ML080450445

New England Coalition, Inc'S (NEC) Ninth Supplemental Disclosure Pursuant to 10 C.F.R. 2.336

ML080450445
Person / Time
Site:	Vermont Yankee
Issue date:	02/07/2008
From:	Tyler K New England Coalition, Shems, Dunkiel, Kassel, & Saunders, PLLC
To:	Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel
SECY/RAS
References
50-271-LR, ASLBP 06-849-03-LR, RAS 15072
Download: ML080450445 (29)

Text

CL4-5 /*_o7.ý-

DOCKETED USNRC February 7, 2008 (2:12pm)

UNITED STATES OFFICE OF SECRETARY RULEMAKINGS AND NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION ADJUDICATIONS STAFF Before the Atomic Safety and Licensinu Board In the matter of ENTERGY NUCLEAR VERMONT YANKEE, LLC ) Docket No. 50-271-LR and ENTERGY NUCLEAR OPERATIONS, INC. ) ASLB No.06-849-03-LR Vermont Yankee Nuclear Power Station )

License Renewal Application )

NEW ENGLAND COALITION, INC.'S (NEC) NINTH SUPPLEMENTAL DISCLOSURE PURSUANT TO 10 C.F.R. § 2.336 Pursuant to 10 C.F.R. § 2.336, New England Coalition, Inc. (NEC) hereby supplements its -disclosures with the attached document and updated privilege log.

February 7, 2008 New England Coalition, Inc.

by: .

Andrew Raubvogel!

Karen Tyler SHEMS DUNKIEL KASSEL & SAUNDERS PLLC For the firm Attorneys for NEC O~5 A" 0.2-

UNITED STATES NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION Before the Atomic Safety and Licensin, Board In the matter of )

ENTERGY NUCLEAR VERMONT YANKEE, LLC ) Docket No. 50-271-LR and ENTERGY NUCLEAR OPERATIONS, INC. ) ASLB No.06-849-03-LR Vermont Yankee Nuclear Power Station )

CERTIFICATE OF DISCLOSURE 1, Karen Tyler, being properly sworn, state the following to the best of my personal knowledge:

1. New England Coalition, Inc.'s disclosures are accurate and complete, pursuant to 10 C.F.R. § 2.336, as of February 7, 2008.

DATED at Burlington, Vermont this 7th day of February, 2008 by: 11 Karen Tyler Subscribed and sworn to before me this 7th day of February, 2008.

Clara Cavitt C

Notary Public My commission expires 0 /7

Page 1 of 2 ktyler@sdkslaw.com From: Noverflo@aol.com Sent: Friday, January 11,2008 12:26 PM To: JGR@nrc.gov Cc: KTYLER@SDKSLAW.com; dlochbaum@ucsusa.org; shadis@prexar.com

Subject:

Re: Questions & Comments - January 8, 2008 meeting with VY/Entergy Hi Jonathan, thanks for the presentation slides At the end of the subject meeting I submitted to you two hand written questions which I asked the SIA speaker who did not answer my questions. I am resubmitting these questions in case my handwriting was difficult to read.

At the meeting I also wanted to add a comment regarding Union of Concerned Scientists Dave Lochbaum's question relating to oxygen excursions but I was prevented from doing so by Entergy's lawyer who instructed Entergy not to reply to my questions.

My two questions are paraphrased below:

1. What data do you have, to support your statement that the heat transfer coefficients you used to determine the Green functions were conservative (slides 44 and 51) and what do you believe is the degree of conservatism?

2. Does the geometry of the nozzle in slide 9 represent the design geometry of the vessel nozzle or does it represent the "as installed geometry." You have indicated that the validity of the assumption that shear stresses can be neglected is very sensitive to the geometry. It is therefore important to ascertain that the dimensions you used to calculate pipe reactions and peak stress were obtained from the dimensionally correct construction documents and that they also reflect the dimensionally correct geometry at the onset of the extended life period.

Comment Regarding Dave Lochbaum's Question.

A proper NRC reply to Dave.s question is important for the following reasons:

1. The Environmental correction factor, Fen, varies exponentially with the oxygen content.

2. The experimental fit curve for Fen is based on only one data point at the very low end of the oxygen concentrations.

3. The fatigue usage of each transient is multiplied by its respective Fen. Since the final usage.

factors are a summation of these products for all transients over the 60 year period one must be assured that the correct oxygen for each transient was employed. This oxygen must reflect the 2/7/2008

Page 2 of 2 correct concentration at the surface of the given component in question at the time of the transient.

It is not clear at all the oxygen concentrations that are measured either daily or bi-weekly at some point in the plant represent the correct value that should be used by the Fen equation in its present form.

I would be grateful if the NRC address the above in the FSAR.

Sincerely, Joe Hopenfeld Start the year off right. Easy ways to stay in shape in the new year.

No virus found in this incoming message.

Checked by AVG Free Edition.

Version: 7.5.516 / Virus Database: 269.19.1/1219 - Release Date: 1/11/2008 10:19 AM 2/7/2008

/

UNITED STATES OF AMERICA NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION Before the Atomic Safety and Licensina Board In the Matter of )

)

Entergy Nuclear Vermont Yankee, LLC ) Docket No. 50-271-LR and Entergy Nuclear Operations, Inc. ) , ASLBP No. 06-849-03-LR

)

(Vermont Yankee Nuclear Power Station) )-

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I, Clara Cavitt, hereby certify that copies of NEW ENGLAND COALITION, INC.'S NINTH SUPPLEMENTAL DISCLOSURE AND CERTIFICATE OF DISCLOSURE in the above-captioned proceeding were served on the persons listed below, by U.S. Mail, first class, postage prepaid; by Fed Ex overnight to Judge Elleman; and, where indicated by an e-mail

.address below, by electronic mail, on the 7th day of FebruAry, 2008.

Administrative Judge Office of the Secretary Alex S. Karlin, Esq., Chair Attn: Rulemaking and Adjudications Staff Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Mail Stop: 0-16C1 Mail Stop T-3 F23 U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, DC 20555-0001 Washington, DC 20555-0001 E-mail: hearingdocket@nrc.gov E-mail: ask2@nrc.gov Sarah Hofmann, Esq.

Administrative Judge Director of Public Advocacy Thomas S. Elleman , Department of Public Service Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel 112 State Street, Drawer 20 5207 Creedmoor Road, #101 Montpelier, VT 05620-2601 Raleigh, NC 27612 E-mail: sarah.hofmann@state.vt.us E-mail: elleman@eos.ncsu.edu Lloyd B. Subin, Esq.

Office of Commission Appellate Adjudication Mary C. Baty, Esq.

Mail Stop: O-16C1 Office of the General Counsel U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Mail Stop 0-15 D21 Washington, DC 20555-0001 U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission E-mail: OCAAmail@nrc.gov Washington, DC 20555-0001 E-mail: lbs3@nrc.gov; mcb 1@nrc.gov Administrative Judge Dr. Richard E. Wardwell Anthony Z. Roisman, Esq.

Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel Mail Stop T-3 F23 National Legal Scholars Law Firm U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 84 East Thetford Road Washington, DC 20555-0001 Lyme, NH 03768 E-mail: rew@nrc.gov E-mail: aroisman(inationallegalscholars.com

Marcia Carpentier, Esq. David R. Lewis, Esq.

Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel Matias F. Travieso-Diaz Mail Stop T-3 F23 Pillsbury Winthrop Shaw Pittman LLP U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 2300 N Street NW Washington, DC 20555-0001 Washington, DC 20037-1128 E-mail mxc7@nrc.gov E-mail: david.lewis@pillsburylaw.com matias.travieso-diaz@pillsburylaw.com Peter C. L. Roth, Esq.

Office of the Attorney General 33 Capitol Street Concord, NH 03301 Peter.roth@doi.nh.gov SHEMS DUNKIEL KASSEL & SAUNDERS, PLLC b y:__ _

Clara Cavitt, for Andrew Raubvogel, Esq. and Karen Tyler, Esq.

91 College Street Burlington, VT 05401 802 860 1003 802 860 1208 (fax)

-* araubvogel@sdkslaw.com ktylergsdkslaw.com for the firm Attorneys for New England Coalition, Inc.

NEC Privilege Log Attorney. Work Document* Author Email Client Product Number Document Description/Title Date Name Title Job assignment Recipients Email attachment Privilege Privilege Karen Email re: Licensing Board. Tyler, Order - Vermont Yankee Hopenfeld, Expert witness Raymond Expert input to attorney work JH-1 License Renewal 10/12/2006 Joram PhD for NEC Shadis product. Yes Yes Hopenfeld, Expert witness Karen JH-2 Email re: Reply and References 10/11/2006 oram PhD for NEC Tyler None Yes Yes Email re: opposition to cont. 3 Hopenfeld, Expert witness Karen JH-3 reconsideration 10/10/2006 joram PhD for NEC Tyler None Yes Yes Karen Tyler, Hopenfeld, Expert witness Raymond Expert input to attorney work JH-4 Email re: Reply and References 10/9/2006 joram PhD for NEC Shadis product. Yes Yes Karen Email re: Comments on Tyler, Entergy Motion to dismiss and Hopenfeld, Expert witness Raymond Expert input to attorney work JH-5 list of references 10/9/2006 Joram PhD for NEC Shadis product'. Yes Yes Email re: Amendments Hopenfeld, Expert witness Karen JH-6 regarding CUFs 8/4/2006 joram PhD for NEC Tyler None Yes Yes Email re: Comments on Hopenfeld, Expert witness Karen JH-7 ENVY's Response 6/28/2006 Joram PhD for NEC Tyler None Yes Yes Email re: Comments on Hopenfeld, Expert witness Karen Expert input to attorney work JH-8 ENVY's Response 6/27/2006 Joram PhD for NEC Tyler product. Yes Yes Karen Tyler, Email re: Comments on Hopenfeld, Expert witness Raymond Expert input to attorney work JH-9 ENVY's Response 6/25/2006 Joram PhD for NEC Shadis product. Yes Yes Email re: Comments on Response to Summary Hopenfeld, Expert witness Karen JH-10 -Judgment 4/8/2007 Joram PhD for NEC Tyler None Yes Yes Email re: Comments on Response to Summary Hopenfeld, Expert witness Karen JH-11 Judgment 4/10/2007 Joram PhD for NEC Tyler None Yes Yes Karen Tyler, E-mail re: Contention 3 motion Hopenfeld, Expert witness Raymond Expert input to attorney work JH-12 for summary judgment 4/30/2007 Joram PhD for NEC Shadis product. Yes Yes JH-13 E-mail re: Vermont Yankee LR 5/11/2007 Hopenfeld, PhD Expert witness Karen Yes Yes 1 of 23

NEC Privilege Log Attorney Work Document Author Email Client Product Number Document Description/Title Date Name Title Job assignment Recipients Email attachment Privilege Privilege (Dkt No. 50-271-LR) Joram for NEC Tyler None Hopenfeld, Expert witness Karen JH-14 E-mail re: final declaration 5/9/2007 Joram PhD for NEC Tyler None Yes Yes E-mail re: NEC - VY Hopenfeld, Expert witness Karen H-1 Relicensing 5/18/2007 Joram PhD for NEC Tyler None Yes No E-mail re: Statement of Facts not in Dispute re NEC Contention 4 in VY License Hopenfeld, Expert witness Karen JH-16 Renewal... 5/31/2007 Joram PhD for NEC Tyler None Yes Yes Karen Tyler, E-mail re: Statement of Facts Raymond not in Dispute re NEC Shadis, Contention 4 in VY License Hopenfeld, Expert witness Ulrich Expert input to attorney work JH-17 Renewal... 5/31/2007 Joram PhD for NEC Witte product. Yes Yes Karen Tyler, Raymond E-mail re: Entergy Nuclear Shadis, Vermont Yankee, LLC, and Hopenfeld, Expert witness Ulrich JH-18 Entergy Nuclear Operations... 6/5/2007 Joram PhD for NEC Witte None Yes Yes Karen Tyler, Ronald Shems, Andrew Raubvogel, Raymond Shadis, Hopenfeld, Expert witness Ulrich JH-19 E-mail re: Entergy documents 6/17/2007 Joram PhD for NEC Witte None Yes Yes Ulrich Witte, E-mail re: documents Hopenfeld, Expert witness Raymond JH-20 associated with fatigue analysis 6/18/2007 joram PhD for NEC Shadis None No Yes E-mail re: documents Hopenfeld, Expert witness Ulrich JH-21 associated with fatigue analysis 6/18/2007 joram PhD for NEC Witte None No Yes 2 of 23

NEC Privilege Log Attorney Work Document Author Email Client Product Number Document Description/Title Date Name Title Job assignment Recipients Email attachment Privilege Privilege Hopenfeld, Expert witness Karen JH-22 E-mail re: NEC Contention 2 7/2/2007 Joram PhD for NEC Tyler None Yes Yes E-mail re: "Feedwater nozzle Finite Element Model & Heat Transfer Coefficients" VY- Hopenfeld, Expert witness Ulrich JH-23 10Q-301 7/4/2007 Joram PhD for NEC Witte None No Yes Karen Tyler, Ulrich Witte, Hopenfeld, Expert witness Raymond JH-24 E-mail re: NEC Contention 2 7/9/2007 Joram PhD for NEC Shadis Draft Hopenfeld Declaration Yes Yes Hopenfeld, Expert witness Karen JH-25 E-mail re: Contention 4 7/10/2007 Joram PhD for NEC Tyler None Yes Yes E-mail re: Declaration in Hopenfeld, Expert witness Karen JH-26 support of new Contention 2 7/10/2007 Joram PhD for NEC Tyler Draft Hopenfeld Declaration Yes Yes Memo to Karen Tyler re:

Comments on Entergy Summary Disposition - Hopenfeld, Expert Witness JH-27 Contention 4  ? Joram PhD for NEC Yes Yes Hopenfeld, Expert Witness Karen JH-28 E-mail re: Contention 2 7/11/2007 Joram PhD for NEC Tyler None Yes Yes Hopenfeld, Expert Witness Karen JH-29 E-mail re: Contention 2 7/12/2007 Joram PhD for NEC Tyler Draft Hopenfeld Declaration Yes Yes Karen Tyler, Raymond Shadis, Hopenfeld, Expert Witness Ulrich JH-30 E-mail re: Contention 4 7/14/2007 Joram PhD for NEC Witte Draft Hopenfeld Declaration Yes Yes Ulrich Witte, Raymond Shadis, Hopenfeld, Expert Witness Karen JH-31 E-mail re: Contention 4 7/14/2007 Joram PhD for NEC Tyler Draft Hopenfeld Declaration Yes Yes Hopenfeld, Expert Witness Karen JH-32 E-mail re: Contention 4 7/15/2007 Joram' PhD for NEC Tyler Draft Hopenfeld Declaration Yes Yes 3 of 23

NEC Privilege Log Attorney Work

.Document Author Email Client Product Number Document Description/Title Date Name Title Job assignment Recipients Email attachment Privilege Privilege Hopenfeld, Expert Witness Karen JH-33 E-mail re: Contention 4 7/15/2007 Joram PhD for NEC Tyler None Yes Yes Hopenfeld, Expert Witness Karen JH-34 E-mail re: Contention 4 7/16/2007 Joram PhD for NEC Tyler Draft Hopenfeld Declaration Yes Yes Hopenfeld, Expert Witness Karen JH-35 E-mail re: Contention 2 7/17/2007 Joram PhD for NEC Tyler None Yes Yes E-mail re: declaration re: Hopenfeld, Expert Witness Karen J1H-36 Contention 2 9/3/2007 Joram PhD for NEC Tyler HopenfeldDeclaration Yes Yes Hopenfeld, Expert Witness Ulrich JH-37 E-mail re: References 8/24/2007 Joram PhD for NEC Witte None No Yes Karen Tyler, Ulrich Witte, E-mail re: Revised New Hopenfeld, Expert Witness Raymond JH-38 Contention 2 8/28/2007 Joram PhD for NEC Shadis Hopenfeld Contention2F.doc Yes Yes E-mail re: revised new Hopenfeld, Expert Witness Karen JH-39 contention 2 8/30/2007 Joram PhD for NEC Tyler HopenfeldDeclaration.doc Yes Yes Hopenfeld, Expert Witness Karen JH-40 E-mail re: final declaration 8/31/2007 Joram PhD for NEC Tyler None Yes Yes E-rtiail re: Revised New Hopenfeld, Expert Witness Karen j-H-41 Contention 2 8/27/2007 Joram PhD for NEC Tyler None Yes Yes Ulrich Witte, Hopenfeld, Expert Witness Raymond JH-42 E-mail re: Discovery, issues 8/9/2007 oram PhD for NEC Shadis None No Yes E-mail re: Signature Page for Amended Contention 2 Reply Hopenfeld, Expert Witness Karen JH-43 Declaration 10/2/2007 Joram PhD for NEC Tyler Contention 2 Reply Yes Yes Hopenfeld, Expert Witness Karen JH-44 E-mail re: new Contention 2 9/30/2007 Joram PhD for NEC Tyler None Yes Yes Comments on Entergy's Hopenfeld, Expert Witness Karen JH-45 Revsied Contention 2 Answer 10/1/2007 Joram PhD for NEC Tyler None Yes Yes Karen Tyler, Hopenfeld, Expe rt Witness. Raymond JH-46 E-mail re: Required References 10/30/2007 Joram PhD for NEC Shadis REQReferences.doc Yes Yes 4 of 23

NEC Privilege Log Attorney Work Document Author Email Client Product, Number Document Description/Title Date Name Title Job assignment Recipients Email attachment Privilege Privilege Karen Tyler, Hopenfeld, Expert Witness Raymond 2007.09.06.OIG.audit-license-JH-47 E-mail re: NEC Contention 4 10/25/2007 Joram PhD for NEC Shadis renewal-program.pdf Yes Yes E-mail re: Amended Hopenfeld, Expert Witness Karen JH-48 Contention 2 Reply 10/25/2007 Joram PhD for NEC Tyler None Yes Yes Hopenfeld, Expert Witness Karen JH-49 E-mail re: Required References 11/6/2007 Joram PhD for NEC Tyler None Yes Yes E-mail re: January 8 NRC Mtg Hopenfeld, Expert Witness Karen JH-50 re: Contention 2A 1/9/2008 Joram PhD for NEC Tyler None Yes Yes E-mail re: January 8 NRC Mtg Joram Expert Witness Karen NRCPresentationforVY(01-JH-51 re. Contention 2A issues 1/8/2008 Hopenfeld PhD for NEC Tyler 08-2008).ppt Yes Yes Ronald Email re: Licensing Board Shems, Order - Vermont Yankee Expert witness Karen RJ-1 License Renewal 10/17/2006 Jones, Ross PhD for NEC Tyler None Yes Yes Email re: Licensing Board Order - Vermont Yankee Expert witness Ronald RJ-2 License Renewal 10/17/2006 Jones, Ross PhD for NEC Shems None Yes Yes Email re: Licensing Board Order - Vermont Yankee Expert witness Ronald RJ-3 License Renewal 10/17/2006 Jones, Ross PhD for NEC Shems None Yes Yes Ronald Email re: Licensing Board Shems, Order - Vermont Yankee Expert witness Karen Rjones-RJ-4 License Renewal 10/17/2006 Jones, Ross PhD for NEC Tyler VYreferences.doc Yes Yes Email re: Licensing Board Order - Vermont Yankee Expert witness Ronald RJ-5 License Renewal 10/12/2006. Jones, Ross PhD for NEC Shems None Yes Yes Email re: Licensing Board Order - Vermont Yankee Expert witness Ronald RJ-6, License Renewal 10/11/2006 Jones, Ross PhD for NEC Shems None Yes Yes Ronald Shems, Expert witness Karen RJ-7 Email re: experts 9/27/2006 Jones, Ross PhD for NEC Tyler None Yes Yes RJ-8 Email re: Licensing Board 9/22/2006 Jones, Ross PhD Expert witness Ronald None Yes Yes 5 of 23

NEC Privilege Log Attorney Work Document Author Email Client Product Number Document Description/Title Date Name Title Job assignment Recipients Email attachment Privilege Privilege Memorandum and Order - for NEC Shems Vermont Yankee License Renewal Proceeding Expert witness Ronald Rj-9 Email re: Quick question 8/24/2006 Jones, Ross PhD for NEC-. Shems None Yes Yes Expert witness Ronald RJ-10 Email re: Quick question 8/24/2006 Jones, Ross PhD for NEC Shems None Yes Yes Email re: Entergy Nuclear Vermont Yankee, LLC, and Entergy Nuclear Operations, Expert witness Ronald Appendix E to Entergy RJ-11 Inc. 7/29/2006 Jones, Ross PhD for NEC Shems Application Yes Yes Email re: Entergy Nuclear Vermont Yankee, LLC, and Entergy Nuclear Operations, Expert witness Ronald RJ-12 Inc. 7/29/2006 Jones, Ross PhD for NEC Shems None Yes Yes Email re: Licensing Board Order Vermont Yankee Expert witness Ronald RJ-13 License Renewal Proceeding 7/25/2006 Jones, Ross PhD for NEC Shems . None Yes Yes Email re: Licensing Board Order Vermont Yankee Expert witness Ronald USF&W letter RJ-14 License Renewal Proceeding 7/25/2006 Jones, Ross PhD for NEC Shems 3-06 re VY.doc Yes Yes FactSheet.3-Email re: Licensing Board 1199.2006.03.pdf; Order Vermont Yankee Expert witness Ronald Permit.3-1199.

RJ-15 License Renewal Proceeding 7/25/2006 Jones, Ross PhD for NEC Shems 2006.03.30.pdf Yes Yes Expert input to attorney work

.product; APPENDIX C.doc; Appendix Cover.doc; Appendix B.doc; Email re: Licensing Board Appendix A.doc; Order Vermont Yankee Expert witness Ronald ShadDecline RJ-16 License Renewal Proceeding 7/25/2006 Jones, Ross PhD for NEC Shems (Vernon-Turner).doc Yes Yes Email re: Licensing Board Order Vermont Yankee Expert witness Ronald RJ-17 License Renewal Proceeding 7/25/2006 Jones, Ross PhD for NEC Shems None Yes Yes Email re: Licensing Board Expert witness Ronald RJ-18 Order Vermont Yankee 7/25/2006 Jones, Ross PhD for NEC Shems None Yes Yes 6 of 23

NEC Privilege Log Attorney Work Document Author Email Client Product Number Document Description/Title Date Name Title Job assignment Recipients Email attachment Privilege Privilege License Renewal Proceeding Email re: Licensing Board Order Vermont Yankee Expert witness Ronald RJ-19 License Renewal Proceeding 7/24/2006 Jones, Ross PhD for NEC Shems None Yes Yes Email re: Licensing Board Order Vermont Yankee Expert witness Ronald RJ-20 License Renewal Proceeding 7/19/2006 Jones, Ross PhD for NEC Shems None Yes Yes Email re: Licensing Board Order Vermont Yankee Expert witness Ronald RJ-21 License Renewal Proceeding 7/19/2006 Jones, Ross PhD for NEC Shems None Yes Yes Email re: Water Contention Expert witness Ronald Expert input to attorney work RJ-22 reply2.doc 6/29/2006 Jones, Ross PhD for NEC Shems product. Yes Yes Email re: Water Contention Expert witness Ronald RJ-23 reply.doc 6/29/2006 Jones, Ross PhD for NEC Shems None Yes Yes Email re: Water Contention Expert witness Ronald RJ-24 reply.doc 6/29/2006 Jones, Ross PhD for NEC Shems None Yes Yes Email re: Water Contention Expert witness Ronald Expert input to attorney work RJ-25 reply.doc 6/29/2006 Jones, Ross PhD for NEC Shems product. Yes Yes Email re: Water Contention Expert witness Ronald RJ-26 reply.doc 6/29/2006 Jones, Ross PhD for NEC Shems None Yes Yes Email re: Water Contention Expert witness Ronald Expert input to attorney work RJ-27 reply.doc 6/28/2006 Jones, Ross PhD forNEC Shems product. Yes Yes Email re: Water Contention Expert witness Ronald Expert input to attorney work RJ-28 reply.doc 6/28/2006 Jones, Ross PhD for NEC Shems product. Yes Yes Email re: NEC/Biology Report Expert witness Ronald RJ-29 - Invoice 6/27/2006 Jones, Ross PhD for NEC Shems None Yes Yes Email re: NEC/Biology Report Expert witness Ronald RJ-30 - Invoice 6/23/2006 Jones, Ross PhD for NEC Shems None Yes Yes Email re: NEC/Biology Report Expert witness Ronald RJ-31 - Invoice 6/23/2006 Jones, Ross PhD for NEC Shems None Yes Yes Expert witness Ronald RJ-32 Email re: VY Hearing - 6/16/2006 Jones, Ross PhD for NEC Shems None Yes Yes Expert witness Ronald R -33 Email re: Vty Hearng 6/16/2006 Jones, Ross PhD for NEC Shems None Yes Yes Email re: NEC/Biology Report Expert witness Ronald RJ-34 - Invoice 5/25/2006 Jones, Ross PhD for NEC Shems Invoice-Rjones(052506).rtf Yes Yes RJ-35 Email re: NEC-Memo(riones)- 5/24/2006 Jones, Ross PhD Expert witness Ronald None Yes Yes 7 of 23

NEC Privilege Log Attorney Work Document Author Email Client Product Number Document Description/Title Date Name Title Job assignment Recipients Email attachment Privilege Privilege final for NEC Shems Email re: NEC-Memo(rjones)- Expert witness Ronald RJ-36 final 5/24/2006 Jones, Ross PhD for NEC Shems Jones Declaration Yes Yes Email re: NEC-memo(rjones)- Expert witness Ronald RJ-37 VTer4.doc 5/24/2006 Jones, Ross PhD for NEC Shems None Yes Yes Email re: NEC-memo(rj ones)- Expert witness Ronald RJ-38 Ver4.doc 5/24/2006 Jones, Ross PhD for NEC Shems None Yes Yes Ronald Shems, David Email re: NEC-memo(rjones)- Expert witness Mears; P. Expert input to attorney work RJ-39 Ver4.doc 5/24/2006 Jones, Ross PhD for NEC Parenteau product. Yes Yes Ronald Shems, Email re: NEC/Vermont David Yankee - updated biological Expert witness Mears; P. Expert input to attorney work RJ-40 report 5/24/2006 Jones, Ross PhD for NEC Parenteau product. Yes Yes Ronald Shems, Email re: NEC/Vermont David Yankee - updated biological Expert witness Mears; P. Expert input to attorney work RJ-41 report 5/24/2006 Jones, Ross PhD for NEC Parenteau product. Yes Yes Ronald Shems, David Email re: NEC/Vermont Expert witness Mears; P.

R)-42 Yankee - biological report 5/23/2006 Jones, Ross PhD for NEC Parenteau None Yes Yes Ronald Shems, David Email re: NEC/Vermont Expert witness Mears; P. Expert input to attorney work RJ-43 Yankee - biological report 5/23/2006 Jones, Ross PhD for NEC Parenteau product. Yes Yes Email re: NEC/Vermont Expert witness Ronald RJ-44 Yankee - biological report 5/23/2006 Jones, Ross PhD for NEC Shems None Yes Yes Email re: NEC/Vermont Expert witness Ronald RJ-45 Yankee - biological report 5/23/2006 Jones, Ross PhD for NEC Shems None Yes Yes RJ-46 Email re: Environmental 5/21/2006 Jones, Ross PhD Expert witndss Ronald None Yes Yes 8 of 23

NEC Privilege Log Attorney Work Document Author Email Client Product Number Document Description/Title Date Name* Title Job assignment Recipients Email attachment Privilege Privilege Report Attachment for NEC Shems Email re: Water Contention Expert witness Ronald Expert input to attorney work RJ-47 reply2.doc 6/29/2006 Jones, Ross PhD for NEC Shems product. Yes Yes Email re: Vermont Expert witness Ronald RJ-48 Yankee/NEC - biology 6/28/2006 Jones, Ross PhD for NEC Shems None Yes Yes Email re: Vermont Yankee Expert witness Ronald RJ-49 Affidavit 6/27/2006 Jones, Ross PhD for NEC Shems None Yes Yes Email re: Vermont Expert witness Ronald RJ-50 Yankee/NEC - biology 6/28/2006 Jones, Ross PhD for NEC Shems None Yes Yes Expert witness Ronald RJ-51 Email re: chemical enginieer 9/20/2006 Jones, Ross PhD for NEC Shems None Yes Yes Ronald Shems, Karen Tyler, Email re: Water Contention Expert witness Raymond Expert input to attorney work RJ-52 reply3.doc 6/29/2006 Jones, Ross PhD for NEC Shadis product. Yes Yes E-mail re: Statement of Facts not in Dispute re NEC Contention 4 in VY License Roisman, Attorney for VT Karen AR-1 Renewal Proceeding 6/5/2007 Anthony JD DPS Tyler None No Yes E-mail re: Statement of Facts not in Dispute re NEC Contention 4 in VY License Roisman, Attorney for VT Karen AR-2 Renewal Proceeding 6/1/2007 Anthony JD DPS Tyler None No Yes E-mail re: Statement of Facts not in Dispute re NEC Contention 4 in VY License Roisman, Attorney for VT Karen AR-3 Renewal Proceeding 6/1/2007 Anthony JD DPS Tyler None No Yes E-mail re: Statement of Facts Statement of Material Facts re not in Dispute re NEC Entergy's Motion for Contention 4 in VY License Roisman, Attorney for VT Karen Summary Disposition of AR-4 Renewal Proceeding 5/31/2007 Anthony D DPS Tyler NEC Contention 4.pdf No Yes Karen Tyler, NRC.Summary disposition Roisman, Attorney for VT Ronald denied Oyster Creek6 AR-5 E-mail re: VY License Renewal 7/3/2007 Anthony JD DPS Shems, 07.wpd No Yes 9 of 23

NEC Privilege Log Attorney Work Document Author Email Client Product Number Document Description/Title Date Name Title Job assignment Recipients Email attachment Privilege Privilege Sarah Hofmann Karen Tyler, joram Hopenfeld, E-mail re: Steam Dryer Shadis, Ronald Steamdryer RAI Review -

RS-1 Meeting 2004 5/9/2007 Raymond Shems 2004.pdf Yes Yes Karen Tyler, IR 07-26-2004 Joram REFUELING.pdf; IR 02 Hopenfeld, 2006 REFUELING.pdf; Shadis, Ronald NRC LTR 2 RE JEFFORDS RS-2 E-mail re: Contention 3 Draft 5/9/2007 Raymond Shems RE- CRACKS.pdf Yes Yes Karen Tyler, Joram Hopenfeld, E-mail re: Second Round Dryer Shadis, Ronald' IR 02-01-2006 RS-3 Cracks 5/8/2007 Raymond Shems REFUELING.pdf Yes Yes Karen Tyler, Joram Hopenfeld, Ronald Shems, E-mail re: Ans 2 Entergy Shadis, Ulrich Ans 2 Entergy statement of RS-4 Statements 6/5/2007 Raymond Witte facts.doc Yes Yes Joram Hopenfeld, Karen Tyler, E-mail re: HELB- Mihama, Shadis, Ulrich RS-5 Japan 6/5/2007 Raymond Witte in200608.HELB-JAPAN.doc Yes Yes J oram Hopenfeld, Davis Bessie CRDM Nozzle E-mail re: FENOC -Surprise Shadis, Karen Erosion Corrosion.doc; RS-6 FAC 6/5/2007 Raymond Tyler, in200608.HELB-JAPAN.doc Yes Yes 10 of 23

NEC Privilege Log Attorney Work Document Author Email Client Product Number Document Description/Title Date Name Title Job assignment Recipients Email attachment Privilege Privilege Ulrich Witte Ulrich Witte, Joram Hopenfeld, E-mail re: EPRI FAC Shadis, Karen RS-7 REPORT 6/5/2007 Raymond Tyler None Yes Yes Ulrich Witte, J oram Hopenfeld, Shadis, Karen RS-8 E-mail re: NUREG CR-5632 6/5/2007 Raymond Tyler NUREG-CR%205632.pdf Yes Yes Karen Tyler, Ronald Shems, E-mail re:Entergy Document Shadis, Ulrich RS-9 Production 6/29/2007 Raymond Witte None Yes Yes Joram Hopenfeld, Karen Tyler,"

E-mail re: HELB- 7vfihama, Shadis, Ulrich RS-10 Japan 7/13/2007 Raymond Witte in200608.HELB-JAPAN.doc Yes Yes Joram Hopenfeld, Karen Tyler, Davis Bessie CRDM Nozzle Shadis, Ulrich Erosion Corrosion .doc; RS-11 E-mail re: Contention 4 7/13/2007 Raymond Witte in200608.HELB-JAPAN.doc Yes Yes Joram Hopenfeld, Karen Tyler, Shadis, Ulrich RS-12 E-mail re: Contention 4 7/13/2007 Raymond Witte Draft Hopenfeld Declaration Yes Yes 11 of 23

NEC Privilege Log Attorney Work Document Author Email Client Product Number Document Description/Title Date Name Title Job assignment Recipients Email attachment Privilege Privilege Karen Tyler, Joram Hopenfeld, Ulrich Witte, Unanalyzed Condition I.doc; Shadis, Ronald Unanalyzed.doc; RS-13 E-mail re: Contention 4 7/16/2007 Raymond Shems hope_2004013.pdf Yes Yes Karen Tyler, Joram Hopenfeld, Andrew Raubvogel, E-mail re: revised new Shadis, Ulrich RS-14 Contention 2 9/4/2007 Raymond Witte Yes No Karen Tyler, Shadis, Ronald RS-15 E-mail re: Cooling Towers 8/30/2007 Raymond Shems RAI on CTs 08-29-07.doc Yes No Karen Tyler, 2007 08-30 Auto Scram E-mail re: 08/30/07 VY - Shadis, Ronald Turbine Valve Stop RS-16 EVENT REPORT 8/31/2007 Raymond Shems Closure.doc Yes No Joram Hopenfeld, Karen Tyler, E-mail re: Fwd: VY steam Shadis, Ulrich \YSteamDryerReport.7 RS-17 dryer report 8/2/2007 Raymond Witte 2007.pdf Yes No Statement of Position.doc; HopenfeldASLBTestimA.doc; NEC INITIAL POSITIONS RESPONSE.doe; E-mail re: ASLB EPU HOPENFELD Statement of Position & NEC Shadis, Karen DECLARATION.doc; RS-18 Response to Enter/Staff 8/2/2007 Raymond Tyler Hopenfeld Last Page.doc Yes No RS-19 E-mail re: Discovery Issues 8/9/2007 Shadis, Karen 1 - 2007 - 006 LR Inspection Yes Yes 12 of 23

NEC Privilege Log Attorney Work Document Author Email Client Product Number Document Description/Title Date Name Title Job assignment Recipients Email attachment Privilege Privilege Raymond Tyler, Report.pdf Joram Hopenfeld, Ulrich Witte, Andrew Raubvogel E-mail re: VY Cooling Tower Shadis, Karen RS-20 Incident 8/22/2007 Raymond Tyler None Yes No E-mail re: Entergy document Shadis, Ulrich RS-21 disclosures 9/24/2007 Raymond Witte None No Yes Joram Hopenfeld, Karen E-mail re: Questions about Tyler, Vermont Yankee's reactor Shadis, Ulrich 20080109-vy-ucs-nrc-nozzle-RS-22 vessel nozzle fatigue 1/09/2008 Raymond Witte fatigue.pdf No Yes Karen Tyler, E-mail re: Statement of Facts Raymond not in Dispute re NEC Shadis, Contention 4 in VY License Consultant for Joram UW-1 Renewal Proceeding 5/30/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Hopenfeld None Yes Yes Karen Tyler, Raymond Shadis, Joram Hopenfeld, E-mail re: Entergy statement of Consultant for Andrew Expert input to attorney work UW-2 facts 6/5/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Raubvogel product. Yes Yes Entergy's Answer to DPS Karen Notice of Intention to Tyler, Participate and Petition to Raymond Intervene.doc; 2006-06-22 Shadis, Answer 2 NEC Petition.doc; E-mail re: ASME XI Appendix Consultant for Joram Declaration ofjohn Hoffman UW-3 L 6/8/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Hopenfeld (2).pedf; VY LR Yes Yes 13 of 23

NEC Privilege Log Attorney Work Document Author Email Client Product Number Document Description/Title Date Name Title Job assignment Recipients Email attachment Privilege Privilege 092206mo4.doc; NEC Petition for Leave to Intervene 50-2712 OCR.pdf; index.htm; index.htm; 2006-06-2 NEC REPLY OCR pdf.pdf 2006-09 VY LR

.doc; NRC Staff Answer to DPS Petition to Intervene3.doc E-mail re: summary of my Consultant for Karen UW-4 priorities 6/8/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Tyler None Yes Yes Consultant for Karen UW-5 E-mail re: NUREG/CR-6934 6/8/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Tyler cr6934.pdf Yes Yes E-mail re: review of SIA Consultant for Karen UW-6 Fatigue Analysis 6/14/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Tyler VY-16Q-401rbredacted.pdf Yes Yes E-mail re: review of SIA Consultant for Karen UW-7 Fatigue Analysis 6/15/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Tyler None Yes Yes Consultant for Karen UW-8 E-mail re: motion for extension 6/15/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Tyler None Yes Yes Consultant for Karen UW-9 E-mail re: motion for extension 6/15/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Tyler None Yes Yes Consultant for Karen UW-10 E-mail re: motion for extension 6/16/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Tyler LR006619.pdf Yes Yes Draft Declaration of Ulrich Witte in support of motion to Consultant for Karen extend time with UW-11 E-mail re: review of declaration 6/18/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Tyler comments.doc Yes Yes Karen Tyler, Ronald Shems, Raymond Draft Declaration of Ulrich Shadis, Witte in support 6f motion to E-mail re: FR: review of Consultant for Andrew extend time with UW-12 declaration 6/18/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Raubvogel comments.doc Yes Yes Draft Declaration of Ulrich Consultant for UW-13 Witte 6/17/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC No Yes 14 of 23

NEC Privilege Log Attorney Work Document Author Email Client Product Number Document Description/Tide Date Name Title Job assignment Recipients Email attachment Privilege Privilege Joral E-mail re: documents "Hopenfeld, associated with SIA fatigue Consultant for Karen UW-14 analysis 6/18/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Tyler LR006468.pdf; LR006470.pdf Yes Yes Joram Hopenfeld, Karen E-mail re: documents Tyler, LR006482.pdf, associated with SIA fatigue Consultant for Raymond LR006491.pdf; UW-15 analysis 6/18/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Shadis LR006519.pdf; LR006271.pdf Yes Yes Joram E-mail re: documents Hopenfeld, associated with SIA fatigue Consultant for Karen UW-16 analysis 6/19/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Tyler LR006435.pdf Yes Yes Joram E-mail re: documents Hopenfeld, associated with SLA fatigue Consultant for Karen LR006477.pdf; UW-17 analysis 6/19/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Tyler LR006421.pdf; LR006528.pdf Yes Yes Karen Tyler, Joram Hopenfeld, E-mail. re: Contention 4 Consultant for Raymond UWV-18 extension 6/21/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Shadis None Yes Yes Karen Tyler, Raymond Shadis, Consultant for Joram UW-19 E-mail re: References 6/25/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Hopenfeld ACRS VY 2007t.pdf Yes Yes Karen Tyler, E-mail re: document review at Consultant for Raymond UW-20 VTY -6/26/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Shadis None Yes Yes documents associated with fatigue analysis from SIA; Consultant for Karen documents associated with UW-21 E-mail re: NEC Contention 2 7/2/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Tyler fatigue analysis from SIA Yes Yes 15 of 23

NEC Privilege Log Attorney Work Document Author Email Client Product Number Document Description/Title Date Name Title Job assignment Recipients Email attachment Privilege Privilege Consultant for Karen Expert input to attorney work UW-22 E-mail re: contention 3 7/2/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Tyler product. Yes Yes Consultant for UW-23 Memo re: Contention 3 Witte, Ulrich NEC No Yes E-mail re: Contention 3 Consultant for Karen Expert input to attorney work UW-24 Declaration 7/2/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Tyler product. Yes Yes Consultant for UW-25 Memo re: Contention 3 Witte, Ulrich NEC No Yes Draft Declaration of Mr. Ulrich Consultant for UW-26 K. Witte 6/2/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC No Yes Joram Hopenfeld, Consultant for Karen UW-27 E-mail re: Entergy documents 7/3/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Tyler LR001817.pdf Yes Yes Joram Hopenfeld, Consultant for Karen UW-28 E-mail re: Entergy documents 7/4/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Tyler None Yes Yes E-mail re: notice re: proprietary Consultant for Karen Expert. input to attorney work UW-29 documents 7/5/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Tyler product Yes Yes E-mail re: notice re: proprietary Consultant for Karen Expert input to attorney work UW-30 documents 7/5/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Tyler product Yes Yes E-mail re: Entergy document Consultant for Karen UW-31 production 7/5/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Tyler None Yes Yes Karen Tyler, Raymond Shadis, Consultant for Joram UW-32 E-mail re: Contention 4 7/9/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Hopenfeld None Yes Yes E-mail re: Entergy's Eighth Consultant for Karen UW-33 Supplemental 7/9/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Tyler None Yes Yes Joram Hopenfeld, Consultant for Karen UW-34 E-mail re: NEC Contention 2 7/9/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Tyler None Yes Yes UW-35 E-mail re: NEC Contention 2 7/9/2007 Witte, Ulrich Consultant for Joram LR006523.pdf Yes Yes 16 of 23

NEC Privilege Log Attorney Work Document Author Email Client Product Number Document Description/Title Date Name Title Job assignment Recipients Email attachment Privilege Privilege NEC Hopenfeld, Karen Tyler Joram Hopenfeld, Consultant for Karen UW-36 E-mail re: NEC Contention 4 7/9/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Tyler Draft Hopenfeld Declaration Yes Yes Consultant for Karen UW-37 E-mail re: Contentions 2, 4 7/11/2007. Witte, Ulrich NEC Tyler None Yes Yes Consultant for Karen UW-38 E-mail re: Contention 4 7/11/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Tyler! NUREG 1801 Excerpts Yes Yes Consultant for Karen Expert input to attorney work UW-39 E-mail re: Contention 4 7/11/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Tyler product Yes Yes Raymond Shadis, Consultant for Karen Expert input to attorney work UW-40 E-mail re: Contention 4 7/11/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Tyler product Yes Yes Consultant for Karen UW-41 E-mail re: Contention 4 7/12/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Tyler Draft Witte Declaration Yes Yes E-mail re: Entergy's 8th Consultant for Karen UW-42 Supplemental Disclosure 7/12/2007 \Witte, Ulrich NEC Tyl1r None Yes Yes E-mail re: FAC Inspection Consultant for Karen UW-43 Program 7/12/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Tyler None Yes Yes Consultant for Karen UW-44 E-mail re: Contention 4 7/12/2007 Witte, Ulrich- NEC Tyler None Yes Yes Karen Tyler, Joram Hopenfeld, Consultant for Raymond UW-45 E-mail re: Contention 4 7/13/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Shadis None Yes Yes Joram Hopenfeld, Karen Tyler, E-mail re: mass transfer Consultant for Raymond UW-46 coefficient for FAC 7/13/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Shadis None Yes Yes 17 of 23

NEC Privilege Log Attorney Work Document Author Email Client Product Number Document Description/Title Date -Name Title Job assignment Recipients Email attachment Privilege Privilege Karen Tyler, Consultant for Raymond UW-47 E-mail re: Contention 4 7/13/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Shadis None Yes Yes Consultant for Karen UW-48 E-mail re: Contention 4 7/13/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Tyler None Yes Yes Consultant for Karen UW-49 E-mail re: Contention 4 7/14/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Tyler None Yes Yes Consultant for Karen UW-50 E-mail re: Contention 4 7/14/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Tyler Draft Witte Declaration Yes Yes Consultant for Karen UW-51 E-mail re: Contention 4 7/14/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Tyler Draft Witte Declaration Yes Yes Consultant for Karen UW-52 E-mail re: Contention 4 7/15/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Tyler Draft Witte Declaration Yes Yes Consultanit for Karen UW-53 E-mail re: Contention 4 7/15/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Tyler Draft Witte Declaration Yes Yes Consultant for Karen UW-54 E-mail re: Contention 4 7/15/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Tyler None Yes Yes Consultant for Karen UW-55 E-mail re: Contention 4 7/15/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Tyler Nmp_2003003.pdf Yes Yes Karen Tyler, Consultant for Andrew UW-56 E-mail re: Contention 4 7/16/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Raubvogel Draft Witte Declaration Yes Yes LRPD-02 Rev 2 ARM eval Consultant for Karen for VY may 2006 UW-57 E-mail re: Contention 4 7/16/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Tyler 030771 001.pdf Yes Yes Consultant for Karen UW-58 E-mail re: Contention 4 7/16/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Tyler LR002895.pdf Yes Yes Consultant for Karen LR005942 -- SELF UW-59 E-mail re: Contention 4 7/16/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Tyler ASSESSMENT 2004.pdf Yes Yes Consultant for Karen UW-60 E-mail re: Contention 4 7/16/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Tyler nureg 1801 vol 2 rev. 1.pdf Yes Yes Consultant for Karen UW-61 E-mail re: Contention 4 7/16/2007 "Witte, Ulrich NEC Tyler None Yes Yes Consultant for Karen UW-62 E-mail re: Contention 4 7/16/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Tyler None Yes Yes 18 of 23

NEC Privilege Log Attorney Work Document Author Email Client Product Number Document Description/Title Date Name Title Job assignment Recipients Email attachment Privilege Privilege Consultant for Karen UV-63 E-mail re: Contention 4 7/16/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Tyler None Yes Yes Consultant for Karen UW-64 E-mail re: Contention 4 7/16/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Tyler Draft Witte Declaration Yes Yes Consultant for Karen UW-65 E-mail re: Contention 4 7/16/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Tyler Draft Witte Declaration Yes Yes Consultant for Karen UW-66 E-mail re: Contention 4 7/16/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Tyler Draft Witte Declaration Yes Yes Consultant for Karen UW-67 E-mail re: Contention 4 7/16/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Tyler Draft Witte Declaration Yes Yes Karen Tyler, Consultant for Andrew UW-68 E-mail re: Contention 4 7/16/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Raubvogel None Yes Yes Karen Tyler, Consultant for Andrew UW-69 E-mail re: Contention 3 7/17/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Raubvogel None Yes Yes Consultant for Karen UW-70 E-mail re: Contention 4 7/17/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Tyler None Yes Yes Consultant for Karen UW-71 E-mail re: Contention 3 7/18/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Tyler Draft Witte Declaration Yes Yes Karen Tyler, DRF ge dryer analysis Consultant for Andrew proprietyary 2005.pdf; Draft UW-72 E-mail re: Contention 3 7/19/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Raubvogel Witte Declaration Yes Yes Karen Tyler, DRF ge dryer analysis Consultant for Andrew proprietyary 2005.pdf; Draft UW-73 E-mail re: Contention 3 7/19/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Raubvogel Witte Declaration Yes Yes Consultant for Karen UW-74 E-mail re: Contention 3 7/19/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Tyler LR002112.pdf Yes Yes Consultant for Karen UW-75 E-mail re: Contention 3 7/19ý/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Tyler CR 2007-02133ocr.pdf Yes Yes Consultant for Karen UW-76 E-mail re: Contention 3 7/19/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Tyler Draft Witte Declaration Yes Yes UW-77 E-mail re: Contention 3 7/24/2007 Witte, Ulrich Consultant for Karen ATTACHMENT A.pdf; Yes Yes 19 of 23

NEC Privilege Log Attorney Work Document Author Email Client Product Number Document Description/Title Date Name Title Job assignment Recipients Email attachment Privilege Privilege NEC Tyler, engineering report rev 0 page Raymond 1.jpg; engineering report rev 0 Shadis, page 2 .jpg; engineering report Joram rev 0 page 3.jpg Hopenfeld; Andrew Raubvogel Joram Hopenfeld, Raymond Shadis, Consultant for Karen UW-78 E-mail re: Contention 3 7/25/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Tyler None Yes Yes Karen Tyler, Raymond Shadis, Consultant for Joram UW-79 E-mail re: Contention 3 7/26/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Hopenfeld None Yes Yes Joram Hopenfeld, Raymond' Shadis, Consultant for Karen UW-80 E-mail re: Contention 3 7/26/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Tyler None Yes Yes Karen Tyler, Andrew Raubvogel, Consultant for Raymond UW-81 E-mail re: Hearing preparation 7/27/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Shadis - None Yes Yes Consultant for Karen UW-82 E-mail re: Contention 3 7/31/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Tyler None Yes Yes Raymond Shadis, Karen E-mail re: article in Burlington Consultant for Tyler, UW-83 free press 8/27/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Andrew Burlington Free Press.pdf Yes Yes 20 of 23

NEC Privilege Log Attorney Work Document Author Email Client Product Number Document Description/Title Date Name Title Job assignment Recipients Email attachment Privilege Privilege Raubvogel Karen Tyler, Andrew Raubvogel, E-mail re: VY Document Consultant for Raymond UW-84 Review 8/27/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Shadis None Yes Yes Karen Tyler, Andrew Raubvogel, Joram Hopenfeld E-mail re: F\V: necessary Consultant for Raymond UW-85 references 8/28/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Shadis None Yes Yes Consultant for Joram UW-86 E-mail re: References 8/24/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Hopenfeld None No Yes Karen Tyler, Raymond Shadis, Joram Hopenfeld, Consultant for Andrew UW-87 E-mail re: Discovery issues 8/9/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Raubvogel None Yes Yes Joram Hopenfeld, Karen Tyler, Consultant for Raymond UW-88 E-mail re: Discovery issues 8/9/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Shadis None Yes Yes Raymond Shadis, Andrew Raubvogel, Karen E-mail re: FW: Contention 4 Consultant for Tyler, UW-89 msj 8/13/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Joram None Yes Yes 21 of 23

NEC Privilege Log Attorney Work Document Author Email Client Product Number Document Description/Title Date Name Title Job assignment Recipients Email attachment Privilege Privilege Hopenfeld

\VY-16Q-Andrew 303r0REDACTED.pdf; \Y-E-mail re: FW: Docket no. 50- Raubvogel, 16Q-401r0REDACTED.pdf; 271-LR --- challenge to the Consultant for Karen VY-16Q-UW-90 proprietary designations 8/17/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Tyler 404r0REDACTED.pdf Yes Yes Raymond Shadis, E-mail re: Entergy document Consultant for Karen UW-91 disclosures 9/25/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Tyler None Yes Yes Karen Tyler, Raymond Shadis, Joram Hopen feld, Ronald Shems, E-mail re: Entergy's document Consultant for Andrew UW-92 disclosures 9/13/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Raubvogel None Yes Yes Karen Tyler, Raymond Shadis, Joram Hopenfeld, Ronald E-mail re: Board Order re: Shems, Contention 3; Entergy Consultant for Andrew UW-93 document disclosures 9/13/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Raubvogel Yes Yes Karen Tyler, Raymond Shadis, Joram Hopenfeld, E-mail re: Entergy document Consultant for Ronald UW-94 disclosures 9/13/2007 Ulrich Witte NEC Shems, None Yes Yes 22 of 23

NEC Privilege Log I F Attorney Work Document Author Email Client Product Number Document Description/Title Date Name Title Job assignment Recipients Email attachment Privilege Privilege Andrew Raubvogel Karen Tyler, Raymond Shadis, Joram Hopenfeld, E-mail re: Board Contention Consultant for Andrew UW-95 2A Order 11/7/2007 Ulrich Witte NEC Raubvogel None Yes Yes Karen Tyler, Raymond Shadis, Joram.

Hopenfeld, Consultant for Andrew UW-96 E-mail re: Contention 2A 11/30/2007 Ulrich Witte NEC Raubvogel None Yes Yes Karen Tyler, Raymond Shadis, E-mail re: NRC Presentation Consultant for. Joram NRC Presentation for VY UW-97 for VY (01-08-2008) 1/9/2008 Ulrich Witte NEC Hopenfeld (01-08-2008).ppt Yes Yes Karen "

Tyler, Raymond Shadis, E-mail re: plain language Consultant for Joram UW-98 synopsis of 1/8 meeting 1/9/2008 Ulrich Witte NEC Hopenfeld None Yes Yes Raymond Shadis, Joram E-mail re: Questions about Hopenfeld, Vermont Yankee's reactor Consultant for Karen UW-99 vessel nozzle fatigue 1/9/2008 Ulrich Witte NEC Tyler None Yes Yes 23 of 23