ML20205S780

Responds to Appeal Re Denial of FOIA Request for Documents Re Creation of Contention 5 & Harassment & Intimidation Panels.Forwards Documents Listed in App A.App B Documents Available in PDR

ML20205S780
Person / Time
Site:	Comanche Peak
Issue date:	06/02/1986
From:	Grimsley D NRC OFFICE OF ADMINISTRATION (ADM)
To:	Garde B GOVERNMENT ACCOUNTABILITY PROJECT
Shared Package
ML20204J043	List: IA-85-153, Forwards Schedule of Contention 5 Panel Activities & Blank Deficiency Data Sheet (Dds).Preparation & Submittal of Dds for Review Areas Prior to Panel Discussions or During Briefing by Panel Members Requested ML20204J040 ML20205S780 ML20205S806 ML20205S815 ML20205S821 ML20205S835 ML20205S852 ML20205S884 ML20205S910 ML20205S927
References
FOIA-85-153, FOIA-86-A-17 NUDOCS 8606120893
Download: ML20205S780 (5)

Text

~

Q

1. pe en o UNITED STATES g .

8 o NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION 7; y WASHf NGTON, D, C. 20555

% , , , , , ** JUN 0 2 1986 Ms. Billie Pirner Garde, Director /

Environmental Whistleblower Clinic Government Accountability Project IN RESPONSE REFER 1555 Connecticut Avenue, NW, Suite 202 TO F0IA-85-153 and Washington, DC 20036 F01A-86-A-17

Dear Ms. Garde:

This is in response to your letter dated March 6,1985, in which you requested, pursuant to the Freedom of Information Act (FOIA), records concerning the creation of the Contention 5 Panel and the Harrassment and Intimidation Panel regarding the Comanche Peak nuclear power plant.

The records identified on the enclosed Appendix A are subject to your F0IA request and are now available for public inspection and copying at the NRC Public Document Room (PDR) in file folder F01A-85-153 under your name. The records identified on the enclosed Appendix B have already been made available at the PDR under the accession numbers included with the descriptions of.the records on Appendix B.

This completes action on your request and, therefore, we are taking no further action on your letter dated March 3,1986, in which you appealed our lack of response to your F0IA request.

v: Sincerely,

%,w Donnie H. Grimsley, Director Division of Rules and Records Office of Administration

Enclosures:

As stated l

l I

l l

e 8606120893 860602PDR

-g7 ch DES l

Re: F01A-85-153 APPENDIX A

_ RECORDS IN POR FILE F01A-85-153

1. 09/84 EG8G Report, " Comanche Peak Steam Electric Station Alleged Climate of Intimidation," Prepared for NRC under DOE Contract No. DE-AC07-761001570 (NRC FIN No. A6819) (82 pages).

2. 11/06/84 Note to Darrell G. Eisenhut, NRR, from Vincent S. Noonan, NRR,

Subject:

" Formation of Panel to Formulate an NRC Position of Hearing Contention #5 (Adherence to QA/QC Requirements at Comanche Peak) (2 pages).

3. 12/06/84 Memorandum for Comanche Peak Intimidation Panel Members from Vincent S. Noonan, NRR,

Subject:

" Intimidation Panel Charter" (3 pages).

4. 12/14/84 " Comanche Peak Intimidation Panel Meeting Summary" (5 pages).

5. 12/19/84 Draft memorandum for Harold R. Denton, et al. , from William J.

Dircks, EDO,

Subject:

" Formation of Paiiel to Prepare NRC Staff Position on Comanche Peak Hearing Contention No. 5" with three enclosures (7 pages).

6. 12/24/84 Memorandum for Harold R. Denton, et al., from William J.

Dircks,EDO,

Subject:

" Formation of % nel to Prepare NRC Staff Position on Comanche Peak Hearing Contention No. 5" with

three enclosures" (7 pages).

7. 12/24/84 Memorandum for Harold R. Denton, et al., from William J.

Dircks, EDO,

Subject:

" Formation of7Enel to Prepare NRC Staff Position on Intimidation at Comanche Peak" with two enclosures (6 pages).

8. 12/24/84 Memorandum for Harold R. Denton, et al., from William J.

Dircks, EDO,

Subject:

" Formation ~'ofTinel to Prepare NRC Staff Position on Intimidation at Comanche Peak" with two enclosures (6 pages).

9. 01/02/85 Memorandum for Comanche Peak Intimidation Panel from James E.

Gagliardo, Chairperson,

Subject:

" Summary of Panel Meeting on December 21" (3 pages).

10. 01/04/85 " Comanche Peak Intimidation Panel," Summary of meeting on 01/04/85 (9 pages).

11. 01/11/85 " Comanche Peak Intimidation Panel,'" Summary of meeting on 01/11/85 (2 pages).

\

Re: F01A-85-153 APPENDIX A (Continued)

12. 01/30/85 Draft memorandum for Victor Stello, Jr., DEDR0GR, et al.,

from William J. Dircks, EDO,

Subject:

" Panel to Prdpare NRC Staff Position on Comanche Peak Hearing Contention No. 5" with two enclosures (7 pages).

13. 01/30/85 Memorandum for Comanche Peak Intimidation Panel from James E. Gagliardo, Chairperson,

Subject:

" Revised Schedule of Panel Activities" (3 pages).

14. 01/30/85 " Comanche Peak Intimidation Panel Meeting," Summary of meeting on 01/30/85 (1 page).

15. 02/01/85 " Comanche Peak Intimidation Panel Meeting," Summary of meeting on 02/01/85(1page).

16. 02/18/85 " Report to EG&G Idaho, Inc.," by David G. Bowers, Research Scientist, containing analysis of QC personnel interviews (22 pages).

17. 02/22/85 EG&G Notegram to Study Team / Intimidation Panel from Bruce Kaplan enclosing organizational information (24 pages).

18. 02/28/85 Memorandum for Victor Stello, Jr., DEDROGR, et al., from t William J. Dircks, EDO,

Subject:

" Panel to FFepare NRC Staff Position on Comanche Peak Hearing Contention No. 5" with two enclosures (7 pages).

19. 03/85 Draft report by Bruce L. Kaplan, EG8G, et al., entitled

" Comanche Peak Steam Electric Station: lileged Climate of Intimidation, Supplementary Report" (33 pages).

20. undated Note to TRT Group Leaders from Chet Poslusny with attached schedule of Contention 5 panel activities and blank Deficiency Data Sheet (3 pages).

21. undated et al. , from Draft memorandum William to Harold J. Dircks, EDO, R. Denton,

Subject:

NRR, ii oT7anel to

" Formatio Prepare NRC Staff Position on Intimidation at Comanche Peak" with two enclosures (7 pages).

22. undated " Definition of Intimidation, Harrassment and Discrimination" (6pages).

Re: F01A-85-153 APPENDIX A (Continued)

23. undated Draft memorandum to Harold R. Denton, NRR, et al., from William J. Dircks, EDO, " Formation of Panel' fo Trepare NRC Staff Position on Comanche Peak Hearing Contention No. 5" with three enclosures (14 pages).

24. undated " Contention 5 (Adherence to AQ/QC Requirements at Comanche Peak) Working Group" (2 pages).

25. undated " Working Group Tasks" (1 page).

26. undated " Draft Study Team Report--Comanche Peak Project" (7 pages).

1

Re: F0IA-85-153 APPENDIX B RECORDS SUBJECT TO FOIA-85-153 ALREADY IN PDR

1. 01/08/85 Letter to M.D. Spence, TUGCO, from Darrell G. Eisenhut, NRR,

Subject:

" Formation of Two Panels Consisting of NRC Senior Staff Management to Address Comanche Peak Hearing Issues" Accession No. 8501I40444 ADOCK 50-445A.

2. 01/09/85 Memorandum for Palladino and Commissioners from Darrell G.

Eisenhut,NRR,

Subject:

" Board Notification - Formation of Two Panels Consisting of NRC Senior Staff Management to Address Comanche Peak Hearing Issues (Board Notification No. 85-04)" Accession No. 8501100487 ADOCK 50-445A.

3. 03/04/85 Letter to M.D. Spence, TUGCO, from Darrell G. Eisenhut, NRR,

Subject:

" Panel to Prepare NRC Staff Position on Comanche Peak Hearing Contention No. 5 - Working Charter' Accession No. 8503130542 AD0CK 50-445A.

4. 10/20/83 OIA REPORT " Review of Concerns Expiessed by Citizens Association for Sound Energy About Conduct of Region IV Investigations / Inspections" PDR/F0IA/ Garde 84-210; PDR Accession No. 8505160481

5. 10/20/83 ~0 1A REPORT:!' Comanche Peak--Markey Letter Re: Region IV Investigations /

Inspections. PDR/F01A/ Garde /84-210; PDR Accession No. 8505160465

?