ML071650053: Difference between revisions

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
(Created page by program invented by StriderTol)
(Created page by program invented by StriderTol)
Line 16: Line 16:


=Text=
=Text=
{{#Wiki_filter:R45 /3 743 DOCKETED USNRC June 13, 2007 (11:1Oamn)
{{#Wiki_filter:R45   /3 743 DOCKETED USNRC June 13, 2007 (11:1Oamn)
OFFICE OF SECRETARY RULEMAKINGS AND ADJUDICATIONS STAFF Docket No. 50-219-LR RADIOACTIVE CONTAMINATION AND CANCER NEAR THE OYSTER CREEK NUCLEAR REACTOR Apresentation to the Atomic Safety and Licensing Board of the U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Joseph J. Mangano, MPH MBA Executive Director Radiation and Public H-ealth Project May 3 )1, 2007 atep 15f ~C-/- 0 3 R AIRBORNE EMISSIONS FROM U.S. NUCLEAR PLANTS IODINE-131 AND PARTICULATES  
OFFICE OF SECRETARY RULEMAKINGS AND ADJUDICATIONS STAFF Docket No. 50-219-LR RADIOACTIVE CONTAMINATION AND CANCER NEAR THE OYSTER CREEK NUCLEAR REACTOR Apresentation to the Atomic Safety and Licensing Board of the U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Joseph J. Mangano, MPH MBA Executive Director Radiation and Public H-ealth Project May 3)1, 2007 atep ~C-/-
*, 1970-1993 (in curies)1. Dresden IL 31 reactors 97.22 2. Oyster Creek NJ I reactor 77.05 3. Millstone CT 3reactors 32.80 4. Quad Cities IL 2 reactors 26.95 5. Indian Point NY 3) reactors 17.50*Radioactive chemicals with half life of 8 days or longer Source: Tichler J et al. Radioactive Materials Released from Nuclear Power Plants. Upton NY: Brookhaven National Laboratories, for U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission, annual reports.U.S. NUCLEAR REACTORS WITH HIGHEST GASEOUS AIRBORNE RELEASES FOR VARIOUS RADIOACTIVE CHEMICALS, 200 1-2004 (total U.S. reactors in operation  
15f 03R
=103)Total Fission Products Oyster Creek rank 1I0 Total Iodine Isotopes Oyster Creek rank = 5 Strontiurn-90 Oyster Creek rank = 2 Strontium-89 Oyster Creek rank = I Source: U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission, wwwxreirs.com/EDB/"effluerit.
 
Figure 1 Average Sr-90 in NJ Baby Teeth, by Birth Year Source:- Radiation and Public Health Project'75-77 '78-80 '81-83 '84-86 '87-89 '90-92 '93-95 '96-98 IDE Avg. picocuries Sr-90 per gram calcium at birthI Page I of I LLM ~<--_B &#xfd;ar Gah Ei<-Site Comparison L 'JK -- Help_Ca'ncer Incidence Rates by County in New Jersy I_____ All Sites, 2000-2004
AIRBORNE EMISSIONS FROM U.S. NUCLEAR PLANTS IODINE-131 AND PARTICULATES *, 1970-1993 (in curies)
________ICounty ilRi-sk Poplto Cae Crude Rateli Age-Adjusted Rate][Q-ame Ma 5083401 440 866.1ij[ 612.11 (Ocean ]1 672491 222 845.91 602.:4: kIh2quicester  
: 1. Dresden IL           31reactors                97.22
]1013401 757 574.]81 588.9 ImnOLt ]1ll 313665] 198 608.5] 583.81 lIwarren 11 318 601.]51 58 1.-31 lBudlington  
: 2. Oyster Creek NJ       I reactor                 77.05
-31 1311 600.]01 580.21 (Atflantic  
: 3. Millstone CT         3reactors                 32.80
]I1299=902 800615.41 580.ILISuSeX ]I 4111 30j 524.]91 578.9 I'Saiem 11 32333261 103 647]l~ 578.4 Kcmisim ]1I 2591281 140 574.81 5 71.3 (Bergen 447143 298 663,.]9[ 567.6 IMercer ]l 17251 1016571.0l 566.0 (Essex. ]1 339759611 2106 529.]91 5479 IMIjdIesex 1 3868 2047 52.4] 538.6 j(ion -11 ] 02641 49 564.11 5-35.6 j11-tantirdi.
: 4. Quad Cities IL       2 reactors               26.95
11 338051 535.10 532.3)1oe53t1l 83551 792 515.2- 531I.5 (cumh7a0d 5~ 395 53.3 524.1 (Passaic J 3 22412388 499.41 514.51 11usn ] 0491330 437.0] 471.ISTATE ] 4283985125186&#xfd; 584.0] 556.:977 Note: All rates are per 100,000. Rates are age-adjusted to the 2000 U.S. Standard Million Population.
: 5. Indian Point NY       3)reactors                 17.50
http://www.cancer-rates.i nfo/nj/al ldetails.php 5/30/2007 Figure 3 1999-2004 Mortality, Ocean County vs. U.S.for Five Most Common Causes of Death, Whites Source: National Center for Health Statisticsht~iwndr d~o Rates Adjusted to 2000 U.S. standard population Five causes account for 83% of all U.S. deaths 15 I-5-10-15-20-25-30 Circulatory Cancer Respiratory Acc/Sui/Hom Nervous Sys.I El % Ocean DOceanCounty is Above/Below U.S.
*Radioactive   chemicals with half life of 8 days or longer Source: Tichler J et al. Radioactive Materials Released from Nuclear Power Plants.       Upton NY:
Figure 1, Sr-90 in Baby Teeth and Cancer Incidence 0-9 Monmouth/Ocean County, New Jersey Picocuries Sr-901g Calcium vs. Cancer Cases/20,OOO Population Five year lag (Sr begins '80-2, Ca begins '85-7)5 4.5 4 3.5 3 2.5 2 I---------------------
Brookhaven National Laboratories, for U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission, annual reports.
'80-2 '81-3 '82-4 '83-5 '84-6 '85-7 '86-8 '87-9 '88-90'89- '90-2 '91-3 '92-4 '93-5 91 I-~--o-Sr9O  
U.S. NUCLEAR REACTORS WITH HIGHEST GASEOUS AIRBORNE RELEASES FOR VARIOUS RADIOACTIVE CHEMICALS, 200 1-2004 (total U.S. reactors in operation =103)
--a-Ca 0-91}}
Total Fission Products                     Oyster Creek rank     1I0 Total Iodine Isotopes                     Oyster Creek rank   = 5 Strontiurn-90                             Oyster Creek rank   = 2 Strontium-89                               Oyster Creek rank   = I Source: U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission, wwwxreirs.com/EDB/"effluerit.
 
Figure 1 Average Sr-90 in NJ Baby Teeth, by Birth Year Source:- Radiation and Public Health Project
'75-77 '78-80 '81-83 '84-86 '87-89 '90-92 '93-95 '96-98 IDE Avg. picocuries Sr-90 per gram calcium at birthI
 
Page I of I LLM ~<--_B         &#xfd;ar Gah   Ei<-Site Comparison L 'JK-- Help_
Ca'ncer Incidence Rates by County in New Jersy I_____                             All Sites, 2000-2004         ________
ICounty            ilRi-sk Poplto     Cae     Crude Rateli Age-Adjusted Rate]
[Q-ame Ma                       5083401     440         866.1ij[         612.11 (Ocean           ]1             672491   222           845.91           602.:4:
kIh2quicester ]1013401                       757         574.]81           588.9 ImnOLt ]1ll                     313665]       198       608.5]           583.81 lIwarren           11                       318         601.]51           58 1.-31 lBudlington -31                           1311         600.]01           580.21 (Atflantic       ]I1299=902                 800615.41                     580.
ILISuSeX             ]I           4111     30j         524.]91           578.9 I'Saiem           11             32333261       103     647]l~           578.4 Kcmisim           ]1I           2591281       140       574.81           571.3 (Bergen                         447143     298           663,.]9[         567.6 IMercer             ]l       17251       1016571.0l                     566.0 (Essex.           ]1           339759611 2106         529.]91           5479 IMIjdIesex                     3868       2047 1      52.4]             538.6 j(ion             -11]       02641         49         564.11           5-35.6 j11-tantirdi. 11                             338051     535.10           532.3) 83551 1oe53t1l     792         515.2-           531I.5 (cumh7a0d                           395        5~
53.3             524.1 (Passaic         J         3   22412388               499.41           514.51 11usn]             0491330                 437.0]           471.
ISTATE           ]           4283985125186&#xfd;           584.0]           556.:977 Note: All rates are per 100,000. Rates are age-adjusted to the 2000 U.S. Standard Million Population.
http://www.cancer-rates.i nfo/nj/al ldetails.php                                                 5/30/2007
 
Figure 3 1999-2004 Mortality, Ocean County vs. U.S.
for Five Most Common Causes of Death, Whites Source: National Center for Health Statisticsht~iwndr d~o Rates Adjusted to 2000 U.S. standard population Five causes account for 83% of all U.S. deaths 15 I
  -5
-10
-15
-20
-25
-30 Circulatory       Cancer               Respiratory         Acc/Sui/Hom Nervous Sys.
IEl % Ocean DOceanCounty is Above/Below U.S.
 
Figure 1, Sr-90 in Baby Teeth and Cancer Incidence 0-9 Monmouth/Ocean County, New Jersey Picocuries Sr-901g Calcium vs. Cancer Cases/20,OOO Population Five year lag (Sr begins '80-2, Ca begins '85-7) 5 4.5 4
3.5 3
I---------------------
2.5 2
    '80-2 '81-3 '82-4 '83-5 '84-6 '85-7 '86-8 '87-9 '88-                       '89- '90-2 '91-3 '92-4 '93-5 90        91 I-~--o-Sr9O --a-Ca 0-91}}

Revision as of 06:22, 23 November 2019

2007/05/31-Limited Appearance Statement of Joseph J. Mangano
ML071650053
Person / Time
Site: Oyster Creek
Issue date: 05/31/2007
From: Mangano J
Radiation & Public Health Project
To:
Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel
SECY RAS
References
50-219-LR, RAS 13763
Download: ML071650053 (6)
v • d • e


Text

R45 /3 743 DOCKETED USNRC June 13, 2007 (11:1Oamn)

OFFICE OF SECRETARY RULEMAKINGS AND ADJUDICATIONS STAFF Docket No. 50-219-LR RADIOACTIVE CONTAMINATION AND CANCER NEAR THE OYSTER CREEK NUCLEAR REACTOR Apresentation to the Atomic Safety and Licensing Board of the U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Joseph J. Mangano, MPH MBA Executive Director Radiation and Public H-ealth Project May 3)1, 2007 atep ~C-/-

15f 03R

AIRBORNE EMISSIONS FROM U.S. NUCLEAR PLANTS IODINE-131 AND PARTICULATES *, 1970-1993 (in curies)

1. Dresden IL 31reactors 97.22
2. Oyster Creek NJ I reactor 77.05
3. Millstone CT 3reactors 32.80
4. Quad Cities IL 2 reactors 26.95
5. Indian Point NY 3)reactors 17.50
  • Radioactive chemicals with half life of 8 days or longer Source: Tichler J et al. Radioactive Materials Released from Nuclear Power Plants. Upton NY:

Brookhaven National Laboratories, for U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission, annual reports.

U.S. NUCLEAR REACTORS WITH HIGHEST GASEOUS AIRBORNE RELEASES FOR VARIOUS RADIOACTIVE CHEMICALS, 200 1-2004 (total U.S. reactors in operation =103)

Total Fission Products Oyster Creek rank 1I0 Total Iodine Isotopes Oyster Creek rank = 5 Strontiurn-90 Oyster Creek rank = 2 Strontium-89 Oyster Creek rank = I Source: U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission, wwwxreirs.com/EDB/"effluerit.

Figure 1 Average Sr-90 in NJ Baby Teeth, by Birth Year Source:- Radiation and Public Health Project

'75-77 '78-80 '81-83 '84-86 '87-89 '90-92 '93-95 '96-98 IDE Avg. picocuries Sr-90 per gram calcium at birthI

Page I of I LLM ~<--_B ýar Gah Ei<-Site Comparison L 'JK-- Help_

Ca'ncer Incidence Rates by County in New Jersy I_____ All Sites, 2000-2004 ________

ICounty ilRi-sk Poplto Cae Crude Rateli Age-Adjusted Rate]

[Q-ame Ma 5083401 440 866.1ij[ 612.11 (Ocean ]1 672491 222 845.91 602.:4:

kIh2quicester ]1013401 757 574.]81 588.9 ImnOLt ]1ll 313665] 198 608.5] 583.81 lIwarren 11 318 601.]51 58 1.-31 lBudlington -31 1311 600.]01 580.21 (Atflantic ]I1299=902 800615.41 580.

ILISuSeX ]I 4111 30j 524.]91 578.9 I'Saiem 11 32333261 103 647]l~ 578.4 Kcmisim ]1I 2591281 140 574.81 571.3 (Bergen 447143 298 663,.]9[ 567.6 IMercer ]l 17251 1016571.0l 566.0 (Essex. ]1 339759611 2106 529.]91 5479 IMIjdIesex 3868 2047 1 52.4] 538.6 j(ion -11] 02641 49 564.11 5-35.6 j11-tantirdi. 11 338051 535.10 532.3) 83551 1oe53t1l 792 515.2- 531I.5 (cumh7a0d 395 5~

53.3 524.1 (Passaic J 3 22412388 499.41 514.51 11usn] 0491330 437.0] 471.

ISTATE ] 4283985125186ý 584.0] 556.:977 Note: All rates are per 100,000. Rates are age-adjusted to the 2000 U.S. Standard Million Population.

http://www.cancer-rates.i nfo/nj/al ldetails.php 5/30/2007

Figure 3 1999-2004 Mortality, Ocean County vs. U.S.

for Five Most Common Causes of Death, Whites Source: National Center for Health Statisticsht~iwndr d~o Rates Adjusted to 2000 U.S. standard population Five causes account for 83% of all U.S. deaths 15 I

-5

-10

-15

-20

-25

-30 Circulatory Cancer Respiratory Acc/Sui/Hom Nervous Sys.

IEl % Ocean DOceanCounty is Above/Below U.S.

Figure 1, Sr-90 in Baby Teeth and Cancer Incidence 0-9 Monmouth/Ocean County, New Jersey Picocuries Sr-901g Calcium vs. Cancer Cases/20,OOO Population Five year lag (Sr begins '80-2, Ca begins '85-7) 5 4.5 4

3.5 3

I---------------------

2.5 2

'80-2 '81-3 '82-4 '83-5 '84-6 '85-7 '86-8 '87-9 '88- '89- '90-2 '91-3 '92-4 '93-5 90 91 I-~--o-Sr9O --a-Ca 0-91

Retrieved from "https://kanterella.com/w/index.php?title=ML071650053&oldid=2176353"