ML20214W144
| ML20214W144 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Issue date: | 06/10/1987 |
| From: | Grimsley D NRC OFFICE OF ADMINISTRATION & RESOURCES MANAGEMENT (ARM) |
| To: | Sholly S MHB TECHNICAL ASSOCIATES |
| Shared Package | |
| ML20213E209 | List:
|
| References | |
| FOIA-87-113, FOIA-87-60, RTR-NUREG-1150 NUDOCS 8706150108 | |
| Download: ML20214W144 (5) | |
Text
U.S. NUCLEAR RE;U T Y COMMISSION wc scia uoutst Nuva:Risi (Q
F0/ A-27-6 0 v 17-NJ_
r"%
f(' T 'I asesi na RESPONSE TO FREEDOM OF h*"
l/l ""
%,.ees /
INFORMATION ACT (FOlA) REQUEST SUN 10 150/
e DOCILET NUM8tR.Si ut aspeceael REOutsfER Nr.
Jf m 3L /k PART I.-REC ftQs RELE ASED OR NOT LOCATED (See checked bones)
~ ~
No agency records subject to the request have been located.
No additenal agency records subject to the request have been located.
Agency records subsect to the request that are identifed in Appendsu are already avalable for public irapection and copymg in the NRC Public Document Room, 1717 H Street. N.W., Washmgton, DC.
Agency records subsct to the request that are identsfed in Appendia are bemg made avaslable for public mspecten and copyng in the NRC Public Document Coorn,1717 H Street, N.W., Washmgton, DC, m a folder under the FOICnumber and requester name.
I-The nonpropretary versen of the proposal (s) that you agreed to accept m a telephone conversaten with a member of my staff is now being made avadable for public inspecten and coying at the NRC Pubiac Document Room,1717 H Street, N W, Washington, DC, m a folder under the FOIA number and requester name.
Enclosed is information on how you may obtain access to and the charges for copymg records placed in the NRC Pubhc Document Room,1717 H Street, N.W., Washington, DC.
Agency records subject to the request are enclosed. Any apphcable charge for copes of the records provided and payment procedures are noted in the comments section.
Records subpect to the request have been referred to another Federal agency (es) for revow and direct response to you.
In view of NRC's response to this request, no further accon a bemg taken on appealletter dated PART li.A-INFORMATION WITHHELD FROM PUBLIC DISCLOSURE Certain informaton in the requested records is being withheld from pubhc desclosure pursuant to the FOIA exemptons described m and for the reasons stated m Part II, sec-tions 8 C, end D. Any released portons of the documents for which only part of the record is being withheld are bemg made avadable for public inspecten and copyeg in the NRC Pubhc Document Room,1717 H Street, N W., Washmgton, DC, in a folder under this FOIA number and requester name.
Comments i
I 8706150108 870610 PDR FOIA SHOLLYB7-60 PDR s
$sGNATURE DIRECTOR, OrWSIOVOF RULES AND RECORDS J]
vi ~
r v%'
/t Ix
( Ls e
1 p
URC FORM 464 iPen o it esi
Re:
F01A. 37-60 & 37-113 e-APPENDIX B
RECORDS MAINTAINED IN THE PDR UNDER THE AB0VE RE0 VEST NUMBER huMBER DATE DESCRIPTION 1.
6/11/82 IDCOR/NRC SFD Mtg. (hand written notes)(2 pages) 2.
7/14/82 Letter to Dr. A. Buhl, VP, Technology for Energy Corp. from A. S. 8enjamin, Sandia National Lab. (1 page) 3.
7/7/82 NRC/IDCORTechnicalExchangeMtg.(Attachment.ListofAttendees) hand written (4 p3ge3) 4, 7/7-9/82 Proposed Agenda, NRC/IDCOR Mtg. on Risk Code Development and Value-Impact Analysis, New Mexico (2 pages) 5.
8/24/82 NRC/lDCOR Interface Meeting, SASA Program Review Agenda, Techno for Energy Corp, Knoxville, TN (3 pages) 6.
6/24/82 Memo for Attached List from R. Bernero DRA, RES
Subject:
NRC/IDCOR Mtg. on Risk Codes and Value-Impact Analysis (7 pages) 7, 6/10/82 Memo for Attached List from D. Ross. DD, RES,
Subject:
Severe Accident Research Program (SARP) (4 pages) 2.
5/27/82 Interoffice Memo to Distribution from T.G. Tyler, TEC,
Subject:
Minutes of IDCOR/NRC Interface Mana held May 11, 1982 (6 pages)gement Meeting on Organization and Priorties 9.
NRC-IDCOR Agreements and Subsequent Actions (Undated) (3 pages) 10.
9/9/83 Letter from A. Buhl, TEC to D. Ross Technical Exchange Meetings (11 pages), subject Agenda for NRC/IDCOR 11.
12/14/83 Memo for Distribution from T. Speis, MRR,
Subject:
Sumary of NRC/IDCOR Mtg. on Acqident Phenomenology and Containment Loading - Nove 29-December 1, 1983 (4E pages) 12, 7/7-9/82 Vugraphs of NRD/IDCOR Technical Exchange Meeting (203 pages) 13.
6/7/83 Letter from Cordell Reed, Chairman, ICCOR Steering Group. Atomic Industrial Forum. Inc. to Secretary of the Comission,
Subject:
Proposed Comission Policy Statement on Severe Accidents and Related Views on ReactorRegulation(2pages) 14.
11/11/82 Letter from A. Buhl to D. Ross
Subject:
Listing of Significant DegradedCoreIssues(10pages) 15.
Enclosure II - Proposed Alterations to IDCOR Degraded Core Issues (Undated) 16.
3/2/83 IDCOR Mtg. Notes (hand written) '4 pages) 17, 3/2/83 Agenda, IDCOR/NRC Managers Mtg., AIF Bethesde Offices (35 pages) 18.
Memo (undated) to Attached List from R. Bernero, DRA,
Subject:
Minutes of NPC/10COR Exchange Mtg., 7/7-8/82 (8 oages) l 13.
8/24-25/82 Vugraphs - NPC/IDCOR Mtg. on Accident Sequences, Knoxville, T L
J
Re:
FO! A 37-60 0 37-113 APPENDIX U
RECORDS MAINTAINED IN THE PDR UNDER THE AB0VE RE0UEST NUMBER MBER DATE DESCRIPTION 20.
8/20/82 Vugraphs for Worksho IDCOR Task 23 (6 pages) p held in Chicago, IDCOR Task 10 as Input to 21.
Vugraphs/ charts - Subtask 3.2-Assess Dominant Sequences (undated)(42 pages) 22.
11/18/81 Outlir.e of Severe Accident Decison-Making Process (13 pages) 23.
5/21/81 Vugraphs --IDCOR Potential Contractor Information Meeting, Knoxville, TN (78 pages)
WSIM 24' wi/M Trip Report, A. S. Benjamin to Distribution IDCOR Potential Contract Information Meeting (4 pages) 25*
12/3/80 Letter from D. Goeser, Westinghouse to Members of AIF Degraded Core Subconnittee,
Subject:
Initial Program Plan (16 pages) 26.
5/8/81 Industry Degraded Core Rulemaking Program Charter (12 pages) 27.
4/9/81 IDCOR Vugr4phs presented at the Licensing Information Services Conference, Clearwater Beach, FL (24 pages) 28.
Agreement, IDCOR & RES (undated) (19 pages) 29.
11/26/84 Memo for Distribution from T. Spels, NRR,
Subject:
NRC/IDCOR Mtg.
on Baseline Risk Profile and Operator Procedures for Accident Mitigation (6 pages) 30.
8/16/84 Letter for Distribution from J. Siegel, Atomic Industrial Forum,
Subject:
Additional Transmittal of Advance Material for IDCOR/NRC Mtg 38 (38pages) 31.
4/25/84 Issue Paper 2.1.1 on Plant Categorization (17 pages) 32.
7/29/84 Note to Silberberg from Ralph Meyer,
Subject:
Review of NRC and IDCOR Meltdown Models (14 pages) 33.
9/9/83 Letter to D. Ross from A.Buhl, TEC,
Subject:
Agenda for NRC/IDCOR Technical Exchange Meetings (11 pages) 34.
11/21/83 Letter to D. Ross from A. W. Snyder (4 pages) 135.
1/6/84 Memo for Attached List from R. Bernero
Subject:
NRC/IDC(OR Technical Exchange Meeting on Fission Product Release and Transport 8 pages) 36.
12/30/83 Letter to C. Reed, Commonwealth Edison Company from D. Ross (16 pages) 37.
8/3/84 Meme for Distribution from T. Spets, NRR & R. Bernero, RES,
Subject:
MRC/IDCOR Meeting on Integrated Analysis of Fission Product Behavior (30 pages) 38.
6/13/84 Meso for Distribution from T. Speis & R. Bernero
Subject:
Sunnary of NRC/IDCOR Meeting on Integrated Analysis of Severe Accident Containment loads - May 15-17, 1984- (229 pages) 39.
10/12/84 Memo for Distribution from T. Speis & R. Bernero,
Subject:
Summary of NRC/IDCOR Meeting on Integrated Analysis of Fission Product Behavior -
August 28-29, 1984 (165 pacesi l
Re:
FO! A-37-60 a 37-113 APPENDIX B
RECORDS MAINTAINED IN THE PDR UNDER THE ABOVE REQUEST NUMBER
. NUMBER DATE
_ DESCRIPTION 40.
Vugraphs - Severe Accident Regulatory Implementation Program (undated) (5 pages) 41' 1/11/85 Memo for D. Ross from T. Spets,
Subject:
Severe Accident Issue Papers 1.2.1 and 1.2.5 (16 pages) 42.
Draft - Issue 1.2.1 - Containment Thermal and Hydraulic Behavior (undated) (15 pagi 43.
2/23/84 Memo for Multiple Addressees from D. Ross,
Subject:
Issue Paper Status (6 pages) 44.
Draft consents on Issue Paper 2.3.1 - Design and Operation Changes to Prevent Severe Accidents Including Sabotage Protection (8 pages) 45.
9/15/83 Memo for Attached List from D. Ross,
Subject:
Severe Accident Issues Papers (7 pages) 46.
12/30/83 2 page commentary on issue paper format, plus some issue papers with marginal notations by D. Ross (35 pages) 47.
Appendix A, Example of Information Papers on Technical Issues (undated) (31 pages:
48.
White Paper - Conditions Leading to and Resulting from Diffusion Flames (undated) (39 pages) 49.
4/9/85 List of IDCOR Technical Reports Published (6 pages) 50.
4/20/84 Memo for Distribution from M. Silberberg,
Subject:
IDCOR Reports (1 page) 31*
3/4/86 Memo for T. Speis, DSRO from Z. Rosztoczy, DSRO,
Subject:
Minutes of December 10, 1985 NRC/IDCOR Meeting on the Peach Bottom Reference Plant Analysis (93 pages) 52.
10/4/84 Memo for Multiple Addressees from J. A. Murphy,
Subject:
IDCOR-NRC Issue Papers (1 page) 53.
Handwritten notes - meeting 5/3/85 (2 pages) 5 :- [-
L~
Issue Paper (undated) ~. -,; q ' '-
S4*
.s i-
- -W
.d. (8 pages) 55.
9/23/83 Draft paper entitled " Severe Accident Decisions for Existing Nuclear Power Plants," Draft Two, to Multiple Addressees from J. C.
l Malaro (47 pages) 1 Additional listings 4/22/87 56.
4/30/85 NRC-IDCOR (hand written notes) (4 pages) 57.
3/5/85 Memo for Addressess from D. Ross,
Subject:
NRC/IDCOR Technical Issues HanNritten notes (2 pages) 58, 3/26/85 59, 5/7/85 Letter from P. Cybulskis, Battelle Columbus to M. Silberberg,
Subject:
April 30,1985 NRC/IDCOR meeting. (7 pages)
r Re:
F01 A-37-60 S37-113 APPENDIX B
RECORDS MAINTAINED IN THE PDR UNDER THE AB0VE REQUEST NUMBER NUMBER DATE DESCRIPTION 60.
4/19/85 Letter from P. Cybulskis, Battelle Columbus to M. Silberberg,
Subject:
In-vessel Hydrogen Generation (6 pages) 61.
4/8/85 Letter from P. Cybulskis, Battelle Columbus to M. Silberberg,
Subject:
March 26 NRC/IDCOR Meeting (3 pages) 62.
11/15/85 Memo for Attached List from Z. Rosztoczy,
Subject:
NRC/IDCOR Meeting on Severe Accident Uncertainties (3 pages) 63.
12/9/85 F. Haskin vugraphs
Subject:
Limited Applicaticn of Latin Hypercube Sampling for NUREG-1150 (16 pages) 64.
5/9/85 Memo for Spels from Z. Roszto meeting on March 26, 1985 (7 pages)czy,
Subject:
Minutes of the NRC/IDCOR 65.
6/21/85 Memo for Speis from Z. Rosztoczy,
Subject:
Minutes of the NRC/IDCOR Meeting on April 30,1985 (11 naces) 66.
3/4/86 Memo for F. Gillespie and G. Arlotto from Spets,
Subject:
Status Updates Regarding Resolution of IDCOR Technical Issues and Review of Idcor Report 85.2 (3 aages)
Report Sections 9.6.2.1 to 9.6.2.14 Type A thru Type N (undated)(21 pa 67.
68.
4/85 MAAP Uncertainty Analyses (84 pages) 69.
9/3/85 Memo for Z. Rosztoczy frora R. Barrett,
Subject:
IDCOR Uncertainty Analysis (3 pages)
TECHNICAL ASSOCIATES TECHNICAL CONSULTANTS ON ENERGY & THE ENVIRONMENT Dale G Bridenbaugh 1723 Harnett 115E Sib tx y Rochard 8 Hubbard n Jose. California 95125
)
Gregory C. Minor Phone:(408) 266 2716 /
'n j
26 January 1987 fMI.OGN UT iWORE41;Q ACT REQUEST Mr. Donnie H. Grimsley, Director
[d7f ~[ 7, g Q Division of Rules and Records
/~2 f-[ f Office of Administration U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washing ton, D.C.
20555 s
Dear Mr. Grimsley:
Pursuant to the Freedom of Information Act, please make publicly available single copies of records as follows:
A.
All documents prepared by or for IDCOR (Industry Degraded Core Rulemaking group) or IDCOR contractors concerning severe accident analysis, risk assessment, source term analysis and estimation, etc.
Previous FOIA requests along these lines were made in 1984.
You may wish to consult the responses to those requests in determining which additional' documents need to be released.
In addition, it is likely that a substantial number of records will be subject to this request in view of the NRC/IDCOR technical meetings which have been ongoing the past several years.
Thus, I would request that as batches of documents become available for release that your office make partial responses to this request, rather than await a massive final response.
If there are any questions, please do not hesitate n
to call me directly at (408) 266-2716.
>/
Sincerely, I.
- 0 e
Steven C. Sholly
}'
h h0D' im m)
I 6
M Q TECHNICAL CONSUL T
.n'.**
N f
W-Date G Br.denbaugh RtChJtd B Hubbard 1723 Hamdton A renue-Gutte K Gregory C Minor San Jose. CaMosa 9512S phone (408) 266 2716 16 February 19 87
% %uestg
~
~Mr. Donnie H. Grimsle.
'Oivision-of Rules and Records h *7 Rto
~
y, Director
' ' 'i s Of fice ofghdminis trae. ion
[I/d-hg g
U.S. Nuclear. Regulatory-Commission Washington,,D.C.y 20555
_)
RE:
FOIA Request for Records Related to Individual Plant Evaluations and Related Records
Dear Mr. Grimsley:
>}
i Pursuant to the Freedom of Information Act, please, make available at the Comdission's Washington, D.C.,
d, Room records.in (the 'following categories:
Public Document' e.
A.
All.IDCOR (Industry Degraded Core Rulemaking) concerning what are ~ referred to as reports
" Individual Plant Evaluations" or IPEs.
This Category should be evaluated liberally -- it is intended to cover not only documents designated as IDCOR.. but also documents prepared by or for IDCOR' contractors and/or IDCOR
~
(utilitics)'which are in NRC's possession.
sponsors B.
All "Indiv1' dual Plant Evaluations" or IPEs, whether in dratt 'or final form, in NRC's possession, whether docketed or,not,' and whether transmitted formally
}
or not.
t g '%,,
s,
r C.
All NRC and/or NRC, sponsored evaluations, critiques,
' Plant Evaluations" or IPEs.connen ts, reviews, etc.,' related to the " Ind p
,\\,
+
s D.
All correspondence be, tween NRC and utilities concerning
[
y IPEs..
Ak correspondence between NRC and IDCOR/IDCOR contractors E.
concerning IPEs.
t at
(.
e
)
)
j o.
\\
t i
i p
~
7
,y t
m
,'[
- ~
Donnie H. Grinsley 16 February 19 87 If-there are any. questions _-concerning any aspect of this request,'please contact me by-telephone at (408) 266-2716.
Your prompt attention to ' this request will be appreciated.
Sincerely,.
K f.
Steven C. Sholly Associate Consultant l'
l L
I l
/
G/6s / 3th ca 1
Itse.co./su.c. wb
-r h -[zy fnXS
<x-***Sd co l=CiIsk b-s
'S A v ~ i a-A u seer 4 a.s.'.
Qot. Tye PLAers- -._
t Y'
'[ 8% - ft'1c T.
m SFb i.<-L
~-
rn.exr (mto guk~ o
- s. -<. - - k
.-r Wt-A\\ n.
') '
m (I.he-.k C4 u.Jesh Th
% wd. PY 8 4-4-ce{.
ib 1,38) 7,4J - - 2.5 -3 r1 a ~ s
.~
m ses m Ace. / 'i <d k..A l
E,y 4.e.Tr m.
c_.~, % 6%-
ph, wj s.ed.
%.3(-
,~,J
- s. q o.jl 2o frA 3 L * '"
V"**
,3 %
-bh,,s.I.cN:
^ t.'da.d An-3
( n-y k,ie.lta.se do A -
-.. f.a.- - m I
- c a.ho n,G,4p, w/ gc5 - < 8ve co d o.t>, (,h A 1,L45 r-Sudes M c 4 1.C o _
m -og m.E?
O
'May..
,ae
'~
J a.c g
% d
- d.<.s o e ce,4. ;
m eru',
is
=+5
( LL.d W sss 3 e_,o3,, A i f ilt m e h g h - ~ M iA che.
J<.AY 5
a' s-s
~
T*
T.
ton $ -
% h eegwg f
- AS f Cor/rr*\\ v ejt'\\5 k
m E/
W Y
Y o,
h N "N **" A**'
o,. h 9,
[A4s
-w g
p/
es La w-
[~[i "
'~,~
T M o(r 7oys f '*f=~
mh. dse~ m&
f s.
l l
ese e
9 er r-r-
...-e-
-..,U w-~-,
.,.-ww
.--,..-e=
w-
,,,,..,--%,-er-ym,v.-ev--..--,-w,--w-we..
e
U Sandia National Laboratories Albuquerque. Nte w M e xico 87185 July 14,-1982 Dr. Anthony Buhl, Vice President Technology for Energy Corporation 10770 Dutchtown Road Knoxville, Tennessee 37922.
Dear Tony:
It was a pleasure seeing you in Albuquerque last week during the NRC/IDCOR technical exchange meeting.
I think the meeting will serve as a useful point-of-departure for future technical exchanges.
In accordance with the ground rules of the meeting, much of the data we presented was preliminary in nature.
Due to an oversight on our part, however, some of the vugraph copies that we distributed (including your copy) were not appropriately marked as preliminary, while others were stamped with the following message:
DRAFT - INFORMAL AND PRELIMINARY AND AS SUCH MAY CONTAIN ERRORS NOT YET CORRECTED.
FOR IN-HOUSE PRIVATE DISTRIBUTION AND NOT FOR EXTERNAL RELEASE WITHOUT CONSENT OF AUTHORS.
As I mentioned to Stu Asselin after the meeting, we would appreciate your treating the vugraphs as though they have been stamped as above.
If you use them in your analyses or quote them in any way, please mention simultaneously that they are preliminary, have not gone through Sandia's peer or management review process, and may be subject to change.
I hope your brief stay in Albuquerque was a pleasant and informative one.
I'll probably see you in Knoxville on August 23-24.
Sincerely, Allan S. Benjamin, Supervisor Nuclear Systems Technology Division 9411 ASB:9411:dm Copy to:
Bb
Abc1>wed I.
n i s G,Qi b WU (y t > G c / n c.'s t "Te.
s c.o sm, w2z.
e
- Lwen, L'..~r L v.
( C lif c. <'. c k
1
)a,tb in, ra bld (10-9 P/9 -E213 Alla.t E R
- t-!
- .; y.,,w -.
- ;
/, t _ -i L
.,, y y,'-:,f L,s '. t: :!
-i
- t. v._.O
. d::
2.
43
.; -h -
- '.~., d b
. 16:,cl.
5,w t_
~~ 2 s H_ <;f t,9 75H '.
!, t. 4 ~'<di2.
sii-5~ s -iH -2571~
~
l 8 'viv~u y b/5 Ai2.c.-c t > c :
I,3 - i )
M'3 -- 5%
5 y ;2.c_
2.6 s a
U A<2.v._
4 Cvua184 H Ag Mt.c -TG5 (300 443 - ff4 o NM O !c 8 A 'S B C /~
(G/4)' -48& 78'5 y
Ri c.larA $ O c.m,o SC_. L_
L '!
M. - T.' 9 diu b tj ev NRC-NRK.
(3ct)47d-No' SisWa (n/ bfck S/ 'l-- '
Sb5 - 2 9'6~-!?21 L
i legey (s.3vtee.
Tec s oco e.
cois -que -sese l
W.Asra.R.
Acts a s-7c4 - c u a f b s i y T f u /-l L T*E C-.- Z O M g i 5 -4 &l-5~8.5~C,
) G 'n. uj k055
,\\)@_C-Rf$
3 0 (
t+ J.'?
Q.9_ F
~
$f fe-t
'2kOL/EW77.=C llSkSS'5ICG
=
- g. f.
EMI y/6 AsT.27/
~
/s'.l7f l. fdff5dM 7E~C-(Drd2 (6/0 f6? -5W4 l
tu Ar.re L m - twa
@r> uc -rm T2.7 Han' i~ni-m c2
@'2) an-sw
~7~ /O.
O a)e E6iG
(;cs) 52',- % 'l
%, &. D e Q,.t'{ e n.
EG-7G-
/
Es t'.S^2.(,. 137Y
~~
CM A lis so n EG4G aos - 5 a6 -loo 9,
I a..
vfa l{
E i'M /
(+!s) E5C-2.M5'-
~ ? '3,1
[dG ').i; 36
- 2.\\I
~ _. 4 C, '
O. A.1 }
c f/'*N.nt?lifI?.i.l EPR[
4/C 2" : :
.' H G t
Bh
W.'B, h 1 v e v i u SAZ SWL-
.az _
F. e.. % L m SNL YANs'4[eWL SWC '
sz3-3 I2 %g 757)
Orc-Keu,lvn PAL 5C s
u,.c :..:
5.r'
. 's &
A.i O' ? 1 C n
$44-dDHS D.'A f/T-532-7:63
.a doe 2\\[ yard SNL 50 5 - 84 4 - lo T74 Es f(_,' -h
&c.'.) - fif
'i&S6~
%. ). d :'s
- u. M, ht c l.9 ) a. w J S W L-sa r-ev Y-veog s L. %y&
sm sos ~ sn s a, G. G.
LC sut sos - 844 - 5s59 C soeun.-eeeuwa o n t.-
5n-939 w,r KE e,,
l,c 0,t eg' 2i w-P.s L,/s.a-En
.37r-3 s r/
v.
.c u
[ & 73 e q cree f.HL-c c - PH -3To 1 Dit u 6sreiv.eap GG t.-4 (2i 5) - PR 5-2 oc/5 N~
b SNt_
sr-8/m -sp e N cL et L ($et-an s AJ L So S - t W - l$e/ 5
. J.
~
~T~xevas fakrr
~5 N L S 'G) 2 g2 - 2610 l-laa,s LJewi ENL sts) 282-2s29-4 m ak, f
%L anL sos-s yv sor z 6.L i y c. G, c,.,
aw.ncea.
- 9 u -. =.'
..: 1
/
['t tim QA.4l G REi/
5 b) L
~C 5
- h4'1-iHC7 bod
'1 f Td h3 Nk.cWY 9!T-Sb
'fC03
~
., w-
=.. -
3. s ' '
- __..-,.r.-
' '. ~
.4m;=;;a-Y y cf$f,
~ rack 6al p
I
- ruLt 8,its2 E> d 4 Mesrg hAttl NANIWAYsoa
?AoNtf $10tf8E f
m n.x. A Cun aioq,.ian tottc/ 2Es (Jop 44.s -suo Soseer tt 85weso hfic,lgeS (sot) ll+5 -SYS&
+,v. 3 c 4,;;,z.<.i
-iN u L.3 _ u.s.;, q i-f.c rc.
m
'...: x ' :
- c'c
.o..
- 3.. r-i. ;
Av.no S Benenc,,a SnL sas--g+4.-4-1c9 Jh.*K V C n.2.2I2 5'iv t
-Sc5-i H - 2.5 7 cs 06NR W bc/rl't 'S L3d/v
//4 - f'24 - 721 d
f y
j'. - ; ' j l.~..
a'!?
'hl- ?$~/ 3 L'.,_fNRR li lNR}pv NRC
'Z~v a. n o.bhon V C. L R ZI3 - 8 2 5-2044 Tuy' 031 leg.
TEc- )3'Dc2 0,15 - 96t, - sesco W. K.ETz 12' k(_125 5t 3 -7c.4-N 9 -Gwxhelbosr U1hc [i'e e S 30l
(-<.1. 7 W 3!
y okn @a JL I
v' 19 bl 5~- 6 3 2 -Jc6 z.
/tb J f'", ~'P, 49 Tc1 - ! l' J<
G ? 7" - 9 dC
.% T
~
7455 rad Tc:? - / ::
.4 )
r - P GC - TE T~C a.
feNY Ti vi-It 77EC - / O Cm I T
- 9 L L~ 595 4 den Yc <-
E.E - lOcoA 2:6-359-C'030
- I4 ;
. &.;. w w :y.1 s i:. c a q.,
,: 94-u u
- ,..!'.'.s;...
- ,
c-c. :,
.a..;.
./ v. L_
l s.
~i ht-bitsts TVA gr-ssz-ms i
M SVoA
[tzA rT
'3 W L S \\6 - 2.s2 - 26 3 0 h' arts ld w]
'ML Sts - 2 $2-24 2 Lt
// g [ tt/
Wu Syr- ?~:5-51 6 F. E c. s c. b skin SNL s% - 3%~ h% -
~
~.A-W ? ^.S Y ~b ~ E'?b _b
..i t. s C,.
.h
- ..~
i 5 M m ua.
w : c-l i a s
% s-4 M - W c W,3,I4x.c&
S// L./SA.t a c-MY 3'M L
$ 4 L.
- ? %'
.. ~
._f;.1 E~n,
>~; :? T44
} q C a'
-' ' 'a V%cc ksn$n PAT-3I 2. -323- ?^759-
'87 C., c. ;.t nI
- .:. ix s. :. a
'R.E. l}eng y' FAI at z - a e 3 - e 7ro R R. Sem>ETr SN L 505-846-49a'+
i,-
fafo ks/PAa f,vt fsr - WYG
/177 DAMyl ORAYEK S/VL ST - 84 c-3ff 8
. u_
s c,u m -o 7:>L For - f44 - S hfd K'E ~ i n Lu d,w I
SLr 5cq - 27f 321
/lda gu t,v, m' uu w
Sa <_
p; - en a e 7Y-on.
- n n. t e.. w G..>
... Ib.: a,. C.
- i. ? -
7a s,>v B.R Sann
.ent sr ec.m1 a1<E, Kas re dee9 oc&4 (2/s) -1.0 s - 2ogs m i' 0,,
esis :,eginii On).rs
?d.f5'
$.T hbg.71g
./V.<'tj' A'Es (y0i) 4 n -4.2.t2 L
f l
l i
i I-ein
.O
- - - - - - - - -, ~
~
i.
.r
+
PROPOSED AGENDA (Revised 6/30/82)
NRC/IDCOR MEETING ON RISK CODE DEVELOPMENT AND VALUE-IMPACT ANALYSIS July 7-9, 1982 Albuquerque, New Mexico
Purpose:
To exchange information available to date on risk codes and value-impact studies.
The information exchange will include an update of where programs are to date, where they are going, and the schedule for future activities.
Scope:
Risk Code information will be exchanged in three basic areas:
1.
phenomena; 2.
modeling of phenomena; and 3.
integration of modeling into the codes.
Phenomena to be considered include:
1.
thermal-hydraulics; and 2.
fission product behavior.
Value-impact information will be exchanged in the following areas:
l.
benchmaking of plant risk; 2.
risk reduction analyses; 3.
cost analysis; and 4.
characterization of benefits versus costs.
Ground Rules:
See attachment.
I.
OVERVIEWS OF PROGRAMS l
A.
NRC Programs (R. Bernero, NRC) 30 min.
B.
IDCOR Programs (M. Fontana, IDCOR) 30 min.
C.
EPRI Programs related to Degraded Core Risk Code Development (R. Seghal, EPRI) 30 min.
Total for Overview 1 hr. 30 min.
II.
CODE DEVELOPMENT FOR PHYSICAL PROCESS ANALYSIS IN PRA A.
General Perspectives on Approach 1.
NRC (D. Aldrich, SNL) 15 min.
2.
IDCOR (E. L. Fuller, EPRI at TEC) 15 min.
j B.
Thermal-Hydraulic Modeling P
l 1.
NRC - MARCH (R. Denning, BCL) 90 min.
l 2.
IDCOR - MAAP (B. Henry, FAI) 70 min.
f$
--i.
C.
Fission Product Mode, ling 1.
NRC - MATADOR (P. Baybutt, BCC) 90 min. -
2.
IDCOR (R. -Seghal EPRI, R. Burns EPS) 60 min.
D.
Sensitivity Studies, Benchmarking, and Uncertainty Analyses 1.
NRC (D. Aldrich, SNL) 30 min.
~'
2.
IDCOR (E. Fuller, EPRI/TEC, R. Henry FAI) 30 min.
E.
Schedule 1.
NRC (D. Aldrich, SNL) 15 min.
2.
IDCOR (E. Fuller, EPRI/TEC) 15 min.
F.
Summary of Discussions 60 min.
Total for Code Development 8 hr. 10 min.
III.
VALUE-IMPACT STUDIES A.
General Perspective 1.
NRC (A. Benjamin, SNL) 30 min.
2.
IDCOR (S. V. Asselin, IDCOR) 30 min.
B.
Benchmarking of Plant Risk 1.
NRC (A. Benjamin, SNL) 30 min.
2.
IDCOR (J. Young, EI) 30 min.
C.
Risk Reduction Analysis 1.
IDCOR (S. V. Asselin, TEC) 30 min.
2.
NRC (SNL Staff) c i
a.
Methodology 45 min.
b.
Initial Results 75 min.
c.
Uncertainty Analysis 45 min.
d.
Cost Analysis 15 min, e.
Benefit vs. Co'sts 30 min.
D.
Schedule 1
1.
NRC 15 min.
2.
IDCOR 15 min.
l E.
Summary of Discussions 60 min.
Tctal for Value/ Impact 7 hr. 30 min.
IV.
SUMMARY
OF DISCUSSIONS AND DEFINITION OF FUTURE ACTIVITIES 90 min.
Grand Total 17 hr. 10 min.
l-l
,,7...
c..
.m
s.
cc:
ows ky. RES fiightnijESI
'. N0rberg, RES J. Jenkins, RES SASA Branch J. Long, NRR/ DIS B. W. Sheron, NRR/ DIS E. D. Thonn, NRR/ DIS J. Hunter, INEL N. DeMuth, LANL E. Haskin, SNL S. Hodge, ORNL I
l i
1 1
I l
l m
B/5
4$
NRC-IDCOR INTERFACE MEETING SASA PROGRAM REVIEW AGENDA
- +---
TECHNOLOGY FOR ENERGY CORPORATION 10770 DUTCHTOWN ROAD KN0XVILLE, TN 37922 August 24, 1982 8:30 AM Opening Remarks and Introduction of Attendees R. Curtis Background on NRC SASA Program NRC/RES Issues SASA is Attempting to Resolve 9:00 AM Progress Reports ORNL - SASA Progran Introduction (5 min)
S. A. Hodge Accident Sequence Analyses (15 min)
R. M. Harrington Degraded Core Analyses (15 min)
S. R. Greene Fission Product Transport Analysis (25 min)
R. P. Wichner 10:00 AM BREAK 10:10 AM INEL - SASA Program J. Hunter Brown's Ferry Station Blackout T-H Analysis Results Scrara Discharge Volume Analysis Using RELAPS IREP Sequence Analysis Depressurization of CE Plants Without PORVs Characterization of 2-loop plants for SGTR B&W Behavior Under LOFW Conditions with (40 Min) multiple failures i
Plans for Indepth Analysis of CE Plant T-H Analysis In Support of Containment Management Strategy Support of the Resolution of USI A-47 Results of Hydrogen Replication (20 Min)
R. Chambers 11:10 AM LANL - SASA Program Strategies for H venting from the Primary N. DeMuth 2
Systen Plans for Indepth Analysis for Oconee 12:10 PM LUNCH m
.-,w,,-,-,,vn,-.
,,---,-r
~-,.,-,-,,-~,,--,-.,n--,----~---.,-,-,---,-,-..n,,-mnw---s,,,,
2-1:15 PM SNL - SASA Program PWR Containment Accident Management E. Haskin Study for Zion, Surry and Bellefonte Plants.
- Systematic Study of Containment Loading Failure Modes, and Operation Actions
- Radiological Consequences from Severe Accidents MARCH P$difications Pressurized Thennal Shock - Maine Yankee Containment 2:15 PM Comments and Discussions 3:00 PM Adjourn l
il e
4 6
e e
e 7
,w--..+...--.w._~
..--y
.v-....,---,...-9y,-,
g-ee>e-e---ear-'W-=-
e-9*--e'-*-
~9-*--"
e*-
- -t W*
' ' ' = "- ' * ' -