ML15293A032: Difference between revisions

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
(Created page by program invented by StriderTol)
(Created page by program invented by StriderTol)
 
Line 19: Line 19:
{{#Wiki_filter:E-mail from Lisa S. Kwong to Paul M. Bessette September 17, 2015, 4:39 PM ATTACHMENT 13 to NYS DECLARATION
{{#Wiki_filter:E-mail from Lisa S. Kwong to Paul M. Bessette September 17, 2015, 4:39 PM ATTACHMENT 13 to NYS DECLARATION


1 Mihir Desai From: Lisa S. Kwong Sent: Thursday, September 17, 2015 4:39 PM To: pbessette@morganlewis.com Cc:Sutton, Kathryn M. (ksutton@morganlewis.com); Kuyler, Raphael Philip (rkuyler@morganlewis.com); sherwin.turk@nrc.g ov; Harris, Brian (Brian.Harris@nrc.gov);
Mihir Desai From:                             Lisa S. Kwong Sent:                             Thursday, September 17, 2015 4:39 PM To:                               pbessette@morganlewis.com Cc:                               Sutton, Kathryn M. (ksutton@morganlewis.com); Kuyler, Raphael Philip (rkuyler@morganlewis.com); sherwin.turk@nrc.gov; Harris, Brian (Brian.Harris@nrc.gov);
Deborah Brancato (DBrancato@riverkeeper.org);
Deborah Brancato (DBrancato@riverkeeper.org); Lisa M. Burianek; John J. Sipos; Mihir Desai; Brian Lusignan; Teresa Manzi
Lisa M. Burianek; John J. Sipos; Mihir Desai; Brian Lusignan; Teresa Manzi


==Subject:==
==Subject:==
IP -- Notice of objection to proprietary/confidentiality designation Attachments:
IP -- Notice of objection to proprietary/confidentiality designation Attachments:                       2015 09 17 NYS Notice of Objection to Proprietary Designation FINAL.pdf Good afternoon, Paul.
2015 09 17 NYS Notice of Objection to Proprietary Designation FINAL.pdfGoodafternoon,Paul.
Attached please find the State of New Yorks Objection to Confidential/Proprietary Designations for Certain Documents Relating to Contentions NYS25, NYS26B/RKTC1B and NYS38/RKTC5. Feel free to call me at your earliest convenience to discuss. I look forward to speaking with you.
AttachedpleasefindtheStateofNewYork'sObjectiontoConfidential/ProprietaryDesignationsforCertainDocumentsRelatingtoContentionsNYS 25,NYS26B/RK TC 1BandNYS38/RK TC 5.Feelfreetocallmeatyourearliestconveniencetodiscuss.Ilookforwardtospeakingwithyou.Thanks, LisaLisaS.KwongAssistantAttorneyGeneralEnvironmentalProtectionBureauNewYorkStateOfficeoftheAttorneyGeneralTheCapitolAlbany,NY12224Tel:518 776 2422Fax:518 650 9363Lisa.Kwong@ny.ag.gov UNITED STATES NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING BOARD
: Thanks, Lisa Lisa S. Kwong Assistant Attorney General Environmental Protection Bureau New York State Office of the Attorney General The Capitol Albany, NY 12224 Tel: 5187762422 Fax: 5186509363 Lisa.Kwong@ny.ag.gov 1
  -----------------------------------------------------------
x In re:        Docket Nos. 50
-247-LR; 50-286-LR  License Renewal Application Submitted by ASLBP No. 07
-858-03-LR-BD01 Entergy Nuclear Indian Point 2, LLC,  DPR-26, DPR-64 Entergy Nuclear Indian Point 3, LLC, and Entergy Nuclear Operations, Inc.
September 17 , 201 5 -----------------------------------------------------------
x  STATE OF NEW YORK'S  OBJECTION TO PROPRIETARY AND/OR CONFIDENTIAL DESIGNATION S FOR CERTAIN DOCUMENTS RELATING TO CONTENTIONS NYS
-25, NYS-26 B/RK-TC-1 B AND NYS-38/RKTC-5  In accordance with the Atomic Safety and Licensing Board's September 4, 2009 Protective Order, the State of New York objects to Entergy's designatio n of the documents listed below as containing proprietary information subject to non
-disclosure
. The documents include: Entergy's Statements of Position and Pre
-filed Testimony relating to Contentions NYS
-25, NYS-26 B/RK-TC-1 B and NYS-38/RK-TC-5, and various documents prepared by Entergy's vendor, Westinghouse. Based on the State's review, the documents appear to primari ly contain information that is not exempt from public inspection pursuant to 10 C.F.R.  
§ 2.390. Entergy's request to entirely withhold the information contained in these documents as privileged or confidential trade secrets and/or commercial or financial information is, therefore , overly broad. To facilitate further consultation and resolution of this dispute, the State requests that Entergy (or its vendor, Westinghouse) indicate, with specificity, (1) the portion(s) of the document s it deems proprietary and confidential by page and line or column number; (2) the basis for such claim (s); and (3) the harm that would result fro m public disclosure.
The documents that are the subject of the State's Objection are the following:
EXHIBIT NUMBER DESCRIPTION, DATE, PAGES EXTENT OF CONFIDENTIALITY DESIGNATION STATE OF NEW YORK OBJECTION STATE OF NEW YORK PROPOSED RESOLUTION ENT000615 Entergy's Statement of Position Regarding Contention NYS
-25 (Embrittlement), August 10, 2015 , 63 pages. Entire document withheld from public disclosure
. Proprietary designation is overly broad and seeks to exempt from disclosure information unrelated to trade secrets or confidential commercial or financial information.
Document should be disclosed for public inspection subject to limited redaction of information that reveals vendor's secret methodologies or techniques or confidential trade organization analysis, if any
. ENT000616 Testimony of Entergy Witnesses Nelson F. Azevedo, Robert J.
Dolansky, Alan B. Cox, Jack R. Strosnider, Timothy J. Griesbach, Randy G. Lott, and Mark A. Gray Regarding Contention NYS
-25 (Embrittlement), August 10, 2015, 158 pages. Entire document withheld from public disclosure
. Proprietary designation is overly broad and seeks to exempt from disclosure information unrelated to trade secrets or confidential commercial/financial information.
Document should be disclosed for public inspection subject to limited redaction of information that reveals vendor's secret methodolog i es or techniques, if any. ENT000678 Entergy's Statement of Position Regarding Contention NYS
-26B/RK-TC-1B (Metal Fatigue), August 10, 2015, 70 pages. Entire document withheld from public disclosure
. Proprietary designation is overly broad and seeks to exempt from disclosure information unrelated to trade secrets or confidential commercial/financial information.
Document should be disclosed for public inspection subject to limited redaction of information that reveals vendor's secret methodologies or techniques, if any. ENT000679 Revised Testimony of Entergy Witnesses Nelson F. Azevedo, Alan B. Cox, Jack R. Strosnider, Randy G. Lott, Mark A. Gray, and Barry M. Gordon Regarding Contention NYS
-26B/RK-TC-1B (Metal Fatigue), August 10, 2015, 172 pages. Entire document withheld from public disclosure
. Proprietary designation is overly broad and seeks to exempt from disclosure information unrelated to trade secrets or confidential commercial/financial information.
Document should be disclosed for public inspection subject to limited redaction of information that reveals vendor's secret methodologies or techniques, if any. ENT000698 Entergy's Revised Statement of Position Regarding Contention


NYS-38/RK-TC-5 (Safety Commitments), August 10, 2015, 73 pages
UNITED STATES NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING BOARD
. Entire document withheld from public disclosure
-----------------------------------------------------------x In re:                                                          Docket Nos. 50-247-LR; 50-286-LR License Renewal Application Submitted by                        ASLBP No. 07-858-03-LR-BD01 Entergy Nuclear Indian Point 2, LLC,                           DPR-26, DPR-64 Entergy Nuclear Indian Point 3, LLC, and Entergy Nuclear Operations, Inc.                               September 17, 2015
. Proprietary designation is overly broad and seeks to exempt from disclosure information unrelated to trade secrets or confidential commercial/financial information.
-----------------------------------------------------------x STATE OF NEW YORKS OBJECTION TO PROPRIETARY AND/OR CONFIDENTIAL DESIGNATIONS FOR CERTAIN DOCUMENTS RELATING TO CONTENTIONS NYS-25, NYS-26B/RK-TC-1B AND NYS-38/RKTC-5 In accordance with the Atomic Safety and Licensing Boards September 4, 2009 Protective Order, the State of New York objects to Entergys designation of the documents listed below as containing proprietary information subject to non-disclosure. The documents include:
Document should be disclosed for public inspection subject to limited redaction of information specifically related to trade secrets or confidential commercial/ financial information, if any. ENT000699 Revised Testimony of Entergy Witnesses Nelson F. Azevedo, Robert J. Dolansky, Alan B. Cox, Jack R. Strosnider, Timothy J. Griesbach, Barry M.
Entergys Statements of Position and Pre-filed Testimony relating to Contentions NYS-25, NYS-26B/RK-TC-1B and NYS-38/RK-TC-5, and various documents prepared by Entergys vendor, Westinghouse.
Gordon, Randy G. Lott, and Mark A. Gray Regarding Contention NYS
Based on the States review, the documents appear to primarily contain information that is not exempt from public inspection pursuant to 10 C.F.R. § 2.390. Entergys request to entirely withhold the information contained in these documents as privileged or confidential trade secrets and/or commercial or financial information is, therefore, overly broad.
-38/RK-TC-5 (Safety Commitments), August 10, 2015, 146 pages.
To facilitate further consultation and resolution of this dispute, the State requests that Entergy (or its vendor, Westinghouse) indicate, with specificity, (1) the portion(s) of the documents it deems proprietary and confidential by page and line or column number; (2) the basis for such claim(s); and (3) the harm that would result from public disclosure.
Entire document withheld from public disclosure
. Proprietary designation is overly broad and seeks to exempt from disclosure information unrelated to trade secrets or confidential commercial/financial information.
Document should be disclosed for public inspection subject to limited redaction of information specifically related to trade secrets or confidential commercial/ financial information, if any. 2 EXHIBIT NUMBER DESCRIPTION, DATE, PAGES EXTENT OF CONFIDENTIALITY DESIGNATION STATE OF NEW YORK OBJECTION STATE OF NEW YORK PROPOSED RESOLUTION ENT000681 Westinghouse, WCAP
-17199-P, Rev. 1, Environmental Fatigue Evaluation for Indian Point Unit 2, Dec. 2014 , 95pages. Entire document withheld from public disclosure
. Proprietary designation is overly broad and seeks to exempt from disclosure information unrelated to trade secrets or confidential commercial/financial information.
Document should be disclosed for public inspection subject to limited redaction of information specifically related to trade secrets or confidential commercial/ financial information, if any. ENT000682 Westinghouse, WCAP
-17200-P, Rev. 1, Environmental Fatigue Evaluation for Indian Point Unit 3, Dec. 2014, 89pages. Entire document withheld from public disclosure
. Proprietary designation is overly broad and seeks to exempt from disclosure information unrelated to trade secrets or confidential commercial/financial information.
Document should be disclosed for public inspection subject to limited redaction of information specifically related to trade secrets or confidential commercial/ financial information, if any. ENT000683 Westinghouse, Calculation Note CN-PAFM-13-32, Rev. 3 "Indian Point Unit 2 (IP2) and Unit 3 (IP3) Refined EAF Analyses and EAF Screening Evaluations," June 25, 2015, 104 pages. Entire document withheld from public disclosure
. Proprietary designation is overly broad and seeks to exempt from disclosure information unrelated to trade se crets or confidential commercial/financial information.
Document should be disclosed for public inspection subject to limited redaction of information specifically related to trade secrets or confidential commercial/ financial information, if any. ENT000688 Westinghouse, Calculation Note CN-PAFM-13-40, Rev. 1, "Indian Point Unit 2 and Unit 3 Pressurizer Spray Nozzle Transfer Function Database Development and Environmental Fatigue Evaluations," Jan. 15, 2015, 138 pages. Entire document withheld from public disclosure
. Proprietary designation is overly broad and seeks to exempt from disclosure information unrelated to trade secrets or confidential commercial/financial information.
Document should be disclosed for public inspection subject to limited redaction of information specifically related to trade secrets or confidential commercial/ financial information, if any. ENT000689 Westinghouse, WCAP
-12191, Rev. 4, Transient and Fatigue Cycle Monitoring Program Transient History Evaluation Report for Indian Point Unit 2, Dec. 2014 , 52 pages. Entire document withheld from public disclosure
. Proprietary designation is overly broad and seeks to exempt from disclosure information unrelated to trade secrets or confidential commercial/financial information.
Document should be disclosed for public inspection subject to limited redaction of information specifically related to trade secrets or confidential commercial/ financial information, if any. ENT000690 Westinghouse, WCAP
-16898-P, Rev.1, Indian Point Unit 3 Transient and Fatigue Cycle Monitoring Program Transient History Evaluation , May 2015 , 72 pages. Entire document withheld from public disclosure
. Proprietary designation is overly broad and seeks to exempt from disclosure information unrelated to trade secrets or confidential commercial/financial information.
Document should be disclosed for public inspection subject to limited redaction of information specifically related to trade secrets or confidential commercial/ financial information, if any.    


3 EXHIBIT NUMBER DESCRIPTION, DATE, PAGES EXTENT OF CONFIDENTIALITY DESIGNATION STATE OF NEW YORK OBJECTION STATE OF NEW YORK PROPOSED RESOLUTION NYS000363 Westinghouse, WCAP
The documents that are the subject of the States Objection are the following:
-17149-P, Rev. 1, Evaluation of Pressurizer Insurge/Outsurge Transients for Indian Point Unit 2 and Westinghouse, WCAP-17162-P, Rev. 1, Evaluation of Pressurizer Insurge/Outsurge Transients for Indian Point Unit 3, July 2010 , 111 pages. Entire document withheld from public disclosure
EXHIBIT           DESCRIPTION,                   EXTENT OF           STATE OF NEW YORK               STATE OF NEW YORK NUMBER            DATE, PAGES              CONFIDENTIALITY                OBJECTION                        PROPOSED DESIGNATION                                                RESOLUTION ENT000615  Entergys Statement of Position  Entire document     Proprietary designation is overly   Document should be Regarding Contention NYS-25      withheld from public broad and seeks to exempt from     disclosed for public (Embrittlement), August 10,      disclosure.          disclosure information unrelated to inspection subject to limited 2015, 63 pages.                                      trade secrets or confidential       redaction of information that commercial or financial             reveals vendors secret information.                        methodologies or techniques or confidential trade organization analysis, if any.
. Proprietary designation is overly broad and seeks to exempt from disclosure information unrelated to trade secrets or confidential commercial/financial information.
ENT000616  Testimony of Entergy Witnesses  Entire document      Proprietary designation is overly  Document should be Nelson F. Azevedo, Robert J. withheld from public broad and seeks to exempt from      disclosed for public Dolansky, Alan B. Cox, Jack R. disclosure.          disclosure information unrelated to inspection subject to limited Strosnider, Timothy J.                                trade secrets or confidential       redaction of information that Griesbach, Randy G. Lott, and                        commercial/financial information. reveals vendors secret Mark A. Gray Regarding                                                                    methodologies or Contention NYS-25                                                                        techniques, if any.
Document should be disclosed for public inspection subject to limited redaction of information specifically related to trade secrets or confidential commercial/ financial information, if any. NYS000364 Westinghouse (W)  
(Embrittlement), August 10, 2015, 158 pages.
- Calculation Note, CN
ENT000678  Entergys Statement of Position  Entire document     Proprietary designation is overly   Document should be Regarding Contention NYS-        withheld from public broad and seeks to exempt from     disclosed for public 26B/RK-TC-1B (Metal Fatigue),    disclosure.          disclosure information unrelated to inspection subject to limited August 10, 2015, 70 pages.                            trade secrets or confidential       redaction of information that commercial/financial information. reveals vendors secret methodologies or techniques, if any.
-PAFM-09-21, Indian Point Units 2 & 3 Charging Nozzles Environmental Fatigue Evaluation, Jun. 18, 2010 , 85 pages. Entire document withheld from public disclosure
ENT000679  Revised Testimony of Entergy    Entire document     Proprietary designation is overly   Document should be Witnesses Nelson F. Azevedo,    withheld from public broad and seeks to exempt from     disclosed for public Alan B. Cox, Jack R. Strosnider, disclosure.          disclosure information unrelated to inspection subject to limited Randy G. Lott, Mark A. Gray,                          trade secrets or confidential       redaction of information that and Barry M. Gordon Regarding                        commercial/financial information. reveals vendors secret Contention NYS-26B/RK-TC-                                                                 methodologies or 1B (Metal Fatigue), August 10,                                                           techniques, if any.
. Proprietary designation is overly broad and seeks to exempt from disclosure information unrelated to trade secrets or confidential commercial/financial information.
2015, 172 pages.
Document should be disclosed for public inspection subject to limited redaction of information specifically related to trade secrets or confidential commercial/ financial information, if any. NYS000365 Westinghouse (W)
ENT000698  Entergys Revised Statement of  Entire document     Proprietary designation is overly  Document should be Position Regarding Contention    withheld from public broad and seeks to exempt from     disclosed for public NYS-38/RK-TC-5 (Safety          disclosure.          disclosure information unrelated to inspection subject to limited Commitments), August 10,                              trade secrets or confidential       redaction of information 2015, 73 pages.                                      commercial/financial information. specifically related to trade secrets or confidential commercial/ financial information, if any.
- Calculation Note, CN
ENT000699  Revised Testimony of Entergy    Entire document     Proprietary designation is overly   Document should be Witnesses Nelson F. Azevedo,    withheld from public broad and seeks to exempt from     disclosed for public Robert J. Dolansky, Alan B.      disclosure.          disclosure information unrelated to inspection subject to limited Cox, Jack R. Strosnider,                              trade secrets or confidential       redaction of information Timothy J. Griesbach, Barry M.                        commercial/financial information. specifically related to trade Gordon, Randy G. Lott, and                                                                secrets or confidential Mark A. Gray Regarding                                                                    commercial/ financial Contention NYS-38/RK-TC-5                                                                information, if any.
-PAFM-09-67, IPECPROP00057917, Pressurizer Surge Nozzle and Lower Head Transfer Functions for Indian Point Units 2 and 3, Jun. 18, 2010 , 86pages. Entire document withheld from public disclosure
(Safety Commitments), August 10, 2015, 146 pages.
. Proprietary designation is overly broad and seeks to exempt from disclosure information unrelated to trade secrets or confidential commercial/financial information.
2
Document should be disclosed for public inspection subject to limited redaction of information specifically related to trade secrets or confidential commercial/ financial information, if any. NYS00036 6 Westinghouse (W)
- Calculation Note. CN
-PAFM-09-77, IPECPROP00057881/3, Indian Point Units 2 & 3 Accumulator Nozzle Environmental Fatigue Evaluation, Jun. 18, 2010 , 94 pages. Entire document withheld from public disclosure
. Proprietary designation is overl y broad and seeks to exempt from disclosure information unrelated to trade secrets or confidential commercial/financial information.
Document should be disclosed for public inspection subject to limited redaction of information specifically related to trad e secrets or confidential commercial/ financial information, if any. NYS000367 Westinghouse (W)
- Calculation Note, CN
-PAFM-09-79, IPECPROP00057559, Indian Point Unit 2 Boron Injection Tank Nozzle Environmental Fatigue Evaluations, Jun. 18, 2010 , 76pages. Entire document withheld from public disclosure
. Proprietary designation is overly broad and seeks to exempt from disclosure information unrelated to trade secrets or confidential commercial/financial information.
Document should be disclosed for public inspection subject to limited redaction of information specifically related to trade secrets or confidential commercial/ financial information, if any. Executed on September 17 , 2015 Signed (electronically) by Lisa S. Kwong Assistant Attorney General Office of the Attorney General of the State of New York


The Capitol Albany, New York 12224
EXHIBIT          DESCRIPTION,                  EXTENT OF          STATE OF NEW YORK                STATE OF NEW YORK NUMBER            DATE, PAGES              CONFIDENTIALITY                OBJECTION                        PROPOSED DESIGNATION                                                RESOLUTION ENT000681 Westinghouse, WCAP-17199-P,      Entire document      Proprietary designation is overly  Document should be Rev. 1, Environmental Fatigue    withheld from public broad and seeks to exempt from      disclosed for public Evaluation for Indian Point Unit disclosure.          disclosure information unrelated to inspection subject to limited 2, Dec. 2014, 95pages.                                trade secrets or confidential      redaction of information commercial/financial information. specifically related to trade secrets or confidential commercial/ financial information, if any.
ENT000682 Westinghouse, WCAP-17200-P,      Entire document      Proprietary designation is overly  Document should be Rev. 1, Environmental Fatigue    withheld from public broad and seeks to exempt from      disclosed for public Evaluation for Indian Point Unit disclosure.          disclosure information unrelated to inspection subject to limited 3, Dec. 2014, 89pages.                                trade secrets or confidential      redaction of information commercial/financial information. specifically related to trade secrets or confidential commercial/ financial information, if any.
ENT000683 Westinghouse, Calculation Note  Entire document      Proprietary designation is overly  Document should be CN-PAFM-13-32, Rev. 3            withheld from public broad and seeks to exempt from      disclosed for public Indian Point Unit 2 (IP2) and  disclosure.          disclosure information unrelated to inspection subject to limited Unit 3 (IP3) Refined EAF                              trade secrets or confidential      redaction of information Analyses and EAF Screening                            commercial/financial information. specifically related to trade Evaluations, June 25, 2015, 104                                                          secrets or confidential pages.                                                                                    commercial/ financial information, if any.
ENT000688 Westinghouse, Calculation Note  Entire document      Proprietary designation is overly  Document should be CN-PAFM-13-40, Rev. 1,          withheld from public broad and seeks to exempt from      disclosed for public Indian Point Unit 2 and Unit 3  disclosure.          disclosure information unrelated to inspection subject to limited Pressurizer Spray Nozzle                              trade secrets or confidential      redaction of information Transfer Function Database                            commercial/financial information. specifically related to trade Development and Environmental                                                            secrets or confidential Fatigue Evaluations, Jan. 15,                                                            commercial/ financial 2015, 138 pages.                                                                          information, if any.
ENT000689 Westinghouse, WCAP-12191,        Entire document      Proprietary designation is overly  Document should be Rev. 4, Transient and Fatigue    withheld from public broad and seeks to exempt from      disclosed for public Cycle Monitoring Program        disclosure.          disclosure information unrelated to inspection subject to limited Transient History Evaluation                          trade secrets or confidential      redaction of information Report for Indian Point Unit 2,                      commercial/financial information. specifically related to trade Dec. 2014, 52 pages.                                                                      secrets or confidential commercial/ financial information, if any.
ENT000690 Westinghouse, WCAP-16898-P,      Entire document      Proprietary designation is overly  Document should be Rev.1, Indian Point Unit 3      withheld from public broad and seeks to exempt from      disclosed for public Transient and Fatigue Cycle      disclosure.          disclosure information unrelated to inspection subject to limited Monitoring Program Transient                          trade secrets or confidential      redaction of information History Evaluation , May 2015,                        commercial/financial information. specifically related to trade 72 pages.                                                                                secrets or confidential commercial/ financial information, if any.
3
 
EXHIBIT      DESCRIPTION, DATE,                EXTENT OF              STATE OF NEW YORK                STATE OF NEW YORK NUMBER              PAGES                CONFIDENTIALITY                  OBJECTION                        PROPOSED DESIGNATION                                                    RESOLUTION NYS000363 Westinghouse, WCAP-17149-      Entire document        Proprietary designation is overly  Document should be P, Rev. 1, Evaluation of        withheld from public    broad and seeks to exempt from      disclosed for public Pressurizer Insurge/Outsurge    disclosure.            disclosure information unrelated to inspection subject to limited Transients for Indian Point                            trade secrets or confidential      redaction of information Unit 2 and Westinghouse,                                commercial/financial information. specifically related to trade WCAP-17162-P, Rev. 1,                                                                      secrets or confidential Evaluation of Pressurizer                                                                  commercial/ financial Insurge/Outsurge Transients                                                                information, if any.
for Indian Point Unit 3, July 2010, 111 pages.
NYS000364 Westinghouse (W) -              Entire document        Proprietary designation is overly  Document should be Calculation Note, CN-PAFM-      withheld from public    broad and seeks to exempt from      disclosed for public 09-21, Indian Point Units 2 & 3 disclosure.            disclosure information unrelated to inspection subject to limited Charging Nozzles                                        trade secrets or confidential      redaction of information Environmental Fatigue                                  commercial/financial information. specifically related to trade Evaluation, Jun. 18, 2010, 85                                                              secrets or confidential pages.                                                                                      commercial/ financial information, if any.
NYS000365 Westinghouse (W) -              Entire document        Proprietary designation is overly  Document should be Calculation Note, CN-PAFM-      withheld from public    broad and seeks to exempt from      disclosed for public 09-67, IPECPROP00057917,        disclosure.            disclosure information unrelated to inspection subject to limited Pressurizer Surge Nozzle and                            trade secrets or confidential      redaction of information Lower Head Transfer                                    commercial/financial information. specifically related to trade Functions for Indian Point                                                                  secrets or confidential Units 2 and 3, Jun. 18, 2010,                                                              commercial/ financial 86pages.                                                                                    information, if any.
NYS000366 Westinghouse (W) -              Entire document        Proprietary designation is overly  Document should be Calculation Note. CN-PAFM-      withheld from public    broad and seeks to exempt from      disclosed for public 09-77, IPECPROP00057881/3,      disclosure.            disclosure information unrelated to inspection subject to limited Indian Point Units 2 & 3                                trade secrets or confidential      redaction of information Accumulator Nozzle                                      commercial/financial information. specifically related to trade Environmental Fatigue                                                                      secrets or confidential Evaluation, Jun. 18, 2010, 94                                                              commercial/ financial pages.                                                                                      information, if any.
NYS000367 Westinghouse (W) -              Entire document        Proprietary designation is overly  Document should be Calculation Note, CN-PAFM-      withheld from public    broad and seeks to exempt from      disclosed for public 09-79, IPECPROP00057559,        disclosure.            disclosure information unrelated to inspection subject to limited Indian Point Unit 2 Boron                              trade secrets or confidential      redaction of information Injection Tank Nozzle                                  commercial/financial information. specifically related to trade Environmental Fatigue                                                                      secrets or confidential Evaluations, Jun. 18, 2010,                                                                commercial/ financial 76pages.                                                                                    information, if any.
Executed on September 17, 2015 Signed (electronically) by Lisa S. Kwong Assistant Attorney General Office of the Attorney General of the State of New York The Capitol Albany, New York 12224 (518) 776-2422 Lisa.Kwong@ag.ny.gov 4


(518) 776-2422 Lisa.Kwong@ag.ny.gov 4
E-mail from Lisa S. Kwong to Paul M. Bessette September 17, 2015, 4:39 PM ATTACHMENT 13 to NYS DECLARATION
E-mail from Lisa S. Kwong to Paul M. Bessette September 17, 2015, 4:39 PM ATTACHMENT 13 to NYS DECLARATION


1 Mihir Desai From: Lisa S. Kwong Sent: Thursday, September 17, 2015 4:39 PM To: pbessette@morganlewis.com Cc:Sutton, Kathryn M. (ksutton@morganlewis.com); Kuyler, Raphael Philip (rkuyler@morganlewis.com); sherwin.turk@nrc.g ov; Harris, Brian (Brian.Harris@nrc.gov);
Mihir Desai From:                             Lisa S. Kwong Sent:                             Thursday, September 17, 2015 4:39 PM To:                               pbessette@morganlewis.com Cc:                               Sutton, Kathryn M. (ksutton@morganlewis.com); Kuyler, Raphael Philip (rkuyler@morganlewis.com); sherwin.turk@nrc.gov; Harris, Brian (Brian.Harris@nrc.gov);
Deborah Brancato (DBrancato@riverkeeper.org);
Deborah Brancato (DBrancato@riverkeeper.org); Lisa M. Burianek; John J. Sipos; Mihir Desai; Brian Lusignan; Teresa Manzi
Lisa M. Burianek; John J. Sipos; Mihir Desai; Brian Lusignan; Teresa Manzi


==Subject:==
==Subject:==
IP -- Notice of objection to proprietary/confidentiality designation Attachments:
IP -- Notice of objection to proprietary/confidentiality designation Attachments:                       2015 09 17 NYS Notice of Objection to Proprietary Designation FINAL.pdf Good afternoon, Paul.
2015 09 17 NYS Notice of Objection to Proprietary Designation FINAL.pdfGoodafternoon,Paul.
Attached please find the State of New Yorks Objection to Confidential/Proprietary Designations for Certain Documents Relating to Contentions NYS25, NYS26B/RKTC1B and NYS38/RKTC5. Feel free to call me at your earliest convenience to discuss. I look forward to speaking with you.
AttachedpleasefindtheStateofNewYork'sObjectiontoConfidential/ProprietaryDesignationsforCertainDocumentsRelatingtoContentionsNYS 25,NYS26B/RK TC 1BandNYS38/RK TC 5.Feelfreetocallmeatyourearliestconveniencetodiscuss.Ilookforwardtospeakingwithyou.Thanks, LisaLisaS.KwongAssistantAttorneyGeneralEnvironmentalProtectionBureauNewYorkStateOfficeoftheAttorneyGeneralTheCapitolAlbany,NY12224Tel:518 776 2422Fax:518 650 9363Lisa.Kwong@ny.ag.gov UNITED STATES NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING BOARD
: Thanks, Lisa Lisa S. Kwong Assistant Attorney General Environmental Protection Bureau New York State Office of the Attorney General The Capitol Albany, NY 12224 Tel: 5187762422 Fax: 5186509363 Lisa.Kwong@ny.ag.gov 1
  -----------------------------------------------------------
x In re:        Docket Nos. 50
-247-LR; 50-286-LR  License Renewal Application Submitted by ASLBP No. 07
-858-03-LR-BD01 Entergy Nuclear Indian Point 2, LLC,  DPR-26, DPR-64 Entergy Nuclear Indian Point 3, LLC, and Entergy Nuclear Operations, Inc.
September 17 , 201 5 -----------------------------------------------------------
x  STATE OF NEW YORK'S  OBJECTION TO PROPRIETARY AND/OR CONFIDENTIAL DESIGNATION S FOR CERTAIN DOCUMENTS RELATING TO CONTENTIONS NYS
-25, NYS-26 B/RK-TC-1 B AND NYS-38/RKTC-5  In accordance with the Atomic Safety and Licensing Board's September 4, 2009 Protective Order, the State of New York objects to Entergy's designatio n of the documents listed below as containing proprietary information subject to non
-disclosure
. The documents include: Entergy's Statements of Position and Pre
-filed Testimony relating to Contentions NYS
-25, NYS-26 B/RK-TC-1 B and NYS-38/RK-TC-5, and various documents prepared by Entergy's vendor, Westinghouse. Based on the State's review, the documents appear to primari ly contain information that is not exempt from public inspection pursuant to 10 C.F.R.  
§ 2.390. Entergy's request to entirely withhold the information contained in these documents as privileged or confidential trade secrets and/or commercial or financial information is, therefore , overly broad. To facilitate further consultation and resolution of this dispute, the State requests that Entergy (or its vendor, Westinghouse) indicate, with specificity, (1) the portion(s) of the document s it deems proprietary and confidential by page and line or column number; (2) the basis for such claim (s); and (3) the harm that would result fro m public disclosure.
The documents that are the subject of the State's Objection are the following:
EXHIBIT NUMBER DESCRIPTION, DATE, PAGES EXTENT OF CONFIDENTIALITY DESIGNATION STATE OF NEW YORK OBJECTION STATE OF NEW YORK PROPOSED RESOLUTION ENT000615 Entergy's Statement of Position Regarding Contention NYS
-25 (Embrittlement), August 10, 2015 , 63 pages. Entire document withheld from public disclosure
. Proprietary designation is overly broad and seeks to exempt from disclosure information unrelated to trade secrets or confidential commercial or financial information.
Document should be disclosed for public inspection subject to limited redaction of information that reveals vendor's secret methodologies or techniques or confidential trade organization analysis, if any
. ENT000616 Testimony of Entergy Witnesses Nelson F. Azevedo, Robert J.
Dolansky, Alan B. Cox, Jack R. Strosnider, Timothy J. Griesbach, Randy G. Lott, and Mark A. Gray Regarding Contention NYS
-25 (Embrittlement), August 10, 2015, 158 pages. Entire document withheld from public disclosure
. Proprietary designation is overly broad and seeks to exempt from disclosure information unrelated to trade secrets or confidential commercial/financial information.
Document should be disclosed for public inspection subject to limited redaction of information that reveals vendor's secret methodolog i es or techniques, if any. ENT000678 Entergy's Statement of Position Regarding Contention NYS
-26B/RK-TC-1B (Metal Fatigue), August 10, 2015, 70 pages. Entire document withheld from public disclosure
. Proprietary designation is overly broad and seeks to exempt from disclosure information unrelated to trade secrets or confidential commercial/financial information.
Document should be disclosed for public inspection subject to limited redaction of information that reveals vendor's secret methodologies or techniques, if any. ENT000679 Revised Testimony of Entergy Witnesses Nelson F. Azevedo, Alan B. Cox, Jack R. Strosnider, Randy G. Lott, Mark A. Gray, and Barry M. Gordon Regarding Contention NYS
-26B/RK-TC-1B (Metal Fatigue), August 10, 2015, 172 pages. Entire document withheld from public disclosure
. Proprietary designation is overly broad and seeks to exempt from disclosure information unrelated to trade secrets or confidential commercial/financial information.
Document should be disclosed for public inspection subject to limited redaction of information that reveals vendor's secret methodologies or techniques, if any. ENT000698 Entergy's Revised Statement of Position Regarding Contention


NYS-38/RK-TC-5 (Safety Commitments), August 10, 2015, 73 pages
UNITED STATES NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING BOARD
. Entire document withheld from public disclosure
-----------------------------------------------------------x In re:                                                          Docket Nos. 50-247-LR; 50-286-LR License Renewal Application Submitted by                        ASLBP No. 07-858-03-LR-BD01 Entergy Nuclear Indian Point 2, LLC,                           DPR-26, DPR-64 Entergy Nuclear Indian Point 3, LLC, and Entergy Nuclear Operations, Inc.                               September 17, 2015
. Proprietary designation is overly broad and seeks to exempt from disclosure information unrelated to trade secrets or confidential commercial/financial information.
-----------------------------------------------------------x STATE OF NEW YORKS OBJECTION TO PROPRIETARY AND/OR CONFIDENTIAL DESIGNATIONS FOR CERTAIN DOCUMENTS RELATING TO CONTENTIONS NYS-25, NYS-26B/RK-TC-1B AND NYS-38/RKTC-5 In accordance with the Atomic Safety and Licensing Boards September 4, 2009 Protective Order, the State of New York objects to Entergys designation of the documents listed below as containing proprietary information subject to non-disclosure. The documents include:
Document should be disclosed for public inspection subject to limited redaction of information specifically related to trade secrets or confidential commercial/ financial information, if any. ENT000699 Revised Testimony of Entergy Witnesses Nelson F. Azevedo, Robert J. Dolansky, Alan B. Cox, Jack R. Strosnider, Timothy J. Griesbach, Barry M.
Entergys Statements of Position and Pre-filed Testimony relating to Contentions NYS-25, NYS-26B/RK-TC-1B and NYS-38/RK-TC-5, and various documents prepared by Entergys vendor, Westinghouse.
Gordon, Randy G. Lott, and Mark A. Gray Regarding Contention NYS
Based on the States review, the documents appear to primarily contain information that is not exempt from public inspection pursuant to 10 C.F.R. § 2.390. Entergys request to entirely withhold the information contained in these documents as privileged or confidential trade secrets and/or commercial or financial information is, therefore, overly broad.
-38/RK-TC-5 (Safety Commitments), August 10, 2015, 146 pages.
To facilitate further consultation and resolution of this dispute, the State requests that Entergy (or its vendor, Westinghouse) indicate, with specificity, (1) the portion(s) of the documents it deems proprietary and confidential by page and line or column number; (2) the basis for such claim(s); and (3) the harm that would result from public disclosure.
Entire document withheld from public disclosure
. Proprietary designation is overly broad and seeks to exempt from disclosure information unrelated to trade secrets or confidential commercial/financial information.
Document should be disclosed for public inspection subject to limited redaction of information specifically related to trade secrets or confidential commercial/ financial information, if any. 2 EXHIBIT NUMBER DESCRIPTION, DATE, PAGES EXTENT OF CONFIDENTIALITY DESIGNATION STATE OF NEW YORK OBJECTION STATE OF NEW YORK PROPOSED RESOLUTION ENT000681 Westinghouse, WCAP
-17199-P, Rev. 1, Environmental Fatigue Evaluation for Indian Point Unit 2, Dec. 2014 , 95pages. Entire document withheld from public disclosure
. Proprietary designation is overly broad and seeks to exempt from disclosure information unrelated to trade secrets or confidential commercial/financial information.
Document should be disclosed for public inspection subject to limited redaction of information specifically related to trade secrets or confidential commercial/ financial information, if any. ENT000682 Westinghouse, WCAP
-17200-P, Rev. 1, Environmental Fatigue Evaluation for Indian Point Unit 3, Dec. 2014, 89pages. Entire document withheld from public disclosure
. Proprietary designation is overly broad and seeks to exempt from disclosure information unrelated to trade secrets or confidential commercial/financial information.
Document should be disclosed for public inspection subject to limited redaction of information specifically related to trade secrets or confidential commercial/ financial information, if any. ENT000683 Westinghouse, Calculation Note CN-PAFM-13-32, Rev. 3 "Indian Point Unit 2 (IP2) and Unit 3 (IP3) Refined EAF Analyses and EAF Screening Evaluations," June 25, 2015, 104 pages. Entire document withheld from public disclosure
. Proprietary designation is overly broad and seeks to exempt from disclosure information unrelated to trade se crets or confidential commercial/financial information.
Document should be disclosed for public inspection subject to limited redaction of information specifically related to trade secrets or confidential commercial/ financial information, if any. ENT000688 Westinghouse, Calculation Note CN-PAFM-13-40, Rev. 1, "Indian Point Unit 2 and Unit 3 Pressurizer Spray Nozzle Transfer Function Database Development and Environmental Fatigue Evaluations," Jan. 15, 2015, 138 pages. Entire document withheld from public disclosure
. Proprietary designation is overly broad and seeks to exempt from disclosure information unrelated to trade secrets or confidential commercial/financial information.
Document should be disclosed for public inspection subject to limited redaction of information specifically related to trade secrets or confidential commercial/ financial information, if any. ENT000689 Westinghouse, WCAP
-12191, Rev. 4, Transient and Fatigue Cycle Monitoring Program Transient History Evaluation Report for Indian Point Unit 2, Dec. 2014 , 52 pages. Entire document withheld from public disclosure
. Proprietary designation is overly broad and seeks to exempt from disclosure information unrelated to trade secrets or confidential commercial/financial information.
Document should be disclosed for public inspection subject to limited redaction of information specifically related to trade secrets or confidential commercial/ financial information, if any. ENT000690 Westinghouse, WCAP
-16898-P, Rev.1, Indian Point Unit 3 Transient and Fatigue Cycle Monitoring Program Transient History Evaluation , May 2015 , 72 pages. Entire document withheld from public disclosure
. Proprietary designation is overly broad and seeks to exempt from disclosure information unrelated to trade secrets or confidential commercial/financial information.
Document should be disclosed for public inspection subject to limited redaction of information specifically related to trade secrets or confidential commercial/ financial information, if any.    


3 EXHIBIT NUMBER DESCRIPTION, DATE, PAGES EXTENT OF CONFIDENTIALITY DESIGNATION STATE OF NEW YORK OBJECTION STATE OF NEW YORK PROPOSED RESOLUTION NYS000363 Westinghouse, WCAP
The documents that are the subject of the States Objection are the following:
-17149-P, Rev. 1, Evaluation of Pressurizer Insurge/Outsurge Transients for Indian Point Unit 2 and Westinghouse, WCAP-17162-P, Rev. 1, Evaluation of Pressurizer Insurge/Outsurge Transients for Indian Point Unit 3, July 2010 , 111 pages. Entire document withheld from public disclosure
EXHIBIT           DESCRIPTION,                   EXTENT OF           STATE OF NEW YORK               STATE OF NEW YORK NUMBER            DATE, PAGES              CONFIDENTIALITY                OBJECTION                        PROPOSED DESIGNATION                                                RESOLUTION ENT000615  Entergys Statement of Position  Entire document     Proprietary designation is overly   Document should be Regarding Contention NYS-25      withheld from public broad and seeks to exempt from     disclosed for public (Embrittlement), August 10,      disclosure.          disclosure information unrelated to inspection subject to limited 2015, 63 pages.                                      trade secrets or confidential       redaction of information that commercial or financial             reveals vendors secret information.                        methodologies or techniques or confidential trade organization analysis, if any.
. Proprietary designation is overly broad and seeks to exempt from disclosure information unrelated to trade secrets or confidential commercial/financial information.
ENT000616  Testimony of Entergy Witnesses  Entire document      Proprietary designation is overly  Document should be Nelson F. Azevedo, Robert J. withheld from public broad and seeks to exempt from      disclosed for public Dolansky, Alan B. Cox, Jack R. disclosure.          disclosure information unrelated to inspection subject to limited Strosnider, Timothy J.                                trade secrets or confidential       redaction of information that Griesbach, Randy G. Lott, and                        commercial/financial information. reveals vendors secret Mark A. Gray Regarding                                                                    methodologies or Contention NYS-25                                                                        techniques, if any.
Document should be disclosed for public inspection subject to limited redaction of information specifically related to trade secrets or confidential commercial/ financial information, if any. NYS000364 Westinghouse (W)  
(Embrittlement), August 10, 2015, 158 pages.
- Calculation Note, CN
ENT000678  Entergys Statement of Position  Entire document     Proprietary designation is overly   Document should be Regarding Contention NYS-        withheld from public broad and seeks to exempt from     disclosed for public 26B/RK-TC-1B (Metal Fatigue),    disclosure.          disclosure information unrelated to inspection subject to limited August 10, 2015, 70 pages.                            trade secrets or confidential       redaction of information that commercial/financial information. reveals vendors secret methodologies or techniques, if any.
-PAFM-09-21, Indian Point Units 2 & 3 Charging Nozzles Environmental Fatigue Evaluation, Jun. 18, 2010 , 85 pages. Entire document withheld from public disclosure
ENT000679  Revised Testimony of Entergy    Entire document     Proprietary designation is overly   Document should be Witnesses Nelson F. Azevedo,    withheld from public broad and seeks to exempt from     disclosed for public Alan B. Cox, Jack R. Strosnider, disclosure.          disclosure information unrelated to inspection subject to limited Randy G. Lott, Mark A. Gray,                          trade secrets or confidential       redaction of information that and Barry M. Gordon Regarding                        commercial/financial information. reveals vendors secret Contention NYS-26B/RK-TC-                                                                 methodologies or 1B (Metal Fatigue), August 10,                                                           techniques, if any.
. Proprietary designation is overly broad and seeks to exempt from disclosure information unrelated to trade secrets or confidential commercial/financial information.
2015, 172 pages.
Document should be disclosed for public inspection subject to limited redaction of information specifically related to trade secrets or confidential commercial/ financial information, if any. NYS000365 Westinghouse (W)
ENT000698  Entergys Revised Statement of  Entire document     Proprietary designation is overly  Document should be Position Regarding Contention    withheld from public broad and seeks to exempt from     disclosed for public NYS-38/RK-TC-5 (Safety          disclosure.          disclosure information unrelated to inspection subject to limited Commitments), August 10,                              trade secrets or confidential       redaction of information 2015, 73 pages.                                      commercial/financial information. specifically related to trade secrets or confidential commercial/ financial information, if any.
- Calculation Note, CN
ENT000699  Revised Testimony of Entergy    Entire document     Proprietary designation is overly   Document should be Witnesses Nelson F. Azevedo,    withheld from public broad and seeks to exempt from     disclosed for public Robert J. Dolansky, Alan B.      disclosure.          disclosure information unrelated to inspection subject to limited Cox, Jack R. Strosnider,                              trade secrets or confidential       redaction of information Timothy J. Griesbach, Barry M.                        commercial/financial information. specifically related to trade Gordon, Randy G. Lott, and                                                                secrets or confidential Mark A. Gray Regarding                                                                    commercial/ financial Contention NYS-38/RK-TC-5                                                                information, if any.
-PAFM-09-67, IPECPROP00057917, Pressurizer Surge Nozzle and Lower Head Transfer Functions for Indian Point Units 2 and 3, Jun. 18, 2010 , 86pages. Entire document withheld from public disclosure
(Safety Commitments), August 10, 2015, 146 pages.
. Proprietary designation is overly broad and seeks to exempt from disclosure information unrelated to trade secrets or confidential commercial/financial information.
2
Document should be disclosed for public inspection subject to limited redaction of information specifically related to trade secrets or confidential commercial/ financial information, if any. NYS00036 6 Westinghouse (W)
- Calculation Note. CN
-PAFM-09-77, IPECPROP00057881/3, Indian Point Units 2 & 3 Accumulator Nozzle Environmental Fatigue Evaluation, Jun. 18, 2010 , 94 pages. Entire document withheld from public disclosure
. Proprietary designation is overl y broad and seeks to exempt from disclosure information unrelated to trade secrets or confidential commercial/financial information.
Document should be disclosed for public inspection subject to limited redaction of information specifically related to trad e secrets or confidential commercial/ financial information, if any. NYS000367 Westinghouse (W)
- Calculation Note, CN
-PAFM-09-79, IPECPROP00057559, Indian Point Unit 2 Boron Injection Tank Nozzle Environmental Fatigue Evaluations, Jun. 18, 2010 , 76pages. Entire document withheld from public disclosure
. Proprietary designation is overly broad and seeks to exempt from disclosure information unrelated to trade secrets or confidential commercial/financial information.
Document should be disclosed for public inspection subject to limited redaction of information specifically related to trade secrets or confidential commercial/ financial information, if any. Executed on September 17 , 2015 Signed (electronically) by Lisa S. Kwong Assistant Attorney General Office of the Attorney General of the State of New York


The Capitol Albany, New York 12224
EXHIBIT          DESCRIPTION,                   EXTENT OF          STATE OF NEW YORK                STATE OF NEW YORK NUMBER            DATE, PAGES              CONFIDENTIALITY                OBJECTION                        PROPOSED DESIGNATION                                                RESOLUTION ENT000681 Westinghouse, WCAP-17199-P,      Entire document      Proprietary designation is overly  Document should be Rev. 1, Environmental Fatigue    withheld from public broad and seeks to exempt from      disclosed for public Evaluation for Indian Point Unit disclosure.          disclosure information unrelated to inspection subject to limited 2, Dec. 2014, 95pages.                                trade secrets or confidential      redaction of information commercial/financial information. specifically related to trade secrets or confidential commercial/ financial information, if any.
ENT000682 Westinghouse, WCAP-17200-P,      Entire document      Proprietary designation is overly  Document should be Rev. 1, Environmental Fatigue    withheld from public broad and seeks to exempt from      disclosed for public Evaluation for Indian Point Unit disclosure.          disclosure information unrelated to inspection subject to limited 3, Dec. 2014, 89pages.                                trade secrets or confidential      redaction of information commercial/financial information. specifically related to trade secrets or confidential commercial/ financial information, if any.
ENT000683 Westinghouse, Calculation Note  Entire document      Proprietary designation is overly  Document should be CN-PAFM-13-32, Rev. 3            withheld from public broad and seeks to exempt from      disclosed for public Indian Point Unit 2 (IP2) and  disclosure.          disclosure information unrelated to inspection subject to limited Unit 3 (IP3) Refined EAF                              trade secrets or confidential      redaction of information Analyses and EAF Screening                            commercial/financial information. specifically related to trade Evaluations, June 25, 2015, 104                                                          secrets or confidential pages.                                                                                    commercial/ financial information, if any.
ENT000688 Westinghouse, Calculation Note  Entire document      Proprietary designation is overly  Document should be CN-PAFM-13-40, Rev. 1,          withheld from public broad and seeks to exempt from      disclosed for public Indian Point Unit 2 and Unit 3  disclosure.          disclosure information unrelated to inspection subject to limited Pressurizer Spray Nozzle                              trade secrets or confidential      redaction of information Transfer Function Database                            commercial/financial information. specifically related to trade Development and Environmental                                                            secrets or confidential Fatigue Evaluations, Jan. 15,                                                            commercial/ financial 2015, 138 pages.                                                                          information, if any.
ENT000689 Westinghouse, WCAP-12191,        Entire document      Proprietary designation is overly  Document should be Rev. 4, Transient and Fatigue    withheld from public broad and seeks to exempt from      disclosed for public Cycle Monitoring Program        disclosure.          disclosure information unrelated to inspection subject to limited Transient History Evaluation                          trade secrets or confidential      redaction of information Report for Indian Point Unit 2,                      commercial/financial information. specifically related to trade Dec. 2014, 52 pages.                                                                      secrets or confidential commercial/ financial information, if any.
ENT000690 Westinghouse, WCAP-16898-P,      Entire document      Proprietary designation is overly  Document should be Rev.1, Indian Point Unit 3      withheld from public broad and seeks to exempt from      disclosed for public Transient and Fatigue Cycle      disclosure.          disclosure information unrelated to inspection subject to limited Monitoring Program Transient                          trade secrets or confidential      redaction of information History Evaluation , May 2015,                        commercial/financial information. specifically related to trade 72 pages.                                                                                secrets or confidential commercial/ financial information, if any.
3


(518) 776-2422 Lisa.Kwong@ag.ny.gov 4}}
EXHIBIT      DESCRIPTION, DATE,                EXTENT OF              STATE OF NEW YORK                STATE OF NEW YORK NUMBER              PAGES                CONFIDENTIALITY                  OBJECTION                        PROPOSED DESIGNATION                                                    RESOLUTION NYS000363 Westinghouse, WCAP-17149-      Entire document        Proprietary designation is overly  Document should be P, Rev. 1, Evaluation of        withheld from public    broad and seeks to exempt from      disclosed for public Pressurizer Insurge/Outsurge    disclosure.            disclosure information unrelated to inspection subject to limited Transients for Indian Point                            trade secrets or confidential      redaction of information Unit 2 and Westinghouse,                                commercial/financial information. specifically related to trade WCAP-17162-P, Rev. 1,                                                                      secrets or confidential Evaluation of Pressurizer                                                                  commercial/ financial Insurge/Outsurge Transients                                                                information, if any.
for Indian Point Unit 3, July 2010, 111 pages.
NYS000364 Westinghouse (W) -              Entire document        Proprietary designation is overly  Document should be Calculation Note, CN-PAFM-      withheld from public    broad and seeks to exempt from      disclosed for public 09-21, Indian Point Units 2 & 3 disclosure.            disclosure information unrelated to inspection subject to limited Charging Nozzles                                        trade secrets or confidential      redaction of information Environmental Fatigue                                  commercial/financial information. specifically related to trade Evaluation, Jun. 18, 2010, 85                                                              secrets or confidential pages.                                                                                      commercial/ financial information, if any.
NYS000365 Westinghouse (W) -              Entire document        Proprietary designation is overly  Document should be Calculation Note, CN-PAFM-      withheld from public    broad and seeks to exempt from      disclosed for public 09-67, IPECPROP00057917,        disclosure.            disclosure information unrelated to inspection subject to limited Pressurizer Surge Nozzle and                            trade secrets or confidential      redaction of information Lower Head Transfer                                    commercial/financial information. specifically related to trade Functions for Indian Point                                                                  secrets or confidential Units 2 and 3, Jun. 18, 2010,                                                              commercial/ financial 86pages.                                                                                    information, if any.
NYS000366 Westinghouse (W) -              Entire document        Proprietary designation is overly  Document should be Calculation Note. CN-PAFM-      withheld from public    broad and seeks to exempt from      disclosed for public 09-77, IPECPROP00057881/3,      disclosure.            disclosure information unrelated to inspection subject to limited Indian Point Units 2 & 3                                trade secrets or confidential      redaction of information Accumulator Nozzle                                      commercial/financial information. specifically related to trade Environmental Fatigue                                                                      secrets or confidential Evaluation, Jun. 18, 2010, 94                                                              commercial/ financial pages.                                                                                      information, if any.
NYS000367 Westinghouse (W) -              Entire document        Proprietary designation is overly  Document should be Calculation Note, CN-PAFM-      withheld from public    broad and seeks to exempt from      disclosed for public 09-79, IPECPROP00057559,        disclosure.            disclosure information unrelated to inspection subject to limited Indian Point Unit 2 Boron                              trade secrets or confidential      redaction of information Injection Tank Nozzle                                  commercial/financial information. specifically related to trade Environmental Fatigue                                                                      secrets or confidential Evaluations, Jun. 18, 2010,                                                                commercial/ financial 76pages.                                                                                    information, if any.
Executed on September 17, 2015 Signed (electronically) by Lisa S. Kwong Assistant Attorney General Office of the Attorney General of the State of New York The Capitol Albany, New York 12224 (518) 776-2422 Lisa.Kwong@ag.ny.gov 4}}

Latest revision as of 05:31, 31 October 2019

NYS Attachment 13: E-mail from Lisa S. Kwong to Paul M. Bessette September 17, 2015, 4:39 PM
ML15293A032
Person / Time
Site: Indian Point  Entergy icon.png
Issue date: 10/20/2015
From:
State of NY, Office of the Attorney General
To:
Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel
SECY RAS
Shared Package
ML15293A030 List:
References
RAS 28407, ASLBP 07-858-03-LR-BD01, 50-247-LR, 50-286-LR
Download: ML15293A032 (6)
v • d • e


Text

E-mail from Lisa S. Kwong to Paul M. Bessette September 17, 2015, 4:39 PM ATTACHMENT 13 to NYS DECLARATION

Mihir Desai From: Lisa S. Kwong Sent: Thursday, September 17, 2015 4:39 PM To: pbessette@morganlewis.com Cc: Sutton, Kathryn M. (ksutton@morganlewis.com); Kuyler, Raphael Philip (rkuyler@morganlewis.com); sherwin.turk@nrc.gov; Harris, Brian (Brian.Harris@nrc.gov);

Deborah Brancato (DBrancato@riverkeeper.org); Lisa M. Burianek; John J. Sipos; Mihir Desai; Brian Lusignan; Teresa Manzi

Subject:

IP -- Notice of objection to proprietary/confidentiality designation Attachments: 2015 09 17 NYS Notice of Objection to Proprietary Designation FINAL.pdf Good afternoon, Paul.

Attached please find the State of New Yorks Objection to Confidential/Proprietary Designations for Certain Documents Relating to Contentions NYS25, NYS26B/RKTC1B and NYS38/RKTC5. Feel free to call me at your earliest convenience to discuss. I look forward to speaking with you.

Thanks, Lisa Lisa S. Kwong Assistant Attorney General Environmental Protection Bureau New York State Office of the Attorney General The Capitol Albany, NY 12224 Tel: 5187762422 Fax: 5186509363 Lisa.Kwong@ny.ag.gov 1

UNITED STATES NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING BOARD

x In re: Docket Nos. 50-247-LR; 50-286-LR License Renewal Application Submitted by ASLBP No. 07-858-03-LR-BD01 Entergy Nuclear Indian Point 2, LLC, DPR-26, DPR-64 Entergy Nuclear Indian Point 3, LLC, and Entergy Nuclear Operations, Inc. September 17, 2015

x STATE OF NEW YORKS OBJECTION TO PROPRIETARY AND/OR CONFIDENTIAL DESIGNATIONS FOR CERTAIN DOCUMENTS RELATING TO CONTENTIONS NYS-25, NYS-26B/RK-TC-1B AND NYS-38/RKTC-5 In accordance with the Atomic Safety and Licensing Boards September 4, 2009 Protective Order, the State of New York objects to Entergys designation of the documents listed below as containing proprietary information subject to non-disclosure. The documents include:

Entergys Statements of Position and Pre-filed Testimony relating to Contentions NYS-25, NYS-26B/RK-TC-1B and NYS-38/RK-TC-5, and various documents prepared by Entergys vendor, Westinghouse.

Based on the States review, the documents appear to primarily contain information that is not exempt from public inspection pursuant to 10 C.F.R. § 2.390. Entergys request to entirely withhold the information contained in these documents as privileged or confidential trade secrets and/or commercial or financial information is, therefore, overly broad.

To facilitate further consultation and resolution of this dispute, the State requests that Entergy (or its vendor, Westinghouse) indicate, with specificity, (1) the portion(s) of the documents it deems proprietary and confidential by page and line or column number; (2) the basis for such claim(s); and (3) the harm that would result from public disclosure.

The documents that are the subject of the States Objection are the following:

EXHIBIT DESCRIPTION, EXTENT OF STATE OF NEW YORK STATE OF NEW YORK NUMBER DATE, PAGES CONFIDENTIALITY OBJECTION PROPOSED DESIGNATION RESOLUTION ENT000615 Entergys Statement of Position Entire document Proprietary designation is overly Document should be Regarding Contention NYS-25 withheld from public broad and seeks to exempt from disclosed for public (Embrittlement), August 10, disclosure. disclosure information unrelated to inspection subject to limited 2015, 63 pages. trade secrets or confidential redaction of information that commercial or financial reveals vendors secret information. methodologies or techniques or confidential trade organization analysis, if any.

ENT000616 Testimony of Entergy Witnesses Entire document Proprietary designation is overly Document should be Nelson F. Azevedo, Robert J. withheld from public broad and seeks to exempt from disclosed for public Dolansky, Alan B. Cox, Jack R. disclosure. disclosure information unrelated to inspection subject to limited Strosnider, Timothy J. trade secrets or confidential redaction of information that Griesbach, Randy G. Lott, and commercial/financial information. reveals vendors secret Mark A. Gray Regarding methodologies or Contention NYS-25 techniques, if any.

(Embrittlement), August 10, 2015, 158 pages.

ENT000678 Entergys Statement of Position Entire document Proprietary designation is overly Document should be Regarding Contention NYS- withheld from public broad and seeks to exempt from disclosed for public 26B/RK-TC-1B (Metal Fatigue), disclosure. disclosure information unrelated to inspection subject to limited August 10, 2015, 70 pages. trade secrets or confidential redaction of information that commercial/financial information. reveals vendors secret methodologies or techniques, if any.

ENT000679 Revised Testimony of Entergy Entire document Proprietary designation is overly Document should be Witnesses Nelson F. Azevedo, withheld from public broad and seeks to exempt from disclosed for public Alan B. Cox, Jack R. Strosnider, disclosure. disclosure information unrelated to inspection subject to limited Randy G. Lott, Mark A. Gray, trade secrets or confidential redaction of information that and Barry M. Gordon Regarding commercial/financial information. reveals vendors secret Contention NYS-26B/RK-TC- methodologies or 1B (Metal Fatigue), August 10, techniques, if any.

2015, 172 pages.

ENT000698 Entergys Revised Statement of Entire document Proprietary designation is overly Document should be Position Regarding Contention withheld from public broad and seeks to exempt from disclosed for public NYS-38/RK-TC-5 (Safety disclosure. disclosure information unrelated to inspection subject to limited Commitments), August 10, trade secrets or confidential redaction of information 2015, 73 pages. commercial/financial information. specifically related to trade secrets or confidential commercial/ financial information, if any.

ENT000699 Revised Testimony of Entergy Entire document Proprietary designation is overly Document should be Witnesses Nelson F. Azevedo, withheld from public broad and seeks to exempt from disclosed for public Robert J. Dolansky, Alan B. disclosure. disclosure information unrelated to inspection subject to limited Cox, Jack R. Strosnider, trade secrets or confidential redaction of information Timothy J. Griesbach, Barry M. commercial/financial information. specifically related to trade Gordon, Randy G. Lott, and secrets or confidential Mark A. Gray Regarding commercial/ financial Contention NYS-38/RK-TC-5 information, if any.

(Safety Commitments), August 10, 2015, 146 pages.

2

EXHIBIT DESCRIPTION, EXTENT OF STATE OF NEW YORK STATE OF NEW YORK NUMBER DATE, PAGES CONFIDENTIALITY OBJECTION PROPOSED DESIGNATION RESOLUTION ENT000681 Westinghouse, WCAP-17199-P, Entire document Proprietary designation is overly Document should be Rev. 1, Environmental Fatigue withheld from public broad and seeks to exempt from disclosed for public Evaluation for Indian Point Unit disclosure. disclosure information unrelated to inspection subject to limited 2, Dec. 2014, 95pages. trade secrets or confidential redaction of information commercial/financial information. specifically related to trade secrets or confidential commercial/ financial information, if any.

ENT000682 Westinghouse, WCAP-17200-P, Entire document Proprietary designation is overly Document should be Rev. 1, Environmental Fatigue withheld from public broad and seeks to exempt from disclosed for public Evaluation for Indian Point Unit disclosure. disclosure information unrelated to inspection subject to limited 3, Dec. 2014, 89pages. trade secrets or confidential redaction of information commercial/financial information. specifically related to trade secrets or confidential commercial/ financial information, if any.

ENT000683 Westinghouse, Calculation Note Entire document Proprietary designation is overly Document should be CN-PAFM-13-32, Rev. 3 withheld from public broad and seeks to exempt from disclosed for public Indian Point Unit 2 (IP2) and disclosure. disclosure information unrelated to inspection subject to limited Unit 3 (IP3) Refined EAF trade secrets or confidential redaction of information Analyses and EAF Screening commercial/financial information. specifically related to trade Evaluations, June 25, 2015, 104 secrets or confidential pages. commercial/ financial information, if any.

ENT000688 Westinghouse, Calculation Note Entire document Proprietary designation is overly Document should be CN-PAFM-13-40, Rev. 1, withheld from public broad and seeks to exempt from disclosed for public Indian Point Unit 2 and Unit 3 disclosure. disclosure information unrelated to inspection subject to limited Pressurizer Spray Nozzle trade secrets or confidential redaction of information Transfer Function Database commercial/financial information. specifically related to trade Development and Environmental secrets or confidential Fatigue Evaluations, Jan. 15, commercial/ financial 2015, 138 pages. information, if any.

ENT000689 Westinghouse, WCAP-12191, Entire document Proprietary designation is overly Document should be Rev. 4, Transient and Fatigue withheld from public broad and seeks to exempt from disclosed for public Cycle Monitoring Program disclosure. disclosure information unrelated to inspection subject to limited Transient History Evaluation trade secrets or confidential redaction of information Report for Indian Point Unit 2, commercial/financial information. specifically related to trade Dec. 2014, 52 pages. secrets or confidential commercial/ financial information, if any.

ENT000690 Westinghouse, WCAP-16898-P, Entire document Proprietary designation is overly Document should be Rev.1, Indian Point Unit 3 withheld from public broad and seeks to exempt from disclosed for public Transient and Fatigue Cycle disclosure. disclosure information unrelated to inspection subject to limited Monitoring Program Transient trade secrets or confidential redaction of information History Evaluation , May 2015, commercial/financial information. specifically related to trade 72 pages. secrets or confidential commercial/ financial information, if any.

3

EXHIBIT DESCRIPTION, DATE, EXTENT OF STATE OF NEW YORK STATE OF NEW YORK NUMBER PAGES CONFIDENTIALITY OBJECTION PROPOSED DESIGNATION RESOLUTION NYS000363 Westinghouse, WCAP-17149- Entire document Proprietary designation is overly Document should be P, Rev. 1, Evaluation of withheld from public broad and seeks to exempt from disclosed for public Pressurizer Insurge/Outsurge disclosure. disclosure information unrelated to inspection subject to limited Transients for Indian Point trade secrets or confidential redaction of information Unit 2 and Westinghouse, commercial/financial information. specifically related to trade WCAP-17162-P, Rev. 1, secrets or confidential Evaluation of Pressurizer commercial/ financial Insurge/Outsurge Transients information, if any.

for Indian Point Unit 3, July 2010, 111 pages.

NYS000364 Westinghouse (W) - Entire document Proprietary designation is overly Document should be Calculation Note, CN-PAFM- withheld from public broad and seeks to exempt from disclosed for public 09-21, Indian Point Units 2 & 3 disclosure. disclosure information unrelated to inspection subject to limited Charging Nozzles trade secrets or confidential redaction of information Environmental Fatigue commercial/financial information. specifically related to trade Evaluation, Jun. 18, 2010, 85 secrets or confidential pages. commercial/ financial information, if any.

NYS000365 Westinghouse (W) - Entire document Proprietary designation is overly Document should be Calculation Note, CN-PAFM- withheld from public broad and seeks to exempt from disclosed for public 09-67, IPECPROP00057917, disclosure. disclosure information unrelated to inspection subject to limited Pressurizer Surge Nozzle and trade secrets or confidential redaction of information Lower Head Transfer commercial/financial information. specifically related to trade Functions for Indian Point secrets or confidential Units 2 and 3, Jun. 18, 2010, commercial/ financial 86pages. information, if any.

NYS000366 Westinghouse (W) - Entire document Proprietary designation is overly Document should be Calculation Note. CN-PAFM- withheld from public broad and seeks to exempt from disclosed for public 09-77, IPECPROP00057881/3, disclosure. disclosure information unrelated to inspection subject to limited Indian Point Units 2 & 3 trade secrets or confidential redaction of information Accumulator Nozzle commercial/financial information. specifically related to trade Environmental Fatigue secrets or confidential Evaluation, Jun. 18, 2010, 94 commercial/ financial pages. information, if any.

NYS000367 Westinghouse (W) - Entire document Proprietary designation is overly Document should be Calculation Note, CN-PAFM- withheld from public broad and seeks to exempt from disclosed for public 09-79, IPECPROP00057559, disclosure. disclosure information unrelated to inspection subject to limited Indian Point Unit 2 Boron trade secrets or confidential redaction of information Injection Tank Nozzle commercial/financial information. specifically related to trade Environmental Fatigue secrets or confidential Evaluations, Jun. 18, 2010, commercial/ financial 76pages. information, if any.

Executed on September 17, 2015 Signed (electronically) by Lisa S. Kwong Assistant Attorney General Office of the Attorney General of the State of New York The Capitol Albany, New York 12224 (518) 776-2422 Lisa.Kwong@ag.ny.gov 4

E-mail from Lisa S. Kwong to Paul M. Bessette September 17, 2015, 4:39 PM ATTACHMENT 13 to NYS DECLARATION

Mihir Desai From: Lisa S. Kwong Sent: Thursday, September 17, 2015 4:39 PM To: pbessette@morganlewis.com Cc: Sutton, Kathryn M. (ksutton@morganlewis.com); Kuyler, Raphael Philip (rkuyler@morganlewis.com); sherwin.turk@nrc.gov; Harris, Brian (Brian.Harris@nrc.gov);

Deborah Brancato (DBrancato@riverkeeper.org); Lisa M. Burianek; John J. Sipos; Mihir Desai; Brian Lusignan; Teresa Manzi

Subject:

IP -- Notice of objection to proprietary/confidentiality designation Attachments: 2015 09 17 NYS Notice of Objection to Proprietary Designation FINAL.pdf Good afternoon, Paul.

Attached please find the State of New Yorks Objection to Confidential/Proprietary Designations for Certain Documents Relating to Contentions NYS25, NYS26B/RKTC1B and NYS38/RKTC5. Feel free to call me at your earliest convenience to discuss. I look forward to speaking with you.

Thanks, Lisa Lisa S. Kwong Assistant Attorney General Environmental Protection Bureau New York State Office of the Attorney General The Capitol Albany, NY 12224 Tel: 5187762422 Fax: 5186509363 Lisa.Kwong@ny.ag.gov 1

UNITED STATES NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING BOARD

x In re: Docket Nos. 50-247-LR; 50-286-LR License Renewal Application Submitted by ASLBP No. 07-858-03-LR-BD01 Entergy Nuclear Indian Point 2, LLC, DPR-26, DPR-64 Entergy Nuclear Indian Point 3, LLC, and Entergy Nuclear Operations, Inc. September 17, 2015

x STATE OF NEW YORKS OBJECTION TO PROPRIETARY AND/OR CONFIDENTIAL DESIGNATIONS FOR CERTAIN DOCUMENTS RELATING TO CONTENTIONS NYS-25, NYS-26B/RK-TC-1B AND NYS-38/RKTC-5 In accordance with the Atomic Safety and Licensing Boards September 4, 2009 Protective Order, the State of New York objects to Entergys designation of the documents listed below as containing proprietary information subject to non-disclosure. The documents include:

Entergys Statements of Position and Pre-filed Testimony relating to Contentions NYS-25, NYS-26B/RK-TC-1B and NYS-38/RK-TC-5, and various documents prepared by Entergys vendor, Westinghouse.

Based on the States review, the documents appear to primarily contain information that is not exempt from public inspection pursuant to 10 C.F.R. § 2.390. Entergys request to entirely withhold the information contained in these documents as privileged or confidential trade secrets and/or commercial or financial information is, therefore, overly broad.

To facilitate further consultation and resolution of this dispute, the State requests that Entergy (or its vendor, Westinghouse) indicate, with specificity, (1) the portion(s) of the documents it deems proprietary and confidential by page and line or column number; (2) the basis for such claim(s); and (3) the harm that would result from public disclosure.

The documents that are the subject of the States Objection are the following:

EXHIBIT DESCRIPTION, EXTENT OF STATE OF NEW YORK STATE OF NEW YORK NUMBER DATE, PAGES CONFIDENTIALITY OBJECTION PROPOSED DESIGNATION RESOLUTION ENT000615 Entergys Statement of Position Entire document Proprietary designation is overly Document should be Regarding Contention NYS-25 withheld from public broad and seeks to exempt from disclosed for public (Embrittlement), August 10, disclosure. disclosure information unrelated to inspection subject to limited 2015, 63 pages. trade secrets or confidential redaction of information that commercial or financial reveals vendors secret information. methodologies or techniques or confidential trade organization analysis, if any.

ENT000616 Testimony of Entergy Witnesses Entire document Proprietary designation is overly Document should be Nelson F. Azevedo, Robert J. withheld from public broad and seeks to exempt from disclosed for public Dolansky, Alan B. Cox, Jack R. disclosure. disclosure information unrelated to inspection subject to limited Strosnider, Timothy J. trade secrets or confidential redaction of information that Griesbach, Randy G. Lott, and commercial/financial information. reveals vendors secret Mark A. Gray Regarding methodologies or Contention NYS-25 techniques, if any.

(Embrittlement), August 10, 2015, 158 pages.

ENT000678 Entergys Statement of Position Entire document Proprietary designation is overly Document should be Regarding Contention NYS- withheld from public broad and seeks to exempt from disclosed for public 26B/RK-TC-1B (Metal Fatigue), disclosure. disclosure information unrelated to inspection subject to limited August 10, 2015, 70 pages. trade secrets or confidential redaction of information that commercial/financial information. reveals vendors secret methodologies or techniques, if any.

ENT000679 Revised Testimony of Entergy Entire document Proprietary designation is overly Document should be Witnesses Nelson F. Azevedo, withheld from public broad and seeks to exempt from disclosed for public Alan B. Cox, Jack R. Strosnider, disclosure. disclosure information unrelated to inspection subject to limited Randy G. Lott, Mark A. Gray, trade secrets or confidential redaction of information that and Barry M. Gordon Regarding commercial/financial information. reveals vendors secret Contention NYS-26B/RK-TC- methodologies or 1B (Metal Fatigue), August 10, techniques, if any.

2015, 172 pages.

ENT000698 Entergys Revised Statement of Entire document Proprietary designation is overly Document should be Position Regarding Contention withheld from public broad and seeks to exempt from disclosed for public NYS-38/RK-TC-5 (Safety disclosure. disclosure information unrelated to inspection subject to limited Commitments), August 10, trade secrets or confidential redaction of information 2015, 73 pages. commercial/financial information. specifically related to trade secrets or confidential commercial/ financial information, if any.

ENT000699 Revised Testimony of Entergy Entire document Proprietary designation is overly Document should be Witnesses Nelson F. Azevedo, withheld from public broad and seeks to exempt from disclosed for public Robert J. Dolansky, Alan B. disclosure. disclosure information unrelated to inspection subject to limited Cox, Jack R. Strosnider, trade secrets or confidential redaction of information Timothy J. Griesbach, Barry M. commercial/financial information. specifically related to trade Gordon, Randy G. Lott, and secrets or confidential Mark A. Gray Regarding commercial/ financial Contention NYS-38/RK-TC-5 information, if any.

(Safety Commitments), August 10, 2015, 146 pages.

2

EXHIBIT DESCRIPTION, EXTENT OF STATE OF NEW YORK STATE OF NEW YORK NUMBER DATE, PAGES CONFIDENTIALITY OBJECTION PROPOSED DESIGNATION RESOLUTION ENT000681 Westinghouse, WCAP-17199-P, Entire document Proprietary designation is overly Document should be Rev. 1, Environmental Fatigue withheld from public broad and seeks to exempt from disclosed for public Evaluation for Indian Point Unit disclosure. disclosure information unrelated to inspection subject to limited 2, Dec. 2014, 95pages. trade secrets or confidential redaction of information commercial/financial information. specifically related to trade secrets or confidential commercial/ financial information, if any.

ENT000682 Westinghouse, WCAP-17200-P, Entire document Proprietary designation is overly Document should be Rev. 1, Environmental Fatigue withheld from public broad and seeks to exempt from disclosed for public Evaluation for Indian Point Unit disclosure. disclosure information unrelated to inspection subject to limited 3, Dec. 2014, 89pages. trade secrets or confidential redaction of information commercial/financial information. specifically related to trade secrets or confidential commercial/ financial information, if any.

ENT000683 Westinghouse, Calculation Note Entire document Proprietary designation is overly Document should be CN-PAFM-13-32, Rev. 3 withheld from public broad and seeks to exempt from disclosed for public Indian Point Unit 2 (IP2) and disclosure. disclosure information unrelated to inspection subject to limited Unit 3 (IP3) Refined EAF trade secrets or confidential redaction of information Analyses and EAF Screening commercial/financial information. specifically related to trade Evaluations, June 25, 2015, 104 secrets or confidential pages. commercial/ financial information, if any.

ENT000688 Westinghouse, Calculation Note Entire document Proprietary designation is overly Document should be CN-PAFM-13-40, Rev. 1, withheld from public broad and seeks to exempt from disclosed for public Indian Point Unit 2 and Unit 3 disclosure. disclosure information unrelated to inspection subject to limited Pressurizer Spray Nozzle trade secrets or confidential redaction of information Transfer Function Database commercial/financial information. specifically related to trade Development and Environmental secrets or confidential Fatigue Evaluations, Jan. 15, commercial/ financial 2015, 138 pages. information, if any.

ENT000689 Westinghouse, WCAP-12191, Entire document Proprietary designation is overly Document should be Rev. 4, Transient and Fatigue withheld from public broad and seeks to exempt from disclosed for public Cycle Monitoring Program disclosure. disclosure information unrelated to inspection subject to limited Transient History Evaluation trade secrets or confidential redaction of information Report for Indian Point Unit 2, commercial/financial information. specifically related to trade Dec. 2014, 52 pages. secrets or confidential commercial/ financial information, if any.

ENT000690 Westinghouse, WCAP-16898-P, Entire document Proprietary designation is overly Document should be Rev.1, Indian Point Unit 3 withheld from public broad and seeks to exempt from disclosed for public Transient and Fatigue Cycle disclosure. disclosure information unrelated to inspection subject to limited Monitoring Program Transient trade secrets or confidential redaction of information History Evaluation , May 2015, commercial/financial information. specifically related to trade 72 pages. secrets or confidential commercial/ financial information, if any.

3

EXHIBIT DESCRIPTION, DATE, EXTENT OF STATE OF NEW YORK STATE OF NEW YORK NUMBER PAGES CONFIDENTIALITY OBJECTION PROPOSED DESIGNATION RESOLUTION NYS000363 Westinghouse, WCAP-17149- Entire document Proprietary designation is overly Document should be P, Rev. 1, Evaluation of withheld from public broad and seeks to exempt from disclosed for public Pressurizer Insurge/Outsurge disclosure. disclosure information unrelated to inspection subject to limited Transients for Indian Point trade secrets or confidential redaction of information Unit 2 and Westinghouse, commercial/financial information. specifically related to trade WCAP-17162-P, Rev. 1, secrets or confidential Evaluation of Pressurizer commercial/ financial Insurge/Outsurge Transients information, if any.

for Indian Point Unit 3, July 2010, 111 pages.

NYS000364 Westinghouse (W) - Entire document Proprietary designation is overly Document should be Calculation Note, CN-PAFM- withheld from public broad and seeks to exempt from disclosed for public 09-21, Indian Point Units 2 & 3 disclosure. disclosure information unrelated to inspection subject to limited Charging Nozzles trade secrets or confidential redaction of information Environmental Fatigue commercial/financial information. specifically related to trade Evaluation, Jun. 18, 2010, 85 secrets or confidential pages. commercial/ financial information, if any.

NYS000365 Westinghouse (W) - Entire document Proprietary designation is overly Document should be Calculation Note, CN-PAFM- withheld from public broad and seeks to exempt from disclosed for public 09-67, IPECPROP00057917, disclosure. disclosure information unrelated to inspection subject to limited Pressurizer Surge Nozzle and trade secrets or confidential redaction of information Lower Head Transfer commercial/financial information. specifically related to trade Functions for Indian Point secrets or confidential Units 2 and 3, Jun. 18, 2010, commercial/ financial 86pages. information, if any.

NYS000366 Westinghouse (W) - Entire document Proprietary designation is overly Document should be Calculation Note. CN-PAFM- withheld from public broad and seeks to exempt from disclosed for public 09-77, IPECPROP00057881/3, disclosure. disclosure information unrelated to inspection subject to limited Indian Point Units 2 & 3 trade secrets or confidential redaction of information Accumulator Nozzle commercial/financial information. specifically related to trade Environmental Fatigue secrets or confidential Evaluation, Jun. 18, 2010, 94 commercial/ financial pages. information, if any.

NYS000367 Westinghouse (W) - Entire document Proprietary designation is overly Document should be Calculation Note, CN-PAFM- withheld from public broad and seeks to exempt from disclosed for public 09-79, IPECPROP00057559, disclosure. disclosure information unrelated to inspection subject to limited Indian Point Unit 2 Boron trade secrets or confidential redaction of information Injection Tank Nozzle commercial/financial information. specifically related to trade Environmental Fatigue secrets or confidential Evaluations, Jun. 18, 2010, commercial/ financial 76pages. information, if any.

Executed on September 17, 2015 Signed (electronically) by Lisa S. Kwong Assistant Attorney General Office of the Attorney General of the State of New York The Capitol Albany, New York 12224 (518) 776-2422 Lisa.Kwong@ag.ny.gov 4

Retrieved from "https://kanterella.com/w/index.php?title=ML15293A032&oldid=2027897"