L-2022-149, U4R33 Steam Generator Tube Inspection Report
| ML22277A803 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Turkey Point  |
| Issue date: | 10/04/2022 |
| From: | Strand D Florida Power & Light Co |
| To: | Document Control Desk, Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation |
| References | |
| L-2022-149 | |
| Download: ML22277A803 (11) | |
Text
October 04, 2022
U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Attn: Document Control Desk Washington D C 20555-0001
RE: Turkey Point Nuclear Generating Station, Unit 4 Docket No. 50-251 Subsequent Renewed Facility Operating License DPR-41
U4R33 Steam Generator Tube Inspection Report
Florida Power & Light Company (FPL) hereby submits the enclosed Turkey Point Unit 4 Cycle 33 Refueling Outage (U4R33) Steam Generator Tube Inspection Report. In accordance with Turkey Point Technical Specification (TS) 6.9.1.8, the report is required within 180 days after the initial entry into MODE 4 following completion of the Steam Generator tube inspection required by Turkey Point TS 6.8.4.j.
This letter contains no new regulatory commitments.
Should you have any questions regarding this submission, please contact Mr. Kenneth Mack, Fleet Licensing Manager, at 561-904-3635.
I declare under penalty of perjury that the foregoing is true and correct.
Executed on the 04 day of October 2022.
Sincerely,
Dianne Strand General Manager, Regulatory Affairs Enclosure Attachments
cc : USNRC Regional Administrator, Region II USNRC Project Manager, Turkey Point Nuclear Generating Station USNRC Senior Resident Inspector, Turkey Point Nuclear Generating Station Ms. Cindy Becker, Florida Department of Health
Florida Power & Light Company
9760 SW 344th Street, Homestead, FL 33035 Turkey Point Unit 4 L-2022-149 Docket No. 50-251 Page 1 of 10 Enclosure Turkey Point Unit 4 TP4-33 Steam Generator Tube Inspection Report
Introduction:
The enclosed Steam Generator Tube Inspection Report for Turkey Point Unit 4 is submitted for the inspection of the SGs during refueling outage 33 (hereafter referred to as the TP4-33 inspection or outage), as required by Technical Specification section 6.9.1.8. Per the Turkey Point Unit 4 Technical Specification section 6.8.4.j.d.2.c, the 5th ISi period is 72 EFPM. The inspection in TP4-33 was performed in accordance with Technical Specification 6.8.4.j and was the 1st inspection of the SGs in the 5th ISi period. The prior outage (TP4-32) was a SG inspection "skip". At unit shutdown for the TP4-33 inspection, the SGs had operated for approximately 31.27 EFPY since installation, including 7.35 EFPM in the 5th ISi period. Since the previous SG inspection (TP4-31), the SGs operated for approximately 1.43 EFPY and 1.30 EFPY during fuel cycles 31 and 32, respectively, leading up to the TP4-33 inspection. Initial entry into Mode 4 following completion of the TP4-33 inspection was made on April 7, 2022. References to past SG Tube Inspection Reports for Turkey Point Unit 4 are provided in Appendix A along with a list of acronyms used in this report.
Turkey Point Unit 4 is a Westinghouse 3-loop PWR with Model 44F steam generators. The SGs are U tube heat exchangers with tube bundles fabricated using thermally treated Alloy 600 tubing. Each SG contains 3,214 tubes arranged in 45 rows and 92 columns, in a square-pitch configuration. Nominal tube OD is 0.875" with a 0.050" nominal wall thickness. Each SG tube bundle is supported by one drilled-hole flow distribution baffle (FOB) and 6 quatrefoil, broached-hole tube support plates (TSPs) all fabricated from stainless steel. Two (2) sets of anti-vibration bars (AVBs) in the U-bends also provide tube bundle support (AV1/4, AV2/3). Rows 1-8 of tubing in each SG were stress relieved in the U-bend region after bending.
A. Scope of Inspections Performed on each SG The TP4-33 inspection scope was selected to meet the requirements of plant Technical Specifications, NEI 97-06 Rev 3 and its referenced EPRI SGMP Guidelines. In addition, since Turkey Point plant has submitted a License Amendment Request 1 to adopt "Revised Frequencies for Steam Generator Tube Inspections" (TSTF-577 Rev 1), the SG inspection in TP4-33 is considered as the implementation outage to align the scope of the SG Program with TSTF-577 Rev 1 requirements. Unless otherwise noted, the TP4-33 base inspection scope in each SG was:
Primary-side:
- 100% full-length enhanced probe 2 exams of all active tubes.
- U-bends of rows 1 & 2 were inspected with the +Point' probe between the uppermost TSP on the HL and CL.
- All other active tubes were inspected full-length with the X-probe (array/bobbin coils).
- Examination of peripheral tubes at the TTS, BLG/OXP indications within the H* depth of the tubesheet, and all tubes within the tubesheet program are included in utilizing full-length enhanced probe exams.
1 Turkey Point Units 3 and 4, Improved Technical Specifications Conversion, Volume 16, Revision 0, Section 5.0, Administrative Controls (NRG ADAMS Accession Number ML21265A387).
2 The enhanced probe inspection method is described in the NRG Final Safety Evaluation for TSTF-577 Rev. 1 (NRG ADAMS Accession No. ML21098A188).
Turkey Point Unit 4 L-2022-149 Docket No. 50-251 Page 2 of 10 Enclosure
- All "high residual stress" tubes were inspected with the +Point' probe:
- in the HL tubesheet section (TSH+3" to TEH), and
- at all HL tube support structures, and at the uppermost CL TSP.
- 100% inspection of dings/dents >5V in the HL, U-bend and uppermost CL TSP using the
+Point' probe.
- All dings/dents -5,.5v were screened with the bobbin coil.
- Various diagnostic/special interest exams using the +Point' probe including all I-codes from the X-probe exams (bobbin/array coils), tubes in the vicinity of newly identified or prior PLPs and tubes adjacent to the locations of known foreign objects.
- Visual inspection of all mechanical and welded plugs.
- Visual inspection of all channel head bowl components and bowl scan everywhere within the channel head bowl with remote visual camera in both the HL and CL per Westinghouse NSAL 12-1 Rev 1, "Steam Generator Channel Head Degradation," October 2017.
Secondary-side:
- Visual/cleanliness inspection at the TTS (annulus, no-tube lane) after upper bundle flush and sludge lancing at the TTS.
- Foreign object search and recovery (FOSAR) at the TTS including in-bundle exams.
- Upper-bundle visual inspection from the uppermost TSPs.
- Visual inspection of components of the Upper Internals including the feedwater ring & supports, J tubes, and moisture separator components. UT thickness measurements were also obtained at select locations on the feedwater ring.
B. Degradation Mechanisms Found The following degradation mechanisms were identified during the TP4-33 inspection:
- A single axially-oriented, crack-like ODSCC indication (SAi) was identified in the U-bend of the tube located at R9C80 in SG-C. This was the first occurrence of a crack-like indication in the Turkey Point Unit 4 SGs. No other indications were reported for the TP4-33 inspection that were indicative of corrosion degradation within the defined pressure boundary.
- Wear at AVB contact points.
- Wear at horizontal tube support structures (FDBs, TSPs).
- Wear due to foreign object(s) at the TTS.
Inspection Expansion:
Since the base scope exams included a 100% full-length inspection of all tubes in each SG with an enhanced probe, expansion of the inspection program due to the ODSCC indication found was not required. Additional details on the crack-like ODSCC indication are provided later in the report.
Turkey Point Unit 4 L-2022-149 Docket No. 50-251 Page3of10 Enclosure C. NOE Techniques utilized for each Degradation Mechanism Table 1 a is the list of the EPRI ETSSs used for degradation detection during the TP4-33 inspection.
Table 1a - NOE Detection Techniques for Degradation Mechanisms Detection ETSS used for Detection Degradation Location / Applicability probe Mechanism 196041.1 R6 AVB locations 96004.1 /.2 R13 Wear Broached TSPs 27091.2 R2 FO wear (with or w/o part present)
Bobbin 96005.2 R9 Pitting In the freespan and sludge pile 1-28411 R4 At FDBs locations 1-28412 R5; 1-28413 R5 In the freespan 1-28413 R5 At broached TSPs 24013.1 R2; 10013.1 R1 Axial ODSGG At Dents/Dings :s; 5V 1-28424 R4; 1-28425 R4 At Dents/Dings > 5V 10411.1/.2 RO All U-bends 128424 R4 sludge pile/expansion transition 20511.1 RS Axial PWSGG At expansion transition 111524 RO Gire PWSGG 21410.1 R6 Gire ODSGG
+Point' 96511.1 R16; 96511.2 R16 Axial/Gire PWSGG In low row U-bends 10908.4 R1 Wear at AVB supports 96910.1 R11 Wear at broached TSPs 21998.1 R4 Volumetric freespan 27901.1 R1; 27902.1 R2; 27903.1 R1; 27904.1 R2; 27905.1 R2; 27906.1 R1; Wear 27907.1 R2 FO wear (with or w/o part present) 17901.1/.3; 17902.1/.3; 17903.1/.3; 17904.1/.3; 17905.1/.3; 17906.1/.3 117908.3/.6; 117909.3/.6 R1 AVB wear 111956.1 Rev 4; 111956.2 R3 Broached TSP, FOB locations Array 20400.1 R5 Axial/Gire ODSGG At expansion transition 20402.1 R5 At TSPs; ext. to DNG/DNT :s;5v 10413.2 RO Axial ODSGG In low row U-bends 20403.1 R5 freespan ODSGG 20500.1 R4 Gire PWSGG At expansion transitions / extended 20501.1 R4 / 20502.1 R4 Axial PWSGG to DNG/DNT :s;5v 23513.1 R3 Axial/Gire PWSGG Low row U-bends
Table 1 b is the list of the EPRI ETSSs used for degradation sizing based on the degradation mechanisms reported during the TP4-33 ECT inspection.
Table 1 b - NOE Sizing Techniques for Degradation Mechanisms Sizing ETSS used for Sizing Degradation Location / Applicability probe Mechanism Bobbin 196041.1 Rev 6 A VB locations 1 0908.4 Rev 1 96910.1 Rev 11 Wear TSP and FOB locations
+Point' 27905.1 Rev 2 Foreign object wear at TSPs Just above or below TSP edges
27901.1 Rev 1 FO wear (volumetric) at or slightly above TTS 1-28432.1 Rev 2 AxialODSGG U-bend Turkey Point Unit 4 L-2022-149 Docket No. 50-251 Page 4 of 10 Enclosure
D. Location, orientation (if linear), and measured sizes (if available) of service induced indications Axial ODSCC: A single axial crack-like indication (SAi) was reported on a tube (R9C80) in the U-bend section of SG-C. The indication was located close to the apex of the tube, on the flank, and approx.
3.5 inches from the nearest anti-vibration bar support (AV1 +3.49). The indication was identified during full-length ECT exams using the X-probe and was detected by both the bobbin and array coils (reported as NQI with bobbin, SAi with array). The flaw was confirmed with the +Point' (and mag-biased +Point') probes to be OD-initiated and was characterized as ODSCC. The ECT response did not reveal the presence of a ding or geometric anomaly in proximity to the indication, and the tube does not belong to the population of tubes with high residual stresses. The indication had a voltage amplitude of 0.43 volts using the +Point' probe. Flaw profile analysis (line-by-line sizing) determined an axial length of 0.16 inches and a maximum depth of 62% TW using the voltage amplitude sizing of ETSS 1-28432.1. The flaw profile is shown in the Chart below. (It should be noted that the maximum depth was calculated at 71 % TW when a phase angle sizing approach was used. This more conservative value is also benchmarked for condition monitoring purposes (see section G of the report.).
NOE Sized Crack Profile PTN-4C Tube R9 C80 Axial ODSCC in U-Bend Region 100 --,----------------------------------,
90 -+PT Crack Profile 1-28432 (Voltage Amplitude Sized) 80
70 i6o 1-
'cf?
-50
.c
-0..
~40 w
~30
20
10
0 --------,-------------,----------------
0.00 0.02 0.04 0.06 0.08 0.10 0.12 0.14 0.16 0.18 Axial Position (inches)
Wear: Attachment B provides the listing of other service-induced indications (mechanical wear) reported during the TP4-33 inspection, including locations and measured sizes. For AVB wear, the indication depths as sized by the bobbin probe ETSS are provided. For all other locations, the indication depths as sized by the +Point' probe ETSS are provided.
Turkey Point Unit 4 L-2022-149 Docket No. 50-251 Page 5 of 10 Enclosure
E. Number of tubes plugged during the inspection outage for each degradation mechanism Seven (7) tubes were plugged based on the TP4-33 inspection; the tubes plugged for each degradation mechanism are summarized below in Table 2:
Table 2 - TP4-33 Tubes Plugged
SG Tube Degradation Notes Mechanism R35C38 FO wear Newly detected indications in CL at TTS in TP4-33; most likely R35C41 FO wear attributed to foreign object wear. No FOs were observed during A R38C36 FO wear visual exams at these locations. Tubes preventively plugged and stabilized to add margin for a 2-cycle OA.
R37C65 AVB wear Wear at multiple AVB supports (AV2, AV3, AV4). Preventively plugged to add margin for a 2-cycle OA.
31% TW at AV2-0.33 (plus wear at AV1, AV2+0.71). Considered to B R34C46 AVB wear have growth potential, preventively plugged to add margin for a 2-cycle OA.
R34C53 AVB wear 27%TWat AV2. Considered to have growth potential, preventively C Axial ODSCC Crack-like plugged to add margin for a 2-cycle OA.
R9C80 (SAi) Specifications (plug-on-detection). indication. Plugged as required by plant Technical
F. Number and percentage of tubes plugged to date, and the effective plugging percentage in each steam generator The number and percentage of SG tubes plugged to-date, and the effective plugging percentage in each SG are summarized in Table 3.
Table 3 - Tubes plugged to-date and effective plugging percentage SG-A SG-B SG-C Total Tubes Plugged 37 29 13 79 Percent Plugged 1.15% 0.90% 0.40% 0.82%
G. Results of Condition Monitoring, including the results of tube pulls and in-situ testing All indications found in TP4-33 met the condition monitoring (CM) requirements of NEI 97-06 Rev 3 and Turkey Point Technical Specifications for structural and leakage integrity. No indication exceeded the structural limits. The tubes identified for plugging were screened against the in-situ test selection criteria contained in the EPRI SGMP Steam Generator In-Situ Pressure Test Guidelines, Rev 5, and provided for Turkey Point Unit 4 conditions. None of the tubes identified for plugging met the requirements for in-situ pressure testing, and no tube pulls were performed.
Appendix B has a listing of all mechanical wear indications.
- 1. The axial ODSCC indication on the tube in the U-bend ( described in Section D of this report) was assessed for CM and for in-situ testing. Comparison with the CM screening chart indicates the ODSCC indication met both burst and leakage integrity using both sizing methods discussed in section D of the report. For both methods, the 95/50 burst pressure (as Turkey Point Unit 4 L-2022-149 Docket No. 50-251 Page6of10 Enclosure found) was greater than 6,000 psi, which exceeded the 4,542 psi (3xNOPD) margin requirement. The ODSCC indication fell below the screening limits for burst and leakage; therefore, structural integrity requirements were met.
A review of potential causal factors was performed for the unprecedented crack-like indication in a SG on this unit. A lookback review of prior ECT inspection results showed no precursor signals in the bobbin data. (This section of tubing had not previously been examined with an enhanced probe.). It should be noted that the U-bends in row 9 are likely to have higher residual stresses (due to U-bend forming) than the U-bends of rows 10 and higher. This may be a contributing factor. The tube was also confirmed to be supported in the U-bend by AV1/AV4 based on the plant-specific AVB positioning study previously completed. Review of raw ECT data also revealed there was no AVB interaction with the tube at the location of the indication. The operating experience and results of this indication was reported to the industry SG Management Program (SGMP) for further review.
- 2. The maximum observed AVB wear indication (31%TW) in TP4-33 was less than the CM limit lines for both burst and leakage requirements. The maximum wear indication depths at TSPs and at TSP edges were 17% TW and 20% TW, respectively. These indications fell well below their respective CM limit curves. The maximum wear indication at FOB locations was 12% TW; all indications fell below the CM limit curve. Leakage potential for these shallow TSP and FOB wear indications is negligible. Therefore, TSP and FOB wear indications met the structural performance criteria for burst and leakage.
- 3. Three (3) tubes had newly reported FO wear during the full-length array probe exam in the CL at the TTS region of SG-A. The indications were sized using the +Point probe; the maximum depth was 39% TW (2 tubes). The tubes were located several columns in from the periphery and are relatively close to each other. It is not known whether the indications were attributed to the same foreign object or multiple objects. No FOs were identified during visual exams on the secondary side in that region. A lookback review of the historical bobbin data for these indications shows there was no discernable ECT signals at the prior inspection (TP4-31). It is likely these indications were not reported at a prior inspection since the locations were not previously examined with an enhanced probe. To add margin to the OA, these tubes were preventively plugged and stabilized. Historical FO wear indications that have been detected at TSPs were reported again in TP4-33 but showed no significant change. No PLP signals were detected at TTS and TSP locations having FO wear. All FO wear indications at TSPs and at the TTS fell below the CM limit curve.
- 4. No degradation was detected during the +Point inspection of "high residual stress" tubes, low row U-bends and the DNG/DNT inspection scope. During the array probe inspection of tubes within the tubesheet region, no indication was detected at locations where BLGs/OXPs were located.
- 5. Channelhead Components Visual Inspection:
- Tube Plug Inspection: During the inspection of tube plugs in TP4-33, all installed plugs were confirmed to be in their correct location. In addition, all plugs were found to be dry; no dripping plugs were identified. No degradation or visible signs of leakage were noted on the plugs during the visual inspection.
- Other Channelhead Inspections: Visual inspection of various channel head components were performed to identify degradation per guidance in Westinghouse NSAL 12-1 Rev 1, "Steam Generator Channel Head Degradation". Areas inspected include the divider plate to-channelhead weld, the weld at the top of the channelhead bowl drain tube, the channelhead-to-tubesheet girth weld seam region, the divider plate, and all cladded Turkey Point Unit 4 L-2022-149 Docket No. 50-251 Page 7 of 10 Enclosure surfaces of the channel head bowl and tubesheet. No degradation was found; the observed condition during the TP4-33 inspection is consistent with the manufacturing process.
- 6. Secondary-side Inspections and Maintenance:
- A total of 211 lbs. of sludge was removed from the three SGs based on upper bundle flush and sludge lancing in TP4-33 (76, 65 and 70 lbs. in SGs A, B and C, respectively). The TTS locations of all legacy FOs were visually inspected. One newly identified FO was found; it was removed during TTS FOSAR. The object was in the HL of SG-B and appears to be a piece of machine curl. An evaluation is in place for all irretrievable (legacy) FOs that have the potential to cause tube damage. Upper tube-bundle visual exams in all 3 SGs in the upper bundle reported the broached openings on the TSPs to be open and free of deposits.
- Upper Internals Inspection: Visual inspections performed in all 3 SGs (for erosion/corrosion, mechanical damage, foreign material, and unusual conditions) included the primary/secondary moisture separators, drains, swirl vanes, feedring and J-nozzles. No fouling was observed in the flow holes of the moisture separators, and no erosion or corrosion was apparent on the separators or swirl vanes. A minimal amount of scouring was observed inside some of the J-tubes at the interface with the feedring; these have been noted previously and do not appear to have changed. The welds of all steam drum components were noted to be intact. Repairs made in TP4-31 to address wall-thinning on the outside of the SG-B feedring3 were noted to be intact, and no abnormalities were reported based on UT thickness measurements taken on all 3 feedrings in TP4-33.
H. Primary-to-secondary leakage rate observed in each SG during the previous cycle No primary-to-secondary leakage was observed during the previous 2 cycles (Cycles 31, 32).
I. Calculated accident induced leakage rate As described in the H* alternate repair criteria (ARC) for the Turkey Point Plant4, the accident induced leakage rate from the portion of the tubes below 18.11 inches from the TTS is calculated from any observed normal operating leakage that cannot be attributed to a source other than the tubesheet expansion region. For Turkey Point Unit 4, the maximum operational primary-to secondary leakage rate from the portion of the tubes below 18.11 inches from the top of the tubesheet is determined by multiplying any normal operating leakage by a factor of 1.82 to determine the accident induced leakage rate. Since no operational primary-to-secondary leakage has been observed (per section H of this report), the calculated accident induced leakage rate is zero.
J. Results of monitoring for tube axial displacement (slippage)
A condition for licensing H* was to monitor for tube slippage within the tubesheet region. Monitoring for tube slippage was completed during the TP4-33 inspections. No tube slippage was reported.
3 Reference Response to RAI #3 on TP4-31 SG Tube Inspection Report (ADAMS Accession No. ML20176A287)
4 Turkey Point Nuclear Generating Station Unit Nos. 3 and 4 - Issuance of Amendments Regarding Permanent Alternate Repair Criteria for SG Tubes (TAC NOs. ME8515 and ME8516); ADAMS Accession No. ML12292A342 Turkey Point Unit 4 L-2022-149 Docket No. 50-251 Page8of10 Enclosure APPPENDIX A -Additional Information
References to recent SG Tube Inspection Reports (SGTIR)
Outage ADAMS Accession No.
EOC-26 TP4-27 ML13277A358 EOC-28 TP4-29 ML16298A391 EOC-30 TP4-31 ML19268B738
Abbreviations and Acronyms:
ARC Alternate Repair Criteria NSAL Nuclear Safety Advisory Letter AVB Anti Vibration Bar OA Opertional Assessment BAC Baffle plate cold OD Outside Diameter BAH Baffle plate hot ODSCC OD Stress Corrosion cracking BLG Bulge OXP Over-expansion CL Cold Leg PLP Possible Loose Part CM Condition Monitoring PWSCC Primary Water sec ONG Ding SAi Single Axial Indication ONT Dent sec Stress Corrosion Cracking ECT Eddy Current Testing SG Steam Generator EFPM Effective Full Power Months SGMP SG Management Program EFPY Effective Full Power Years SVI Single volumetric indication EPRI Electric Power Research Institute TEC Tube End Cold ETSS Exam Technique Spec Sheet TEH Tube End Hot FOB Flow Distribution Baffle TS Tubesheet FO Foreign Object TSC Tubesheet Cold FOSAR Foreign Object Search and Retrieval TSH Tubesheet Hot HL Hot Leg TSP Tube Support Plate ISPT In-Situ Pressure Test TTS Top of Tube Sheet NEI Nuclear Energy Institute TW Through Wall NOPD Normal operating pressure differential VOL Volumetric indication NQI Non-quantifiable indication Turkey Point Unit 4 L-2022-149 Docket No. 50-251 Page 9 of 10 Enclosure Appendix B - TP4-33 Listing of Indications Wear at AVB supports
SG-A SG-B (cont'd)
ROW COL VOLTS IND %TW LOCATION
====== --------- ROW COL VOLTS IND %TW LOCATION 29 25 0.99 TWD 24 AV4 -0.22====== ---------
37 65 1.04 TWD 25 AV2 -0.02 0.29 TWD 8 AV2 +0.04 1.45 TWD 30 AV4 -0.07 31 13 0.48 TWD 16 AV2 +0.00 37 71 1.00 TWD 25 AV2 +0.50 0.47 TWD 16 AV3 -0.07 0.70 TWD 20 AV3 +0.23 0.34 TWD 13 AV4 +0.04 25 12 0.30 TWD 12 AV2 +0.17 33 16 0.36 TWD 13 AV4 -0.10 26 20 0.18 TWD 5 AVl +0.41 33 62 0.29 TWD 11 AV2 -0.41 30 16 0.19 TWD 6 AV2 +0.02 33 78 0.24 TWD 6 AVl -0.02 30 30 0.24 TWD 6 AV3 -0.05 0.23 TWD 6 AV2 -0.02 30 76 0.42 TWD 13 AV3 -0.02 34 46 0.47 TWD 16 AVl +0.23 30 80 0.28 TWD 8 AV2 +0.05 0.40 TWD 14 AV2 +0.71 31 77 0.45 TWD 14 AVl +0.09 31 80 0.29 TWD 10 AVl +0.09 SG-C 0.26 TWD 9 AV2 +0.20 ROW COL VOLTS IND %TW LOCATION 32 74 0.43 TWD 11 AVl -0.05====== ---------
0.39 TWD 10 AV2 +0.07 32 70 0.67 TWD 20 AVl +0.17 0.33 TWD 9 AV3 +0.00 34 53 0.83 TWD 27 AV2 +0.51 32 76 0.41 TWD 13 AV4 -0.13 35 31 0.88 TWD 24 AV2 +0.21 33 72 0.65 TWD 15 AVl +0.05 12 4 0.28 TWD 12 AV4 +0.17 0.42 TWD 11 AV3 -0.19 13 4 0.42 TWD 14 AV4 +0. 40 33 74 0.29 TWD 10 AVl -0.02 22 7 0.36 TWD 15 AV2 -0.05 35 67 0.38 TWD 12 AV4 -0.25 22 82 0.21 TWD 8 AVl +0.18 37 20 0.34 TWD 11 AVl +0.14 22 83 0.26 TWD 13 AV4 +0.00 0.38 TWD 12 AV2 +0.10 24 12 0. 40 TWD 16 AV4 -0.43 37 65 0.62 TWD 18 AV3 +0.16 26 82 0.33 TWD 12 AVl +0.31 40 49 0.28 TWD 10 AV4 -0.09 27 80 0.34 TWD 12 AV3 +0.11 42 63 0.25 TWD 7 AV3 +0.55 27 81 0.30 TWD 11 AVl +0.11 0.32 TWD 12 AV4 -0.07 SG-B 28 79 0.25 TWD 10 AVl +0.00 ROW COL VOLTS IND %TW LOCATION 30 15 0.31 TWD 13 AVl +0.05
30 75 0.25 TWD 10 AV2 +0.51 26 64 0.66 TWD 20 AV2 +0.56 31 79 0.23 TWD 11 AVl +0.07 0.70 TWD 21 AV3 +0.64 31 80 0.26 TWD 10 AV3 -0.07 27 72 0.71 TWD 22 AVl +0.00 32 16 0.47 TWD 18 AV2 +0.07 34 46 1. 35 TWD 31 AV2 -0.33 32 70 0.52 TWD 16 AV3 +0.15 13 35 0.21 TWD 9 AV3 -0.68 33 76 0.23 TWD 9 AVl +0.09 13 42 0.29 TWD 11 AVl +0.06 34 17 0.27 TWD 10 AVl -0.09 21 6 0.33 TWD 13 AV3 +0.03 34 53 0.40 TWD 17 AVl -0.22 23 85 0.35 TWD 13 AV3 -0.04 34 75 0.34 TWD 10 AV4 -0.02 26 68 0.32 TWD 12 AV3 +0.23 36 74 0.16 TWD 6 AV3 -0.37 26 71 0.20 TWD 6 AV2 +0.00 37 71 0.15 TWD 6 AVl +0.09 26 83 0.24 TWD 10 AV2 +0.11 37 73 0.23 TWD 9 AV3 -0.47 27 72 0.51 TWD 18 AV2 +0.07 38 68 0.43 TWD 14 AV3 -0.02 27 82 0.26 TWD 10 AV4 +0.20 39 69 0.25 TWD 9 AV2 -0.30 30 65 0.50 TWD 12 AV2 +0.15 40 68 0.17 TWD 7 AV2 -0.33 0.25 TWD 7 AV3 +0.00 30 73 0.48 TWD 12 AV3 +0.00 0.76 TWD 17 AV4 -0.17 Turkey Point Unit 4 L-2022-149 Docket No. 50-251 Page 10 of 10 Enclosure Appendix B - TP4-33 Listing of Indications Wear at TTS, FOB and TSP
SG-A SG-B (cont'd)
ROW COL VOLTS IND LOCATION %TW ETSS 8 3 0. 38 WAR 02H -0. 67 13 96910. 1 0.42 WAR 02H -0. 67 18 27905.1 35 38 0.30 WAR TSC+0.08 30 27901.1 9 80 0.10 WAR 02H +0. 4 8 4 96910.1 35 41 0. 46 WAR TSC+0.00 39 27901.1 0.19 WAR 02H +0. 51 11 27905.1 38 36 0.45 WAR TSC+0.05 39 27901.1 28 80 0.19 WAR 05H -0. 56 11 27905.1 13 4 0. 26 WAR BAH-0.24 12 96910. 1 0.14 WAR 05H-0.56 6 96910.1 17 8 0.11 WAR BAH-0.16 5 96910. 1 29 80 0.14 WAR 03H-0.51 6 96910.1 18 86 0.26 WAR BAC-0. 32 11 92910.1 31 60 0. 42 WAR 02H-0.32 16 96910.1 0.25 WAR BAC-0. 32 13 27905.1 0.42 WAR 02H -0. 32 18 27905.1 21 6 0.16 WAR BAH-0.13 8 96910.1 33 18 0.07 WAR 02H -0. 72 3 96910. 1 26 10 0.14 WAR BAH+0.35 7 96910.1 0.10 WAR 02H-0. 72 8 27905.1 26 13 0.16 WAR BAH+0.43 7 96910. 1 35 49 0.19 WAR 02H-0.37 8 96910.1 36 61 0.29 WAR BAH-0.29 12 96910.1 0.23 WAR 02H -0. 37 13 27905.1 0.36 WAR BAH-0.27 17 27905.1 40 25 0.10 WAR OlC +0. 37 5 96910.1 39 28 0.12 WAR BAH+0.11 6 96910.1 43 37 0.29 WAR 04C +0. 51 15 27905.1 4 58 0.14 WAR 02H+O. 40 6 96910.1 0.21 WAR 04C +0. 51 10 96910.1 0.25 WAR 02H+0.40 13 27905.1 43 39 0.13 WAR 04C+0.48 7 96910. 1 10 62 0.19 WAR 04H+O. 43 8 96910.1 0.22 WAR 04C +0. 48 12 27905.1 44 38 0.35 WAR 04C+0.51 16 96910.1 11 86 0.19 WAR 04C+0.48 11 27905.1 0.46 WAR 04C +0. 51 19 27905.1 0.16 WAR 04C+0.48 7 96910.1
SG-C SG-B ROW COL VOLTS IND LOCATION %TW ETSS ROW COL VOLTS IND LOCATION %TW ETSS 28 82 0.23 WAR BAH+O. 43 11 27905.1 27 22 0.22 WAR TSH+0.08 25 27901.1 0.22 WAR BAH+0.43 7 96910.1 19 86 0.20 WAR BAH-0.29 8 96910.1 5 12 0.26 WAR 04H+0.45 10 96910. 1 0.22 WAR BAH-0.29 12 27905.1 0.39 WAR 04H+0.45 17 27905.1 0.22 WAR BAH-0.32 9 96910.1 5 86 0.10 WAR OlH+0.69 4 96910. 1 0.24 WAR BAH-0.32 13 27905.1 0.10 WAR OlH+0.69 8 27905.1 29 39 0.11 WAR BAH+0.40 5 96910.1 8 3 0.38 WAR 02H-0. 67 13 96910. 1 0.14 WAR BAH+0.40 9 27905.1 0.42 WAR 02H-0.67 18 27905.1 35 70 0.19 WAR BAH-0.37 8 96910.1 9 80 0.10 WAR 02H+O. 4 8 4 96910.1 0.22 WAR BAH-0.37 12 27905.1 0.19 WAR 02H+O. 51 11 27905.1 36 19 0.12 WAR BAH+0.48 5 96910.1 28 80 0.19 WAR 05H-0.56 11 27905.1 0.13 WAR BAH+0.48 9 27905.1 0.14 WAR 05H-0.56 6 96910. 1 40 26 0.17 WAR BAH-0.37 7 96910. 1 29 80 0.14 WAR 03H-0.51 6 96910.1 0.19 WAR BAH-0. 37 11 27905.1 31 60 0.42 WAR 02H-0.32 16 96910.1 0.12 WAR BAH+0.03 5 96910. 1 0.42 WAR 02H-0.32 18 27905.1 0.14 WAR BAH+0.03 9 27905.1 33 18 0.07 WAR 02H-0. 72 3 96910.1 42 48 0.25 WAR BAH-0.40 10 96910. 1 0.10 WAR 02H-0. 72 8 27905.1 0.28 WAR BAH-0.40 14 27905.1 35 49 0.19 WAR 02H-0.37 8 96910.1 44 53 0.13 WAR BAH-0.32 6 96910.1 0.23 WAR 02H-0. 37 13 27905.1 0.16 WAR BAH-0.32 10 27905.1 40 25 0.10 WAR OlC+0.37 5 96910.1 43 37 0.29 WAR 04C+0.51 15 27905.1 ROW COL VOLTS IND LOC'N %TW ETSS 0.21 WAR 04C+0.51 10 96910.1 43 39 0.13 WAR 04C+0.48 7 96910.1 5 12 0. 2 6 WAR 04H +0. 45 10 96910.1 0.22 WAR 04C+0.48 12 27905.1 0.39 WAR 04H +0. 45 1 7 27 905.1 44 38 0.35 WAR 04C+0.51 16 96910. 1 5 86 0.10 WAR OlH +0. 69 4 96910.1 0. 46 WAR 04C+0.51 19 27905.1 0.10 WAR OlH +0. 69 8 27905.1