ML19209C477

Response in Support of NRC 790911 Motion to Strike Miami Valley Power Project Contention 17 Re Fire Protection of Cable Trays.Terminates All Related Discovery.Also Supports Motion to Vacate Hearing Date.W/Certificate of Svc

ML19209C477
Person / Time
Site:	Zimmer
Issue date:	09/14/1979
From:	Conner T, Wetterhahn M CINCINNATI GAS & ELECTRIC CO., CONNER, MOORE & CORBER
To:
References
NUDOCS 7910150627
Download: ML19209C477 (6)

Text

._ . __ __ __ /C

. .

• o m s s- g

/s LI$  %

p N 6 49 A U.E *..*.D 5 ".a' *. .* S C 7 '.v7 7. _ "w.', *6 ~

,

NUCI.IAR REGUI.ATCRY CC.vlCSSICN b

• m r

.n w.e .w.ac.a c:.

.. . )

)

The Cincinnati Gas & Electri: ) Cocket No. 50-258 Comcany, et al. )

(Wm. H. Zi==er Nuclear 2cwer

• Station) ) 1

.

., b,2 ,4 . CA.,4 . 5 .%.S,CNs . .O .,4.sC .-

.

c .

.w ... , s. . C. . sI . O S . =. _.... .

.V *.9.4'f.r

-1 1 ?Y ?,** f7TV 5,v* W. f 7. 9T .D 9.TVsJm *? m. ww m m-^

1 "/ ,

.

e n v.s . .T.v.4 . . V"N . vf.s* V.O

w. .r. 9T C C h C.e.. hv.- v. G. e. .e.e s e..C m..e. C m. m C N C s-

.

---

Ca.%. e . .e.s .va- -v suD

. t:r . .e.. Lu r v.4 A m. .r C ,J 0 .e su.m D .r s C nA R v. .e.r.? A . ,..N+G n.t e.r e m. O n AND MCTICN TO VACATI EEARING CATI AND i'

_OR

r,u.,D n . AT CsJa, . e:. . ,:.:-

.

C.'1 S e e *w a ..". e . _' _' , 'c/9,

. ~- ".e N. uc .'. a. .= .- =.a .- c, u _' = ~. ,r w, ... ._' a s .4 r.

( n s.I:.C n ). S ,2_: .ww ..e ,.e A, n s. .,.. 4..'s. a. Cw. .. . a.,,4n 1-d 4 ,,

. .

ow . w.. . o u.e wn, mys.. e .n.a.C' w

"f . s*, C a, e d..i..".C, .-=,_',.4..".";

~ . ^ '..'*. e .# .4 ." O -y .- .. a..C *,. _4 " .". ^#

w_ ."=.".'a. ~,._~ .=., V s~ ,

• 4..,.a 3..,.g e.w.

^^*a..._4. .o .'.

• 35 .=. a S .4 s- .#..^ - ".'".a w w,...- . . . , .

.c. a. .- e. .x.d. s- *w .mA .

a C . S e e" . .= ." e . .' .' , .' 9 ~t C. , .sy

. . ' a c, .'. .i. c = . . . s ' --^w "w.. s e ' .. .= ", a .4 *7 a d. ,= '

a..,=...

3 ,- -

_w .v 4. _s . 4 y.m.1.T.2.,f ., c.w e wg _* .t .. ~m;, n c. - . a 8 -

(n.v.yt..on} .- .- , ..- a g .i A ws _. a--A

- -

c e y- , .a. w. e .,. L .i. , 101.,o .. .w,. v, .O.,,

. we -. a.m . a .- 2. A ---a ,. . .C n 1.,. .* 2

. a . ..4. 3 -. . . . .. .

.

,m=,=

.w . d =y= ym e 2 .- ,23 2

• vW - **.a S a== .

' 4 **

8"9.b. ag w g.4 S

2. .'. a- Q

, .**a

• 2. *. a d

"

. - . "".*.*%.

. T.' a. A **.Q . .a .w ..*. 4..=. .S *.* .a ,,.h .I .* w 4 .' w**w * *f a .***f

.m *

.w ..b. 4 3 e m

. =i e.

we . a. .m. .. 4.w e .=. . . .y= y .1 4m w s .m. oc . . , ..

• b. a L^ .4..w. 4

. . .3.. . .

4 a Jaa. 3

.

7. 7 a C . 4 ,.,,

.

C .^ .. . .".'./ , a

, , = .. ', _. . a. ".'- a C' './ s1.. ~-'o . .

-

-

..

.".= ,~. _= .# .# ' s- ..%'.',.4.....**..

-

..*. .= d. -

(444. . Q m. , . .w. a, _. ,a. 2 g s., a-. .aA w a*

. ., ,

. . . 3 .

,

,.q , . . y-y _1....a

.. . _4 , . . , _7.,.

a ...a, g.a.

.%. .., G... a..%.r a.

v en .a.e. . _4n A .e .- as s

w. ... w . _n/ ~ .m. . . m. .w ,/..,. n. s,. . a.  % ...u.w a m.,e e w JL e

.'3 n.f . Aa

% w . .w dab.ed .C., e y- ,. .a.m. b. e .w .T ^v, .T..Q, ", . Q , S e ~. ~. 4..=. ~

f,, wm ._e w .k. o .- - * . .$. 4,. .J e .w 3

..e ,

. I.4 g b

,.8 8.,

. .88 _w

,8 O 8%

. .

4 89

. . -4" a .M. 8 . #%. ..

.)

(.1 7910150 0

-

-

_ __ _ _ _ _ __ _ _ _ . _ _ _ _ . _

-

2- s

..u e .sLuC S t3 = --

i-a ...o

,

.-- 4 .. _ . .. 4 -. . d a. , _ S ,:: _ s -- ,. .s. e _3 ,d a .,.

-n#c .med i

- bv .

cur.se.' ." o . . W '. o . . " . = - '

. .'M .

.R- be - - .. ^- " a- . .=---d a - wc " '.."

not appear for the deposition scheduled by the NRC Staff, w . h. .Jo t,. 3 2

-.a . - ..o . . -.seend . .c o .-.,4.. 4.. - _.

-- ga . c.,., . s, , ... c

-

w. , -

he would not be a witness for the Project en Contention 17.

.

By telephone call of September 10, 1979, as confi ed by letters to Mr. Hofstader and Miss I.eah Kosik of the same date (with coc.ies to the Board and other .carties),

Mr.

,

.=.o s ,- , . a e. .4 , e..c. .eg w

.

-

sel- : c w. nyy s t, . . . . . .3 4w-...

-, ., s w.a . ... w - .do L,. , a not appear at a deposition in response to the Applicants ' i 1/

subpcena issued August 23, 19 7 9 , '~"" nor would he appear as a witness on behalf of MV?P.

vC,4

.4 .w.a . .a.w

. , ,

.as.,Ce - -

. . ,..1. .

. n.,s s.,_og o ..

.w,

.. .

w

..e .4 4 3 ., _

..%,.

,=yy "" e a '" .= s .= '.Y.' .. .a - s s , C C .*. . .a .". . 4 ".

- .I. ~t . .." s ' e =- _' w.I'**

.-. "..

~-

-.

-

_' a

-

w .i. -m a .. .# _-, .m "..".e ."- a C o d o# ..'"..'.a- y*-* ,Caad.'.*.C,

.

-- ....' ...'. e.. '. . '-,~

.

"

• 4as based sClely en Mr. HCfstader's assertiCns COncerning a .3 7 e';'* e A .i .*. = de C,"-a 4 a s C .#. _# .4 ..- a- y .- .,"- a C 4 C .". -#*w .-

.

". -a -'"ia .. ~~="-

.;a

_.n d ..". = . ..".a 3.. %-"ac

,

.

waa- .- =. ' _ v .d . . -.  ; -. .'d._. .v.o# - =- . d= e- _= s _' =-

.

_2/

3 C .1. a .

. . . . e.sa.

- * .

. * . = - Q , i = g A. 4

. .n' s *'5

'

.3C E,. f= , . .,.. . 2 . * *

.i.f. e... ,

. . #.

.

^

v.de. .=. dr. 4 . ..i .. ; . . a w w-. - - . . .a . . . .'w . a-

-

w" .= . -- =d a' -"a,

-

/ , .' , , c, .=. . . ,

,

- y- -...a .r c .. s i d e-=

.4 --- - '

--. ".de 'v_d..,  : c a--,d. ' a-

.

- ". a. _= d, .. 4-- aa.' ..

~#

-

-

1/ "he subpcena was issued by Ell:abeth 3Cwers t.ga.4.

. an, n. m.4- .e., a .e . ../ .=..d , ActinC

.

.  ?.4 a .s_4..C. _ C a _-d o = . . a .i. . ~

.. .

.o c a a 5 o w.ae e 5 . " ...

2/ ..u. e .u.,

_

e .* ..,;* e c . ". o .'. w= e ..*. .' .' , _' ' ' .' . a -

witnesses by August 24, 1979 in crder to facilitate

.

d_i c ve-v..

a . .cee 1'e a-

--

--

-

"

.. . e _= w^ = - .".- -"-- - . . . .. e _= " ..  : . 7. .=., _' .k ,

Counsel

.'. .aIao .

for Miami Valley Pcwer Project dated August 24, -

1134 231

. -- _

. _. . .. . . . _ . - . . . _ .

.

--

.. b.e Ca,n*a....ic".

- was "ased - ""C. ~'t',

- . C ^w..s _d w- #.a _" _* _d.. * . ' " . . = ..."

u. o .# s .=. d e _ , " " ..a.,_

. e .' v , ..".a. y- _ c 4s =c ~, e..~3 4-..a a. .- _4 . . ". a 3

-_4_-=. , _ o *. .=. c -

tion department a Underwriters Iabcratories," would testify as to the alleged inadequacies. *hus it is clear that there exists no specific basis for Centention 17 as required by 10 C. F . R. 5 2. 714 (b) and it should be soricken.

As an independent ground, Applicants move that the c o n* a.n*.

. 4 a... b - e s _ _d c .k e.. i .n ~..". = ~ ~..".a__i _- _4 .. ' .-a _~ ~ c = ~ o _ _d a s = d .d. - a s s e d -

_3/

.c *. .".a. 3. _ c i, e c . - a-. .1 .=. . d .. c. .o C ...=.. _4^r. . . 'e ".. = v -a ..c

- ~,. " e e.. "

answered. Applicants have pointed cut repeatedly in the cas*

, o ."._is 'ca-d -~ .". a "u d a- n o .#. --

_ -

e-- o." r. a'ry_1_4.=...s .=..d

_. /

. .

i

~..".e _i _- - _d3- k.'. ~.o

- d i scova-v, . -- C c .s i d- e _d .., _4 _ s y - a v _i o u s a..x -

. ,

'

e_4an.ca ..".a__-=, =..x-"se #-_-

'

- -.. " e y .- c.a- a d _4 ..c. ,

. _4a- . . ^ . .\."s t. o. ' a-

.e ,_---

43,,-=. -asyc.d_

- .

~~

. di s w- ^,v a - v. .-= "" es.s,-

-- .o".e- ' _# ^., _- .'e. -cs . _o ,

...us a, "4-

..-a c .i . . . _' . . ". = _---c a a,. d _4 . .c. "e daa...ad - - - "e %.cw- .

-t- cg.,w1e _w C o- u .. 4 a a--..

,. t o- 1 a. s , ..4- ,s.

.-~. .4 . ...a .m. . .%e.,3 1, 1 .,. . 4. .. . _4a-

'

,

- .S.,4

---

4 4 _i e.. . c.. - ur. A o-- 4 --a.t_4saa_'

4 --

o# _ ". a .- .

- . . =.1__4** . . .

C.. .C e y =.. ". a- _- _O, ' '

• 9 i:1, i-

-

-

. .".- a .". - _ -a . . a 4 . . c. .=ca_d - -as"ad . = . .

-

-

C _ .d.e s e . ._d ..c C c _ ,.," e _ '. ,' - c' c., .

1. --

---

= ".a .a.

. " .. c,

_

"--

--- . ". a s v _' a

.

, u-,_ose c# ~ ~ ~. s...i d. a_

. . _ _4 .. 3 C c.. . =.". _4 - .. .' 7 . _...= s " c".. = s ". _- =

...a.

__a_

-

.. c._,4 a ,, s

- - . . 2. _4 c__u. e--e .: ,_ .. --. - , a - - . .

4 s - , u 4 , t_4 s..,,_,.

--_

Power Project dated August 24, 1979.

_.4/

. See " Apo. licants ' Motion to Dismiss -he Miami 7allev.

0cwer Proiect s as a .:artv. to the Proceeding" which is incorporated by reference herein. See also Pennsy'.vania

.ocwe.- & -ri c_.". C^... . =..v_ ( S usgueha....a s _ a,= ~.. _r _'-- = c . .. c .c . = ,. _ - . . ,

. -

--

Un:.ts 1 anci 2) , Occket Nos. 50-387 and 353), Me=crand".=

. . - v,-

e_. . .. sv.w..ec,-_- .: ....d n.,_4 s c o ..a,. . .y.c _. _4 , . . a- --

,. a

-.c . ., _

. < . .

-

o _ .: -

(August 24, 1979).

I134 232

-

.. - . .-.

_ - .

. .

_4_  ; )iI 9 MI A

'

,. ...i_

appears to be nothing further Oc consider with regard to Contention 17, Applicants 5/

wculd move to vacane the Licensing 3 card's order.-~

In the alternative, if the Board dces not gran Staff's or Applicants' motion, the Applicants would move the Board to permit until September 21, 1979 for the filing of =ctions for su= mary disposition with all responses due by Oc cber 5, 1979.

Considering the limited nature of this single conten-tion, these dates are reasonable and would perni: the Board to dispose of the issue without the need for an evidentiary session.

Respectfully submitted, CONNER, MCORE & CCRSER

\

l

'

l -

Q v.C'? &

Croi . Conner, Jr. 'J

'

I i

Mark J. Netterhahn Counsel for Applicants Sep e=ber 14, 1979 5/ 1134 233 In should parties be noted prior to that the setting the hearing Scard did not ec11 the dates.

Part 2, Appendix A SI(b). 10 C.F.R.

Lead counsel for Applicants has a long standing co==itment abrcad for these dates which cannot be rescheduled. Furthermore, internal counsel for The Cincinnati Gas & Electric Cetpany has co==itments to be out during that period which will require him of Cincinnati hearing session. during part of the scheduled Nevertheless, if i

--

hearings he scheduled during that week, is necessarv tha:

Applicants will be present. counsel d'or he

_ _ .._ __ __ __ ..__ _ _ __ . _ _ _ . .

. .

.

UNITED STATIS OF AMERICA s.IIs C. v r.n,.R :. G w r a, . C R v. Cv.v u.. . c- . m v.- 4

_w. ,e s

..e w... .va....... w. )

)

The Cincinnati Gas & Electric ) Occket No. 50-358 Company, en al. )

)

(William H. Zimmer Nuclear Pcwer )

),,

• '

J

. .

= b

- . ~

u .e.. . -..v v_ L n . _, v.e

- -

.==.v... .

I hereby certify that copies of " Applicants' Response to 'NRC Staff Motion to Strike Miami Valley Power Project Contention Number 17, Concerning Fire Protection of Cable Trays and the Termination of all Discovery Relating Thereto' and Motion to Vacate Hearing Date and for Additional Relief,"

dated September 14, 1979, in the captioned matter, was served upon the following by deposit in the United States mail this 14th day of Sectember, 1979: .

e h 3 .7 e s .,e u,w..w.c e _22_ _ , T.. .v.4. w.w.a e.' ~. .e s _- . a . , r..

-

-

.

_as . .33 L.w.a.4 .~. $ .' n' ~. ^ " _4C .Ca#s.V,

, . - n'~.^*.._4..

.. .C a.# s .V. a.".# - .~ .i .~ ^ .". s _4 .". ~

and *i ansing Board Appeal Scard

n. . a . q. u,. ...-, . . _ q .- .-c,.,, . .

..., ., ..

u.w.  : s.;ue_:. --- so..n: ---

2- w_.y .

C ~.,.

. . .'m_' s a .* c .~. C c .~. ..~.. .' a m .' .. .~.

Washington, D.C. 20555 Washing:cn, D.C. 20555

' . . ..

.. 7 a.a..k .7 .=.c o e-- , .V.a- . " e _- u.".a__.=.., n' . .._',

^ '

.

<=_#=.v.

-

= . d

-.

n. . m_4 .a.a m...; .m ,. A. . _4 ..- a .r. s .4 . . ; ..n.

. ., w- .e.r. s .4 .;. ,. n y y e.s .' 2. 3 .,. : . -.2 . a t s --

.=.c a. d- r.S. N. u c _' =- .=. _- :. a c, "_ _' _= ~ ~ .-";

. -

School of Natural Rescurces Cc:= is sion University of Michigan Washing:cn, D.C. 20555 A.... a, wc, L4 . .w. 4.3 .-...

, .

,. --

u 0 o.

a.,. , n* ., - -  :

w. ..4 a_n*P 2 **

Cw . 3 4 . . w - .] -. 5

-

<-*

.%1 . %2. s. .e. .U.

^

=.=.4m..,

s .

w

. .V.a..m. w.- o w

• 4 . m,...m .4 .; - .uwa . ,:

m

..n...a._i -

a n' o em w. s .- .e., g - a e.y ,A - 9

. - . . .T 4 c a- .n. a~ .4 . .;~ "6 . Q . 9. 0 -w a .n*. 2. a ;e n. _* .n . . _en  ;

2,C a. A. .

r

w. ......_4 m s _4w , ..

"

..-3. y,w.

. 1 33- .qec,,--

-

n12-^-w.V, ".. a s.b.4 .".~ ~.,~ .". ,s ' . v' .

'

0...~.~,

L* , .~..~ . 2s .4.c . .

".N a s w._4 .... . . . , -

s.C. 7 0 .:. :

_ r. w.a _i s, s . . . =2

. - - . ...,

.w .r a g .

..

C - L'..'s e _' _#.'.*- . . " . = ". . s"- . ..= _# #_

,.

.q.4C.h 4 a d- 5. 3 a .l -*3 ' ."6 , -ag.

~

.

7-~

C##'"*

. . . c .#. ..". e T.X a "". -- 4 ", -3 ~

2 "; ' '

6~w . .g .4 . ...g.. , n e. 4 -- g g _ a- .~2 -.

.

a . A- 3 .4 _- a. e , _-

Licensine. Ac.ceal Scard .

U.S. Nuc'. ear Rec.n' a crv.

s. c...... '--

^

r. . s . N u c .' e a.- R e : "_ _' .=.. . v.

. . a a _' a. . .

C .- .*. s s .4 6. .. *.v *a s n' .' ..g . .'. , . ' . ,~ . . ' F .:. .: .:.

_s Washing cn, D.C. 20555

.p.1 1 _, 2... - .. . . .v.e _. , . , . r..

_as Dr. Lawrence R. Cuarles General Counsel n4 .

. . . . .e,:- _ e,. ,, -.. .

- .._4 c e .. g .4 . .c. c .4 . . n 4 . .. . , _. 4 n,a g =

.

.

_= . a c. _ ._ _4 _-

__

Ac.ceal . ,. 3 card Cc==. a nv.

r .s.

-

4 L. - .~ , .,. ., s~ , ,: . . , . ..--y

. ,-.. .cs . _:

u,:_.4-, . = c ,< u-u e .

e w- . .. 4 s a _4w.- .

. C .4 .. C .4 ... . .,. _. , e .u._, ,w s

,. .J

,e .~

--Aa .4..C..w.. , . .w.. .

7  :::

- . . . ,

ll34 2,, 3 4

'

- -. .- --. . . - . . . . .-. .- _ . .

-

.

,

Mr. Chase R. Stephens Leah S. Kosik, Esq.

Docketing and Service Section Attorney at Law Office of the Secretary 3454 Cornell Place U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Cincinnati, Ohio 45220 Commission Washington, D.C. 20555 John D. Woliver, Esq.

Clermont County Community William Peter Heile, Esq. Council Assistant City Solicitor Box 151 City of Cincinnati Batavia, L. o 45103 Box 214 Cincinnati, Ohio 45202 3

_

-

Mark Netterhahn

!l34 235