ML17309A692

From kanterella
Revision as of 10:59, 29 June 2018 by StriderTol (talk | contribs) (Created page by program invented by StriderTol)
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Application for Amends to Licenses DPR-67 & NPF-16,utilizing Guidance of GL 89-01, Implementation of Programmatic Controls for RETS & NUREG-1301, ODCM Guidance:Srec for Pwrs.
ML17309A692
Person / Time
Site: Saint Lucie  NextEra Energy icon.png
Issue date: 01/22/1993
From: SAGER D A
FLORIDA POWER & LIGHT CO.
To:
NRC OFFICE OF INFORMATION RESOURCES MANAGEMENT (IRM)
Shared Package
ML17227A699 List:
References
RTR-NUREG-1301 GL-89-01, GL-89-1, L-92-329, NUDOCS 9302010127
Download: ML17309A692 (22)


Text

ACCEIERAT~DOCUMENTDISTUTIONSYSTEMREGULAINFORMATION DISTRIBUTIO YSTEM(RIDS)ACCESSION NBR:9302010127 DOC.DATE:

93/01/22NOTARIZED:

YESDOCKET¹FACIL:50-335 St.LuciePlant,Unit1,FloridaPower&LightCo.0500033550-389St.LuciePlant,Unit2,FloridaPower&LightCo.05000389AUTH.NAMEAUTHORAFFILIATION SAGAR,D.A.

Florida,.Power

&LightCo.RECIP.NAME RECIPIENT AFFILIATION DocumentControlBranch(Document ControlDesk)

SUBJECT:

Application foramendstolicensesDPR-67&NPF-16,respectively, utilizing guidanceofGL89.-01,"Implementation ofProgrammatic ControlsforRadiological EffluentTSs"&NUREG1301,"ODCM:SREC forPWRs."DISTRIBUTION CODE:A009DCOPIESRECEIVED:LTR ENCLSIZE:TITLE:OR/Licensing Submittal:

AppendixINOTES:RECIPIENT IDCODE/NAME PD2-2LANORRISIJINTERNAL:

ACRSNRR/DREPDIR10ENUDOCS-ABSTRACT OGC/HDS3RGN2DRSS/RPBEXTERNALEG&GAKERSIDPNL/BAKER,D.A.

COPIESLTTRENCL1122,33101110111111RECIPIENT IDCODE/NAME PD2-2PDNRR/BRADFUTEgJ NRR/DREP/PRPB11 OC/jsFMBEGFI01NRCPDRCOPIESLTTRENCL111111101111NOTETOALL"RIDS"RECIPIENTS:

PLEASEHELPUSTOREDUCEWASTEICONTACTTHEDOCUMENTCONTROLDESK,ROOMPl-37(EXT.504-2065)

TOELIMINATE YOURNAMEFROMDISTRIBUTION LISTSFORDOCUMENTS YOUDON'TNEED!TOTALNUMBEROFCOPIESREQUIRED:

LTTR18ENCL15

'If($5~%4lII P.O.Box28,Ft.Pierce,FL34954-0128

~g2213%L-92-32910CFR50.90U.S.NuclearRegulatory Commission Attn:DocumentControlDeskWashington, D.C.20555Gentlemen:

RE:St.LucieUnits1and2DocketNos.50-335and50-389ProposedL'icenseAmendments Imlementation ofProrammaticControlsforRadioloicalEffluentTechnical Secifications GenericLetter89-01Inaccordance with10CFR50.90,FloridaPower6LightCompany(FPL)submitsarequesttoamendFacilityOperating LicensesDPR-67andNPF-16forSt.LucieUnits1and2,respectively.

Theseproposedlicenseamendments havebeendeveloped utilizing theguidanceofGL89-01,"Implementation ofProgrammatic ControlsforRadiological EffluentTechnical Specifications" andNUREG1301,"OffsiteDoseCalculation ManualGuidance:

StandardRadiological EffluentControlsforPressurized WaterReactors."

Assuch,theprocedural detailsoftheRadiological EffluentTechnical Specifications (RETS)havebeenrelocated totheOffsiteDoseCalculation Manual(ODCM)orProcessControlProgram(PCP)asappropriate pertheAdministrative ControlssectionoftheTechnical Specifications.

Inaddition, newprogrammatic

controls, forradioactive effluentandradiological environmental monitoring havebeenaddedtotheTechnical Specifications (TS).TheODCMhasbeenrevisedinaccordance withtheproposedchangestotheAdministrative ControlssectionoftheTSsoitmaybeimplemented immediately uponissuanceoftheamendments.

Whereverpossible, thestandardTSwordingofNUREG1301wasusedinthecontrolssectionoftheODCM.Deviations fromtheNUREG1301wordingaremarkedandexplained inEnclosure 1.CurrentSt.LucieTSsetpoints, LCOs,andsurveillance requirements werenotchanged.TheTSbasesofNUREG1301wereusedintheODCMinlieuofSt.LucieTSbases.9302010127 930122PDRADOCK05000335PPDRSllfpgQroepcpmpfflQAOgJw ff4i)f, St.LucieUnits1and2DocketNos.50-335and50-389ProposedLicenseAmendments Imlementation ofProrammaticControlsforRadioloicalEffluentTechnical Secifications GenericLetter89-01PagetwoAttachments 1and2tothisletterincludetheproposedSt.LucieUnits1and2Technical Specification changes,respectively.

Attachment 3isaSafetyAnalysisinsupportoftheproposedamendments.

Attachment 4isa"Determination ofNoSignificant HazardsConsideration."

Enclosure 1isacopyoftherevisedODCMandNUREG1301deviation document.

Theproposedamendments havebeenreviewedbytheSt.LucieFacilityReviewGroupandtheFPLCompanyNuclearReviewBoard.Inaccordance with10CFR50.91(b)(1),acopyoftheproposedamendments arebeingforwarded totheStateDesigneefortheStateofFlorida.Pleasecontactusifthereareanyquestions aboutthissubmittal.

Verytrulyyours,D.A.SVicePridentStL'lDAS/JWH/kw DAS/PSL0836-93Attachments Enclosure cc:StewartD.Ebneter,RegionalAdministrator, RegionII,USNRCSeniorResidentInspector, USNRC,St.LuciePlantMr.JacobD.Nash,FloridaDepartment ofHealthandRehabilitative Services St.LucieUnits1and2DocketNos.50-335and50-389ProposedLicenseAmendments Imlementation ofProrammaticControlsforRadioloicalEffluentTechnical Secifications GenericLetter89-01PagethreeSTATEOFFLORIDA))COUNTYOFST.LUCIE)SS~D.A.Sagerbeingfirstdulysworn,deposesandsays:ThatheisVicePresident, St.LuciePlantfortheNuclearDivisionofFloridaPower&LightCompany,theLicenseeherein;Thathehasexecutedtheforegoing document; thatthestatements madeinthisdocumentaretrueandcorrecttothebestofhisknowledge, information andbelief,andthatheisauthorized toexecutethedocumentonbehalfofsaidLicensee.

D.'A.gerSTATEOFFLORIDACOUNTYOFSt.LueieTheforegoing instrument wasacknowledged beforemethis22nddayofJanuary1993byD.A.Sager,whoispersonally knowntomeandwhodidtakeanoath.KarenWestNameofNotaryPublicMyCommission expires4>894Commission No.KARENWESTNotayPub&state atPet8amt".shnExpltesAPflts,t694COMMttCC003222 4:Ia'jQ~3'4a'LA~">+A~~~MLaA~4,>

St.LucieUnits1and2DocketNos.50-335and50-389ProposedLicenseAmendments Imlementation ofProrammaticControlsforRadioloicalEffluentTechnical Secifications GenericLetter89-01ENCLOSURE 1OFFSITEDOSECALCULATION MANUALANDDEVIATION DOCUMENTFORST.LUCIEUNITSIAND29302010127 DEVIATION DOCUMENTFORST.LUCIEUNITS1AND2ODCMThisdeviation documentisprovidedtoassistinthereviewprocesssincetheODCMsubmittal attemptstousethestandardTSwordingofNUIREG-1301 whereverpossible.

Itexplainsthedeviations fromNUREG-1301 wordingbasedonsitespecificdesignandinstances wherethecurrentPlantTechnical Specifications haveadditional ormorerestrictive requirements thanthosegiveninNUREG-1301.

TheSt.LucieODCMsubmittal copyhasmarginnoteskeyedtotheseexplanations.

St.LNUREGDev.ODCM1301PAGEPAGEDESCRIPTION OFDEVIATION 5NamingCHANNELFUNCTIONAL TESTastitleinsteadof1301'snameofANALOGCHANNELOPERATIONAL TEST.Thedefinition isidentical.

Thisisneededforhumanfactors.ThiswillkeepusfromhavingaCommonEffluent&AccidentChannelwithtwodifferent namesforafunctional test.142935375CHANNELCALIBRATION definition usesthecurrentPlantTSwordin,not1301's.Our'sisaboutequivalent

&evenincludesCHANNELFUNCTIONAL TEST.Samehumanfactorsconcernastheitemimmediately above.12TABLE1.1FREQUENCY 4/M*isourcurrentTS.39Wearenotchangingthefrequency tothatof46NUREG1301.481412**-ToclarifywhenPisrequired.

Ourcurrent15131301TABLE1.2"OPERATIONAL MODES"isnotinsubmittal.

Effluents MonitorsOPERABLEstatusarenotaffectedbyMODEchanges.Therefore, theTableisnotneeded.151513013/4CONTROLS&SURVEILLANCE REQUIREMENTS APPLICABILITY" for3.0.3,3.0.4,4.0.3,4.0.4,and4.0.2.barenotincludedinsubmittal.

Seeitemimmediately aboveforsamereasons.TheSurveillance Frequency maximumallowable extension inallotherSTSis254perintervalonlyandnot254per3consecutive intervals.

St.LNUREGDev.ODCM1301PAGEPAGEDESCRIPTION OFDEVIATION 16152124283832423343344538493950405142554957576859701301'sAction:"Theprovisions ofControls3.0.3and3.0.4arenotapplicable" isNOTincludedinanyControlStatement intheODCM.Seeabovetwoitemsforreasons.17-18192122252532TheODCMInst.Table(s)~onlincludethoseMonitorsthatareDesignBaseApplicable toSt.Lucie.Refertothesame1301TableNo.toseewhichexclusions weremadefortheTableofinterest.

Instruments sameasourcurrentlantTS.17181820222823292431MINIMUMCHANNELSOPERABLEinthisTableisN.A.duetoDesignBaseApplicability.

ByNOThavinga1301instrument tomeasureFlowRate,theACTIONrequirement specified intheODCMsubmittal isdifferent than1301's,anduniquelyspellsoutwhattheplantmustdotoinsurereleaseconditions arecontrolled conservatively.

ThewordinofthisACTIONStatement inthisTableisourcurrent101218202023202327371301specifies 1.E-07micro-Curie/ml detection limit.CurrentPlantTSis2.0E-07.1301hasNotes(1)thru(4)andtheODCMomitsthe1301Note(2),whichisN.A.sinceallourliquideffluentmonitorsfallunderNOTE1'stype.1301suggestpurchasing calibration sourcesfromvendorswhoparticipate inNISTcrosscheckprogramsetc.WewillkeethecurrentPlantTSNoteforthistablewhichreuiresvendorswhoaretraceable toNIST.

St.LNUREGDev.ODCM1301PAGEPAGEDESCRIPTION OFDEVIATION 132224272630321301APPLICABILITY is"*".ByDesign,PSL'sAirEjectorsmaybe,andarenormallyaligned,tothePlantVent(s)wherethePlantVentMonitorprovidestherequiredmonitoring functionatalltimes.The'ODCMAPPLICABILITY of"**"takescreditforthiscapability.

SeeTABLENOTATIONfortheactualstatement.

141522261301itemsb.thrue.N.A.toSt.Luciesince2533airejectorisonlyaNobleGasMonitor.24301301hasaNotation"**",butitdoesNOTapplyon1301'sTable3.3-13listofInstrumentation.

16172430273229391301Notation"*-Atalltimes"vstheODCMsubmittal's

"*-Atalltimeswhilemakingreleasesviathispathway"totakecreditforbeingabletoadministratively tagoutsomeventilation systemfans,etc.1301hasSAMPLINGFREQUENCY asContinuous vsODCMDaily.DesignBaseofSt.LuciedoesnotprovideforContinuous collection ofacomposite sample.1301hasNote(6).WeusethecurrentlantTS.1829391301hasSAMPLINGFREQUENCY "M"GrabSamplevsODCMDailyGrabSamplefordissolved andentrained gasesasercurrentlantTS.1301hasMINIMUMANALYSISFREQUENCY of"M"(forMonthly)vsODCM4/Mfromthecomposite aserthecurrentlantTS.1932333839404248424349505155561301intheACTIONStatement "Control6.9.2"vsODCM"PlantTS6.9.2"whereTS6.9.2dealswithSpecialReports.WepreferTStobetherecognized document.

St.LNUREGDev.ODCM1301PAGEPAGEDESCRIPTION OFDEVIATION 2032421301DrinkingWaterAnalysis, etc.isnotinthecurrentlantTSorODCMduetoSt.Lucienotbeingafreshwatersite.Therefore, Footnote"*"wasomittedfromODCM.2135461301"TypeofActivityAnalysis" specifies Principal GammaEmitters.

TheODCMsays"NobleGasP.G.E"asourcurrentlantTSNote"e"forthistable"exclusivel "listcertainNuclideLLD'sforgaseoussamples.OurDesignBasesisthatthePlantVentParticulate andCharcoalContinuous Samplingdeviceisacommoncollection pointforallWasteGasStorageTankandContainment Purgereleasepathways, hencewemeettheNRC'srequirement toperformallanalysisrequiredby1301'sTable4.11-2.2235461301'sNote(3)isNote(6)intheODCM.i.e.,extrasamplesrequiredwithinonehourofa>15aReactorpowerchange...."~aeercurrentlantTSwordin2335461301'sNote(4)isnotincludedinODCM.Itis24hourfrequency TritiumSamplewhentherefueling canalisflooded.ThisisnotincurrentPlantTS.TritiumLevelshavenotbeenobservedabove1.E-06uCi/ccforyearsunderanyOperational Mode.Wesample4/Matasensitivity of4.E-OSuCi/cc,wellbelowtherequiredLLDof1.E-06etc.2435461301"4.AllReleaseTypesaslistedin1,2,and3above"vsODCM's"in3.above".Thisisexplained byDeviation g[21],whereWasteGasStorageTanks6Containment arecoveredbyPlantVentContinuous Collection.

2535'61301'swordingisconfusing onthisline,buttheODCMisusinthecurrentPlantTSwordinunderrespective columntopics.Thisisthecontinuous analysesforNobleGasesbyamonitoretc.

St.LNUREGDev.ODCM1301PAGEPAGEDESCRIPTION OFDEVIATION 2640511301'3.11.2.4.states"c.0.3mremtoanyorganofaMEMBEROFTHEPUBLIC".ODCMuses"c.0.3mremtoanyorgan."asourcurrentPlantTSisworded."atorbeyondthesiteboundary" isinclusive ofall,including MEMBERSOFTHEPUBLIC.26a4051TheGASEOUSRADWASTETREATMENT ControlStatement 3.11.2.4Surveillance Statement 4.11.2.4.1 TheDeviation brieflstatedis:ThereisanEditorial Difference, concerning thephysicaldescription forthelocation(s) ofwheretheLimit(s)applyfortheSt.LucieSite,betweentheCurrentTechSpecandNUREG-1301.WhattheCurrentTechSecstates:Page3/411-13"..whentheprojected gaseouseffluentairdosesduetogaseouseffluentreleasesfromthesitetoUNRESTRICTED AREASseeFiure~5.1-1whenaveragedover31days,wouldexceed:"WhattheODCMSubmittal states:Page40"..whentheprojected dosesin31daysduetogaseouseffluentreleases, fromeachunit,toareasatandbeondtheSITEBOUNDARYseeFiure5.1-1wouldexceed:".

Exlanations:

TheODCMwordingisasperpage[51]ofNUREG-1301 "ODCMGuidance:

StandardRadiological EffluentControlsforPressurized WaterReactors".

ThePlantStafffeelsthatNUREG-1301's guidanceinspecifying "toareasatandbeondtheSITEBOUNDARYseeFiure5.1-1"iscorrectforthisSt.LuciePlantODCMControl.Tofurthersupportthisposition, (continued)

~~St.LNUREGDev.ODCM1301PAGEPAGEDESCRIPTION OFDEVIATION TheGASEOUSRADWASTETREATMENT Limitsforoperability aretiedtoLCOs3.11.2.2"DOSENOBLEGASESiiand3.1123>>DOSEIODINE131IODINE133'RITIUM~

ANDRADIONUCLIDES INPARTICULATE FORM"whereeachoftheLCO'suse"toareasatandbeondtheSITEBOUNDARY" seeFiure5.1-1"astheircontrolling locationforapplicability.

Logically, relatedLCOsshouldalsohavethesamepointofapplicability.

==

Conclusion:==

27ThePlantStafffeelsthatthewordingdifferences betweencurrentTSandNUREG-1301 areeditorial innatureandthattheintentoftheTechSpecGASEOUSRADWASTETREATMENT LCOisnot,diminished byusingthewordingofNUREG-1301 intheODCMSubmittal.

Surveillance 4.11.2.4.1 wasnotdiscussed sinceitmustfollowthewordingoftheControlStatement.

48561301ACTIONb.OurODCMuses"Withtheconfirmed*

level..."

ThisisourcurrentTSwordin2850581301specifies 40Monitoring Locations andtheODCMsubmittal statesonly27Locations.

Sevenof16Sectorsareoverwater;Locations arebasedon1,5,and10mileRings,eachSectoroverland,proximity toresidences andaccessibility.

ThisisourcurrentTSwordin29305050591301specifies composite andtheODCMsubmittal statesGrabSamplesWeekly/Monthly.

Theeffluentflow(CircWater)byparameters oftheOceanarefairlyconstant, agrabsamplewouldsuffice.ThisisourcurrentTSwordin601301Table3.12-1Item3disODCMItem3b.1301requiresonelocation, ODCMusestwolocations.

ThisisourcurrentTSwordin,ODCMuses1forindicator and1foracontrol.Samesituation forODCMTable3.12-1Item4a.forCrustacea andFish.

St.LNUREGDev.ODCM1301PAGEPAGEDESCRIPTION OFDEVIATION 3150601301Table3.12-1Item4a:MilkSamples:ODCMdoesnotaddressasnosuitablemilkanimalwithin5km,nosizablemilkanimalherdfrom5to8km.OurcurrentTSwordin3233343550505053616161641301Table3.12-14b/ODCM4a1&2;1301specifies "EdiblePortion",

ODCMdoesnot.Althoughforfishtheedibleportionisabout504oftheweight,theorgansareexcellent.

indicators ofcontamination.

Forthecrustacea sampledthesamelogicisapplied(organsasindicators}.

OurcurrentTSwordincr, 1301Table3.12-14c:FoodProductsirrigated byeffluentaffectedwaterslthecurrentTSwordinc[orODOMdonotaddressasSt.LucieEffluentisdischarged totheOceanwhichisnotusedforirrigation.

1301Table3.12-14c/ODCM4b1:1301specifies "3kinds"ofbroadleafvegetation (BLV),CurrentPlantTSandODCMhaveno"kinds"secified.Otherthandecorative foliage,theareaclosetotheplant(theisland)islimitedonthevarietyofBLValthoughthesamplingprogrampermitsavarietyofBLVtobesampled.Basically, mangroveistheonlyplantcommontotheplantarea.ODCMTable3.12-2"ReortinLevelsforRadioactivit Concentrations inEnvironmental Samles"usesthecurrentPlantTechSecReortinLevelValues.Therearenodifferences in1301andthecurrentPlantTS,itsjusthowthelimitislistedrelativetoDrinkingWaterbeingpresentornot.UsingthecurrentTSwordingavoidsgivingtheappearance

.thatalimithasbeenchangedintheODCMsubmittal process.DrinkingWaterisnotapplicable totheSt.LucieSite.

St.LNUREGDev.ODCM1301PAGEPAGEDESCRIPTION OFDEVIATION 365465ODCMTable4.12-1"Detection Caabilities.."

usescurrentPlantTSLLDsrescribed forTritiumandI-131andtheirresectivefootnotes

"*"and"**".Therearenodifferences in1301andthecurrentPlantTS,itsjusthowthelimitislistedrelativetoDrinkingWaterbeingpresentornot.UsingthecurrentTSwordingavoidsgivingtheappearance thatalimithasbeenchangedintheODCMsubmittal process.3757-681301's3.12.2includeswordingfor:"ifelevatedreleasesthen...etc.ThiswasnotincludedinODCMsincebyDesignBaseswedonothaveanyelevatedreleasepointsbydefinition.

38576813013/4.12'.2 LANDUSECENSUS,thefootnoteof1301page68includes"ofatleastthreekindsofvegetation."

TheODCMdoesnotsecifthreekindsbutusescurrentPlantTS.SeeDeviation 34aboveforexplanation.

3959'0ODCMin3.12.3hasan"*"on"Commission" fortheODCMfootnote, and4.12.3explainsthedescription oftheInterlaboratory Comparison ProgramnotbeingincludedintheODCMaslongastheEnvironmental Protection AgencyistheILCProgramofrecord.TheEPAprogramisawellknownNRCapprovedprogramandtherequirement foradescription oftheEPAprogramshouldnotbeneeded.We,theStateofFlorida(HRS),participate intheEPAILCProgram.TheODCMusesthecurrentPlantTSwordin406575ODCMinBASESfor3/411.2.1DOSERATE,doesnotincludetheNUREG1301sentence"Examples ofcalculations forsuchMEMBERSOFTHEPUBLIC,withappropriate occupancy factors,shallbegivenintheODCM"becausecurrentPlantTSSemiannual Reortreuiresustodoactualvisitorassessment foreachannualreortininterval.