ML20137R624

Forwards Draft Independent Review Package & Voting Sheets of RES Independent Review Board Members.Members Voted 4 to 0 That NRC Should Proceed W/Human Uses of Byproduct Matls - Revs to 10CFR35, Sponsored by NMSS

ML20137R624
Person / Time
Issue date:	07/27/1984
From:	Bernero R NRC - RESEARCH INDEPENDENT REVIEW BOARD
To:	Minogue R NRC OFFICE OF NUCLEAR REGULATORY RESEARCH (RES)
Shared Package
ML20136D915	List: ML20136D909 ML20136E266 ML20136E272 ML20136E278 ML20136E295 ML20136E318 ML20136E323 ML20136E492 ML20136E705 ML20136E879 ML20136F099 ML20136F109 ML20136F154 ML20137Q526 ML20137Q531 ML20137Q538 ML20137Q545 ML20137Q557 ML20137Q566 ML20137Q572 ML20137Q579 ML20137Q585 ML20137Q596 ML20137Q605 ML20137Q644 ML20137Q655 ML20137Q660 ML20137Q671 ML20137Q682 ML20137Q688 ML20137Q690 ML20137Q692 ML20137Q695 ML20137Q697 ML20137Q705 ML20137Q710 ML20137Q715 ML20137Q719 ML20137Q721 ML20137Q724 ML20137Q726 ML20137Q734 ML20137Q742 ML20137Q747 ML20137Q760 ML20137Q766 ML20137Q777 ML20137Q783 ML20137Q791 ML20137Q796 ... further results
References
FRN-50FR30616, RULE-PR-35 AA73-1, NUDOCS 8509230596
Download: ML20137R624 (2)

Text

. _ _ . . . _ _ . . . ._ . . . __

R - 2 Tl4.

l l

l JUL 2 7 B64 MEMORANDlM FOR: Robert B. Minogue Director Office of Nuclear Regulatory Research J

FRCH: Robert M. Bernero Chairinan RES Independent Review Board

SUBJECT:

MINUTES OF RIRB DELIBERATIONS FOR OMOING RULEMAKING SPONSORED bf NHSS i The rulemaking review package received June 1, 1984 (Mail Control j RES-841230A), states:

...the Office of Nuclear Material Safety and Safeguards

has reviewed the on-going rulemaking activities listed i below. On the basis of our review, we recormend the l approval of continued activity on these rules."

Enclosed is the draft independent review package as prepared by responsible

RES staff and considered by the RES Independent Review Board.

Also enclosed are the voting sheets of the RIRS rmbers that reflect their deliberations. As indicated, the RIRB members voted 4 to O that t

the kRC should proceed with " Human Uses of Byproduct Material - Revisions to 10 CFR Part 35." sponsored by MSS. By their concurrence in these sinutes, the RIRB members reconstend that the RES independent recocinendation read, as proposed by one RIRB megaber, as follows:

Although RES agrees that MRC should proceed with this ongoing ruismaking, the Consission paper and supporting documents such as the regulatory anelysis should be modified to state that this consolidation of widely dispersed requirements will result in a greater degree of safety along with cost savings by not requiring a license amendment every time a procedure is changed. The Coonission paper, as now written, would indicate that there is little incentive for continuing on with this rulemaking since it states on page 9 of the Cossetssion paper that the effect of

! e509230596 040727 PDR

$$"50N30616 ee rst:>

m, ..>

cu,>

1 1

JUL 17 B64 )

selecting the reconnended alternative would be that the staff does not expect any change in worker or public dose or signiff-cant cost or savings.

Robert M. Bernero, Chairman RES Independent Review Board

Enclosures:

1. Draft independent review package for

"}kanan Uses of Byproduct Material-Revisions to 10 CFR Part 35"

2. Voting sheets of RIRB merabers Distribution RAMitB/r/ f RES Cent. File Cnron/ Circ

.aao N GArlotto KGoller 0Bassett RBernero

...) .-

cenicep IRS, RB FAMRBlitRA0 RIRB M RIRB kR 'l , Qhmn h[;R}RS,

..J ... ..... 'h ...... iff... . "?{? ... .....

""> !!!7484.....?!..lB4......  ?!l .984. . . . . . . milM . . . . . . 1wtte4. . . . . ut.Ste4. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

_