ML041130199

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Oversight Panel Final Restart Checklist Public Release Memo
ML041130199
Person / Time
Site: Davis Besse Cleveland Electric icon.png
Issue date: 04/21/2004
From: Christine Lipa
NRC/RGN-III/DRP/RPB4
To: Grobe J
NRC/RGN-III
References
Download: ML041130199 (11)


Text

April 21, 2004 MEMORANDUM TO: John A. Grobe, Chairman Davis-Besse Oversight Panel FROM: Christine A. Lipa, Chief Branch 4 /RA/

Division of Reactor Projects

SUBJECT:

DAVIS-BESSE 0350 OVERSIGHT PANEL FINAL RESTART CHECKLIST PUBLIC RELEASE The purpose of this memorandum is to inform you that the 0350 Panel Restart Checklist has been updated from the version provided with our February 26, 2004, restart recommendation memorandum to James Caldwell, and is now finalized. With this memorandum, this finalized Restart Checklist will also be publicly available in ADAMS.

Attachment:

Davis-Besse IMC 0350 Restart Checklist Revision 3, Updated March 31, 2004

Contact:

Christine Lipa 630-829-9619

DOCUMENT NAME: C:\ORPCheckout\FileNET\ML041130199.WPD To receive a copy of this document, indicate in the box: "C" = Copy without attachment/enclosure "E" = Copy with attachment/enclosure "N" = No copy OFFICE RIII RIII NAME RBaker:dtp CLipa DATE 04/19/04 04/21/04 OFFICIAL RECORD COPY

Attachment March 31, 2004 DAVIS-BESSE IMC 0350 RESTART CHECKLIST, REVISION 3*

ITEM DESCRIPTION RISK LEAD STATUS PANEL (CS) INTERIM INSPECTION REPORTS _CLOSURE

_FINAL IR#

IR ISSUED

1. Adequacy of Root Cause Determinations 1.a Penetration Cracking and Red Panel Closed. Discussed in IR 03-04. 04/29/03 IE Reactor Pressure Vessel (IR 03-04)

Corrosion 05/09/03 1.b Organizational, Panel Closed. Discussed in IRs 02-15 and 02-18. 06/17/03 IE Programmatic and (IR 02-18)

Human Performance 07/24/03 Issues

2. Adequacy of Safety Significant Structures, Systems, and Components 2.a Reactor Pressure Vessel Jacobson Closed. Discussed in IRs 02-07, 02-10, 03-17, 03-23, 02/10/04 IE Head Replacement 04-02, and Inspection Results Memorandum from SRI. (IR 04-02)

(ML040611099) 03/22/04 2.b Containment Vessel Farber Closed. Discussed in IRs 02-07 and 03-05. 07/15/03 BI Restoration Following (IR 03-05)

Reactor Pressure Vessel 08/05/03 Head Replacement

  • Restart Checklist, Revision 3 was issued to FirstEnergy Nuclear Operating Company on July 2, 2003 Page 1 of 10

Attachment March 31, 2004 DAVIS-BESSE IMC 0350 RESTART CHECKLIST, REVISION 3*

ITEM DESCRIPTION RISK LEAD STATUS PANEL (CS) INTERIM INSPECTION REPORTS _CLOSURE

_FINAL IR#

IR ISSUED 2.c Structures, Systems, and Holmberg Closed. Discussed in IRs 02-09, 02-12, 03-10, and 11/18/03 IE Components Inside 03-23. (IR 03-10)

MS Containment 03/05/04 BI 2.c.1 Emergency Core Cooling Yellow Coyne Closed. Discussed in IRs 03-06 and 03-17. 09/02/03 MS System and Containment Thomas (IR 03-17)

BI Spray System Sump 09/29/03 2.d Extent-of-Condition of Thomas Closed. Discussed in IRs 02-09, 02-14, 03-13, and 10/14/03 IE Boric Acid in Systems 03-22. (IR 03-22)

MS Outside Containment 12/23/03 BI 2.e High Pressure Injection White Jacobson Closed. Discussed in IRs 03-10, 03-15, 04-02, and 02/19/04 MS Pump Internal Inspection Results Memorandum from NRR. (IR 04-02)

BI Clearance/Debris (ML040690129) 03/22/04 Resolution

  • Restart Checklist, Revision 3 was issued to FirstEnergy Nuclear Operating Company on July 2, 2003 Page 2 of 10

Attachment March 31, 2004 DAVIS-BESSE IMC 0350 RESTART CHECKLIST, REVISION 3*

ITEM DESCRIPTION RISK LEAD STATUS PANEL (CS) INTERIM INSPECTION REPORTS _CLOSURE

_FINAL IR#

IR ISSUED

3. Adequacy of Safety Significant Programs 3.a Corrective Action Jacobson Closed. Discussed in IRs 02-11, 03-09, and 03-10. 02/05/04 ALL Program Falevits (IR 03-10) 03/05/04 3.b Operating Experience Jacobson Closed. Discussed in IRs 02-11 and 03-09. 06/20/03 ALL Program (IR 03-09) 07/07/03 3.c Quality Audits and Self- OBrien Closed. Discussed in IRs 02-11, 03-09, and 03-23. 10/09/03 ALL Assessments of Jacobson (IR 03-23)

Programs 12/05/03 3.d Boric Acid Corrosion Jacobson Closed. Discussed in IRs 02-09, 02-11 02-12, 03-09, 07/22/03 IE Management Program and 03-17. (IR 03-17)

MS 09/29/03 BI 3.e Reactor Coolant System Jacobson Closed. Discussed in IRs 02-11 and 03-09. 05/20/03 IE Unidentified Leakage (IR 03-09)

MS Monitoring Program 07/07/03 BI

  • Restart Checklist, Revision 3 was issued to FirstEnergy Nuclear Operating Company on July 2, 2003 Page 3 of 10

Attachment March 31, 2004 DAVIS-BESSE IMC 0350 RESTART CHECKLIST, REVISION 3*

ITEM DESCRIPTION RISK LEAD STATUS PANEL (CS) INTERIM INSPECTION REPORTS _CLOSURE

_FINAL IR#

IR ISSUED 3.f In-Service Inspection Jacobson Closed. Discussed in IRs 02-11 and 03-09. 05/20/03 IE Program (IR 03-09)

MS 07/07/03 BI 3.g Modification Control Jacobson Closed. Discussed in IRs 02-11 and 03-09. 05/20/03 ALL Program (IR 03-09) 07/07/03 3.h Radiation Protection White Slawinski Closed. Discussed in IRs 02-06, 02-16, 03-08, and 07/22/03 ORS Program House 03-17. (IR 03-17)

PRS 09/29/03 3.i Process for Ensuring Passehl Closed. Discussed in IR 03-19. 11/04/03 ALL Completeness and (IR 03-19)

Accuracy of Required 01/28/04 Records and Submittals to the NRC

  • Restart Checklist, Revision 3 was issued to FirstEnergy Nuclear Operating Company on July 2, 2003 Page 4 of 10

Attachment March 31, 2004 DAVIS-BESSE IMC 0350 RESTART CHECKLIST, REVISION 3*

ITEM DESCRIPTION RISK LEAD STATUS PANEL (CS) INTERIM INSPECTION REPORTS _CLOSURE

_FINAL IR#

IR ISSUED

4. Adequacy of Organizational Effectiveness and Human Performance 4.a Adequacy of Corrective Wright Closed. Discussed in IRs 02-15 and 02-18. 06/17/03 ALL Action Plan (IR 02-18) 07/24/03 4.b Effectiveness of Wright Closed. Discussed in IRs 02-15, 02-18, 03-12, 04-03, 02/05/04 ALL Corrective Actions and Inspection Results Memorandum from Followup (IR 04-03)

Management & Human Performance Inspection team. 03/31/04 (ML040690129)

5. Readiness for Restart 5.a Review of Licensees Thomas Closed. Discussed in IR 03-22. 11/04/03 ALL Restart Action Plan (IR 03-22) 12/23/03 5.b Systems Readiness for Thomas Closed. Discussed in IRs 02-13, 02-14, 03-03, 03-10, 02/20/04 IE Restart Passehl 03-11, 03-22, 03-24, 04-04, and Inspection Results (IR 04-04)

MS Memorandum from Followup Restart Readiness 03/25/04 Assessment Team Inspection team. (ML040690129) 5.c Operations Readiness for Thomas Closed. Discussed in IRs 03-11, 04-04, and Inspection 02/18/04 IE Restart Passehl Results Memorandum from Followup RRATI team. (IR 04-04)

(ML040690129) 03/25/04

  • Restart Checklist, Revision 3 was issued to FirstEnergy Nuclear Operating Company on July 2, 2003 Page 5 of 10

Attachment March 31, 2004 DAVIS-BESSE IMC 0350 RESTART CHECKLIST, REVISION 3*

ITEM DESCRIPTION RISK LEAD STATUS PANEL (CS) INTERIM INSPECTION REPORTS _CLOSURE

_FINAL IR#

IR ISSUED 5.d Test Program Thomas Closed. Discussed in IR 03-25. 12/09/03 IE Development and (IR 03-25)

MS Implementation 01/28/04 BI

6. Licensing Issue Resolution 6.a Verification that Relief Hopkins Closed. Discussed in IR 03-04. 04/29/03 IE Requests A8 and A12 (IR 03-04)

BI regarding the Shell to 05/09/03 Flange Weld (previously submitted by letter dated September 19, 2000) is not Impacted by the Midland RPV Head

  • Restart Checklist, Revision 3 was issued to FirstEnergy Nuclear Operating Company on July 2, 2003 Page 6 of 10

Attachment March 31, 2004 DAVIS-BESSE IMC 0350 RESTART CHECKLIST, REVISION 3*

ITEM DESCRIPTION RISK LEAD STATUS PANEL (CS) INTERIM INSPECTION REPORTS _CLOSURE

_FINAL IR#

IR ISSUED 6.b American Society of Hopkins Closed. Discussed in IR 03-04. 04/29/03 IE Mechanical Engineers (IR 03-04)

BI (ASME) Code Relief 05/09/03 Request for Failure to Maintain Original Radiographic Tests of the Midland Head to Flange Weld (Planned Relief Request A26) 6.c ASME Code Relief Hopkins Closed. Discussed in IR 03-04. 04/29/03 IE Request for Inability to (IR 03-04)

BI Radiographically Test 05/09/03 100% of the Midland Reactor Pressure Vessel Head to Flange Weld (Planned Relief Request A27)

  • Restart Checklist, Revision 3 was issued to FirstEnergy Nuclear Operating Company on July 2, 2003 Page 7 of 10

Attachment March 31, 2004 DAVIS-BESSE IMC 0350 RESTART CHECKLIST, REVISION 3*

ITEM DESCRIPTION RISK LEAD STATUS PANEL (CS) INTERIM INSPECTION REPORTS _CLOSURE

_FINAL IR#

IR ISSUED 6.d Resubmit Relief Request Hopkins Closed. Discussed in IR 03-04. 04/29/03 IE A2 (previously submitted (IR 03-04)

BI by letter dated September 05/09/03 19, 2000) for ASME Code for Inability to Perform 100% volumetric and surface examination of Head to Flange Weld 6.e Reconciliation Letter that Hopkins Closed. Discussed in IR 03-04. 04/29/03 IE Demonstrates How the (IR 03-04)

BI New Reactor Pressure 05/09/03 Vessel Head Correlates With the ASME Code and QA Index for Section III and Section XI -

Commitments 6.f Verification Letter of Hopkins Closed. Discussed in IR 03-04. 04/29/03 IE Technical Specification (IR 03-04)

BI Pressure/Temperature 05/09/03 Curves for New Vessel Head - Commitment

  • Restart Checklist, Revision 3 was issued to FirstEnergy Nuclear Operating Company on July 2, 2003 Page 8 of 10

Attachment March 31, 2004 DAVIS-BESSE IMC 0350 RESTART CHECKLIST, REVISION 3*

ITEM DESCRIPTION RISK LEAD STATUS PANEL (CS) INTERIM INSPECTION REPORTS _CLOSURE

_FINAL IR#

IR ISSUED 6.g Request to relocate High Hopkins Closed. Discussed in IR 03-17, and License 08/21/03 MS Pressure Injection and Amendment Issued 08/12/03. (ML031830237) (IR 03-17)

BI Low Pressure Injection 09/29/03 Subsystems Flow Balance Testing from Technical Specifications 4.5.2.h to Updated Safety Analysis Report Technical Requirements Manual

  • Restart Checklist, Revision 3 was issued to FirstEnergy Nuclear Operating Company on July 2, 2003 Page 9 of 10

Attachment March 31, 2004 DAVIS-BESSE IMC 0350 RESTART CHECKLIST, REVISION 3*

ITEM DESCRIPTION RISK LEAD STATUS PANEL (CS) INTERIM INSPECTION REPORTS _CLOSURE

_FINAL IR#

IR ISSUED

7. Confirmatory Action Letter Resolution 7.a Verification that Panel Closed. Closure will be documented in CAL 3-02-001 02/23/04 ALL Confirmatory Action Closure Letter, Enclosure 1 to the Restart Approval N/A Letter Items are Letter. 03/08/04 Resolved, Including a Public Meeting to Discuss Readiness for Restart Cornerstones:

IE - Initiating Events MS - Mitigating Systems BI - Barrier Integrity EP - Emergency Preparedness ORS - Occupational Radiation Safety PRS - Public Radiation Safety PP - Physical Protection ALL - Affects all cornerstones

  • Restart Checklist, Revision 3 was issued to FirstEnergy Nuclear Operating Company on July 2, 2003 Page 10 of 10