ML14205A040
| ML14205A040 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Diablo Canyon  |
| Issue date: | 04/04/2014 |
| From: | Phan S Invensys/Triconex |
| To: | Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation |
| Shared Package | |
| ML14205A031 | List:
|
| References | |
| 3500897372, 993754, DCL-14-034 993754-1-812 (-NP), Rev 1 | |
| Download: ML14205A040 (138) | |
Text
- 1 n v e. n s* s* 0
- i f1 v*e. f1 s*.!:l s* Operations Management Triconex Project: PG&E PROCESS PROTECTION SYSTEM REPLACEMENT Purchase Order No.: 3500897372 Project Sales Order: 993754 PACIFIC GAS & ELECTRIC COMPANY NUCLEAR SAFETY -RELATED PROCESS PROTECTION SYSTEM REPLACEMENT DIABLO CANYON POWER PLANT VALIDATION TEST SPECIFICATION (VTS) Document No. 993754-1-812 Revision 1 I April 04 ,201 4 I Title Author: Nuclear IV&V En ineer Reviewers:
A rovals:
Document: 993754-1-8 12 Title: DCPP PPS Validation Test Specification Revision: 1 Page: 2 of 138 Date: 0 4/04/201 4 Document Change History Revision Date Change Author 0 11/12/2013 Initial Issue S. Phan 1 0 4/04/2014
Document: 993754-1-8 12 Title: DCPP PPS Validation Test Specification Revision: 1 Page: 3 of 138 Date: 0 4/04/201 4 Table of Contents List of Tables
............................................................................................................
7 List of Figures ...........................................................................................................
8
Document: 993754-1-8 12 Title: DCPP PPS Validation Test Specification Revision: 1 Page: 4 of 138 Date: 0 4/04/201 4 1 Purpose.................................................................................................................
9 2 Scope ..................................................................................................................
11 2.1 V10 Tricon Portion of the P PS ......................................................................................................................
12 3 References
.........................................................................................................
13 3.1 PG&E Documents
................................................................................................
.........................................
13 3.2 Invensys Operations Management Documents
..............................................................................................
13 3.3 NRC Documents ................................................................................................
........................................
13 3.4 Industry Documents
................................................................................................
.......................................
13 4 Definitions, Acronyms, and Abbreviations
...................................................
15 4.1 Definitions
................................................................................................
.....................................................
15 4.2 Acronyms ................................................................................................
......................................................
15 4.3 Abbreviations
................................................................................................
................................................
16 5 Test Specification Identifier
............................................................................
17 6 Features to be Tested
.......................................................................................
19 6.1 Hardware Validation Testing
.........................................................................................................................
19 6.2 System Validation Testing
.............................................................................................................................
19 7 Features not to be Tested
................................................................................
21 7.1 Diagnostic Functions
................................................................................................
.....................................
21 7.2 SRS Tag Tracebility for Untested Features
...................................................................................................
21 8 Test Approach Refinements
...........................................................................
22 8.1 Validation Techniques
................................................................................................
...................................
22 8.1.1 Techniques for System Validation ......................................................................................................
22 8.2 Hardware Validation Testing
.........................................................................................................................
23 8.2.1 Hardware Configuration
.....................................................................................................................
23 8.2.2 Hardware Validation Test Prerequisites
.............................................................................................
24 8.2.3 Outline of Hardware Validation Testing
.............................................................................................
25 8.3 System Validation Testing .............................................................................................................................
25 8.3.1 Factory Acceptance Test Prerequisites
...............................................................................................
25 8.3.2 Field Input Simulation
........................................................................................................................
26 8.3.3 Test Anomalies
................................................................................................
...................................
26 8.3.4 Test Environmental Conditions
..........................................................................................................
26 9 Test Identification
............................................................................................
27 9.1 Hardware Validation Tests Identification
......................................................................................................
27 9.1.1 Hardware Validation Test Case Identifier
..........................................................................................
27 9.2 Hardware Validation Test Design
.................................................................................................................
28
Document: 993754-1-8 12 Title: DCPP PPS Validation Test Specification Revision: 1 Page: 5 of 138 Date: 0 4/04/201 4 9.2.1 Power-up Test System Verification
....................................................................................................
28 9.2.2 Field Input / Output Verification
........................................................................................................
29 9.3 Factory Acceptance Tests Identification
........................................................................................................
30 9.3.1 Factory Acceptance Test Case Identifier
............................................................................................
30 9.3.2 SRS Tag Traceability
..........................................................................................................................
32 9.4 Factory Acceptance Tests Design
..................................................................................................................
32 9.4.1 External Interface Requirements
.........................................................................................................
32 9.4.1.1 Inputs/Outputs
...............................................................................................................................
32 9.4.1.2 User Interfaces
..............................................................................................................................
32 9.4.1.3 Hardware Interfaces
......................................................................................................................
32 9.4.1.4 Manual Trip Switches and Indications
..........................................................................................
33 9.4.1.5 Manual Bypass Switches
...............................................................................................................
34 9.4.1.6 Out-of-Service Switches (OOS)
....................................................................................................
35 9.4.1.7 Trip and Bypass Test Features
......................................................................................................
38 9.4.1.8 Software Interfaces
........................................................................................................................
38 9.4.1.9 Communication Interfaces
.............................................................................................................
39 9.4.2 External Input/Output
.........................................................................................................................
39 9.4.3 Functional Requirements
....................................................................................................................
40 9.4.3.1 System Diagnostics
.......................................................................................................................
40 9.4.3.2 Failure Alarms
...............................................................................................................................
41 9.4.3.3 Trouble Alarms
.............................................................................................................................
42 9.4.3.4 Bypass Alarms
..............................................................................................................................
44 9.4.3.5 RTD Failure Alarms
......................................................................................................................
45 9.4.3.6 Out-of-Service Alarms
..................................................................................................................
46 9.4.3.7 Remove From Service (RFS) Indication
.......................................................................................
47 9.4.3.8 Time Response
..............................................................................................................................
48 9.4.4 Online Test and Calibration Access
....................................................................................................
49 9.4.4.1 Online Test and Calibration Access
..............................................................................................
49 9.4.4.2 Test Analog Indication
..................................................................................................................
51 9.4.4.3 Annunciator Output
.......................................................................................................................
52 9.4.4.4 Channel in Maintenance
................................................................................................................
53 9.4.4.5 Test-In-Trip ................................................................................................
...................................
54 9.4.4.6 Test-In-Bypass ..............................................................................................................................
56 9.4.4.7 Tunable Constants and Setpoints
..................................................................................................
59 9.4.4.8 Data Retention after Power Cycle
................................................................................................. 60 9.4.5 Wide Range Reactor Coolant Temperature
........................................................................................
61 9.4.6 Wide Range Reactor Coolant Pressure
...............................................................................................
67 9.4.7 Delta Temperature - Temperature Average (DTTA)
.........................................................................
72 9.4.8 Pressurizer Level
................................................................................................
................................
91 9.4.9 Pressurizer Vapor Temperature
..........................................................................................................
93 9.4.10 Steamflow ................................................................................................
...........................................
97 9.4.11 Steamline Break Protection
..............................................................................................................
102 9.4.12 Steam Generator Narrow Range Level
.............................................................................................
116 9.4.13 Turbine Impulse Chamber Pressure
..................................................................................................
131 9.4.14 Security ................................................................................................
.............................................
135 9.4.15 Maintainability
................................................................................................
..................................
135 10 Feature Pass / Fail Criteria
...........................................................................
137 10.1 Qualitative Method
................................................................................................
......................................
137 10.2 Quantitative Method
................................................................................................
....................................
137 10.3 Acceptance Criteria Accuracy and Precision
...............................................................................................
137
Document: 993754-1-8 12 Title: DCPP PPS Validation Test Specification Revision: 1 Page: 6 of 138 Date: 0 4/04/201 4
Document: 993754-1-8 12 Title: DCPP PPS Validation Test Specification Revision: 1 Page: 7 of 138 Date: 0 4/04/201 4 List of Tables Table 1: Validation Test Specification Outline
...................................................................................................
10 Table 2: V10 Tricon Protection Set Requirements Categories
.............................................................................
20 Table 3: The list of requirements without the associated test case identifier(s)
....................................................
21
Document: 993754-1-8 12 Title: DCPP PPS Validation Test Specification Revision: 1 Page: 8 of 138 Date: 0 4/04/201 4 List of Figures Figure 1: Tricon Protection Set Architecture for the PPS Replacement System-----
12 Figure 2: Overall Validation Test Document Structure--------------..
17
Document: 993754-1-8 12 Title: DCPP PPS Validation Test Specification Revision: 1 Page: 9 of 138 Date: 0 4/04/201 4 1 Purpose This document constitutes the entire validation test specification (VTS) for the Invensys Operations Management (IOM) portion of the Diablo Canyon Power Plant Process Protection System Replacement Project. Per PG&E's request, and as described fully in the validation test plan [Ref 3.2.5], this specification also addresses specific communication interface testing of the Tricon , NetOptics Network Port Aggregator Tap (hereafter, "port aggregator")
, Maintenance Workstation (MWS) and KVM switch. Under IOM process, hardware validation testing is embedded in the system validation test plans and test specifications. Therefore, this document addresses the design of protection set Tricon hardware validation testing. Note that, under IOM process, hardware validation includes a considerable amount of hardware verification testing; i.e., assessing conformance of the hardware to Hardware Requirement Specifications (HRS). IOM's deliverables to PG&E consist primarily of four V10 Tricon systems, executing application
specific TriStation Application Projects (TSAPs). The V10 Tricons are major elements in the four protection sets that make up the plant protection system; one Tricon per protection set.
The detailed description of IOM's scope of delivery, which effectively defines the items subject to validation, is provided in the project management plan (PMP) [Ref 3.2.2]. Hereafter, the four Tricons subject to this validation test are referred to collectively as the "V10 Tricon Protection Set". Individually, the protections sets are denoted as Protection Set I, Protection Set II, Protection Set III, and Protection Set IV (using a Roman numeral convention).
The protection sets include equipment outside IOM's scope of delivery. Except where noted, in this document the terms Protection Set I, Protection Set II, Protection Set III, and Protection Set IV refer exclusively to the protection set components with Invensys scope of supply.
This document describes the design of all validation tests to be carried out on the V10 Tricon Protection S et. Several tests are common to one or more V10 Tricon Protection Sets, because of redundant functionality and/or design among them. Some tests are unique to a specific V10 Tricon Protection Set, because of its unique functions or design.
This document contains sufficient detail to permit the development of the validation test cases and procedures, although test case and procedure details will draw upon information in the engineering documents.
This VTS was developed in accordance with PPM 6.0: Test Control [Ref 3.2.1] and conforms to IEEE-829-1983: IEEE Standard for Software Test Documentation [Ref 3.4.2] and NRC guidance documents (Section 3.3). Table 1 describes the correlation between PPM development requirements, IEEE-829-1983 guidance, and the layout of this document.
Document: 993754-1-8 12 Title: DCPP PPS Validation Test Specification Revision: 1 Page: 10 of 138 Date: 0 4/04/201 4 Table 1: Validation Test Specification Outline PPM 6.0 Section 4.
2.1 IEEE 829-1998 Sections 5.0 VTS Sections Cover Page 5.0 Test Design Specification Cover Page
1.0 Purpose
5.1 Purpose
- 1. Purpose 2.0 Test Outline
2.1 Scope
5.2 Outline
- 2. Scope 5.2.1 Test design specification Identifier
- 5. Test S pecification Identifier
5.2.2 Feature
to be tested
- 6. Features to be Tested
- 7. Features not to be Tested 2.2 Test Approach
5.2.3 Approach
refinements
- 8. Test Approach Refinements 2.3 Test Elements 5.2.4 Test Identification
- 9. Test Identification
2.4 Acceptance
Criteria
5.2.5 Feature
Pass/Fail Criteria
- 10. Feature Pass/Fail Criteria 3.0 Test Requirements
8.2 Hardward
Validation Testing
8.3 System
Validation Testing
4.0 References
None Apply
- 3. References 5.0 Terms, Definitions, and Acronyms. None Apply
- 4. Definitions, Acroyms, and Abbreviations
Document: 993754-1-8 12 Title: DCPP PPS Validation Test Specification Revision: 1 Page: 11 of 138 Date: 0 4/04/201 4 2 Scope The scope of this test specification is defined by the system validation test plan. In brief, this test specification will include hardware of all four V10 Tricon Protection Sets and their related TriStation Application Project (TSAP). MWS and the communication peripherals (media converters, port aggregator taps and touchscreen device via a KVM switch) will be utilized as test tools for complete interface tests between V10 Tricon Protection Set and MWS.
This specification does not encompass the validation testing for any other hardware or software, although it may describe the use of other hardware and software during validation testing.
As a validation test specification, this document describes those tests that assess the conformance of the test items against their requirements specifications, as found in the four V10 Tricon Protection S et software requirements specifications (SRSs) [Refs 3.2.7] and hardware requirements specifications (HRSs) [Refs 3.2.11 thru 9.2.14]. Thus, software verification testing is explicitly out-of-scope of this test specification. (Such testing is specified in the software verification test specification [Ref 3.2.6].)
In the DCPP PPS Replacement Project, there is no system requirements specification. Instead, there is a hardware requirements specification (HRS) and a software requirements specification (SRS). The SRS contains the bulk of the product functional requirements, since most functionality is implemented in software. Therefore, the SRS is tantamount to a system requirements specification, and the system validation test is carried out against the SRS.
The HRS is also tantamount to a system hardware requirements specification, and the hardware validation test (HVT) is carried out against the HRS.
Document: 993754-1-8 12 Title: DCPP PPS Validation Test Specification Revision: 1 Page: 12 of 138 Date: 0 4/04/201 4 2.1 V10 Tricon Portion of the PPS Gateway Switch (Typ of 2)
From Prot Set II Port Aggregator Tap (Typ of 2)
From Prot Set IV Port Aggregator Tap (Typ of 2)
From Prot Set III Port AggregatorTap (Typ of 2)100BaseT (Copper)(Typ of 2)
Prot Set I ALS Legend: Multi-Mode Optical Fiber RS-422/RS-485 Serial or 100BaseT Copper
4-20 mA Analog Copper
Maintenance Workstation
Network Interface Controller To Control Room HMI (CC4)Prot Set I MWS HMI Peripherals Prot Set I ALS MWS Computer MWS NIC Analog/USB Copper Prot Set I Port Aggregator Tap (Typ of 2) 1 4-20 mA Analog RTD Signals TCM1 (7L)TCM2 (7R)NET1 (Not Used)
Prot Set I Tricon Class II Class I Prot Set 1 Primary RXM Triplicated RS-485 I/O Bus (Copper)Prot Set 1 Remote RXM Triplicated Optical Fiber Class I Class II A B Media Converter (Typ of 2) 100BaseT (Copper)(Typ of 2)
Class II Class I Optical Fiber TCM1 (7L)/TCM2 (7R)
NET2 (Typ of 2)(Typ for ALS "A" and ALS "B")
KVM Switch Prot Set I Tricon MWS Computer 1 2 Ethernet Switch (Typ of 2)
NIC 1 (Typ of 2)
To Gateway Server Figure 1: Tricon Protection Set Architecture for the PPS Replacement System.
Document: 993754-1-8 12 Title: DCPP PPS Validation Test Specification Revision: 1 Page: 13 of 138 Date: 0 4/04/201 4 3 References 3.1 PG&E Documents
3.1.1 Deleted
3.1.2 PG&E 08-0015-SP-001, Function al Requirements Specification (FRS) Revision 9.
3.1.3 Deleted
3.1.4 PG&E Process Protection System (PPS) Replacement Interface Requirements Specification (IRS) Revision 9.
3.1.5 Deleted
3.1.6 PG&E Project Letter 993756-35R, PG&E Plant Operating Data
3.2 Invensys
Operations Management Documents
3.2.1 Invensys
Project Procedures Manual (PPM). 3.2.2 Project Management Plan (PMP), 993754-1-905.
3.2.3 Software
Quality Assurance Plan (SQAP), 993754-1-801.
3.2.4 Software
Verification and Validation Plan (SVVP), 993754-1-802.
3.2.5 Validation
Test Plan (VTP), 993754-1-813.
3.2.6 Software
Verification Test Specification, 993754-1-869. 3.2.7 Software Requirements Specification, 993754-11-809.
3.2.8 Deleted
3.2.9 Deleted 3.2.10 Deleted 3.2.11 Hardware Requirements Specification Protection Set I, 993754-11-807.
3.2.12 Hardware Requirements Specification Protection Set II, 993754-12-807.
3.2.13 Hardware Requirements Specification Protection Set III, 993754-13-807.
3.2.14 Hardware Requirements Specification Protection Set IV, 993754-14-807.
3.2.15 Software Design Description, 993754-11-810.
3.3 NRC Documents
3.3.1 Branch
Technical Position 7-14, Guidance on Software Reviews for Digital Computer-Based Instrumentation and Control Systems, Revision 5, U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission.
3.3.2 U.S. NRC Regulatory Guide (RG) 1.168, Verification, Validation, Reviews, and Audits for Digital Computer Software Used in Safety Systems of Nuclear Power Plants.
3.3.3 U.S. NRC Digital Instrumentation and Controls Interim Staff Guidance DI&C-ISG-06. 3.3.4 10 CFR50, Appendix A, GDC 21 "Protection System Reliability and Testability.
3.3.5 U.S. NRC Regulatory Guide (RG) 1.170, Software Test Documentation for Digital Computer Software used in Safety System of Nuclear Power Plants.
3.4 Industry
Documents 3.4.1 IEEE 1012 - 1998, Standard for Software Verification and Validation.
3.4.2 IEEE 829 - 1983, Standard for Software Test Documentation.
Document: 993754-1-8 12 Title: DCPP PPS Validation Test Specification Revision: 1 Page: 14 of 138 Date: 0 4/04/201 4 3.4.3 IEEE 1074-1995, Standard for Developing Software Life Cycle Processes. 3.4.4 IEEE 610.12-1990, Standard Glossary of Software Engineering Terminology.
Document: 993754-1-8 12 Title: DCPP PPS Validation Test Specification Revision: 1 Page: 15 of 138 Date: 0 4/04/201 4 4 Definitions, Acronyms, and Abbreviations
4.1 Definitio
ns Acceptance (Pass/Fail) Criteria: Decision rules used to determine whether a software or hardware passes or fails a test.
Black Box Testing - (1) Testing that ignores the internal mechanism of a system or component and focuses solely on the outputs generated in response to selected inputs and execution conditions. (2) Testing conducted to evaluate the compliance of a system or component with specified functional requirements. Factory Acceptance Test (FAT): See System Validation Test. Project Traceability Matrix: A table that shows the trace of customer requirements to product requirements, to product design elements, to verification tests, and to validation tests. System Validation Test:
Also known as a factory acceptance test (FAT), when carried out at the supplier's facility, this test evaluates the product system against its requirements.
Test Plan: A document describing the scope, approach, resources, and schedule of intended testing activities. It identifies test items, the features to be tested, the testing tasks, who will do each task, and any risks requiring contingency planning.
Test Procedure: A document specifying the sequence of actions for the execution of a test. Test Specification:
A specification that translates customer requirements and design features into test specifications and test approaches for validation by testing. It may add to or refine the test approaches described in the Validation Test Plan. (Also known as the Test Design Specification.)
Validation:
The process of assessing an item to determine its level of conformance with its requirements, i.e., to determine its level of quality. For example, software is validated at its software requirements specification. Validation answers, "Did we build the right thing?" Verification:
The process of assessing an item to determine whether it has been implemented in accordance with its design. Verification answers, "Did we build the thing right?"
4.2 Acronyms
AI Analog Inputs ALS Advanced Logic SystemDCPP Diablo Canyon Power Plant DTTA Delta Temperature
/Average Temperature FAT Factory Acceptance Test FRS Functional Requirements Specification FSR Full Scale Range HRS Hardware Requirements Specification HVT Hardware Validation Test I/O Input/Output
Document: 993754-1-8 12 Title: DCPP PPS Validation Test Specification Revision: 1 Page: 16 of 138 Date: 0 4/04/201 4 IRS Interface Requirements Specification IV&V Independent Verification and Validation LTOPS Low Temperature Overpressure Protection System M&TE Measurement and Test Equipment MWS Maintenance Workstation NIST National Institute of Standards and Technology NRC Nuclear Regulatory Commission OOR Out-of-Range OOS Out-of-Service OPDT Overpower Delta-T OPTR Overpressure Turbine Runback OTDT Overtemperature Delta-T OTTR Overtemperature Turbine Runback PG&E Pacific Gas and Electric PMP Project Management Plan PPM Project Procedures Manual PPS Process Protection System PRC Project Review Committee PTM Project Traceability Matrix QA Quality Assurance RTS Reactor Trip System S/G Steam Generator SDD Software Design Description SIDR System Integration Deficiency Report SIL Software Integrity Level SQAP System Quality Assurance Plan SRS Software Requirements Specification SVT Software Verification Test SVVP Software Verification and Validation Plan TCM Triconex Communications Module TiB Test-in-Bypass TiT Test-in-Trip TS1131 TriStation 1131 TSAP TriStation Application Project TTD Trip Time Delay VTP Validation Test Plan VTS Validation Test Specification
4.3 Abbreviations
None
Document: 993754-1-8 12 Title: DCPP PPS Validation Test Specification Revision: 1 Page: 17 of 138 Date: 0 4/04/201 4 5 Test Specification Identifier This document is used as the system validation test specification for all protection set Tricons in the Diablo Canyon Power Plant Process Protection System Replacement Project.
There are no other system validation test specifications for Tricon protection set.
This section discusses the overall identifier assignment scheme i n the test design specification.
Figure 2 shows the overall structure of the verification test documents for the PPS Project.
Validation Test Plan Validation Test SpecificationHVT & FAT Test Procedures PSIHVT & FAT Test Procedures PSIIHVT & FAT Test Procedures PSIIIHVT & FAT Test Procedures PSIV Used by Used by Used by Used by Guide Appendix Appendix Appendix Appendix Test Cases (Word File & Excel File)
Test Cases (Word File & Excel File)
Test Cases (Word File & Excel File)
Test Cases (Word File & Excel File)
Figure 2: Overall Validation Test Document Structure.
One Validation Test Plan is developed for the entire PPS Project (993754-1-813). One Validation Test Specification is generated for the entire PPS Project (993754-1-812). One Hardware Validation Test (HVT) Procedures and one Factory Acceptance Test (FAT) Procedure are specified for each PPS Protection Set. There are total four (4) sets of Hardware Validation Test Procedures and four (4) sets of Factory Acceptance Test Procedure. Each HVT Procedure has one appendix excel file (of test cases).
Each FAT Procedure has multiple appendixes excel file and word file (of test cases).
Document: 993754-1-8 12 Title: DCPP PPS Validation Test Specification Revision: 1 Page: 18 of 138 Date: 0 4/04/201 4 The identifier assignment scheme is developed in accordance with PPM 4.0, Project Document and Date Control, and PMP Appendix B. The unique identifier assigned to this design specification is 993754-1-812. The identifiers assigned to the Hardware Validation Test Procedures and Factory Acceptance Test Procedures are shown below.
Protection Set Number HVT Procedure Document Number (MS Word File)
FAT Procedure Document Number (MS Word File) PS I 99375 4-11-902-0 993754-11-902-1 PS II 993754-12-902-0 993754-12-902-1 PS III 993754-13-902-0 993754-13-902-1 PS IV 993754-14-902-0 993754-14-902-1
Document: 993754-1-8 12 Title: DCPP PPS Validation Test Specification Revision: 1 Page: 19 of 138 Date: 0 4/04/201 4 6 Features to be Tested This section describes the features (i.e., functional, performance, and other requirements) to be tested. It specifically identifies the features that apply to each of the four V10 Tricon Protection
Sets, as well as to the port aggregator. Not all test item features will be validation tested. See Section 7 for identification of features that will not be tested, including justification for not testing those features during validation testing.
6.1 Hardware
Validation Testing Hardware validation testing, under IOM process, involves substantial hardware verification activity. HVT assesses whether the completed V10 Tricon Protection Sets satisfy the requirements specified in their respective hardware requirements specifications (HRSs). The Tricon platform is supplied with certificates of conformance for the internal components of the platform. No verification testing of those components is required. However, as further verification of the assembled hardware, the following features are tested as part of hardware validation testing:
Tricon Power modules Tricon I/O modules I/O module points, including spare points specified in drawings or the HRS Tricon Communication Modules interface with MWS Loop Instrument power supplies
6.2 System
Validation Testing System validation testing assesses whether the completed V10 Tricon Protection Sets satisfy the requirements specified in their respective software requirements specifications (SRSs). The FRS [Ref 3.1.2], and IRS [Ref 3.1.4] provide the system-level requirements. The requirements applicable to the V10 Tricon (i.e., Invensys scope of supply) were translated into software and hardware requirements, and those are the basis of validation testing.
System validation testing addresses the requirements categories shown in Table 2, taken from the indicated sections of the SRS.
Document: 993754-1-8 12 Title: DCPP PPS Validation Test Specification Revision: 1 Page: 20 of 138 Date: 0 4/04/201 4 Table 2: V10 Tricon Protection S et Requirements Categories SRS Section Requirements Category
3.1 External
Interface Requirements
3.1.1 External
Systems 3.1.2 Inputs/Outputs 3.1.3 User Interfaces
3.1.4 Hardware
Interfaces
3.1.5 Software
Interfaces
3.1.6 Communications
Interfaces
3.2 External
Input/Output
3.2.1 Analog
Output Signals
3.2.2 Analog
Input Signals
3.2.3 Discrete
Input Signals
3.2.4 Discrete
Output Signals
3.3 Functional
Requirements
3.3.1 System
Diagnostics
3.3.2 Applicable
To All 3.3.3 Wide Range Reactor Coolant Temperature 3.3.4 Wide Range Reactor Coolant Pressure
3.3.5 Delta
Temperature
- Temperature Average (DTTA)
3.3.6 Pressurizer
Level
3.3.7 Pressurizer
Vapor Temperature
3.3.8 Steamflow
3.3.9 Steamline Break Protection 3.3.10 Steam Generator Narrow Range Level 3.3.11 Turbine Impulse Chamber Pressure
3.7 Software
System Attributes
3.7.4 Security
3.7.5 Maintainability
Document: 993754-1-8 12 Title: DCPP PPS Validation Test Specification Revision: 1 Page: 21 of 138 Date: 0 4/04/201 4 7 Features not to be Tested This section describes all those requirements against which the V10 Tricon P rotection Sets will not be validated.
Document: 993754-1-8 12 Title: DCPP PPS Validation Test Specification Revision: 1 Page: 22 of 138 Date: 0 4/04/201 4 8 Test Approach Refinements
8.1 Validation
Techniques For the safety-related DCPP project, Invensys IV&V engineers employ rigorous validation testing techniques to ensure quality of the Tricon hardware and Tricon application software. The validation techniques facilitate both dynamic testing and static testing of the TSAP functionality.
8.1.1 Techniques
for System Validation During the Requirements Phase of the DCPP project, IV&V engineers employ the techniques below to validate four (4) system Protection Sets. The techniques are grouped under either dynamic testing or static testing.
Document: 993754-1-8 12 Title: DCPP PPS Validation Test Specification Revision: 1 Page: 23 of 138 Date: 0 4/04/201 4 8.2 Hardware Validation Testing Hardware validation testing validates the V10 Tricon Protection Sets' hardware against their respective HRSs. The HVT purpose and scope are defined in the validation test plan. That plan provides a basic description of the test approach. This document provides additional test approach information.
8.2.1 Hardware
Configuration The hardware being validated is the deliverable V10 Tricon Protection Set hardware for Protection Set I, Protection Set II, Protection Set III, and Protection Set IV. The V10 Tricon Protection S ets' components are provided with certificates of conformance from the IOM Tricon manufacturing facility. Prior to hardware validation testing, the hardware is assembled in the IOM Lake Forest facility, in a climate-controlled, secure test environment. All four V10 Tricon Protection Sets are received, assembled, and tested in this facility, at essentially the same time.
Document: 993754-1-8 12 Title: DCPP PPS Validation Test Specification Revision: 1 Page: 24 of 138 Date: 0 4/04/201 4 8.2.2 Hardware Validation Test Prerequisites
Document: 993754-1-8 12 Title: DCPP PPS Validation Test Specification Revision: 1 Page: 25 of 138 Date: 0 4/04/201 4 8.2.3 Outline of Hardware Validation Testing HVT is performed in parallel (not necessarily "simultaneously"; i.e., in lock step) on each of the four V10 Tricon Protection S et s. The testing first verifies that the hardware configuration is correct. This is accomplished through a series of inspections, power-on tests, and calibration verification steps, to confirm the hardware configuration conforms to design documentation and is in proper working order. Testing continues via the execution of the hardware validation test procedures, which comprise the hardware validation test cases. (These test s identify the set of hardware validation tests that will sufficiently verify and validate the Tricon Protection Sets against their design descriptions and requirements specifications.) Per the software verification and validation plan (SVVP) [Ref 3.2.4
]; HVT results are documented in the hardware validation test report.
8.3 System
Validation Testing System Validation Testing (SysVT) validates the V10 Tricon Protection S ets against their respective software requirements specifications.
The test targets are the four deliverable V10 Tricon platforms loaded with the four deliverable TriStation application projects (TSAPs), each one developed specifically for a specific V10 Tricon Protection S et: Protection Set I, Protection Set II, Protection Set III, and Protection Set IV. SysVT is performed on each V10 Tricon Protection Set using (via) Factory Acceptance Test procedure (FAT) by Nuclear IV&V personnel, supported by Nuclear Delivery personnel and Nuclear QA personnel. The tests may be witnessed by PG&E representatives.
Before System validation testing can begin on any individual V10 Tricon Protection S et, the following prerequisites must be met, in the order shown, for that V10 Tricon Protection S et.
Document: 993754-1-8 12 Title: DCPP PPS Validation Test Specification Revision: 1 Page: 26 of 138 Date: 0 4/04/201 4 8.3.3 Test Anomalies In the event a V10 Tricon Protection S et is found to be in nonconformance with its requirement specifications, or in case of any abnormal test conditions, the anomaly is documented on a System Integration Deficiency Report (SIDR), in accordance to PPM 6.0 and PPM 10.0, Nonconformance and Corrective Action. Software anomalies are also documented per PPM 7.0.
8.3.4 Test Environmental Conditions System validation tests are carried out under the normal environmental conditions (temperature and humidity) of the Triconex facility.
Document: 993754-1-8 12 Title: DCPP PPS Validation Test Specification Revision: 1 Page: 27 of 138 Date: 0 4/04/201 4 9 Test Identification
9.1 Hardware
Validation Tests Identification The hardware validation test procedures and test cases are developed in four separate documents, one for each of the V10 Tricons in Protection Set I, Protection Set II, Protection Set III, and Protection Set IV: Title Document Number Protection Set I HVT Procedure s 993754-11-902-0 Protection Set II HVT Procedure s 993754-12-902-0 Protection Set III HVT Procedure s 993754-13-902-0 Protection Set IV HVT Procedure s 993754-14-902-0 These documents therefore specify all the hardware validation test procedures and their supporting test cases. Complete execution of these procedures, with acceptable results, constitutes validation of the V10 Tricon Protection Sets' hardware. No other hardware validation testing is necessary, prior to execution of the system validation tests.
9.1.1 Hardware
Validation Test Case Identifier The unique test case identifier will be used in two places:
- 1. In PTM as test case traceability tag
- 2. In Word file as test case number The test case identifier has the following ID convention:
<Test Category>-<Protection Set>-<Group of Tests>-<Test Case Index> Where: Attributes Description / Format / Acceptable Values
<Test Category>
Description:
indicates the Test Category of the test case.
Format: 3 characters are used to abbreviate the Test Category.
Acceptable Values H VT (Hardware Validation Test) : <Protection Set>
Description:
indicates the Protection Set to which the test case is assigned. Format: 2 digits are used.
Acceptable Values 11 (Protection Set I) : 12 (Protection Set II) 13 (Protection Set III) 14 (Protection Set IV)
<Group of Tests>
Description:
to indicate which Group of Test for each test case intends to verify. Format: 3 characters are used to abbreviate the Group of Tests.
Acceptable Values PUT (Power-up Test) : FIO (Field Input/Output)
Document: 993754-1-8 12 Title: DCPP PPS Validation Test Specification Revision: 1 Page: 28 of 138 Date: 0 4/04/201 4 <Test Case Index>
Description:
to indicate the test case number.
Format: 3 digits are used.
Acceptable Values 1 - 999 : 9.2 Hardware Validation Test Design
Document: 993754-1-8 12 Title: DCPP PPS Validation Test Specification Revision: 1 Page: 29 of 138 Date: 0 4/04/201 4
Document: 993754-1-8 12 Title: DCPP PPS Validation Test Specification Revision: 1 Page: 30 of 138 Date: 0 4/04/201 4 9.3 Factory Acceptance Tests Identification The factory acceptance test procedures and test cases are developed in four separate documents, one for each of the V10 Tricons in Protection Set I, Protection Set II, Protection Set III, and Protection Set IV: Title Document Number Protection Set I Factory Acceptance Test Procedures 993754-11-902-1 Protection Set II Factory Acceptance Test Procedures 993754-12-902-1 Protection Set III Factory Acceptance Test Procedures 993754-13-902-1 Protection Set IV Factory Acceptance Test Procedures 993754-14-902-1 These documents therefore specify all the factory acceptance test procedures and their supporting test cases. Complete execution of these procedures, with acceptable results, constitutes validation of the deliverable V10 Tricon Protection Sets. No other factory acceptance testing is necessary, prior to delivery of the V10 Tricon Protection Sets to PG&E. 9.3.1 Factory Acceptance Test Case Identifier The unique test case identifier will be used in two places: 1. In PTM as test case traceability tag
- 2. In Word file as test case number The test case identifier has the following ID convention:
<Test Category>-<Protection Set>-<Group of Tests>-<Test Case Index> Where: Attributes Description / Format / Acceptable Values
<Test Category>
Description:
indicates the Test Category of the test case.
Format: 3 characters are used to abbreviate the Test Category.
Acceptable Values FAT (Factory Acceptance Test) : <Protection Set>
Description:
indicates the Protection Set to which the test case is assigned. Format: 2 digits are used.
Acceptable Values 11 (Protection Set I) : 12 (Protection Set II) 13 (Protection Set III) 14 (Protection Set IV)
Document: 993754-1-8 12 Title: DCPP PPS Validation Test Specification Revision: 1 Page: 31 of 138 Date: 0 4/04/201 4
Document: 993754-1-8 12 Title: DCPP PPS Validation Test Specification Revision: 1 Page: 32 of 138 Date: 0 4/04/201 4 9.3.2 SRS Tag Traceability In general, each test case identifier is traceable to a single or multiple requirment elements in the SRS. Each requirment element is tagged by a base requirement ID (R-#) or a derived requirement ID (DR-#), which is specified in the SRS. The test cases traceability is documented in the initial revision of the Validation Test Specification. As the Validation Test Specification is updated with PG&E design inputs revision 9, it is also streamlined with the removal of the test cases traceability from this revision of the specification and moving forward. The test cases traceability will be part of the Implementation
-phase PTM referenced by this specification.
The streamlining effort of moving the test cases traceability from the Validation Test Specification to the PTM complies with IEEE 829-1983 guidance on the test cases traceability and requirement coverage and completeness.
9.4 Factory
Acceptance Tests Design The following sections represent the general categories of V10 Tricon Protection Set features subject to system validation testing. Each section identifies system validation "tests" of those features. The tests are assigned identifiers that are used as the test procedure identifiers. Only a brief description of the test is provided, the aim being only to identify the number and types of test s that make up factory acceptance testing. Test details are provided in the test procedures and test cases.
Tracing back to the SRS requirements is accomplished via the test identifier and the project traceability matrix.
9.4.1 External
Interface Requirements This test verifies that the Tricon TSAP satisfies the requirements imposed on the Tricon Protection S et to interface with other systems.
9.4.1.1 Inputs/Outputs
[NO REQUIREMENTS]
9.4.1.2 User Interfaces
[NO REQUIREMENTS]
9.4.1.3 Hardware Interfaces This test verifies that the Tricon TSAP satisfies the requirements imposed on the Tricon Protection S et to interface with other systems.
Document: 993754-1-8 12 Title: DCPP PPS Validation Test Specification Revision: 1 Page: 33 of 138 Date: 0 4/04/201 4 9.4.1.4 Manual Trip Switches and Indications This test verifies that the Tricon TSAP satisfies the requirements imposed on the Manual Trip Switches and Indication.
Document: 993754-1-8 12 Title: DCPP PPS Validation Test Specification Revision: 1 Page: 34 of 138 Date: 0 4/04/201 4 9.4.1.5 Manual Bypass Switches This test verifies that the Tricon TSAP satisfies the requirements imposed on the Manual Bypass Switches and Indication.
Document: 993754-1-8 12 Title: DCPP PPS Validation Test Specification Revision: 1 Page: 35 of 138 Date: 0 4/04/201 4 9.4.1.6 Out-of-Service Switches (OOS)
This test verifies that the Tricon TSAP satisfies the requirements imposed on the Out-of-Service Switches and Indication.
Document: 993754-1-8 12 Title: DCPP PPS Validation Test Specification Revision: 1 Page: 36 of 138 Date: 0 4/04/201 4
Document: 993754-1-8 12 Title: DCPP PPS Validation Test Specification Revision: 1 Page: 37 of 138 Date: 0 4/04/201 4
Document: 993754-1-8 12 Title: DCPP PPS Validation Test Specification Revision: 1 Page: 38 of 138 Date: 0 4/04/201 4 9.4.1.7 Trip and Bypass Test Features This test verifies that the Tricon TSAP satisfies the requirements imposed on the Trip and Bypass Test Features. 9.4.1.8 Software Interfaces
[NO REQUIREMENTS]
Document: 993754-1-8 12 Title: DCPP PPS Validation Test Specification Revision: 1 Page: 39 of 138 Date: 0 4/04/201 4 9.4.1.9 Communication Interfaces This test verifies that the Tricon TSAP satisfies the requirements utilize the TSAA protocol for runtime non-safety Ethernet communications. 9.4.2 External Input/Output
[NO REQUIREMENTS]
Document: 993754-1-8 12 Title: DCPP PPS Validation Test Specification Revision: 1 Page: 40 of 138 Date: 0 4/04/201 4 9.4.3 Functional Requirements 9.4.3.1 System Diagnostics This test verifies that the Tricon TSAP satisfies the requirement to provide capabilities for diagnostics and error handling of Tricon Protection Set System. This test design is created based on the function requirements of section 3.3.1 (System Diagnostic) in the SRS.
Document: 993754-1-8 12 Title: DCPP PPS Validation Test Specification Revision: 1 Page: 41 of 138 Date: 0 4/04/201 4 9.4.3.2 Failure Alarms This test verifies that the Tricon TSAP satisfies the requirement to provide Failure Alarm for Tricon Protection Set System. This test design is created based on the function requirements of section 3.3.1.2.2 (Failure Alarms) in the SRS.
Document: 993754-1-8 12 Title: DCPP PPS Validation Test Specification Revision: 1 Page: 42 of 138 Date: 0 4/04/201 4 9.4.3.3 Trouble Alarms This test verifies that the Tricon TSAP satisfies the requirement to provide Trouble Alarm for Tricon Protection Set System. This test design is created based on the function requirements of section 3.3.1.2.3 (Trouble Alarms) in the SRS.
Document: 993754-1-8 12 Title: DCPP PPS Validation Test Specification Revision: 1 Page: 43 of 138 Date: 0 4/04/201 4
Document: 993754-1-8 12 Title: DCPP PPS Validation Test Specification Revision: 1 Page: 44 of 138 Date: 0 4/04/201 4 or Test Conditions 9.4.3.4 Bypass Alarms This test verifies that the Tricon TSAP satisfies the requirement to provide Bypass Alarm for Tricon Protection Set System. This test design is created based on the function requirements of section 3.3.1.2.4 (Bypass Alarms) in the SRS.
Document: 993754-1-8 12 Title: DCPP PPS Validation Test Specification Revision: 1 Page: 45 of 138 Date: 0 4/04/201 4 9.4.3.5 RTD Failure Alarms This test verifies that the Tricon TSAP satisfies the requirement to provide RTD Failure Alarm for Tricon Protection Set System. This test design is created based on the function requirements in the SRS.
Document: 993754-1-8 12 Title: DCPP PPS Validation Test Specification Revision: 1 Page: 46 of 138 Date: 0 4/04/201 4 9.4.3.6 Out-of-Service Alarms This test verifies that the Tricon TSAP satisfies the requirement to provide Out-of-Service Alarm for Tricon Protection Set System. This test design is created based on the function requirements of section 3.3.1.2.6 (Out-of-Servcie Alarms) in the SRS.
Document: 993754-1-8 12 Title: DCPP PPS Validation Test Specification Revision: 1 Page: 47 of 138 Date: 0 4/04/201 4 9.4.3.7 Remove From Service (RFS) Indication This test verifies that the Tricon TSAP satisfies the requirement to provide an indication for each THot or TCold signal if a signal has been removed from service.
Document: 993754-1-8 12 Title: DCPP PPS Validation Test Specification Revision: 1 Page: 48 of 138 Date: 0 4/04/201 4 9.4.3.8 Time Response This test verifies that the Tricon TSAP satisfies the requirements total throughput time shall not exceed 200 msec for Tricon Protection Set System. This test design is created based on the function requirements in the SRS.
Document: 993754-1-8 12 Title: DCPP PPS Validation Test Specification Revision: 1 Page: 49 of 138 Date: 0 4/04/201 4 Requirements Applicable to All Protective Functions
9.4.4 Online
Test and Calibration Access This test design is to verify the initiation (enabling) of the Online Test and Maintenance process. This test design is created base on the Online Test and Calibration Access of section 3.3.2.1.1 in the SRS. 9.4.4.1 Online Test and Calibration Access
Document: 993754-1-8 12 Title: DCPP PPS Validation Test Specification Revision: 1 Page: 50 of 138 Date: 0 4/04/201 4
Document: 993754-1-8 12 Title: DCPP PPS Validation Test Specification Revision: 1 Page: 51 of 138 Date: 0 4/04/201 4 9.4.4.2 Test Analog Indication
Document: 993754-1-8 12 Title: DCPP PPS Validation Test Specification Revision: 1 Page: 52 of 138 Date: 0 4/04/201 4 9.4.4.3 Annunciator Output
Document: 993754-1-8 12 Title: DCPP PPS Validation Test Specification Revision: 1 Page: 53 of 138 Date: 0 4/04/201 4 9.4.4.4 Channel in Maintenance
Document: 993754-1-8 12 Title: DCPP PPS Validation Test Specification Revision: 1 Page: 54 of 138 Date: 0 4/04/201 4 9.4.4.5 Test-In-Trip
Document: 993754-1-8 12 Title: DCPP PPS Validation Test Specification Revision: 1 Page: 55 of 138 Date: 0 4/04/201 4
Document: 993754-1-8 12 Title: DCPP PPS Validation Test Specification Revision: 1 Page: 56 of 138 Date: 0 4/04/201 4 9.4.4.6 Test-In-Bypass
Document: 993754-1-8 12 Title: DCPP PPS Validation Test Specification Revision: 1 Page: 57 of 138 Date: 0 4/04/201 4
Document: 993754-1-8 12 Title: DCPP PPS Validation Test Specification Revision: 1 Page: 58 of 138 Date: 0 4/04/201 4
Document: 993754-1-8 12 Title: DCPP PPS Validation Test Specification Revision: 1 Page: 59 of 1 38 Date: 0 4/04/201 4 9.4.4.7 Tunable Constants and Setpoints
Document: 993754-1-8 12 Title: DCPP PPS Validation Test Specification Revision: 1 Page: 60 of 138 Date: 0 4/04/201 4 9.4.4.8 Data Retention after Power Cycle
Document: 993754-1-8 12 Title: DCPP PPS Validation Test Specification Revision: 1 Page: 61 of 138 Date: 0 4/04/201 4 9.4.5 Wide Range Reactor Coolant Temperature Purpose of this test design is to test the correctness of the Wide Range Reactor Coolant Temperature trip determination and its outputs. This test design is created based on the function requirements of section 3.3.3 (Wide Range Reactor Coolant Temperature) in the SRS.
Document: 993754-1-8 12 Title: DCPP PPS Validation Test Specification Revision: 1 Page: 62 of 138 Date: 0 4/04/201 4
Document: 993754-1-8 12 Title: DCPP PPS Validation Test Specification Revision: 1 Page: 63 of 138 Date: 0 4/04/201 4
Document: 993754-1-8 12 Title: DCPP PPS Validation Test Specification Revision: 1 Page: 64 of 138 Date: 0 4/04/201 4
Document: 993754-1-8 12 Title: DCPP PPS Validation Test Specification Revision: 1 Page: 65 of 138 Date: 0 4/04/201 4
Document: 993754-1-8 12 Title: DCPP PPS Validation Test Specification Revision: 1 Page: 66 of 138 Date: 0 4/04/201 4
Document: 993754-1-8 12 Title: DCPP PPS Validation Test Specification Revision: 1 Page: 67 of 138 Date: 0 4/04/201 4 9.4.6 Wide Range Reactor Coolant Pressure Purpose of this test design is to test the correctness of the Wide Range Reactor Coolant Pressure trip determination and its outputs. This test design is created based on the function requirements of section 3.3.4 (Wide Range Reactor Coolant Pressure) in the SRS.
Document: 993754-1-8 12 Title: DCPP PPS Validation Test Specification Revision: 1 Page: 68 of 138 Date: 0 4/04/201 4
Document: 993754-1-8 12 Title: DCPP PPS Validation Test Specification Revision: 1 Page: 69 of 138 Date: 0 4/04/201 4
Document: 993754-1-8 12 Title: DCPP PPS Validation Test Specification Revision: 1 Page: 70 of 138 Date: 0 4/04/201 4
Document: 993754-1-8 12 Title: DCPP PPS Validation Test Specification Revision: 1 Page: 71 of 138 Date: 0 4/04/201 4
Document: 993754-1-8 12 Title: DCPP PPS Validation Test Specification Revision: 1 Page: 72 of 138 Date: 0 4/04/201 4 9.4.7 Delta Temperature
- Temperature Average (DTTA)
Purpose of this test design is to test the correctness of the overall DTTA function trip determination and its outputs. This test design is created based on the function requirements of section 3.3.5 (Delta Temperature - Temperature Average) in the SRS.
Document: 993754-1-8 12 Title: DCPP PPS Validation Test Specification Revision: 1 Page: 73 of 138 Date: 0 4/04/201 4
Document: 993754-1-8 12 Title: DCPP PPS Validation Test Specification Revision: 1 Page: 74 of 138 Date: 0 4/04/201 4
Document: 993754-1-8 12 Title: DCPP PPS Validation Test Specification Revision: 1 Page: 75 of 138 Date: 0 4/04/201 4
Document: 993754-1-8 12 Title: DCPP PPS Validation Test Specification Revision: 1 Page: 76 of 138 Date: 0 4/04/201 4
Document: 993754-1-8 12 Title: DCPP PPS Validation Test Specification Revision: 1 Page: 77 of 138 Date: 0 4/04/201 4
Document: 993754-1-8 12 Title: DCPP PPS Validation Test Specification Revision: 1 Page: 78 of 138 Date: 0 4/04/201 4
Document: 993754-1-8 12 Title: DCPP PPS Validation Test Specification Revision: 1 Page: 79 of 138 Date: 0 4/04/201 4
Document: 993754-1-8 12 Title: DCPP PPS Validation Test Specification Revision: 1 Page: 80 of 138 Date: 0 4/04/201 4
Document: 993754-1-8 12 Title: DCPP PPS Validation Test Specification Revision: 1 Page: 81 of 138 Date: 0 4/04/201 4
Document: 993754-1-8 12 Title: DCPP PPS Validation Test Specification Revision: 1 Page: 82 of 138 Date: 0 4/04/201 4
Document: 993754-1-8 12 Title: DCPP PPS Validation Test Specification Revision: 1 Page: 83 of 138 Date: 0 4/04/201 4
Document: 993754-1-8 12 Title: DCPP PPS Validation Test Specification Revision: 1 Page: 84 of 138 Date: 0 4/04/201 4
Document: 993754-1-8 12 Title: DCPP PPS Validation Test Specification Revision: 1 Page: 85 of 138 Date: 0 4/04/201 4
Document: 993754-1-8 12 Title: DCPP PPS Validation Test Specification Revision: 1 Page: 86 of 138 Date: 0 4/04/201 4
Document: 993754-1-8 12 Title: DCPP PPS Validation Test Specification Revision: 1 Page: 87 of 138 Date: 0 4/04/201 4
Document: 993754-1-8 12 Title: DCPP PPS Validation Test Specification Revision: 1 Page: 88 of 138 Date: 0 4/04/201 4
Document: 993754-1-8 12 Title: DCPP PPS Validation Test Specification Revision: 1 Page: 89 of 138 Date: 0 4/04/201 4
Document: 993754-1-8 12 Title: DCPP PPS Validation Test Specification Revision: 1 Page: 90 of 138 Date: 0 4/04/201 4 I
Document: 993754-1-8 12 Title: DCPP PPS Validation Test Specification Revision: 1 Page: 91 of 138 Date: 0 4/04/201 4 9.4.8 Pressurizer Level Purpose of this test design is to test the correctness of the Pressurizer Level function trip determination and its outputs. This test design is created based on the function requirements of section 3.3.6 (Pressurizer Level) in the SRS.
Document: 993754-1-8 12 Title: DCPP PPS Validation Test Specification Revision: 1 Page: 92 of 138 Date: 0 4/04/201 4
Document: 993754-1-8 12 Title: DCPP PPS Validation Test Specification Revision: 1 Page: 93 of 138 Date: 0 4/04/201 4 9.4.9 Pressurizer Vapor Temperature Purpose of this test design is to test the correctness of the Pressurizer Vapor Temperature function trip determination and its outputs. This test design is created based on the function requirements of section 3.3.7 (Pressurizer Vapor Temperature) in the SRS.
Document: 993754-1-8 12 Title: DCPP PPS Validation Test Specification Revision: 1 Page: 94 of 138 Date: 0 4/04/201 4
Document: 993754-1-8 12 Title: DCPP PPS Validation Test Specification Revision: 1 Page: 95 of 138 Date: 0 4/04/201 4
Document: 993754-1-8 12 Title: DCPP PPS Validation Test Specification Revision: 1 Page: 96 of 138 Date: 0 4/04/201 4
Document: 993754-1-8 12 Title: DCPP PPS Validation Test Specification Revision: 1 Page: 97 of 138 Date: 0 4/04/201 4 9.4.10 Steamflow Purpose of this test design is to test the correctness of the Steamflow Compensation determination and its outputs. This test design is created based on the function requirements of section 3.3.8 (Steamflow) in the SRS.
Document: 993754-1-8 12 Title: DCPP PPS Validation Test Specification Revision: 1 Page: 98 of 138 Date: 0 4/04/201 4
Document: 993754-1-8 12 Title: DCPP PPS Validation Test Specification Revision: 1 Page: 99 of 138 Date: 0 4/04/201 4
Document: 993754-1-8 12 Title: DCPP PPS Validation Test Specification Revision: 1 Page: 100 of 138 Date: 0 4/04/201 4
Document: 993754-1-8 12 Title: DCPP PPS Validation Test Specification Revision: 1 Page: 101 of 138 Date: 0 4/04/201 4
Document: 993754-1-8 12 Title: DCPP PPS Validation Test Specification Revision: 1 Page: 102 of 138 Date: 0 4/04/201 4 9.4.11 Steamline Break Protection Purpose of this test design is to test the correctness of the Steamline Break Protection function trip determination and its outputs. This test design is created based on the function requirements of section 3.3.9 (Steamline Break Protection) in the SRS.
Document: 993754-1-8 12 Title: DCPP PPS Validation Test Specification Revision: 1 Page: 103 of 138 Date: 0 4/04/201 4
Document: 993754-1-8 12 Title: DCPP PPS Validation Test Specification Revision: 1 Page: 104 of 138 Date: 0 4/04/201 4
Document: 993754-1-8 12 Title: DCPP PPS Validation Test Specification Revision: 1 Page: 105 of 138 Date: 0 4/04/201 4
Document: 993754-1-8 12 Title: DCPP PPS Validation Test Specification Revision: 1 Page: 106 of 138 Date: 0 4/04/201 4
Document: 993754-1-8 12 Title: DCPP PPS Validation Test Specification Revision: 1 Page: 107 of 138 Date: 0 4/04/201 4
Document: 993754-1-8 12 Title: DCPP PPS Validation Test Specification Revision: 1 Page: 108 of 138 Date: 0 4/04/201 4
Document: 993754-1-8 12 Title: DCPP PPS Validation Test Specification Revision: 1 Page: 109 of 138 Date: 0 4/04/201 4
Document: 993754-1-8 12 Title: DCPP PPS Validation Test Specification Revision: 1 Page: 110 of 138 Date: 0 4/04/201 4
Document: 993754-1-8 12 Title: DCPP PPS Validation Test Specification Revision: 1 Page: 111 of 138 Date: 0 4/04/201 4
Document: 993754-1-8 12 Title: DCPP PPS Validation Test Specification Revision: 1 Page: 112 of 138 Date: 0 4/04/201 4
Document: 993754-1-8 12 Title: DCPP PPS Validation Test Specification Revision: 1 Page: 113 of 138 Date: 0 4/04/201 4
Document: 993754-1-8 12 Title: DCPP PPS Validation Test Specification Revision: 1 Page: 114 of 138 Date: 0 4/04/201 4
Document: 993754-1-8 12 Title: DCPP PPS Validation Test Specification Revision: 1 Page: 115 of 138 Date: 0 4/04/201 4
Document: 993754-1-8 12 Title: DCPP PPS Validation Test Specification Revision: 1 Page: 116 of 138 Date: 0 4/04/201 4 9.4.12 Steam Generator Narrow Range Level Purpose of this test design is to test the correctness of the Steam Generator Narrow Range Level function trip determination and its outputs. This test design is created based on the function requirements of section 3.3.10 (Steam Generator Narrow Range Level) in the SRS.
Document: 993754-1-8 12 Title: DCPP PPS Validation Test Specification Revision: 1 Page: 117 of 138 Date: 0 4/04/201 4
Document: 993754-1-8 12 Title: DCPP PPS Validation Test Specification Revision: 1 Page: 118 of 138 Date: 0 4/04/201 4
Document: 993754-1-8 12 Title: DCPP PPS Validation Test Specification Revision: 1 Page: 119 of 138 Date: 0 4/04/201 4
Document: 993754-1-8 12 Title: DCPP PPS Validation Test Specification Revision: 1 Page: 120 of 138 Date: 0 4/04/201 4
Document: 993754-1-8 12 Title: DCPP PPS Validation Test Specification Revision: 1 Page: 121 of 138 Date: 0 4/04/201 4
Document: 993754-1-8 12 Title: DCPP PPS Validation Test Specification Revision: 1 Page: 122 of 138 Date: 0 4/04/201 4
Document: 993754-1-8 12 Title: DCPP PPS Validation Test Specification Revision: 1 Page: 123 of 138 Date: 0 4/04/201 4
Document: 993754-1-8 12 Title: DCPP PPS Validation Test Specification Revision: 1 Page: 124 of 138 Date: 0 4/04/201 4
Document: 993754-1-8 12 Title: DCPP PPS Validation Test Specification Revision: 1 Page: 125 of 138 Date: 0 4/04/201 4
Document: 993754-1-8 12 Title: DCPP PPS Validation Test Specification Revision: 1 Page: 126 of 138 Date: 0 4/04/201 4
Document: 993754-1-8 12 Title: DCPP PPS Validation Test Specification Revision: 1 Page: 127 of 138 Date: 0 4/04/201 4
Document: 993754-1-8 12 Title: DCPP PPS Validation Test Specification Revision: 1 Page: 128 of 138 Date: 0 4/04/201 4
Document: 993754-1-8 12 Title: DCPP PPS Validation Test Specification Revision: 1 Page: 129 of 138 Date: 0 4/04/201 4
Document: 993754-1-8 12 Title: DCPP PPS Validation Test Specification Revision: 1 Page: 130 of 138 Date: 0 4/04/201 4
Document: 993754-1-8 12 Title: DCPP PPS Validation Test Specification Revision: 1 Page: 131 of 138 Date: 0 4/04/201 4 9.4.13 Turbine Impulse Chamber Pressure Purpose of this test design is to test the correctness of the Turbine Impulse Chamber Pressure function trip determination and its outputs. This test design is created based on the funct io n requirements of section 3.3.11 (Turbine Impulse Chamber Pressure) in the SRS.
Document: 993754-1-8 12 Title: DCPP PPS Validation Test Specification Revision: 1 Page: 132 of 138 Date: 0 4/04/201 4
Document: 993754-1-8 12 Title: DCPP PPS Validation Test Specification Revision: 1 Page: 133 of 138 Date: 0 4/04/201 4
Document: 993754-1-8 12 Title: DCPP PPS Validation Test Specification Revision: 1 Page: 134 of 138 Date: 0 4/04/201 4
Document: 993754-1-8 12 Title: DCPP PPS Validation Test Specification Revision: 1 Page: 135 of 138 Date: 0 4/04/201 4 9.4.14 Security Purpose of this test design is to test the system logon access to the Tricon Protection Set TSAP via the MWS will be administratively control using physical security and passwork logon security measures.
9.4.15 Maintainability Purpose of this test design is to test the capability to place and maintain multiple channels Out of Service (Trip or bypass).
Document: 993754-1-8 12 Title: DCPP PPS Validation Test Specification Revision: 1 Page: 136 of 138 Date: 0 4/04/201 4
Document: 993754-1-8 12 Title: DCPP PPS Validation Test Specification Revision: 1 Page: 137 of 138 Date: 0 4/04/201 4 10 Feature Pass / Fail Criteria Two methods, one qualitative and one quantitative, are used to establish the pass/fail criteria. The pass/fail criteria are specified within each of the test cases. Alternately, the test procedure may specify the pass/fail criteria, for test cases in which pass/fail is dependent on the specific test procedure employed.
Document: 993754-1-8 12 Title: DCPP PPS Validation Test Specification Revision: 1 Page: 138 of 138 Date: 0 4/04/201 4