ML14031A160: Difference between revisions
StriderTol (talk | contribs) (Created page by program invented by StriderTol) |
StriderTol (talk | contribs) (Created page by program invented by StriderTol) |
||
| Line 16: | Line 16: | ||
=Text= | =Text= | ||
{{#Wiki_filter:April 23, 2014 | {{#Wiki_filter:April 23, 2014 Mr. Russell J. Bell Senior Director, New Plant Licensing Nuclear Energy Institute 1201 F Street, NW Suite 1100 Washington, D.C. 20004 | ||
Mr. Russell J. Bell Senior Director, New Plant Licensing Nuclear Energy Institute 1201 F Street, NW Suite 1100 Washington, D.C. 20004 | |||
==SUBJECT:== | ==SUBJECT:== | ||
COMMENTS ON NUCLEAR ENERGY INSTITUTE 08-01, REVISION 5: | COMMENTS ON NUCLEAR ENERGY INSTITUTE 08-01, REVISION 5: | ||
INDUSTRY GUIDELINE FOR THE ITAAC CLOSURE PROCESS UNDER 10 CFR PART 52 | |||
==Dear Mr. Bell:== | ==Dear Mr. Bell:== | ||
The Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) has completed its review of Nuclear Energy Institute (NEI) 08-01, Revision 5, Industry Guideline for the ITAAC Closure Process Under 10 CFR Part 52, which was submitted to the NRC on July 18, 2013 (Agencywide Documents Access and Management System (ADAMS) Accession No. ML13233A220). NEI 08-01 provides guidance for the inspections, tests, analyses and acceptance criteria (ITAAC) program for new nuclear plants licensed under Title 10 of the Code of Federal Regulations (10 CFR), Part 52. | The Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) has completed its review of Nuclear Energy Institute (NEI) 08-01, Revision 5, Industry Guideline for the ITAAC Closure Process Under 10 CFR Part 52, which was submitted to the NRC on July 18, 2013 (Agencywide Documents Access and Management System (ADAMS) Accession No. ML13233A220). NEI 08-01 provides guidance for the inspections, tests, analyses and acceptance criteria (ITAAC) program for new nuclear plants licensed under Title 10 of the Code of Federal Regulations (10 CFR), | ||
The staff provided comments on NEI 08-01, Revision 5, in a February 12, 2014, email (ADAMS Accession No. ML14056A453). At a public | Part 52. | ||
The staff provided comments on NEI 08-01, Revision 5, in a February 12, 2014, email (ADAMS Accession No. ML14056A453). At a public meeting on February 27, 2014 (ADAMS Accession No. ML14069A049), the staff received feedback that its comments were either: | |||
: 1. editorial comments that do not need to be addressed for the NRC to endorse NEI 08-01, Revision 5, in an update to Regulatory Guide (RG) 1.215, Guidance for ITAAC Closure Under 10 CFR Part 52; | |||
: 2. related to ITAAC Closure Notification (ICN) examples that had already been reviewed and accepted by the staff; or | |||
: 3. not consistent with NRC positions stated in earlier public meetings. | |||
Based on that public meeting feedback, the staff committed to reassess its comments and publically document the results of that reassessment. | |||
The staff determined that some comments were editorial in nature or did not otherwise need to be addressed in order for the staff to endorse NEI 08-01, Revision 5. The staff encourages licensees and NEI to consider these comments when developing ICNs and when revising NEI 08-01 in the future. As part of its reassessment, the staff determined that although some comments would not prevent NRC endorsement of NEI 08-01, Revision 5, those comments may be discussed in the staffs next revision to RG 1.215. In some cases, however, the staff determined that it would be unable to endorse certain portions of NEI 08-01, Revision 5, unless the comments are resolved. The enclosure to this letter provides the staffs original comments and an explanation of the reassessment for each item. | |||
R. Bell The staff intends to discuss the results of this reassessment in a May 22, 2014, public meeting. | |||
If you have any questions regarding the staff comments, please contact Mr. Steven Bloom at (301) 415-2431. | |||
Sincerely, | |||
/RA/ | |||
Brian Anderson, Chief ITAAC and Generic Communication Branch Division of Construction Inspection | |||
& Operational Programs Office of New Reactors Project No.: 0689 | |||
==Enclosure:== | |||
NRC Comments on NEI 08-01, Revision 5 | |||
ML14031A160 *via email NRO-001 OFFICE NRO/DCIP/IGCB OGC(NLO)* BC:NRO/DCIP/IGCB NAME SBloom MSpencer BAnderson DATE 4/11/14 4/23 /14 4/23/14 | |||
DCIP Distribution List (Updated 1/27/2014) | |||
Email Agarwal, Duli duli.agarwal@hq.doe.gov Ainger, Kenneth kenneth.ainger@exeloncorp.com Aitken, Steve aitkensy@inpo.org Albuquerque, Paulo pcalbuqu@southernco.com Austgen, Katie kra@nei.org Bagnal, Charles charles.bagnal@ge.com Beard, James james.beard@gene.ge.com Bell, Russell rjb@nei.org Berger, J. Pierre jean-pierre.berger@edf.com Bergman, Jana Jbergman@Curtisswright.com Bessette, Paul pbessette@morganlewis.com Brooks, Marc marc.brooks@dhs.gov Bryant, Barry barry.bryant@dom.com Burdick, Stephen sburdick@morganlewis.com Butler, Skip skip.butler@ge.com Campbell, Patricia patricial.campbell@ge.com Carnes, William carnesws@westinghouse.com Carr, Jack jack.carr@cbi.com Castell, Curtis curtis.castell@cbi.com Cesare, Guy gcesare@enercon.com Chandler, Lawrence lchandler@morganlewis.com Clem, David djclem@southernco.com Clouser, Timothy timothy.clouser@luminant.com Cottingham, Ann awc@nei.org Couture, Gerard F. couturgf@westinghouse.com Cullington, E. ecullington@earthlink.net Cummins, Edward cumminwe@westinghouse.com Danielson, Gustave bud.danielson@hq.doe.gov Davis, Jim jtdavis@southernco.com Dolley, Steven steven_dolley@platts.com Ezell, Julie julie.ezell@scana.com Fay, Tom tom.fay@fluor.com Fertel, Marvin msf@nei.org Fonseca, Carlos carlos.fonseca@cbi.com Frantz, Stephen sfrantz@morganlewis.com Fraser, Robert Robert_Fraser@mnes-us.com Gaukler, Paul paul.gaukler@pillsburylaw.com Giles, M. mgiles@entergy.com Gove, Patrick govepa@bv.com Grant, Eddie eddie.grant@excelservices.com | |||
Grant, Eddie erg-xl@cox.net Gray, Susan sgray@dnr.state.md.us Gresham, James greshaja@westinghouse.com Gunter, Paul paul@beyondnuclear.org Gwyn, Dealis dwgwyn@moxproject.com Haines, Jay jayhaines@tamu.edu Halnon, Greg ghalnon@firstenergycorp.com Harvey, Mark mwharvey1960@yahoo.com Hastings, Peter pshastings@duke-energy.com Head, Jerald jerald.head@ge.com Hegner, Joseph joseph_hegner@dom.com Heymer, Adrian aph@nei.org Hinds, David david.hinds@ge.com Horin, W. whorin@winston.com Howard, Danny danny.r.howard@fluor.com Huss, William William.Huss@pillsburylaw.com Jacobson, Shaun shaun.jacobson@cbi.com Jaworsky, Mari mari.jaworsky@duke-energy.com Jenkins, Susan jenkinse@dhec.sc.gov Kelly, Nicole nicole.kelly@mccaedu.org Keys, Julie julie.keys@urs.com Kitchen, Robert robert.kitchen@pgnmail.com Kray, Marilyn marilyn.kray@exeloncorp.com Laskowski, Lenny leonard.laskowski@ge.com LeJeune, Peter plejeune@balch.com Lejeune, Peter plejeune@balch.com LeRoy, Peter peter.leroy@cbi.com Levin, Howard howard_levin@msn.com Lewis, David david.lewis@pillsburylaw.com Lyman, Ed elyman@ucsusa.org Lyons, John john.lyons@cbi.com Mahan, Howard Chmahan@southernco.com Maher, William william.maher@fpl.com Mariotte, Michael nirsnet@nirs.org Markert, John C. cmarkert@nuscalepower.com Marshall, Wanda wanda.k.marshall@dom.com McCabe, Brian brian.mccabe@pgnmail.com Medlock, Clint mmedlock@southernco.com Mermelstein, Irv imermels@bechtel.com Midlik, Dave dwmidlik@southernco.com Miller, Garry garry.miller@pgnmail.com Miras-Wilson, Rachel rwilson@winston.com Mitchell, Stanley stanley.mitchell@exeloncorp.com | |||
Moen, Stephan stephan.moen@ge.com Moran, Mike nucmike2002@yahoo.com Morgan, Michael Michael.Morgan5@ge.com Murawski, John murawski@newsobserver.com Nesrsta, James jjnesrsta@cpsenergy.com Oesterle, Eric eroeste1@Bechtel.com O'Neill, John john.o'neill@pillsburylaw.com Orthen, Richard richard.orthen@nexteraenergy.com Paglia, Al apaglia@scana.com Pate, Russell rwpate@southernco.com Peterson, Scott media@nei.org Pitts, Al al.pitts@unistarnuclear.com Pitts, Harold harold_pitts@mnes-us.com Pleins, Ed pleinsel@westinghouse.com Polich, Timothy timothy.polich@cbi.com Popa, Markus Markus.Popa@Hq.Doe.Gov Quinn, Vanessa vanessa.quinn@dhs.gov Ray, Thom raytj@westinghouse.com Repka, David drepka@winston.com Rezk, Tamer tamer.rezk@cbi.com Riccio, James jim.riccio@wdc.greenpeace.org Rolfson, Greg Greg_Rolfson@mnes-us.com Romashko, Darryl dcromashko@tva.gov Rosenfeld, Elliot elliot.rosenfeld@dep.state.nj.us Rubin, Michael rubinmp@westinghouse.com Scarola, Ken kenscarola@nuclearautomation.com Schlaseman, Caroline cschlaseman@mpr.com Schumitsch, Walter Walter.schumitsch@ge.com Smith, Tyson trsmith@winston.com Stallings, John john.stallings@ge.com Stan, Thomason, sthomasu@southernco.com Stevenson, Rick richard.stevenson@cbi.com Sutton, Kathryn ksutton@morganlewis.com Swanson, Ronald reswanso@bechtel.com Taylor, Larry larry.taylor@pgnmail.com Taylor, Marlene marlene.taylor@exeloncorp.com Temple, Robert nuclaw@mindspring.com Thomason, Stan sthomason@southernco.com Thompson, Ryder Ryder.Thompson@scana.com Torres, Alan atorres@scana.com Traiforos, Spyros satconsult@msn.com Travieso-Diaz, Matias matias.travieso-diaz@pillsburylaw.com Van Wyk, Jake jacob.vanwyk@scana.com | |||
Vaughn, Lisa lfvaughn@duke-energy.com Waites, Brandon bwwaites@southernco.com Waltman, C. | Vaughn, Lisa lfvaughn@duke-energy.com Waites, Brandon bwwaites@southernco.com Waltman, C. cwaltman@roe.com Warren, Jim jim@ncwarn.org Webb, Maria maria.webb@pillsburylaw.com Wessel, Ronald wesselrp@westinghouse.com Wink, Roger rwink@ameren.com Woodlan, Donald donald.woodlan@luminant.com Zinke, George gzinke@entergy.com Zorn, Jason zornjc@westinghouse.com arp@nei.org bpgarde@aol.com dashurberg@hpacorp.com dwoodla1@txu.com ecg@nei.org hundrupa@gao.gov jfulto1@entergy.com jrfergus@duke-energy.com llbauman@aol.com lynchje@inpo.org pmblanch@comcast.net sbhaber@hpacorp.com}} | ||
cwaltman@roe.com Warren, Jim jim@ncwarn.org Webb, Maria maria.webb@pillsburylaw.com Wessel, Ronald wesselrp@westinghouse.com Wink, Roger rwink@ameren.com Woodlan, Donald donald.woodlan@luminant.com Zinke, George gzinke@entergy.com Zorn, Jason zornjc@westinghouse.com arp@nei.org bpgarde@aol.com dashurberg@hpacorp.com dwoodla1@txu.com ecg@nei.org hundrupa@gao.gov jfulto1@entergy.com jrfergus@duke-energy.com llbauman@aol.com lynchje@inpo.org pmblanch@comcast.net sbhaber@hpacorp.com}} | |||
Latest revision as of 09:56, 4 November 2019
| ML14031A160 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Nuclear Energy Institute |
| Issue date: | 04/23/2014 |
| From: | Steven Bloom NRC/NRO/DCIP/CITB |
| To: | Bell R Nuclear Energy Institute |
| Bloom S, NRO/DCIP/IGCB, 415-2431 | |
| Shared Package | |
| ML14031A195 | List: |
| References | |
| Download: ML14031A160 (20) | |
Text
April 23, 2014 Mr. Russell J. Bell Senior Director, New Plant Licensing Nuclear Energy Institute 1201 F Street, NW Suite 1100 Washington, D.C. 20004
SUBJECT:
COMMENTS ON NUCLEAR ENERGY INSTITUTE 08-01, REVISION 5:
INDUSTRY GUIDELINE FOR THE ITAAC CLOSURE PROCESS UNDER 10 CFR PART 52
Dear Mr. Bell:
The Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) has completed its review of Nuclear Energy Institute (NEI) 08-01, Revision 5, Industry Guideline for the ITAAC Closure Process Under 10 CFR Part 52, which was submitted to the NRC on July 18, 2013 (Agencywide Documents Access and Management System (ADAMS) Accession No. ML13233A220). NEI 08-01 provides guidance for the inspections, tests, analyses and acceptance criteria (ITAAC) program for new nuclear plants licensed under Title 10 of the Code of Federal Regulations (10 CFR),
Part 52.
The staff provided comments on NEI 08-01, Revision 5, in a February 12, 2014, email (ADAMS Accession No. ML14056A453). At a public meeting on February 27, 2014 (ADAMS Accession No. ML14069A049), the staff received feedback that its comments were either:
- 1. editorial comments that do not need to be addressed for the NRC to endorse NEI 08-01, Revision 5, in an update to Regulatory Guide (RG) 1.215, Guidance for ITAAC Closure Under 10 CFR Part 52;
- 2. related to ITAAC Closure Notification (ICN) examples that had already been reviewed and accepted by the staff; or
- 3. not consistent with NRC positions stated in earlier public meetings.
Based on that public meeting feedback, the staff committed to reassess its comments and publically document the results of that reassessment.
The staff determined that some comments were editorial in nature or did not otherwise need to be addressed in order for the staff to endorse NEI 08-01, Revision 5. The staff encourages licensees and NEI to consider these comments when developing ICNs and when revising NEI 08-01 in the future. As part of its reassessment, the staff determined that although some comments would not prevent NRC endorsement of NEI 08-01, Revision 5, those comments may be discussed in the staffs next revision to RG 1.215. In some cases, however, the staff determined that it would be unable to endorse certain portions of NEI 08-01, Revision 5, unless the comments are resolved. The enclosure to this letter provides the staffs original comments and an explanation of the reassessment for each item.
R. Bell The staff intends to discuss the results of this reassessment in a May 22, 2014, public meeting.
If you have any questions regarding the staff comments, please contact Mr. Steven Bloom at (301) 415-2431.
Sincerely,
/RA/
Brian Anderson, Chief ITAAC and Generic Communication Branch Division of Construction Inspection
& Operational Programs Office of New Reactors Project No.: 0689
Enclosure:
NRC Comments on NEI 08-01, Revision 5
ML14031A160 *via email NRO-001 OFFICE NRO/DCIP/IGCB OGC(NLO)* BC:NRO/DCIP/IGCB NAME SBloom MSpencer BAnderson DATE 4/11/14 4/23 /14 4/23/14
DCIP Distribution List (Updated 1/27/2014)
Email Agarwal, Duli duli.agarwal@hq.doe.gov Ainger, Kenneth kenneth.ainger@exeloncorp.com Aitken, Steve aitkensy@inpo.org Albuquerque, Paulo pcalbuqu@southernco.com Austgen, Katie kra@nei.org Bagnal, Charles charles.bagnal@ge.com Beard, James james.beard@gene.ge.com Bell, Russell rjb@nei.org Berger, J. Pierre jean-pierre.berger@edf.com Bergman, Jana Jbergman@Curtisswright.com Bessette, Paul pbessette@morganlewis.com Brooks, Marc marc.brooks@dhs.gov Bryant, Barry barry.bryant@dom.com Burdick, Stephen sburdick@morganlewis.com Butler, Skip skip.butler@ge.com Campbell, Patricia patricial.campbell@ge.com Carnes, William carnesws@westinghouse.com Carr, Jack jack.carr@cbi.com Castell, Curtis curtis.castell@cbi.com Cesare, Guy gcesare@enercon.com Chandler, Lawrence lchandler@morganlewis.com Clem, David djclem@southernco.com Clouser, Timothy timothy.clouser@luminant.com Cottingham, Ann awc@nei.org Couture, Gerard F. couturgf@westinghouse.com Cullington, E. ecullington@earthlink.net Cummins, Edward cumminwe@westinghouse.com Danielson, Gustave bud.danielson@hq.doe.gov Davis, Jim jtdavis@southernco.com Dolley, Steven steven_dolley@platts.com Ezell, Julie julie.ezell@scana.com Fay, Tom tom.fay@fluor.com Fertel, Marvin msf@nei.org Fonseca, Carlos carlos.fonseca@cbi.com Frantz, Stephen sfrantz@morganlewis.com Fraser, Robert Robert_Fraser@mnes-us.com Gaukler, Paul paul.gaukler@pillsburylaw.com Giles, M. mgiles@entergy.com Gove, Patrick govepa@bv.com Grant, Eddie eddie.grant@excelservices.com
Grant, Eddie erg-xl@cox.net Gray, Susan sgray@dnr.state.md.us Gresham, James greshaja@westinghouse.com Gunter, Paul paul@beyondnuclear.org Gwyn, Dealis dwgwyn@moxproject.com Haines, Jay jayhaines@tamu.edu Halnon, Greg ghalnon@firstenergycorp.com Harvey, Mark mwharvey1960@yahoo.com Hastings, Peter pshastings@duke-energy.com Head, Jerald jerald.head@ge.com Hegner, Joseph joseph_hegner@dom.com Heymer, Adrian aph@nei.org Hinds, David david.hinds@ge.com Horin, W. whorin@winston.com Howard, Danny danny.r.howard@fluor.com Huss, William William.Huss@pillsburylaw.com Jacobson, Shaun shaun.jacobson@cbi.com Jaworsky, Mari mari.jaworsky@duke-energy.com Jenkins, Susan jenkinse@dhec.sc.gov Kelly, Nicole nicole.kelly@mccaedu.org Keys, Julie julie.keys@urs.com Kitchen, Robert robert.kitchen@pgnmail.com Kray, Marilyn marilyn.kray@exeloncorp.com Laskowski, Lenny leonard.laskowski@ge.com LeJeune, Peter plejeune@balch.com Lejeune, Peter plejeune@balch.com LeRoy, Peter peter.leroy@cbi.com Levin, Howard howard_levin@msn.com Lewis, David david.lewis@pillsburylaw.com Lyman, Ed elyman@ucsusa.org Lyons, John john.lyons@cbi.com Mahan, Howard Chmahan@southernco.com Maher, William william.maher@fpl.com Mariotte, Michael nirsnet@nirs.org Markert, John C. cmarkert@nuscalepower.com Marshall, Wanda wanda.k.marshall@dom.com McCabe, Brian brian.mccabe@pgnmail.com Medlock, Clint mmedlock@southernco.com Mermelstein, Irv imermels@bechtel.com Midlik, Dave dwmidlik@southernco.com Miller, Garry garry.miller@pgnmail.com Miras-Wilson, Rachel rwilson@winston.com Mitchell, Stanley stanley.mitchell@exeloncorp.com
Moen, Stephan stephan.moen@ge.com Moran, Mike nucmike2002@yahoo.com Morgan, Michael Michael.Morgan5@ge.com Murawski, John murawski@newsobserver.com Nesrsta, James jjnesrsta@cpsenergy.com Oesterle, Eric eroeste1@Bechtel.com O'Neill, John john.o'neill@pillsburylaw.com Orthen, Richard richard.orthen@nexteraenergy.com Paglia, Al apaglia@scana.com Pate, Russell rwpate@southernco.com Peterson, Scott media@nei.org Pitts, Al al.pitts@unistarnuclear.com Pitts, Harold harold_pitts@mnes-us.com Pleins, Ed pleinsel@westinghouse.com Polich, Timothy timothy.polich@cbi.com Popa, Markus Markus.Popa@Hq.Doe.Gov Quinn, Vanessa vanessa.quinn@dhs.gov Ray, Thom raytj@westinghouse.com Repka, David drepka@winston.com Rezk, Tamer tamer.rezk@cbi.com Riccio, James jim.riccio@wdc.greenpeace.org Rolfson, Greg Greg_Rolfson@mnes-us.com Romashko, Darryl dcromashko@tva.gov Rosenfeld, Elliot elliot.rosenfeld@dep.state.nj.us Rubin, Michael rubinmp@westinghouse.com Scarola, Ken kenscarola@nuclearautomation.com Schlaseman, Caroline cschlaseman@mpr.com Schumitsch, Walter Walter.schumitsch@ge.com Smith, Tyson trsmith@winston.com Stallings, John john.stallings@ge.com Stan, Thomason, sthomasu@southernco.com Stevenson, Rick richard.stevenson@cbi.com Sutton, Kathryn ksutton@morganlewis.com Swanson, Ronald reswanso@bechtel.com Taylor, Larry larry.taylor@pgnmail.com Taylor, Marlene marlene.taylor@exeloncorp.com Temple, Robert nuclaw@mindspring.com Thomason, Stan sthomason@southernco.com Thompson, Ryder Ryder.Thompson@scana.com Torres, Alan atorres@scana.com Traiforos, Spyros satconsult@msn.com Travieso-Diaz, Matias matias.travieso-diaz@pillsburylaw.com Van Wyk, Jake jacob.vanwyk@scana.com
Vaughn, Lisa lfvaughn@duke-energy.com Waites, Brandon bwwaites@southernco.com Waltman, C. cwaltman@roe.com Warren, Jim jim@ncwarn.org Webb, Maria maria.webb@pillsburylaw.com Wessel, Ronald wesselrp@westinghouse.com Wink, Roger rwink@ameren.com Woodlan, Donald donald.woodlan@luminant.com Zinke, George gzinke@entergy.com Zorn, Jason zornjc@westinghouse.com arp@nei.org bpgarde@aol.com dashurberg@hpacorp.com dwoodla1@txu.com ecg@nei.org hundrupa@gao.gov jfulto1@entergy.com jrfergus@duke-energy.com llbauman@aol.com lynchje@inpo.org pmblanch@comcast.net sbhaber@hpacorp.com