ML043220259
| ML043220259 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Waterford  |
| Issue date: | 11/15/2004 |
| From: | Dodds R Entergy Operations |
| To: | Document Control Desk, Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation |
| References | |
| SR-04-001-00, W3FI-2004-0109 | |
| Download: ML043220259 (25) | |
Text
Entergy Entergy Operations, Inc.
17265 River Road Kitlona La 70066 Tam cfnl 710 oAAA Ralph A. Dodds Acting Director.
Nuclear Safety Assurance Waterford-3 W3FI-2004-0109 November 15, 2004 U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Attn: Document Control Desk Washington, DC 20555
SUBJECT:
12-Month Special Report SR-04-001-00 on the 12th Refueling Steam Generator Tube Inservice Inspection Waterford Steam Electric Station, Unit 3 Docket No. 50-382 License No. NPF-38
Dear Sir or Madam:
Attached is Special Report (SR) Number SR-04-001-00 for Entergy Operations, Inc (EOI)
Waterford Steam Electric Station Unit 3. This report provides the complete results of the Refuel 12 Steam Generator Tube Inservice Inspection. This special report is being submitted in accordance with Technical Specifications 4.4.4.5.b and 6.9.2.
If you have any questions or require additional information, please contact Ron Williams at 504-739-6255.
Very truly yours, T
I RAD/RLW/ssf Attachments
- 1.
Special Report SR-04-001-00, Steam Generator Eddy Current Examination (12TH Refueling Outage)
- 2.
Location and Percent of Wall-Thickness Penetration for Each Indication I1Nr
W3Fl -2004-0109 Page 2 cc:
Dr. Bruce S. Mallett U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Region IV 611 Ryan Plaza Drive, Suite 400 Arlington, TX 76011 NRC Senior Resident Inspector Waterford 3 P.O. Box 822 Killona, LA 70066-0751 U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Attn: Mr. Nageswaran Kalyanam MS O-7D1 Washington, DC 20555-0001 Wise, Carter, Child & Caraway Attn: J. Smith P.O. Box 651 Jackson, MS 39205 Winston & Strawn Attn: N.S. Reynolds 1400 L Street, NW Washington, DC 20005-3502 Louisiana Department of Environmental Quality Office of Environmental Compliance Surveillance Division P. O. Box 4312 Baton Rouge, LA 70821-4312 American Nuclear Insurers Attn: Library Town Center Suite 300S 29th S. Main Street West Hartford, CT 06107-2445
W3Fl -2004-0109 Page 3 e-mail:
Standard Distribution bcc:
Waterford 3 Records Center Licensing Green Folder File D.J. Meatheany W.C. Greeson R.C. O'Quinn B.K. Ricker (W-GSB-1 00)
(N-GSB-62)
(N-SYS)
(W-GSB-355)
(W-GSB-355)
Attachment I W3FI -2004-0109 SPECIAL REPORT SR-04-001-00 STEAM GENERATOR EDDY CURRENT EXAMINATION (12TH REFUELING OUTAGE) to W3Fl-2004-0109 Page 1 of 5 SPECIAL REPORT SR-04-001-00 STEAM GENERATOR EDDY CURRENT EXAMINATION (12TH REFUELING OUTAGE)
1.0 INTRODUCTION
This report is submitted in accordance with Technical Specification 4.4.4.5.b. that requires the complete eddy current test results from Refuel #12 to be submitted in a special report pursuant to Technical Specification 6.9.2, within 12 months following the inspection.
The report shall include:
- 1.
Number and extent of tubes inspected.
- 2.
Location and percent of wall-thickness penetration for each indication of an imperfection.
- 3.
Identification of tubes plugged or sleeved.
The eddy current testing examination program was performed to meet and exceed the requirements of Technical Specification 3/4.4.4. Waterford 3 performed all S/G eddy current testing examinations in accordance with EPRI TR 1003138, "PWR Steam Generator Examination Guidelines Revision 6" and its Appendix H qualified techniques.
Previous reports contained additional detail as was required in the annual report in revision 0 of NEI 97-06. The current revision (Rev. 1) no longer requires this information; therefore, it has been removed from the format of the report.
2.0 Steam Generator Design The Waterford 3 Model 70 (3410 MWT) re-circulating steam generators were designed and fabricated by Nuclear Steam System Supplier Combustion Engineering (CE), Inc. in accordance with ASME Code, Section ill NB for Class I vessels. The Waterford 3 steam generators each consist of 9,350 high temperature mill annealed Inconel 600 U-tubes arranged in a one-inch inner diameter triangular pitch pattern representing 103,574 ft2 of heat transfer area. The U-tubes are 3/4" O.D. by 0.048" nominal wall thickness explosively expanded the full depth of the tubesheet (CE's Expansion Process) and welded to the primary cladding. The secondary tube bundle support structure consists of carbon steel eggcrates. The secondary supports are arranged in the following order:
seven full horizontal eggcrate supports six horizontal partial eggcrate supports two anti-vibration straps (hot and cold batwings) seven vertical straps to W3FI-2004-0109 Page 2 of 5 3.0 Inspection Results 3.1 RF12 Scope (Number and Extent Tested)
The Refuel #12 SIG eddy current testing (ECT) program consisted of the following inspection plans in Table 3.1:
Table 3.1 RF12 ECT Inspection SG#1 ECT Examination Type Inspections Conducted
% Scope Extent Tested Bobbin 8906 100 TEH to TEC RPC ET HL 8906 100
+3 to -8" of TTS Small Radius U-bends (1-2) 120 100 07H to 07C Small Radius U-bends (3-10) 102 20 07H to 07C Previous/New Dents Ž2 volt 141 N/A NA Previous/New Dings Ž5 volt 138 N/A NA Previous/New Wear 62 N/A NA Special Interest 856 N/A NA SG #2 ECT Examination Type Inspections
% Scope Extent Tested Conducted Bobbin 8916 100 TEH to TEC RPC ET HL 8916 100
+3to-8" of TTS Small Radius U-bends (1-2) 123 100 07H to 07C Small Radius U-bends (3-10) 102 20 07H to 07C Previous/New Dents 22 volt 106 N/A NA Previous/New Dings Ž5 volt 185 N/A NA Previous/New Wear 89 N/A NA Special Interest 328 N/A NA NOTE: The U-Bend Low Row (1-10) region of the respective tubes In each SIG were examined with "+Pt." and straight sections inspected with bobbin coil.
3.2 Tube Integrity Acceptable tube integrity was demonstrated at the end of cycle 12 and condition monitoring requirements on burst pressure (3ANOP) and accident leakage rates were satisfied for all forms of degradation mechanisms identified during the Refuel #12 S/G eddy current testing.
All indications identified were well below their associated structural limits.
The Waterford 3 Refuel #12 Condition Monitoring Report was to W3FI -2004-0109 Page 3 of 5 documented via Westinghouse Document SG-SGDA-03-52, 'Waterford 3 RF12 Condition Monitoring Report and Interim Operational Assessment."
As part of Waterford 3's adherence to perform In-Situ Screening in accordance with EPRI, TR-107620, 'Steam Generator In-Situ Pressure Test Guidelines", Rev. 1, all indications identified were screened with one test required.
In-situ pressure testing was performed on the flaw that exceeded the screening criteria. The flaw was taken to main steam line break (MSLB) pressure with zero leakage. The tube R75-C91 is located in SG#2.
The condition was entered into Entergy's corrective action program.
4.0 Location and Percent of Wall-Thickness Penetration for Each Indication of an Imperfection This data is summarized in Attachment 2. The only flaws sized and left in service are for wear.
5.0 Percentage of Tubes Plugged or Sleeved Table 5.1 list the repairs made in RF12 and the cumulative repairs to date:
Table 5.1 Tubes Repaired to Date SG #1 SG #1 SG #2 SG #2 Plugs
% Plugged Plugs
% Plugged Prior to RF12 444 4.75 %
434 4.64 %
/
RF12 127 N/A 50 N/A Total 571 6.11%
484 5.18 %
Sleeved Tubes 0
N/A 0
N/A On November 7, 2003 Waterford 3 successfully completed all S/G eddy current examinations and plugging activities. Additionally, Waterford 3 performed visual inspection of the S/G tubesheets for evidence of leaking tube plugs. As a result of the tubesheet scans, Waterford 3 did not identify any leaking tube plugs. The S/G primary side manways were closed on November 14, 2003 to complete the RF#12 inspection.
The following Tables 5.2 and 5.3 list the tubes plugged during RF12 outage in SG #1 and SG #2, respectively.
to W3Fl -2004-0109 Page 4 of 5 List of Tubes Plugged During Waterford 3's RF12 Outage Table 5.2 Steam Generator #1 Tube Tube Tube Count Row Column Count Row Column Count Row Column 1
3 1
44 5
63 87 128 114 2
5 1
45 141 63 88 55 115 3
16 2
46 38 64 89 46 116 4
27 3
47 50 68 90 35 117 5
18 6
48 69 69 91 38 118 6
20 14 49 74 70 92 68 118 7
11 15 50 72 74 93 72 118 8
21 15 51 66 76 94 74 118 9
79 15 52 90 78 95 35 119 10 16 16 53 99 79 96 67 119 11 44 18 54 61 81 97 38 120 12 6
22 55 58 82 98 44 120 13 18 22 56 111 83 99 72 120 14 98 24 57 57 87 100 37 121 15 82 26 58 72 88 101 49 121 16 47 29 59 57 89 102 26 122 17 76 30 60 59 89 103 30 122 18 30 38 61 63 89 104 88 122 19 7
39 62 68 90 105 133 123 20 60 40 63 90 90 106 100 124 21 22 42 64 66 92 107 43 125 22 32 46 65 128 92 108 20 126 23 44 46 66 142 94 109 15 127 24 37 47 67 68 96 110 51 127 25 42 48 68 86 96 111 45 129 26 41 49 69 63 97 112 129 129 27 36 50 70 73 97 113 22 130 28 58 50 71 99 103 114 38 130 29 78 50 72 53 105 115 68 132 30 48 54 73 87 105 116 125 133 31 39 55 74 89 105 117 9
135 32 49 55 75 58 106 118 18 136 33 75 55 76 82 106 119 42 136 34 38 56 77 84 106 120 12 138 35 46 56 78 142 106 121 37 141 36 48 56 79 38 108 122 70 142 37 47 57 80 58 108 123 17 145 38 138 58 81 37 109 124 20 146 39 29 59 82 47 109 125 101 151 40 43 61 83 15 111 126 16 160 41 139 61 84 132 112 127 76 160 42 30 62 85 17 113 43 140 62 86 127 113 to W3Fl -2004-0109 Page 5 of 5 List of Tubes Plugged During Waterford 3's RF12 Outage Table 5.3 Steam Generator #2 Tube Tube Tube Count Row Column Count Row Column Count Row Column 1
48 6
18 19 35 35 65 111 2
1 155 19 19 37 36 73 67 3
4 126 20 21 123 37 75 91 4
6 162 21 21 129 38 75 113 5
9 51 22 25 117 39 78 120 6
10 20 23 27 33 40 83 119 7
10 24 24 27 39 41 89 39 8
10 160 25 29 35 42 90 52 9
11 29 26 29 51 43 91 53 10 12 14 27 34 130 44 93 23 11 12 156 28 37 51 45 107 65 12 15 113 29 42 140 46 107 93 13 16 18 30 45 35 47 108 92 14 16 160 31 53 101 48 117 109 15 16 166 32 54 88 49 122 110 16 19 27 33 56 88 50 135 57 17 19 33 34 58 50 W3FI -2004-0109 Location and Percent of Wall-Thickness Penetration for Each Indication to W3Fl -2004-0109 Page 1 of 15 Percent of Wall-Thickness Penetrations for SIG #1 - RF1 2 Row Column Indication
% TW Support Location 62 10 PCT 21 BW5
-0.73 67 11 PCT 22 BW5 0.98 59 13 PCT 9
BW6 0.72 38 14 PCT 19 BW5 0
74 14 PCT 16 BW1
-1.73 74 14 PCT 22 BW4 0.78 19 15 PCT 21 BW5
-0.84 19 15 PCT 15 BW5 0.75 61 15 PCT 11 BW5
-0.82 61 15 PCT 9
BW5 0.94 61 15 PCT 21 BW6
-0.68 61 15 PCT 10 BW6 1.01 36 16 PCT 21 BW5 0.95 64 16 PCT 20 BW4
-0.76 64 16 PCT 25 BW5
-0.84 64 16 PCT 18 BW5 0.7 36 18 PCT 12 BW5
-1 62 18 PCT 22 BW4 0.84 66 18 PCT 23 BW5
-0.72 82 18 PCT 22 BW4 0.9 73 19 PCT 6
BW4 0.85 42 20 PCT 11 BW5
-0.8 62 20 PCT 14 BW4
-0.76 62 20 PCT 22 BW4 0.76 76 20 PCT 20 BW6 0.87 82 20 PCT 19 BW6
-0.81 55 21 PCT 18 BW6 0.75 81 21 PCT 12 08C 0.78 6
22 PCT 29 TSH 0.11 32 22 PCT 12 BW5
-0.82 78 22 PCT 16 BW5 0.66 78 22 PCT 18 BW6 1.05 70 24 PCT 23 BW5
-0.74 70 24 PCT 21 BW6 0.94 19 27 PCT 17 BW5 0.74 61 27 PCT 11 BW4 0.71 67 27 PCT 10 BW5 0.78 69 27 PCT 9
BW5 1.1 71 27 PCT 9
BW4
-0.73 77 27 PCT 8
BW4
-0.82 77 27 PCT 12 BW5
-0.74 77 27 PCT 10 BW5 0.87 77 27 PCT 17 BW6
-0.87 77 27 PCT 10 BW6 0.93 87 27 PCT 10 BW7
-0.65 83 29 PCT 5
BW5
-0.2 to W3FI-2004-01 09 Page 2 of 15 Percent of Wall-Thickness Penetrations for SIG #1 - RF1 2 87 87 105 107 100 114 61 61 77 105 59 76 80 80 80 82 82 21 51 109 113 42 50 110 114 37 39 87 70 88 102 104 110 116 120 120 105 110 37 105 127 44 44 67 88 45 59 31 PCT 31 PCT 31 PCT 31 PCT 32 PCT 34 PCT 35 PCT 35 PCT 35 PCT 35 PCT 37 PCT 38 PCT 38 PCT 38 PCT 38 PCT 38 PCT 38 PCT 39 PCT 39 PCT 39 PCT 39 PCT 40 PCT 40 PCT 40 PCT 40 PCT 41 PCT 41 PCT 41 PCT 42 PCT 42 PCT 42 PCT 42 PCT 42 PCT 42 PCT 42 PCT 42 PCT 43 PCT 44 PCT 45 PCT 45 PCT 45 PCT 46 PCT 46 PCT 47 PCT 48 PCT 49 PCT 49 PCT 15 BW3 23 BW3 9
BW7 12 BW7 18 09H 18 BW9 11 BW5 10 BW6 7
BW5 23 BW5 21 BW6 18 BW5 19 BW4 17 BW5 27 BW6 23 BW5 35 BW6 9
BW5 15 BW6 9
BW5 12 BW7 9
BW5 15 BW5 16 BW7 15 BW6 17 BW5 29 BW5 16 BW9 17 BW6 20 BW3 26 BW3 16 BW3 25 BW3 20 BW6 18 BW3 24 BW3 13 BW3 18 BW3 16 BW5 9
BW7 17 BW8 20 BW5 16 BW5 8
BW6 22 BW3 19 BW5 10 BW5 0.71 0.75
-0.72
-0.78
-0.96 1.71 0.85 0.67
-0.98 0.99
-1.1
-0.95 0.81
-0.87
-0.98
-0.89
-1.01 0.68 0.82
-0.75 0.97 0.92
-0.96
-0.82
-0.82
-0.92
-0.7 1.98 0.92
-0.62
-0.79
-0.75 0.64
-0.79
-0.7 0.83 0.85 0.82 0.98 0.62 0.66
-0.81 0.75
-0.42
-0.71 0.75 0.95 to W3FI-2004-01 09 Page 3 of 15 Percent of Wall-Thickness Penetrations for SIG #1 - RF12 120 131 46 43 105 117 82 82 82 19 57 24 50 50 50 126 23 51 28 68 76 96 96 29 85 129 24 30 32 38 138 81 26 82 19 61 63 63 46 43 81 137 44 48 50 25 31 50 PCT 51 PCT 52 PCT 53 PCT 53 PCT 53 PCT 54 PCT 54 PCT 54 PCT 55 PCT 55 PCT 56 PCT 56 PCT 56 PCT 56 PCT 56 PCT 57 PCT 57 PCT 58 PCT 58 PCT 58 PCT 58 PCT 58 PCT 59 PCT 59 PCT 59 PCT 60 PCT 60 PCT 60 PCT 60 PCT 60 PCT 61 PCT 62 PCT 62 PCT 63 PCT 63 PCT 63 PCT 63 PCT 64 PCT 65 PCT 65 PCT 65 PCT 66 PCT 66 PCT 66 PCT 67 PCT 67 PCT 19 BW2 7
08C 15 BW5 22 BW5 17 BW3 11 BW3 16 BW5 27 BW5 16 BW6 18 BW5 17 BW4 8
BW5 11 BW5 15 BW5 14 BW5 18 BW2 18 BW5 14 BW4 8
BW5 18 BW5 17 BW6 17 BW3 14 BW3 18 BW5 18 BW4 16 BW3 10 BW5 14 BW5 8
BW5 6
BW5 14 09H 25 BW4 10 BW9 10 BW4 10 BW5 11 BW5 8
BW5 9
BW6 23 BW5 24 BW5 21 BW4 11 BW4 16 BW5 16 BW5 26 BW5 18 BW5 21 BW5 0.74 0.67 0.75 0.78
-1.07
-0.73
-0.7 1.1
-0.73 0.97 0.87
-0.81
-0.84 0.76 0.86 0.75 0.65 0.8
-0.71
-0.81
-0.77
-0.62 0.94
-0.75 0
-0.45
-0.84 0.68 0.84 1.01
-1 0.75
-1.98
-0.89 0.76 1.12 1.32 1.05
-0.87
-0.9
-0.68 0.73 0.72
-0.81
-0.8
-1.11 0.87 to W3Fl -2004-0109 Page 4 of 15 Percent of Wall-Thickness Penetrations for SIG #1 - RF12 51 51 24 56 114 46 100 100 48 48 48 126 144 105 105 145 48 48 48 108 116 116 97 97 101 98 102 118 146 51 105 123 133 133 133 68 136 146 49 61 78 78 146 83 107 82 53 67 PCT 67 PCT 68 PCT 68 PCT 68 PCT 70 PCT 70 PCT 70 PCT 72 PCT 72 PCT 72 PCT 72 PCT 72 PCT 73 PCT 73 PCT 73 PCT 74 PCT 74 PCT 74 PCT 74 PCT 74 PCT 74 PCT 75 PCT 75 PCT 75 PCT 76 PCT 76 PCT 76 PCT 76 PCT 77 PCT 77 PCT 77 PCT 77 PCT 77 PCT 77 PCT 78 PCT 78 PCT 78 PCT 79 PCT 79 PCT 80 PCT 80 PCT 80 PCT 81 PCT 81 PCT 82 PCT 83 PCT 32 BW4 22 BW5 12 BW9 18 BW4 9
BW1 21 BW5 11 BW3 7
BW6 25 BW5 21 BW5 18 BW5 9
BW3 6
BW9 11 BW4 18 BW5 26 BW1 12 BW5 13 BW5 14 BW5 12 BW3 10 BW2 12 BW3 20 BW3 15 BW7 15 BW3 14 BW3 13 BW3 12 BW4 23 BWi 27 BW4 14 BW7 10 BW6 14 BW2 16 BW3 16 BW4 25 BW6 10 BW2 19 BW4 25 BW9 8
BW5 9
BW5 7
BW6 30 BW1 13 BW3 20 BW3 18 BW5 14 BW9 0.84
-0.78 1.52
-0.65
-1.59 0.73
-0.81
-0.71
-0.8 0.06 0.89 0.97 1.96 0.91 0.86 0.84
-0.79
-0.03 0.8
-0.9 0.99 0.99
-0.94
-0.79 0.76
-0.64 0.76 0.77 1.5 0.92 0.95
-0.65
-0.69
-0.61
-0.58 0.99
-1.18 1.07
-1.61 0.82
-0.61 1.02
-1.73 0.93 0.88 0.88
-1.33 to W3FI-2004-01 09 Page 5 of 15 Percent of Wall-Thickness Penetrations for SIG #1 - RF12 53 83 PCT 26 BW9 1.59 55 83 PCT 19 BW9 2.14 67 83 PCT 14 BW9 1
147 83 PCT 15 06C
-0.2 62 84 PCT 14 BW9
-1.91 62 84 PCT 10 BW9 1.89 82 84 PCT 9
BW6
-0.95 82 84 PCT 10 BW6 0.98 73 85 PCT 15 BW9
-1.98 81 85 PCT 8
BW9 1.75 141 85 PCT 31 BW3
-0.96 147 85 PCT 17 09H 0
54 86 PCT 30 BW9
-1.7 56 86 PCT 20 BW9 1.89 58 86 PCT 32 BW9 1.66 60 86 PCT 32 BW9 1.61 62 86 PCT 32 BW9 1.71 80 86 PCT 12 BW9
-1.65 82 86 PCT 16 BW9 0.21 53 87 PCT 27 BW9
-1.93 64 88 PCT 24 BW9
-1.63 72 88 PCT 20 BW9
-1.71 146 88 PCT 19 BW1 1.51 146 88 PCT 7
BW9 1.59 147 89 PCT 19 BW1
-2.13 126 90 PCT 7
BW2 0.71 147 91 PCT 9
BW9 1.9 54 92 PCT 20 08H 0.37 130 94 PCT 4
BW2
-0.82 142 94 PCT 11 BW2 0.9 121 95 PCT 16 BW3 1
145 95 PCT 10 BW9
-2 76 96 PCT 18 BW5
-0.98 82 96 PCT 18 BW5
-0.82 90 96 PCT 12 BW3
-0.89 83 97 PCT 12 BW5
-0.86 83 97 PCT 11 BW6
-0.85 83 97 PCT 7
BW6 0.85 127 97 PCT 20 BW8 0.76 78 98 PCT 21 BW6 0.73 106 98 PCT 8
BW7 0.84 49 99 PCT 19 BWi 1.96 78 100 PCT 21 BW5
-0.74 78 100 PCT 24 BW6 0.96 146 100 PCT 15 BW9
-1.72 145 101 PCT 12 BW1 1.69 145 103 PCT 19 BW1 2.07 to W3Fl -2004-0109 Page 6 of 15 Percent of Wall-Thickness Penetrations for S/G #1 - RF12 145 103 PCT 14 BW2
-0.26 145 103 PCT 25 BW8 0.76 145 103 PCT 14 BW9
-1.74 45 105 PCT 18 BW5
-1 45 105 PCT 9
BW5 0.08 45 105 PCT 13 BW5 0.08 125 105 PCT 7
BW9 1.89 107 107 PCT 16 BW6 0.87 107 107 PCT 17 BW7 0.84 117 107 PCT 20 BW7 0.83 24 108 PCT 29 BW5 0.91 42 108 PCT 23 BW5
-0.57 42 108 PCT 9
BW5 0.65 58 108 PCT 11 BW5
-0.88 78 108 PCT 17 BW4
-0.58 78 108 PCT 13 BW5
-0.7 78 108 PCT 9
BW6
-1.01 39 111 PCT 11 BW5 0.94 61 111 PCT 13 BW4 0.78 139 111 PCT 13 BW2
-0.83 22 112 PCT 11 BW5 0.79 42 112 PCT 10 BW5
-0.89 42 112 PCT 9
BW5 0.98 141 113 PCT 11 BW9
-1.95 56 114 PCT 8
BW5
-0.89 56 114 PCT 8
BW5 0.78 45 115 PCT 22 BW1 0.9 45 115 PCT 19 BW5
-0.63 49 115 PCT 18 BW5
-0.69 53 115 PCT 19 BW5 0.81 61 115 PCT 10 BW4 0.77 91 115 PCT 9
BW9 0.47 132 116 PCT 17 BW7
-0.84 99 117 PCT 20 BW4
-0.85 61 119 PCT 8
BW4 0.7 135 119 PCT 30 BW2
-0.78 135 119 PCT 23 BW2 0.68 135 119 PCT 23 BW3 0.81 135 119 PCT 26 BW4
-0.84 135 119 PCT 23 BW4 1.03 135 119 PCT 14 BW7
-0.89 137 119 PCT 9
BW2
-0.47 50 120 PCT 7
BW5 0.9 54 120 PCT 7
BW5
-0.94 54 120 PCT 7
BW5 0.81 72 120 PCT 24 BW4 0.92 133 121 PCT 21 BW2
-0.83 to W3Fl -2004-0109 Page 7 of 15 Percent of Wall-Thickness Penetrations for SIG #1 - RF12 133 121 PCT 31 BW2 0.77 133 121 PCT 17 BW3
-0.5 74 124 PCT 27 BW5
-0.87 74 124 PCT 14 BW5 0.97 74 124 PCT 18 BW6
-0.82 133 125 PCT 10 07C
-1 72 126 PCT 17 BW4
-0.83 72 126 PCT 25 BW4 0.98 72 126 PCT 17 BW5
-1.16 72 126 PCT 13 BW5 0.15 72 126 PCT 12 BW6 0.99 82 126 PCT 14 BW6 0.87 61 127 PCT 8
BW4 0.79 123 127 PCT 20 BW2 0.75 127 127 PCT 19 BW3 0.77 131 127 PCT 10 07H 0.77 76 128 PCT 13 BW4 0.6 76 128 PCT 13 BW5
-0.8 76 128 PCT 9
BW5 1.06 76 128 PCT 12 BW6
-0.78 76 128 PCT 24 BW6 0.85 127 129 PCT 10 BW2
-0.69 50 134 PCT 9
BW5
-0.8 59 135 PCT 17 BW5
-0.95 55 137 PCT 19 BW4 0.7 55 137 PCT 17 BW5 0.8 63 137 PCT 24 BW5
-0.97 79 137 PCT 18 BW4 0.78 82 138 PCT 9
BW4
-0.78 82 138 PCT 9
BW4 0.9 82 138 PCT 12 BW5 0.69 82 138 PCT 22 BW6 1.04 57 139 PCT 17 BW4 0.64 61 139 PCT 18 BW4 0.82 67 139 PCT 10 08C 0.74 76 140 PCT 22 BW6 0.98 82 140 PCT 12 BW4 0.89 82 140 PCT 23 BW6
-0.92 82 140 PCT 9
BW6 0.98 78 142 PCT 12 BW4
-0.73 78 142 PCT 10 BW5 0.14 78 142 PCT 12 BW6
-0.81 82 142 PCT 17 BW6
-0.85 48 144 PCT 26 BW5
-0.88 48 144 PCT 11 BW5 0.71 74 144 PCT 7
BWi
-1.29 74 144 PCT 9
BW5 0.81 to W3FI-2004-01 09 Page 8 of 15 Percent of Wall-Thickness Penetrations for SIG #1 - RF12 74 144 PCT 11 BW6 0.89 78 144 PCT 24 BW4
-0.92 78 144 PCT 16 BW4 0.78 78 144 PCT 9
BW5
-0.75 78 144 PCT 11 BW5 0.34 78 144 PCT 9
BW6
-0.78 78 144 PCT 22 BW6 0.98 104 144 PCT 10 BW3
-0.89 95 145 PCT 9
09C 0.72 100 146 PCT 8
BW4
-0.73 100 146 PCT 7
BW6
-0.7 100 146 PCT 8
BW6 0.87 104 146 PCT 9
BW3
-0.83 57 147 PCT 21 BW5 0.41 81 147 PCT 21 BW6 0.87 81 149 PCT 21 08C 0.8 83 149 PCT 23 BW7 0.64 44 156 PCT 12 BW5 0.62 81 159 PCT 18 BW9
-2 19 167 PCT 25 BW5 0.76 40 168 PCT 12 BW5 0.76 19 171 PCT 14 BW5
-0.93 to W3Fl -2004-0109 Page 9 of 15 Percent of Wall-Thickness Penetrations for SIG #2 - RF12 Row Column Indication
% TW Support Location 1
45 PCT 14 04C
-0.28 1
53 PCT 13 04C
-0.92 1
175 PCT 9
01H 0.08 3
113 PCT 12 06C 0.2 3
175 PCT 6
01H
-0.83 11 175 PCT 20 BW1 1.4 14 164 PCT 21 04C
-0.33 18 174 PCT 21 02C
-0.83 19 3
PCT 27 BW5 0.81 19 25 PCT 30 BW5
-0.86 19 25 PCT 19 BW5 1
19 65 PCT 28 BW5
-0.87 19 111 PCT 19 BW5 0.94 19 113 PCT 12 BW5
-0.8 19 113 PCT 9
BW5 0.9 19 117 PCT 20 BW5
-0.96 21 109 PCT 22 BW5 0.78 22 44 PCT 9
BW5
-1 22 68 PCT 22 BW9 1.38 23 15 PCT 8
BW5
-0.82 23 27 PCT 18 BW5
-0.91 24 56 PCT 10 BW5
-0.9 24 110 PCT 12 BW5
-0.99 27 137 PCT 18 BW1
-0.76 29 69 PCT 16 BW9
-1.5 32 112 PCT 15 BW5 0.82 33 15 PCT 13 BW5
-0.76 34 144 PCT 18 BW5
-0.86 34 170 PCT 15 BW5 0.84 35 17 PCT 15 BW5
-0.83 35 37 PCT 14 BW5
-0.93 35 53 PCT 15 BW5
-0.86 35 53 PCT 12 BW5 0.92 36 4
PCT 10 BW5
-0.78 36 54 PCT 14 BW5
-0.69 37 65 PCT 12 BW5
-0.67 37 125 PCT 18 BW5
-0.8 37 141 PCT 17 BW5
-0.85 37 155 PCT 25 BW5
-0.84 37 157 PCT 22 BW5
-0.72 37 157 PCT 14 BW5 0.91 40 108 PCT 26 BW5
-0.8 40 108 PCT 25 BW5 0.86 40 154 PCT 19 BW5 0.91 41 9
PCT 13 BW5
-0.29 41 39 PCT 19 BW5 0.95 to W3Fl-2004-0109 Page 10 of 15 Percent of Wall-Thickness Penetrations for S/G #2 - RF12 41 69 41 107 41 107 41 111 41 127 41 139 41 149 41 167 42 108 42 108 43 37 43 37 43 69 43 69 43 149 44 16 44 16 44 40 44 40 44 48 44 50 44 52 44 52 45 69 45 145 45 145 45 167 46 6
46 32 46 40 46 52 46 52 46 64 46 68 46 68 47 51 47 143 47 147 47 147 48 18 48 18 48 30 48 46 48 52 48 52 48 70 48 70 PCT PCT PCT PCT PCT PCT PCT PCT PCT PCT PCT PCT PCT PCT PCT PCT PCT PCT PCT PCT PCT PCT PCT PCT PCT PCT PCT PCT PCT PCT PCT PCT PCT PCT PCT PCT PCT PCT PCT PCT PCT PCT PCT PCT PCT PCT PCT 20 BW9 24 BW5 16 BW5 19 BW5 20 BW5 15 BW5 27 BW5 20 BW5 12 BW5 16 BW5 25 BW5 23 BW5 23 BW5 34 BW5 18 BW5 32 BW5 13 BW5 16 BW5 14 BW5 15 BW5 16 BW5 17 BW5 11 BW5 19 BW9 28 BW5 21 BW5 26 BW5 22 BW5 19 BW5 12 BW5 18 BW5 12 BW5 34 BW5 21 BW5 28 BW5 17 BW5 32 BW5 17 BW5 22 BW5 39 BW5 20 BW5 13 BW5 13 BW5 13 BW5 5
BW5 22 BW5 15 BW5
-1.96
-0.7 0.15 0.93 0.83 0.92 0.79 0.9
-0.57 0.84
-0.72 0.87
-0.77 0.86 0.86
-0.76 0.83
-0.7 0.86 0.94
-0.57
-0.72 0.87
-1.57
-0.93 0.6
-0.64
-0.81
-0.8 0.82
-0.61 0.82 0.94
-0.67 0.88 0.91 0.85
-0.61 0.7
-0.71 0.95
-0.78
-0.92
-0.6 0.84
-0.67 1.1 to W3Fl -2004-0109 Page 11 of 15 Percent of Wall-Thickness Penetrations for SIG #2 - RF1 2 48 128 PCT 34 BW5 0.21 48 128 PCT 36 BW5 0.82 49 149 PCT 25 BW5 0.84 50 142 PCT 20 BW5
-0.74 52 34 PCT 11 BW6
-1.04 52 164 PCT 18 BW9 1.35 53 95 PCT 27 BW1
-1.64 54 84 PCT 27 BW1
-2.08 54 88 PCT 39 BW9 1.97 54 94 PCT 32 BW9 1.69 55 85 PCT 24 BW9 1.79 56 88 PCT 42 BW9 1.7 59 35 PCT 32 BW6 0.7 60 42 PCT 14 BW4 0.77 60 58 PCT 16 BW6 0.67 64 154 PCT 16 BW6
-0.85 65 85 PCT 24 BW9 1.83 65 127 PCT 18 BW4
-0.66 66 50 PCT 25 BW9 1.4 66 96 PCT 17 BW1 2
66 156 PCT 13 08C
-0.15 67 85 PCT 27 BW9 1.99 68 144 PCT 18 BW4
-0.65 69 25 PCT 21 BW6 1.08 69 35 PCT 12 BW5 0.97 69 85 PCT 32 BW9
-1.61 70 56 PCT 14 BW5 0.91 70 138 PCT 10 BW5 0.48 70 160 PCT 18 08C 0.8 71 159 PCT 12 BW4
-0.78 72 104 PCT 18 BW5 0.9 73 53 PCT 10 BW5
-0.92 73 53 PCT 16 BW5 0.84 73 53 PCT 26 BW6
-0.69 73 53 PCT 20 BW6 0.81 73 57 PCT 30 BW6 0.89 74 20 PCT 19 BW9 2.67 74 48 PCT 26 BW4 0.85 74 48 PCT 35 BW5 0.9 74 48 PCT 20 BW6 0.85 74 118 PCT 26 BW4
-0.83 74 118 PCT 27 BW5
-0.77 74 118 PCT 14 BW6 0.9 76 24 PCT 13 BW4
-0.76 76 24 PCT 15 BW5
-0.82 76 24 PCT 12 BW6 1.08 76 156 PCT 12 BW4 0.83 to W3FI -2004-0109 Page 12 of 15 Percent of Wall-Thickness Penetrations for SIG #2 - RF12 77 37 PCT 17 BW4
-0.88 77 37 PCT 21 BW4 0.85 77 37 PCT 19 BW5
-0.91 77 37 PCT 23 BW5 0.72 77 47 PCT 13 BW4
-0.83 77 49 PCT 11 BW5 1.01 77 51 PCT 22 BW4
-0.85 77 57 PCT 22 BW5
-0.91 77 61 PCT 28 BW4
-0.8 77 61 PCT 26 BW4 1.14 77 71 PCT 22 BW4 0.69 77 71 PCT 23 BW5 0.66 77 71 PCT 20 BW6 0.75 77 107 PCT 15 BW4
-0.79 77 107 PCT 18 BW5
-0.7 77 107 PCT 29 BW5 0.15 77 107 PCT 25 BW5 1.01 77 117 PCT 19 BW6
-0.7 78 20 PCT 11 BW4
-0.71 78 28 PCT 14 BW6
-0.78 78 28 PCT 10 BW9
-1.38 79 25 PCT 12 BW6 1.02 79 27 PCT 25 BW9 1.83 79 49 PCT 13 BW6
-0.48 79 139 PCT 16 08C
-0.15 80 26 PCT 13 08C
-0.92 80 28 PCT 14 BW6 0.92 80 48 PCT 34 BW5
-0.96 80 52 PCT 20 BW4 0.8 80 86 PCT 15 BW9
-1.48 80 150 PCT 14 08H 1.04 81 21 PCT 20 BW6
-0.83 81 27 PCT 16 BW4
-0.85 81 27 PCT 21 BW6 1.03 81 33 PCT 23 BW5
-0.99 81 33 PCT 27 BW5 0.76 81 33 PCT 18 BW9 1.86 81 49 PCT 22 BW5 0.97 81 49 PCT 18 BW6
-0.47 81 49 PCT 9
BW6 1.06 81 57 PCT 32 BW4
-0.73 81 61 PCT 15 BW4 0.62 81 87 PCT 22 BW6 0.86 81 91 PCT 14 BW4 1.15 81 91 PCT 12 BW5 1.07 81 97 PCT 18 BW4 1.13 81 97 PCT 28 BW5 0.86 to W3Fl -2004-0109 Page 13 of 15 Percent of Wall-Thickness Penetrations for S/G #2 - RF12 81 97 82 22 82 26 82 26 82 26 82 26 82 28 82 28 82 28 82 54 82 64 82 64 82 128 82 128 83 33 83 35 83 35 83 35 83 41 83 57 83 107 83 153 83 159 85 87 85 143 86 158 88 132 88 132 90 20 90 52 91 107 91 117 91 147 92 136 93 149 94
'30 94 40 94 40 94 56 94 56 96 42 96 42 96 136 96 150 97 51 97 85 97 85 PCT PCT PCT PCT PCT PCT PCT PCT PCT PCT PCT PCT PCT PCT PCT PCT PCT PCT PCT PCT PCT PCT PCT PCT PCT PCT PCT PCT PCT PCT PCT PCT PCT PCT PCT PCT PCT PCT PCT PCT PCT PCT PCT PCT PCT PCT PCT 12 BW6 13 BW4 17 BW5 13 BW5 19 BW6 23 BW6 17 BW4 20 BW5 27 BW6 15 BW4 25 BW4 21 BW6 29 BW5 21 BW6 11 BW5 26 BW5 23 BW7 19 BW7 16 BW3 29 BW3 22 BW3 14 BW1 22 BW9 16 BW5 19 BW3 8
BW5 14 BW3 12 BW3 20 09H 13 03H 14 BW3 16 BW3 21 09C 15 BW4 22 BW3 20 09C 16 BW3 18 BW6 12 BW3 12 BW4 24 BW3 18 BW3 13 BW3 19 BW3 15 BW3 14 BW3 15 BW4
-0.68 0.86
-1.07 0.68
-0.93 0.85
-1
-1 0.78 0.88 0.94
-0.88 1.17 0.77 1.01 0.9
-0.93 1.02 1.01
-0.87
-0.8
-0.18
-1.72 0.81
-0.61
-1
-0.76 0.89
-1.05
-0.81 0.97
-0.98
-1.02
-0.76
-0.76 0.03
-0.83 1.05
-0.79
-0.91
-0.81 0.81 1.08 0.84
-0.72 0.99 0.92 to W3Fl -2004-0109 Page 14 of 15 Percent of Wall-Thickness Penetrations for S/G #2 - RF12 98 134 PCT 14 BW3
-0.79 98 134 PCT 18 BW3 0.82 100 36 PCT 12 BW5
-0.77 100 134 PCT 10 07C
-0.06 101 25 PCT 33 BW1 2.1 101 149 PCT 25 09C
-0.98 101 149 PCT 25 09C 0.83 102 78 PCT 21 BW3
-0.76 103 147 PCT 14 09C
-1.06 103 149 PCT 28 09H
-0.29 103 149 PCT 12 09H 0.94 104 122 PCT 17 BW3
-0.88 105 59 PCT 16 BW5 0.9 105 85 PCT 21 BW6
-0.77 105 143 PCT 26 09H
-1.17 105 143 PCT 17 09H
-0.03 105 143 PCT 18 BW3 1.14 105 143 PCT 18 BW6
-0.63 106 116 PCT 17 BW7
-0.97 107 51 PCT 10 BW7
-0.68 107 55 PCT 15 BW5 0.25 107 55 PCT 20 BW5 0.96 107 55 PCT 18 BW6
-0.93 109 141 PCT 14 BW5 0.95 110 48 PCT 13 BW3 0.87 110 78 PCT 18 BW6
-0.76 113 109 PCT 25 BW3 0.77 114 42 PCT 12 BW7 0.87 114 54 PCT 16 BW7 1.04 114 106 PCT 19 BW4
-0.15 114 112 PCT 16 BW3 0.87 115 109 PCT 11 BW8 0.75 117 39 PCT 21 BW5
-0.89 119 45 PCT 20 BW4
-0.94 119 67 PCT 13 09C 0.09 121 111 PCT 19 BW7 0.76 123 115 PCT 9
08C
-0.86 125 133 PCT 13 BW4
-0.76 127 125 PCT 10 06C
-0.98 130 50 PCT 8
BW5
-0.88 133 61 PCT 12 BW3 0.24 133 61 PCT 22 BW5 1.06 133 117 PCT 18 BW3 0.81 134 52 PCT 16 BW1 1.36 134 52 PCT 18 BW2 0.75 135 113 PCT 22 BW8
-0.09 137 61 PCT 14 09C
-1.1 to W3Fl -2004-0109 Page 15 of 15 Percent of Wall-Thickness Penetrations for SIG #2 - RF12 138 64 PCT 15 BW7 0.82 141 69 PCT 15 BW7 0.75 141 75 PCT 15 BW1 1.81 142 68 PCT 23 10C
-0.16 143 67 PCT 21 BW8 0.64 143 103 PCT 18 BW9
-1.7 144 86 PCT 18 BW1 1.66 144 88 PCT 13 BW9 1.83 144 100 PCT 9
BW9
-1.82 145 77 PCT 16 BW1 1.68 145 77 PCT 16 BW8
-0.81 145 83 PCT 16 BW1 1.75 145 85 PCT 11 BW1
-1.92 145 85 PCT 12 BW7 0.99 145 85 PCT 23 BW8
-0.93 145 85 PCT 26 BW8 0.93 145 85 PCT 20 BW9
-1.54 145 87 PCT 17 BW9
-1.82 145 89 PCT 15 BW4
-0.93 145 89 PCT 13 BW7
-0.92 145 89 PCT 24 BW8
-0.89 145 89 PCT 15 BW8 0.92 145 89 PCT 13 08C
-1.02 145 95 PCT 29 BW8
-0.87 145 95 PCT 18 BW8 0.93 145 101 PCT 13 BW3 0.95 145 103 PCT 22 BW9 1.98 146 78 PCT 28 BW9 1.82 146 80 PCT 24 BW9 1.94 146 82 PCT 27 BW1 1.78 146 84 PCT 28 09H 0.77 146 84 PCT 21 BW9 1.94 146 88 PCT 31 BWI 1.98 146 88 PCT 31 BW9 1.83 146 90 PCT 15 BW9 1.48 147 81 PCT 17 09H 0.76 147 85 PCT 13 BW1
-1.57 147 85 PCT 14 BW6 1.01 147 85 PCT 21 BW7 0.88 147 87 PCT 21 BW2
-0.73 147 87 PCT 17 BW7
-0.86 147 87 PCT 14 BW7 0.53 147 87 PCT 20 BW8
-0.86 147 87 PCT 27 BW8 0
147 91 PCT 30 BW8