ML19253B728

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Ack Receipt of Informing NRC of Position Re Penalty Imposed for Violation Noted in Insp Rept 50-289/74-30.Mitigates Amount of Penalty
ML19253B728
Person / Time
Site: Crane Constellation icon.png
Issue date: 11/20/1974
From: Knuth D
US ATOMIC ENERGY COMMISSION (AEC)
To: Creitz W
METROPOLITAN EDISON CO.
Shared Package
ML19253B717 List:
References
NUDOCS 7910180715
Download: ML19253B728 (3)
v • d • e


Text

A 4. p m* &r my ph L Y. &rm m w$W.n u. NE.Mf,m:

h?wg f*

w e

~, n-,

, m. a.Y.c ?&ww., vl ? ? 5$,

W i

.f

- g?

d 5

~

.n g d $.

f.

7~ng o w.,4

. M M.m>14.u,:w m m m x@.+hv.< m.;e

,q... r va

+

+ w@. w.

M..q.

,ey,J, r*s. #..

.m. w. ya'n' a:. :. 6..

a.

. s We..

c

  1. '* W A'.V,r.C '.+ e", :.i. Ps qyag,J.f 4 WC..1,c,:www;m;.w, mpg.M.u.q
4. up..w -

r.f c v y

f;.. u.w,v A.4Qw.Mp... mJp<;~.

am

r.. -..

p g.~. A.p&m.,.w.e,p.. - a y

w yu m yp J

., w w 3 ~p a
n.y & m..y. p.

..s.n.w.

.qz.g i u.

.sp n1s.y.

..e

  • W sp,g< w ~ ~n u..

r o %,.1,.,

.s y ; s.n %.' w,;V e'.i %, w,N V.

  • n.'".
  • gL V~:.ef.

xV.%.t m..i.-v;n.th m. ~%my..,...w.

.... 9 w: t - hv *s

.+

-- m.

4,.,.y. 7

<.4. s. ; m A,-

}.

e g

.v -a

. e#. w.

m o.

n:.,w.) + NOV.2,0

. x. v&.m.mge n._%..; Ps:.c r.w.

u...

- ;6n.a,,z e

?.

.v

,,~.. 6'n, ~ m.~s.s..

s+

e n.ye e,.m > v.o.,

.r.1

,',f.,^*

q'%) h h_.,

e.

e

.zw

- - m ;o'O*..p, 'f ".f"Q, ,..

. c

_3

~ 'l

r. -

c r

f' 3,

y!

g l

...' t ;,

c

,. x'a-

- y

.; y,, y,p e

..;. ~{:

t y

- y l:

~

y y,,. m. : -

,.s x

.~,.,.uaV,.,...

w.,.:. x.>.

s w.

+

.v.

  • ---C s.

u,,:..{-

c, g.

1

....w;-

  • $w- * ' 2 w. 4 we.

==

\\

J

  • ar cs,:

.s.s.

L, s

e

-. ~

p..

~

1 7 i,....&.

., a,,.,

,.j..

., W.. s

, 4 (i 7..

4 T (,-M..

W..% c..G. uM7.'. cg5 ',KQUgh 4 g 9 g x

1-

.... g.1 29'

'S, x -. %, 4 ^

S:

c 1.- - Wy..".

..u

. g:

.,gw m

,3..

ud4=an company,i.

If, z.

{O c.3.-hMetropolitan n

k

?. n.d '.ATTNr. Mr.k Walter E lCraitzI;e. m- - Me.w w.~m.. e r.*. Y.yy'M.g'e,.v..

Mt MW

-, : c.M,m. e -

A gg7g<;$N&.,,cO. Md.N 1 T., Cs z

n,,

@.,~>PreefAent u.'>'f 4-g@T M

'.; ?, ~.~,.t a' r.

.o".

e.w<.<7,f,.,.M*, p

. p q5 J M-t,'x > -. '7 'y :

' 2. '.

pg@:u..af g[Pennsylvanf a,",19603

.y. p..?N 4,g.. c._',,

e- ' - -

  • PD. q m,'. '

d,e V....r, '

.s,.

yJ

.+

e g.

y; s

P.MW 12,KPM0. Bear 542 x/. W-

. ' l.4M..n.

4 nwa

~

s y u u M p y m. m, y x.,.4 &. g e, M nae.p,M,.

, u. s..- n gw j~

m. m. y., p g. ~. m. g a /. g.,a. m. @.n$ '. h +. w w. m,, a w. m s,,a :rws m m..

.%u w

g.

x

  • ~

I I.

AM% kN *.

'i 9 '$w:. R f W"^ %n'.

J.i.- ' N,

  • 2:.'.W.., Taman F. m, NT."m. @Q;..,

'M?,i.W.,.L:@. n v.w..fxy'&...k*'%e.

s. 'p.- 'M's O ' l.

N, m. W, ;', # t,..

N w.-

74 p @. p&.,.. %m.,-. w.s q;~-

.m~&s y.,u

.s

- ^m-

.c

~

- :s s w

s w

n c

c w w, n.:

m.

w p.

y cThis will arknaviedge receipt of your letter of October 16,.1974,. hat ;

X t

h.T. NN provided your response to our letter ef. September.' DOM enclosed 23, 1974 and the w'.

fy:# T{gtbe.5eptember' 23~,g m, Jetice.of Proposed Imposition of mil Nmhy32, i

%g@Mt'sestablished thg'amogat ef penalty at;Four TN=====d Do11ses]$4 h!. Q a' result.?of n recent faspectihn' f 3lddafThree,Milir_ Island DaitbMWg, findings r=T=+4==

$EWJMAMNipMMy@'

& M M@.The'.resycase af ne*=her M 1974 foutlined you j

%dFthe proposediinposition of civil penaltyfand provided information ece ;Q p.,@Near, ninf t.h. s.'. violation!f..o.und,during ~eur. recent inspection.: ;With regardi @f,,o ;

M4

~

w.

n

~

r,badtte yourJoestfaae domestning whethei th...a. violation warranted a civil; Q.v Qhp deaalty.Att.ss the9aWasion's)osition'that.a licensea's f=41nte to, i' 9M N Wmeet critical. security ltequirementsfof:10 CFR Part.73'and.its implementing 7 i N$**durftfplaifm?.the;respectims? set lferth in 'the, Betice of J1elationMN[p.i'd 37 EQ6A subMW=117 increases;theirialCof3ndustrial:aabotage, 'and may adversely CE

$j.h,JMaffect',de'public besiths safety-[kinteresttFailure to, control;p.$lN.N.:@

J#cNW:see.mes:t. o,.:tha' plant faeM4ty,is...a,, serious 'via1=t4aa :and. is ea=====-steV F. mi a

4 4

4.,ey.

d yl.M.with the emnetion.%.Howeverd dee'. te the======1 circumstances of (1) a W D W ' 8 delivery, truck. protruding EL @ a~ security gate while.being~ unloaded

%Wf snNinh peuvented elasiasithm gatatfor 'a(short perie@and:(2Lthe very i

'."7

~

N @ g. q @lf

@j1imitefaesee's throdaW the 'seta' whMaltheitrock'was' there/ the~civilii@

3

$D@s D@ penalty:Js"miti.=*=2 Yran Pour Thomasad 'De f-cM Five amadaed.Dollarm b3,500)M t

XM M M D*S$/ 1?M

  • e K' e %%.-M;db 'and we' have wi father questions maing this metter at this

'Cenera11y4 the~ correctivesttan which.w prop'se appears to'be'.yys+1ste, o

- st...'?

. k;.% p p p.4,.%;

3

.,W y m:

W.;

-o

- % *L3% m pgL. K r> % y.g.nw.m. % ;c.4.;- p@.r,n>Qy m.?>;M.~,.g ;&

.y.

e

%. c M5;@-Q@g,WW&{Mffe'4DW@%$$$; 7 g.~ :f2'M.& S.[Y$fN. M M C.', ?p F ' $.. - m%.# t v Q

.-Q%$

i M-b dN. i e.. o J ~W~L.&w!p@p$i&.w%wA%,,0 &~&WdC,A,:Y%g rQ.. - Eh[. pR.y W,m e.

n;W. _.?*y Q +A n&% h:w.an.~ n.4A $f% g -Q _).g,. Q _y!: %. p N ',p:p e

.w. y. -

4 va

. g+YA dr_'-~ tg~.;n...% '*. y ': A %. f.y.,2ff q.V A

4

-y wm..

_ i,c A

W.

Q.. _, ;.$,

v n

'.n a J n r

14M %

W ',9 *, v.g#M. 4 V ~,w w Tl.Ji @ %.~-.,ii 5

b ~.x. M@.V* - Q

  • 5 Q--n

. P.%.

% = W.;h.; Cs,,, N @t,T,p f,M i e 6 4 ~

  • cQQ e

A4' V

yggg,

-3 p

-w--.--

nAde.s, n

((( _ h iff ^*4 7d tM f-h-37.4 ^ v' #. '

2 c he ' Teh

.w

'w* *.ps w'*%b'~ $ fy 9." s. 'kY.D, + 9 :? wum.

..bl3 O'.. M,1, 2

4 n.

e--

n o-b

m. #

'~ -

.-.-.' W.

- SU RNA A4 $

9 i*

^

s

.g P

(s,* *

s. 4 4'

4 q

qM[.

g

.,7,.y g> '.,, D. ATS

, 's, (, w

. k e

  • 7 g

s re *.s

~~ s

  • m r a _ _.

b Y

I'9 IM I"'NM9 M' f,

[*

.O Y

L m.s -__ c.,je - w A g Jc' Pen,,sf.2 u w

%amm. hyww# M% _ %%u x

M&Mk.gm.,....Qc. A b "..,

. ?

q?" g4.c.-4: M. A.

y.r<b. 9W,,e m

.a

..., m :,:

-v.

, wc k T:.-[y,k h/n M;.~M %y$ w ~% v:k.s @

uq.;h W,D M M..4w M 4 W",w;M. W., &,.vig.4:

c.....

Y dw.&'h M M"69 N.Vm.5 &s

.m tW "i

->.3

.i A

P W c

=4-

'-1 0.7 -

s3 C$

dMfkdO MNI. n b ~.$.h, CNN<

t-4np yu

-a M

Nk;-[ '.'

f6Mh,Q8.dYTN $5NM.M g q% y M #.Ty@ @DTrNN.W"Ma$hD N M hEJMMh.N.NA',

WS.4: Wp;J H am W hij.h,-

k Mp 3$33Vg+Y

(( P** v p % m ; w 9. m :r %.t. g m. x %,;;, p% ;. 3 OV.,2G..h.. :a.pe.:w h

M n h

.p E %.. kWgg.n.

gh k' ;.Gy,s n~.x)t;'h D #ch.;w.e w y.YdbN< g k,v

s. q -

,.: m; $ $ y.1S. W ^r W.m.

t s 4p w wMetropati*==' Edison Campany

Q
6 7 m*,,., y Dg#.. :

.c.

-s

,,y p l

i

... *(

S j

4 o

NQ d~ N.N 9 - Q O 7 9 %.r.[. $.:.,['.3..

. - r;

m

~.

n.

v

,d, yw; w % M;S ff. Tj,s.

ak.

.:w.w.c;P.m;n.m...n:@m~g.wm.-y::,,, m. & v:j:

c

., M c..;_w n.

u e,w v

y -.:qs 4ym LWy w.

.p;,

. sun g n.u p~ g, w:

~

.:. y W :; m, y 2 A%, y',' 7 Af ter careful ea==,4 Aeration of;your; :.. m. W.

m

< x'8 t.b:m. - '

t* w.a

c?,. ~~,

e a

~>:~-n.

.1 4

,.W c

~*

.W

,W

"; r n v-response and in consideration of tha"

.'^

l

.g 'p@% I 7mstters 41scussed above. we have ecacinded that the violation did occur.

V m view of the reasons and explanations set forth in your response as '. .'

%y@yjg/diseaseed in this letter, the proposed penalty.i g7 above. Accordinglyi we hereby serve the emc.losed Order on Metropolitan J a' civil pena 1ty fa the amount'of Three Thousand

-i M. g;fX Idison Company 4--a-i==

hOM5dNhN%g@D($3.500)r RJ

Five Eundred Douars'.
c. e p.:

e' m

qwep4m g g w i 2F w s m e s' M NhE$$

b NNhh MD

~bs y bh,. m s

weM p.pRw$eI-M%wh.t~ ice m.

i e, g. o _ e ao

$gw%nQ.8w~gM@MM*M[%.k QiE wg.m_e 4,m m"b M

~

g w

M~MT Q

  1. M M~.MMM Od MiM@

rig wgmm:w@u$s.bv4w%ydsyMgam Id.r. xn.th M

M dMQ 8M3 edQ nsw j ho.Wwrpf nes.1 story operations o,;.,r

$w$m h.N oeure#g @yh y ?$w w@g a MidfP y4 gE piqMiWg;Mg3

., u n n.:s c f !N k WN ? & f % k k S h x $ m w &w m n. h ; m y ord.k 1.e 1.s civ113 extmym fh W

h 9 @W M g (M S p# 8 % M 8

&# #$ MM$

$Ed.

Wi W

wees Ebmemmew memy s e w n ep m m s. m n M S > M@ a& q. ~fi,% s)a@

WGMR4 W6f GU 141!wwwwww RWMn kw@!ht ng m

wm

. ya:,;w%.me.gmmMy fly.n.c me@s+;pupW:.mpe.~,.s:%p yy -lt zem. +

w.m.m,um - <

m.w

.nt

' K s-7 %;kW ff4 4 ' ~,m%w& 3 OWl

h. M L:;

?. M,&*,

u a

n a

4 x

w%

m, M,u% M u k,Ny M E N! M M $ M D

N R $ w w w w w& w w w w se%K m

S C-r % ~&- M g wMewMMr Q y M R p p. M M + &w %w m v; n.

k $ &n y.%, N;9" M W ' %+$ g$ g& std %

r;t+ %:Ampitw&M.f y & $p&&k Q&QyQ1;W

'n.. Of Q

..f i G di

>lNkQ::

V hfb2M D

$di.

.p 9 :

4p

.a wmy v

g~D Y?b ibY$$

l}Y.

mw b

Y

$3 ih$

y

.s.

hg l*'h

%&f

.f D ~

r Q

_ ' fl.4 ('yhW, _,..,

f.*k '

j

?? ffff, #)nn f y{ms'orSrnMg;'7Q

.g;_ N%' *fCVlA'Vj,

W*

%E.

KRE%4M'irytcrs,

.s.

RQ 69 no evc3vn

$ufu $ k N

,c.NMMN~kINMN5h

" k h-I)FN lft w =

_31Mi$/7Wlie 64 51/7fG74WLT/74;j Ar *-g II/ { '

S h M $dye

. -. ~ _..

~ c fsj* 3-;jg n.-

-- -=

U L Q g",4 & n <s.- W - & b :8 N'-N.'42s g._

^

G

'h. Chu-:: n R..--T a g:._

s

W / % n.'. g @y %.?yf:Q,').[ & & % W & % N $ [: &s.c. [ & & jp:f..h h m b;..y,. &

h ff 7[',:m'.&j%s' O$$ '

b Wc M b M W # N ici%$y n?e@ w% n.'g 9 m & w~ w?.

+;ewmHA'q.a.y 4 3,J.$P d

W.M-

k. T ;j-

. m & a. m;ma-q.n@4 A W :K M$o@G c

.w w y

.2.4 u m.w.

4:.www w - b. W. m w M 4. M R.h -u.:AN%vM W

nwh Y'

W :@~ w&.,.n:g.w%qv n%s q

. g. x m 7.; s : W~

5cf c

$? h** trope 11tas Edison lpl'U,m.*e m.

g

~1 ~~ Q UR.

~

ghd w pqg L7 Qpg g.p:.

s s I!

4$Me Capeuy y?je

.9 34MQg J MMQ '

l$r h k $ k r $ w$p jgf4 M}

Wlff; M;w< n. m s g u p 5@0EE R h h!$5ege 7 LL***** 505 M

% p^

\\

wmy m

e :e w m.

.mse%x +p. v..:.w.y.,: n.,

w m# -

v.t. m. m,.,e.

w.

..~

~ z..: u

r

~

.. :. / e# g w

,.n...,.m.a.. y%

y D g' 4 f'

.~.c

^g*

.; D trihit 0 3 N M (3k'g"..% -.;

  • ,a.

M-,=.,.,

g T

  • A'4{

? -.Q]f L. K. smhins, DE ?? %y? }.'7 QQ.f y'y.2: - % [. : y X[. ~ )

^

..g.2' j,.J. M

c

~

'M...

[.

').

~

- WW L. V. Gossisk, ADR '. r $ -MY: Ab 9;

F b.Js.G.; Davis, DD7o,10.' ',,*[QY.y::[:.. % # i M[h(,

E:.Y.

D. F. Knuth, DRO o

%2. YM].

fi 9%Q?2 (fD[$ N,k.

'[

^T) 020 Regions I,~II; III, IV, Y &g&..i[Ed6 Q$M4 l Q'a'C +

'c

'f ~

M, [ Q C.(W. r W =an,AD, REHF 20 N.#. Qp.,.,fd'W

@m e,.14 'I.iCobb',~A/bf ROJQ)M%@

/% B M k M

.~M.

Criar, AD,'.C0110:' Sc l @fY, Q p n M'M Wy@ldM M f M lM MD@N N.D M2@hr5

. L.;

fM5%N9 r nir.eter..comino m y g w re ci 6

,:no,nr:L g

w

&@@@me.Cf DeYoung,7 DM LMR' N@MR.' r:w r.,ertuaus,No@ltL j.jk MihS N

A e

mg r! m?ce11er7AD, on:L@e aw@ME@@g@@gw t

M M

MgMKEL eMGMW M w 3 v.!a. suovheit.-AD, m o in.

LN schroederg DD.- T1:LT WWj?MMWW@m@9 '.M sF4gd@4t OSSMA}r.

MW YN DMWQN

.Q Q N

$gg:yy.m'y MurrayfiChiaf, REC OGC3Q Ayj@ @& M % N Qw

.rraleyfus,Acas0)W w g g ' r r e a,rADe rl as(cr %g ; g@@i Q g @

gj.i C

.a.sr, chi.r,taxias pgg pujm y.

ar m eda c tras rn.mwagasi vggggy.

u e m ru g'rilas j d N h.Nf h p ; w'~ Y ' m# (( e p a t e nkfg %

s if M Readin Yh h

m s %)f h

%ww

+

[ Ff M RO' Reading'hi as D h p$ w eh khhm ywDDrosno n u.s ru am+nMy[%ggh.7,,y$.gA.

h h

Q pay.

.m i; b F8E N.n. w h bv p.1. Fe % a. m. s w ~e x,s. w..m. M. y p u SDC',.

N b

ikz w 2iw in v

~4[,m~; M' '.j h. n)N1YY Nh 4

.n w:

a...

n n

[&gN f ya u u

w,w,ysIcMih[b(W%%.i.m@M'I rg~ m' W &

' N./ b.-

ax n WpuXr; x1ue rsxnimrogno@wega i

&NA M

  1. Y
  • di '# OkQQQ,1NN.,

N Of

'5 lf 9es%e%,s -

. m i,r 71,.

w m a.4.n u m c Dwoimo s4 hdbW4WdMMMMW

~

b@kMk= nim %.N.Y%9 6.e m;rhew.cu.e...,.

w:

. ~ c m.cor Mk i@$7kNdhl$$Nhb5hM h d e$

e$, M@5

$i!

h $ $ g a! M M9 M F $

N M$

hl w% %w u @m % g M w%m $ y% m q hW mm p

M4 dW 4s MME F

x a wM=7: n m e+5M &.gp?p:a, w&p'y. w%,;;+m,u. w% w y

e

P %m m
m w:p a + 2gwmvx.+.: w

%w yp g

.a.msm nr yp.< n,1; M. e *,:.e T ~.-

  • s%. 3.,..

Q7 p

s

., yp wp,p;w &yw 2 rc f

e Y

'u g

5 $.~Y n.,h*,

(. ' lh35, i.,

b fe

l., '.

?

m..r. w:w..g w mn.a, am

-. n.,.c y: x,w:.:> m,, ~.~. Y... m ~

b (b 5 A $ N $ k h M N $ M @f. m... m. x SM i

. m.

n

,Yh.h,;.~. qg

.,.p,, a. u;l,-Qfh-.'~?? b-s

.k w

-fDY Qh$h2 Y $ e,h h&?I' l k.5

?

\\

W y+bmen w;wM. p i g n m-sw w

% n. ~.J.awww cW GRl,.y'h&

, k n ',%

tw v weyWg

-..n- -

kx i

B&mq$sM(

m-.

y m$ $ 3 o H %NNEr? ? ?n, M W N '

1x%:

4i%.

- ~..

?:NnUNk NW.' v n

u 8.

k

... w.

k'4

=

s U.asMNd 7 #*' NN[ ~

-[

[

^*

A e w,

- w- ~ ~ M G L u m w '

.,-r,.

w,

I ; ' '-- ~ --' --

"'~^~#

g'414.* +mmi

-n

__y.

ww.,, g.v a. 3 144b J64 a,

.

Retrieved from "https://kanterella.com/w/index.php?title=ML19253B728&oldid=4884010"