ML20149E061
Text
{{#Wiki_filter:O 2 at m -~ ~ _e es. ,,, g 5 l )* sofgjy 3 '/ /. l n .$-h.r K ci.r;.c, aa,ta, c.- : ^ %-v,- M.Mmok<upns_ es,, D h j e e /.- ##ey An af h /.r., g,,,4 i yfe We, Ce,-A A c ubi 4 die d4 (,y,- s oc.A,Ae-3, n r.s, CJ %Ay-e. n s.,l 4 oc->- m n.,n .yg- . 7% w. - J.},-,,' d' - = j,, -,a3.c - er a. u u. s 7ke a6/.C.4 mA,L ? A d' c /~ g. 4,,.. a-a m% [m W 5 w/L wue/ y%w a Adu, c. e,
- g As py o~~
m a ,at s i., m A 9 w f., w a -uw. = va 4 a A4 e c/ d 'A ~~4 l~ 4 n. L 4 m p kguv4.< A L~ % ^l A ~ lEj g &Q m JA f~ A #""Pl !!!j_g n., s', e - p - _ m rd n $D A ( & f * 'f & s s--> ~ M A A~.
=,, g -{ M=O N fa M N (Aa m de d) s on f'. 6Y ,4 ac cep/ aMn4 9 G 4 0 0 D T \\ l ) 9 .m e= 8 we ep p u&8
u * ~ ~ --- ALLECAT171,N DATA FORM une F.m sn inetn e en enr m ti1.azi RECEMN3 CFMC5 Docket Number (if ap31 ./jW / OY Ob $ 0 0 1 (- g.n.n . m. ctNEA C 1 ee n / t l \\ ~~""
- 2. Functional Arse (s) Involved:
onsite health and safety operatiorm (cr.cs.c,,oorste tweni t offs!ta health and safaty construction foguard. emer ncy prope edness other isMi,_IM, l A-I A l Li F lM A lb l lElel/f 1014.IfI l/ Id i LD 16 l [blo Icla imleWir-Inl H e lo WI IMIP1 !alvl/ IT1 3.
Description:
GErfr14 lclN-144I I/_ly-12I lbl Tt DI I / I O VIO!9 i liIIIIIl1IIIIIIIIIIIIl! ~ security guard
- 4. Source of Allegation:-
cont. actor employee (chect soprconste tens news med a licensee employee . private citizen NRC employee s organization (specifyi-a other (spec'tyi _/ uw oo vy
- 5. Date Allegation Recelired:
)
- 6. Name of Individual t% we iMoose end test nernel Receiving Allegation:
l
- 7. Office:
{ g ACTION OFFICE N k ^ " "Cse < +c-n ~;d' I' " ' '" 3 D .~.
- 8. Action Office
Contact:
(m: me iMii i. end t et ns,n.)
- 9. FTS Telephone Number:
y 4 { ., 3ygg [ Open,if followup ections are p'ending or in progress
- 10. Status:
%,,,3 Closed,if followup actions are completed Mu oo YY 11.1 Document N05.
- 11. Date Closed:
3 b l7" { A l A W l5 lF {G.IA., \\ lJ l N l1 !6 N l bi 1 f.l E !4 Remstks: IA il l a It I T-lY I b~ l 0 1 l/l! / M I I) 1 0 I / I / l 3 li.1 Man-hours
- "g /
f 3 .A- $!f s x
- 13. Allegation Num(Date r er:
D' f. ,/ State of Cal (famia y ormmarormsnce =. 1 JOHN K. YAN DE KAMP y \\0 3380 WIL5 HIRE pouLEVARD. R amer er,a LOS ANcELE.S 90010 c m39u uo4 September 28, 1983 Director Darrell G. Eisenhut, Division of Licensing of fice of Nuclear Reactor Regulation U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 20555 Washington, D.C.
Dear Mr. Eisenhut:
Canyon Nuclear Pacific Gas and Electric Company (DiabloNuclear Regulatory Commi Units 1 and 2); 50-275 0.L. and 50-323 0.L.
- Project, Docket Nos.
Richard B. Hubbard, On September 15, 1983, our consultant, the enclosed received in the mail from an anonymous sourcewhich is dated the document, P. Foley As you wil1 note,is purportedly from the files of the H.in the e document. August 12, 1983, Company and refers to documentation problems construction work at Diablo Canyon. forwarded to you.for such action as you This material istbeing deem warranted. very truly yours, ~ JCHN K. VAN DE KAMP 1 Attorney Gene F ( 't N i.1 A STRUMWASSER i MICHAEL Special unsel to the Attorney General 4 MJS:hs Q e Enc. Lawrence Chandler ) ) w/ enc. cc: l John Martinv' i Richard D. Hubbard ) i I.A 9 G~ JL./ ~ f J 9 9 g,3 9 1 9 / D e?
,y ' a. ',,. - p.': i ,4 t,.,. ~ * : R.d
- erv.'
v / . t. :a :. *.. . w.c.'.... w. -gf..... ,*...p.-./.:Jy, t,,.. 4 4 :. 3,..~.. a y. ... ' +. ', ..*r 6. 4 a........ p.;.+.,;q,.r,...- f.. ., *,..i s e. ;, v .i. ..m %.r rs,,..
- .n.
.,4.5 g... - f *..p'.,,as,c** ;'p.-r. -..<.*. J '..g.. )** p w. ..r,n a
- e..
..*'KW T.;',q'h. [e..'.,.1(.y:.g. ~,.. W.
- W %,,.VAid s
s.;,.;.....:-!. -. a s.
- ,r....,..,..s-..x
- i,,.. 9 o t. *.: s. t..<.M k., w
- ,.., J...y.'.*. f,.. ',
t ',- # e. n.e ~. < - c y..... r. L
- . r.o s
- .?.-.
v ,,....M.w..,,, ... s s. .es.... v
- w. : ; >W. + ;.,q..,... ?'.
2
- w...
.,..,:...,..i:.. . '*,.9. :r.' ;. t. w...:5. ;...e.m... : w v. .:w..p.;. :',Me. -.n.v M... +:- .u .Q,: ./ 4 p,'.. i. r.. pm l. -:l.:.%.;9...; ......+.c...%...s:%,p:.n...w.,.... gM> p:C 'rW r.9.;:.M.' n,,y,,&,.., -... o. w. n n;..
- . :S #... $,
m,. :.s.,;} ;L.w:..., _... ..,. g.... m,,g.,. g.,4 g. f. .a
- G
.r ..n
- .
- . m
..y.
- h. %.4,,4,4%..: y.c.::Y.-vi.4
.i o.. -?. l' ':. '-.? L 4.1 5 : i..;,.:. v,-M.;e..k.w.:... : e :...G.. ~... e9.5 ..... S;,.. ~...e%,.7., = i ,,.. -s .w; . n .,c: . ;a.:s ....,.'...'.~..1..p;%3* y: v.n ..:.:. s.. .,#.. ; $w%....,.n. u,,..w,, V..~..... .. V.<,%, gc. .e. c. -. .l,:, s n.p.. .,,,.u.,... ;s,....f..:. ..ur,.. :,..,.,,.s ...w....'+ J.. ... C.sm e. . es. *. l.*....,.* .,k P.. - ... a.v..;:.W [.r,,@,y y. - : '. i., .?.-Q,1. ;,..r:.. l.. .L
- G c
l ye. . : :<:.,.p. --.,7, ds.;, .. r. $.. +,.<,,,.v. ....%..~.
- .. : :t'.m:: :,-n
..r<?..y. ;.::. :.,..,.y;,; ; y.:.: w. y :.. e..:. :.<. .a ;...,ye.. '.....'. n.; ;;r....
- .....,.- m.a
. y.
- .,,, : ni.. s::m;y,
~. ~ t .. *.n : .p* u&.es,o.v=p.;*s g<;3.g.w<:):;~.:;p .o ..,..*.:.;.. a,,..r ,=#., y g. e.. - p-c v. .y ...: w;;m a
- - e.:
r c.: . n.. '. 1 ..=.. r .'p. .ll: . o.. v . 7, ...,,....g sgy l s-s
- p..,.. ;' =...,
.s.4,'..g. '.,., ~. 1 ,p'~
- i.
.b.~g..
- u ;;. ~
_o e+ ..l . :w. 1 o,.. .., z...m.* ?,. w... g.v. :.
- )' M l
./ .: e ....~ 4..Li,.T, Q,,..y
- q
. ~.. l
- ~~ < Y.
.:,.,M <. s.).N.P. E..: s ' : -... . : WC:Q; s.w...?.. .o ()l. -
- w;; p~ -[',' yar.1 r.... O.. I
.8...a :.. *. 4 :r. ..,c.. s.,. e. ..a;: ../. . * -"t;:s 4 ".v:. :... * .. ~.
- w.
a 4n .r . i*. [.. .... ?.. ',.'.I D ';. i M. & M l..L.,/T ;,.~=:; -j-2- \\ i ,*g. w. ., g.. v.:... c .,, ': i..,. ..t :..y
- 7..,.c q...-
a.,[... 4, q. 3.m.., i l p.., m.... c, ....*;. m,.'. <.P...v,:.,:p,en.s.. yv...., pry. r. t.,..d...... v ;.....,....,....
- v..r.c. c,.,e
~ e \\ n. ...r...,.-
- s....
..j,,...'T3.i.g'. '.;: j-. f...... .t W '..). t. .F. .,. c. T..- 1 ., '.b.
- *..../..
P r, i .......,x.,,:, s.....,.. py i l , ';. e.,, ..... :-...... n. s,...,. u .s l = . r......... %.,,.a.,..g,.si:*-:s= y,... / 4.,..;.. '... r...... =., .<*.v. p. ...,.,.;., r. ....**r. . y 1 \\
- .,,. g 3.,;.3..
- q>..r..,...u'._,,.C g.
... b :.... : :p.,.p.p..
- a. s...u.;. gd;.,v.c..i.,...y.:..
t .~ .,:n -- c. ..-...... : e. . w w...,....w.. ..-...., u;u;..:v,ca..... g... m..: ,.z ?.. . r ::.. a. , /...:. . e.. -,.,. u. m,W Q:...,..#aTs..Z-t;PTAkA G ~*V:.'::,%;y..,g,....-@l:Gl<.W:'.s fid!. . g.w.9.g. RG g .. +.... . eu. ..... u.....:. u. z ~. .g ,/. ....,..e. 1 .. ~.. .: s......
- s.
- 4..
v..... y.. ; < - -.-..,w,.... . =.:: r...:.- ( .. =. ) m .I i 41 9 ;.. n. ,.. c.,.......,.. ...w,.....,<,. ..e. .r.........: ~.,... n,.. 4. ..,1,..,.. .,., m. .s....
x > /u ~
- /
y3:emmr' r-7 i, R. ,1 ] DATF: 08-12-83 i I F J J = _m.Ts e ; H 7 Th_ h t :--~ - - - ~ m Page 1 of 4 LM Ohi-$ ETER-OFFIG MDD I i
SUBJECT:
WL:e Traceability for Ciredt 4:rd ter.e by Both P.G. & E. m d H.P. Foley. Ibare are cany cases hwolvir.g Cirede Pull Packages in sitich either: (1.) 7eley ccqileted the eriginal installac.cn ed P.G. & E. took cver subsequent ed or (2) P.G. & E. ccepleted he init:Lal inst:allation e.d Teley took cver subsequent w:k In both n the cir::uit (c.i. Fullcuts, Repulls, Reficats). .ases vire traceability is twc rvidet en cur paperd due
- o.a failu::e to reference either 'Di or 4R r.xbers en the We are t. uhle to locate ahy Oiredt In:stallation Face:ds.
doexentation that paavides vire tra.:cability fer rany of dase cire.:it pull packages. We' have ide.tified system mrbers for rest cf these ciredts. For each roladex circdt card indicating P.G. & E. wd Le resdarched either the "?:c:t' c; 'To" equi;=s;tt locaticn ecdes. NE The 'systa:: arbers thus identified Lt 2: 17, 21,09, 55, 49, HOWARD P. FOLEY 03, 08 md 54 (see Attrd=ent 1 for ciredt i.afermar.im. ). COMPANY i
- e. c. sox ::-
AVP A SEACM. CAuf. i 9:W24 ses. sis.rst t j i c m e.- At.A.EVf C?rr.v. Pt 4N Sny Assui SA7meCAf.. ud.AYkano C>C CC.M.us04 l 084AA1, T ELt S eMW:.tunG. 70en$nyAMA >CL.'1 T O.e.1"51A$ .C$ mGEt!5. CAUSC5V+sA e i.wm fine T. CAR A ciwia w4 64*'*tt. Tf.Nmi$$(( a..w gi.rmA Pt wa $nV wA ) at w C8t.f ANS. n.CV15 dea j
- aC6 MK. 4 A6'.CMA pit'i s tumCM. P4 NN5ny AmA A scr+4cm0. vimCama 1 4 7t.aAt CI N.UfAsa 1 Aa.ed.. RCACA f u?3 0m. ANCe<A i
w A Sme.Gt Ott. O C. Caumen sese.sarr l (CaaCP,10M. 4484m7 A r
ATTAfW"ff 1 'U~ pw. 2 nr I (... f CIggIr_d "H Of' EGlIPMENT M "ID" ECUIPMENr gl l( ~ C06H03-SZ:R 4KV BUS G W B 6 17 006H08. SMR 4KV BUS 0 CUB 6 17 l F00?05 TE@t BOX A 218 FOR INIK SIR NL* . F00F06 TE@t BOX A218 FOR INIK SIR E* F28P003 DIESE. N 12 CONT.ACIOR 21 CSL GEN ST.ARTING AIR 21 PE B C2iP 12B F28P90E CSL CEN 12 CDNT.ACIOR PE B 21 DSL TURBOCRARCER AIR 21 c m r 12B F34P00A LCC AUX SALT WIR PP 11 17 AUX SALT WIR FP 11
- 17. l CATE OP 18 CAII OPER 18 F34P03X Tat BOX A218 FORINIK STR NL*
F34P00XA ICC AUX SALT t m ?? 1.1 17 GAIE OPER 18 F34POM ' 430V e C 1 BUS F 09 TIPM BUS A 218 FOR NL* HC:AIG STR F34P02A AUX SALT WATER PP 11 (WIE -17 w d BOX A 218 FCR Nf
- OPER 18 UfEAKE STR F34P02B TEM 1 BOX A 218 U(d" dC STR NL* CCNIR BD IVB1 SNRRDS 55 F34?03 430V FCC 1 BUS F 09 CCNIR BD lVB1 S/EECUARDS 55 F34PO4 LCC AUX SALT WIR FP 11 17 AUX SALT WIR FP 11 CAIZ 17 GAIE OF 18 QPER 18 3
7 F39P00 430 FCC 1 BUS F 09 TEFM BCX A 218 FCR FL* nau Sn F39P00X TE! ECX A 218 FCR DrddG NL* THE STA j CWAAO P. FCLEY F39P02 5',.UR 410/ EUS F CUB 8 17 TER4 ECX A 218 FCR EH CC fd P ANY Di M" STR F4LF00 480V iCC 1 BUS F 09 TEMi ECX A 21S FOR E* BTXG STR F41P00A iTC@! BOX A 213 ftR DrJXI 1* SIR F41P00XA 70' 601 U 1 & 2 AUX SLT 17 tvTR TIE F4LP01AX TDti ECX A 218 FOR IND.W.- Ef FC/ 601 U 1 & 2 AUX SLT 17 ' SI VIR u.:. F4LPC2AX TEt! ECX A 218 FOR DirA.E NL* TCV 601 U 1 & 2 AUX SLT 17 l ST .,,/, FIR TIE i F56POCC DIESE., CD113 CC hrICR 21 DSL CR4 ST.ARTE C AIR 21 ! PNL A C 2 P 133 I 3
- Not. listed
. =--.,. ~ - -
O>1 ,u - m u t s umu a 3,. CTPCUTT # 'TPGf' EDUtitENT Q "tO" NM b' G31P06 ' DIESEL GEN 12 EXClTATION 21 CDNIPtLDSL121Crh Cus PRec G31P07 CCNr PNL DSL 12 !Cr PHP NL*' DSL GDI 12 FCI IHP PRIMDC ^ PRDOC G31P08 CCNE PNL DSL 12 !CI Q PRIMING G54P90 480V FEC 1 BUS G 09 G54P00A LOC AUX SLT WIR PP 12 17 AUX SALT WIR PP 12 GA GATE OP 19 CP!1 19 G54P90X LCC AUX SLT WIR-PP 12 G,CE OP 19 G54P01 480V lCC 1 BUS G 09 G54P02 (ENIR BD IVB1 SAP 7CUARD 55 AUX SLT bTR PP 12 cad CPER 19 G54P03 480 FCC 1 BUS C 09-CCNIR BD IVB1 SAETCdARDS C54P04 1CC AUX SALT WIR PP 12 17 AUXSALTWIRFP12GM CA"D. OP 19 OPER 19 G60F00 480V FCC 1 BUS G 99 G60F00A EC4 FAN E101 ALF. SALT kTR PP 12 C60F01 480V FCC BUS G fi 6* ~* M C62P00B. DIES ~.~ CEN 11 CCNIACICR 21 CSL GEN STARITU AIR e PNL B CCMP 11 B mE G62P90E DIE GEN 11 CCrdCIOR 21 DSL TU%%'4 APE AIR HowAao P. Fi: LEY Ll COMPANY G70F03 480V FCC
- 2US G 09 H23P0GB DIESEL GN 11 CCNIAcrea 21 DSL GD1 STARIDC A.3 PSL A CTP ll A K23P06 DIESEL CD111 EXCITA2TCN 21 CCNT PNL CSL 11 tCI CUB PRIMDC
.) E23P07 CCNT PNL CSL 11 FCI PMP NL* CSL CEN 11 1Cr PMP PR I!C PRIMDC H23P08 , CONT P!L CSL 11 FCT Pi; P PRDOC M41100 480V FCC 1 BUS H 09 H41P00X1 PCV 495 AUX SALT '*TR [ xA AL2429CC MDi RNJNCLUOR CABUET 4 49 m 201ml DIrsEL.cEs 11 ExC=ATI4 cub \\
- tbt Listed
g. . ;f.,,, m u nent t ica e if i' _ m 'TRctf' ICUIP4Nr 3 "fD" EttJLmT ' (( ~,. AU.301DG1 DIESEL-GN 12 Dr1T.id CB AU.491DFL DIESEL GDI 13 DI1TAS GB a AP2491IG MAIN ANNUNCLGOR CABI 4-AY2423DF2 2 BOX A 218 FOR IhTAKE SE AY5070DF3 SWCR 4KV BUS F CUB 9 93 SWCR 4KV BUS F, CUB 12 1%775V91C PULL BOX 2 42A INTK SIR tL* M SCX A 218 FCR INIAKE SIR IO4775V01X PULL BOX Z' 42A DTIK i IM775V04C PULL BOX Z 42A INIK E NL.* TEPM BOX A 218 FOR .DEAKE SI'R IM775VMX~ PULL BcK I 42A DEK' ! IM775V05C PULL BCX Z 42A INIK SIR NL* TERM BOX A 218 FCR a DEAb2 SIR IM775V05X PULL BGX Z 42A D M S"G. IM785V01 MECH PSL NO 198 CWP 11* C2 FIR BD IVB1 CHLORDE SLT eX:,CJARCS
- 3+=
IM785VM CDNIR BD IVB1 Mi Xe:.CJARCS IC4785V05 CDNIR BD LVB1 y, FAFECCt.RDS o.vAao P. Fot.EY ' M 94A M T?aCDC DISIR FNL 08 HEAT D ACE CDST COMPANY 9 M cL943 M UACING DISTA PNL 08 HEAT UACE CONI LC BB to 10194B M C195A HEAT TPACUC DISTR FNL 03 HEAT D ACE C7TI 10 AB tC 10195A M C195B HEAT T?ACDC DISTR FNL 08 HEAT T?N 2 C:hT M *3 10 101953 I e qe H
- Not LLsced
U~ u.s. nucuAn necuureny ALLEGATION DAT.A FORM _ ene . :m ' ineuvcuano en tw.. e.o. it1-an MCEIVING OFFICE Docket Number (if ap,:- - - [ ~ 1 CAA/Y'OA/ <--- S O S tu i (- F.ciiity(i..i inv iv.et: D/A6LO-t,,,,,,,, in.n a.,,,, 5 D 3 m.m. asumc
- 2. Functional Area (s) Involved:p onsite health and safety operations tchect sooroprien bades31 offsite health and safety construction d
% emergency prepare ness safeguards other tser',WI _ ~ 9 1 I M I f l 8-l O } F l $ 4 { l Wl8i bl b [II/ lolMSI T I I IIIIIII IfII I L 3.
Description:
lIii IjilIiil i1Jl I[ I_ l Ii I I i i i l f I I I IT f fli I L ~ 1I II security guard -
- 4. Source of Allegation:
contractor employee scrwt encroonm t>osa news media ilcensee employee L. private citizen NRC employee C
- N IO OOkbON-0F i
[ orgenization :se.ew) t 78 tG(m/ A*1 - TM l dWJ/3 _ -- other tsp sityl Mu oo vy
- 5. Date Allegation Received:
jg g' g g y 3 tarsi rwo (n.a.w m1 taar umei
- 6. Name of Individual Receiving Allegation:
4 -i
- 7. Office:
m-_ ACT1CN OFFICE iness two nnaaet..a ies um.)
- 5. Action Offles
Contact:
- 9. FTS Telephone Number:
g g l7 p { Open,if followup actions are pending or in progress ~
- 10. Status:
l d , Closed, if followup actions are comp ete (Check onel MM 00 Yv 11.1 Document Nos._ 't. Date Closed: {= U. Remads: [ l l l l l l l l l ; j l l l l l l l w u> sa a.c,a ( 'f I I I i l I I IIIIIIII IIIl 1 j v, om. ,12.1 %.q q g ll l R v gf l 3 -A a
[,, '.g ~ UNITED gTATES 4 '[ff) g NUCi. EAR-REGULATORY COMMISSION, u E REGION Y .h*""e['! I 14sc man AUNE,suRE 210 ,e' WALNUT CAKEX. CALIFORNIA 94596 MEMORANDUM FOR:
- 0. C. Shackleton, Director, Office of Investigations, Region V '*.'.
FROM: T. W. Bishop, Director, Resident, Reactor Projects and. Engineering Programs Branch, Region V
SUBJECT:
DIABLO CANYON ALLEGATION - MR. C. NIEB2RGER OF TRI SAN LUIS OBISPO TELEGRAM-TRIBUNE REGARDING FALSIFIED,VELDER QUALIFICATIONS The attached hand writte'n note, M. Mendonca to D. Kirsch, dated 0,:tober 6, j 1983, describes the subject allegation which were received on October 3, 1983. I request that your office take the lead in investigating this matter and report the results to myself in the course of the investigation. The allegation has been assigned alligation number RV-83-0039. Please let me know your schedule for investigating this matter and any preliminary findings, as soon as possible, since this information cay be of interest to the comission during a Diablo Canyon Commission briefing on October 28, 1983. O a y . W. Bishop, ire:ctor Resident, Reactor Projects and Engineering Programs, Region V
Enclosure:
As Stated cc w/o enclosure: D. Kirsch, RV J. Crews, RV P. Morrill, RV M. Mendones, RV 1 e e =e. e .}}