ML20245J426

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Summary of 890808 Meeting W/Util & Sandia at Sandia Re PRA Study for Plant.Attendance List & Viewgraphs Encl
ML20245J426
Person / Time
Site: South Texas  
Issue date: 08/11/1989
From: Dick G
Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
To:
Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
References
NUDOCS 8908180025
Download: ML20245J426 (56)
v • d • e


Text

y

,,m c.

cD t [if 4'c UNITED STATES d /4' ((

NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION WASHING ton, D, C, 20555

..h[.*[

August 11, 1989 Docket'Nos. 50-498-and 50-499 LICENSEE: Houston Lighting-& Power Company FACILITY: South Texas Project, Units 1 and 2

SUBJECT:

SUMMARY

OF MEETING TO DISCUSS THE PRA STUDY FOR THE SOUTH TEXAS PROJECT (STP) 0'n August 8, 1989, the staff and its contractor, Sandia Laboratories met with

-the licensee'at Sandia to. discuss the PRA study for STP. The purpose of the meeting was for the licensee to acquaint the staff and Sandia with the methodology and format used in the study in order to facilitate its review. is a listing of meeting attendees.

The. licensee made an overview presentation about STP highlighting unique features of the plants, in particular; two slide along units, few shared systems', the. concept of the 3 train safety systems, an RHR system completely inside containment, and a 4 train concept for the auxiliary feedwater system. is a copy of the handouts used in the presentation.

The licensee discussed the differences between the STP PRA study and the one previously done for Indian Point. Sandia had_ reviewed the Indian Point Study so the discussion provided a point of reference for the STP review. Areas discussed were support system modeling, treatment of common cause, plant event tree models,. treatment of external events, and treatment of operator actions.

A general. summary of the results of the STP PRA wgre presented. The total core damage frequency was estimated to be 1.7x10~ events / reactor-year, with the major contribution (over 99%) coming from internal initiating events. Of the core damage event sequences considered in the study, 53% were initiated by a loss of offsite power. The second largest contributor was a steam generator tube rupture (91).

Handouts used in the discussions are included in.

The license also " walked" the reviewers thru an event sequence.

i OFol l

[

'I s908180025 890811 PDR ADOCK 05000498 L

P PDC t

7 j ;j

=-- - - -

'l* ;.

-. Y>

^

p ik

  • 7
1. -2,

iTh'ere will be,a followup meeting to be. held at the STP site..'It will_ include aL plant?"walkdown" of portions of key systems modeled in the PRA and followup-

. methodology: discussions _-if required. ' The_ site' visit is expected to occur in October;of this' year.-

OriginalSidned By George F. Dick, Jr.

p'

~

George ~ F. Dick,' Jr. : Project' Manager Project Directorate IV.

Division of Reactor Projects - III, IV,'V and Special ProjectsL

-Office-of Nuclear Reactor Regulation.

Enclosures:

LAs stated 7

cc w/ enclosures:

See next'page a.

i e

f e-O

' l'DJSiRIBUTION' 140cket File T

NRC PDR 1.o' al-PDRD J. Sniezek c

PD4 Reading'4 F. Hebdon

- G. Dick: ' '

OGC-Rockville

~

E.' Jordan-B. Grimes

" ~ E.-Chelliah ACRS.(10)

E. Holler, (Region IV)

T. Martin (Region IV)

A.'Thadani C. Moon R.:Barrett G. Kelly k P

/PM PD4/Dd-3Diek:sr FHebdc n 08ho /89 08/ti/89 An

-x-L--um--

_w------..x_=--.-x.

t.

\\ s 5

. There will be a followup meeting to be held at the STP site.

It will include a plar,t "walkdown" of portions of key systems 'modeled in the PRA and followup

. methodology discussions if required. The site visit is expected to occur in October of this year.

-LepiJhbA George F. Dick, Jf.], Project Manager Project Directorate IV Division of Reactor Projects - III, IV, V and Special Projects Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation

Enclosures:

As stated cc w/enciesures:

See next page r

m t.-

A, i

Mr. J. H. Goldberg South Texas Project Houston Lighting and Power Company CC:

Brian Berwick, Esq.

Resident Inspector / South Texas Assistant Attorney General Project Environmental Protection Division c/o U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission P. O. Box 12548 P. O. Box 910 Capitol Station -

Bay City, Texas 77414 Austin, Texas 78711 Ms. Iris J. Jones Mr. J. T. Westermeier Acting City Attorney General Manager, South Texas Project City of Austin Houston Lighting and Power Company P. O. Box 1088 P. O. Box 289 Austin, Texas 78767 Houston, Texas 77483 Mr. S. L. Rosen Vice President, Nuclear Engineering Mr. R. J. Miner and Construction Chief Operatinc Officer Houston Lighting & Power Company City of Austir Electric utility P. O. Box 289 721 Bartor, Springs Reac Wadsworth, Texas 77483 Austin. Texas 78704 Mr. M. A. McBurnett Mr. R. J. Costello Manager, Operations Support Licensing Mr. M. T. Hardt Houston Lighting and Power Company City _Public Service Board P. O. Box 289 P. O. Box 1771 Wadsworth, Texas 77483 Sin Antonio, Texas 7829E Mr. E. T. Molnar Jack R. Newman, Esq.

Mr. L. W. Hurst Newman 6-Holtzinger, P. C.

Bechtel Corporation 1615 L Street, NW P. O. Box 2166 Washington, D.C.

20036 Houston, Texas 77252<2166 Melbert Schwartz, Jr., Esq.

Mr. R. P. Verret Baker & Botts Mr. R. L. Range One Shell Plaza Central Power and Light Company Houston, Texas 77002 P. O. Box 2121 Corpus Christi, Texas 78403 Doub, Puntzing and Glasgow Attorneys at Law Suite 400 808 Seventeenth Street, N.W.

Washington, D.C.

20006

i g

. 4 -

e t-Mr. J. H. Goldberg South Texas Project Houston Lighting & Power Company l

CC*

Regional Administrator, Region IV Bureau of Radiation Control U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission State of Texas Office of Executive Director 1101 West 49th Street for Operations Austin, Texas 78756 611 Ryan Plaza Drive, Suite 1000 Arlington, Texas 76011 Office of.the Governor ATTN: Ms. Darla Parker Joseph M. Hendrie Office of Intergovernmental Relations 50 Bellport Lane Post Office Box 13561 Bellport, New York 11713 Austin, Texas 78711 Judge, Matagorda County Gerald E. Vaughn, Vice President Matagorda County Courthouse-Nuclear.0perations 1700 Seventh Strect Houston Lighting & Power Company Lay City, Texas-77414 P. O. Box 289 Wadsworth, Texas 77483 Licensing Representative Houston Lighting and Power Company R. W. Chewning, Chairman Suite 610 Nuclear Safety Review Board Three Metro Center Houston Lighting & Power Company Bethesda, Maryland 2C814 P. 0. Box 289 Wadsworth, Texas 77453 Rufus S. Scott Associate General Counsel Heuston Lighting & Power Company P. O. Box 1700 houston, Texas 77001

,-------_m---_w__--

_-u--

'.t p f4:.

m.

._ I

. Enclosure I h

ll

. South Texas Project - PRA. Study August.8, 1989 l

Name Organization.

~A. W. Harrison HL&P-lR. P. Murphy HL&P J.-Lambright-Sandia-E. Klamerus

.Sandia

D.. M. Kunsman Sandia D.lB. Mitchell Sandia M.'E. Powell.

HL&P

D. W. Stillwell' HL&P
A. Camp Sandia

-W.

Cramond -

Sandia E.~Chelliah_

NRC G.. Dick.

NRC

..T. ' Wheeler

.Sandia-o.

u - _.__-_'___ _.__-----__ _. - - - -. - - -. _ _ _ _. _ _. _.. _ _.. - _.

e r

gs y gl iop ne ar e vuii an r e pt whn i

o ek ml l

i l

c a s a c

is d

e ua pih a

RMPF SDC r r oe

~

l A

l v

oi CR

\\

r IR I

/ U

~

P S E

OU e

d "f V E I N

w n

RKL o

o EAE P

T EMI S

P g

P l

R a

n i

i) c l

i g

o i

o o

C n

l

/yws o

l e

r a

a oi o

p ee wdi i

t t

e n

u gr lwi l

e r u t

l c

e e

i s

at s

c poa M

E ahu Sl F 1

c B

hs r

r t

o f

i e

DS N

+

k ga t

i n

nt e nr i

U ta iu rt lu ec t

c u

r ar R

iWS GI t

C NN OV l

I I

^M i

A L R OE

=

M OS CE QLg/

s R

r ree n egr a.u d

t i

t r

at Wh a

c a

a l

u o

y 2 u

c

\\

i/t r

r h

.c s

t c

o r

i l

DS a

N C

i i

R w/t i

y S

n r

a U

l dnu o

N, " j.-

l o

B jf e

4 t

i N'

S tn

/

e m

ey 1

2 N

5 k

t r n

ia S

M a

d F

b nu m

o E

B i

d e

n re s

i n

u d

lr k

o n

i o

i i

P H

u a

a g

s r

Te r

in d

e e

r a

im a

n r

g e ul a

8' t

o u

t c

r a

o W uC G

e o

e D

t r

S l

t l

iagS it a

t 5

p g

l a

u i

t n e

k-e O

in ni k n G

d e loa e t

l a

e s

s s

liu ECI E E

a Mn F

n s a

d sot u

B p%

pN q '

N ro s

t iL s [#

e a

n r

l e

~

3 en e

N go G

ai l

A s

t l s e

oi s

Vm ie L

=

s_

P hn D

L s

ga e

T wf ir HT O

L R

P C

A l

E 4 O,i

, b nM{ 9 it v4wf d

c {l t

}

}y -

N f

o-l b

f.,lajd l:

j 1!l

)

p

~

N,n

~

, ggO t

WM t

O-o-I g

m ed g: g(

n y

a j

do,.

W

4. ""

9*.

r o7 p

t."

1.

l l

i.n nDG

!II II i

I ec e

e "2 e

n yec 1

Mn,YaO r

e e.

i !"

se e

b m

t ee e

st s e

eau n

aY WGo e:

e H

r u EeIS'a o

c G

n ' a T L'

~

ll

's 1

C c

T 4

/

i s

m

[

Steam Generator

/

//

Personnel

& Equipment

}

Reactor Head f-f'

-l &._ %

. N

~

d

\\

l"

\\

~%

- JUIn"e' 1-Q,

,1 Upper Intemals Storage

  • y Q

o l

l-n

! di Reactor

~

sg

\\,:.,

j

/ 4~

a

.g..

. Operating Floor Coolant -

,~ 3

'y l El. 68'. 0"

~.J

@!,[$/

Pump m r :j-

's

- Fuel Storage Pit a

L I

Reactor V.,

j Prsssure "'

I /

N

,,.,N Refueling Canal Vessel I

' \\

N'N

l. A
',1 -'

f

['R,

/

h N.

To Fuel V

$,e

  • j l l

Transfer Canal g

M w

In Fuel Handling

(-,

N e

x s

  • s.

/

    1. - Refueling-Lower 3

s,[

Cavity internals 3

Storage l

/

Residual Heat Removal Pump I

i Reactor Containment Building

)

Section STP

1

)

P P

M P

6 M

C 8

M P

U U

1 1

U Y

S S

N N

S T

(

Y A

I I

Y 1

Y A C A

S N

R N R

N R

C CN E

E T E T

I G

E A

S G

S R S

G R

R I

R C E C

R T

E C M C

E Y

M E E E

M S

L E

,~

E C

P

,~ j C

P

{r g%

E US

=

a C

u ~

A V

H

}.

7

, f.

f RY y g^ p Y

E L

L G

g-I A

,~

N h 5

M" la.

O

. R va T

g t

J E

c T

r L

c r

1 U

  • J C A

E

, " ~

e R

g R

t O

i 4

/

e n

75 T

r, E

I f

r 2,,,,

V L/

s yo - /

4, pbr E

i

.)

m =n /

j.

p a

m T

l D,g'(<<-

, 4, -)

i""

,~7y a

i a

m a

4

o n We s i

=

u 0,

f 7[u4 g

g*

a" T s

1 g

3 m'

g y>m,,,m ga P s:

q

)

a 4

a G

4 gc g,na

^

  • 1 2

'i:

[.

" O G

_ a.

N I

D j

D L

-s IU g_

R D?

O T j

T N$,f C N E

A M

'[/ (

E R N IATNOC

m i

i r

e Reactor.

C Containment,. j j

n

=

Building,.-

4

f.,.,~. <,,.,,. l. '

ccess Do.or 1

i g

,. Post Accident Sampling System

{

.y N

y' i #.y

  1. g

+l p; si

~ ~.

L ',

4.

9:(ph I

n 3 % 77/ 3'"5 4 g["

N IMs:Muy Operating Floor I

8 i

Spen,t Fuel,,Pg;ols -

5 5 hipping Bay El. 68 - 0" l

n:, -

y I',.y gy n

y 7

h 1

g,wy,,

Low Head'

' c;@l.

P Safety injection j1, 4f j

Pump w

f s

High Hea'd I ;m Safety injection i,

Pump Containment Spray Pump 1

1 Fuel Handling Building

_____.____.__m___

'4 a\\

t e

~"

'/

}*Q

~li i

ib 5

i i

's if m

!,'\\'.

~

j$

3

' je b

x E

.3

\\

/

/

s o

E

'f\\

(

y,

/

Il

'!/h h

l' { ', '/

x s

\\

x

.9

//

- /15

/

\\

p$b Tuw

/",

4/

i

,I.p1 -

N e

p//

b,

,, w$

E

',/,E

$s g

f[/h",(e

'N y

u E

g C

e

6*1; /

ti r

xi

/

\\

Tu E

N'.E Q,

.?

n, c

n

/ / \\'

m u s

\\

x

[=

j 1l i

4 o

/

E

\\

u

'Q4-

\\,

g g g\\.

j/

/

1 v

/

{

l

=h i

l g=

/

v

. s s

e 1

.e B O

.v r

b~

r nu

~

t l

t l

I F

O V-

'mo 000 0 0 _000

^

I 1

3' u

V A n.iarT

-x m

oP L'

s i

3<

,no

.i enni

__r C

r

- fc o gO O 000 3C

'C 5-z

~

E O

F 1

. =L 3'

i V

a niarT

.1u

=:

aY

)

m iig g,i 3c

. m ni m

4 r"~c',o 0 0[ O 0 0 00 C g

F

' C, a

==

5e m

=

'C niarT 1

...E-g 3

V rotareneG

.W o

h"P

.leseiD ybdnatS d 7

d s

igg,1 o

/

==k inii g"M i

1 1

5'

'o 7

1 1

=

$E d

i m

m 3

a m

h

$Y 5

m 3?

5 S

5 m

2 "n-I

0 I

  • 5 5

"0 l

)P

'6 E

"0 Y

0 T

M L

E 5

(

L R

N 3

S E

"0 O

A b

R F

E O

'2 F

P L

5 E

2 T

R V

O 8

A O M U

L R

L L

& T R

E "0

O

/

E P

t A O

L T

R

  • 7 NR F

E T

O 0

E I

,~

K GN A

O 1

l 3

NE L

L d

!l8

!,l ! l8 l

l I

EG P F

E N

D

/

I

~-

2

{

. GN T N

oA EP F

3 I

O

- 5E$

Eh DN L

I 5

S i

_1

~_

c. LE 3

i UM N I

j 'f g

l

]NE B E O

~

~

GI 0

Y3 s

RN T 2

S F

I!

O 8

R H

E

. OA C V

N L

U 0l O

O 6

E T

TR E E

L 8

3 i

T H AL F.

AR S T

"0 S

L A

'0 U O E

I DH 0

A N

RA 1

NP T

N X RM L

l E

A E

OA P

E L

TU 4

P E

NL N

-[l ll{

e

. EA

}

I E

s K

un 5 !

a A

m_ C L

E T

A N

n

.. GR S

T" E

U R5 M

AT E

I O

i-hC u

P XU I

0 S

T O

N ED AN E

L N S

R A

U K

F F

E A

Q t

t T

t H

O N

. S G X

E L

E E

N I

i J

G g5 3

I

~

N

D g3 W

E E

,W 2

${

R Eu T

E V O

.8 U

L D "0 D*

A O S E U C O

A N KL A5 Vn H E CE L 5

~

~

L ON D L "0

XI NA E E ES KP G

AO 8

CT 2

L E

r_

ro t

s t

e a

n u

n i

t r

i t

L c

O A

m t

3 n c

f j

e a

il e

ule d 8 t

au a2 S

r n

d d r,l yo GE ia HMf w

M gE

'y

.t c

l

]y f

I k

t r

l'

]

v

[

R l

g I

v O.

l n

l 3

n b"

O. o

\\

t g

N \\

y e

re ta w

N de

~

e E

k F

ca y

l a

5' a

i w

ro r

n k

e l

t o

a a

e M

W wk v

n la da V

eTe e n

F o

g ya i

t r r a

ao l

il t o

iS s

x l

u S.

A M

1

~ - T

y C

I MO s-E

.l n

re t

d a

t e

e n

n w

e t

p o

e r

p o

d m

i mra P

t i

t i

a P

a e

n ae m

e l

t a

o r

u i

ep F

a s

e t

SO e

t I

t c

y t

n c r r

a A

r S

a o

ie e e

w c

p C

r t

i l

l ewvn a

d rg l

i h o a a w

e ule xm on i

l e

r au u u t

pP VM d v F

rd AP cd i

s d

al op f e

e e a yo eu l

i mm F V HM RB i

l t u e

.. \\ \\

N.

A D R 1_

Y <

[

"o Y

w P

I Y

y s

I'

_===

f e

r.

n x

g u

Y g_..

l s

p_.

fe i

le R

i y

m4 te w

N f

a n e S

a V

=A, v

w.

o n

g wi la it wt O

l o

/

s f

e i

d 8 m

a2 a

r.

l e

GE t

rg m

S on r

n ti o

ad f

ia rl t

i e u a

M nB P

l e

G en i

b ru T

  • s 0

S 1

ZW w

Q Z

_<w>

ww&

I F-

tne d

d s

e mt n

e a

e T

t g

p s

C y

e e

r d

E s

g n

J F

e i

S O

s E

y yl l

R nl a

l P

a c

ia i

c r

r S

i t

s tc A

e e

y h

X e

l r

P E

E h

T T

H e

TU O

S

irde la il ig Co ee t n l o l

ni p

.ia9 gr aC lom e

t u i

t t

i st y

ssou' n

nr ECP e

oh c ea cu s

st sr s

it sn E

DS E, e kn) 4 n Xl Sm u

N a

  • e T C e

a Hp I

I' p

g

' ro u S

r B

t S u

ap S

I' M

r W

em A

n u C

e P ET C(

G W

~

eC TP l

seC SE i

p D

wm YC cu S N )

cP foe

g..

S g

l Cr e

l E

h h~

l FN 5

[

OIA PR F

5 l

T I

H-SE i

{

m N E p

R u

\\

O

)

P 1

H 5

N 7-C I

8 g

(

n p

p T T a

T

]t m

m A E n

u u

e P

P L H m

1 1

l 5

5 ern H

l E

d oi i

R T a

H L

i t l

sct t an u eo R

ORC t

ji;8 I!!.

!l; i* i

! i !! '

ert E

don T

i t e sc m<

p nam m

N i en Ri u

[

a S

t

)

I 1

n

~

o X

C H

)

'C l

R b

s m

H u

R y

1 F

c

)R C

c A

p l

Rm n

V1 Hu RP l'

k 2'

St g Co e d

RHL Sl g Co e RCt

ig Co ee o

t n l

l p

a gr aC ni, l

i ru i

e o t.

at t y s

sog' n

hc nr ECp e

cu ea s

psr st s

it sn E

DS E a.

kn) 5.

T C

'X S_

N a

e 3 H g

I r

gi 3

o u r

S r

B S

t u

S ap i '

M rem W

A nu CC(

eP G

ET lW TP eC S

C s

C eC SE C

i p

D C

Wm Y

Cu S

E CP

!j.

fo

!jg"g.

S

=

!0 E

wu

i N

f

.M!

F 5

W O

'R

?"

!;; i l

.( I:

i P

n I

-n H

S lig s;s l

m 3ji..

~

N p;!

~

j a.

i u

j?

3 P

O

\\

i

__{i Y

llZN":.C k i 5

i I

i

. vg T

.o i

n

$ p

[a i;

m.

n ;

AE t

i n

o.

e P

N; L

t i -

i ii!!.m i

5 s'

r j

t t

n i E

H r

v 2M R

a

. u dol H

l i t

=.

i t Hu l

6si u

r n "

Dso R

i i b R C =_ i Ij i

ij

!;l;h f[t

1. l3i!

i[;

j 3[I drtc l!i ii : i I j i! '

U i'i E

j[

1 j:

h"~ h=k.g!

r

!i

~

n den i"

T te l

W i

iMst an l

N en jRi l

a

.!t l

ii I

d g" i

h n

iE

.6 i

l Os

.C u

n b

j m

e:

- e l

y l

i r

t t

,u i a On C

n b!~

1 p

d~

i

.h~

i Rm M: '-

Hu d

RP b!'

i is e.

p3g j

L.3 Co e St g in RCg d

RHt l5lo n

~

jj;-

l

hl a9 Co i

t "

e e o

l nI p ag gr aC l

e 8 mi I

i nd r u i

t t

nlin at y

s s8u nr ECP eoohc ea cu soPsr st sC i t sn E

n)

>DS Ee k

5m i

N a

e T C 6 Xl e

Hp I

p gi r

r u B o u r

1 S

S t

M ap S i r

W em A

nu CC (

eP G

ET lW TP eC eC SE s

i w *P Y

D S

p f

S BC E

T F

x-S W

pA 3

O R

P IHS m

N p

{

u O

)

P y. k S

pmD 7-C I

ad T

n p

rd a

PAT

]t m

m S

A n

u u

e P

P m

L I

1 5

5 ern H

H E

d oi M

R a

H L

it l

sct t an u eo ORC R

Ii-l 't ej 8 ! '

!!l ti:

i },!! '

don

{,

E ert 2T T

i t e

= - '

p scnam m

N ien u

[

Ri a

i S

I t

j ~

7l n

o X

l C

H Oc i

R

]

s m

H u

R j

r c

A j

QR C

c

~

]

j 3:g i

n

]n

.R

!i R. K } gH g

.Ri 7

-- i gg1:

g >=

H

}

li R

.'I St 9 Co 9

RH' Co e RCL

i9 Co ee o

t "

l l

nI p ag gr aC Is'm.

e i md r u i

t t

s'u nl n at y

nr ECP eooht ea cu soPsr st 1l sC it s.

E

>DS Ea

,s.

I

.i N

M!

xH ;;

I 8

ro u t.s S

B

}{

p M

r em A!

nu eP ET h~

h, s w TP

[

QC SE C

j=

o Y

g j

S jn

u
m f

.'j gc S

j E

W N_

F

,d O

R P

I H

,m S

n

_(

m

,m N

p

=

u O

)

P S

y

.k 7-C I

ad n

PAT

}t m

m T

p p

rd a

n, e

P P

A S

n u

u ern H

H l

L m

1 t

5 5

. l 1

E d oi a H

L m'

i" l

is c t t

R

~

a n m"

tu e o R

O,R C

[

g jn E

!;[t i!

s.

i i

8i

!i.!e e j g l! !;j,5:

er t don p

tI" s

m,-

T mn m"

it e f,

scnam ei Ri y,

N S

ien g

a n

y, I

t 5

Mg n

jp,.

L~

o X

l n

C H

g.

g R

0 m

H l"

4:

p
['

u R

c 0p p

Hu c

p A

Rm

=

RP 0

g' st g Co e R H x.

d Sl g Coe RCL

W H ni i

hl 4j" e

H Co gr E!

o

![

C s, w =i f i" e

np p e js l

ijw aC N

e m

l t y tnd i

so nHn5t nr E EgP h eP.Mth6eh@

ea st f1 in lC. IDS i

s.

l E..

i i!.

n}

k i

.Wl!j i i. 5 ;.

N a

r

.f" d 'N ",

T c

.M' H.

e 9

$r I

g S

S gi r

I~1 o u u g I

tap S j M

r Wg em nu C

eP C {

G ET lW TP eC g

eC SE s

i p

D YC W m v

S C u C P fo S

8 E

T

(

F S

W O

R P

I 1 )/

HS m 7,s N

P g\\

u O

g/

P S

y $

7 C

I ad T

n p

p rda p AT

- At m

m AE S

n u

u e

P P

L m

S 5

I i

g ern H

H E

d oi a H

L R

t isct t an u eo ORC R

ei*

i iij ; 'i.I I

s e!i'

! !i don pI" E

ert T

it e o

p scnam m

N en I

Ri u

a S

I tn o

X OC C

H R

s m

H R

I i

F OR C

a p

Rm n

Hu RP st 9 Co'

,d RHl c o '9 l

,Cl

Ifil!

!i1 i

GNU P O O O O CL LR AE IT T A NEW S

P SE OO L

D m

N A

W K

W C

O E

P N

I R

S S

t f

TN A

T EN WEA O

H PI S X GTE M

T H O

PN SE W P

NDH N

C E

I E

C MR LL O C UL L

O P P C OAE NM P.

O WU OC T C

C S C

CS A I

P L

WM S

A M

C U R

C P SE S L IT L

I EI N

T HC E

L

)

R L

Ms Y

S U

O A

E T

T AU YS S

C E

A S

CD B*

T G Y

EIS SD ER S

D E R

(

1 EM LESSEV XR

M yr e

E J

a i

T l

i r a x

oT S

u A

5 Y

S t

Rp e Ec n To AC No n

W.i T

a n

n n

DT ]i gi 3i n

r o

o o

,i t

t t

t l

l l

l r

aa a a aa a a u n u n u n u n Eu o

t g

., tcg ccg At g t

t t

i i

i i

EF As AS AS "AS A

F iwf

'n n

'n n

~

A Y

l R

A IL IX U

9 N

A S-

~~_)

~ ~

'N

)

Um v m Um vn tne m

c' Q<,

r k,

e rn d

oia i

t s

tt ii t an u eo o Rc ert doa it e stm

/

/

/

/

naea I

Ri a tnoc 9*W m

^

Oj O @;

N J

J

A S

P P

T S

D S

N S

N A

T O

N I

S E'

E T

S S

V C

P G

U S

E A

P N

A L

I I

C E

L R

L D

A O

N E

N O

N T

E D

O M

R A

E O

M E

R W

M M

E T

E T

O E

X P

E M

C R

E O

B E

T T

F F

F S

S O

T O

O E

Y N

C S

T E

T T

N N

V N

N E

T E

E E

E R

R M

M M

E O

T T

T T

F P

A N

A A

F P

E A

E E

I u

R L

R R

D S

T P

T T

Y E

K O

O 0

O O

)

S L

G E

D D

O E

M E

R E

R H

N E

T I

N W

W O

L

)

S O

P S

T E

H E

N C

S E

S O

I T

G U

R R

S RI N

B F

T E

ES I

S R

A I

WF L

R N

H E

M C

Of E

U O

T T

(

N PO D

O I

I A

E O

FDT W

W S

D EF

( EI E

N TO M

DD D

E A

L E

I M S SUN E

C S

B P

SS S

E S ELO D

I P

A E

FS R

T P

TCC U

V T

D S

FO O

S P

AN L

R P

L OLS T

Y I

E TIY C

EN T

Y ET E

M C

S E

S R

N SO S

C NN D

HHE E VM R

RA I

I N

TIE O

TTT V

T T

RED LT E

RLM M

IIS R

EWN S

AA D

O P

WWY T

O T

WOU M

IU N

PNI M

S C

P N

OPO E

TT E

PIu E

RR A

P E

P B T

NC P

UAQ T

EET P

U V

C S

EA E SME S

WWR M

S E

CA8 Y

S D

/

Y OOO I

I S

SS OOM S PPP R

RYY ED M

TTE P

M E

TLL T

R E

T T

CCU E

W CNL R

DA T

TTS R

IIS T

O EOA O

NU S

RRY O

RR S

P L

C P

AG Y

OOS P

TTR Y U E

I P

E S

PP P

CCE S

C S

U WF PPL U

EEH I

6 A

S CA T

UuL S

LLT T 2 R 1 B CS R SSA EEO R 1 T

R O

E O

C E

P E

P E

H P

R P

L T

U H

U E

O S

T S

O O

O O

O

)

I R

P T

E N

(

E M

Y P

T I

I U

L Q

I E

B R

A O

F C

T O

I c

L A

N E

P DF O

S T

S P

O I

U D

N M A HA T

A E

E E

TT A

C S

M T

R EE R

U E

S O

MB E

N G

Y F

P O

S D

S

) S O

M I

U D

L' M

S J A

L E

GG F

O S

Y S

L N

MN O

C S

L N

P A E

( I P

A O

E M

S F

P N

P N

R RE E

O I

A D

T I

C EL D

E S

S TF O

T E

S D

T M

N V

A E

E EF E

I B

L S

LO S

M T

E A

U T

A N

D B KN O

A T

O O

EO I

E I

I M

A EI R

R L

T T

RS A

T A

A Y

A GN VT U

C L D A

R Q

I T

EP RAN F

I R

LX OTU Y

I C

A PE FSR L

T I

E I

T N

L L

T A

S A

P C

L T

O U

X u

U A

M Q

E N M D

O 0

O O

O O

N O

I T

A N

L O

U I

C T

R SA I

S R

TEL C

E S

O NRU E

I M

E S

EUC R

E C

A E

S VDRS R

N R

R E

EEIL F

U E

G T

C0 CCE O

T D

A O0 GOED P

N I

O R4 S

NRRO T

U E D T

P1 L

IP M RDR P

E -

E T

F AE E

E E

RH D

AEOE TEE D C

E PS O

IS E STB N

R A

M TNTR Nu M

E T SW SIORT TAT E

U A

E S

LNPA AR T

Q M

S N

E M

EISTT AR S

E OS L

DO R

E D

ESN EUO Y S RES E

EP L

T T

ORR ESGGT S

FTE D

SSU A

S MO OVPA A

R T

A O

LU N

T Y

JYTEUMER E

N NTA M

E D

O A

N S EAC OAGE T

E OST S

DEE I

S ER SEMNEERDAN N

V I

T S

OES T

P VETRR ESSG ME I E TD N

P MRA C

SEWROTHGNN EAG AND E

P TB N

P L

OOT CROORRD F

M MEN V

I E -

U T

ESPPCTAEPPOO M

O O

R E E

ERS F

S DM PENEMSSJCEA R

OR REE OECuVE EEEA RE T

F FET T

TWE Y

MTIS VR RRMOOT N

NW N

OR L

SR TEOW NCS E

D IOOS A

TPT T

FYTRC FOTTE M

E P

L N

S OSCEAE LNNE T

P P

P ECE O

EHPNELEAR A

O ACU VIS M

STLTMINOVLH E

L MISTL ERN EREOILOFEPT R

E R

TO S

GO T

V STR CCP T

AP N

E E

ECE IES N

TP I

T E D TEH SLE E

SU A

A T

ALT AER V

S M

L E

S TEO B

E E

L L S E

P E

O P

R M

D D

W O

H O

O N

T T

T C M E O

0 O

O O

O

~

S L

T L

N A

E V

C R

E I

O M

F L

S A

I D

S N

E E

I R

S T

)

S E

N 8

A T

E 8

B X

E M

9 E

R U

1 N

I C

W R

F 0

S O

E S

0 U

D H

T R

Y S

T N

O L

L R

K O

E F

L N

E L

V E O V

A R

E D W W

O E

S 1

S F

L S

S E

8 NI A

A A

R 9

OS N

N E

I 1

IY O

R L

T F A

(

TL I

E S

E O

S CA T

T S

R N R

P E

AN A

X P

O R

RA T

E P

N S

F P

U E

N I

E T

T T

TS E

F H

N N

S A

NT M

O W

E O

M IN U

V I

E C

T T E T

E LV O

N R

C R

AE D E

A L

A O

I M

A R

M TL E

T E

N E

AA T

A H

R T

Y PN E

E T

E N

G SR L

R T I O

E P

T F

X L

DT M

O E L

O EX O

A D

LE C E

R I

O I

T E

T H

A E

A H

A T

T R

T T

P E

E O

S O S M D M

O O

0 O

O O

A R

P R

)

O S

J I

A S

M Y

S L

N E

A I

S N

Y A

K L

R O

A N

O O

N O

T B

A E

A S

D U

D L

N N

R Q

E u

O A

E I

S M

I H

H N

A I

T T

H B

S C

N O

C

(

A N

E N

A S

T G

O R

M A

N O

T D

I D

T T

D U

S M

E A

u E

A A N

I L

R S G R

S M O

T E

E S

u P

I D

P P

D T

M T

E O

0 P

N C

P I

P C

M I

A u

T L I

N F

R S S R

E S

S O

N8 T

C U

W E

I7 S N

S Q

E C

T A2 O

E E

I N

N w1 S

D S V

E E

S -

A D

R U

M R

E K

D E

Q T

rC T

S S

E T

E A

O/

O A

A L

N S E

G N

B T

I I

R EE A

T T

SR S

S D

T R

N UU I

I E

E O

A N

S S

L D

T T

T Y

Y I

A R

S L

L A

E R

O R

A A

T R

E P

I N

N E

O P

M F

A A

D M O I

O O

O O

O O

O

T Y

C T

D N

A N

L O

E S

ET A

O U

P VR M

T Q

E -

R S

E N

T O

R R

I NN N

E F

I E D

D V

F N

S E

A E

TE F

U N

C S

D Y

N O

O N

P UD L

EP S

I E

LE L

VO D

L T

UN P

CT AS ETNN I

S QO T

NC UI OA A

E EI S

I E N S PNI T

U ST R

AYR OI TY E

Q A

N SI MLE T

AC D

YFC I

IDP AW PUN GROI S

I TNO HI TE ECNE F

S YERNAP TRCG CII VNI E

LRTE ITAR NFMOOT S

AU M"

E W

E EI I CI N Y

NDRPYT RDM UCTETA L

AEOI RI DOEE QE RAU A

C TUES ETE EPE CQ N

YOCQVF DCLT S.S D R I A

RRAEOF UABN UOFE EPE C0 YLE A

RELFI E Y

V RGE RCRDL YECC DR R

O -

NRR EN NP RTNNSOT E

C LI" E

VI LA EFEI WM V

EMAT V

O A

NS VAU O

T O

RR URMO CYUDOE O

QYDNN C

ENARC ELNEPR CDELNI E E

FTATEE RLAEUU EESLI V

R O

MSTR AMF D

RZ" AWTE T

MC DE Y

R L

SR G

RI EC ML E

UM EO N

EP SO RA N

SO PH O

TY AR EN E

ER YS L

T BP TA G

RF T

T R

G O

O N

W H

O T

S L

0 0

O

~

~

E G

Y 4

6 4

A C

M N

0 0

0 A

E 1

1 1

D U

Q x

x x

E E

'R R

7 2

7 Y

O F C

C 1

1 1

N E

U Q

Y E

C R

N F

E U

E S

S Q

G T

T E

A N

N R

M E

E F

A V

V D

E E

E G

E G

G A

R N

N M

O I

I A

C T

T D

N A

A O

I I

E I

T T

R T

I I

O P

N N

C I

I I

R L

C L

L A

S A

A T

E N

N O

D R

R T

E E

T T

N x

I E

L L

A A

T T

O O

T T

~

I t-6 I

~b

?

o c<

t.

x w

m es c

O D

&O W

d w

yc r-z g

W w

O g, -

C w

to w

n2w w

to y.

m U

E z

e o

w 2

o z"

D F

<x-------

O e

2 ~5 E

E W

x o

. u.

x W

l "g

g-________

i o E

o<

~2 z

6 x

0

~

e 3

c U

w w

g 2

c t

O c

O R

w J

c G

z W

7 O

C C

w n.

x C

E

=

i.

l l

1 l

l l

l l

l l

to ac.

MISN30 Ml"119V90Bd e

r4 e

a.c.9 u.

NHLPIN0083 052689

  • l-22 Pickard, Lowe and Garrick. Inc.

1l!

l

.i

=

I

~

T T

L L

E E

E M

M S

A F

F E

O O

L S

E E

E P

R T

M M

U L

I I

O T

E T

T R

N M

G A

T T

C F

A A

E I

O T

F H

H A

I E

T T

T N

M A

A S

G I

E P

P I

T R

E S

U E

E G

T L

S S

A O

A I

A A

M N

N A

E E

A O

D F L

L D

E E

E I

T T

T T

R R

T P

C A

N N

I A

L E

D D

A R

T O

M E

E L

C N

S N

T T

P S

I I

I A

A E

A L

L S

D T

T T

O O

G N

N N

S S

E E

E O

I I

P M

M C N

N T

N N

U U

S I

I E

A A

T L

E T

T A

L G

N N L A

R O

O M

A C

C S

L P

U I

O I

I I

V R

I I

I G

S T

L L

A U

T S

O E

T R

F E

O F 8

1 9

2 T

D 2

3 3

A T C T

N S

E C

E R

G E

A P

M A

D T

N A

L P

Y D

C E

N P

E U

U O

Q R

E 5

5 5

6 G

R F

0 0

0 0

S 1

1 1

1 G

L E

A x

x x

x P

U T

N 8

3 8

0 S

N A

4 5

6 3

P U

I O

I I

I V

R I

I I

G

'}

w I-1:.

I o

l.

e

~.

I w

=!

~E w

2 W

t' w

O D

c e

w O

. c.

>O m

.5 en ee

_ "g w

a?

a e

o o

2--

<x.__.=

z x

w co w

2,*

e E>

y 0

2 2

W m

5

'8 c-w a

w e

2 c

g-o.________

u-M C

  • O w

~

N o n-C n.

e

-t 2

o e

w a

1 2

0 3

P z

at w

O 1

c

-o w

c.

=

E

-m a

f5

&on.

a.

I

-l i

I

'l-1 I

I I

I L

g

-d MISN30 Ml"lIBv80Wd e.r 639 m

l l

1 2.1-24 NHLP1N0083.052689.

Pickard, Lowe and Garrick, Inc.

______-____s

2 i -

i0 i 1 i

i 0

1

~

)R x

A 3

2 E

-0Y 1

1

- R O

i T

E i

C L

I A

TN i

ER E

C i

R R

E E

P i

P S

H T

5l lllIIl IIl II N

T E

9 l

'0 E V

i 5

1

(

= -

i 0

i Y

N1 i

C 5

A xil i ll N

0 E

i E

3 1

M5 U

i x

Q 4

E 2

i R

e F

IIIll iiiiI 0

=

D S

1 x

N P

7 A

l 5

ID l

P

.E 0'

i U

M i

1 O

i R

E i

G L

i I !I lII llli iii TN i

i ECR E

P H

i TS 0

1

.WsO [2i8a*

i i

O y i "- o ?. Ia @

i N. 7 f j9i80 oUE.

i

I t-I 4,

l' l

l

__ ro

?o x

-g l

N.

w i

4 o x w

- -'o

_s g

o-z f,

d c

c c

w w

a C.

c m

w m_.-___

z m

w>

o ' W-g *o 3

2" o

m e

<x-----

z e

w e-w a

x 2s D

m.

o o

e w

n a

c x

a e

m z

e C'

o o

O a

uo t

W E

2 w

  • A eo

_a oD g-

-o

.c c

a 2

w o

I O

7 c

w o

c.

m

=

+

3 a

2 oun.

I I

I I

l l

l i

I I

4 o

-d MISN30 MMISYBOWd t.

.P t,

.1-3 NHLP1N0083.052689 Pickard. Lowe and Garrick. Inc.

I

- e e,

.e, 4,

p; <

g-i l'

.+

i. ':

I o

11

~

l e

~

o u

80 N-It w

a C

X W

2w 4

O C

C O

w w

c.

a.

o O<

- ~w g

y C

W o

A m

M n

m 2

W Wg I,

o 2

0 x

w Z

M

~

9 E

w O

7 L

O g

w C

c.

2 o

2 om O

x 5

o e

~

m W

6 W

2 2

O Q.

c 0

D C

w O

=

g a

O O

  • 2______

3 0

C C

w

=

c.

=

=

1 rn ao l

I I

l l

l l

l l

l i

E o

i

~

AllSN30 Ain10V90Wd g.,

W W

h3

.P u.

NHLP1 N0083.052689 2.1-26 Pickard. Lowe and Garrick, Inc.

la e

tog, m

T a f

3 9 7

7 6 5 5 5 1

1 1

1 oa 5

D tnee cr r op eC P

)

r s s s s s s s s s s s e

r r

r h

e e e t

h r

h r

r r

r I

p a

a a

a a

a a a t

n n e

t e e e e n

" t y y y o o y o y y y y s

  • n

" e 1

5 7

m m 7

m6 3 4 6

ie 3 6 5

4 6 9 lp v

1 9

1 1

e 6

5 4,

p 1

1 1

e 6

2 8 a

8 n

1 t

o n

(

eve gn i

t ia itn I) i r

e

" a h

  • e t

" y 2

2 5

3 4

2 d

4 e

" r 0 0 0 0

0 0 0 0 r

1 1

1 1

1 1

1 1

e e

4 1

x x x x x 1

h p

x x x w

1 1

1 s

0 8 0 4

7 3 9 1

y t

r s

n 9 2 6 6

1 2 3 1

o e

e g

" v c

e

" e n

(

e ta u

C qe tn s

ev m

E o

r g

f n

y i

t

)

c i

8 n

a e

t r

in o

uq I

A e

y t

(

r g

b n

f e

in n

v l

w s s t

u t

w E

o o

n le B

o o

lF e

m v C w A w d

g C

n W E C

F g

lo C

lo e

D k

r i

a t

n V F O F o

e a

A M

it 5

L c

i 2

W l

W o V

r t

f i

d B

n H

o it a

f a

o 1

F l

C a I

E n

e B

p s in e

p M ml 1

ir s

n ir lA T

r g

A O T e S o

i 2

E T o a

r v

t L e 2

r e

is le n

f f

fo e e o o l

h o

n t

i s b r

e P R a

t c

s c it O s b e

a s e b

O T l

r s a s v e

r l

s r

c lo a

O G o e a

l o u x

o e P T

L S L R P A L T E Is L S ggiobg 39E.

! 3aOE E.

i l!.I

!j j

r 1

'2 e

h*

4 u

7 3

iq

  • g n

hce t

n 5

4 ito 0'

0 1

1 a

l x

x u

m 2

6 is 1

5 p

o lraC e

tn t

o a

M e

H g

at n y

a a

n s

t R

c e

c c

isi c

e H

e f

ui D

D n

f n

f e

E d g u

e e

e is r

r q

o o

my e

C CI r l S

ol f

f f a o

o*

t r c n

ei e

s t

s" ps v

s s"

i E

o o

nt a l

L ot eg it s

a a

e u

m b

l l

r e e e

a a

st t

ef C

h v o D

le ia iar is eia n

n et en n

n s

s s

f t

e Dr d

e ia iar it s

y y e

s o

r r o s

r t

r u

n c

u ie r

r o o

n a r

f o

e f

et e o

a n

T Tt T

Tt f

f m

e a

On ah ia D

a On H A hB W rWre rOr C

ia W

rWe rO l

r t

te%

t l

r t

e r n

F it 1

a F

eF n et n

s d F

eF n et ne c5 a

A vAe vs ne n

A vAe v s r

r o

oa ef t

t o

oaiv o

o n

tr n

n o

e e

n cnG ceh E a

,a n

cnG ceGat ui at t

n p

u s

e eem eli r

r e eem ell r t

m q

s i Rv Rt wg e 0e i Rv Rt eu e nn v

v n

a so v aa e

E s ia a

r r

a n

n n

r r

i E

h s

eo D oDte o

ri Tr ot e

e D oDte o

eH I

r f

ri ot T

S y ot ia G iaG

- T Sy ToD1 g f

b et e

e s

o ne er at r

e e

a e

n s s u

r r

e r

ineD erd ni e e Tl n

r n

ri l

irD y

S h

r ee n e

e i ub ol iaoai it r

r r

t r

e e

i r

T n b ub oli lu eia ul e

r ir f i lu Ws b wn s

I wl hi a

l e u aueo l

l l

f r

ir f iaoee ie i

t a o Ci u aueo m

LAG T FTbB FPGt D ED T FTbB FPF wi v

h n

m n es u

a c S

e n me

)

r 0

eef 1

r hf e

i t

d f

w e

o tn o

r y 1

e P

ac v

n e

E e

d e e

a g

it u

g t

s nq P

n f

ee f

i O

sf r

(

ta e

f 3

i r t o

pl ti P

u 1

n s

O ss I

2 s

e t

o O

lur e

L L

sa lb e s a

R A

T 1

2 u, Y

- g l*

g1, gj g" ah{8

[

lji l

o u

' T 2

2 2

in q

fo hce t

n y 4 4

4 ito c

0 0

0

" n

" e la 1

1 1

" u x

x x

u m

^q 5

3 6

is er 4

4 3

F o

lra C

e tno M

at g

na s

n t

R e

c isfic c

e H

A A

I ui n

f D

C IS C S n

f e

E u

e O H O H d g eis r

L H L H q

o l

f la o

ol my e

C f

rl S

a o

e e

f a

fo e

e r c tn S

S r

r ei e

s P

u E

o C

li P

!u ps t

v s

i a C la nt a l

R F R F g

iot e

s a

I ta e u

m la b a

t v o r

r B

r D

e n n

e e

e rP e n s

s e

w ia iar w

d il e

w eD y y e

r s

t r

o r

r o o

n t

P f

e r o n ir: a C

oC l

P T Tt P

a u

f os P ed a m

n On i

a f

t t

a C W rWe C

A ia r

r O ea C Cn t

b e a e%

r n

F A F eF n A

s r

et h

A t

a A

vAe r

T v s r r

cS r

t r

r n

V o

V o

o a o e V o o n t

o e

0 n

cnG 0

a c e t

v 0 pt ui n

t a

pa 6

e eem 6

a el O 6 p

u r

r r

u nn v

v 1,

e F m

q 1,

i R i a Rt e 1,

e aa A n r S n h

e 4

r r

4 n

C o e

4 s

D oDte la G

a i

e f

e r

e l

l T

A T o Gg i in a

ot f

la o

b it S y V

a cG s

e e

u e

r it le s s e

ir eet h t

n n eD n

H rt l

y S

n i r

r n

e e e c

r e b lub ol e P s B lu wst e h s la ul a

s r

r f l

s ia e i s

c e m

s u ia ueo s D ie f

oiw s

ei o

A v

E T FTbB E P D E FPDS E TD m

n se u

a c

S e n me

)

r 0

eef 1

hf t i f

d o

t C

C er y n

A A

a c 2

ev V

V n

d e

E H

H e

e g

u t

a g

D B

n q P

n A

A ee i

E E

sf r

(

ta e

f f

3 i

r t o

o t

P pl i

1 n

s s

u O

s s I

2 s9 sU lt o"

o" O

e e

L" L"

L ur s a lb e

a R s T

3 4.

5

'A qE$g5

[. E

,41, E! 3a R?

l

o 6 5

3 2

u T

1 1

1 1

q f

in o

hce t

n y 4 6

c s

4 o

  • n 0

0 0

it 0

" e la 1

1 1

1

" u x

x x

x u

" q m

^ e 6 6

2 0

is r

2 2

2 2

F o

lra o

C e

tno M

at n

g a

n s

H H

H ic t

R R

R isf e

c c

e A

I D

D D

ui n

f n

C S

f e

E d g u

O H

e e

e e is q

L H

r r

r o

o o

my e

f S

la o

C C

C r

l ol e

f f

f f a t

e o

o o

r c n

S r

eit e

P lu s

s s

ps v

s s

s i

E C

i o

o o

nt a

a R

F L

L l

g iot e

s ta a

e m

lu b r

a a

s s

s a

t D

l e

r n

n n

v o eeg e

r io io io e n P

s t

e e

i sh w

eD y y t

t t

e s

t o

n f ie P

c c

c r

c C

t C

i e

n O Ditc o

n A

A A -

ia n a r

f u

P ed m

t t

t w

l r n r n r n d

C C n t

a A

h D ia r

t oa oa oa t

l t

l t

l e%

r S

a ee n

F d

r n

l A

t a

r r

T vi e r

aP aP aP c5 r

V o o n

r r

r t

o o

oa r tr n

t at n

cF o 0

pt ee ee ee ui o

e a

,a a

e 6

pa ph ph ph f

p u

r m

q e

e F ee u

Ot Ot Ot nn r

r D

R h b 1,

e e

e e aa S n e

n n

a l

miz mz mi t

4 n

C o

r s z

h i

s e

e f

r V

ot a l

l e

i l

l A T r ot a

r i r i r i ot o

b G

iaG f

Tl H

er ae it icG eb eb eb s

T T

T s s u

a a

a e e y

S le e

h n

n le t

r r

eer gt S gS gt la r

u e

h s Ws D S

ul s

liwn e s

c e n n

n a

e e

f Ci A

a oev s

ei oo oo oo v m

iD ED E FPGO E TD LT LT LT o

m n se u

a c S

e n w

mc

)

lo r

t ee F

f i

h i f

W d

t fo t

e F

r y n

3 e

M acn v

f d

e E

o e e g

u a

g p

t s

p nq P

n ir s

ir ee

(

i T

o T

s r t

f a

l e

r e

3 it o

l n

pl r t P

i t

a i

u 1

n c

it b

O a

O e

a u

ltss i

2 r

r e

ur e

L R

P T

s a lb e

a R

s T

6.

7.

8 9

A w $3 u*

g { n. O ?. E a C b 1

u f

iq

' T 1

o n

h c

e t

n y 4 o

c it

'* n 0 1

a

" e

" u x

lu

" q m

^ e 0 is r

2 F

lo r

a C

e tno ta M

e H

a.

tn y

g s

a e

e c

c in t

c i

c e

e s

f D

u i

n f

n f

e E

d g

u e

is e

r q

o m

e o

ly C'

r la S

f f

o" t

e ic r

ne s*

p s t

v s

E o"

n ita L

o e

t g

it s

a a e u

m e

d l

b a

a t

n v o h

C D

B et g

e n a

r s

f e

d i o u

n n

d y y t

e n i e

t r

n s

o n iai lo tn a r

f o

e leg i m u

a He r a f

C i

A O

On v T r o

T B in a

l n

F s

et l

d C

l t

1 E t

a r

a r

v s eing nW R too e%

r o c5 n

aF H nC n t

t o

oa sh it r

n o

e t

c eeit nA R ef u

a i

a p

u r

el Dwi e

v io n n n

m q

e Rt it v

p e

o Ge aa e

n ad s n i v h

r s

e o

e o I

Di o

it r

i d

f r

l ld o

ot o

b G T f

r oit e d

s u

e aah eD dle eM s s rF y

S le r

e e

in r

eb r

e e t

r r

r b o m

ie lu s a Cd a

ia owet u

los e

lul s

won e r

t f

o a

f i

o e o

D FPTGa TM CD NF v

m s

n e u

a c S_

e n me

)

r 0

ee 1

f h i f

t f

d o

t e

n r y 4

e a c v

n d e e

E g

e u a

g tnq P

n ee i

(

t s r f

a e

3 l

r t

t P

pl t

1 n

u OO ltss i

2 e

e L

ur l

s a b

e a

3 s

T R A 1

z q;$y8g u

,',,O

?kn.

f. 3 a 5,

.u.

'4, l

CE

=

h

$0 wF W%

-cr L C j

u E

c

  • T T

S

. M.

e C

O

-a

=

es x.

x

=

h$

5

=

A

.O e

U w

c02 ea c

p5b E

E y

I

==

f

~m DE t

a E

e oI TP F

0

" I E"

U E

O

'=

M c

E 0

y n

a a E.E W

D U m c-J E A 03

==

$Q C

8 E

e e

a 3-n x

O

>0 O

E a e gm Wc C

C e e c

g V

~O MK R

%. E

-D Co 2 eE x x Q.

M C

o coe o 6

6 O

e c

g

6. >

c m 6

w Q

2 hC y>

b b hE 3

-ee cS8 EE e

OgO o g

oc,oo r8 e

==

S "E

6 8

4 C

A m

u 6

(

p c

m g

gM D

W cM g #

(

>(

m

=

b 6

oO 4

6-H

> eg c g

g o O mog c

O o

g.

u o aM s

y c u oOo c oc w

Gy oJyo e

wJx. o o eo m

s u

u u

3 k

C e c k g <

=C u g>

m g

e g<c(

  • j E

c o 0 SR O 0 02 eBgo Fw00 0 m

m wa m e

=

C op

'5 -

a c

t_

o a

0-(

Com 5 6

6M x o~

u0

+hI E

p T I E bt 2 c 5 ES$o E=bTJ 2E E

T m e 2y2o c o

=ne-z m e

ym-e E E ^ 'E

  • NI ECIEE
  • 'O E

I <

'E C 'E Y E E

a w aaam w F ue$m

<0 Ho aaomo g>

m o M

W c Eo m

O hh 2C

~5 w0 E>

e m

w no C

W D

]

o

=

e cF l

n.

e=

mb w

o-2 o

e U$

?

?

L 1

O O

mm eJ O

O

=*

i J

J R"

a, a

g <a E

e-N H

NHLM N0083.052689 2.l-11 Pickard. Lowe and Garrick, Inc.

s

e 0

0 uq 1

1 in hce t

n 4

4 ito 0

0 1

a 1

l x

x u

7 7

im 1

1 s

p lo raC e

t n

o M

at g

s n

t R

R c

e H

H sf e

c i

ui D

D n

ff e

E d g u

e e

ei r

r q

o e

o m

S C

C rlol f

f f

t o

o r

n ei e

s s

ps v

s s

E o

o nt L

e L

ot i

g t

a au m

r e

d la a

a h

n 8

v D

l e

r C

a t

eeg e n ef r

g e

s o

u n s t

s d

it e

e is ie e

h wia t

n i d

y n

r c

C c

o r

n s

on iai lo eg i

e t

r n

e f

f o

n w

On He e

n O Di P T a

r a f

t f

u C

l v T o

Bn a

r l

h d

C W A

O T C i

t a

A B

ia eeS A

F s

et i

t r

r iE d

oo e%

l r

n F

d r

l l

ng nW R a

r r T vie A

r v s ein aF H nC n

t o

c5 n

t o

o oa r V

o o ash tr n

a nA R ef ui t

t n

cF o 0

n f

a c eei t

t it o

e a

,a a e 6

e r

eliDwi e n v o nn a

p u

r m

q e

e F ee r

B R hb 1,

i e

Rt it v

p ige aa v

ie o

t 4

r n

Ad s n r v e

n n

n C o r s la rI r ot D

e o

e o Oi o

d f

i s

e e

A T t

o b

G ia G r

l o

ot G

T f

r Ld d i

V ot a it oit e n

erFaah eD ae e

le r

dle eM s

u T le e r r h n

ib s

won e r

H y

S le r t n

eb r

e r

e e

i r r

ee r b o r

s B ia oev s u ie lu C ie lu a

~

s W r

e sa Cd ul wn e s r

to os e

la m

ie A

ia owet u l

i oe D E D E FPGO E T D

FPTGa TM CD NF f

v m

n u

a S

e m

)0 ee 1

hf t

fo t

e n

r 6

e ac v

d e

E g

e a

g nq t

P n

ee i

(

f sf n

e 3

I t

rt, P

P pl f

1 n

O O

ss f

2 O

O t

l e

L L

ur l

s b

4.

Re a

3 T

1 1

, r-g

=

". TU g E.E f i @ j*_8 T

l L

e

't o 9 9

u T 0 0

iq f

n hce t

n 4

s o

0 0

it a

1 1

lu

", x x

m 5

4 is 1

1 7

o l

raC h

k n

c g

e t

r us n

u e

ot oi y

o p

taS r T r

r S

o M

O h

h t

t e

k g

sW n

at.

c n

e n

u eR v

g u

e a

o u

n Gr l

n isfic s

t NI t

ni I

S h

it e

c t

mt n

t c

e h

ui n n

f g

S a s u

n n

f o

H ee Co la d g e

E u

z ei u

s o r H

Si e b

o t

r v wu o

m q

r e s a lot C

r ly e

h f

S t

iz d ul o

ol r

e a

d f

f sV F n A u e

r e

o r c t

v O

lu tue e

n C s r

n I

k in ei t r

s p

e s

oa s

is ppe S e i uep Hr r o

nt E

L a

a S

F RDO HBD L ot e

it s g

a e a

u b m

e S

la s

f t

a h

C k

ie p

v o D

C tef R

itc l

d o e n h

t s

osg me no y y e

d e

e k

is r u er S aR al t

r n

c c

f n a r

eoo ir t

et r nd i m z o o

f e

u a

n u

r V C

il A

t 6ntah e

a e

a vSt we t

a hB S Or R

ur lad t

t s

e%

r r

e s e a

o o nwO n

F s d V

et s n V eW Dl c5 a

r r

v s P

t n

a eo e e t

o o R o

r C

n r

y r

l e

or ui r

n at l

e pGt u

O c eGF n t

t o

e a

,ar P

ell er n

etpf oo e

t f

g n n p

u r

B eApo Dmio au a Cf m

q e

e Rt e

oet in a a AsCOC a p SR r onl r

e n

n e

t h

n s

e ie o

f riOk s i

Tt e r nt T lao ot b

G aG iz o

T f

oDL cr SS o oa eP C e e o

s o

r u e e

s s r

u Tl u

erd et v r

y S

le e s n e

r S o lu wV Vne r

r r

lu n igR lul Ws e

lu e o c

ileO Ope r

s s

wl oR R en a

f m

ie e e ia oae i f e n a

aliH a o p

Ci r

h v

D ED PO FPFbt U FbP POG FAR s

m n e u

a c S

e n me r

)0 ee f

1 h i f

t f

d e

o t

r y n

ac 7

e n

v d e e

E e

g u

t a

g n q n

ee P

it r

sf

(

a e

3 it r t pl in P

R u

1 I

O T

ss 2

e O

G ltu r le L

S s a b

e s

~

a 5

6 R A T

1 1

Eg-l

". 7 0 y{a. [*

& O4

l lIi

- 9 N

/

  • 'e 7

~

' l" a

.e t

    • o 8

u

' T 0

iq f

n o

hce t

n y

4 o

c it 0

  • n a

1

" e l

" u x

u

" q m

^ e 4

is r

1 F

o lraC e

tno M

at n

g a

e c

in s

t R

c c

e H

si f ui n

f D

n f

e E

d g u

e e is r

q o

my e

C r

l S

ol f

f a t

o r c n

ei e

s ps t

v s

i E

o nt a L

ot eg it s a

a e

m d

lu l

r b

ee a

t a

st C

n v o f

D eiea g

a e n s

n s r

f ai i

d y y r

c it e

e Dr in lo n

e s

u e

tn a o

n f

u eo r a leg iam e

OnH T r o

B in C

l t

a A h B rO T C l

t i

oo e%

r d

t n

F d

et n nW R 1

o c5 a

r t

r vs ne aF H nC n

t n

t o

o oai v r

n at nA R ef ui t

o e

a

,a ceh E p

u r

Br eli e n p

ige aa t

v o nn e

Rt wg v m

q e

e o

e n

n a

n i v r

h n

s e ie o

ri r ot Di o

it d f

I ld o

ot o

b G aG T r

ot ia f

d s

Tl er at eD r

r i dle eM s s u

lu eei in r l

n eb r

e e y

s e

e r wn b o sa Cd ul r

Ws s

a t

iaoe e o

os e

la o m

ie e

r f

Ci u

i oe D ED FPGt TM lCD NF v

h m

n es u

a c S

e n me

)

r 0

ee f

1 hf t i f

d e

o tn r y 8

e acn v

d e

e E

e g

u t

a g

nq P

n ee i

r sf

(

ta e

3 i

r t t

P pl i

1 n

u O

ss i

2 e

O ltur e

L l

s a b

e s

a 7

R A

~

T 1

y*..i %

EqE$g$:

EE. o2 :a

.E.

ll

l l

i i

.^ -

'l" a

  • t e
  • o 7

7 u

' T 0

O' in q

fo hce t

n y

4 r'

o c

'n 0

0 it 1

1 a

" e l

" u x

x u

" q m

^e 1

1 is r

1 1

F lo raC e

tnoM at n

g a s

c e

H H

in t

R R

c e

c si f ui D

D n

f n

f e

E d g u

e e

is e

r r

q o

o my e

C C

rl S

ol f

f f a t

o n

o r c ei e

s s

ps t

v s

s i

E o

o nt a L

L ot eg it s

a a e m

lee d

d lu r

b a

a n

n v o C

st A

d t

f D

eiea a

a e n g

er nW n s s

d it Dr in i

d e

isfe aF d

y y e

n t

e n

s u

ai lo e

c t

r f a A A e

t r

n a o

a f

eo leg n

f r a leg f

u iam B OnH T r o

Bni e

Or n

C l

d u

ie Bn n

t a

rO T C l

h B r

i i

t d

e ot av oo e%

l r

t n

F s

et n

nW R oo 1

n r

i n

vHe T D nC n

a r

vs ne aF H nC at o

v o

r t

r t

o c5 t

t o oaiv o

r n

nA R ef

,a c1 E n

r ef ui t

o e

a ceh E p

u r

eli e n p i o Be Ri g vt t

v r

e n eo vo nn m

q e

Rt wg ie o

Ge n

h i DM it d f

v iGe aa e

n a

n n io r v r

n oit h

s e o ri r ot Di o

it d

ie I

t o

b G T r

ld o

aG T wia o

ot f

a ot i eD d

d s

eC eM s s dle eM at r

u e r ri Tl e ri n

s r

e e t

ee n in r l

y S

e r

eb r

e r en i nn Cd ul a

i wn b o r

sa Cd s

lu We lu I

s wibii t

aoe e o os e

l i

o e Ci iao e aa e

la o m

ie r

r f

h ur r oe u

h D FPGt TM CD NF ED FP TTT NF v

m t

s n

e u

a c S

e n me

)

r 0

ee 1

f hf t

f id o

t e

n r y 9

e ac v

n e

E d e g

e u

a g

nq t

P n

ee i

(

t r

sf a

e 3

i t

rt P

P pl i

1 n

u O

O ss I

2 O

O lt e e

L L

ur l

s a b

9.

Rs e

a 8

T 1

1 A

EgE$gh3 y,1

  • y5*" f k p3S.5P

!?

o 7

u

' T 0 0

iq f

n o

hce t

n y 8 8

o

'n 0

0' it c

a 1

1

" e lu

" u x

x

" q m

^e 1

1 is r

1 1

F o

lra C

h k

e c

g t

u u s n

rot oi y

o taS r T r

h S

o M

h r

t t

e g

sW n

at n

u e

g n

s e

eR v

a o

u n

e Gr l

n R

ic t

ni i

H sfi c

c h

t n

e mt it n

t ui e

f n u n

D n

f a s u

E o

la d is g

q tee Ce e

e z

e Si e b

o r

d u l

wu o

o my r v S

t e s a lot C

C roll s V F n f

a f

f n

r o

o r c e

u e e"

ei n

I k

s s

ps t

r v

t E

p p e S o '*

s s

i u e p Hr o

o nt e

RD O HB l

L ot a g

it s a

a e m

la u

n b

a s

e t

D k

p p

v o h

o e

t m

O d o dt e n s

ic e

n o n o y y r

S a k

al W

aB t

e c

F n a r

C u

et u

nd dh i m A

a l

we s

eg t

l vS t

t n

a l

S s

n o

em le us e%

r r

a F

ad o

B oV V e e

Dl ia v a l

t h r

c5 tr t

t lor T

C r

R n

r oei o

n y

a O ui u

ct o r

t p

e tet lo oo a

eS B gP nn u

p g

W m

t q

au is f

Cf R e S in r aa n

t i F

s I

e SR r o

onl A

o o oloz ot r

e h

r f

f s

o T T la o Tf o T oi s

o r

b nt o

r et r

o o:

e eP C i

a eCu s s y

u u

eb r

r r

r o

r r

s e e r

S V n e e

e ul l

lu n a

v gR F

lu wn lud s la o R en lu m

Ope la a ialiH l

ioer e e f

y ia er l

al m

POG FV FAR A FFGD FFP v s u

n e S

l a c e n me

)0 r

1 ee f

h f

f id t

o e

t r y 0

n 1

e ac n v

d e

e E

e g

u P

n ip nq t

a g

ee rT sf i

r

(

ta r

e 3

i 1

n R

to r t t

pl i

c u

T a

ss I

2 e

G e

lt le S

R ur s a b

e s a

0 R

1 A

T 2

2 l

yyM z, $yo$E

?ka.

! !a 3E

se <

~

Table 1.51. Analysis of Top-Ranking Sequence Contributing to Mean Core Damage Frequency I

Sequence Element Event Description een Frequency (per year) initiating Event Loss of Offsite Power 9.0 x 10 2 All Three Diese' Generators Supplying Safety-Related 4.5 x 10-3 System Failures FollowinD 4,160V Buses initiating Event Turbine-Driven Auxiliary Feedwater 1.1 x 10'1 Pump Train Failure To Recover Auxillary 7.1 x 10'1 Feedwater Operator Actions Failure To Recover Offsite or Ons'te 3.9 x 10

AC Power Remaining Plant Response Successful Operation of Remaining 9.9 x 10

Systems Total Sequence Frequency

  • 1.2 x 10-5

' Product of contributors.

l NHLP1N0060.040889 1.5-B Pickard Lowe and Garrick. inc.

.,1

'+

g..

Table 1.5-2. Analysis of Contributors to Diesel Generator System Split Fraction G3 l'

- Loss of All Three Diesel Generators Frequency Cause Alignment Cutset Terms.

1.

2.168-03 Failure of Three Trains of Diesel Generators (1-1,1-2,13) 2.

1.607-03 Total Hardware Contribution 3.

1.070-03 Independent Hardware Contribution 4.

5.370-04 Total Dependent Hardware Contribution

- 5.

.1.665-06 Diesel Generator Start - Common Cause 6.

4.543-04 Diesel Generator Run - Common Cause 7.

4.355-06 Diesel Generator Room Ventilation Fan Start - Common Cause 8.

3.153-07.

Diesel Generator Room Ventilation Fan Run - Common Cause

' 9.

7.322-07 Backdraft Damper Open - Common Cause

10. 2.395-05 Diesel Generator Feeder Breaker Close - Common Cause i t.

9.665-06 4.iG-kV Support Breaker Open - Common Cause 12, 2.137-05 4.it-!.V Load Breaker Open - Common Cause

13. 5.700-06 LOSP Trip Relay Energize - Common Cause
14. - 4.916-04 Total Maintenance Contribution
15. 4.095-04 Diesel Generator Maintenance Contribution
16. 8.191-05 Diesel Generator Room Ventilation Fan Maintenance Contribution I
17. 2.089-05 Total Diesel Generator Test Contribution
18. 4.873-05 Total Human Error Contribution 19..

3.377-05 Undervoltage/Overvoltage Device Calibration

20. 3.907-08 iP28PF03-EW 0011, Operator Falls to Open Cooling Water Valve
21. 1.491-05 1P28PF03-EW 0011, Post-Test Restoration Error

. Note: Exponential notation is indicated in abbreviated form; i.e.,2.168-3 = 2.168 x 10'3 l

l J

NHLP1N0060.0408tB 1.5-9 Pickard Lowe and carrick. Inc.

A

L S

E N

E D

O E

N I

I T

E L

O P

R T

U H

N M

R T

E R

EEEEE EEEEE A

D E

MMMMM MMMMM V

N I

Y T

I I I I I I I I I I E

R N

TTTTT TTTTT S

P EEEEE EEEEE D

E I

6 E

E GGGGG GGGGG R

D I

8 N9 AAAAA AAAAA G

N V

L1 TTTTT TTTTT I

I

-2 UUUUU UUUUU R

E O

N 8 OOOOO OOOOO E

E O9 W

R C

SFFFFF FFFFF I

1 E

S Y E OOOOO S OOOOO O

H S

N E

P T

iR

%%%%% N %%%%%

I V

S R

M A L

I 51114 L 44886 k

A S M V 51111 7

N k

V 8

S R

A M E

R U 8

k 3

Y 1

3 5

A T S 1

4 E

W S

3 S

N W

.L F

SS R SSR OA O

NRR U NRR U O

F O

F CC NI UUO O NI UUO D

O SI M M

T-I I

LR EM OO H S M OO H NS P

&O G 06 7

0 HH E

0 HH AY H

06 6

P T A3 284 G 3 - 285 V A G

E CS T

0 - - -

I A

kW R - -

I U

T T

NH O 'O 3 1 2 8 U

03128 5 F D

O T 4

s O

3 O E

I T T-E S

DR 9

L 7

EO 33 a 4

HH D

F SP F

AE GG O

l I BR ER M

O e

e O

i

1]9]l 4i' i;

i

!1 Yka g :.

. e' '

....e 4_

2 3-

.I

'e i

2 2

0 I

2 8

I 1

6 I

1 ESA E C SA T

C S

n T 4

S I

O 1

E W H R n S)

O O R

F F

U T

T O

O O H

L L

E 2

(

P P I

l L

N 1

7 2 T

O 3 3 N

IT 0 0 E

A 5 5 C

R G-G R

U

~

E E E

M M

-P D

U U m

0 N N o

1 l

D D S

~

~

N N

~

A A A A I

j

~

A A E

T T

L T

D D N

t r

2 2 E

8 e

3 3 C

0 0 R

w 1

1 o

E

- ~

P G G P

E E n n m

~

e U U 5

i N N 9

ls

\\

l f

6 f

o f

~

o

~

yr ev u

o l

4 E

c L

e t

r T

N n

E o

C N

C4 R

E P

1 l

2 h

6 t

N 5

5

\\

1

\\

I e

\\

\\

r s

i u

g 0

iF 0

9 8

7 6

5 4

3 2

1 0

1 0

0 0

0 0

0 0

0 0

$Na0 E y"53$o zf: 15ae6Sg*

,u, i $

m fE1 1o.j.F.

l(l r

. e e 'es s v..'

'if.

=

,+

  • I

,. =*

w d

5 8r

- n E$

g e

g G

f C

Y

- "K 5

E E

g e

c

~

E I

E i

- 2 w

N E

2 g

>=

3Fi e

Y O

eC O

o l

Ez

f ari g=

l e

I

(

l l

I I

I I

l I

p o

e se e.

e in w.

m a

m o

k.

W o

o o

o o

o o

o o

ADN3no3wd 3Au'annno NHLP1N0079.051589 15.6-22 Pickard, Lowe and Garrick,Inc.

Retrieved from "https://kanterella.com/w/index.php?title=ML20245J426&oldid=3908568"