ML19345H107

Motion for Resumption of Evidentiary Hearing on Contention 13.New & Matl Info Previously Unavailable Now Available. Info May Indicate Prejury by Applicants' Witnesses Re Contention 13.Certificate of Svc Encl

ML19345H107
Person / Time
Site:	Zimmer
Issue date:	04/21/1981
From:	Feldman J FELDMAN, J.H., JR., MIAMI VALLEY POWER PROJECT
To:	Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel
References
NUDOCS 8104300506
Download: ML19345H107 (4)

Text

/ ,9 A

' , . >4: WI> / /.

e R[Ql{[g%= . .< Oocco  %

-3 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA U b E

~

' 6u.s,  %- ApR 2 91981m j-NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION APR g 0981P h.

y Y ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING BOARD DEC9 e et

1. Charles Bechhoefer, Chairman

• Dr. Frank F. Hooper, Member N /

~t Dr. M. Stanley Livingston, Member In the Matter of:  :

CINCINNATI GAS & ELECTRIC -

DOCKET NO. 50-358 COMPANY, ct.al.,

(William H. Zimmer Nuclear  : APPLICATION FOR OPERATING LICENSE Power Station)

MOTION BY INTERVENOR MIAMI VALLEY POWER PROJECT FOR RESUMPTION OF EVIDENTIARY HEARING ON CONTENTION 13 Comes now the intervenor,of the Miami Valley Pcwer Itoject (MVPP),

by and through counsel, and hereby moves the Atomic Safety and Licensing Board for an Order to reopen the evidentiary hearing on contention 13 for the reason that new and material evidence unavailable to intervenor at the time of the last evidentiary hearing has just been made avail-l able to intervenor and for the further reason that such information may

(

l indicate that witnesses for the applicants may have perjured themselves at the last evidentiary hearing concerning contention 13. If this Motion is granted, intervenor further moves the Board for a continuance in the deadline set for filings of proposed findings of fact and con-l Clusions of law. .-

l ..

Respectfully submitted, James . Feldmao Q r.

216 E st Ninth " Street, 5th floor Cine nnati, Ohio 45202 (513) 621-6151 s.

8104300 9 0 6

MEMORANDUM IN SUPPORT At the evidentiary hearing in this matter during the week of March 2, 1981, counsel for the intervenor of Miami Valley Power Project inquired of witnesses for the applicants as to the costs they would incur in order to provide repircement power in the event of a total shut-down of the Zimmer Plant. Defendant's answered that there would be little or no costs since the power from Zimmer was not necessary due to the applicants' reserve capacity.

On April 8, 1981, counsel for intervenor MVPP received in the mail a letter from Mr. E. A. Borgmann and to Mr. Harold Denton, dated April 2,1981, in which Mr. Borgmann provided information as to the monthly costs to maintain the Zimmer Plant in an inactive status. In that f

letter (a copy of which is attached hereto as Attachment 1) he indicates a 5.3 million dollar monthly cost for replacement power in the event that the Zimmer Plant is inactive.

This letter contradicts testimonial elicited at the hearing, and for this reason MVPP seeks the opportunity to further cross-examine applicants concerning their financial capacity to operate the Zimmer I Plant in light of this additional evidence.

l Respectfully submitted, l /T/- '[- r

~

, A' g 8 '/W/}

James H. Fe L4=an, Jr. L' t

I i

l l

{

l l

I j  :.

e, . .

. C_.

w d-ATTACHMENT ?.

- ,9y 1

m --

THE CINCINNATI GAS & ELECTRIC COMPANY crr'-- - "

CINCINNATI.oHlo 4 52cl Wili, O -

c. a. a o R G M AN N sc . ..c c cs.oc , gQC NW O<

ygs?.G 2 b p3 34 $P Docket No. 50-358

{ --

April 2, 1981 ..

0 /8 l Mr. Harold Denton, Director  %

Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation s ,

{ U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission "

Washington, D.C. 20555 l

l l RE: WM. H. ZIMMER NUCLEAR POWER STATION -

UNIT 1 - MONTHLY COST OF INACTIVE STATUS

Dear Mr. Denton:

i

~

This is' in response to the NRC letter of Marc h 25, 1981 from R. L. Tedesco to E. A. Borgmann. In that letter, the staff requested l that the applicant provide its best estimate of the monthly cost to maintain the Zimmer Plant in an inactive status while awaiting a full power operating license. As requested, this information was provided orally to Mr. I. A.

Peltier, Licensing Project Manager, before noon on Friday, March 27.

Attached is a copy of the information given to Mr. Peltier by phone.

Very truly yours, THE CINCINNATI GAS & ELECTR.IC COMPA1R l

By E. A. BORGMANN EAB: dew Enclosure cc: Charles Bechhoefer State of Ohio )

M. Stanley Livingston County of Hamilton)ss Frank F. Hooper Troy B. Conner, Jr. Sworn to and subscribed before me this Oam.s P. Fenstermaker Steven G. Smith 3N day of April, 1981.

William J. Moran J.1. ' ert Newlin W '.l. 2( Porter, Jr. /J( m % f [ / w tmeu D. Flynn Notary Public i 'I Daniels k W. Peter Heile MARGAR_T L. HUEER James H. Feldmani Jr4 N:::y FctS. :: Oi C do John D. Woliver 1 y Cc::nr.is:.sa Ea; a / g. 13, 11,43 l @ FC O ( ' Mary Reder g} gg4 rg David K. Martin George E. Pattison Q gp- Andrew B. Dennison l . _ . . _ . _ . _ _ _ _ __ _ - _ _ . _ - - _

~ .~

COST OF PEPIACEMI:NT ENERGY AND CAPITAL EXPENSE INCURRED (4JE TO LICENSING DEIAYS (ALL COST ESTIMATES ARE IN OJRRENT DOLIARS) Capital Extense .*

Energy Capital Cost of Peplacement +

Esti- Total Replace- Estimated Expense Average Delay Capital Incre- snated Replace- ment Capital

• Cost of Energy cost During Expense Replace- Nuclear mental Length ment -

Energy Cost Per of Unit at Delay Per Replacement Fuel ment Fuel Fuel of Month Cost Delay Cost Month Completion Period Mix t Fuel Cost 6 6 6 6 Hills /kWh Months $1 x 10 $1 x 10 $1 x 10 $1 x 10 MWe Coat oi! Gas Hills /kWh Mills /kWh unit 16.0 5.3 1030 10.0 6.0 95 5 24.5 9.2 15.3 3 Zimmer 792 e

d ,

d LD rp 3-1, f, C IN C # '

C h*d30E

• g, o $o Nli U'8  %

i 81 y9 s 7 l t g 5

UNITED STATES OF AMERICA j NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION ,/ c ,,,,, n.,. g ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING BOARD l IE-

- APR 2 41981> [-9' Charles Bechhoefer, Chairman O!!i::s dtM W ,*

. Dr. Frank F. Hooper, Member t/ DxWW3G32ME4 A

Dr. M. Stanley Livingston In\,

In the Matter of  :

CINCINNATI GAS AND ELECTRIC  :

COMPANY, ET AL,  : DOCKET NO. 50-358 (William H. Zimmer Nuclear  : APPLICATION FOR Power Station)  : OPERATING LICENSE.

I _ _. . __ __

CERTIFICATE.OF SERVICE I hereby certify that copies of Motion bv Intervenor Miami Vallev Power Proiect for Resumption of Evidentiarv Hearine on Contention 13, and Attachment in the above-captioned proceed-ing have been served on the following persons by posting the same

in the U.S. Mails, postage prepaid, this 71 day of Anril 1981 i

i Charles Bechhoefer, Esq., Chairman Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D.C. 20555 Dr. Frank F. Hooper Troy B. Conner, Esq.

i^ School of Natural Resources Conner, Moore & Corber l University of Michigan 1747 Pennsylvania Avenue, N.W.

Ann Arbor, Michigan 48109 Washington, D.C. 20006 William J. Moran, Esq. John D. Woliver, Esq.

General Counsel P.O. Box 47

! Cincinnati Gas & Electric Co. 550 Kilgore Street P.O. Box 960 Batavia, Ohio 45103 Cincinnati, Ohio 45201 Chairman W. Peter Heile, Esq. Atomic Safety and Licensing Appeal Assistant City Solicitor Board Room 214, City Hall U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission

! Cincinnati, Ohio 45220 Washington, D.C. 20555

Charloa A. Barth, Eng. Chairman

.O.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Room MNBB 9604 Panel 7735 Old Georgetown Road U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Bethesda, Maryland 20014 Washington, D.C. 20555 Chase Stephens Mary Reder Docketing and Service Section Box 270 -

Office of the Secretary Route 2 U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission California, Kentucky 41007 Washington, D.C. l20555 .

David K. Martin, Esq.

. , , Richard S. Salzman, Esq. '

Assistant Attorney General

. Chairman i Division of Enviromental Law

.-'- Atomic Safety & Licensing Appeal Attorney General for the Commonwea; Board l of Kentucky U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 209 St. Clair Street Washington, D.C. 20555 Frankfort, Kentucky 40601 Lawrence Quarles Andrew B. Dennison Atomic Safety & Licensing Appeal 200 Main Street Board , Batavia, Ohio 45103 U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D.C. l20555 i .

g Michael C. Farrarl Esq.

f Atomic Safety & Licensing Appeal George Patti' son Board  !

Prosecuting Attorney U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Clermont County Washington, D.C. 20555 154 Main Street Batavia, Ohio 45103

' Administrative Judge M. Stanley Livingston 1005 Calle Largo Santa Fe, New Mexico 87501 I

f'

. lfr. _ '

l James H. Feldman, Jr.

A orney for MVPP 2 6 East Ninth Street C nci-nati, Ohio 45202 (513) 621-6151 l

l l

- , , , -. a ,---p-,- r--.e - , - - - - - , ,