|
---|
Category:LEGAL TRANSCRIPTS & ORDERS & PLEADINGS
MONTHYEARML20056E5101993-08-11011 August 1993 Comment Opposing Proposed Rule 10CFR20 Re Radiological Criteria for Decommissioning ML20059P0531990-10-15015 October 1990 Comment Opposing Proposed Rules 10CFR2,50 & 54 Re Nuclear Power Plant License Renewal IR 05000358/19820101986-06-24024 June 1986 Applicant Exhibit A-49,consisting of Forwarding Partially Withheld Safety Insp Rept 50-358/82-10 on 820607- 0818 (Ref 10CFR2.790) & Notice of Violation ML20129A3751985-05-16016 May 1985 Order Revoking CPPR-88,based on Util 840127 Plan to Convert Facility to Coal Fuel ML20133N3621985-03-14014 March 1985 Unexecuted Amend 3 Terminating Indemnity Agreement B-85 ML20094C3571984-08-0202 August 1984 Transmittal of Info Re Util 840320 Motion for Withdrawal of OL Application.Fuel Removed from Site,Steam Supply Sys Modified & CRD Mechanisms Removed.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20087H7881984-03-20020 March 1984 Motion Requesting Issuance of Order Authorizing Withdrawal of Application.Plant Will Be Used as Part of New Fossil fuel-fired Electric Generating Plant.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20087N2281984-03-0101 March 1984 Endorsement 25 to Nelia Policy NF-249 ML20079F8181984-01-16016 January 1984 Response Opposing Miami Valley Power Project 831231 Proposed Issues & Support for Contentions Re Qa.Issues Not Specific or Litigable.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20083J5321983-12-31031 December 1983 Proposed Issues & Prospective Witnesses Supporting Miami Valley Power Project Proposed Contentions Re Qa,Character & Competence.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20079H6901983-12-14014 December 1983 Petition Per 10CFR2.206 to Defer Judgment or Decision on Proposed Course of Action for Completion of Facility Until Suppl Created for Record of J Keppler 831215 Briefing.W/O Encls ML20082P8501983-12-0606 December 1983 Response Opposing City of Mentor 831115 Memorandum in Support of NRC 831031 Motion to Defer Rulings on Miami Valley Power Project Motion to Reopen Record.Motion W/O Merit.Certificate of Svc Encl.Related Correspondence ML20082M5791983-12-0202 December 1983 Response Opposing Applicant 831115 Answer to NRC 831031 Motion to Defer Ruling on Petition for Reconsideration & Motion for Leave to File Addl Evidence Prior to 831215 Conference of Counsel.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20082L0991983-11-30030 November 1983 Memorandum in Support of City of Mentor Motion to Further Defer Rulings Until Completion of Investigation Into Matl False Statements by NRC & Applicants.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20082D6991983-11-15015 November 1983 Memorandum in Support of NRC Motion to Defer Rulings on Miami Valley Power Project Motion to Reopen & City of Mentor Motion to Further Defer Rulings Until Completion of Investigation.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20081M7951983-11-15015 November 1983 Answer Opposing NRC Motion to Defer Rulings on Miami Valley Power Project (MVPP) 831003 Motion to Reopen Record.Decision Should Not Be Deferred to Await Completion of Investigation. Certificate of Svc Encl ML20085K7841983-10-18018 October 1983 Answer Opposing Miami Valley Power Project 831003 Petition for Reconsideration of ASLB 830915 Memorandum & Order Denying Project Motion to Reopen Record to Admit Eight Late Filed Contentions on Qa.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20078K5621983-10-13013 October 1983 Memorandum in Support of Miami Valley Power Project (MVPP) Petition for Reconsideration of ASLB 830915 Order.Mvpp Urges ASLB to Address Stds for Reopening Record.Issues Should Be Included to Ensure Complete Record.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20078F9641983-10-0606 October 1983 Notification to Commission of Miami Valley Power Project Misrepresentation in 831003 Motion for Reconsideration of ASLB 830915 Order.No Util Counsel Communicated W/Govt Accountability Project.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20078F8891983-10-0606 October 1983 Notice of Jh Laverty Employment W/Conner & Wetterhahn,Pc. Laverty Will Not Participate in Matters Leading to OL Issuance Due to Previous Employment W/Commissioner Roberts. Certificate of Svc Encl ML20078F8751983-10-0606 October 1983 Notice of Jh Laverty Employment W/Conner & Wetterhahn,Pc. Previous Employment W/Commissioner Roberts Eliminates Any Contribution to Zimmer Case ML20080P0771983-10-0303 October 1983 Motion for Extension to File Appeal Until 10 Days After Svc of ASLB Decision on Miami Valley Power Project Petition for Reconsideration.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20080P0141983-10-0303 October 1983 Petition for Reconsideration of ASLB 830915 Order Denying Miami Valley Power Project Motion to Reopen Record for Admission of Eight Proposed Contentions.Addl Info Provided Since Original Decision.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20080P0481983-09-26026 September 1983 Affidavit of T Devine Summarizing 830919 Discussion W/ C Weaver Re Summary of Interview in Torrey Pines Rept. Weaver Seriously Challenges Completeness of Interview Summary ML20080P0291983-09-26026 September 1983 Affidavit of D Jones for Govt Accountability Project Protesting Torrey Pines Rept Chapter on Cases Studies.Ref to Author Interviews Incomplete & Thus Inaccurate.Analysis of Whistleblower Missed Real Problem of Lack of Freedom ML20080P0671983-09-24024 September 1983 Affidavit of R Reiter for Govt Accountability Project Expressing Dissatisfaction of W/Summarized Interview in Torrey Pines Rept ML20080F2451983-09-13013 September 1983 Memorandum Supporting Miami Valley Power Project 830603 Motion to Reopen Record for Admission of Eight Contentions. Torrey Pines Mgt Review & NRC Repts Confirm Project Substantially Correct on Qa.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20080E6921983-09-12012 September 1983 Answer Opposing Miami Valley Power Project 830826 Motion for Leave to Submit New Documents & for ASLB Review of Pending Investigations.Motion Unjustified Attempt to Bend Rules on Late Contentions.W/Certificate of Svc ML20080D2791983-08-26026 August 1983 Motion for Leave to Submit New Evidence in Support of 830603 Proposed Contentions & for ASLB Review of Significant Pending Investigations.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20080C7171983-08-25025 August 1983 Answer Opposing Miami Valley Power Project 830811 Motion for Leave to File Reply Brief to Util & NRC Answers to Project 830712 Motion to Compel Discovery.Project Had Opportunity to Brief Issue in Original Motion.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20076A6451983-08-15015 August 1983 Notice of Substitution of Counsel for Amicus Curiae Brief & Appearance Before Aslb.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20024E5591983-08-11011 August 1983 Motion for Leave to File Reply Brief to Applicant & NRC 830803 & 01,respectively,answers Opposing Miami Valley Power Project Motion to Compel Discovery.Assertion of Boundary on Discovery Should Be Briefed.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20024E3941983-08-0505 August 1983 Motion for Leave to File Reply Brief & for Clarification of Responsibility to Duplicate Previous Analysis & Evidentiary Submissions.Util Challenge Frivolous,Heavy on Chutzpah & Deficient on Common Sense.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20077L5161983-08-0303 August 1983 Response Opposing Miami Valley Power Project 830707 Reply Brief Supporting Project 830603 Motion to Reopen Record.Aslb Lacks Jurisdiction to Hear Motion to Reopen to Admit Eight late-filed Contentions.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20024D1381983-07-27027 July 1983 Answer Opposing Miami Valley Power Project 830712 Motion for Protective Order to Withhold Identity of Persons Upon Whose Allegations Project Relied in Seeking to Reopen Record.Motion W/O Merit.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20024D1261983-07-27027 July 1983 Answer Opposing Miami Valley Power Project 830712 Motion to Reopen Record for Admission of Eight QA Contentions. Motion Actually Is Untimely Appeal from Earlier ASLB Rulings.Relief Sought Contrary to Commission Orders ML20024D1171983-07-27027 July 1983 Answer Opposing Miami Valley Power Project 830712 Motion to Defer Ruling on Review of ALAB-727 Pending Ruling on Motions to Reopen.No Justification Given to Delay Review for Unrelated Matters ML20080A2721983-07-21021 July 1983 Response to Applicant Motion for Leave to Respond to Miami Valley Power Project Reply Brief.Applicant Should Respond Only to Substance of Proposed Contentions Re QA Program Inadequacy.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20076L4691983-07-15015 July 1983 Motion for Leave to Respond by 830729 to Miami Valley Power Project (MVPP) Reply Brief Re Applicant Opposition to Eight QA Contentions.Mvpp Reply Distorts Record & Applicant Position.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20072N4501983-07-12012 July 1983 Reply Brief Supporting Miami Valley Power Project 830603 Motion to Reopen Record for Admission of Eight Contentions on QA & Corporate Character & Competence & Motion to Compel Discovery on Contentions ML20072N4631983-07-12012 July 1983 Motion to Reopen Record for Admission of Eight Contentions on QA & Corporate Character & Competence.Aslab Has Jurisdiction Even If ASLB Lacks Jurisdiction to Reopen Record ML20072N4741983-07-12012 July 1983 Motion to Defer Ruling on Whether to Review ALAB-727 Until ASLB & Aslab Rule on Miami Valley Power Project 830603 & 0712 Motions to Reopen Record to Admit Contentions on QA & Character & Competence,Or Alternatively,To Reopen Record ML20072N4901983-07-12012 July 1983 Motion for Protective Order to Shield Identity of Affiants Providing Portion of Basis for Miami Valley Power Project Eight Proposed Contentions.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20072K7331983-07-0101 July 1983 Answer Opposing Miami Valley Power Project 830629 Motion for Leave to File Reply Brief to Util & NRC Answers to Project 830603 Motion to Reopen Record.No Purpose Would Be Served by Permitting Redundant Discussion.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20024B0591983-06-29029 June 1983 Motion for Leave to File Reply Brief,By 830706,to NRC & Util 830630 Answers to Miami Valley Power Project 830603 Motion to Reopen Record to Admit Eight Contentions on QA & Util Character & Competence.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20072F4481983-06-22022 June 1983 Memorandum Supporting Miami Valley Power Project 830602 Motion to Reopen Record to Admit Eight Contentions on QA & Lack of Corporate Character & Competence.Reopening Necessary to Foster Public Confidence in Nrc.W/Certificate of Svc ML20024A6661983-06-20020 June 1983 Response Opposing Motions to File Amicus Curiae Brief in Support of Miami Valley Power Project Motion to Reopen Record for Admission of Eight QA Contentions.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20024A6621983-06-20020 June 1983 Response Opposing Miami Valley Power Project 830603 Motion to Reopen Record for Admission of Eight QA Contentions. Motion Untimely ML20076J1201983-06-16016 June 1983 Petition for Leave to File Amicus Curiae Brief Re Miami Valley Power Project Motion to Reopen Record to Admit Eight Contentions on QA & Character & Competence.Requests Extension of Time.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20076J1361983-06-16016 June 1983 Ohio Sierra Club Amicus Curiae Brief Supporting Miami Valley Power Project Motion to Reopen Record to Admit Eight Contentions.Contentions Provide Evidence That QA Problems Exist.Certificate of Svc Encl 1993-08-11
[Table view] Category:PLEADINGS
MONTHYEARML20087H7881984-03-20020 March 1984 Motion Requesting Issuance of Order Authorizing Withdrawal of Application.Plant Will Be Used as Part of New Fossil fuel-fired Electric Generating Plant.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20079F8181984-01-16016 January 1984 Response Opposing Miami Valley Power Project 831231 Proposed Issues & Support for Contentions Re Qa.Issues Not Specific or Litigable.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20079H6901983-12-14014 December 1983 Petition Per 10CFR2.206 to Defer Judgment or Decision on Proposed Course of Action for Completion of Facility Until Suppl Created for Record of J Keppler 831215 Briefing.W/O Encls ML20082P8501983-12-0606 December 1983 Response Opposing City of Mentor 831115 Memorandum in Support of NRC 831031 Motion to Defer Rulings on Miami Valley Power Project Motion to Reopen Record.Motion W/O Merit.Certificate of Svc Encl.Related Correspondence ML20082M5791983-12-0202 December 1983 Response Opposing Applicant 831115 Answer to NRC 831031 Motion to Defer Ruling on Petition for Reconsideration & Motion for Leave to File Addl Evidence Prior to 831215 Conference of Counsel.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20082L0991983-11-30030 November 1983 Memorandum in Support of City of Mentor Motion to Further Defer Rulings Until Completion of Investigation Into Matl False Statements by NRC & Applicants.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20081M7951983-11-15015 November 1983 Answer Opposing NRC Motion to Defer Rulings on Miami Valley Power Project (MVPP) 831003 Motion to Reopen Record.Decision Should Not Be Deferred to Await Completion of Investigation. Certificate of Svc Encl ML20085K7841983-10-18018 October 1983 Answer Opposing Miami Valley Power Project 831003 Petition for Reconsideration of ASLB 830915 Memorandum & Order Denying Project Motion to Reopen Record to Admit Eight Late Filed Contentions on Qa.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20078K5621983-10-13013 October 1983 Memorandum in Support of Miami Valley Power Project (MVPP) Petition for Reconsideration of ASLB 830915 Order.Mvpp Urges ASLB to Address Stds for Reopening Record.Issues Should Be Included to Ensure Complete Record.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20080P0771983-10-0303 October 1983 Motion for Extension to File Appeal Until 10 Days After Svc of ASLB Decision on Miami Valley Power Project Petition for Reconsideration.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20080P0141983-10-0303 October 1983 Petition for Reconsideration of ASLB 830915 Order Denying Miami Valley Power Project Motion to Reopen Record for Admission of Eight Proposed Contentions.Addl Info Provided Since Original Decision.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20080F2451983-09-13013 September 1983 Memorandum Supporting Miami Valley Power Project 830603 Motion to Reopen Record for Admission of Eight Contentions. Torrey Pines Mgt Review & NRC Repts Confirm Project Substantially Correct on Qa.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20080E6921983-09-12012 September 1983 Answer Opposing Miami Valley Power Project 830826 Motion for Leave to Submit New Documents & for ASLB Review of Pending Investigations.Motion Unjustified Attempt to Bend Rules on Late Contentions.W/Certificate of Svc ML20080D2791983-08-26026 August 1983 Motion for Leave to Submit New Evidence in Support of 830603 Proposed Contentions & for ASLB Review of Significant Pending Investigations.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20080C7171983-08-25025 August 1983 Answer Opposing Miami Valley Power Project 830811 Motion for Leave to File Reply Brief to Util & NRC Answers to Project 830712 Motion to Compel Discovery.Project Had Opportunity to Brief Issue in Original Motion.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20024E5591983-08-11011 August 1983 Motion for Leave to File Reply Brief to Applicant & NRC 830803 & 01,respectively,answers Opposing Miami Valley Power Project Motion to Compel Discovery.Assertion of Boundary on Discovery Should Be Briefed.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20024E3941983-08-0505 August 1983 Motion for Leave to File Reply Brief & for Clarification of Responsibility to Duplicate Previous Analysis & Evidentiary Submissions.Util Challenge Frivolous,Heavy on Chutzpah & Deficient on Common Sense.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20077L5161983-08-0303 August 1983 Response Opposing Miami Valley Power Project 830707 Reply Brief Supporting Project 830603 Motion to Reopen Record.Aslb Lacks Jurisdiction to Hear Motion to Reopen to Admit Eight late-filed Contentions.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20024D1381983-07-27027 July 1983 Answer Opposing Miami Valley Power Project 830712 Motion for Protective Order to Withhold Identity of Persons Upon Whose Allegations Project Relied in Seeking to Reopen Record.Motion W/O Merit.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20024D1261983-07-27027 July 1983 Answer Opposing Miami Valley Power Project 830712 Motion to Reopen Record for Admission of Eight QA Contentions. Motion Actually Is Untimely Appeal from Earlier ASLB Rulings.Relief Sought Contrary to Commission Orders ML20024D1171983-07-27027 July 1983 Answer Opposing Miami Valley Power Project 830712 Motion to Defer Ruling on Review of ALAB-727 Pending Ruling on Motions to Reopen.No Justification Given to Delay Review for Unrelated Matters ML20080A2721983-07-21021 July 1983 Response to Applicant Motion for Leave to Respond to Miami Valley Power Project Reply Brief.Applicant Should Respond Only to Substance of Proposed Contentions Re QA Program Inadequacy.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20076L4691983-07-15015 July 1983 Motion for Leave to Respond by 830729 to Miami Valley Power Project (MVPP) Reply Brief Re Applicant Opposition to Eight QA Contentions.Mvpp Reply Distorts Record & Applicant Position.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20072N4501983-07-12012 July 1983 Reply Brief Supporting Miami Valley Power Project 830603 Motion to Reopen Record for Admission of Eight Contentions on QA & Corporate Character & Competence & Motion to Compel Discovery on Contentions ML20072N4631983-07-12012 July 1983 Motion to Reopen Record for Admission of Eight Contentions on QA & Corporate Character & Competence.Aslab Has Jurisdiction Even If ASLB Lacks Jurisdiction to Reopen Record ML20072N4741983-07-12012 July 1983 Motion to Defer Ruling on Whether to Review ALAB-727 Until ASLB & Aslab Rule on Miami Valley Power Project 830603 & 0712 Motions to Reopen Record to Admit Contentions on QA & Character & Competence,Or Alternatively,To Reopen Record ML20072N4901983-07-12012 July 1983 Motion for Protective Order to Shield Identity of Affiants Providing Portion of Basis for Miami Valley Power Project Eight Proposed Contentions.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20072K7331983-07-0101 July 1983 Answer Opposing Miami Valley Power Project 830629 Motion for Leave to File Reply Brief to Util & NRC Answers to Project 830603 Motion to Reopen Record.No Purpose Would Be Served by Permitting Redundant Discussion.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20024B0591983-06-29029 June 1983 Motion for Leave to File Reply Brief,By 830706,to NRC & Util 830630 Answers to Miami Valley Power Project 830603 Motion to Reopen Record to Admit Eight Contentions on QA & Util Character & Competence.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20072F4481983-06-22022 June 1983 Memorandum Supporting Miami Valley Power Project 830602 Motion to Reopen Record to Admit Eight Contentions on QA & Lack of Corporate Character & Competence.Reopening Necessary to Foster Public Confidence in Nrc.W/Certificate of Svc ML20024A6661983-06-20020 June 1983 Response Opposing Motions to File Amicus Curiae Brief in Support of Miami Valley Power Project Motion to Reopen Record for Admission of Eight QA Contentions.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20024A6621983-06-20020 June 1983 Response Opposing Miami Valley Power Project 830603 Motion to Reopen Record for Admission of Eight QA Contentions. Motion Untimely ML20076J1201983-06-16016 June 1983 Petition for Leave to File Amicus Curiae Brief Re Miami Valley Power Project Motion to Reopen Record to Admit Eight Contentions on QA & Character & Competence.Requests Extension of Time.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20076J1361983-06-16016 June 1983 Ohio Sierra Club Amicus Curiae Brief Supporting Miami Valley Power Project Motion to Reopen Record to Admit Eight Contentions.Contentions Provide Evidence That QA Problems Exist.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20024A0801983-06-10010 June 1983 Motion of Appalachia-Science for Extension to File Previously Submitted Amicus Curiae Brief Supporting Miami Valley Power Project Renewed Attempt to Obtain Hearing on Eight QA Contentions.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20024A0771983-06-10010 June 1983 Motion of Cumberland Chapter of Sierra Club for Extension to File Previously Submitted Amicus Curiae Brief Supporting Miami Valley Power Project Renewed Attempt to Obtain Hearings on Eight QA Contentions ML20071P9121983-06-0606 June 1983 Motion for Leave to File Amicus Curiae Brief Supporting Miami Valley Power Project Motion to Reopen Record to Admit Eight Contentions on QA & Character & Competence ML20071P8901983-06-0606 June 1983 Brief Supporting Miami Valley Power Project Request to Reopen Licensing Hearing Re Plant Operation.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20071P8851983-06-0606 June 1983 Request to File Amicus Curiae Brief Supporting Miami Valley Power Project Efforts to Obtain Further Public Hearing ML20071Q0241983-06-0303 June 1983 Amicus Curiae Brief Supporting Miami Valley Power Project Motion to Reopen Record for Admission of Eight Contentions on QA & Util Character & Competence.Hearings Only Comprehensive Way to Address Problems.W/Certificate of Svc ML20023D8641983-06-0303 June 1983 Motion to Reopen Record for Admission of Eight Contentions on QA & Character & Competence Or,Alternatively,For ASLB to Exercise Discretion to Consider Whether Stds for 830715 Demonstration of Sua Sponte Authority Met ML20072N4281983-06-0202 June 1983 Motion to Reopen Record for Admission of Eight Contentions on QA & Corporate Character & Competence,Or Alternatively, for ASLB to Consider Whether Stds for 820715 Exercise of Sua Sponte Authority Exists ML20076J2001983-05-31031 May 1983 Cumberland Chapter of Sierra Club Request to File Amicus Curiae Brief Supporting Miami Valley Power Project Renewed Attempt to Obtain Hearing on Eight QA Contentions ML20076J2091983-05-20020 May 1983 Cumberland Chapter of Sierra Club Amicus Curiae Brief Supporting Miami Valley Power Project Renewed Attempt to Obtain Hearing on Eight QA Contentions.Util Cannot Be Trusted to Correct Deficiencies.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20076J1641983-05-20020 May 1983 Appalachia-Science in the Public Interest Request to File Amicus Curiae Brief Supporting Miami Valley Power Project Attempt to Obtain Hearing on Eight QA Contentions ML20076J1691983-05-17017 May 1983 Appalachia-Science in the Public Interest Amicus Curiae Brief Supporting Miami Valley Power Project Renewed Attempt to Obtain Hearings on Eight QA Contentions.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20070M1601983-01-0707 January 1983 Answer in Opposition to Miami Valley Power Project 821223 Memorandum & Motion for Notification of Future Communications & Prohibition of Further Improper Ex Parte Contacts.Nrc Correspondence & Certificate of Svc Encl ML20079J1781982-12-23023 December 1982 Supplemental Memorandum in Support of Miami Valley Power Project 820820 Petition for Reconsideration of Commission 820730 Order & Motion for Notification of All Future third- Party Communications.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20070F1091982-12-16016 December 1982 Answer Opposing Miami Valley Power Project 821130 Petition to Establish Detailed Structure for Public Participation Through Audit.Intervenor Fails to Demonstrate Process Necessary to Carry Out NRC Goals.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20070C5211982-12-10010 December 1982 Memorandum Supporting Zimmer Area Citizens-Zimmer Area Citizens of Ky & City of Mentor,Ky 821119 Petition for Appointment of Consulting Firm to Review & Monitor third- Party Audit.Certificate of Svc Encl 1984-03-20
[Table view] |
Text
- =
UNITEDSTATESOFAMEskh"g0 NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMIS$[$N BEFORE THE ATCMIC SAFETY ANgIgf?p$7N&3idlRD In the Matter of .
0Frg,n 00
.mgC7 SECT:
g ste m .. - ,
THE CINCINNATI GAS AND ELECTRIC D6bMEE No. 50-358 COMPANY, et. al.
(Wm. H. Zimmer Nuclear Power Station)
CITY OF MENTOR'S MEMORANDUM IN SUPPORT OF MVPP'S PETITION-FOR RECONSIDERATION OF THE BOARD'S SEPTEMBER 15, 1983 ORDER Pursuant to 10 CFR $2.771(b) the City of Mentor files thic memorandum in support of MVPP's Petition for Reconsideration. Mentor, by virtue of its proximity to the Zimmer Nuclear Power Station has always been extremely concerned over charges that relate to the safety of the -
plant and the consequent protection of its citizenery.
Mentor has always taken the view that full public participation in the context of adjudicatory hearings is the only means available to fully protect.the interests of the public, -
particularly in this case. Mentor once more urges the Board to place substance over procedure by reconsidering its Order of September 15,'1983.
First, Mentor would urge the Board to reconsider its findings regarding the third and fifth criteria under Mississippi Power and Light Company, et al. (Grand Gulf Nuclear Station, Units 1 and 2), ALAB-704, 16 NRC 1725 (1982). .
The fifth criterion- turns on whether a new proceeding would delay operation of the plant. The Board finds that a new proceeding probably would not c'use a delay but does not find that MVPP has made a compelling showing
- 8310190146 831013 PDR ADOCK 05000358 C 9J@
i I G PDR
O O t to tnat effect. By virtue of a letter to the board dated October 5, 1983, subsequen't to the. Board's Order of September 15, 1983, from counsel for applicant, in which applicant estimates the time for completion of the plant to be
'two to three years hence, a finding that new proceedings will not delay operations is now warranted. The third criterion deals with whether MVPP may reasonably be expected to assist in developing a sound record. It
.is this intervenor's belief that without MVPP the very issues we are concerned with would not have been raised and would have gone unaddressed. Since the Board refuses to raise these issues sua sponte the public is left with no one other than MVPP to. raise these issues and accordingly develop a record. The choice is one of having a record or having no record on admittedly serious issues. ' The criticisms by the Board of MVPP of tardiness and disorganization ring with a double standard that must be addressed. ,
Staff and Applicant can hardly be considered model participants in these proceedings on either score. Disorganization and failure to keep to their own timetables have been hallmarks of the Applicant's part.icipation, as evidenced by staff and applicants insistence to go to hearing prematurely in emergency planning contentions. Yet the Board wouEd impose exacting standards on intervenors who represent the public's interest. MVPP deserves more than an indication that this criterion weighs in its favor. MVPP has made the required compelling showings that it can and will assist in developing a sound record and likewise that new proceedings will not delay the I
. =
operation of this plant. Accordingly Mentor urges the ,
Board to reconsider these two findings as well as the conclusion that would flow from them.
The Board pivots its decision on the Commission's statement with " Fairness to all involved in NRC's adjudicatory procedures requires that every participant fulfill the obligations inposed by and in accordance with applicable law and Commission regulations." (Emphasis added.)(Board's Memorandum and Order (September 15, 1983),at 36). Again, this intervenor cannot help but feel the blade of the double standard being honed to a fine point. The utility may distort, cover-up, swear to self-serving time schedules, withhold information, destroy its credibility with everyone involved, yet is still afforded full participation in the adjudicatory process. Staff is equally guilty of -
manipulating the flow of information. The Board is not blind to the respective conduct of these parties in this .
proceeding and has heard many complaints to this effect.
Yet the Board seems to require more of the public than it would of the other participants. If MVPP has not fulfilled its obligations, then surely the other parties to the proceedings have been far more remiss, and fairness to all can hardly be used as a basis -to deny MVPP participation.
Finally, Mentor would urge the Board to fully address the standards for reopening the record. Although this intervenor observes with the Board that none of the issues have been litigated, it nevertheless maintains that the standards for reopening still applicable. Long Island
r
~
. Lighting company (Shoreham Nuclear Power Station, Unit 1), CBP-83-30, 17 NRC , , slip op. p. 16 (June 22, 1983). Those standards for reopening the hearing are (1)whether the motion is timely, (2) whether it addresses
. sionificant safety (or environmental) issues, and (3) whether a different result might be reached if the profferred material were considered. Pacifi.}_ Gas and Electric Co.,
(Diablo Canyon Nuclear Power Plant, Units 1 and 2) ALAB-598,11 NRC 876,879 (1980). This case represents a unique situation as to timeliness but as. to the second and third prongs of the standards there can be no doubt that the subject matter-deals with significant safety issues and that a different result might be reached if the material' were to be considered in an adjudicatory setting. When balancing all the factors, a different result is indicated.
In short the Board has placed procedure over substance, legal niceties over the safety of the public.
In spite of Applicant's and Staff's delays and obfuscations,
.the Board has chosen to single out the public and preclude them from participation. The results of this decision are not consistent with the totality of the findings, nor are the results consistent with public, national or NRC policy that protection of the public is paramount.
Accordingly, Mentor urges the Board to:
- 1. find that MVPP has made a compelling showing that h the operation of the plant will not be delayed by virtue of new proceedings,
- 2. find that MVPP has made a compelling showing that MVPP will assist in developing a sound record,
~
- 3. admit the eight contentions of quality assurance and character and competence by_ virtue'of the above findings
- and.to allow litigation upon proper _ refinement of those
, issues, or in the alternative, to find that, upon balancing tha': standards for reopening the record and the criteria .,
'for admission of late contentions the public interest demands admission of the eight contentions.
Respectfully submitted, m , e, q ;
% .. ( \fu ) .
DEBORAH FABER WEBB .
Attorney for City of Mentor i
i Dated: October. 13, 1983 9
e t
9 h
i ,
i f %
. UNITED STATES CF AMERICA NUCLCAR REGULATORY Cor. MISSION 00(.dET ET USNEC ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICFl! SING BOARD In the Matter of a
- 8300117 P3 :47 CINCINNATI CAS & ELECTRIC :
.. DOCKET NO. ' 50-358 COMPANY, et al. ,s (William H. 2immer Nuclear : CEF'.40' k N W", ^ -
. Power Station) a A" PLICATION FOR AN CPERATING DD*.2NSE
. CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I HEREBY CERTIFY that copies of the foregoing " City of Mentor's Memorandum in Support of MVPP's P.etition for Reconsideration of the Board's September'15, 1983 -
Order" have been served upon the following by. mailing La first class, postage prepaid, this 13th day of October,1983.
Jchn H. Frye, III, Esq.. Troy N. Conner, Esq.
Chairman, Atomic Safety & Licensing Board Conner, Moore & Corbet U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 1747 Pennsylvania Avenue, N.V.
Vashington, D. C. 20555 Vashington, D.C. 20005 .
Dr. Frank F. Hooper William J. Moran..Esq.
Atomic Safety & Licensing Board General Counsel, Cin'ti. Gas & Electric Co.
School of Natural Resources P.O. Box 960 University of Michigan Cincinnati, Ohio 45201 '
Ann Arbor, Michigan 48109
-John D. Voliver, Esq. .
Dr. H. Stanley Livingston .P.O. Box 47 , ,
Atomic Safety & Licensing Board 550 Kilgore Street ,
1005 Calle Iargo Batavia, Ohio 45103 Sante Fe, New Mexico 87501 -
- George E. Pattison, Esq.
Docketing and Service Section '462 E. Main Street -
Office of the Secretary Batavia, Ohio 45103 U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D. C. 20555 James H. Feldman, Jr. , Esq. ,
. q.-
.Fifth Level ;
Charles A.,Barth, Esq.
. .216 East Ninth St'reet U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Cincinnati, Ohio 45202 R:om ENBB 9604 7735 Old Georgetown Road David K. Martin, Esq. ,
Bsthesda, Maryland 20014 Office of the Attorney General 209 St. Clair Street
~
, Atomic Safety & Licensing Appeal Board Frankfort, Kentucky 40501 U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission
.. Washington, D. C. 20555 -Andrew B. Dennison 200 Main Street ,
Atomic Safety & Licensing Board Panel -Batavia, Ohio . 45103 - 8 U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission ~
- Vashington, D.C. 20555 .
Thomas De' vine Government Accountability Project -
of- the Institute for Policy Studies A f g 1901-Q. Street, N.W. b,Of7/)Cu (,o M4 J
' Washington, DC 20009
.i -
Deborah Faber Webb
" ' 7967 Alexandria Pike
- Alexandria, Kentucky 41001 M h%Graenor City of Mentor