05000302/LER-1980-051-01, /01T-0:on 801214,during Troubleshooting Operations While Isolating Leak in Fire Svc sys,FSV-107 Was Shut, Isolating Fire Svc from Aux Bldg Deluge Contrary to Tech Specs.Caused by Failure to Interpret Design Function

/01T-0:on 801214,during Troubleshooting Operations While Isolating Leak in Fire Svc sys,FSV-107 Was Shut, Isolating Fire Svc from Aux Bldg Deluge Contrary to Tech Specs.Caused by Failure to Interpret Design Function

ML19340D392
Person / Time
Site:	Crystal River
Issue date:	12/26/1980
From:	Hernandez V FLORIDA POWER CORP.
To:	NRC OFFICE OF INSPECTION & ENFORCEMENT (IE REGION I), NRC OFFICE OF INSPECTION & ENFORCEMENT (IE REGION II)
Shared Package
ML19340D390	List: 05000302/LER-1980-051, Forwards LER 80-051/01T-0 05000302/LER-1980-051-01, /01T-0:on 801214,during Troubleshooting Operations While Isolating Leak in Fire Svc sys,FSV-107 Was Shut, Isolating Fire Svc from Aux Bldg Deluge Contrary to Tech Specs.Caused by Failure to Interpret Design Function
References
LER-80-051-01T, LER-80-51-1T, NUDOCS 8012300512
Download: ML19340D392 (2)

LER-1980-051, /01T-0:on 801214,during Troubleshooting Operations While Isolating Leak in Fire Svc sys,FSV-107 Was Shut, Isolating Fire Svc from Aux Bldg Deluge Contrary to Tech Specs.Caused by Failure to Interpret Design Function

Event date:
Report date:
3021980051R01 - NRC Website

text

.

t :CE.NSEE EV E.NT E.:C.;7 Ex s at7.

.yrac. st.:co I I

i i

!O is. 22:2 m :a :~.e 4.. 21:. ns:.ve wi- : a i: i.i I ? I Li C ?.) ?! 2 WI O I 0 I C 1 0 0 i CIO f

0 0 Wi l' l h ! 1 1

E' C; ~ I t 7.

..;o.a ;:u

.u......-

r..

.a ;..

..s

.. ~,.... -

v-

.'1*:".! t

• gi 0 r 5 t 0 r -' O f 310 ; 2 y^i l r 2 i l i 4i 8r 0Gil i9 N.:.:c850!G"

'2i6'

- ~ "

c. ir w..ig

?u

.. i,r :m

.~4 a

avss :ss:. meres A.: >aea2:u::..s::,,ss:::@

Durino troubleshootino noprations while isolatino a leak in the Fire Service I

. 2,.

System, FSV-107.was shut, isolating Fire Service from the Aux. Building Deluge, t

t.,..

Sprinkler and Hose Stations contrary to Tech Specs 3.7.11.2 and 3.7.11.4.

The valve had been shut at 2311 on 12/14/0,0 but no backup Fire Suppression System was

,,.,; i 5i f available or established for the affected area. There was no effect uoan the i

I :. 7 _i i health or safety of the ceneral oublic. This is the first occurrence for FSV-107,!

the first event reported contrary to T. S. 3.7.11.4 and the second event reported contrary to T. S. 3.7.11.2.

...t

~

s,

i;

- s tu

..n

i.ss

v.

,.m.

r. :::

.c~a%::::a

u ::::

su :::.

i Af B l@ l Af@ l A l@ l V i A I L : Vt E8 X i("Q l Et/?) 10 t @

I:i si a

il-u u

4

!?--

.,g..e;aveur-taa s.i:u s,2 u

...tse:

..:=

= i.,:.:~

5,:n t C.

3.s s:

@ %vstag a t":" l IAl0l l-I l0f;ili

!.,. f I Of 1i lT !

l!

l Of

1 26

.4

~3

.7 44

,A; C,%

m;*'.'s t

,a,s t -*

t ses nc:s%

a-sc. eg%;

..:.s e c a, soe v t.._.v.s u

...-. g s.

ust mir

.cu.s

..v u

r..,

.s.u..,.

l X'QiHl'9 l Z irG l Zi@

l 010 i O f I

l Yl(B I N 'L9

! A l(S IM [01013 v

U v

V m

v a

Ausz ::::aisres n:::aa terw s 4 - ess :')

s

,, i :, f_ 1e cause of this event is attributed to failure to recoonize the desian function i of FSV-107. When the system was discovered to be isolated, FSV-107 was opened

.,, and operability was restored at 0105. The cause of the leak was determined to be,

,,;; j a partially open hydrant.

It was closed. Personnel involved have critiqued the

..,t event and will oresent lessons learned trainino to all operational shifts by 1/15/61 i

s ic:u-.

.e vt -:::.

92 i? A rb s

% 8Cg g e

-%.ga gya r.3 g*:)-

s

ts::Via.

0.g :v g ay 0 21:r :*.

i,, s i i r l@ f 1 !0 !0 _I@{

NA l

11 @l Drawino Review by SR0 I

'.J u e ht,.7 58 8tstAJeg s a g s g a.g f av:vW s a;=t% Tv t.:CafiCN :s st.1gg isti ZI @ W @l it NA I

{

NA

[

u i,

8tetossig i arc 36e(3

.n...

=rs:

- e,

n i 01 01 0@l Z !@l NA iii7i i

r a

,P u

81s seg s a 6.N.h 8'13

%Lvige

ss::me*C%

j, i<!l0101Ol@[

NA l

u

^

.:ss ee== = Ava.;r:% s4;:;.;

• d mt l Z @[:sseme-NA le4ai g

u si

,,,.,,";$ 7:..-. s @

N'c'5i *

!: i e e ! N Q!

NA

/

I,Ii!i tirii i e f "Name of Preparer:

4'#- /' #

/ 4 ' m %,,,,ey3

(.., /. )*

..a

,y:- %--

r

(

(5:.'.".C**).A SI~??? T'ETI.t?.I MC.:M.CC'i S -.}

801 u n o o$p

SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION 4

Report No.:

50-302/80-051/0lT-0 Facility:

Crystal River Unit. #3 Report Date:

26 December 1980 Occurrence Date:

December 14, 1980 l'

Identification of Occurrence:

Failure to have the Deluge and Sprinkler Systems operable i

contrary to Technical Specification 3.7.11.2.

Failure to have Fire Hose Stations operable contrary to Technical Specification 3,7.11.4 Conditions Prior to Occurrence:

Mode 1 power operation (escalation from 75% to 100%).

Description of Occurrence:

1 On December 14, 1980 a leak at the S.W. corner of the berm was reported to the Control Room. At P.311 the senior licensed -

operator sent to investigate the report shut FSV-107, to isolate the leak, but he did'not realize the valve was a yard loop isolation even though the appropriate drawing was consul ted. At 0050 on December 15,1980 a second senior licensed operator reviewed the troubleshooting actions and discovered that the Auxiliary Building Fire Service.had been isolated. An operator was innediately sent to open FSV-107'.

Operability was restored at 0105.

l Designation of Apparent Cause:

The cause of this event is attributed to failure of peIsonnel to accurately interpret drawing FD-302-231 for the function of FSV-107. The cause of the leak was determined to be a partially open hydrant.

Analysis of Occurrence:

No Fire Watch, equivalent capacity fire hose or other backup System of Fire Suppression was available to the affected-portion of the. Auxiliary Building during the event. There l

was no effect upon the health or, safety of the general public.

Corrective Action

l System operability was restored by opening FSV-107. The leak was' resolved by closing the partially open hydrant. The event has been critiqued by the Operational shift involved and lessons Learned training will be provided to all operational shifts by January 15, 1981. (This is the. earliest time possible i

to instruct all personnel, due to shift scheduling) i-Failure Data:

This is the first' occurrence.for FSV-107, the first event re-ported contrary to Technical Specification 3.7.11.4 and the -

I second event reported contrary to Technical-Specification 3.7.11.2.