ML072000473
| ML072000473 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Technical Specifications Task Force |
| Issue date: | 07/19/2007 |
| From: | NRC/NRR/ADRO/DIRS |
| To: | |
| Hamm, Matthew DIRS/ITSB 415-1472 | |
| References | |
| Download: ML072000473 (4) | |
Text
Questions on NRC Review Fees The 1Q07 review fee amount for TSTF-487, "Relocate DNB Parameters to the COLR,"
of $37,975 (roughly 150 person-hours) seems very high. The total review fees for TSTF-487 were over $55,000 for a change to relocate parameters to the COLR.
The review fees do not seem to be commensurate with the complexity of the change.
- TSTF-491, "Removal of Main Steam and Main Feedwater Valve Isolation Times From Technical Specifications," was a simple change to relocate a value from the TS. $26,996 in review fees was assessed.
- TSTF-490, "Deletion of E Bar Definition and Revision to RCS Specific Activity Tech Spec," was a large, complex change that replaced the use of E-bar in the TS with a new parameter, Dose Equivalent Xenon. Specification 3.4.16, RCS Specific Activity, was substantially rewritten and the analysis basis was changed.
The NRC review fees were $32,725.
The BWROG Travelers do not appear to be receiving equivalent review fees.
- TSTF-475, "Control Rod Notch Testing Frequency and SRM Insert Control Rod Action," which was resubmitted in 4Q06, and received an RAI in 3/07 and a response was provided in 5/07, has received no review fees in 2006 or 2007.
- TSTF-476, "Improved BPWS Control Rod Insertion Process (NEDO-33091),"
which was submitted in 2004 and 2005, and was approved in early 2007, received
$1,178 in review fees in 2004 and 2005 and no review fees in 2006 and 2007.
- TSTF-477, "Add Action for Two Inoperable Control Room AC Subsystems," had three revisions submitted in 2006 and was approved in early 2007. There were no review fees assessed.
- TSTF-478, "BWR Technical Specification Changes that Implement the Revised Rule for Combustible Gas Control," which has submitted in 2005 and 2007, and has been the subject of numerous meetings and RAIs, has received no review fees.
- TSTF-484, "Use of TS 3.10.1 for Scram Time Testing Activities," was submitted in 2005 and approved at the end of 2006. There were no review fees assessed.
- TSTF-495, "Bases Change to Address GE Part 21 SC05-03," was submitted in 7/06. An RAI was received in 1/07 and the response was submitted in 4/07.
There have been no review fees assessed.
Description TSTF Number Applicability NRC Review Fee Report Submittal Date Review Status Approval Date Provide Actions for One Steam Supply to Turbine Driven AFW/EFW Pump Inoperable TSTF-412-A, Rev. 3 PWRs Fee Data 1/8/2007 NRC Approves 7/17/2007 2005
$1,099.00 Q1 2005
$1,025.00 Q1 2005
$4,505.90 Q2 2005
$102.50 Q4 2006
$1,025.00 Q1 2006
$20,562.00 Q2 2006
$8,571.00 Q3 2006
$3,971.00 Q4 2007
$8,463.00 Q1
$49,324.40 Total:
Revision to RCP Flywheel Inspection Program (WCAP-15666)
TSTF-421-A, Rev. 0 W
Fee Data 11/30/2001 NRC Approves 10/22/2003 2003
$156.00 Q3 2003
$702.00 Q4
$858.00 Total:
Extend PCIV Completion Times (NEDC-33046)
TSTF-454-A, Rev. 1 BWRs Fee Data 9/21/2005 NRC Approves 12/13/2005 2003
$4,134.00 Q4 2004
$468.00 Q1
$4,602.00 Total:
Provide an Exception to the Requirement to Have One RHR Shutdown Cooling System in Operation TSTF-459, Rev. 1 BWRs Fee Data 2/13/2006 TSTF Withdrew 11/3/2006 2003
$1,950.00 Q4 2004
$3,385.00 Q1 2004
$312.00 Q2 2004
$1,950.00 Q4
$7,597.00 Total:
Control Rod Scram Time Testing Frequency TSTF-460-A, Rev. 0 BWRs Fee Data 9/7/2003 NRC Approves 5/27/2004 2003
$156.00 Q4 2004
$1,092.00 Q1 2004
$3,744.00 Q2 2004
$707.00 Q3
$5,699.00 Total:
Page 1 of 3 19-Jul-07
Description TSTF Number Applicability NRC Review Fee Report Submittal Date Review Status Approval Date Addition of time performance Surveillance Requirement (SR) note to Source Range Monitor (SRM) SRs TSTF-465, Rev. 0 BWRs Fee Data 9/18/2003 TSTF Withdrew 4/14/2006 2003
$624.00 Q4 2004
$1,498.00 Q1 2004
$608.00 Q2 2004
$2,355.00 Q3 2004
$3,438.00 Q4 2005
$550.00 Q1
$9,073.00 Total:
Control Rod Notch Testing Frequency and SRM Insert Control Rod Action TSTF-475, Rev. 1 All Fee Data 5/22/2007 Under NRC Consideration 2004
$6,437.00 Q4
$6,437.00 Total:
Improved BPWS Control Rod Insertion Process (NEDO-33091)
TSTF-476-A, Rev. 1 BWRs Fee Data 1/9/2007 NRC Approves 5/23/2007 2004
$1,099.00 Q4 2005
$79.00 Q1
$1,178.00 Total:
Revise MTC Surveillance for Startup Test Activity Reduction (STAR) Program (WCAP-16011)
TSTF-486, Rev. 2 CE Fee Data 5/10/2007 Under NRC Consideration 2006
$0.00 Q1 2006
$0.00 Q2 2006
$325.00 Q3 2006
$5,968.00 Q4 2007
$2,105.00 Q1
$8,398.00 Total:
Relocate DNB Parameters to the COLR TSTF-487-A, Rev. 1 CE Fee Data 5/4/2007 NRC Approves 6/5/2007 2006
$554.00 Q1 2006
$2,255.00 Q2 2006
$325.00 Q3 2006
$13,997.00 Q4 2007
$37,975.00 Q1
$55,106.00 Total:
Page 2 of 3 19-Jul-07
Description TSTF Number Applicability NRC Review Fee Report Submittal Date Review Status Approval Date Deletion of E Bar Definition and Revision to RCS Specific Activity Tech Spec TSTF-490-A, Rev. 0 PWRs Fee Data 9/13/2005 NRC Approves 3/15/2007 2006
$1,743.00 Q2 2006
$7,307.00 Q3 2006
$10,221.00 Q4 2007
$13,454.00 Q1
$32,725.00 Total:
Removal of Main Steam and Main Feedwater Valve Isolation Times From Technical Specifications TSTF-491-A, Rev. 2 PWRs Fee Data 5/18/2006 NRC Approves 12/29/2006 2006
$6,216.00 Q2 2006
$12,859.00 Q3 2006
$7,921.00 Q4
$26,996.00 Total:
Modify RHR - High Water Level Bases to Address Decay Heat Removal with Upper Internals Installed TSTF-492-T, Rev. 0 W
Fee Data Approved for Use 2006
$205.00 Q1 2006
$1,640.00 Q2 2006
$205.00 Q3 2006
$13,851.00 Q4
$15,901.00 Total:
Risk-Informed Containment Isolation Valve Completion Times (BAW-2461)
TSTF-498, Rev. 0 B&W Fee Data 12/22/2006 Under NRC Consideration 2007
$977.00 Q1
$977.00 Total:
Page 3 of 3 19-Jul-07