ML091490666
| ML091490666 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Indian Point  |
| Issue date: | 05/29/2009 |
| From: | Andrea Jones NRC/OGC |
| To: | Lathrop K, Lawrence Mcdade, Richard Wardwell Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel |
| SECY RAS | |
| References | |
| 50-247-LR, 50-286-LR, RAS E-259 | |
| Download: ML091490666 (12) | |
Text
UNITED STATES NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION WASHINGTON, D.C. 20555-0001 OFFICE OF THE GENERAL COUNSEL May 29,2009 Administrative Judge Administrative Judge Lawrence G. McDade, Chair Dr. Richard E. Wardwell Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel Mail Stop T-3 F23 Mail Stop T-3 F23 U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, DC 20555-0001 Washington, DC 20555-0001 Administrative Judge Dr. Kaye D. Lathrop 190 Cedar Lane East Ridgeway, CO 81432 In the Matter of ENTERGY NUCLEAR OPERATIONS, INC.
(Indian Point Nuclear Generating Station Units 2 and 3)
Docket Nos. 50-247-LR and 50-286-LR
Dear Administrative Judges:
Pursuant to the Atomic Safety and Licensing Board's December 18, 2008, "Memorandum and Order (Addressing Requests that the Proceeding be Conducted Pursuant to Subpart G)," slip op. at 13, and the Licensing Board's "Order (Granting Consent Motion Regarding Mandatory Disclosures)," dated January 30, 2009, at I , the staff of the U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission ("Staff') herein notifies the Licensing Board and the parties that the hearing file has been supplemented for this proceeding. Materials in the hearing file may be accessed through the Agencywide Documents Access and Management System ("ADAMS"). An index containing the ADAMS accession number, date, and title or description of each item in Hearing File Index, Supplement 4 is appended hereto as Attachment 1.
On or about June 4, 2009, the newly identified documents in the hearing file will be made available via the Electronic Hearing Docket ("EHD"), which may be accessed at the following URL: http://ehd.nrc.gov/EHD Proceeding/home.as~.The hearing file will be contained in a sub-folder entitled, "Indian PT Hearing File, Supplement 4" in the "Indian-PT-2&3-50-247&50-286-LR" folder of the EHD.
In addition, as required by 10 C.F.R. § 2.336(b)(5), the Staff is producing an updated privilege log, identifying documents withheld under the deliberative process privilege and documents containing proprietary, sensitive, or privacy-related information, which are appended hereto as Attachments 2 and 3, respectively. Also, attached is the Declaration of Brian E. Holian formally invoking the deliberative process privilege with respect to each of the documents in
Judge McDade May 29,2009 Judge Lathrop Judge Wardwell . The Staff will preserve and maintain the privileged documents identified in these logs during the pendency of this proceeding.
Further, pursuant to 10 C.F.R. 5 2.336(c), attached is the Affidavit of Andrew L. Stuyvenberg, certifying that all relevant materials required by this section have been disclosed, and that the disclosures are accurate and complete as to documents identified by May 22, 2009.
Finally, the NRC Staff notes that it has made a good faith effort to identify and characterize all documents meeting the criteria of 10 C.F.R. 5 2.336(b) and 10 C.F.R. 5 2.1203 in this proceeding. In identifying these documents, the Staff does not concede their relevance to the license renewal issues to be decided in this proceeding.
Enclosures:
Attachment 1 - Hearing File Index, Supplement 4 Attachment 2 - Deliberative Process Privilege Log Attachment 3 - Proprietary and Sensitive Information Log Declaration of Brian E. Holian Affidavit of Andrew L. Stuyvenberg cc w1Encls.: Service List
Attachment 1 - lndian Point License Renewal Hearing File Index Supplement 4 - May 29,2009 Accession Document ID # Number Date Title 2009101126 lndian Point LR Hearing - FW: lndian Point Conference Call- call-in 04-00 1 ML091350397 1/26/2009 procedures04-002 ML091350455 1/29/2009 2009/01/29 lndian Point LR Hearing - 17 safety problems found at lndian Pt.04-003 ML091120802 4/22/2009 2009104l22 lndian Point LR Hearing - Telecon on 4/27 at 1:00 pm EST 04-004 ML091170216 4/27/2009 2009104/27 lndian Point LR Hearing - FW: Revised comparative pictures04-005 ML091270867 5/7/2009 2009/05/07 lndian Point LR Hearing - FW: RE: Conference call time request 04-006 ML091400219 511112009 2009/05/11 lndian Point LR Hearing - FW: RAI Fig 2 2009/05/13 lndian Point LR Hearing - Draft RAI 3.4.2-2 related to the IP2 AFW 04-007 ML091330555 5/13/2009 pump room fire event open item 04-008 ML091350456 5/13/2009 2009/05/13 lndian Point LR Hearing - Hudson River Estuary meetings clarification 2009/05/14 lndian Point LR Hearing - Fwd: Hudson River Estuary meetings04-009 ML091350457 511412009 clarification 2009/05/14 lndian Point LR Hearing - RE: Entergy lndian Point Units 2 & 3 -
04-010 ML091340299 5/14/2009 Section 401 WQC - NOlA and RFI 04-01 1 ML091350174 5/15/2009 2009/05/15 lndian Point LR Hearing - Draft RAls 2009/05/19 lndian Point LR Hearing - RE: Teleconference Call Summary --April 04-012 ML091390874 5/19/2009 27,2009 2009/05/19 lndian Point LR Hearing - Teleconference Call Summary -- April 27,04-013 ML091390877 5/19/2009 2009 Page 1 of 1
Attachment 2 - lndian Point License Renewal Hearing File Index Deliberative Process Privilege, Supplement 4 - May 29, 2009 Certain c ~cumentsother rise subject to inc usion in the hearing file and mandatory disclosures for this proceeding have been determined by the NRC Staff to c mtain informatit n subject to withh )Iding from public disclosures as predecisional, deliberative information. Pursuant to 10 C.F.R. § 2.336(b)(5),
7 Accession Author Name1 Document Document Page ID # i umber Title Date Type Comment Count DPP 2008107125 Indian Point LR Hearing - Internal transmission of 001 simple answer 7/25/2008 E-Mail comments regarding EIS 4 2008108104 lndian Point LR Hearing -
DPP ID. Logan information on cost of mitigation Internal transmission of 002 DPP 003 F D. Logan alternatives 2008/09/16 Indian Point LR Hearing - RE:
Convert ppt to mglL 8/4/2008 E-Mail 9/16/2008 E-Mail comments regarding EIS Internal transmission of comments regarding EIS 2
2 DPP D. Logan 2008/09/17 Indian Point LR Hearing - Internal transmission of 004 redbreast sunfish (Lepomis auritus) 911712008 E-Mail comments regarding EIS 2 DPP 2008/09/18 Indian Point LR Hearing - RE: Internal transmission of 005 NRCINRR IP - Same para as last e-mail 911812008 E-Mail comments regarding EIS 2 2008/09/19 lndian Point LR Hearing - RE:
DPP D. Logan Impingement sampling at IP - from Internal transmission of 006 NRCINRR chapter 4 9/19/2008 E-Mail comments regarding EIS 2 2008/09/19 lndian Point LR Hearing - RE:
DPP ID. Logan Impingement sampling at IP - from Internal transmission of 007 DPP 008 F D. Logan NRCINRR chapter 4 2008/09/19 Indian Point LR Hearing - RE:
IP - Same para as last e-mail 9/19/2008 E-Mail 9/19/2008 E-Mail comments regarding EIS Internal transmission of comments regarding EIS 2
2 DPP V. Cullinan 2008111/12 Indian Point LR Hearing - Internal transmission of 009 PNNL Entrainment and Impingement 11/12/2008 E-Mail comments regarding EIS 9 DPP n ai l ;; i ; 200811 1/14 Indian Point LR Hearing - Internal transmission of 010 references 11/14/2008 E-Mail comments regarding EIS 5 DPP H. Nash 2008/12/15 Indian Point LR Hearing - RE: Internal transmission of 01 1 NRCINRO The bluefish question 1211512008 E-Mail comments regarding EIS 3 DPP V. Cullinan 2009/01/05 Indian Point LR Hearing - RE: Internal transmission of 012 PNNL This might help. -Dennis 1/5/2009 E-Mail comments regarding EIS 10 DPP D. Logan 2009/01/08 Indian Point LR Hearing - RE: Internal transmission of 013 NRCINRR Question... 1/8/2009 E-Mail comments regarding EIS 2 2009/01/27 lndian Point LR Hearing -
DPP V. Cullinan Responses to Question from Conference Internal transmission of 014 PNNL Call 1-27-09 1/27/2009 E-Mail comments regarding EIS 3 Page 1 of 2
Attachment 2 - lndian Point License Renewal Hearing File Index Deliberative Process Privilege, Supplement 4 - May 29, 2009 Accession Author Name1 Document Document Page ID# Number Affliation Title Date TYpe Comment Count DPP D. Logan Internal transmission of 015 ML091350392 NRCINRR 2009102120 Indian Point LR Hearing - 2l2012009 E-Mail comments regarding EIS 7 DPP D. Logan 2009103/17 Indian Point LR Hearing - Internal transmission of 016 ML091350390 NRCINRR Primrose path 3/17/2009 E-Mail comments regarding EIS 2 DPP D. Logan 2009104/15 Indian Point LR Hearing - Internal transmission of 017 ML091350375 NRCINRR ENSR 2000 4/15/2009 E-Mail comments regarding EIS 2 2009104/29 lndian Point LR Hearing -
DPP D. Logan NMFS's comments on the Indian Point Internal transmission of 018 ML091350372 NRCINRR biological assessment 4/29/2009 E-Mail comments regarding EIS 5 DPP V. Cullinan 2009104130 Indian Point LR Hearing - Internal transmission of 019 ML091350425 PNNL Selection of RIS 413012009 E-Mail comments regarding EIS 2 DPP 2009105/07 Indian Point LR Hearing - Re: Internal transmission of 020 ML091350430 J. Ward PNNL Conference call time request 5/7/2009 E-Mail comments regarding EIS 3 Page 2 of 2
Attachment 3 - Indian Point License Renewal Hearing File Index Proprietary and Sensitive Information, Supplement 4 - May 29, 2009 Certain documents otherwise subject to inclusion in the hearing file and mandatory disclosures for this proceeding have been determined by the NRC Staff to contain trade secrets, privileged or confidential commercial or financial information or to contain sensitive unclassified non-safeguards information (SUNSI), or personally identifiable information (PII). Pursuant to 10 C.F.R. §2.336(b)(5), the Staff is providing this log to identify the following documents, which are either designated proprietary or which have been withheld because they contain SUNS1 or PI1 and are subject to protected status under Section 2.390.
ID # Accession Number Author NameIAffiliation TitleIDescription Document Date Document Type Comment Page Count 2009105107 Indian Point LR Hearing - FW: RE:
Conference call time 04-001 ML091350370 D. Logan NRCINRR request 5/7/2009 E-Mail Contains PI1 3 Page 1 of 1
May 29, 2009 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION BEFORE THE ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING BOARD In the Matter of )
ENTERGY NUCLEAR OPERA1-IONS, INC. Docket Nos. 50-247 & 50-286-LR
)
ASLBP NO.07-858-03-LR-BD01 (Indian Point Nuclear Generating Units 2 and 3) )
DECLARATION OF BRIAN E. HOLIAN I, Brian E. Holian, do hereby state as follows:
- 1. I am employed as the Director of the Division of Licensing Renewal ("DLR") in the U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission's ("NRC") Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
("NRR"). My supervisory responsibilities include oversight of the NRC Staff's review and evaluation of the Indian Point Nuclear Generating Station Units 2 and 3 license renewal application.
- 2. As part of their responsibilities in updating the hearing file and mandatory disclosures for these proceedings, NRC staff members under my supervision identified certain documents as privileged because they contained information concerning the Staff's pre-decisional deliberative process. Those documents are listed in Attachment 2 to the May 29, 2009 submission of the Staff's Hearing File Index Supplement 4.
- 3. I have personally reviewed the documents identified as privileged in Attachment 2, and have determined, in accordance with the guidance set forth in Management Directive 3.4, that they contain pre-decisional information concerning the Staff's review of the license renewal application. All documents contain either Staff's analyses, recommendations, opinions, or evaluations, and may not necessarily reflect the final agency position with respect to the
matters discussed therein. Each of the documents comprises part of the deliberative process necessary for the Staff's review of the pending license renewal application.
- 4. Further, I have determined that disclosure of these documents could result in harm to the agency, in that it would (a) prematurely disclose the preliminary views of individual Staff members andlor the Staff prior to reaching a final agency decision, and could thus create confusion as to the actual policy or views of the NRC Staff; (b) hinder the efficiency of the Staff, in that forced disclosure of its internal discussions on an unresolved issue would tend to chill all future deliberations and would interfere with the Staff's ability to engage in a free exchange of opinions and analyses prior to publishing its final review documents; and (c) imply or suggest incorrectly that the opinions of the Staff members involved in these communications are actually the final decisions of the agency, while no such final decision has yet been made.
- 5. Accordingly, I formally invoke the deliberative process privilege with respect to each of the documents listed in Attachment 2 to the May 29, 2009 submission of the Staff's Hearing File Index Supplement 4.
- 6. I declare under penalty of perjury that the foregoing is true and correct to the best of my knowledge, information and belief.
Brian E. Holian Executed in Rockville, Maryland this 29th day of May, 2009
May 29,2009 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION BEFORE THE ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING BOARD In the Matter of )
)
ENTERGY NUCLEAR OPERATIONS, INC. ) Docket Nos. 50-247 & 50-286-LR OPERATIONS, INC. ) )
1 ASLBP NO.07-858-03-LR-BD01 (Indian Point Nuclear Generation Station, )
Units 2 and 3) 1 AFFIDAVIT OF ANDREW L. STUWENBERG CONCERNING MANDATORY DISCLOSURE REQUIREMENT OF 10 C.F.R. 6 2.336(b)
I, Andrew L. Stuyvenberg, do hereby state as follows:
- 1. I am employed as a Project Manager in the Division of License Renewal in the U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission's ("NRC") Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation. I serve as a project manager for the Indian Point Nuclear Generating Station, Units 2 and 3 license renewal application ("LRA"). Among other things, I am managing the preparation of the hearing lile and mandatory disclosures in connection with the LRA at issue in this proceeding.
- 2. I hereby certify that all relevant materials required to be disclosed pursuant to 10 C.F.R. 5 2.336 (b) and (c) in the captioned proceeding have been disclosed, and that the disclosures are accurate and complete for documents identified as of May 20, 2009.
- 3. I declare under penalty of perjury that the foregoing is true and correct to the best of my knowledge, information and belief.
// / -,(, - -
Executed in Rockville, Maryland this 29th day of May, 2009
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION BEFORE THE ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING BOARD In the Matter of )
1 EN-TERGY NUCLEAR OPERATIONS, INC. ) Docket Nos. 50-2471286-LR
)
(Indian Point Nuclear Generating 1 Units 2 and 3) 1 CERTIFICA'TE OF SERVICE I hereby certify that copies of the foregoing Letter to the Atomic Safety and Licensing Board regarding the Indian Point Hearing File, including: Attachment 1 - Indian Point License Renewal Hearing File Index Supplement 4, Attachment 2 - Deliberative Process Privilege Log, - Proprietary and Sensitive Information Log, Declaration of Brian E. Holian, dated May 29, 2009, and Affidavit of Andrew L. Stuyvenberg, dated May 29, 2009, have been served upon the following through deposit in the NRC's internal mail system, with copies by electronic mail, or, as indicated by an asterisk, by deposit in the U.S. Postal Service, with copies by electronic mail this 2gthday of May, 2009:
Lawrence G. McDade, Chair Office of Commission Appellate Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel Adjudication Mail Stop - T-3 F23 U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Mail Stop: 0-16G4 Washington, D.C. 20555-0001 Washington, DC 20555-0001 E-mail: Lawrence.McDade@nrc.nov E-mail: OCAAMAI L.resource@nrc.gov Dr. Richard E. Wardwell Office of the Secretary Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel Attn: Rulemaking and Adjudications Staff Mail Stop - T-3 F23 Mail Stop: 0-16G4 U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D.C. 20555-0001 Washington, DC 20555-0001 E-mail: Richard.Wardwell@nrc.gov E-mail: Hearing.Docket@nrc.qov Dr. Kaye D. Lathrop Zachary S. Kahn Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel 190 Cedar Lane E. Mail Stop - T-3 F23 Ridgway, CO 81432 U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission E-mail: Kave.Lathrop@nrc.sov Washington, DC 20555-0001 E-mail: Zacharv.Kahn@nrc.qov
Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel Manna Jo Greene*
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Hudson River Sloop Clearwater, Inc.
Mail Stop: T-3 F23 112 Little Market Street Washington, DC 20555-0001 Poughkeepsie, NY 12601 (Via Internal Mail Only) E-mail: mannaio@clearwater.orq Kathryn M. Sutton, Esq.* William C. Dennis, Esq.*
Paul M. Bessette, Esq. Assistant General Counsel Martin J. O'Neill, Esq. Entergy Nuclear Operations, Inc.
Morgan, Lewis & Bockius, LLP 440 Hamilton Avenue 1111 Pennsylvania Avenue, NW White Plains, NY 10601 Washington, D.C. 20004 E-mail: wdennis@entergy.com E-mail: ksutton@moraanlewis.com E-mail: pbessette@moraanlewis.com E-mail: martin.o'neill@morganlewis.com Michael J. Delaney, Esq.* Mylan L. Denerstein, Esq.*
Vice President - Energy Department Janice A. Dean, Esq.
New York City Economic Development Executive Deputy Attorney General, Corporation (NYCDEC) Social Justice 110 William Street Office of the Attorney General New York, NY 10038 of the State of New York E-mail: mdelaney@nycedc.com 120 Broadway, 25thFloor New York, NY 10271 E-mail: mylan.denerstein@oag.state.nv.us janice.dean@oa~.state.nv,us Justin D. Pruyne, Esq.* Diane Curran, Esq.*
Assistant County Attorney Harmon, Curran, Spielberg & Eisenberg, LLP Office of the Westchester County Attorney 1726 M Street, NW, Suite 600 148 Martine Avenue, 6thFloor Washington, D.C. 20036 White Plains, NY 10601 E-mail: dcurran@harmoncurran.com E-mail: idp3@westchester~ov.com Daniel E. OINeill, Mayor* John J. Sipos, Esq.*
James Seirmarco, M.S. Charlie Donaldson, Esq.
Village of Buchanan Assistants Attorney General Municipal Building New York State Department of Law Buchanan, NY 10511-1298 Environmental Protection Bureau E-mail: vob@bestweb.net The Capitol Albany, NY 12224 E-mail: john.si~os@oaa.state.ny.us
Robert Snook, Esq.* Daniel Riesel, Esq.*
Office of the Attorney General Thomas F. Wood, Esq.
State of Connecticut Ms. Jessica Steinberg, J.D.
55 Elm Street Sive, Paget & Riesel, P.C.
P.O. Box 120 460 Park Avenue Hartford, CN 06141-0120 New York, NY 10022 E-mail: robert.snook@~o.state.ct.us E-mail: driesel@sprlaw.com jsteinberg@sprlaw.com Victor Tafur, Esq.* Joan Leary Matthews, Esq.*
Phillip Musegaas, Esq. Senior Attorney for Special Projects Deborah Brancato, Esq. New York State Department of Riverkeeper, Inc. Environmental Conservation 828 South Broadway Office of the General Counsel Tarrytown, NY 10591 625 Broadway, 14'~Floor E-mail: phillip@riverkeeper.orq Albany, NY 12233-1500 vtafur@riverkeeper.org E-mail: jlmatthe@~w.dec.state.nv.us dbrancato@riverkeeper.org Elise N. Zoli, Esq.* John Louis Parker, Esq.*
Goodwin Procter, LLP Office of General Counsel, Region 3 Exchange Place New York State Department of 53 State Street Environmental conservation Boston, MA 02109 21 South Putt Corners Road E-mail: ezoli@goodwinprocter.com New Paltz, NY 12561-1620 E-mail: jlparker@gw.dec.state.nv.us Ross H. Gould, Esq.*
10 Park Ave, #5L New York, NY 10016 T: 917-658-7144 E-mail: rgouldesq@qmail.com Counsel for NRC Staff