ML18291B228: Difference between revisions
StriderTol (talk | contribs) (Created page by program invented by StriderTol) |
StriderTol (talk | contribs) (StriderTol Bot change) |
||
| Line 15: | Line 15: | ||
=Text= | =Text= | ||
{{#Wiki_filter:November 9, 2018 MEMORANDUM TO: | {{#Wiki_filter:November 9, 2018 MEMORANDUM TO: | ||
Licensing Branch 1 Division of Licensing, Siting and Environmental Analysis Office of New Reactors | Samuel S. Lee, Chief Licensing Branch 1 Division of Licensing, Siting and Environmental Analysis Office of New Reactors FROM: | ||
Omid Tabatabai, Senior Project Manager | |||
/RA/ | |||
Licensing Branch 1 Division of Licensing, Siting and Environmental Analysis Office of New Reactors | |||
==SUBJECT:== | ==SUBJECT:== | ||
| Line 22: | Line 25: | ||
In March 2017, the U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) staff began a regulatory audit of certain documents of the NuScale Power, LLC (NuScale) design certification application (DCA) pertaining to the Containment and Ventilation Systems. The NRC staff issued its initial audit plan on March 29, 2017, and an addenda to the audit plan on June 28, 2018 (Agencywide Documents Access and Management System Accession Nos. ML17087A077 and ML18177A087). The intent of this audit, in part, was to gain a more detailed understanding of the NuScale design in technical areas associated with containment and ventilation systems and to identify information that will require docketing to support the basis of the regulatory decision. | In March 2017, the U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) staff began a regulatory audit of certain documents of the NuScale Power, LLC (NuScale) design certification application (DCA) pertaining to the Containment and Ventilation Systems. The NRC staff issued its initial audit plan on March 29, 2017, and an addenda to the audit plan on June 28, 2018 (Agencywide Documents Access and Management System Accession Nos. ML17087A077 and ML18177A087). The intent of this audit, in part, was to gain a more detailed understanding of the NuScale design in technical areas associated with containment and ventilation systems and to identify information that will require docketing to support the basis of the regulatory decision. | ||
This interim audit summary report documents the NRC staffs audit activities and progress from April 3, 2017 through August 31, 2018. The NRC staff conducted the audit in accordance with the Office of New Reactors (NRO) Office Instruction NRO-REG-108, Regulatory Audits. | This interim audit summary report documents the NRC staffs audit activities and progress from April 3, 2017 through August 31, 2018. The NRC staff conducted the audit in accordance with the Office of New Reactors (NRO) Office Instruction NRO-REG-108, Regulatory Audits. | ||
Docket No. 52-048 | Docket No. 52-048 | ||
==Enclosure:== | ==Enclosure:== | ||
: 1. NRC Staff Interim Audit Report for Containment and Ventilation Systems cc: NuScale DC ListServ CONTACT: Omid Tabatabai, NRO/DNRL 301-415-6616 | : 1. NRC Staff Interim Audit Report for Containment and Ventilation Systems cc: NuScale DC ListServ CONTACT: Omid Tabatabai, NRO/DNRL 301-415-6616 | ||
ML18291B228 | ML18291B228 | ||
NAME | *via email* | ||
DATE | NRO-002 OFFICE NRO/DLSE/LB1: PM NRO/DLSE/LB1: LA* | ||
NRO/DSRA/SCVB: BC* | |||
NAME OTabatabai MMoore* | |||
DJackson (HWagage for) | |||
DATE 10/19/2018 10/22/2018 11/8/2018 | |||
1 U.S. NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION REGULATORY AUDIT OF CONTAINMENT AND VENTILATION SYSTEMS AS PART OF THE NUSCALE POWER, LLC DESIGN CONTROL DOCUMENT REVIEW INTERIM AUDIT | |||
==SUMMARY== | ==SUMMARY== | ||
REPORT FOR APRIL 3, 2017 THROUGH AUGUST 31, 2018 NRC Audit Team: | REPORT FOR APRIL 3, 2017 THROUGH AUGUST 31, 2018 NRC Audit Team: | ||
Hanry Wagage, NRO, Audit Lead Clinton Ashley, NRO Anne-Marie Grady, NRO Syed Haider, NRO Alfred Hathaway, RES Raul Hernandez, NRO Peter Lien, RES Shanlai Lu, NRO Jeffrey Schmidt, NRO Carl Thurston, NRO Boyce Travis, NRO Rebecca Karas, NRO, Branch Chief (Reactor Systems Branch) | |||
Diane Jackson, NRO, Branch Chief (Containment Branch) | |||
Mohsen Khatib-Rahbar, ERI (NRC Contractor) | |||
Alfred Krall, ERI (NRC Contractor) | |||
Zhe Yuan, ERI (NRC Contractor) | |||
Omid Tabatabai, NRO, Senior Project Manager I. | |||
AUDIT LOCATION AND DATES The U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) staff conducted the audit from NRC Headquarters in Rockville, Maryland, through NuScales electronic reading room (eRR) and also at (1) the NuScale Office at 11333 Woodglen Drive, Suite 205, Rockville, Maryland 20852 and (2) NuScale Integral System Test (NIST-1) facility located at Oregon State University in Corvallis, Oregon. This interim audit summary report is for the period of April 3, 2017, through August 31, 2018. | |||
II. | |||
Background and Audit Basis In a {{letter dated|date=December 31, 2016|text=letter dated December 31, 2016}}, NuScale submitted to the U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) Revision 0 of the NuScale Standard Plant Design Certification Application (DCA) (Agencywide Documents Access and Management System (ADAMS) Accession No. ML17013A229). The NRC staff initiated this DCA review on March 27, 2017. NuScale submitted Revision 1 of DCA to the NRC on March 15, 2018 (ADAMS Accession No. ML18086A090). Application documents for the NuScale design are available at the NRC Website at https://www.nrc.gov/reactors/new-reactors/design-cert/nuscale/documents.html. | |||
II. | |||
The intent of this audit, in part, was to gain a more detailed understanding of the NuScale design in technical areas associated with containment and ventilation systems and identify information that will require docketing to support the basis of the regulatory decision. The NRC staff issued an audit plan on March 29, 2017, and an addenda on June 28, 2017 (ADAMS Accession Nos. ML17087A077 and ML18177A087, respectively). The addenda narrowed the audit scope by limiting it to three specific areas: containment pressure analysis, containment integrated leakage rate testing (ILRT), and containment Isolation. This interim audit summary report has been prepared in accordance with NRO-REG-108, Regulatory Audits, Revision 0, April 2, 2009 (ADAMS Accession No. ML081910260). | 2 The intent of this audit, in part, was to gain a more detailed understanding of the NuScale design in technical areas associated with containment and ventilation systems and identify information that will require docketing to support the basis of the regulatory decision. The NRC staff issued an audit plan on March 29, 2017, and an addenda on June 28, 2017 (ADAMS Accession Nos. ML17087A077 and ML18177A087, respectively). The addenda narrowed the audit scope by limiting it to three specific areas: containment pressure analysis, containment integrated leakage rate testing (ILRT), and containment Isolation. This interim audit summary report has been prepared in accordance with NRO-REG-108, Regulatory Audits, Revision 0, April 2, 2009 (ADAMS Accession No. ML081910260). | ||
III. DOCUMENTS AUDITED The NRC staff performed an audit of documents, as necessary, shown in the attachment. | III. DOCUMENTS AUDITED The NRC staff performed an audit of documents, as necessary, shown in the attachment. | ||
IV. | IV. | ||
Audit Activities and Summary of Findings The audit activities included the following review areas: | |||
containment peak pressure analysis; containment heat removal; methodology of mass and energy release from the reactor coolant system; ASME qualification of the containment vessel; containment leak rate testing, including NuScale exemption request no. 7, 10 CFR 52, App. A, GDC 52 Containment Leakage Rate Testing; combustible gas control, including NuScale exemption request no. 2, 10 CFR 50.44 Combustible Gas Control; equipment survivability; containment isolation, including NuScale exemption request no. 9, 10 CFR 50, Appendix A, GDC 55, 56, and 57 Containment Isolation; containment flooding and drain; pipe break hazard analysis; NIST-1 test observation; range of reactor recirculation valve opening; containment stratification; and containment nodalization. | |||
The NRC staff had numerous (more than 100) interactions with NuScale, including teleconferences, test observations, and face-to-face meetings. The audit enhanced the NRC staffs review of the NuScale DCA by providing an opportunity to review non-docketed | |||
The NRC staff had numerous (more than 100) interactions with NuScale, including teleconferences, test observations, and face-to-face meetings. The audit enhanced the NRC staffs review of the NuScale DCA by providing an opportunity to review non-docketed | |||
supporting design information that was not submitted with the DCA. Specifically, the audit documents that were made available to the NRC staff for review have enabled the staff to efficiently obtain the information that they need in order to continue their review and prepare their safety evaluation report. Furthermore, the audit allowed the NRC staff to limit issuing requests for additional information (RAIs), as needed, to: | 3 supporting design information that was not submitted with the DCA. Specifically, the audit documents that were made available to the NRC staff for review have enabled the staff to efficiently obtain the information that they need in order to continue their review and prepare their safety evaluation report. Furthermore, the audit allowed the NRC staff to limit issuing requests for additional information (RAIs), as needed, to: | ||
Gain a better understanding of the detailed calculations, analyses and/or bases underlying the formal application and confirm the staffs understanding of the NuScale application. | |||
Identify additional information, necessary for the applicant to supplement its application, assisting the staff to reach a regulatory decision. | |||
Establish an understanding in an area where the staff has identified potential concerns, and in turn allow the staff to issue clear RAIs enabling the applicant to provide quality and timely responses. | |||
Enhance the staffs understanding of the NuScale design in support of making a regulatory decision. | |||
As stated in the June 28, 2018, addenda to the audit plan, the staffs supplemental containment audit involved three stages. Stage 1 included the staff visiting the NuScales NIST-1 testing facility in Corvallis, Oregon, and observing the HP-49 test. The HP-49 test was to show that NRELAP5 code was capable of appropriately modeling the containment thermal hydraulic phenomena that would result from an inadvertent RRV-opening event as the limiting liquid-space discharge event. NuScale has identified this as the limiting peak containment pressure design basis event in the design certification application. Stage 2 was to audit the raw HP-49 test data, which the staff conducted on August 7 and 8, 2018, at NuScales office in Rockville, Maryland. The main objective of Stage 2 was to verify the decay heat and peak containment pressure measurements at the NIST-1 test facility, and gather the initial conditions from the data set to be used in the staffs confirmatory NRELAP5 and TRACE calculations of the NIST-1 HP-49 test. The staff found that Stage 1 and Stage 2 audits met all stated objectives. Stage 3 is to audit NuScales HP-49 post-test assessment report. NuScale provided this report on its eRR for audit in mid-September and the staff is currently auditing it. The staff will provide more details about the audit activities related to Stages 1 through 3 in a final audit summary report after completing the containment audit. | As stated in the June 28, 2018, addenda to the audit plan, the staffs supplemental containment audit involved three stages. Stage 1 included the staff visiting the NuScales NIST-1 testing facility in Corvallis, Oregon, and observing the HP-49 test. The HP-49 test was to show that NRELAP5 code was capable of appropriately modeling the containment thermal hydraulic phenomena that would result from an inadvertent RRV-opening event as the limiting liquid-space discharge event. NuScale has identified this as the limiting peak containment pressure design basis event in the design certification application. Stage 2 was to audit the raw HP-49 test data, which the staff conducted on August 7 and 8, 2018, at NuScales office in Rockville, Maryland. The main objective of Stage 2 was to verify the decay heat and peak containment pressure measurements at the NIST-1 test facility, and gather the initial conditions from the data set to be used in the staffs confirmatory NRELAP5 and TRACE calculations of the NIST-1 HP-49 test. The staff found that Stage 1 and Stage 2 audits met all stated objectives. Stage 3 is to audit NuScales HP-49 post-test assessment report. NuScale provided this report on its eRR for audit in mid-September and the staff is currently auditing it. The staff will provide more details about the audit activities related to Stages 1 through 3 in a final audit summary report after completing the containment audit. | ||
As part of the evaluation of NuScales Exemption Request #7 on ILRT, staff issued RAI 9474 asking NuScale to show (through analysis, testing, or combination) that the maximum containment allowable leak rate is met and that containment leak tight integrity is restored after each refueling outage. Staff is currently evaluating NuScales RAI response, including a revised analysis provided in EC-A013-1691, Revision 2, on the eRR. The staff is also reviewing this analysis for the containment ASME III design, and ASME inspection of flange bolts 2-inch diameter and smaller. | As part of the evaluation of NuScales Exemption Request #7 on ILRT, staff issued RAI 9474 asking NuScale to show (through analysis, testing, or combination) that the maximum containment allowable leak rate is met and that containment leak tight integrity is restored after each refueling outage. Staff is currently evaluating NuScales RAI response, including a revised analysis provided in EC-A013-1691, Revision 2, on the eRR. The staff is also reviewing this analysis for the containment ASME III design, and ASME inspection of flange bolts 2-inch diameter and smaller. | ||
The June 28, 2017, addenda to the audit plan included containment isolation because of a staffs expectation that the audit may be needed to support reviewing NuScales response to RAI 8836, Question 3.6.2-2, which was expected later on August 30, 2018. This RAI response was delayed until December 2018. However, the staff does not foresee now any plan for using the present audit to support reviewing the RAI-8836 response. | The June 28, 2017, addenda to the audit plan included containment isolation because of a staffs expectation that the audit may be needed to support reviewing NuScales response to RAI 8836, Question 3.6.2-2, which was expected later on August 30, 2018. This RAI response was delayed until December 2018. However, the staff does not foresee now any plan for using the present audit to support reviewing the RAI-8836 response. | ||
V. CONCLUSION This audit is currently in progress and the NRC staff will issue a final audit summary report after completing the audit. | 4 V. | ||
CONCLUSION This audit is currently in progress and the NRC staff will issue a final audit summary report after completing the audit. | |||
==Attachment:== | ==Attachment:== | ||
Documents Audited by the Staff No. | Documents Audited by the Staff No. | ||
1 | File Document Name Rev. # | ||
1 00002090_1_RPV and CNV Flange Geometry Stud.pdf RPV and CNV Flange Geometry 1 | |||
2 32-9257575-000 NuScale Reactor Core Chemical Deposition Analysis.pdf NuScale Reactor Core Chemical Deposition Analysis 3 | |||
51-9257323-000 AIS for NuScale GSI-191 Evaluation.pdf AIS for NuScale GSI-191 Evaluation 4 | |||
DD-F010-4444_R0_Bioshield_Re-Design_to_Support_Environmental_Qu alification_Profile.pdf Bioshield Re-Design To Support Environmental Qualification Profile 0 | |||
5 DI-0303-51058_R0.pdf NIST-1 Data Processing for Code Assessment Purposes 0 | |||
6 EC_0000_3853_R1_Calcs_to_Support | |||
_NIST-1_Distortion_Analysis_and_Modeling_ | |||
of_Containment_and_Pool_Heat_Tran sfer Calculations to Support NIST-1 Distortion Analysis and Modeling of Containment and Pool Heat Transfer 1 | |||
7 EC_A013_00003036_01_CNV_Ultimat e_Pressure_Integrity_Analysis.pdf CNV Ultimate Pressure Integrity Analysis 1 | |||
8 EC_A013_3377_R0_CNV_Primary_Str ess_Analysis.pdf Primary Stress Analysis of the Containment Vessel 0 | |||
9 EC_B020_2877_R1 ECCS Combustible Gas Analysis.pdf ECCS Combustible Gas Analysis 1 | |||
10 EC_B020_4365_R0, Containment Gas Composition Calculation.pdf Containment Gas Composition Calculation 0 | |||
11 EC_F010_5233_00_CNV_Support_Int erface_with_RXB_Floor.pdf CNV Interface with RXB Floor 0 | |||
12 EC-0000-2250-R0_Feedwater_Piping_Failure_Analysi s.pdf Feedwater Piping Failure Analysis 0 | |||
13 EC-0000-2714-R0_Steam_System_Piping_Failure_An alysis.pdf Steam System Piping Failure Analysis 0 | |||
14 EC-0000-2786_R2_Failure_of_Small_Lines_Car rying_Primary_Coolant_Outside_Conta inment.pdf Failure of Small Lines Carrying Primary Coolant Outside Containment 2 | |||
15 EC-0000-4718_R0_GOTHIC_HELB_Cases_of_ | |||
NS_Top_of | |||
_Model_and_RXB_Pool_Room.pdf GOTHIC HELB Cases of NuScale Top of Module RXB Pool Room 0 | |||
No. | 2 No. | ||
16 | File Document Name Rev. # | ||
16 EC-0000-4720_R1_NS_High_Energy_Line_Bre ak_Scenario_Definition_Top_of_Modul e.pdf NuScale High Energy Line Break Scenario Definition - Top of Module 1 | |||
17 EC-0000-4721 1_GOTHIC_HELB_Causes_of_NS_To p_of_Module_and_RXB_Pool_Room GOTHIC HELB Cases of NuScale Top of Module RXB Pool Room 1 | |||
18 EC-0000-4745_R0_GOTHIC_HELIB_Cases_of_ | |||
NS_Top_of_Module_and RXB_Pool_Room_BioShield_Blowout_ | |||
Panels.pdf GOTHIC HELB Cases of NuScale Top of Module and RXB Pool Room with Bioshield Blowout Panels Design 0 | |||
19 EC-0000-4746_R0_GOTHIC_HELIB_Cases_of_ | |||
Revised_M&E_for_NS_Top_of_Modul e_and_RXB_Pool_Room.pdf GOTHIC HELB Cases of Revised M&E for NuScale Top of Module and RXB Pool Room 0 | |||
20 EC-0000-5435-R0_final.pdf Containment Pressure Initial Condition Sensitivity Calculations 0 | |||
21 EC-A010-2322-R3 Reactor Module Seismic Model.pdf Reactor Module Seismic Model 3 | |||
22 EC-A010-3559-R3 Reactor Module Seismic Calculation.pdf Reactor Module Seismic Calculation 3 | |||
23 EC-A010-4270-1.pdf Long Term Cooling Analysis 1 | |||
24 EC-A013-1691_R0 Containment Vessel Flange Bolting Calculation.pdf Containment Vessel Flange Bolting Calculation 0 | |||
25 EC-A013-2341 2 Contain Pressure Temperature Response Design Basis Events Analysis.pdf Containment Pressure and Temperature Response to Design Basis Events 2 | |||
26 EC-A013-2341_R1 Containment Pressure and Temperature Response Design Basis Events Analysis.pdf Containment Pressure and Temperature Response to Design Basis Events 1 | |||
27 EC-A030-4101, R0 Class 1 Piping Stress Analysis For RCS Discharge_Line.pdf Class 1 Piping Stress Analysis For RCS Discharge Line 0 | |||
28 EC-B060-4543 0.pdf GOTHIC Passive Cooling of NuScale Control Room Building 1 | |||
29 EC-B060-4544_ | |||
R0_GOTHIC_Passive_Cooling_Analys is_of_NS_RXB_Main_Pool_Room.pdf GOTHIC Passive Cooling Analysis of NuScale RXB Main Pool Room 1 | |||
30 EC-B175-3253_R0 Ultimate Heat Sink Boil Off Calculation.pdf Ultimate Heat Sink Boil Off Calculation 0 | |||
31 EC-F010-3108 Rev. 7.pdf Seismic Soil-Structure Interaction Analysis of NuScale Reactor Building for ISRS Generation 0 | |||
No. | 3 No. | ||
32 | File Document Name Rev. # | ||
Valves Design Spec | 32 ECN_A010_4189_R0_For EQ-A010-3642 Correction to Table 3-1.pdf Corrections to Table 3-1 Normal Operating Pressures and Temperatures for DHRS Lines (for EQ-A010-3642, 0) 0 33 ECN_A010_4575_R0 For EQ-A010-3642 Overpress Protect Require Steam Gen System Piping.pdf Revision of Overpressure Protection Requirements for Steam Generator System Piping (for EQ-A010-3642, 0) 0 34 ECN_A010_4614_R0 For EQ-A010-2224 2nd Systems Contain Isolat Valves Design Spec Term Change.pdf Secondary Systems Containment Isolation Valves Design Spec. | ||
Terminology Change (for EQ-A010-2224, 0) 0 35 ECN_A010_4981_R0 For EQ-A010-3642,RXM Class 1, 2, 3 Piping Design Spec. Terminology Change.pdf RXM Class 1, 2, 3 Piping Design Spec. Terminology Change (for EQ-A010-3642, 0) 0 36 ECN_A010_5024_R0 For EQ-A010-2224 Material Specification Update.pdf Material Specification Update (for EQ-A010-2224, 0) 0 37 ECN_B020_4991_R0 Add Evaluation of Hydrogen Mixing during ECCS operation.pdf Add Evaluation of Hydrogen Mixing during ECCS Operation (for EC-BZ020-4365, 0) 0 38 ECN_B020_5023_R0 For EQ-B020-2140 Material Specification Update.pdf Material Specification Update (for EQ-A010-2140, 2) 0 39 ECN_B030_4700_R0_For EQ-B030-2258 ASME Design Specs Decay Heat Removal System Actuat Valves.pdf ASME Design Specification for Decay Heat Removal System Actuation Valves (for EQ-B030-2258, 0) 0 40 ECN_B030_4849_R0_For EQ-B030-2258 Decay Heat Remov Actuat Valves Load Combin Changes.pdf Decay Heat Removal Actuation Valves Design Specification Terminology and Load Combination Changes (for EQ-B030-2258, 0) 0 41 ECN_B090_4290_Deisgn Solution for the HELB FR.pdf Design Solution for the HELB FR (for SD-B090-1680, 0) 0 42 ECN_B090_4436_Add Passive Vent requirement to the FS.pdf Add Passive Vent Requirements to the FS (for FS-B090-0533, 3) 0 43 ECN-0000_4908_R0 Containment Pressure and Temperature Updates ER-0000-4316.pdf Containment Pressure and Temperature Updates (for ER-0000-4908, 1) 0 44 ECN-0000-4968_R0 Update Appendix A Table A-1 Environmental Zones ER-0000-4316.pdf Update Appendix A Table A-1, Environmental Zones Required Update (for ER-0000-4316, 1) 0 45 ECN-0000-4998_R0 Various Updates to ER-0000-4316 Body, Figures and Tables.pdf Various Updates to ER-0000-4316 Body, Figures and Tables (for ER-0000-436, 1) 0 | |||
No. | 4 No. | ||
46 | File Document Name Rev. # | ||
46 ECN-0000-5032_R0 For ER-0000-3921 Reorganization of Chapter 5.0.pdf Reorganization of Chapter 5.0 (for ER-0000-3921, 0) 47 ECN-0000-5033_R0 For ER-0000-3921 Misc Wording Adjustments Licensing Purposes.pdf Miscellaneous Wording Adjustments for Licensing Purposes (for ER-0000-3921, 0) 0 48 ECN-0000-5036_R0 For ER-000-3921 Reorganization of Chapter 3.0.pdf Reorganization of Chapter 3.0 (for ER-0000-3921, 0) 0 49 ECN-A010-4742_R0 For EQ-A010-2224 ASME Design Specs Second Systems Contain Isolation Valves.pdf ECN for ASME Design Specification for Secondary Systems Containment Isolation Valves (for EQ-A010-2224, | |||
: 0) 0 50 ECN-A013-5079_R0 For EC-A013-2341 Additional M&E Tables for Licensing.pdf ECN for EC-A013-2341, 2 (Containment Pressure and Temperature Response to Design Basis Events) 51 ECN-A013-5131_R2 For EC-A013-2341 O-RELAP v1.3.0 input decks for mass unit conversion.pdf Adding M&E Tables for Licensing (for EC-A013-2341, 2) 0 52 ECN-B030-4744_R0 For EQ-B030-2258 ASME Design Specs Decay Heat Remov System Activat Valves.pdf ECN for ASME Design Specification for Decay Heat Removal System Actuation Valves (for EQ-B030-2258, | |||
: 0) 0 53 EC-T080-3822-R1.pdf NRELAP5 Assessment Against NuScale Separate Effects High Pressure Condensation Test Series NIST-1 HP-02 1 | |||
54 ED-F012-3661_ | |||
R2_BioShield_General_Arrangement_ | |||
and _Details.pdf BioShield General Arrangements Details 2 | |||
55 EQ_A010_00002235_01_ASME_Desi gn_Specification_for_Primary_System s_Containment_Isolation_Valves.pdf ASME Design Specification for Primary Systems Containment Isolation Valves 1 | |||
56 EQ_A011_00001775_01_ASME Design Specification for Reactor Pressure Vessel.pdf ASME Design Specification for Reactor Pressure Vessel 1 | |||
57 EQ_A013_00001826_01_ASME Design Specification for Containment_Vessel.pdf ASME Design Specification for Containment Vessel 1 | |||
58 EQ_B020_00002140_02_ASME_Desi gn_Specification_for_Emergency_Core | |||
_Cooling_Valvespdf ASME Design Specification for Emergency Core Cooling System Valves 2 | |||
59 EQ-A010-2224_R0 ASME Design Specification for Secondary System Containment Isolation Valves.pdf ASME Design Specifications for Secondary Systems Containment Isolation Valves 0 | |||
No. | 5 No. | ||
60 | File Document Name Rev. # | ||
60 EQ-A010-2235_R0 ASME Design Specification for Primary Systems Containment Isolation Valves.pdf ASME Design Specifications for Primary Systems Containment Isolation Valves 0 | |||
61 EQ-A010-3642_R0 ASME Design Specification for RXM Class 1 2 3 Piping.pdf ASME Design Specifications for RXM Class 1, 2, and 3 Piping 0 | |||
62 EQ-A013-5418 R0 - ASME Design Specification for Containment EPAs.pdf Design Specification for CNV Electrical Penetration Assemblies 0 | |||
63 EQ-B030-2258_R0 ASME Design Specification for Decay Heat Removal System Activation Valves.pdf ASME Design Specification for Decay Heat Removal System Actuation Valves 0 | |||
64 ER_A010_2009_4_NuScale__Reactor | |||
_Module_Design_Parameters.pdf NuScale Reactor Module Design Parameters 4 | |||
65 ER_A013_3246_R1 Containment Vessel Structural Eval for Combustible Gas.pdf Containment Vessel Structural Evaluation for Combustible Gas 1 | |||
66 ER_B020_4364_R0_GSI_191_Assess ment_of_Debris_Accumulation_on_P WR_Sump_Performance_Evaluation_ | |||
of_Ex_Vessel_and_In_Vessel GSI-191, Assessment of Debris Accumulation on Pressurized Water Reactor [PWR] Sump Performance - | |||
Evaluation of Ex-vessel and In-vessel Effects 0 | |||
67 ER_P000_7002_R0_PRA_Quantificati on_Notebook_.pdf Probabilistic Risk Assessment Quantification Notebook 0 | |||
68 ER_P010_7007_R0_Accident_Sequen ce_Analysis_Notebook_wECN.pdf Accident Sequence Analysis Notebook 0 | |||
69 ER_P010_7008_R0_Success_Criteria | |||
_Notebook_wECN.pdf Success Criteria Notebook 0 | |||
70 ER_P020_00004896_00_Severe_Acci dent_Selection_Methodology.pdf Severe Accident Selection Methodology 0 | |||
71 ER_P020_00004904_00_Hydrogen_D eflagration___Adiabatic_Isochoric_Co mplete_Combustion.pdf Hydrogen Deflagration-Adiabatic Isochoric Complete Combustion 0 | |||
72 ER_P020_7024_R0_Level_2_Probabili stic_Risk_Assessment_Notebook_wE CN Level 2 Probabilistic Risk Assessment Notebook 0 | |||
73 ER_P060_00007077_A_TRN_16T__G eneral_Transient_with_Two_Trains_of | |||
_DHRS__Reactor_Recirculation_Valve | |||
_Open__Loss_of_DC_Power_.pdf TRN-16T: General Transient with Two Trains of DHRS and Reactor Recirculation Valves Open (Loss of DC Power) | |||
A 74 ER_P060_4715_R0_TRN_07T__Gene ral_Transient_with_Stuck_Open_RSV_ | |||
and_No_Mitigation.pdf TRN-07: General Transient with Stuck Open Reactor Safety Valve and No Mitigation, from a PRA Level 2 Perspective 0 | |||
75 ER_P060_4724_R0 NuScale MELCOR Basemodel.pdf NuScale MELCOR Basemodel 0 | |||
No. | 6 No. | ||
76 | File Document Name Rev. # | ||
76 ER_P060_4748_R0_LEC_06T__RVV_ | |||
LOCA_with_No_Mitigation.pdf LEC-06T: Reactor Vent Valve LOCA with No Mitigation, from a PRA Level 2 Perspective 0 | |||
77 ER_P060_4749_R0_LCC_05T__Char ging_Line_Break_Inside_Containment | |||
_with_No_Mitigation.pdf LCC-05T: Charging Line Break Inside Containment with No Mitigation, from a PRA Level 2 Perspective 0 | |||
78 ER_P060_4750_00_LCU_03T__Uniso lated_Charging_Line_LOCA_Outside_ | |||
Containment, No_Mitigation.pdf LCU-03T: Unisolated Charging Line LOCA Outside Containment with No Mitigation, from a PRA Level 2 Perspective 0 | |||
79 ER_P060_4857_R0_LCC_05T__Char ging_Line_Break_Inside_Cntmt_Compl ete_ECCS_Failure_wECN.pdf LCC-05T: Charging Line Break Inside Containment with Complete ECCS Failure, from a PRA Level 2 Perspective 0 | |||
80 ER_P060_7047_R0_LCU_05T__Uniso l_Chging_LOCA_Outside_CNV_w_CF DS, ECCS.pdf LOU-05T: Unisolated Charging Line LOCA Outside Containment with CFDS and ECCS 0 | |||
81 ER_P060_7050_R0_LEC_09T__ECC S_Valve_LOCA_with_Charging_Injecti on.pdf LEC-09T: ECCS Valve LOCA with Charging Injection 0 | |||
82 ER_P060_7075_00_TRN_08T__Gene ral_Transient_RSVs_Fail_to_Open_No | |||
_Mitigation.pdf TRN-08T: General Transient with Reactor Safety Valves Failed to Open and No Mitigation 0 | |||
83 ER_P060_7076_R0_TRN_14A__Gene ral_Transient_with_Cycling_RSV__AT WS_.pdf TRN-14A: General Transient with Cycling Reactor Safety Valve (ATWS) 0 84 ER_P060_7082_R0_NRELAP5_PRA_ | |||
Base_Model.pdf NuScale NRELAP5 Probabilistic Risk Assessment Base Model 0 | |||
85 ER-0000-2486 4 Safety Analysis Analytical Limits report.pdf Safety Analysis Analytical Limits Report 4 | |||
86 ER-0000-2486 Revision 5.pdf Safety Analysis Analytical Limits Report 5 | |||
87 ER-0000-3921_R0 Long Term Core Cooling Methodology Report.pdf Long Term Core Cooling Methodology Report 0 | |||
88 ER-0000-4316_R1 Environ Service Conditions Electrical and Mechanical Equipment Qualification.pdf Environmental Service Conditions for Electrical and Mechanical Equipment Qualifications 1 | |||
89 ER-0000-4391 0_Mass_and_Energy_Release_and_C ontainment_Vessel_Pressure_and_Te mp_Response_Method Mass and Energy Release and Containment Vessel Pressure and Temperature Response Methodology 0 | |||
90 ER-A013-3246_R0 Containment Vessel Structural Eval for Combustible Gas.pdf Containment Vessel Structural Evaluation for Combustible Gas 0 | |||
No. | 7 No. | ||
91 | File Document Name Rev. # | ||
91 ER-A013-3635_R0 Containment System Failure Modes and Effects Analysis.pdf Containment System Failure Modes and Effects Analysis 0 | |||
92 ER-A013-4785 0.pdf 10 CFR 50 Appendix J Containment Leakage Testing Assessment 0 | |||
93 ER-P020-5092_Rev_0 Assessment of LRSAP for NuScale level 2 PRA.pdf Assessment of Low-Risk Severe Accident Phenomena for the NuScale Level 2 PRA 0 | |||
94 FS_B080_00000542_02_Control_Roo m_Normal_Ventilation.pdf Control Room HVAC System (CRVS) | |||
Functional Specification 2 | |||
95 MSS SDD SD-C010-1722 0 Main Steam System Design Description.pdf Main Steam System Design Description 0 | |||
96 OP-0000-10842_R0 Module Refueling Operations.pdf NuScale Model Refueling Operations 0 | |||
97 RP-1215-19690 - concept of automation.pdf Concept of Automation A | |||
98 SD_B090_00001680_R0_Reactor_Buil ding_HVAC_System_Design_Descripti on.pdf reactor Building HVAC System (RBVS) System Design Description 0 | |||
99 SDR-0615-15509_R4.pdf OSU NIST-1 Facility Description Report 4 | |||
100 SwUM-0304-15495 3 - NRELAP5 Version 1.3 Code Manual Appendix A - | |||
Input Requirements.pdf NRELAP5 Version 1.3 Input Data Requirements 3 | |||
101 TR-0216-21604.pdf Superseded Document NuScale Power Containment Vessel Integrated Leak Rate Testing Options 0 | |||
102 TR-0916-51502-P.pdf NuScale Power Module Seismic Analysis 0}} | |||
Latest revision as of 10:55, 5 January 2025
| ML18291B228 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | NuScale |
| Issue date: | 11/09/2018 |
| From: | Tabatabai-Yazdi O NRC/NRO/DLSE/LB1 |
| To: | Samson Lee NRC/NRO/DLSE/LB1 |
| Tabatabai-Yazdi O/NRO/415-6616 | |
| References | |
| Download: ML18291B228 (12) | |
Text
November 9, 2018 MEMORANDUM TO:
Samuel S. Lee, Chief Licensing Branch 1 Division of Licensing, Siting and Environmental Analysis Office of New Reactors FROM:
Omid Tabatabai, Senior Project Manager
/RA/
Licensing Branch 1 Division of Licensing, Siting and Environmental Analysis Office of New Reactors
SUBJECT:
U.S. NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION STAFF INTERIM AUDIT REPORT FOR CONTAINMENT AND VENTILATION SYSTEMS (DOCKET NO.52-048)
In March 2017, the U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) staff began a regulatory audit of certain documents of the NuScale Power, LLC (NuScale) design certification application (DCA) pertaining to the Containment and Ventilation Systems. The NRC staff issued its initial audit plan on March 29, 2017, and an addenda to the audit plan on June 28, 2018 (Agencywide Documents Access and Management System Accession Nos. ML17087A077 and ML18177A087). The intent of this audit, in part, was to gain a more detailed understanding of the NuScale design in technical areas associated with containment and ventilation systems and to identify information that will require docketing to support the basis of the regulatory decision.
This interim audit summary report documents the NRC staffs audit activities and progress from April 3, 2017 through August 31, 2018. The NRC staff conducted the audit in accordance with the Office of New Reactors (NRO) Office Instruction NRO-REG-108, Regulatory Audits.
Docket No.52-048
Enclosure:
- 1. NRC Staff Interim Audit Report for Containment and Ventilation Systems cc: NuScale DC ListServ CONTACT: Omid Tabatabai, NRO/DNRL 301-415-6616
- via email*
NRO-002 OFFICE NRO/DLSE/LB1: PM NRO/DLSE/LB1: LA*
NRO/DSRA/SCVB: BC*
NAME OTabatabai MMoore*
DJackson (HWagage for)
DATE 10/19/2018 10/22/2018 11/8/2018
1 U.S. NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION REGULATORY AUDIT OF CONTAINMENT AND VENTILATION SYSTEMS AS PART OF THE NUSCALE POWER, LLC DESIGN CONTROL DOCUMENT REVIEW INTERIM AUDIT
SUMMARY
REPORT FOR APRIL 3, 2017 THROUGH AUGUST 31, 2018 NRC Audit Team:
Hanry Wagage, NRO, Audit Lead Clinton Ashley, NRO Anne-Marie Grady, NRO Syed Haider, NRO Alfred Hathaway, RES Raul Hernandez, NRO Peter Lien, RES Shanlai Lu, NRO Jeffrey Schmidt, NRO Carl Thurston, NRO Boyce Travis, NRO Rebecca Karas, NRO, Branch Chief (Reactor Systems Branch)
Diane Jackson, NRO, Branch Chief (Containment Branch)
Mohsen Khatib-Rahbar, ERI (NRC Contractor)
Alfred Krall, ERI (NRC Contractor)
Zhe Yuan, ERI (NRC Contractor)
Omid Tabatabai, NRO, Senior Project Manager I.
AUDIT LOCATION AND DATES The U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) staff conducted the audit from NRC Headquarters in Rockville, Maryland, through NuScales electronic reading room (eRR) and also at (1) the NuScale Office at 11333 Woodglen Drive, Suite 205, Rockville, Maryland 20852 and (2) NuScale Integral System Test (NIST-1) facility located at Oregon State University in Corvallis, Oregon. This interim audit summary report is for the period of April 3, 2017, through August 31, 2018.
II.
Background and Audit Basis In a letter dated December 31, 2016, NuScale submitted to the U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) Revision 0 of the NuScale Standard Plant Design Certification Application (DCA) (Agencywide Documents Access and Management System (ADAMS) Accession No. ML17013A229). The NRC staff initiated this DCA review on March 27, 2017. NuScale submitted Revision 1 of DCA to the NRC on March 15, 2018 (ADAMS Accession No. ML18086A090). Application documents for the NuScale design are available at the NRC Website at https://www.nrc.gov/reactors/new-reactors/design-cert/nuscale/documents.html.
2 The intent of this audit, in part, was to gain a more detailed understanding of the NuScale design in technical areas associated with containment and ventilation systems and identify information that will require docketing to support the basis of the regulatory decision. The NRC staff issued an audit plan on March 29, 2017, and an addenda on June 28, 2017 (ADAMS Accession Nos. ML17087A077 and ML18177A087, respectively). The addenda narrowed the audit scope by limiting it to three specific areas: containment pressure analysis, containment integrated leakage rate testing (ILRT), and containment Isolation. This interim audit summary report has been prepared in accordance with NRO-REG-108, Regulatory Audits, Revision 0, April 2, 2009 (ADAMS Accession No. ML081910260).
III. DOCUMENTS AUDITED The NRC staff performed an audit of documents, as necessary, shown in the attachment.
IV.
Audit Activities and Summary of Findings The audit activities included the following review areas:
containment peak pressure analysis; containment heat removal; methodology of mass and energy release from the reactor coolant system; ASME qualification of the containment vessel; containment leak rate testing, including NuScale exemption request no. 7, 10 CFR 52, App. A, GDC 52 Containment Leakage Rate Testing; combustible gas control, including NuScale exemption request no. 2, 10 CFR 50.44 Combustible Gas Control; equipment survivability; containment isolation, including NuScale exemption request no. 9, 10 CFR 50, Appendix A, GDC 55, 56, and 57 Containment Isolation; containment flooding and drain; pipe break hazard analysis; NIST-1 test observation; range of reactor recirculation valve opening; containment stratification; and containment nodalization.
The NRC staff had numerous (more than 100) interactions with NuScale, including teleconferences, test observations, and face-to-face meetings. The audit enhanced the NRC staffs review of the NuScale DCA by providing an opportunity to review non-docketed
3 supporting design information that was not submitted with the DCA. Specifically, the audit documents that were made available to the NRC staff for review have enabled the staff to efficiently obtain the information that they need in order to continue their review and prepare their safety evaluation report. Furthermore, the audit allowed the NRC staff to limit issuing requests for additional information (RAIs), as needed, to:
Gain a better understanding of the detailed calculations, analyses and/or bases underlying the formal application and confirm the staffs understanding of the NuScale application.
Identify additional information, necessary for the applicant to supplement its application, assisting the staff to reach a regulatory decision.
Establish an understanding in an area where the staff has identified potential concerns, and in turn allow the staff to issue clear RAIs enabling the applicant to provide quality and timely responses.
Enhance the staffs understanding of the NuScale design in support of making a regulatory decision.
As stated in the June 28, 2018, addenda to the audit plan, the staffs supplemental containment audit involved three stages. Stage 1 included the staff visiting the NuScales NIST-1 testing facility in Corvallis, Oregon, and observing the HP-49 test. The HP-49 test was to show that NRELAP5 code was capable of appropriately modeling the containment thermal hydraulic phenomena that would result from an inadvertent RRV-opening event as the limiting liquid-space discharge event. NuScale has identified this as the limiting peak containment pressure design basis event in the design certification application. Stage 2 was to audit the raw HP-49 test data, which the staff conducted on August 7 and 8, 2018, at NuScales office in Rockville, Maryland. The main objective of Stage 2 was to verify the decay heat and peak containment pressure measurements at the NIST-1 test facility, and gather the initial conditions from the data set to be used in the staffs confirmatory NRELAP5 and TRACE calculations of the NIST-1 HP-49 test. The staff found that Stage 1 and Stage 2 audits met all stated objectives. Stage 3 is to audit NuScales HP-49 post-test assessment report. NuScale provided this report on its eRR for audit in mid-September and the staff is currently auditing it. The staff will provide more details about the audit activities related to Stages 1 through 3 in a final audit summary report after completing the containment audit.
As part of the evaluation of NuScales Exemption Request #7 on ILRT, staff issued RAI 9474 asking NuScale to show (through analysis, testing, or combination) that the maximum containment allowable leak rate is met and that containment leak tight integrity is restored after each refueling outage. Staff is currently evaluating NuScales RAI response, including a revised analysis provided in EC-A013-1691, Revision 2, on the eRR. The staff is also reviewing this analysis for the containment ASME III design, and ASME inspection of flange bolts 2-inch diameter and smaller.
The June 28, 2017, addenda to the audit plan included containment isolation because of a staffs expectation that the audit may be needed to support reviewing NuScales response to RAI 8836, Question 3.6.2-2, which was expected later on August 30, 2018. This RAI response was delayed until December 2018. However, the staff does not foresee now any plan for using the present audit to support reviewing the RAI-8836 response.
4 V.
CONCLUSION This audit is currently in progress and the NRC staff will issue a final audit summary report after completing the audit.
Attachment:
Documents Audited by the Staff No.
File Document Name Rev. #
1 00002090_1_RPV and CNV Flange Geometry Stud.pdf RPV and CNV Flange Geometry 1
2 32-9257575-000 NuScale Reactor Core Chemical Deposition Analysis.pdf NuScale Reactor Core Chemical Deposition Analysis 3
51-9257323-000 AIS for NuScale GSI-191 Evaluation.pdf AIS for NuScale GSI-191 Evaluation 4
DD-F010-4444_R0_Bioshield_Re-Design_to_Support_Environmental_Qu alification_Profile.pdf Bioshield Re-Design To Support Environmental Qualification Profile 0
5 DI-0303-51058_R0.pdf NIST-1 Data Processing for Code Assessment Purposes 0
6 EC_0000_3853_R1_Calcs_to_Support
_NIST-1_Distortion_Analysis_and_Modeling_
of_Containment_and_Pool_Heat_Tran sfer Calculations to Support NIST-1 Distortion Analysis and Modeling of Containment and Pool Heat Transfer 1
7 EC_A013_00003036_01_CNV_Ultimat e_Pressure_Integrity_Analysis.pdf CNV Ultimate Pressure Integrity Analysis 1
8 EC_A013_3377_R0_CNV_Primary_Str ess_Analysis.pdf Primary Stress Analysis of the Containment Vessel 0
9 EC_B020_2877_R1 ECCS Combustible Gas Analysis.pdf ECCS Combustible Gas Analysis 1
10 EC_B020_4365_R0, Containment Gas Composition Calculation.pdf Containment Gas Composition Calculation 0
11 EC_F010_5233_00_CNV_Support_Int erface_with_RXB_Floor.pdf CNV Interface with RXB Floor 0
12 EC-0000-2250-R0_Feedwater_Piping_Failure_Analysi s.pdf Feedwater Piping Failure Analysis 0
13 EC-0000-2714-R0_Steam_System_Piping_Failure_An alysis.pdf Steam System Piping Failure Analysis 0
14 EC-0000-2786_R2_Failure_of_Small_Lines_Car rying_Primary_Coolant_Outside_Conta inment.pdf Failure of Small Lines Carrying Primary Coolant Outside Containment 2
15 EC-0000-4718_R0_GOTHIC_HELB_Cases_of_
NS_Top_of
_Model_and_RXB_Pool_Room.pdf GOTHIC HELB Cases of NuScale Top of Module RXB Pool Room 0
2 No.
File Document Name Rev. #
16 EC-0000-4720_R1_NS_High_Energy_Line_Bre ak_Scenario_Definition_Top_of_Modul e.pdf NuScale High Energy Line Break Scenario Definition - Top of Module 1
17 EC-0000-4721 1_GOTHIC_HELB_Causes_of_NS_To p_of_Module_and_RXB_Pool_Room GOTHIC HELB Cases of NuScale Top of Module RXB Pool Room 1
18 EC-0000-4745_R0_GOTHIC_HELIB_Cases_of_
NS_Top_of_Module_and RXB_Pool_Room_BioShield_Blowout_
Panels.pdf GOTHIC HELB Cases of NuScale Top of Module and RXB Pool Room with Bioshield Blowout Panels Design 0
19 EC-0000-4746_R0_GOTHIC_HELIB_Cases_of_
Revised_M&E_for_NS_Top_of_Modul e_and_RXB_Pool_Room.pdf GOTHIC HELB Cases of Revised M&E for NuScale Top of Module and RXB Pool Room 0
20 EC-0000-5435-R0_final.pdf Containment Pressure Initial Condition Sensitivity Calculations 0
21 EC-A010-2322-R3 Reactor Module Seismic Model.pdf Reactor Module Seismic Model 3
22 EC-A010-3559-R3 Reactor Module Seismic Calculation.pdf Reactor Module Seismic Calculation 3
23 EC-A010-4270-1.pdf Long Term Cooling Analysis 1
24 EC-A013-1691_R0 Containment Vessel Flange Bolting Calculation.pdf Containment Vessel Flange Bolting Calculation 0
25 EC-A013-2341 2 Contain Pressure Temperature Response Design Basis Events Analysis.pdf Containment Pressure and Temperature Response to Design Basis Events 2
26 EC-A013-2341_R1 Containment Pressure and Temperature Response Design Basis Events Analysis.pdf Containment Pressure and Temperature Response to Design Basis Events 1
27 EC-A030-4101, R0 Class 1 Piping Stress Analysis For RCS Discharge_Line.pdf Class 1 Piping Stress Analysis For RCS Discharge Line 0
28 EC-B060-4543 0.pdf GOTHIC Passive Cooling of NuScale Control Room Building 1
29 EC-B060-4544_
R0_GOTHIC_Passive_Cooling_Analys is_of_NS_RXB_Main_Pool_Room.pdf GOTHIC Passive Cooling Analysis of NuScale RXB Main Pool Room 1
30 EC-B175-3253_R0 Ultimate Heat Sink Boil Off Calculation.pdf Ultimate Heat Sink Boil Off Calculation 0
31 EC-F010-3108 Rev. 7.pdf Seismic Soil-Structure Interaction Analysis of NuScale Reactor Building for ISRS Generation 0
3 No.
File Document Name Rev. #
32 ECN_A010_4189_R0_For EQ-A010-3642 Correction to Table 3-1.pdf Corrections to Table 3-1 Normal Operating Pressures and Temperatures for DHRS Lines (for EQ-A010-3642, 0) 0 33 ECN_A010_4575_R0 For EQ-A010-3642 Overpress Protect Require Steam Gen System Piping.pdf Revision of Overpressure Protection Requirements for Steam Generator System Piping (for EQ-A010-3642, 0) 0 34 ECN_A010_4614_R0 For EQ-A010-2224 2nd Systems Contain Isolat Valves Design Spec Term Change.pdf Secondary Systems Containment Isolation Valves Design Spec.
Terminology Change (for EQ-A010-2224, 0) 0 35 ECN_A010_4981_R0 For EQ-A010-3642,RXM Class 1, 2, 3 Piping Design Spec. Terminology Change.pdf RXM Class 1, 2, 3 Piping Design Spec. Terminology Change (for EQ-A010-3642, 0) 0 36 ECN_A010_5024_R0 For EQ-A010-2224 Material Specification Update.pdf Material Specification Update (for EQ-A010-2224, 0) 0 37 ECN_B020_4991_R0 Add Evaluation of Hydrogen Mixing during ECCS operation.pdf Add Evaluation of Hydrogen Mixing during ECCS Operation (for EC-BZ020-4365, 0) 0 38 ECN_B020_5023_R0 For EQ-B020-2140 Material Specification Update.pdf Material Specification Update (for EQ-A010-2140, 2) 0 39 ECN_B030_4700_R0_For EQ-B030-2258 ASME Design Specs Decay Heat Removal System Actuat Valves.pdf ASME Design Specification for Decay Heat Removal System Actuation Valves (for EQ-B030-2258, 0) 0 40 ECN_B030_4849_R0_For EQ-B030-2258 Decay Heat Remov Actuat Valves Load Combin Changes.pdf Decay Heat Removal Actuation Valves Design Specification Terminology and Load Combination Changes (for EQ-B030-2258, 0) 0 41 ECN_B090_4290_Deisgn Solution for the HELB FR.pdf Design Solution for the HELB FR (for SD-B090-1680, 0) 0 42 ECN_B090_4436_Add Passive Vent requirement to the FS.pdf Add Passive Vent Requirements to the FS (for FS-B090-0533, 3) 0 43 ECN-0000_4908_R0 Containment Pressure and Temperature Updates ER-0000-4316.pdf Containment Pressure and Temperature Updates (for ER-0000-4908, 1) 0 44 ECN-0000-4968_R0 Update Appendix A Table A-1 Environmental Zones ER-0000-4316.pdf Update Appendix A Table A-1, Environmental Zones Required Update (for ER-0000-4316, 1) 0 45 ECN-0000-4998_R0 Various Updates to ER-0000-4316 Body, Figures and Tables.pdf Various Updates to ER-0000-4316 Body, Figures and Tables (for ER-0000-436, 1) 0
4 No.
File Document Name Rev. #
46 ECN-0000-5032_R0 For ER-0000-3921 Reorganization of Chapter 5.0.pdf Reorganization of Chapter 5.0 (for ER-0000-3921, 0) 47 ECN-0000-5033_R0 For ER-0000-3921 Misc Wording Adjustments Licensing Purposes.pdf Miscellaneous Wording Adjustments for Licensing Purposes (for ER-0000-3921, 0) 0 48 ECN-0000-5036_R0 For ER-000-3921 Reorganization of Chapter 3.0.pdf Reorganization of Chapter 3.0 (for ER-0000-3921, 0) 0 49 ECN-A010-4742_R0 For EQ-A010-2224 ASME Design Specs Second Systems Contain Isolation Valves.pdf ECN for ASME Design Specification for Secondary Systems Containment Isolation Valves (for EQ-A010-2224,
- 0) 0 50 ECN-A013-5079_R0 For EC-A013-2341 Additional M&E Tables for Licensing.pdf ECN for EC-A013-2341, 2 (Containment Pressure and Temperature Response to Design Basis Events) 51 ECN-A013-5131_R2 For EC-A013-2341 O-RELAP v1.3.0 input decks for mass unit conversion.pdf Adding M&E Tables for Licensing (for EC-A013-2341, 2) 0 52 ECN-B030-4744_R0 For EQ-B030-2258 ASME Design Specs Decay Heat Remov System Activat Valves.pdf ECN for ASME Design Specification for Decay Heat Removal System Actuation Valves (for EQ-B030-2258,
- 0) 0 53 EC-T080-3822-R1.pdf NRELAP5 Assessment Against NuScale Separate Effects High Pressure Condensation Test Series NIST-1 HP-02 1
54 ED-F012-3661_
R2_BioShield_General_Arrangement_
and _Details.pdf BioShield General Arrangements Details 2
55 EQ_A010_00002235_01_ASME_Desi gn_Specification_for_Primary_System s_Containment_Isolation_Valves.pdf ASME Design Specification for Primary Systems Containment Isolation Valves 1
56 EQ_A011_00001775_01_ASME Design Specification for Reactor Pressure Vessel.pdf ASME Design Specification for Reactor Pressure Vessel 1
57 EQ_A013_00001826_01_ASME Design Specification for Containment_Vessel.pdf ASME Design Specification for Containment Vessel 1
58 EQ_B020_00002140_02_ASME_Desi gn_Specification_for_Emergency_Core
_Cooling_Valvespdf ASME Design Specification for Emergency Core Cooling System Valves 2
59 EQ-A010-2224_R0 ASME Design Specification for Secondary System Containment Isolation Valves.pdf ASME Design Specifications for Secondary Systems Containment Isolation Valves 0
5 No.
File Document Name Rev. #
60 EQ-A010-2235_R0 ASME Design Specification for Primary Systems Containment Isolation Valves.pdf ASME Design Specifications for Primary Systems Containment Isolation Valves 0
61 EQ-A010-3642_R0 ASME Design Specification for RXM Class 1 2 3 Piping.pdf ASME Design Specifications for RXM Class 1, 2, and 3 Piping 0
62 EQ-A013-5418 R0 - ASME Design Specification for Containment EPAs.pdf Design Specification for CNV Electrical Penetration Assemblies 0
63 EQ-B030-2258_R0 ASME Design Specification for Decay Heat Removal System Activation Valves.pdf ASME Design Specification for Decay Heat Removal System Actuation Valves 0
64 ER_A010_2009_4_NuScale__Reactor
_Module_Design_Parameters.pdf NuScale Reactor Module Design Parameters 4
65 ER_A013_3246_R1 Containment Vessel Structural Eval for Combustible Gas.pdf Containment Vessel Structural Evaluation for Combustible Gas 1
66 ER_B020_4364_R0_GSI_191_Assess ment_of_Debris_Accumulation_on_P WR_Sump_Performance_Evaluation_
of_Ex_Vessel_and_In_Vessel GSI-191, Assessment of Debris Accumulation on Pressurized Water Reactor [PWR] Sump Performance -
Evaluation of Ex-vessel and In-vessel Effects 0
67 ER_P000_7002_R0_PRA_Quantificati on_Notebook_.pdf Probabilistic Risk Assessment Quantification Notebook 0
68 ER_P010_7007_R0_Accident_Sequen ce_Analysis_Notebook_wECN.pdf Accident Sequence Analysis Notebook 0
69 ER_P010_7008_R0_Success_Criteria
_Notebook_wECN.pdf Success Criteria Notebook 0
70 ER_P020_00004896_00_Severe_Acci dent_Selection_Methodology.pdf Severe Accident Selection Methodology 0
71 ER_P020_00004904_00_Hydrogen_D eflagration___Adiabatic_Isochoric_Co mplete_Combustion.pdf Hydrogen Deflagration-Adiabatic Isochoric Complete Combustion 0
72 ER_P020_7024_R0_Level_2_Probabili stic_Risk_Assessment_Notebook_wE CN Level 2 Probabilistic Risk Assessment Notebook 0
73 ER_P060_00007077_A_TRN_16T__G eneral_Transient_with_Two_Trains_of
_DHRS__Reactor_Recirculation_Valve
_Open__Loss_of_DC_Power_.pdf TRN-16T: General Transient with Two Trains of DHRS and Reactor Recirculation Valves Open (Loss of DC Power)
A 74 ER_P060_4715_R0_TRN_07T__Gene ral_Transient_with_Stuck_Open_RSV_
and_No_Mitigation.pdf TRN-07: General Transient with Stuck Open Reactor Safety Valve and No Mitigation, from a PRA Level 2 Perspective 0
75 ER_P060_4724_R0 NuScale MELCOR Basemodel.pdf NuScale MELCOR Basemodel 0
6 No.
File Document Name Rev. #
76 ER_P060_4748_R0_LEC_06T__RVV_
LOCA_with_No_Mitigation.pdf LEC-06T: Reactor Vent Valve LOCA with No Mitigation, from a PRA Level 2 Perspective 0
77 ER_P060_4749_R0_LCC_05T__Char ging_Line_Break_Inside_Containment
_with_No_Mitigation.pdf LCC-05T: Charging Line Break Inside Containment with No Mitigation, from a PRA Level 2 Perspective 0
78 ER_P060_4750_00_LCU_03T__Uniso lated_Charging_Line_LOCA_Outside_
Containment, No_Mitigation.pdf LCU-03T: Unisolated Charging Line LOCA Outside Containment with No Mitigation, from a PRA Level 2 Perspective 0
79 ER_P060_4857_R0_LCC_05T__Char ging_Line_Break_Inside_Cntmt_Compl ete_ECCS_Failure_wECN.pdf LCC-05T: Charging Line Break Inside Containment with Complete ECCS Failure, from a PRA Level 2 Perspective 0
80 ER_P060_7047_R0_LCU_05T__Uniso l_Chging_LOCA_Outside_CNV_w_CF DS, ECCS.pdf LOU-05T: Unisolated Charging Line LOCA Outside Containment with CFDS and ECCS 0
81 ER_P060_7050_R0_LEC_09T__ECC S_Valve_LOCA_with_Charging_Injecti on.pdf LEC-09T: ECCS Valve LOCA with Charging Injection 0
82 ER_P060_7075_00_TRN_08T__Gene ral_Transient_RSVs_Fail_to_Open_No
_Mitigation.pdf TRN-08T: General Transient with Reactor Safety Valves Failed to Open and No Mitigation 0
83 ER_P060_7076_R0_TRN_14A__Gene ral_Transient_with_Cycling_RSV__AT WS_.pdf TRN-14A: General Transient with Cycling Reactor Safety Valve (ATWS) 0 84 ER_P060_7082_R0_NRELAP5_PRA_
Base_Model.pdf NuScale NRELAP5 Probabilistic Risk Assessment Base Model 0
85 ER-0000-2486 4 Safety Analysis Analytical Limits report.pdf Safety Analysis Analytical Limits Report 4
86 ER-0000-2486 Revision 5.pdf Safety Analysis Analytical Limits Report 5
87 ER-0000-3921_R0 Long Term Core Cooling Methodology Report.pdf Long Term Core Cooling Methodology Report 0
88 ER-0000-4316_R1 Environ Service Conditions Electrical and Mechanical Equipment Qualification.pdf Environmental Service Conditions for Electrical and Mechanical Equipment Qualifications 1
89 ER-0000-4391 0_Mass_and_Energy_Release_and_C ontainment_Vessel_Pressure_and_Te mp_Response_Method Mass and Energy Release and Containment Vessel Pressure and Temperature Response Methodology 0
90 ER-A013-3246_R0 Containment Vessel Structural Eval for Combustible Gas.pdf Containment Vessel Structural Evaluation for Combustible Gas 0
7 No.
File Document Name Rev. #
91 ER-A013-3635_R0 Containment System Failure Modes and Effects Analysis.pdf Containment System Failure Modes and Effects Analysis 0
92 ER-A013-4785 0.pdf 10 CFR 50 Appendix J Containment Leakage Testing Assessment 0
93 ER-P020-5092_Rev_0 Assessment of LRSAP for NuScale level 2 PRA.pdf Assessment of Low-Risk Severe Accident Phenomena for the NuScale Level 2 PRA 0
94 FS_B080_00000542_02_Control_Roo m_Normal_Ventilation.pdf Control Room HVAC System (CRVS)
Functional Specification 2
95 MSS SDD SD-C010-1722 0 Main Steam System Design Description.pdf Main Steam System Design Description 0
96 OP-0000-10842_R0 Module Refueling Operations.pdf NuScale Model Refueling Operations 0
97 RP-1215-19690 - concept of automation.pdf Concept of Automation A
98 SD_B090_00001680_R0_Reactor_Buil ding_HVAC_System_Design_Descripti on.pdf reactor Building HVAC System (RBVS) System Design Description 0
99 SDR-0615-15509_R4.pdf OSU NIST-1 Facility Description Report 4
100 SwUM-0304-15495 3 - NRELAP5 Version 1.3 Code Manual Appendix A -
Input Requirements.pdf NRELAP5 Version 1.3 Input Data Requirements 3
101 TR-0216-21604.pdf Superseded Document NuScale Power Containment Vessel Integrated Leak Rate Testing Options 0
102 TR-0916-51502-P.pdf NuScale Power Module Seismic Analysis 0