t 381 861000431 C IF/LIF/LI i 0291580SMITSH+ 0. 7 1 0.61 11431 121 11 L 1 401 94'l000601 C IF/LIF/LI i 0301580SM109H+ 0. 0 1 0.81 11371 191 11 l; i 401 981000601 C IF/LIF/LI I 0301580SM109H+ 0. 0 1 2. 4 ! 11411 151 11 I 411 651999991 C IF/LIF/LI i 0311580SMITSH+ 0. 9 1 1.41 11531 41 11 l 411 891000601 C IF/LIF/Lt 1 0311580SM101H+ 0. 0 1 1.11 11451 121 il I 42l 41999991 H 107C106CI i 0631580SMl02H+ 0. 0 1 1.01 11411 101 11 1 421 701999991 H IF/LIF/LI I 0651580SMITSH+ 0. 9 1 3.01 11481 61 11

) l_____I___I___I___l __I i___I___1_____I___I___I___I___I I i _ .__

) FLORIDA POWER & LIGHT COMPANY

CUMULATIVE REPDRT 82/87, ST. LUCIE S/G A, UNIT 1

. STEAM-GENERATOR: A PAGE: 3 0F- 11 LOCATIOth ALL DATE: 08/20/87 CPITERIA: 1% TO 19% TIME: 10:58:24 .

I

__________________gg__

_=

7==_______________-

ILINIROWlHEAT#lLEGIREDITSTIREMIREELlPROBEl LOCATION IVOLTSIMILIDEGI % ICHI i i i i i l___l __I____1_____1==- ______________I_____I___I___!___I__I I 4211041000601 H IF/LIF/LI I 0651580SM109H+ 0.0 1 1.71 11511 21 11 1 431 871000601 C IF/LIF/L1 1 0331580SMITSH+ 1. 8 1 1.11 11391 171 il

I 431 951000441 C lF/LIF/LI I 0331580SMITSH+ 1.1 1 0.91 11431 141 11 1 441 401999991 C IF/LIF/Lt 1 0331580SMITSH+ 1. 8 l 1.81 11411 151 11' I 441 961000441 C IF/LIF/LI I 0331580SMITSH+ 0. 9 1 1.11 11421 151 11 1 441 981000441 C IF/LIF/LI i 0331580SM105H+ 0. 4 1 0.81 11391 171 il I 451 29100060i C IF/LIF/LI I 0341580SM104H+ 0. 5 1 1.01 11491 81 11 1 451 331000601 C IF/LIF/LI I 0341580SMIO1C+ 0. 5 1 0.81 11461 111 11 1 451 831000441 C IF/LIF/L1 1 034tS80SM102C+ 0.1 1 1.01 11481 91 11 l 451 651000441 C IF/LIF/Lt I 0341580SM102H+ 0. 3 1 0.81 11501 71 11 l ' 461 26199999I li IF/LIF/L t 1 0161580SMIBWi+ 0. 0 1 0.51 11441 101 il I 461 686000601 H IF/LIF/Lt 1 0171580SMl02H- 0. 5 l 2.31 11421 151 11 1 501 86iOOO601 C IF/LIF/LI i 0361580SMITSH+ 1.1 1 2.11 11521 56 il i 501 94I999991 C IF/LIF/Li 1 0361580SMITSH+ 3. 8 1 0.71 11491 81 il~

l 501 961999991 C IF/LIF/Li 1 0361580SM102H- 0. 3 1 0.61 11411 151'il l 501 98199999t'C IF/LIF/LI i 0361580SMITSH+ 0. 6 1 1.51 11401 161 11 I 5011201000601 C IF/LIF/LI i 0361580SM102H+ 28.4 1 1.41 11431 141 il l'511 231000601 H'IF/LIF/LI l 0141580$M103H+ 0. 5 1 1.61 11381 171 il l-Sil 391000601 H IF/LIF/LI I 0141580SMl02H+ 0. 4 1 1.31 11501 41 11 1 511 811000601 C IF/LIF/LI i 0361580SMITSH+ 0. 7 1 1.61 1146l ill il i 1. I I C IF/LIF/L1 1 03615805MITSH+ 7.1 1 0.91 11401 161 11 4 521 821999991 C IF/LIF/LI I 0361580SMITSH+ 7. 0 l 1.11 11441 131 11 1 521 841999991 C IF/LIF/L1 1 0361580SMITSH+ 1. 0 1 1.11 11411 151 il 1.521 981000601 C IF/LIF/LI i 0361580SMl03H+ 28.7 1 0.61 11471 101 11 1 5211041999991 C IF/LIF/LI i 0361580SM109H+ 0. 0 1 1.51 11371 191 11 1 541 841999991 C IF/LIF/LI i 0371580SMiO2H- 1. 0 1 1.11 11151 121 51 l

1 541 901999991 C IF/LIF/LI i 0371580SMITSH+ 0. 7 l 1.61 11461 61 11

, I 551 81100060i C IF/LIF/L1 1 0381580RMITSH+ 0. 8 I 4.16 11521 71 11 1 5511011000601 C IF/LIF/Lt 1 0381580RMITSH+ 0. 7 1 2.51 11391 191 11 1 561 361999991 H IF/LITSClRITI 0121580SMITSC+ 0. 7 I 4.41 11521 51 11 f 2.31 1 0461580SMITSH+ 3.1 11451 I 561 981000601 H IF/LIF/Lt 71 il

} 1 571 411999991 H IF/LITSClRITI 0111580SM104h+ 0. 3 i 1.21 1146l ill 11 f I 571 69100050i H IF/LIF/LI 1 0111580SMITSH+ 0. 9 1 3.21 11551 El 11 1 5711011000601 H IF/LIF/LI 1 0461580SMITSH+ 3. 2 l 1.91 11341 181 11 1 58I 14100060( H IF/LIF/L1 1 0111580SMITSH+ 1. 4 i 1.91 11421 151 il I 581 561999991 H IF/LIF/LI I 0101580SDl02H- 0. 3 1 0.91 11461 41 11 l 581 961000601 H IF/LIF/LI i 0471580SMITSH+ 3. " I 1.91 11401 161 11 1 581 981000601 H IF/LIF/LI i 0471580SMITSH+ 0. 5 1 2.01 11451 ill il I- 1 I i H !F/LIF/LI I 0471580SMITSH+ 3. 2 1 2.81 11431 131 11 1 591 231000661 H IF/LIF/Lt 1 0101580SDITSC+ 7.1 1 3.31 11341 171 11 1 591 251000601 H IF/LIF/LI I 0101580SDITSH+ 4. 2 1 1.71 11371 131 il 1 591 471999991 H IF/LIF/LI I 01015BOSDl02H+ 0. 5 1 1.41 11321 191 11 1 5911131000601 H IF/LIF/LI i 0471580SMITSH+ 0. 6 1 1.71 11371 181 il I 601 481000601 H IF/LIF/L1 1 0091580SMITSH+ 7. 9 1 2.21 11471 51 11 1 611 211000411 H IF/LIF/L1 1 0091580SMITSH+ 4. 4 t 0.61 11381 141 11 I l i 1 1 l l___I___i_____1___1 __I___I___I____I_____I___________________i -

L i

\.

FLORIDA POWER & LIGHT COMPANY

l CUMULATIVE REPORT 02/87, ST. LUCIE S/G A, UNIT 1 STEAM GENERATOR: A PAGE:' 4 OF 11 LOCATION: ALL DATE: 08/20/87 CRITERIA: 1% TO 19% TIME: 10:58:24

.l L I N I RDW l HEAT # 1 LEG I REQ l TST I REM I REEL I P ROBE l LOCATION IVOLTSIMILIDEGI % (CHI l___I___I_____I___I___I___I___I____I_____l. __ ____I_____l___I___I___I__I I 611 711000601 H IF/LIF/LI I 0091580SMITSH+ 0. 6 1 2.01 11431 91 11 1 611 911999991 H IF/LIF/LI l 04S1580SMITSH+ 1. 2 1 0.91 11511 21 11 1 I I I H IF/LIF/Lt 1 0481580SMl02H+ 0. 0 1 0.91 11441 101 11 1 Gil 931000601 H IF/LIF/LI I 0481580SMITSH+ 3. 7 l 1.31 11361 191 11 l'611 951000601 H IF/LIF/LI I 0481580$MITSH+ 1. 2 1 0.91 11484 61 il

n 6111071000501 H IF/LIF/Li I 0481580SM109C+ 0. 0 l 1.71 11481 61 il j i 621 881999991 H lF/LIF/LI I 0481580SM104H+ 0. 0 1 0.71 11451 91 il .

I 621 921000501 H IF/LIF/LI i 0481580SMITSH+ 0. 9 l 1.61 11421 121 11 l i i I i H IF/LIF/LI I 0481580SMITSH+ 3. 7 1 0.81 11381 171 11 ,

I 6211241000601 H IF/LIF/Li 1 0481580SM101H+ 0. 0 1 1.41 11381 171 il ]

I i 1 IH IF/LIF/LI I 0481580SM109C+ 0. 0 1 2. 8 l 11501 41 il a I 641 461000221 H IF/LIF/LI i 0071580SM102H+ 0. 0 l 0.51 11111 191 51 I 641 701000411 H IF/LIF/LI i 0071580SMl02C+ 0. 6 1 0.51 11131 161 St I 641 981999991 H IF/LIF/L1 1 0491580SM109H+ 0. 0 1 1.51 11421 91 11 [

l 6411081999991 H IF/LIF/Li 1 0491580SMl09C+ 0. 0 1 1.91 11411 101 !!

! 6411101999991 H lF/LIF/Lt 1 049tS80SMITSH+ 1. 5 1 0.81 11371 141 il l I 6411221999991 H IF/LIF/LI I 0491580SM109H+ 0. 0 1 2.06 11431 81 11 1 6411341000501 H IF/LIF/Lt 1 0491580SM109C+ 0. 0 1 2.11 11451 51 11 1 651 291000221 H IF/LIF/LI 1 0071580SM102H+ 0. 3 1 1.21 11421 81 11 1 651 311000221 H IF/LIF/L1 1 0071580$Ml01H+ 0. 3 1 0.91 11361 146 il I 6511011999991 H IF/LIF/LI I 0491580SMITSH+ 2. 8 1 0.91 11331 191 11 l t 6511131999991 H IF/LIF/LI I 0491580SM110C+ 0. 0 1 2.41 11461 4 t _11 - i I 66l 361000221 H IF/LITSCIRITI 0061580SM107C- 0. 7 1 1.11 11351 181 11 l l l 661 681000221 H IF/LIF/Lt 1 0061580SM101H+ 0. 4 1 0.91 t1391 131 11 l 1 661 921999991 H IF/LIF/LI- 1 0501580SMITSH+ 0. 9 1 2.41 11421 121 il l 1 661 981999991 H IF/LIF/LI 1 0501580SM109H+ 00 1 1.61 11351 181 11 1 6611301999991 H IF/LIF/LI i 0501580SM109C+ 0. 0 1 1.01 11451 91 11 1 671 291000211 H lF/LIF/LI i 006l580SM103H+ 0. 4 1 1.11 11391 131 11 1 671 391000211 H IF/LITSCIRITI 0061580SM104H+ 0. 2 1 0. 8 f 11441 78 11 l l 671 711000221 H IF/LIF/LI I 0061580SMl04H+ 0. 3 1 1.21 11351 181 11 1 67 871000608 H lF/LIF/LI I 0501580SM104H+ 0. 4 1 3.51 11401 141 il l- 11371 181 11 I 681 821999991 H IF/LIF/Li 1 0511580SMITSC+ 1. 8 1 1.01 l t 681104l000501 H IF/LIF/LI I 0511580SM101H+ 0. 9 1 2.01 11521 il 11 l l i I I H IF/LIF/L1 l 0511580$M109H+ 0. 0 1 1.71 11401 151 11 l 6911131000501 H IF/LIF/LI I 0511580SMl09H+ 0. 0 1 2.91 11501 41 Il

( 0. 0 1.41 11461 81 11 I 6911231999991 H IF/LIF/Lt 1 0511580SM109C+ l I 701 381000211 H IF/LIF/LI I 0051580SMITSH+ 2. 7 l 1.51 11371 181 11 L

L 1 701 981000601 H iF/LIF/LI I 0521580BM109H+ 0. 0 1 2.01 11391 16l 11 I I I I H IF/LIS941(R)1 0681580SMl09H+ 0. 0 1 2.01 11391 161 11 1 711 431000111 H IF/LIF/LI i 00415BOSDl02H+ 0. 0 1 1.51 61361 191 11 1 711 731000111 H IF/LIF/LI i 0041580SDITSH+ 6. 6 1 1.21 11121 181 51 1 711 911000601 H IF/LIF/LI i 05215BOSM109C+ 0. 0 1 1.41 11481 61 il

! 7111291000601 H IF/LIF/LI I 0521580SM109C+ 0. 0 1 3.41 41361 171 11 1 721 32100060I H 1F/LIF/Lt 1 0041580SDITSH+ 0. 7 l 1.11 11431 til 11 1 731 351000111 H IF/LIF/LI I 0031580$DITSH+ 2. 2 l 1.31 11381 131 11 1 I I I i i i I I __ l _ _ I _. . I I I i l l

l FLORIDA POWER & LIGHT COMPANY l

CUMULATIVE REPORT 02/87, ST. LUCIE S/G A, UNIT 1

. STEAM GENERATOR: A PAGE: 5 0F 11

-LOCATION: ALL DATE: 08/20/87 CRITERIA:- 1% TO 19% TIME: 10:58:24 1 1 1. I IEXTENT I I I I I CURRENT I I LI N I ROW l HEAT # 1 LEG I REQ l TST l REM I REEL l PROBE l LOCATION IVOLTSIMILIDEGI % ICHI

=l I l _____ I __ _ I _ __ I _ __ I __ _ I ____ I _ ____ I _ _ ____ _____ ___ _ __ __ I ____ _ I _ __ l __ I _ __ I __ I

'l 731 731000111 H IF/LIF/LI i 0041580SDl03H+ 0. 2 1 0.66 11181 101 51 1-731107199999! H IF/LIF/Lt 1 0531580SMIO9C+ 0. 0 1 0.61 11511 31 11 iL741 361000111 H IF/LIF/LI i 0031580SD102H+ 0. 2 1 1.21 11371 141 il I 741 661000601 H IF/LIF/L1 1 003I580SDIBW3+ 0. 6 1 0.81 1134l 181 il I 751 931999991 H lF/LIF/LI I 0541580SMITSH+ 0. 6 1 2.21 11501 71 li I 751 951000601 n IF/LIF/L1 1 0541580SMITSH+ 0. 9 l 1.81 11561 al il 1 75l1071999991 H I F/LIF /L I I 0541580SM109C+ 0. 0 1 2.71 11411 161 11

.I 761 361999991 H IF/LIF/LI i 0591580SM101H- 0. 4 1 1.91 11441 111 11 1 761 481999991 H IF/LIF/LI I 0591580SMITSC+ 3. 4 1 1,01 11371 191 11 1 761 601999991 H IF/LIF/LI i 0591580SMITSH+ 11.2 1 6.11 1 51 121 il I 761 701999991 H IF/LIF/LI I 0591580SMITSH+ 6. 6 1 0.71 11401 15l 11 1 761 761999991 H IF/LIF/L1 1 0594580SMITSH+ 4. 2 1 3.01 11441 111 11

-l 761 881999991 H IF/LIF/LI

~

1 0591580SMITSH+ 3. 9 1 1.91 11411 141 11 i '761 98100050I H IF/LIF/LI I 0591580SMITSH+ 1.1 1 1.51 11431 121 11 1 771 471000601 H IF/LIF/LI i 0591580SMITSC+ 5. 2 1 1.31 11481 71 11 i 77) 49199999I H 1F/LIF/LI i 0591580SMITSC+ 5. 9 1 2.1I 11511 Al 11 1 771 596999991 H IF/LIF/L1 1 0591580SMITSH+ 0. 7 1 1.11 11421 131 11 1 I I I H IF/LIF/Lt 1 0591580SMITSC+ 3. 6 1 1,71 11511 41 11 1 781 941999991 H IF/LIF/Lt 1 0581580SMl09C+ 0. 0 1 1.61 (1371 181 Il 1 7811001000601 H IF/LIF/LI i 0581580SMITSH+ 7. 6 1 2.31 11461 81 11 1 791 39199999I H IF/LIF/Ll- 1 0581580SM104H+ 0. 0 1 1.21 I1491 51 il I 791 431999991- H IF/LIF/L1 1 0581580SMITSH+ 3. 5 1 1.21 11431 ill il I 7911231999991 H IF/LIF/LI I 0571580SM109H+ 0. 3 1 1.21 11361 151 11 1 801 561999991 H IF/LIF/LI I 0561580SMITSC+ . 5. 2 1 1.31 I1321 141 11 1 8011041000601 H IF/LIF/Lt I 0571580SMITSH+ 3. 5 1 1.31 11381 131 il 1 8011101000501 H IF/LIF/L1 1 0571580SMA09H+ 0. 0 1 1.81 11471 31 il I 8011341999991 H IF/LIF/Lt I 0571580SM109C+ 0. 0 1 1.51 11471 31 !!

l Bil 371999991 H IF/LIF/LI 1 0561580SMITSH+ 1.1 1 1,61 11321 141 11 I I ( lH IF/LIF/LI I 0561580SM101H+ 0. 5 1 1.11 1137t' 91 11 1 8111231000601 H IF/LIF/Li 1 0561580SMl09H+ 0. 0 1 1.61 11351 111 11 1 8111251000601 H IF/LIF/LI I 0561580SM109H+ 0. 0 1 2.61 11441 El li l i I I H IF/LIF/LI 1 0561580SMIO9C+ 0. 0 1 3.11 11381 81 11 1 8111291000601 H IF/LIF/Li 1 0561580SM109C+ 0. 0 f 3.11 11441 El 11 1 8111351000601 H IF/LIF/L1 1 0561580SMl05H+ 0. 0 l 1.11 11326 141 il i I I I H IF/LIF/Li 1 0561580SMl09C+ 0. 0 1 2.61 11381 81 11 1 821 441999991 C IF/LIF/Lt 1 0471580SMITSC+ 9. 2 1 1.01 11381 151 Il I 821 521999991 C IF/LIF/L1 1 0481580SMITSH+ 0. 8 l 1. 01 (1401 151 il I 82) 701999991 C IF/LIF/LI I 04Bl580SM101H+ 0. 0 l 1.61 1142! 121 11 i B21 881999991 C IF/LIF/LI I 0481580SMITSH+ 38.0 1 2.21 11411 131 11

-I B211101999996 C IFillF/LI I 04Bl580SMITSH+ 0. 6 1 1,61 11481 El 11

.I 831 511999991 C IF/LIF/L1 1 0471580SMITSH+ 1. 3 1 2.21 11361 171 11

( 1 83I 751000601 C IF/LIF/LI I 0471580SMITSC+ 1.1 1 2.11 11406 121 11 I 8311011999991 C IF/LIF/Lt 1 0471580SMITSH+ 2. 6 i 1. 31 11351 181 il

! 83I1171999991 C 1F/LIF/LI I 0471580SM109C+ 0. 0 1 1.21 11461 61 il I 8311231999991 C IF/LIF/L1 1 0471580SM109H+ 0. 0 1 1.51 11481 41 if l___l.__I____ l___I___I___I___I____1_____I______________ -- I I I I I I f

FLORIDA POWER & LIGHT COMPANY L__._--___-

CUMULATIVE REPORT ,

02/87, ST. LUCIE S/G A, UNIT 1 l STEAM GENERATOR: A PAGE 6 OF 11 1 LOCATION: ALL DATE: 08/20/87 I CRITERIA: 1% TO 19% TIME: 10:58:24 l

ILINIROWlHEATelLEGIREQlTSTlREMIREELIPROBEl LOCATION IVOLTSIMILIDEGI % ICHI l I__.l.__I_....l__.l.._l__.l___l _..l.___.l - ________________.l.____I___I___1 __l..l 1.11 11444 141 11 i 84l1141999991 C IF/LIF/L1 1 0461580SMITSH+ 1. 0 l I

1 851 611999991 C IF/LIF/L1 1 0461580SMITSH+ 6. 5 1 3.91 11551 31 11 i 8511031000601 C IF/LIF/LI I 0451580SM109H+ 25.6 1 0.91 11471 ill 11 f I 8511351999991 C IF/LIF/LI 1 0451580SM109C+ 0. 0 1 1.51 11461 121 11 i 861 60199999! C IF/LIF/LI i 0451580SMITSH+ 5. 0 f 1.61 11431 151 il I 861 821999991 C IF/LIF/LI I 0451580SMITSH+ 1. 8 1 1.21 11511 71 11 1 I I I C IF/LIF/LI I 0451580SMITSH+ 1. 9 1 1.31 11471 ill 11 l 8611061000601 C IF/LIF/L1 1 0451580SMITSH+ ?. 5 1 1.61 11491 96 11 3 J

3.51 11461 121 11 'l 1 8611341000601 C IF/LIF/LI I 0451580SM109C+ 0.1 1 i 871 411999991 C IF/LIF/LI i 0441580SMITSH+ 22.7 1 0.81 11461 121 11 1 871 511000606 C IF/LIF/LI i 0441580SMITSH+ 0. 7 1 1,81 11571 il 11 1 871 891999991 C IF/LIF/Lt I 0441580SM104C+ 0. 0 1 1.51 81571 il il i 8711071999991 C IF/LIF/Lt 1 0441580SM109C+ 0. 0 1 0.91 11451 131 il I 8711171000501 C !F/LIF/LI 1 0441580SMIO3H+ 1. 6 I 0. B l 6153l 51 11 I 8711391999991 C IF/LIF/L1 1 0441580SM109H+ 0. 0 l 1.81 11551 31 if L: l 891 511999991 C IF/LIF/LI I 0521580SM103H+ 0. 2 1 1.51 61471 121 il j l 8911071999991 C IF/LIF/LI 1 0521580SM109H+ 0. 0 1 2.11 11431 151 11

.I 901 861000601 C IF/LIF/Li i 0511580SMITSH+ 1. 4 1 2.71 11501 31 11-I 9011241000601 C IF/LIF/LI I 0521580SM101H+ 1.1 1 1.21 11401 181 il i

I i I i C IF/LIF/Li 1 0521580SMIO9C+ 0. 0 1 3.21 11541 51 11 i 911 731999991 C IF/LIF/Lt I 0511580SM103H+ 0. 4 1 1.81 11501 31 11 1 911 891999991 C IF/LIF/Lt 1 0511580SM103H+ 0. 0 1 1.11 11411 121 11 1 911 911999991 C IF/LIF/LI I 0501580SMITSH+ 1. 2 1 1.11 11441 101 11 l 9111011000601 C IF/LIF/LI i 0501580SMl09C+ 0. 0 1 2.01 11481 61 il I 9111091000601 C IF/LIF/LI l 0501580SM109H+ 0. 0 1 1.51 11431 111 11 I 921 901000601 C IF/LIF/Lt 1 050I580SMITSH+ 1. 2 1 4.61 11361 191 il I I i ! C IF/LIF/LI 1 0501580SMITSH+ 8. 5 1 1.21 11381 171 il 1 9211241000601 C IF/LIF/L! l 0501580SMl09H+ 0. 0 1 2.31 11381 171 11 1 931 551999991 C IF/LIF/Lt 1 0491580SM103H+ 0. 3 1 1.01 11481 El 11 1 9311231000601 C IF/LIF/LI I 0491580SM109C+ 0. 0 1 2.11 11431 151 11 1 941 941000601 C IF/LIF/LI i 0431500SM109H+ 0. 0 1 3.41 11531 71 11 I 941114l000501 C IF/LIF/LI I 0441580SM109H+ 0. 0 1 1. 5 I 11431 121 11 1 9411201000601 C IF/LIF/LI i 0441580SM109H+ 0. 0 1 2.21 1142: 161 il I 951 871999991 C IF/LIF/LI i 04315BOSMITSC+ 3.1 1 1.01 11371 191 11 i i i i C IF/LIF/LI I 0431580SMITSC+ 2. 2 1 1.01 11421 151 11 1 951 91l999991 C IF/LIF/Lt 1 0431580SM103H+ 0. 0 1 1.31 11551 21 11 l 951 951999991 C IF/LIF/Lt 1 0431580SMl09H+ 0. 0 1 1.41 11551 El 11 1 951 991999991 C IF/LIF/L1 1 0431580SM1094+ 0. 0 1 1.11 11541 31 11 1 9511091000601 C IF/LIF/Lt 1 0431580SMITSH+ 3. 4 1 1.11 11391 171 il I I I I C IF/LIF/LI 1 0431580SM109H+ 0. 0 1 1.41 11131 181 5I i 9511171999991 C IF/LIF/LI I 04315805M109H+ 0. 0 1 2.51 11521 51 It i 9611241000501 C IF/LIF/LI I 0431580SM101H+ 0. 0 1 1.11 11411 151 11 l 971 611000501 C IF/LIF/Li 1 0121580SFl02H+ 0.1 1 2. 0 ( 11461 71 il I 971 651999991 C IF/LIF/L1 1 0121580SFITSH+ 5. 6 1 1.71 114BI 51 11

1 981 941000601 C IF/LIF/LI I 0421580SMIBW2+ 0. 7 1 2.21 11491 91 11 i i l i I i i 1 I I I I I I l____1___

FLORIDA POWER & LIGHT COMPANY

CUMULATIVE REPORT f

02/07, ST. LUCIE S/G A. UNIT 1 STEAM GENERATORS.A PAGE: 7 0F 11 LOCATION: ALL DATE: 08/20/87 CRITERIA: 1% TO 19%. TIME: 10:58:24 l

l 1 i i i IEXTENT I I i i i CURRENT I I LIN I RDW lHEAT# I LEG I REG I TST I REM I REEL l P ROBE l LOCATION IVOLTSIMILIDEGI % ICHI l ___________________1 ____I___I___I___l__I I

.i___I___1 l___I___I___l___I____I_ _-

) I 991 631999991 C IF/LIF/L4 1 0121580SFITSH+ 8. 6 1 1.01 11381 161 II .l l 991 771999951 C 1F/LIF/LI I 0121580SF103H+ 0. 5 1 1.61 11441 91 11 l i 0401580SM101H+ 0. 0 1.61 11551 41 11 l 11021 901999991 C IF/LIF/LI 1 110211241000601 C IF/LIF/Lt 1 0401580SMl09H+ 0. 0 1 3.11 11451 141 11 1 l 11031 531999991 C IF/LIF/Lt 1 0101580SMITSC+ e. 7 i 3. 6 i i147i 9i li ;

I 1103) 691999991 C IF/LIF/L1 1 0101580SMiBW3+ 0. 0 1 0.91 11501 61 II 11031 771000601 C IF/LIF/Lt 1 0101580SMITSH+ 1. 2 1 3.01 11531 41 11. !

l- l 1 i C IF/LIF/L1 1 0101580$MITSC+ 3. 3 1 0.91 11431 131 11 !

11031 991999991 C IF/LIF/Lt 1 0391580SMid9C+ 0. 0 1 1.51 11511 31 11 11041 881999991 C IF/LIF/LI i 0391580SMITSH+ 1. 0 1 0.91 11511 31 11

-110411041999991 C IF/LIF/LI i 0391580SMITSH+ 1. 0 l 1.41 11401 151 11 ;

110411201000601 C IF/LIF/LI I 0391580SMITSH+ 0. 8 1 2.11 1148) El il I I I i C IF/LIF/LI I 0391580SM109C+ 0. 0 1 2.41 11461 Bf 11

'1105I 431999991 C IF/LIF/LI 1 0101580SM105C+ 35.7 1 1.11 11451 111 11 110511171999991 C IF/LIF/Li 1 0381580RMl09C+ 0. 0 1 1.81 11501 91 11 11061 401000601 C fF/LITSHIRITI 0091580SM104H+ 0. 3 I 2.01 11441 121 it 1 (1061 741000601 C IF/LIF/LI I 0091580SM102C+ 0. 4 1 1.01 11491 71 11 I 110611041000601 C IF/LIF/L1 1 0381580RM109C+ 0. 0 1 2.11 11441 151 11 11071 211999991 C IF/LIF/LI i 0091580SMl02H- 0. 3 1 1.91 11551 El il 11071'671000601 C IF/LIF/LI i 0091580SMITSH+ 5. 4 1 1.71 11531 41 Il 11071 731999991 C IF/LIF/LI I 0091580SMITSH+ 0. 6 1 1.41 11471 91 11-11081 141000411 C IF/LIF/LI l 0081580SMl02H+ . 0. 0 l. 1.31 11391 171 il 11081 341000601 C IF/LIF/LI i 0081580SMITSH+ 1.1 1 3.31 11531 il 11 11081 881999991 H IF/LIF/Li l 0451580SMITSH+ 0. 7 1. 1.51 11461 61 11 110811061000601 H IF/LIF/LI I 0451580SM109H+ 0. 0 1 3.31 11441 81 11 11091 691000601 C IF/LIF/LI 1 0081580SMITSH+ 1. 5 1 2.91 11501 51 il 11091 931000501 H IF/LIF/L1 1 0451580EMITSH+ 0. 9 I 1.71 11401 121 11 11101 381999991 C IF/LIF/Li I 0071580SMITSH+ 0. 7 1 1.41 11071 151 il 111011061400601 H IF/LIF/Lt 1 0441580SMITSH+ 1. 3 1 1.21 I1431 111 il i I I I H IF/LIF/LI 1 0441580$M109H+ 0. 0 1 2.61 11361 191 Il 11111 831999991 H IF/LIF/Li 1 044l580SMITSH+ 0. 7 1 1,71 11511 21 11 111111071999991 H IF/LIF/LI I 0441580SM109H+ 0. 0 1 1.01 1151l 21 11 11121 461999991 C IF/LIF/L1 1 0071580SM103H- 0. 5 1 1.31 11471 101 11 11121 501999991 C IF/LIF/LI i 0071580$Ml02H+ 0. 6 1 0.71 -11381 181 11 11121 82l999991 H IF/LIF/Li 1 0431580SMITSH+ 6. 5 1 1.01 11381 121 il 111211001999991 H IF/LIF/LI i 0431580SMITSH+ 3. 0 1 0.81 11371 131 11 l 1 l 1 iH IF/LIF/LI I 0431580SM109C+ 0. 0 1 1.91 11381 121 11 l 111211041999991 H IF/LIF/LI i 0431580SMl09C+ 0. 0 1 1.41 11381 121 il l

i I I I H IF/LIF/L1 1 0431580SM105C+ 0. 0 1 0.61 11381 121 11 I 11141 981999991 H IF/LIF/LI 1 0424580SMITSH+ 0. 7 1 1,41 11431 141 11 111411041000601 H IF/LIF/LI i 0421580SM109H+ 0. 0 1 1.21 11461 111 11 l i I I H IF/LIF/Lt 1 0421580SM1090+ 0. 0 1 2.21 11491 81 il 11151 11999991 H 107C106Cl 1 0021580SDl03H+ 22.5 1 1.31 11421 91 il 11151 131000411 C IF/LIF/L1 1 0061580SM103H- 0. 8 1 0.81 11161 91 S i 11151 15l000411 C IF/LIF/Li 1 0061580SMl03H+ 0. 5 i 1.31 11441 91 11 l___I___I_____I___I___1__ l___l ___1.____I___________________I_____1___I___I___I__I FLORIDA POWER 8 LIGHT COMPANY

CUMULATIVE REPORT .

02/87, ST. LUCIE S/G A, UNIT 1 E 'f

-STEAM GENERATOR: A PAGE: 8 0F 11 #

fil DATE: 08/20/87 L .

-LOCATION: ALL CRITERIA: 1% TO 19% TIME: 10:58:24

~ ~ ~~

I I I I IEkTENT I~~~5 1 l l CURRENT l

! LIN I ROW l HEAT # 1 LEG I REQ l TST I REM I REEL I PROBE l LOCATION IVOLTSIMILIDEGI % ICHI

! I I l___I___l. ___l __I___l___I___I I I -l I I 1115i 171000421 C IF/LIF/LI I 0061580SM104H+ 0. 6 1 2. 01 .11351 191 11 ;

11151113!00060! H IF/LIF/LI I 0421580SM109C+ 0. 0 1 3.01 11391 171 11 1116l 21999991 H.107C106Cl 1 0021580SD102H+ 0. 3 i 1.41 11471 Al 11 11171 831000601 4 IF/LIF/LI I 0411580SMITSH+ 3. 0 1 2.41 11431 151 11 i i l- I H IF/LIF/LI I 0411580SMITSH+ 5. 6 1 0.91 11481 101 il 11191- 11999991 H 107Cl06C1 l 0021580SDl02H- 0. 4 1 0.91 11351 171 il 11191 51000114 H 107C106Cl 1 0021580SDl03H- 0. 6 1 1.21 11441 71 il 11191 231000441 C IF/LIF/LI 1 0041580SFl02H+ 0. 2 1 1.21 11521 51 11 11191 791000601 C IF/LIF/LI I 0041580SFl02H+ 0. 4 1 1.51 11501 71 il 11191 851000601 H IF/LIF/L1 1 0411580SMITSH+ 1. 3 1 2.51 11431 151 11 11201 21999991 H 107C106Cl 1 0021580SD102H- 0. 3 1 0.51 11491 21 il 112011001999991 H IF/LIF/LI 1 0401580SMITSH+ 0. 9 l 1.91 11411 71 11 1 I l- I H IF/LIF/LI I 0401580SMITSH+ 2. 6 1 1.21 11321 191 il I I I I H lF/LIF/LI i 0401580SM109C+ 0. 0 1 2.01 11381 ill 11 112011041999991 H IF/LIF/LI i 0401580SMITSH+ 0. 6 1 1.91- 11451 21 11 11211 171000441 C IF/LIF/LI l'0031580SFITSH+ 7. 3 1 1.81 11441 131 11 11211 511000601 C IF/LIF/Li 1 0551580SMl03H+ 0. 5 1 1.81 11511 71 il 11211 551999991 C IF/LIF/L1 1 0551580SMITSH+ 0. 9 1 1.11 11421 151 11 11211 731999991 C IF/LIF/LI I 003!580SFITSH+ 0. 7 1 0.81 11221 31 SI 112111131999991 H IF/LIF/L1 1 0401580SM109C+ 0. 0 1 2.01 11431 51 i l 11221 441000601 C IF/LIF/LI i 0031580SFlTSH+ 1. 9 I 5.51 11551 21 11 11231 511000601'H IF/LIF/LI i 0391580SM102H+ 0. 4 1 1.11 11561 31 il 11241 761000601 H IF/LIF/LI I 0381580SMITSH+ 4. 4 1 3.41 11441 111 11 11241 781999991 H IF/LIF/LI i 0386580SM106H+ 18.4 l 1.01 11491 61 11 11241 841000601 H IF/LIF/Li 1 0381580SMITSH+ 2. 6 1 1.51 11461 91 il 11241 941000221 H IF/LIF/Li 1 038158?SMITSH+ 1. 0 1 1.4t 11421 131 il l

I i i iH IF/LIF/LI i 0381580bM109C+ 0. 0 1 1.21 11531 11 11 11241 961000221 H IF/LIF/LI i 0381580SMii74+ 0. 0 1 1.31 11381 181 11 l 11251 551000601 H IF/LIF/Lt I 0371580RMITSts 0. 5 1 4.71 11441 121 11 11251 631000601 H IF/LIF/LI i 0371580RM105H+ 0. 3 1 1.81 11511 21 il 11251 891000601 H IF/LIF/LI I 03Sl580SMITSH+ 0. 9 1 3.51 11441 til 11 112511031000601 H IF/LIF/LI i 0381580SM104C- 0. 2 1 1.71 11441 til 11 11261 241000601 H IF/LIF/LI i 0371580RM102H- 0. 5 i 1.11 i1491 51 il 11271 331999991 H IF/LIF/LI i 0361580SMITSH+ 39.0 1 0.51 11451 111 11 '

11271 351999991 H IF/L!F/LI I 0361580SM101C+ 0. 4 1 1.01 11431 141 11 11271 691000501 H IF/LIF/LI I 0361580SMiTSH+ 1.2 1 3.01 11441 121 11 1 1 I iH IF/LIF/Lt 1 0361580SM104C+ 0. 4 1 0.41 11481 71 il 11271 891000601 H IF/LIF/LI i 0361580SMl03H+ 0. 4 1 0.81 11491 51 il i I I I H IF/LIF/Lt 1 0361580SM105H+ 0. 4 1 0.81 11511 21 11 i 1 I i i H 1F/LIF/LI i 0361580SM102C+ 0. 5 1 0.81 11481 71 il '

11281 141000411 H IF/LIF/LI i 0361580SM101H+ 0.1 1 0.91 .11461 101 11 i i l i H IF/LIF/Lt 1 0361580SM104H+ 0. 3 1 0.71 11501 41 11 11281 441000601 H IF/LIF/LI i 0361580SM102H+ 0. 0 1 0.71 11421 151 1' 112811041000211 H IF/LIF/Li 1 0351580SM109H+ 0. 0 1 1.61 11461 141 il 11291 291999991 H IF/LIF/L1 1 0351580SM101H+ 0. 3 1 0.91 11471 121 11 I I i 1 1 I I I I I I i 1 I I I FLORIDA POWER & LIGHT COMPANY

CUMULATIVE REP 0dT 02/87, ST. LUCIE S/G A, UNIT 1 STEAM GENERATOR: A PAGE: 9 0F 11 LOCATION: ALL DATE: 08/20/87 CRITERIA: 1% TO 19% TIME: 10:58:24 I i 1 1 IEXTENT 1 i i i i CURRENT I ILINIROWlHEAT#1LEGIREQlTSTIREMIREELIPROBEl LOCATION IVOLTSIMILIDEGI % JCHI i i i l i i i l i 1 1 i l I I 1 11301 451999991 H IF/LIF/LI i 0341580SMITSH+ 1. 0 1 1.21 11.31 191 11 113011041000211 H IF/LIF/L1 1 0341580SM109H 0.00 1 3.41 11421 151 il 1132l 441999991 H IF/LIF/Li 1 0331580SM101H- 0. 4 1 1.01 1150i 61 11 11321 601000601 H IF/LIF/LI I 0331580SM101H+ 3. 7 1 6.11 1 51 121 11 11321 841000601 H IF/LIF/LI i 0331580SMITSH+ 1. 0 1 2.61 11441 121 11 11331 1?l000601 H IF/LIF/LI I 0321580SMITSH+ 3. 2 1 2.01 11461 71 il I I I ( H IF/LIF/LI i 0321580SM102H+ 0. 4 1 1.11 11481 Si il 11331 211999991 H 1F/LIF/LI I 0321580SMITSC+ 3. 0 1 0.91 11401 131 il 1133l 251999991 H IF/LIF/L1 1 032iS80SMITSH+ 4. 3 1 1.06 11411 121 il 11331 356999991 H 1F/LIF/Lt 1 0326580SMITSH+ 2.1 1 0.81 11471 61 il 11331 671000601 H IF/LIF/L1 1 0321580SMITSH+ 0. 8 I 2.61 11351 191 il 1133) 871999991 H IF/LIF/LI 1 0321580SM*TSH+ 0. 9 1 1.01 11501 21 11 11331 931000211 H IF/LIF/LI i 0321583SM109C+ 0. 0 1 1.21 (1381 151 il 11341 12l000601 H IF/LIF/LI 1 0321580SMITSH+ 0. 5 1 1.51 11491 41 11 ,

1 I l l H IF/LIF/Lt 1 0321580SMITSH+ 3.1 1 1.51 11361 181 11 (i

!!461 71 11 1134l 241999991 H !F/LIF/LI I 0321580SMl02H+ 0. 4 1 1.21 11341 321000601 H IF/LIF/Ll 1 0321580SMITSH+ 2. 4 1 1.61 ,1511 11 11 1 I i 1H IF/LIF/LI i 0321580SMITSH+ 5. 6 1 1.01 11391 141 il I i I l H IF/LIF/LI I 0321580SM!TSH+ 7. 3 1 2.11 11481 51 11 l i I I H IF/LIF/LI I 0321580SMl04H+ 0. 2 1 1.41 11391 141 11 i

11341 50I000601 H IF/LIF/LI i 0321580SMITSH+ 1. 2 1 3.51 11441 91 11 l 1 1 I l H IF/LIF/LI I 032I580SMITSH+ 3. 2 1 1.11 11351 191 11 11341 581999991 H IF/LIF/LI i 0321580SMITSH+ 0. 8 l 1,81 11431 101 11 l

l 11341 601000601 H IF/LIF/LI I 0321580SMl02H+ 0. 4 1 0.91 11441 91 il i I I I H IF/LIF/LI i 0321500SMITSC+ 1. 4 t 2.21 11431 101 11

{ 1135I 131eee41i H ir/tiF/Li i e31i38eSMiO3H+ e. 4 i 1. 5 i i149i 2i ii 11351 451000601 H IF/LIF/LI I 0311580SMl03H+ 0. 5 1 1.81 11461 61 11 l 11411 121 11 11351 511999991 H IF/LIF/LI i 0311580SM105H+ 0. 4 1 1.51 l 0. 4 1.31 11351 191 il 11351 671000501 H IF/LIF/L1 1 0311580SMl04H+ 1 l 11361 381000601 H IF/LIF/LI I 0311580SMl02H+ 0. 2 1 1. 0 i 11461 61 11 11361 561999991 H IF/LIF/LI i 0311580SMITSH+ 0. 5 1 1.61 11451 71 11 l 3.61 11511 41 11 11371 451000601 H IF/LIF/LI I 0301580SMITSH+ 1. 7 I 11371 751999591 H IF/LIF/Lt I 0301580SMITSH+ 1. 8 1 0.71 11481 7i 11 11376 971000601 H IF/LIF/LI I 0301580SM109H+ 0. 0 1 6.81 11441 ill 11 11381 201999991 H IF/LIF/LI I 0291580SMITSC+ 4. 8 1 1.71 11451 81 11 1 I I iH IF/LIF/LI i 0291580SMITSC+ 3.1 1 1.01 11501 31 11 11381 241999991 H IF/LiF/LI I 029tS80SMITSH+ 5. 3 1 0.91 11431 101 11 l l l 1 i H IF/LIF/LI 1 0291580SMITSH+ 6. 5 1 0.71 11421 ill 11 1 I i i H iF/LIF/Li 1 0291580SM101C+ 0. 5 I 0.51 11351 191 il l i 0291580SMITSH+ 6. 8 1.21 11481 51 11 I 11381 301999991 H IF/LIF/LI 1 l 1 1 I I H IF/LIF/LI I 0296580SMITSH+ 7.1 1 1.01 11501 31 11 l 11381 321999991 H IF/LIF/LI i 0291580SMl02H+ 0. 0 1 1.21 11511 21 il l I I ( l H IF/LIF/L1 1 029tS80SM103H+ 0. 0 1 0.51 11431 101 11 i I i i H IF/LIF/LI i 0291580SM103C+ 0. 0 1 1.61 11451 81 il 11381 361999991 H IF/LIF/LI I 0291580SMITSH+ 0. 6 1 3. 9 ' 11391 141 11 l i i i i i i i i i a 1 i I i i i l

FLORIDA POWER 4 LIGHT COMPANY

CUMULATIVE REPORT 02/87, ST. LUCIE S/G A, UNIT 1 PAGE: 10 OF 11 STEAM GENERATOR: A LOCATION: ALL DATE: 08/20/87 CRITERIA: 1% TO 19% TIME: 10:58:24

~

i l IE$ TENT I l I i l CURRENT 1 l l ILINIROWlHEAT#1LEGIREQlTSTlREMIREELIPROBEl LOCATION IVOLTSIMILIDEGI % ICHI i I i i i l 1 i I I i 1 i l I I 11381 481000601 H IF/LIF/LI I 0291500SMITSH+ 1.1 1 2. 7 I (1391 141 11 11391 331999991 H IF/LIF/LI I 0281580SMITSH+ 1. 8 1 1.71 11381 181 il i 11391 43 999991 H IF/LIF/LI I 0291580SMITSH+ 1. 4 1 2.11 11431 101 11 l 1 1 I i H IF/LIF/L1 1 0291580SMITSH+ 2. 8 l 2.21 11421 111 11 l 11391 451999991 H IF/LIF/LI i 0291580SMITSH+ 1.1 1 2.81 11431 101 11 l 1 1 I l H IF/LIF/LI I 0291580SMITSH+ 2. 7 l 1,61 11461 71 11 j 11391 671999991 H IF/LIF/LI I 0291580SM101H+ 0. 0 1 1.01 11431 101 11 11391 971000111 H IF/LIF/LI I 0291580SMl09H+ 0. 0 1 1.81 11381 151 11 11401 321999991 H IF/LIF/Li 1 0281580SMITSH+ 1. 9 1 2.71 11391 161 il i I i i H IF/LIF/LI l 0281580SM ITSH+ 4. 4 1 1.81 11401 151 11 11401 361999991 H IF/LIF/LI i 0281580SMITSH+ 0. 6 1 2.21 11471 G1 il 11401 561999991 H IF/LIF/L1 1 0281580SMITSH+ 1. 7 1 1.01 11421 131 11 11401 781999991 H IF/LIF/LI 0281580SMITSH+ 0. 5 l 1.01 11461 91 il 1142l 241999991 H IF/LIF/LI i 0271580SM101C+ 0. 6 1 0.71 11421 91 11 11421 321999991 H IF/LIF/L1 1 0271580SM101C+ 0. 0 1 1.51 11461 51 il 11421 341999991 H IF/LIF/L1 1 0271580SMITSH+ 0. 8 1 0.81 11431 81 11 11421 461999991 H IF/LIF/L1 1 0271580SMITSH+ 0. 6 1 1.51 11471 41 il 11421 481999991 H IF/LIF/L1 1 0271580SMITSH+ 0. 8 1 1.31 11501 11 11 11421 501999991 H IF/LIF/LI 1 0271580SMITSH+ 2. 3 1 1.71 11501 11 11 61421 521999991 H IF/LIF/Lt 1 0271580SMITSH+ 1. 5 i 1.11 11371 141 11 11421 601999991 H lF/LIF/LI I 0261580SM104H+ 0. 0 1 1.31 11211 171 SI 11431 311999991 H IF/LIF/L1 1 026l580SMITSH+ 0. 4 1 3.31 t1491 91 11 11431 711999991 H IF/LIF/LI i 0261580SM105H+ 0. 0 1 1.61 11471 ill il 11431 971000111 H IF/LIF/LI I 0261580SMl09H 0.00 1 1.41 11231 141 51 11441 321999991 H IF/LIF/LI I 0251580SMITSH+ 0. 7 1 1.61 11361 181 11 1 1 1 i H IF/LIF/LI i 0251580SMITSH+ 1. 9 l 2.91 11361 181 il 11441 481999991 H IF/LIF/LI I 0251580SMITSH+ 1. 5 l 2.21 11371 171 11 11451 511999991 H IF/LIF/L1 1 0251580SMITSH+ 0. 7 1 2.21 11411 141 il 11461 121000411 H IF/LIF/Li I 0241580SMl01C- 0. 4 1 1.21 11551 il 11 11461 481999991 H IF/LIF/LI I 0241580SMl02H+ 0. 2 1 1.11 11361 191 11 11471 EE'.999991 H IF/LIF/Lt t 0241580SM103H- 0. 3 1 0.91 11481 81 11 11471 671999991 H IF/LIF/LI I 024I580SM103H+ 0. 5 1 0.81 11401 161 11 11471 711999991 H IF/LtF/LI I 0241580SM102C+ 29.7 1 1.11 11521 41 11 11471 731999991 H IF/LIF/LI I O241580SM103H- 0. 5 1 1.81 11461 101 il 11471 751999991 H I F/LIF /L I I 0241580SM103H+ 0. 3 1 0. 7 I 11501 61 11 1148) 401999991 H IF/LIF/L1 1 0231580SMITSH+ 1. 2 1 1.01 11461 101 il (1481 741999991 H IF/LIF/LI i 0231580SM103H+ 27.4 1 1.21 11531 31 11 11491 271999991 H IF/LIF/LI I 0221580SM103H+ 0. 0 1 1.61 11371 181 il (1491 33199999I H IF/LIF/LI I 0221580SM101h+ 0. 0 1 0.61 11471 91 il 11501 401999991 H IF/LIF/LI i 0221580SM102H+ 0. 0 1 1,01 11431 131 il 1150I 461999991 H IF/LIF/LI i 0221580SM102H+ 0. 0 1 0.81 11421 141 11 11531 51000111 H 107CIO6Cl 1 0551580SM103H+ 0. 4 1 2.11 11501 il il 11561 601999991 H IF/LIF/LI I 0191580SM101H+ 0. 8 1 1.61 11531 38 11 11571 231999991 H IF/LIF/L1 1 0191580SM101C+ 31.0 1 0.81 11441 121 11 11591 15l000441 H lF/LIF/LI I 0181580SM10$H+ 0. 4 1 0.61 11321 181 il l i I i t i I i i l I i i i t FLORIDA POWER & LIGHT COMPANY

I.

CUMULATIVE REPORT j 02/87, ST, LUCIE S/G A, UNIT 1 STEAM GENERATOR: A PAGE: 11 OF 11 LOCATION: ALL DATE: 08/20/87 CRITERIA: 1% TO 19% TIME: 10:58:24 1 L.IN I ROW I HEAT # 1 LEG l REQ l TST I REM I REEL I PROBE i LOCATION iVOLTB(MILIDEGI % iCHl 1___ I ___ I _____1___ I ___ I __ I ___ l . -l- l___________ i .I I I I I 11601 401999991 H IF/LIF/LI i 0181580SM101H- 0. 5 1 0.51 11371 121 li 11611 211000601 H IF/LIF/Li I 0171580SMl01H+ 0. 5 1 2.11 .l142l 151 11 l i -l I I I i l l___1__ i_____1___I___I___1___i - 1 ____

l 393 l l NUMBER OF TUBES SELECTED FROM CURRENT OUTAGE:

l NO TREND ANALYSIS REQUESTED 1

L 1

l -

J i f j i )

)

l l

FLORIDA POWER 8 LIGHT COMPANY

CUMULATIVE REPORT 82/87, ST. LUCIE S/G A, UNIT 1 STEAM GENERATOR A PAGE: 1 0F 8 LOCATION: ALL DATE: 08/20/87 CRITERIA: 20% TO 39% TIME: 11:08:06

~

l~~~i~~~l ~~i~ IE5TENTI Tl I i ~~i CURRENT l ILINIROWlHEAT#1LEGIREQlTSTIREMIREEllPROBEl LOCATION IVOLTSIMILIDEGI % ICHI

'l I i ! I I I I I _

i i l i i i 1 l- 61 441999991 C IF/LIF/Li 1 0141580SMITSH+ 29.9 I 0.41 11181 361 11 1 121 141000221 C IF/LIF/Lt 1 0161580SM101H+ 0. 8 l 1.51 11201 361 il i 121 521999991 C IF/LIF/Lt I 0161580SM101H- 0. 8 1 0.71 11301 261 11 1 151 411999991 C IF/LIF/LI l 0171580SFl03H- 0. 5 l 1.71 1133l all il i 151 651999991 C IF/LIF/L1 1 0171580SFl01H+ 0. 4 1 0.71 11281 261 11 1 171 19l000431 C IF/LIF/LI I 0171580SF101H- 0. 3 1 0.61 11291 251 il

~1 181 21000601 H 107C106Cl 1 06315805M101H+ 0. 0 1 1.41 11291 231 il i 201 161000601 C IF/LIF/Lt i 0191580SMITSH+ 1. 3 1 2.81 11311 241 11 1 20l'321999991 C IF/LIF/L1 1 0191580SMITSH+ 0. 6 1 0.71 11171 371 11-l 218 191000431 C IF/LIF/LI I 0191580SMIO1H-- 0. 6 1 1.11 11211 331 il 1 221 221999991 C IF/LIF/Li ! 0201580SMITSH+ 1. 8 1 0.71 11161 361 11 i 231 191000431 C IF/LIF/LI 1 0201580SMITSH+ 5. 6 1 1.31 1132l 201 il 1 231 251999991- C IF/LIF/L1 1 0201580SMl01H- 0. 5 1 0.91 11271 251 il i 251 211000601 C IF/LIF/LI I 0211580SMITSH+ 1. 9 I 2.11 1134l 241 il 1 261 401999991 C IF/LIF/L1 1 0221580SMITSH+ 0. 4 l 1.11 11191 331 11 1 261 801000411 C'IF/LIF/Li 1 0221580SMl04H- 0.30 1 0.81 11351 261 il i 291 551999991 C IF/LIF/LI I 0241580SFITSH+ 0. 5 1 2.01 1135l 221 11 1 291 67t000501 C IF/LIF/LI I 0241580SF102H- 0. 5 I 1.61 11221 361 11 1 2981051000601 C IF/LIF/LI i 0241580SFl06C+ 1. 4 1 2.11 11201 381 Il I i i l C IF/LIF/LI I 0241580SFITSC+ 12.5 1 3.11 1 91 221 il

! 321 801000421 C IF/LIF/L1 1 0251580SF101H+ 0. 6 1 0.81 11251 291 11 1 331 331000601 C IF/LIF/LI I 0261580SM103H+ 0. 6 l 1.31 11351 231 11 l 341 121000221 C IF/LIF/LI I 0271580SM101H+ 0. 5 1 0.51 11251 331 11 1 341 14l000221 C IF/LIF/L! l 0271580SM101H- 0. 6 1 1.01 11361 Bil 11 1 341 401999991 C IF/LIF/L1 1 0271580SM105H+ 22.8 1 1.11 11371 201 11 1 351 651000601 C IF/LIF/Lt 1 0271580SMITSH+ 0.8 1 0.71 11301 281 il t 351 791999991 C IF/LIF/LI i 027!580SMITSH+ 1.1 1 0.51 11241 341 il I 3511011000601 C IF/LIF/LI I 0271580SM109C+ 0. 0 1 1.81 11371 201 11 1 361 181000431 C IF/LIF/Li 1 02Bl580SMl02C+ 0.1 1 1.51 11171 391 11 1 361 281999991 C IF/LIF/L1 I 0281580SMITSC+ 5. 9 1 0.91 11261 301 il 1 371 751000601 C IF/LIF/LI 1 0281580SM101H+ 0. 0 1 1.81 11271 291 il 1 371 931000431 C IF/LIF/LI I 0291580SM101H- 0. 2 1 0.61 1135l 211 11 l 381 401000601 C IF/LIF/LI i 0291580SMITSH+ 0. 7 1 1.91 11291 271 11 !

l 386 681000601 C IF/LIF/LI i 0291580SM101H- 0. 2 1 1.41 11351 211 18 I 38l 761999991 C IF/LIF/LI I 0291580SMITSH+ 2. 4 1 0.81 l1351 211 11 1 381 981000431 C IF/LIF/LI I 0291580SMIBW2+ 0. 0 1 0.41 11298 271 11 ),

1 391 13100022l C IF/LIF/LI I 0301580SMIO2H+ 0. 0 1 1.51 11331 231 11 ;

I 391'191000601 C IF/LIF/Lt 1 0301580SMITSC+ 4. 5 1 0.91 11291 271 11 l 1 391 391000601 C IF/LIF/L1 1 0301580SMITSH+ 5. 7 1 1.31 11251 311 11 (

l 391 41100060i C IF/LIF/LI I 0301580SM105H+ 0. 0 1 0.91 11101 221 Si j l 3911111000431 C IF/LIF/Lt i ^^~:580SMIO1H+ 0. 2 1 0.51 11331 231 11 1 401 441000601 C IF/LIF/LI I 0311580sMITSC+ 0. 7 1 2.31 11351 211 11 1 4011061000601 C IF/LIF/LI I 0301580SM109C+ 0. 0 t 1.41 11361 201 11 I 411 71000211 C 107Hf06HI I 002t380SDIBW3+ 0. 0 l 1.71 11171 381 11 1 411 591000601 C IF/LIF/L1 1 0311580SMITSH+ 0. 6 I 3. 8 l 11361 201 11 i i i ___ i ___ t _i___i___'___i___.____i_____i___________________i_____i___i___i l

l l

l FLORIDA POWER & LIGHT COMPANY I i

_ - - _ _ _ _ _ _ _ -_- _ i

7 -_ _ _ _ - - _ _ _

CUMULATIVE REPORT 02/87, ST. LUCld S/G A, UNIT 1 STEAM GENERATOR: A PAGE: 2 OF 8 LOCATION: ALL DATES- 08/20/87

' CRITERIA: 20% TO 39% TIME: 11:08:06

~~ ~~ ~

.i~~~[~~~g ~[~~ IEXTENT I I ~i~~~~~l i CURRENT l i ILINIROWlHEAT#1LEGIREQlTSTlREMIREELlPROBEl LOCATION IVOLTSIMILIDEGI % ICHI i i_____I___1___i___i__i i t___i___i_____i___i___i___i___i____i -- 11311 251 11 1 All 891000601 C IF/LIF/L1 1 0311580SMITSH+ 1. 0 1 1.11 1 1 1 1 C IF/LIF/L1 1 0311580SMITSH+ 1. 4 1 1.91 1134l 221 11 ,

t 421 701999991 H IF/LIF/LI I 0651580SMITSH+ 3. 4 1 0.81 11221 331 11 1 I l I H IF/LIF/LI I 0651580SMITSH+ 4. 3 1 1.21 11231 321 11 1 421 961000441 H IF/LIF/LI I 0651580SM109C+ 0. 0 1 1,41 i1151 391 11 1 421100100044l H IF/LIF/L! l 0651580SMIO9C+ 0. 0 1 1.91 11231 321 il I 431 3310E0501 H 1F/LIF/L1 1 0651580SM101H- 0. 4 l 1.31 11351 201 11 1 441 721000601 C IF/LIF/LI l 0331580SMITSH+ 3. 8 1 1.61 11331 231 11 1 441 961000441 C IF/LIF/LI I 0331580SMIBW3- 3. 0 1 0.71 11231 321 il I 441 981000441 C IF/LIF/LI i 0331580SMITSH+ 0. 8 1 2.71 11241 311 il I 4411001000441 C (F/LIF/Lt 1 0331580SM ITSH+ 0. 3 1 0.91 11321 241 il i 1 1 l C IF/LIF/Li 1 0336580SM109C+ 0.1 1 1.31 11261 301 il I 4411041000601 C IF/LIF/L1 l 0331580SM109C+ 0. 0 1 1.81 11231 321 11 1 4411081000441 C IF/LIF/LI i 0331580SM109C+ 0.1 - 1 1.81 11291 271 il i 451 151000421 C IF/LIF/LI i 0341580SM403H+ 0. 0 1 0.71 11231 321 11 I I I I C IF/LIF/Lt 1 0341580$M105H+ 0. 0 l 0.51 11251 301 it i 1 451 291000601 C lF/LIF/Lt 1 0341580SM101H+ 0. 4 1 0.61 11361 201 il l 1 451 951000441 C IF/LIF/L1 1 0341580SMIO9H+ 0. 0 1 1.01 11281 281 11 1 1 4511211000441 C IF/LIF/LI I 0341580SM109H+ 0. 0 1 0.81 11351 211 il

! 461 961000441 C IF/LIF/LI 1 0341580SM109H+ 0. 0 1 1.61 11261 301 il 4 I 4611001000441 C IF/LIF/LI 1 0341580$M109C+ 0. 0 1 1.31 11271 291 11 I l' I 471 551000601 H IF/LIF/LI 1 0161580SMITSH+ 1.1 1 1.91 11111 231 Si !

l 471113 000501 C IF/LIF/LI I 0351580SM109H+ 0. 0 '

O.81 11221 321 11 l 1 481 14100022l H IF/LIF/L1 l 0151580SMl04H+ 0. 4 3.81 11371 211 11 i l 0. 0 1.01 11321 231 11 j l 4811061999991 C IF/LIF/LI I 0351580SMl09H+ i

! l 491 211000601 H IF/LIF/LI i 0151580SMITSH+ 4. 5 1 4.21 11261 301 11 1 4911111999991 C IF/LIF/LI I 0351580SM109H+ 0. 0 1 1.01 11351 201 11 :

I 501 4199999: H 107C106Cl 1 0641580SMl01H+ 0. 0 1 1.31 11251 301 11 1 501 981999991 C (F/LIF/Lt ! 0361580SMITSH+ 1. 2 1 0.71 11311 251 il I i ! l C IF/LIF/LI 1 0361580SMITSH+ 2. 6 1 0.91 11171 381 11 I i i i C IF/LIF/LI 1 0361580SM109C+ 0. 0 1 1.11 11161 391 11 1 5011001999991 C IF/LIF/LI I 036l580SMIO9C+ 0. 0 1 1.11 11321 241 11 1 511 15l000421 H IF/LIF/L1 1 014l580SM102H+ 0. 2 i 1.31 11261 281 11 1 5111071000501 C IF/LIF/LI I 0361580SM109H+ 0. 0 1 1.71 I1341 221 il I 521 281000601 H IF/LIF/LI i 0131580SMl01H- 0. 4 1 1.41 1125l 291 il I 521 901999991 C IF/LIF/LI i 0361580SMITSH+ 4. 9 1 1.01 11351 211 il I 521 961000601 C IF/LIF/Lt 1 0361580SMITSH+ 2.1 1 1.11 11331 231 il i 5211001000601 C IF/LIF/LI i 0361580SM109H+ 0. 0 1 1.31 11291 271 il

f. I 54l 21999991 H 107Cf06Cl 1 0641580SM101H+ 0.1 1 1.21 11351 201 11 1 I 541 901999991 C IF/LIF/Lt i 0371580SMITSH+ 1. 2 l 1.41 11311 241 il l 548 94100060t C IF/LIF/LI I 0371580SMITSH+ 0. 7 1 0.81 11281 271 il l 1 0121580SMITSH+ 0. 9 2.71 11311 251 il t

1 551 331000601 H IF/LIF/L1 1 i 551 791999991 H IF/LIF/L1 1 0121580SM101H- 0. 7 l 1.11 11321 241 11

)' 0.91 11291 291 11 l 1 5511211000501 C IF/LIF/LI 1 0381580RM104C+ 21.3 1 1 561 961000501 H IF/LIF/LI 1 0461580SMl09C+ 0. 0 1 1.41 11201 321 11 1 I i 1 1 I I i 1 I I I I i i 1

FLORIDA POWER & LIGHT COMPANY

r..

CUMULATIVE REPORT 02/87, S T. LUCIE S/G A, UNIT 1 I

STEAM GENERATOR: A PAGE: 3 OF 8 LOCATION: ALL DATE: 08/20/87 CRITERIA: 20% TO 39% TIME: 11:08:06 l

~

1 I~~~I~ I IEXTENT I ~~I'~~~T l l CURRENT I ILINIROWlHEAT#1LEGIREQlTSTlREMIREEllPROBEl LOCATION IVOLTSIMILIDEGI % ICHI i l I i l i i i i i ! i 1 1 1 1 1 561 961000501 H IF/LIF/LI I 0461580SM109C+ 0. 0 1 2.11 11181 341 11 1 571 311999991 H IF/LITSCIRITI 0111580SM103H+ 0. 4 1 0.91 11231 321 11

,! 581 221999991 H IF/LIF/LI I 0111580SMITSC+ 6. 5 i 1.71 11331 231 11 1 581 961000601 H IF/LIF/L1 1 0471580SMITSH+ 0. 7 1 3.51 11231 311 11 I I I I H IF/LIF/LI 1 0471580SMITSH+ 2. 8 1 0.71 11151 381 11 1 591 451999991 H IF/LITSC'RITI 0101580SD103H+ 0. 2 1 0. 9 I 11291 221 11 1 5911191999991 H IF/LIF/LI i 0471580SM101H+ 0. 0 l 1.01 11301 251 il I 601 181000601 H IF/LIF/LI I 0101580SDl02H+ 0. 0 l 1.81 11221 291 il I 601 381000601 H IF/LITSCl RITI 0091580SMITSH+ 4. 3 1 1.51 1131l 211 11 4 1 601 421999991 H iT/LITSCIRIT! 0091580SM103H- 0. 5 1 0.51 11301 221 11 .

I 601 76199999! H IF/LIF/LI I 0091580SM102C+ 0. 5 1 0.71 11251 278 11 k I 601100l000501 H IF/LIF/L1 1 0471580SM109C+ 0. 0 l 1,91 11141 391 11 f I i i H IF/LIF/Li(R)I 0681580RM103C+ 0. 0 1 1.91 11141 391 11 I

0.61 11271 271 11 {

l 6011081000501 H IF/LIF/LI i 0471580SMITSH+ 1. 7 1 1 611 431000411 H IF/LIF/LI i 0091580SM104H- 0. 5 1 0.51 11321 201 11 1 611 471000411 H IF/LIF/LI i 0091580SMITSH+ 0. 7 1 0.91 11221 301 il I 6111011000601 H IF/LIF/LI i 0481580SMl09C 0.00 1 1.51 11351 201 11 1 621 281000411 H IF/LIF/LI 1 0081580SMl02H- 0. 2 1 0.61 11221 291 il I 6211101000601 H IF/LIF/LI I 0481580SMITSH+ 0. 6 1 0.81 11291 261 !!

l 1 631 431000411 H IF/LIF/LI 1 0081580SM102H+ 0. 4 1 1.11 L1241 271 11 1 631 891999991 H IF/LIF/LI i 0491580$MITSH+ 3. 7 1 0.51 11261 261 11 l

l 6311011000601 H IF/LIF/LI 1 0491580SMITSH+ 3. 4 1 1.21 11291 231 il i I I I H IF/LIF/LI I 0481580SMITSH+ 3. 6 1 1.21 11301 251 11 l 1 6311271999991 H IF/LIF/LI i 0481580SMl09C+ 0. 0 1 1.21 11321 231 11 l l 644 881999991 H IF/LIF/LI i 0491580SMITSH+ 0. 3 1 1.11 11281 241 11 j i 64l 941999991 H 1F/LIF/LI i 0491580SM101H+ 0. 0 1 0.81 11311 211 11 1

1 651 391000601 H I F/L ITSC I RIT I 007t5o0SMl03H+ 0. 3 1 1.91 11281 231 11 1 651 811999991 H IF/LIF/LI i 0501580SMITSH+ 1. 0 1 1.31 11281 251 11 1 6511011999991 H IF/LIF/LI I 0491580SM102H+ 0. 0 1 1.51 11201 321 11 1 661 881999991 H IF/LIF/LI l 0501580SMITSH+ 0. 5 1 0.81 11151 371 11 1 661 961999991 H IF/LIF/LI 1 0501580SM109C+ 0. 0 1 1.41 11151 371 11 1 6611081999991 H IF/LIF/LI l 0501580SM1090+ 0. 0 1 2.01 11321 211 11 1 6611101000601 H IF/LIF/Lt t 0501580SM109H+ 0. 0 1 3.91 11291 24l 11 1 671 471000601 H IF/LIF/Lt 1 0061580SM104H+ 0. 3 1 1.01 11331 201 11 1 671 934200501 H IF/LIF/LI I 0501580SM109C+ 0. 0 1 1.71 1129: 241 11 1 671113h000501 H IF/LIF/LI i 0501580SM109H+ 0. 0 1 3.01 11251 281 11 1 6711271999991 H IF/LIF/L1 1 0506580SMIO9C+ 0. 0 1 1.01 11301 231 il i G81 441200601 H IF/LIF/LI I 0051580BMITSC+ 6. 0 1 1.01 11081 201 il 2 681 481200211 H IF/LIF/Lt 1 0051580SMITSC+ 5. 3 1 0.81 (1321 221 11 '

I 681 96l200601 H IF/LIF/L1 1 051!580SM1094+ 0. 0 1 4.61 11321 231 11 l i H li/LIF/Ll(R) 1 0681580SM109H+ 0. 0 1 4.61 11321 231 11

[ I

0. 0 2.41 11221 331 il 1 1 I l H If/LIF/Lt 1 0511580SMl09C+ 1 I I I 1 I H IF /LIF/L i (R) I 0681580SM109C+ 0. 0 1 2.41 11221 331 11 l 1 6811061999991 H IF /LIF/LI I 0511580SM109C+ 0. 0 1 1.91 11291 261 11 l l 691 391000601 H IF/LIF/LI i 005 580SMITSH+ 0. 5 1 3. 2 t 11341 20! 11 I I I I I I i 1 I I I I I I I 1

FLORIDA POWER & LIGHT COMPANY

l CUMULATIVE REPORT 02/87, ST. LUCIE S/G A, UNIT 1 STEAM GENERATOR: A- PAGE: 4 0F 8 LOCATION: ALL- DATE: 08/20/87 CRITERIA: 20% TO 39% TIMES. 11:08:06 I ,1 1 1 IEXTENT I I I I l ~~~~~~ CURRENT I 2 ILINIROWlHEAT#1LEGIREQlTSTIREMIREELlPROBEl LOCATION IVOLTSIMILIDEGI % ICHI i 1 I I l ___ l ___ I ___1___1___ _ I _ _I_ _ _ _ ___I_____I___I___I___1__l !

l 691 531000211 H IF/LIF/LI I 0051580SMl01H+ 0. 4 1 0.81 11331 211 11 ]

1 6911131000501 H IF/LIF/LI 1 0511580SMITSH+ 2. 4 1 1.11 11281 271 il i 701 621000211 H IF/LIF/Lt 1 0041580SDITSC+ 5. 0 1 1.21 11321 231 11 l 701 961000601 H IF/LIF/Lt 1 0511580SMITSH+ 0. 6 1 3.41 11301 261 il f i 7011221000601 H lF/LIF/LI i 0521580SM109H+ 0. 0 1 4.11 11271 281 11 }

l'711-571000601 H IF/LIF/LI I 0041580SDITSC+ 4. 8 l 1.9i 11271 281 11

4. 9 1.01 11181 341 al {

l 731 63100011l H IF/LIF/LI i 0031580SDITSC+ 1 I 751 451999991 H IF/LIF/LI I 0031580SD104H+ 0. 8 1 1.61 11311 211 11.

I 751 931999954 H IF/LIF/L1 1 0541580SM109C+ 0. 0 1 2.21 11291 261 11

'l 7511331999991 H IF/LtF/LI i 0541580SM109C+ 0. 0 1 1.91 11261 291 il j i 7611061999991 H'IF/LIF/L1 1 0591580SM109H+ 0. 0 1 1.21 11191 361 11 i

1 771 391000601 H IF/LIF/LI I 0591580SMITSH+ 1. 3 1 2. 0 ! 11241 311 it I 771 491999991 H IF/LIF/LI i 0591580SM104H- 0. 3 1 0.91 1135l 211 11 I 771 731000601 H IF/LIF/L1 1 0591580SMITSH+ 7. 5 1 0.91 11181 371 11 1 771 811999991 H IF/LIF/LI 1 0591580SMITSH+ 1. 0 1 0.91 1134l 221 il I 7711031999991 H IF/LIF/LI i 0591580SMITSH+ 5. 3 1 1.21 1135l 211 11 I 791 391999991 H IF/LIF/LI I 0581580SMITSH+ 1. 7 1 1.01 11281 271 11 I 7911111000601 H IF/LIF/LI I 0571580SMITSH+ 0. 8 1 0.91 11271 251 Il I 7911231999991 H IF/LIF/LI 1 0571580SMl09H+ 0. 0 1 0.81 11311 211 il I 7911391000501 H IF/LIF/LI 1 0571580SM109C+ 0. 0 1 1.51 11181 341 il i I l i H IF/Ll09Hl(R)1 0681580SMl09C+ 0. 0 l 1.51 11181 341 il 1 801110l000501 H IF/LIF/L1 I 0571580SM109C+ 0. 0 1 1.91 11211 311 11 I 8011181999991 H IF/LIF/LI I 0571580SMl09H+ 0. 0 1 0.71 1124l 281 11 8011321999991 H IF/LIF/Lt 1 0571580SM109C+ 0. 0 1 1.11 11301 221 il 1 8111171000501 H IF/LIF/LI i 0561580SM109C+ 0. 0 1 2.21 11171 301 11 1 821 58l999991 C IF/LIF/LI I 0481580SMITSH+ 1.1 1 1.31 11251 301 11 I 834 511999991 C IF/LIF/LI I 0471580SMl02H+ 0. 4 l 1.41 11291 241 11 1 831 731000601 C IF/LIF/LI I 0471580SMITSC+ 0. 5 1 2.51 11321 211 il 1 8311191999991 C IF/LIF/LI 1 0471580SM109C+ 0. 0 1 2.51 1133l 201 il 1 8411001999991 C IF/LIF/LI 1 0461580SM109C+ 0. 0 1 1.01 11311 271 il I 861 401000601 C IF/LIF/LI I 0441580SMITSH+ 2. 6 1 1.41 11261 321 11 1 861 441000601 C IF/LIF/Lt 1 0451580SMITSH+ 0. 9 l 1.31 11241 341 11 I 861 461999991 C IF/LIF/L1 1 0451580SMITSC+ 5. 7 1 1.11 11391 201 il I 861 601999991 C IF/LIF/L1 1 0451580SMITSH+ 6. 3 1 1.31 11301 281 11 1 I I I C IF/LIF/LI i 0451580SMITSH+ 6. 5 1 0.51 11301 281 11 ,

i 861 961000601 C IF/LIF/LI I 0451580SMITSH+ o0.0 1 1.31 11201 381 11 l.8611201000601 C IF/LIF/LI i 0451580SM109C+ 0, 0 1 1.71 11271 311 11 1 871 391999991 C IF/LIF/L1 1 0441580$M101H+ 0. 0 1 0.61 11311 271 11 1 871 511000601 C IF/LIF/LI I 0441580SM103H+ 0. 0 1 1.01 11331 261 11 1 871 531999991 C IF/LIF/L1 1 0441580SM105H+ 0. 0 1 1.11 11371 221 11 I 871 611999991 C IF/LIF/Li 1 0441580SM103H- 0. 5 1 0.81 11371 221 11 1 871 631999991 C IF/LIF/LI I 0441580SM101H+ 19.7 1D I 2.91 1 91 221 11 1 881 621000601 C IF/LIF/LI I 0531580SMITSH+ 5. 0 1 0.51 11351 201 11 1 881134t999991 C IF/LIF/LI 1 0531580SM1094+ 0. 0 1 1.71 11351 201 11 1 B?i 471000601 C lF/LIF/LI I 0521580SMITSC+ 5. 3 1 1.71 11371 211 11 1 i i i i i i l_ _t i __

l i i I I i l

FLORIDA POWER & LIGHT COMPANY t

L _ _ _ . _ _ _ _ _

y; CUMULATIVE REPORT )

02/37, ST. LUCIE .S/G. A, UNIT 1 STEAM GENERATOR: a PAGE: 5 0F 8 LOCATION 'ALL ~DATE: 08/20/87

' CRITERIA: 20% TO 39% TIME: 11:08:06

=- __________

~1 I I I IEXTENT I I I I l CURRENT I (LINIROWlHEAT#1LEGIREQlTSTIREMIREELlPROBEl LOCATION- IVOLTSIMILIDEGI % ICHI !

i___i___i_____1___i___i___i___i____i i _ __ _i_____i___i___1___i__i i 1 891 971999991 C IF/LIF/LI i 0521580SM109C+ 0. 0 't 1.31 1134l 24l'11 I 1 891-991000601 C IF/LIF/L1 1 0521580SM109H+ 0. 0 1 1.51 11301 271 il i 1 8911011000601~C IF/LIF/LI I 0521560SMl09H+ 'O. 0 1 4.01 11261 311 11 1 8911071999991 C IF/LIF/L1 1 0521580SM102H- 0. 6 l 1.61 11201 361 il I 901 941999991- C IF/LIF/LI i 0511580SMITSH+ 1.0 1 1.21 11291 241 11 I 9011041999991 C IF/LIF/L1 1 0511580SM109C+ 0. 0 ' 1 0.81 11251 281 il _

l 9011161999991 C IF/LIF/LI i 0521580SMITSH+ 0. 6 1 0.61 11251 321 11 I 911 951000601 C IF/LIF/L1 1 0501580SM109H+ 0. 0 1 1.91 11261 291 11 1 931 931000601 C'IF/LIF/LI 'l 0491580SM101H- 0. 2 1 1.41 11291 26l 11 1 9411021999991 C IF/LIF/LI 1 0431580SMl09H+ 0. 0 1 3.01 11231 321 11 1 9411241000501 C IF/LiF/Li I 0441580SM109H+ 0. 0 l 1.51 (1361 231 il I 9411341000601 C IF/LIF/Lt 1 0441580SM109C+ 0. 0 1 2.11 11271 318 il I 971 61l000506 C IF/LIF/LI 1 0121580SFl01C+ 0. 3 1 0.71 11331 211 it' I 9711051999991 C IF/LIF/L1- 1 0421580SM109H+ 0. 0 1 1.51 11361 211 il I 981 581999991 C IF/LtF/L1 I 0121580SF4TSH+ 3. 8 1 1.71 11211 331 11 1 981 94100060f C IF/LIF/Lt 1 0421580SM101H+ 0. 2 1 1.11 11271 291 11 1 9811001000676 s. IF/LIF/LI i 0421580SMITSH+ 1. 7 1 1. 8 ! 11311 251 il l I I i C'lF/LIF/LI I 0421580SMITSH+ 2. 0 1 1.01 1135l 221 il 1 9811201999991 C IF/LIF/LI I 0421580SMl09C+ 0. 0 1 1.21 11181 361 11 11011 331999991 C IF/LIF/Li 1 0111580SM101H+ 0. 4 1 1.21 1132l 231 il 11021 361999991 C IF/LtF/LI I 0111580SMITSH+ 1.0 1 0.51 11231 311 11 11021 401000608 C IF/LIF/LI I 0111580SMITSH+ 1. 6 1 0.51 11201 331 il 11031 731000501 C IF/LIF/Li 1 0191580SMITSH+ 4. 8 l 1.61 11341 211 11 11041 32l999991 C IF/LITSHIRITI 0101580SMITSH+ 0. 4 1 0.91 11211 331 11 11041 961000501 C IF/LIF/LI i 0391580SMITSH+ 1. 7 1 1.11 11281 261 il 11051 171000441 C IF/LIF/LI I 0101580SM101H+ 0. 2 1 0.81 11201 331 11 11051 411000601 C IF/LITSHIRITI 0101580SM101H+ 0. 0 1 1.11 11191 341 11 11051 551999991 C IF/LIF/LI 1 0091580SM103H+ 0. 2 l 1.51 11351 201 il 11051 771999991 C IF/LIF/LI i 0091580SM101H+ 0. 5 1 0.91 1124l 301 11 11071 751999991 C IF/LIF/LI I 0091580SM102H+ 0. 3 1 0.71 11271 271 11 11081 141000411 C IF/LIF/L) 1 0081580SM104H+ 0. 0 1 0.61 11241 321 11 11081 981999991 H IF/LIF/LI I 0451580SMITSH+ 1. 2 1 1.51 11271 25l il 110811101999991 H IF/LIF/LI I 0451580SMITSH+ 0. 8 1 1.11 11271 251 11 11091 291000601 C IF/LIF/LI 1 0081580SM106H+ 0. 0 1 1.01 11351 211 il 110911031999991 H IF/LIF/LI I 0451580SMITSH+ 0. 9 1 1.51 11151 371 11 11101 501999991 C IF/LIF/LI i 0081580SMITSH+ 7. 2 1 1.81 1 981 331 51 111011041999991 H IF/LIF/LI I 0441580SMITSH+ 0. 9 l 1.71 1131l 241 11 11111 51000111 H 107Cl06Cl 1 0021580SDl02H+ 0.60 1 0.81 11241 281 il 11111 991999991 H IF/LIF/Li 1 0441580SMl09C+ 0. 0 1 1.51 11311 241 11 111111311999991 H IF/LIF/LI I 0441580SMl09C+ 0. 0 1 1.11 11241 311 11 11121 241999991 C IF/LIF/Li 1 0071580SMl03H+ 0. 7 1 0.81 11241 311 11 111211001999991 H IF/LIF/LI I 0431580SMITSH+ 0. 9 I 1.61 11301 all 11 l

i 11131 851000601 H IF/LIF/L1 1 0431580SMITSH+ 0. 6 l 1.71 11311 201 11 1 I i 1 H IF/LIF/Lt 1 0431580SMITSH+ 3. 6 1 0.91 11281 231 11 111411001999991 H IF/L1F/Lt 1 0421580SMITSH+ 1. 8 1 0.61 11211 341 11 l l 1 i i i l i i i i i I i l I l

L FLORIDA POWER & LIGHT COMPANY

CUMULATIVE REPORT 02/87, ST. LUCIE S/G A, UNIT 1 l

' STEAM GENERATOR: A PAGE: 6 0F 8 LOCATION: ALL DATE: 08/20/87

-CRITERIA: 20% TO 39% TIME: 11:08:06 l 1

1 I I .I IEXTENT I I I I I CURRENT I ILINIROWlHEAT#1LEGlREQlTSTlREMIREELIPROBEl LOCATION IVOLTSIMILIDEGI % ICHI .j

(___l___i_____I___i___i___I___I .

I 1 _ .___- ___i_____i___i___i___i__i l 111411041000601 H IF/LIF/LI i 0421580SMITSH+ 0. 7 t 0.91 11351 211 11 1 111411241000601 H IF/LIF/LI i 0421580SM109H+ 0. 0 1 1.71 11311 251 11 l 11151 71000111 H 107Cl06CI I 0021580SDITSH+ 1. 8 .1 2.21 11231 291 11 1

-1 I I I H 107Cl06Cl 1 0021580SDITSH+ 2.2 1 1.91 11301 221 Il I i i 1.H 107Cl06Cl i 0021580SD104H+ 0. 3 1 0.61 11271 251 11 l' I i ! H 107C106Cl I 0021580SDiBW3- 2.1 1 0.81 11241 281 11 i l l l C 107H106Hi 1 0571580SDIBW3+ 0. 0 l 1.01 1133l 261 11 11151 931999991 H IF/LIF/Li 1 0421580SMITSH+ 2. 6 1 2.31 1134l 22f 11

'l11511131000601 H IF/LIF/LI I 0421580SM109H+ 0. 0 1 4.31 11221 331 11 11161 181000421 C iF/LIF/L1 1 0051580SF102H- 0. 2 1 1.11 11221 351 il 111611041000601 H IF/LIF/LI I 0411580SM109H+ 0. 0 1 2.71 11291 29A 11 11171 73100043l C IF/LIF/Lt 1 0051580SFl01H- 0. 5 1 0.91 11371 201 il 111811241999991 H tF/LIF/LI 1 04115805M109H+ 0. 0 1 1.21 11271 311 il 11191 451000441 C IF/LIF/L1 1 0041580SFl01H+ 0. 5 1 0.71 11281 291 il 11191 891999991 H IF/LIF/LI 'l 0401580SMITSH+ 1. 6 1 0.81 1116l 381 11 11201 30i000441 C IF/LIF/Lt I 0031580SFl04H- 0. 2 1 1.31 11331 231 11

'l1201 801999991 C IF/LIF/Li 1 0041580SFl01H+ 1. 0 1 1.91 1134l 231 11 11211 231999991 C IF/LIF/LI I 0031580SFITSH+ 3. 4 1 0.91 11241 311 11 1 I I I C IF/LIF/LI I 0031580SFITSH+ 6. 3 1 1.01 11281 281 11 11211 671999991 C IF/LIF/LI 1 0031580SFITSH+ 4. 3 1 1.31 11241 311 11 11211 791999991 C IF/LIF/LI I 0031580SFITSH+ 1. 3 1 1.11 11351 211 11 11221 961000221 H IF/LIF/Lt 1 0391580SM109C+ 0. 0 1 2.51 11231 321 11 112211061000601 H IF/LIF/Lt 1 0391580SMl09H+ 0. 0 1 2.51 11321 241 11 11231 131000601 H IF/LIF/LI I 0391580SMl01H+ 0. 4 1 2.01 11261 301 11 i i I i H IF/LIF/LI 1 0391580SM101H+ 0. 9 1 1.51 11361 211 11 11231 451999991 H IF/LIF/LI I 0391580SM101H+ 0. 9 1 1.01 11291 271 il 112311131000221 H IF/LIF/Lt i 0391580SMl09H+ 0. 0 1 2.01 11351 221 11 I i l i H IF/LIF/LI i 0391580SM109C+ 0. 0 1 1.71 11341 231 11 11241 961000221 H IF/LIF/Li 1 0381580SMITSH+ 0. 7 1 1.51 11291 271 il 112411041000601 H IF/LIF/L1 1 0381580SM109H+ 0. 0 1 2.71 11201 361 11 11251 331000601 H lF/LIF/L1 1 0371580RMl02H+ 0. 5 1 1.21 11291 321 il 11251 511000601 H IF/LIF/L1 1 0371580RM101H+ 0. 5 l 1,91 11381 201 11 41251 671999991 : H IF/LIF/LI I 0371580RMITSH+ 0. 7 i 1.31 11341 261 il 11251 911000601 H IF/LIF/Lt I 0381580SM109C+ 0. 0 1 1.91 1134l 221 il 112511031000601 H IF/LIF/LI i 0381580SMl09H+ 0. 0 1 1.21 11291 271 11 1 1 'l I H IF/LIF/LI 1 0381580SM109C+ 0. 0 1 1.01- 11231 331 il 11261 241000601 H IF/LIF/LI 1 0371580RM106H+ 0. 9 1 2.71 11291 321 Il 11261 581999991 H IF/LIF/LI I 0371580RMITSC+ 5. 0 1 1.01 11381 201 11 11261 961000601 H IF/LIF/LI I 0371580RMITSH+ 0. 4 1 1.41 11261 351 11 l

l i I I I H IF/LIF/Lt 1 0371580RM109C+ 0. 0 1 2.61 11271 341 11 l 11271 71000608 H 107Cl06Cl 1 0011580SDITSH+ 1. 5 1 1. 9 I 11281 241 11 l 11271 311999991 H IF/LIF/LI i 0361580SM102H+ 0. 3 1 0.61 11361 231 11 11271 511999991 H IF/LIF/LI I 0361580SMITSH+ 0. 6 i 1. 6 l 11261 351 11

[ 11271 531000604 H IF/LIF/LI i 0361580SMITSH+ 0. 6 1 3.31 11351 241 11 11271 831999991 H IF/LIF/LI i 0361580SMITSH+ 1. 8 1 0.81 i. 'l 221 il i I I I I i i I I I i i I . I I FLORIDA POWER & LIGHT COMPANY

CUMULATIVE REPORT

'02/87, ST. LUCIE, S/G A, UNIT 1 {

STEAM GENERATORS'A PAGE: 7 0F 8 LOCATION: ALL DATE: 08/20/87

' CRITERIA: 20% TO 39%: TIME: 11:08:06

~

1 1 ~~i~~~~~i~~~lEXTENT I I I i~ l CURRCNT l ILINIROWiHEAT#1LEGIREQlTSTlREMIREELlPROBEl LOCATION IVOLTSIMILIDEGI % (CHI l___I___I_____l __I___I___I___I____I_____l - _ _ _ _ - = __

! = l___I___I___1__I !

11281 141000411 H IF/LIF/LI I 0361580SMITSH+ 2. 0 1 1.61 11371 221 il '

11281 201999991 H IF/LIF/LI i 0361580SMITSC+ 3. 5 1 1.71 11271 341 11 11281 321999991 H IF/LIF/LI I 0361580SM102H+ 0. 0 1 1.41 11301 301 11 11281-441000601 H IF/LIF/Li 1 0361580SM101H+ 0. 0 1 1. 5 l 1132l 281 11 11281 941000601 H IF/LIF/Lt 1 0351580SM109C+ 0. 0 1 2.51 11391 221 11 11291 131000411 H IF/LIF/LI I 0351580SMl01H+ 0. 4 1 0.61 11261 361 11 11291 291999991 H IF/LIF/LI 1 0351580SMl03H+ 0. 4 1 0.61 11281 341 il 11291 591999991 H lF/LIF/LI i 035tS80SMITSH+ 4. 0 1 0.91 11231 391 11 11291 87I000601 H IF/LIF/Li I 0351580SMITSH+ 2. 4 i 1.01 11381 231 il 11291 911000211 H IF/LIF/LI I 0351580SMITSH+ 0. 3 1 2.21 I1361 231 il 11301 141000601 H IF/LIF/LI i 0341580SMITSH+ 1. 5 1 1.51 11371 221 11 11301 941000601 H IF/LIF/Li 1 0341580$M109H+ 0. 0 1 3.91 11368 231 11 11311 451999991 H IF/LIF/LI I 0331580SMITSH+ 0. 6 1 1.41 11161 371 il 11311 651999991 H IF/LIF/LI I 034l580SMITSH+ 1. 0 1 1.11 11251 361 il 11311 751999991 H IF/LIF/LI I 0341580SMITSH+ 2. 8 1 0.61 11291 321 il 11311 831999991 H IF/LIF/LI I 0341580SMITSH+ 0. 8 1 0.91 11291 321 il l I I I H IF/LIF/LI I 0341580SMITSH+ 1. 5 1 0.81 11281 33) il 11311 851999991 H IF/LIF/L1 1 0341580SMITSH+ 1. 0 1 0.71 11301 301 11 11321 201999991 H IF/LIF/LI i 0331580SMITSC+ 4.2 1 1.81 11161 371 il 11321 501000601 H IF/LIF/L1 1 0331580SMITSH+ 3. 0 1 1.21 11351 201 11 11321 841000601 H IF/LIF/Lt 1 0331580SMITSH+ 0. 7 1 3.31 11321 231 11 11321102100021I H IF/LIF/LI 1 0331580SM109H+ 0. 0 1 2.21 11151 381 il 11331 671000601 H IF/LIF/LI i 0321580SMITSH+ 2. 0 1 1.21 11321 221 11 11331 691000601 H IF/LIF/LI I 0321580SMITSH+ 0. 9 l 1.51 11341 201 11 I I I I H IF/LIF/LI I 0321580SMITSH+ 2. 2 1 0.81 11271 271 il 11331 731999991 H IF/LIF/LI 1 0321580SMITSH+ 1. 9 1 1.51 11321 221 11 113311051000211 H IF/LIF/LI I 0331580SM109C+ 0. 0 1 1.71 11301 251 11

.11341 41999991 H 107C106Cl i 0011580SDl02H+ 0. 5 1 0.71 11151 381 11 11341 961000601 H IF/LIF/LI I 0311580SMl09H+ 0. 0 1 4.51 11221 331 11 11351 731000601 H lF/LIF/LI I 0311580SMITSH+ 2. 0 1 3.41 11331 211 11 11351 851999991 H IF/LIF/LI I 0311580SMl03H+ 0. 5 i 1.51 11301 241 11 11351 951000111 H IF/LIF/LI I 0311580SM105H+ 0. 4 1 1.11 11271 281 11 11371 691999991 H IF/LIF/LI l 0301580SM101H+ 0. 3 1 0.51 11321 241 il 11381 32199999I H IF/LIF/LI I 0291580SMITSH+ 2. 9 I 4.11 1120t 331 11 l 11381 381000501 H IF/LIF/LI I 0291580SM102H+ 0. 0 1 0.61 11221 311 11 11381 681000601 H IF/LtF/LI I 0291580SM104H+ 0.0 1 1.21 11301 231 11 l 0. 0 1. 3 I 11331 201 11 11391 431999991 H IF/LIF/LI I 0291580SM102H+ 1 11391 951000111 H IF/LIF/L1 1 0291580SM109H+ 0. 0 1 3.21 1 981 371 Si i l' l IH IF/LIF/LI I 0291580SM109C+ 0. 0 1 2.11 11231 301 11 11401 321999991 H IF/LIF/LI I 0281580SMITSH+ 3. 4 1 1.11 1124l 301 il

} 11401 501999991 H IF/L!F/LI i 0281580SMITSH+ 0. 8 l 1.1 l 11311 231 11 11401 581999991 H IF/LIF/Lt I 0281580SMITSH+ 1. 4 1 0.71 11281 261 il 11411 211999991 H IF/LIF/LIRBDI 0541580SM102H+ 0. 2 1 1.61 11321 241 11 f 11321 241 11 11421 601999991 H IF/LIF/LI i 0261580SMITSH+ 0. 7 l 1.11 l 11431 511999991 H IF/LIF/L1 1 0261580SMITSH+ 1. 3 1 1.41 1135l 221 11 p I l I I I i l___I___1_____I___I___l___I___1____I_____I____=

l FLORIDA POWER & LIGHT COMPANY

CUMULAT2VE REPORT 02/87, ST. LUCIE S/G A, UNIT 1 STEAM GENERATOR: A PAGE: 8 0F 8

' LOCATION: ALL DATE: 08/20/87 CRITERIA: 20% TO 39%' ' TIME: 11:08:06

~~~~

l~~~i~~~I I IEXTENT I I I i $ CURRENT I ILINIROWlHEAT#1LEGIREQlTSTIREMIREELIPROBEl LOCATION IVOLTSIMILIDEGI % ICHI l __I___I_____I___I___1.__l___I l _____I 1 . . l___I___I___I__t 11431 951000111 H IF/LIF/L1 1 0261580SM109H+ 0. 0 1. 2.31 11181 201 SI 11441 21000601 H 107C106Cl 1 0011580SDl02H+ 0. 4 1 0.81 11311 211 il 11441 321999991 H IF/LIF/LI i 0251560SMITSH+ 0. 3 - l 1.91 11311 231 11 11461 241000601 H IF/LIF/Lt I 0241580SM104H+ 0. 4 - 1 2.81 11291 261 11 11471 271999991 H IF/LIF/LI i 0231580SMIBW1+ 0. 0 1 0.81 11271 281 11 11471 291999991 H IF/LIF/L1 1 0231580SM102C+-13.1 1 0.41 11331.221 il 11471 591999991 H IF/LIF/LI I 0241580SM101H- 0. 3 1 0.51 11331 221 il 11481 321000601 H IF/LIF/Li i 0231580SMITSH+ 0. 6 l 2.11 11251 30I 11

'l152l 421999991 H IF/LIF/LI i 0211580SM104H+ 0. 2 l 1.11 11331 221 11 11531 11999991 H 107C106Cl 1 0011580SD103H+ 0. 4 1 0.91 11311 211 11 11561 42l999991 H IF/LIF/LI I 0191580SM102H+ 0. 3 1 1.61 ;1331 ?21 11 I I l_,

I I I I i 1. I 1 _I i i 1 i NUMBER OF TUBES SELECTED FROM CURRENT OUTAGE: 296 ND TREND ANALYSIS REQUESTED I

l l

L L i l !

l

)

I

(

l I

I FLORIDA POWER & LIGHT COMPANY l

1 l

CUMULATIVE REPDRT

'02/87,.ST. LUCIE S/G A, UNIT 1 {

-l STEAM GENERATOR: A- PAGEn- -1 0F 2 j

~ LOCATION: ALL DATE: 08/20/87 !

CRITERIA: 40% TO 100% TIME: 10:52:10 ILINIROWlHEAT#1LEGIREQlTSTlREMIREELIPROBEl LOCATION IVOLTSIMILIDEGl % ICHI ]

-l 1 I I i l i~ l 1 l ___ I _ _ _ I _____ l _ _ _ I ___ I _ __ I _ __ l . - -

j 1 51 211000431 C IF/LIF/LIRP!l 0141580SM101H- 0. 4 I 1.81 1 971 551 11

'l 2811041000421 C.lF/LIF/LIRPIl 0231580SM106C+ ' 1. 0 1 2.01 11101 421'11 {

1~391 851000431 C IF/LIF/L'IRPIl 0301580SMITSH+ 1. 0 l' 1.21 11111 451 11 j L -1 411 71000211 H 197Cl06CIRPIl 0631580SMIBW3+ 0. 0 i 1.91 'l 1N!!' FBI il j l 411 171000421 C IF/LIF/LIRPIl 0311580SMITSC+ 4. 5 1 2.21 11021 511:11- i L i 4411081000441 C'lF/LIF/LIRPIl 0331580SMl09H+ 0. 0 1 2.41 l 931 581 11- -f I 491 271999991 H IF/LIF/LIRPIl 0151580SMITSH+ 5. 5 1 4.41- I 86t'481 51 '

h 1.91 11051 4 81 il l 581 181000431 H IF/LIF/LIRPIl 0111580SM103H+- 0. 6 1

[ I 601.221999991 H IF/LIF/LIRPIl 0101580SDITSC+ 6. 6 l 1. 0 ! - 11021 481'11 y

I i 601 961000601 H IF/LIF/LIRPIl 0471580SMl09C+ 0. 0 1 2.21 11628 441 il 1,661 681000221 H IF/LIF/LIRPIl 0061580SM101H+ 0.8 1 1.01 11011 531 il {

h 1.41 11011 501 11 p i 661 941999991 H IF/LIF/LlRPIl 0501580SM!09H+- 0.0 l' 1 l 671L351000211 H IF/LIF/LIRPIl 0061580SMITSC+ 4.1 1 1.41 11031 511 11 I 71I1091000501 H IF/LIF/LIRPIl 0521580SM109H+ 0. 0 1 2.21 I 951 581 il I 7111131000501 H.iF/LIF/LIRDIl 0521580SMITSH+ 1. 3 1 0.88. 11081 461 11 ]

k 0. 5 1.31 11101 441 it I 1 1 i H.lF/LIF/LIRPIl 0521580SMl02H- i !

} l 741 601000111 H IF/LIF/LIRPIl 0031580SDITSC+ 5. 0 1 1.71 11101 421 il 1 f- ~l 741 761000111 H IF/LIF/LlRPIl 0031580SDl01H+ 0. 9 1 0.91 11011 501 11 I 771.471000601 H IF/LIF/LIRP!l 0591580SMITSC+ ' 6. 3 1 0.81 11031 511 il l I 771 771000501 H IF/LIF/LIRPIl 0591580SM101H- 0. 4 1 2.11 11081 461 il I 821 461999991.C IF/LIF/LIRPIl 0481580SMITSC+ 5. 3 1 2.11 1 851 661 11 1 1 '.i i l'C IF/LIF/LIRPIl 0481580SMITSC+ 4. 9 1 0.91- 11121 421 11 0.61 11101 441 11

[ l 931 45f999991- C IF/LIF/LIRPIl 0491580SMITSH+ 11.3 I 931 751999991 C IF/LIF/LIRPIl 0491580SM101H+ 0. 2 1

1 0.81 11041 501 il E

l I 9411241000501 C IF/LIF/LIRPIl 0441580SMITSH+ 0. 7 1 0.81 11151 421 il l 11031 471000501 C IF/LIF/LIRPIl 0101580SM102C+ 10.6 1 0.71 11101 421 11 l Lr 110811041999991 H IF/LIF/LIRPIl 0451580SM109C+ 0. 0 1 0.91 11081 431 il 11091l 71000111 H 107Cl06CIRPIl 0021580SDl01H+ 0. 5 1 1.11 11031 481 il 11111 71000111 H 197Cl06CIRPIl 0021580SDITSH+ 3. 8 1 1.41 1 911 581 il ~J 11121 61000111 H 107Cl06CIRPIl 002I580SD10!H+ 0. 2 1 1.21- 1 821 661 il 11141 961000501 H IF/LIF/LIRPIl 0421580SMl09H+ 0. 0 1 2.41 11101 431 il '

11161 901000501 H IF/LIF/LIRP!l 0411580SM101H+ 0. 6 1 1.61 I 931-Gil 11 11181 241000431 C IF/LIF/LIRPIl 0841580SFl01H+ 0. 5 l 1.41 1 881 641 il 11191 931000701 H IF/LIF/LlRP!l 0401580SM109H+ 0. 0 1 1.21 1 901 631 il 11211 131000411 C IF/LIF/LIRPIl 0038580SFITSH+ 1. 7 1 0.81 11061 471 il litil 691000501 C IF/LIF/LIRPIl 0031580SFl02H+ 0. 5 1 1.01 11101 441 il 112111031000501 H IF/LIF/LIRPIl 0401580SMITSH+' O.7 1 1.71 1 991 551 il 11261 941000221 H lF/LIF/LIRPIl 0371580RMl09C+ 0. 0 1 1.31 11151 471 il 11271 251999991 H IF/LIF/LIRPIl 0361580SMl03H+ 0. 4 1 0. 6 l 11011 601 il 11271 971000211 H (F/LIF/LIRDIl 0361580SM109H+ 0. 0 1 1.21 81121 501 il 112711031000601 H-lF/LIF/LIRPIl 0361580SMl09H+ 0. 0 1 2.51 11111 501 il 11281 141000411 H IF/LIF/LIRPIl 0361580SMITSH+ 1. 6 1 0.71 11051 561 il 113411001000111 H IF/LIF/LIRPIl 0311580SM109H+ 0. 0 1 1.41 11081 471 11 11371 71000111 C 107HiO6HIRPIl 0571580SDiBW3+ 0. 0 1 0.81 11111 461 il 11381 321999991 H IF/LIF/LIRPIl 0291580SMl03H+ 8.1 1 0.71 11091 431 11 I I I I l___I___I_____I___I___1___I___l ___I_____I___________________I_____I FLORIDA POWER & LIGHT COMPANY

l CUMULATIVE REPORT )

02/87, ST. LUCIE S/G A, UNIT 1 )

('

STEAM GENERATOR: A PAGEt 2 0F 2 LOCATION: ALL DATE: 08/20/87 CRITERIA: 40'/. TO 100% TIME: 10:52:10 f

__ - - - = = _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ = _ _ _ _ _ _ _ - - -_ j lEXTENT I I i i CURRENT i ;

i i i i i 1 l l LIN I R0W I HE4T# 1 LEG I REO I TST l REM I REEL I P ROBE I LOCATION IVOLTSIMILIDEGl % iCHI {

i i i i I i f l i __ _ I _ __1___ __ I ___ I ___ I _ _ _ t _ _ I _ _ __ I _ _ ___ I __ _ _ _ --

11401 321999991 H IF/LIF/LIRPIl 0281580SMITSH+ 2. 3 1 1.01 11071 451 11 )

I1451 15100060i H IF/LIF/LIRPIi 0241580SMl01H+ 0. 4 i 0. 9 I i1081 451 11 {

11541 321999991 H IF/LIF/LIRPIl 0201580SMIBW3+ 1. 0 1 0.61 11111 421 11 11621 141000411 H IF/LIF/LIRPIl 0171580SM104H+ 0. 5 1 2.31 l 981 541 il j f i l i I i 1 l I i I l i i i l i i NUMBER OF TUBES SELECTED FROM CURRENT GUTAGE: 47 NO TREND ANALYSIS REQUESTED l

f l

l l

FLORIDA POWER & LIGHT COMPANY

CUMULATIVE REPORT 02/87, ST. LUCIE,: S/G .B, UNIT 1-

STEAM GENERATOR: B PAGE: 1 OF 8 LOCATION -ALL DATE: 08/20/87

- CRITERI A: 1% TO 19% TIME: 11:47:07 I

~ ~ ~~~~

~~~ ~~

f l i I lEXTENT I I l i~~~~~ l CURRENT l i ILINIROWlHEAT#lLEGlREQlTSilREMIREELIPROBEl LOCATION IVOLTSIMILIDEGI % ICHI I l l I I I I i i I i __ ____ l_____1___l___1___!__t l l 71 151000441 H IF/LIF/LI i 01515805Fl01H+ 32.0 1 1.21 11581 '11 11 1.101 561000601 H IF/LIF/Li- 1 0161580SFl01H+ 0. 8 1 2.11 11511 til il i 116 411999991 H IF/LIF/L1 1 0161580SFl01H+ 0. 3 l 1.61 11581 41 11 i'151 451999991 H IF/LIF/LI I 0181580SM105C+ 0. 0 1 1.21 11511 31 il 1 171 291999991 H IF/LIF/Li 1 01915805M101H+ 31.0 1 1.31 11381.191 11 1 171 311999998 H IF/LiF/LI i 0191580SMITSC+ 0. 6 1 1.71 '11411 15l 11 l'171 451999991 H IF/LIF/LI i 0191580SMl01H+ 0. 0 1 0.81 11471- 81 11 1 181 681999991 H IF/LIF/L1 1 0191580SM101H+ 0. 0 1 0.81 11491 51 11 1 191 191999991 H IF/LIF/LI I 0201580SM102H+ 0. 0 1 1.11 11431 161 11 l 201 46l000601 H IF/LIF/LI i 0201580SM103C+ 24.0 1 1.61 11431 161 i t '

1 1 1 i H IF/LIF/Lt 1 0201580SMl02C+ 26.2 1 2.01 11471 111 il i 211 75l000601 H IF/LIF/Lt 1 0211580SMl04C+ 18.3 1 1.01 11441 151 11 1 251 431999991 H IF/LIF/LI I 0231580SMITSH+ 1. 0 1 1. 2 I 11601 21 11 1 1 251 551000601 H lF/LIF/LI i 0231580SM105C+ 28.4 1 0.81 11561 61 11 1 1 I l' I H IF/LIF/LI I 0231580SMITSC+ 3. 2 ' i 1.61 11491 131 il 1 261 201999991 H IF/LIF/Li I 0241580SMITSH+ 2. 4 1 2.81 11561 81 il i 261 921000421 H IF/LIF/LI I 0231580SM109H+- 0. 3 1 20.01 11381 41 51 i 1 281 14l00060l H lF/LIF/LI I 0251580SMITSH+ 1. 9 I 4.11 11371. El 51 ]

l i 1 l'H IF/LIF/LI i 0251580SMITSH+ 3. 7 1 5.61 11561 61 il I l i I H IF/LIF/LI I 0251580SMITSC+ 8.1 1 1.91 11551 71 11 .

.I I 'l I H IF/LIF/Lt 1 0251580SMITSC+ 4. 8 1 2.71 11511 ill 11 )

I 281 561999991 H IF/LIF/LI I 0251580SMITSH+ 0. 7 1 2.71 11471 151 11 !

'l' I I I H IF/LIF/LI i 0251580SM104C- 0. 6 l 1.81 11581 41 il 1 291 .31999991 H 107Cl06Cl I 0011580SDl03H- 0. 5 1 2.01 11521 101 11

'l 291 211999991 H IF/LIF/LI I 0251580SMITSH+ 2. 7 1 1.61 11471 151 11 1 291 331999991 H IF/LIF/LI I 0251580SMITSC+ 1. 8 I 3.61 11541 81 11 1 291 351999991 H IF/LIF/Lt 1 0251580SMITSH+ 0. 8 1 1, 7.1 11441 171 11 l 291 491999991 H IF/LIF/LI i 0251580SMl01C+ 0. 0 1 0.81 11351 41 Si 1 291 731000601 H IF/LIF/Li' I 0251580SMIBWi+ 0. 0 1 1.91 11501 121 11

'l 301 241999991 H lF/LIF/LI I 0261580SFITSC+ 4. 3 l 1.21 11431 191 11 i 1 301 281999991 H IF/LIF/LI i 0261580SFlTSH+ 2. 2 1 1.41 11511 91 11 i i 301 441999991 H IF/LIF/LI 1 0261580SFITSH+ 1. 0 1 1.91 11501 101 11 [

1 301 621999991 H IF/LIF/LI I 0261580SFlTSH+ 0. 8 1 0.71 11551 41 11 i 321 921000421 H IF/LIF/LI I 0271580SM109C+ 0. 0 1 2.01 11451 171 11 !

l 3211081000421 H IF/LIF/L1 1 0271580SM109C+ 0. 0 l 2.11 11441 191 11 i 4 331 331999991 H IF/LIF/L1 1 0281580SMITSH+ 1. 8 1 3.81 11561 71 il 1 341 61000111 C 107H106HI I 0591580SD102H+ 10.9 I 0.91 11441 151 il 1 361 181999991 H IF/LIF/LI I 0301580SMITSC+ 5. 9 1 2.71 11501 141 11

'l 136l 201999991 H !F/LIF/L1 1 0301580SMIO2H+ 0. 6 1 1.01 11551 81 il 1 361 401000601 H IF/LIF/LI i 0301580SMITSC+ 1.9 1 2.81 11591 31 il 1 361 981000431 H IF/LIF/Li 1 0301580SM107C+ 0. 0 1 1.81 11581 Al 11

-1 371 11999991 H 107Cl06Cl i 0011580SD101H+ 0. 5 1 1.21 11531 91 li

! 371 191999991 H IF/LIF/LI I 0301580SMITSC+ 5. 9 1 2.61 11571 61 il I 371 311000601 H IF/LIF/LI i 0304580SMITSH+ 6. 5 1 1.51 11561 7l 11 I I I I H IF/LIF/L1 1 0301580SMITSC+ 3.1 1 3.41 11511 131 11 I I 1 1 I I I___I___I_____I___I___1___I___I I - 1 FLORIDA POWER AND LIGHT COMPANY <

CUMULATIVE REPORT l

02/87, ST. LUCIE, S/G B, UNIT 1 h PAGE: 2 OF 8 j l STEAM GENERATOR: B: t

' DATE: 08/20/87 LOCATION: ALL CRITERIA: 1% TO 19%- TIME: 11:47:07 l 1 -1 i 'lEXTENT 1 I I I I CURRENT I ILINIROWlHEAT#1LEGIREQlTSTIREMIREELIPROBEl LOCATION IVOLTSIMILIDEGI % (CHI !

I I I l i I I I l - = l

_________ l ._ ___ I _ __1.__ I _ __ I __ I i 371 331999991 H IF/LIF/LI I 0301580SMITSH+ 3. 5 1 2.41 11561 71 il 1 371 591999991 H IF/LIF/Lt 1 0311580SMITSC+ 0. 6 1 1.91 11471 111 il 1 371 771999991 H IF/LIF/LI I 0311580SMITSH+ 0. 5 l 1.11 11451 141 11 l 381 661000601 li IF/LIF/LI i 0311580SMITSH+ 0. 9 I 4.01 11431 161 11 1 381 741999991 H IF/LIF/LI I 0311580SMITSH+ 0. 9 l 1.91 11461 12i'il 1 381 781999991 H IF/LIF/LI 1 0311580SMITSH+ 1.1 I 1.01 11441 151 11 1 391 851999991 H lF/LIF/LI i 0321580SMITSH+ 0. 4 1 1.81 11531 51 il I 401 12l000221 H IF/LIF/LI I 0331580SMITSH+ 1. 0 1 1.41 11521 71 11 l'411 151000441 H IF/LIF/LI i 0331580SMITSH+ 1.2 1 1.11 11471 121 il i i 1 I H IF/LIF/L1 1 0331580SMITSH+ 1. 2 l 1.11 11471 12l il I 411 291999991 H IF/LIF/LI I 0331580SMITSC+ 6. 6 1 3.21 11411 191 il 1 421 121000221 H IF/LIF/Lt 1 0351580SMITSH+ 1. 0 l 3.11 11541 11 il i 421 381999991 H IF/LIF/LI i 0341580SMITSH+ 1. 5 1 2.91 11581 41 11 1 431 15!000441 H IF/LIF/LI i 0351580SM101H+ 0. 0 1 1.21 11541 11 il

! 431 871999991 H IF/LIF/LI I 0351580SMITSH+ 1. 2 1 1.21 11401 191 11 1 035l580SM109C+ 0. 0 1,91 11501 71 il 1 43110310004tl H IF/LIF/L1 1 i 44l 201999991 H IF/LIF/LI I 0361580SMITSC+ 7. 9 1 1.71 11431 181 11 1 441 241000501 H IF/LIF/L1 1 0361580SMITSC+ 7.1 1 3.11 11451 161 il 1 441 441999991 H IF/LIF/L1 1 0361580SMITSC- 2. 6 1 3.31 11561 51 11 1 441 461999991 H IF/LIF/LI i 0361580SMITSH+ 2. 2 1 2.91 11481 13l 11 i i i i i H IF/LIF/LI I 0361580SMITSC+ 2. 9 1 1.21 1157! 41 11 1 441 801999991 H IF/LIF/LI 1 0361580SMITSC+ 0. 4 1 0.81 11461 151 11 l 441 841000601 H IF/LIF/LI I 03615SOSMITSH+ 1. 4 1 1.51 11501 ill il I 441 861999991 H 1F/LIF/Lt 1 0364580SMITSH+ 0. 2 1 4.21 I150i 111 il 1 441 881999991 H IF/LIF/LI i 0361580SMITSH+ 0. 9 1 1.61 1144! 171 it i i I i H IF/LIF/LI 1 0361580SMl01H+ 0. 0 1 2.41 11594 31 11 1 451 351999991 H IF/LIF/LI i 0361580SM103H+ 0. 0 1 0.61 11551 61 11 1 451 431999991 H IF/LIF/LI I 0361580SM103H+ 0. 0 1 1.01 11571 41 11 1 451 491999991 H IF/LIF/LI I 0361580SMITSH+ 3. 2 1 1.81 11521 91 11 I 451 511999991 H IF/LIF/LI 1 0361580SMITSH+ 1. 5 1 2.5I 11521 91 i l

f. I 451 651999991 H IF/LIF/L1 1 0361580SMITSH+ 0. 2 1 0.91 11311 111 SI I 461 4I999991 H 107C106Cl i 0011580SDl02H+ 0. 6 1 0.81 11551 71 il 1 461 461999991 C IF/LIF/L1 1 0151580SFlTSH+ 1. 6 I ?.41 11471 101 11 1 471 11999991 H IO7C106CI I 0011580SD103H+ 0. 4 1 1.21 11521 101 il I 481 821999991 H IF/LIF/LI I 0381580SMITEH+ 2. 3 1 1.91 11491 131 il 1 491 731000601 C IF/LIF/LIRNCI 0571580SM102H+ 0. 0 1 1.61 11491 11 11 1 l i I C IF/LIF/LI I 0571580SMl04H+ 0. 0 1 1. 0 i 11491 il 11 1 491 751000601 C IF/LIF/LIRNCI 0571580SM102C+ 3. 4 1 1.01 11491 il 11 I 511 231999991 C IF/LIF/LI I 0141580SMITSH+ 0. 9 1 6.51 11501 141 11 f 1 5211281999996 H IF/LIF/L1 1 0391580SM109C+ 0. 0 1 1.71 11551 71 11 f 5411241999991 H IF/LIF/LI I 040158aSMl09C+ 0. 0 l 1.41 11541 81 11 f I 0401580SMl08H+ 9. 7 0.51 11421 191 11 I 5411301999991 H IF/LIF/LI 1 1 561 221000601 C IF/LIF/Lt 1 0111580SMITSC+ 7. 7 1 2.11 11461 Bi 11 1 561 901999991 H IF/LIF/LI i 0411580SMITSH+ 0. 5 1 2.21 11491 91 il I 561 981000601 H IF/LIF/Lt 1 0411580SMITSH+ 1.1 1 0.81 11391 181 il I I i i I 1 i i i l i

! I I I I _

FLORIDA POWER AND LIGHT COMPANY I - _ _ _ _ _ _ - _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ - _ _ _ _ _ _ _ - _ _ _ - _ _ - - - _ - - _

CUMULATIVE REPORT 02/87, ST. LUCIE, S/G B, UNIT 1 b PAGE: 3 OF. 8 i : STEAM. GENERATOR: B LOCATION: ALL DATE: 08/20/87 CRITERIA: 1% TO 19% TIME: 11:47:07 p

~ ~~~ ~~

1 1 I I IEXTENT I i 1 l l CURRENT l ILIN1ROWIHEAT#1LEGlREQlTSTIREMIREELIPROBEl LOCATION IVOLTSIMILIDeG1 % ICHI I I I l 1 l___I___I l_____I _ l_ l I I I i 1 5611221999991 H IF/LIF/Lt t 0411580SM109C+ 0. 0 1 1.71 (1511 71 11 I 5611281000601 H IF/LIF/Lt t 0411580SM109C+ 0. 0 1 1.81 11511 71 11 I 5611301999991 H IF/LIF/LI 1 0411580SMi@9C+ 0. 0 1 1.41 11531 51 11 '

1 571 691000601- C (F/LIF/LI 1 0111580SM101C+ 0. 0 1 0.81 11441 ill 11 I 5711071999991 H IF/LIF/LI I 0411580SM109H+ 0. 0 1 2.81 11481 101 11 l

1 581 981999991. H'IF/LIF/LI 1 0411580SMITSH+ 19.9 1 0.81 11491 91 11 1 591 511999991 C IF/LIF/LI i 0101580SM101C- 0. 4 i '1.01 !!441 111 11 i

.I Gil 451000601 C IF/LIF/LI I 0091580SM104C+ 2.1 ! 1.91 11491 31 11 i I 6111071999991 H IF/LIF/LI I 0431580SM104C+ 0. 4 1 1.81 11531 91 11 )

I 6111331999991 H IF/LIF/LI l 0431580SMl09C+ 0. 0 1 3.71 1144l 171 il 1 6111351999991 H IF/LIF/L1 1 0431580SM109C+ 0. 0 1 1.91 11501 121 it' 1 621-94l999991 H IF/LIF/Lt 1 0431580SMITSH+ 4. 3 1 2.31 11481 141 11 1 I I I H IF/LIF/Li' I 0431580SM109H+ 0. 0 1 0.81 11511 111 il I 6211041000601 H IF/LIF/LI i 0431580SMITSH+ 1. 0 1 2.11 11461 161 11.

I 6211301000601 H IF/LIF/Lt 1 0431580SM109C+ 0. 0 1 2.41 11601 11 11 1 64) 841999991 H IF/LIF/LI i 0441580SMl04C+ 2. 7 1 1.71 11451 ill 11 J l 641 881999991 H IF/LIF/LI 1 0441580SMITSH+ 4.7 1 1.51 11461 91 11 1 6411001999991 H IF/LIF/L1 1 0441580SMITSC+ 1. 3 1 1.11 11391 191 11 I

I 6411021999991 H IF/LIF/LI I 0441580SMITSC+ 0. 6 I 1.01 11461 91 11 i 6511331999991 H IF/LIF/Lt I 0441580SM109C+ 0. 0 1 2.81 11471 81 11 l 6811041999991 H IF/LIF/Lt I 0461580SMITSH+ 1. 5 1 2.41 11511 21 11

-1 6811241000501 H IF/LIF/L1 1 0461580SM109H+ 0. 0 1 2.91 11491 51 11 1 68t1281999991 H IF/LIF/Lt 1 0461580SM109H+ 0. 0 1 3.21 11491 51 11 1 6911191000601 H IF/LIF/LI 1 0461580SM109H+ 0. 0 1 2.41 11491 51 11 1 701 961999991 H IF/LIF/LI ! 0471580FMITSH+ 4. 3 f 1.11 11481 71 1.1 1 7011061999991 H IF/LIF/LI I 0471580FMITSH+ 2. 6 1 1.41 11478 81 11 1 7011281999991 H IF/LIF/LI I 0471580FMl09H+ 0. 0 1 2.01 11451 111 il I 721 441000601 C IF/LIF/LI 1 0041580SFITSC+ 5. 8 l 1.41 11361 51 S I I 721 481000111 C IF/LIF/LI i 004f580SFITSC+ 6. 7 1 1.01 (1501 131 11 1 721 50l000111 C IF/LIF/LI I 0041580SFITSH+ 2.1 1 1.01 11511 121 11 l-7211281000601 H IF/LIF/LI I 0471580FMl09H+ 0. 0 1 1.51 11401 181 11 1 731 491000111 C IF/LIF/Lt 1 0041580SFlTSC+ 7. 0 1 1.41 11251 191 51 I ?31 63100011I C IF/LIF/LI I 004l580SFITSH+ 0. 8 1 1.91 11561 51 11 1 _I l' I C IF/LIF/LI 1 0041580SFITSH+ 1. 3 1 1.61 11521 101 il 1 1 1 I C IF/LIF/L t 1 0041580SF105H+ 0. 2 1 0.91 11451 191 11 1 731 894999991 H IF/LIF/Lt 1 0481580SMITSC+ 4. 7 1 1.31 11391 181 11 l 1-7311091999991 H IF/LIF/LI i 0481580SMITSH+ 1.1 1 1,81 11471 81 il I 73l133100060i H IF/LIF/Lt 1 0481580SM109H+ 0. 0 1 2.31 11501 51 il I 741 501000111 C IF/LIF/Lt I 0041580SFITSC+ 6. 8 1 1.41 11521 101 11

.I 741 861999991 H IF/LIF/LI I 0491580SMITSH+ 0. 9 1 1.11 11521 101 11 6 7411061000601 H IF/LIF/LI i 049f580SMITSH+ 1. 8 1 2. 0 i 11471 151 11 1 7411181999991 H IF/LIF/L1 1 0481580SM109C+ 0. 0 1 0.81 11391 181 il 1.7411341000501 H IF/LIF/Lt 1 0481580SM109C+ 0. 0 1 1.51 11441 121 it i 75l 511999991 C IF/LIF/L1 1 0481580SMITSH+ 1. 4 1 1.91 11501 91 il i I I I C IF/LIF/Li I 0481580SMITSH+ 4.1 1 1. 7 f 11501 91 11

__l = i l i 1 __I___I_____l. _I___I___I___I____l_____l_- -

1 I FLORIDA POWER AND LIGHT COMPANY E______ _ I

7,~--,-----------

l CUMULATIVE REPORT I 02/87, ST. LUCIE, S/G B, UNIT 1- l I

STEAM GENERATOR: B PAGE: 4 0F 8 !

08/20/87 i LOCATION: ALL DATE:

TIME: 11:47:07 k

' CRITERIA: 1% TO 19%

b '

~

I: 1 1 'l IEXTENT I I I i l CURRENT- 1 l

'lLINIROWlHEAT#1LEGlREQlTSTIREMlREELlPROBEl LOCATION IVOLTSIMILIDEGI % ICHI .

l l ___ I ___ l ' l___I___I___I___I____I_ l.. . . -

I. I I 11511 I I I 71 11-l 1 751 511999991 C IF/LIF/LI I 0481580SMITSH+ 4. 6 ~l 1.40

'l 751-851999991.C IF/LIF/Li 1 0481580SMITSH+ 0. 6 l 1.71 11511 71 11 l

lu75l 871999991 C IF/LIF/LI I 0481580SMITSH+ 0.7 1 2.81 11501 91 11.

l 7511351000501 C IF/LIF/LI I 0491 580Sl09C+ 0. 0 1 2.11 11461.141 11 l l 761 461999991 C IF/LIF/LI I 0491 580SITSH+ ~ 1.6 1 1.31 11431 171 11 j i 761 761999991 C lF/LIF/LI I 0491 580SITSH+ 0. 7 I 1.01 11421 191 11 ;

i'781 661999991 C IF/LIF/LI I 0511580SMITSH+ 2. 5 i 1.61 11481- 81 11 I l'781 981999991 C IF/LIF/Lt 1 0511580SM109C+ 0. 0 1 2.21 -1152l 31 il 'j i 7811241000601 C IF/LIF/L) l'0501580SM109C+ '0.0 1 2.61 11481 121 il ) '

I 791 471999991 C IF/LIF/LI 1 0511580SMl02H+ 0. 3 1 1.61 11451 121-11 f 791 851999991 C IF/LIF/Li 1 0511580SMITSH+ 0. 5 1 0.91 11451 12I 11 l

f. 2.01 11551 31 11

'l l 801 761999991 C IF/LIF/LI i 0521580SMITSH+ 0. 7 l

! 811 531999991 C IF/LIF/Lt 1 0531580SM103H+ 0. 0 l 1. 2 i (1461 131 11 1 8211081000601 C IF/LIF/LI 1 0541580SMlBW2+ 0. 0 i 1.41 11421 131 11 a 8211341999991 C IF/LIF/Lt 1 0541580SM109C+ 0. 0 1 1.11 11431 121 il f .l

1. 0 2.71 11511 31 11 l 1 831 851000601 C IF/LIF/LI i 0551580SMITSH+ 1 l C IF/LIF/LI I 0551580SM102C+ 29.5 1 2.11 11481 71 11 ll 1 1 1 1,91 11481 71 11 l l 8311291000601 C IF/LIF/Lt I 0551580SM109H+ 0. 0 1 1 8311351999991 C IF/LIF/Li 1 0551580SM109H+ 0. 0 ! 0.91 11481 71 11 1 8411221000601 C IF/LIF/L1 1 055l580SMtBW3+ 11.8 1 1.01 11451 111'11 1 I I I C IF/LIF/LI I 0551580SM104C+ 1. 6 I 0.61 11511 31 il I I I I C IF/LIF/LI I 0551580SM102C+ 7. 3 1 1.31 11481 71 11 1 8411281999991 C IF/LIF/LI I 0551580SMl09C+ 0. 0 1 1.11 11491 61 il I 851 451000601 H IF/LIF/LI I 0541580SMl01H+ 0. 0 1 1.21 11451 151 11 I l- 1 I H IF/LIF/LI I 0541580SMl03H- 0. 8 l 1.01 11521 61 il '

I 851 611999991 H IF/LIF/LI l 0541580SM102H+ 0. 0 1 1.31 11521 61 11 I 851 851999991 H IF/LIF/Li I 0541580SMITSH+ 0. 7 1 2.51 11511 71 li 1 8511031999991 H 1F/LIF/LI 1 0551580SMITSC+ 1. 0 1 1.31 11461 61 11 1 I I I H IF/LIF/L1 1 0551580SMITSC+ 0. 6 -1 2.41 11421 11l il I 8511051999991 H IF/LIF/LI 1 0551580SMITSH+ 1. 7 I 1.11 1143l 101 11 l-871 451000601 H IF/LIF/Li 1 0561580SMITSH+ 2. 0 1 1.51 11511 71 11 1 871 471999991 H IF/LIF/LI i 0561580SMITSC+ 5. 2 1 1.11 11461 121 11 1 881118l000601 H lF/LIF/LI I 0571580SMl09C+ 0. 0 1 4. 5 l 11371 181 Al I 8911351000601 H IF/LIF/Lt 1 05Bl580RM109H+ 0. 0 1 2.61 11411 181 11 1 911 431999991 H IF/LIF/Li 1 0501580SMITSC+ 4. 5 1 2.01 11531 El il

.1 911 651999991 H IF/LIF/L1 1 0501580SMIO1H+ 0. 0 1 0.91 11411 191 11 1.9111351000601 H IF/LIF/LI i 0511580SMl09C+ 0. 0 1 2.11 11471 121 it

! 9211081999991 H IF/LIF/LI I 0501580SM103C+ 13.7 1 0.51 11441 151 Il I 931 831999991 H IF/LIF/LI i 0491580SMITSH+ 0. 4 1 2.31 11491 131 Il I 9311071000601 H IF/LIF/L1 1 0491580SMITSh+ 1. 6 1 1.41 11511 lit il I 941 681999991 H IF/LIF/LI I 0141580SMITSC+ 2. 6 1 2. 5 : 1146l 181 li 1 941 821999991 C IF/LIF/L1 1 04Bl580SMITSH+ 0. 9 I 2.51 11501 91 il I 941 841999991 C IF/LIF/LI i 0481580SMITSH+ 0. 7 l 1,71 11461 131 11 1 951 891999991 C IF/LIF/L1 1 0481580SMITSH+ 1. 0 1 3.01 11531 51 11 I 9511071000601 C (F/LIF/LI i 0471580SMITSH+ 1. 6 I 2. 8 i (1481 121 11 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 i l i i i i 1 4 1

1 1

FLORIDA POWER AND LIGHT COMPANY l .. .. ..

l' . .

CUMULATIVE REPORT 02/87,.ST. LUCIE, S/G B, UNIT 1 5 0F. 8 PAGE:

STEAYf6ENERATOR: B.

[' ,

.LOCA110N ALL DATE: 08/20/87 11:47:07

-CRITERIA: l'A TO 19% TIME:

i

['

I l. l IEXTENT 1 I i 1 1 CURRENT I Ji ~!

1 e l'LIN I ROW l HEAT # 1 LEG l REQ l TST I REM I REEL I PROBE l LOCATION IVOLTSIMILIDEGI % ICHI 1 I I I I I I

. l ___ I ___ I _____ I ___ l ___ I ___ I ___ I ____ l -

I 961 441997991 H IF/LIF/L1 1 0141580SMIDW3+ 0. 5 1 0.41 11411 El SI 1: 961: 481999991 H IF/LIF/L1 l'0141580SMIBW3- 1. 0 1 0.71 11451 191 11 .

I i 'l' I H IF/LIF/LI 'l 0141580SMIBW3- 0. 3 1 1.01 11581 61 11 l 11'971 691000601 H IF/LIF/LI 1 0131580RM103H+ 0. 2 1 1.41 1154l'101 11 1 9711071999991 C IF/LIF/L1 1 0571580SMITSH+ 1. 8 I 3.11 11401 141.11 l 1 0461580SM109C+ 0. 0 1.11 11501 -51 11

.1: 9711271999991 C IF/LIF/Cl 1 1 9711331000601 C .lF/LIF/L1 1 0461580SM109H+ 0. 0 1 2.91 11511 41 11 l 9711351000508 C IF/LIF/Li 1 0461580SM109H+ 0. 0 l 1.81 11391 181 11 !

l 991 31199999I H IF/LIF/Lt 1 0121580SF102H+ 0. 5 1 0.81 11601 11 il I 9911071999991 C IF/LIF/Lt I 0461580SMITSH+ 1. 7 1 1.21 11471 91 11 11001.641999991 H IF/LIF/LI I 0121580SFITSC+ 0. 6 1 0.61 11491 141 11

.11001 82100060l C IF/LIF/Lt 1 0451580SMITSH+ 0. 4 1 3.01 lir31 31 11 110011301000501 C IF/LIF/LI i 0451580SMl09C+ 0. 0 1 1.21 11501 71 il 11011 471999991 H IF/LIF/Li 1 0121580SFlTSC+ 5. 7 1 1.31 11461 181 11 1 I I I H IF/LIF/LI i 0121580SFITSC+ 4. 8 1 1.21 11471 171 il 1 1. I I H IF/LIF/L1 1 0121580SFITSC+ 4.1 1 1.71 It571 41 11 11011 591999991 H IF/LIF/LI 1 0121580SFITSH+ 4. 8 1 2.01 11551 71 11 11011 611999991 H IF/LIF/Li 1 0121580SFITS4+ 4. 6 I .1.81 11451 191 11 11011 811999991 C 17/LIF/Lt 1 0451580SM103H+ 0. 5 1 0.81 11481 91 11 11011 851000601 C IF/LIF/LI i 0451580SMITSH+ 0. 3 1 2.81 11441 141 11 11011 871999991 C IF/LIF/LI I 0451580SMITSH+ 3. 8 1 1.01 11481 91 il 110111091000601 C IF/LIF/L1 1.0451580SMITSH+ 1.1 1 2.31- 11481 91 11 11021'481000501 H IF/LIF/LI l 0121580SFl02H- 0. 4 l 1.11 11561 61 11 11021 501999991-H IF/LIF/L1 1 0121580SFITSH+ 0. 6 1 0.71 11511 121 11

. l103l 371000501 H IF/LITSCIRITI 0111580SMITSC+ 12.0 1 2.01 11611 41 11 1 I I I H IF/LilSCIRITI 0111580SMITSC+ 6. 6 ! 4.31 11571 81 Il 11031 591999991 H IF/LIF/LI i 0111580SMITSH+ 1. 6 1 2.41 !!62I 31 11 11041 401999991 H lF/LIF/LI I 0111580SMITSH+ 0. 6 1 2.71 1164) 11 11 11051 331000601 H IF/LIF/LI i 0101580SFlTSC+ 6. 7 i 4.31 11471 171 11 11051 571000411 H IF/LIF/L1 1 0101580SF104C+ 31.5 1 0.51 11571 81 11 110511071999991 C IF/LIF/L1 1 0431580SMITSH+ 0. 8 l 1.21 11531 31 11 110511011000601 C IF/LIF/LI I 0431580SMITSH+ 0. 5 1 2.41 11531 31 11

'l10611141000601 C lF/LIF/LI 1 0431580SM109H+ 0. 0 1 4.81 11571 11 11 110711231999991 C IF/LIF/LI I 0421580SMl09C+ 0. 0 1 1.61 11511 121 11-11081 941000601 C IF/LIF/Li 1 0421580SM109H+ 0. 0 1 3.91 11511 121 11 110811181999991 C IF/LIF/L1 1 0421580SMl09H+ 0. 0 1 1.91 11551 81 11 11091 771000421 H IF/LIF/Li 1 0081580SFlTSH+ 3. 4 1 1.01 11581 81 il 11101 781000431- H IF/LIF/L1 1 0081580SFITSH+ 0. 8 1 1.11 11481 191 11 11111 331000431 H IF/LITSClRITI 0081580SFITSH+ 1. 0 1 1.61 11631 21 11 l- 11111 351000431 H IF/LITSClRITI 008.1580SctTSC+ 1. 0 1 2.21 11601 51 11 L 11111 391000431 H IF/LITSCl RITl 00Bl580$FITSH+ 1. 0 1 1.31 11531 131 11 l- 11111 411000436 H IF/LIF/LI I 2081580SFITSH+ 6. 8 1 0.91 11521 141 il I 11116 451000431 H IF/LIF/LI i 0081580SFITSH+ 1. 0 1 1.61 11591 61 14 11111 471000431 H IF/LIF/LI 1 0081580SFITSH+ 1. 1 1 4.31 11561 101 il l I 0411560SM109C+ 0. 0 1.11 11461 81 li 111111091999991 C lF/LIF/LI 1 t

i l i I I I I i 1 6 _

i i t i I FLORIDA POWER AND LIGHT COMPANY n . . .. . .. - _ _ _ _ _ - _ _ - _ _ - _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ - - - _ _ _ _ _ _ _ - _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ - - _ _ - _ _

l CUMULATIVE REPORT ,

l B, UNIT.1-02/87, ST. LUCIE, S/S L

STEAM GENERATOR: B- PAGE: 6 OF' 8 L

LOCATION .ALL DATE: 08/20/87 l CRITERIA: .1% TO 19% TIME: 11:47:07 i 1

I i l ,1 -lEXTENT I I I 'l l CURRENT I ILINIRDWlHEAT#1LEGIREQlTSTlREMIREELlPROBEI LOCATION IVOLTSIMILIDEGI % ICHI 1 'l I i 1 i l- 1 I i _ _

__ ! _ l I 1 i 1.

111121 381000431 H IF/LITSCIRITI 0071580SFlTSC+ 3. 7. I- 2.91 (157 41 il 1112l 441000431 H.lF/LIF/Li i 0071580SFlTSH+ 1. 1 ' 1 2.01 11561 51 il '

11121 941999991- C'IF/LIF/L1 1 0401580SMITSH+ 1. 3 1 2.91 11481 151 11

'l1131 151000601 H IF/LIF/LI l 0071580SFITSH+ 1. 3 1 1.51 11561 51 11 11131 311000431 H IF/LITSCIRITI 0071580SFITSC+- 1. 0 1 2.11 11571 41 11 11131 431000431 H IF/LIF/LI I 0071580SFITSH+ 0. 9 1 2.31 11591 il il 11131 691000601 H IF/LIF/LI i 0071580SFITSH+ 0. 6 1 2.61 11461 181 11 1 i l i H IF/LIF/LI i 0071580SF102H+ 0. 8 1 1.71 11491 141 1.1 11141 881999991 C lF/LIF/LI I 0391580SMl01H- 0. 5 1 1.01 11461. 51 11 11141 941000601 C.lF/LIF/LI l 0401580SMITSH+ 1.1 1 1.61 11461 171 11 11161 61000211 H 107Cl06CI i 0591580SDITSH+ 2.1 l 1.81 11431 131 11 11161 941999991 C IF/LIF/LI I 0391580SMITSH+ 0. 6 1 2.61 11401 131 11 ~

~11171 31999991 H 107Cl06Cl 1.0591580SD102H- 0. 5 1 1.11 1146i' 91 il 11171 21I000601 H IF/LIF/L1 1 0051580SFITSC+ 5. 8 l 2. 7 i 11561 11 11 11181 841999991 C IF/LIF/Lt 1.0381580SMITSH+ 1.1 1 3.21 11501 91 11 11191 851999991 C IF/LIF/LI I C381580SMITSH+ 4. 7 l 1.11- 11481 111 11 11191 871999991 C IF/LIF/Li I 0381580SMITSH+ 0. 8 I. 3.31 11431 161 11 11191 971000411' C IF/LIF/LI I 0381580SMl09H+ 0. 0 I '2.01 11511 El 11 11201 61000211 H 107Cl06CI: 1 0591580SDl02H+ 0. 5 1 0.81 11431 131 11 11201.801999991 C IF/LIF/LI i 0371580$MITSH+ 1. 0 1 3.61 11541 11 11 11211 671999991 H IF/LIF/Lt 1 0031580SMITSH+ 0. 8 1 2.01 11521 101 il 11211 871999991 C IF/LlF/LI l 0371580SMITSH+ 0. 8 1 2.21 11521 41 11 l~ l i I C IF/LIF/LI i 0371580SM101H- 0. 5 i 1.01 11511 51 11 1122l 141000411 H IF/LIF/Li I 0031580SMITSH+ 3. 5 1 2.21 11541 81 11 11221 461000601 H IF/LIF/L1 1 0031580$MITSH+ 1. 2 1 1.91 11461 171 11 11221 481000601 H IF/LIF/LI I 0031580SMITSH+ 0. 9 -1 3.31 11531 91 il 11221 701999991 H IF/LIF/LI I 0031580SMITSC+. 2.8 1 2.41 11531 9( 11

'l1221 761999991 H IF/LIF/LI i 0031580SMITSH+ 1. 0 1 3.91 11471 151 II 112261201000411 C IF/LIF/L1- 1 0371580SM109H+ 0. 0 1 0.71 11461 111 il 11231 351999991 H 1F/LIF/LI I 0541580SM102H+ 0. 5 1 0.91 11421 181 11 112311091000221 H IF/LIF/LI 1 0541580SM109H+ 0. 0 I 1.91 11521 61 11 112311231000221 H IF/LIF/LI i 0541580SM109H+ 0. 0 1 2.91 61501 81 11 11241 221999991 H IF/LIF/LI I 0531580SMITSC+ 6. 2 1 3.31 11441 1SI il 11248 281999991 H IF/LIF/LI i 0531580SM104H+ 0. 6 1 1.31 11441 151 11 l

11241 361999991 H IF/LIF/LI I 0531580SMITSH+- 1. 7 i 1.51 11511 81 11 112411441999991 H IF/LIF/Li 1 0531580SMITSH+ 6. 4 1 2.01 11521 71 11 11241 541999991 H lF/LIF/LI l'OS31580SMITSH+ 6. 4 1 1.71 11411 181 11 11241 601999991 H IF/LIF/LI i 0531580SMITSC+ 0. 5 i 1.21 11491 101 11 y

.41241 781000601 H IF/LIF/LI l 0531580SMITSH+ 0. 7 1 4.21 11431 161 11 l

l 11251 11999991 H 107C106Cl 1 0591580SD101H- 0. 3 1 0.81 1146l 91 11 11251 451999991 H IF/LIF/LI I 0521580SM101H+ 0. 0 1 1.31 11431 17l 11 f 11251 851999991 H IF/LIF/Lt 1 0531580SMl01H- 0. 4 1 1.51 11461 131 11 I i l- 1 H IF/LIF/Lt I 0531580SM101H+ 0. 5 l 1.21 11461 131 11

) i i i H IF/LIF/Lt 1 0531580SM103W+ 0. 0 1 0.51 11401 191 11 11261 761000601 C IF/LIF/LI I 2361580SMITSH+ 1.1 1 5. l i 11521 41 11 i I I I I___I___I_____I___I___I___l _ l____I__ l I l FLORIDA POWER AND LIGHT COMPANY

- - - _ __ - _ _____ - _ ___ ______-___ ____ ___ ____ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ -.____________-____/

CUMULATIVE REPORT 02/87, ST. LUCIE, S/G B, UNIT 1 STEAM GENERATOR: B PAGE: 7 OF 8 LOCATION: ALL DATE: 08/20/87 CRITERIA: 1% TO 19% TIME: 11:47:07 ILINIROWlHEAT#1LEGIREQlTSilREMIREELIPROBEl LOCATION IVOLTSIMILIDEGI % ICHI l___1___I .I I I I i 1 _I _ _

l i I I l__I 11271 331999991 C IF/LIF/Li 1 0351580RMITSC+ 4. 5 1 3.51 11451 61 11 (1281 581000601 C IF/LIF/LI 1 0351580RM144H- 0. 2 1 1.51 11441 71 Il 112811081000211 C IF/LIF/LI 1 03515BORM103C+ 0. 0 1 0.81 11381 161 il 112811121000211 C IF/LIF/LI 1 0351580RM1090+ 0. 0 1 1.91 11401 131 11 11291 331999991 C IF/LIF/LI I 0341580SMITSC+ 4. 3 1 2.01 11461 ill 11 11291 351000601 C IF/LIF/LI I 0341580$MITSH+ 1. 8 1 1.41 11401 191 11 11291 431999991 C IF/LIF/L1 1 0341580SMITSH+ 3. 7 1 2.01 11521 41 11 11291 691000601 C IF/LIF/LI I 0341580$MITSH+ 1. 4 1 2.31 11441 141 il 11291 711999991 C IF/LIF/LI I 0341580SMITSH+ 1.1 1 0.91 I1491 81 11 11301 141000411 C IF/LlF/L1 1 03415805MITSH+ 1. 3 1 1.81 11471 101 11 11301 281000601 C IF/L'F/LI I 0341580SMITSH+ 3. 5 1 0.81 11461 111 il 11301 321000601 C IF/LIF/Lt 1 0341580SMITSH+ 1. 4 1 3.01 11521 41 il 11301 401000601 C IF/LIF/L1 1 0341580SMITSH+ 1.1 ! 1.31 11401 191 11 l1301 481000501 C IF/LIF/LI I 0341580SMtTSH+ 5.4 1 0. 7 t 11481 91 11 11301 581999991 C IF/LIF/LI I 0341580SMITSH+ 0. 8 1 1. 3 i 11461 ill 11 i i i I C IF/LIF/Lt 1 0341580SMITSH+ 3. 3 I 1.01 11501 71 Il 11301 601999991 C IF/LIF/LI I 03415805MITSC+ 1. 8 1 1.31 11481 91 11 11311 211000601 C IF/LIF/L1 1 0321580SMITSH+ 2. 4 1 1.01 11401 191 11 11311 871999991 C IF/LIF/LI I 0331580SM103H+ 0. 0 1 1. 0 ) 11511 51 11 11321 141000411 C IF/LIF/LI I 0321580SMl01H+ 0. 5 1 1.51 11541 41 11 11321 841999991 C IF/LIF/LI I 0321580SM108H+ 0. 3 1 0. 6 i 11241 131 51 11331 71000211 H 107C106Cl I 0591580SDIBW3+ 0. 0 1 0.61 11391 181 il 11331101100021t C IF/LIF/LI I 0321580SM109H+ 0. 0 1 2.21 11561 21 11 11341 61000601 H 107C106CI 1 0591580SDl02H+ 0. 5 t 1.51 11491 51 il 11341 941000111 C IF/LIF/Lt I 0301500SM108H+ 0. 4 l 1.41 11441 31 11 11351 51000211 H 107C106CI 1 0591580SDiBW3+ 0. 0 i 1.61 11521 11 11 I I I I C 107Hl06HI I 0021580SDIBW3+ 0. 0 1 1.11 11571 41 il 11361 61000211 C 107H106HI 1 0021580SDIBW3+ 0. 0 1 0.71 11461 181 11 l 11391 391000601 C IF/LIF/Lt 1 0271SF ITSH+ 3. 0 1 0. 8 i 11431 151 II 1 1 I I C IF/LIF/L1 1 027tSF 104C+ 15.2 1 1.51 11431 151 11 l

1 11391 431999991 C IF/LIF/LI I 0271SF ITSH+ 3. 7 I 1. 7 ! 11511 El 11 l 11391 551999991 C IF/LIF/LI 1 0271SF ITSH+ 0. 8 1 0.81 11451 131 il 11401 441999991 C IF/LIF/LI I 0271SF ITSH+ 1. 2 1 1. 3 f 11471 111 11 11401 561000601 C IF/LIF/LI i 0271SF ITSH+ 0. 6 1 3.61 1145I 131 11 11411 211999994 C (F/LIF/LI I 0261580SFITSH+ 1. 5 I 3.51 11511 21 11 11411 671000601 C IF/LIF/L1 l 0261580SFIO4C+ 2. 8 1 1.21 11501 31 11 11421 561000601 C IF/LIF/LI I 025f580SMl02H+ 0. 4 l 1.71 11471 81 11 r 11431 331000601 C IF/LIF/Li 1 0251580SM101C+ 0. 4 1 0.61 11451 101 11 11431 611999991 C IF/LIF/li 1 0251580SMIBW3- 1. 5 1 0.91 1149f 51 11 1143l 87100060L C IF/LIF/LI i 0251580SM103H- 0. 5 1 1.81 11501 31 11 l1451 371999994 C IF/LIF/Li I 0F41580SM107H- 0. 4 1 1. l i 11491 51 li l

11461 78199999f C IF/LIF/LI i OE11580SM!01H+ 0. 5 1 0.71 11501 31 11 l I 0221580SM105C+ 30.4 0. 7 i 11461 9! il 11471 231000601 C IF/LIF/LI I 11471 33100060! C IF/LIF/LI l 0221580SMITS"+ 0. 9 1 1.2! 11501 31 11

l. 11481 201000601 C IF/LIF/Lt 1 0221580SMITSH+ 0. 7 1 2. 5 > 1144! 121 il i t i i i I 1 l 1 l I I I I i I FLORIDA POWER AND LIGHT COMPANY

c CUMULATIVE. REPORT 02/87, ST. LUCIE, S/G B, UNIT 1 STEAM GENERATOR: B- PAGE: 8 Or : 8 1

LOCATION: ALL' DATE: OS/20/87 (

' CRITERIA' 1% TO 19% TIME: 11:47:07 (

l- 1- 1 I IEXTENT.1 1 I l I CURRENT l ILINIROWlHEAT#1LEGIREQlTSTlREMIREELIPROBEl LOCATION. IVOLTSIMILIDEGI % ICHI l___I___I_____l ~l' I' I I l--- l____--- -l _I___I___I___I__l ,

11481:221000601 C IF/LIF/LI i 0221580SMITSH+ 1. 5 ~ l 1.11 11471 8(111 11491 371000601 C IF/LIF/Li 1 0211580SM107H- 1. 2 1 2.11 11411 161 11 l 11511 151000421 C IF/LIF/LI I 0231580SMITSH+ 0. 3 I .1.11 -11531 21 11

- 11511 551999991- C'lF/LIF/Ll- 1 0231580SM101H+ 0. 3 1 0.71 11411-161 11 l I

11521'281999991 C IF/LIF/LI I 0231580SM102H+ 0. 6 1 0.91 (1391 181 11 11521 721999991 C IF/LIF/LI I 0231580SMl01H+ 0.8 1 1.41 11531 21 11

- 11551,191000431 C-IF/LIF/Lt 1 0181580SM101H+ 0. 0 f 0. I 11421 151 11 .;

11551 291000601 C IF/LIF/L1 -1 0181580SM103H+ 0. 0 1 1.31 11401 171 11 -l

'l1591 551999991 C IF/LIF/L1 1 0171580SM102H+ 2. 6 1 0.61 11501 '71 11 !

11601 361999991 C IF/LIF/LI I 0171580SMIO1H+ 0. 7 l- 0.61 1144l 14 : 1i l 1160l'401999991 C IF/LIF/L1 1 0171580SM101H+ 0. 0 ~l 1.31 1152l 58-11 )

11611.291999991 C IF/LIF/LI ! 0171580SM105H+ 0. 4 1 1.01 ~l1401 191 11 l I

'l___I___I_____I___I___I___l___I____I_____t __ _ _ _ _ _

__ t ___I___1___1___l__I

' NUMBER OF TUBES SELECTED FROM CURRENT OUTAGE: 295 i NO TREND ANALYSIS REQUESTED 1

( l

{ l L

1 i.

l-l 1

FLORIDA POWER AND LIGHT COMPANY

CUMULATIVE REPORT 02/87, ST. LUCIE, S/G B,' UNIT 1

' STEAM GENERATOR: B- PAGE: 1 0F 6 LOCATION: ALL DATE: 08/20/87 CRITERIA: 20%'TO 39% TIME: 11:52:51

-. - ------- .--------- - _= --

ILINIROWlHEAT#1LEGIREQlTSTIREMIREELlPROBEl- LOCATION IVOLTSIMILIDEGI % ICHI ,

1- 1 1 1 i i I i I ___l__ f (___I l l- 1 1 71 71000111 C 107Hl06H1 1 0591580$Dl06H+ 15.2 1 0.61 11391 211 il i 111-511999991 H IF/LIF/Li 1 0161580SFIO1H+ 6. 3 1 1.81 11351 271 11 1 181 281999991 H'IF/LIF/LI l 0191580SMITSC+ 0. 6 1 1.31 11341 241 11 1 181.701999991 H IF/LIF/LI 1 0191580SM107C- 0. 3 1 0.61 11341 241 11 .

1 201- 41999991 C 107Hl06HI I 0591580SD101C- 0. 2 1 0.41 '11351 261 11- l 1 231 471999991'H IF/LIF/LI i 0221580SM102H+ 30.0 1 0.81 !!351 271 11 !

I 261 201999991'H IF/LIF/LI- t 0241580SM104H+ 0. 6 1 1.51 1133l 321 11 j i 271 431999991 H IF/LIF/LI I 0241580SMITSH+ 0. 8 1 0.91 1138t 271 11 j i 281-141000601_H IF/LIF/Li 1 0251580SMITSC+ 2. 5 1 2.11 11261 341 11

.l 281 561999991 H IF/LIF/LI I 0251580SMIBW3+ 0. 0 l 0.61 11311 301 16 1 291 15l000441 H IF/LIF/L1 -1 0251580SM101H+ 0. 3 1 0. 7 f 1136) 251 11 1'291 351999991 H IF/LIF/Lt 1 0251580SM101H- 0. 3 1 1.81 11331 28l 11 1 2911011000601 H IF/LIF/Lt. 1 0261580SFITSC+ ~9. 7 l 1.11 11331 301 11 1 2911031000421 H IF/LIF/Lt 1 0261580SFlTSC+ 9. 8 1 0.91 11291 341 11 L i 311 691999991 H IF/LIF/Lt 1 0271580$M101H+ 0. 0 1 0.91 11431 201 11 l 1 331 18999991 H 107C106Cl 1 0011580SDl01H- 0.1 1 0.61 1.143l 211 11 l 331 351999991 H IF/LIF/LI i 0281580SMITSH+ 'O.6 1 1.01 11351 311 il l

L I 341 341999991- H IF/LIF/Lt 1 0291580SMITSH+ 0. 4 l 1. 3 I 1144l 211 11 l 341 621999991 H ;F/LIF/Li 1 0291580sMITSH+ 0. 3 1 1.71 1134l 321 11 l

j i 361 621000608 H IF/LIF/L1 1 0301580SMITSH+ 1. 0 1 2.31 1144l 211 il l 1 361 821999991 H IF/LIF/Li 1 0301580SMl01H+ 0. 0 1 0.71 11351 311 11 l 1 371 311000501 H IF/LIF/Ll' I 0301580SMITSH+ 0. 7 1 1.31 11311 351 it i i i i H IF/LIF/Lt 1 0301580SMITSH+ 1. 0 1 2.01 11361 301 11 i i i i H IF/LIF/LI I 0301580SMITSH+ 6. 9 l 1.71 11341 32I il l I I I H IF/LIF/LI I 0301580SMITSC+ 2. 2 1 5.01 11431 221 11 1 371 631999991 H IF/LIF/LI I 0311580SMITS4+ 0. 9 l 1.71 11371 241 il

! 381 681999991 H IF/LIF/LI i 0311580SMITSs+ 0. 7 1 0.71 11251 381 11 1 384 721999991 H IF/L1F/LI I 0311580SMITSH+ 0. 9 1 1.11 11361 261 11 1 381 801999991 H IF/LIF/LI 1 0311580SMITSH+ 1. 2 1 1.31 11391 221 11 1 391 751000601 H IF/LIF/Lt 1 03215805MITSH+ 1. 0 1 1.91 11351 251 11 I 401 241999991 H IF/LIF/LI I 03315895MITSC+ 6. 6 1 1.91 11381 221 11 1 All 871000601 H IF/LIF/Li 1 0341580SMITSH+ 0. 6 1 1,71 11421 23l 11 1 I I I H IF/LIF/LI 1 034t580SM101H+ 0. 3 1 0.91 11411 241 11 1 I I I H IF/LIF/Lt 1 0341580SMl02H+ 0. 3 1 1.51 11321 341 18 14 1091000441 H IF/LIF/LI i 03,1580SMl09H+ 0. 0 1 1.01 1120: 231 St I 421 241000601 H IF/LIF/Lt 1 0351580SMITSC+ 6. 3 1 4.91 11351 251 11 1 421 621999991 H IF/LIF/LI I 0341580SM101C+ 0. 3 1 1.41 11441 211 11 1 4211101000441- H IF/LIF/LI I 0341580SM109C+ 0. 0 1 1.51 11421 231 11 1 <43 251999991 H IF/LIF/LI 1 0351590SMITSC+ 6. 6 1 1.41 11251 371 11

'l 441 141000221 H IF/LIF/LI ! 036-1580SMITSC+ 3. 0 1 0.96 6134l 26l 11 1 441 24100?S01 H IF/LIF/L) 1 036158e3MITSC+ 6. 7 I 1.11 11351 251 11 1 I I ' H IF/LIF/LI I 0361580SMITSC+ 5. 4 1 3.61 11221 361 il I 441 46199999) -l IF/LIF/LI i 0361580SM!TSC+ 1. 8 1 1.21 11301 291 11 i 441 781999991 H IF/LIF/Lt 1 036tS80SM;TSH+ 2. 2 1 0.41 11171 261 51 1 441 861999991 H IF/LIF/LI 1 036tF80SMITGW+ 0. 9 l 1.61 11311 281 11

' ' I I I I i I l-- l --- l ----- l --- l -- I --_l--- I ..

FLORIDA POWER AND LIGHT COMPANY

CUMULATIVE REPORT 02/87, ST. LUCIE, S/G B, UNIT 1 l l

' STEAM GENERATOR: B PAGE: 2 0F 6-LOCATION:-ALL DATE: 08/20/87 CRITERIA: 20% TO 39% TIME: 11:52:51

______ __ _ =

ILINIROWlHEAT#1LEGIREQlTSTlREMIREELIPROBEl LOCATION IVOLTSIMILIDEGI % ICHI I- 1 I i l i l l_ l _

i _! I' l___f___I__1 -l l 441 941000441 H IF/LIF/LI 1 0361580SM109C+ 0. 0 1 2.01 11341.261 il 1 451 211999991 H IF/LIF/LI i 0361580SM102H+ 0. 0 1: 1.01 11201 231 51 1 451 871000601 H lF/LIF/LI I 0371580SMITSH+ 1. 2 1 2.91 11381 221 11 1 471 71000111 H 107CIO6Cl 1 0011580SD101H+ 0. 5 1 'O.31 11421 221 11 1 471 511999991 C IF/LIF/LI l'0151580SFl04H- 0. 6 i 1.41 11251 361 11 1 481 38I999991 C IF/LIF/LI l'0151580SFlTSH 10.009 I 0.81 .11371 231 11 1 48l1221999991 H lF/LIF/LI I 0381580SM109C+ 0. 0 1 2.61 11411 201 11 l 1.5211021000601 H IF/LIF/LI I 0391580SMl01H+ 32.2 1 1.01 11251 351 11 {

l 541 921000601 H lF/LIF/L1 1 0401580SMITSH+ 1. 0 1 2.01 11331 28) .11 1 561 921999991 H IF/LIF/Lt 1 0411580SMITSH+ 0. 5 1 0.71 11301 271 11 1 571 871999991 H lF/LIF/Li 1 0411580SMITSH+ 4. 6 1 1.11 11351 221 11 1 5711291999991 H IF/LIF/L1 1 04115805MIBW3+ 0. 0 1 1.01 11331 241 il I 581 94t999991 H IF/.LIF/LI -t 0411580SMITSH+ 0. 6 1- 0.91. 11351 221 il

! 6011181999991 H IF/LIF/Lt 1 0421580SM101H+ 0. 7 ' I 0.81 11301 311 il I 6111191999991 H lF/LIFILI I 0431580SMIO9C+ 0. 0 1 2.01 11361 251 il I 6111291999991 H IF/LIF/Lt 1 0431580SM109C+ 0. 0 1 1.01 11291 321 11 1 6111331999991 H IF/LIF/LI I 0431580SM109C+ 0. 0 1 2.16 1112t 291 51 1 6211281000601 H IF/LIF/LI I 0431580SMIO90+ 0. 0 1 2.21 1137; 241 il I 631 991999991 H IF/LIF/Li 1 0444580SMITSC+ 1. 3 1 1.21 11311 291 11 I 6411281000601 H IF/LIF/LI I 0441580SM109C+ 0. 0 1 1.71 11291 321 il I 651 311000221 C IF/LIF/LI i 0071580SM101H+ 0. 5 1 1.41 1120! 384 il I 6611321999991 H IF/LIF/LI i 0451580RM101H+ 20.1 1 0.81 11291 32) il I 671 431000221 H IF/LIF/LI 1.0621540NGITSH+ 0.1 1 1.11 11221 24tM5!

l 671 451000221 H IF/LIF/Lt 1 0621540NGITSH+ 0.1 1 1.21 (1181 311M51 1 6711351999991 H IF/LIF/LI 1 046l580SMl03C+ 0. 0 1 1.91 11271 341 11 1 681 94l999991 H IF/LIF/Li 1 0461580SMl090+ 0. 0 1 2.21 11241 371 il I 6811161999991 H IF/LIF/LI I 0461580SMl09H+ 0. 0 1 1.21 11351 241 11 l

'l 6811261999991 H IF/LIF/LI I 0461580SM109C+ 0. 0 1 2.71 11331 271 11 1 6811281999991 H IF/LIF/LI I 0461580SM109C+ 0. 0 1 1.41 11311 291 il 1 691 271000601 C IF/LIF/L1 1 00615803MIBW1+ 0. 0 1 3.81 11241 341 il .

I 6911091999991 H IF/LIF/LI I 0461580SM109C+ 0. 0 1 0.98 11351 241 il _{

l 6911191000601 H IF/LIF/L1 1 0461580SM109C+ 0. 0 l 1.21 11311 291 11 l 1 6911331999991 H IF/LIF/Li 1 0461580SM109C+ 0. 0 1 1.31 11321 281 11 ]

I 701 941000501 H IF/LIF/Lt 1 0471580FM109C+ 0. 0 1 1.21 11321 281 11 1 711 491000111 C IF/LIF/LI i 0051A580SITSC+ 7.1 1 3.01 (1361 261 11 ;

I 7111331999991 H tF/LIF/Li 1 0471580FM109C+ 0. 0 1 1.21' 11281 331 11 1 721 401000601 C IF/LIF/LI 1 0041580SFITSH+ 0. 9 1 1.01 11101 361 51 l 1 1 1 l C IF/LIF/L1 ! 0041580SFITSH+ 1. 3 1 1.61 11391 261 il ;

i 1 1 l C IF/LIF/LI i 0041580SFITSH+ 1. 7 I 2.61 11271 381 11 1 7211041999991 H IF/LIF/L1 1 0481580SMITSH+ 2. 9 I 0. 9 I 1135I 221 il I 721118l000501 H IF/LIF/L1 1 0481580SM109C+ 0. 0 1 1.91 11231 35l 11 1 7211261999991 H IF/LIF/LI I 0471580FM109H+ 0. 0 1 1.91 11371 221 11 1 731 451000111 C IF/LIF/LI I 0041580SFITSH+ 1. 7 1 1.21 11321 331 11 f I 731-631000111 C IF/LIF/LI I 004I580SFt01H+ 0. 5 l 1.41 11351 301 11 i 1 741 401000601 C IF/LIF/LI l 004tS80SFlTSH+ 0. 7 2.11 11431 211 11 f 1

i i i l i___i___i_____i___i___i___i___i____i i___- i i FLORIDA POWER AND LIGHT COMPANY

)

CUMULATIVE REPORT 02/87, ST. LUCIE, S/G B, UNIT 1

~

iSTEAM GENERATOR: B' PAGE: 3.0F G :)

LOCATION: ALLE DATE: 08/20/87 l

o. CRITERIA 20% TOL-39%1 TIME: 11:52:51

__=

l 1 .1 1 IEXTENT I I I I I CURRENT l ILINIROWlHEAT#1LEGIREQlTSTlREMIREELlPROBEI LOCATION IVOLTSIMILIDEGI % ICHI l- I 'l' _l' i l___I___1 . l_____l ____I_____I___l___I___I__I I IL751 511999991' C IF/LIF/Li' I 0481580SMITSH+ 1.1 1 2. 3 i - 11401.201 il I 761 661999991 C IF/LIF/L1 1 0491 580SITSH+ 3. 9 1 0.91 11331 281 11 1-7611361999991 C IF/LIF/LI i 0494 580Sl09H+ 0. 0 1 2.01 11301 301 il I 771 871999991 C IF/LIF/L1 1 0501580SMITSH+ 1. 9 1 0.71 11271 331 11 l'7711091999991 C IF/LIF/LI I 0501580SMl09C+ 0. 0 1 0. 6 l 11071 331 51 1

.!1781 441999991 C IF/LIF/Lt 1 0511580SMITSH+- 1. 7 i '1.41 11381 201 11

' l: 781 601999991 C-lF/LIF/L1 l 0511580SMITSH+ 3.1 1 0.91 11351 23I il

! 791129t999991 C IF/LIF/L1 1 0521580SMl09H+ 0. 0 1 1.41 11271 331.il I 801 721999991 C lF/LIF/LI l 0521580SMl02H+ 0. 7 1 0.76 11351 251 il 1:801.981999991 C IF/LIF/LI.

- 1 0521580SMITSH+ 2. 5 1 0.81 11331 271 il 1 8011001000501 C IF/LIF/LI I 0521580SMITSH+ 1.1 l 1.61 11331 271 11 1 8011321999991 C IF/LIF/LI I 0521580SM109H+ 0. 0 1 1.11 11391 211 11 1 8211321999991 C IF/LIF/LI i 054l580SM109H+ 0. 0 1 1.61. 11351 221 il 1.8311191999991 C lF/LIF/Lt 1 0551580SM109C+ 0. 0 1 1.71' 11291 301 11 1 8411181000601 C IF/LIF/LI I 0551580SM109C+ 0. 0 1 1.71 11381 201 11 1 8411341999991 C IF/LIF/LI l 0551580SMl09C+ 0. 0 1 1.71 11231 361 11 1 851 511999991 C IF/LIF/Li .1 0571580SMITSC+ 5. 9 i 3.01 11341 221 il I 8511191999991 H IF/LIF/LI 1 0551580SM109C+ 0. 0 1 1.01 11281 291 11 1.861 521000601 H lF/LIF/Li- l 0564580SMITSC+ 6. 2 1 2.01 1124l 341 11 1 8611241000501 H IF/LIR/LI l 0551580SM109C+ 0. 0 1 1. 31 ~ 11321 241 11 1 871 471999991 H IF/LIF/LI I 0561580SMITSC+ 5. 5 1 0.81 1119i 391 11 1 871 751000601 H IF/L;F/LI L 0561580SMl01H+ 0. 4 1 1.41 11371 221 11 1 881 481999991 H IF/LIF/LI 1 0571580SMITSC+ 5.1 1 1.31 11251 321 il i 891 531999991 H IF/LIF/Li I 0571580SM102H+ 0. 0 1 1,41 11251 321 11 1 891 691999991 H lF/LIF/Lt 1 0571580SM101H- 0. 5 1 1.01 11321 241 il I 901 581999991 H IF/LIF/LI I 0521580SMITSH+ 3. 6 1 0.81 11331 29I 11 1 9011001000601 H lF/LIF/LI i 0511580SM109C+ 0. 0 1 1.41 1123I 361 11 1 911'531000601 H IF/LIF/LI l 0501580SM I TSC+ 6. 9 1 3.21 11251 341 Il

! 921 481000601 H IF/LIF/L1 1 0501580SMITSC+ 6. 8 1 1.61 11221 371 il 1.921 94l999991 H IF/LIF/L1 1 0501580SMITSH+ 4. 7 1 0.81 11391 211 11 I 9211101999991 H IF/LIF/LI I 0501580SMITSC+ 0. 4 1 0.71 11331 271 11 1 9311071000601 H IF/LIF/LI I 0491580SMITSH+ 0. 8 1 2.31 11311 301 11 1 1 1 i H l'F/LIF/LI i 0491580SMITSH+ 2.1 1 0.71 1123I 371 il I '941 341000601 H IF/LIF/Li 1 0141580SM101H+ 0. 0 1 1.31 1137) 271 11

'l~941 481000601 H IF/LIF/L1 1 0141580SM102H+ 0. 4 1 0.91 11241 391 11 1 1 1 i H IF/LIF/Lt 1 0141580SM106C+ 0. 4 1 1.91 1144l 201 il

! 951 631999991 H IF/LIF/Lt 1 014l580SMIBW3+ 1. 6 1 0.81 11371 271 11 1 9511071000601 C IF/LlF/Lt. t 0471580SMITSH+ 1. 3 1 2.61 11301 311 11 i I i i C IF/LIF/LI i 0471580SM101H+ 0. 0 i 1.21 11331 281 il i I i i C IF/LIF/LI 1 0471580SM109C+ 0. 0 1 1.51 11241 371 11 1 9511331999991 C IF/LIF/LI I 0471580SM109C+ 0. 0 1 2.01 1132! 291 il I 961 541999991 H IF/LIF/Lt 1 0131580RMITSH+ 3. 2 1 1.31 11401 241 11

(. 1 0121580SFl01H+ 0. 5 1.01 11331 321 11 l 1 991 311999991 H IF/LIF/Lt i l 991 356000601 H IF/LIF/LI i 0121580SFITSC+ 6. 3 1 2.01 11341 311 11 f

11001 301999991 H IF/LIF/LI i 0121580SFITSH+ 1.1 1 1.51 11231 391 il l- _______t I i l i I I___I___I_____I___I___I___I___I____l - , . - _

l '.

FLORIDA POWER AND LIGHT COMPANY

CUMULATIVE REPORT 02/87, ST. LUCIE, S/G B, UNIT 1 STEAM GENERATOR: B RAGE: 4 OF 6 LOCATION: ALL DATE: 08/20/87 CRITERIA: 20% TO 39% TIME: 11:52:51

~

~~

i l I i IEXTENT I I i l l CURRENT l I LIN I ROW l HEAT # 1 LEG I REQ l TST I REM l REEL l P ROBE l LOCATION IVOLTSIMIL JEGI % ICHI i l i i 1 i l i i 1 i i i I i 1 __

11001 541999991 H IF/LIF/LI I 0121580SFITSC+ 5. 9 1 1.91 11381 261 11 11011 451000701 H IF/LIF/LI I 0621540NGITSH- 0. 2 1 0.91 11L31 22tM i i i i i H IF/LIF/LI I 0621540NGITSH- ?. 2 1 0.91 11231 221M51 11011 851000601 C IF/LIF/LI I 0451580SM101H+ 0. 3 1 0.51 11301 301 il 110111051000501 C IF/LIF/LI I 0451580SM109H+ 0. 0 1 2.21 11331 261 11 110111071000601 C IF/LIF/Lt 1 0451560SMITSH+ 1. 0 1 1.31 11351 241 11 110111171000501 C IF/LIF/LI i 0451580SM109C+ 0. 0 1 1. 51 11381 211 11 11021 421000701 H IF/LIF/LI i 0621540NGITSH- 0.1 1 1.11 11231 22tM i l i i l H IF/LIF/LI I 0621540NGITSH+ 0.1 1 1.11 11231 22iM51 11021 481000501 H 1F/LIF/LI I 0121580SF101H+ 0. 5 1 3.11 1136l 291 11 11031 431000701 H IF/LIF/LI I 0621540NGITSH+ 0. 0 1 0.81 1122l 241M i I l i I H IF/LIF/LI I 0621540NGITSH+ 0. 0 1 0.81 11221 241N51 1104l 221000601 H IF/LIF/LI I 0111580SMITSH+ 0. 7 l 1.71 1137! 271 11 11051 171000411 H IF/LIF/LI L 0101580SFITSC+ 2. 5 i 1.01 1143I 211 11 11061 961999991 C IF/LIF/LI i 0431580SMITSH+ 0. 8 1 2. 0 I 11331 261 il 110611261000501 C IF/LIF/L1 1 0431580SMl09C+ 0. 0 1 2.41 11281 321 il 11071 431000411 H IF/LIF/LI I 0091580SF101H+ 0. 5 l 1. 31 1133l 301 il 110711071000601 C IF/LIF/Lt I 0431580SMITSH+ 0. 7 1 2.21 11301 301 il 11081 801000421 H IF/LIF/LI I 0091580SFITSH+ 3.1 1 1.2I 11441 201 11 110811061999991 C (F/LIF/LI i 04265803MITSH+ 1. 3 1 2.11 1141l 211 11 11091 15l000601 H IF/LIF/LI I 0091580SFlTSH+ 4. 0 1 2.81 11431 211 11 11091 471000421 H IF/LIF/LI i 0091580SFl01H+ 0. 5 i 1.11 11331 301 il 11091 711000421 H IF/LIF/L1 1 0081580SFITSH+ 1. 2 1 1.11 1144l 231 11 11101 761000431 H IF/LIF/LI i 0081580SFITSH+ 1. 0 1 0.91 11431 24) il 11111 251000431 H IF/LIF/LI i 0081580SFITSC+ 7. 0 1 0.91 I1141 351 51 1111l 331000431 H IF/LITSCIRITI 008I580SFlTSH+ 5.1 1 0.81 11401 271 il (1111 371000431 H IF/LITSCIRITI 0081580SFlTSH+ 1. 0 1 1.21 11451 221 11 11111 471000431 H IF/LIF/LI I 0081580SFITSH+ 2. 2 1 1.51 11391 281 il 11111 871999991 C IF/LIF/LI I 0411580SM101H+ 0. 5 1 1. 4 i 11331 241 il 11121 221000431 H IF/LIF/LI 1 0071580SFITSC+ 7. 3 1 1.21 1142l 221 11 11121 60100043I H IF/LIF/LI i 0071580SFlTSH+ 0. 9 I 1.11 11391 261 11 11121 781000601 H IF/LIF/LI i 0081580SFITSH+ 0. 6 l 1.41 11321 351 11 11131 151000601 H IF/LIF/LI I 0071580SFl01H+ 0. 3 1 2. 4 l 11421 221 il 11131 691000601 H IF/LIF/L1 1 0071580SFIO1H+ 0. 6 1 1.31 11391 261 11 11131 71100044l H IF/LIF/LI I 0071580SFITSH+ 0. 8 l 1.51 11141 321 51 11141 941000601 C IF/LIF/LI I 0401580SM109H+ 0. 0 1 2.71 11421 201 11 l 11161 861999991 C IF/LIF/LI I 0391580SM101H- 0. 5 1 0. 8 ! I1241 331 11 l 11161 901999991 C IF/LIF/LI 1 0391580SMITSH+ P,6 1 0.51 11251 32I 11 11161 961999991 C IF/LIF/LI I 0391580SMITSH+ .6 l 1.01 1122l 351 il 111611221000501 C IF/LIF/LI I 0391580SM109C+ 0. 0 1 2.11 11301 261 11 l 11171 211000601 H IF/LIF/LI I 00515E05 ITSC+ 5. 5 1 2.31 (1351 271 11 11171 811000601 C IF/LIF/LI I 0391580SMITSH+ 1.1 1 0.91 11201 371 11 l I 0391580SMl09H+ 0. 0 2. 31 11281 281 11 i 11171 951000411 C IF/LIF/LI l l 11181 841999991 C IF/LIF/LI i 0381580SMITSH+ 2. 8 1 1.11 1138I 201 11 11181 881999991 C IF/LIF/Li 1 0381580SMITSH+ 0. 9 1 1.01 11321 261 11 i i i i , i i i i i i i i i i i 1

f FLORIDA POWER AND LIGHT COMPANY l

CUMULATIVE REPORTL 02/87, ST. LUCIE, S/G' B, UNIT 1

' STEAM GENERATOR: B PAGE: 5 0F 6 LOCATION: ALL DATE: 08/20/87 CRITERIA: 20% TO 39% TIME: 11:52:51

~ "~

~~

I I I I lESTENT I i~ l l ~~~~I~~~~~~ CURRENT l ILINIROWlHEAT#1LEGIREQlTSTIREMIREELIPROBEl LOCATION IVOLTSIMILIDEGI % ICHI ;

l' 'l I i l i I I I _f __. ________1_____I___I___l___I__l l 11181 921000411 C IF/L'lF/LI I 0381580SM102H+ 0. 2 1 1.51 11381 201 11

1. I i 1 C IF/L1F/LI 8 0381580$Ml09H+ 0. 0 1 2.51 .11381 201 11 11191 851999991 C IF/LIF/LI I 0381580SMITSH+ 0. 8 1 2.31 1134l 241 11' ,

1 I l- 1 C IF/LIF/LI i 0381580SMITSH+ 2. 8 I 1.21 11381 201 11 11201 661000601 H IF/LIF/Lt 1 0041580SFITSC+' 0.9 1 2.51 11271 351 11 11201'881999991 C-IF/LIF/Li 1 0371580SMITSH+ 1. 2 1 1.41 11381.218 il l I I I C IF/LIF/LI I 0371580SMITSH+ 1. 9 l 1.81 1135l 241 il 1 1 1 i C IF/LIF/LI I 0371580SMITSH+ 2. 5 1 1.61 11291 311 !!

112011181000411 C Ir/LIF/Lt 1 0381580SMl09C+ 0. 0 1 1.21 11321 261 il 11211 331999991 H IF/LIFILI I 0031580SMITSH+ 2. 3 1 1.51 11371 261 il 11221 461000601 H IF/LIF/LI I 0031580SM103H+ 0. 0 1 0.81 11401 23i il 11221 781000601 H IF/LIF/LI i 0031580SMITSH+ 1.1 I 1.61 11061 30i 51 11241 241999991 H IF/LIF/LI I 0531580SMITSC+ 6. 9 . I 1.91 I1381 201 il 1124l 401999991 H IF/LIF/LI i 0531580SMITSC+ 4. 8 - l 1.31 11361 221 il 112411221000221 H IF/LIF/LI i 0531580SMl09H+ 0. 0 1 2.01 11221 351 il 11251 15t000421 H IF/LIF/LI 1 0521580SMl01H+ 0. 0 1 2.21 11391 221 il 11251 371999991 H IF/LIF/LI I 0521580SM107H+ 0. 0 1 1.81 11291 .331 il 112611001000221 C IF/LIF/LI I 0361580SM109H+ 0. 0 1 3.81 11251 351 11 1126l1121000221 C IF/LIF/LI i 0361580SM102H+ 0. 5 l 1.11 11331 261 il 11271 591999991 C IF/LIF/Li 1 0361580SMITSH+ 0. 8 1 0.71 1135l 24l 11 11271 611000601 C IF/LITSHIRITI 0361580SM101H+ 0. 5 1 1.71 11301 301 11 11281 581000601 C IF/LIF/Lt 1 0351580RM101H+ 0. 0 1 2.61 11281 291 11 11281 761000601 C IF/LIF/LI i 035I580RM103C- 0. 5 1 1.71 11351 201 11 11291 23t999991 C IF/LIF/LI 1 0341580SMITSH+ 4.1 1 0.81 11361 231 11 l 11291 431999991 C IF/LIF/LI I 0341580SMITSH+ 2. 8 l 1.01 11261 341 il .

I 11291 511999991 C IF/LIF/Li 1 0341580SMITSC+ 0. 6 1 0.81 11316 281 11 I 8

11291 691000601 C IF/LIF/LI I 0341580SMITSH+ 1. 0 1 1.01 11371 221 11 11291 971000211 C IF/LIF/LI -1 0341580SM109C+ 0. 0 1 1.41 11261 341 11 i i

11301 781000601 C IF/LIF/Lt 1 0331580SMITSH+ 1. 0 1 1.31 11201 371 11 !

l 113011081000211 C IF/LIF/Lt I 0331580$Ml09H 0.00 1 1.71 11271 311 11 I i l i C IF/LIF/LI i 0331580SM109H+ 0. 0 1 1.71 1127I 311 11 1 1 1 1 C IF/LIF/LI I 0331580SM1090+ 0. 0 1 1.21 11311 271 11 113011161000601 C IF/LIF/Lt t 0331580SM104H+ 0. 0 1 2.41 11321 271 11 11311 391000601 C 1F/LIF/LI i 0331580SM104H+ 0. 0 1 1.51 11341 251 il 11318 431999991 C IF/LIF/L1 1 0331580SM101C+ 23.8 1 0.91 .133, 251 11 1131l 491999991 C IF/LIF/LI i 0331580SM101H+ 0. 0 1 1.11 11381 215 11 !

113111011000211 C IF/LIF/LI I 0331580SM101H+ 0. 0 1 1.21 11351 241 11 '

61000601 H 107C106CI I 0591580SD101H- 0. 4 1 1.01 11301 28, il 11321 11341 61000601 H 107C106Cl i 0591580SDIBW3+ 0. 0 1 0.91 11221 311 il 11361 61000211 C 107H106HI I 002l580SDiBW3+ 0.0 1 0.91 11301 351 11 1 I I I H 107C106Cl I 0591580SDiBW3+ 0. 0 1 1.11 11221 371 11 l 11391 491000601 C IF/LIF/LI 1 0271SF IBW3+ 0. 0 1 1.01 11381 211 11 11401 161000421 C IF/LIF/L1 l 027tSF 101H+ 35.7 1 0.71 11271 321 it l

l 11401 561000601 C IF/LIF/LI i 027lSF ITSH+ 1. 7 l 1. 2 l 11331 PGl 11 11451 351999991 C IF/LIF/LI i 0241580SMl01H- 0. 3 1 0.4i 11581 221 11 i ; I t i 1 l i I i l i i 1 I _l.__ _ _ _ _

FLORIDA POWER AND LIGHT COMPANY

l '

CUMULATIVE. REPORT

'02/87,,ST. LUCIE, S/G B, UNIT 1-STEAM GENERATOR: P. PAGE: 6 OF- 6 LOCATION:'ALL DATE:

08/20/87-CRITERIA: 20% TO 39% TIME: 11:52:51

I I 1 lEXTENT I 1 I I I CURRENT l 11 ILINIROWlHEAT#1LEGIREQlTSTIREMIREELIPROBEl LOCATION IVOLTSIMILIDEGI % ICHI I 1 I I 'l l 'l___l __I_____I___l___I___l___I____I__-__I -

1

! I'1451 471999991 C IF/LIF/LI 1 0241580SM106C+ 24.0 1 0.51' 11361 221 11-11461 921000111 C IF/LIF/LI I 0231580SM109C+ 0. 0 1 2.51 11301 301 11 11471 31999991 H 107C106Cl I 0581580RM102H+ 0. 6 1 1.01. 11301 291 11

-11471.571000501 C IF/LIF/Li- l 0221580SM105H- 0. 6 1 0.81- 11221 381 11

'l1491 71000604 H 107C106Cl l'0581580RMIBW3+ - 0. 0 1 2. 5 I 11381 211 il i i I l C 107Hl06HI 1 0021580SDIBW3+ 1. 3 1 2. 4 f 11431 211 11

'11511 11999991 H 107Cl06Cl 1 0581580RMIO1H+ 0. 8 1 1.31 11231 351 11 11521 441999991 C IF/LIF/LI i 0231580SM101H- 0. 6 I 0.81 11371 211-11 1153l 29I000604 C IF/LIF/L1 1 0191580SMIO4H+ 0.6 1 0.91 11371 211 11. ,

l___l___I_____I___I___I___l___I I l' __ l 1 __l.__l___l._4 i

NUMBER-OF TUBES SELECTED FROM CURRENT DUTAGE: 211 i NO TREND ANALYSIS REQUESTED i

t FLORIDA POWER AND LIGHT COMPANY

y

. . . CUMULATIVE REPORT L .

.02/87, ST. LUCIE, S/G- B, UNIT 1 l

. i

')

STEAM GENERATOR:'B PAGE: 1 0F 1.

LOCATIONEALL DATE: 08/20/87

' CRITERI A: 40% TO 100% TIME: 11:43:23 1'

-__a._______.-- _____ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ - _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ - _____

lLINIROWlHEAT#1LEGIREQlTSTlREMIREELIPROBEl

. LOCATION IVOLTSIMILIDEGI % ICHI l l ._l___l_____l.__I__ l___I___l ~l 1 -__.____I_____I_.__l__ l___I__I j 11121 491 11

-l:151.-.71000111 C 197Hl96HiRPIl 0594580SDIBW3+ 0. 0 1 0.81 i 301 601999991 H IF/LIF/LIRPII 0261580SF1TSH+ 0. 8 1 1.21 11161 47l 11 ;

I 351 511999991 H IF/LIF/LiRPIi 0291580SMITSH+ 0. 8 l 1.41 11211 441 11 ;

I 371 231999991 HflF/LIF/LI

~

1 8301580SMITSC+ 5. 8 1 1.11 11151 501 il

0. 3 0.51 11211 441,il l 391 '31999991 H 197Cl06CIRPIl 0011580SDiO1H+ 1 l'461 701999991 C IF/LIF/LIRP!l 0161580SMITSC+ 5. 5 1 2.41 l 941 601 11

-1.471 631999991 C IF/LIF/LIRPIl 0151580SFITSC+ 5. 3 1 1.91 11081 521 11 ,

i 481 701999991 C IF/LIF/LIRPIl-0151580SFITSC+ 4. 7 1 1.01 11191 421 11 I i 5411221999991 H IF/LIF/LIRPIl 0401580SM109H+ 0. 0 i 1.81 11001 561 il 1 581 361000601 C IF/LIF/LIRPIl 0101580SMITSC+ 5. 8 I 5.91 11211 411 11-l 601 61000111 H 197Cl06CIRP!l 8021580SDl91H+ 1. 0 1 1.71 11221 431 11 l 611 471999391 C IF/LIF/LI i 0091580SM101H- 0. 5 1 1.01 11061 501 il I 6211041000601 H'lF/LIF/LIRPIl 0431580SMl09H+ 0. 0 1 0.61 11201 401 il l'.651 491000221 C IF/LIF/LIRPII.0071580SMITSC+ 6.0 1 1.51 1 971 591 11-

-l' 6811381000501- H IF/LIF/LIRPIl G461580SMITSH+ 10.9 1 1.01 11081 531 il i 761 481000601 C IF/LITSHIRITI 0491 5BOSITSC+ 6. 5 1 1.31 11041 541.11 1.11 11161f471:il 1 841'481999991 C IF/LITSHIRPIl 0561580SMITSC+. 5.7 1 l 8911351000601 H IF/LIF/LIRPII. 0581580RM109C+ 0. 0 1 2.81 11161'411:11-11001 441999991 H IF/LIF/LIRPIl 01215806F ITSC+ 5. 3 1 3.01 11081 551:11 11101 761000431. H'lF/LIF/LIRPIl 8081580SFITSH+ 0. 8 l -2.11 11171 481 11-11111.:71000211 H 197Cle6CIRPIl 0591580SDl01H+ 0. 5 i 1.31 11131 461 il 11121 ~ 461000601 - H lF/L!F/LIRPIl 0071580SFl01H+ 0. 0 1 0.61 11221 431 il 1112I 981999991 C IF/LIF/LIPP!I 0401580SM109H+ 0. 0 1 1.71 litel 421 il l 11191 51000211 H 197Cl06ClHP!l 0594580SD101H- 0. 4 1 1.61 I 99! 591 1'l '\

11201 241999991 H IF/LIF/LIRPIl 8031580SM192H+ 0. 6 1 0.41 11191 431 11 i?

11211'971000411 C IF/LIF/LIRPIl 0371580SMl01H+ 0. 4 1 0.91 11f61 531-11.*

1127ll 231999991 C IF/LIF/LIRP!l 0351580RMITSC+ 5. 9 I t. J J !!OSI 34.t il '

11381 941000601 C IF/LIF/LlRPIl 0281580SFl99H+ 0. 0 1 1.91 ._1 941 461 Si 1146l 201000601~ C IF/LIF/LIRPIl 0231580SM101H- 0. 5 i 1.71 11201 All 11 i 1_ _I___I_____I__ l __l___I___I____I_____I______________

_I___t__.J._.;__I_.{; )

NUMBER OF TUBES SELECTED FROM CURRENT DUTAGE: 29 ,

4 NO. TREND ANALYSIS REQUESTED ,

i R s ,

3 3 >

9, e j

, 5

')

\; )

p.

.. 4

'g 3 *

~- A e

i7 h x )

FLORI'IA POWCR AND LIGHT COMPANY s j I

! A ," *

} y

._ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ ___ _. . u__ 1 , __ __ _ ____ __,___ _ _ _ _ _ _ _

l !

j I

1

)

i ATTACHMENT 3 Response to Question 4 PSL Unit #1, Florida Power & Light 1985/1987 Flaw Growth Study-ECT S/G Exam 1

, c, I

3r i

4

'i b \

l L

! s e... MCl2:7 1

Page 1 of 3 L

Introduction Inservice eddy current examination was performed, in February / March i

1987, on 100% of open tubes in the St. Lucie Unit I steam generators.

This report is to document the efforts by Florida Power & Light Company 1

-to. assess flaw initiation and/or growth during the operating cycle I'

preceeding the February 1987 refueling outage.

Statement of Problem Determination of flaw initiation and growth may be accomplished by comparison of defect sizes and/or Lissajous patterns from consecutive )

inspections. Changes in ECT interpretation guidelines must be included in ]

these comparisons to draw conclusion on initiation / growth. This report i documents the results of two such studies as interpreted using the 1987 ECT inspection guidelines.

Statistical Analysis for Flaw Growth To determine !f flaw growth had occurred,144 indications that were reported in 1985 were compared to the depth readings reported in 1987.

The 144 data points (Table 1) were choosen from the "A" steam generator which had historically contained indications in greater numbers and severity as compared to the "B" steam generator. For the purpose of this ,

study only indications of 20% to 39% throughwall in 1985 were used. The !

results was as follows:

Number of Data Points = 144 Mean Change in Size = -12.33 Standard Deviation =

3 8654 The negative mean of 12.33% occurs due to a change in ECT Data Analysis curves. A steam generator specific Three Point Fit Sizing Curve was implemented in the 1987 inspection to improve the accuracy of defect sizing as contrasted to the ZETEC supplied curve used the the 1985 inspection. The differences in the two curves at the range of 20 to 39 percent is -12 percent. Therefore, this data review supports the conclusion that no growth has occurred for previously reported flaws. For more detail of the Three Point Fit Qualification see report entitled "PSL -

Unit #1 -Florida Power and Light, Eddy Current Data Evaluation Curve, Steam Generator A and B".

)

MCl3:1

_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ i

Page 2 of 3 The standard deviation of +8.654 is well within the accuracy range of e'ddy 1 current for depths of less tTian 30 percent. !

Historical Review of ECT Data To determine whether new flaw indications' have initiated during .the i preceding fuel cycle and to ascertain if growth had occurred for these indications the following samples were selected:

1. Each ECT indication of 40% or greater in both "A" and "B" steam generator.

2. 30 indications in the sludge region in the range of 20 to 39 percerst in "A" steam generator.

3. 30 indications in the eggcrate region in the range of 20 to 39 i percent in "A" steam generator.

1

4. 30 indications in the' drilled support region in the range of 20 to )

39 percent in "A" steam generator.

5. 10 indications' in the lower batwing assembly and mid-span elevation in the range of 20 to 39 percent in "A" steam generator.

The indications between 20 to 39 percent were chosen from "A" steam generato. which has historically contained indications in greater numbers and severity as compared to "B" steam generator. Approximately 80% of the indications chosen had not been reported in 1985 and contained relatively high amplitude signals when compared to the total population. In summary, the selection process was biased to tubes which have the highest ;

probability of containing new flaw indications, j The historical comparison was conducted using a DDA-4 print-out of the 1987 indication and a print-out of the 1985 indication when present or a print out of the area in 1985 if the indication was not present. Figure 1 is i the flow chart that was used by a minimum of two Level Ill or IIA i individuals for each comparison to determine if flaws had initiated and/or flaw growth was apparent.

There were 178 indications reviewed for apparent growth of which 157 indicated no change between 1985 and 1987. Fif teen had apparent growth and 6 had apparent decrease. All indications that were 40% and greater in 1987 were present in the 1985 data. Apparent growth was defined in this study as a change of phase angle and/or increase of amplitude. The changes observed in phase angle or amplitude are believed to be within anticipated fluctuation limits expected for bobbin coil tests. The results of this study are included as Figure 2. It was concluded that apparent initiation or growth occurred.

MCl3:1

p Page 3 of 3 l

Of the.178 indications reviewed,159 were not reported in 1985. During the time the indication was being reviewed for apparent growth, the_ question

was asked "Why was it not reported?" During the period between the 1985 inspection and the 1987 inspection developmental work for flaw detections and sizing was completed as well as the results of the 1985 tube removal. .

This information was incorporated within the ECT Data Analysis training prior to the 1987 inspection. Figure 3 is a graphic illustration of the l

reasons that the. indications were not reported in 1985. It was evident that improved detection / sizing and analysis capabilities were the major reasons for the flaws not being reported in 1985. Again these resuits confirm that flaws were present in 1985 and flaw initiation has not occurred.

Conclusion 1 Flaw initiation and/or growth did not occur during the operational cycle spanned by the 1985/1987 steam generator inspections.

I I

I l

1 l

MCl3:1

_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _J

5; 4 .l.

-4 Attachment 1 St. Lucie Unit'1 Flaw Distribution by Percent Through Wall 1987 1985 A 'B Total- -

A B, Total'-

40% or Greater 47' 29 76 -74 29 103

~20% to 39% 323 236 559 356 163 519 Less than 20% 582- 368 950 221 237 485 =

Total 1585 1080 I.

l MCl3:1

TABLE 1 Peg 21 of 3

> PSL-1 1985-87 ECT GROWTH STUDY For Indications Called in Both 1985 and 1987 .

5/G A 1987 1985 % 1987 1985 %

Line_ Row % % Change Line Row % % Change 10 4 8 26 -18 40 94 19 33 -14 11 41 16 , 38 -22 40 98 15 31 -16 17 59 7 22 -15 40 106 20 38 -18 20 18 24 17 +7 41 59 20 16 +4 22 32 9 31 -22 41 89 22 32 -10 23 5 17 26 -9 43 87 17 38 -21 25 29 10 18 -8 44 72 23 36 -13 26 52 7 11 -4' 44 104 32 38 -6 28 36 8 22 -14 -

46 68 15 13 +2 28 52 11 34 -23 47 55 23 27 -4

~ ~

~28 60 5 22 -17 50 66 5 25 -20 29 ~61 2 16 -14 50 120 14 33 -19 29 Id5 38 31 +7 51 23 17 21 -4 33 33 23 29 -6 51 81 11 24 -13 i

33 39 16 24 -8 52 96 23 33 -10 33 49 18 27 -9 52 100 27 36 -9 35 101 20 26 -6 55 33

25 39 -14 36 32 4 32 -28 55 101 19 37 -18 37- 41 16 34 -18 56 98 7 24 -17 i

l 37 75 29 38 -9 57 101 18 21 -3 1

38 40 27 29 -2 E8 14 15 34 -19 39 39 31 35 -4 58 96 31 25 +6 40 44 21 23 -2 58 96 16 37 -21 MCI 2:8 t- ---------_____ ___ _ _ _ _ _ _ _

-" l Pega 2 of 3 PSL-1 1985-87 ECT GROWTH STUDY For Indications Called in Both 1985 and 1987 S/G A 1987- '1985 %' 1987 1985 %

Line Row % % Channe Line Row % % Change t .

58 98j 11' 24 -13 77 73 37 38 -1 l

l~ 58 298 13 -28. -15 80 104 13 28 -15 59 23 17 31. -14 81 123 6 18 -12 59 25 13 26 ' -13' 81 125 2 15 -13 60 18 29 38 -9 81 129 2 23 -21=

60 38 21 37 -16 81 135 14 23 -9 60 48 '5. 29 -24 83 73 21 38 -17

-61 71 9 34 -25 83 75 12 28 -16 61 95 6 22 -16 86 40 32 .29 +3

~62 110 26 17 +9 86 120 31 15 +16 63 .101 25 38 -13 86 134 12 24 -12 65 39 23 22 +1 88 62 20 29 -9 66 110 24 37 -13 89 47 21 36 -15 67 87 14 25 -11 91 101 6 27 -21 68 44 20 27 -7 91 109 11 22 -11 68 96 23 31 -8 92 90 19 32 -13 70 '96 25 34 -9 92 124 17 6 +11

.70 98 16 29 -13 93 93 26 27 -1

. '70 122 28 38 -10 93 123 15 23 -8 71 129 17 29 -12 95 109 17 25 -8 72 32 11 25 -14 98 100 25 24 +1 75' 95 2 39 -37 103 77 4 33 -29 77 47 51 30 +21 104 120 6 8 -2 MC12:8

Pega 3 ef 3 PSL-1 1985-87 ECT GROWTH STUDY For Indications Called in Both 1985 and 1987 S/G A 1987 1985 % 1987 1985 %

Line Row % % Change Line Row % % Change 106 40 12 27 -15 127 53 24 25 -1 107 67 4 33 -29 127 89 5 24 -19 108 34 1 21 -20 132 50 20 35 -15 108 106 8 .19 -11 132 84 12 31 -19 109 69 5 34 -29 133 67 19 33 -14 110 105 11 23 -12 133 69 20 18 +2 113 85 23 30 -7 134 32 22 1 -21 114 104 11 23 -12 134 32 5 22 -17

~

114 124 25 35 -10 134 96 33 36 -3 115 113 33 34 -1 135 45 6 32

_ -26 117 83 15 29 -14 135 73 21 24 -3 117 83 10 21 -11 136 38 32 6 -26 119 79 7 13 -6 137 45 4 23 -19 119 85 15 25 -10 137 97 11 28 -17 122 44 2 11 -9 138 48 14 26 -12 i

123 51 3 . _18, . -15 . 144 2 21 28 -7

-124 76 11 16 -5 146 24 26 38 -12 124 84 9 24 -15 161 21 15 37 -22 125 33 32 38 -6

'125 51 20 22 -2 sagfl90%

' bl (hME*G 125 '55 12 18 -6 ^

126 24 32 33 -1

] - --12.33 127 7 24 37 -13 c: : P4cf MC12:8

f.)

1-

' FIGURE Historical Review Flow Chg Was Indiction Present in 1985 1

Yes No l

l Why was it Not Reported .i i

1. Improved Detection /

Sizing anti Analysis Capability

2. Distorted Signal - 1985 New Flaw initiation

-l

3. Unknown - 1985 - ;

4. Indication not Present - 1985 1 t

Flow Growth is increase Degradation Apparent I l

1 l

Yes No i

4 l

1

_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ .- 1

O I W = HR H T H E N TO S G SW S R AR R '

O C T CG E S T S R S E I I T N N N G N D .

N DR A O E O O U NO E I R I T I T I F R T A T N T N E G A P A E A E I TD C P C R C R C CE D I A I A I A U EW N D D P D P L E A NO N P N P 7I I N I A I A 8V s T 9E 0 . . .

S 1 R 2 1 2 3 m

0 2 07 1 9 5

1 7

5 1

0 0 0 0 0 9 7 5 3 1 0 0

_ 1 1 1 1 1 9 7 0 0 0 0 0 5 4 3 2 1

_ $3E - @~

9 I -

5 Z Y 5 1 I T 8 T N

T S I 9

O = L 1 E N / I S R N B - E S E O A R N T I P L P 1 O 58 A T A A I E C C N 5 T T T 91 R E G 8 O I

A G T S I 9 N N C E I S 1 U I N D D S N E

D I N Y D - O N D A D L E I I

C I

E E A T N T m V N R W A U T T 0 O A O O C L C R 2 R T N I E O P

D S K D T

A W N I N N 7 E I A D U I S 8 R G 9 / . . . .

1 S 1 2 3-4 2

s 5 0 5 s .

0 5 8 0 1 9 8 8 5

2 1

4 1

v28 1

0 0 0 0 0 6 3 2 0 0 0 O 0 0 0 5 0 1 1 1 1 9 8 S 5 2 1 1 5 0

$o5y_$-

'l

F:

ATTACHMENT 4 1:

" Response to Question 5 PSL Unit # 1, Florida Power & Light Eddy Current Data Evaluation Curve for Steam Generator A and B i

I f

Page 1 of 2 Introduction During the 1985 ECT Examination at St. Lucie Unit #1 the A.S.M.E.

System Calibration Standards that were used had various wall thickness's

(.046" to .051"). The tubing material in the steam generators is Inconel

/600,.750 inch in diameter with a nominal wall thickness of .048 inch.

Although the standards that were used had various wall thickness's, they were within the range cf a nominal tube of .048 inch as permitted by the A.S.M.E. Code. Upon review of the results during the 1985 testing it was determined that a more reliable, repeatable and accurate examination could be conducted if the system calibration standards were .048 inches in thickness.

Statement of Problem The data analysis curve used during the 1985 examination over estimated indication depths due to minor wall thickness differences between the in-generator tubing and the system calibration standards.

Description of Occurrence i

At the beginning of the 1985 examination a 3 point fit curve was established using a calibration standard with a wall thickness of .051" which was over estimated indication depth for .048" wall material with a test frequency of 400 KHZ. As an example the phase angle of the 20%

A.S.M.E. flat bottom hole is 132 degrees in .051" wall tubing. When applying a 3 point fit curve based on a .051" wa!! tubing and examining

.048" wall tubing this flaw would be evaluated as 34% To standardize the data analysis it was determined that the 4.i curve, provided with the DDA-4 Data Analysis Sof tware, would be used to identify flaw depth. The 4.1 curve is still conservative as it would apply to a 3 point fit curve for .048 inch wall material at 400 KHZ. Therefore, to develop tube standards having a wall thickness of .048" would more accurately identify the depth of in-generator flaws at 400 KHZ. ;

Method of Analysis Prior to the 1987 examination Florida Power & Light procured A.S.M.E.

Calibration Standards from Combustion Engineering that have a nominal wall thickness of .048 inch (see attached drawings). To confirm the statement that a 4.1 curve over estimated indication depth, a 3 point fit curve was developed using the .048" standard. Attached is a drawing of the three point fit and 4.1 curves that illustrate the differences at a specific phase angle. As an example a 40% flaw using the 4.1 curve would be 28%

l on the 3 point fit curve. This difference of 12% also applies at 20% thru

! wall. This information confirms that the 4.1 curve on .048 inch v li f material at a test frequency of 400 KHZ over estimated indication d 4 i l is conservative.

i MCl2:8 b

1

.i l

Page 2 of 2 Conclusion A comparison of the ECT depth reading was conducted to complete the study to determine the effect of changing the evaluation curve between 1985 and 1987.

Attached is a listing of tubes in A Steam Generator where flaw readings for 1985 and 1987 could be compared. For the purpose of this study the flaws that were identified as less than 20% in 1985 were not included. The results of 114 Data

- Points indicate a -12.333 Mean with a Standard Deviation of + 8.654. The -12.333 Mean correlates with the difference in the 3 point curve ant the 4.1 curve from - .;

40% to 20% thru wall. Also when these results are applied to the 1985/1987 data '

It would indicate there is no apparent growth in the flaws.

j

)

i I

i 1

i l

MCl2:8

. . _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ 1

Page 2of2 Conclusion A comparison of the ECT depth reading was conducted to complete the study to determine the effect of changing the evaluation curve between 1985 and 1987.

Attached is a listing of tubes in A Steam Generator where flaw readings for 1985 and 1987 could be compared. For the purpose of this study the flaws that were identified as less than 20% in 1985 were not included. The results of 114 Data '

Points indicate a -12.333 Mean with a Standard Deviation of + 8.654. The

-12.333 Mean correlates with the difference in the 3 point curve and the 4.1 curve from 40% to 20% thru wall. Also when these results are applied to the -

1985/1987 data it would indicate there is no apparent growth in ti e flaws.

l l

l 1

.)i l

l l

M CI2:8 1

f .

I I M *e 7,, . , , , , , , , , ',

/I

/- *%s.'-

I

+

t l l j l

e l, l

? l' '

gg .d . n- 4 i ,

i i 'i '

! l

/ . i l \.I';s: y. !

I l ,

i se u c

i -

/ i I ; s w.

, a .,

I

/

s ;- l 1

i

.N. -

g s I %. s 54 4 . ! ! :

N)a i : !

I f \ !

l ! I N N_ i.

,j . .:

,'\ / !

4, f , 3 i/

l i i ; i I l iJ/M H '- I 1

?!l 5'+n /42 L_s((i

~

se .i-f '

l l

]Nt !

i, 4

t 4 i i, ,

.w . ..

a l

A i ,,9 i I i i i l N

{ ' '

10 '.! . i I ,

10 29 10 40 56 60 M 80 98 106 lie 129 138 140 150

'. THROUGH WALL VS. PHRSE ANGLE GEGREES) DEG 48 A8'

< h 189 gh CHANNEL e 1 60 60 l 112 347 155 29 g 3,7

- - 28 58 4,

9' I J h+ M i

. i 1

i 1

l l

t

,' j lllJ WS a . $M 2.S E"

$~ *EN$z Ux_E" 5P @8 -

_gO E =d -

,gw ,=

~

$' E g( -

pp .

4' A

/

C A

/

N R B

K 2

6 4

+-

S S

T C

E 5

A .

A g 4,

((= [

S f' U

/

N _' fI F

JL 4

e 2 g C a 0 r e T A

m10 S s

/

N s

a h g t'.

=-

,TC E

S'

, 2 A A

/

W

/

N t

s - . ,.

a -

- 9 2

6 7 so 0 3

1 s 1 c, / G i 4

L 3 -

l r l' l 1

7 7 s 0 6 ns 1 i 3 1

F l oi -

3 h. 2 1

/

3 '

i th at C

) mi 8 rh 8 8 6 4 I f

ow 3 50 2

7 9

/

7 E _l : I i i

, R S T A

(

nr ie F

E b %

- T nm ou 8 N t n 5

/ 9 E in 3 4 - C

~

e t -

8 0 i 4 0 6

/ D _{ , d af ce E

7 4 5 / e i e %

1 h fb 1

- t i 1 tf 8 o U -

0 2 r o

ro e

o RH 0 5 N w o D l 4 ' 0 C .

. O G f cu T N l e

e E T I 0 t li :

D C R 0 B n al T I E 6 e i A a 0 W - F T m ey rn 4 E -

R l Z eie l 8 o, lI 4

/

8 B D O e n H "A rl ul t

edb l l a

P o 8 K mea 1 _ 1 1 P - sa w U c 4 0 t e

ai dl -

E S n 0 0 e ed mar dil D I 4 .

eve u fo /A s t

I GL s h ov r f e 0 W : BE r 1 3

l as cra ap h 2

6 A .

IEG D 7 cl t t t

1

RTSI N 5E 5S oO .

~1 i t so I

/ E R 1 N em~ Aih 1 TN S IO MU K . . T it l e Fl "A l

a

RB S CQO A u 2 RR AAHR LIEN .E " t EAR OR c E FC B ITFLNT A R A :

S -

E A : ELTITT T H :: : TLSRSA R P RR X AAEEEE O i FS U MWTSTH H N ,

T P

.E L j c

4 hD E - G T. N .

EA h /

3 l

A

/

3 A

/

N R B

r "

g 4

9 l

4

=

T C

E G

S 2 -

S A

/ ;'

A

/

g F - J U N - .

4 2 l C

r 1

1 A r ,. 9 ,

W0 /

N u

n t T

4

[,' t(.

C E

_2 S~

A A ,

fN f .

/

R

/ a . ,

N s a ~

2 6

9) 7 00 '

9 1

)

/

(G 1

(/ 3 1

3 .u 5

%3 0 9

6 1

F ns oi 1

T 2 1 /

3 i G

c. 1

th at mi %

) rh 2 9 sr

(

4 6 ) I f

ow 4 8

2 / : s T nr

o. 6 9 7 (E d t

A

(

ie b

F

- m l t nm ou 1

8 f 7 E n i n 5 f

(/ 0 3 o 4 6 C e t -

4 D _ - d at E

~

7 / _

4 ca 5 / e i e .

1 h f 1

- t i h. 7 1 tf 7 U -

o 2 r ro -

mR H g 5

) N w o

o e cu D

0 (C f u , _ O G T N l e E T I 0 e t li :

D C R 0 B n al T I E 6 e i A

. - F T m rn c060 3 8 W - E R l e

Z "A

ey eie l v 3 3 / B ~ : _D O

P n H K 2 "

rl el t

edb l l a

1 P o 8 ea mea w U c n 40- 1 e ei dl -

E S e sd dii

v. A D I 0. 40-L S aa r

eva h ov e

r v / o I sL 5 1 l cra h c y W A

mE P 3 ae ap t 6 _ :

rE G D 7 cl t t 1 aTS NI 5E 5S o.

n) 'l l t sg I

/

pea Ait i s

tN m 1 tU t

N l r0 S u ..T t e a a8 S uQO _A Pl "A u

2 t mR ALIEN uA RAHR OR

.E c

E rC B ITFLNT A S -

. - R ELTITT A

E LD AE A

H e : :

TLSRSA T CR IUH P

.E [ -

nR aAAEEEE FS B MWTSTH O

N ,

SST MEE AP MD , T. EA N

L G

h j 4

/

3

ii; I

gE $ " $MO 8 *.Scs Q EE GE 5. .

g8 g 2$ -

.% g , E eR -

yp . *

.l 1

4 G ,

A A S

/ / R E . , -

u N B . #

4

- = T 5 4 - - C 2 E S fi A A R ,

/ / F T. .m .

o N .f

! -l e

2 g C a l P 8 1 A w -

9 ,

41 .

/

N aI D - g ' t T C

E 2 S

,. A

/ R y ,

c R s E - - .

2 6

7 8 6

1

/ ) G 1

{ /. .

4 1

3 (G ,

7

. 8 6 ns 1 1

F oi C .

6 2

1

/

3 l

~

i th at c

) mi %

rh 2 o 0 0 4

6 I

f ow 4 G 1. o / E I : I ,

S T nr y 0 7 ,R A

(

i e

. 1 E b ,

T t

am cu 1

0 N n in 6 E

9 .s

^

o t -

0 4

6 ) -

C d at 3 (D

7 o. 6 / l ,

4 ca 5 / e ie ,

1 h fh %

- t i . 9 1 tf 7 0 o - 2 r ro -

0 5 ) N w o f o e cu D

/ w 0,

4 E

0 (C O T

G N

I 0 l

B e t n

ii sl e

T D C R 0 e i A I E 6 m ra

, ' W F T ey el e l 0

/ .

5. 8 ) .J g E

D R

O l

e n

Z H "A rl ul t

edb l l a

4 1

/

1 (B P P o 8 K

c 4 0 i-a sa ai mea dl w

U n 0 0 e ed dii E S e mar eva u D I 4 A GL hov r I a S_ l cra

)A 1 h

$ c, o W :

BE Dr 3 ae ap t u IE G s 6 (

7 cl t t

RTS N 5E _ o 1 O li t so I 1

/ E I 5.

t U S

N p om Aib 1 TN R IO a.,

K T t

t e l

e

' RB SS LIEN LQO A Fl "A u

t 2 .E RR EA FC A

R AHR ITFLNT OR c A

E - B R A -

S E g ELTITT A :: : TLSRSA T H AAEEEE O H

P T -

RR R FS B MWTSTH N

gT . E. C 4

gE P D

T. NG EA h'F

/

3 -

' jl1 l,l

l l! )))

$NU

- WE yg '

g =NEQ8 e tgEg GE noEg e goh5gms -

e ghO-wa:Ub 8 - I -

~

A

/

D A

/

E g

n Kj . .

g o

4" G

9 T

C 5

2, g'[ [

E S f o

A

/

A a ,

/ F J C N . .

4 , .

e

- g 2 C a r F y00 1 A

/

N a

e n I

,. S T

i'. -

C E

_2 S' A A a [f /

/

U

/

N s a .

2 9

6 y0

1 : -

u0 2

4 1

/

3 G O 7 .

- 1 9

1 9 0 6 sa 1 ol -

w10 5 2

1

/

3 F I t

th G

- at mi 3 _

) rh 0 9 4 6

I ow 4 _

w2 f - _

0 o, / i:

S T nr F -

, 7 ,R

(

A i e E b nm L

- N E

t n

oe i m 0

6 u 83 4 C

~

e t -

u 0 o 6 d at E 3 / D 4 ca 7 5 / e i e 1 h fh 5 9

- t i 1 tf 7 U -

o 2 r ro -

R 5 N w o e D

- H T

a 4 0 C ,

O T

G N

0 l

o e

f t

cse li :

E C I

0 B n al T D R e i A E 6 4 .

I W - F T m ey ra w00 6 4 8 ) 3 E

D R

O l

e n

Z R "A rl el t

el e l

l l

a 3 /

1 (8 ;1 P

P o 8 c 4 0 K 4 sa si edb mea dl w-U S n 0 0 1 e ed dii 3

E D I 4 I S

e mar eva hov e

r

/ I CL S 1 cra nC .

4 l[ W )A :

SE IE G D P 3 l

ee ap h t _

1 6 ( : RTSIN 5E 7

o .

1 O cl ri t

t oo t

I

/ E R 3S tU N pem Att l

1 TN IOS n..

a T ae a RSS tQO A Pl "A

" u 2 t RRA EAR AHR LIEN OR

.E c FC B ITFLNT A E - R A :

S '

ELTITT E A e ::: TLSRSA T H 1RR AAEEEE O P T N H FSB MWTSTH ,

T P

.EL G

j C

4 E

D T. N -

EA h /

3

' i I i

' PS'L-1 1985-87 ECT GROWTH STUDY ! ' Page'l of 3 L For Indications Called in Both 1985 and 1987 S/G A 1987 '1985 % 1987 1985 %

Line Row % % Change Line Row % % Change 10 4' 8 26- .-18 40 98 15 31 -16 11 41 16 38 -22 40 106 20 38 -18

-17 '59 7 22 -15 41 .89 22 32 -10

.\.

22- 32 9 31 -22 43 87 17. 38 -21

.23 5 17.' 26 -9 ~ 44 72 23 36 -13 28 36 '8 22 -14 44~ 104 32 38 -6 28- 52 34 -23

~

11 47 55 23 27 -4

-28 60 3 22 -17 50 86 5- 25 -20 29 -105 '38 '31 . + 7' 50 120 14 33 -19

33. 33 23 29 -6 51 23 17' 21 -4 33- 39 '16 24 -8 51 81 11 24 -13 33 49. 18 27 -9 52 96 23 33 -10

-35 101 20- 26 -6 52 100 27 36 -9 36 32 4 32 -28 55 33 25 39 -14 37 41 16 34- -18 55 101 19 37 -18 37 75 29 38 -9 56 98 7 24 -17 38 40 27 29 -2 57 101 18 21 -3 39 39 31 35 -4 58 14 15 34 -19 40 44 21 23 -2 58 96 31 25 +6 40 94 19 33 -14 5S 96 16 37 -21 l

l l

' MCl3:1

h PSL-1 1985-87 ECT GROWTH STUDY-- Page 2 of 3

' For Indications Called in Both 1985 and 1987 1987 .1985 .%

S/G A - Line Row % % _, Change 75 95 2 39 '

1987 -1985 .%

Line ' Row _ % %, Change 77 47 51 30 +21 58 '98 11 24 -13 80 104 13 28 -15 158 98- 13. '28 ' -15 81 129 2 23 -21 59: 23. 17 31. -14 81 135 14 23 -9 59' '25 13 26 -13 83 73 21 38 -17

.60 18 29 38' ' -9 83 75 12 28. -16 60 38 21 37 -16 86 40 32 29 +3 60 48 5 29 -24 86. 134- 12 24 -12

'61- 71 9 34 -25 88 62 20 29 -9 61 95 6 22 -16. 89 47 21 36 -15

-63 101 25' 38 -13 91 101 6- 27 65 39 23 .22 +l- 91 109 11 22 -11

66. 110- 24 37 -13 92 90 19 32- -13 67 87 14 25 -11' 93 93. 26 27 -1 68 44 20 27 -7 93 123 15 23 -8 68 96 23 31 95 109 17- 25 -8

- 70 96 25 34 -9 98 100 25

24 +1 70 98 16 29 -13 103 77 4 33 -29 70 122 28 38 -10 ~7~) 7> 37 'lfr -/

71 129 17 29 -12 90 /c)([ f3 7g -/$

72 32 11 25 -14 l

MCl3:1

1 PSL-1 1985-87 ECT GROWTH STUDY Page 3 or 3 For Indications Called in Both 1985 and 1987 S/G A 1987 1985 % L1987 1985 %

Line- Row % % Change Line Row % % Change 106 40 12- 27 -15 127 53 '24 25 -1 1

'107 '67 4 33 -29 127 89 5 24 -19 .4 108 34 1 21- -20 132 50 20 35 -15

.109 69 5 34 -29 132 84 12 31 -19 110 105 11 23 -12 133 67 19 33 -14 113' 85 23 30- -7 134 32 1 22 -21

-114 104 11 23 -12 134~ 32 5 22 -17 114 124 25 35 -10 134 96 33 36. -3 115 -113 33- 34 -1 135 45 6 32 -26 117 83 15 29 -14 135 73 21 24 -3 117 83 10 21 -11 136 38 6 32 -26 119 85 15 25 -10 137 45 4 23 -19

124. 84 9 24 -15 137 97 11 28 -17

- 125 33 32 38 -6 138 48 14 26 -12 125 51 20 22 -2 144 2 28 21 -7

~ 126 25 32 33 -1 146 24 26 ' 38 -12

'127 7 24 37 -13 161 21 15 37 -22 1985/20% or Greater N = 114 x = -12.33 -

N ,

S = 18654

!!! ?') ,

o g7 i

l

j. MCl3:1 L - -

,y-., - - - _ -

7 i

i k

I I

99 6 V Si d3S L&l 1

S0-08NSO

^ ' ' " - - - - - ___ _ __ 1

ML20238F259

Text

SUMMARY

SUMMARY

Navigation menu

Search