ML073110425
| ML073110425 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Vermont Yankee  |
| Issue date: | 11/01/2007 |
| From: | Cavitt C, Tyler K New England Coalition, Shems, Dunkiel, Kassel, & Saunders, PLLC |
| To: | Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel |
| SECY RAS | |
| References | |
| 50-271-LR, ASLBP-06-849-03-LR, RAS 14629 | |
| Download: ML073110425 (24) | |
Text
43 1?+ qýA DOCKETED USNRC November 1, 2007 (4:21pm)
UNITED STATES OFFICE OF SECRETARY NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION' RULEMAKINGS AND ADJUDICATIONS STAFF Before the Atomic Safety and Licensina Board In the matter of )
ENTERGY NUCLEAR VERMONT YANKEE, LLC ) Docket No. 50-271-LR and ENTERGY NUCLEAR OPERATIONS, INC. ) ASLB No.06-849-03-LR Vermont Yankee Nuclear Power Station )
CERTIFICATE OF DISCLOSURE I, Karen Tyler, being properly sworn, state the following to the best of my personal knowledge:
.1. New England Coalition, Inc.'s disclosures are accurate; and complete, pursuant to 10 C.F.R. § 2.336, as of November 1, 2007.
DATED at Burlington, Vermont this 1st day of November, 2007 by:
Karen Tyler Subscribed and sworn to before me this 1st day of November, 2007.
&ýVý Clara Cavitt Notary Public My commission expires L5e y-C.2.
Tt~P-teL~ T~ -
UNITED STATES NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION Before the Atomic Safety and Licensing Board In the matter of ENTERGY NUCLEAR VERMONT YANKEE, LLC ) Docket No. 50-271-LR and ENTERGY NUCLEAR OPERATIONS, INC. ) ASLB No.06-849-03-LR Vermont Yankee Nuclear Power Station )
NEW ENGLAND COALITION, INC.'S (NEC)'SEVENTH SUPPLEMENTAL DISCLOSURE PURSUANT TO 10 C.F.R. § 2.336 Pursuant to 10 C.F.R. § 2.336, New England Coalition, Inc. (NEC) hereby supplements its disclosures with the attached updated privilege log.
November 1, 2007 New England Coalition, Inc.
by:
Andrew Raubvogel.
Karen Tyler SHEMS DUNKIEL KASSEL & SAUNDERS PLLC For the firm Attorneys for NEC
'I NEC Privilege Log Document Attorney Work Author Email Client Product Number Document Description/Title Date Name Title Job assignment Recipients Email attachment Privilege Privilege Karen Email re: Licensing Board Tyler, Order - Vermont Yankee Hopenfeld, Expert witness Raymond Expert input to attorney work J1-I1 License Renewal 10/12/2006 Jorami PhD for NEC Shadis product. Yes Yes
- Hopenfeld, Expert witness Karen H-2 Email re: Replyand References 10/11/2006 Jorami PhD for NEC Tyler None Yes Yes Email re: opposition to cont. 3 Hopenfeld, Expert witness Karen J--3 reconsideration 10/10/2006 Joram PhD for NEC Tyler None Yes Yes Karen Tyler, Hopenfeld, Expert witness Raymond Expert input to attorney work JH-4 Email re: Reply and References 10/9/2006. Joram PhD for NEC Shadis product. Yes Yes Karen Email re: Comments on Tyler, Entergy Motion to dismiss and Hopenfeld, Expert witness- Raymond Expert input to attorney work JH-5 list of references 10/9/2006 Joram PhD for NEC Shadis product. Yes . Yes Email re: Amendments/ Hopenfeld, Expert witness Karen J--6 regarding CUFs 8/4/2006 Joram PhD for NEC Tyler None Yes Yes Email re: Comments on. Hopenfeld, Expert witness Karen JH-7 ENVY's Response 6/28/2006 Jorami PhD for NEC Tyler *None Yes Yes Email re: Comments on Hopenfeld, Expert witness Karen Expert input to attorney work JH-8 ENVY's Response 6/27/2006. Jorain PhD for NEC Tyler product. Yes .Yes Karen Tyler, Email re: Comments on Hopen.feld, Expert witness Raymond Expert input to attorney work JH-9 ENVY's Response 6/25/2006 jorami PhD for.NEC' Shadis product. Yes Yes Email re: Comments on Response to Summary Hopenfeld, Expert witness Karen JH-10 Judgment 4/8/2007 Joram. PhD for NEC Tyler None Yes Yes Email re: Comments on Response to Summary Hopenfeld, Expert witness Karen JH-11 Judgment 4/10/2007 jorami PhD for NEC Tyler None Yes Yes Karen Tyler, E-mail re: Contention 3 motion Hopenfeld, Expert witness Raymond Expert input to attorneywork JH-12 for summary judgment 4/30/2007 Joram PhD for NEC Shadis' product. Yes Yes JH-13 E-mail re: Vermont Yankee LR 5/11/2007 Hopenfeld, PhD Expert witness Karen Yes Yes 1 of 22
NEC Privilege Log Document Attorney Work Author Email Client Product Number Document Description/Title Date Name Title Job assignment Recipients Email attachment Privilege Privilege (Dkt No. 50-271-LR) Joram for NEC Tyler None Hopenfeld, Expert witness Karen JH- 14 E-mail re: final declaration 5/9/2007 Joram PhD for NEC Tyler None Yes Yes E-mail re: NEC- VY Hopenfeld, Expert witness Karen JH- 15 Relicensing 5/18/2007 joram PhD for NEC Tyler None Yes No E-mail re: Statement of Facts not in Dispute re NEC Contention 4 inVY License Hopenfeld, Expert witness Karen JI-16 Renewal... 5/31/2007 joram PhD for NEC Tyler None Ye Yes Karen Tyler, E-mail re: Statement of Facts Raymond not in Dispute re NEC Shadis, Contention 4 in VY License Hopenfeld, Expert witness Ulrich Expert input to attorney work j1H- 17 Renewal... 5/31/2007 Joram- PhD -for NEC Witte product.' Yes Yes Karen Tyler, Raymond E-mail re: Entergy Nuclear Shadis, Vermont Yankee,. LLCQ and Hopenfeld, Expert witness Ulrich jJH- 18 Entergy Nuclear Operations... 6/5/2007- joramn PhD for NEC Witte None Yes Yes Karen Tyler, Ronald Shems, Andrew
- Raubvogel, Raymond Shadis, Hopenfeld, Expert witness Ulrich JH-19 E-mail re: Enterg, documents 6/17/2007 Joramn PhD for NEC Witte None Yes Yes Ulrich Witte, E-mail re: documents Hopenfeld, Expertwitness Raymond J1IH-20 associated with fatigue analysis 6/18/2007 Jorami PhD for NEC Shadis None No Yes E-mail re: documents. Hopenfeld, Expert witness Ulrich 11-1-21 associated with fatigue analysis 6/18/2007 Joran PhD for NEC Witte None No Yes 2 of 22
NEC Privilege Log Attorney Work Document Author Email Client- Product Number Document Description/Title Date Name Title Job assignment Recipients Email attachment Privilege Privilege Hopenfeld, Expert witness Karen JH-22 E-mail re: NEC Contention 2 7/2/2007 Joram PhD for NEC Tyler None Yes Yes E-mail re: "Feedwater nozzle Finite Element Model & Heat Transfer Coefficients" VY- Hopenfeld, Expert witness. Ulrich JH-23 10Q-301 7/4/2007 Joram PhD for NEC Witte None No Yes Karen Tyler, Ulrich Witte, Hopenfeld, Expert witness Raymond JH-24 E-mail re: NEC Contention.2 7/9/2007 joram PhD for NEC Shadis Draft Hopenfeld Declaration Yes Yes Hopenfeld, Expert witness Karen JH-25 E-mail re: Contention 4 7/10/2007 Joram PhD for NEC Tyler None Yes Yes E-mail re: Declaration in Hopenfeld, Expert witness Karen JH-26 support of new Contention 2 7/10/2007 Joram PhD for NEC Tyler Draft Hopenfeld Declaration Yes Yes Memo to Karen Tyler re:
Comments on Entergy-Summary Disposition - Hopenfeld, Expert Witness J-I-27 Contention 4. Joram PhD forNEC Yes Yes Hopenfeld, Expert Witness Karen JH-28 E-mail re: Contention 2 7/11/2007 joram PhD for NEC Tyler None Yes Yes Hopenfeld,. Expert Witness Karen JH-29 E-mail re: Contention 2 7/12/2007 Joram PhD for NEC Tyler Draft Hopenfeld Declaration Yes Yes Karen-Tyler, Raymond Shadis, Hopenfeld, Expert Witness Urich JH-30 E-mail re: Contention 4. 7/14/2007 Joram PhD 'for NEC Witte Draft Hopenfeld Declaration Yes Yes Ulrich I Witte, Raymond Shadis, Hopenfeld, Expert Witness Karen jH-31 E-mail re: Contention 4 7/14/2007 Joram PhD for NEC Tyler Draft Hopenfeld Declaration Yes Yes Hopenfeld, Expert Witness Karen H-32 *E-mail re: Contention 4 7/15/2007 joram PhD for NEC Tyler Draft Hopenfeld Declaration Yes Yes 3 of 22
NEC Privilege Log Attorney Work Document Author Email Client Product Number Document Description/Title Date Name Title Job assignment Recipients Email attachment Privilege Privilege Hopenfeld, Expert Witness Karen
_JH-33 E-mal re: Contention 4 7/15/2007 Joram PhD for NEC Tyler, None Yes Yes Hopenfeld, Expert Witness Karen J--34 E-mail re; Contention 4 7/16/2007 joram PhD for NEC Tyler Draft Hopenfeld Declaration Yes Yes Hopenfeld, Expert Witness Karen jJ--35 E-mail re: Contention 2 7/17/2007 oram PhD for NEC Tyler None Yes Yes E-mail re: declaration re: Hopenfeld, Expert Witness Karen JH-36 Contention 2 9/3/2007 Joram. PhD. for NEC Tyler HopenfeldDeclaration Yes Yes Hopenfeld, Expert Witness Ulrich JH-37 E-mail re: References 8/24/2007 Joram PhD for NEC Witte None No Yes Karen Tyler, Ulrich Winte, E-mail re: Revised New Hopenfeld, Expert Witness. Raymond JH-38 Contention 2 8/28/2007 Joram PhD for NEC Shadis Hopenfeld Contention2F.doc Yes Yes E-mail re: revised new " Hopenfeld, Expert Witness Karen JH-39 " conteintion 2 8/30/2007 joram. PhD for NEC . Tyler HopenfeldDeclaration.doc Yes Yes Hopenfeld, Expert Witness. Karen JH-40 E-mail re: final declaration 8/31/2007 joram PhD for NEC Tyler None Yes Yes E-mail re: Revised New . Hopenfeld, Expert Witness Karen.
JH-41 Contention 2 8/27/2007 Joram PhD for NEC Tyler None Yes Yes Ulrich Witte, Hopenfeld, Expert Witness Raymond JH-42 E-mail re: Discovery issues .8/9/2007 Joram PhD for NEC Shadis None No Yes E-mail re: Signature Page for Amended Contention 2 Reply Hopenfeld, Expert Witness Karen JH-43 Declaration 10/2/2007 Joram. PhD. for NEC Tyler. Contention 2 Reply Yes Yes Hopenfeld, Expert Witness Karen
-44 E-mail re: new Contention 2 9/30/2007 Joram PhD for NEC Tyler None . Yes Yes HComments on Entergy's Hopenfeld, Expert Witness Karen H-45 Revsied Contention 2 Answer 10/1/2007 Joram PhD for NEC Tyler None Yes Yes Karen Tyler, Hopenfeld, Expert Witness Raymond JH-46 E-mail re: Required References 10/30/2007 Joram PhD for NEC Shadis REQReferences.doc Yes Yes 4 of 22
NEC Privilege Log Document Attorney Work Author Email Client Product Number Document Description/Title Date Name Title Job assignment Recipients Email attachment Privilege Privilege Karen Tyler, Hopenfeld, Expert Witness Raymond 2007.09.06.OIG.audit-license-JH-47 E-mail re: NEC Contention 4 10/25/2007 Joram PhD for NEC Shadis renewal-program.pdf Yes Yes E-mail re: Amended Hopenfeld, Expert Witness Karen JH-48 Contention 2 Reply 10/25/2007 Joram PhD for NEC Tyler None Yes Yes Ronald Email re: Licensing Board Shems, Order- Vermont Yankee Expert witness Karen RjI- License Renewal 10/17/2006 Jones, Ross PhD for NEC Tyler None Yes Yes Email re: Licensing Board Order - Vermont Yankee Expert witness Ronald RJ-2 License Renewal 10/17/2006 Jones, Ross -PhD for NEC Shems None Yes Yes Email re: Licensing Board Order - Vermont Yankee Expert witness Ronald RJ-3 License Renewal 10/17/2006 Jones, Ross PhD for NEC Shems None Yes Yes Ronald Email re: Licensing Board Shems, Order - Vermont Yankee Expert witness Karen Rjones-RJ-4 License Renewal 10/17/2006 Jones, Ross PhD for NEC Tyler VYreferences.doc Yes Yes Email re: Licensing Board Order - Vermont Yankee Expert witness Ronald RJ-5 License Renewal 10/12/2006 Jones, Ross PhD for NEC Shems None Yes Yes Email re: Licensing Board Order - Vermont Yankee Expert witness Ronald RJ-6 License Renewal 10/11/2006 Jones, Ross PhD for NEC Shems None Yes Yes Ronald Shems, Expert witness. Karen Rj-7 Email re: experts 9/27/2006 Jones, Ross PhD for NEC Tyler None Yes Yes Email re: Licensing Board Memorandum and Order -
Vermont Yankee License Expert witness Ronald RJ-8 Renewal Proceeding 9/22/2006 Jones, Ross PhD for NEC Shems None Yes Yes Expert witness Ronald RJ-9 Email re: Quick question 8/24/2006 Jones, Ross PhD for NEC Shems None Yes Yes RJ-10 Email re: Quick question 8/24/2006 Jones, Ross PhD Expert.witness Ronald None Yes Yes 5 of 22
NEC Privilege Log Attorney Work Document Author Email Client Product Number Document Description/Title Date Name Title job assignment Recipients Email attachment Privilege Privilege for NEC Shems Email re: Entergy Nuclear Vermont Yankee, LLQý and Entergy Nuclear Operations, Expert witness Ronald Appendix E to Entergy
_- 11 Inc. 7/29/2006 .Jones, Ross PhD for NEC Shems Aplication Yes Yes Email re: Entergy Nuclear '
Vermont Yankee, LLQ, and Entergy Nuclear Operations, Expert witness Ronald RJ-12 Inc.' 7/29/2006 Jones, Ross PhD for NEC Shems None Yes Yes, Email re: Licensing Board Order Vermont Yankee Expert witness Ronald RJ- 13 License Renewal Proceeding 7/25/2006 Jones, Ross PhD for NEC Shems None Yes Yes.
Email re: Licensing Board Order Vermont Yankee Expert witness Ronald USF&W letter RJ- 14 License Renewal Proceeding 7/25/2006 Jones, Ross PhD .for NEC Shems 3-06 re VY.doc Yes Yes FactSheet.3-Email re: Licensing Board 1199.2006.03.pdf; Order Vermont Yankee Expert witness Ronald Permit.3-1199.
RJ- 15 License Renewal Proceeding 7/25/2006 Jones, Ross PhD for NEC Shems 2006.03.30.pdf Yes: Yes Expert input to attorney work product; APPENDIX C.doc; Appendix Cover.doc; Appendix B.doc; Email re: Licensing Board Appendix A.doc; Order Vermont. Yankee Expert witness Ronald ShadDecline RJ- 16 License Renewal Proceeding 7/25/2006 Jones, Ross PhD for NEC Shems (Vemon-Turner).doc Yes Yes Email re: Licensing Board Order Vermont Yankee. Expert witness Ronald RJ- 17 License Renewal Proceeding 7/25/2006 Jones, Ross PhD for NEC Shems None Yes Yes Email re: Licensing Board Order Vermont Yankee Expert witness Ronald Rj:18 License Renewal Proceeding 7/25/2006 Jones, Ross PhD for NEC Shems None Yes Yes Email re: Licensing Board
- Order Vermont Yankee Expert witness Ronald Rj- 19 License Renewal Proceeding 7/24/2006 Jones, Ross PhD for NEC Shems None Yes Yes RT-20 Email re: Licensing Boar 7/19/2006 Hones, Ross PhD Expert witness Ronald None Yes Yes 6 of 22
NEC Privilege Log Attorney Work Document Author
- Email Client Product Number Document Description/Title Date Name Title. Job assignment Recipients Email attachment Privilege Privilege Order Vermont Yankee for NEC Shems License Renewal Proceeding Email re: Licensing Board Order Vermont Yankee Expertwitness Ronald RJ-21 . License Renewal Proceeding 7/19/2006 Jones, Ross PhD for NEC Shems None Yes Yes Email re: Water Contention Expert witness Ronald Expert input to attorney work RJ-22 reply2.doc 6/29/2006 Jones, Ross PhD for NEC Shems product. Yes Yes Email re: Water Contention Expert witness Ronald RJ-23 reply.doc 6/29/2006 Jones, Ross PhD for NEC Shems None Yes Yes Email re: Water Contention Expert witness Ronald RJ-24 reply.doc 6/29/2006 Jones, Ross PhD for NEC Shems None Yes Yes Email re: Water Contention Expert witness Ronald Expert input to attorney work RJ-25 reply.doc 6/29/2006 Jones, Ross PhD for NEC Shems product. Yes Yes Email re: Water Contention Expert witness Ronald RJ-26 reply.doc 6/29/2006 Jones, Ross PhD for NEC Shems None Yes Yes Email re: Water Contention Expert witness Ronald Expert input to attorney work RJ-27 reply.doc " 6/28/2006 Jones, Ross PhD for.NEC Shems product. Yes Yes Email re: Water Contention Expert witness Ronald Expert input to attorney work RJ-28 reply.doc 6/28/2006 Jones, Ross PhD for NEC . Shems product. Yes Yes Email re: NEC/Biology Report Expert witness Ronald RJ-29 - Invoice 6/27/2006 Jones, Ross PhD for NEC Shems None Yes Yes Email re: NEC/Biology Report Expert witness Ronald RJ-30 - Invoice 6/23/2006 Jones, Ross PhD for NEC Shems None Yes Yes Email re: NEC/Biology Report Expert witness Ronald RJ-31 - Invoice 6/23/2006 Jones, Ross PhD for NEC Shems None Yes Yes Expert witness Ronald RJ-32 Email re: VY Hearing 6/16/2006 Jones, Ross PhD for NEC Shems None Yes Yes Expert witness Ronald RJ-33 Email re: VY Hearing " .6/16/2006 Jones, Ross PhD for NEC Shems None Yes Yes Email re: NEC/Biology Report Expert witness Ronald RJ-34 - Invoice, 5/25/2006 Jones, Ross PhD for NEC Shems Invoice-Rjones(052506).rtf Yes Yes Email re: NEC-Memo(rjones)- . Expert witness Ronald RT-35 final 5/24/2006 Jones, Ross PhD for NEC Shems None Yes Yes Email re: NEC-Memo(rjones)- Expert witness Ronald RJ-36 final 5/24/2006 Jones, Ross PhD for NEC Shems Jones Declaration Yes Yes Email re: NEC-memo(rjones)- Expert witness Ronald RJ-37, Ver4.doc 5/24/2006 Jones, Ross PhD for NEC Shems None Yes Yes 7 of 22
NEC Privilege Log Attorney Work Document Author Email Client Product Number Document Description/Title Date Name Title Job assignment Recipients Email attachment Privilege Privilege Email re: NEC-memo(rjones)- Expert witness Ronald RJ-38 Ver4.doc 5/24/2006 Jones, Ross PhD for NEC Shems None Yes Yes Ronald Shems, David Email re: NEGmemo(rjones)- Expert witness Mears; P. Expert input to attorneywork RJ-39 Ver4.doc 5/24/2006 Jones, Ross PhD for NEC Parenteau product. Yes Yes Ronald Shems, Email re: NEC/Vermont David Yankee - updated biological Expert witness Mears; P. Expert input to attorney work RJ-40 report 5/24/2006 Jones, Ross PhD for NEC Parenteau product. Yes Yes Ronald Shems, Email re: NEC/Vermont David Yankee - updated biological Expert witness Mears; P. Expert input to attorney work RJ-41 report 5/24/2006 Jones, Ross PhD. for NEC Parenteau product. Yes Yes Ronald Shems, David Email re: NEC/Vermont Expert witness Mears; P.
RJ-42 Yankee - biological report 5/23/2006 Jones, Ross PhD for NEC Parenteau None Yes Yes Ronald Shems, David Email re: NEC/Vermont Expert witness Mears; P. Expert input to attorney work RJ-43 Yankee - biological report 5/23/2006 Jones, Ross -- PhD for NEC Parenteau product. Yes Yes Email re: NEC/Vermont Expert witness Ronald RJ-44 Yankee - biological report 5/23/2006 Jones, Ross PhD for NEC Shems None Yes Yes Email re: NEC/Vermont Expert witness Ronald RJ-45 Yankee - biological report 5/23/2006 Jones, Ross PhD for NEC Shems None Yes Yes Email re: Environmental Expert witness Ronald RJ-46 Report Attachment 5/21/2006 Jones, Ross PhD for NEC Shems None Yes Yes Email re: Water Contention .Expert witness Ronald Expert input to attorney work RJ-47 reply2.doc 6/29/2006 Jones, Ross PhD for NEC Shems product. Yes Yes Email re: Vermont Expert witness Ronald RJ-48 Yank&e/NEC - biology 6/28/2006 Jones, Ross PhD for NEC Shems None Yes Yes 8 of 22
NEC Privilege Log Attorney Work Document Author Email Client Product Number Document Description/Title Date Name. Title Job assignment Recipients Email attachment Privilege Privilege Email re: Vermont Yankee Expert witness Ronald RJ-49 Affidavit 6/27/2006 Jones, Ross PhD for NEC Shems None Yes Yes Email re: Vermont Expert witness Ronald RJ-50 Yankee/NEC- biology 6/28/2006 Jones, Ross PhD for NEC Shems None Yes Yes Expert witness Ronald RJ-51 Email re: chemical engineer. 9/20/2006 Jones, Ross PhD forNEC, Shems None Yes Yes Ronald Shems, Karen Tyler, Email re: Water Contention Expert witness Raymond Expert input to attorney work RJ.52 reply3.doc 6/29/2006 Jones, Ross PhD for NEC Shadis product. Yes Yes E-mail re: Statement of Facts not in Dispute re NEC Contention 4 in VY License Roisman, Attorney for VT Karen AR-1 Renewal Proceeding 6/5/2007 Anthony JD: DPS Tyler None No Yes E-mail re: Statement of Facts not in Dispute re NEC Contention 4 in VY License Roisman, Attorney for VT Karen AR-2 Renewal Proceeding 6/1/2007 Anthony D DPS Tyler None No Yes E-mail re: Statement of Facts notin Dispute re NEC.
Contention 4 in VY License Roisman, Attorney for VT Karen AR-3 Renewal Proceeding' 6/1/2007 Anthony JD DPS Tyler None No Yes E-miail re: Statement of Facts Statement of Material Facts re not in Dispute re NEC Entergy's Motion for Contention 4 in VY License Roisman, Attorney for VT Karen Summary Disposition of AR-4 Renewal Proceeding 5/31/2007 Anthony JD DPS Tyler NEC Contention 4.pdf' No Yes Karen Tyler,.
Ronald Shems, NRC.Summary disposition Roisman, Attorney for VT Sarah denied Oyster Creek6 AR-5 E-mail re: VY License Renewal 7/3/2007 Anthony JD DPS Hofmann 07.wpd No Yes Karen Tyler, E-mail re: Steam Dryer Shadis, . ". Joram Steamdryer RAI Review -
RS-I Meeting 2004, 5/9/2007 Raymond Hopenfeld, 2004.pdf Yes Yes 9 of 22
NEC Privilege Log Attorney Work.
Document Author Email Client Product Number Document Description/Title Date Name Title job assignment Recipients Email attachment Privilege Privilege Ronald
-_Shems Karen Tyler, IR 07-26-2004 Joram REFUELING.pdf; IR 02 Hopenfeld, 2006 REFUELING.pdf; Shadis, Ronald NRC LTR 2 RE JEFFORDS RS-2 E-mail re: Contention 3 Draft 5/9/2007 Raymond Shems RE- CRACKS.pdf Yes Yes Karen Tyler, Joram Hopenfeld, E-mail re: Second Round Dryer Shadis, Ronald IR 02-01-2006 RS-3 Cracks 5/8/2007 Raymond Shems REFUELING.pdf Yes Yes Karen Tyler, Joram Hopenfeld, Ronald Shems, E-mail re: Ans 2 Entergy Shadis, Ulrich Ans 2 Entergy statement of RS-4 Statements 6/5/2007 Raymond Witte facts.doc Yes Yes Joram Hopenfeld, Karen Tyler, E-mail re: HELB- Mihamna, Shadis, Ulrich RS-5 Japan 6/5/2007 Raymond Witte in200608.HELB-JAPAN.doc Yes Yes jor-am Hopenfeld, Karen Tyler, Davis Bessie CRDM Nozzle E-mail re: FENOC -Surprise Shadis, Ulrich Erosion Corrosion.doc; RS-6 FAC 6/5/2007 Raymond Witte in200608.HELB-JAPAN.doc Yes Yes Ulrich Witte, E-mail re: EPRI FAC Shadis, Joram RS-7 REPORT- 6/5/2007 Raymond Hopenfeld, None Yes Yes 10 of 22
NEC Privilege Log Attorney Work Document Author Email Client Product Number Document Description/Title Date Name Title job assignment Recipients Email attachment Privilege Privilege Karen
_____Tyler Ulrich Witte, Joramn.
Hopenfeld, Shadis, Karen RS-8 E-mail re: NUREG CR-5632 6/5/2007 Raymond Tyler NUREG-CR%205632.pdf Yes Yes Karen Tyler, Ronald Shems, E-mail re: EntergyDocument Shadis, Ulrich RS-9 Production 6/29/2007 Raymond Witte None Yes Yes Joram Hopenfeld, Karen Tyler, E-mail re: HIELB- Mihama, Shadis, Ulrich RS- 10 Japan 7/13/2007 Raymond Witte in200608.HELBJAPAN.doc Yes Yes Joram Hopenfeld, Karen Tyler, Davis Bessie CRDM Nozzle Shadis, Ulrich Erosion Corrosion .doc; RS-11 E-mail re: Contention 4 7/13/2007 Raymond Wite in200608.HELB-JAPAN.doc Yes Yes*
Joram Hopenfeld, Karen Tyler, Shadis, Ulrich RS- 12 E-mail re: Contention 4 7/13/2007 Raymond Wite Draft Hopenfeld Declaration Yes Yes Karen Tyler, Joram Hopenfeld, Unanalyzed Condition I.doc; Shadis, Ulrich Unanalyzed.doc; RS-13 E-mail re: Contention 4 7/16/2007 Raymond Witte, hope _2004013.pdf Yes Yes 11 of 22
NEC Privilege Log Attorney Work Document Author Email Client Product Number Document Description/Title Date Name Title Job assignment Recipients Email attachment Privilege Privilege Ronald Shems Karen Tyler, Joram Hopenfeld, Andrew Raubvogel, E-mail re: revised new, Shadis, Ulich RS- 14 Contention 2 9/4/2007 Raymond Witte Yes No Karen Tyler, Shadis, Ronald RS-15 E-mail re: Cooling Towers 8/30/2007 Raymond Shems RAI on CTs 08-29-07.doc Yes No Karen Tyler, 2007 08-30 Auto Scram E-mail re: 08/30/07 VY Shadis, Ronald Turbine Valve Stop RS- 16 EVENT REPORT 8/31/2007 Raymond Shems Closure.doc Yes No Joram Hopenfeld, Karen Tyler, E-mail re: Fwd: VY steam Shadis, Ulrich VYSteamDryerReport.7 RS-17 dryer report 8/2/2007 Raymond Witte 2007.pdf Yes . No Statement of Position.doc; HopenfeldASLBTestimA.doc; NEC INITIAL POSITIONS RESPONSE.doc; E-mail re: ASLB EPU HOPENFELD Statement of Position & NEC Shadis, Karen DECLARATION.doc; RS-18 Response to Enter/Staff 8/2/2007 Raymond Tyler Hopenfeld Last Page.doc Yes No Karen Tyler, Joram.
Hopenfeld, Ulich Shadis, Witte, 1 - 2007 - 006 LR Inspection RS-19 E-mail re: Discovery Issues 8/9/2007 Raymond -Andrew Report.pdf Yes Yes 12 of 22
NEC Privilege Log Attorney Work DDocument Author TEmail Client -Product Number Document Description/Title Date Name Title job assignment Recipients Email attachment Privilege Privilege
_Raubvogel E-mail re: VY Cooling Tower Shadis, Karen RS-20 Incident 8/22/2007 Raymond Tyler None Yes No E-mail re: Entergy document Shadis, Ulrich RS-21 disclosures 9/24/2007 Raymond Witte None No Yes Karen Tyler, E-mail re: Statement of Facts Raymond not in Dispute re NEC Shadis, Contention 4 in-VY License Consultant for Joram UW- 1 Renewal Proceeding 5/30/2007 Witte, Ulrich I NEC Hopenfeld None Yes Yes Karen Tyler, Raymond Shadis, Joram Hopenfeld, E-mail re: Entergystatement of Consultant for Andrew Expert input to attorney work UW-2 facts 6/5/2007 Witte, Uhich I NEC Raubvogel' product. Yes Yes Entergys Answer to DPS Notice of Intention to Participate and Petition to Intervene.doc; 2006-06-22 Answer 2 NEC Petition.doc; Declaration of John Hoffman
- (2).pedf; VY LR 092206mo4.doc; NEC Petition for Leave to Intervene 50-2712 OCRFpdf; Karen index.htm; index.htm; 2006-Tyler, 06-2 NEC REPLY OCR Raymond pdf.pdf; 2006-09 VY LR Shadis, .doc; NRC Staff Answer to E-mail re: ASME XI Appendix Consultant for Joram. DPS Petition to UW-3 L 6/8/2007 Wite, Ulrich NEC Hopenfeld Intervene3.doc Yes Yes E-mail re: summary of my Consultant for Karen UW-4 priorities 6/8/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Tyler None Yes Yes 13 of 22
NEC Privilege Log Attorney Work Document Author. Email Client Product Number Document Description/Title Date Name Title Job assignment Recipients Email attachment Privilege Privilege Consultant for *Karen UW-5 E-mail re: NUREG/CR-6934 6/8/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Tyler cr6934.pdf Yes Yes E-mailxre: review of SIA Consultant for.. Karen UW-6 Fatigue Analysis 6/14/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Tyler VY-16Q-401rbredacted.pdf Yes Yes E-mail re: review of SIA Consultant for Karen UW-7 Fatigue Analysis 6/15/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Tyler None Yes Yes Consultant for Karen UW-8 E-mail re: motion for extension 6/15/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Tyler None Yes Yes Consultant for Karen UW;91; E-mail re: motion for extension 6/15/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Tyler None Yes Yes Consultant for Karen UW-10 E-mail re: motion for extension 6/16/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Tyler LR006619.pdf Yes Yes Draft.Declaration of Ulrich Witte in support of motion to Consultant for Karen extend time with UW-11 E-mail re: review of declaration 6/18/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Tyler comments.doc Yes Yes.
Karen Tyler, Ronald Shems, Raymond Draft Declaration of Ulrich Shadis, Witte in support of motion to E-mail re: FW: review of Consultant for Andrew extend time with.
UW-12 declaration 6/18/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Raubvogel comments.doc Yes Yes Draft Declaration of Ulrich Consultant for UW-13 Witte 6/17/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC No Yes Joram.
E-mail re: documents Hopenfeld, associated with SIA fatigue Consultant for Karen UW-14 analysis . 6/18/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Tyler LR006468.pdf; LR006470.pdf Yes Yes Joram Hopenfeld, Karen E-mail re: documents Tyler, LR006482.pdf; associated with SIA fatigue. Consultant for Raymond LR006491.pdf; UW-15 analysis 6/18/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Shadis LR006519.pdf; LR006271.pdf Yes Yes FUW- 16 E-mail re: documents 6/19/2007 Witte, Ulrich Consultant for Jorami LR006435.pdf - Yes Yes 14 of 22
NEC Privilege Log Document AAttorney Work Author Email Client Product Number Document Description/Title Date Name Title Job assignment Recipients Email attachment Privilege Privilege associated with SIA fatigue - NEC Hopenfeld, analysis Karen Tyler Joram E-mail re: documents Hopenfeld, associated with SIA fatigue Consultant for Karen LR006477.pdf; UW-17 analysis 6/19/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Tyler LR006421.pdf; LR006528.pdf Yes Yes Karen Tyler, Joram Hopenfeld, E-mail re: Contention 4 Consultant for Raymond UW- 18 extension 6/21/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Shadis None Yes Yes Karen Tyler, Raymond Shadis, Consultant for Joram LW- 19 E-mail re: References 6/25/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Hopenfeld ACRS VY 2007t.pdf Yes Yes Karen Tyler, E-mail re: document review at Consultant for Raymond UW-20 VY 6/26/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Shadis None Yes Yes documents associated with fatigue analysis from SIA; Consultant for Karen documents associated with UW-2 1 E-mail re: NEC Contention 2 7/2/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Tyler fatigue analysis from SIA Yes Yes Consultant for Karen Expert input to attorney work LAW-22 E-mail re: contention 3 7/2/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Tyler product. Yes Yes Consultant for UW-23 Memo re: Contention 3 Witte, Ulrich NEC No Yes E-mail re: Contention 3 Consultant for Karen Expert input to attorney work UW-24 Declaration 7/2/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Tyler product. Yes' Yes Consultant for UW-25 Memo re: Contention 3 Witte, Ulrich NEC No Yes Draft Declaration of Mr. Ulrich Consultant for UW-26 K. Witte 6/2/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC No Yes 15 of 22
NEC Privilege Log Attorney Work Document Author Email Client Product Number Document Description/Title Date Name Title Job assignment. Recipients Email attachment Privilege Privilege Joram Hopenfeld, Consultant for Karen UW-27 E-mail re: Entergydocuments 7/3/2007- Witte, Ulrich NEC Tyler LR001817.pdf Yes Yes Joram Hopenfeld, Consultant for Karen UW-28 E-mail re: Entergy documents 7/4/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Tyler None Yes Yes E-mail re: notice re: proprietary Consultant for Karen Expert input to attomeywork UW-29 documents 7/5/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Tyler product- Yes Yes E-mail re: notice re: proprietary Consultant for Karen Expert input to attorney work UW-30 documents 7/5/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Tyler product Yes Yes E-mail re:Entergy document Consultant for Karen UW-31 production 7/5/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Tyler None Yes Yes Karen Tyler, Raymond Shadis, Consultant for Joram LTW-32 E-mail re: Contention 4 7/9/2007 Witte) Ulrich -NEC Hopenfeld None Yes Yes E-mail re: Entergys Eighth Consultant for Karen "
UW-33 Supplemental 7/9/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Tyler None Yes Yes Joram Hopenfeld, Consultant for Karen UW-34 E-mail.re: NEC Contention 2 7/9/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Tyler None Yes Yes Joram Hopenfeld, Consultant for Karen LUW-35 E-mail re: NEC Contention 2 7/9/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Tyler LR006523.pdf Yes Yes Joram Hopenfeld, Consultant for Karen UW-36 E-mail re: NEC Contention 4 7/9/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Tyler Draft Hopenfeld Declaration Yes Yes Consultant for Karen UW-37 E-mail re: Contentions 2,4 7/11/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Tyler None Yes Yes UW-38 E-mail re: Contention 4 7/11/2007 Witte, Ulrich Consultant for Karen NUREG 1801 Excerpts Yes Yes 16 of 22
NEC Privilege Log Attorney Work Document Author Email Client Product Number Document Description/Title Date Name Title job assignment Recipients Email attachment Privilege Privilege NEC Tyler Consultant for Karen Expert input to attorney work UW-39 E-mail re: Contention 4 7/11/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Tyler . product Yes Yes Raymond Shadis, Consultant for Karen Expert input to attorney work UW-40 E-mail re: Contention 4 7/11/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Tyler product Yes. Yes Consultant for Karen UW-41 E-mail re: Contention 4 7/12/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Tyler Draft Wite Declaration Yes Yes E-mail re: Entergy's 8th Consultant for Karen UW-42 Supplemental Disclosure 7/12/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Tyler None Yes Yes E-mail re: FAC Inspection Consultant for Karen UW-43 Program 7/12/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Tyler None Yes Yes Consultant for Karen UW-44 E-mail re: Contention 4 7/12/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Tyler None Yes Yes Karen Tyler, Joram Hopenfeld, Consultant for Raymond UW-45 E-mail re: Contention 4 7/13/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Shadis None Yes Yes Joram Hopenfeld,.
Karen Tyler, E-mail re: mass transfer Consultant for Raymond UW-46 coefficient for FAC 7/13/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Shadis None Yes Yes Karen Tyler, Consultant for Raymond UW-47 E-mail re: Contention 4 7/13/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Shadis None Yes Yes Consultant for Karen LUw-48 E-mail re: Contention 4 7/13/2007 Witte, Ulich NEC Tyler None Yes Yes Consultant for Karen LAW-49 ' E-mail re: Contention 4 7/14/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Tyler None Yes Yes Consultant for Karen UW-50 E-mail re: Contention 4 7/14/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Tyler Draft Witte Declaration Yes Yes 17 of 22
NEC Privilege Log Attorney Work Document Author Email Client Product Number Document Description/Title Date Name Title Job assignment Recipients Email attachment Privilege Privilege Consultant for Karen UW-51 E-mail re: Contention 4 7/14/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Tyler Draft Witte Declaration Yes Yes Consultant for Karen UW-52 E-mail re: Contention 4 7/15/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Tyler Draft Witte Declaration Yes Yes Consultant for Karen UW-53 E-mail re: Contention 4 7/15/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Tyler Draft Witte Declaration Yes Yes Consultant for Karen UW-54 E-mail re: Contention 4 7/15/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Tyler None Yes Yes Consultant for Karen UW-55 E-mail re: Contention 4 7/15/2007 'Witte, Ulrich, NEC Tyler Nmp 2003003.pdf
- Yes Yes Karen Tyler, Consultant for Andrew UW-56 E-mail re: Contention 4 7/16/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Raubvogel Draft Witte Declaration LRPD-02 Rev 2 ARM eval Yes Yes Consultant for Karen for VY may 2006 UW-57 E-mail re: Contention 4 7/16/2007 Witte, Ulrich. NEC Tyler 030771 001.pdf Yes Yes Consultant for Karen UW-58 E-mail re: Contention 4 7/16/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Tyler LR002895.pdf Yes Yes Consultant for Karen LR005942 -- SELF UW-59 E-mail re: Contention 4 7/16/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Tyler ASSESSMENT 2004.pdf Yes Yes Consultant for Karen UW-60 E-mail re: Contention 4 7/16/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Tyler nureg 1801 vol 2 rev. 1.pdf Yes Yes Consultant for Karen UW-61 E-mail re: Contention 4 7/16/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Tyler None Yes Yes Consultant for Karen UW-62 E-mail re: Contention 4 7/16/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Tyler None Yes Yes Consultant for Karen UW-63 E-mail re: Contention 4 7/16/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Tyler None Yes Yes Consultant for Karen UW-64 E-mail re: Contention 4 7/16/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Tyler Draft Witte Declaration Yes Yes Consultant for Karen UW-65 E-mail re: Contention 4 7/16/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Tyler Draft Witte Declaration Yes Yes Consultant for Karen UW-66 E-mail re: Contention 4 7/16/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Tyler Draft Witte Declaration Yes Yes Consultant for Karen UW-67 E-mail re: Contention 4 7/16/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Tyler Draft Witte Declaration Yes Yes 18 of 22
NEC Privilege Log S*' *Attonmey. Work Document Author Email Client Product Number Document Description/Title Date Name Title Job assignment Recipients Email attachment Privilege Privilege Karen Tyler, Consultant for Andrew UW-68 E-mail re: Contention 4 7/16/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Raubvogel None Yes Yes Karen Tyler, Consultant for Andrew UW-69 E-mail re: Contention 3 7/17/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Raubvogel None Yes Yes Consultant for Karen UW-70 E-mail re: Contention 4 7/17/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Tyler None Yes Yes Consultant for Karen UW-71 E-mail re: Contention 3 7/18/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Tyler Draft Witte Declaration . Yes Yes Karen Tyler, DRF ge dryer analysis Consultant for Andrew proprietyary 2005.pdf; Draft UW-72. E-mail re: Contention 3 7/19/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Raubvogel Witte Declaration Yes Yes Karen Tyler, DRF ge dryer analysis Consultant for Andrew proprietyary 2005.pdf; Draft UW-73 E-mail re: Contention 3 7/19/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Raubvogel Witte Declaration Yes Yes Consultant for Karen.
UW-74 E-mail re: Contention 3 7/19/2007 Wite, Ulrich. NEC Tyler LR002112.pdf Yes Yes Consultant for Karen.
UW-75 E-mail re: Contention 3 7/19/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Tyler CR 2007-02133ocr.pdf Yes Yes Consultant for Karen UW-76 E-mail re: Contention 3 7/19/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Tyler Draft Witte Declaration Yes Yes Karen
- Tyler, Raymond Shadis, ATTACIvMENT A .pdf; Joram engineering report rev 0 page Hopenfeld; 1.jpg; engineering report rev 0 Consultant for Andrew page 2 .jpg; engineering report UW-77 E-mail re: Contention 3 7/24/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC "Raubvogel rev 0 page 3.jpg Yes Yes Joram, Hopenfeld, Consultant for Raymond UW-78 E-mail re: Contention 3 7/25/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Shadis, None. Yes Yes
.19 of 22
NEC Privilege Log D tEAttorney Work Document Author Email Client Product Number Document Description/Title Date Name Title job assignment Recipien Email attachment Privilege Privilege Karen Tyler Karen Tyler, Raymond Shadis, Consultant for Joram UW-79 E-mail re: Contention 3 7/26/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Hopenfeld None Yes Yes Joram
- Hopenfeld, Raymond Shadis, Consultant for Karen UW-80 E-mail re: Contention 3 7/26/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Tyler None Yes Yes Karen Tyler, Andrew Raubvogel, Consultant for Raymond UW-81 E-mail re: Hearing preparation 7/27/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Shadis None* Yes Yes Consultant for Karen UW-82 E-mail re: Contention 3 7/31/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Tyler None Yes Yes Raymond Shadis, Karen Tyler, E-mail re: article in Burlington Consultant for Andrew UW-83 free press -8/27/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Raubvogel Burlington Free Press.pdf Yes Yes Karen Tyler, Andrew Raubvogel, E-mail re: VY Document Consultant for Raymond UW-84 Review 8/27/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Shadis None Yes Yes Karen Tyler, E-mail re: FW: necessary Consultant for Andrew LJW-85 references 8/28/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Raubvogel, None Yes Yes 20 of 22
NEC Privilege Log Attorney Work Document Author Email Client Product Number Document Description/Title Date Name Title Job assignment Recipients Email attachment Privilege Privilege Joram Hopenfeld Raymond Shadis Consultant for Joram UW-86 E-mail re: References 8/24/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Hopenfeld None No Yes Karen Tyler, Raymond Shadis, Joram Hopenfeld, Consultant for Andrew UW-87 E-mail re: Discovery issues 8/9/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Raubvogel None Yes Yes Jorarn Hopenfeld,'
Karen Tyler, Consultant for Raymond UW-88 E-mail re: Discovery issues 8/9/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Shadis None Yes Yes Raymond Shadis, Andrew Raubvogel, Karen Tyler, E-mail re: FW: Contention 4 Consultant for Joram UW-89 msj 8/13/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Hopenfeld None Yes Yes VY-16Q Andrew 303r0REDACTED.pdf; VY-E-mail re: FW: Docket no. 50- Raubvogel, 16Q-401rOREDACTED.pdf; 271-LR--- challenge to the Consultant for Karen VY- 16Q-UW-90 proprietary designations 8/17/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Tyler 404rOREDACTED.pdf Yes. Yes Raymond Shadis, E-mail re: Entergy document Consultant for Karen Uw-91 disclosures 9/25/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Tyler None Yes Yes UW-92 E-mail re: Entergys document 9/13/2007 Witte, Ulrich Consultant for Karen None Yes Yes 21 of 22
i .
NEC Privilege Log Attorney Work Document Author Email Client Product Number Document Description/Title Date Name Title job assignent Recipients Email attachment Privilege Privilege disclosures NEC Tyler, Raymond Shadis, Joram Hopenfeld, Ronald Shems, Andrew Raubvogel Karen Tyler, Raymond Shadis, Joram Hopenfeld, Ronald E-mail re: Board Order re: Shems, Contention 3; Entergy Consultant for Andrew UW-93 document disclosures 9/13/2007 Witte, Ulrich NEC Raubvogel Yes Yes Karen Tyler, Raymond Shadis, Joram Hopenfeld, Ronald Shems, E-mail re: Entergy document Consultant for Andrew JW-94 disclosures 1 9/13/2007 Ulrich Witte NEC Raubvogel None Yes Yes 22 of 22