ML20209H319

Proposed Tech Specs Pages Modifying TS 3/4.4.8.1,Figures 3.4-2 & 3.4-3 to Extend RCS Pressure Temperature Curves to 20 EFPY

ML20209H319
Person / Time
Site:	Waterford
Issue date:	07/15/1999
From:	ENTERGY OPERATIONS, INC.
To:
Shared Package
ML20137X504	List: ML20209H305 ML20209H319
References
NUDOCS 9907200187
Download: ML20209H319 (17)

Text

.

2500 i' iT i 5

_- l. _...- -..i. g

.

wesRact i

I 9

.N. Y. D..ROS FAT.Ic

... LT IGNr

1..

.ig 7.

o epi.. i.,

1 3,,

aspec 3;a.s.m !

7 lc,

+- -

t-n t

i '>

... t

. a :._.. _.

.f.

.l,:

i j

4.

2000

~

f.i.. __

a, t..

.. 1.

i__.

g._ _ _. [.i.] !

c; j

....d.ogn.et se._nuP ; i-l 1

g,i 3....

.3

__ 3-j

... 1.

... ; p.

gg t ;:

r

-., y.i

-- I.T,.

+r._..

. -].*. -

I i

. 214 *Pt I

'*-'M-ne. a.t-r.l -.

r

- en

...6 t

r..

.._,i 1

.,;...

.,.._..2,

r..

. II, ;

..j _a 4

1.

.. ; t. 4 _.,.. i. l !.

7 I1000

.b..l'.

i.

3..

-p g.

. Lit 1NACCEPTABLE 3

.l+ _

..' m_..._.o...........

7-

._.!..O_P..ER_A.*.!.O 4...

i l.

i

. I...

.... _. o 1 I...

i

..1.

t

...,. 5. r.

{. g." f.}.-

_....[i

-..'.._...g.)

...._ ;., ;,. -=

j i

.8 j.

MTM M

.. j _....p

,,,,n g,

..p..

_t._ _. _.. asso*F to gassy sents Hn

...... > 1 i i.._ _..

...c

_._1.

p.!

4.-

.. 7'.'.

J..

. g._..

4

>345V 409/1 Hn i..._.

.:.!'.j.].'..

...... i,,. 4 4.-

..[

3. ; _.

... L..

.t ;

.. _..i

..

500

.?

...i,.

...I

.:..L '.. _,

].

.},.............;..

J l.i.

a

.- ;.. p j'...

.~

E

-j

.l.'

.i-b r.

i..

.. 4 stem....

L

... _[ i.(. _...i

.g

.3 g,

.,' j.p.,'

j

, :g : %:3. __._1E q_;.

g.._

_ ~... _...

11....

n.

..... ; i 7.4 0

10G 200 300 400 500 SelCATED RCS TEMPERATURE. Ts, 'F PIG U M 3.4 2 WATERPORD UNIT 3 HEATUP CURVE REACTOR COOLANT SYSTEM PRESSURE. TEMPERATURE UMITS 0-15 EFPY CURVE SASil: PEAR SURFACE FLUtleCE a 3 23 a 1019 n/ent e 20 EFPY WATERFORD - UllIT 3 3/4 4-30 Amendment No.106 9907200187 990715 PDR ADOCK 05000382 P

PDR

2500 INSERVICE

[

I HYDROSTATIC E' LTOP'AUSNI RENT:

fI TEST TsuP. FN *p '.

l

tSPGCIPICATION 3.4.8.39-1 100*P/HR COOL 30WN 2000 :.

?

r l

i r,

i 3

i.

i I

l i.

m:s'i I

I

~

E LownsYsapr i

i T

I

.{

".....Ta r.,31E"F,i ; '!

a.{.

.1 i

i*

. 'i i...

I I

.t.

E.,: UNACCE = TABLE i

.I.

l

. i-.

i.- l

. i.i I'

l E-OPERAT IONil i

.'. i E.

,c

..r

• i l1000

~

i.,.

.l

.,.i.,.

l

.. 1..i..

g.: 1.,.

...q.

..j..

m, E

~,

<1sser 10*Pn HR

-- r -

2138'F TO $300*P 30*PM HR E

g l

> 300*F 100'P/1 HR

... i.

I ymme f '.i.

. y.

6

.t r

j...j..

l.

..... r

...p..

i

_7-M.

I.

i j

i 3:y -

i

_.,.,.;. _.1._.

l_.. _ i.

I v.

. ;i

' ' 1 i ' '1.- -

i...- J.l. -

.,. 3*P-i';!;

i' 'l';'

0 O

100 200 300 400 500 INDICATED RCS TEMPERATURE, Tc, 'F I

FIGURE 3.4 3 i

.WATERFORD UNIT 3 COOLDOWN CURVE REACTOR COOLANT SYSTEM PRESSURE TEMPERATURE UMITS 0-15 EFPY CURVE BASIS: PEAR SURFACE FLUENCE e 2 29 a 1019 n/ cat e 20 EFPY WATERFORD - UNIT 3 3/4 4-31 Amendment No.106 i

l

i NPF-38-218 ATTACHMENT B PROPOSED MARKED-UP SPECIFICATIONS

2500 i G

I E

1. 8BBMCE i

l

. I

. _ w r..

.N.. Y. D R,O S FAtm

...g

..-.i i

i..

.E - h; (1 e.l 1.. '

l aspecrma 3;a.t.3U g" t E.

3. m ;.......

. m..._.. _ _

.L

.. l,.

...... m 2000 5

'ji.,,_

.i

.).

..-l.,.

i

. jr1li1

'+

i i i * '- - -

-'j :

go.FasingnuP ;,: I 1

- -l _- I E... Idem lgg7 sgMcE'

• t f-*-

J,J" - 7r 'i i

I r

. g.

.....u.W.,. 311.*,P.t'.I...... -=.

. n_,'

- *F --

_me g'..,..

.s. _....

E"1800 i.,',..t, - - - -- - -. --- ( t.

7

m.. ; { _

i, I

.3

'i.

g!

CPTnbLE

- ie p

7-H '-

-I....

i

.E'"itfNACC..

., j.

.I,5 l I.........._..'.{

.i (#4.ER. A.'. !.DR. ~.~.. ". _-

. '., '..,.9 i

~t '. - -

-~

.}.,_

r.--

e ---

.1

.i m

E 000 r

...j-.i.l..'.g.___ -g. '...

+ :-

p L.c t.j..;.

1..i M

gl, gig,

....g.,,.

4 '.

<M 30*m M 5,.

_.,i

-... 411 l

L.

2 W PTO g344*F WP/1 HR

. _. + r-1 'I.'; -

.i..

.. g..,.

>348*F 00*P/1 NR

...;.:.T,.1.i.

..t_.;.,' _;...

...t,,.

6'

.3 6

1

.,.....i._..

800 [

. 3 t, 1

._.. L,...

. 1 '..

l.

[... ;

z ; j,.9 j -..

p..

..r

....l r..

-}

.I,.

r_

..... _. i. ;,.i.

l,. -

. l

.-3

.. 7

3..

.. 4..; y 3

3,..

n

.. -).

0 c,

.;i11....

Ja,

..... ; e 1.4 0

100 200 300 400 500 DOCATED RCS TEMPERATURE, Ts, 'F l

i RGUIE 3.4 2 WATERFORD UNIT 3 HEATUP CURVE REACTOR C001. ANT SYSTEM PRESSURE.

TURE UMITS

- % dEFPy

.2 0 CURVE basil: PEAR SURFACE FLUEleCE = 2 29 a 104 n/ent e 20 EFPY i

WATERFORD - UNIT 3 3/4 4-30 Amendment No.106 1

1

2500 INSERVICE I

8 HYDROSTATIC f;l TEST E

LTOP'AUGNI IENT:

E TEMP., 2N *P'.

l

tSPSCIPICATION 3.4.8.St-

.i

...i.

100*P/HR COOL 30WN 2000 :.

+

I m

r i

E i.

i I

i E.

- m'i I

i i

i i

E-L0wasisspr

,i; r

.. : 1

.....TauPy sta*F

.,. I.. i

...j a..

i

. i.

I i,

i l-

......7 I

.t.

E,;UNACCE 'TiB'i.E I

.r -'

I

.l..'I E-OPERAT I ON i,

.c i

i I

.r '

..'l--

.-l 3

i

.1.1.

.l

.,.!.. l t

l1000

.. )..

g..: i,.... j.

,3 RCS TBdP.

CtD RATE l.

~;

4:188'F 10'P/1 NR Q

i g

i

~

l 2135'FTO $300*F 30*P/14t

~ g

> 300*F 100*P/1 HR

i. ;..!._..

l

.l. '.... t g...i

. y.,.g 500

~

s..

1, I

l

...g.

-g 1

,... 7,.

i.

I

.t

-..,.;.._.{..

.i g J....

. sep,-

i...l...

i....

3...,.

!q

';;i

;l;*'

0 O

100 200 300 400 500 INDICATED RCS TEMPERATUM Tc, 'F FIGURE 3.4 3 WATERFORD UNIT 3 COOLDOWN CURVE REACTOR COOLANT SYSTEM PRESSURE TEMPERATURE UMITS J S "O EFPY 6-O CURyt SA515: PEAR SURFACE FLutNCE = 2.29 a 1019 n/ cat e 20 ErPY WATERFORD - UNIT 3 3/4 4-31 Amendment No.106

5 r

NPF-38-218 ATTACHMENT C PROPOSED SPECIFICATIONS h

l

2500

.:..... 7.;.....

.7

..;.. r

.., s. _......,..

7...

a M ERYlCE 1 ;,..,

I..

..t

7.. g.g......... o....

. q.y...

i

.i...

...r.t. _-.........;

+.....

.....H.Y...O.M.- oe rATIC...t... r !......

g..

...l...!..

4..-

.! 1.i....,....... p

......,7...

l.y !...

...;.j.. [p2.

....pgg.. g pop 3. 4 [.{.,....... u

{7..]. -

...[...

y

.. 4..

. 4. a.., !,.....

..p,

-}...j.

z.. g

.g.g.

p...........

.... g...

, j..

- l.,

.. O l..,

...g - 4........;g. 9

+

....j.. 4...

w.

+

p..

,,.q. {.. ;....... _,. 9 7........_. 9.y 4.g.

.n,.

...j...l..............l7.$. 7 r. g.,

,_.p ;...;...

2000

~

i i i

-.l....... _..s

..,..., p. 4_f._...q..a:...". 2 -

4

~... v.. 7 4:......

...... I,...

....z.

.. t...+.

.. +

r [.... J..

7.,! -

.e n.

r w.

i r

2...

.t.

.... 3..

..g

. 50*F/H4 HiATUP.L.F..i.....

t.

L.i...

i

... 7.. _+. I..

...1 2.4

._...i.....

i j

,L.

.i

..T....

.....,, t...

l..

gyagd {;

i r

r.

t

- f:2. :- - ::$:

g 4.-

. ;',. r::7.;:.$..

.---t::3.+-

r; - -

t:

.o...

. }.

i

,......,..................4...........

._....p.....i...

.. j......

.y:..

p)...,..l...

...;...,_v..p

......i...

l

_.7 ;.....

ggg.j......

+ _...._

._.fj

.j...;......

....,k.,.......

4.

...!..,.2.

4 4...

r. 4

.l.,

i...i... -

...a.

......,r..,

i i

.._...l...,....i.4,... +., ~.l 1-... i l

_..H..

..g -

.F...,.....

i, J.

.......tp......h. p...

t 1

..a.

.t..

....g..i..9..p..

4 e...

....4,.......

....e~

.s...

l.L l 3

.9.,..

[l j

p.

g-

• (.l l.

. +..

4

.. }.,...

.-..F

..} +

M. 7..P

""4t vt-

...q..

.4.....;..

.... p..

E E:. L.:.ttlNAC.CEPABi"Er "

L

+8 1_++ +~:-

4 1.- P r

T 7....._[.. g.-..g g..... g; - y +-r7 7

y 7

9 m y - 7 1 7

.....9.....t....,-,-

-l....,,-

1

, l. -".. '.. -

+

.s

.s..

,... =

,.4...,.

, l... g..

...A

,1

. }.,

.......t........

..a t J,.... 4..

i

.{

.....t....t...,......... -

.a

.m 1000

... _.....w....

+

r.

I 1 g

_,........g..

.4..

. j..

g g.

gg

.I

. ;g

,-s

.. p +..

.....i..- _...

..o..a.p...g._

......#,.p.

. 7...y

...g.

_i t...

_..i J..,t...

< 200*P 30 'F/1 H R

..4.....t

...... -.i 4.._......

.. _... +:

..: p

.s.4:' p.4J 4. 7. p...

.r a r

4.. : :

[.! i.

H,...,._...i. 4,... 4.,.....

2200'F TO g348*F 50*F/1 HR

rr i

.. a...J.:

.....,...{.-

.;... 4...,

... i J....~......

> 345'F 90'F/1 HR

.+...J.....+-.

...a..

.O

......:.....l.,...a,..........-

g

....)~ 4.3..,..,

y

.....g..g....

i.....

.}. o-.6...._

..p.

. 1 g

..t..J !.-...l

!.i.L4-.L. --..... L..._i

..J.

1. I.....L.

. 4J

. 4 4..T.. T'. t.4...

R i

n +

i t

1 i

ry :- rt-

1

::[!i.l 3

.t..,. :t ;:/

r

.f.t...l....$

"+1..;.i...

.t.... ".H: t..r: 7:".r *;:

F t

..1..

.l.g 4

..-,i

~+f -

,.... 9,...[...T.,

.,. is. i..

.i.o.,-.--tm I i

....,p. l,. 1.+.r.

--.or. i. _i.

... _i i

...-.i-.

2.:

4

.....+}.

J.

9

....!...-......9.,r..+..-.

..l-

,....a..

.. - 9..

.~..

...I......-r.

~

-y

....4....p.,

.4.

s.

...I.........

.....4..i...-

.a... [..

.....,..1.....i.....

...+...g....T..-.

...i....

6..

...,j. ~

.....L

...I..

......p_.....+.4f..+-..

...4g...+,.....

.a p-p-

g..

.!. : 4.[....

..l.....

..L..

4 l. n.

...J

..........i...

4i

... 4.. 41,...i-..+...;...l.....

l J... l.

......i

-l (... l.

l

+

4.q...

.. *).4...4....

...4..

a. 4. i 4..

...(

g

.4

...9..

s 7..+..

a.

l

..I.

.... ~..

._.a i

.....,i..

dis...

4, ~p. a+

. t..,....,.,...p-. I. I

.....~....1..w!..t...,...,.4..a.-+...a,.-

i

..w..

a 1

...... +..

.a' 4,' e a.....

.p

.a.

4.

I,

.-I.....4...,...a......

g.,. j.J..p

.,.,..,...,..j...

. d..,

.,.g....

~,......i.. i.,...,.

1. n.

r..,

y,.....

.,..r.,.

O 0

100 200 300 400 500 INDICATED RCS TEMPERATURE, Tc, 'F 1

i FIGURE 3.4-2 i

1 WATERFORD UNIT 3 HEATUP CURVE i

REACTOR COOLANT SYSTEM PRESSURE-TEMPERATURE UMITS 2

0-20 EFPY l

CURVE SA515: PEAK SURFACE FLUENCE = 2.29 x 100 2 e 20 EFPY n/cm 1

l WATERFORD-UNIT 3 3/4 4-30 AMENOMENT NO. 106

2500 E

.. j..

11i.

~

k4..I NYDftOST/. TIC.

c 1lE '

' INSERVICE.

t' T

. t... t.... 1....

,a -

p.

_6...

...u.

.... i.. )

i TR r 3

i

. T. ri

. i..

i..

..j.

.i~

........p,.

.._.g..r.g 3:::.y.

4. gap.;. 3;g y9.

t7

..t-4..

i r-4,,

1-

-i-d81MTIOM S 4.8.$P ~ -

..t*

l.

a

. ;I I

6 l M-' F/ARC00LMWN " "?" '-"

i

- ' - ' b

-l-I

..j..'

.c 2000 p. :t zt:... c i. [.

p. :p.

j..

.M j. - f: 'y;

. j..

i 4

...i.-

...j,

-.7. g.

..p.

........ a... g..

..j...

...y.

..,..,4,....,..........i..

...'..1..,...

..q... l.,

...i......,....l t

l

• T

.)..

.,.a

4..

..,...i 9

7, -,..

.......o.....

8

.. I. 4.+,.

.4.,

.g

..g.

[..

i i

...g g.9ERflCE ' ++ "*

- - i l. i

-l l

.j -...r:

P p..

...?..i.....

.f ]...5 4..., p..... ;

......L..........,

"... 4. M..$,

8 I

~.1:a::....i l:.

..:.:.i:. t

..l s,..,j,. 4..,.,...j...,

.....g. 4 p.....

.,, -..i: L... {...L

.... ::1.t :\\::..

. i.

1500

...::.1 L..

~~

i. i...p:.

r

................. r... 4

.a...,,.....,...,..

.. j...'. 1..!

. i.....;. 1..,..}...

....'.'...i..

I

. f.

..i. i..i..

... J... L...

l. l.......i ' j..t. p..

...!...._. LL }...l.

d....

e

.._I. l

........i.l'.........L

..4...

in-i 4

..4.........

M m..

... 2...UNAC P.T. A BL E...1.

_i4

...1.. L.

.. i..

.....i... I'.

..1.'. 1 4

l a...

4 i

iiE

J..... O.p...q&,A DN"..:i.

12 7

...4.......4.41%.

_L,.

i

.1 1

-..., !./... 3...j..

....f'...

i,..

.. t,'.. ;....t...

.. }... L

.a.... L.4,..t. 4.. 7..-..A,..

..J

.....l....

j

.....o.............. g..........3..

i.

4..,... p..[...1..........

....t.

,... p..... g...

...9...

...g........

.g gg

... o...

i

.. p... j.......

.. j..

..l..

RCS TEL1P.

C/D RATE m

....v..... 7._

.....-..r....,...

..j..

..i. 7........

< 135'F 10'F/1 HR F

....;.. i,..., _. 1..

i

.i...

.. p i

............7....q...

.. 7..

3...

.....g...;.-..

p.

_. 3. a, j. '..

2136*F TO s200*F 30'F/1 HR

..............j..

y...

3...

>200*F 100'F/1 HR y

.i......j......,.

g i.

.........4

.p7... 77.....,f.7 g

-4,.....

q..

i

... 9_9..+h h... _, -.,

.. j..

l

. fo.. b l..

.6..n...

.e...,

I j f,

a

. i I.. Ii.. i....:. l..i.............L.....;. 4..

3

... 9,.. 8........

..,.4'..

1 1

.6.....,...j

....i.u j..

..p L

4 6

j.. L,.

.... j......

y

.c

.i.

i_.

47

...... l....

. i..........i..

.....g........

.u...

. {.,

g, j..

p g 1,.g

}

y..

......[.....'...

.......;...p.9.........

,..j..

....(

.,3e

...;.,. g.

.,n.

........7...,...,......y.

...........q...i..,..;.......

......!.. j.;...

.}--. 6

..,...i..

.....;...- ~ 4,,,

i.

.4

......p......

S-

....}.....,...j.....;..

.I

.L.,

s.

.........i...I,..4.....

.m...

..l

.g.

ypg.

....... }.

4

. 4.. ~. : i..j....,

.l...

c..

.4

.....a..4.....

.. H Wp..Mmpo.

...4..

... 9

".... ;..,i..,.,;......,...

..,..,..y...-.,., - 7 j.'..

j.., g,,.

.,!,.....,i.!.'.,..,.....

g.

.~

l

..}.

I i,..,. i..,I.i..,I

....;.3 0

100 200 300 400 500 INDICATED RCS TEMPERATURE, Ta, 'F FIGURE 3.4-3 WATERFORD UNIT 3 COOLDOWN CURVE REACTOR COOLANT SYSTEM PRESSURE-TEMPERATURE LIMITS 0-20 EFPY CURVE BASIS: PEAK SURFACE Fl.UENCE = 2.29 x ids tved a 20 EFPY CATERFORD-UNIT 3 3/4 4-31 AMENOMENT NO. 106

8 4

I NPF-38-218 ATTACHMENT D CONTAINS PROPRIETARY INFORMATION REFERENCES t

NPF-38-218 LIST OF REFERENCES

1. Affidavit Pursuant to 10CFR2.790 Regarding Proprietary Information

2. B&W report 51-1234900-00, Fluence Uncertainty Information For Extending Waterford Unit 3 P-T Limits to 20 EFPY 1

L_

A.

i aus F R AM ATO M E April 30,1999 TECHNOLOGlES

,gg, Mr. J.B. Perez Entergy Operations, Inc.

Waterford 3 P.O. Box B Killona LA 70066

Subject:

Amdavit ofJoseph J. Kelly

References:

1)

FTI Document 51-1234900-00 2)

Contract Order NWC00082 3)

FTI Job No. 4100594

Dear Mr. Perez:

This letter is submitted in response to your request for an affidavit documenting the proprietary nature ofinformation contained in Reference 1, above, which was provided under the Contract Order in Reference 2.

Framatome Technologies, Inc. (FTI) has determined that a portion of ti mformation in FTI document 51-1234900-00 is " Proprietary," and is thereby supported by an amdavit signed by J.J. Kelly, Framatome Technologies, Inc. (the owner of the information). This amdavit, which is enclosed, sets forth the basis on which the information may be withheld from public disclosure by the Commission and addresses with specificity the consi& rations listed in 10 CFR 2.790. Accordingly, please submit this amdavit with your hzasmittal material and request that in accordance with 10 CFR 2.790, the NRC withhold from public disclosure the information which is Proprietary" to Framatome Technologies, Inc.

Please provide FTl a copy of your transmittal letter to the NRC, which submits this information in order for our file to be complete, and so we may reference the transmittal if additional information is required.

If you have any questions, please give me a call at (804) 832-3341.

Sincerely, James F. Cuvelier Customer Representative i

JFC/lbm Enclosure c:

KA Sabethia 155 Mill Ridge Road, Lynchburg, VA 24502-4341 Telephone: 804-832-3700 Fax: 804-832-0622 Internet: http://www.framatech.com

7 1

~ AFFIDAVIT OF JOSEPH J. KELLY A.

' My name is Jowph L Kelly. I aan Manager of B&W Owners Group Services for Framatome Technologies, Inc. (FTI),'and as such, I am authorized to execute this Affidavit.

B.

I am familiar with the criteria applied by FTI to determine whether certain information of FTI is proprietary and I am familiar with the procedures established within FTI to ensure the proper application of these criteria.

C.

In determining whether an FTI document is to be classified as proprietary information, an initial determination is made by the Unit Manager, who is responsible for originating the document, as to whether it falls within the criteria set forth in Paragraph D hereof. If the information falls within any one of these criteria, it is classified as proprietary by the originating Unit Manager. This initial determination is reviewed by the cognizant Section Manager. If the document is designated as proprietary, it is reviewed again by me to assure

. that the regulatory requirements of 10 CFR Section 2.790 are met.

D.

The following information is provided to demonstrate that te vovisions of 10 CFR Section 2.790 of the Commission's regulations have been considered:

(i)

The information has been held in confidence by FTI. Copies of the document are i

clearly iden.tified as poprietary.

In addition, whenever FTI transmits the information to a customer, customer's agent, potential customer or regulatory agency, the transmittal requests the recipient to hold the information as proprietary. Also, in order to strictly limit any potential or actual customer's use of proprietary information, the substance of the following provision is included in all agreements entered into by FTI, and an equivalent version of the proprietary provision is included in all of FTfs proposals:

7 AFFIDAVIT OF JOSEPH J. KELLY (Cont'd.)

"Any proprietary infoimation concerning Company's or its Supplier's products or manufacturing processes which is so designated by Company or its Suppliers and disclosed to Purchaser incident to the performance of such contract shall remain the property of Company or its Suppliers end is disclosed in confidence, and Purchaser shall not publish or otherwise disclose it to others without the written approval of Company, and no rights, implied or otherwise, are granted to produce or have produced any products or to practice or cause to be practiced any manufacturing j

processes covered thereby.

I Notwithstanding the above, Purchaser may provide the NRC or any other regulatory agency with any such proprietary information as the NRC or J

such other agency may require; provided, however, that Purchaser shall first give Company written notice of such proposed disclosure and Company shall have the right to amend such proprietary information so as to make it non-proprietary. In the event that Company cannot amend such 4

proprietary information, Purchaser shall prior to disclosing such information, use its best efforts to obtain a commitment from NRC or such other agency to have such information withheld from public inspection.

Company shall be given the right to participate in pursuit of such confidential treatment "

]

l 2

,v 1

AFFIDAVIT OF JOSEPH J. KELLY (Cont'd.)

I (ii)

The following criteria are customarily applied by Ffl in a rational decision process i

to determine whether the information should be classified as proprietary.

I Information may be classified as proprietary if one or more of the following criteria are met:

a.

Information reveals cost or price information, commercial strategies, production capabilities, or budget levels of FTI, its customers or suppliers.

b.

The information reveals data or materiel concerning FTI research or development plans or programs of present or potential competitive advantage to FTI.

c.

The use of the information by a competitor would decrease his expenditures, in time or resources, in designing, producing or marketing a similar product.

d.

The information consists of test data or other similar data concerning a process, method or component, the application of which results in a competitive advantage to FTI.

e.

The information reveals special aspects of a process, method, component or the like, the exclusive use of which results in a competitive advantage to FTI.

j f.

The information cont > Jus ideas for which patent protection may be sought.

3

g

=,

AFFIDAVIT OF JOSEPH J. KELLY (Cont'd.)

The document (s) listed on Exhibit "A", which is attached hereto and made a part hereof, has been evaluated in accordance with normal FTI procedures with respect to classification and has been found to contain information which falls within one or more of the criteria enumerated above. Exhibit "B", which is attached hereto and made a part hereof, specifically identifies the criteria applicaole to the

. document (s) listed in Exhibit "A".

(iii)

The document (s) listed in Exhibit "A", which has been made available to the United

- States Nuclear Regulatory Commission was made available in confidence with a request that the document (s) and the information contained therein be withheld from public disclosure.

(iv)

The information is not available in the open literature and to the best of our knowledge is not known by Combustion Engineering, EXXON, General Electric, Westinghouse or other current or potential domestic or foreign competitors of FTI.

(v)

Specific information with regard to whether public disclosure of the information is likely to cause harm to the competitive position of FTI, taking into accoet the value of the information to FTI; the amount ofeffort or money expended by FTI developing the information; and the case or difficulty with which the informatien could be properly duplicated by others is given in Exhibit "B" E.

I have personally reviewed the document (s) listed on Exhibit "A" and have found that it is considered proprietary by FTI because it contain:. information which falls within one or more of the criteria enumerated in Paragraph D, and it is information which is customarily held in confidence and protected as proprietary information by FTI. This report comprises 4

i

a AFFIDAVIT OF JOSEPH J. KELLY (Cont'd.)

Information utilized by FTI in its business which afford FTI an opportunity to obtain a competitive advantage over those who may wish to know or use the information contained in the doccment(s).

}

O

/

JO.E H LY State of Virginia)

)

SS. Lynchburg City of Lynchburg)

Joseph J. Kelly, being duly swom, on his oath deposes and says that he is the person who subscribed his name to the foregoing statement, and that the matters and facts set forth in the statement are true.

i 1/

1 i

b PH Subscribed and sworn before me this Son day of 1999.

A Sw Notary Publicin and for the City of Lynchburg, State of Virginia.

My Commission Expires ab 1M79 l

J 5

f

m....

EXHIBITS A & B EXHIBIT A FTI Document No. 51-1234900-00, " Fluence Uncertainty Information for Waterford Unit 3 PT Limits to 20 EFPY," July 1995.

(

i EXHIBIT B The above listed document contains information waich is considered Proprietary in accordance with Criteria c, d, and e of the attached affidavit.

1

.