SBK-L-09193, 10 CFR 50.55a Request: PR-1, Containment Building Spray Pump Testing on Recirculation Flow Path for the Third 10-Year Interval
| ML092890326 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Seabrook  |
| Issue date: | 10/13/2009 |
| From: | St.Pierre G NextEra Energy Seabrook |
| To: | Document Control Desk, Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation |
| References | |
| PR-1, SBK-L-09193 | |
| Download: ML092890326 (18) | |
Text
NEXTer'a" ENERGY October 13, 2009 Docket No. 50-443 SBK-L-09193 U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Attention: Document Control Desk Washington, DC 20555-0001 Seabrook Station 10 CFR 50.55a Request: PR-1, Containment Building Spray Pump Testing on Recirculation Flow Path for the Third 10-Year Interval Pursuant to 10 CFR 50.55a(a)(3)(i), NextEra Energy Seabrook, LLC (NextEra Energy Seabrook) hereby requests NRC approval of the following request for the third 10-year interval: use of the flow allowed by the recirculation flow path for In-Service Testing (IST) of the Containment Building Spray (CBS) Pumps in lieu of the flow specified in the ASME OM Code.
The request is provided as Attachment 1 to this letter. provides hydraulic test data to support the request.
NextEra Energy Seabrook requests approval by the end of the second 10-year interval, August 17, 2010.
A similar request for the second 10-year interval was approved by the NRC on May 30, 2003 (NRC Accession No. ML031070510). The circumstances and basis for the prior NRC approval have not changed. NextEra Energy Seabrook is near the end of its second 10-year interval using ASME OM Code, 1995 Edition, 1996 Addenda, and will be transitioning to the latest edition of the ASME OM Code incorporated by reference in 10CFR50.55a(b) - ASME OM Code, 2004 Edition, for the third 10-year interval which starts in August 2010. A line by line comparison has shown the new ASME OM Code, 2004 Edition to be consistent with ASME OM Code, 1995 Edition, 1996 Addenda for the issue described below.
ISTB-3300(e)(1) and (2) of ASME OM Code specify that reference values shall be established within +/-20% of the pump design flow.
The initial design of the CBS system incorporated a 4-inch recirculation line for testing. This line is capable of flowing 68% of design flow (63% of Best Efficiency Point [BEP]). Relief Request PR-i was submitted at the start of the second 10-year interval for Seabrook Station to test the CBS pumps using the original recirculation line at the reduced flow. This was accepted by the NRC for the second 10-year interval. NextEra Energy Seabrook is requesting acceptance NextEra Energy Seabrook, LLC, P.O. Box 300, Lafayette Road, Seabrook, NH 03874
U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission SBK-L-09193 Page 2 of this lower flow rate for the third 10-year interval for Seabrook Station per 10 CFR 50.55a Request PR-i attached to this letter.
If you have any questions regarding this submittal, please contact Mr. Michael O'Keefe, Licensing Manager, at (603) 773-7745.
Sincerely, NextEra Energy Seabrook, LLC Gen~e St. Pierre Vice President - North cc:
S. J. Collins, NRC Region i Administrator D. L. Egan, NRC Project Manager W. J.' Raymond, NRC Resident Inspector to SBK-L-09193
Proposed Alternative in Accordance with 10 CFR 50.55a(a)(3)(i)
--Alternative Provides Acceptable Level of Quality and Safety--
Relief Request PR-1, CBS Pump Testing on Recirculation Flow Path
- 1. ASME Code Component(s) Affected Containment Building Spray Pumps CBS-P9A, CBS-P9B
2. Applicable Code Edition and Addenda
3. Applicable Code Requirement
ISTB 3300 Reference Values (e) Reference values shall be established in a region(s) of relatively stable pump flow.
(1) Reference values shall be established within +/-20% of pump design flow rate for the Comprehensive test.
(2) Reference values shall be established within +/-20% of pump design flow rate for Group A and Group B test, if practicable. If not practicable, the reference point flow rate shall be established at the highest practical flow rate.
4. Reason for Request
- Testing of the Containment Building Spray Pumps (CBS-P9A, CBS-P9B) is performed using a recirculation line that passes 68% of the Design Flow The Containment Building Spray (CBS) system is designed to remove the energy discharged to the containment following a loss-of-coolant accident (LOCA) or main steam line break (MSLB) to prevent the containment pressure from exceeding design pressure and to reduce and maintain containment temperature and pressure within acceptable limits.
The CBS pumps are motor-driven, horizontal, centrifugal pumps. The subject pumps are designed to take suction from either the Refueling Water Storage Tank (RWST) in the Emergency Core Cooling System (ECCS) injection mode or the containment recirculation
sump in the ECCS recirculation mode. The CBS pump discharges the flow back into the containment through the containment spray nozzles. Each train of the CBS system includes one 100% capacity pump.
As such, the CBS pumps are required to be inservice tested in accordance with Subsection ISTB of the 2004 Edition, of American Society of Mechanical Engineers (ASME) Code for the Operation and Maintenance of Nuclear Power Plants (OM Code). Subsection ISTB 3300(e)(1) of the OM Code requires that comprehensive tests reference values be established within +/- 20% of pump design flow.
The flow path used to perform both the biennial comprehensive pump test and the quarterly Group A test are the same. The CBS pumps take suction from the Refueling Water Storage Tank (RWST) through a series of manual valves and a suction check valve and discharge water back to the RWST. The pump discharge flow path contains a piping run to a heat exchanger (CBS-E-16A or CBS-E-16B) and then continues to the containment spray ring header penetration(s) (X-14 and X-15). Upstream of this penetration is the return line to the RWST. In the return line, there is an air-operated valve (AOV) (open/close type) specific to each train (CBS-V31 and CBS-V32) with no remote throttling capability. The return lines for each traintie together into a common line that utilizes a similar type AOV (CBS-V33). This common line then connects to the RWST, which is located downstream.
The Safety Injection pumps also utilize this common return line to the RWST. CBS pump flow is measured utilizing a flow indicator (FI-2340) located in the common return line to the RWST. Due to the design of the valves, there is no practical method to vary the resistance of test path to adjust flow. IST testing is performed at this fixed reference condition.
During the pre-operational test period, a test (PT 1-12.1) was performed to verify CBS system performance. PT 12.1 was performed utilizing a temporary manual throttle valve installed in a spool piece (for a temporary strainer) in the common RWST return line. This spool piece still exists as a bolted joint but the manual valves and strainer have been removed. Installation of a similar temporary throttle valve with the plant on-line to achieve additional flow points for the subject pumps is impractical due to the use of this line by other pumps such as the Safety Injection pumps. Installation of a temporary manual throttle.
valve during shutdown periods would require extensive and intrusive modifications.
Alternative means to vary system resistance in order to provide additional test data were evaluated. The local manual throttling of either CBS-V31, CBS-V32 or CBS-V33 was eliminated as an option due to the potential for valve damage since these valves incorporate a soft seat type design. Additionally, local manipulation of these valves at power would over ride the automatic signals that these valves receive to close to protect the containment spray flow path to containment.
The potential to vary system resistance utilizing a manual valve located in the pump suction lines was also evaluated. This option was eliminated due to the potential to cavitate the pumps and reduce net positive suction head (NPSH) margin for the pumps. As a result,
the Containment Spray Pumps (CBS-P9A, CBS-P9B) can only be tested on a recirculation flow path which is sized for approximately 63% (1900 GPM) of the Best Efficiency Point (BEP) Flow of 3000 GPM and approximately 68% of the required design flow of 2808 GPM.
Full flow testing would require system alignment to the containment spray headers and subsequent discharge to the containment. In order to perform full flow testing without alignment to the spray headers, temporary piping would be required to recirculate water to/from the ECCS Containment Sumps. This was performed one time previously, to verify CBS pump curve data (pre-operational test 1-PT-11, Containment Recirculation Sump Operability Demonstration). 1-PT-i 1 required modification of the sump by means of building a 2 to 3 foot high steel dyke around the top of the sump (at -26' elev. floor level).
in order to hold the volume of water required to achieve the necessary pump NPSH without flooding the containment. The spray header piping would also require modification by means of removing the spool pieces downstream of valves CBS-V13 and CBS-V19 and connecting temporary pipe (minimum 8" diameter) from the 25' elevation in containment to the ECCS Sumps at -26' elevation. Recent (OR12) installation of the sump modifications under DCR 06-002, Debris Interceptors,.has installed flow interceptors,.
- further reducing the available volume of the sump for testing. Performing these temporary
- modifications to the CBS system or enlarging the recirculation piping and components to achieve 80% design flow is not warranted since there will be no improvement in our ability to detect pump degradation.
5. Proposed Alternative and Basis for Use
Testing of the subject pumps utilizing the recirculation flow path provides for substantial flow testing in a stable region of the pump curve; well above the minimum continuous flowrate specified by the pump manufacturer. Testing the CBS pumps at reference values established in this region~of the pump curve will not cause damage to the pumps and will provide meaningful data to assess pump operational readiness.
In order to compensate for testing the subject pumps at a reduced flow rate during the comprehensive pump test, as required by ISTB 3300(e)(1), the CBS pumps are included in the Predictive Maintenance Monitored Equipment Program. This program includes thermography, enhanced vibration monitoring and analysis of the pump and periodic sampling and analysis of the lube oil. Station personnel will also perform Static Motor Testing using the Baker Advanced Winding Analyzer Series IV (AWAIV) equipment and Dynamic Motor Monitoring utilizing the Baker EXP3000 equipment. On-line testing using the EXP3000 utilizes a multitude of tests to determine the power quality, motor operating conditions, motor performance, and load originated issues.
If measured parameters are found outside of the normal operating range or were determined to be trending toward an unacceptably degraded condition, corrective actions are required.
These corrective actions include monitoring additional pump parameters, review of
relevant data to determine the cause of the deviation, and potential removal from service.
Reference values for testing the Containment Spray pumps will be established and pump testing will be performed while operating on the installed recirculation loop. This program contains testing and analysis requirements beyond those required by the 2004 Edition of the ASME OM Code.
6. Duration of Proposed Alternative
The compensatory actions associated with this alternative method for testing will extend for the Third Interval.
- 7. Precedents.
Reference TAC MB 6676 NRC Letter dated May 30, 2003' (ML031070510) and NYN-02109 Letter dated October 28, 2002 (ML023100271).
Relief Request PR-1 Hydraulic Data
CBS-P-9A Performance Data 1015/2000 to 4/2312009 300-IST Required Action Upper Limit 290 PT-11/12.1 PumD Curve 280 -
-w 55 270 a.
260 -
250 IST Required Action Lower Limit EE 98-006 System Minimum Requirement 240 1i I
1-600 1700 1800 1900 2000 GPM 2100 2200 2300 2400
CBS-P-9B Performance Data 8/23/2000 to 5/29/2009 300 -
-IST Required Action Upper Limit 290-1.
280 PT-1 1/12.1 Pump Curve 270 Or__
!IST Required Action Lower Limit I.
fn*.#V 250 EE 98-006 System Minimum Requirement 240 1 1600 1700 1800 1900 2000 GPM 2100 2200 2300 2400
IST PUMP DATA LOG CBS-P9A RDS No. 4 Procedure No. OX1406.02 Activity No. I-CBS-OT-006 Flowpath: RecirclRWST Range Limits:
OM W] ASME El Restricted R1 Page 1 of 2 Hydraulic Entry Test Test Vibraton Data Points Speed Test ResuIts Comments Completed by Date Date Parameters (ACCIALIRA)
DP Q 1 1 213 4/ 5 5126/2009 4/23*29 281.5 1930 na ACC None Couture psid gpm Vibration Units:
rpm Date 5/2612009 11118/2006 10/20/2008 284 1940 j
n ACC None Couture psid gpm Vibration Units rpm Date 11/18/2008 91212008 7/28/2008 279 1940 I I na ACC None Couture psid 9pm Vibration Units:
rpm Date 9/212008 819/2008 519/2008 279 1940 I i IA 1 o
Acc None Couture psid Qprn Vibration Units:
rpm Date 61912008 2119/2008 2/11/2008 281.5 1940 i [I I I na ACC None Couture psid 9pm Vibration Units:
rpm Date 2/19/2008 1/7/2008 911812007 11119/2007 8/27/2007 280 paid 279 psid 1940 Qpm 1930 9pm Vibration Unts:
Vibration Units:
na rpm na rpm ACC ACC None 6/2712007 1/3/2007 10/11/2000 812312008 614/2007 12118/2006 9/2612006 7/4/2006 279 psid.
281.5 psid 279 psid 281 psid 1940 ppm 1940 Gppm 1950 opM 1945 opm I I I I Vibration Units:
I I I I
Vibration Units:
Vibration Units: in/sec
---I.rt-I It-:
Vibration Units:
na rpm nla rpm N/A rpm n/a rpm N/A rpm ACC ACC ACC ACC ACC None None None None None None Couture Date 11712008 Couture Date 9/18/2007 Couture Dale 6/27/2007 Couture Date 1/312007 Parry Date 10/1112006 Parry Date 8123/2006 Parry i
i 4113/2006 4/10/2006 281 psid 19p40 1ibrato 1Un1ts ppm Vibration Units:
Date 4/13/2006 112712006 111C/2006 284 1940 N A 1
1 NA ACG Nont Couture psid
- gpm Vibration Units:
rpm Date 1/27/2006 11/8/2005 13124/2005 282 1940 NA ACC None Couture psid gpr Vibration Units:
rpm Date 11/8/2005 814/2005 81112005 279 1950 NIA ACC None Couture psid gp-n Vibration Units:
rpm Date 814/2005 313/2005 2115/2005 281.5 1940 N/A ACC None Couture psid gpm Vibration Units; rpm Date 313/2005 12/2/2004 11/=2004 281 1940 noa ACC None Masters psid gpm Vibration Units:
rpm Date 121/2004 9/2/2004 8/29/2004 280 1940 n/a Acc None Parry psid opm Vibration Units: in/sec rpm Date 9/212004 6/30/2004 617/2094 281 1935 jj NIA ACC None Couture psid gpm Vibration Units:
rpm Date 6130/2004 3126/2004 3/17/2004 282 1930 N/A AGO on Parry psid gpm Vibration Units:
in/sec rpm Date 3/2612004 Similar to:
ES1804.055 Form 0
IST PUMP DATA LOG CBS-P9A Activity No. 1-CBS-OT-006 Flowpath: Recirc/RWST RDS No. 4 Procedure No. OX1406.02 Range Limits:
Restricted R Page 2 of 2 Hydraulic Entry Test Test Vibration Data Points Speed Test Results Comments Completed by Date Date Parameters (ACC/AI/RA)
DP a
1 2
3 4
5 108/2004 12/2212003 279 1940 NIA ACC None Parry psid gpm Vibration Units:
in/see rpm Date 118/2004 1011/2003 9/29/2003 281 1940 F
-0 N/A ACC None Gwinn psid gpm Vibration Units:
rpm Date 10/112003 7/18/2003 7/102003 280 1940 T
I I
N ACC None GWinn paid gpm Vibration Units:
rpm Date 7/18/2003 4/30/2003 4/17/2003 281 148 N
=
NA ACC None Gwtnn paid gpm Vibration Units:
rpm Date 4/30/2003 V2323)2003 11201203 281 1940 jjiL i ii NIA ACC None M~cCormnac1R psid gpm Vibration Units:
rpm Date 1/23/2003 11/7/2002 11/1/2002 281 1940 INI I
I NA ACC None (tapes psid gpm Viration Units:
rpm Date 11/7/2002 8/14/2002 8/9/2002 279 1940 I j j
N/A ACO None Kapes paid gpm Viration Units:
rpm Date 8/14/2002 6/17/2002 8/13r20o2 279 1940 I1 I
jj N1 ACo None Kiopes psid GPm Vibration Units:
rpm Date 6/17/2002 5/20o2002 5/18/2002 281 1950 j Ij j I
N/A ACC None Kapes paid gpm Vibration Units:
rpm Date 5/20/2002 2/27t2002 2/22(2002 281 1945 N/A ACC None Kapes psio gpm Vibration Unit:
rpm Date 2/27/2002 12*6/2001 11/30/2001 283 1950 I
]
I I
N/A AC None Kiapes psid gpm Vibration Units:
rpm Date 12/6/2001 9/11/2001 917/2001 281 1950 1
1 1
N/A ACC None K.apes psid gpm Vibration Units:
rpm Date 9/11/2001 6/20'2001 6/1512001 282.3 1040 j j
j N/A ACC None Klapes.
poid gpm Vibration Units:
rpm Date 6/20/2001 3/29/2001 3/23/2001 280 1940 IjjjI I
N/A ACO None Klapes psid Gpm Vibration Units:
rpm Date 3/29/2001 1/7/2001 12/30/2000 281.5 193.0 1
N/A ACC None Klapes psaid pm Vibration Units:
rpm Date 1/7/2001 10/10/2000 10/5/2000 282 1940 NA ACC Baseline for RDS#04 Kapes psid GPm Vibration Units:
rpm Date 10/10/2000 Comments: RDS # 04 revised for CBS-P-9A due to calibration tolerance/instrument uncertainty for DCR 99-36 pressure gauges (2%).
All else from RDS 4 remains the same. Added instru uncertainty of 14 psid to TS Limit of 262 psid = 276 psid. This assumes the worst case.
Similar to:
ES1804.055 Form 0
IST PUMP DATA LOG CBS-P9A Activity No. 1-CBS-OT-008 Flowpath:
Recirc/RWST RDS No. 1 Procedure No. OX1406.02 Range Limits:
Restricted I]
Page I of I Hydraulic Entry Test Test Vibration Data Points Speed Test Results Comments Completed by Date Date Parameters (ACC!AL/RA)
DP1 1
2 31 4_
5 ACL/)
7/16/2003 1 o7/10W003 282.9 1940
- o. 2.
32 9
o.1 1o 2
3 o. 2 s NA
_ rsld gpm Vibration Units: in/seC rpm 1091200 2/101[
81.4 1950 0.0.32[0 a2[0.24F0.28 N/A psid 9pm Vibration Units:
in/sec rpm Comments: RDS # 01 for CBS-P-9A due to update of 1sT Program to ASME OM Code.
Added instr. uncertainty of 1.1 psid to TS limit of 262 psid =263.Ipsid.
ACC None Gadnn Date 7V1612003 ACC Baseline for RDS 401 Klapes Date 1019/2001 Newreference data from 01R001158001.
Similar to:
ES1804.055 Form 0
IST PUMP DATA LOG CBS-P9A Activity No. 1-CBS-OT-008 RDS No. 2 Procedure No. OX1406.02 Flowpath: RecircIRWST Range Limits:
Restricted W/
Page 1 of 1 Hydraulic Entry Test Test Vibration Data Points Speed Test Results Comments Completed by Date Date Parameters (ACC/AL/RA)
DP Q 1 1 2 13 14 5
t1412009 2001 282 1940 028 0.28 0.19 0.22 023 na AGo None Coutu pert gpm Vibration Units:
in/sec rpn Date 2-4/2009 3/3112007 3/12/2007 281.3 1940 0.2910.3210.181 0.211 0.28 n/a ACC None Couture psid gpm Vibration Units: in/sec rpm Date 3/31/2007 5/18/2005 5/9/2005 283.5 1940
.30 T
0.19 0.24 0.27 N/A ACC None Couture psid 9pm VbrationUnits:
in/sec rpm j ___.........
Date 5118/2C05 Comments: RDS#2 just revises RDS#1 to increase the ALERT Vibration Limit to 0.350 ips as Relief Request PR-3 was approved.
Similar to:
ES1804.055 Form 0
IST PUMP DATA LOG CBS-P9B Activity No. 1-CBS-OT-007 Flowpath: Recirc I RWST RDS No. 2 Procedure No. OX1406.02 Range Limits:
Restricted 9 Page 1 of 2 Hydraulic Entry Test Test Vibration Data Points Speed Test Results Comments Completed by Date Date Parameters (ACCIAURA)
DP a
1 121314 5
7/7/2009 5/2912009 283 1920 j
I f
I na ACC None Couture psid gpm Vibration Unils:
rpm Date 7/7/2009 3123)2009 2312009 285.5 1910 I
I J na ACO None Couture psid gpm Vibration Units:
rpm Date 3/23/2009 1/8/2009 12/1/2008 283 1915 1
1 na ACC None Couture psid gpm Vibration Units:
rp Date 11812009 10M7/2008 9/8/2008 283 1920 NA ACC None Couture psad gpm Vbrton Units:
rpm Dale 10(7/2008 68/8/2008
/18/2008 263 1910 Ina ACI None Couture psid gPm Vibration Units:
rpm Date 8/8/2008 5/18/2008 3/27/2008 286 1920 NIA ACO None Parry p5Ad gprn Vibration Units: rn/sec rpm Date 5116/2008 1/285/2000 12/31/2071 288 1910 INA ACC None Party psid gpm Vibration Units:
rpm I
Date 1/26/2008 10/31/2007 10/8/2007 283 paid 1920 1
jJ Ij I gpm Vibration Units:
na rpm ACC None i
I J
JI L1J1 712712007 1711612007 283.5 1
1925 pald 611/2007 2/12/2007 412312007 1/30/2007 288 psid 283 psid gpm 1910 Gpm 1920 gpm 1910 gpm Vibration Units.
mI n U Vibration Units:
i U InIt Vibration Un/t:
Vibration Unito:
Vibration Unita:
ha rpm na rpm na rpm ACC ACC ACC None None None Couture Date 1013112007 Couture Data 7/27/2007 Couture Date 6/1/2007 Couture Dale 2112/2007 1/2/2007 1 1214i20061 283.5 n/a 9/28/2006 6113/2006 1/4/2006 9/2612005 8/14/20C6 5/22/2006 12/5/2005 9112/2005 pis 283 pai 28 ps 283 ps 28 psi Id id 1930 gpm 56 1915 -. I I I I --"
id GpM Vibration Unitl:
1.5 19 20 I I id 4pm Vibration Units:
4 1930 1
1 -
I d
gpm
\\Vbration U6i1.
N/A rpm N/A rpm N/A rpm N/A rpm ACC ACC ACC ACC ACC None None None None print 0507914 Couture Date 1/2/2007 Parry Date 9/28/2006 Parry Date 6113/2006 Couture Date 1/4/2006 Couture Date 9/26/2005 7/1/2005 16/21/2005 283.5 1910 I
I I
NA ACC CR 05-07984 Couture psid gpm Vibration Units:
rpm Date 711/2005 1130/2005 114/2005 285 1920 AI I
I NN ACC one Couture psid gpm Vibration Units:
rpm Date 1/30/2005 1012812004 1011112004 206M5 1920 1
1 NIA ACC None Couture paid GPr Vibrat/an Units:
rpm Data 10/28/2004 9/112004 7/21/20o4 285 N915 NA ACC Nore Parry
- psid, 9P Vibration Units:
intsic prn Dat 9/1/2004 Similar to:
ESI804.055 Form 0
IST PUMP DATA LOG CBS-P9B Activity No. 1-CBS-OT-007 RDS No. 2 Procedure No. 0X1406.02 Flowpath: Recirc / RWST Range Limits:
OM R] ASME El Restricted 91 Page 2 of 2 Hydraulic Entry Test Test J Vibration Data Points Speed Test Results Comments Completed by Date Date Parameters (ACC/ALYRA) oP I
..121 31=
5110/2004 4/26e120111 286.5 psid 1915 1 1
1 1
1 gpm I
Vibration Units: in/sec WEa rpm ACC See Comprehensive Parry pump test on same Date 5/1012004 say 2/12/2004 2/5/2004 285.5 1920 paid gpm 11/1712003 1111012003 285.6 1930 psid gpm 8/25(2003 811912003 283 1920 psid gpin 6/2/2003 512712003 285.8 1910 paid gpm 3/7/2003 31/Z2003 285 1920 paid gpm 12112/2002 12/912002 285.5 1920 psid 9pm 9/23/2002 9116/2002 285 1915 paid gpm 711712002 6/2412002 287 1920 psid gpm 5/20/2002 5118/2002 284 1910 psid gpm 41812002 4/3/2002 288.5 1900 psid 9pm 1114/2002 1/912002 285 1910 psid gpm 10/19/2001 10/17/2001 288.5 1920 psid 9pm 8/1/2001 7/25/2001 286.9 1915 paid gpm 5/7/2001 5/2/2001 285 1920 psid gpm N/A rpm ACC None n/a rpm NIA rpm ACC None ACC INone NIA rpm ACC None N/A rpm ACC Vibration Units:
None-test WO#0236182 None N/A rpm ACC H/A rpm N/A rpm N/A rpm N/A rpm N/A rpm ACC ACC None None ACC I01 W000081 Parry Date 2112/2004 Parry Date 11/17/2003 Gwine Date 8/2512003 Gwinn Date 6/2/2003 McCormack Date 317/2003 Ktapes Date 12112/2002 Klapes Date 9/2312002 Masters Date 7/17/2002 Parry Date 5120/2002 Klapes Date 4/8/2002 K/apes Date 1/14/2002 Klapes Date 10/19t2001 Klapes Cate 811/2001 Klapes Date 51/72001 Klapes Date 2/13/2001 KWapes Date 12/8/2000 Klapes Date 8/30/2000 ACC ACC None None N/A rpm N/A rpm NIA rpm ACC ACC None W/Compreh. CBS-OT009 -retest 01W000494 ACC None 2/13/2001 12/6/2000 2/7/2001 11/2512000 286.5 psid 1920 9pm 287 psid 287 esid 1920 gpm 1920 N/A rpm NIA rpm N/A ACC ACC ACe None None Baseline for RDS #02 8/30/2000 18123/2000 Vibratian Units:
psd 9r-V[
l I*
1*
r.
Comments:
RDS # 02 revised for CBS-P-9g due to calibration tolerance/instrument uncertainty for DCR 99-36 pressure gauges (2%).
All else from RDS 2 remains the same. Added instru uncertainty of 14 psid to TS Limit of 262 psid = 276 psid. This assumes the worst case.
Similar to:
ES1804.055 Form 0
IST PUMP DATA LOG CBS-P9B Activity No. I -CBS-OT-009 RDS No. 3 Procedure No. OX1406.02 Flowpath: Recirc I RWST Range Limits:
OM RI ASME [I Restricted RI Page 1 of 1 Hydraulic Entry Test Test Vibration Data Points Speed Test Results Comments Completed by Date Date Parameters (ACC/AURA)
DP Q
11213 41 11812009 11211/2008 2853 1915 01 0.290.20 0.2 05 na ACC None Couture psid g a~,
Vibration Units:
rpm Date 1/8/2009 1/26/2008 112/31/2001 286.0 psid 1910 gpm 0.331.27 10.19 10.24 10.33 Vibration Units:
in/see N/A rpm ACC ACC None 2/1212007 11/30/2007 3/8/2006 12/28/2006 4110/20051 3129/2085 285.2 psid 285 psid 284.5 psid 285 psid 1920 gpm 1910 gpm 1915 ppm 1915 ppm 0.32 Io.27 1o0.20 0.241 0.32 Vibration Units:
in/sec 0 32 1 o* 29_[0 91T025 10.32 Vibration Units:
ln/sec 0.32 1 0.2810.2010.241 0.32 Vibration Units:
In/sec na rpm FNone N/A rpm ACC None Parry.
Date 30/2006 Parry Date 1/26/2008 Couture Date 2/12/2007 NIA rpm ACC None 5/10/2004 1 4/26/2004 Couture Date 4/10/2005 Parry Dale 5/10/2004 0.310.301 0.211 0.25 0.31 Vibration Units:
IPS n/a rpm Acc NRC Approved Relief Request for 0.350 ips as new ALERT Level Comments: RDS#3 just revises RDS#2 to increase the ALERT Vibration Limit to 0.350 ips as Relief Request PR-3 was approved.
Similar to:
ES1804.055 Form 0
IST PUMP DATA LOG CBS-P9B Activity No. 1-CBS-OT-009 Flowpath: Recirc / RWST RDS No. 1 Procedure No. OX1406.02 Range Limits:
Page 1 of 1 Hydraulic Entry Test Test Vibration Data Points Speed Test Results Comments Completed by Date Date Parameters (ACCALRA) so=
o
-- -3 6/2/2003 5/27/2003 286.7 1910 0.410.301
- 0. 2 4 034 N/A ACC None G..
.nn ps d gpm Vibration Units:
in/sec rpm Date 6/2/2003 11/15/2002 5/18/2002 284 191 0f33321 021 10.25I0.32 N/A AL retest-WO#01 C3570 Klapes psid On"-
Vibration Units:
in/sec rpm Date 11/15/2002 7/17/2002 6/24/2002 284 1920 0.311 0.30 1 0.19 I 0.25 0.32 N/A' ACC None Masters psid gpm Vibration Units:
in/sec rpm Date 7/17/2002 7/26/2001 7/25/2001 286.9 1
0.35 C.28.1 0.201 0.2610.26 A
AL Baseline data for Klapes psid gpm V aion Units, in/sec rpm RDS #1-Vib pt 1 In Date 7/25/2001 ALERT Comments: RDS # 01 for CBS-P-9B due to update of IST Program to ASME OM Code. New reference data from 01 RO01 159001.
NOTE: Vibration pt. #1 in ALERT range - see CR # 01-07360.
Added instr. uncertainty of 1.1 psid to TS limit of 262 psid
- 263.1 psid.
Similar to:
ES1804.055 Form 0