05000348/LER-1981-007-01, /01T-0:on 810402,mathematical Sign Error Was Found in Load Summation in Turbine Driven Auxiliary Feedwater Pump Nozzle Load Design Analysis.Caused by Designer Error. Seismic Restraint Mod Made

/01T-0:on 810402,mathematical Sign Error Was Found in Load Summation in Turbine Driven Auxiliary Feedwater Pump Nozzle Load Design Analysis.Caused by Designer Error. Seismic Restraint Mod Made

ML20008F688
Person / Time
Site:	Farley
Issue date:	04/15/1981
From:	Hairston W ALABAMA POWER CO.
To:	NRC OFFICE OF INSPECTION & ENFORCEMENT (IE REGION II)
Shared Package
ML20008F682	List: 05000348/LER-1981-007, Forwards LER 81-007/01T-0 05000348/LER-1981-007-01, /01T-0:on 810402,mathematical Sign Error Was Found in Load Summation in Turbine Driven Auxiliary Feedwater Pump Nozzle Load Design Analysis.Caused by Designer Error. Seismic Restraint Mod Made
References
LER-81-007-01T, LER-81-7-1T, NUDOCS 8104210499
Download: ML20008F688 (2)

LER-1981-007, /01T-0:on 810402,mathematical Sign Error Was Found in Load Summation in Turbine Driven Auxiliary Feedwater Pump Nozzle Load Design Analysis.Caused by Designer Error. Seismic Restraint Mod Made

Event date:
Report date:
3481981007R01 - NRC Website

text

_.

.T4. v. Cec [_ i il 1

1.Q I

verAss,aiN::a Tus au. ncuiam :n>oamT:Om

~

o a i i A I t l J.J.s I r I i l@i.l of ol -l o Io Io Io Io I-lo lo l@al 411 il 11 l1 l@l I

l

,, cu a @

,go3 u:E~su coof

>4 ucENs.N -.E.

u umst n,E o o3D

"'T' l t l@l o l 5101010131418 l@l ol 4 0121811 J@l0 la 11 is is li l@

cU 5

to el DOCKET NUMB ER 64 69 EVENTCATE M

II AEPoATOATE E3 EVENT DESCRIPDON AND PRC8ABLE CONSEQUENCES h t o 8 2 l l On 4-2-81 while using the existing L' nit 1 design analysis as an aid in analyzing the l

to 13 l l t_f.,i

?

3..,4 1 4,,. ro. s..,.

t>. -,

-,,,,1, in,As, t e,,,, a, t o - 4. A es,*, -,*s.-,*f,.k1

, f -l.

10141 l error fn the s - tiaa of '-cos h74 been 2de in the t' nit 1 Turkir.e Driven A?vilinrv l

~

M l Feeduster Pu o (TDAWP) nozz1e lond design ansivsis. This error resulted in a condition!

I that could have caused one or :rore of the TDAWP vendor nozzle lead criteria to be ~

l

_ot7l;l exceeded had the equipment been subjected t'o the effects of a Safe Shutdown Earthquake I o e s l l while operating at full capacity in a post accident code. This error is limited only ec[

'> e a o (CONT'D) na sysTEu cAust cAusa cow.

v4Lve.

coes coes susccos cowomaNTeoos sueco:s suscoes oisi IW I cl@ LBJ@ L AJ@ I z i z i z Iz 12 Iz I@ LzJ@ LZJ @

~

O 9

to

' 11 12 13 IS 13 20 SEQUENTIAL OCCURREFCE PEPORr MEVIS3CM LE Rs80 EVENTYEAR RE7 ORT No.

Co3E TYPE NO.

• I

!# l 11

!' O l 0 l 7 l l0 Il I d

W W

gg.

23 22 23 24 26 27 28 29 JJ 38 32 C'r P

r-M D

McVR$

58 4 O

FCA S.

SUPPU ER MA.U7 PER

-~

[JJ@[Z_j@

W@

W@

ali 01010l0l [Jj@

l NI@

l 21@

lZj919l9l@

a 24 ss 34 ao 4

42 42 a

47 CAU*E DESOFIPTION AND CORRECTIVE ACTIONS h i 10 l l This incident was caus'ed by an isolated error in load su==ation by the designer. Cor-

['

s tiI l rective action consisting of codification of a seistic restraint has been made'.

I i 121 I I

i tal I

~ l i # 41 I l

a, ao I

us

% PCWER OTHER STATUS on y

Ol500vf RY CESOR1, Tion l5l W @ lololOl@l

~ l' l D l@l Designer notification l

NA i

A$iveTY cSTENr l

AMcVNTCP ACTIVtTY @ I LCCAT!CN 08 RELEASE @

Is t L. z_J @s es RELEAsEl z!@l nEtzAsE NA I

NA l

io

.s u.

PE A5oNNEL EX7OSURES NUusEn Ti9E DEscRs9T1oN I

tTIIofclol@lzi@l 1

NA i

,Easo w El'i m L s cEs:R,,ricN@^

Nana ta l i of 01 o l@l NA l

8 9 11 12 83 LOSS os ce C AMACE To FACILITY

~

TYTE CE3CRi771oM l9i N' S 3 9 to 53 m i,'We,["'"'"'a a[om.o 4M

- ii!!!riviiiiri

• Usuci ty g

NRC LTU CNLY i

u-(205) 899-5156 f;A.'.!E OF PREPAPER L'. C. Hairston. III pg335

~

a__

._m i

s

(

LER 81-007/01T-0

.j i

1

]

Event Descriptien and Probable Consequences (Cont'd) the Unit 1 TDAWP. This report is being sub:sitted in accordance with i

Tech. Spec. 6.9.1.8.1.

The health / safety of the public was not affected.

i I

4 r

1 l

t I;-

I i

. i..

1 4

t I

i l

l 5

t i

.u e

d i

i i

o e

1e e hm,

ee

- wem

.ie ww -

%, gee,

rytw, e e - + w ye

,,gy>-

+p e w4-yvt

---

re-*

P&-

en~.e---ye er?-

eweem'---wvv--,W=*

y a

h-

--m--e-ees-9,yw^

9ym, - - - -

p..,.pg*=

9 -9.

p 3 p -

gym ?

- 99

- m-.mt1

- yp7,y-ywrmw