ML20205A251
| ML20205A251 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Diablo Canyon  |
| Issue date: | 12/12/1984 |
| From: | Cummings G, Wade W EG&G, INC., LAWRENCE LIVERMORE NATIONAL LABORATORY |
| To: | Kirsch D NRC OFFICE OF INSPECTION & ENFORCEMENT (IE REGION V) |
| Shared Package | |
| ML20205A195 | List: |
| References | |
| CON-FIN-A-0753, CON-FIN-A-753, CON-FIN-B-8552 WOW:85-05, WOW:85-5, NUDOCS 8504250464 | |
| Download: ML20205A251 (8) | |
Text
.
"$@S Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory A
DEC l8 pg q.
Dceember 12,-1984 SEGIg y.,, p",
WOW: 85-05 Mr'. Dennis F. Kirsch U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission, Region V 1450 Maria Lane, Suite 210 Walnut Creek, California 94596 PROGRESS REPORT, NOVEMBER 1984 TECHNICAL ASSISTANCE FOR INSPECTION OF REACTORS UNDER CONSTRUCTION, FIN A0753, FIN B8552.
1.
PROJECT DESCRIPTION The Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory (LLNL) is providing tech-nical assistance to the Region V offices of the U.S. Nuclear Regula-tory Commission (NRC) for conducting inspections at selected nuclear reactor sites.
1.1 Task 1 - Diablo Canyon, Unit 2 - Design Verification Program As a consequence of an independent design verification program, many modifications and additions to the. piping and electrical raceway support systems and building structural steel are being implemented I
at Diablo Canyon, Unit 2.
The LLNL is assisting the NRC in assess-ing the adequacy of this work.
1.2 Task 2 - Palo Verde Nuclear Power Plant - Inspection of Reactors Under Construction The construction of Unit 1 is nearing completion and a number of inspection requirements are to be accomplished before the initial fuel loading can begin.
LLNL is assisting the NRC in completing this work.
2.
PROGRESS - NOVEMBER 1984 i
2.1 Task 1 - Diablo Canyon, Unit 2 Inspections were resumed of electrical raceway and HVAC supports during the weeks of November 5 and 12 following the necessary badging and orientation of two additional part-time inspectors.
A detailed list of the items inspected is provided on Attachment C.
l t
8504250464 e50404 DR ADOCK 0500 5
An EqualOvortwny Errpops
- lknersityof Cattma RO Bar 808 LMymore. Cat %na 94550
- Te%ohone (415M:2-1100
- Twx 910-386-6339 UCLLL LMR
'.. Mr. D;nnis F. Kirsch Dectmber. 12, 1984 Page 2 2.2 Task 2 - Palo Verde, Unit 1 2.2.1 Subtask 1 - Radiography Examination This work was completed in September.
2.2.2 Subtask 2 - Fire Protection Systens Inspection The scheduled follow-up site inspection was completed on November 16, 1984 and a final report of the findings is in preparation.
Contrary to the objective identified in the Project's work state-ment, the inspection did not focus strongly on 10CFR50 Appendix R criteria.
The most significant finding was an apparent lack of administrative control over access to various areas and adherence to procedures. However, positive changes were evident on the follow-up visit.
2.2.3 Subtask 3 - Design Control System Inspection The initial draft report for this task submitted to Paul Narbut for comment led to an unplanned series of meetings with the staff, the applicant (APS) and his contractor (Bechtel) to promote mutual understanding of the findings and their significance to the objectives of.the inspection. As a consequence, the report has been extensively modified to include some degree of resolution by APS and Bechtel to each of the findings as well as the introduction of additional items.
The revised report will be submitted for comment again pending the conclusion of the meetings.
3.
FUNDING A detailed report of axpenditures for this report period is provided in Attachments A & B.
4.
. PERSONNEL, SUBCONTRACTS, AND CONSULTANTS This work is being conducted with assistance from EG&G - Energy Measurements, Inc. of San Ramon, California and the National Loss Control Service Corporation.
5..
MEETINGS / TRAVEL Paul Herman traveled to Palo Verde site November 14-16, 1984 for a planned follow-up visit for Task 2, subtask 2.
Clyde Morton, Charles Simkins and Wally Wade variously attended meetings at Bechtel, Norwalk on November 6,
7, 13 and 14, at Bechtel, San Francisco on November 29 and 30 and at NRC offices in
-Walnut Creek for Task 2, subtask 3 discussions.
6.
CONCERNS None
y; Mr. Dennis F. Kirsch December 12, 1984 Page 3 7.
PLANS Inspections at Diablo Canyon, Unit 2 are to continue through December 21, 1984.
Reports for Task 2 subtasks 2 & 3 should be
~
completed.
WALLACE 0. WADE PROJECT MANAGER EG8G MECHANICAL ENGINEERING DEPARTMENT Approved:
/
GARTH E. CUMMINGS
[
DEPUTY PROGRAM LEADER NUCLEAR SYSTEMS SAFETY PROGRAM Attachment
' Distribution:
LLNL NRC EG&G/SRO G. Cununings, L-91 R. Gilbert C. Morton J. Johnson, L-91 A. Chafee C. Simkins R. Langland, L-90 P. Morrill M. Eli, L-390 E. Frigillana C. Meier, L-90 L. Mil 1 V R. White, L-777 P. Narbut
~ G. Johnson, L-228 R. Dodds P. Chan, L-777
F ATTACHMENT A ESTIMATED PROJECT FINANCIAL STATUS: November FY 1985 FIN B8552 DIABLO CANYON UNIT 2 COST ANALYSIS:*
November Year to Date I
Direct Staff Effort:
0.8 FTE-Mo 0.4 FTE-Yr II Direct Labor Costs 3.7K 3.7K Materials & Services 0.0 0.0 ADP Support 0.0 0.0 Subcontracts 8.1 8.1 Travel Expenses 1.6 1.6 Indirect Labor Costs 4.5 4.5 Other ( Recharges )
0.4 0.4 Other (FY84 Unbilled Costs) 0.0
<1.1>
General & Administrative 0.' O 0.0 Total Costs 18.2K s
17.1K Liens 31.9K Total Costs + Liens t
49.0K Percentage of Available Funds 48.6%
III Funding Status:
Prior Year FY 1985 Projected FY 1985 Funds FY 1985 Funding Carryover Funding Level Rec'd to Date Bal. Needed
$100.9K
$100.9K
$ 0.0K
$ 0.0K
- Note: These figures are for cost analysis only, and may differ slightly from final billing figures.
r ATTACHMENT A ESTIMATED PROJECT FINANCIAL STATUS: November FY 1985 FIN A0753 Palo Verde COST ANALYSIS:*
November Year to Date I
Direct Staff Effort:
0.2 FTE-Mo 0.1 FTE-Yr II Direct Labor Costs 0.8K 0.8K Materials & Services 0.0 0.0 ADP Support 0.0 0.0 Subcontracts 10.6 20.8 Travel Expenses 0.2 0.2 Indirect Labor Costs 0.9 0.9 Other (Recharges )
0.3 0.5 Other (FY84 Unbilled Costs) 0.0 0.0 General & Administrative 1.6 1.6
' Total Costs 14.4K 24.8K Liens 32.3K Total Costs + Liens S
57.1K Percentage of Available Funds 83.6%
III Funding Status:
Prior Year FY 1985 Projected FY 1985 Funds FY 1985 Funding Carryover Funding Level Rec'd to Date Ba1. Needed
$48.3K
$68.3K
$20.0K
$ 0.0K
- Note: These figures are for cost analysis only, and may differ slightly from final billing figures.
f ATTACHMENT A ESTIMATED PROJECT FINANCIAL STATUS: November FY 1985 FIN A0753 Diablo Canyon COST ANALYSIS:*
November Year to Date I
Direct Staff Effort:
0.0 FTE-Mo 0.0 FTE-Yr II Direct Labor Costs 0.0K 0.0K Materials & Services 0.0 0.0 ADP Support 0.0 0.0 Subcontracts
<2.0>
0.0 Travel Expenses 0.0 0.0 Indirect Labor Costs 0.0 0.0 Other ( Recharges )
0.0 0.0 Other (FY84 Unbilled Costs) 0.0 0.0 General & Administrative 0.0 0.0 Total Costs
< 2. 0 K) 0.0K I
Liens 0.0K Total Costs + Liens 0.0K Percentage of Available Funds 0.0%
III Funding Status:
Prior Year FY 1985 Projected FY 1985 Funds FY 1985 Funding Carryover Funding Level Rec'd to Date Bal. Needed
$17.6K
$17.6K
$ 0.0K
$ 0.0K
- Note: These figures are for cost analysis only, and may differ slightly from final billing figures.
Page 1 of 1 ATTACHMENT B FIN:
189 A0753 and 189 B8552
~
TITLE:
Technical Assistance for Inspection of Reactors Under Construction - (A0753)
Techncial Assistance for Inspection of Diablo Canyon -
Design Verification Program - (B8552)
PERIOD:
November, 1984 Facility Identi-Costs
- Cumulative
- Facility Name/
Docket / Report fication per this Fiscal Report Title Number Number Period Year TASK I Diablo Canyon - 2 12.6 12.6 Design Verifica-tion TASK II Palo Verde - 1 Completed Radiography 0.0 0.0 i
Subtask 1 Examination (completed)
Subtask 2 Fire Protection 0.0 0.0 System Inspection Subtask 3-Design Control 14.4 24.8 Inspection
- Figures may differ slightly from final billing.
]
Page 1 of 1 o,
ATTACHMENT C U
N LOG I
PART START CCPFLETE STATUS l%N HlN LOC T
ITEM NWEER DATE DATE CRIT C(NTACTS AFF STATUS DATE INSP IRS B119TURBINEBLDG 2 RACDMY SLPPORT S-28N-A-104-4-90 11/06/84 QCP 9 MORRIS (N BE ELD 1U14/84 DM 1.0 QCP E9 t%CARMY F0 MWt PMC 1.0 E-3033V R11U14/84 11120 TURBIE BLD6 2 RACDMY SUPPORT S-82-1-C-85-8-6 11/06/841UOF84 QCP E9 MORRIS (N BE ACCWD-m 11/06/84 DM 1.0 1%CARTEY F0 PMC 1.0 D121 C(NTA!!NENT 2 RACOMY SUPPORT S-18-2-F-117-2-80 1UO6/841UO6/84 QCP 9 MORRIS (N BE ACCWO-@ 11/06/84 DH 1.0 QCP E9 t%CARTNEY F0 PMC 1.0 M122 C(NTAIPMENT 2 RACOMY SUPPORT S-48-5-F-117-1-16 1UO6/841UO6/84 QCP 9 MORRIS (N BE ACC W O-M 1 UO6/84 O H 1.0 QCP ES !%CARTNEY F0 PMC 1.0 H123 C(NTAIPNENT 2 RACDMY SUPPORT S-217A + 91-2-163 1UO6/841UO6/84 QCP E9 MORRIS (N BE ' ACCWO-m 1UO6/84 DM 1.0 MACARTEY F0 PMC 1.0 H124 C@(TA!!NENT 2 RACDMY SUPPORT S-221-2F-117-B-30 1U14/841U14/84 QCP E9 MORRIS (N BE ACCWO-@ 1U14/84 DH 1.0 t%CARTHEY F0 6LJ 1.0 B125 C(NTADNENT 2 RACDMY SUPPORT S-3670-2G-91-1-126 1U14/841U14/84 QCP E9 MORRIS (N BE ACC W O-Z 1 U14/84 OM 1.0 P%CARTNEY F0 GLJ 1.0 M126INTAKEBLOG 2 RACDMY SUPPORT S-244-45-2A-104-21411U14/841U14/84 QCP 9 MORRISON BE ACCWO-M IU14/84 DM 1.0 QCP E9 1%CARTNEY FO 6LJ 1.0 M127INTAKEBLDG 2 RACD MY SUPPORT S-257-1-28-140-2-3 11/14/84 QCP E9 MORRIS (N BE PHYSICAL 1U14/84 DM 1.0 t%CARTNEY F0 !WR 1U14/84 GLJ 1.0
- E-3043 M128INTAKEBLDG 2 RACDMY SUPPORT S-60A-2A-104-3-15 11/14/8411/14/84QCP9 HORRIS(N BE ACCWO-M 1U14/84 OH 1.0 QCP E9 1%CARTEY F0 GLJ 1.0 M048 C(NIAllNENT 2 MNJLUS~~10036-02-13-M1' F15/841UO4/84 QCP 3 RION(ND F0 PHYSICAL F15/84 AGD 4.0 QCP5A RECORDS 3/15/84 QCP C7 ACCWO-QA 1U05/84
.