ML040150581

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Columbia - Pre-Submittal Meetingslides - Alternative Source Term License Amendment
ML040150581
Person / Time
Site: Columbia Energy Northwest icon.png
Issue date: 01/14/2004
From:
Energy Northwest
To:
Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
References
Download: ML040150581 (27)
v • d • e


Text

[ --- ['- - f ____ F- I-_.- [____ r-- rl r -- r- r--- r'- F 171 - 1'--- I-- I NR C/Energy Northwest Meeting i'-:

Alternative Source Terml IF License Amendment Pre-submittal Meeting January 14, 2004 ENERGY People Vision Solutions

F -- F- FI

. [ _

F I - I". -- FIT [ \ F-... ( --- [ I-- 1-- - - 1-- --f Introduction Engineering Management: Mike Humphreys Robin Feuerbacher Licensing Management: Doug Coleman Project Team Personnel: Abbas Mostala Tim Powell Mike Brandon Contractor Support: Jim Metcalf ENERGY 2 w NORTHWEST People Vision Solutions

r- - -- F- I--- I-- 1-7, r- - - vI--- F-v - V r--- --- I-- I --- V--

1--,

.. AST... Agenda AST Submittal Purpose

  • Scope of Technical Specifications Changes
  • SGT JCO Resolution
  • Draw Down Analysis
  • Meteorological Data
  • Control Room Inleakage
  • Dose Analyses and Differences
  • AST Submittal Schedule
  • Accuracy and Completeness
  • Staff Review Topics ENERGY 3 (PeopleNORTHWEST Vision Solutions

- __ .___ - .- - .- __ - . - - I __

I ~~1- I-- I I. 17 r-- Ii [ -- r r-7to - r~ - - i*-' V---

AST Submittal Purpose Mike Brandon

  • Revision to Technical Specifications and Bases to reflect AST methodology (Reg Guide 1.183)
  • Resolution of standby gas treatment/secondary containment draw down analysis

@ ENERGY 4 NORTHWEST People Vision Solutions

rl.-- i- - r -- I --- r-- - I --- r --' - F- - --- ,-.-- r

, --- r-- I --

Scope of TS Changes Mike Brandon I

I I-I; TS SECTION CHANGE Definitions Revised DOSE EQUIVALENT I-131 LCO 3.1.7 SLC and Added MODE 3 Table 3.3.6.1-1 Table 3.3.6.2-1, Deleted "during CORE ALTERATIONS" LCO 3.6.4.1, .2 & .3 and added "recently" SR 3.6.1.3.10 Revised secondary bypass leakage from

< 0.74 scfh to 0.04%[volume]/day TS 3.6.1.8 MSLC Deleted in its entirety

. ENERGY 5 NORTHWEST People Vision Solutions

T'-_- I_- I --

1__ I to [.-- 1-~ f 1 1- Io^ ri r- i - F-'- L--- T V-Scope of TS Changes 1.

Mike Brandon TS SECTION CHANGE SR 3.6.4.1.1 Replaced > 0.25 inch vacuum wg with > 0 SR 3.6.4.1.4 Deleted this 24 month surveillance to draw down in < 120 seconds SR 3.6.4.3.3 Added new requirement to verify SGT reaches > 5000 cfm in < 2 minutes TS 5.5.7 VFTP Revised SGT System flowrate for filter testing range from "4012 to 4902" to "4500 to 5500" cfm

, ENERGY 6 NORTHWEST People - Vision - Solutions

I' -- - - I -- I' --- - . ( --- Il--

f -. -- l.o 1 - r-- v>-- rem i', v- rm r- r- v-SGTJCO Resolution A

Mike Brandon

  • JCO for nonconformance with 120 second draw down time assumed in Licensing Basis X AST License Amendment will resolve this Jco and establish the new Licensing Basis w The information necessary for staff review and approval will be provided in the AST submittal

, ENERGY 7 v NORTHWEST People Vision Solutions

r-- F--- I 1 -- 7 r7 V rc

--- v---.. r

f. rr F-- r r--_

Draw Down Analysis

-tK

,.; . . -- -;;-.. Si.-i. Robin Feuerbacher Iil

.1
  • Reactor Building (RB) Model
  • Model will use 3 nodes

- ECCS pump room (basement elevation)

- Refueling floor (top floor)

- Remainder of building (RB middle section)

ENERGY NORTHWEST People Vision Solutions

r - r- (-- Igo --- , I- r-- i--. f-- as-- i- r- f7 rIt fi- - f---v Draw Down Analysis Robin Feuerbacher

  • Requirements of SRP 6.2.3
  • Certified 5 %/ 95 % meteorological data
  • Sensitivity analyses being performed a QA database for inputs/assumptions approved by Energy Northwest ENERGY 9 NORTHWEST People Vision Solutions

F ___ 1- rz: 1-- (-- V-- f-- F - V -t - r-: r- C~ - l--~ i- _.

Meteoro ogical Data Robin Feuerbacher Recent plant meteorological data

  • Expert meteorological vendor Measurement units clearly identified
  • Meteorological data scrubbed for completeness and accuracy by vendor and Energy Northwest
  • Two separate databases maintained by vendor and Energy Northwest for final verification
  • Reasonableness checks performed with vendor and NRC codes ENERGY People Vision* Solutions

- -- '--'1-- - _[-I.I - - T---

-- r' rV-R- F--- r--~~~~~~~~~~~.

to F-a--

Meteorological Data

  • 1 Robin Feuerbacher ii ..

w Joint Frequency Distributions compared with PNNL on-site data at lower elevation

  • Four years of recent meteorological data verified for AST (1996-99)
  • Less than five years of data allowed per RG 1.194 n By RG 1.183, meteorological data collected per FSAR
  • Wind speed classes in guidance per RG 1.111 m ENERGY NORTHWEST People*Vision*Solutions

-- r- M- e Rae ---

F-- o-- r o-- o ia- l- D--- rta--I.-

Meteorological Data Robin Feuerbacher I Data recovery (%)

1996 1997 1998 1999 Lower elevation* 88.3 91.1 93.7 87.9 90.2 Upper elevation* 86.0 90.9 94.2 85.3 89.1

  • Composite of delta temperature, wind speed, and wind direction available simultaneously

~ ENERGY 12 NORTHWEST People .Vision Solutions

(--- F- I---- a-- s i -_ -~r- 1- I r- -- r fr - r-- r-ControlRoom Inleakage

", -e ,, "

I

..., .t -

.1 %.,

Robin Feuerbacher

, . .t , , --, , ,

. 7 I F-11 1I Tracer Gas Test completed November 2003 Used ASTM E741 Methodology per RG 1.197 Measured Unfiltered Inleakage (under review)

Single Train results: 7 scfm Dual Train results: 27 scfm Unfiltered Inleakage input into AST analyses Single Train: 40* + 10 (ingress/egress) cfm Dual Train: 65* + 10 (ingress/egress) cfm

  • Uncertainty not included per RG 1.197 if < 100 cfm n ENERGY 13 NORTHWEST.

People *Vision

  • Solutions

f- ir r-F-- 7-- . - -- F-- F-- y--- I- r- - r r r. - - ,

AST Dose Analyses Robin Feuerbacher

  • STARDOSE computer code for record of analyses RADTRAD for checking purposes by analyst and another independent contractor
  • QA database for inputs/assumptions approved by Energy Northwest

@ ENERGY 14 NORTHWEST People Vision Solutions

, - I r: r-V. (. I. rvn tn F- re-r- r- I_,_ I v,17 r V Dose Analyses - LOCA Robin Feuerbacher

  • Current Core Inventory Source Term
  • Drywell spray removal credited per SRP model

~ ENERGY 15 w NORTHWEST People Vision Solutions

r--Ad ~~~ o . r a---. r- -- - - - r7- F r---- V V -- r_., . F Dose Analyses - LOCA (cont.)

Robin Feuerbacher Releases assumed as ground level Containment leakage of 0.50%/day Secondary containment bypass leakage of 0.04%/day

  • 46 scfh MSIV leakage, evenly distributed over 4 lines (may increase pending dose sensitivity analyses and adequate margin to limits)
  • Factor of two reduction in leakages at 24 hours2.777778e-4 days <br />0.00667 hours <br />3.968254e-5 weeks <br />9.132e-6 months <br />
  • Control Room Emergency Filtration auto-initiated both trains, 1 train manually secured at 30 minutes, no credit for securing one remote intake

^ ENERGY 16 NORTHWEST People *Vision Solutions

r--- r- ---

V~ r-V r r--- r7 - Fr r F- rT V~ V7 vi-r (~

'7 r-7 _

Differencesfrom

-Previous Submittal- LOCA

  • Revised Control Room (CR) make-up air flows (1300 cfm dual / 800 cfm single train)
  • Reduced unfiltered inleakage (75 cfm dual / 50 cfm single CREF train including CR ingress/egress)
  • Revised ARCON96 and PAVAN atmospheric dispersion factors (X/Qs) for 1996-99 data
  • 20-minute Reactor Building draw down, no mixing credit
  • Dose Conversion Factors based FGR 11 & 12 default data in RADTRAD

- ENERGY 17 NORTHWEST People -Vision* Solutions

C+-- r- r~- [-~ - 1.~ r-- r -  :~ v-~ rm r - -- or VT~ r~~ z~

Dose Analyses - MSLB Robin Feuerbacher

.S.- - S-----------

  • Activity for release based on Technical Specifications Dose Equivalent Iodine limits
  • MSIV closure time of 6 seconds (>Tech Spec limit)

-Control Room Emergency Filtration (CREF) not credited

  • Direct ground release to environment - no Turbine Building holdup
  • Maximum makeup flow for normal CR ventilation (1100 cfm), no filter credit ENERGY 18 PNORTHWEST People Vision Solutions

1-:-F r~-~i---- -- An 7 r[ r-- - r----- r, r- r - F-Differencesfrom Previous Submittal- MESLB Direct application of Dose Equivalent 1-131 ifl_ "Control Room X/Qs based on RG 1.194 "puff" release model (no steam buoyancy considered)

Off-site X/Qs based on 1996-99 data

. ENERGY 19 VsNORTHWEST People Vision Solutions

r--- r--- r r r-- ( - -- --- r-- - - -- [---- I-Dose Analyses - CRDA Robin Feuerbacher Fuel damage equals 1.79% of the core

  • Fuel melting occurs in 0.0138% of the core
  • Release fractions of 100% noble gas and 50%

iodine from melted fuel and fraction of core inventory in the fuel gap

  • No credit for CREF filters

^ ENERGY 20 NORTHWEST People Vision Solutions

r -- ---- r---- r- -- F-- r-- i re r- r--- r-- R--- - - r--- F-- F --

Differencesfrom i1 I.-

~

....... ~

Previous Submittal - CRDA

'i a I

--`

. ., . II V i

.I

.,I I.: ".

.. ;I. - I_,I 7-

  • Revised CR make-up air flows (same as LOCA analysis)
  • Reduced CR unfiltered inleakage (same as LOCA analysis)
  • Revised X/Qs for 1996-99 data (same as LOCA analysis)

ENERGY 21 VNORTHWEST People -Vision* Solutions

- (-

rae- - f--- r- - - (- r--- r--- ro-- r- r- c- rTd r-- C. I -- [ r_ _F- F.

Dose Analyses - FIIA Robin Feuerbacher

  • 24 hours2.777778e-4 days <br />0.00667 hours <br />3.968254e-5 weeks <br />9.132e-6 months <br /> fuel decay prior to accident Release to the environment occurs over 2 hour2.314815e-5 days <br />5.555556e-4 hours <br />3.306878e-6 weeks <br />7.61e-7 months <br /> period
  • Fuel damage is 0.528% of the core ENERGY 22 @ NORTHWEST People Vision Solutions

r-- - r r-. r r--- F---r-r-r r---- r- r--- i-- r--- r~- F- F - ( -- F. ( _ I Differencesfrom Previous Submittal - FHA

  • Revised CR make-up air flows (same as LOCA analysis)

Reduced CR unfiltered inleakage (same as LOCA analysis)

Revised X/Qs for 1996-99 meteorological data (same as LOCA analysis)

CREF filter efficiency of 95% for gaseous iodine, 99%

for particulate removal (same as LOCA analysis)

^ ENERGY 23 NORTHWEST People Vision* Solutions

r- r r r-- rm..... r F_ F F___ F- rT.

VF__ FT r r- I- - r---

F- F__ I- -- -

AST Submittal Schedule Robin Feuerbacher Ii:~,

Activit Date Meteorological data verified 11/20/03 - complete Control room tracer gas tests 11/10/03 - complete Atmospheric dispersion factors 12/31/03 - complete Dose analyses 2/13/04 Secondary cont. draw down analyses 2/28/04 CNSRB review and approval 4/14/04 NRC submittal 4/30/04 S ENERGY 24 w NORTHWEST People Vision Solutions

r.--- [-a -- r--- r- -- r---- -- r--- r--- r- F_ I- -- F__ 1..--. F__ I Accuracy and Completeness Doug Coleman GENERIC ACTIONS

  • Engineering Reorganization Creation of Design Authority Positions Implementation of the Engineering Electronic Database
  • Quest for Excellence plan m ENERGY 25 WNORTHWEST People -Vision
  • Solutions

F.- F___ I- - __ [ r~

F-.-K-- r-V _ F r r- r_

F F_ F__ r__ rCr ram- o - r-- -- r - r- -

Accuracy and Completeness Mike Brandon SPECIFIC ACTIONS B Line-by-line review Rigorous certification

  • Independent reviews by external experts
  • Independent review by Energy Northwest QA ENERGY 26 NORTHWEST People Vision
  • Solutions

r - (,--- I -- (____ r--- r r-- r--- r- r-- r-- r---- c- r- [_ _ f, F___, f- -

Staff Review. Topics Doug Coleman Anticipated review period

-Coordination of RAIs

  • NRC review team
  • Emerging issues

^ ENERGY 27 VNORTHWEST People Vision

  • Solutions
Retrieved from "https://kanterella.com/w/index.php?title=ML040150581&oldid=2633609"