ML20147D482
| ML20147D482 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Oyster Creek, 05000000, Crane |
| Issue date: | 01/06/1988 |
| From: | Grimsley D NRC OFFICE OF ADMINISTRATION & RESOURCES MANAGEMENT (ARM) |
| To: | Weiss E UNION OF CONCERNED SCIENTISTS |
| Shared Package | |
| ML17342B416 | List: |
| References | |
| FOIA-87-696, RTR-NUREG-0588, RTR-NUREG-0737, RTR-NUREG-588, RTR-NUREG-737, RTR-REGGD-01.097, RTR-REGGD-1.097 NUDOCS 8801200182 | |
| Download: ML20147D482 (5) | |
Text
.-
U.S NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION oc so<a atovist %wetosi
,p** ** %,
U~ [# 7,obst n,E h
3, al f
f RESPONSE TO FREEDOM OF I "'"
dd*'
/
INFORMATION ACT (FOlA) REQUEST JAN 6 1988 oocait waEa si weww.a.,
REQUt$yta E _16 R. w m ie O
PART 3.-RECORDS RELE ASED OR NOT LOCATED t_See dwcaeJ bole 1 No agency records oubrect to the reque t have been located-No addstocol agency records evbrect to the request have been bcated Agency records evbrect to the roovest that are noentted in Appendia a'e airsady avadable for pubhc arspecten and cocyrt m the NRC P@6sc Docurreet Room.
1717 H $treet. N W., Washegtor., DC X
b re being made aveastde for pubhc repection a4 copyeg m the NRC Pvt. Document Agency records subpoet to the roovest that are identifed e Appenas Room,1717 H Street. N W., Wash.ngton. OC, in a fokser under the FOIA number and regwester name The nonproonetary verson of the proposaust that you ageoed to accoot e a totephone conve'saton wth a member of my staM e now torg made avalatde for putdec inspecten and coveg at the NRC Pubhc Document Room.1717 H Street. N W, Wash ngton, DC, e a fokser under the FOIA number and 'eoveeter name Enclosed 'e eformaton on how yow may obtam access to and the charges for copyeg records placed in the NRC PwN=c Docummet Room l'17 H Street. N W. Washegton OC.
Agency records subrect to the request s'e encbsed. Any apphcable Che'ge for Copaes of the reCo'ds prow and parerent procedures 50 noted m the Comments seC1ca.
SeCords subroC1 to the roQvest have been fe'e' red to another Federal agefscy(es) for review eM dwect response to you.
In vow of NRC's response to the reqwest, no further action a being taken on sOpeal letter dated PART 11 A-INFORMATION WITHMELD FROM PUSLIC DISCLOSURE Certam informaton in the roovested records e t+ng wrthheid fror. putd.c docioswes oursuant to the FOiA esemptons descreed m aM for the reasons stated e Part II. sec-tions S. C, 6nd D Any released ;ortons of the documents for which only peq of the 'ecord e teng withhe6d are being made avadatne for pwtdeC Wepecton and Copy *g O the NRC Pubhc Document Room,1717 H St'oet. N W., Wuhergton, DC, m a toloer u e ins FOtA numtee and reques'er name Comments i
Si J St. DrotCtOR, DYSOW RuttS %d atConDS t/OLML /. K(n:b l
tRCFont 8801200182 880106 is e PDR FOIA l
b8 FREEDOM OF CFORMATION ACT RESPONSE F01A NUMBEL$t [d'[M =[ 7*[#f/[,
DATE:
PAJT 11 R-APPLICABLE FOIA EXEMPTIONS Records subject to the request that are described in the eeclosed Append ces are being withheld in their entirety of in part under FOIA Enempt ons and for the reasons set forth below pursuant to 5 U.S.C 562tb) and 10 CFR 9.5tal of NRC Regulatons.
- 1. The wthheid eformaton e propedy claseded purswant to Esecutw Oroer 12X4 (EXEMPTON 11
- 2. The wthhe6d informanon rotates sole y to the enternal personnel rules ord procedures of NRC. (EXEMPTION 2) e
- 3. The wthheld ardormation e specAcacy enempted from pubesc disclosure by statute recated (DEMPTION 31 Secten 141146 of the Atom.c Ereigy Act *Nch preheets the decscowre of Restncted Data or Formerty Restncted Dats (42 U S C. 21612105).
Secten 147 of the Atoms Energy Act *Nch prohstats the decloswee of Unclasssfed Safeguards information 142 U S C. 2167).
- 4. The wthheld mformation e a trade secret or co nmoroal or fcancel eformaten that a berg ethheld for the reasordst ed cated (DEMPTON 4)
The eformata:in e consde*ed to be confdente bwseess (propretet enfoimaton.
The eformation e consdered to be propretary riormatuan pwrswant to 10 CFR 2.730(dHit The informaten was samtted and received an cor(dence from a foreign sowrce purswant to 10 CFR 2 790idH21.
- 5. The wthheld informaton consists of ariteragency or antraegency recoros that see not avadates through decovery dwrrq lat.gaten Decloswee of predece onal information wowA 'end to anhetnt the open and frere enchange of dess essent$ to the des berattve process Where records are wthhid m thea entrety, the facts s's anestncatdy intertwined wth the Dredecrsronal information There eso are no reestinstdv segregable factual portons becewee the reisese of the facts would permet ta anorect equiry into the prooects.onal process of the agency IEREMPTION 5J S. The wthheid information a esempted from pubiec dedoeu e becawse ets otscloswre would reswit e a cleady unwarra'ted anvas on of personal pr%ecy. (DEMPTION 61 r
- 7. The wthhe6d informaton conersts of investsgatory records Compled for law eeforcement pu pcess and a beir$ etrfwed for the reason (s) irecated IDEVPTION h r
_. _t e -.n.nf_._
, b._. e _ r.v._. _ d_.- f _
c._._
._s _
pcasbry ab* them t(b 134$ g(tgon to shseid potentel n'ongdoing of a vclaten of NRC roowwoments from evestgators (DEMPTON hall Declosure would constitute as unwarranted evasen of pe sonal pr%ecy lExEMPTION hCo the informaton consats of names of ind<vdwals a'd other eformaron t*e dedosu e of *Nch would ressat soonctise of contdentet sources (DEMPTON hD'l r
PART 88 C-DENYING OFFICIALS Pursuent to 10 CFR 9 9 r J,. or J 15 of the U S Nwcinar Regulatory Comme.en regulatons. n has been determined that the efor-etion *vthheed e ememos tram prtducten or doctoswee.
and that ets production e doctosure e contrary to ee putdie inte est The persons respons.bie for the o n.ai a o those cdfces ioentded below as denyrg o cases and the Drector.
w Orcason of Rules and Plecoros. Omco of Admsnetration, for any connais that may be appea6ed to the Esecwtrve Dweetor for Oreretone itDoi OENYING OFFICIAL TITLE OFFICE RECORDS DEN 410 tl APPELLATE OFFICIAL
/.)>uith)
O
- M B CYW1 0% O s Nouw
. LwC,
QOg
'n'"'"
G + 7L X
g r
i PART 11 D-APPEAL RIGHTS l
The denial by each denying official identrfied in Part li.C may te appealed to the Appenate Official identifed in that secton. Ahy such appeal must be in wrmno and must to made with n 30 dan of rece.pt of thes response. Appeals must be odoressed as approonste to the E secutive Drector for Operstaons or to the Secretary of the Commassson. U.S. Nuclear RequLatory Commsssson, Washington, DC 20565, and should cleady state on the env4 ope and in the letter that it 's an "Appeel from en Irvtual FOIA Decis on.
r asac tonne ese iPort b U S. NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION reasi FOIA RESPONSE CONTINUATION i
L
ti Re: F01A-87-696 APPENDIX B RECORDS PARTIALLY WITHHELD 1.
9/26/85 Report of Investigation, Case 1-84-021, (45 pages)
Portions deleted. Exemption 6 & 7C.
The following are exhibits to the above report:
2.
Exh. 1 Memo dated 1/24/85 from Dircks to Hayes, subject: Union of Concerned Scientists' Supplemental 2.206 Petition on TMI-1 Emergency Feedwater System.
(1 page) Released.
3.
Exh. 2 Ltr dated 5/20/83 to Denton, from Hukill w/ attachments.
(18 pages) released.
4.
Exh. 2A GPUN Licensing procedures, dated 3/1/81 (17 pages) released.
5.
Exh 2B Ltr dated 5/20/83 to Denton from Hukill w/ enclosures. (5 pages) released 6.
Exh 2C IE Bulletin No.79-01B dated 1/14/80 with attached D0R Guidelines.
(51 pages) released.
7.
Exh 3 Ltr dated 2/10/84 from Hukill to Stolz w/ attachments.
(12 pages) released. Available in PDR, Accession 8402160395.
8.
Exh 3A Various dated GPUN Project Accountability Sheets.
(43 pages) released.
9.
Exh 4 Undated Report of Interview /LaGrange. (5 pages) released.
- 10. Exh 4A Undated Report of Interview /LaGrange. (5 pages) released.
- 11. Exh 4B Letter dated 4/25/84 to Hukill from John Stoir with enclosure.
(9 pages) released. Available in PDR, Accession No. 8405160153.
- 12. Exh 4C Letter dated 5/31/84 to John Stolz from R.F. Wilson, Release.
(16 pages) A milable in PDR, Accession 8406050104.
13.
Exh 4D GPU Nuclear notes re: Meeting with NRC. Released. (8 pages)
- 14. Exh 5 Memo dated 6/25/81 from M.J. Stromberg to R.F. Wilson.
l (31 pages) Released, t
15.
Exh 5A Memo dated 6/25/81 fro.n M.J. Stromberg to R.F. Wilson.
(11 pages) Released.
- 16. Exh 5b Memo dated 8/21/81 from F.G. Maus to J. Stromberg. (20 pages) released.
Re: F01A-87-696 APPENDIX B (Contirued) 17.
Exh SC GPUN AQ Audit Procedures.
(26 pages) released.
18.
Exh 5d GPUN memo to D. Croneberger.
(3 pages) released.
19.
Exh SE GPUN memo to D. K. Croneberger, subject: Proposed corrective action to audit. Released.
(2 pages).
20.
Exh 5F Memo dated 4/4/84 to M. J. Stromberg from R. J. Guimond.
(2 pages) released.
21.
Exh SG Memo dated 5/16/84 from R. J. Guimond to R. J. Chisolm.
(12 pages) released.
- 22. Exh 6 Transcript / Wilson.
(46 pages) Released.
23.
Exh 7 Transcript /Croneberger (46 pages) Portions deleted, Ex. 6 & 7C.
24 Exh 7A GPUN EQ Procedures dated 7/1/84.
(52 pages) released.
25.
Exh 7B GPUN EQ Procedures dated 10/15/81.
(11 pages) released.
26.
Exh 7C GPUN memo dated 1/12/84. (1 page) Released.
27.
Exh 8 Transcript /Chisolm (45 pages) Portions deleted, Ex. 6 & 7C.
- 28. Exh 9 Transcript /Maus (83 pages) Portions Deleted Ex. 6 & 7C.
29.
Exh 10 Transcript /Boucher (54 pages) released.
30.
Exh 11 Transcript /Long (22 pages) released.
31.
Exh 11A Handwritten notes of Long/ Meeting with QA (1 page)
Released.
32.
Exh 12 Transcript /Kazanas (47 pages) Portions deleted Ex. 6 & 7C.
i l
l l
l
Re: F01A-87-696 APPENDIX B (Continued)
- 33. Exh 13 Transcript /Stromberg (25 cages) Portions deleted Ex. 6 & 70.
- 34. Exh 14 Transcript /Bader (48 pages) Portions deleted Ex. 6 & 7C.
- 35. Exh 15 Transcript /Magitz (42 pages) released.
- 36. Exh 16 Transcript /Guimond (49 pages) Portions deleted Ex 6 & 7C.
- 37. Exh 17 Transcript /Alatary (17 pages) Released.
38.
Exh 18 Statement, dated 4/9/85 (11 pages) Released.
39.
Exh 19 Statement, dated 4/9/85 (17 pages) Released.
40.
Exh 20 Report of Interview, Levine (1 page) Released.
41.
Exh 21 Statement / Harding, (6 pages) Released.
42.
Exh 22 Report of Interview /Smyth (1 page) Released.
43.
Exh 23 Transcript /Broughton, (10 pages) Released.
- 44. Exh 24 Transcript /Wetmore (19 pages) Released.
- 45. Exh 25 Transcript / Clark (28 pages) Released.
l 46.
Exh 25A IE-Information Notice 85-39 (2 pages) Available in the PDR Accession No. 850520059.
i l
47.
Exh 30 Region I Press Release. (1 page) Released.
48.
Exh 31 "Inside NRC' article (3 pages) Released.
49.
Exh 32 Article in "Harrisburg Patriot", (1 page) Released.
l
\\
' ' tTNION OF CONCERNED SCIENTISTS m6 e si,ei,.sw s.3io. wa.si
,,e., oC 2oo3.
<2o2, 332.o,oo October 15, 1987 FREEDOM OF INFORMATION ACT REQUEST Director, Division of Rules and Records Q[d[M -d7-d f[e Office of Administration U.S.
Nuclear Regulatory Commission y/
Washington, D.C.
20555 RE:
Freedom of,Information Act Request
Dear Director,
Pursuant to the federal Freedom of Information Act, the Union of Concerned Scientists hereby requests the following:
1.
Any report (s) done by the Office of Investigations related to the request by UCS that the NRC investigate whether GPU made l
material false statements relating to the environmental qualification of safety equipment at Three Mile Island, Unit 1.
2.
Any report (s) done by the Office of Inspection and Audit related to UCS's request for an investigation into the staff's conduct in re-iterating without review GPU's unfounded claims regarding environmental qualification.
Please note that both UCS requests for investigations were made as part of a petition filed by UCS pursuant to 10CFR 2.206, l
May 9,
1984.
Harold Denton, then Director of NRR, stated on September 25, 1984, that GPU had made "invalid" statements and that the matter had been referred to OI.
See "Director's Decision Under 10CFR 2.206, September 24, 1984, pp. 32-34."
In addition, Robert Pollard and I were interviewed by George Mulley i
of OIA in the summer of 1984 in regard to the OIA investigation of the NRC staff.
Therefore, it is clear that both investigations were at least begun.
I look forward to your response within ten days, as provided by law.
Very truly yours, s
V Ell'yn
, Weiss General Counsel
-%il10302l5
,) (
1 l
Cambridge Offlec: 26 Church Street Ctmbridhe. Sta. achusetts 02238 16th 547 5552