ML20214F452

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Forwards 840620 Telcon Records Documenting Addl Info Re Alleged Deficient Expansion Joints,Provided by Alleger in Case RII-84-A-0094.Record of 840607 Telcon & Related Info Also Encl
ML20214F452
Person / Time
Site: Vogtle  Southern Nuclear icon.png
Issue date: 06/21/1984
From: Lankford J
NRC OFFICE OF INSPECTION & ENFORCEMENT (IE REGION II)
To: Herdt A
NRC OFFICE OF INSPECTION & ENFORCEMENT (IE REGION II)
Shared Package
ML20214F174 List:
References
FOIA-85-221 NUDOCS 8611250307
Download: ML20214F452 (7)
v • d • e


Text

.

'A 88 4 UteffE08YATES

,ef 9{g hvCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION

.? , , . e nEason u

{e I 191 MARIETTA 8fmEET.N.Vi SutTE 3900

/ ATLANTA.9EOAGIA 30333

          • ~

/

JUN 21 1984  :

l MEMORANDUM FOR: A. R. Herdt. Chief. Engineering Branch Division of Reactor Safety FROM: J. 9. Lankford. Investigative Coordinator .

SUBJECT:

VOGTLE: ALLEGED CONSTRUCTION DEFICIENCIES CASE NO: RII-84-A-OO94 Reference our memo of June 12, 1984. subject as above.

We have been recontacted by the alleger in this case. The enclosed memo documents some additional information regarding expansion joints he provided which will need to be included in your review of his concerns. ,

As always. your assistance is appreciated.

Jeff Lankford Enclosure Memorandum to Case File. 6/20/84 l

l l

8611250307 861120 PDR FOIA FOWLER 85-221 PDR g

MEMORANDUM TO CASE FILE (x) Telecon !

Participants:

ALGR  ! Files RII-34-A-OO94 i

( ) Mtg  ! J. B. LANKFORD I Date: 06/20/84 '

( ) Review I I Times 3:30 pm Confidentiality Req: Yes ALGR called to provide additional information.

1 EXPANSION JOINTS - ALGR had earlier identified a concern regarding the removal of ether foam between the control buildin's and the fuel handling building walls (See Memo to Case File dated 6/8/84).

ALGR explained that attempts were made to remove the foam using cables with hool.s. He said the cables were powered by air. ALGR is concerned that the hooks may have caught r,h conduit which ran between the two walls and danaged or loosened the conduit. ALGR, did nct know which level any damage might have occurred. ALGR enplained that there is an area where you can view some of the .

remaining foam. He described this area as B Level of the Control Building, Unit 2 side where you enter into the fuel handling building. He explained that in this area you can remove some plyboard from some joints and see the foam.

13 Prepared by: J. kford Date: 06/20/04 \b

MEMORANDUM TO CAEE FILE U:) Telecon :

Participants:

W. A. ----HASSON.III:

-----I-E4-A-0094 File: RI s ) Mtg  : J. B. LANEFORD  : Date: 06/20/E4

Time: 3:20 pm

( ) Review  :

Confidentiality Reg: Yes ALGR called to provide additional information.

EXPANSION JOINTS - ALGR had earlier identified a concern regarcing the removal of ether foam between the control building and the fuel handling building walls (See Memo to Case File dated 6/8/E4).

ALGR e :clained that attempts were made to remove the foam using He said the cables were powered by air. AL5R cables with hools.

is concerned that the hool.s may have caught on conduit which ran between the two walls and damaged or loosened the condult. ALGR did not know which level any damage might have occurred. ALGF esplained that there is an area where you can view some of the Jb remaining foam. He described this area as B Level of the Contr:1 Building. Unit 2 side where you enter into the fuel handling building. He enplained that in this ares you can remove some

  • plyboard from some joints and see the foam.

ALGR explained that the NLRS had declined to pursue his complaint.

He had been told by the NLRB representative that he might be able to pursue the issue of his < 4A? s~ under the " whistle blowers" law. I told ALGR that I celleved that the " whistle blowers" law only applied to individuals who identify concerns o the federal government and not to private corporations. I toic him I would attempt to get some additional information on this.

I told ALGR thet we would lile to contact the GFC Ouality Concerns Program and review their review of his concerns but we w .ul d not be able to do that without divulging his identity.

ALGF atted that we wait a weel or so before proceeding with this resiew. He said he would call me baci in about a weel..

A ha 4e still worling with the union in anattemptlgg Mpparantl.

f 1

Frepared Es: J. L niford Date: 06/20/E4 i

l1J r

- . _ .. .g. _.M m,-v - ,--m6- wy,.y,, ,-i. - __.

.F ,

[. 7_7 3 . g ,p, .v

~ *

  • ' 1

MEMORANDUM TO CASE F2LE

~

ISi~iel e Eon ~I~E$r~t IE[p 3n t s i~5r~[~YEU55 ELL'~ ~ ~i~Eil ei~R 55 ~E d ~52665I ~

i ) Mtg Bruno URYC . Date: 06/20/94

( ) Review  : Jeff LANIFORD  : Time: pm Mr. TRUMBELL. a lawyer with the National Labor Relat2ons Ecard (NLRB). called to see if ttfe NRC was f ollowing up on concerns of ~'

~~

. TRUMBELL described the concerns had identified to him and they were the same as those provided to RII byl .

TRUMBELL e;;plained that the NLRB was not going to be able to help We enplained to TRUMBELL that the NRC would review the technical i ssues identi fi ed by . but the NRr old not I

address the circumstances surrounding g

, 5 - s '. ,

f*",-

r 1

I l

l i

/b

w. ,

--g e Of M, 8 e g ,

@NM, @$$Mh%"$h!$iN'7M!hl)hh.M(fjjj(ggggpfgjgyi e

z

u -

m u,s u ,u o w es e m o m u n .ns. V~ * ' ' * * * ' " ' "'

. , . e. .. r i.e , e **

  • e ' : * :-
  • ~  ;

RECElvlNG DFFICE Dschet Number lif applicckts! -

). Focilitylies) Involved: 1*? o m.1 ers me e ven s. o. n -

V067Lf IO f C. OIO Y 3- }

graesac. veine Gt NE RtCI II I IIIl

~

. I IJ l t: .

2. Functional Arests11nvolved.

IChet6.ppI6peiste boste 1i _ operations . ,

onsite health and safety I construction -

offsite health and safety

._ safeguards ,_

emergency preparedness

_ other (specity:

3. D2scription: 1)lt IL. l6 l(, l(l3l lClo l#'l5 l7 l4 lu lc 171/ l e l#l lbl Elf l/]

u .,,,i ic, wa ch...cie,.'

icitlEl.'flclllEISI I I I l l l IIIIIIIIIIl IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII

^

IllIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIlll

~-' -

4. Source of Allegation:

tct ett orp'on'isie boil --

contractor employee _ security guard * ,.

_ Iicensee employee _ news media

_ NRC employer _ private citizen I organiration tspecif y I

V.,otherispecisy1 SAMfd 8*WTAAC70A fMPLCYf(

't l

MM DD YY E. Date Allegation Received: g g 7 lg g/

f,. Name of Individual tr ..i , . so;i:.i. .og t.., n.m ei 38 [ A a/A'Fosf b Rectiving Allegation.

7. Of fice: g 7J ACT10N CTFICE
t. Action Of fice Contact. es . i s 6,,ii;.ii .no 1. i e . .. d 8. [ A A/A404
b. MS lelephone Number:

7 4 g .

4 / d) { 4/.

10. Glatus:

s e i,, , , .. , _/ Open,if followup actions are pending or in progress Closed,if followup actions are co npleted MM DD YY .

11. D0te Closed:

l l .

12. Remarks: l l ll l l ll l l l l l l l l l l l l l l l l ll stinui to so chaieciersi g gggggggg
13. Allegation Numi er:

Det. e v.e, u., /7 R {y -

g s/ -A- o o 9 d

- _ - _ - -._2.::: n .._- ___-_., ..,_- _ - . _ _ ,- - ,__ -. - ,-_-_.

MEMORANDUM TO CASE FILE

~si ic~ econ _--_ -- ----- ----------- ---: File: RII-84-A-OO94

Participants:

J. B. Lantford  : Date: 06/07/84

, 3 ngg

Time: 3:30 pm

( ) Review Confidentiality Req: Yes ALGR called to to see what action we had talen on his concerns.

I e:: p l ai ned to ALGR that the intale structure was not classified as a safety related system. However, an flooding evaluation was

-in progress and the intal e structure was included in this evaluation to determine the effects should the structure fail.

ALGR also described two areas where concrete pours had been made prior to the removal of all trash. One area was around the reactor where neutron detector slots are located. The other area was around the 5 way restraint area. where there are penetrations for steam to run to the turbine building. ALER e>:pl ained that he did not 1. n ow the proper terms for the locations. I suggested that we have another telephone call and I would attempt to get an engineer to sit in so that we might get a better understanding as to the specific locations he was talling about. .

ALGR stated that there is was a pipe in the control building with water running through it (11 the time. He did not 1.n ow where the water was coming from but he had heard that there was an underground spring on the plant site. He had heard that there had been some problems with bact. fill sini:ing when the initial construction began.

ALGR stated that his main concern was with the GPC Ouality C He feels that he'was mistreated and Wor.-'ensProgram.

for bringing concerns to this group. He sold he Inows at

- others who have attemped to identify problems and they have been reassigned.

(:: -

JEFFR QVB. LANKFORD titVESTIGATIVE COORDINATOR

} 0l T

a4

/ .

l *

.?,.~.... . . N .'*

,~ _ & }Q}2,':.~

',,' p;

.c q ~~  : ' l* _'.f.

e

, .~

~a ;. 7  ;

b

< ; % :[ ??t:6-. v

..' *- n' se .

K7

- i m.- '. --

'  !< f :' ..;-

.~

r , ,., ,r ,. , * ;r e- i, '

.s?"

I's: ;

, ,, .L'd f ';*? *  ;.,"l-:9 ~

1. ' ' t,,.K. ,a'r.h, w;.)r.

.a e,- '(

', , v7 9' e ' *;. .n

-..& co;et e .,< ~*^3_..e ],?'.?.; p'.

~

A

~,.: sy w . : n t .'.

.  :- - v . . ,

e - , J:b.+b.

we. ~ -l * 'v- ., ,"? % ~ ...t'-

. (; .. p*, y sjh W :& , ; . .

  • .b h '. e t.

m~, vf..-Ay ,-n.:.H.:cc. p , w ,s .... ..,y

~. sp%. .* . f.g v s; 4

.44

^ vg aq,p .p,v i. -l$c).L ,

  • o1wqu}.] h. s

,.-y..ru.2 4. Qg .u; . m,:..w p

^

W

$.$&W 5*fW'&_

_ s Y ,' f EWHW% & f _& 53fY. GMMMMM.KC$ 0 Wb M ?Y  %;5.h$ 4 W

sR Me tf,-@g)N;g. nt W M M O W g m%il %2 h m e:q u w, R

a w.g..

~

g

%.. L.s. p Q %@ p,d@g 4.y p;tR p/ N f . .,.

m

m. v.=p;e w p wwe%g.m

,2<-WW m:.w

.p ;L o

.u

.e.p  : M.t,p w<e&.%w-B H 2 f%Q w

sfMw., a -

.wp c g

-g.~a?v/M:&PMf?'M.ure.ft%

f W % %.W0

~

n

?R 4:W'N p$$ e ':- . ;

m W QQ w 16Qfa, r

f# &(G?y" 14k J+f--iQ W

&m&y#we%e[a & lme%m _ _

1 W w

~*C**= h C d

'. dghm

&. g,

_4.o%@My%g%p,.g.e y:7:a k" .

8 - g.6 ,w @4 Jn s Tu - as ar m m - r=~- M & A een) -< w alw@py*g :g.g , w 'n i hq

pK  % www na um4.u==f... - ..._._t 3 % f. G r i

. ,':: O J],6:::,%:

s .L. .

V.;:% h ;)%., :h?'lp %c. < m.%wl.y&jQR:. e,f 1 p h: .

E D nunrnDDn2,13Y  % if3,, ; ;; ~g:e .

D > w eram, em me me tnam a em>=n..  ;'. . :. VE-

f. 21. es .*

i&W* *' i; I

t

.y. ...p - -}p c 1.<g z

%fn p ,* *: ,, _

EO I OE EM d&O d# ' UEId" " * * * ** **'"a= $ ..y 1 . 1 I

b-

~' f." ,{* i *.S N. . ** "

. . .Wc'%< *

..I f *[. %< f4pO. %naincito N.uvut ,=.R V*;w a',m. ,,4  !

.,. b,e

-/M4: 9: 2-$f %

. , c.> %,.v/ v u

.Q t b & r .f,HI.t.Qg_.4h.

e gW,; ,o .ma 4.. .;1 .

,,4 ,,u.. g .,u y .s _ _ ..

k,[k<.v.N h:khN@kk'ghkp's..pc. e m . u,s: - b

+ --

a. mm.ur.

Nw . ..t. .

l y,h  ?. lm n~ y,.m <.w~.e,m$

. if'* h ,

" 5' '

t kd Chw

  • L

~

% hYkkN, A e b;

p: g ;g 4; w ,.D., ..pp.@h-ca.m.ee i

.w . 'T g

rma o

-a (: - Sy?

! '* . h Yi Wms Y$' b - - - - - - - - - - -

i .i s.c li cy f 4hs %yY

r.,- .o = a.

sa. ~u c~-- ar - -

.s. - -

D &,,f.

gly.-. v i MW=.w@m

.W. ,L. '.y..,e Y' Y. .

k%kr$I' *~Y&I* p ,

( %w .

%n 'a T, . =

{ eW

\w,Yhl[ j Ms?!'.Mi 5 . _ _ _ _ _ @__M

,NkIh:.Nr.h+;, l b, $,-  %- k'r:M,e.[. c n ,,. - h f s roosus v - me, n i.e e Q 7

m.,y
.g;: ,

kj e xhf a$ ,  ;

j s ts.Ast.s To osum == == s<c. t etws @7 ih- . g.5.M o m

-.se%w:e.m&p%IN@2 t ~

N. w:M .

.-R

.m g

Vw

n. rtc Q M. qw;&_M:y: l

2, %m;M.y.w.: -

e 9 %- .- ,

1;~;n. .

.. .wc' c.n..p q .. c.-<.-

e 2.$ c . y _*r WA * * * *

  • 0$,,hh
  • s
  • th .$ *2 O V,*f.7", ,'- )

t.

,';'f .?,;.f Y 'l:?.f > .-L :y 3.:.y p,.Q

...,n~.- --- . _. ~ . - = , .c <.

O

.v%m@c.s - . a;.f;,.h; g.q?'eg. } As *

<?

? YnY.?

7 y, a. ch:.??.,yg,wkhl..

>: o AvgvWN %W: : w.%. . . ..

. %u,, h.y: .,.,.

. l,

.ws. .-:. c:c.- ye,f[.s:.

wbu.i m.s %,. ~ ... ....,'I  ;~,

e . c..

m<.v...

.'y .n' y:

. . ./

  • ,a e.~ m . :- w ,,L.,.....

- .m.,.s~,

L P h , ;, . * *,f*, *c*

k [., . n ,,n:

L

,[ . v. ;4 c.}- . 8 "I$%', '$,A. [ *NI

. . .g 'a,'(

.* E

%. ,.45*frv 4 jf;;;+:v 'rfy ..;. ': u . i .,

ciQ t

~qm . .6. ;g*'

%a~h . a p%,e -; ^u v.
:. Q; i. 1., . :., . . ..:> -

s ai , ;m.e. ,.: , :. x .

..=.& '." . :, -

x*4'"B"'f'y'**u'3*'F'**m:r

<f m , )Q'i.;c':3".) QW'1"*T,*",Ml'?]s y,y 6 .n ,: .%. r - .

.jgr A n, r >g' f?g*T***9

,3 . L . - M

,x ] q~V.?. ~ o.o u ?,.r M.Q:..

.:7'

,. t .' .

53 f g g,- fg 9ge: t j ? h.f n:s& af. g 1,,

'.y) }Fg&fnk,W.TilW.p f;g; j  % %.:. M. Mag:

,g.9ppy . - _ _

Retrieved from "https://kanterella.com/w/index.php?title=ML20214F452&oldid=3274920"