ML19322C679
| ML19322C679 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Crane, Davis Besse  |
| Issue date: | 01/19/1979 |
| From: | James Keppler NRC OFFICE OF INSPECTION & ENFORCEMENT (IE REGION III) |
| To: | Moseley N NRC OFFICE OF INSPECTION & ENFORCEMENT (IE) |
| Shared Package | |
| ML19322C677 | List: |
| References | |
| TASK-TF, TASK-TMR TAC-11050, NUDOCS 8001200003 | |
| Download: ML19322C679 (2) | |
Text
-.
.~. p g
Ja=uary 19, 1979
- d. k.
s
- :.. *m.E 12'.;,:m cc1an3sION
[g.
. :.mm:- :. K Ui S.04lY..
' ' A -
h ra i,..
gnn:2.t::.CM 7CE:
M. C. Masc 137, 3irec:or, 3ivisica of. 24ac:ce l h' Cpersticca 1: spec:1ca, 5 l
Il 1
o
- 3. D. Sor: burg, Director, Divisica cf Recc:or Const:ue:Lon I: spec:Lon, U i
73cH:
Jmes G. Keppler, Director, un f
B 1
1 SUMIC-*:
2.ICCEMI2IDAUCN FCR NC"!?'CACCS CF I.1CI:131NC 3 CARDS MD REQUIS-' FCE TICCi! CAL ASSISTANCI (ACS ?JC46EH2) 4
\\
~
j
- he e= closed hspe :sr ma=cracdu:a da:ad Ja=uary 3,1979, vich acciosures, J
ide :1. fica several pote=:1s.1 problems whhh are bei=g er vill be pursued
{
a: ':4vis-3asse 1 which appear :s be ge== ic :s 34V pla=:s.
Is M[j s
ad41:1=n := the 1:ans idan:1 died 1.s the =emorm.du=, an issue (described j
is e= 1: sed Acti== ::a=.LI3 73C335E*) c=ccerning C;C 17 vhich was g
rece=:17 resolved a: ;ay12-3asse 1 could possibl7 be co==ca to c:hcr l
7 2=:s u=d e review by E l (e.g., Oavis-Besse 2 and 3).
~hs CDC 17 1
g p!
1:sa a=d sc== of the other 1:ess say only be ge:aric to 3'.V 1
gj, 7 4=:s
[
hay 1=.; 3echtal a.s the archi:ac:--=giseer. Ve are avara tha some of i
p
- he items have been previously identified and disposicia=ed at other' l)d e
7h: 3 -
~
s..
f.
In ac==:da=ce vi:h the i=sycetsr's rec===e=datic=, ICI supervision PC has :: viewed :ha sa:ari.ali:7 and relrrancy of :hsse na::ers :o all 4
3! Lg pe:di=g esses befors 3 cards. involv'.-.g 3&W as tha 3535 su: plier. 2.ased y6. ij
== i=for=a:10: we have on those cases Gavis-5 esse 2 and 3. F'm d
[f 1 a:d 2, Creece Ccu=:7. '~:ree F.ile Is b -d 2), guida:ca giren is j[
( j hc 1320, a=d a *.1har:1 i=:arprutscion of the.w.C 1530 wrds "... 7 sev l
- g i:f cr=a:10.. :Ea: c:uld casc=sb17 be :ese
- e. 2a pu::i:g a sev or i
rl didfer=== ligh: coes as issue before :he 3 card or as :sisis; a :sw 3
f issue", 2.'!! believes EC polhy dic:a:as :ha: :he infer:.2:1cn b<a f
':U f
f::.rarded to al'. si::1:g 3 cards fer esses 1:volvi:g 3'W as :he 2i325
(
[
supplier. To our 'c:cviedge, cane of :he i=fer=acia: rela as to
- [6 scecific isaues u= der :::siders:1cs in the pending hearisgs. 1;C s
does =c: 's=cv cha sig:1f' -'- n of the infor.a ti: as i: say affac:
0 %.
I
- e== a:sff post:1ces.
.A.U 3
a k
I
!2.
Noralius Rev Heepler
-, '. *1
~
8 0 01 ~o 0 0 003
'13/79 Ui3/791/13/79
' !'i cs
=)---
J 4
,4 1
4 S::eeter K: p
-* - M '
7a: del
'enes Es.re s I.
.1
..i.gi49
. i, 3,,. 9
..r,3 / o.
..i., /,s.o
./,.w, /,, e.
,,,,/s7 4,
s g
n
./.
..g
- +.
)
1 h-
..I.
i er m _
m'.-
~
g
-Ne s%g - :-
j
.. = _,.
. "....* }.. f.* **p -[]4"U / q [].)
e.
= ' '.
p
'G'*I, O
r, t.v.c o
,.._.a..<.
. m 4
k,,
m..
s.'...s....."
.d a= e-.a * *.e Ww*.s,. !.....w..m.., _e4.'v=..:.+ i ~
.;............ m'.g.,.;.% 4.a. e. t a. %
c,.s --
..... =
... e. =n %+=.m., m
,s i
. *u
.I a,
l' d
d Fan
y 1
7 g.-haugh '~~~ believes tha: h'2C policy as described in F.C 1310 dis aces
- e : 2:031 :31 of "hid imdor=.acice to si::ing 3 cards, 1:11 :uescimas 34 app: pria: c e.ss of dois; so.
n wuld seem thac 4 = ara of f w:1n a:d issa pec=.acurs way of v'is; thi4 isfor=.acian wuld be for s
g.1 :s sv* av 2:4 di.sposi:1:n de isfor:s:ics during the fevelopsenc
< q of de SC and OC Supplaces: rsi.s:ing :s CI.14suancs for the affac:ad planc.s. h the case of Sree Mila 1J14:4 2 acd other opers:ing p;.gnes where ce Sa and SC Suppice:: have already bec 1.asued, :he giorr.scian could be evaluated for applicacica :s those plAs:s as an j
i sn geard.: :sview 2mk.
i, 9,
Tor your i= lor =acien, liacad belev 14 :he status of re-tisws a:
3 a., avis-3 esse 1 of the 1:m.s 1 the inspec:sr =emorandum:
it Oc 1 - Duri=g a :eca== 1:spectisa de 1.icanses vus :squested to 1
provide 1:.for=a ian :o rec:cene :he apparent ince sis:e=cy
{
becvca: de 75A1 scacces: en fuel asse=b17 cec balddovu
'd for:a a=4 the s * *at:2:1ve :cqu1:=anc :s place j
1 rastrie: ::a ce s:s::1:; de f urth reactor c oi2==
""his 1:f::=.a:1:n vill be avai'abla ?eo:aarv 1379, h) pu=p.
O f
Oen 1 - 7e h:.
ta= fc11:vi g :he licensee's efforts :s decer=1;:s the =a ade of the pcver oscilla:12:s. Ta daca ce r
- y sa=i==2 osc 'ticus have been app : d-a:a17 1.3% and do 3 k[i
- s presa' = a safety proca.
- oc appe.s:
h,
=
c.
n= 3
'"he pressurizar lava.1 quescian 's p ssc ly :he subtec:
,;e b
i d of c
' ' a:14.s b41ese Nn 40d :he licensee. Ve
[
have coc add:=maad the poss' sci:7 :hs-nmLi and :.a*caup l'
' d i
1:st:.:= c :2:1:n do =cc =ee: COC 1.7.
i 11,*,
i is
)
naa 4 - To ou: 'ccvimige, di.s pechlen has :ec developed ac 031.
j
. u,.
'*=* plan.s i:.spect :his 1:e= 1: 7 bruary 1979.
L O c $'- h :sspecse := a: 1:s:s of ::cc:coi' aces, the lisasses 12 -
y develapi=g cri: aria for decac or subs:1:u:1:n vne 2 cc ram-:=r is operstad vi:h 1scert s::ists cut of ser rica.
1 b,*
o i:
h e h - 72 ur 'covlad;e, this pr:bic '.as :cc developed at 23 1.
f1 H
ve pla: :s isscec: :hi.: 1:e 1: Teb:aar7 1379.
1 C vi'1 ase the issui:
of any :sch=1:s1 reviews c edue:ed vt:1 h relata 2
[
3 i:ca 1: :he ins ec::: =esors=dt=2 :: diseosi:1ca :he 1:=a aa :hev L
talata := levis-3 esse 1.
37 copy Of :hia 14::4r. :he.usia:an:
l ires: rs for ac'- d - * *_ ? eg :=s a=d Field Coor:1::::: are requesced j
,s
((l O p :vida 7*!! v*.:
answers :s ::a folievi:g quescicus.
}l P
+
i l
l al e
U b,b )O T D f$lf]Q
! 3n i
dJu uJJ UUW
{
l,
.. ;, d.
,)
% _-.m. m
-.d
- an
)
\\.
r z,.
.s.
q i
., u.........,.... -
..._.c
}
4 :ge.
s 3..
7
.._..~.
...s. -,,.,.... u g..,, a.....ul'.-,--
. h..., w... ~ ~.
v.
. ~.
,.~,ca.: ::..w.c !
o
M3: --
r,..
. < ~ ~. f
- 3. 3.
horscurg Janu.ary 19, 1979 i
j 1
Assis ane Direc e: for ach:.1:21 > eer.us 0
0 1.
Eas WJ. g e= ard - * ' ' y d e:c=is ed tha: the 35'4 core lif: probles is i
cc: an unreviewed saf a:7 quas:1=nt I
l'
- . 3as DJ. generical.17 de:c=i=ed tha: the 34V power oscill.ation
'problaa is ec: an u=:eviewei safety question!
~ ~ '
Does the failure of cold and makaup isst:.rzes:ation :s follow 3.
t*i tha ::ansis== coca:1:uta a CDC 1.3 problem 7 Assista:e 31 ec:ce for ?ield Coordisation 1.
Is.hes a seed to develop scand. sed M'J tec.5. '.1:a1 specific.ations
. '(
for con:1=ued plas: co. eraticas.ri:h f ai' ed 5 cra date :r.,
j
- r..
.::i=gst
.ar
-[
. l.; g Is :hara a sacd :s develop scands d MW :echnical specifhscices
- t f:: res::12:10:s c ses::i=g a fourth : se::: coolas pu=p belov i
i t
cartai: tecyers:uresT i
.s I
o I
- 1 i
io; ycur c:=ve=ie:ca, ::a hc=2 is :he bspec:c: ce:: :acd== have han s{.
re:7 ped o= separa:s pages. If you eed addi:1:=al 1 fsr=sti = plaa'as
. [
ec=:sc: J. S. Cre.svel.1 ( 37-9311),o J. 7. S:res::: (337-9 *3) of =7 s, :tf.
- V e
J
. p[
i James G. Iape.lar
. =
. \\-
'l m
op.a, 01: actor
[
t 1
M esuras:
i.
1.
Xe=crand=a fr:a J. S. C:sswell i
to J. 7. S::se:ar, d:d,1/3/79 j
i I
O.
Rac7 ped e.::srpcz (5) f =a :he i
1/3/79 zecors=dum 3.
F.e=arasdus fr:c. J. 7. Strescar i
to 1. *i. 'Jood:.:f f, d:d, 6/ 9 /73 t
f cc: v/
- cs.::es U
I. *. Jcidan, II S. Z. 3:7==, 13-J. S. C:ssv.all, II-~
..s 4
I D n 'V W ?. ' :s lh nj.
i
' u l"
j
~ Ulh a,,,
u.
.rp D ---
- ~ ~
.a.i R.;,' y yJ!
[%,
1m.w r....,..~..m...,+-,
, t. s _., - a,._.,.
'.N 't?.W6';.?g..-..-
. s... y - :. m -9.'3_':T2%.m.i.6G-~4E"*2 ^u o+
- ~ "' "'- M' h" "'#' "" ~
y 4
l d
I
WITI: $*MZ3
. p * "8ve%
g
. g.= y,. a. n.e.
= =. a.g g -.* y e
y,.g. r g 4
. "'r.
- s A(C:CN til
- ...=- t-g 799 accSCvt t.* ec.c w
.%. fff
, 1 m,
=.s es..v. w oes wn
.g y
4:ua /,.,...,
y as.
C
" cks: %. 'C-3CC/201 C
A
+ca.t o 3.-Q wa.ce ~.xy a,
.v. e.. at. a., c. o. a.a, s.eu.,s2. $%...C..
< 4 C. <
w:
- 3. C
,3 e..,,,a C...
. 3.,....
e y.....
. f. ; * $.,
e.i.s.t.*
.y y.
.sI.. *. p
- s. g =
3"d~..=.===.
O *.,
.s.=
w t.....s....
..e y...
%M........
T.
- J.4 44.
......)
. 2 J
,.wn.
b.t..a 3
.a. : 4., 3 4,
3...
t.33...s
%...t
.,,. a a
34 C.t t.3 e p. a.
3
..=.4
- ...a.
.u j
- y...
t
.....44..,,
- 5..b.
... a,
.t
.. 3 s..;......
...4..
4.
6
.s.....
2..
.u 3 1.
a.
t.
2.
4a
=.1.
.e.,
1.
.. a...a..
2 3...... t;. a.
3 4
- a..e.,
. a..
L.2. L....
t',.
- .. a..*.a..a.,3.
=.e3 A 4.,.;. 2
- 4 Sb. u............
.. 3....,...
.a
<. e. _2 3..
1 2.. n.,, 33 p..
,... e
.u.,
..., 3 ;.....
.....s s
. y.
..y....
,g eg 3. gg.
.g.
- 5. A k.
y y
t
.%. a.
a, A.,e...
4 3. t. a..
S.
.... a.3. :.SSSt ~.a..
s
.t
... i....
%.. L3 t
p..
e t t;". L..L.e
.;.. w a
,.e 4
a... 3
..4_.
as...3
.J 31..
,/
..a.1 t'.3-3'.,, ( zS 1.'.... ~.-... '.11.. -..-. 1 ) -.. ' '.'.. :1v.
=.S
- a
. 33.
a_..t S; _ A. a 3.,..
._a.a.
.a s A ;../.... s
.u
\\
CC.
a
.=
3 d t...* 24C*
a**45.
.. 3 4v*.3
. e s s a : 2.. 5:102$
- a eCO3..-..o...,:
saw
=.e *7 y g g t..........
._u
.s.. t.s g 3 S e._. u f... a.p.._..
._sa..g.
.no
. e.3 Su...
13 3.,'3.,
2...
4..
92..
2....
.s 3 e..-. '.,..
.w.
1334 a..
,. J.a.e.
4.
4.t.
.s. 23 2 C. s,.._. a
.4...
a s.
..u...
.3..~..
e
- a a.
5 e g
.t...,
. 4.t.%..
a.
y.
- 4..
2.... a.
1... 4 4.? *.. SS
.e
..t......
4..
. 5
- 1....
f
.. =.
- e.... '
C.;,.,
.J
.6 c S....s...
5...
3
._b1
.b
.. i$ 4
.= A *4... 384 a e,..e s e.
4.f.,
b.4 2.
...?
s o_n. t J.b :. 4..
%.g
%..y... 3. ~ t...
,1.s.
..... 3
.6..
..S yy
.. eg a.s.,...a 3
.a g33g
.?.:g. g,. ;.
.s
..;.......,.....4.'. %.t
.....t
&. C 3 e.. a.
....a.
...a.
a..
4...
y
.a a...d.
.. ? 4.4 ' *s. * /., f 2 *.F ** ".h.
h.
". 9.'ya q*. *..S M. *S..*.**.'.'.8'* ***
t a.g.4,.4 7.
.t.
e
/
.y...
y
. gg 3.**..s.
.t 3..**....
4.
.%4
- ..pe..:gg54
... s.t..... a.
4...-........
a....
e 1.'
.C 4.
t. --
t..t.a.....*
3...
3 -
.s...
. 2V.
3 e....s 3.
.4=
t....
a-l
'/
ef I
t f
7
/
r0 Q
~
Cs p& h O t 7 h
l i
o dd 6 Nlilib, I
oo I
e J.
?..
$.....=
9
. 4.g2._v, o,
f 4.
- c.
s.a c.1..
,.aze.,
.,s.
..s.
.s
->..>:.1..>....s.2.. e.<
z a..
a u
, 0.5u.
(
g escilla:icus 1: st ea;: 7:sssure, stea= ' lev, and s:r.2: g am ers :c:
p. a..y cu:le: :c=pera:ures cculd cccur unde: ce::ai: c=ndi:icns.
!= vas shes= da: de oscilla:1ces vere cf :he :7;e associa:ed-vi h the rela:ic= ships becuee: 'eedua: : h 2:1 A 'er p:=s-
'sure' d:cp and tube =es: ;; essure d:cy, whid are et'-N:ed c eduesd to levels of no censecue=cs (no 'esccac!c :s rese:::
~
svs ta.n) be. ac, sus = e== ci de tube ces: 1=:.: :ss.s 2:ce.. As a resul: ed de :ests, a: adjv.s:able crifica has bee: i stalled e des, c._e.- sa.- d -- c.3
'. e s. u -... e. -. -. s.c....v'. # e 3
.,,e
..s. a,....
..s-a.z2...2;. a. e..,a. 2.a a..
.... ag<..s _ e g ca s.
the ez:s "or eli= *=2:ica cf escil'.2:icns ii dey shculd dev-icy
.. a....,. ~.. < <. <,,
- . <.g.ue
...z. <., < r.. a.
e...;
.s
. e.. e.e....
s a.... y e-;
c.44 ce sa
.a.,,s.ucsa
.k e s.. _.._._.-., s.. 5 _-
.s
.s.
_w._
a;.a,
_e._. _e _,..
f..
r...
== a.' s o. c. =.
- a...'. e..'.'ec.c....'.=.'~-..~.=.'.=......ss.....
...w a.s n a..
a_..g....,.. -.. e. s.... <._..,.
.u.e
- 1. a.-
.n.
,,o/<:_. :.
.u
...s.
3
..s a,._,.
2.
e_._e
..,e
..a.,
....s : -
.._a_ e,,v _,.,.ac
.,c
.a.s..s,,,.,.e,.r.-.......
s.a.;.
..-f
.:sa........... e, e.
~....
,c.
, ss c:
.u.e ye.g.. e
..a,
.. s i m
e.:..._......,....,...u..,--
- s _s... a __ a.
s a c_a..a s
._u.. c.u a.-
e.
s'....'.
'_=~
.. n s s u: '_.- * '. *v = ' '-.-.'..-'.-*~.*..a..s.'.=~.~.s.
s
.e..;............. a.
s.e.e.
, cu e.....u.
. a. e
.....a.,. n;.a. a s st, as,. ss +.:
- ~ ~,. ~.--'-. '.. =,-.-ss -'..a-
.v. vc'.'.-.'...=.',.
~. u c..-.
.- c L2..
e s
.a 1 2._. ~., s.s
, s
...,e :._.;... z _...a
.u..<s
.,e
.a I.
a a
asa-7s,s,s a :2Caec as :.0c.,csure,..
seC14s e of ;;essurd * *--
av a.a a_.e a
..w,. s
.k.e sa_.2-.2
.u.e
..s u.a._...
._2,.,,.e.._..
e..
.. v.
f..
2...- u...V a.
.. eas c.. u. z...-, a...e.. ::.
1.,. e l
A_, s o c..a.
2...<.. u.e. V e.....
4.
g
'. a s..."...'. 2 -.....2'.e.,'.-.-
C'..s s
..:.2.. *-***).....,,'..'.c...
.-t.,..,.
2..y
..g
.u.1
- 1. :.u~
g f. u.g.
a... a g
.3
,t e..,)
2
. %. 4
.g a.... ~. _.as
_e.J. _a a.
7,* 8.%s.2 a_2_**7 3.,...
.u..
..: ea.a.
4...
3e e
..a..e>
- a...a. u.
s u.a.
3.-
6 l
...,;.. g _,,.... _ 3.......a
- _ s_y._ s v s.._... d.
%..a*xe.
..s _._.3 s..
u.1 J.
% e
,.V a.....,4 u
- a.. a c.u..)
as
?..
9 s.... *. ". a. a.
20 4.
_.J
.a a
... s c.a shu.:..
31..a..._a _-.... c. 4 a.
.s. a.a
... s. s. a... a.
a u*
ata-a....
a-
.s...,
.a.
._,2 a_ *. u...:
.cs._.4.y.
_.=c......
.g
..a.. k
- 2. e-"a 2 Ca., a.a a
- G a..
J. 7. 5::ss:::
3
.4:ur:73, *379 e.,.c..
...-... ~a s.. :. s,...
1-..
.-.. s. t s
...s.1...
.s;.<-. a a
.a
--...a.a....e
,.e..c-
., a_. s r,. a..-
.es_a.a s... -a_s.t
.a.....a.ez
- m: sys:s= := decar=i:s vers: casa da:=a *. :::di:1:=s.
~~.:e asc:::
2= be epera:ad ;er ia ~ech ' 21 5;eci'icati:.s *. h 2o :==a:
~
1:c= s sci: cue c' se: ries.
If da ;eak.:cv== '.:es:imes " s"'.r.
he 'es=:a cf he c=:s (-his has bee = d e :ssa a: 'a'-is -isss a),
e
'ac:::s a:s :c: ap;lisd :s c==sa:- stise17 :: 1::: ra1 as such as
-. q a:d
- c' a' :a.
2 5.
- 7. :1:surt 3 ias cib es a= avas: ca: =c:_-. si a: a I&*J f a c'.I' :f.::.i d
.nsul ai. a save.
_*.-A
~z_s..
sx.~.=.
'.'.'.'.' ~..'.,'..
c..,.'t e,...
. a 4.:...,-..s...a
.aa....a.s
- s. 1.a e
..,,a.,y,g a.
..u
...2.
s.. > m.. a.-
- z.. e s,..,,
- - --< :2 -
- 1:=s.
.f)
/s
\\.,8 A." *
- 5. C: as := '.i K44c.
..s.....
...s..
1s.
.a. s... s t
-.. /
e _.,.....,.s.
2*t
,1**
- =
- 1. C. L :p w
.e su..
l fM i l f '
'l b
.4, JN
- b j h,. jh I
dd e
N l
I i
4 e%
e b
1i '
c+
r+
CJ O
73O l
0
)
e+
W
-