ML20040F715

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Responds to 710823 Memo Re Design Capabilities for Containment Vessel.Margin Above Calculated Valves Should Be Applied to Cover Uncertainties in Defined Loca,Rather than Redefining Accidents
ML20040F715
Person / Time
Site: 05000000, Limerick
Issue date: 09/20/1971
From: Morris P
US ATOMIC ENERGY COMMISSION (AEC)
To: Case E
US ATOMIC ENERGY COMMISSION (AEC)
Shared Package
ML20040F238 List:
References
FOIA-81-385 NUDOCS 8202100176
Download: ML20040F715 (1)


Text

-

r v. y

  • y el. asst,.;d.. m q.,.4.,,,,

..e:,n. m.,s w

..s n: a.W. A

7. y.,.,,.

y,,

+ - -,.

s.--w :- <- ---em.p' 4. -w:-;;m ::m?. *=.m, ;ag: : <w.~* rr r/c.5h

,.~e.'.

.-ric e -

t_r w.

w w r

n.;c.q w.. g.,...c~- - -- u. t~,.

. ~.

e v.

, c.: w

%-r-Q; e.

.... p~, &.,/2 u,7,. '

  • y,5w.~.,,,,-.2. m, yi, %.. y. 4 A,...,p.,,v. ~,.p.- W-.
h..,y,m...
~; am c

.e

+.

.e a-

,'.. n V. O.

,-.
,* M.

s.

.3-3

.. v.a.. ~~..a

....c 73 r. ;

  • 2,, ~~
n..,. : tM s.

,,.....,j.

, 'ys. 7

. r e.,..

... v c..4z> > 4 *'w-..., ~. J.g.2 c mq.*

.-n.

s sv

..or. u, e

/

c y

,a V

i ' yl. t *:.. -

r, -,,

a w..,

. *,.&. %*. m.4.c... *,....y : !N.

'.*n q 7.c ^

  • -,c. l7,

.~....3%..; e

'*% r m,.. '

  • 1 u

.,? m.c

.;..,. 4

., y, 9 p.p.4,.. t

~ u. 7. 4, n.,.. es.,r.-...q'f e,..

is

,-., -....,.. =.-

r

... w

. f.

  • m r

.s,...,',.,e.

p*^

,?,.

.p...

.. T * 'L.. Am h t*

-.4 4

... ~u M i i 4, '%. ?.LL.,W..D#.:

2, t.

N,,.a......,.

.%.,u.~'.. :

. c. +a. e....,,G

&-.,.. i,> y(w,13d:'s d.M.,;..:.&..C...' ;.: w.M,m r

u.

.e

..t

...,-e.w,,,,.,~.,,

....,m-.

.s,,

y;4... w.

-j

<...u,.

+-

o n..

,? v..., u. ;,,

a.

2.+

?..

c.s.

.u

.s.c s,

k..'..,

,. 4,e sd.,:.i*,,%. $4,fl^ CY 2. '.n W, ".~ ' l\\

n % *..'.!"p\\ W., < a.: :.*. *e.O '.*, ;-d. *.

o

-.4'-

9, *?' ',.,., c !,,e.

...$,.n...h_

.. o.,

a. rd *

-+

e,-s f <.r-w,p.,-

s.S EP 2 : 0.Q+:,..,.. -.,.

.a f,t'

^...

.L

.ifhmn. 6M-f,.*.W[..h) h ~; $ ; ' {.* M,. "..,

'*;79 M..f,,*\\y 8.3 Iw.} 4 '..%...*' *

. "'* ! N -

Q f[.*: ;. h 4. h^f, f,... s k,7 e - Q.-

.y L 'c.;,ita.r..s\\

,,.kM,h[ 4,Ik;'.] ' (~*

v, e... '....,.-a.gs...

  • .'. o a_v.-

d?

>*I

h. ** F.... '{,, ' ' ' ?,,b
  • f. *"'

.-.... e'.. g

... ~

.w ; ; c.J~. y s.
n.L,. -*,. ;. t.

w-a.

.s,,

y Ln

.s 3

r..~...-,5 a

W C.! Case,$;DL'rectbN.c $...k~hWi,.W

...i

- n '., w ~8.

n,x. 4. g.,

a.. p w.., e m u,

. m.

y..

.g, r ~ 2, - Yvz.=3. g.,m :.... n:

n !

c. r..

.; : 2,.

..; y :... :

.s. 4.y i::O.R,;',d cyca.y ^i m.3.iy& ' :x..; s

1 Q.. $. @.

4'u ;

~~

k*

A cf ~ 7..

?.

7u. M I ':.r'

' Division of.Jtemctor. Standa'rds fnM..,.$ 4 (.

{.7-W M ff., W,V.s 7; :

u i

j, yS+. ;'..?.. ~y,s. r_..u., w,.,. yn,..v.o. a. r.: u Y.. '.M,..N. ;.M..,! ' ?'.BWR;COWADDEN1'.,.'DESNM. Sh.[a M

v.

~~

.g g.r p

3.3%p~ $.-N..UNj2.A A/,.YN,.b3 b.5.h

..3..~.

.., x.... e...

.w fN. 9"?'s D. D~Y'm,~N:

e.

y....

T

.En.

, u u i gtji $m,e.;%w. ;.., wm' n..e.c. m. v. > J n

. w

..s h.

. a.m.~

-W c..'. ;In.your menormium -of August %23f;197.1, -ankevaluation -of t@c. w

  • 1'

..:,.. t.,.e..v

..fg., r. r. M..

.-7 w :

e*-

e s-

.3

.. -.w ~m c.N. w.w.. ~.,..

.. y

v...,. r.A %. 3 r m..., ;

.s,, -

. r:t f

m.e. n -.

f,

,..w.

..m -.,

~-

i

.%3Q'f ~ ' -capabilities !for?.the 7.hariclecontainmenthre'ssel-waa :providedA. In It ch'f.3#1%,

Y' i "that document'the expected. response.of the. containmant cesseltforW,.V

'G..N. O -

raccidents.other.?han the design'. basis losaiof-coolant accident was s'.c.f'

~. -

') :

>I j,.y'gl,..

qj we arelcf 'the;opiritnnfthat the amargins'itdisE.i.$.'i M.E,..._ %q. evaluated.VAs,,,,ou knowS"be. a 3 ;,0 g

y.y c.,,. G.

~

ic'odrWs - - @...h.W.. '.

B 2

m g,'?[,y;% lent.ra ther' than iredefining kaccidents'f 'and d. hat "the 3WR. groups' f

9:

In conjunction with'DRS personnal;'have_agreedi hat a '157. margin.

". ??L'f.;

N for peak containment ' pressure and a 30% margin for deck differen-i,@?.

i,i t

~

~ -

'v

.e tial pressure was adequate.C9.d!+-

g[. w *b ::& a -; s-A9 '-

' G,

-p-

..i ten W-c.O,,

R, 6 We would be pleased to provide ~. assistance in the preparation of T :

~

i.Y'r..

a Safety Guide on the acceptable design bases.for BWR cont =fn=*ntsI u

' end would assign C. Lear on;m.~. par.t-time ' basis 71.M.;.C..

.J< E.'.mTy-lM" Ell MMU ".

...,c

@T,M.O.

",p....

,.y.-

x,.

p:

'm. s n r: n-

% W " W::.M, %c.. %...

n

~. _.

Q';.M k?..y y.p'y;;.

f.M..%,. c t;.:.2 Yfu 7M 'fQclly,., a... a > tf.% lW-;9.%,n:.;.w.s.&'*a J.,.... a.

. c...;..:.., a m.

p.

?w u 4

c /fj v; P s s?,.!was l e

A..u7V.s"?=LodginalSiped brGC..'~,,MW,U&3 m.c $ bp W

'A. -

M 7.$iN-M.:W, oJ i'R. W. 1:N-

.q y* M. :.O,4ym *+.. to.a.r -

m a

n~

&2 v.'.g.. r t c -

~,v r.

v a y. e,

.. ~&

y. /... =., g. s.,.

s.,

c.v f 3 "a A.

Yh;*5i [ifit"7k#M#*N-.M8MM"M7i *O 'I.Me***

't, Q.S,L' ',6.e-KJ'.cp
  • NQ.w.KQ'a%.'.J** Q'k

4h. y..

.yy.e..

.o ym a.

..:..., m m],.ps; r

..t.

~w

.,. +

m -

.y r. p.

n.>;.

. +

~

.m... G yl"f/J..~,J,i g:~';e".~' Peter A..horris, Director... D.

c :.

.7 f.

77. ;
.h wy 7. 7, -

Division of Reactor 1LicensLDE w.. m:'N M T.~I."

~

Jg.r A yyy 2 x :

.?.. c...: & c ~ ~. -. ~

G-n....~:.-*

W

.y...g+5',W- %-&.*q e.%. W Lt.yJP.WW.N.MM :-Ma,. a. n+ Lmf.d.W. P. ?.. K*+W Ueg. Eh

d w; m,,,.,%e'. *.,, w. u,. -m.,... u......

y.x<.;

M

.<.a-

....,~2

...s*',...a.... ~~.. v. x.,..,.,c>;,,.

.n... g.

., ~.

~

'."L' w. m c, : y.-

r 1 :n. y..".=m.*';

3..

Distributim

.. w.n O.y. ; w

i.

...w.

.n.,.

-.Doeket w. N s '. w.T +g j...

...w c..,

y.... s.., W i M'-

.g.

. -.m.g...

.W ?:'

+." ' O p.-N '. d' U. C 6' ibm". J.M,,, % 4.s'dr.3, "

4..-A 0. G - DRL. Reading'O;.$

3..: %

'c '

b.m,W.S % @;3 m*W '-

%a,,,,r.

.'BWR'~lsJ11e.w.,v. rg n.a, p.%.

~4.

ep..

m, c,. p 3n. g p m c:. n u,,f

(,

a : g;.. N t3%.. %. m.

p.. : s g ra

~

'N~

.'p'dM,,.. - ? E.'RSBoya.D.. RL. '_,.w.M,^ #."e.. m.,W.. s.m..,..I.,N.'.N.M.%g.

A'.n.,..'E,Y T. w'w,N.M.,.

ND D

N E

m m.

e e. ;>g

,. e 3

4 4 :.n.

.a r

,j,ig,-gg,,;..gQ. iy,py.g )pg< gs.y

1..y'.6,. ~

j g%,gg -;..;. yg-fq ;g g,3497y,j,fgt; k(..:.$ '...

'..,1,

- -DRL g

.g ~,

M m.16.. a,.,,

.,,..~.-.,

e _... v.x,..:~-y,.s,.

..v.s

.,o,,.,.,s - a.

e. m....n.vcv-

.. m..+.

c.

n.

. s

..,m..s.r..

. 7,.

., ~;..... he >

-m....

A. s..kuc. p.v.y~.; C.; m :, p. v..?:;4

a w a -

3

- W.a.s!'.,cy.

+y. 3 y

- 2..

, m +.. :

. os,1.t

.X....". c. :r., * > 2, M:.s w:.C e '~ ',a..?;,%.J.c:

y:. v,, w :-.. b :%: *>

L-v A,:.

..L'h !.

4.,,,b..',.w;. '.

n

. , y..s &. < +.:.- e%m..,:A..,v 4. e;. %::

~.%. u.,n %..,,. 4.. % u. %..,'.MW';.~-M...

s

.p,,, - :.

c.

- s..

p} m..m: p:.. ?.. '

3s v

.. -..u.. %.. n.3.,.:. -.+:.;A.~- :..w,w.m. e.. >..,;. v.. w. +-w ;ns :

.a ;.m.w:

. V'..
?:r.

..% ; >.' :n v

e. a.n. e. e,..., my.
v. %,.:.,...

.. v

c...

..c.... a,. a.,

.e v...

~

cx q.,.,;......

^ ;.! f%.y..: 9=g.

  • ~.*w y+ g 1::.,n:,..e.,e:-,

e

.r. s.,. :A.. w.

a.. :.-

n

.,n.c

.p

-g-2,... -m.9g

. g:a.-..,.

Wl,n-N.... e.% w.....::s...J..cA..n,9,

v r.

fu.v:\\t

.sQ

. -. y.,.

y vs

.~

c

  • t:D - < :m:

.., P.m

. ':. M W,.%

s.

O.

m.p : ":...

.a, a

.c :.e..?r.; w. W

. a., n,-w,.w:.:...;; 9,, M' aM.-

. ~-.. c. J,y..f.

.*t r.c.;W.:; 1, tea @v

..v.. A &J w.

+.*s.- n.e<+% 'p'n+mt:cW -

M :.

Qc r

S rwg.i. -y

4. *ya;.

pu v,

-. MeefNgyr r+v g* v4 o @. c.Wve -- n

. n,.:

y.-~

~^

e,

~ ~ s~~' Av,:. -w..u w - ~

--r'".y~

..1e,,.n w::u.b.-a. p93L W.^ W...

~s

.a p

~

nW. -, ^r

'bkh th b N.bN '

1

& a,. n...~.

N.U,,. r M$MM, ;;'i'.hN.n ? bE.hd.,eM.%.:b.NNw:k.v?$umm;,.1.wm w a:

, e & r+

me m,Jg y

.v.,

h.v c 1~m cs s%

SDRL'.YWRMlf ODhADhTNJ 'NDR W /T Q:W.MV.FS.WiE'Atow %MB-F J.t N h,, w['5M'(

y.OSg p:P e Qd,-7.%,Lh.,,;.

$m:6P,.DIMJ pm

.n ~

up wno

' nb.'.i".; yM M h.up;ge.. m

~

y //Pi

% ESBo dc+.-,.'M MP E

e.

c y.

&,,, ~~W

%m,

.=9..l.-1.7.]71h A*5 591 mil 71%y..) L*:9 /.j.'].'d_.Jhn..:.b_n.r:WIU.Q,S S d. h, h.. Nm%tWD.

.m

~s.

.3 5

w.,

3.,.,pA9 M.i &g;.a p @w.g,.; gm g_w,

,.. g.

,.,g,wy, g m o.

...... m.cu.m, w ~. 4 u.

m- -_

p., w w_202100176 811019 U.-

pp.

.-1s-pj p.4. %

db 8

$k,'

MM.W;ccm, 2

PDR FOIA

.o, m4.Y.s.Q. n.*y& WNU ); A.h 9. 4-ar wm sM 2: W M s hu.w Q Q'a +p ZITZER81-385 PDR ev W

.t ?

i n%fM M.

.. 2, wm.p.qru r2"XL.

u

.