ML20237J880

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Discusses Hs Phillips 861031 Memo Re Review of Insp Repts. Request for Review of Brown & Rooot Audit Performance Past 1982 Confirmed.Citation Concerning Historical Deficiencies Fails to Discharge NRC Enforcement Responsibilities
ML20237J880
Person / Time
Site: Comanche Peak, 05000000
Issue date: 11/04/1986
From: Barnes I
NRC OFFICE OF SPECIAL PROJECTS
To: Phillips H
NRC
Shared Package
ML20237J513 List:
References
FOIA-87-428 NUDOCS 8708180390
Download: ML20237J880 (1)


Text

_ _ - - _ _ -

Go qq 7

-fq o

2 -

t o=

l MEMORANDUM FOR:

H. S. Phillips, Senior Resident Reactor Inspector, Construction Comanche Peak FROM:

I. Barnes, Chief, Comanche Peak Task Group

SUBJECT:

REVIEW 0F INSPECTION REPORh

Reference:

Memorandum Phillips to Barnes dated October 31, 1986, same subject.

q With respect to the subject memorandum, I believe it is appropriate to restrict comment to statements for which I have direct personal knowledge.

I certainly requested that you review Brown & Root cudit performance past 1982 and expected it to be comprehensive.

The purpose of that request was to provide a fuller context of audit performance than provided by information from only 1980 - 1982 time frame. Without.information from 1983 - 1986, a meaningful assessment of enforcement significance could not have been made and Region IV could not have responded to any IE question in this regard.

Accordingly, I do not consider that a citation concerning historical programmatic deficiencies either appropriately discharges our enforcement responsibilities or fully captures performance in the area in question.

i 0@ nag sgned BY.

Ian Barnes, Chief Comanche Peak Task Group bec: w/ reference letter R. L. Spessard, IE S. Connelly. 01A l

i l

RIV:CPRT IBarnes:gb ll/.r/86

\\ b' 8708180390 870814 PDR FOIA WILLIAM 87-428 PDR

___;