ML033180435
| ML033180435 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Wolf Creek  |
| Issue date: | 11/12/2003 |
| From: | Donohew J NRC/NRR/DLPM/LPD4 |
| To: | |
| References | |
| TAC MB9875, TAC MB9876, TAC MB9879 | |
| Download: ML033180435 (22) | |
Text
- -
NRC FORM 658 U.S. NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION (9-1999)
TRANSMITTAL OF MEETING HANDOUT MATERIALS FOR IMMEDIATE PLACEMENT IN THE PUBLIC DOMAIN This form is to be filled out (typed or hand-printed) by the person who announced the meeting (i.e., the person who issued the meeting notice). The completed form, and the attached copy of meeting handout materials, will be sent to the Document Control Desk on the same day of the meeting; under no circumstances will this be done later than the working day after the meeting.
Do not include proprietarymaterials.
DATE OF MEETING The attached document(s), which was/were handed out in this meeting, is/are to be placed 11/12/2003 in the public domain as soon as possible. The minutes of the meeting will be issued in the near future. Following are administrative details regarding this meeting:
Docket Number(s) 05000482 Plant/Facility Name Callaway Plant TAC Number(s) (if available) MRI'b' Mq 9 Yf a 7A 9 R Reference Meeting Notice October 28,2003 (ADAMS ML032960521)
Purpose of Meeting (copy from meeting notice) To discuss (1) the licensee's RAI responses on two applications dated 06/26/03 and (2) potential instrumentation digital upgrades.
NAME OF PERSON WHO ISSUED MEETING NOTICE TITLE Jack Donohew Senior Project Manager OFFICE Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation DIVISION Division of Licensing Project Management BRANCH Project Directorate IV-2 Distribution of this form and attachments:
Docket File/Central File PUBLIC 51Rw NRIC FORM 658 (9-1999) PRINTED ON RECYCLED PAPER This form was designed using InForms
NRC STAFF'S HANDOUT AGENDA NRC/UNION ELECTRIC COMPANY MEETING CALLAWAY PLANT, UNIT I NOVEMBER 12, 2003
- Introduction
- MFW/AFW Mods and SGTR Accident Re-Analysis Application (ADAMS ML031950570) - Information Needed by Staff
- Shield Wall Penetration and LBB Methodology Application (ADAMS ML031920631) - Information Needed by Staff PUBLIC COMMENT
- Potential Instrumentation Digital Upgrades for Callaway Plant PUBLIC COMMENT
- Adjourn Meeting Acronyms: AFW = auxiliary feedwater LBB = leak before break MFW = main feedwater Mods = modifications SGTR = steam generator tube rupture
CALLAWAY MEETINGS ON NOVEMBER 12, 2003
Richard Eckenrode 08:30 - (response received)
Chu-yu Liang 09:00 - (response received)
Richard Lobel 09:30 - (response received)
Joseph Golla 10:00 - 10:30 (response received)
- 2. SHIELD WALL PENETRATION AND LBB METHODOLOGY (10:30 - noon)
Roger Pedersen 10:30 - (response received)
Mark Hartzman 11:00 - (no response received)
Pat Patnaik 11:30 - (no response received)
- 3. INSTRUMENTATION DIGITAL UPGRADES (13:00 - 15:30)
Angelos Marinos Matt Chiramal
LICENSEE'S HANDOUT CMP OO-1009A Replacement of Feedwater Isolation Valve (FWIV) Actuators
v 1.A A; It I 07' U-A I .. A I1 I:,
AI I p.
X-Eli v - I 4%I"I I...
-f';4
^V2 ToCoodensa M system medium pressure pressureless(drainage pressure) r---- Auxiliary medium kIW" Inr.0WZscrn..n.
_. ". de am tn:p rwta nvermtwv. Wr~Itw"Utfurn UPC upper pislon chamber ."Mu TdW k"UfY ,ctc.h O..emtt. ear I'WoVI"utMer ng8,#.Vn gsflUc LPC... lower piston chamber MV1 -4normally energized MV5+MV6 normally de-energized MVI+MV34MV5el. power supply train 1 MV2+MV4 +MV6el. power supply train 2 E= plug connection for aux. medium de-energized energized V. /
-I.
/
/
// SCHUIDR
~~I - I ~~I - I ~
/ /
- II ,-I I I w RRUNNf*R -- I IL 0 I r*OWWM._ *- . . .
MFIV / MSIV System medium operated actuator PPS -Actuator L(K7 for quick closing valve Layout diagram lNORMAL OPERATION (keep open) l D lA31 103.224.185
A aed CALLAWAY PLRNT IMPACT ALLIANCE Callaway and Wolf Creek Plants I&C Digital Upgrade Plan/
Diversity & Defense in Depth Analysis NRC Status Meeting November 12, 2003 I&C Digital Upgrade 2003-11 NRC Presentation Slides.ppt Page: 1/13 AFRAMATOME ANP
rfil,=%
4][.,,_ PURPOSE t CALLAWAY y PLRAT Callaway (AUE), Wolf Creek (WCNOC) and Framatome ANP (FANP) are planning a comprehensive Digital upgrade of Major l&C Systems. This meeting is to present the following items to the NRC and obtain feedback:
- An Overview of the AUE/WCNOC Digital Upgrade Plan
- An Overview of how the Diversity & Defense in Depth (D3) Analysis demonstrates that the FANP design meets the guidance of NUREG/CR-6303 and BTP-19 I&C Digital Upgrade 2003-11 NRC Presentation Slides.ppt Page: 2 /13 AFRAMATOME ANP
Agenda CALA WRY PLRnT
- 1. Introduction Dave Shafer II. Objectives Tim Herrmann 111. Digital Upgrade Overview Dan Wingbermuehle IV. LSELS/BOP ESFAS/MSFIS Modification Paul Bisges V. Diversity & Defense in Depth Analysis Phil Liddle VI. Licensing Activities Dave Shafer VII.Summary Dave Shafer VIII.NRC Informal Feedback I&C Digital Upgrade ige: 3/13 2003-11 NRC Presentation Slides.ppt PN AFRAMATOME ANP
I - INTRODUCTION Representatives AUE Tim Hei rrmann FANP Phil Liddle Dan Wiingbermuehle Joerg Pflugbeil Dave SIhafer Jerry Mauck Paul Bic3ges Paul Mangano WCNOC Bill Eales Steve Wideman I&C Digital Upgrade 2003-11 NRC Presentation Slides.ppt Page: 4 /13 AF~RAMATOME ANP
I -OBJECTIVES CRI PLF lOT Outline AUEIWCNOC DCS upgrade program Describe the LSELS/BOP ESFAS/MSFIS upgrade and schedule Describe the Diversity & Defense in Depth (D3) design approach Describe near term licensing activities NRC Feedback and Resources
- Feedback on D3 design approach
- Forecast future resource requirements
- Support AUE's Refuel 14 (2005) schedule l&C Digital Upqrade 2003-11 NRC Presentation Slides.ppt Page: 5 / 13 A
FRAMATOME ANP
&6 Eb III - DIGITAL UPGRADE OVERVIEW LAWAY PLA flT The DCS Upgrade Solution - Why?
- Obsolescence
- Increasing inventory costs
- Aging workforce
- Antiquated analog systems
- Recruiting issue for l&C and electrical
- Best in class - stand alone experts
- Data availability limited
- Reduce manual work
- Reduce Frequency of Surveillance Tests
- Design Provisions to Automate Select Surveillance Tests
- Simplified and Common Testing Methods for TXS Platform
- Reduce Troubleshooting Time
- Reduce Time to Perform Surveillance Tests
- Reduce Manpower Required to Perform Surveillance Tests
- Human Performance issues in the plant
- Loss of current system knowledge
- Improve Safety Analysis Margin
- Improve Plant Efficiency
- Reduce Uncertainties I&C Digital Upqrade 2003-11 NRC Presentation Slides.ppt Page: 6 /13 A
FRAMATOME ANP
[ Lai,,,.,,III- DIGITAL UPGRADE OVERVIEW CALLAWAY PLART DCS ARCHITECTURE Bus Architecture
- Fault tolerant
- Redundant Processors
- Option available for SR and NSR platforms
- lntegrated Non-Safety Related Soft Controls
- NSR component control and status
- SR component control and status
- Safety Signal priority
- Enhances Human Performance
- Information Availability
- Event Logging
- Troubleshooting eintegration and Automation of Processes I&C Digital Upgrade A
EL 2003-11 NRC Presentation Slides.ppt Page: 7/13 FRAMATOME ANP
Ik III - DIGITAL UPGRADE OVERVIEW Do CALLAWAY PL~nT DCS Migration Path 2003 2007
- Condensate Polisher System (AUE) *Main Turbine Controls/EHC
- Non-Safety Operation and Monitoring *Feedwater Heater Controls/ Performance System Backbone (OM690) (AUE) Monitoring
- BCMS (AUE) *Main Control Board (Turbine/EHC, FW Htr.
Controls) 2004 *TCCM/RVLIS
- Fire Protection (AUE)
- 2008
- Plant Computer Conversion to OM690 (AUE) *Westinghouse 7300 NSSS Controls
-Flux Mapping System (AUE) *BOP Controls Foxboro N1E
- Plant Computer Conversion to OM690 *BOP Controls Foxboro 1E (WCNOC) *Main Control Board (Turbine, 1E/N1E, NSSS
-Supervisory Controls (WCNOC) Controls)
- Emergency Diesel Generator Controls 2005 -Main Feed Pump Controls
- Load Shedding Emergency Load 2010 Sequencing System (LSELS) (WCNOC 2006) -Solid State Protection System (SSPS)
- Balance of Plant Engineered Safety 'Westinghouse 7300 Protection Features Act. System (BOP ESFAS) -Nuclear Instrumentation System (NIS)
(WCNOC 2006) 'Main Control Board (W7300 1E, SSPS, NIS)
-Main Steam and Feedwater Isolation System (MSFIS) (WCNOC 2006)
I&C Digital Upgrade A
2003-11 NRC Presentation Slides.ppt Page: 8/ 13 FRAMATOME ANP
IV - LSELS/BOP ESFASIMSFIS CALLA WAY PLAnlT MODIFICATION 2005 System Modifications
- Load Shedder and Emergency Load Sequencer (LSELS)
- Balance of Plant Engineered Safety Features Actuation System (BOP ESFAS)
- Main Steam and Feedwater Isolation System (MSFIS)
Why?
- Consolidated Controls Obsolescence
- MSIV/FWIV Actuator Upgrade i I&C Digital Upqrade 2003-11 NRC Presentation Slides.ppt Page: 9 /13 AFRAMATOME ANP
ALAA IV - LSELS/BOP ESFAS/MSFIS MODIFICATION 401 I.vU.
Hardware as-built (unhiangedj (i)(i) i)(i) e} ELI T l . 4.<,.^>1New TXS systeiiis i,~-';
I&C Digital Upgrade 2003-11 NRC Presentation Slides.ppt Page: 10 /13 AFRAMATOME ANP
V - Diversity & Defense in Depth Analysis 4.
CALLRWRY PLRnT V
See FANP Proprietary Insert I&C Digital Upgrade AFRAMATOME 2003-11 NRC Presentation Slides.ppt Page: 11 /13 ANP
Vil -
SUMMARY
CLLAWAY PLAHlT Licensing Actions Schedule Milestone Submittal/Completion Date Licensee Submittals
- D3 Topical 2/2004 Priority Logic Module
- Lic. Amend. Request Submittal AUE 9/2004 WCNOC 9/2005 NRC Approval Required
- Topical 12/2004
- Amendment Approval 7/2005 nplementation 9/2005 I&C Digital Upgrade 2003-11 NRC Presentation Slides.ppt Page: 12 /13 AFRAMATOME ANP
CLLA WAY 9>
PLAfT NRC INFORMAL FEEDBACK
- Feedback on D3 design approach
- Forecast future resource requirements
- Support AUE's Refuel 14 (2005) schedule I&C Digital Upgrade 2003-11 NRC Presentation Slides.ppt Page: 13 /13 A
FRAMATOME ANP
I
_- N 1W I I'