ML19317D584
| ML19317D584 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Oconee, Mcguire, McGuire  |
| Issue date: | 10/01/1973 |
| From: | Jennifer Davis US ATOMIC ENERGY COMMISSION (AEC) |
| To: | Thies A DUKE POWER CO. |
| Shared Package | |
| ML19317D586 | List: |
| References | |
| NUDOCS 7912060826 | |
| Download: ML19317D584 (2) | |
Text
_
,r--m e w n - enw. - g v.u w - -.., :.
a ;~m im +...1u%gh%3L,.
.m ; *";,', n;Qff9
- fm y,, \\
. +, -, g:
g.1 Y
$ ;l~~~ Y ff.
.; y
,J,4 7
Duke Poser Company Docket No. 50-269 t
Atta: Mr. A. C. Thies hYfh* _,....fc/.#g-a.c
--:m.- : [t.
(
Sa=iar Vice Prestdaat f_ p t k'?h l-WU$St y: R }. : ' '
5 '~.$$
f
. 422 seeth Chersh Street s' ' ' ' ',
J
_(:
X % u s Gh?$&6/M, 2.T MM 9 i
Charlotte, Merth Carolina 28201'
~-
l
~
,c
~
-+
1 2
i This refers to year letter dated May ~25, 1973, 'te Mr. M. C. M===1=y, Director,ReglemII,'DirectorateofRegulatoryOperatises,andtothe(
l 1etter dated July 31, 1973, from !!r William I.. Porter in which Duke ' '
{
Poder Compeay regnested that certain informatica e==emined in.Regulatoryi ' ~
~
operations Inspection Report No. 50-269/73-4 be withheld frea publief '
t
[
disclosure en the basis that such informariam is cessidered proprietary. '
~
i on the basis of eer review of your request we de not agree that the.
informaties claimed to be proprietary is, is fact, proprietary. With l
respect to the predicted values of borou concentrattees and remeter l
coolant system flows',~we' note that these itsee are already a matter of public record. The Final Safety Analysis Report submitted to the Connaission by the Duke Peeer Company is available in the Public Document i
Roem. h understand that the boros concentratiene reported'tm Report l
No. 50-269/73-4 may be in error.
If yee desire to correct the record 9
in this matter, you may submit the appropriate informatica.-
i
[
With respect to measured values cf reactor ecolant flow, we note that similar informattom for Ocesse Euclear' Station Unit 1 was submitted to j
l the Commission with your letter dated A" gest 23, 1973, and has been placed in the Public Da*= ant Room.
W behave that the resulta of testa performed to eenfixa predicted operating parameters camatitute informaties that ehem14 be diselesed ander the Cremissica's policy to achieve an effective balance between legitimate concerne for protection of competitive positions and the l
right of the public to be fully apprised ok the bases for and effects.
of licensing actions.
4912060J M l
j
'*'~,Q
(
s
'_~#
O F FICE >,,, _ _ _
p
...y--
g.m m}.tg g,~m. ag. s[
SUMMAMED-
~-_
.m,
.c L
n ww g
om.. -.
e_---
r ye swuu
-y---,
7
m~.z~n,. - ::.;
Mrim,m,,,
~.w n, n.n.e.m -,y f
c o' r
-b L
Ts M s
f
!,,,.,., "?.
s i
A. c. Yhtee - 7 1. ' 2:5 f-2+P m.wuw:we6w-mm.
r m2 w
W @ % g &,r3 BW.
v.,A v "" g z 2. G C
. 6,,
c.
- m-
';* vD x,,; y} f T"*T" y,47,'4f y,.x
~ 'k d.
s
_.-X.,,
,,y,
Cassidering the above, we believe that the.justificaties fez v42"*-
_' j from publie di=ala==ee the inforestiam identified by you im Report N
Ee. 50-269/73-4 has met been supplied. Im view of this situaties, we D-?
,I ples to plees the s.,J E in the Comunission's Public Document Room unless,
[
within 30 days of the date of this letter, you provida as with justification i
for withholding the taformattee from publie diaeleeure.
}
I In the event you seek to further justify your claim that eartain informe-.
l tism is this repe tis proprietary sed properly esbject te vi nhalding,( L g
~
[
seek justifiaa**am ehem1d take inte asement these mattere ubiek"ers y y yy,af.
identified in the at*=*h===*
to this.1seter :; f ~ 'M T p$1 n : 3. '.h. :-Q ie
-t.,.
..e.
.f
-u l Simmaraly,--
.. - ~
~
+ :
t e.3, l
y
, John C hvia, Deputy Director for Fieli operattarm
~
-,'Directorata of Regulatory Operations r
Enclosure:
condiciana for Acaerding Proprietary Protecties.
c.
f
~
sa:
1 Mr. William L. Porter Duke Power Company l
s 422 South Church Street l
i Charlotte,, Norther Caroline 28201 -
3
+
Mr. Troy B. Conner, Jr.
Conner & Knotts 1747 Pennsylvania Ave., H. W.
l Suite 1050 Washington, D. C.
20006 i-bec:
~
[
D. F. Knu th, RO -
-R. H. Engelken, RO:V l' RO Files B. H. Grier, RO DR Cental Files l
R. C. DeYoung, L
{
A. Schwencer, L DR Reading' File l
D. J. Skovholt, L PDR
))g J. P. O'Reilly, RO:I Local PDR i
[U N. C. Moseley, RO:II TIC
{Q D,
i P
,)
/'
J. G. Keppler, RO:III i
[
R. W. Smith. RO:IV i'
f
)
I..\\
Y t
h omcr> [RO F,S_&_EB,,,,,,,y:
,h.1 C OGC RO:DDF0 l
Ellis:das-g
, T _M y.
sunu mr> _RC_P,aulu Inhurcr Tmr"* M rg;d,C_Dayip
..a_,
l i
,.,b e
,.y,
+:'
y%{'
4.L TE> __g]}73 __ __ y ['s7] ~~W __}((_ *, l 4 'g 4 ?" p 3-groreAEense fwor'yt5r sten >gema ***="* ***-* *=r+%. r '_.. i_L..~,. a~.. T' '"7'- ', ' ^ ^ ' ' - ^ ^ l j [, a ? A R,,,u%L$uMJYa,,i ~ ^- l- - I - 4 S~- NA".&ll= ' " = ' L-Xx,,,
) g-._ 9 x m c #,.:9 ;-7 w ; #.,, e + 7. c # C
- QW. A
.,jj:Q 2p@yi~ Q. , 1 - E==di**m== Specified by 14 - M Board Q '.E n - order ef. January-8, 1973,As Requisite x *gF;wiM - G sor W 4=f Proprietary Protecties To-A h====t 1. The document has been classified as proprietary by the Company-in accordance with normal Company procedures with respect to such classification. 2. The document coment== information of a proprietary nature which is customarily held in confidance by the Company and not customarily made av=11=hle to the public. 3. Where such he or the infarmation comemined therein has beam mada aseilable to the United States Atomic Energy cm-immiam, or others, it has been given as a eenfidential dimela==ve with a request by the Company I that such informattom not be disclosed or divulged to others. r 4. The dae = ant contains information either vital to a competitive advantage which the Company may have or information which is potentially helpful to competitors of the company affecting the internats of the Company, its customers, and suppliers. 8 5. I In determining whether a document is to be classified as proprietary, the following procedure has been used by the Company asserting such [ c1=i=: (a) an initial determination as to whether a document or report should be classified as proprietary has been made by the author of the report as the person most knowledgeable with respect to the content of said report, the nature of the sensitivity of information contained therein, the state of the art and knowledge in the industry with respect to the subject matter of said report, and the usefulness of the information contained in the report with respect to assisting competitors or giving the Company a competitive advantage relating thereto and (b) thereafter, if a pra14=f==ey determination has been made to classify the report as proprietary, that determination has been reviewed by the==nagement level supervisors of the originator of the report and if such determination was approved upon review, the report was classified as proprietary. 6. In determining whether information is propriatary, the follwing criteria and standards were utilized by the Company. Information is proprietary if any one of the following are met: i It rev=mla the disting=i=hi=f aspects of a process (or a component, s. ) structure, tool, method, etc.) whose exclusive use by the Company constitutes a competitive-economic advantage over other companies. l l i omet> .________________.4._____:---- SURNAMED l I DA M Form AEC418 (Rev.SS3) AECM 0240 ft u.s aowasmasaer caumins oce,ca. wie._see-asa . - ~ a _ - .._. -.,.~ ..-. - ~ ~ ~ _ ..n+... n. --w. 4 ( ~.._ ~ ~ 7912060 b /
Li. N }2&M*Cy-%p',',y;'x. 4
- n..,:,, W y.;-: v -
4g:pp..af e,,,,,.,ga > v%y'&yy; 2yp,-+ n,,n.
- e.m 7f a y..
3- ; ; O. 7. 3 7,..~ ~, ' g3, ~ gd e 7 h d-qKp?cyffg 4
- y-s e y,
.L. .g u,% r , N._.; A q , '..s y V.".y, - - 4,1 ,-4. ww,,
- b., It consists of' supporting data, <=-1=M==
test data, relative ter ? M'f-; a procese (or sumponent, structure, toel, method,.etc.) the applicaties - of which data secures a compeettive economic advantage, e.g., by~ 2' opti=tantion er improved andatability. Its use by a competitor W.ld reduce his expenditure or resources c. or improve his competitive positica in the design, mammfacture, shipment, installation, assersace of q=m14ty, or tiennaing a similar product. d. It reveals east er pries information, producties capacities, budget .x levels, er esmercial strategies of-the Company, its eastemere erj esppliare, disk when used by the com constitutaa a competitive g ecomende advantage ever othme cer;sataa. f It reveals aspects of past, present, or futura Company-or customer-l e. j funded development plans and programs of potential commercial value to q the Company. f. It couraine potestable laventions for which patent protection any be desirable.- l 7. In order for a document to be accorded proprietary protectice, the owner of the information contained therein must certify that the dos ment meets l the tests set forth above. In addition, each docume 4t aball have been I reviewed by the Regulatory Staff and will be accorded proprietary protectica t } only upon the certifiention by the Staff that based upco its review, i the document appears to be one which properly should be classified as a propr1stary document pursenat to the provisions of 10 CFR 2.790. l i I t i l I I s. ( k'nt d i k omcE> = - - - - - - - i SURNAMED _-_z ~ i DATED = d -~J . ' t-Form AEC 318 (Rev. S53) AECM 0240 -- 1.T u.a. eavaamma%, enemimo omcuz ter ee. ass'. -; N~ ..V-Gm"r,* . - w.w w m.w e..,.w':.* M 6G. h 4w..AA.m. se:s.,u-A.W h.-...'-eenI S h eadi M t d' w.t%.. ._.s.e
17 ~ r [/ o c-V f'" ' %,, UNITED STATES 7/ ' 'lyg ATOMIC ENERGY COMMISSION } p s 3e< DIRECTORATE OF REGULATORY OPERATICUS i j mecios n - suire ets g (/ gsr.rd o' p 230 peacarare siacer. Nearawest y,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, At t.4 sr 4, cconcia acaos August 22, 1973 H. D.' Thornburg, Chief, Field Support and Enforcement Branch Directorate of Regulatory perations, Headquarters DUKE POWER CCMPA'TY (CCONEE 1), LICENSE NO. DPR-38, DOCKET NO. 50-269 - LICENSEE'S REQUEST FOR DELETION OF PROPRIETARY INFORMATION, REPORT NO. 50-269/73 h Enclosed for your information la a memorandum to files documenting a telephone contersation amcng R. F. Warnick, Region II, Paul Barton, K. S. Canady and J. E. Smith, Duke Power Ccmpany, and R. Straub, Babcock and Wilcox Company. Additional information on this subject is contained in =y memorand's to you dated June h, 1973 I f / de-C. E. Murphy, RO:II:CEM Facilities Test and Startup Branch
Enclosure:
l Memo to Files dtd 6/5/73 cc w/ encl: (RQ;HQ Files DR Central Files l l e TRANSMITTED BY FACSIMILE 2:20 p.m. (je) 8-22-73 7912060 t i}}