ML20149M451
| ML20149M451 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Diablo Canyon  |
| Issue date: | 02/23/1988 |
| From: | Grimsley D NRC OFFICE OF ADMINISTRATION & RESOURCES MANAGEMENT (ARM) |
| To: | Garde B GOVERNMENT ACCOUNTABILITY PROJECT |
| Shared Package | |
| ML20149M453 | List: |
| References | |
| FOIA-84-21 NUDOCS 8802260053 | |
| Download: ML20149M451 (8) | |
Text
_
S. N EAR REGULATORY COMMISSION w esca ttoutst % vun+
,....e.
f FOIA-84-2I
[.
k l
itseo%5E fvit 5
RESPONSE TO EED ole I "
i N ""'
\\
[/
INFORMATION ACT (FOIA) REQUEST W 23 m oocatt Nuvsta si vreesaree.c GARDE, BILLIE P.
M ~c)7832j PART I.-RECORDS RELEASED OR Not LOCATED (See checked bones)
No agency recorde subrect to the request have been located.
No additonal agency records subact to the roovest have been located Agency records sub:ect to the request that are ioent#ed in Apown 6m are already avadabee for pube.c espection and copWS e the N RC Pee Document Room.
1717 H street. N W., Washogton OC.
Agency records subrect to the request that are identifed n Appendes are bemg made asadable for publ.c especten and copvN m the NRC Pu%c Document X
Coom.1717 H Street N.W., Washegton. DC, e a folder under the FOIA number av requester name The nonpropretary versen of the proposaHal that you agreed to accept m a teere conversabon wth a enember of rey staM e new being made avaiabie for pubi.c mspecton and coymg at the NRC Pu%c Document Room.1717 H Street, N W. Washmgtor. X, in a folder under tNs FOIA nurnber an't roomter name Enclosed e informaton on how you may obta n access to and the charges for cocyng ** cords placed in the NRC Pu%c Document Room 1717 H $rree Agency records subset to t*, ro@est are enclosed Any appr<ab6e charge for coces ce the records prosded and pasment procedures are noted m the cortenents secton.
F;ecords subsect to the roovest have been referred to another Federal agencytest 6 ww and drect respoese to vou.
In view of NRC's response to the request, no further acton a bemg taken ori aopeal ar-er dated PART lt A-INFORMATION WfTHMELO FROM PUBLIC Disclosure Certain informaton in the roovested records e being uthheid from puble dscloso e cswant to the Fot A ewnptms oescreed in and for the ressors stated e Part 11. sec-X tens B. C, and O. Any released portens of the documents for *Nch only part of e -Nord a being *nhhe6d are derng made avadable for puolic inspecten and copying s1 the NRC Public Document Room.1717 H Street. N W.. Washington. DC. m a fo.oer ver the FotA number and requester name.
C,,....nts R cords that are being pitced in the NRC PDR are also being placed in the Local Public Document Room for Diablo Canyon located at the R. E. Kennedy Library, California Polytechnic State University Government Documents and Maps Dept., San Luis Obispo, CA 93407.
Additional records subject to your request have been identified in responses to a prGvious FOIA request. These responses are maintained in the PDR in folder FOIA-84-744 undar the name of DEVINE.
You may obtain copies of those records by referring to the cbove FOIA folder.
(
kh3080223 GARDE 84-pj pg A
signa o.af CTOM. DQ15CN OF S AND a NRC Fs.M 464 den C esi
g F01A-84-2I FREEDOM OF INFORMATION ACT RESPONSE FOfA NUMBEQtS):
g, g gg PART 11 B-APPLICA8tE F5tA EXEMPTtONS E
Records subsect to tre request that are described in the enclosed Appenoices are being withheld in their entirety or in part under FOIA Esemptons and for me reasons set forth below pursuant to 5 U.S.C. 552(b) and 10 CFR 9.54a) of NRC Regulations.
1
'N w*hboM information is property classafed pursuant to Executwo Order 12356 (EXEMPTION 11
- 2. The w+thbeid informoonn reistes solety to the intomal personnel rules and procedures of NRC. (EXEMPTON 2)
- 3. The wthheld information a specsficaey esernpted from putAc d sclosure by statute irk $cated: (EXEMPTON 3)
Secton 141145 of the Atome Energy Act whch proh@ts tne disclosure of Restncted Data'or Fortre*1y Restrcted Data 142 U S C. 2161-21661.
Secten 10 of the Atomic Energy Act whch proNbets the osciosure of Unclassfed Safeguards inforrnston 142 U S C. 2167).
- 4. The wtr*gid r.fo.enetion is a trade secret or ccc+vercial or feancial r.formaton that a being withbeid for the reasWs) indicated. (EXEMPTION 41 The mformation is considered to be confidentel business (propretaryl eformation.
The informatson is cons.dered to be propnetary informaton purst ent to f 0 CFR 2.790id411.
s The information was submitted and recewed in corifidence from a foreign source pursuant to 10 CFr. 2.790fdM2).
- 5. The wthheld informaton consists of interagency or intraegency records that s*e not available through decovery dureg intgation. Dectosure of predecisional information would tend to inNbet the open and frank enchange of ideas essent41 to the dehberative process. Where records are withhe6d an ther entrety, the facts are anestricably intertweed wth the predecrononal mformaton. There also are no reasonatWv segregable factual portons because the release of the facts would permet an mdwect inqury into the prodocisaonal process of the egency. (EXEMPTON $
X
- s. The withheid anformation is empted frorn putre d.csosure because.ts dsciosure wouid result m a ciearly un*arranted invas.on c personal prw.cy. IEXEMPTION 6) e X
- 7. The withheid information consets of investgatory records compded for law enforcement purposes av o bemg wthbeid for the reason (si indicated. IEXEMPTION 7)
Desclosure would interfere wth an enforcement proceedeg because et could reveal the scope, directen, and focus of enforcement efforts. and thus could possoy allow them to take acton to shieJd potential wrongdoang or a violation of NRC requeroments from evestgators (EXEMPTON 7(AH s
X Doctosure would constrtute an unwwvanted invason of personal prwacy IEXEMPTION 7tC)I The informaton consats of names of indrviduals and other informaton the desclosure of wNch would reveal identities of confideet.al sources. (EXEMPTION 7tOH PART ti.C-DENYING OFFICI ALS l
l Dursuant to 10 CFM 9 9 and Ior 916 of the U S. Nuclear Regulatory Ccrnmeson regulatons. et has been determoed that ths irdoceton wthrend e enempt from producten or deciosure, l
and that 'ts producten or declosure a contrary to the putAc interest. The persons responsible for the densat a o those omculs identafed beeow as denying offesa4 and the Director.
l Deveen of Rules and Records. Office of Admrvstraten, for any denials that may be appealed to the Enocceve Dvector 'or OperatorsigDot l
OENYlNG OFFICIAL TITLE / OFFICE RECORDS DENtEO l
APPELLATE OFFictAL Rggl Administrator -
gg-5F"'"
John B. Martin 5
7 PART 11 D-APPEAL RIGHTS The denial by each denying official identrfed in Part II.C may be appealed to the Appeltate Official identifed in that secten. Any such appeal must N in i
wr ting and must be made within 30 days of receipt of this response. Appeats must be addressed as appropriate to the Executuo Director for Operations or to I
the Secretary of the Commissson, U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission, Washington, DC 20566, and should clearty state on the ennlope and in the letter that it is en "Appeal from an inPial FOIA Decision.
8eaC Fom es4 iPen a U.S. NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION
- o*>
FOlA RESPONSE CONTINUATION
^
Re: FOIA-84-21 (15th Partial)
APPENDIX W RECORDS BEING PLACED IN PDR 1.
11/23/83 Allegation Data Form. (5 pages) 2.
11/23/83 Allegation Data Form. (2 pages) 3.
Undated A11e ation No. 87. (1 page) s 4.
Undated Allegation No. 88. (1 page) 5.
Undated Allegation No. 75. (1 page) 4 l
l l
Re: F0!A-84-21 (15th Partial)
APPENDIX X PORTIONS OF RECORDS WITHHELD EXLMPIION5 6 AND 7(C) 1.
Undated Handwritten notes. (1 page)
~
2.
Undated Handwritten notes to Denny. (5 pages) 3.
Undated Allegation No. 63. (1 page) 4.
Undated Questions.
(4 pages) 5.
3/20/83 Problems Statement with attachments.
(9 pages) 6.
4/4/83 Allegation #10, Characterization:
Seismic tilting of containment.
(1 page) 7.
4/4/83 Allegation ill, Characterization:
Classification of Platferm (Category I vs Category II).
(1 page) 8.
4/4/83 Allegation #12, Characterization:
HELBA did not meet FDAR, R. G. 1.46, (1 page) 9.
4/4/83 Allegation #14, Characterization: Loads on Annulus Structural Steel not calculated properly.
(1 page)
- 10. 4/4/83 Allegation #15, Characterization:
Inadequate Tornado load analysis of Turbine Building.
(1 page)
- 11. 4/4/83 Allegation #16, Characterization: High energy pipe break restraints inadequate.
(1 page)
- 12. 4/4/83 Allegation #17, Characterization:
(1 page)
- 13. Undated Allegation #48, Characterization:
Seismic Interaction Study.
(1 page)
- 14. Undated Allegation Data Form, re: Diablo Canyon Units 1 and 2.
(10 pages)
- 15. Undated Allegation Data Form, re: Diablo Canyon Units 1 and 2.
(8 pages)
- 16. Undated Allegation Data Form, re: Diablo Canyon Units 1 and 2.
(1 page) 17.
10/13/83 Memo to 0. C. Shackleton from T. W. Bishop, re:
Diablo Canyon Allegation-Mr. C. Nieberger of the San Luis OBISPO Telegram-Tribune Regarding Falsified Welder Qualifications.
(4 pages) 18, 10/24/83 Disposition of NCR.
(1 page)
Re: F0!A-84-21 (15th Partial)
APPENDIX X PORTIONS UF 1TCURDT WITHHELD EALMPTIUMb 6 AND 7(C)
(Continued)
- 19. Undated Allegation Data Form, re: Diablo Canyon Unit 1.
(2 pages) 20.
11/9/33 Letter to a named individual from D. F. Kirsch, re:
Allegation Tracking System No. RY-83-A-0055.
(2 pages) 21.
11/9/83 Interview Sheet.
(2 pages) 22.
11/21/83 Conversation record, Dr. H. Myers, alleger.
(6 pages) 23.
11/21/83 Conversation record, Dr. H. Myers, alleger.
(4 pages) 24.
11/21/83 Notes from Telecon (9:10 ).m.-10:55 p.m.) from Dr. H. Myers to T. W. Bisiop.
(5 pages) 25.
12/2/83 Memo to a named individual from the NRC from the Quality Control Inspector, Level II.
(1 page) 26.
12/2/83 Sumary of Special Inspector, Diablo Canyon, re:
Issue i 25, written by: John R. Fair.
(1 page) 27.
12/2/83 Sumary of Special Inspector, Diablo Canyon, re: Concerns, witten by: Edward H. Girard.
(2 pages).
28.
12/2/33 Sumary of Special Inspector, Diablo Canyon, re:
Issue J 25, written by: John R. Fair. (1 page) 4 29.
12/2/83 Sumary of Special Inspector, Diablo Canyon, re: Concerns, written by: Edward H. Girard.
(2 pages) 30.
12/2/83 Sumary of Special Inspector, Diablo Canyon, re:
Concerns, written by: Edward H. Girard.
(2 pages) 31.
12/3/83 Sumary of Special Inspector, Diablo Canyon, re: Concerns, written by: Edward H. Girard.
!2 pages) 32.
12/27/83 Document Deficiency Notice, re: Purchase Orders, with attachments.
(15 pages)
- 33. Undated Allegation Data Form, re:
Diablo Canyon Units 1 and 2.
(1 page)
- 34. There is no document numbered "34"
- 35. Undated Allegation Data Form, re:
Diablo Canyon Units 1 and 2, with attachments.
(5 pages)
i l
Re: F01A-84-21 (15th Partial)
APPENDIX X PORTIONS OF RECORD 5 WITHHELD
~ EXEMPTIONS 6 AND 7(C)
(Continued) 36.
1/2/84 Sumary of Special Inspector, Diablo Canyon, written by:
W. J. Wagner.
(1 page) 37.
1/5/84 Sumary of Special Inspector, Diablo Canyon, written by:
S. D. Reynolds, Jr.
(1 page) 38.
1/6/84 Sumary of Special Inspector, Diablo Canyon, written by:
S. D. Reynolds, Jr.
(1 page) 39.
1/6/84 Sumary of Specini Inspector, Diablo Canyon, re: QC Personnel and Plant Saftey Issues, written by:
A. B. Ruff.
(1 page) 40.
1/6/84 Sumary of Special Inspector, Diablo Canyon, re: Allegation-Inspection of 1/5 to 1/12 QC Personnel Inspector, written by A. B. Ruff.
(1 page) 41.
1/7/84 Sumary of Special Inspector, Diablo Canyon, re:
Diablo Canyon Concerns, with attachments, written by:
Edward H. Girard.
(5 pages) 42.
1/7/84 Sumary of Special Inspector, Diablo Canyon, written by:
W. J. Wagner.
(1 page) 43, 1/7/84 Sumary of Special Inspector, Diablo Canyon, written by:
W. J. Wagner.
(1 page) 44.
1/7/84 Sumary of Special Inspector, Diablo Canyon, written
'sy:
W. J. Wagner.
(1 page) 45, 1/7/84 Sumary of Special Inspector, Diablo Canyon, N:
Issue #25, written by:
John R. Fair.
(1 page) 46.
1/7/84 Sumary of Special Inspector, Diablo Canyen, re:
Issue #25, writte by: John R. Fair.
(1 page) 47.
1/7/84 Sumary of Special Inspector, Diablo Canyon, re:
Issue #25, written by:
John R. Fair.
(1 page) 48.
1/7/84 Sumary of Special Inspector, Diablo Canyon, written by:
J. Hernandez.
(1 page)
y Re:
FOIA-84-21 (15th Partial)
APPENDIX X PCRTIONS OF RECORD 5 WITHHELD EXEMPTIONS 6 AND 7(C)
(Continued) 49.
1/7/84 Sumary of Special Inspector, Diablo Canyon, re:
Issue #25, written by:
John R. Fair.
(1 page) 50.
1/9/84 Sumary of Special Inspector, Diablo Canyon, re: Gonzalo Hernandez, written by:
J. Hernandez.
(1 page) 51.
1/9/84 Sumary of Special Insp. Diablo Canyon, re: 25. (1 page) 52.
1/9/84 Sumary of Special Insp. Diablo Canyon. (3 pages) 53.
1/9/84 Sumary of Special Insp. Diablo Canyon. (1 page) 54.
1/9/84 Sumary of Special Insp., Diablo Canyon, re: Allegation Inspection of 1/5. (2 pages) 55.
1/10/84 Converration Record. (2 pages) 56.
1/10/84 Sumary of Special Insp. re: Diablo Canyon Concerns. (1 page) 57.
1/11/84 Sumsry of Special Inspections, re: Allegation Inspection. (1 page) 58.
1/12/84 Sumary of Special Insp. re: Diablo Canyon Concerns. (2 pages) 59.
1/13/84 Sumary of Special Insp. re: Diablo Canyon Concerns. (3 pages) 60.
1/13/84 Sumary of Special Insp. re: Diablo Canyon Concerns. (14 pages) 61.
1/14/84 Sumary of Special Insp., re: G. Hernandez. (1 page) 62.
1/14/84 Sumary of Special Insp., re: G. Hernandez. (1 page) 63.
1/14/84 Sumary of Special Insp., re: G. Hernandez. (1 page) 64.
1/14/84 Sumary of Special Insp.,(16 pages) 65.
1/17/84 Sumary of Special.Insp., re: Allegations Inspectica, il page)
i Re:
F0!A-84-21 (15th Partial)
APPENDIX X PORTIONS OF F.ECORU5 WITIEiELD EXEMPTIONS 6 AND 7(LT ~
~~
(Continued) 67.
1/17/84 Sumary of Special Insp. re: Allegation Insp. (1 page) 68.
1/17/84 Sumary of Special Insp. re Diabin Canyon. (1 page) 69.
1/17/84 Sumary of Special Insp. re Diablo Canyon. (1 page) 70.
1/17/84 Sumary of Special Insp. re Diablo Canyon. (3 pages) 71.
1/17/84 Sumary of Special Insp. re: Diablo Canyon Concerns. (1 page) 72.
1/17/84 Sumary of Special Insp., (1 page) 73.
1/18/84 Sumsry)of Spccial Insp., re: Allegation Investigation.
(1 page 74.
3/5/84 Froblem Statement, Allegation # 24 26. (4 pages)
- 75. 3/7/84
-Problem Statement, Allegation f 57. (3 pages) 76.
3/9/84 Problem Staternent, A11agstion No.101. (5 pages) 77.
3/12/84 Attachment No. 1. (3 peges) 78.
3/16/84 Problem Statement, Allegation # 71, '3: 183. (4 pages)
/
79.
3/21/84 Problem Statement, Allegation f 56. (2 pages)
.c
)
GQYERNMENT ACCOUNTA0luTY PROJECT Institute for Policy Studies j
1901 Que $treet N W.. Woshington. D C 20000 (202)234G2 January 9,1984 HAND-DELIVERED 9 January 1984 FREEDOM OF INFORMATN)N ACT REQUEST Director
/b gf.fo-Py Office of Administration U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Comissicn Washington, D.C.
20555 To Whor.: It May Conc?rn-Pursuact to the frfeaom of Information Act (F01 A), 5 U.S.C. $552, the Government Accountability Project (GAP) of the Institute for Policy Studies, requests copies of any and all agency records and information, including but not limited to notes, letters, memoranda, draf ts, minutes, diaries, logs, calendars, tapes, transcripts, sumaries, interview reports, procedures, instructions, engineering analyses, draw-ings, files, graphs, charts, maps, photographs, agreements, handwritten notes.
studies, data sheets, notebooks, books, telephone messages, computations, voice recordings, and any other data compilations, interim and/or final reports, status reports, and any and all other records relevant to and/or generated in connection with the Safety Evaluation Report related to the operation of the Diablo Canyon Nuclear Fower Plar% Units 1 and 2. MUREG-0675 Supplemnt No. 21 (December,1983)
("SSER 21"). This.acludes, but is not limited to, any and all NRR regulations, calculatfons, and judgments used to enluate any of the allegations referred to in SSER 21. We request that each responsive document be identif!cd by the allega-tion number (s) to which it may relate.
If any of the material covered by this request has been destroyed and/or removed, ple&se provide all surrounding documentation, including but not limited to a des-cription of the action (s) taken, relevant date(s), and justification (s) for the l
action (s).
GAP requests that fees be waived, hecause "finding ipformation can be considered as primarily benefitting the general public." 5 U.S.C. 3552(a)(4)( A).
The Government Accountability Project is t non-profit, non ' partisan public interest organization concerned with honest and open govertueent.
Through legal representation, advice.
l national conferences, films, publications and pub 1ic outreach, the Project promotes l
whistleblowers as agents of goverrament accountability. Through its Citizens Clinic, GAP offers assistance to local public interest and citizens groups who seek to ensure the health and safety of their comunities.
The citizens Clinic is currently assisting citizens groups in the California area concerning the Diablo Canyon Nuclear Power Plant.
For any documents oi portions that you deny due to a specific F0!A exemption, please provide an index itemizing and describing the documents or portions of documents withheld. The index should provide a detailed justification of your l
grounds for claiming each exemption, explaining why each exemption is relevant to the document or portion of the document withheld.
This index is required under Sf%
L Dire
- tor. of Admir.istration 2-
. January 9,1984
_,~ U.S Nu,clea Rewlatory Comission
.v.
Vaughn v. Rosen (1), 484 F.2d 820 (D.C.Cir.1973), ceet, denied, 415 U.S. 977 (1974).
We look forward to your response to this request witt.in ten days.
Very truly p urs.
Y
- y. 3 hw o
~
Billie Pirner Garde Citizens Clinic Director BPG:me i
f d
.q.
'wc, a,, -. - -
n.
c
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -