ML101740347: Difference between revisions

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
(Created page by program invented by StriderTol)
(Created page by program invented by StriderTol)
 
(One intermediate revision by the same user not shown)
Line 3: Line 3:
| issue date = 06/16/2010
| issue date = 06/16/2010
| title = 2nd Request for Additional Information on Relief Request for 1st Period Limited Weld Examinations. (Tac ME1821)
| title = 2nd Request for Additional Information on Relief Request for 1st Period Limited Weld Examinations. (Tac ME1821)
| author name = Feintuch K D
| author name = Feintuch K
| author affiliation = NRC/NRR/DORL/LPLIII-1
| author affiliation = NRC/NRR/DORL/LPLIII-1
| addressee name =  
| addressee name =  
Line 9: Line 9:
| docket = 05000331
| docket = 05000331
| license number = DPR-049
| license number = DPR-049
| contact person = Feintuch K D, NRR/DORL/LPL3-1, 415-3079
| contact person = Feintuch K, NRR/DORL/LPL3-1, 415-3079
| case reference number = TAC ME1821
| case reference number = TAC ME1821
| package number = ML101740160
| package number = ML101740160
Line 19: Line 19:


=Text=
=Text=
{{#Wiki_filter:ENCLOSURE 2 nd REQUEST FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION ON RELIEF REQUEST FOR 1 ST PERIOD LIMITED WELD EXAMINATIONS AT DUANE ARNOLD ENERGY CENTER (TAC NO. ME1821)
{{#Wiki_filter:2nd REQUEST FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION ON RELIEF REQUEST ST FOR 1     PERIOD LIMITED WELD EXAMINATIONS AT DUANE ARNOLD ENERGY CENTER (TAC NO. ME1821)
In a letter dated July 30, 2009, NextEra Energy Duane Arnold, LLC submitted a relief request for an alternative to the required 1 st period limited weld examinations for the 4 th ten-year interval of various welds at the Duane Arnold Energy Center (DAEC). On January 26, 2010, the NRC asked two RAIs to which DAEC responded on Feb. 25, 2010. The Vessels and Internals Integrity Branch is in the process of writing the Safety Evaluation, and a peer-review process has identified additional RAIs as addressed below.  
In a letter dated July 30, 2009, NextEra Energy Duane Arnold, LLC submitted a relief request for an alternative to the required 1st period limited weld examinations for the 4th ten-year interval of various welds at the Duane Arnold Energy Center (DAEC). On January 26, 2010, the NRC asked two RAIs to which DAEC responded on Feb. 25, 2010. The Vessels and Internals Integrity Branch is in the process of writing the Safety Evaluation, and a peer-review process has identified additional RAIs as addressed below.
follow up on RAI 2 from January 26, 2010 request For CUA-J024 weld in the Reactor Water Cleanup System, this is a weld between a forged penetration and a cast valve, 50% coverage was probably the best coverage to be expected by the inspection. You have said in the July 30, 2009 submittal that 50% coverage is OK because the weld is not susceptible to IGSCC. But the only reason that weld is in RI Category 2 is because it is susceptible to IGSCC, otherwise, it is Category 4. Please clarify this apparent discrepancy.


follow up on RAI 2 from January 26, 2010 request For CUA-J024 weld in the Reactor Water Cleanup System, this is a weld between a forged penetration and a cast valve, 50% coverage was probably the best coverage to be expected by the inspection. You have said in the July 30, 2009 submittal that 50% coverage is OK because the weld is not susceptible to IGSCC. But the only reason that weld is in RI Category 2 is because it is susceptible to IGSCC, otherwise, it is Category 4. Please clarify this apparent discrepancy.
===RAI 3===
RAI 3 There is an inconsistency in the documentation provided. Page 1 of 1 on report no. UT-07-029 "UT Calibration/Examination" shows the exam angle of the Search Unit as "60 o", and the mode is listed as "shear". But Page 2 of 2 on UT-07-028 "Supplemental Report" shows a sketch of the inspection configuration and it includes a notation that the transducer was at "60 o RL, not 60 o , shear mode. Please clarify.
There is an inconsistency in the documentation provided. Page 1 of 1 on report no. UT-07-029 UT Calibration/Examination shows the exam angle of the Search Unit as 60o, and the mode is listed as shear. But Page 2 of 2 on UT-07-028 Supplemental Report shows a sketch of the inspection configuration and it includes a notation that the transducer was at 60o RL, not 60o, shear mode. Please clarify.
RAI 4 Please clearly identify the wave modality, insonification angles, and scan directions used for all ultrasonic examinations.  
 
===RAI 4===
Please clearly identify the wave modality, insonification angles, and scan directions used for all ultrasonic examinations.
 
===RAI 5===
Did the inspection exam category R-A meet ASME Code, Section XI, App VIII qualification requirements?
 
===RAI 6===
Supply a description of the materials of construction for the B1.40 RV head to flange weld and the R1.16 RMA-J004 weld.


RAI 5 Did the inspection exam category R-A meet ASME Code, Section XI, App VIII qualification requirements?
===RAI 7===
RAI 6 Supply a description of the materials of construction for the B1.40 RV head to flange weld and the R1.16 RMA-J004 weld.
Provide a better copy of the photo in submittal for CUA-J024 weld.
RAI 7 Provide a better copy of the photo in submittal for CUA-J024 weld.  
ENCLOSURE


ENCLOSURE RAI 8 State whether there were any recordable indications detected in the required inspections and if so, how these indications were dispositioned.
===RAI 8===
RAI 9 The original July 30, 2009 submittal includes the following statement:
State whether there were any recordable indications detected in the required inspections and if so, how these indications were dispositioned.


"The Nondestructive Examination (NDE) procedure used for this examination incorporates the examination techniques qualified under Appendix Vlll of the ASME Section XI Code by the Performance Demonstration Initiative (PDI). That procedure was approved under Relief Request NDE-ROO8 on January 31,2007."
===RAI 9===
The January 31, 2007 document provides authorization to use an alternative to Code requirements, not NRC approval of a procedure. Reword this paragraph to reflect the fact that the NRC authorized the use of the alternative for the remainder of the 4 th ISI interval at DAEC.}}
The original July 30, 2009 submittal includes the following statement:
The Nondestructive Examination (NDE) procedure used for this examination incorporates the examination techniques qualified under Appendix Vlll of the ASME Section XI Code by the Performance Demonstration Initiative (PDI). That procedure was approved under Relief Request NDE-ROO8 on January 31,2007.
The January 31, 2007 document provides authorization to use an alternative to Code requirements, not NRC approval of a procedure. Reword this paragraph to reflect the fact that the NRC authorized the use of the alternative for the remainder of the 4th ISI interval at DAEC.
ENCLOSURE}}

Latest revision as of 16:48, 13 November 2019

2nd Request for Additional Information on Relief Request for 1st Period Limited Weld Examinations. (Tac ME1821)
ML101740347
Person / Time
Site: Duane Arnold NextEra Energy icon.png
Issue date: 06/16/2010
From: Feintuch K
Plant Licensing Branch III
To:
Feintuch K, NRR/DORL/LPL3-1, 415-3079
Shared Package
ML101740160 List:
References
TAC ME1821
Download: ML101740347 (2)
v • d • e


Text

2nd REQUEST FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION ON RELIEF REQUEST ST FOR 1 PERIOD LIMITED WELD EXAMINATIONS AT DUANE ARNOLD ENERGY CENTER (TAC NO. ME1821)

In a letter dated July 30, 2009, NextEra Energy Duane Arnold, LLC submitted a relief request for an alternative to the required 1st period limited weld examinations for the 4th ten-year interval of various welds at the Duane Arnold Energy Center (DAEC). On January 26, 2010, the NRC asked two RAIs to which DAEC responded on Feb. 25, 2010. The Vessels and Internals Integrity Branch is in the process of writing the Safety Evaluation, and a peer-review process has identified additional RAIs as addressed below.

follow up on RAI 2 from January 26, 2010 request For CUA-J024 weld in the Reactor Water Cleanup System, this is a weld between a forged penetration and a cast valve, 50% coverage was probably the best coverage to be expected by the inspection. You have said in the July 30, 2009 submittal that 50% coverage is OK because the weld is not susceptible to IGSCC. But the only reason that weld is in RI Category 2 is because it is susceptible to IGSCC, otherwise, it is Category 4. Please clarify this apparent discrepancy.

RAI 3

There is an inconsistency in the documentation provided. Page 1 of 1 on report no. UT-07-029 UT Calibration/Examination shows the exam angle of the Search Unit as 60o, and the mode is listed as shear. But Page 2 of 2 on UT-07-028 Supplemental Report shows a sketch of the inspection configuration and it includes a notation that the transducer was at 60o RL, not 60o, shear mode. Please clarify.

RAI 4

Please clearly identify the wave modality, insonification angles, and scan directions used for all ultrasonic examinations.

RAI 5

Did the inspection exam category R-A meet ASME Code,Section XI, App VIII qualification requirements?

RAI 6

Supply a description of the materials of construction for the B1.40 RV head to flange weld and the R1.16 RMA-J004 weld.

RAI 7

Provide a better copy of the photo in submittal for CUA-J024 weld.

ENCLOSURE

RAI 8

State whether there were any recordable indications detected in the required inspections and if so, how these indications were dispositioned.

RAI 9

The original July 30, 2009 submittal includes the following statement:

The Nondestructive Examination (NDE) procedure used for this examination incorporates the examination techniques qualified under Appendix Vlll of the ASME Section XI Code by the Performance Demonstration Initiative (PDI). That procedure was approved under Relief Request NDE-ROO8 on January 31,2007.

The January 31, 2007 document provides authorization to use an alternative to Code requirements, not NRC approval of a procedure. Reword this paragraph to reflect the fact that the NRC authorized the use of the alternative for the remainder of the 4th ISI interval at DAEC.

ENCLOSURE

Retrieved from "https://kanterella.com/w/index.php?title=ML101740347&oldid=2131566"