RA-13-1004, 10 CFR 26 Unsatisfactory Fitness-For-Duty Blind Performance Testing Results

10 CFR 26 Unsatisfactory Fitness-For-Duty Blind Performance Testing Results

ML13324A539
Person / Time
Site:	Oconee, Mcguire, Catawba, Harris, Brunswick, Crystal River, Robinson, McGuire
Issue date:	11/06/2013
From:	Waldrep B Duke Energy Carolinas
To:	Document Control Desk, Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
References
RA-13-1004
Download: ML13324A539 (7)

Text

1. &m- CMSW p

%,ENSM. EcorHIP. 0. fts imf chdtN 202UO1LIMM far 704 32 UN 10 C *26.719(c) ormA-3-16,2013 RA-13-1004 U.S. Ncmer ReAowry Cam n*w ATTN: Document Co* Desk WaOngton, DC 2058.0001 muoin*mk Steam Electc Pftnt CatbaM Nuclar Statkm Units 1nd 2 Units 10nd2 OcWk Nlif 50-325 and 50.324 D e MW 5"413 and 50414 Licens NOs DPR-71 &Wd DPR-02 Uosne Nas. NPF-3W an NPF-52 Cry" Rkw Nuchw Gewng Plot MC*uk*Nuolw Stm Unkt 3 Units Iand 2 Docke NO. 0-302 Docket Nos60-369 a 5"0-370 Lkense No. DPR-72 Licens Ho. NPF-9 and NPF-17 Shtrean Haris"NucNaPowW Pet Ocor" Nudear Show Uniti Units 1, 2 nd 3 Docket No. 50400 Docket No 09,50-27 a4nd 50-287 Liew No. NPF-63 Licens cas. OPR-36, OPR-47 en OPR-55 H.M Robinson 8room Elcrc PWt Unit 2 DockNo. "I0281 Licenoe No. OPR-23 Sub*et: 10 CFR 26 UNSATISFACTORY ITNESS-FOROX,'TY BLIND PERFORMANCE TESTING RESULTS Ladhawa GeneWmen:

Purawnt to 10 CFR 26.719(oX3), Duke Energy Pr* Inc. (DEP), Duke Enegy Forida, Inc.

(DEF)nd Duke Energy CrOnn, LLC (DEC) owbod an unsascry*n peormance tsting resujt from Corp Reach Trifngle Park (RTP) for the DEP, DEF and DEC FitneweFor-Outy Progrm on Septebe 19,2013. Insacordonce with 10 CFR 26.719(cXl),

i leMW provides

• rert of the Incidnt ond a corme" action tha has boen Won.

On September 18, 2013 Duke Enewy Fitnes for Duty taff proces a lab eo from LipCorp RTP and n errorwwas discovared at lim" 1615. Superftion wa noiWfied of the tub error wt approxistly 1630 on Sepembe 18,i2013 to seem eoubt.

Subeeen tois wvent s enlae inkfte Dke Enegw"cct action pr 0, m. Duke Energy mdethe required evet to to NRC at 1432 on Seember 19,2013.

KI~k

U.S. Nuckea Regulftor Commission Ocb 24, 2013 Serial: RA-13-1004 Page 2 LobCorp RTP wm asked to perborm an hwesbgston to dWrmn the cause of the event and identify oocv aomns to prvent recurr of the error. This kwestiAbn has been oomed and conr*cM atnm ome been xcrpwrtd InLabCorp's stmndud operabrig procmdurew The setdhet to tVs kete6ss tme event, the resutn muS a nd the equ e t s t a report wtn 30 days of wcomei an Wivesgatn of any tstn eros or unisetactoy perfao dWbscvd inpeufomieces, testng Them er no new egulstoy comn*wuns made Inthis sumta. Ifyou have additiona qustions, plens a T. J. Wsdwtrh at (704) 382-S35.

konemor y C drop VAk*P~eek*A*O-por Govemrnane 4 oporwo -L~ot

1. kwedlpton of Unsoisfatory Ftns-For-Outy Testing Result

U.S. N*er Regu ry Commsion October 24, 2013 Serial: RA-13-1004 Ppe 3 xc: (W achment)

V. McCree, Regkxw Tminsraor U.S. Nucer ReguLatory Commiion - Region It Mau One Tower 245 Poechtree Center Ave, NE Sutte 1200 Atnta, GeorgI 30303-1257 W.M.Deaw, Regona I lnsrao U.S$. NUCOW AReglatOry Commission - Regon I i

2100 Renaisnce oulevard, Suits 100 King of Pruss, PA 194*-2713 N= (*V atcm en.t)

J. C. Paoe, NRR PrAec Mwn (CNS &MNS)

U&.Nuclea Regulaowy Comi~ssio 1166W6ckvftePikew Rockvile, MD 20852-2738 R.V.Guzman, NRR Pf Mnager (ONS)

U.S. Nucls Rogor VCommbsin 11656 Rodcvft Pie MOOl Stops C2 Rodwe, 0MO 20852-27V3 C.Ordbn NRR Projec Mnger (8SEP)

U.S. N*uler Reguaory Commisso 11586Rocl Pike mmltp s D15 R~ockvll, MO 2085-2738 A. L Ha NRR Proe Mage (SHNPP, Unit 1)

U.S. Nucler Reulatory Commsion 11656 Rodl Pike M StW 8 G*A Rockvll, MO 20652-2738 S.P. Unpin, NRR Projed Manger (HRMSP, Unt 2)

U.S. Nucla Reguakwy Co"mon 11I5 Rockvt Pike Mad Stop a em Rockyll, MD 20852-2738

U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commlneslor Oc0be 24, 2013 Serial: RA-13-1004 Poge 4 E. L Ctows NRC Senior Resident Inspector Oconm Nucw SWIon J. Zeil"r NRC Senior Rekit In#o-"ctx McGubs Nuclear Station G. A. Hutto NRC Senior Res"e Inpector Cataw Nuclear Station M.P. Castt NRC Senor Rensim WPW swwkk S""am Eleti PlriIt Uni Nn. I and 2 NAWGSnior Resident Inspector H. Rbkno Steam Eec*tr Plant Unit No. 2 J. 0. Auin NRC S~n RmsWt InspetO Shtew n Hai NuedW Pow Plwt. Unit I

U.S. Nuclew Regulao Comrnmsson October 24,2013 Serial: RA-13-1004 paoe 5 b= (without fecment)

T. J. Wadorth M.C. Nowa C. J. Waik J. R. Robertson R. D.Hent L.J. Grze D.R.We~

0. H. Corleft W. R. HlghMr R.SSe Oconee *M FIOS 601.01 - ON030M McGuire MsW Fils 601.01 - M*01DM Cemvaw Mietewr FRO 61.011 - CNO4WM ELL NCMPA-1 PMPA NCEMC W. R. Murray (For ONP Lionxgfticw Records Fies)

F. Frando (For CR3 Lmllnkg/ftNucieer Records Files)

R. N. Smith (For HNP LicenosiNuea Records Film)

C. k CaudoU (For RNP s/uclear Record. Fl~es)

T. K.Paswsi (For CNS e Records)

K.L Crane (For MN$ UscensingNucear Record)

J. E. Smith (For ONW LisWlNUclea Records)

Fie: (Carp***)

ATTACHMENT I Investgation of Unsatisfactory Fitness.For-Duty Blind P rfwmanoe Tosting Results

United States Regatory CoinssIOm RA-13-l004, Atacsnent I Pag I of I On S*eptmber 18, 2013, Duke Energy Fitness for Duty stff prcesed a lab report from LapCorp Resewch Trige Park (RTP) which wtonted an aror. LmbCorp repomtod a blind swp* so rave that should have been repore s positive for nitrae Anotifition was mde to the Nucr Rgul y Co ission by te Duke Energ Flet Uimn Manager (Even Number 49359).

The repon lob WMS owoctod by Duke Enegy and askd to 1)ritest ft spocen, 2) send Bottle"B' of 1, aopl Inqusto tthe ineedn suppyin lab, ESohlyLaborat*orie n, ,

for additin tsi, ind 3) end e anMquot of te orn sample to aother kndpenen lab, Cuest OiWagstim ESohy Lamoratories, ft. *w sed to etas the "bao ftrom which the sampie wow provid and to tost the sample (botio -W) sent by LabCorp RTP. Quest DiaginowasaMdtotthedtprviddbyLabCorpRTP.

rePofted cworrcty aopositive for nitrile indiatin an adulterated sample.

Upon Ide0otion of ft er.Oa, p RTP beWn a iantkal iwdglan, the result of which w provided to Due Ener on October 10, 2013. Addionuy, the Duke EneW Supervisor, Fftnes for Duty, reavewd the lab reort wit the Medical Reviw Offlcer (MRO).

The ULaborp RTP repot stated tha the technician awnwaz the sam e nally dentfed a potentia positiv niftt by 00ororimetic analysis and concluded that confirmatory tsI"g by ion dhom gam phly requmire. Cofiaion %t*W was coducftd but fled to onim presence o L*Corp RTP yielded no coknclWu nirt An Investigation by findingo Iolatn the Initalngativetetresutaby ion chrom'"alogrphy for"the elarwcdspecimen. ft was conclPuided thatthetehniia should have performed addlitional tsI"g tomrsolvte1 Ion ChromWatgraph was usd IDperform aT-cnflmdwoy %Wst and Micted a negatve repnsew. The lithly caus of the reporting erro by U*Corp RTP was#thatrcedural guida noe d not eads withi the LWabop RTP organization to chlene* disparity betwoon the "pesumptveposive and *confinvoory negaveOW results. A wreve of podt activtie iniia Ancy.

d,oscrp (blin sample reports and conditiomns eorts for the previous 10 years) was unable to kW*tif any Other Simle erro reported by LabCorp RTP. Thus, this Incident appears to be an Isolate error.

LCorp reised SNdar COp Procedure (SOP) 5.E.4, "Nitri Co m in UriMne by Ion ChroMa mto add a Os siMir to other lab procere Inorder to add potenial disities botwaen WOWtalecrep np d aonfimatote . The now stop requires the t resu1,1 laboai torly techicin to positvel reconcile disc prepacles betwwe the WOWie screening reults and le confirmatoytet resutsfor nitries This correctieaton to revisetheSOP and add theaoremenioe - stepwascncmpletedon October 15,2013.