ML063520022

Pilgrim - Letter Informing the Administrative Judges and Parties That the Staff'S Hearing File Index Has Been Updated

ML063520022
Person / Time
Site:	Pilgrim
Issue date:	12/15/2006
From:	Roth D NRC/OGC
To:	Abramson P, Cole R, Austin Young Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel
Giitter R
References
50-293-LR, ASLBP 06-848-02-LR
Download: ML063520022 (26)

Text

December 15, 2006 Administrative Judge Administrative Judge Richard F. Cole Paul B. Abramson Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel Mail Stop: T-3F23 Mail Stop: T-3F23 U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, DC 20555-0001 Washington, DC 20555-0001 Administrative Judge Ann Marshall Young, Chair Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel Mail Stop T-3 F23 U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, DC 20555-0001 In the Matter of Entergy Nuclear Generation Company and Entergy Nuclear Operations, Inc.

(Pilgrim Nuclear Power Station)

Docket No. 50-293-LR; ASLBP No. 06-848-02-LR

Dear Administrative Judges:

The NRC Staff hereby provides its notice that it has updated the hearing file for this proceeding pursuant to 10 C.F.R. § 2.336(d) as modified by the Board's Order Regarding Schedule for Proceeding and Related Matters (November 29, 2006). An index containing the ADAMS accession number, date, and title or description of each item in the hearing file is appended hereto as Attachment 1. The Staff is also producing, as Attachment 2, updates to its privilege logs as required by 10 C.F.R. § 2.336(b)(5), and is continuing to preserve and maintain all privileged documents during the pendency of this

R. Cole December 15, 2006 P. Abramson A. Young proceeding. Also attached are the Affidavit of Perry Buckley, as required by 10 C.F.R.

§ 2.336(c), and the Declaration of Pao-Tsin Kuo, Acting Director of the Division of License Renewal, formally invoking the deliberative process privilege.

Sincerely,

/RA/

David E. Roth Counsel for the NRC Staff

Enclosures:

Hearing File Index Privilege Log - Deliberative Process Affidavit of Perry Buckberg Declaration of Pao-Tsin Kuo cc: Attached Service List

ATTACHMENT 1 PILGRIM LICENSE RENEWAL HEARING FILE AND MANDATORY DISCLOSURES HEARING FILE INDEX Supplement 1 - December 15, 2006 Accession Number Document Date Title/Description:

01-01 ML061590232 03/07/2006 03/07/2006 - RIC 2006 Presentation - T1F - Garry G.

Young - License Renewal.

01-02 ML063470051 05/01/2006 (PD) Ecology Meeting Notes Pilgrim Nuclear Power Station Site Audit on May 1, 2006.

01-03 ML063470072 05/02/2006 (PD) Pilgrim Nuclear Power Station License Renewal Site Audit Off-Site Meetings May 2-4, 2006 Draft Meeting Notes.

01-04 ML063470067 05/18/2006 (PD) PNPS LR EIS Ecology Meeting May 18, 2006.

01-05 ML062920265 10/03/2006 2006/10/03-EMAIL: (PA) FW Waste Minimization Plan.

01-06 ML062900231 11/02/2006 Request for Additional Information for the Review of the Pilgrim Nuclear Power Station License Renewal Application (TAC MC9669).

01-07 ML063480351 11/02/2006 E-mail: (PD) Draft RAI.

01-08 ML063480402 11/06/2006 E-MAIL: (PD) Fwd: Entergy Nuclear Cultural Resources Protection Plan.

01-09 ML062960274 11/07/2006 Request for Additional Information for the Review of the Pilgrim Nuclear Power Station License Renewal Application (TAC MC9669) (Section B.1.16.1).

01-10 ML062760508 11/07/2006 Summary of Conference call on September 25, 2006, with Entergy Nuclear Operations, Inc.

01-11 ML063450086 11/08/2006 E-MAIL: (PA) Nuclear-Impacted Communities [from J.

Berger to A. Williamson].

Page 1 of 2

Accession Number Document Date Title/Description:

01-12 ML063450084 11/11/2006 E-MAIL: (PA) Request for Additional Information (RAI)

Regarding Severe Accident Mitigation Alternatives (SAMA) for Pilgrim Nuclear Power Station, May 22, 2006.

01-13 ML063450082 11/13/2006 E-MAIL: (PA) Re: Nuclear-Impacted Communities [to J.

Berger].

01-14 ML063450081 11/14/2006 E-MAIL: (PA) Re: Request for Additional Information (RAI) Regarding Severe Accident Mitigation Alternatives (SAMA).

01-15 ML063450079 11/16/2006 E-MAIL: (PA) Fwd: Re: Nuclear-Impacted Communities.

01-16 ML063480323 11/16/2006 E-MAIL: (PD) Pilgrim PT Curve Amendment MD1218 Conference Call.

01-17 ML063480328 11/17/2006 E-MAIL: (PD) WP copy of RAI Letter.

01-18 ML063280073 11/28/2006 Request for Additional Information Regarding Severe Accident Mitigation Alternatives for Pilgrim Nuclear Power Station (TAC NO. MC9676).

01-19 ML063480389 11/30/2006 E-mail: (PD) SAMA RAI.

Page 2 of 2

ATTACHMENT 2: PILGRIM NUCLEAR POWER STATION LICENSE RENEWAL HEARING FILE AND MANDATORY DISCLOSURES PRIVILEGE LOG - DELIBERATIVE PROCESS PRIVILEGE Supplement 1: December 15, 2006 Certain documents otherwise subject to inclusion in the hearing file and mandatory disclosures for this proceeding have been determined by the NRC Staff to contain information subject to withholding from public disclosure as predecisional, deliberative information. Pursuant to 10 C.F.R.

§ 2.336(b)(5), the Staff is providing this log to identify the following documents, withheld under the deliberative process privilege.

PDP Accession Author Title/Description: Document Document Addressee / Comment Page No. Number Name/ Date Type Addressee Count Affiliation: Affiliation DP- ML0634605 Szeligowski E-mail: (PD) Phone 3/29/2006 E-Mail, Note Duda S, Hurley Staff comments 1 01-01 29 J, Earth Tech, Call with Bob Schaaf. to File incl B, - Earth Tech, regarding phone Inc Telcon Inc call Record, Verbal Comm DP- ML0634703 Szeligowski E-MAIL: (PD) Phone 3/30/2006 E-Mail, Note Duda S, Hurley Staff comments 3 01-02 34 J, Earth Tech, Log - USEPA. to File incl B, - Earth Tech, regarding phone Inc Telcon Inc call Record, Verbal Comm DP- ML0634703 Szeligowski E-MAIL: (PD) 3/30/2006 E-Mail Duda S, Hurley Staff comments 1 01-03 18 J, Earth Tech, Conversation with B, - Earth Tech, regarding phone Inc MA Div. Marine Inc call Fisheries.

DP- ML0634605 Szeligowski E-MAIL: (PD) Re: 3/30/2006 E-Mail Schaaf R G, Contains staff 1 01-04 32 J, Earth Tech, Pilgrim - Cape Wind NRC recommendations Inc Marine regarding tribe Archaeological reference Assessment. document.

Page 1 of 17

PDP Accession Author Title/Description: Document Document Addressee / Comment Page No. Number Name/ Date Type Addressee Count Affiliation: Affiliation DP- ML0634703 Szeligowski E-MAIL: (PD) 4/3/2006 E-Mail, Note Duda S, Hurley Staff comments 3 01-05 23 J, Earth Tech, Conversation with to File incl B, - Earth Tech, regarding phone Inc Bob Schaaf [sent Telcon Inc call 4/3/06]. Record, Verbal Comm DP- ML0634702 Szeligowski E-MAIL: (PD) Re: 4/5/2006 E-Mail Flynn C, Hurley Staff comments 1 01-06 34 J, - Earth Pilgrim writing - B, - Earth Tech, and Tech, Inc Abbreviations for Inc recommendations common use.

DP- ML0634702 Szeligowski E-MAIL: (PD) 4/6/2006 E-Mail Schaaf R G, Staff notes and 1 01-07 19 J, Earth Tech, Conversation with NRC recommendations Inc Robert Walker. from phone call DP- ML0634605 Szeligowski E-MAIL: (PD) Phone 4/10/2006 E-Mail Besson M, Staff comments 1 01-08 22 J, Earth Tech, Call with Bob Schaaf Duda S, regarding phone Inc [4/10/06]. Pappalardo M, call Stehling N, -

Earth Tech, Inc DP- ML0634605 Szeligowski E-MAIL: (PD) Issues 4/14/2006 E-Mail, Schaaf R, - Staff 7 01-09 44 J, Earthtech, Questions REV02 Report, NRC recommendations Inc 041406.doc. Miscellaneou for questions s

DP- ML0634605 Szeligowski E-MAIL: (PD) 4/18/2006 E-Mail Duda S, Flynn Staff comments 1 01-10 24 J, Earth Tech, Conversation with C, Hurley B, - regarding phone Inc Bob Schaaf Earth Tech, Inc call

[4/18/06].

Page 2 of 17

PDP Accession Author Title/Description: Document Document Addressee / Comment Page No. Number Name/ Date Type Addressee Count Affiliation: Affiliation DP- ML0631101 Rubin M P, (NPA-PD-LR) Memo 4/26/2006 Memoranda Franovich R L, Internal memo with 8 01-11 33 NRC/NRR/A to R. Franovich Re: NRC/NRR/ADR recommended DRA/DRA/AP Request for O/DLR/REBA questions LA Additional Information to Support the Staffs Severe Accident Mitigation Alternative Review for Pilgrim Nuclear Power Station (TAC No.

MC9676).

DP- ML0634702 Flynn C, - E-MAIL: (PD) Re: 4/26/2006 E-Mail Hurley B, Recommendations 2 01-12 25 Earth Tech, Draft Audit Szeligowski J, - and deliberation on Inc Checklists. Earth Tech, Inc checklist DP- ML0634605 Provenzano E-MAIL: (PD) Re: 4/28/2006 E-Mail Parker A, Comments 1 01-13 48 S, Earth Meeting with Szeligowski J, regarding meeting Tech, Inc Marshfield-PNPS Earth Tech, Inc Site Audit.

DP- ML0634700 , NRC (PD) Meeting 5/3/2006 Meeting , Impressions of site 4 01-14 52 Minutes: PNPS Site Minutes audit Audit Meeting with US EPA Region 1, MA Coastal Zone Management Dept.

Of Environmental Protection and Div.

Of Maine Fisheries on May 3, 2006.

Page 3 of 17

PDP Accession Author Title/Description: Document Document Addressee / Comment Page No. Number Name/ Date Type Addressee Count Affiliation: Affiliation DP- ML0634605 Szeligowski E-MAIL: (PD) 5/10/2006 E-Mail Flynn C, Hurley Comments 1 01-15 27 J, Earth Tech, Conversation with B, Spera M, - regarding phone Inc Bob Schaaf. Earth Tech, Inc call DP- ML0634702 Parker A, - E-MAIL: (PD) Audit 5/11/2006 E-Mail, Note Provenzano S, Draft of 10 01-16 64 Earth Tech, Notes. - Earth Tech, recommendations Inc. Inc. from meeting DP- ML0634604 Provenzano E-MAIL: (PD) Re: 5/15/2006 E-Mail Parker A, - Comments on site 10 01-17 88 S, - Earth Audit Notes. Earth Tech, audit Tech, Inc. Inc.

DP- ML0634700 Provenzano (PD) Additional 5/15/2006 - No , Contains internal 2 01-18 46 S, Earth question for Entergy Document staff Tech, Inc 5/15/06. Type Applies recommendation DP- ML0634702 Provenzano E-MAIL: (PD) PNPS 5/15/2006 E-Mail Szeligowski J, - Comments on site 2 01-19 13 S, Earth Site Audit Notes Earth Tech, audit Tech, Inc [from S. Inc.

Provenzano].

DP- ML0634702 Parker A, E-MAIL: (PD) Re: 5/16/2006 E-Mail Provenzano S, Comments 10 01-20 16 NRC PNPS Site Audit Earth Tech, Inc regarding site audit Notes.

DP- ML0634700 , NRC (PD) Pilgrim License 5/16/2006 Meeting , Comments from 6 01-21 59 Renewal Meeting Summary meeting with NMFS May 16, 2006.

DP- ML0634702 Flynn C, NRC E-MAIL: (PD) Re: 8/4/2006 E-Mail Duda S, Comments and 1 01-22 83 Pilgrim human Provenzano S, recommendations health/epidemiology Earth Tech, Inc re: SEIS studies.

Page 4 of 17

PDP Accession Author Title/Description: Document Document Addressee / Comment Page No. Number Name/ Date Type Addressee Count Affiliation: Affiliation DP- ML0634503 Duda S, E-MAIL: (PD) RE: 8/7/2006 E-Mail Nash H L, NRC Comments and 3 01-23 83 Earth Tech, EFH outline. recommendations Inc re: SEIS DP- ML0634503 Nash H L, E-MAIL: (PD) RE: 8/10/2006 E-Mail Duda S, Earth Comments and 3 01-24 85 NRC EFH outline [from H. Tech, Inc recommendations Nash]. re: SEIS DP- ML0634702 Flynn C, - E-MAIL: (PD) Re: 8/29/2006 E-Mail Craig N, Earth Comments and 1 01-25 24 Earth Tech, NRC Section [sent Tech, Inc recommendations Inc. 8/29/06]. re: SEIS DP- ML0634702 Flynn C, - E-MAIL: (PD) Re: 8/29/2006 E-Mail Craig N, Earth Comments and 1 01-26 20 Earth Tech, NRC Review [sent Tech, Inc recommendations Inc. 8/29/06]. re: SEIS DP- ML0634702 Flynn C, - E-MAIL: (PD) Re: 9/1/2006 E-Mail Craig N, Earth Comments and 1 01-27 91 Earth Tech, NRC Review. Tech, Inc recommendations Inc. re: SEIS DP- ML0634703 Flynn C, - E-MAIL: (PD) Pilgrim 9/1/2006 E-Mail Craig N, Earth Comments and 1 01-28 06 Earth Tech, DEIS, new and Tech, Inc recommendations Inc. significant re: SEIS information.

DP- ML0634703 Szeligowski E-MAIL: (PD) Pilgrim 9/1/2006 Letter Duda S, Parker Comments and 1 01-29 17 J, Earth Tech, - Chapter 8. A, Provenzano recommendations Inc S, - Earth Tech, re: SEIS Inc DP- ML0634700 Fulford P, - E-MAIL: (PD) Pilgrim 9/5/2006 E-Mail Green K, Personal 3 01-30 40 No Known COF. Meyer J, Palla impressions re:

Affiliation R L, ISL, Inc, conflict of interest NRC Page 5 of 17

PDP Accession Author Title/Description: Document Document Addressee / Comment Page No. Number Name/ Date Type Addressee Count Affiliation: Affiliation DP- ML0634702 Flynn C R, E-MAIL: (PD) PNPS 9/7/2006 E-Mail Craig N, Hurley Comments and 1 01-31 84 Earth Tech, Uprate Discrepancy. B, - Earth Tech, recommendations Inc Inc re: SEIS DP- ML0634703 Flynn C, NRC E-MAIL: (PD) Re: 9/7/2006 E-Mail Craig N, Earth Comments and 2 01-32 39 NRC Section. Tech, Inc recommendations re: SEIS DP- ML0634702 Flynn C R, E-MAIL: (PD) FW: 9/7/2006 E-Mail Hurley B, Earth Comments and 1 01-33 93 Earth Tech, PNPS DEIS sections Tech, Inc recommendations Inc 4.3 and 4.8.3. re: SEIS DP- ML0634702 Flynn C R, E-MAIL: (PD) Re: 9/8/2006 E-Mail Craig N, Hurley Comments and 4 01-34 95 Earth Tech, PNPS Uprate B, Earth Tech, recommendations Inc Discrepancy. Inc, NRC re: SEIS DP- ML0634703 Flynn C R, E-MAIL: (PD) Re: 9/11/2006 E-Mail Duda S, Hurley Comments and 1 01-35 00 Earth Tech, Question on Pilgrim B, - Earth Tech, recommendations Inc Radiological Section Inc re: SEIS 2.2.7.

DP- ML0634703 Flynn C, E-MAIL: (PD) Ltr to 9/13/2006 Letter , - No Known Comments and 4 01-36 08 Earth Tech, Bob from C. Flynn of Affiliation recommendations Inc Earth Tech. re: SEIS DP- ML0634703 Flynn C, - E-mail: (PD) 9/13/2006 E-Mail Dover R, - No Comments and 2 01-37 03 Earth Tech, Southeastern Mass Known recommendations Inc. Health Study Affiliation re: SEIS (SMHS).

DP- ML0634702 Flynn C, E-MAIL: (PD) Re: 9/17/2006 E-Mail Hurley B, Earth Comments and 3 01-38 87 Earth Tech, PNPS DEIS section Tech, Inc recommendations Inc 4.3 and 4.8.3. re: SEIS Page 6 of 17

PDP Accession Author Title/Description: Document Document Addressee / Comment Page No. Number Name/ Date Type Addressee Count Affiliation: Affiliation DP- ML0634503 Duda S, E-MAIL: (PD) PNPS 10/4/2006 E-Mail Nash H L, NRC Comments and 2 01-39 86 Earth Tech, - Sect 2. recommendations Inc re: SEIS DP- ML0634503 Nash H L, E-MAIL: (PD) Re: 10/6/2006 E-Mail Duda S, Earth Comments and 2 01-40 90 NRC PNPS - impingement Tech, Inc recommendations and entrainment re: SEIS occurrences XCL.

DP- ML0634504 Duda S, E-mail: (PD) Re: 10/6/2006 E-Mail Nash H L, NRC Comments and 3 01-41 21 Earthtech, Inc PNPS - impingement recommendations and entrainment re: SEIS occurrences (from S.

Duda).

DP- ML0634503 Duda S, E-MAIL: (PD) PNPS 10/6/2006 E-Mail Nash H L, NRC Comments and 2 01-42 87 Earth Tech, - impingement and recommendations Inc entrainment re: SEIS occurances.

DP- ML0630403 Segala J P, Draft Safety 11/2/2006 Draft Safety Lund A L, Comments and 61 01-43 96 NRC/NRR/A Evaluation Report Evaluation NRC/NRR/ADR recommendations DES/DSS/SB Input for Pilgrim Report O/DLR/RLRA re: Draft SER PB Nuclear Power (DSER),

Station License Memoranda Renewal Application Sections 2.2 Plant-Level Scoping Results and 2.3 Scoping and Screening Results.

Page 7 of 17

PDP Accession Author Title/Description: Document Document Addressee / Comment Page No. Number Name/ Date Type Addressee Count Affiliation: Affiliation DP- ML0634803 Ellis D E, E-MAIL: (PD) Branch 11/2/2006 E-Mail Auluck R C, Comments and 3 01-44 57 Entergy Corp Technical Position Buckberg P H, recommendations 9.5-1 and Appendix NRC re: draft SER A for Pilgrim (Docket No. 50-293) [dated 11/2/06 from D. Ellis to P. Buckberg and R. Auluck].

DP- ML0631101 Duda S, NOTE: (NPA-PD-LR) 11/3/2006 Note , Comments and 1 01-45 40 Earth Tech, Pilgrim Exhibit F4 recommendations Inc. re: SEIS DP- ML0631101 Duda S, NOTE: (NPA-PD-LR) 11/3/2006 Note , Comments and 1 01-46 35 Earth Tech, South recommendations Inc. Massachusetts re: SEIS Health Study.

DP- ML0634502 Nash H L, E-MAIL: (PD) Re: 11/6/2006 E-Mail Dillard S, Comments and 2 01-47 92 NRC Pilgrim Sec. 4.8.2. Earthtech, Inc recommendations re: SEIS DP- ML0634804 Pappalardo E-MAIL: (PD) Re: 11/6/2006 E-Mail Williamson A R, Comments and 2 01-48 25 M, Earth Entergy Nuclear NRC recommendations Tech, Inc Cultural Resources re: draft SEIS Protection Plan.

DP- ML0634502 Franovich R E-MAIL: (PD) P2 11/6/2006 E-Mail Emch R L, Muir Comments and 2 01-49 93 L, NRC Sentence for 2.1.5, J M, Pham B recommendations Pilgrim and VY. M, Schaaf R G, re: SEIS Williamson A, NRC Page 8 of 17

PDP Accession Author Title/Description: Document Document Addressee / Comment Page No. Number Name/ Date Type Addressee Count Affiliation: Affiliation DP- ML0634502 Nash H L, E-mail (PD) Fwd: 11/7/2006 E-Mail Williamson A R, Comments and 4 01-50 96 NRC marine mammal NRC recommendations writeup. re: SEIS DP- ML0630601 Dennig R L, Request for 11/7/2006 Memoranda, Chernoff H K, Recommendations 3 01-51 89 NRC/NRR/A Additional Request for NRC/NRR/ADR re: RAI DES/DSS/SC Information - Pilgrim Additional O/DORL/LPLI-2 VB Response to Generic Information Letter (GL) 2003-01, (RAI)

Control Room Habitability (TAC No. MB9840)

DP- ML0634803 Buckberg P E-mail: (PD) Fwd: 11/7/2006 E-Mail Iqbal N, NRC Comments and 2 01-52 53 H, NRC Branch Technical recommendations Position 9.5-1 and re: draft SER Appendix A for Pilgrim (Docket No.

50-293) [dated 11/7/06 follow up to e-mail sent 11/2/06].

DP- ML0634502 Mitchell J A, E-mail: (PD) Fwd: 11/8/2006 E-Mail Lui C H, Palla Impression re: 4 01-53 89 NRC Reference to David R L, Yerokun J website Chains web site. E, NRC DP- ML0634803 Meyer G W, E-MAIL: (PD) Re: 11/8/2006 E-Mail Blough A R, Comments and 3 01-54 84 NRC Pilgrim drywell - Conte R J, recommendations onsite followup of UT Hiland P L, re: draft SER data. Lund L, OHara T L, NRC Page 9 of 17

PDP Accession Author Title/Description: Document Document Addressee / Comment Page No. Number Name/ Date Type Addressee Count Affiliation: Affiliation DP- ML0631805 Wilson G, Pilgrim Nuclear 11/8/2006 Memoranda, Lund L A, Comments and 8 01-55 00 NRC/NRR/A Power Station - Draft Safety NRC/NRR/ADR recommendations DES/DE Safety Evaluation Evaluation O/DLR/RLRA re: Draft SER Input for License Report, Draft Renewal Application Section .5 (TAC NO.

MC9669)

DP- ML0634803 Blough A R, E-MAIL: (PD) Re: 11/9/2006 E-Mail Conte R J, Comments and 4 01-56 17 NRC Pilgrim drywell - Hiland P L, recommendations onsite followup of UT Lund A L, re: draft SER data [dated 11/9 Meyer G W, from R. Blough to OHara T L, multiple recipents]. NRC DP- ML0633402 Buckberg P EMAIL: (NPA-PD- 11/9/2006 E-Mail Davis J A, Recommendation 4 01-57 38 H, NRC/NRR LR) Fwd: Re: Pilgrim NRC/NRR re: RAI Drywell - Onsite Followup of UT Data.

DP- ML0634502 Palla R L, E-MAIL: (PD) 11/9/2006 E-Mail Williamson A R, Recommendation 2 01-58 98 NRC Information Needed NRC re: RAI From Entergy for Pilgrim Contentions.

DP- ML0634503 Williamson A E-MAIL: (PD) Re: 11/13/2006 E-Mail Davis J, Emch Comments and 2 01-59 51 R, NRC Fwd: Entergy R L, NRC recommendations Nuclear Cultural re: SEIS Resources Protection Plan.

Page 10 of 17

PDP Accession Author Title/Description: Document Document Addressee / Comment Page No. Number Name/ Date Type Addressee Count Affiliation: Affiliation DP- ML0634502 Lund A L, E-MAIL: (PD) Re: 11/14/2006 E-Mail McLaughlin M Comments and 3 01-60 99 NRC Pilgrim Government M, NRC impressions re:

to Government meeting with local Debrief. government DP- ML0634503 Muir J M, E-MAIL: (PD) Sct 11/14/2006 E-Mail Williamson A R, Comments and 2 01-61 01 NRC/NRR/A 2.1.5 paragraph. NRC recommendations DRO/DLR/RE re: SEIS BA DP- ML0633403 Cwalina G C, Y020060252 - Tom 11/16/2006 E-Mail Gurdziel T, Impressions and 2 01-62 20 NRC/NRR/A Gurdziel Email re. NRC/NRR comments from DES Concerns Deficiency phone in the GE-Designed conversation Upper Support for Reactor Cores Shroud Tie Rods DP- ML0634503 Kotzalas M A, E-MAIL: (PD) Pilgrim 11/17/2006 E-Mail Williamson A R, Recommendations 2 01-63 40 NRC - meteorological NRC re: conference call assistance.

DP- ML0634503 Kotzalas M A, E-MAIL: (PD) Re: 11/17/2006 E-Mail Brown L A, Recommendations 2 01-64 43 NRC Fwd: 2006/11/16-LB Williamson A R, re: conference call Order (Administrative NRC Matters Regarding Telephone Conference) [from M.

Kotzalas].

Page 11 of 17

PDP Accession Author Title/Description: Document Document Addressee / Comment Page No. Number Name/ Date Type Addressee Count Affiliation: Affiliation DP- ML0634503 Williamson A E-MAIL: (PD) Re: 11/17/2006 E-Mail Brown L A, Recommendations 2 01-65 55 R, NRC Fwd: 2006/11/16-LB Kotzalas M A, re: conference call Order (Administrative NRC Matters Regarding Telephone Conference.

DP- ML0634502 Adams S A, E-MAIL: (PD) Draft 11/20/2006 E-Mail, , Sandia Draft statement of 10 01-66 90 NRC/NRR/P Statement of Work. Statement of National Labs work with MAS/PCMB Work (SNL) comments DP- ML0634503 Williamson A E-MAIL: (PD) PNPS 11/21/2006 E-Mail Brock K M, Comments and 2 01-67 58 R, NRC SAMA Contention. Brown L A, recommendations Greene N A, re: SEIS Mitchell J A, Rikhoff J J, NRC DP- ML0634803 Sydnor C R, E-MAIL: (PD) FYI: 11/21/2006 E-Mail Buckberg P H, Comments and 3 01-68 34 NRC Pilgrim LRA - Cheruvenki G recommendations Postponement of SE S, Diaz-Castillo re: draft SER on TLAAs pending Y, Mitchell M A, resolution of fluence NRC method/benchmarkin g.

DP- ML0634503 Williamson A E-MAIL: (PD) Pilgrim 11/22/2006 E-Mail Sheehan N A, Comments on draft 4 01-69 62 R, NRC Draft SEIS Press NRC SEIS press release Release.

Page 12 of 17

PDP Accession Author Title/Description: Document Document Addressee / Comment Page No. Number Name/ Date Type Addressee Count Affiliation: Affiliation DP- ML0633402 Wen P C, EMAIL: (NPA-PD- 11/22/2006 E-Mail McCaughey B, Comments and 3 01-70 40 NRC/NRR LR) BWRVIP-139 Advanced recommendations (Commitment #37). Technologies & on draft SER Labs International, Inc DP- ML0634803 Lambros L, E-MAIL: (PD) Re: 11/22/2006 E-Mail Buckberg P H, Comments and 3 01-71 37 NRC Fwd: FYI: Pilgrim Cheruvenki G recommendations LRA - Postponement S, Shea J J, re: draft SER of SE on TLAAs NRC pending resolution of fluence method/benchmarkin g.

DP- ML0634503 Palla R L, E-MAIL: (PD) 11/27/2006 E-Mail Williamson A R, Comments and 2 01-72 46 NRC Meeting re: NRC recommendations Contentions. re: SEIS DP- ML0633403 Khanna M K, Y020060252 - 11/27/2006 E-Mail Eusebio L, Comments and 4 01-73 28 NRC Concerns Deficiency NRC recommendations in the GE-Designed re: draft SER Upper Support for Reactor Cores Shroud Tie Rods (Email from Meena Khanna, Dated 11/27/2006, RE:

Y020060252, Letter from Tom Grudziel to Michael Wallace).

Page 13 of 17

PDP Accession Author Title/Description: Document Document Addressee / Comment Page No. Number Name/ Date Type Addressee Count Affiliation: Affiliation DP- ML0634803 Cheruvenki G E-MAIL: (PD) Pilgrim 11/27/2006 E-Mail Buckberg P H, Comments and 3 01-74 43 S, NRC - LRA. NRC recommendations re: draft SER DP- ML0634804 Wen P C, E-mail: (PD) Re: 11/27/2006 E-Mail Buckberg P H, Comments and 3 01-75 42 NRC Pilgrim - LRA [from Cheruvenki G recommendations P. Wen]. S, NRC re: draft SER DP- ML0634804 Cheruvenki G E-MAIL: (PD) Fwd: 11/27/2006 E-Mail Buckberg P H, Comments and 2 01-76 31 S, NRC RPV internals - NRC recommendations Pilgrim. re: draft SER DP- ML0634503 Franovich R E-MAIL: (PD) Phone 11/27/2006 E-Mail Emch R L, Comments re: 2 01-77 49 L, NRC call with Garry Young Williamson A R, following up on

[from R. Franovich]. NRC phone call DP- ML0634803 Meyer G W, E-mail: (PD) Input to 11/28/2006 E-Mail Buckberg P H, Comments and 3 01-78 48 NRC Entergy Drop-in; LR Lund L A, NRC recommendations Inspection Status. re: draft SER DP- ML0634803 Cheruvenki G E-MAIL: (PD) Fwd: 11/28/2006 E-Mail Davis J A, NRC Comments and 4 01-79 11 S, NRC Pilgrim - LRA [dated recommendations 11/28/06 from G. re: draft SER Cheruvenki to J.

Davis].

DP- ML0634503 Young G G, E-MAIL: (PD) Re: 11/28/2006 E-Mail Williamson A R, Comments and 2 01-80 66 Entergy Corp Phone Call with NRC recommendations Garry Young [from re: meeting G. Young].

Page 14 of 17

PDP Accession Author Title/Description: Document Document Addressee / Comment Page No. Number Name/ Date Type Addressee Count Affiliation: Affiliation DP- ML0634503 Cheruvenki G E-MAIL: (PD) Fwd: 11/28/2006 E-Mail Davis J A, NRC Comments and 4 01-81 07 S, NRC Pilgrim - LRA [from recommendations G. Cheruvenki on re: draft SER 11/28/06].

DP- ML0634503 Franovich R E-MAIL: (PD) Re: 11/29/2006 E-Mail Williamson A R, Comments and 3 01-82 04 L, NRC SAMA RAI NRC recommendations Conference Call - re: conference call Thursday @ 2:30pm EST [from R.

Franovich].

DP- ML0634804 Cheruvenki G E-MAIL: (PD) Fwd: 11/29/2006 E-Mail Davis J D, NRC Comments and 4 01-83 37 S, NRC Pilgrim - LRA [dated recommendations 11/29/06 from G. re: draft SER Cheruvenki to J.

Davis].

DP- ML0634503 Cheruvenki G E-MAIL: (PD) Fwd: 11/29/2006 E-Mail Davis J D, NRC Comments and 6 01-84 10 S, NRC Pilgrim - LRA. recommendations re: draft SER DP- ML0634503 Wen P C, E-MAIL: (PD) Fwd: 11/29/2006 E-Mail Davis J A, NRC Comments and 5 01-85 08 NRC FW: NRC Comments recommendations on Pilgrim Draft SER re: draft SER Section 3.1.

Page 15 of 17

PDP Accession Author Title/Description: Document Document Addressee / Comment Page No. Number Name/ Date Type Addressee Count Affiliation: Affiliation DP- ML0633504 Samaddar S Safety Evaluation 11/30/2006 Memoranda, Lund L A, Comments and 22 01-86 77 K, Input Regarding Safety NRC/NRR/ADR recommendations NRC/NRR/A Section 2.4, Scoping Evaluation O/DLR/REBB re: draft SER DES/DE and Screening Results: Structures, Pilgrim Nuclear Power Station License Renewal Application (TAC MC9669).

DP- ML0634605 Williamson A E-MAIL: (PD) Re: 11/30/2006 E-Mail Franovich R L, Comments and 3 01-87 38 R, NRC SAMA RAI NRC recommendations Conference Call - re: conference call Thursday @ 2:30pm EST.

DP- ML0634503 Williamson A E-MAIL: (PD) Re: 11/30/2006 E-Mail Franovich R L, Comments and 3 01-88 63 R, NRC SAMA RAI NRC recommendations Conference Call- re: conference call Thursday @ 2:30pm EST Page 16 of 17

PDP Accession Author Title/Description: Document Document Addressee / Comment Page No. Number Name/ Date Type Addressee Count Affiliation: Affiliation DP- ML0633901 Hamzehee H Draft Safety 12/1/2006 Draft Safety Kuo P T, Comments and 38 01-89 98 G, Evaluation with Open Evaluation NRC/NRR/ADR recommendations NRC/NRR/A Items Regarding Report O/DLR re: draft SER DES/DE/EQV Entergy Nuclear (DSER),

B Operations, Inc., Memoranda License Renewal Application for Pilgrim Nuclear Power Station, dated January 27, 2006.

Page 17 of 17

December 15, 2006 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION BEFORE THE ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING BOARD In the Matter of )

)

ENTERGY NUCLEAR GENERATION ) Docket No. 50-293-LR COMPANY AND ENTERGY NUCLEAR )

OPERATIONS, INC. ) ASLBP No. 06-848-02-LR

)

(Pilgrim Nuclear Power Station) )

AFFIDAVIT OF PERRY BUCKBERG CONCERNING MANDATORY DISCLOSURE REQUIREMENT OF 10 C.F.R. § 2.336(c)

I, Perry Buckberg, do hereby state as follows:

1. I am employed as a Project Manager in the Division of License Renewal in the Nuclear Regulatory Commissions (NRC) Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation. I serve as a project manager for the Pilgrim Nuclear Power Stations license renewal application (LRA).

2. I hereby certify that all relevant materials required to be disclosed pursuant to 10 C.F.R. § 2.336 (b) and (c) in the captioned proceeding have been disclosed, and that the disclosures are accurate and complete as of the date of this certification.

3. I declare under penalty of perjury that the foregoing is true and correct to the best of my knowledge, information and belief.

/Original Signed By/

Perry Buckberg Executed in Rockville, MD this 15th day of December, 2006

December 15, 2006 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION BEFORE THE ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING BOARD In the Matter of )

)

ENTERGY NUCLEAR GENERATION ) Docket No. 50-293-LR COMPANY AND ENTERGY NUCLEAR )

OPERATIONS, INC. ) ASLBP No. 06-848-02-LR

)

(Pilgrim Nuclear Power Station) )

DECLARATION OF PAO-TSIN KUO I, Pao-Tsin Kuo, do hereby state as follows:

1. I am employed as the Acting Director of the Division of Licensing Renewal (DLR) in the Nuclear Regulatory Commissions (NRC) Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation (NRR). My supervisory responsibilities include oversight of the NRC Staffs review and evaluation of the Pilgrim Nuclear Power Station license renewal application.

2. As part of their responsibilities in preparing the hearing file and mandatory disclosures for these proceedings, NRC staff members under my supervision identified several documents as privileged because they contained information concerning the Staffs deliberative process. Those documents are listed in Attachment 2 to the December 15, 2006, submission of the Staffs Hearing File.

3. I have personally reviewed the documents identified as privileged in , and have determined, in accordance with the guidance set forth in Management Directive 3.4, that they contain predecisional information concerning the Staffs review of the license renewal application. All documents contain either the Staffs analyses, recommendations, opinions, or evaluations, and may not necessarily reflect the final agency position with respect to the matters discussed therein. Each of the documents comprises part

of the deliberative process necessary to the Staffs review of the pending license renewal application.

4. Further, I have determined that disclosure of these documents could result in harm to the agency, in that it would (a) prematurely disclose the preliminary views of individual Staff members and/or the Staff prior to reaching a final agency decision, and could thus create confusion as to the actual policy or views of the NRC Staff; (b) hinder the efficiency of the Staff, in that forced disclosure of its internal discussions on an unresolved issue would tend to chill all future deliberations and would interfere with the Staffs ability to engage in a free exchange of opinions and analyses prior to publishing its final review documents; and (c) imply or suggest incorrectly that the opinions of the Staff members involved in these communications are actually the final decisions of the agency, while no such final decision has yet been made.

5. Accordingly, I formally invoke the deliberative process privilege with respect to each of the documents listed in Attachment 2 to the December 15, 2006 submission of the Hearing File Supplement 1.

6. I declare under penalty of perjury that the foregoing is true and correct to the best of my knowledge, information and belief.

/Original Signed By/

Pao-Tsin Kuo Executed in Rockville, MD this 15th day of December, 2006

UNITED STATES OF AMERICA NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION BEFORE THE ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING BOARD In the Matter of )

)

ENTERGY NUCLEAR OPERATIONS, INC. ) Docket No. 50-293-LR

)

(Pilgrim Nuclear Power Station) ) ASLBP No. 06-848-02-LR

)

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I hereby certify that copies of the letter notifying the administrative judges and the parties that the hearing file and mandatory disclosures, privilege log, accompanying declaration, and affidavit in the above-captioned proceeding have been served on the following by electronic mail and deposit in the U.S. Mail Service or by deposit in the U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commissions internal mail system as indicated by a single asterisk(*), or by deposit in the U.S.

mail system, as indicated by a double asterisk (**) this 15th day of December, 2006.

Administrative Judge* Administrative Judge*

Richard F. Cole Paul B. Abramson Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel Mail Stop: T-3F23 Mail Stop: T-3F23 U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, DC 20555-0001 Washington, DC 20555-0001 E-mail: rfc1@nrc.gov E-mail: pba@nrc.gov Administrative Judge* Office of Commission Appellate

• Ann Marshall Young, Chair Adjudication Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel Mail Stop: O-16C1 Mail Stop: T-3F23 U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, DC 20555-0001 Washington, DC 20555-0001 E-mail: OCAAMail@nrc.gov E-mail: amy@nrc.gov Office of the Secretary*

Sheila Slocum Hollis** Attn: Rulemaking and Adjudications Staff Duane Morris LLP Mail Stop: O-16C1 1667 K Street, NW, Suite 700 U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, DC 20006 Washington, DC 20555-0001 E-mail: sshollis@duanemorris.com E-mail: hearingdocket@nrc.gov

Atomic Safety and Licensing Board* Terence A. Burke, Esq.**

Mail Stop: T-3 F23 Entergy Nuclear U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 1340 Echelon Parkway Washington, DC 20555-0001 Mail Stop: M-ECH-62 Jackson, MS 39213 Molly H. Bartlett, Esq.**

52 Crooked Lane David R. Lewis, Esq.**

Duxbury, MA 02332 Paul A. Gaukler, Esq.

E-mail: mollyhbartlett@hotmail.com Pillsbury, Winthrop, Shaw, Pittman, LLP 2300 N Street, NW Chief Kevin M. Nord** Washington, DC 20037-1137 Fire Chief & Director Duxbury Emergency E-mail: david.lewis@pillsburylaw.com Management Agency paul.gaukler@pillsburylaw.com 668 Tremont Street Duxbury, MA 02332 Town Manager**

E-mail: nord@town.duxbury.ma.us Town of Plymouth Fax: 781-934-6530 11 Lincoln St.

Plymouth, MA 02360 E-mail: msylvia@townhall.plymouth.ma.us

/RA/

David E. Roth Counsel for the NRC Staff