NL-08-1038, Comment (6) of T. E. Tynan on Behalf of Southern Nuclear Operating Company, Inc., on Draft Generic Environmental Impact Statement for License Renewal of Vogtle, Units 1 & 2, Supplement 34: Difference between revisions

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
(Created page by program invented by StriderTol)
(StriderTol Bot change)
 
Line 19: Line 19:
=Text=
=Text=
{{#Wiki_filter:Southern Nuclear Operating Company, Inc.
{{#Wiki_filter:Southern Nuclear Operating Company, Inc.
Vogtle Electric Generating Plant 7821 River Road Waynesboro, Georgia 30830 Tel 706.724.1562 or 706.554.9961                           ) 11: 59 SOUTHERN     YA COMPANY July 14, 2008 Docket No.:         50-424                                           NL-08-1038 50-425 U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Document Control Desk Washington, DC 20555-0001
Vogtle Electric Generating Plant 7821 River Road Waynesboro, Georgia 30830 Tel 706.724.1562 or 706.554.9961
                                                                          /c             /
) 11: 59 SOUTHERN YA COMPANY July 14, 2008 Docket No.:
50-424 50-425 U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Document Control Desk Washington, DC 20555-0001 NL-08-1038
/c  
/
Vogtle Electric Generating Plant Units 1 and 2 License Renewal Application Comments on Draft Generic Environmental Impact Statement for License Renewal of Nuclear Plants, Sup~plement 34 Ladies and Gentlemen:
Vogtle Electric Generating Plant Units 1 and 2 License Renewal Application Comments on Draft Generic Environmental Impact Statement for License Renewal of Nuclear Plants, Sup~plement 34 Ladies and Gentlemen:
In May 2008, the NRC issued the draft Generic Environmental Impact Statement, Supplement 34 (SEIS) for the Vogtle Units 1 and 2 and requested comments be provided by July 16, 2008. Southern Nuclear Operating Company (SNC) has completed review of the draft SEIS and provides in the enclosures, a tabular list of comments,, discrepancies and errata noted during the review. SNC recognizes that NRC developed the draft SEIS from review of the SNC Environmental Report (ER), as well as their own independent analysis of the relevant subject material.
In May 2008, the NRC issued the draft Generic Environmental Impact Statement, Supplement 34 (SEIS) for the Vogtle Units 1 and 2 and requested comments be provided by July 16, 2008. Southern Nuclear Operating Company (SNC) has completed review of the draft SEIS and provides in the enclosures, a tabular list of comments,, discrepancies and errata noted during the review. SNC recognizes that NRC developed the draft SEIS from review of the SNC Environmental Report (ER), as well as their own independent analysis of the relevant subject material.
Line 27: Line 30:
Please address questions or comments to D. L. Fulton at 205-992-7536 or T.C.
Please address questions or comments to D. L. Fulton at 205-992-7536 or T.C.
Moorer at 205-992-5807.
Moorer at 205-992-5807.
50 A) ~ /~   e-b     e-e-s'-~ ~2~-~-~-if'                                   62Ž~~e~~&=-
50 A) ~  
/~ e-b e-e-s'-~ ~2~-~-~-if' 62Ž~~e~~&=-


I I U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission NL-08-1038 Page 2 of 3 Mr. T. E. Tynan states he is a Vice President of Southern Nuclear Operating Company, is authorized to execute this oath on behalf of Southern Nuclear Operating Company and to the best of his knowledge and belief, the facts set forth in this letter are true.
I I U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission NL-08-1038 Page 2 of 3 Mr. T. E. Tynan states he is a Vice President of Southern Nuclear Operating Company, is authorized to execute this oath on behalf of Southern Nuclear Operating Company and to the best of his knowledge and belief, the facts set forth in this letter are true.
Respectfully submitted, SOUTHERN NUCLEAR OPERATING COMPANY T. E. Tynan Vice President - Vogtle Sworn to and subscriptedbefore me this J                   day of 2008
Respectfully submitted, SOUTHERN NUCLEAR OPERATING COMPANY T. E. Tynan Vice President - Vogtle Sworn to and subscripted before me this J day of 2008
              --lta~ry Public Notary Public, 8urSP county. Georgia My commission expires: MY       Comrnmision E.piles Novmbet 11,2011 TET/DLF/dmw
--lta~ry Public Notary Public, 8urSP county. Georgia My commission expires: MY Comrnmision E.piles Novmbet 11,2011 TET/DLF/dmw


==Enclosures:==
==Enclosures:==
Line 37: Line 41:
: 2. Errata Table for the Draft Generic Environmental Impact Statement, Supplement 34 for the VEGP Units 1 and 2 License Renewal Application
: 2. Errata Table for the Draft Generic Environmental Impact Statement, Supplement 34 for the VEGP Units 1 and 2 License Renewal Application


U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission NL-08-1038 Page 3 of 3 cc: Southern Nuclear Operating Company Mr. J. T. Gasser, Executive Vice President           w/o Enclosures Mr. T. E. Tynan, Vice President - Vogtle             w/o Enclosures Mr. D. H. Jones, Vice President - Engineering         w/o Enclosures Ms. M. M. Caston, Vice President and Corporate Counsel                                               w/o Enclosures Mr. M. J. Ajluni,, Manager - Nuclear Licensing       w/o Enclosures Mr. N. J. Stringfellow, Licensing Supervisor - Vogtle w/o Enclosures Mr. S. M. Blanton, Balch and Bingham LLP,             w/o Enclosures Mr. C. R. Myer, Project Manager - License Renewal w/o Enclosures Mr. T. C. Moorer, Project Manager - Environmental w/o Enclosures Document Services RTYPE: CVC7000 (letter, Enclosures 1 & 2)
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission N L-08-1038 Page 3 of 3 cc:
Southern Nuclear Operating Company Mr. J. T. Gasser, Executive Vice President w/o Enclosures Mr. T. E. Tynan, Vice President - Vogtle w/o Enclosures Mr. D. H. Jones, Vice President - Engineering w/o Enclosures Ms. M. M. Caston, Vice President and Corporate Counsel w/o Enclosures Mr. M. J. Ajluni,, Manager - Nuclear Licensing w/o Enclosures Mr. N. J. Stringfellow, Licensing Supervisor - Vogtle w/o Enclosures Mr. S. M. Blanton, Balch and Bingham LLP, w/o Enclosures Mr. C. R. Myer, Project Manager - License Renewal w/o Enclosures Mr. T. C. Moorer, Project Manager - Environmental w/o Enclosures Document Services RTYPE: CVC7000 (letter, Enclosures 1 & 2)
Nuclear Regulatory Commission Mr. J. P. Leous, Environmental Project Manager
Nuclear Regulatory Commission Mr. J. P. Leous, Environmental Project Manager
      - Vogtle                                           w/ Enclosures Mr. D. J. Ashley, License Renewal Project Manager
- Vogtle Mr. D. J. Ashley, License Renewal Project Manager
      - Vogtle                                             w/ Enclosures Dr. W. D. Travers, Regional Administrator           w/ Enclosures Mr. S. P. Lingam, NRR Project Manager - Vogtle       w/ Enclosures Mr. G. J. McCoy, Senior Resident Inspector - Vogtle w/ Enclosures State of Georgia Mr. N. Holcornb, Commissioner -                     w/o Enclosures Dept. of Natural Resources w/o Enclosures Tetra Tech NUS, Inc.
- Vogtle Dr. W. D. Travers, Regional Administrator Mr. S. P. Lingam, NRR Project Manager - Vogtle Mr. G. J. McCoy, Senior Resident Inspector - Vogtle State of Georgia Mr. N. Holcornb, Commissioner -
Ms. K. K. Patterson, Project Manager                 w/o Enclosures
Dept. of Natural Resources w/o Enclosures w/ Enclosures w/ Enclosures w/ Enclosures w/ Enclosures w/ Enclosures w/o Enclosures Tetra Tech NUS, Inc.
Ms. K. K. Patterson, Project Manager w/o Enclosures


          . VogtleElectric Generating Plant Units 1 and 2 License Renewal Application Enclosure 1 Comment Table for the Draft Generic Environmental Impact Statement, Supplement 34
. VogtleElectric Generating Plant Units 1 and 2 License Renewal Application Comment Table for the Draft Generic Environmental Impact Statement, Supplement 34 Comment Table For The Draft Generic Environmental Impact Statement, Supplement 34 VEGP Units 1 and 2 License Renewal Application Draft SEIS Section No.
 
Draft SEIS Section Title Page Line SNC Comment Beginning with the sentence "VEGP has a cooling tower-based heat dissipation system" and continuing to the end Of the paragraph, the text should be deleted as irrelevant to the purpose of the section, which is to identify the federal action. NRC does not license cooling towers. As an alternative option, the text should be revised to indicate that natural draft cooling tower make-up water for the circulating system comes from the river, mechanical draft cooling tower make-up for the auxiliary systems comes from groundwater, The Proposed Federal and that blowdown from both systems goes to the river. Section 1.3 Action 1-7 37-40 3.1.2 accurately describes the systems.
Enclosure 1 Comment Table For The Draft Generic Environmental Impact Statement, Supplement 34 VEGP Units 1 and 2 License Renewal Application Draft SEIS  Draft SEIS Section No. Section Title                 Page     Line     SNC Comment Beginning with the sentence "VEGP has a cooling tower-based heat dissipation system" and continuing to the end Of the paragraph, the text should be deleted as irrelevant to the purpose of the section, which is to identify the federal action. NRC does not license cooling towers. As an alternative option, the text should be revised to indicate that natural draft cooling tower make-up water for the circulating system comes from the river, mechanical draft cooling tower make-up for the auxiliary systems comes from groundwater, The Proposed Federal                           and that blowdown from both systems goes to the river. Section 1.3 Action                         1-7   37-40   3.1.2 accurately describes the systems.
Description of Nuclear Power Plant and Site and Plant Interaction with the 2.0 Environment 2-1 7-10 The text should be revised consistent with comment on Section 1.3 The draft SEIS describes the SRS intakes as "inactive".
Description of Nuclear Power Plant and Site and Plant Interaction with the 2.0   Environment                   2-1     7-10     The text should be revised consistent with comment on Section 1.3 The draft SEIS describes the SRS intakes as "inactive".
While it is true that SRS no longer has operating nuclear reactors, and therefore, surface water requirements are greatly reduced from Facility and Site Description historic volumes, the SRS still withdraws approximately 40,000 and Proposed Plant gallons per minute (gpm) of Savannah River water (see page 2.12-Operation During the 6 of the ER for a brief discussion of reduced water withdrawal, and 2.1 Renewal Term 2-4 5
While it is true that SRS no longer has operating nuclear reactors, and therefore, surface water requirements are greatly reduced from Facility and Site Description                   historic volumes, the SRS still withdraws approximately 40,000 and Proposed Plant                             gallons per minute (gpm) of Savannah River water (see page 2.12-Operation During the                           6 of the ER for a brief discussion of reduced water withdrawal, and 2.1   Renewal Term                   2-4       5     email from Bill Payne, WSRC Environmental Services Section).
email from Bill Payne, WSRC Environmental Services Section).
The SEIS states that South Carolina "may" limit access to the EnergySolutions waste disposal facility in Barnwell, S.C.
The SEIS states that South Carolina "may" limit access to the EnergySolutions waste disposal facility in Barnwell, S.C.
In fact, EnergySolutionswas not successful in its petition to the South Carolina Legislature to keep Bamwell open to wastes other Gaseous Waste Processing                       than those from the Atlantic Compact. The LLW disposal facility will Systems and effluent                           no longer accept wastes from states that are not part of the Atlantic 2.1.4.3 Controls     -              2-13     40     Compact.
In fact, EnergySolutions was not successful in its petition to the South Carolina Legislature to keep Bamwell open to wastes other Gaseous Waste Processing than those from the Atlantic Compact. The LLW disposal facility will Systems and effluent no longer accept wastes from states that are not part of the Atlantic 2.1.4.3 Controls 2-13 40 Compact.
El - 1
El - 1 Comment Table For The Draft Generic Environmental Impact Statement, Supplement 34 VEGP Units 1 and 2 License Renewal Application Draft SEIS Draft SEIS Section No.
 
Section Title Page Line SNC Comment The draft SEIS states that the transmission lines are owned, operated and maintained by SNC.
Enclosure 1 Comment Table For The Draft Generic Environmental Impact Statement, Supplement 34 VEGP Units 1 and 2 License Renewal Application Draft SEIS       Draft SEIS Section No.       Section Title                       Page     Line       SNC Comment The draft SEIS states that the transmission lines are owned, operated and maintained by SNC.
The lines are owned, operated and maintained by GPC and Power Transmission Georgia Transmission Company. See page 4.12-3 of the ER. SNC 2.1.7 System 2-16 4
The lines are owned, operated and maintained by GPC and Power Transmission                                       Georgia Transmission Company. See page 4.12-3 of the ER. SNC 2.1.7     System                               2-16       4       has responsibility only for the power plant.
has responsibility only for the power plant.
Power Transmission 2-1.7     System                               2-17       16     Same comment as above.
Power Transmission 2-1.7 System 2-17 16 Same comment as above.
Power Transmission 2.1.7       System                               2-18       4       Same comment as above.
Power Transmission 2.1.7 System 2-18 4
SNC determined, after submittal of the environmental report, that CZMA certification to the State of Georgia is not required. The program document for the Georgia Coastal Management Program identifies state requirements for consistency of federal activities, such as licensing, with the program.1 The document indicates that if a federal activity is likely to affect coastal uses or resources, then consistency applies.2 VEGP is not located in the Georgia coastal zone and, due to its distance from the coastal zone, is not likely to affect coastal uses or resources. The VEGP-Mctntosh transmission line does extend into a county (Effingham) that is located within the Georgia coastal zone but continued operation of the line will not 2.2.1       Land Use                             2-19     5-13     change and is not likely to affect coastal uses or resources.
Same comment as above.
                                              -~                 .1.*
SNC determined, after submittal of the environmental report, that CZMA certification to the State of Georgia is not required. The program document for the Georgia Coastal Management Program identifies state requirements for consistency of federal activities, such as licensing, with the program.1 The document indicates that if a federal activity is likely to affect coastal uses or resources, then consistency applies.2 VEGP is not located in the Georgia coastal zone and, due to its distance from the coastal zone, is not likely to affect coastal uses or resources. The VEGP-Mctntosh transmission line does extend into a county (Effingham) that is located within the Georgia coastal zone but continued operation of the line will not change and is not likely to affect coastal uses or resources.
2-35 to This statement regarding the closest Class I area is inconsistent 2.2.4'    Meteorology and Air Quality          2-36    40-2      with the information presented in Table 8-3, page 8-18.
2.2.1 Land Use 2.2.4' Meteorology and Air Quality 2-19 5-13
1 State of Georgia Coastal Management Program and Program Document, National Oceanographic and Atmospheric Administration Office of Ocean and Coastal Resources Management and Georgia Department of Natural Resources Coastal Resources Division, June 2003. Available online at http:llcrd.dnr.state.ga.us/assets/documnents/GCMP.pdf. Accessed June 4, 2008.
-~  
.1.*
2-35 to 2-36 This statement regarding the closest Class I area is inconsistent with the information presented in Table 8-3, page 8-18.
40-2 1 State of Georgia Coastal Management Program and Program Document, National Oceanographic and Atmospheric Administration Office of Ocean and Coastal Resources Management and Georgia Department of Natural Resources Coastal Resources Division, June 2003. Available online at http:llcrd.dnr.state.ga.us/assets/documnents/GCMP.pdf. Accessed June 4, 2008.
2 Ibid., page 234.
2 Ibid., page 234.
El -2
El -2 Comment Table For The Draft Generic Environmental Impact Statement, Supplement 34 VEGP Units 1 and 2 License Renewal Application Draft SEIS Section No.
 
Draft SEIS Section Title Paqe Line SNC Comment The groundwater supply information in the draft SEIS is not consistent with information provided in the SNC ER. As indicated in Section 2.3 of the ER the Tertiary and Water Table aquifers yield approximately 3 million gallons per day (mgd) and the Cretaceous 2.2.8.2.1 Water Supply 2-90 14-15 aquifer yields approximately 5 billion gpd.
Enclosure -1 Comment Table For The Draft Generic Environmental Impact Statement, Supplement 34 VEGP Units 1 and 2 License Renewal Application Draft SEIS    Draft SEIS Section No. Section Title               Paqe     Line     SNC Comment The groundwater supply information in the draft SEIS is not consistent with information provided in the SNC ER. As indicated in Section 2.3 of the ER the Tertiary and Water Table aquifers yield approximately 3 million gallons per day (mgd) and the Cretaceous 2.2.8.2.1 Water Supply                 2-90     14-15   aquifer yields approximately 5 billion gpd.
4-17 to As noted in comments on Section 2.1.7, Georgia Power, not SNC, 4.2 Transmission lines 4-18 39-2 maintains the rights-of-way.
4-17 to             As noted in comments on Section 2.1.7, Georgia Power, not SNC, 4.2   Transmission lines           4-18     39-2   maintains the rights-of-way.
The SCE&G D-Area powerhouse (which is now operated by the Cumulative Impacts on DOE SRS contractor, and which is in the process of being retired) is 4.8.3 Terrestrial resources 4-57 9-10 within 6 miles of VEGP. See Figure 2-2.
The SCE&G D-Area powerhouse (which is now operated by the Cumulative Impacts on                         DOE SRS contractor, and which is in the process of being retired) is 4.8.3   Terrestrial resources       4-57     9-10   within 6 miles of VEGP. See Figure 2-2.
Cumulative Socioeconomic COL was submitted March 2008 and currently under review at the 4.8.5 Impacts 4-61 16-20 NRC.
Cumulative Socioeconomic                       COL was submitted March 2008 and currently under review at the 4.8.5   Impacts                     4-61     16-20   NRC.
The statement that minority and low-income populations could experience a disproportionately high and adverse impact from plant shutdown is unsubstantiated. The statement should be replaced with a statement that there would be no disproportionately high and adverse impact or a supporting case should be developed that minority and low-income populations currently receive disproportionately high positive benefits that would then be lost 8.1 No-Action Alternative  
The statement that minority and low-income populations could experience a disproportionately high and adverse impact from plant shutdown is unsubstantiated. The statement should be replaced with a statement that there would be no disproportionately high and adverse impact or a supporting case should be developed that minority and low-income populations currently receive disproportionately high positive benefits that would then be lost 8.1   No-Action Alternative     '-8-6     28-39   upon shutdown.
'-8-6 28-39 upon shutdown.
Table 8-3, page 8-18 is inconsistent with the information presented 8.2   Alternative Energy Sources   8-18       1     in Section 2.2.4.
Table 8-3, page 8-18 is inconsistent with the information presented 8.2 Alternative Energy Sources 8-18 1
in Section 2.2.4.
El -3
El -3


Vogtle Electric Generating Plant Units 1 and 2 License Renewal Application Enclosure 2 Errata Table for the Draft Generic Environmental Impact Statement, Supplement 34 I
Vogtle Electric Generating Plant Units 1 and 2 License Renewal Application Errata Table for the Draft Generic Environmental Impact Statement, Supplement 34 I
 
Errata Table For The Draft Generic Environmental Impact Statement, Supplement 34 VEGP Units 1 and 2 License Renewal Application Draft SEIS Draft SEIS Section No. Section Title Page Line Errata Liquid Waste Processing Systems This sentence is incomplete. Need to add "were released" 2.1.4.1 and effluent Controls 2-11 22-23 between "gases" and "from".
Enclosure 2 Errata Table For The Draft Generic Environmental Impact Statement, Supplement 34 VEGP Units 1 and 2 License Renewal Application Draft SEIS   Draft SEIS Section No. Section Title                       Page     Line   Errata Liquid Waste Processing Systems                       This sentence is incomplete. Need to add "were released" 2.1.4.1   and effluent Controls               2-11   22-23   between "gases" and "from".
Gaseous Waste Processing Systems 2.1.4.2 and effluent Controls 2-12 31 Add "the" between "in" & "form".
Gaseous Waste Processing Systems 2.1.4.2   and effluent Controls                 2-12     31     Add "the" between "in" & "form".
Gaseous Waste Processing Systems 2.1.4.2 and effluent Controls 2-12 32 Change "Gaseous" to "gases in this sentence.
Gaseous Waste Processing Systems 2.1.4.2   and effluent Controls                 2-12     32     Change "Gaseous" to "gases in this sentence.
Gaseous Waste Processing Systems 2.1.4.2 and effluent Controls 2-12 32-23 Change VEPG to VEGP through out the section Gaseous Waste Processing Systems 2.1.4.2 and effluent Controls 2-13 2
Gaseous Waste Processing Systems 2.1.4.2   and effluent Controls                 2-12   32-23   Change VEPG to VEGP through out the section Gaseous Waste Processing Systems 2.1.4.2   and effluent Controls                 2-13       2     Change VEPG to VEGP.
Change VEPG to VEGP.
Gaseous Waste Processing Systems 2.1.4.3   and effluent Controls                 2-13   34-36   Change VEPG to VEGP.
Gaseous Waste Processing Systems 2.1.4.3 and effluent Controls 2-13 34-36 Change VEPG to VEGP.
Gaseous Waste Processing Systems 2.1.4.3   and effluent Controls                 2-13     40     Remove comma after June.
Gaseous Waste Processing Systems 2.1.4.3 and effluent Controls 2-13 40 Remove comma after June.
2.1.5.1   Nonradioactive Waste Streams         2-14     19     Remove "and" between "wastes," & "concrete".
2.1.5.1 Nonradioactive Waste Streams 2-14 19 Remove "and" between "wastes," & "concrete".
2.1.5.1   Nonradioactive Waste Streams         2-14   33-40   Change VGEP to VEGP.
2.1.5.1 Nonradioactive Waste Streams 2-14 33-40 Change VGEP to VEGP.
2.1.5.1   Nonradioactive Waste Streams         2-15       7   Change VGEP to VEGP.
2.1.5.1 Nonradioactive Waste Streams 2-15 7
Pollution Prevention and Waste 2.1.5.2   Minimization                         2-15   26-38   Change VGEP to VEGP.
Change VGEP to VEGP.
2.2.3.1   Surface Water                         2-27     10   Change "radionucllides" to radionuclides.
Pollution Prevention and Waste 2.1.5.2 Minimization 2-15 26-38 Change VGEP to VEGP.
2.2.5.2   Beaverdam Creek                       2-53     26     Add "the" between "of' and "area."
2.2.3.1 Surface Water 2-27 10 Change "radionucllides" to radionuclides.
Water Bodies in Transmission Line 2.2.5.3   ROWs                                 2-54   11,20   Change "mile" to "miles."
2.2.5.2 Beaverdam Creek 2-53 26 Add "the" between "of' and "area."
2.2.5.4.1   Site Vicinity                         2-59     25     Delete one the uses of "is."
Water Bodies in Transmission Line 2.2.5.3 ROWs 2-54 11,20 Change "mile" to "miles."
Threatened and Endangered 2.2.6.2   Terrestrial Species                   2-70     33     Change "stork" to "storks."
2.2.5.4.1 Site Vicinity 2-59 25 Delete one the uses of "is."
Threatened and Endangered 2.2.6.2   Terrestrial Species                   2-70     34     Add "a" in between "is" and "potential."
Threatened and Endangered 2.2.6.2 Terrestrial Species 2-70 33 Change "stork" to "storks."
E2 - I
Threatened and Endangered 2.2.6.2 Terrestrial Species 2-70 34 Add "a" in between "is" and "potential."
 
E2 - I Errata Table For The Draft Generic Environmental Impact Statement, Supplement 34 VEGP Units I and 2 License Renewal Application Draft SEIS Section No.
Enclosure 2 Errata Table For The Draft Generic   Environmental   Impact Statement, Supplement 34 VEGP Units I and 2 License Renewal Application Draft SEIS Draft SEIS Section No. Section Title                          Page      Line    Errata Threatened and Endangered t        t Errata 2.2.6.2   Terrestrial Species                     2-71       14   Change "borrows" to "burrows."
2.2.6.2 2.2.7 Draft SEIS Section Title Threatened and Endangered Terrestrial Species Radiolocical Impacts Errata Page Line Errata t
i       I 2.2.7    Radiolocical Impacts                    2-85     9-31   Change "VEPG" to "VEGP."
t 2-71 14 Change "borrows" to "burrows."
2.2.7 - Radiological Impacts                     2-86     14, 32   Change "VEPG" to "VEGP."
i I
2.2.7   Radiological Impacts                     2-87       28     Change "VEPG" to "VEGP."
2-85 9-31 Change "VEPG" to "VEGP."
2.2.8.5.1 Transient Population                     2-97       5     Change VGEP to VEGP.
2.2.7 -
4.0   Environmental Impacts of Operation       4-1       32     Add "in" between "addressed" and "Chapter."
Radiological Impacts 2-86 14, 32 Change "VEPG" to "VEGP."
Microbiological Organisms (Public 4.1.2   Health)                                 4-14     33, 40   Change VEPG to VEGP.
2.2.7 Radiological Impacts 2-87 28 Change "VEPG" to "VEGP."
Microbiological Organisms (Public 4.1.2   Health)                                 4-15       41     Change VEPG to VEGP.
2.2.8.5.1 Transient Population 2-97 5
Change VGEP to VEGP.
4.0 Environmental Impacts of Operation 4-1 32 Add "in" between "addressed" and "Chapter."
Microbiological Organisms (Public 4.1.2 Health) 4-14 33, 40 Change VEPG to VEGP.
Microbiological Organisms (Public 4.1.2 Health) 4-15 41 Change VEPG to VEGP.
Microbiological Organisms (Public
Microbiological Organisms (Public
.4.1.2     Health)                                 4-16     6,123   Change VEPG to VEGP.
.4.1.2 Health) 4-16 6,123 Change VEPG to VEGP.
Microbiological Organisms (Public 4.1.2   Health)                                 4-17     15-24   Change VEPG to VEGP.
Microbiological Organisms (Public 4.1.2 Health) 4-17 15-24 Change VEPG to VEGP.
4.2.1   Electromagnetic Fields-Acute Effects     4-23       11   Change VEPG to VEGP.
4.2.1 Electromagnetic Fields-Acute Effects 4-23 11 Change VEPG to VEGP.
4.8.1.1   Water Use Impacts                       4-53       14     Change "ground water" to "groundwater."
4.8.1.1 Water Use Impacts 4-53 14 Change "ground water" to "groundwater."
Cumulative Thermophilic 4.8.4.1   Microorganism Impacts                   4-58     20-39   Change VEPG to VEGP.
Cumulative Thermophilic 4.8.4.1 Microorganism Impacts 4-58 20-39 Change VEPG to VEGP.
Cumulative Thermophilic 4.8.4.1   Microorganism Impacts                   459         2     Change VEPG to VEGP.
Cumulative Thermophilic 4.8.4.1 Microorganism Impacts 459 2
8.1     No-Action Alternative                   8-6       30     Change "when" to "if."
Change VEPG to VEGP.
8.2.2   Coal Based IGCC Generation             8-30       29     Change "reject" to "release".
8.1 No-Action Alternative 8-6 30 Change "when" to "if."
8.2.2   Coal Based IGCC Generation               8-35       35     Change "addition" to "additional."
8.2.2 Coal Based IGCC Generation 8-30 29 Change "reject" to "release".
Natural Gas-Fired Combined-Cycle 8.2.3   generation                             8-53       11     Add "visible" between "be" and "from."
8.2.2 Coal Based IGCC Generation 8-35 35 Change "addition" to "additional."
8.2.5   Conservation                             8-65     25-26   Take out one "that."
Natural Gas-Fired Combined-Cycle 8.2.3 generation 8-53 11 Add "visible" between "be" and "from."
E2 - 2
8.2.5 Conservation 8-65 25-26 Take out one "that."
 
E2 - 2 Errata Table For The Draft Generic Environmental Impact Statement, Supplement 34 VEGP Units 1 and 2 License Renewal Application L
Enclosure 2 Errata Table For The Draft Generic Environmental Impact Statement, Supplement 34 L
Draft SEIS Draft SEIS Section No. Section Title Page Line] Errata 8.2.5 Conservation 8-66 25, 30 Change VEPG to VEGP.
VEGP Units 1 and 2 License Renewal Application Draft SEIS Draft SEIS Section No. Section Title                       Page     Line] Errata 8.2.5   Conservation                         8-66   25, 30   Change VEPG to VEGP.
E2 - 3}}
E2 - 3}}

Latest revision as of 15:17, 14 January 2025

"Draft Supplement" is not in the list (Request, Draft Request, Supplement, Acceptance Review, Meeting, Withholding Request, Withholding Request Acceptance, RAI, Draft RAI, Draft Response to RAI, ...) of allowed values for the "Project stage" property.

Comment (6) of T. E. Tynan on Behalf of Southern Nuclear Operating Company, Inc., on Draft Generic Environmental Impact Statement for License Renewal of Vogtle, Units 1 & 2, Supplement 34
ML082490544
Person / Time
Site: Vogtle  Southern Nuclear icon.png
Issue date: 07/14/2008
From: Tynan T
Southern Nuclear Operating Co
To:
Rulemaking, Directives, and Editing Branch
References
73FR22448 00006, NL-08-1038
Download: ML082490544 (11)
v • d • e


Text

Southern Nuclear Operating Company, Inc.

Vogtle Electric Generating Plant 7821 River Road Waynesboro, Georgia 30830 Tel 706.724.1562 or 706.554.9961

) 11: 59 SOUTHERN YA COMPANY July 14, 2008 Docket No.:

50-424 50-425 U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Document Control Desk Washington, DC 20555-0001 NL-08-1038

/c

/

Vogtle Electric Generating Plant Units 1 and 2 License Renewal Application Comments on Draft Generic Environmental Impact Statement for License Renewal of Nuclear Plants, Sup~plement 34 Ladies and Gentlemen:

In May 2008, the NRC issued the draft Generic Environmental Impact Statement, Supplement 34 (SEIS) for the Vogtle Units 1 and 2 and requested comments be provided by July 16, 2008. Southern Nuclear Operating Company (SNC) has completed review of the draft SEIS and provides in the enclosures, a tabular list of comments,, discrepancies and errata noted during the review. SNC recognizes that NRC developed the draft SEIS from review of the SNC Environmental Report (ER), as well as their own independent analysis of the relevant subject material.

As such, SNC acknowledges that some of the discrepancies identified between the draft SEIS and the ER may be the result of use of sources other than the ER in their independent analysis and thus are not relevant.

In developing comments to the draft SEIS, SNC identified certain discrepancies between the NRC draft SEIS and information contained in the SNC ER, responses to NRC Environmental Site Audit Information Request, or Requests for Additional Information (RAIs). This information is identified in Enclosure 1 and where appropriate, includes additional information to clarify SNC comments. In addition, SNC provides in Enclosure 2 an errata list noted during the review for your consideration in the final SEIS. The staff is encouraged to contact SNC for additional clarification or explanation if necessary.

Please address questions or comments to D. L. Fulton at 205-992-7536 or T.C.

Moorer at 205-992-5807.

50 A) ~

/~ e-b e-e-s'-~ ~2~-~-~-if' 62Ž~~e~~&=-

I I U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission NL-08-1038 Page 2 of 3 Mr. T. E. Tynan states he is a Vice President of Southern Nuclear Operating Company, is authorized to execute this oath on behalf of Southern Nuclear Operating Company and to the best of his knowledge and belief, the facts set forth in this letter are true.

Respectfully submitted, SOUTHERN NUCLEAR OPERATING COMPANY T. E. Tynan Vice President - Vogtle Sworn to and subscripted before me this J day of 2008

--lta~ry Public Notary Public, 8urSP county. Georgia My commission expires: MY Comrnmision E.piles Novmbet 11,2011 TET/DLF/dmw

Enclosures:

1. Comment Table for the Draft Generic Environmental Impact Statement, Supplement 34 for the VEGP Units 1 and 2 License Renewal Application
2. Errata Table for the Draft Generic Environmental Impact Statement, Supplement 34 for the VEGP Units 1 and 2 License Renewal Application

U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission N L-08-1038 Page 3 of 3 cc:

Southern Nuclear Operating Company Mr. J. T. Gasser, Executive Vice President w/o Enclosures Mr. T. E. Tynan, Vice President - Vogtle w/o Enclosures Mr. D. H. Jones, Vice President - Engineering w/o Enclosures Ms. M. M. Caston, Vice President and Corporate Counsel w/o Enclosures Mr. M. J. Ajluni,, Manager - Nuclear Licensing w/o Enclosures Mr. N. J. Stringfellow, Licensing Supervisor - Vogtle w/o Enclosures Mr. S. M. Blanton, Balch and Bingham LLP, w/o Enclosures Mr. C. R. Myer, Project Manager - License Renewal w/o Enclosures Mr. T. C. Moorer, Project Manager - Environmental w/o Enclosures Document Services RTYPE: CVC7000 (letter, Enclosures 1 & 2)

Nuclear Regulatory Commission Mr. J. P. Leous, Environmental Project Manager

- Vogtle Mr. D. J. Ashley, License Renewal Project Manager

- Vogtle Dr. W. D. Travers, Regional Administrator Mr. S. P. Lingam, NRR Project Manager - Vogtle Mr. G. J. McCoy, Senior Resident Inspector - Vogtle State of Georgia Mr. N. Holcornb, Commissioner -

Dept. of Natural Resources w/o Enclosures w/ Enclosures w/ Enclosures w/ Enclosures w/ Enclosures w/ Enclosures w/o Enclosures Tetra Tech NUS, Inc.

Ms. K. K. Patterson, Project Manager w/o Enclosures

. VogtleElectric Generating Plant Units 1 and 2 License Renewal Application Comment Table for the Draft Generic Environmental Impact Statement, Supplement 34 Comment Table For The Draft Generic Environmental Impact Statement, Supplement 34 VEGP Units 1 and 2 License Renewal Application Draft SEIS Section No.

Draft SEIS Section Title Page Line SNC Comment Beginning with the sentence "VEGP has a cooling tower-based heat dissipation system" and continuing to the end Of the paragraph, the text should be deleted as irrelevant to the purpose of the section, which is to identify the federal action. NRC does not license cooling towers. As an alternative option, the text should be revised to indicate that natural draft cooling tower make-up water for the circulating system comes from the river, mechanical draft cooling tower make-up for the auxiliary systems comes from groundwater, The Proposed Federal and that blowdown from both systems goes to the river. Section 1.3 Action 1-7 37-40 3.1.2 accurately describes the systems.

Description of Nuclear Power Plant and Site and Plant Interaction with the 2.0 Environment 2-1 7-10 The text should be revised consistent with comment on Section 1.3 The draft SEIS describes the SRS intakes as "inactive".

While it is true that SRS no longer has operating nuclear reactors, and therefore, surface water requirements are greatly reduced from Facility and Site Description historic volumes, the SRS still withdraws approximately 40,000 and Proposed Plant gallons per minute (gpm) of Savannah River water (see page 2.12-Operation During the 6 of the ER for a brief discussion of reduced water withdrawal, and 2.1 Renewal Term 2-4 5

email from Bill Payne, WSRC Environmental Services Section).

The SEIS states that South Carolina "may" limit access to the EnergySolutions waste disposal facility in Barnwell, S.C.

In fact, EnergySolutions was not successful in its petition to the South Carolina Legislature to keep Bamwell open to wastes other Gaseous Waste Processing than those from the Atlantic Compact. The LLW disposal facility will Systems and effluent no longer accept wastes from states that are not part of the Atlantic 2.1.4.3 Controls 2-13 40 Compact.

El - 1 Comment Table For The Draft Generic Environmental Impact Statement, Supplement 34 VEGP Units 1 and 2 License Renewal Application Draft SEIS Draft SEIS Section No.

Section Title Page Line SNC Comment The draft SEIS states that the transmission lines are owned, operated and maintained by SNC.

The lines are owned, operated and maintained by GPC and Power Transmission Georgia Transmission Company. See page 4.12-3 of the ER. SNC 2.1.7 System 2-16 4

has responsibility only for the power plant.

Power Transmission 2-1.7 System 2-17 16 Same comment as above.

Power Transmission 2.1.7 System 2-18 4

Same comment as above.

SNC determined, after submittal of the environmental report, that CZMA certification to the State of Georgia is not required. The program document for the Georgia Coastal Management Program identifies state requirements for consistency of federal activities, such as licensing, with the program.1 The document indicates that if a federal activity is likely to affect coastal uses or resources, then consistency applies.2 VEGP is not located in the Georgia coastal zone and, due to its distance from the coastal zone, is not likely to affect coastal uses or resources. The VEGP-Mctntosh transmission line does extend into a county (Effingham) that is located within the Georgia coastal zone but continued operation of the line will not change and is not likely to affect coastal uses or resources.

2.2.1 Land Use 2.2.4' Meteorology and Air Quality 2-19 5-13

-~

.1.*

2-35 to 2-36 This statement regarding the closest Class I area is inconsistent with the information presented in Table 8-3, page 8-18.

40-2 1 State of Georgia Coastal Management Program and Program Document, National Oceanographic and Atmospheric Administration Office of Ocean and Coastal Resources Management and Georgia Department of Natural Resources Coastal Resources Division, June 2003. Available online at http:llcrd.dnr.state.ga.us/assets/documnents/GCMP.pdf. Accessed June 4, 2008.

2 Ibid., page 234.

El -2 Comment Table For The Draft Generic Environmental Impact Statement, Supplement 34 VEGP Units 1 and 2 License Renewal Application Draft SEIS Section No.

Draft SEIS Section Title Paqe Line SNC Comment The groundwater supply information in the draft SEIS is not consistent with information provided in the SNC ER. As indicated in Section 2.3 of the ER the Tertiary and Water Table aquifers yield approximately 3 million gallons per day (mgd) and the Cretaceous 2.2.8.2.1 Water Supply 2-90 14-15 aquifer yields approximately 5 billion gpd.

4-17 to As noted in comments on Section 2.1.7, Georgia Power, not SNC, 4.2 Transmission lines 4-18 39-2 maintains the rights-of-way.

The SCE&G D-Area powerhouse (which is now operated by the Cumulative Impacts on DOE SRS contractor, and which is in the process of being retired) is 4.8.3 Terrestrial resources 4-57 9-10 within 6 miles of VEGP. See Figure 2-2.

Cumulative Socioeconomic COL was submitted March 2008 and currently under review at the 4.8.5 Impacts 4-61 16-20 NRC.

The statement that minority and low-income populations could experience a disproportionately high and adverse impact from plant shutdown is unsubstantiated. The statement should be replaced with a statement that there would be no disproportionately high and adverse impact or a supporting case should be developed that minority and low-income populations currently receive disproportionately high positive benefits that would then be lost 8.1 No-Action Alternative

'-8-6 28-39 upon shutdown.

Table 8-3, page 8-18 is inconsistent with the information presented 8.2 Alternative Energy Sources 8-18 1

in Section 2.2.4.

El -3

Vogtle Electric Generating Plant Units 1 and 2 License Renewal Application Errata Table for the Draft Generic Environmental Impact Statement, Supplement 34 I

Errata Table For The Draft Generic Environmental Impact Statement, Supplement 34 VEGP Units 1 and 2 License Renewal Application Draft SEIS Draft SEIS Section No. Section Title Page Line Errata Liquid Waste Processing Systems This sentence is incomplete. Need to add "were released" 2.1.4.1 and effluent Controls 2-11 22-23 between "gases" and "from".

Gaseous Waste Processing Systems 2.1.4.2 and effluent Controls 2-12 31 Add "the" between "in" & "form".

Gaseous Waste Processing Systems 2.1.4.2 and effluent Controls 2-12 32 Change "Gaseous" to "gases in this sentence.

Gaseous Waste Processing Systems 2.1.4.2 and effluent Controls 2-12 32-23 Change VEPG to VEGP through out the section Gaseous Waste Processing Systems 2.1.4.2 and effluent Controls 2-13 2

Change VEPG to VEGP.

Gaseous Waste Processing Systems 2.1.4.3 and effluent Controls 2-13 34-36 Change VEPG to VEGP.

Gaseous Waste Processing Systems 2.1.4.3 and effluent Controls 2-13 40 Remove comma after June.

2.1.5.1 Nonradioactive Waste Streams 2-14 19 Remove "and" between "wastes," & "concrete".

2.1.5.1 Nonradioactive Waste Streams 2-14 33-40 Change VGEP to VEGP.

2.1.5.1 Nonradioactive Waste Streams 2-15 7

Change VGEP to VEGP.

Pollution Prevention and Waste 2.1.5.2 Minimization 2-15 26-38 Change VGEP to VEGP.

2.2.3.1 Surface Water 2-27 10 Change "radionucllides" to radionuclides.

2.2.5.2 Beaverdam Creek 2-53 26 Add "the" between "of' and "area."

Water Bodies in Transmission Line 2.2.5.3 ROWs 2-54 11,20 Change "mile" to "miles."

2.2.5.4.1 Site Vicinity 2-59 25 Delete one the uses of "is."

Threatened and Endangered 2.2.6.2 Terrestrial Species 2-70 33 Change "stork" to "storks."

Threatened and Endangered 2.2.6.2 Terrestrial Species 2-70 34 Add "a" in between "is" and "potential."

E2 - I Errata Table For The Draft Generic Environmental Impact Statement, Supplement 34 VEGP Units I and 2 License Renewal Application Draft SEIS Section No.

2.2.6.2 2.2.7 Draft SEIS Section Title Threatened and Endangered Terrestrial Species Radiolocical Impacts Errata Page Line Errata t

t 2-71 14 Change "borrows" to "burrows."

i I

2-85 9-31 Change "VEPG" to "VEGP."

2.2.7 -

Radiological Impacts 2-86 14, 32 Change "VEPG" to "VEGP."

2.2.7 Radiological Impacts 2-87 28 Change "VEPG" to "VEGP."

2.2.8.5.1 Transient Population 2-97 5

Change VGEP to VEGP.

4.0 Environmental Impacts of Operation 4-1 32 Add "in" between "addressed" and "Chapter."

Microbiological Organisms (Public 4.1.2 Health) 4-14 33, 40 Change VEPG to VEGP.

Microbiological Organisms (Public 4.1.2 Health) 4-15 41 Change VEPG to VEGP.

Microbiological Organisms (Public

.4.1.2 Health) 4-16 6,123 Change VEPG to VEGP.

Microbiological Organisms (Public 4.1.2 Health) 4-17 15-24 Change VEPG to VEGP.

4.2.1 Electromagnetic Fields-Acute Effects 4-23 11 Change VEPG to VEGP.

4.8.1.1 Water Use Impacts 4-53 14 Change "ground water" to "groundwater."

Cumulative Thermophilic 4.8.4.1 Microorganism Impacts 4-58 20-39 Change VEPG to VEGP.

Cumulative Thermophilic 4.8.4.1 Microorganism Impacts 459 2

Change VEPG to VEGP.

8.1 No-Action Alternative 8-6 30 Change "when" to "if."

8.2.2 Coal Based IGCC Generation 8-30 29 Change "reject" to "release".

8.2.2 Coal Based IGCC Generation 8-35 35 Change "addition" to "additional."

Natural Gas-Fired Combined-Cycle 8.2.3 generation 8-53 11 Add "visible" between "be" and "from."

8.2.5 Conservation 8-65 25-26 Take out one "that."

E2 - 2 Errata Table For The Draft Generic Environmental Impact Statement, Supplement 34 VEGP Units 1 and 2 License Renewal Application L

Draft SEIS Draft SEIS Section No. Section Title Page Line] Errata 8.2.5 Conservation 8-66 25, 30 Change VEPG to VEGP.

E2 - 3

Retrieved from "https://kanterella.com/w/index.php?title=NL-08-1038,_Comment_(6)_of_T._E._Tynan_on_Behalf_of_Southern_Nuclear_Operating_Company,_Inc.,_on_Draft_Generic_Environmental_Impact_Statement_for_License_Renewal_of_Vogtle,_Units_1_%26_2,_Supplement_34&oldid=5326259"