ML110691284

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
E-mail from J. Higgins, BNL to D. Frumkin, NRR on Support for Manual Action Exemption Reviews
ML110691284
Person / Time
Site: Oyster Creek
Issue date: 05/19/2009
From: Higgins J
Brookhaven National Lab (BNL)
To: Daniel Frumkin
NRC/NRR/DRA/AFPB
References
FOIA/PA-2011-0069, Job Code Y6529, 60-07-358, Job Code N6526
Download: ML110691284 (6)


Text

From:

To:

Cc:

Subject:

Date:

Attachments:

Hins. lames C I n Sullivan. Kenneth Support for Manual Action Exemption Reviews Tuesday, May 19, 2009 9:35:53 AM N6526 - 173 with umencv statement. df Y6529 - 173 with uroencv statement.odf Hi Dan: Attached are 2 examples of urgency statements attached to NRC Form 173s that we received for work from NRC. You'll see the urgency box checked on the left side of the 173 form and also the last page has s separate urgency form. This allows us to start work and puts us on a 30 day clock to submit the proposal, cost estimate and our 189 form. Hope this helps.

Jim Higgins 631-344-2432 From: Daniel Frumkin [1] g\\ oa Sent: Monday, May 18, 2009 3:13 PM To: Sullivan, Kenneth Cc: Paul Lain; Margaret Stambaugh

Subject:

Support for Manual Action Exemption Reviews

Ken, It is good to hear that you are available to help with some of our reviews. Attached is a spreadsheet of the accession numbers of the reviews. The first couple have been completed.

Any insights as to which plants you may be most familiar with would be helpful in our parsing the list of plants.

We hope to get the task order out early June, but these things can't be estimated with precision. Some of the plants have two separate submittals due to preapprovals.

Dan Manual Actions Exemptions Based on Submittals Received by 3/6/2009 Exemption based on Approved Estimated Number DAe of Acton Acceptance Review Date/Accession NoQ PlantrAC Peach Bottom, NRC RAI date/Accession N2 11/21/2008, (ML083150431) 12/23/2008, (ML083400162)

MD7029 and 10/5/2007, MD7030 Yes (ML072820129) 2/4/2008, TMI, MD8081 Yes (ML080350369) 1/27/2008, Browns Ferry Yes/No (ML090330173)

Pilgrim, 3/6/2009, ME0831 Yes (ML090690690) 3/3/2009, TMI, ME0771 No (ML090630134) 22 RAI Response 5/1/2008 (ML081220873),

12/11/2008, (ML083470170) 1/28/2009, (ML090280577)

Request for Withdrawl 3/412009, (ML090650479)

Exemption Issued Date/Accession N2 1/30/2009, (ML090150419) 3/31/2009, (ML090830708)

Acceptance of withdrawl 3/6/2009, (ML090650605)

Oyster Creek, ME0756 Oyster Creek ME0780 Indian Point 2, ME0798 Indian Point 3, ME0799 3/3/2009, Yes (ML090630132) 3/4/2009, No (ML090640225) 3/612009, No (ML090770151) 3/6/2009, Yes/No (ML090760993) 180 Phil working on 4

acc review 10 20 18 22 34 Non-Accept Letter 3120/2009, FitzPatrick, 2/18/2009,

ME0727 No (ML090570050) 1 ML090770058 Wolf Creek, 3/4/2009, ME0797 Amendment (ML090771269)

.15 Peach Bottom, 3/6/2009, ME0855 No (ML090680141) 31 South Texas

Project, 3/3/2009, ME0824 Amendment (ML090680781) 2 Daniel M. Frumkin

<Daniel.Frumkin@nrc.gov>

Team Leader - Fire Protection Branch U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission MS/0-I0C15 Washington, DC 20555-0001 PHONE 301-415-2280

.1 SEP-06-2007 19:13 P. 03 NRC FORM 173 #60-07-358#

U.S. NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION ORDER NUM13.R (6-1998) 60007-358 NRCMD 11.7 60-07-358 STANDARD ORDER FOR DOE WORK (SOEW)

SEP 0 6 2007 T his agreement is entered Into pursuant to the authority of the Energy Reorganization Act Of 1974, as amended* (42 U.S.C. 5801 et seq.). This work will be perfrmrred in accordance with NRC Management Directive 11.7. The parties agree that CICA does not apply to this transaction. To the best of our knowledge, tie work requested will not place DOE and its contractor In direct competition with the domestic private sector, ISSUED TO:

(DOE OQfice)

Mr. Michael D. Holland, Site Manager U. S. Department of Energy P.O. Box 5000 Upton, NY 11973-5000 Attn: Robert Gordon ISSUED bY:

(NRC Offica)

Farouk Eltawila, Director, Div of Risk Assessment & Special Projects Office of Nuclear Regulatory Research RES Proj. Mgr.: Michael Boggi DISTRIBUTION OF OUTGOING (NRC SIGNED):

Attn:

Lab PI Attn: Theresa Loffredo, BN DISTRIBUInON OF INCOMING (DOE SIGNED):

Orig - NRC/OCFO (Attn: Mary Matheson' 3 Copies -Mildred Davis ACCOUNTING CITATION APPROPRIATION SYMBOL 31X0200.760 BAR NUMBER

  • 76015171277 JOB CODE NUMBER N6526 SOC CODE 253D PROJECT PERFORM. PERIOD BEGIN.

END:

9/1512007 11/15/2008 THIS FY FUNDING PERIOD PERFORMING ORGANIZATION:

Brookhaven National Laboratory JOB CODE TITLE:

HUMAN FACTORS ASPECTS OF OPERATIONS 11FRM O

/

0FROM 0

/

TO:

9/15/2007 1 11/30/2007 OBLIGATION AVAILABILITY PROVIDED BY:

A. THIS ORDER

$150,000.00 B. TOTAL OF ORDERS PLACED PRIOR TO THIS ORDER WITH THE PERFORMING ORGANIZATION UNDER THIS JOB CODE FOR THIS FISCAL YEAR.

C. TOTAL ORDERS TO DATE FOR THIS JOB CODE FOR THIS FISCAL YEAR.

(TOTAL A & B)

$150,000.00 STANDARD TERMS AND CONDITIONS ARE PART OF THIS ORDER UNLESS OTHERWISE NOTED (See NRC Managemenl Dir*ctive 11.7).

ATTACHMENTS SECURITY THE FOLLOWING ATTACHMENTS ARE HEREBY MADE A PART OF THIS ORDER; STATEMENT OF WORK

" WORK ON THIS ORDER INVOLVES CLASSIFIED INFORMATION, ADDITIONAL TERMS AND CONDITIONS NRC FORM 187 IS ATTACHED.

OTHER (Specify)

E] WORK ON THIS ORDER INVOLVES SENSITIVE UNCLASSIFIED, Urgent Statement L

UNCLASSIFIED SAFEGUARDS INFORMATION. OR UNESCORTED ACCESS TO PROTECTED AND VITAL AREAS OF NUCLEAR POWER PLANTS. NRC FORM 187 IS ATTACHED.

FEE BILLABLE UNDER 10 CFR PART 170 13 YES NO WORK ON THIS ORDER IS UNCLASSIFIED AND NOT SENSITIVE, REMARKS: (At a minimum, reference the approved proposal (NRC Form 189) by number and date, and indicate If the attached statement of work modifies the DOE proposel);

Request a proposal for the attached urgent statement of work.

A final work package (189) reflecting approved FY07 funds and workscope should be sent within 30 days. Send 5 copies to the Office of Nuclear Regulatory Research (ATTN: Mildred Davis, Mail Stop T-1 0-D5).

CERTIFICATION OF FUNDS This certIfles that funds in the amount cited in Block A are available In the current FY 2007 allotment for work aulhorized by this SOEW.

PONDS CERTiFYING OFFICIAL (Typed Neamie)

SIGNATURE DATE Carol 1. Landesberg

ý (.J

)

SIGNATURES _

ISSUING AUTHORII'Y (Typeo Name sAdi7Ue)

MSIGNATURE DATE Farouk Eltawila, Director, DRASP\\RES S

IG,'tAURo Z_

ACCEPTING ORGANIZATION (Typed Name and "tlee)

GNATURE DATE FUMB - ho RE1 MS

SEP-06-2007 19:14 P. 13 Urgency Statement for Job Code N6526 This work is urgently needed to meet the objectives of the Agency Digital I&C Steering Committee and is included in the initiatives of the Advanced Reactor Research Plan, draft dated March, 2007.

This research was identified as a high priority item in a Phenomena Identification Ranking Table (PIRT) workshop conducted to prioritize human factors issues associated with new and advanced reactors. As such, human factors research is needed to help ensure that NRC review guidance will adequately support safety reviews of the human factors aspects of new and advanced nuclear power plants.

This research looks at the human factors aspects of operations under conditions of degraded instrumentation and control. This research utilizes Brookhaven's experience and expertise in Human Factors and builds on previous work Brookhaven has performed for the NRC.

Project Manager Jose f, RaP Branch Chief, RES/DRASP/PRNIHFRB o onninger Deputy Director, RES/DRASP/PRA Farouk Eltawila Director, RES/DRASP TOTAL P.13

SEP-06-2006 12:26 P. 02 NRC FORM173 #6O-06-390#

U.S. NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION ORDER NUMBER tr-10SB) 60-06-390 NKCMn 1L7 1 1111111 Gl Gill R11!111 1h3 1II II11111 Dl i

lATE OF ISSUANCE STANDARD ORDER FOR DOE WORK (SOEW) 9/6/06 Tnlis agreement Is entered ino pumuaet to the authority af the Energy Reorgarrlzatlon Act of 1974. as amended (42 U.S.C. 6801 el seq.). This work will be performed In accordance with NRC MaengementOite eiv 11.7. The poties agree that CICA does not apply to thils transactlon. To the best of our knowledge, the work requested will not place DOE and 1 conlmtctor In dimeco ompetition with the domestic private S3etor, ISSUED Y0:

(DOE Office)

Mr. Michael D. Holland, Area Manager U. S, Department of Energy Upton, NY 11973 Attn: Robert Gordon IIGUED BY:

(NRC Ofroq)

Farouk Eltawila, Director, Div of Risk Assessment & Special Projects Office of Nuclear Regulatory Research RES Proj, Mar.: Autumn Szabo ACCOUNTING CITATICN APPROPRIATION S`1YMBOL 31X0200.660 t&R NUMBER 1 66015113277 PFERFORMING ORQMAtAI4ON:

Brookhaven National Laboratory J 05 CODE T'm.

HUMAN FACTORS OF ADVANCED REACTORS DISTRIEU'1ON OF OUTGOING (NRC SIGNEDO.

Attn: O'Hara, John M., Lab P1 Attn: Thomas LeMaire, BNL ONISRIBU11ON OF INCOMING (DOE UIGNEDh Oig - NRC/OCFO (Attn: John Walker) 3 Copies -Mildred Davis JOBCODENUMBER Y6529 800COOE 253D PROJECT PERFORM. PERIOD BEGIN;

[ED 10/112004

'6/30/2008 THIS PY FUNDING PERIOD FROM:

TO:

1011f2005 11/30/2006 OBLIGATION AVAILABILrlY PROVIDED BY:

A. THIS ORDER

$45,000.00 9, TOTAL OF ORDERS PLACED PRIOR TO THIS ORDER WITH THE PERFORMING ORGANIZATION UNDER$

THIS JOB CODE FOR THIS FISCAL YEAR.

$150,000.00

0. TOTAL ORDERS TO DATE FOR THIS JOB CODE FOR THIS FISCAL YEAR (TOTAL A & B)

$195,000.00 I STANDARD TERMS AND CONDITIONS ARE PART OF THIS ORDER UNLESS OTERWISE NOTED (See NRC Manaaement Directive 11.7)

I1 ATTACHMENTS SECURITY THE POLLOWING ATTACHMEN'I ARE HEREBY MAIDS A PART OF THIS ORDER; STATEMENT OF WORK WORK ON THIS ORDER INVOLVES CLASSIFIED INFORMATION.

ADDITIONAL TERMS AND CONDITIONS NRC FORM 1871I ATTACHED.

OTHER (Specify) fl WORK ON THIS ORDER INVOLVES SENSITIVE UNCLASSIFIED, Urgent & Mod UNCLASSIFIED SAFEGUARDS INFORMATION, OR UNESCORTED ACCESS TO PROTECTED AND VITAL AREAS OF NUCLEAR POWER PLANTS. NRG FORM'187 IS ATTACHED.

FEE BfLLASLE UNDER 10 CFR PART 170 rl YES El NO 3-WORK ON THIS ORDER IS UNCLASSIFIED AND NOT SENSITIVE.

REMARKS: (At a minimumfffJ?, meernce the approved proposa (NR Faormn

19) by number and (ate, and indicate if the antachea Sa1tement orwok modirfes fe DOE proposal);

REF: SOEW 60-06-179 dated 2/17/06 and 189 dated 6/14/05.

The Urgency Statement is attached.

Modify the 189 to reflect changes in workscope per the attached SOW.

A final 169 reflecting approved funds and workscope should be sent within 30 days. Send 5 copies to the Office of Nuclear Regulatory Research -Attn: Mildred Davis -Address Only - Mail Stop TIC DS.

CERTIFICATION OF FUNDS This certifles that funds In the amount cited In BlockA are available In the current FY 2006 allotment for work authorized by this GOEW.

FUNDS CEtrIPYINC OFFICILA (7YW/Q~me)

ITE Carol 1. Landesberg SIGNATURES SUEPING AUTHORrA(

(Tpod NwMb aft TWO

)

T Farouk Eltawie, Director, DRASP\\RES

__0_

ACCEMiNO ORGANLEAllON (yft/esme sad 711ra)

SI EDATE MAGt FORMd 174*ltu Rirms tha RZn LUG

SEP-0S-2006 12:27 P. OG URGENCY JUSTIPICATION Job Code Number: Y6529

Title:

Human Factors in Advanced Reactors Brookhaven National Laboratory Laboratory:

This modification is needed so that a large number of potential human factors Issues related to new and advanced reactors that were Identified in earlier work can be prioritized so that the appropriate follow-on work can be performed in accordance with the new priorities. The various follow-on tasks will focus on the development of review guidance needed by the regulatory office for the review of new and advanced reactors. The NRC is expecting several applications for new reactors in the Fall of 2007. There is a potential that new guidance will be needed for the review of these applications. This modification will help focus the research needed to develop this new guidance in a timely manner based on reviewers' needs and schedules.

Therefore, it is important that this new work be initiated to meet NRC's anticipated schedule for review of new reactors and to prepare for the later review of advanced reactors.

The results of this work will be a series of reports that will provide a sound technical basis for the support of human performance reviev guidance or regulations for new and advanced reactor applications.

t

/..

1611Vt T

Farouk Eltawila, Director, DRASP, RES Date Date Date TOTAL P.016