ML19325E833
| ML19325E833 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Zion File:ZionSolutions icon.png |
| Issue date: | 10/31/1989 |
| From: | Smith H Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation |
| To: | Lanham D NRC OFFICE OF INFORMATION RESOURCES MANAGEMENT (IRM) |
| References | |
| TAC-73427, NUDOCS 8911090127 | |
| Download: ML19325E833 (6) | |
Text
-
o OCT S 11969 NOTE,TO:
D. Lanham, Document Centrol Desk j
' FROM:
H. Smith, NRR
SUBJECT:
ROBERTLICCIARDODPVCONCERNINGZION(TAC 73427)
I Enclosed u
- chronology (Enclosure 1) related to the Licciardo DPV dated May 11, 1989, concerning containment isolation valves at Zion. is NRR's reccrds associated with the DPV.
Please make the chronology and documents available for public display via NUDOCS. Contact me on x21287 if
/4 additional information is needed.
H. Smith, NRR
Enclosures:
- 1. Chronology - R. Licciardo DPV
- 2. NRR records related to the DPV, as listed on Enclosure 1 cc w/ Encl. 1:
T. Murley J. Sniezek F. Gillespie f
F. Miraglia t
- 12. Rossi F. Congel S. Varga i
G. Holahan A. Thadeni J. Richardson R. Jones L. Marsh C. McCracken C. Patel J. Larkins Y. Wilson R. Licciardo
\\\\
DISTRIBUTION r/
.at Centralfilesv[
bC,5
, f3 'O w/ Enc 1s. 1 & 2 i,' l ( c ' gj ~(
?~
NRC PDR
'3L D d 0
HSmith w/ Encl. 1 ADM RF O
fe NRR:PMSB HSm 16 /
89:jo g
DOC: AME LICCIARDO DPV i
l 8911090127 891031 PDR ADOCK 05000295 P
PNU j
4
(
b UNITED $TATES
[-
f, NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMIS$10N s
wAswmaTow. o. C. Mett
}
k.....,
i October 31, 1989 l
i l
NOTE T0:
D. Lanham, Document Control Oesk l
FROM:
H. Smith, NRR j
$UBJECT: ROBERTLICCIARDODPVCONCERNINGZION(TAC 73427)
Enclosed is a chronology (Enclosure 1) related to the Licciardo DPV dated I
May 11, 1989, concerning containment isolation valves at Zion. Enclosure 2 is
.i NRR's recorJJ associated with the DFV. Please raske the chronology and j
documents available for public display via NUDOCS. Contact me on x21287 if additional information is needed, t
mith, NRR
{
l Enclosures f
- 1. Chronology - R. Licciardo DPV
- 2. NRR records related to the DPV, as listed on Enclosure 1 l
t
}
cc w/ Encl. 1:
l
.T. Murley J. Sniezek i
F. Gillespie i
F. Miraglia E. Rossi j
F. Congel S. Varga G. Holahan A. Thadani i
I J. Richardson R. Jones L. Marsh C. McCracken C. Patel J. Larkins V. Wilson R. Licciardo l'
J l
t i
CHRONOLOGY Robert Licciardo DPV Concerning Containment Isolation \\alves at Zion TAC No. 73427
[
ltem No.
Date Description 1.
5/11/89 Memorandum from R. Licciardo to T. Murley, subject:
Differing Professional View (DPV) Concerning (a)
Issuance of SER to Zion 1 and 2 allowing fuel power operation with open 42" containment isolation valves; (b) methodology used for calculating related offsite doses.
2.
5/18/89 Memorandum from T. Murley to R. Licciardo acknowledging that on May 12, 1989, the Director's Office received his DPV dated May 11, 1989.
Note that this memorandum also requests a listing of persons Mr. Licciardo would like to be considered for the third and alternate members for the Standing Review Panel.
3.
5/25/89 Memorandum from R Licciardo to T. Murley, nominating S. Varga, F. Congel and G. Holahan to consider as third and alternate members of the Standing Review Panel.
4.
5/26/89 Memorandum from T. Murley to F. Miraglia, C. E. Rossi, and F. Congel stating that they have been designated the panel to review and recommend to the Director, NRR, the appropriate disposition of Mr. Licciardo's DPV.
5.
6/2/89 Memorandum from F. Miraglia to R. Licciardo acknowledging that the Standing Review Panel has determined that adequate information has been supplied to initiate a review of the DPV.
6.
6/23/89 Memorandum from F. Miraglia to R. Licciardo acknowledges meeting held on June 16, 1989, and the Panel's request for the following information:
(1) request that Mr. Licciardo more clearly state his concern regarding the time to fuel failure used in LOCA analyses; (2) request that Mr. Licciardo clarify the mechanisms for transporting fission products from the
.g.
primary to containment used in Mr. Licciardo's l
analyses; and (3) request that he provide his view as to the safety significance of proceeding with the pro-posed Zion t.mendment and the safety significance of i
his concern regarding LOCA analyses.
7.
6/30/89 Memorandum from R. Licciardo to F. Miraglia stating i
that the information requested by memo from F.
Miraglia dated 6/23/89 will be provided by July 17 1989.
8.
7/14/89 Memorandum from R. Licciardo to F. Mirgalia stating I
when his response would be submitted.
9.
7/14/89 Memorandum from R. Licciardo to F. Miraglia advising that information provided by his memorandum dated June 30, 1989 will be submitted by July 20, 1989.
(This memo corrects date by which Mr. Licciardo plans to submit his response).
{
10.
7/20/89 Memorandum from R. Licciardo to F. Miraglia transmitting information requested on June 23, 1989.
t i
11.
7/21/89 Memorandum from F. Miraglia to R. Licciardo enclosing a chronology containing status infonation on the DPV concerning containment isolation valvns at Zion.
12, 7/27/89 Note from F. Miraglia to A. Thadani stating that the Standing Review Panel requires information that will
'i provide a technical rationale for time to fuel damage from onset of LOCA in Appendix K analysis.
13.
8/21/89 Memorandum from N. Lauben, RET,, to M. W. Hodges providing comments on the DPV concerning early bluwdown cladding rupture during a large break LOCA.
l 14.
8/22/89 Memorandum from R. Licciardo to F. Miraglia l
commenting on the 8/21/89 memo from N. Lauben to W. Hodges.
15.
8/22/89 Note from F. Miraglia to H. Smith regardirg a telephone call from R. Licciardo pertaining to his concerns about staff analysis submitted to the panel.
16.
8/25/89 Memorandum from R. Jones to A. Thadani pertaining to R. Licciardo's 8/22/89 memo questioning the adequacy I
of Lauben's analysis.
C' 3,
i l
17.
8/29/89 Note f rom A. Thadant to F. Miraglia enclosing memo dated 8/25/89 from R. Jones to A. Thadani as a response l.
to note dated 8/22/89 to A. Thadani from F. Miraglia.
18, 8/31/89 Memorandum f rom Dh' Standing Review Panel (f.
Congel E. Rossi, and F. Miraglia) to T. Murley, which consists of the Panel's recommendation l'
regarding the Licciardo DPV.
The following documents are enclosed:
Reference 1
" Management of Response to Oversight Committee Regarding DPV of R. Licciardo dated May 11, 1989."
Reference 2 - Background Information Related to Differing Professional View, (a) Zion SER and (b)
Methodology used for calculating related offsite doses (included:
Branch Technical Position CSB 6-4 and NUREG 0800, Section 4.2, Fuel System Design).
Reference 3 - Memorandum to F. Miraglia from R.
Licciardo dated 7/20/89 enclosing an Evaluation of the Criteria for and the Calculations of Offsite Doses Deriving from Open Containment Purge Valves During a LOCA at Zion units I and 2.
Reference 4 - Note to F. Miraglia from A. Thadani dated 8/11/89 responding to F. Miraglia's note dated 7/27/89 requesting technical rationale for time to fuel damage from the onset of a LOCA in the Appendix K analysis; enclosed:
Memorandum dated 8/10/89 fror. W. Hodges to A. Thadani.
Reference 5 - Note dated 8/24/89 from A. Thadani to F. Miraglia enclosing correspondence that provides revised analyses to recognize higher linear heat generation rates from Zion (enclosed:
8/23/89 note from W. Hodges to A. Thadani, 8/21/89 memo from N. Lauben to W. Hodges).
Reference 6 - Note dated 8/29/89 from A. Thadani to F. Miraglia enclosing a note dated 8/25/89 from R.
Jones to A. Thadani as a response to F. Miraglia's note dated 8/22/89.
Listing of Memoranda 19.
9/13/89 Memorandum from T. Murley to R. Licciardo consisting of his conclusions pertaining to the DPV regarding Zion containment isolation valves.
l
,n.;,
.,3.-
4 4
?
'4.}g.,
o-l., '
3
" 50.
9/19/89 Memorandum to A. Thadani from F. Miraglia requesting.
that the following action be taken as required by T. Murley's 9/13/89 memorandum regarding Licciardo's DPV..
i.
e f
e l
e, j
.'j t
i i
V'
- l../
}
I,.
{
l
?
I i
'i
. f i
L i
f, e
I I
r l
t k
./
t
}
.i 6
I I
i i
.. -