ML20199E829
| ML20199E829 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | South Texas  |
| Issue date: | 02/09/1982 |
| From: | HOUSTON LIGHTING & POWER CO. |
| To: | |
| Shared Package | |
| ML20199E696 | List:
|
| References | |
| FOIA-85-519 NUDOCS 8603270455 | |
| Download: ML20199E829 (57) | |
Text
s f
/
STATEMENT Place: Houston, Texas Date: February 9 , 1982 I, hereby make the following voluntary statement to Mr. D. D. Driskill, who has identified himself to me as an investigator and Mr. J. E. Gagliardo, Director, Division of Reactor Projects and Engineering Programs, U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission. I make this statement freely with no threats or promises of reward having been made to me.
I am currently the Houston Lighting & Power Company (HL&P), and have been employed in this capacity since October 1980, rmewed Upon joining HL&P, I stud!:d t e 1 story of the South Texas Project (STP), the NRC Show Cause Order, and the information prepared for the May 1981 Atomic Safety Licensing Board (ASLB) hearings. After reviewing the STP engineering program, I felt there was a need to have a third party assessment conducted regarding the design and engineering programs of B wn &-Root, Inc. (B&R) in 3aA4 h
- W t. res geTm order that Ide**44 accurctcly =rud n crteque o$: f ens regar ing the status of these activities at STP. HL&P management autt.orized me to contract with Quadrex, Inc.,
to provide us a quick assessment of STP, primarily in the engineering and nuclear design areas.
d-ou<A w.
In a g r or early December 1980, I f Quadrex
-tmd i ..i. cc.ec I wanted an objective, but quick, assessment of STP in areas such as design verification, single failure criteria, consequences of pipe break, and other areas companies are known to have problems with.
Quadrex began their review in Januar 1981 and completed it near the end of March 1981. During the revie was the HL&P for the assessment by Quadrex. In mid-April, Quadrex gave us an interim report which consisted of a series of questions and assessments utilizing viewgraphs. During this briefing, Quadrex did not answer some of our specific questions.
At that time I contacted of NRR and told him we were condr kg review ared believed we would have some 50.55(e)s to report. I told tw be til 8603270455 860219 PDR FOIA g '
GARDE 85-519 PDR
N "
I.
Statement i 7 wQ .
. wise to give NRC an executive briefing and . -
greed. - -
aid the _-_
hearings would begin on May 11, 1981 and he would be in Bay City. Texas, "
at which time we could have the briefing. i
) On about May 6,1981, I sent a letter to k h' of B&R askin to
( review the Quadrex report within 24 hours2.777778e-4 days <br />0.00667 hours <br />3.968254e-5 weeks <br />9.132e-6 months <br /> of its receipt and identify any '
reportable. items or items indicating a need to issue a Stop Work Order.
V ' ~ E' ' was also asked to provide HL&P a plan of corrective action relating to the Quadrex findings. M i '
On May 7,1981, a meeting was held at B&R during which Quadrex passed out the ;
I report and discussed their findings, using viewgraphs. B&R, during this meeting. -5
-2 expressed concern that the depth of the review was ficient to resolve hm.-v +nW c.k & M s - kr mur arrav '
some of th sues.-but -I beh, eve mar.y of the Quadrex fi ings;w:eser f were accu.ute scyr-*ood.Lig
- g .
that afternoon, and through that night, B&R reviewed the report 3 and presented me with a list of their findings, only one of which was reportable under 50.55(e), on May 8,1981. ;[Mjhdhjhi@[L and I reviewed the F B&R findings and identified two additional 50.55(e) re ortable items. On May 8, 1981, of HL&P, teleptonically notified .
Region IV, MRC, of these thres 50.55(e) reportable items. T On about May 13,19 , during the week of the ASLB hearings in Bay City, Texas, _
I met with S N7'T to.give him an overview of the Quadrex report findings. E At that time, I had either one volume or all three volumes of the Quadrex report.
I briefe re arding the general areas of concern for about 15 to 20 minutes, during which ti perused the report. . ^
- asked me what happens if a
- B&R can't fix the prob eni. I said, "If they can't I'll find someone who can." -
j
'^4 then asked if I was going to send him a copy of the report, and I told him _
i no, but it was on file at HL&P and he would be welcome to review it there.
5 y
During my tcstimony in the hearings that week, NRC attorne asked me _
"Were you satisfied with B&R design activities?" I said, "No" and he asked -
7 "What problems do you see?" I' identified two of the problems, which we had 7
h previously reported on 50.55(e)s. then questioned me regarding my use of j J e i
30 -
e -
{ -
s W Statement the word veracity. Subsequently, changed the line of questioning to the construction area. If I had been asked, I would have discussed the Quadrex report at that time. I never thought f he Quadrex report should be sent to the ASLB because they were looking at only construction activities.
Between May and July,1981, B&R developed a corrective action plan, in response to my earlier request. As a result of this plan, B&R hired a consultant firm from Idaho, contracted with Westinghouse, and hired other engineering firms to resolve problems identified by the Quadrex report.
In late May 1981, HL&P senior management met to detennine whether B&R could successfully complete the project. HL&P management was aware of problems in B&R's QA and construction activities, but realized during these meetings that the Quadrex report provided another dimerfion to the difficulties with the project o.a o , ma ,u..w ...a csg.yu,w d tht B.&R did not fullychmes understand in eer want te c h ge w..utaaed be- the et business
=+W %e thec%
the character of their company. It was then s HL&P look at other wickw options. --
The fact that the Quadrex report existed was not a secret. HL&P and B&R personnel were involved with the Quadrex reviewers during the Quadrex assessment and during progress meetings during January to April 1981. When B&R was criticized during that time frame for.not having completed engineering studies / designs, their excuse was their per~sonnel had been tied up with the Quadrex people. h *y copies N,,
..A %
of the Quadrex report existed at B&R and HL&P. In May 1981, I briefe regarding the Quadrex report and subsequent to that time never gave any atstions
.h n o eua n W to HL&P or B&R personnel to withhold the report from NRC. I was net awue t1at an re' told they could not, in August 1981, take the report to their motel room for review. My only stat as that we would not file the report with NRC, but some HL&P people %aapparen woe. y interpreted my statement to mean we should withhold the report.
In mid-April,1981, I told we were conducting this review and offered to brief the NRR technical staff and if it had not been for the hearing, where I met with I would have met with the NRR staff in Mary}and It was my perception that the I&E area of interest wassin construc'. ionaand the l
NRR area of interest was in technical design problems; therefore, I did not feel g }
/*
/
Statement it was necessary to notify I&E of the report since I had notified NRR.
I have read over and understand the foregoing 4 pages. I certify under penalty of purjury that this statement is true and correct to the best of my knowledge.
Executed on Februar 1982 l
l Executed before me on February 9 , 1982 at Houston, Texas Signatur .AO O D. /iskill, Investigator, NRC Witness: k h d.\. Gaglibrdo, Director, Division of Reactor Projects and Engineering Programs.
Bil
1 __
s i
i
. w
~
' k - (i {, tw kw tu. m Aw p c, s N
" u, me e
- f "* % % ~
- y. ~ n a w ek - ,
Oudud w~ 4 an cf b
'l 'N w- ST P u..m d ,
d
- s3W ask c- %, c.r pc- Am.3 1 k M<ci < ec. ch +o dt M
% % & \d % n..J.,ed. e t- 2n -v I -- J u d % C -N me ir 4 % 4 L ~~ % 9~, e , b Os e swkw+ q p.cl suck as -eh c.c h .oo M c.<3 ~% g ure w <bi e s< % (t'%; cs}
mm3 mat d Qci . :s a s< _t q tre eu 1- i2.,G 4.tv 51 4, d-s~st iw c,% g <f (Q Q s wo %A, -h (6 sutu / -% s 41 L L q=%s -fu s ubu g q<.tc< % d k R.
% ae%4 m att ~se M +r4d % G
<ee uct%dasLd 6ba thu. _ x d Me m L 4 h t w g; qu EA Elo jl9
og a
k %
m Lmm eu . E escb = Al hy %d
< 1 oudd m A, 7 IA c' Pm v G M bt A C4 4 Et I uhu s
. cf ud I A-
~
N. s- o %M -s y bey; it as s. . o \3d cx Q cm. Q.am Sds h v
-cah awe < s J % CF A
- 3. uuq Qu I u% GJ hk ( a. u o.,,,,, d k
./
m me ua . r,rir o c e s %it. 6 wh yx . s- w_a c 1 A '.
L
(
(t C mq b ML sh5 a 5 4 . NS .
mtgi % J q r A .- % dha ~4 Ns Gy abd - 3d cf _
d\ VILE
I.4w *D_k 4 ( O aaA G u d2e J % na.
% 6 mee w r h.
WE(m 15 vp
% e sses h %)
ut da J C~ta et 0.. Q,,w(u E S tt
' A,wu 6 6 30 g% t, th.ys {g g iA , [~4 v eed 6@
LM E w (t s wt %G4 ~
</ tsy . -
)
% 'l f( b( Dv4U dk (d~g tG 4 O s
l, p e dI 4 us . C( Mg 7-9 x4 k A L P '<. bE - Qw it;d NE Bf *"
em Seq m ousel oh ree: - a m cl '3, i '1
/ (4 Q Tecd ch d [u vd 9 I_da.by ,
8 Slo
N M C. VhM96 co ( h se.u.a pecA N d<oba79 cdY - I52aq,ecl m pu. L wM wa. x, t 4 %T - mM m' y w A4% PQx - Os 10 uo w % g u 4 g! :
\ l uGa E4p ed% 9ci 04tte- T ccae acram PmnJ t s 4LP vne d v ,
Okr Syd 'T SI y aced [4 s LJ %a w, wQs dce w oldba sgid M dd dh4
- s %3 M J.
ad d bmx 47yelt W 41 ,o
> 4L. m. vMe
'zf~&eas v. : diu %
+%.ffQ) adhd s A a % m 6 @ u,u cf d
,h 44 l
_mm m W ~qJ d'M m ad 4 w D ,wum A, Al s
< ma r - .
~
DJ x d
n 1 ;
s u 8
W A bdA $cl ,
. MJ O9 J( AQ 2 - 6, m t u w& J Aq q
- A T, y & M. t v =%
-s e w g -
LA na J n
, ,b d w q i4 Mt
$,jk:r %b M A s a Lt 'a
! n y1 1+ t R-e m u 4 +
o th l
WO' a w U
efa r
.b 9 i
A cd g(m "-
l _
i j
A9JL y r& aag. .. AM .m 9 4 ki % Y d 2L L.
i o_ o io Jd 44 6 -N, 1510
W ~
n ,1 g A m m &
m A y b-p kJe 9 #
n -
D is D oM A ne Q % -i
% c2 ,
W ha r
& Id -
A p is-0 -A as vum4fA A w kd4+A
. r 1'
A e UA e
W u
?
a%m Ad w
1 w -ie A
q y we,w'gn m
l .a&l a?
U u ex phly.
er 1 -
.I' J -
w
% , ~L i 24i eW J m J cs,A m(
>R2L o so. sen s .
Tn1. 8/ 4 M "
- NM n
%g 9 +
)A bA m e um 1 sJg JM 3 Mg
%hk $&f$$8D
+O M h *A &
/
qn & q 4L ' '
gA y ' S bm20 1
\ s)iadr #s ,
3 \ ,,
~
63 6 (& ( wAl l
t
. , x j$ >
qn l l
W N A( &
%\ 'h -
A dekk N $ 14 d 'B e t 4e 4+ L p %
In m e . l
^
)
C m h ruuJ) V c9 v \
- 4 N W *liW l ggf,%JL . '
lrl p& b s~ d M p;A A , , ',
My g y
1 l
/
~
.'d h y W 3 Sb 11
~
v.6L M k d+qw v1 M_ q d4 ,
M @,%.-
wQ-
) '
s
.1 y 4 9
. 'b u -
4 10 wk W ; fp& '
d y> M 2 d < f kl 3d (
WA )A A17%
,m-u4 -k 1A a -M- +- w z>J-R" w .
9 10
/,
we t e
=e n s_%g l
. > p nn4 a w,4 W J(i h - -
l h& y.- 4n~AJAv n m a GL & Er.A 4 w
&L A % JJ m y T ^
Y W.
E wlL\bl L ;
s & c ,,1 t a f, si th m
s ~eaC $'
%W8AR a MA /cfA. ,
.w bNtA% Q M A 1 s - ~/ 4m
&Wm pyA +=,D 6n a O '
NR o
' wam%A dw Ndle w $ 44 ik
- a .
Da$
10
@W.T(hks{
A%%
W w
' MA \
l 3 10
r
.shq, ~ ~A w , p x Ag~~a %-twA g pm c
g TsCd A
.;w 9w + Mi 2 ua
- ,%9
- M A JM >?
)
s J ( M w s v NW 4. Y, ~J Lf, swhh Nbb'3 ,u k JuWw2b
'~
y}D
- A 31t W h k M i b4 A4 2
eQ' xsn W6 A ddvQ 4 '$
> J .3 a, A a k v~ a J % ~
w fr it N e, v3una n w e Aqh p &
v3 d^{ 9
- p. & l%A P 3g d % ul l %1 A LL r:
%' m WFL w _ d r) pn s ~(n L w>
T Rd -
bQ M aL
_:x 8[4 L o.
4W Ja ysz_aza'.
s8 m
l O
Y h md>n. 9 ~ @>-
e Q sd ~
Aw9 p r om a ga u ,as a op M Ak un ) ~ I d An:- '
g A % @' nxAd - & SK hiu #L 4Rhouds sud ' %
\ g-m Jw M(
M ~y,4 Avn ca d a A%
4 w
M, "lt!q M. Eh w
c' m%b)
L GMb7h 124 h W. n M (sw ObN & &
n& a, xv% m w
A- bv S J g c -A mg x 6 > da.
N ~A A p- =Ava A
LJht 9
' q pdb l 4 ga 4 HA yrs 3 A;;aG<a 1
- Qds Md4 b cq y4 ExMeA N%h p
CMp-' \g 4
d Pdi P g p1 4 wa ut be h 1 E /gg Q b n [.hd -
u m ,L
-p b w a W%A nA ,LL .G hm
- s
' s; &
pA h t L , )
a R Q > ntL Ld A A$
- 43. s m, h - k L % 't
h p N T> 2A '
3 ,w JMW vJs M 4 k a43cEagt
% Jcl a
- y. _ , A1 a4 W i -
7 C&A w' -
- w. *j 0 4a st NACj A4 % 1td@M A Jb AAC e %
0%Cw \k >& \~l - @
%o n 4 L10 v()sAtk' ]v, N
&w ne J w ^
gf h a
vi A h + q a a/ )u W
>4 , Mm -
uw; DL M{
~~
Nww g =kK ai u. &
Ea
\ ( M' VAL L
, %J.
ayWn, W
wD -y JA U dald 6 3 (L m k % 'y
- Wa
+ s ta ,) y i S k % 4 at so F5 N d
%'(A JL l b % MMqb, q% 1A k%y M esta m &f%
5 % )J>c tdJ1q % & H w
& b
' % ~ )3e J1 n al V39a.
m s o .s s m _ u u t 39 l
\
w p e J r\ M w %kAt M %
- 4 9. A Ab> h( -
o
')w W m ad5 ' ,
mx A.y? ytte fa n
ga w i9 .
a k:1% W d<ae ?N
- mt7w a a M+ u 4 audl%L" A tdL d. %%uM' A. J .
Ax 44 A l i k d,Ma p <MN '
S & Le og Af M 1AbQb deC m A 4< If' ' 4 , S 40 ca; Rw1 A! d hw 7 4 Ly2 m A 4 J u Ov m s m se a py '
1 i ~ -
~$%%g4 .
Q Out 1 -
tu
%q' c
-g p w %, %&l 'f M # tt pq 6]
M % ~ M
~
MJ m
~
e
%m_ u l
- r j-
~
Y k o To 6d s\%L9 q ~5 Md> ~% w A ob U M nemi W g uW % vi.e. A c 4 h d Ms us.uQd evchk a-. salcI.q ucur
@ wh as En a, e km G a JL trMd mid ave a>4 - Sw d dw .
r ms 3cb
- c=1 addt es hMau T i2-C.
n.
f[
b
e'
, I
/
g4g ge e bb,\ '-
J
' @A b qA Me AN E~ g "t ^'O ;
p_g,'W;.'MP hwe x
f e
A,
<4 g y) 4 h 9 00
\
sY*% e s g )ood u' i
T. w %P a s 9 "
1 sa
'b>) {' "g'l g A w+ L '
E i ,
h 6 @' M, W g e hs A a }' ,b M 6
_ _ _ - - - - - - - ~ ' ~ ' ~ __- __. - . - ---- -~-~
W sigh a%
lGL
,(
% d a, m,a _4 n %'~
c-g
.. , Qj 'L, M'"0"' n#% AQ w>
d y d4 6
at [
wa 4 9 m J m 12 3 9/
L e w4 -
I
%b -
3 g(1% JM ~
E g ,i _ 'lQ, +
Q , era M6) L W) u u" dflMM e & wCAf"'"*.4 s
& _% , JAQ >
~l -
@J dJu O
we q>q)A M&f(.
4e ywa ak q ik I1 1N sa
. L --
E l
nn n
'E & I
t T oc3 wd ~5 - O (2. L t% .o- q n,d,
- t. m b e wd mv d2ved L 46.h ed oc %
evn.
df we [ o ttN m d'91 kn n o
%o Ed y w.m tc~s& A schek F s
> .tiv( %J 1- L/9 4f=xf wf c(ul. Oe - % ceN cG k cq . k J \d %u A
+c scf
~ aet wl #
g,q m 9o r it . 3d k=d qc% & Lk% is d z, nu %ct w -fs 04 % ,) '
o_ume'd i % d Q r,, Gd G da> k V""0f ?
cou rad % cc1.
38
g GOS-h ~
I
\
1 - g. y I g}
OC 4t. 9 o, <a,+ s it m Webt 435 Q
~
c c1w ' A l
Y h (
W *1" YLL %*n
,) 4 - wi.- u-~, ad or scJ 7 e
o a -, sm t w c~d As
- am ak pek r d'cd i n - - weuci Gwc vged % g ucck~w~ -
u lu( msa 'b Sc% \
i e, - . a km<
Ylaz ~ m ye - ass bv Ek Oopcue to fcak t -ta'yt mee,/ A 6,A 12c k e d) duff- A l.9 m d' lc d J u>, - %6, & u2e:
/ 14 fs
. Al G _Q[ W k% -
O a, , asu u - S-e u{ sA le kwt l Lt, -
n +vs s / -ddT A uluu E
l ,,
. % d & c4 k 3&W oE f+of ds :
.m d - ev 4 <.a # % .
s 0 0 LL L 3 3\
>i
'>Y
i
~.# .
f n) qA . p&a l ~w- %9 dA L.4'
)%
- [d x
^
> wwM#
T> s & . Jh%c>~y'sJ66d h %1 rW d- b>n g(ynLpg,ey4 cm A 4 4
L Ps 7
Ipl q A p se nx TTJd h vt ps i n n us w u 3In Jd Jy4k .bl3IWMA w y .9 J L w
- ^L % %
dW A
MlW % e un% +d h\n,m% L sqA iL
+-
b y'
c.A p L4J b{w N, o . cO) e p ,
))
i W% ~ A M m,, .~
u ]laJw %]b w ~h t di A L / g \ [,, J L A A % m a x4%
A
$A -
ud% J p m c
-cxmLsde4g 3
s
% L S L' b'PM m Lc
- f N WhW.Y WYA$$ \m 3 WQ f $n dl
}-Y
r A
hyJAda-29 A !aa A 44gd L w~
b6y k & YM Y M %k . W15
) )da 2 qJ4 ss t J J- 9 s om 'A J A so g% gL t p % M s~4 ,Mpp MC %
u -
96 et A em' u' rW$@
s v k ,L, -y.-)szh ' w) c7- ~ %
ML ad a L
T M W' -
nx as u m a JL 4 % M w A . a r1 37
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -- -- I
> -alt! P byl ggc.
- 2. s- 8z (6) 3 50 g 6.Ec ed Ma gg + k%.
yo, La's/_wmungpur4*/w W
~~ l < % u: & .( t gae na 'nker<.u r-f '
> CL Sp
, .-c 4 -
gAe d u afia w.E od w l aInf E4 &f 7 dj Dd M"fulw ha % & >~ so . 3 5 <
a s t 5 h J ikQ= g h %2 hcq
% 7 ,st <e e'd o el e
~, @ (6 md crab, A &
~
vm G z-v u,, , w src y g d(f w>.
1 p t w g b ,_ 4 4' A % s A+ - - pL C1 ,<
? 4e% m % LLN' %
% - hg
%& eC d %u ccmu[adxw puag%
accuAA yw u is - s u d ve Q 9 u ,ad ofJ us rga
?* ,4
( "" * [ Twebb ltz
- Cd 2 of b r : ~c, y & f , ni., em., e4a4 s3 33
-77
r P
. - ~ ama y a w ,
r 16 stig u k %g --
I efim d d co dh dooO 4 %g suc3 _
l Adb 3 uhb d y%$w t h* M>
k.t po-
~
i - au bu au u -,u .c r ma J ;,s
- r ,a - sw < - . .
J d.kk Hou.'% weDccux & ycsic ecs j f
- _e Q$ kt asU ta s 3 kd2 $( Q ( h; .
%f m - J ym n < t n :e x ret s~~ ag 3 L&_ye ck x, ' pch 9 & a kal sabrL l.d s
0 0 04CAA- Cf W y w~ sdr&d pc,a. w <,a
- g _A V-o r
bs
. ~ , _ _ _ -
1 I
p 1 hqt pY E co Y. < cu aaw . ,v a ,
1 I O %N %4 #D M 's % # \Tt
~~
4 @dul M 3 % Cd3Pd%k % ,
,&, u e, ;
t
- r. p W4 W e o
.:W/ ..
Y ,yss kM o~
+t h'b 4x 4
} 4h& sc%
f o[ "v i
b? ZF
- p s
33 l
- e. M *
/
_ 'h L od dku emvashs e v, k ply
@~
~~ s co r .
% mai M aA m'.
ts (4ro
@f'es 99 q to u& S k v % pv e u t,, A7
}k vcuwa Odd Irn % Mg -tfr !a7
% c bb4 J q es w% <m an-, %g ceG ~%
t+ s cua a 8 W
W Q Vks \D*b JMM f s pedA .i i d % oCif 2 wA q vc (dit q h e d - o s b v v ~N w cu wd % c>ceto pb 7 a>se te ana cwk M FI4 t8 OPE +eck la ow Dvd 4h o~aM
e 4x me i ,,
% % s>es. agt) gre,
.y i +;- - wa mmve og Wo c g
df- S eq Wo (q '
N -
Awd6h uc6 evob cuue, q x *
%h
-~4 r9 al =wik 4, %st 2+ us. i%e cAS4-G d ao,m.W ~s q /?'
$du8~ Y &s.4bb&g W _kO&
- dau?4 etQ wac
% w,-
demdo&c d
-nr cewa y to g 1
~4gyg -
q%t W,u, uma L%c oe e - a,&*
m e sNve
,c E
] .
e
~ .
s " a[a; t u\ h T
a S1% $ 2 G U> kv.s "Q sp AC e( i ' ebc%
h m^A .1 % JM a%a dA'
,& 4
-vu+Aa n ri w WL ~ ? h b~ Y]p N A & l bff4,S'[
un f 'v-A~4 0 ~
- k
$b(>fjm %-
L d -
q' '
q A k.TL w4)~)(
y rif~
.a,y w
,.se a - w,e a +w p f(L 3
w L&=- u k % . TW +s (d h a r J w~% -
,A +k (Mijlujoi ~A ch f.M,
'pak n d' b J A ~L ~m y ~hQ m ~Lm JC ,i m. $3A bl e
%r a >3 Vf ' -
O -.
, weMWh kk wa 3 mat edH 74 \+ A ~.p4 5+
Rg (
w 9 u a -
qk nr ; % uvi. 9 % qJ A-s Q rad h y a f f. JpA at.w- w wa~ A .
n vny' & M
.a
. Lpm a - a %,x co.sc(o , sd1k~JL ~4g t1 wA d>> g Lp n
,_ % 9
>@A % ,r L N u u Gt .
cP - 7s 3 ,$ yd4 Ok % udpA 4 ~ M
~MA, 4 5 % Mb< bW
^3 Aw 3 hk' k' 3 A %d o qM%>&t A A % LL po,. 4M.
w i
IQ1Y'N a i[d '
+
dc= ,
JL f $% #au wwr
, v b % 9+ h.
u.
%3 M lei M. A4* $d SLA ~ <3 4 A d, A LA M am h xno4 d) .
e s4 [8 " d3 J _ b41, Wi t Lk \ d A y { >MS S 41 u sn p p ,yck m@
o
O bk M)M
-~JA J> JL -A ,Aq t + \q b %b A al@Al AMy Q w:e 4 % L w
^
kg p Nm ,A 3
,n , ,
$Lg. W wi.
T w &> + w r% 1 L% M ~[f%%
\ pJm tJWLA H L w p(s-s' ea W4a) m omJ
~
- e.mm m k +u cdLt. gM 4%A' 7A U d J a A - r 61%L A m,J k n
{& 'h 6 +dAL AA1 w q wx ~,
4 lp1 w', M pJ4([e 9,p fp v3 LU % AL
. a a h 4-ob-t Q Q Ayh JAa bw% 3 Meb M. 1 h @ % wa k(
A, bse eA th et u ~ t9 A >
a D1 J 4. " ' k f&Od hN v~~gAaa+A J fL wl.'t a x4 t%
4 A ey o 1ilg huwM QJ ) ~n , A>q h hs wp:,:)
u mu d -
w>
A- %6 's(u y M Je .
34
M-P g (N % $2~0 T n
JJ
,n m
%1 L U
fua I
& A f 6a)J s -60t k
% ,ea s -
> _ 69 @0' T Am 1J ~d4>9 '
e ')J ~l ' -L g .'
~% ce "A
%e s Na H_Q, x 2
w sa %m es gh "
U W' ' a,)
'n>
mkk 'W +5 P A 4r u %
%4 -
bb h
1-NN
>a
$$M &
Qtsd1 MA AI
- bb'
~~
a w
&O & ~~ we s), -
yg\%%~A %,A 63e d n a g&-
h1A v A
.W s r --f ,JL
- 1 W 1'4 y L pr u.1% qu 9p '
A amh g' W (JA e ~ h 't 4 b - 4 . u d 3 e < v%u/sM aJ6 vA L agae.
he 4 mi & 4 24
. F hbt N DsiM MAJ)
M nM ' ,-
2m
~
%A /US C em ]+ OD v A h\
) e ,
D
,ws A 'i a a Md% 44. ,
% Csu)A x cp % whaN%
n+~dl o wh Md A t Ar
- % gu& d!LA Lw L 4
%\ , 'M ~ ~ . T)Q %k dd Mh s g a u a a 1 ,( s. - ~1 _a-eb J AhMD q Lik ep & )@A!M C> ult b
pb M '04 a-n A Ah )# m, m a $ - 3& M s:0s 193 tu Af '
M 4 *p %
kt dw% dyt p J 4
6'bh & , d~y dId ud )N"A qa t; A n ca % w \we O J9 w pd 7ths A l lo's r M-A k.- a % LL A u A ' LJJ
& v 2 % A LfW *&nd a4 ,"1 .
< A tar g dmx2 aog
/ aem
~~
u GL %z & uf es en k
[$> N ^
u u
au
%dA y[;h -
w+p~
naay am m
- l u ~
Q% %qt ma so a! 3) w i
h a ad4 m\ .
~
a~ars -
y l
A, a-m U % + ( 4s a /i ) .] A % ~ g n.
M h 3N Ok ;
M Mb ,
j n_
e 644 t]
w u b6 k
WA 4 ELA a 5 L t d-%&abhA JnJA 9 }&~% 4 A
- t AW LA -
q, gh? . t s.1 3 A g~~
L%
j d9 g+A aM3 w cu J A E3 4s l oY v 6L wJwt n ( Hab We
,h M ,JTu b i
.6AGS pyri st l
C@A 3 q n u ,bL 4 4SA.1 m g& q 4
t bqg- a
_,s# # ' p- y a
' t D
9 s 1
1
%#qut"~gfh$( t*@
,+ A
%c su a +
s Q ,Q+- D'+ +
r\'
\
ym f "
ag-r.,g.e,:
\c\ a ~ p Qzu J k ,;A
\ d *' p, ,
\
pp c ay cn" 4_t St 4 i])v um)
) - 4,p [ v# I i &
1
/
nay sk 3m M Mlc a
4 5L L.L A 3 %+ A 4ds% % v>+~ hl, 4&.
I l 0 vd> %4 m W e 4aa d .rt %,R . hw ] * ,f %
~
Mou '
y *W am 4
-t -
Q d waa -d a-__r s ,w u ,
1 - J ua en d u f , c. J IMC .
(d)uki b Nddr , g / 1, 14%Ak a ~& }& y L&.Ad 6 /Jh
~
A O k)MCk I(
y_ a asus m m p> a f d, @ d i tto km
\
E% % m m 1, Jk so.ssre) oAd
% %L by D 4 1); Qh
> 3,tkuk ~ .- @.bn A%a w
Twr W1
,~f Ia d LA a % %.62 s 4
^
E *"
ro.ss 3 e M
3 nJa na V wh
~rt AAM q 3
___,_.._,..---------.-----.,w . , . - -
.g
- y"?
M_A *a
- hWrfdh I ,<
>@A M A S [
34
_ e w_ a . - . . . --- em. m_ .m . - _ _
L
,s 3 %.h1 f
f it e
i
)< $] C r l
% bC % 6 4l
@ %C
)1
! d cb L-m c ma y e s(;
l - 1 j
i f/
~
) a d. ICA l
'U
- 9 su> ca te pp \ l
/ " " l de 4 gs - l g'4
- "" S' At(j che('4 go V k# 1 a :
n# :
&Ju N'
& L c L gfM -
l l
l l
k t
l-l 1
{
l l
l l
35 ef
.,-_______,...--__,,--..---,..---m
O A e ; j A >> d d (% a) q
- [j c 1 y' b
%% R +Jy+ w) wr k u E ,
od 4J, \,aA yp - %
L AL%
r up.
_va
- w w od'~
& y&b vfDw da h..
o.6 % f 2l )w' -
mwgu-a 1\ \A. ,e T3dwa- d 'A p
%h 144 n/DA e u A
cq E M q%) ego ~
I
.6StD & ~J
>w%
h ^MNA M b
m u%UQ%
AS@d%%.%ct 2y%(p(u J .
J 4 6 %
fd , % 4 M Ja M. pin A hr 1o ot x 4 Eq 1 7 Mi hLi E%kiUg@""9" oc
) h%
hb a oE eJ >q.A w c
JA ,Vd.5.aFA
{fv%
J <- !
d qux- -
LLs L a J,dd n
-Q em a 1 oA:- -
A de yDwgM T d d vmJi %, ,
inu# A 4 g, a n Uc%%AAuspd v4A % >MS Cx 6Ld uk W , S
~A a J<am.. sJ4m y J1
%A n t
4 pfbpv M w Y e l cl IOM sO_& L 1 a J ok w v6A 9 i' xo- c- AV (
3s 6 i M a d ' s!g i t
a - axa t\ "a.cA p m
,WO,1 M )%
n v wds l hd cdd"h h wAA y ML . wm A_o vu W > ogs%% .W p'.' V s tw V 4 d A~d. M b Go Es t , Slif TeR 36 W.
t
+aWM w
hk &,
k n
p,c g [anuwduw g Ad LA QQ a H z JprWA Lp nA M L
,y1 vu-g O) qO AM%( u mu t h+ e sam set bA tA 6o 6so
- 4) ed2OPd 34*1 M "ish' d b -
)
ca
,QO h ' A & u
% M)
\
% \ L NA m .
~
OA h
~
dpA e wh M L% & n 53 q% e w& A Wl v n lQ*w 5 cxb Vf a w% ,) N N W ) 14 Jr mA~ L ' %
4 )) i Go & 6 k) &
Y" % 3 ,
% g h a 9 e% a 7a.se e #s Ve@ d6k )s
, $6 l
n .
p, i
g, v' t 1hJ 4 g,
- 4 g' ~ -
vA 3> M e
La 91 JJ &
-p
' TfJL J WL au L
_ m y A) a T,OA,
-wu '
c-
'"(
A sy % FA ) juA R}A t
A ;d4
%p e0'*.
i M
o R f .>
Q> L 7% a E
AArwd-
& -f
,es -
fod b 4 2 u
4 %y %n $4
%4 8 K. w \
N .
< w .
U O k> -
&'4 k&
- t ay n-4 g
+ s wa a
~ .A n m ,)
4AA L A L M, f,_ % y M mf+ '- em ,
e g
f
.g s 5
W $ 0 ,
MA - MV m .A g d.
A+ k m :'
<_yb _. 1 r^um i&M
% y J shb?
-an-wad Mw L I
w )dPhA)11 _ gg h J 1 R
@A #.
r %A A ) A A -wnge_
.rJ L N b w ki w -
ag b a\ukm l ,
r . ', 3 td 24M4- .7 s t y o du w A4 w (
s & G- MA Vf Q, + % '
u s.
3 rH .xu -
d5 w aa mh~k,+a w %4 wids M-awnywt
%p .
ma .-.a- a- . a s n_m. m2 ,s, .a. ,._s __ a ,--a,sa_
h l l
- g. u.e
,- w .- <L ccd mt d T3 p<d s bm 3 77-if rdv !
- e b ccuced ceuI olmd of L.9 -
- % L, md Ldkd m J % pts , o W l m% sed d %5 (w%Qc few -n.t uccZZbn~$D i s< 1 byx . vacu% d ku filc . M (dcul Agvl4%i a Gu e&d ms, of w % & <mduW
%, do usk mlcud 4 82-fTLf"'h m kJ/y!
~ w a n* %
gurken%
aat 6d q s dasw96d Ldidb cmd
- N c_ 6 k d a P. y dd dulua 90t acqfive
-n v4.'.h i cc[ kg upGtz p % A6 9 e oeu A=JHA fy5 -
> autm awa d Wn nQ&s+(fgQ [M~fi w ae a v c Scd %h thP adks wf 1ved qve k L 1E Gy e@ & chdVc. ud3r&if
- LL , w asmu h c. J ve 2 %A s v ufw GH w si d%mtwo heif %g u.e % e Sn 4LhcLA < -.u -fc4 e Eq evofv l en Osb d 9<o hj
! L4a>.)
a Ac.- m ~4 -
uh
, bD jW
". ,,h M __
^
si ~4xE k \ us J 9 wu t, A -c
~
- d. A( - ! del = <ea p d es b
[A ce ,
< A & C., p. A ~ <,fe l Id
- g Olw I M Td k - hf balb e r V w w ftwi tg 4a .mg e-s, h- 4usd e G- &s ccd 4 %u;cuiwE% g, f'f W s
a 1.,_ t ~ .4 i - +%
,[ S Rc)s s~ -u W uqu kuE ca uttNn[p, hk E J M netuud Y sJ % cet or vyt - a '& m q % cde d 14uit o <el 3 aac( e<6 % s,A % 8 e b- >
~%@ u bd. 1ctu~ 4 W '+(a~b d .
>MMw c4( M m q u c o .1 o ML m d 6 <dous a cad .gmedu AM ~dk( c. g 34 e Aa + 04 c+ TA J,4d 8
- -3 bl ~d kct W k .
y f,, w
- au +
n, c. ~_c .r. 7 4 es .c % v
. !c e uc m ,
Q al uAJ LLE -sr w b l-pt.b k 6 %d 4 msud 44 by 3 14 i
.i .
. ., . ~ .- c.x, + -
yJd %g au. Otokuq cd 'tt .3 ewF %d,4.14 $1
> Uq % l'tL 1 n cxcf ;~ kedt va sa w{Vics;-
e e's 1, .- deat <d do s.w mae4 - c A .,. s.
o <u. 5 < Nu et c e q CA
% 4
%i&La p)to - g dol a <et kd seu '
gd%g ;t= usma,LO
~
a.canety L ceuSJz- 6hmt %q li um< sodsdim i
Jhd u#.
a a.
ed e m E m-o -
i 44 P , dad b Tl kbhbM -
yy - o ,e % A r wat <<+.~ H %d Wf* ' $ oc,va.E kr4Gs -
%-w<d d b% g wk 2 t, d 4 c 9 d b %k u( cc M c'6 1 m r o m e e, .
uscd b $ ( g ccfg @ %
m.a ,
)~ ct L 924 c4 m, <c- aa-a -,
ya u a u J. .
ns ,. iu , - asl b ~ 4 GAQ lla i
l 314
- w.y.-rv- hw w*-e=r'eYm---t-w-> 'y-y-.-.p.. , , , -. .,------y--------m -- ---"N
.a-u ac4 <- +o , le (Ju *r-mGo - ' '
> Mud 'E dtdd aqvcc t hh
, cas aa, g-e k pue M ,y 7 %%- L @w 6 ugu 41 dCc
.f T uxad n eu k et . . . . .
7 bd hq cco,duc[ r ci <dk6u f docu woub we was 60 ad % 64
> - AcxLn - %4 a %
> "4 f ,- kJ %1)$ Ls meei at --Q w+
tw & cdcAa dultd 3cou p du 1D<J % 3R Em3 cm c4% T'& A O nd Mk (r wJ e .....e -t w-s 9 84-s c,
'b
/ !1 f )b IM 4- o\ >sm M- jC 19-iq %q k~~u vM A .t m .n ,
Y I3% we4{
l
+ $gh. U,#b wgA M% n 4}th;1
\ .
m wA O 7 Jc V
&: _N- 4
%_) jab.x Ld9 m
/ u gpy
& 4 g%
g.%
hetes
,\+evc 99 dex AM ' t M7 e
l 8 + << n k a p ? g
_px, <
V'
> >.hJ $4 j p%)Jf a g s, ~sw 4
Fq e x e .yu 4 n % .
\ sw u~a mg 9 y% %g 9j [
i '4t~ Hur J% Mi !
d n} ch%d w
fe bdar Nvn G4'rs-L s
%t,.,w).Zb l m p 4 c,$.a vb %a ))\ ~ 9I-3b ).M ana 6 iR in I I
spa .
k L"
- h yrevh k g)/}
Mb<ts ,& jGb &h
\p r iS v3 v n-pd lvM e-
~- Q % off \,
L g d c~o~
ga *%(yAu%h uen
- ~m
% e~ .-
si.r
'g
4
%[W ob 4 & , e g s A yit, o ,b d,-l a w 1 Q
c a n ' na ' 9 .s w d=
a- ' yMla w h- t ,
,w,d Zuj m Spu A au b.;,
$ /A1 h r'q s.d(
qa- h A ,. su luc
% a,.
u p%
ppd 9 A9ky r%, )t ,~ ph:d%
mu. k w a ?S M Ly v&%,
,a -d u gw ,aa 5
a -
,# w s- M d 46 ~
NmW k to.s nn d -4 amulcay v4
,a9' 9 4 ,Uw >
u hy C^t b h% m ud l b ,b14;g A v_ m e7 g>p +pn 77 p.,%
,+
,d
, wasq 1 us
- a. e em, Jv M_ma M a 1tJ1 (JJ L, 4.LA . > R vT4 n,J< j ;
2,,
i.
l l
1
'Q m I
~;, ~,u y uu
.ya g <
,_u.y i e [g as+++b m e@ l a u4 i
'. o AE.
W V%L
? *? i Eesg_*
~% h1 h n>
dlM [ 4 u La_
_u .
> Nia M L 7 u% 0 <~ r ..
3 A
.Il y '
, #) b 4 An i .
ffN> >~Le>
0 -
a r at, ~w n+ % u~g .
g- hkA%
w1nda,d x < ^1g~av u
W*r<Jn4,u~
s ,r ' '7
'~k," t'M p.
s ~. 44 7,q a s qt b m U ~g mi,y 9 Q.a\i ,\
^ca,.821Q ]
kk bY-j0Nq w>/
y 7a%agpggy 4Akib[ ,,,
n
.. .-.. y 3 ;
wh b & %
&+1=$*kA . JN Aub y.%c%A
&% M .s
-b u k e w . Wp hsh %ll ~
A d 4 u A m a d W a i m a A4 f.M. m T3b .
o_ A , tg 4% %A Ao -
9 DV 6 wh4 -
Ma new U -% W
%m k ,ad a L A % % g LU Jr2 g Aij
.dJL . ' s Al LP> ,%w 4,i da m+
-cAN d( I tt[ 3 4 H r Lt-'
w9, b. M/ -
u s e s% m M twvuCSy 4 3
s 7 e) d i m M7 U $'%
ht=k L \u M d ad %%LA J A J C U@ as '
' th% \
kM Wi
)g Ay L 5e &' ;& .
I ba i rbwar ql- M vhw ,d i b d M w M J1 1 4sid 9
'Lc%ggA A a ,pb ne n A ,
ms
,1
%y.- -
I t
g %"& I 7 ts-h1 3
4 iib sit
-Je-
ww a
- e. t I I e
\%! 1 I g l. -)JJk I 2 i' sm M 5' rx }. U] -
y.
. ::ld. U > l ,_
, \ <>.. . A z ,,) ,. Aa- v \ - w. 9 !! -
. x . ,N i. .
\~,. )'< ) re .M &bi.;A - c i s ', .~ J-'
52/ [ ~~~
p ...A.) j ;>>; .- ,./ , u v A . u s .x i, . v.W
) y , r :., i~\ '
j ' k n."y . GJ .-])} , .
v ,~ ,
f '. -
'(. %
. oLnu.m ~:,j, l', E , , f .W ) s.' ' r? )
- f.M ' ~
($ \
n q, l '
+ ,,-~), .pr,,..) -
w \f. -
1.sy . s' -
i . c
(" A
~ * ,1 l pf,
' / nqi, . g x, ) v ). q x ~j p>> oJ. , y
.! .. . (g .
. ,m Yj K05 - &)>& ).. _
)
S ',p,) e y)jja e .. , ..
't,'
, o, , ._v.1a 3/a- ;., v D )- w fj,i- , o
. C,
-] >>. - ,
o V.
J.
- u. s. ,), . =. ,,)
t .
. . >- . w _e
'y W Je'.- f. [ fvD \rb Q.) },
2
{W )
J_ ,
x- ~
) ,,me 7. ' > J J.;- 4~ 3 ' .
3l3 , y ,,, y,, , ;,. }y u ).
g ,. ) %< d /' ., ,,
w~ <w )
ca
~
3, .:=.A J.:
- t. c,, e ; .3 ,-
c.
v) j v.' w ; ..
- r. v.4 . -
, rg,,-
- ~.'.
~ .) j, v: s
- P -~'j A A d' s. Y 4 t
J.-is,);i])] ,
f' 3(r ., , ,.
) .> ). ), },. . -'
).: .~E o ,.... , v%
Jr b% Fi. c' ,.
+'I'$ r ? $ > b )) H '.:4 ( ' !.; >- .
a};,c), ,,. y ,'J., /,b,. r) q _,f )l. j..k
' +
h _ :=f.>>./.
,.x\ s.> ),.'\ .
/ n m x
&y*T' ,. {'; '
1 b ' 'r- CI '
' 3 i: ;,. > : ) .
y..m r ?y ), _'
- b% .
p .tM L' sk
p r
<~~ ~ ' a ?).x
,- .,, ,,; ;,; ,,,_,.. ,. , . T d
,b( d 3 o
- m M hM f M a _a d . , v.--A.k c se _L, du a 6 /
) " bt ]pt L9
%) J ,,a
% cix p., u a c ,m. u, .x,s. .,,%
,,.h l- _f )
l ( %,, & v-gv.oLh1. m{,l*~e u - A J ,,-a / Lbs .,x e ,3 gg, b 2 4.,6 uL v .
& a w:.a 9 k r., w , s. ). g . -
,. _ ~ ..
g
- 4 M l ,V a 4
% A h f i m) n \>)s.'4-b .- 8,J Wf%
S- t 4 .:e . 04 % v . k id 1 Lu (n >h cv<\ /\' -(, m , , ,. s n .,
,- a 6 >>>).o d T bMM3 %N #R vnJ>s /g ,,"74 44 JLnd. ~
,. 3 )1 j L. > - ,,ju_ A y
. ,9,.
&nAPAOw%
s _.
,, ss ~
.s
,. v \ t
.,4))
~i ,
w
' .ps : h ls'.' \C)^ b w.'
Et * )Jjs, q'.) ~'h ( ey /r 9 5.> ),..,90,w 3 y-u _ a . O ' t
@ ;;$,-7,'-<s4 u J.,.,.- ,
hr. ..r** .O1 >> j.e s)) ,m $ L ,. .p_y .f ,, 9%. bA ajv4. i TQ 3 1 w~Dh G'd.L.
,n
_ _ . _ _ . _ _ _ . . . . . . . _ . ____m _ _- _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ . _ 4Ls 7-2
-K3--
u .c , -r-9, m%ag c.cgy o C v8 w[t(qq -p,- k d<- Pk 63 % p d %, w b u - ,, s ,_ _ m kM E ' v4- ug w 3m s y *. do ,P tQ caf I r, o gus j
% %4 ger rw % wmad %
#- l I
}
l l t dw kS, _ c 4 h. . 3 && u- - ees- %-b k . (- du,, bmVcr T EM'4 cm4 %g .rq %f 2 <- % + 6 d b k c kd 3 w( q., - ( gCc-t
$1#
, __3 _ a - - - - - - - - - - , - - - - - - - - - -
b s
,, e p t M"h(t. c t A' t
T ,' M'fE AtM" ed % , fe % , Q ';olGztTepis p 4 zs - W i T Od itG -
,es <.h av
,y ,%
y >
...< g.; ~~~bA %
wcg* s - s m e .yd .c h < 4mc l' 2 V dh (f.1%*., T, Olt) 4%( d TCt IO A8 ' L( k({ v ecete d. If (veud.dm fuf %. a,Ldqhs u q wrusd e et -
<d ee W-d ps cv .h k0 cotscd p.'Cret. wp i ce M, btg_ta
+ ~
p O w u- sd % bi c7 d rd 7, w 59 5
< ane e c m _ es N i Ct. E d 'k vu.eli k u =3 muw ofkr P2(lu.c
> CAL s m L d 6 'pl
> kg, t L L'4 % uf.h
> u & $ h la wasn'\ pGca a [ k vrb
&1 ,
u t; -sw~ s -4
.s w+u tLut ~AA ,..m nL7 rd-%yJ% wd -
4 mu -J gew m i~d*#%m um Yp4L.
> d.a e + sa. <y{ .7 lad k wf %
> w .b23 k of % =#b w+es at M{ m o0nor
,- ap edJJa'{/m/
dd m' ( com i e 5 TM " C Y9 x,.g , v I w T 7 *Y b saz.. % w 32.i
h~
, ,. , am
*.4: r?' %
.g o . ,s, t
d% 4 we vm s WK
$ $ g*,Y e. has u,
demmmm u% ie? S Q' u o
%S Yq,g um 3
- bqu d M44 <._'
cedo.pt m p (~_ ts {m Y VS^
~
s ese s ea Q V ~c A n k Lh 4 & cabt ~ c
+ _ ~ m s PVb _L
- <7 wn. _ms 4&A a
m v a_ t '4 _3 , a k <cg
- %_g %Cra w ' '
_Lves <
, g ms
,}}