ML20135E309
| ML20135E309 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Brunswick  |
| Issue date: | 10/31/1996 |
| From: | CAROLINA POWER & LIGHT CO. |
| To: | |
| Shared Package | |
| ML20135E306 | List: |
| References | |
| ESR-96-00160, ESR-96-00160-R00, ESR-96-160, ESR-96-160-R, NUDOCS 9612110152 | |
| Download: ML20135E309 (59) | |
Text
.. -
e
/) AGE / ep 19 ESR 96-00160, REVISION 0 i
^
ENGINEERING EVALUATION B111R1 CORE SHROUD INSPECTIONS NSSS - REACTOR SYSTEMS BRUNSWICK ENGINEERING SUPPORT SECTION NUCLEAR ENGINEERING DEPARTMENT CAROLINA POWER AND LIGHT COMPANY OCTOBER 1996 i
SAFETY RELATED DR A
O 25 P
Cirolins Pow:r & Light Comp:ny ESR 96-00160 Brunswick Nuclear Plant - Unit 1 Revision 0 Engineering Evaluation Page 2 of 19 List of Effective Pages Page Number Revision 1
0 2
0 3
0 4
0 5
0 6
0 t
7 0
8 0
i 9
0 i
10 0
i
~
{
11 0
12 0
13 0
14 0
15 0
16 0
17 0
18 0
19 0
F I
C rolin2 Powir & Ught Comp:ny Brunswick Nuclear Plant - Unit 1 ESR 96-00160 Engineering Evaluation Revision O l
Page 3 of 19 l
t Table of Contents Page No.
ESR Cover Sheets (2)
Evalu ation Cove r Pa g e..........................................
1 List of Effective Pages
..........................................2 l
Table of Contents l
.............................................3 l
1.0 PURPOSE l
..............................................4
?
2.0 C O N C LU SI O N S........................................... 4
3.0 BACKGROUND
........................................... 4 4.0 FUNCTIONAL REQUIREMENTS................................ 5 5.0 DESIGN BASIS / INPUTS - REFERENCES........................... 6 6.0 INSPECTION
SUMMARY
....................................8 7.0 STRUCTURAL EVALUATION
SUMMARY
........................10 8.0 SHROUD FLUENCE
SUMMARY
17 9.0 SAFETY A N A LYSI S.......................................
18 Tables Table 6.1 - B111 R1 Shroud Inspection Summary........................ 8 Table 7.2 - Safety Factors at End of Fuel Cycle 11 (600 days)..............
14 Table 7.3 - Safety Factors at End of Evaluation Period 14 Table 7.4 - Evaluation Summary - Shroud Circumferential Welds.............
15 Fiaures 1
B111 R1 Shroud Evaluation Flow Chart..........................
11 Attachments A
Letter from Carolina Power and Light Company to the U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission "Submittalof Unit 1 Core Shroud Reinspection Plans" dated July 5,1996 Serial:BSEP 96-0245
........................7pages B
Analysis Outputs 31 pages l
C Shroud Horizontal Weld Stresses..........................
3 pages
)
C:rolina Pow;r & Light Comp:ny ESR 96-00160 Brunswick Nuclear Plant - Unit 1 Revision 0 Engineering Evaluation i
Page 4 of 19 j
l l
1.0 PURPOSE This ESR Evaluation is required as part of Carolina Power and Light Company's commitment to USNRC Generic Letter 94-03 "Intergranular Stress Corrosion Cracking of Core Shrouds in Boiling WaterReactors". As such, this evaluation provides the following:
Documentation of the engineering evaluation performed on the Core Shroud during B111R1.
A basis for the continued use of the BNP1 Core Shroud for at least one additional operating cycle, in the as-found condition, without any operational changes or restrictions. This is accomplished by a rev,'ew of the core shroud structural capacity to the criteria established by the BWRVIP (references 5.6, 5.'7) and approved by the 5
Nuclear Regulatory Commission (reference 5.11).
l A basis for the determination of future shroud inspections.
2.0 CONCLUSION
S i
BNP1 shroud can safely operate in the present condition for a minimum of one e
additional fuel cycle with full FSAR safety margins, without any operational changes or restrictions.
All reported cracking is typical IGSCC located in the heat affected zones of the welds.
3.0 BACKGROUND
in October,1990, RICSIL 054 reported cracking near the circumferential seam weld at the core beltline area of the shroud in a GE BWRl4 located outside the United States. Based on recommendations contained in RICSIL 054, the Unit 1 shroud was inspected in July, 1993, and a near SCO circumferential crack was confirmed on the inside diameter of the Top Guide Support Ring, at the H2 and H3 welds. Welds H2 and H3 were permanently repaired by the installation of a series of clamps about the outside circumference of the shroud. Engineering evaluation EER 93-0536 (reference 5.4) was issued to assess Unit 1 shroud structural integrity.
l l
The BNP1 shroud was re-inspected during the B110R1 refueling outage in the spring of 1995. Engineering evaluation ESR 95-00765 documents the shroud inspection results. This ESR concludes that structuralintegrity of the core shroud will be maintained with full FSAR
C:rolina Pow:r & Light Comp 1ny ESR 96-00160 Brunswick Nuclear Plant - Unit 1 Revision O Engineering Evaluation Page 5 of 19 safety margins for at least the next two fuel cycles and that crack growth during cycle 9 was substantially less than postulated by previous analysis.
l Based on the previous BNP shroud inspections for Units 1 and 2, BWR industry inspection experience, BWRVIP and NRC recommendations and improved inspection tooling, the B111R1 shroud inspection plan was developed and submitted to the NRC on July 5,1996.
The B111R1 shroud inspection plan is included in this report as Attachment A.
l 4.0 FUNCTIONAL REQUIREMENTS l
Details concerning the shroud design, fabrication and functional requirements can be found in reference 5.4. This ESR concludes that the shroud is structurally acceptable to support the follen ng safety design basis functional requirements:
l a) Provide a floodable volume in which the core can be adequately cooled in the event of a breach in the nuclear system process barrier external to the reactor vessel.
l b) Limit deflections and deformations of the reactor vesselinternals to assure that the control rods and the core standby cooling systems can perform their safety functions l
during abnormal operational transients and accidents.
l c) Assure that the safety design -ases (a) and (b) above are satisfied so that the safe shutdown of the plant and removal of decay heat are not impaired.
l l
l i
l r
- a a
g i
C:rolins Pow;r & Light Comptny ESR 96-00160 Brunswick Nuclear Plant - Unit 1 Revision O Engineering Evaluation Page 6 of 19 5.0 DESIGN BASIS / INPUTS - REFERENCES 5.1 U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Generic Letter, GL 94-03 "/ntergranu/ar Stress Corrosion Cracking of Core Shrouds in Boiling Water Reactors" dated July 25,1994 5.2 U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Letter to Mr. R. A. Anderson of Carolina Power and Light Company dated January 3,1995 " Generic Letter 94-03, /ntergranu/ar Stress Corrosion Cracking of Core Shrouds in Boiling Water Reactors, Brunswick Steam Electric P/ ant, Units 1 and 2 (TAC NOS. M90084 and M90085)" including
\\ " Safety Evaluation for Unit 1" and Enclosure 2 " Safety Evaluation for Unit 2" 5.3 Engineering Evaluation Report, EER 94-0077, " Evaluation of Unit 2 Core Shroud Indications and Operability Assessment." Revision 0 dated 06/04/94 5.4 Engineering Evaluation Report, EER 93-0536, " Evaluation of Unit 1 Core Shroud Indications and Operability Assessment of Unit 1 and 2" Revision 2 dated 03/13/94 5.5 Engineering Service Request, ESR 95-00765, " Unit 1 Core Shroud Reinspection Eva/uation" Revision 2 dated 06/20/95 5.6 GE Nuclear Energy document GE-NE-523-113-0894, "BWR Core Shroudinspection and Flaw Evaluation Guidelines" Revision 1 dated March 1995 5.7 GE Nuclear Energy document GE-NE-523-113-0894 Supplement 1, "BWR Core Shroud Distributed Ligament Length Computer Program" dated September 1994 5.8 BWRVIP Inspection Committee document " Reactor Pressure VesselandInternals -
Examination Guidelines (BWRVIP-03)"TR-105696 dated October 1995 5.9 Structural Integrity Associates document RAM-94-092/ SIR-94-029, " Addendum to the Brunswick Unit 1 Screening Criteria", dated April 6,1994.
5.10 CP&L Brunswick Nuclear Plant - Plant Operating Manual - Volume X - Period Test -
OPT-90.1, "/n-Vessel Visua/ Examinations", Rev 17, dated 10/03/96 5.11 U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Letter to Mr. J.T. Beckham, Chairman BWRVIP, dated June 16,1995 " Evaluation of BWR Core Shroud Inspection and Evaluation Guidelines, GENE-523-113-0894 Revision 1, dated March 1995, and BWRVIP Core Shroud NDE Uncertainty & Procedure Standard, dated November 22,1994" 5.12 GE Document GENE-B13-00715-1 Revision 0 " Brunswick Nuc/ ear P/ ant - Unit 1 -
Shroud Examination Plan" September 1996 1
5.13 Supplement 1 Report to OPT-90.1 - GE BNP B111R1 Inspection Summary dated October 1996 l
l
U t
C:rolins Pow;r & Light Comp 1ny ESR 96-00160 Brunswick Nuclear Plant - Unit 1 Engineering Evaluation Revision O Page 7 of 19 5.14 Engineering Service Request, ESR 96-00154, " Unit 2 Core Shroud Reinspection Evaluation" Revision 0 dated 03/08/96 5.15 Drawing FP-50096 Sheet 1 of 2 " Core Structure Assy & FinalMachine - Shroud &
Shroud Top" Revision 2 l
I
Ccrolina Pow:r & Light Cornpsny ESR 96-00160 Brunswick Nuclear Plant - Unit 1 Revision 0 Engineering Evaluation Page 8 of 19 6.0 INSPECTION
SUMMARY
A copy of the CP&L B111R1 shroud inspection plan which was submitted to the U.S.
Nuclear Regulatory Commission is included in this report as Attachment A. Table 6.1 provides the B111R1 shroud inspection summary. See reference 5.12 for the weld specific scan plan and reference 5.13 for the GE examination summary sheets.
ible 6.1 - y111R1 S
% of Wald
% of Examined ID Method Examined Flawed For the upper weld examination,18.8% represents 100% of the accessible area. Access is limited due to the lugs and core spray downcomer piping. For the 18.8 Upper 98.2 upper portion of the weld, thirty-eight (38) indications H1 Ultrasonic were reported, ranging in length from 0.99" to 4.00" 79.8 Lower 12.0 and ranging in depth from 0.32" to 0.66". For the lower portion of the weld, seventeen (17) indications were reported, ranging in length from 2.00" to 6.53" and ranging in depth from 0.18" to 0.67".
1
"*P*
II "
Shroud weld H2 has been permanently repaired by H2 n/a n/a performed the addition of bolted clamps during B109R1.
l No inspection Shroud weld H3 has been permanent!v repaired by performed the addition of bolted clamps during B109R1.
Examined length represents 100% of accessible area. Ten (10) indications were reported, ranging in H4 Ultrasonic 77.6 8.1 length from 2.00" to 8.01" and ranging in depth from 0.10" to 0.62".
+-
Examined length represents 100% of accessible area. Twenty-one (21) indications were reported H5 Ultrasonic 76.8 25.0 ranging in length from 2.00" to 22.46" and ranging in depth from 0.10" to 0.20".
Examined length represents 100% of accessible area. Eight (8) indications were reported ranging in H6a Ultrasonic 76.6 3.8 length from 1.98" to 4.97" and ranging in depth from 0.10" to 0.35".
)
Examined length represents 100% of accessible area.
e n
adons were repoM ranging in H6b Ultrasonic 77.8 8.9 length from 1.98" to 6.94" and ranging in depth from 0.19" to 0.52".
Carolino Power & LigM Company ESR 96-00160 Brunswick Nuc/ ear P/ ant - Unit 1 Revision 0 Engineering Evaluation Page 9 of 19 d
ed l
Examined length represents 100% of accessible area.
l Two (2) indication were reported ranging in length H7 Ultrasonic 76.8 1.6 f
91" to 4.78" and ranging in depth from 0.10" to 0.37".
Examined due to recent industry cracking reported in the HAZ between the access hole cover welds and H8 Visual 22.2 0
shroud weld H8. An EVT-1 of these areas was performed with no indications reported.
"'P*
H9 n/a n/a inspected during B110R1 Shroud "P"
Sup rt n/a n/a BWRVIP developing inspection tools / techniques.
VT-1 Clamps n/a n/a 3 clamps inspected, no anomalies reported.
VT-3
Cuolina Power & Light Comprny ESR 96-00160
)
Brunswick Nuclear Plant - Unit 1 Revision O i
Engineering Evaluation Page 10 of 19 7.0 STRUCTURAL EVALUATION
SUMMARY
Core Shroud Evaluation Conservatisms Assumed aH areas uninspected are fuHy cracked through-waH and no credit was taken in analysis for these areas. (H1-lower,H4,HS,H6a,H6b)
Used 5x 10r' in/hr crack gro wth rate in lieu of measured or predicted BNP crack growth e
rates. (AH welds)
Assumed au reported flaws were through-waH. (H1-lower,H4,HS,H6a,H6b,H7) e l
UT consistently oversized the reported length on all flaws. (AH welds) e Applied UTuncertainty for depth on aH flaws where specific depth limit load analysis e
was run. (H1-upper) l Grew crack lengths (at both tips) for 3 cycles to take credit for 1 additional cycle of e
operation. Used 2000 days. Actualplannedis 534 days of operation for fuelcycle 11, and 632 days for fuel cycle 12 and 705 days for fuel cycle 13 for a total of 1871 days. Also assumed a 100% capacity factor.(H1-lower,H4,H5,H6a,H6b,H7)
Safety Factors The analyses contained in this engineering evaluation used safety factors consistent with BSEP Updated FSAR Section 3.9.5.2.1. For loadings during nornial operation (Level A) and i
upset (Level B) conditions, a factor of safety of 2.25 was used. For emergency (Level C) conditions, a factor of safety of 1.50 was used. For faulted (Level D) conditions, a factor of safety of 1.125 was used.
Shroud Horizontal Weld Stresses Primary membrane (Pb) stresses have been updated to accommodate the increased pressure differentials associated with power uprate. See Attachrr.ent C.
1
.a Czrolins Pow:t & Light Company ESR 96-00160 Brunswick Nuclezr PI:nt - Unit 1 Revision O Engineering Evaluation Page 11 of 19 B111R1 Shroud Weld Evaluation Flow Chart 1
l Evaluate Known Acc.esimmty Limitations at Each Weld.
1r inspect 100% of Access 8ble Areas with Scanner Wolds H1, H4, H5, HSa, Heb. HT.
l tman amessvied?
Y**
No 1r 1r W
,, y,;;,,,,
H1.
.we,,
eeds
.,t4., HSm. HS..
1r Chualify by DLL Limit Load Analys8s (Use olther Full or Partial Thickness Ligaments).
1 gr Structural Integrity Established (M1, H4,H 5, Hea, Heb, H T).
Mr Moquired Inspections Complet e.
Mr Prepare Engineering i
Evaluation Report.
t s
4 Figure 1
l
('
Czrolins Pow:r & Light Comp 1ny ESR 96-00160 Brunswick Nucl:zr PI:nt - Unit 1 Revision O Engineering Evaluation Page 12 of 19 l
Full Thickness Llaament Evaluation Methodoloav (Welds H1-Lower. H4. H5, H6a, H6b, H7)
Step 1 - Collect Information The full thickness ligament data was extracted from the verified inspection summary sheets and input into a Lotus 123 spreadsheet. All uninspected regions as well as partial thickness ligaments were assumed fully cracked. The following spreadsheet variables were also input for each weld location evaluated:
Variable Comment l
"""Y Shroud thickness (tn) 1.25" (H7 see Note 6 to Table 7.4) 189.5"; H1 Shroud outside diameter 177.5"; H4, H5, H6a, H6b 171.0"; H7 Crack Growth Rate 5x104 in/hr Reference 5.8.
Se spreadsheets (Attachment B) and/or Shroud Total inspection Uncertainty Weld Evaluation Summary (Table 6.4) for specific values used.
00 Used 3 fuel cycles of crack growth Lcalc (for Normal / Upset and Faulted)
Reference 5.9. See Attachment B spreadsheet outputs for values From this information, the spreadsheet calculated the weld L,n,n value, the total full thickness ligament length at the end of the evaluation period and the full thickness ligament starting and stopping azimuths. Crack growth, inspection uncertainty and crack proximity were considered in the determination of the end of evaluation period full thickness ligament length.
Step 2 - Determine if Limit Load Analysis Required The total full thickness ligament length at the end of the evaluation period (L,,,) was compared to L,n.n. If L,,, was greater than Lon, then the weld was considered structurally qualified for continued service for a minimum of one fuel cycle. If L,,, was less than Lon, then a detailed limit load analysis using the DLL computer program (reference 5.7) was performed. Note: A limit load analysis was performed for all welds in order to determine the reported safety factors.
l l
Step 3 - Perform DLL analysis i
End of evaluation period full thickness ligament data was input into the DLL computer program along with other required variables. See the DLL computer run outputs contained
a C:rolin2 Power & Light Comp 1ny ESR 96-00160 Brunswick Nuclear Plant - Unit 1 Revision O l
Engineering Evaluation Page 13 of 19 in Attachment B.
l Step 4 - Determine if Weld Structurally Qualified If the required ASME safety margins were met, the weld was considered structurally qualified for continued service for a minimum of one fuel cycle. If a weld could not be structurally qualified by the full thickness ligament length method for the specified minimum evaluation period, then the partial thickness ligament analysis method was used.
Partial Thickness Liaament Evaluation Methodoloav (Weld H1-Uope_d Step 1 - Collect Information The partial thickness ligament depth data was extracted from the verified GE inspection summary sheets and input into a Lotus 123 spreadsheet. All uninspected regions were assumed cracked to a depth equal to the average (0.44") of the maximum depths reported for each indication. The spreadsheet calculated the new ligament thickness at the end of the evaluation period (600 days). Crack growth (5x10 ) and inspection uncertainty 4
(0.106") were considered in the determination of the end of evaluation period ligament depth.
Step 2 - Perform DLL analysis End of evaluation period partial thickness ligament depth data was input into the DLL computer program along with the other required variables. See the DLL computer run output for weld H1-Upper.
Step 3 - Determine if Weld Structurally Qualified if the required safety margins were met, the weld was considered structurally qualified for continued service for one fuel cycle.
l l
C.trolins Power & Light Comprny ESR 96-00160 Brunswick Nuclest PI:nt - Unit 1 Revision 0 Engineering Evaluation Page 14 of 19 Shroud Circumferential Weld Structural Evaluation - Safety Factors 3
Table 7.2 - Safety l' actors at End of Fuel Cycle 11 (600 days)
Normal / Upset Emergency Faulted Calculated UFSAR.
Calculated l UFSAR ^ :
WeldID
' Safety ;
Safety l Safety Safety ~
Calculated UFSAR Safety Safety Factor i Factor !
Factor Factor Factor.
Factor.
I
~"#
13.82 2.25 7.30 1.50 7.19 1.125 1
39.27 2.25 25.17 1.50 24.10 1.125 40.10 2.25 27.06 1.50 25.50 1.125 31.40 2.25 21.50 1.50 19,73 1.125 L_
1 Table 7.3 - Safety Factors at End of Evaluation Period
.. _. - - _ - _ _ _.. Normal / Upset Emergency Faulted Calculated '
UFSAR '
Calculated UFSAR Calculated ;
- Safety Safety Safety Safety Safety l Safety Factor Factor Factor Factor Factor-Factor 13.82 2.25 7.30 1.50 7.19 1.125 13.05 2.25 7.69 1.50 7.50 1.125 i
11.78 2.25 7.55 1.50 7.23 1.125 12.89 2.25 8.59 1.50 8.15 1.125 12.03 2.25 8.12 1.50 7.65 1.125 1
- 7 j
9.42 2.25 6.45 1.50 5.92 1.125
9 I
Csrolina Pow:r & Light Comp:ny ESR 96-00160 Brunswick Nucle:r Plant - Unit 1 Revision 0 Engineering Evaluation Page 15 of 19 Table 7.4 - Evaluation Summary - Shroud Ci~ cumferential Welds r
Wold Evoluedon Evoluedon ID Percentage"8
^
Method un)
(ders)
Acceptable for continued operation l
l Weld H1 is not a safety significant weld i
O.106 Limit Load i
18.8 U 600 No credit taken for fillet weld (depth)
Analysis
- Partial ligaments analyzed (upper) r
. H1 0.0 Lmin
79.8 L 2000 Acceptable for continued operation (length)
Satisfied Uninspected regions assumed fully cracked l All cracks assumed through-wall (lower)
{
O.0 Lmin",,
Acceptable for continued operation H4' 77.6 2000 Uninspected regions assumed fully cracked (length)
Satisfied All cracks assumed through-wall l
Acceptable for continued operation Uninspected regions assumed fully cracked l i
(length)
Satisfied All cracks assumed through-wall 7
-Acceptable for continued operation
.H6a 76.6 2000 Uninspected regions assumed fully cracked I Satisfied All cracks assumed through-wall O.0 Lmin',,
eptable for continued operation j
H6b 77.8 2000 Uninspected regions assumed fully cracked (length)
Satisfied All cracks assumed through-wall 0.0 Lmin'*",,
Acceptable for continued operation H7 76.8 2000 Uninspected regions assumed fully cracked (length)
Satisfied l.
All cracks assumed through-wall H8 Since no indications were reported for weld H8, no analysis was performed. l Notes to Tables 7.4 (1) Evaluation Percentage = The percentage of total weld circumference on which the structural evaluation is based. Remaining percentage is assumed fully cracked.
(2) Inspection uncertainty from reference 5.8 (Scan Type 2a, UT Demonstration 16 for l
I welds H1 to H6b and UT Demonstration 5 for weld H7).
(3) Circumferential shroud weld H1-upper was analyzed using partial ligament thickness.
Measured thickness data was reduced to account for growth and uncertainty. The crack growth calculation used a run time of 600 days (1 fuel cycle). Actual projected length for fuel cycle 11 is 534 days. All uninspected regions were assumed cracked
l Carolin) Pow:r & Light Comp:ny ESR 96-00160 Brunswick Nuclear Plant - Unit 1 Revision O Engineering Evaluation Page 16 of 19 to a starting depth of 0.44" which is the average depth of the maximum depths reported for each indication.
e l
(4)
L,,,, = Minimum required ligament length for limit load single ligament analysis + (2 i
x Crack Growth for Evaluation Period) + Inspection Uncertainty. Since L, at the end of the evaluation period is satisfied ( L,,, > L%n) a detailed limit load analysis is not required to show structural acceptance. A limit load analysis was performed for these i
welds in order to determine the safety factors used in this report.
(5) Uncracked ligaments contained within the high flux zones were assumed fully cracked for the analysis since it is projected that the LEFM fluence threshold level (see Section 8.0) for weld H4 will be reached within the 2000 day evaluation period. Current projection is 11/04/98 which is during fuel cycle 12. Weld H4 will not reach the LEFM fluence threshold during the next operating cycle.
(6) The UT inspection of weld H7 included 100% of the accessible area about the circumference. Access to areas below the weld were limited due to shroud configuration and tooling limitations. Far side results for the scan reported no indications in this lower region. Weld H7 was visually inspected on the outside surface during B109R1 with no indications reported. Results from this inspection (B111R1) identified 2 indications on the upper side (near) of the weld. For analytical purposes, the shroud thickness at this location (1.5") was reduced by 0.25" (1.25") owing to the limitations associated with far side flaw detection as given in reference 5.8. This 0.25" was not assumed to be a flaw for the following:
Very little cracking was identified in H7. Only 2 indications were noted, both on the ID near side.
BNP operates with hydrogen water chemistry (HWC). Weld H7 is located in the lower portion of the vessel which will see the most bcnefit from hydrogen injection (Iow ECP).
Weld H7 has very little fluence sensitization.
The shroud manway access covers had no reportable indications. The shroud manway access cover is more constrained that the H7 weld and has higher residual stress. Additionally, the welds for the covers are ground, creviced and use the same welding process as the H7 '. veld. The shroud manway access cover welds are therefore a conservative comparison for the H7 weld.
l h
\\
l Cirolins Pow:r & Light Compzny ESR 96-00160 Brunswick Nuclear Plant - Unit 1 Revision 0 l
Engineering Evaluation i
Page 17 of 19 l
8.0 SHROUD FLUENCE
SUMMARY
j l
Based on current industry evaluation guidelines, in order to ensure structuralintegrity, a linear elastic fracture mechanics analysis (LEFM) must be performed when the total neutron fluence accumulation at any shroud circumferential weld reaches 3x10 n/cm, E> 1MeV.
2 2
No BNP1 shroud weld is expected to reach the fluence threshold level (3x10 o n/cm,
2 E> 1MeV) for LEFM analysis during the next fuel cycle. The only welds expected to reach this threshold level during the current operating license of BNP1 are H4 and H5. The following table gives the projected neutron fluence levels for each shroud weld at the end of the next fuel cycle (600 days). These projections are based on the flux data from reference 5.4.
Neutron Fluence (n/cm')
End of Fuel Cycle 11 l
H1 1.3E + 18 l
H4 2.9E + 20 l
H5 1.6E + 20 l
H6a 9.3E + 18 l
H6b 8.8E + 18 l
H7 1.3E + 18 Notes:
(1) Flux rates taken at weld ID.
(2) Weld H4 is currently projected to reach the LEFM fluence threshold level during fuel cycle 12.
l l
l
Carolina Power & Light Company ESR 96-00160
)
Brunswick Nuclear Plant - Unit 1 Revision O i
Engineering Evaluation Page 18 Of 19
}
}
9.0 SAFETY ANALYSIS ATTACHMENT B Guideline for 10 CFR 50.59 Safety Evaluations ATTACHMENT 1 10 CFR 50.59 Safety Evaluation Screen
)
ACTMTY NO.
REV.
1.
DOES THE ACTIVITY REQUIRE A CHANGE TO THE OPERATING LICENSE OR TECHNICAL SPECIPICATION?
[ ] YES [ v I NO Seele: ESR 9600100is en engmeanng evolustion report which docuenents the structurel eushfication of the Unst 1 Core Shroud bened on 1
)
the NDE inspections performed dunne the 8111R1 outage. All UFSAR esfoty factore for the Core Shroud well be met for the next j
operating cycle. No physical plant modifications or operational restrictions are roeuwed as e result of this ESR. Therefore, this ESR does not require e change to the opersteng hcense or techrucal specificapon.
Nees: N Yes, and the sempe of the soeuhy la Indeed to e Techmcel Spee4Rcetion/ Operating Licensing change, then eenuptete Section #6 of this tenn, and pseemme per pient messess. N the esene of the eethey is not ensied to a Tech. Spec. er OL change, in edeelen to pressessig a Tech. Spec, or OL change roguest, continue the sessening proceso if No, sentinue the essmening ------
2.
IS THE ACTIVITY fjlM SOUNDED BY A PREVIOUSLY PERFORRAED 10 CPR 50.59 SAFETY EVALUATION 7 l V l YES ( l NO Evatuomen No. The most recent 10CFR 60.59 Safety Evolusoon as conteined in EER 940077. The previous plant specific evoluscone were referenced to one fuel cycle. The conclueene from ESR 96-00100 show that the reeuwed UFSAR eafety mergens are meantomed for et leest one additionel fuel cycle (cycle 11). Therefore the previous esfoty evoluetone are considered boundmg. Addetsonsuy, a genene oefety assessment of shroud weld failures was provided by the BWROG in 1994
- SWR Shroust CrocHeg Genen'c Sehrty Assessment *. GEntr 52SA107P.o7N, lievision 1, August 19N. A ENP plent specefic sesseement was provided in response to Genenc Letter 94-03.
BIsta: N Yes, enmeh e sepy or psevide closument nundser for socieval espebibly of the provisuely perforenad 10 CPR 50.59 Safety Evolunden and con > Session 8 of this form. If lee, sentinue the sessening process 3.
DOES THE ACTIVITY RAAKE CHA80GES TO THE FACILITY AS DESCRIBED les THE SAR?
[ ] YES ( 1 810 Semis:
List SAR home/Sectione sowiewed 4.
DOES THE ACTIVITY 9AAKE CHAffGES TO PflOCEDURES AS DESC8MBED led THE SAR?
I ] YES ( lNO basis:
List SAR home/ Sections sowiewed:
5.
DOES THE ACTIVITY INVOLVE A TEST OR EXPEfueAENT NOT DESCfMBED IN THE SAR?
l lYES ( 1980 Ameis:
List SAR leesns/t y anno reviewed:
M:
NOTE:If any erWen 3 through S le enewsred YES, then mort Secean #8 Not Me (N/A) and complete Unsoviewed Safety Question Deter. t4 tion, otherwise complete Section FS.
S.
OtSCIPLINE PfuNT NAME 1st OSR:
Structuref
/
John W. Vose Jr i
Vh DV Date: 10/36/96 Other OSR:
I f
Date:
Other OSR:
/
/
Date:
4 i
2nd OSR:
Min n.n ar.au
/Che.innemeeM, MD Date:
!ON@
Attach odetional sheets if needed.
)
OAl-109 Rev.5
_m i
I' Ctrolina Pow:r & Light Comp;ny i
ESR 96-00160 Brunswick Nuclear Plant - Unit 1 Revision O Engineering Evaluation Page 19 of 19 ATTACHMENT C 1st osR: Structural-John W. Voss,Jr.
Oa Date: M / 7t9 N (p lem 18SSification Form 2nd oSR: Mechanical Christopher Maliner Date: 10 M.
DOCUMENT NO.
ESR 96-00160 REV.NO.
O YES NO 1.
Does this item (including temporary changes to the facility or procedures as
[]
[XI described in the UFSAR) require a revision to the U.FSAR? (See Section 5.0 of OAl-109 for instruction).
i 2.
Does this item involve a change to the Off Site Dose Calculation Manual? (if yes, see Section 5.0 of OAl-109 for instruction.)
[]
[X]
r 3.
Does this item constitute a change to the Process Control Program? (if yes, see Section 5.0 of OAl-109 for instruction.)
[]
[X) 4.
Does this item involve a major change to a Radwaste Treatment System? (If yes, see Section 5.0 of OAl-109 for instruction.)
[]
[X]
5.
Does this item involve a change to the Technical Specification Equipment List? (If yes, process the change in accordance with ORCl-02.6. For further
[]
[XI instruction see Section 5.0 of OAl-109.)
6.
Does this item impact the NPDES Permit or a "significant environmental impact"? (Use the guidance contained in Attachment A to make this
[]
[X) determination. If yes, see Section 5.0 of OAl-109 for instruction.)
l 7.
Does this item involve a change to a previously accepted:
a.
Quality Assurance Program
[]
[X]
l b.
Security Plan (including Training, Qualification, and Contingency Plans)?
[]
[X) c.
[]
[X]
l (If yes, see Section 5.0 of OAl-109 for instruction and complete a 10 CFR 50.54 evaluation using Attachment D.)
8.
Does the item involve a change to the following Fire Protection Program Documents: OPLP-01; OPLP-01.1; OPLP-01.2; or OPLP-01.5?
[]
[X)
(if yes, see Section 5.0 of OAl-109 for instruction.)
l
References:
Identify specific references used for any "Yes" answer.
(
l OAl-109 Rev.5
i i
j ESR 96-00160, RIvi:izn 0, Att2 chm::nt A AI o F A7 CP&L i
l Carolina Power & Light Company William R. Campbell PO Box 10429 Yece President l
Southport NC 28461 0429 Brunswick Nuclear Plant i
j i
l SERIAL,: BSEP 96-0245 i
JUL 51996 U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission ATTN: Document Control Desk Washington, DC 20555 BRUNSWICK STEAM ELECTRIC PLANT, UNIT NO.1 DOCKET NO 50-325 LICENSE NO. DPR-71 SUBMi1TAL OF UNIT 1 CORE SHROUD REINSPECTION PLANS Gentlemen:
The purpose of this letteris to provide to the Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) the plans for reinspection of the core shroud for the Brunswick Steam Electric Plant (BSEP), Unit 1. These reinspections are planned for the B111R1 refueling outage scheduled to begin on October 5, 1996.
On July 25,1994, the NRC staff issued NRC Generic Letter 94-03, intergranular Stress Corrosion Cracking of Core Shrouds in Boiling Water Reactors." The generic letter requested that licensees submit plans for inspections of the core shroud at least 3 months prior to performing such inspections. Although the generic letter does not address reinspection plans, Carolina Power & Light Company's (CP&L) is submitting the Unit i reinspection plans using the generic letter as guidance. Enclosure 1 of this letter provides the Unit i reinspection scope and associated technical bases. The results of these reinspections will be submitted to the NRC within 30 days fo!!owing completion of the inspections.
Please refer any questions regarding this submittal to Mr. Mark Turkal at (910) 457-3066.
Sincerely, h
William R. Campbell WRM/wrm 1.
B111R1 Core Shroud Reinspection Plans 2.
List of Regulatory Commitments l
l RA M@ 69742dM %t01stM232R60
ESR 96-00160,. R:;visi:n 0, Att: chm::nt A A2 oF A7 Document Control Desk BSEP 96-0245 / Page 2 l
pc-U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission l
ATTN.: Mr. Stewart D. Ebneter, Regional Administrator 101 Marietta Street, N.W., Suite 2900 Atlanta, GA 30323-0199 Mr. C. A. Patterson NRC Senior Resident inspector-Brunswick Units 1 and 2:
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission ATTN.: Mr. David C. Trimble, Jr. (Mail Stop OWFN 14H22) l 11555 Rockville Pike Rockville, MD 20852-2738 The Honorable H. Wells Chairman - North Carolina Utilities Commission P.O. Box 29510 Raleigh, NC 27626-0510 l
J l
L i
l i
l
r,
- ESR 96-00160, Rsvisi::n 0, AttIchmsnt A A 3 oF A7 i
l I
l' ENCLOSURE 1 1
BRUNSWICK STEAM ELECTRIC PLANT, UNIT NO.1 NRC DOCKET NO. 50-325 OPERATING LICENSE NO. DPR-71 i
SUBMITTAL OF UNIT 1 CORE SHROUD REINSPECTION PLANS r
l l
l t
l i
1 1
i l
l l
i l
I I
I.
l I
4
- l lo
r ESR 96-00160, Rnvizion 0, Att: chm:nt A 4 0F A7
~
Core Shroud Reinspection Plan l
l Unit 1 l
B111R1 Outage 1
October 1996 l
l I
l i
l I
o O
Approved by:
W Date: 6-Jo -pg;
//"
l
. - ~
ESR 96-00160, Rsvi: Ion 0, Attachm::nt M M oF A7 Unit 1 B111R1 Outage October 1996 INSPECTION
SUMMARY
l j
The scope ofreinspection for the Unit I core shroud is based on the results of previous inspections l
performed on both Unit I and Unit 2, guidance on shroud inspections contained in NRC Generic Letter 94-03, BWRVIP documents "GuidelinesforReinspection ofBWR Core Shrouds" and "BWR Core ShroudInspection andEvaluation Guidelines" nnd continuing developments in the industry.
The inspections of the Unit I core shroud performed during the B109R1 outage (1993) met the requirements of NRC Generic Letter 94-03 of inspecting accessible areas of the shroud circumferential welds. In addition, vertical welds and several attachments welds, and other parts of the core support structure were examined during these inspections. SpeciSc areas on several circumferential welds were benchmarked, so that they could be re-examined to determine the extent of crack growth. A reinspection of the shroud was performed during the B110R1 outage (1995) l focusing on three objectives: (1) re-examination of selected areas to determine crack growth, (2) examination of previously inaccessible areas by use of specialized tooling and (3) examination of a i
number of the installed clamps to verify no inservice degradation has occurred.
l l
For the B111R1 shroud reinspection, CP&L has developed a prioritized/ ordered inspection scheme l
structured to provide suf5cient data such that an assessment of the structural integrity and previous l
cycle crack growth can be determined (see Table 1). The reinspection plan focuses on three objectives: (1) re-examination of selected areas to determine crack growth, (2) examination of a sample of the installed clamps to verify no inservice degradation has occurred and (3) application of improved inspection techniques for welds where surfaces were not accessible with previously used inspection equipment. Speci5cally, as a minimum, UT examinations will be performed on the accessible areas of welds H6a, H6b and H7 (listed as Priority 1 items in the enclosed Table 1);
selected previously inspected areas on weld H5 to assess crack growth (listed as a Priority 1 item in Table 1); and three repair clamps will be VT inspected (listed as a Priority 1 item in Table 1).
Additional inspections will be performed if measurements indicate that crack growth is greater than anticipated (listed as Priority 2 items in Table 1). Predictions from crack growth models indicate that little,ifany, crack growth is expected. This is consistent with predictions and actual results from the previous Unit 2 inspection.
UT inspections will be' conducted utilizing pulse echo technology. Equipment and procedures for UT, l
and for any supplemental VT, will be qualified in accordance with the inspection guidelines of the l
BWRVIP. The NDE uncertainty will be determined in quali5 cation testing by the inspection vendor.
These qualifications will follow the BWRVIP inspection guidelines.
An engineering evaluation of the inspection results will be performed using the flaw evaluation guidance issued by the BWRVIP in " Core ShroudInspection andEvaluation Guidelines", or other altemativeindustnf criteria.
i l
Page 2
{,
I b
~
ESR 96-00160, R:; vision 0, Attschm:nt A TABLE 1 BNP UNIT 1 CORE SHROUD REINSPECTION - B111R1 Weld Scope Priority Comments 100% of H1 UT 2c Non-safety related weld. Inspect for crack growth and Bottom structural margins.
(BelowRing) i H2/H3 none
- da da Welds repaired by addition of clamps in 1993.
Additional inspections will be performed ifmeasurements indicate that crack growth is greater than anticipated.
h%
Optionally, ifH6a, H6b and H7 are all good for multip!c H4 ofAccessible UT 2b cycles then inspect to reset evaluation baseline period.
Area (Weld can be stmeturally quahfied until B112RI using NDE data from B109R1 and criteria from GENE-523-113-0894.)
As-Required UT 1
Selected previouslyinspected areas on weld H5 to assess crack growth
]
j Additional inspections will be performed if measurements i
H5 indicate that crack growth is greater than anticipated.
100 %
UT 2a Optionally, if H6a, H6b and H7 are all good for multiple ofAccessible cycles then inspect to reset evaluation baseline period.
{
Area (Weld can be structurally qualified until B112RI using l
NDE data from B109RI and criteria from GENE-523 I13-0894.)
100 %
In8Pect 100% of accessible area to obtain data for H6a ofAccessible UT I
g structural assessment.
100%
Inspect 100% of accessible area to obtain data for H6b ofAccessible UT I
structural assessment.
100 %
Inspect 100% of accessible area to obtain data for H7 ofAnble U'I' 1
g stmetural assessment.
BWRVIP to develop tooling. These areas will be inspected H8 none da da consistent with guidance provided by the BWRVIP in the future.
H9 none da da Inspected duringBl10R1 Pod none da da BWRVIP developing inspection tools / techniques.
g, Repair VT-3 clamps & hardware for general appearance and 3
VT 1
nussmg parts.
Clamps VT-1 integrity of tack welds.
4
- Page 3
I 87 0F A7
~'
ESR 96-00160, Riviri:n 0, AttschmInt -A ENCLOSURE 2 BRUNSWICK STEAM ELECTRIC PLANT, UNIT NO.1 NRC DOCKET NO. 50-325 OPERATING LICENSE NO. DPR-71 SUBMITTAL OF UNIT 1 CORE SHROUD REINSPECTION PLANS l
LIST OF REGULATORY COMMITMENTS The following table identifies those actions committed to by Carolina Power & Light Company in this document. Any other actions discussed in the submittal represent intended or planned actions by i
Carclina Power & Light Company. They are described to the NRC for the NRC's information and are l
not regulatory commitments. Please notify the Manager-Regulatory Affairs at the Brunswick Nuclear Plant of any questions regarding this document or any associated regulatory commitments.
Commitment Committed.
l date or outage t
1.
Submit the B111R1 core shroud reinspection results.
30 days I
after i
completion ofinspections t
t
- 2.
CP&L will perform the Core Reinspection Plan as outlined in B111R1 i
enclosure 1.
/l I
i k
s.
\\
Shroud Cbconnserendet Weed Structuret Evalueena LismusentienseILDesennhuseos shroud m.
..1.5 h 8,00.enre test reise.
S, oo.
amie 1
se
,,e.e.e.
4p, wee ED-H1U Cract Growen Rosee SE45 her Lamas e 1IS he geenese on=e in-3111H Teens enmeerese tacenseny. 0.106 m tam = 177.5 h ventied er lO4 N l
Ugemes Assessh 3..a.
Asemanh Imeseg Ceart L4einem Asesenh Aseemsen Esaseg Crack Ligamese Asesespi Asessuen Lemmen Tidutsames Ligamou Asseech Astueum Ugamene TNehnese Nuises Best teegBeg,teggi [esigm My_
Base by BeWi [dugBeg_ te qP [M M,Jul e_h liksneer BWt ldug_
foup
+IEus meM Itsute Bwt Negl & [upi @nese HEstmeM
?
r M Jo~iz e r 1o o 64 m
a ao sEm as e ie4 r
to 3 1i ~. F134 m
75 oo
.ei sHe we T 11li
)f M t5~5 64 T~?II)7 6:ni 7 Ii'-~i44-i sii ~15 7 -F56e mi-
~3r
- i8~--.if i 9~ He we ET3e m
~36-~
T1 e3 i1H
=-~
ITT
~3- ~)o M~)i'li ~~~l6 6 11 4
Jili MT i67 H
3 56 1 ~ lis
~5~~~ ~31 it ~3DJ t.6~o 51 er aDi e636~if 6 i> +4 4
3D 7D7 Ha we--
~42 sa 7 E
(p) i s
adM~4DJ 43~6.3e es 4Di ~M3e-" 115
< ! si s
e61 41T~~5 Ma m
a
- D
<03 lie we
~3 sd M~3) M 41~5 as es 3DJ 36M7D~~~5 44 s
to i~ llT7Viti m
se il 7-~~e3
. hs =
7 MM MM i3-~514 si
- Di M 3o7 il'~~6 34
~7 46 5 ~M 6 9ille we
- f-7ifT-437'D4 we (gp
~4 - ~ e6 so eJ ri~7 6 6 41 44~
IDI to 30~716 - 5 di T
~~ co o ~~ ii f 7 M4 _m_.
61 7 134 we
's -~ We75 Pa io 5M 45 eD}
M 36 d
i1~~~hi17 i 114 ~we ~'"
~9 3 57 44 3
Mi7 1T r5~~M.e~4J M 46~5 43 T~)DJ iMM-i1 '-~~5 H 9
e61 sD -7iiis we
- F~7D-W3 7 iH aini-les we se tD9 56 Y BiH we
~1 e so.o 31M 4o o34
~ai ioDJ D
o
~if~
iM.e~ibDi '- 3 o o 34
~56 riDJ--li6 M~"- D
.,44 s-'
too1 16U~> 154 m
i44 r
e63~"~1D 7 M4 we
~at i6D-To 3 7 IN -~~e-----
O r
i)6 36--'
~F isk is
'os M e57 34
~4e
'ID:936M~~~ Ii
--i eid l '- li n9i1H we -
tr ilFT-MT o 234 we C)
T~r e6 3o ' nidi 4h~5u T93Di-id36-D
,,44 9.
~~i6f.i ~~~ibD 7iM4 we-
~F-tid-M3
~5154 we
.a m
i44
~ir iM M9MM -'5-'ii te T~i4D) is 36 1L-7'iis 9
116 1'- 116 6 o 6ie m
2 1417-46 1 iii4 we a
ilD E3 Q
~is
- M 969HH 673Y 4D)~iid 36~'D-iu
~i r5~~MM~isDJ 44~5U 3F
,'rDJ-'iM36-- I l'
. H r'-'El~~M6Tl~--'
i164 m
4 itiT' 46 5~7ihe we w
946 369 Ii 44
'i, 320 e~IiD i 1 14 m
~U
-'M M936 )6
' o 0se n
.s
'sDJ FHs we F'4fT-161~'o3le we 3
~ie-is Do9)D)
- o o so e
~I)D)~MM----f6 i es C~"El '
s
~
Ii 56 i~ illy 7 iU4 we-
~f iU idN i se u
'46 1 '
ifT7 36s e ""~
~3 F-IIT'- M3~5 He we T
rsd 30~ilDi e b' o it
~BF~isDi~
t46 5'BD o its we
-F""~546 6-%I~6 H4 m
94D3 iD 51o4 m
T9 lit-KI~"~5 M4 m
at 7'e sMio ~
46--"~ 611
~Bi '7aH6
-F~}id M~'ii'li 767 14
~46--'4Di~iiU r T4
<i44 9'
gg M16-""~' l l il l'~5 H4 we
~
iDJ 2o oB
~3 F~4HJ~idd 36~-"
i,es a.
n617 1TT7 16s we o
a4IT-W3 e aid we O
7F~}iidi
~
}Di 4c514
~ir74D)~% 36-- IE~634 70 liU ifD-"~1 Hs we --
~s HIT-46 3 ~o lid w-3
~'e~ ~}M M~ JDJ 4o 5 li'
~4F~)fDI-46M-11 ~~tes T-7 16 )
.IIT
5114 we-~~
~3F~4D~
66 5 5 154 m
O 7
11
.>as
~J<
F7M 36~MD6 t.o~ F3f
~BJ---7@Di MM
' a1 75 1 5 li4 m
i44 F~'i65-in B~144 no s.i 1D 7's'~ ~ 4636 2
'46 3
') se 46 5 ~5344 m -
3C~~
iD 7F~JiTIT-JDJ a6 o e4
~M~741 M -e636-D 9id W-II
'iM
~al
-'iil-in 3T64 we
~-~4F-iD ~M5 e als
=
in~61 e m
66 )
5 H4 we T~}M M^)sDJ e6 o es
~3F~sDJ~d6 M---'1I F
I63 p
T~}i00~iD2 4b'-'~611'
~
ss
.6D'i65 5 He we-"
cI
~r7iDJ
'""'"il ~i44 so
'e6 5~4fT7 Mi we
~3 F~-" bid -.lWI 5 H4~~~nie--
Of s
~'76-ltoio""'-dDJ e67 46
~45-~3)D)-e6 do 4D
<'M
~)F~
60~ AD-'1 14 PD1 417 is T71Uf7M 36 56 3 ' 4 154 we i
4e
.e f6 5-7564 m
~N~-ilD TJsd 36~4ili'-~~~~6-~5 46
-rift i'"-~~)e616
~~~
674 m
~s F iD '
66 6 ~5114 we o
J2 246 5 T~}tili 74DI b~5M T
Hi4~4i1 - El:4 m
m
'6D 3-7'i~~3606 302 r r
'b-'~44
~M~~
i6'5 --iiD - LII4 m
o~~ i34
~3e so55 sil-
'164 m
9
-'sr DoDi ^. eD3 SiH T'
6fI -6D -
.He m
3
~M~
Jed M-"-7D) e3 8
~3F~325 30 ID) 467 it) 3
~J F 26 ) -iiD
'. tos e
-T 3)dM73D) 4o-o'.is
~3i-36 1 iliT-lis e
is e., -
NOTES til Does hem Os tiRI GE Esembesten Swamerv Shoose (25 Croct yewm to egyhed to etalute egement thittsteet fer Ehe owebeelen perled.
838
.regione eesumed erecked is en sworese aspet er housee % 90.44"I.
e3 Lceic = '
segumed Beement length for k,ndl lees eenceme - seressace Sensegwel besegrier sesert Sm 94-o29 Illee. o (St toda = Leets + 2iCrect Geeusin E wtee + Total tussettlem L>certsbey i
I t
o O
M W
as
?
tor 3er9e Mig SpriCHAK.WH4
{
~
h I
p
. i 10/30/1996 14:54 Pila s U1MitBI.0LTT t
Paea 1
10/30/1996 14:54 Pilenamer U1MitEE. OLTP Peee 2
H1 Upper Normal / Upset (600 days 0.44 crack in uninspected) 47 240.9 241.5
.234 DLL: DIS 71tIBtTIED LIGAMENT LENGTH EVALUATION (REVISICII: 02/27/94) 40 241.5 242.7
.214 DATE OF CURRENT ANALYSIS: 10/30/1996 1
49 242.7 250.3
.234 i
StMERY OF INPUTS:
50 250.3 252.7
.104
..==........=...=.
51 252.7 260.3
.234 I
52 260.3 262.7
.304 3-Angle increment 1.0 deg. (CDARSEI
=
53 262.7 270.3
.234 Membrane Stress. Pim
.247. poi
=
54 270.3 272.7
.094 5
Bending Stress. Pb 403. poi
=
.[
55 272.7 200.3
.234 J
Safety Factor. SF a
2.25
=
56 200.3 282.7
.074 Mean Radius. Rm 94.00 inches 57 202.7 290.3
.234 I
=
Dell Thickness, t
.=
1.500 inches L
58 290.3 291.5
.274 -
Material 304 SS
=
l73 59
-291.5 292.7
.274 Stress Intensity, Su = 16900. poi (p) '
60 292.7 300.3
.234 Fluence
= 1.9E+19 n/cm*2 3
61 300.3 302.1
.204 (Thus. LEPM evaluation not applicable) 62 302.1 302.7
.324 63 302.7 310.3
.234 THETA 1 THETA 2 TKICIUfESS 64 310.3 312.7
.114 REGION
{c'eg. ]
[deg.)
[ inches]
Q 65 312.7' 320.3
.234 Q
66
^320.3 322.7
.104 1
.0 20.3
.234
-a
?
67 322.7 330.3
.234 0%
i 2
20.3 22.1
.134 68 330.3 332.7
.034 Q
I 3
22.1 22.7
.134 69 332.7 360.0
.234 4
22.7 30.3
.234 I
S 30.3 31.5
.354 3
6 31.5 32.1
.234 l
LIMIT IDAD RESULTS:
7 32.1 32.7
.354.
....=====
0 32.7 40.3
.234 04 9
40.3 42.7
.294 6*
ALPHA MOPENT Pb' SAPETY 10 42.7
$0.3
.234 ll3 i
toegl (in-1bs)
[psil PACTOR
. RESULT 11 50.3 52.7
.104 O
12 52.7 60.3
.234
[
.0 4.1268*00 9910.
13.91 ACCEPTABLE 13 60.3 60.9
.334 5.0 4.122E+0S 9900.
13.90 ACCElrTABLE 14 60.9 62.7
.254 4
10.0 4.110E*00 9091.
13.89 ACCEPTABLE N
15 62.7 70.3
.234 15.0 4.115E+08 9003.
13.00 ACCEPTABLE E-16 70.3 72.7
.314 20.0 4.113E+00 9877.
13.07 ACCEPTABLE h
17 12.7 00.3
.234 25.0 4.100E*00 9065.
13.05 ACCEPTABLE i
18 00.3 02.7
.244 30.0 4.103E+00 9053.
13.84
-ACCEPTABLE
[
19 02.7 90.3
.234 35.0 4.100E+00 9047.
13.03 ACCEPTABLE 8
20 90.3 92.7
.294 40.0 4.101E+08 9048.
13.03 ACCEPTABLE 3
i 21 92.7 100.3
.234 45.0 4.102E+08 9852.
13.83 ACCEPTABLE i
22 100.3 102.1
.334 50.0 4.100E*00 9046.
13.03 ACCEPTABLE
[
23 102.1 102.7
.334 55.0 4.090E+00 9043.
13.82 ACCEPTABLE 24 102.7 110.3
.234 i
60.0 4.100E+00 9040.
13.03
. ACCEPTABLE 25 110.3 112.7
.234
[
5F.0 4.099E+08 9044.
13.02
'ACCEP1ABLE 26 112.7 120.3
.234 t
70.0 4.097B+08
.9040.
13.82 ACCEPTABLE-27 120.3 120.9
.014 15.0
%.D.'9E+00 19844.
13.02 ACCEPTABLE 20 120.9 122.7
.304 i
00.0 4.091E*00 9043.
13.82 ACCEPTABLE 29 122.7 130.3
.234 05.0 4.10CE+04 9047.
13.03 ACCEPTABLE 30 130.3 130.9
.294 90.0 4.1064'+00 9061.
13.85 ACCEPTABL 31 130.9 132.7
.174 95.0 4.115Er00 9004.
13.88 ACCEPTABLE 32 132.7 140.3
.234
[
100.0 4.117E+00 9000.
13.00 ACCEPTABLE 33 140.3 142.7
.304 105.0 4.124E+08 9904.
13.91 ACCEPTABLE 7
l 34 142.7 150.3
.234 110.0 4.126E+00 9910.
13.91 ACCEPTABLE 35 150.3 152.7
.144 115.0 4.130E+08 9920.
13.93 ACCEPTABLE 36 152.7 160.3
.234 120.0 4.135E+08 9930.
13.94 ACCEPTABLE 37 160.3 162.7
.154 125.0 4.143E*00 9949.
13.97 ACCEPTABLE
?
s 30 162.7 210.3
.234 130.0 4.152E+0e 3971.
14.00 ACCEPTABLE 39 210.3 211.5
.284 i
135.0 4.1565+08 9902.
14.01 ACCEPTABLE N.
.l 40 211.5 212.7
.204 41 212.1 220.3
.234 140.0 4.160E*00 9991.
14.02 ACCEPTABLE
^
145.0 4.166t+0e 10006.
14.05 ACCEPTABLE O
42 220.3 222.7
.134 j
43 222.7 230.3
.234 150.0 4.169E*04 10013.
14.06 ACCEPTABLE
-Q 155.0 4.160E+08 10011.
14.05 ACCEPTABLE 44 230.3 232.7
.164 i
160.0 4.165E+00 10003.
14.04 ACCEPTAB12 45 232.7 240.3
.234 165.0 4.159E+0S 9908.
14.02 ACCEPTABLE i
46 240.3 240.9
.354 170.0 4.154E+08 9975.
14.00 ACCEPTABt2 G
{
i e
i
e e
l 10/30/1996 14:54 F11enamer U1M1?""". 0UT p,
3 t
175.0 4.149E+00 9964.
- 3.99 ACCEPTABLE s
100.0 4.144E*00 9953.
13.97 ACCEPTABLE t
105.0 4.140E*00 9943.
13.96 ACCEPTABLE 190.0 4.136E+08 9934 13.95 ACCEPTABLE 195.0 4.133E*00 9926.
13.94 ACCEPTABLE l
200.0 4.130E+0S 9919.
13.93 ACCEPTABLE i
l 205.0 4.127E+0S 9911-.
13.91 ACCEPTABLE 210.0 4.122E+00 9900.
13.90 ACCEPTABLE 215.0 4.121E*00 9096.
13.09 ACCEPTABLE 220.0 4.120E+04 9895.
13.09 ACCEPTABLE 4
225.0 4.118E+0S 9009.
13.09 ACCEPTABLE 230.0 4.117E*00 9000 13.00 ACCEPTABIA i
235.0 4.115E400 9002.
13.00 ACCEPTABLE yyg -
240.0 4.112E+04 9875.
13.07 ACCEPTABLE (f) i 245.0 4.110E*00 9971.
13.06 ACCEPTABLE 3
1 250.0 4.109E*00 9868 13.06 ACCEPTABLE f
255.0 4.101E*00 9062.
13.05 ACCEPTABLE 260.0 4.107E+00 9064 13.85 ACCEPTABLE f-265.0 4.113E+08 9079.
. 13.07 ACCEPTABLE Q
270.0 4.1168+04 9005.
13.08 ACCEPTABLE O
275.C 4.118Ee05 9893.
13.89 ACCEPTABLE a
200.0 4.118E*00 9891.
13.09 ACCEPTABLE Q
205.0 4.119E+08 9992.
13.09 ACCEPTABLE Q
290.0 4.122E*00 9900.
13.90 ACCEPTABLE 295.0 4.127E+0B 9910.
13.91 ACCEPTABLE Z
300.0 4.131E+08 9921.
13.93 ACCEPTABLE S
i 305.0 4.130E*00 9938.
13.95 ACCEPTABLE
[
l 310.0 4.143E+08 9950.
13.97 ACCEPTABLE St 315.0 4.149Ee00 9964.
13.99 ACCEPTABLE 6'
y t
320.0 4.152Ee00 9972.
14.00 ACCEPTABLE
- 3 325.0 4.153E+08 9975.
14.00 ACCEPTABLE O
{
330.0 4.153E+00 9973.
14.00 ACCEPTABLE 315.0 4.150E+08 9968.
13.99 ACCEPTABLE f
M 340.0 4.146E+08 9957.
13.98 ACCEPTABLE 345.0 4.143E+08 9949.
13.97 ACCEPTABLE 350.0 4.136E+00 9933.
13.94 ACCEPTABLE O
355.0 4.131E.00 9921.
13.93 ACCEPTABLE 3-t e
i.
ACCEPTABLEI MINIMUM SAFETY FAC"IVR = 13.e2 AT 10.0 DEGREES.
k 4
4 1
i W
l O
"Il
- u
..m m
+
m c
-a-. - +.
.4
_~.
e 10/30/1996 15:01 Filenamer U1H1UE.0UT Pace 1
10/30/1996 15:01 Filename: U1H1UE.0UT Pace 2
HI Upper Emergency (600 days 0.44 crack in uninspected) 47 240.9 241.5
.234 DLL: DISTRIBtTTED LIGAMENT LENGTH EVALUATION (REVISION: 02/27/94) 40 241.5 242.1
.214 DATE OF CURRENT ANALYSIS: 10/30/1996 49 242.7 250.3
.234 50 250.3 252.7
.104 StP91ARY OF INPUTS:
51 252.7 260.3
.234
======
52 260.3 262.7
.304 Angle increment 1.0 deg. (CDARSE) 53 262.7 270.3
.234
=
Membrane Stress, Pm 000. poi 54 270.3 272.7
.094
=
Bending Stress. Pb 636. psi 55 272.7 200.3
.234 3
=
Safety Factor, SF
.1.50 56 200.3 202.7
.074
=
Mean Radius, Rm 94.00 inches 57 202.7 290.3
.234
=
Wall Thickness, t 1.500 inches 50 290.3 291.5
.274
=
m Material 304 SS 59 291.5 292.7
.214 gg
=
Stress Intensity, Se = 16900. poi 60 292.7 300.3
.234 gg Fluence
= 1.9E*19 n/cm*2 61 300.3 302.1
.204 (Thus, LEFM evaluation not applicable) 62 302.1 302.7
.324 63 302.7 310.3
.234 f
THETA 1 1HETA2 THICINESS 64 310.3 312.7
.114 Q
REGION
[deg.)
(deg.]
[ inches]
65 312.7 320.3
.234 0
66 320.3 322.7
.104
=4 1
.0 20.3
.234 67 322.7 330.3
.234 Ch 2
20.3 22.1
.134 60 330.3 332.7
.034 C) 3 22.1 22.7
.134 69 332.7 360.0
.234 4
22.7 30.3
.234 5
30.3 31.5
.354
'2)
S 6
31.5 32.1
.234 LIMIT 14AD RESULTS:
1 32.1 32.1
.354 1
=======
G8 0
32.7 40.3
.234
~
9 40.3 42.7
.294 ALPHA MOMENT Pb' SAFETY 3
O 10 42.7 50.3
.234 (deg]
[in-Ibs)
(psil FACMR RESULT
[
11 50.3 52.7
.104 h
12 52.7 40.3
.234
.0 4.062E+00 9754.
7.35 ACCEPTABLE i
13 60.3 60.9
.334 5.0 4.0578+00 9744.
7.34 ACCEPTABLE M
'i 14 60.9 62.7
.254 10.0 4.056E+00 9742.
7.34 ACCEPTABLE l%
15 62.7 70.3
.234 15.0 4.054E*00 9735.
7.34 ACCEPTABLE 08 16 10.3 12.1
.314 20.0 4.044E+00 9713.
7.32 ACCEPTABLE O
17 72.7 80.3
.234 25.0 4.041E+00 9705.
7.32 ACCEPTABLE 10 00.3 02.7
.244 30.0 4.036E+00 9693.
7.31 ACCEPTABLE 3
19 02.7 90.3
.234 35.0 4.033E+00 9607.
7.30 ACCEPTABLE l
20 90.3 92.7
.294 40.0 4.035E+00 9690.
7.30 ACCEPTABLE 3
7 21 92.7 100.3
.234 45.0 4.039E+00 9700.
7.31 ACCEPTABLE l
22 100.3 102.1
.334 50.0 4.039E*00 9700.
7.31 ACCEPTABLE 23 102.1 102.7
.334 55.0 4.033E+00 9605.
7.30 ACCEPTABLE 24 102.7 110.3
.234 60.0 4.030E*00 9679.
7.30 ACCEPTABLE l
25 110.3 112.7
.234 65.0 4.039E+00 9700.
7.31 ACCEPTABLE 26 112.7 120.3
.234 70.0 4.040E*00 9703.
7.31 ACCEPTABLE 3
27 120.3 120.9
.014 75.0 4.041E+00 9105.
1.32 ACCEPTABLE 20 120.9 122.7
.304 30.0 4.044E+00 9711.
7.32 ACCEPTABLE 29 122.7 130.3
.234 05.0 4.041E+00 9705.
7.32 ACCEPTABLE 30 130.3 130.9
.294 90.0 4.045E+00 9715.
7.32 ACCEPTABLE 31 130.9 132.7
.174 95.0 4.052E+00 9731.
7.33 ACCEPTABLE 32 132.1 140.3
.234 100.0 4.062B+00 9754.
7.35 ACCEPTABLE 33 140.3 142.7
.304 105.0 4.074E+00 9784.
1.37 ACCEPTABLE 34 142.7 150.3
.234 110.0 4.001E*00 9000.
7.30 ACCEPTABLE 35 150.3 152.7
.104 115.0 4.005E*00 9011.
7.39 ACCEPTABLE
+
36 152.7 160.3
.234 120.0 4.092E+00 9027.
7.40 ACCEPTABLE
-t 31 160.3 162.7
.154 125.0 4.101E*00 9050.
7.42 ACCEPTABLE 30 162.7 210.3
.234 130.0 4.100E+00 9067.
7.43 ACCEPTABLE 39 210.3 211.5
.204 135.0 4.115E*00 9002.
7.44 ACCEPTABLE 40 211.5 212.1
.204 140.0.
4.121E+00 9097.
7.45 ACCEPTABLE g
41 212.1 220.3
.234 145.0 4.126E+00 9909.
7.46 ACCEPTABLE i
42 220.3 222.7
.134 150.0 4.135E+00 9931.
7.47 ACCEPTABLE 43 222.7 230.3
.234 155.0 4.130E+00 9917.
7.46 ACCEPTABLE l
t 44 230.3 232.7
.164 160.0 4.130E+00 9910.
7.46 ACCEPTABLE O
l 45 232.7 240.3
.234 165.0 4.124E*00 9905.
7.45 ACCEPTABLE I
I 46 240.3 240.9
.354 170.0 4.1198+00 9093.
7.45 ACCEPTABLE te
. _ _ _ - _. _ _ _ _ _ _ - _ - _ _ - - - -. _ -- -~ - -,,. -, -. - -
10/30/1996 15:01 Filenamer U1H10E.OUT Page 3
175.0 4.114E+08 9081.
7.44 ACCEPTABLE 180.0 4.110E*00 9870.
7.43 ACCEPTABLE 185.0 4.106E+08 9860.
7.42 ACCEPTABLE 190.0 4.102E+08 9851.
7.42 ACCEPTABLE 195.0 4.099E+08
- 9843, 7.41 ACCEPTABLE 200.0 4.096E+08 9836.
7.41 ACCEPTABLE 205.0 4.092E*00 9026.
1.40 ACCEPTABLE 210.0 4.095E+08 9835.
7.41 ACCEPTABLE 215.0 4.094E+08 9832.
7.40 ACCEPTABLE 220.0 4.005E+08
- 9810, 7.39 ACCEPTABLE
.s 225.0 4.004E*08 9809.
7.39 ACCEPTABLE 230.0 4.072E+08 9779.
7.37 ACCEPTABLE 235,0 4.072E+08 9778.
7.37 ACCEPTABLE lTg 240.0 4.078E+00 9793.
7.38 ACCEPTABLE
(/)
=
245.0 4.067E+08 9767.
7.36 ACCEPTABLE 2
250.0 4.064E+08 9761.
7.35 ACCEPTABLE 255.0 4.071E+08 9776.
7.37 ACCEPTABLE O
240.0 4.063E+08 9750.
7.35 ACCEPTABLE i
265.0 4.073E+08 9702.
7.37 ACCEPTABLE Q
270.0 4.074E+08 9783.
7.37 ACCEPTABLE Q
275.0 4.069E+08 9771.
1.36 ACCEPTABLE a
200.0 4.066E+0e 9765.
7.36 ACCEPTABLE 0) 285.0 4.067E+08 9767.
7.36 ACCEPTABLE O
290.0 4.068E*00 9769.
7.36 ACCEPTABLE 295.0 4.075E*08 9787.
7.37 ACCEPTABLE 2
300.0 4.081E+08 9802.
7.30 ACCEPTABLE S
305.0 4.079E+08 9796.
7.38 ACCEPTABLE 310.0 4.002E+08 9004.
7.30 ACCEPTABLE SS 315.0 4.082E*00 9003.
7.38 ACCEPTABLE 6*
320.0 4.090E+08 9822.
7.40 ACCEPTABLE 3
325.0 4.089E+08 9019.
7.40 ACCEPTABLE 330.0 4.004E+08 9809.
7.39 ACCEPTABLE h
335.0 4.070E+08 9775.
7.36 ACCEPTABLE 340.0 4.068E+00 9770.
1.36 ACCEPTABLE k
345.0 4.070E*00 9793.
7.30 ACCEPTABLE N
l 350.0 4.075E+00 9786.
7.37 ACCEPTABLE E
355.0 4.066E*08 9765.
7.36 ACCEPTABLE O
B ACCEP7ABLEt MINIMUM SAFETY FACTOR =
7.30 AT 60.0 DECREES.
6 t
i G
o f
~11 tP (4
t k
....n..,
~-,= --
a 10/30/1996 15:03 Filenamet U1H1UF.0tTT
>=
1 10/30/1996 15 03 Filenamer U1H1UF.OUT Psee 2
H1 Upper Faulted (600 days 0.44 crack in uninspected) 47 240.9 241.5
.234 DLL: DISTRIBUTED LIGAMENT LENGTH EVALUATION (REVISION: 02/27/94) 40 241.5 242.7
.314 DATE OF CURRENT ANALYSIS: 10/30/3996 49 242.7 250.3
.234 50 250.3 252.7
.184 StM4ARY OF INPtfrS 51 252.7 260.3
.234 f
=....=........=...
52 260.3 262.7
.304 Angle increment 1.0 deg. (COARSE
- 53 262.7 270.3
.234
'l
=
Membrane Stress. Pm 316. pet 54 270.3 272.1
.094
=
Bending Stress. Pb 642. psi 55 272.7 280.3
.234
.8
=
Safety Factor. SF 1.13
=
56 280.3 282.7
.074 Mean Radius, Rm 94.00 inches 51 282.1 290.3
.234
=
Wall Thickness. t 1.500 inches
=
58 290.3 291.5
.274 Material 304 SS en 59 291.5 292.7
.274 gg Stress Intensity. Se = 16900, psi 60 292.7 300.3
.234 Fluence 30 1.9E*19 n/cm'2 61 300.3 302.1
.234
=
(Thus. LEFM evaluation not applicable) 62 302.1 302.7
.324 63 302.7 310.3
.234
?
THETA 1 THETA 2 THICKNESS 64 310.3 312.7
.114 REGION
[deg.]
[deg.)
[ inches]
65 312.7 320.3
.234 Oo 66 320.3 322.7
.104 1
.0 20.3
.234 67 322.7 330.3
.234 05 l
-4 2
20.3 22.1
.134 68 330.3 332.7
.034 C) 3 22.1 22.7
.134 69 332.7 360.0
.234 4
22.7 30.3
.234 5
30.3 31.5
.354 3S 6
31.5 32.1
.234 LIMIT I4AD RESULTS:
7 32.1 32.7
.354
=======
O 32.7 40.3
.234 Ut 6*
9 40.3 42.7
.294 ALPHA MOMENT Pb' SAFETT 10 42.7 50.3
.234
- 3
[deg)
[in-lbs)
[ps1]
FACTOR RESULT 11 50.3 52.7
.184
,o 12 52.7 60.3
.234
.0 4.062E+08 9754 7.25 ACCEPTABLE 13 60.3 60.9
.334 5.0 4.057E+08 9744.
7.24 ACCEPTABLE M
14 60.9 62.7
.254 10.0 4.056E+08 9742.
7.24 ACCEPTABLE N
15 62.7 70.3
.234 15.0 4.030E+08 9698.
7.21 ACCEPTABLE Of 16 10.3 12.7
.314 20.0 4.044E+08 9 71 '..
7.22 ACCEPTABLE O
17 72.7 80.3
.234 25.0 4.041E+08 5705.
7.22 ACCEPTABLE le 80.3 82.7
.244 30.0 4.036E+0s 9693.
7.21 ACCEPTABLE 3
i 19 02.7 90.3
.234 35.0 4.033E+0S 5687.
7.20 ACCEPTABLE 8
20 90 3 92.1
.294 40.0 4.035E+00 9690.
7.21 ACCEPTABLE d
21 92.7 100.3
.234 45.0 4.024E+08 9663.
7.19 ACCEPTABLE i
22 100.3 102.1
.334 50.0 4.023E+08 9662.
7.19 ACCEPTABLE 23 102.1 102.1
.334 55.0 4.033E+08 5685.
7.20 ACCEPTABLE 24 102.7 110.3
.234 60.0 4.030E+08 9679.
1.20 ACCEPTABLE 25 110.3 112.1
.234 65.0 4.039E+08 9700.
7.21 ACCEPTABLE 26 112.7 120.3 234 70.0 4.040E+00 9703.
7.21 ACCEPTABLE 27 120.3 120.9
.014 75.0 4.041E+08 9705.
7.22 ACCEPTABLE 28 120.9 122.7
.304 80.0 4.044E+00 9711.
7.22 ACCEPTABLE 29 122.1 130.3
.234 05.0 4.041E+08 9705.
7.22 ACCEPTABLE 30 130.3 130.9
.294 90.0 4.045E+08 9715.
7.22 ACCEPTABLE 31 110.9 132.1
.114 95.0 4.052E+08 9731.
7.23 ACCEPTABLE 32 132.7 140.3 234 100.0 4.062E+08 9754.
7.25 ACCEPTABLE 33 140.3 142.7
.304 105.0 4.074E+08 9784.
7.27 ACCEPTABLE 34 142.7 150.3
.234 110.0 4.001E+08 9800.
7.28 ACCEPTABLE 15 150.3 152.1
.184 115.0 4.085E+08 9011.
7.29 ACCEPT *.BLE 36 152.1 160.3
.234 120.0 4.092E+08 9827.
1.30 ACCEPTABLE i
37 160.3 162.7
.154 125.0 4.090E+04 9023.
7.30 ACCEPTABLE 34 162.1 210.3
.234 130.0 4.096E+00 9036.
7.31 ACCEPTABLE 19 210.3 211.5
.284 135.0 4.115E+00 9002.
7.34 ACCEPTABLE 40 211.5 212.1
.284 140.0 4.121E+08 9897.
7.35 ACCEPTABLE 41 212.7 220.3
.234 145.0 4.126E+00 9909.
7.36 ACCEPTABLE h
42 220.3 222.7
.134 150.0 4.128E+00 9914.
7.36 ACCEPTABLE 43 222.1 230.3
.234 155.0 4.130E+08 9917 7.36 ACCEPTABLE D
44 230.3 232.7 164 160.0 4.130E+08 9910.
7.36 ACCEPTABLE 1
45 232.7 240.3
.234 165.0 4.124E+08 9905.
7.35 ACCEPTABLE 46 240.3 240.9
.354 170.0 4.119E+00 9893.
7.34 ACCEPTABLE u
- - - - - - - - ~ _ - ~, - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - --- - - - - - - - - --------- ---
10/30/1976 15:03 Filenamer U1P UF.CtTT Pac *J 175.0 4.114E,08 9001.
7.34 ~
ACCEPTABLE e
100.0 4.110E+0S 9070.
7.33 ACCEPTABLE 105.0 4.106E+08 9060.
1.32 ACCEPTABLE I
190.0 4.102E+08 9051.
7.32 ACCEPTABLE 195.0 4.099E+08 9043.
7.31 ACCEPTABLE
'200.0 4.096E+00 9436.
7.31 ACCEPTABLE 205.0 4.092E+08 9026.
7.30 ACCEPTABLE 210.0 4.0955 00 9835.
7.31 ACCEPTABLE 215.0 4.007E+08 9015.
7.29 ACCEPTABLE e
l 220.0 4.005E+00 9010.
1.29 ACCEPTABLE 225.0 4.004E+00 9009.
7.29 ACCEPTABLE 6
230.0 4.072E+00 9779.
7.27 ACCEPTABLE 235.0 4.072E+0S 9770.
7.27 ACCEPTABLE gyg 240.0 4.069E+08 9771.
7.26 ACCEPTABLE g) e 245.0 4.067E+08 9767 7.26 ACCEPTABLE 3
250.0 4.064E+00 9761.
7.25 ACCEPTABLE E-j 255.0 4.060E+00 9752.
7.25 ACCEPTABLE f
260.0 4.063E+08 9759.
7.25 ACCEPTABLE 265.0 4.073E+00 9702.
7.27 ACCEPTABLE Q
270.0 4.074E+00 9703.
7.27 ACCEPTABLE O
a 5
275.0 4.069E+08 9771.
7.26 ACCEPTABLE S
200.0 4.066E+08 9765.
7.26 ACCEPTABLE O
285.0 4.067E*00 9767 7.26 ACCEPTABLE 290.0 4.060E+00 9769.
7.26 ACCEPTABLE 3
295.0 4.063E+08 9757.
7.25 ACCEPTABLE S
300.0 4.069E+08 9771.
7.26 ACCEPTABLE
(
305.0 4.079E+0S 9796.
7.28 ACCEPTABLE Os 310.0 4.002E*00 9004 7.20 ACCEPTABLE F
1 315.0:
4.082E+08 9003.
7.28 ACCEPTABLE 320.0 4.090E+0e 9022 7.30 ACCEPTABLE 3
i 325.0 4.089E+08 9019.
7.29 ACCEPTABLE
,O 330.0 4.084E+08 9009.
7.29 ACCEPTABLE 335.0 4.070E+08 9775.
7.26 ACCEPTABLE M
340.0 4.068E+08 9770.
7.26 ACCEPTABLE 345.0 4.063E*00 9757.
7.25 ACCEPTABLE i
D t
350.0 4.060E+00 9750.
7.25 ACCEPTABLE O
I 355.0 4.066E+00 9765.
7.26 ACCEPTABLE 7
,3 ACCEPTABLEI MINIMUM SAFETY FACTOR =
7.19 AT 50.0 DEGREES.
7 n
L 1
f i
1 I
L I
I N
o Tl i
^
CU W
b m
m m-
- -. ~,-- - -, -_ ----
-__,__w, w-
Shroud CircumferentleLWel&Structurativolustiert Ugement lengthDeterminetlort SFvous tn=
1.5 in Evel Period-2000 devs date rient 10:
BNP1 00 189.5 in teme -
171 in tupsevnemd Prep =ed sy:
_{ Ja 4 wed c:
H1L crack Growth Reie-SE-05 inthr teme -
176 in treidtede Des 3 so:
811iftT Toim anspecean uncertemey-0.OO en Lmin -
180.8 tn vmffied e _
10 38 %.
.e fGgh Flus Zone trispectlen Dets End of EvolueWon Linement Date End of Evel Crack Tip input for DLL Ans8veio tr9utyOtt Analysie Ugement Aanrnuth Astenuth Emisenne Deys to Futy Artmuth Astrnutti Ueement in High Na Zone?
A3nuth Artenuth Aatmuth Aatenutts Ugement pyg Nurnber_ Start toeglStop toegtt_origth Ord Crocked _
Start idegtStop idestlength 5.1 Start Stop Start.
Step _
_ Start Step Lengt_h (p) f 73.20 28.0 f 24.5 8M5 14.7 26 6 19.7 No No 14.7 26 6 3
2 2983 59 22 40 6 19001 31.3 57.8 43 8 Yes Yes 31.3 57.8 J
67.04 84.66 39.1 15025 62.5 83.2 34.3 No No 6 27 03.2 CO 4
8[17Mi s.O eji.
eE9 ej}
90.
No No (I
5 S2 25 _f 76 80 40_ 6
- 15666,
_ 93.7 J5.3 35 8 No No 93.7 1153 This TebloNot ApplicMe for Q
5 IFS 22 847.47 46.6 18174 120.7 146.0 41.8 Yes Yes 120.7 146.0 Wold H1 Q
7 f 49 83 f65.38 25.7 9465 151.3 163.9 20.9 No No 151.3 163 9 a
20J 20 237.75 47.2 18422 204.7 230.3 42.4 No Yes 204.7 230.3 0) 3 235.70 JJ8 62 4.8 762 237.2 237.2 0.0 Yes Yes O
f3 240.43 241.75 2.2 Cuecked Crocked ff 242.96 s50.54 12.5 3973 244.4 249.1 7.7 No No 244.4 249.1 3
- 2 256.Jr 270.43 23.4 8479 257.8 269.0 80 6 No No 257A 269 0 CD f3 272.25 272.35 0.2 Cesched Crocked is 274.77 28356 15.5 5220 275.6 282.1 10.7 No No 275.6 267.1 h*
- 5 285.70 297. 4 r 19 4 6819 287.2 296 0 14.6 No No 287.2 298.0 O'
f6 299 22 21.7 7797 300.7 310.9 16 9 Yes Yes 300.7 310.9 f7 Jf3 56 JJ8. 56 M 1.3 15976 315 0 337.1 36.5 Yes No 315.0 337.1 g
,0
. gmIth_cnsAO N07MI W IFt C4d t~~ 'w)g p
3" 3
<D3 re Emsrey tipernent length ini =
410.3 E'OE Ug. Length tird =
344.0 Since EOE Lisement LenstFt ) Lenin, e dete5ed Imit leed onetysie is not required.
NOTES til 00ement Date from 8111R1 GE Enemination Summary Sheets 123 Crack growth is appled et each end of Egement (3)
Days to Fuey Crocked = days tm Egement length is aere tactusey: uncertainty + ASME crack proximity rubel for each Egement.
Sti l*gh Nm Zone = plus er minus 15 degrees from ezimuthe 45.135,225 and 315 Se 30-60 etcJ 153 Ideg = 1.6537 in 163 Uninspected regions assumed fury crocked. As crocks assumed throug4 wen (7)
Lesic = mirwnum required Egement length for Ibnut load concerns - reference Structurd Integrity report SIR-94429 Rev. O G1 Emin = Lcese + 2fCrack Growth in Essluetten Periodt + TotW Inspection Uncertainty y
0 3
Qw 1072tt96 HIL BNPICRAK.WK4
10/24/1996 10:11 Fil?n mer U1HILU.O*TT P*ae 1
10/24/1996 10:11 F11+n me: U1HILU.OUT Pro?
2 H1 tower Side Normal / Upset (2000 days) 125.0 1.425E+09 34226.
47.22 ACCEPTABLE
+
DLL: DISTRIBLTTED LIGAMENT LENGTH EVALUATION (REVISION: 02/27/94) 110.0 1.435E+09 34466.
47.55 ACCEPTABLE DATE OF CURREffT ANALYSIS: 10/24/1996 135.0 1.454E+09 34917.
48.17 ACCEPTABLE 140.0 1.482E+09 35589.
49.09 ACCEPTABLE SUP94ARY OF INPtTTS:
145.0 1.519E+09 36478.
50.31 ACCEPTABLE 150.0 1.565E+09 37576.
51.01 ACCEPTABLE Angle increment 1.0 deg. (COARSE) 155.0 1.612E+09 30704.
53.36 ACCEPTABLE
=
Membrane Stress. Pm 247, pel 160.0 1.643E+09 39465.
54.40 ACCEPTABLE
=
Bending Stress. Pb 483. psi 165.0 1.662E+09 39925.
55.03 ACCEPTABLE e
=
Safety Factor. SF 2.77 170.0 1.670E+09 40099.
55.27 ACCEPTABLE
=
Mean Radius, Rm 94.00 inches 175.0 1.672E*09 40146.
55.33 ACCEPTABLE
=
Es11 Thickness. t
=
1.500 inches 180.0 1.675E+09, 40232.
55.45 ACCEPTABLE Material ggg 304 SS 105.0 1.684E+09 40448.
55.75 ACCEPTABLE (f)
=
Stress Intensity. Sm = 16900. psi 190.0 1.689E+39 40571.
55.92 ACCEPTABLE y
Fluence 1.9E+19 n/cm*2 195.0 1.685E+09 40458.
55.76 ACCEPTABLE (Thus. LEFM evaluation not applicable) 200.0 1.667E+09 40036.
55.18 ACCEPTABLE D
205.0 1.637E+09 39309.
54.19 ACCEPTABLE O
THETA 1 THETA 2 THICKNESS 210.0 1.595E*09 38303.
52.81 ACCEPTABLE O
REGION
[deg.]
(deg.]
[ inches]
215.0 1.556E+09 37378.
51.34 ACCEPTABLE Q
220.0 1.526E+09 36658.
50.55 ACCEPTABLE a
1 14.6 26.6 1.500 225.0 1.505E+09 36149.
49.86 ACCEPTABLE Q
2 31.3 57.8 1.500 230.0 1.493E*09 35854.
49.45 ACCEPTABLE O
3 62.5 83.2 1.500 235.0 1.487E*09 35717.
49.27 ACCEPTABLE 4
93.7 115.3 1.500 240.0 1.479E+09
- 35524, 49.00 ACCEPTABLE 3
5 120.7 146.0 1.500 245.0 1.462E+09 35104.
48.43 ACCEPTABLE (D
6 151.3 163.9 1.500 250.0 1.446E+09 34736.
47.92 ACCEPTABLE
{
7 204.6 230.3 1.500 255.0 1.427E*09 34280.
47.30 ACCEPTABLE (n
8 244.4 249.1 1.500 260.0 1.416E*09 33995.
46.91 ACCEPTABLE 6*
9 257.8 269.0 1.500 265.0 1.412E+09 33921.
46.81 ACCEPTABLE 3
10 275.6 282.1 1.500 270.0 1.404E+09
- 31711, 46.52 ACCEPTABLE 11 287.1 296.0 1.500 275.0 1.403E+09 33702.
46.51 ACCEPTABLE
,o 12 300.7 310.9 1.500 200.0 1.395E+09 33510.
46.24 ACCEPTABLE 13 315.0 337.1 1.500 285.0 1.388E+09 33328.
45.99 ACCEPTABLE D
290.0 1.389E+09 33361.
46.04 ACCEPTABLE N
295.0 1.388E+09 33341.
46.01 ACCEPTABLE ED LIMIT I4AD RESULTS:
300.0 1.399E+09 33597.
46.36 ACCEPTABLE O
305.0 1.419E+09 34079.
47.02 ACCEPTABLE 310.0 1.429E+09 34309.
47.34 ACCEPTABLE B
ALPHA MOMENT Pb' SAFETY 315.0 1.447E+09 34760.
47.95 ACCEPTABLE (D
[degl lin-lbs)
(psi)
FAC'IVR RESULT 320.0 1.475E+09 35432.
48.88 ACCEPTABLE 3
325.0 1.512E*09 36321.
50.09 ACL'EPTABLE
.0 1.657E+09 39192.
54.85 ACCEPTABLE 330.0 1.561E+09 37492.
51.10 ACCEPTABLE 5.0 1.664E+09
- 9972.
55.09 ACCEPTABLE 335.0 1.601E*09 38451.
53.01 ACCEPTABLE s
10.0 1.670E+09 40113.
55.29 ACCEPTABLE 340.0 1.629E+09 39117.
53.92 ACCEPTABLE Q
15.0 1.669E+09 40091.
55.26 ACCEPTABLE 345.0 1.644E+09 39485.
54.43 ACCEPTABLE 20.0 1.656E+09 39763.
54.81 ACCEPTABLE 350.0 1.649E+09 39605.
54.59 ACCEPTABLE 25.0 1.629E*09 39133.
53.95 ACCEPTABLE 355.0 1.653E*09 39706.
54.73 ACCEPTABLE 30.0 1.591E+09 38205.
52.67 ACCEPTABLE 35.0 1.552E+09 37200.
51.41 ACCEPTABLE 40.0 1.522E+09 36560.
50.42 ACCEPTABLE ACCEPTABLEl MINIMUM SAFETY FACTOR = 45.99 AT 285.0 DEGREES.
45.0 1.501E+09
- 36050, 49.72 ACCEPTABLE 50.0 1.489E+09 35756.
49.32 ACCEPTABLE 55.0 1.478E+09 35487.
48.95 ACCEPTABLE 60.0 1.475E+09 35426.
48.87 ACCEPTABLE 65.0 1.461E*09 35099.
48.42 ACCEPTABLE 10.0 1.446E*09 34736.
47.92 ACCEPTA2LE 75.0 1.431E+09 34359.
47.41 ACCEPTABLE 80.0 1.419E+09 34074.
47.01 ACCEPTABLE 85.0 1.417E+09 34019.
46.94 ACCEPTABLE 90.0 1.410E+09 33868.
46.73 ACCEPTABLE 95.0 1.406E+09 33761.
46.59 ACCEPTABLE h
100.0 1.397E+09 33544.
46.29 ACCEPTABLE 105.0 1.392E+09 33426 46.13 ACCEPTABLE g
110.0 1.393E+09 33459.
46.17 ACCEPTABLE O
115.0 1.395E+09 33498.
46.23 ACCEPTABLE 7) 120.0 1.405E*09 33754 46.58 ACCEPTABLE
@w
i 10/25/1976 16:58 Filenemer U1HILE.Ctfr Paae 1
10/25/1996 16:50 Filenamet U1HILE.0Lfr P9:e 2
i i
H1 tower Emergency (2000 days)
=
125.0 1.428E*09 34304.
24.45 ACCEPTABLE DLL: DISTRIBUTED LIGAMENT LENGTH EVALUATION (REVISION: 02/27/94) 130.0 1.441E+09 34603.
24.65 ACCEPTABLE DATE OF CURRENT ANALYSIS: 10/25/1996 135.0 1.460E+09
- 35054, 24.97 ACCEPTABLE 140.0 1.488E+09 35726.
25.44 ACCEPTABLE SUP94ARY OF INPUTS:
145.0 1.525E+09 36615.
26.05 ACCEPTABLE 150.0 1.570E+09
- 37713, 26.82 ACCEPTABLE Angle increment 1.0 deg. (COARSE) 155.0 1.621E+09 38919.
27.66 ACCEPTABLE l
=
Membrane Stress, Pm 800, poi 160.0 1.656E+09 39775.
20.26 ACCEPTABLE
=
Bending Stress, Pb 636. psi 165.0 1.679E+09 40329.
28.64 ACCEPTABLE e
Ei Safety Factor. SP
=
1.50 170.0 1.690E+09 40575.
20.01 ACCEPTABLE Mean Radius, Rm 94.00 inches
=
175.0 1.609E+09 40568.
20.01 ACCEPTABLE 05s11 Thickness, L
=
1.500 inches 180.0
.1.693E+09 40654.
28.07 ACCEPTABLE Material 304 SS m
185.0 1.703E+09 4000s.
29.03 ACCEPTABLE Stress Intensity, Sm. 16900. pai 190.0 1.707E+09 40993.
29.10 ACCEPTABLE g
Fluence g
1.9E+19 n/cm*2 195.0 1.690E+09 40787.
28.96 ACCEPTABLE (Thus. LEFM evaluation not applicable) t 200.0 -
1.677E+09 40270.
28.60 ACCEPTABLE L
205.0 1.643E+09 39447.
28.03 ACCEPTABLE O
THETA 1 THETA 2 THICKNESS 210.0 1.598E+09 38302.
27.29 ACCEPTABLE REGION Ideg.)
(deg.]
(inches) 215.0 1.560E+09
- 37457, 26.64 ACCEPTABLE QQ 220.0 1.530E+09
- 36736, 26.14 ACCEPTABLE 1
14.6 26.6 1.500 225.0 1.508E+09
- 36227, 25.78 ACCEPTABLE a
+
2 31.3 57.8 1.500 230.0 1.496E+09 35932.
25.58 ACCEPTABLE Q
3 62.5 83.2 1.500 235.0 1.492E*09 35835.
25.51 ACCEPTABLE 4
93.7 115.3 1.500 l
240.0
- 1. 4 8 0 E
- 09 35540.
25.31 ACCEPTABLE 3}
5 120.7 146.0 1.500 245.0 1.461E+09 35084.
24.99 ACCEPTABLE S
{
l 6
151.3 163.9 1.500 250.0 1.444E+09 34677.
24.71 ACCEPTABLE t
1 204.6 230.3 1.500 255.0 1.423E+09 34102.
24.36 ACCEPTABLE E
i 8
244.4 249.1 1.500 260.0 1.411E+09
- 33897, 24.16 ACCEPTABLE
[
9 257.8 269.0 1.500 265.0 1.407E*09 33704.
24.08 ACCEPTABLE
.3 10 275.6 282.1 1.500 270.0 1.396E+09 33534.
23.91 ACCEPTABLE 11 207.1 296.0 1.500 275.0 1.399E+09 33603.
23.96 ACCEPTABLE
,o 12 300.7 310.9 1.500 200.0 1.391E+09 33412.
23.02 ACCEPTABLE 13 315.0 337.1 1.500 205.0 1.383E*09 33210.
23.60 ACCEPTABLE M
290.0 1.383E+09 33224.
23.69 ACCEPTABLE l%
295.0 1.301E+09 33165.
23.65 ACCEPTABLE D
LIMIT LOAD RESULTS:
300.0 1.392E+09 33421.
23.83 ACCEPTABLE O
i
..................=
305.0 1.410E+09 33864.
24.14 ACCEPTABLE 310.0 1.421E+09 34133.
24.33 ACCEPTABLE 3
ALPHA MOMENT Pb' SAFETY 315.0 1.440E+09
- 34504, 24.64 ACCEPTABLE S
(degl (in-lbs)
(poi]
FACTOR RESULT 320.0 1.468E+09 35256.
2b11 ACCEPTABLE d
l 325.0 1.505E+09 36145.
25.73 ACCEPTABLE
.0 1.630E+09 39334.
27.95 ACCEPTABLE 330.0 1.553E+09 37297.
26.53 ACCEPTABLE f
5.0 1.633E*09
- 39209, 27,06 ACCEPTABLE 335.0 1.509E+09 38159.
27.13 ACCEPTABLE l
10.0 1.639E+09 39359.
27.97 ACCEPTABLE 340.0 1.613E+09 30731.
27.53 ACCEPTABLE j
15.0 1.653E+C9
- 39687, 28.19 ACCEPTABLE 345.0 1.624E+09
- 39009, 27.72 ACCEPTABLE 20.0 1.643E+09
- 39453, 28.93 ACCEPTABLE 350.0 1.620E*09 39094.
27.70 ACCEPTABLE L
25.0 1.620E+09 38918.
27.66 ACCEPTABLE 355.0 1.634E*09 39248.
27.09 ACCEPTABLE 30.0 1.586E+09
- 38007, 27.00 ACCEPTABLE 35.0 1.547E+09 37162.
26.44 ACCEPTABLE 40.0 1.517E+09 36442.
25.93 ACCEPTABLE ACCEPTABLEl MINIMLM SAFETY FACTOR - 23.65 AT 295.0 DEGREES.
I 45.0 1.496E+09 35933.
25.58 ACCEPTABLE 50.0 1.484E+09 35630.
25.37 ACCEPTABLE 55.0 1.470E+09 35311.
25.15 ACCEPTABLE 60.0 1.469E+09 35288.
25.13 ACCEPTABLE 65.0 1.460E+09 35060.
24.97 ACCEPTABLE 70.0 1.445E*09 34697.
24.72 ACCEPTABLE 75.0 1.433E+09 34418.
24.53 ACCEPTABLE 80.0 1.421E+09 34132.
24.33 ACCEPTABLE 85.0 1.419E+09 34078.
24.29 ACCEPTABLE 90.0 1.417E+09 34034.
24.26 ACCEPTABLE D
95.0 1.406E+09 33775.
24.00
%CCEPTABLE 100.0 1.398E+09 33584.
23.94 ACCEPTABLE Q
(
105.0 1.395E+09 33504 23.89 ACCEPTABLE 110.0 1.396E+09 33530 23.91 ACCEPTABLE g
f 115.0 1.401E+09 33635.
23.90 ACCEPTABLE g
l 120.0 1.411E+09 33091.
24.16 ACCEPTABLE L
i w
b e
4
. 4
10/24/1916 11:12 Filen me: U1HILF.OiTT Pac 1
10/24/1996 11:17 Filenamer U1HILF. CUT Paese 2
e H1 Lower Faulted (2000 days) 125.0 1.428E+09 34304.
24.09 ACCEPTABLE DLL: DISTRIBITTED LIGAMENT LENGTH EVALUATION (REVISION: 02/27/94) 130.0 1.441E+09
- 34603, 24.29 ACCEPTABLE DATE OF CUR 9ENT ANALYSIS: 10/24/1996 135.0 1.460E*09 35054.
24.60 ACCEPTABLE 140.0 1.488E+09 35726.
25.06 ACCEPTABLE StM4ARY OF INPtTTS:
145.0 1.525E+09 36615.
25.67 ACCEPTABLE 150.0 1.570E*09 37713.
26.43 ACCEPTABLE Angle increment 1.0 deg. (COARSE) 155.0 1.621E*09 38919.
27.25 ACCEPTABLE Membrane Stress, Pm 816. pai 160.0 1.656E+09 39775.
27.84 ACCEPTABLE
=
Bending Stress, Pb 642, psi 165.0 1.679E+09 40329.
28.22 ACCEPTABLE i
=
Safety Factor, SF 1.39 170.0 1.690E+09
- 40575, 28.39 ACCEPTABLE
=
Mean Radius, Rm 94.00 inches 175.0 1.689E+09 40568.
28.38 ACCEPTABLE
=
W111 Thickness, t 1.500 inches 180.0 1.693E*09 40654.
28.44 ACCEPTABLE
=
m Material 304 SS 185.0 1.703E+09 40888.
28.60 ACCEPTABLE (f)
=
Stress Intensity, Sm = 16900. psi 190.0 1.707E+09 40993.
28.68 ACCEPTABLE y
Fluence
= 1.9E+19 n/cm*2 195.0 1.698E+09
- 40787, 28.53 ACCEPTABLE (Thus. LEFM evaluation not applicable) 200.0 1.677E*09 40270.
28.18 ACCEPTABLE O
205.0 1.643E+09
- 39447, 27.61 ACCEPTABLE 9
THETA 1 THETA 2 THICKNESS 210.0 1.598E*09 38382.
26.08 ACCEPTABLE O
REGION
[deg.)
(deg.)
(inches) 215.0 1.560E+09
- 37457, 26.25 ACCEPTABLE Q
220.0 1.530E+09
- 36736, 25.76 ACCEPTABLE
.a 1
14.6 26.6 1.500 225.0 1.500E+09 36227.
25.41 ACCEPTABLE C) 2 31.3 57.8 1.500 230.0 1.496E+09 35932.
25.20 ACCEPTABLE Q
3 62.5 83.2 1.500 235.0 1.492E*09 35835.
25.14 ACCEPTABLE 4
93.1 115.3 1.500 240.0 1.480E+09
- 35548, 24.94 ACCEPTABLE "I]
5 120.7 146.0 1.500 245.0
- 1. 4 61 E+ 0 9 35084.
24.62 ACCEPTABLE (D
6 151.3 163.9 1.500 250.0 1.444E+09
- 34677, 24.34 ACCEPTABLE 1
204.6 230.3 1.500 255.0 1.423E+09 34182.
24.00 ACCEPTABLE Cn 8
244.4 249.1 1.500 260.0 1.411E+09 33897.
23.81 ACCEPTABLE
{
9 257.8 269.0 1.500 265.0 1.407E*09 33784.
23.73 ACCEPTABLE 3
10 275.6 282.1 1.500 270.0 1.396E+09 33534.
23.56 ACCEPTABLE 11 287.1 296.0 1.500 275.0 1.399E+09 33603.
23.51 ACCEPTABLE h
12 300.7 310.9 1.500 280.0 1.391E+09 33412.
23.48 ACCEPTABLE 13 315.0 337.1 1.500 285.0 1.383E*09 33210.
23.34 ACCEPTABLE M
290.0 1.383E+09 33224.
23.35 ACCEPTABLE N
295.0 1.381E*09 33165.
23.31 ACCEPTABLE 19 LIMIT 14AD RESULTS:
300.0 1.392E+09 33421.
23.48 ACCEPTABLE O
305.0 1.410E+09 33864.
23.79 ACCEPTABLE 310.0 1.421E+09 34133.
23.97 ACCEPTABLE b
ALPHA HOMENT Pb' SAFETY 315.0 1.440E+09 34584 24.28 ACCEPTABLE (D
[deg]
(in-lbs)
(psil FACTOR RESULT 320.0 1.468E+09 35256.
24.74 ACCEPTABLE 3
325.0 1.505E+09 36145.
25.35 ACCEPTABLE
.0 1.638E+09
- 39334, 27.54 ACCEPTABLE 330.0 1.553E+09
- 37291, 26.14 ACCEPTABLE 5.0 1.633E+09 39209.
27.45 ACCEPTABLE 335.0 1.589E*09 38159.
26.13 ACCEPTABLE 10.0 1.639E+09 39359.
27.55 ACCEPTABLE 340.0 1.613E+09
- 38731, 27.12 ACCEPTABLE g
15.0 1.653E*09 39687.
27.78 ACCEPTABLE 345.0 1.624E+09 39009.
27.31 ACCEPTABLE 20.0 1.643E+09 39453.
27.62 ACCEPTABLE 350.0 1.628E+09 39094.
27.37 ACCEPTABLE 25.0 1.620E+09 38918.
27.25 ACCEPTABLE 355.0
- 1. 6 34 E+ 09 39248.
27.48 ACCEPTABLE 30.0 1.586E+09 38087.
26.68 ACCEPTABLE 35.0 1.547E+09
- 37162, 26.05 ACCEPTABLE 40.0 1.517E+09 36442.
25.55 ACCEPTABLE ACCEPTABLES MINIMt24 SAFETY FACTOR. 23.31 AT 295.0 DEGREES.
45.0 1.496E+09 35933.
25.20 ACCEPTABLE 50.0 1.484E+09 35638.
25.00 ACCEPTABLE 55.0 1.470E+09 35311.
24.78 ACCEPTABLE 60.0 1.469E*09 35288.
24.76 ACCEPTABLE 65.0 1.460E*09 35060.
24.61 ACCEPTABLE 70.0 1.445E+09 34697.
24.36 ACCEPTABLE 75.0 1.433E+09 34418.
24.17 ACCEPTABLE 80.0 1.421E*09 34132.
23.97 ACCEPTABLE 85.0 1.419E+09 34078.
23.93 ACCEPTABLE 90.0 1.417E+09 34034.
23.90 ACCEPTABLE
=
95.0 1.406E+09 33775.
23.73 ACCEPTABLE 100.0 1.398E+09 33584.
23.59 ACCEPTABLE 105.0 1.395E+09 33504 23.54 ACCEPTABLE D
110.0 1.396E+09 33538.
23.56 ACCEPTABLE
- D 115.0 1.401E+09 33635.
23.63 ACCEPTABLE 120.0 1.411E+09 33891.
23.00 ACCEPTABLE w
Shroud Circumferentiel Wold Structurel Evoluetl0n Ugement length Determination
=
Shroud In =
1.5 h Evel. Peded - 2000 deve rient n:
BNP1 m, y date OD-177.5 m tease -
185 m?- _._..;
Prepared en 4W IO/Jd/)l4 weid c:
_H4_
Creek Growth Ret =
SE-05 htfw Lease -
180 h tfoustedt Dm n; B111R1 Tetet hspection uncertainty =
0.00 in tmin = 189.8 in verified 8v g
e inspection Date End of Evoluotion ugement Date End of Evat. Crock Tip Input for DLL Analys4 NghFkauZone Ugement Arimuth l Arlenuth. Existing Days to Fu8y hout for DL_t _Ansiysie _ _]nt Start id]eg Stef idegt tength Oni' Aaenuth Aaimuth Upement btFe h N u Zone?
Aalsnuth Astrnuth Numter Start toegl 5,jop._Ideg) Lotypth gni Crocked _
e Animuth Asimuth Ugeme Start Stop Stort Steg_
_ Start Stop Length _.
ggg f
13.30 44 46 48.3 18861 14.8 42.9 43.5 No Yes 14.8 42.9 14.8 30.0 23.5 (p) 2 45.76 48.33 40 415 47.3 44.8 Crocked Yes Yes 3
3 57.47 70.27 29.1 10884 53 0 68.7 24.3 Yes No 53.0 68.7 60.0 64.7 13.5 Cracked 4
7 f.56 F20.4 7 75.8 30317 73.1 118.9 71.0' Yes No 127.2 16Il 150.0 161.2 17.4 No Ne 73.1 118.9 73.1 118.9 71.0 0
6 825.64 762.76 57.5 22708 127.2 161.2 52.7 6
765 34 168 02 4.2 480 166.9 166.5 Crocked No No h
7 203.30 225.32 34.1 12962 2048 2238 29.3 No Yes 204.8 223 8 204.8 210.0 80 Crocked Q
8 2266f 256 05 45 6 17751 228.2 254.5 40 8 Yes No 228 2 254.5 240 0 254.5 22.f:
=.h S
267 04 276.39 14.5 4785 268 6 274.8 9.7 No No 268.6 274.8 2686 274 8
- 9. 7 m
FP 273 62 330.92 79.5 31859 281,2 329.4 14.7 No Yes 281.2 329 4 281.2 300.0 29.2 Q
.__ f f 332.86 338 02 8.0 20do 334.4 336.5 3.2 No No 334.4 336.5 334.4 336.5 32 3m 5.
1.?o3
,O
-~
3>
O 3"
i ai3 e+
Edrep tapement length Ind =
400.4 EOE Ug. Length Ont.
349.1 EDE Lig. Length Ord =
197.8
$1nca E0E llgement lenetttjHIGlifLUXLatL:nire,a dete8ed 8mit jeed anelreis la metJteguired.
NOTE 5 (18 Lagement Dets from 8111Rt GE Enem6 nation Summary Sheets 12)
Crack growth is appNed at each end of Egement (3)
Days to Fusy Crocked - days te Egement length is sero lectusty: uncertainty + ASME crack proximiry sueel for each agement.
101 Wgh Nm Zone = silus or enmus 15 degrees from stimuthe 45,135,225 and 315 6e 30 60 etcJ (5)
Ideg = 1.54898 in (6)
Uninspected regions essawd fusy crocked. A8 cracks assumed through-wes (7)
Lesle = minumum required Roement length for limit load concems - reference Structural Integdtv report StR 94-029 Rev. 0 D
(18 Lmirs = Leste + 2tCrnt Growthin Evespotion rodods + Toted inspection uncertelnty 19)
AB Egements withm al A flus rene assurped fuey cracked for evaluation pedod.
N D
T 10/30/96 4
H4 W
BNP1CRAK.WK4
I 10/22/1996 12:55 Fileneme: U1H4N.OUT Pao
- 1 10/22/1996 12:55 Filenamet U1H4N.0LTT P*ge 2
H4 Normal / Upset (2000 days) High Flux Eones Fully Cracked 145.0 8.826E*00 24106.
19.72 ACCEPTABLE DLL: DISTRIBUTED LIGAMENT LENGTH EVALUATION (REVISION: 02/27/94) 150.0 8.996E+08 24652.
20.10 ACCEPTABLE DATE OF CURRENT ANALYSIS: 10/22/1996 155.0 9.103E*08 24945.
20.34 ACCEPTABLE 160.0 9.239E*08 25317.
20.64 ACCEPTABLE SUP9tARY OF INPUTS:
165.0 9.337E+08 25586.
20.85 ACCEPTABLE 170.0 9.364E+08 25660.
20.91 ACCEPTABLE Angle increment 1.0 deg. (COARSE) 175.0 9.320E+08 25539.
20.82 ACCEPTABLE
=
Membrane Stress, Pm 232. poi 180.0 9.303E*00 25492.
20.78 ACCEPTABLE Eending Stress. Pb 1006. pal 185.0 9.378E+00 25698.
20.94 ACCEPTABLE
.e
=
Safety Factor. SF 2.77 190.0 9.479E+08 25976.
21.17 ACCEPTABLE
=
Mean Radius, Rm 88.00 inches 195.0 9.5098+08 26057.
21.23 ACCEPTABLE
=
Wall Thickness, t 1.500 inches 200.0 9.4665+00 25939.
21.14 ACCEPTABLE 371
=
Material 304 SS 205.0 9.351E+08 25624.
20.89 ACCEPTABLE
(/)
=
Stress Intensity. Sm = 16900, psi 210.0 9.165E+08 25114.
20.47 ACCEPTABLE 2
Fluence 2.2E+19 n/ca'2 215.0 0.909E+08
- 24413, 19.91 ACCEPTABLE i
(Thus. LEFM evaluation not applicable) 220.0 0.585Ee00 23526.
19.19 ACCEPTABLE 225.0 8.162E+08 22366.
18.25 ACCEPTABLE THETA 1 THETA 2 THICKNESS 230.0 7.949E+08
- 21784, 17.10 ACCEPTABLE O
REGION
[deg.]
(deg.]
(inches]
235.0 7.642E+08 20941.
17.10 ACCEPTABLE O
240.0 7.276E+08
- 19939, 16.29 ACCEPTABLE
=A 1
14.9 30.0 1.500 245.0 6.057E+08 18790.
15.37 ACCEPTABLE G
2 60.0 68.7 1.500 250.0 6.489E+08 17783.
14.55 ACCEPTABLE O
3 13.1 118.9 1.500 255.0 6.217E+08 17036.
13.95 ACCEPTABLE 4
150.0 161 2 1.500 260.0 6.015E+08 16648.
13.63 ACCEPTABLE 3
5 204.9 210.0 1.500 265.0 5.959E+00 16329.
13.38 ACCEPTABLE 6
240.0 254.5 1.500 270.0 5.026E+08 15965.
13.08 ACCEPTABLE I.
E 7
268.6 274.8 1.500 275.0 5.812E+00
- 15926, 13.05 ACCEPTABLE E
8 281.2 300.0 1.500 280.0 5.830E+08 15975.
13.09 ACCEPTABLE O
9 334.4 336.5 1.500 285.0 5.982E+00 16393.
13.43 ACCEPTABLE l3
{
i 290.0 6.267E+08 17174.
14.06 ACCEPTABLE
,O 295.0 6.603E+08 19314.
14.90 ACCEPTABLE LIMIT 14AD RESULTS:
300.0 7.120E+C8 19510.
15.95 ACCEPTABLE 305.0 7.502E+08 20550.
16.79 ACCEPTABLE 310.0 7.827E+08 21449.
17.51 ACCEPTABLE N
ALPHA MO8+ENT Pb' SAFETY 315.0 8.126E*08 22260.
18.17 ACCEPTABLE E
(deg)
[in- 's)
[ psi)
FACTOR RESULT 320.0 8.396E+00 23000.
18.77 ACCEPTABLE h
325.0 0.602E+00 23573.
19.23 ACCEPTABLE
.0 9.129E+08
- 25016, 20.39 ACCEPTABLE 330.0 8.743E+08 23958.
19.54 ACCEPTABLE I
5.0 9.204E+08
- 25221, 20.56 ACCEPTABLE 335.0 8.833E+08 24206.
19.74 ACCEPTABLE 10.0 9.274E+08 25413.
20.71 ACCEPTABLE 340.0 8.974E+08 24592.
20.05 ACCEPTABLE n
i 15.0 9.273E*00 25411.
20.71 ACCEPTABLE 345.0 9.101E+08 24939.
20.33 ACCEPTABLE 20.0 9.202E+08 25215.
20.56 ACCEPTABLE 350.0 9.158E+08 25097.
20.46 ACCEPTABLE 25.0 9.109E+08 24962.
20.35 ACCEPTABLE 355.0 9.146E+08 25063.
20.43 ACCEPTABLE 30.0 0.953E+08 24534 20.01 ACCEPTABLE g
35.0 8.729E+08 23920.
19.51 ACCEPTABLE 40.0 8.430E+08 23123.
10.86 ACCEPTABLE ACCEPTABLEI MINIMLDt SAFETY FACIVR. 13.05 AT 275.0 DEGREES.
45.0 8 028E+08 21999.
17.96 ACCEPTABLE 50.0 1.829E+08 21454.
17.52 ACCEPTABLE 55.0 7.557E*00
- 20707, 16,91 ACCEPTABLE 60.0 7.226E+00 19802.
16.18 ACCEPTABLE 65.0 6.841E+08 18746.
15.33 ACCEPTABLE 70.0 6.446E+08 17665.
14.46 ACCEPTABLE 75.0 6.174E+08 16918.
13.85 ACCEPTABLE 80.0 6.032E+08 16530.
13.54 ACCEPTABLE 05.0 5.952E+08 16310.
13.36 ACCEPTABLE i
90.0 5.840E+08 16004.
13.11 ACCEPTABLE 95.0 5.840E+08 16004.
13.11 ACCEPTABLE 100.0 5.866E+08 16074.
13.17 ACCEPTABLE 105.0 6.018E+08 16491.
13.51 ACCEPTABLE Q
110.0 6.303E*08 17272.
14.14 ACCEPTABLE 115.0 6.719E*08 19412.
15.06 ACCEPTABLE
~
120.0 7.191B+08 19706.
16.10 ACCEPTABLE h
125.0 7.608E+08 20849.
17.03 ACCEPTABLE i
130.0 7.960E+08 21834 17.82 ACCEPTABLE D
135.0 8.207E*06 22708.
18.53 ACCEPTABLE M
140.0 8.509E+08 23537.
19.20 ACCEPTABLE l
I 53) t
~
20/30/1996 13:52 Filen me: U1H4E ATJT P*ge 1
10/30/1996 13:52 Filenamer U1H4E.C7JT P+03 2
H4 Emergency (2000 days) High Flux Eones Fully Cracked 145.0 9.038E+08 24766.
11.84 ACCEPTABLE DLL: DISTRIBLTTED LICAMEtrT LENGTH EVALUATION (REVISION: 02/27/94) 150.0 9.238E+08 25314.
12.09 ACCEPTABLE DATE OF CURRENT 8UfALYSIS: 10/25/1996 155.0 9.367E+08 25669.
12.26 ACCEPTABLE SO94ARY OF INPtTTS:
160.0 9.4 92E+ 08 26010.
12.42 ACCEPTABLE 165.0 9.561E+08 26199.
12.50 ACCEPTABLE 170.0 9.557E*08 26189.
12.50 ACCEPTABLE Angle increment 1.0 deg. (COARSEI
=
175.0 9.487E+0B 25997 12.41 ACCEPTABLE Membrane Stress. Pm 821. poi
=
180.0 9.470E*04 25950.
12.39 ACCEPTABLE Bending Stress. Pb 1340. psi
=
185.0 9.545E+08
- 26156, 12.48 ACCEPTABLE t
Safety Factor. SF 1.50
=
190.0 9.613E+08 26343.
12.57 ACCEPTABLE Mean Radius. Rm 88.00 inches
=
195.0 9.608E+08 26329.
12.56 ACCEPTABLE Wall Thickness. t
=
1.500 inches 290.0 9.530E+08 26116.
12.46 ACCEPTABLE Material 304 SS
=
m 205.0 9.320E+08 25703 12.27 ACCEPTABLE Stress Intensity. Sm = 16900, pei (f) 210.0 9.201E+08 25213.
12.05 ACCEPTABLE Fluence
= 2.2E+19 n/ce"2 3
215.0 8.981E+08
- 24609, 11.77 ACCEPTABLE (Thus LErM evaluation not applicable) 220.0 8.692E+08 23818.
11.40 ACCEPTABLE 225.0 8.289E+08 22714.
10.89 ACCEPTABLE O
THETA 1 THETA 2 THICKNESS 230.0 8.056E*08 22075.
10.60 ACCEPTABLE REGION (deg.)
(deg.1 (inches)
O 235.0 7.713E+08 21137.
10.16 ACCEPTABLE Q
240.0 7.312E+08 20037.
9.65 ACCEPTABLE 1
14.9 30.0 1.500 a
245.0 6.879E+08 18849.
9.10 ACCEPTABLE Q
2 60.0 68.7 1.500 250.0 6.525E+08 17881.
8.65 ACCEPTABLE Q
3 73.1 118.9 1.500 255,0 6.253E+08 17134.
8.31 ACCEPTABLE 4
150.0 161.2 1.500 260.0 6.104E+08
- 16727, 8.12 ACCEPTABLE 2
5 204.9 210.0 1.500 265.0 5.943E+08 16285.
7.92 ACCEPTABLE (D
6 240.0 254.5 1.500 270.0 5.804E*08 15906.
1.74 ACCEPTABLE 7
268.6 274.5 1.500 275.0 5.769E+08 15808.
7.69 ACCEPTABLE f.o 8
281.2 300.0 1.500 280.0 5.787E+08 15858.
7.72 ACCEPTABLE 6*
9 334.4 336.5 1.500 285.0 5.939E+08 16275.
7.91 ACCEPTABLE
.3 290.0 6.224E+08 17056.
8.27 ACCEPTABLE LIMIT LOAD RESULTS:
295.0 6.633E+08 18377.
8.79 ACCEPTABLE
,o 300.0 7.034E+08 19276.
9.30 ACCEPTABLE
=..................
305.0 7.382E+08
- 20228, 9.74 ACCEPTABLE M
310.0 7.673E+08 21027.
10.11 ACCEPTABLE ALPHA MOMENT Pb' SAFETY 315.0 7.952E*00 21791.
10.46 ACCEPTABLE 03 (degl (in-lbs)
(ps11 FACIOR RESULT 320.0 8.191E+08 22444.
10.77 ACCEPTABLE O
325.0 8.366E+08 22926.
10.99 ACCEPTABLE
.0 8.949E+08 24522.
11.73 ACCEPTABLE 330.0 8.479E+08 23234.
11.13 ACCEPTABLE 3
5.0 9.017E+08 24710.
11.01 ACCEPTABLE 335.0 0.558E*04 23452.
11.23 ACCEPTABLE O
10.0 9.056E*00 24816.
11.86 ACCEPTABLE 340.0 8.699E+08 23839.
11.41 ACCEPTABLE 3
15.0 9.026E*08 24733.
11.82 ACCEPTABLE 345.0 0.854E+08 24261.
11.61 ACCEPTABLE 20.0 8.932E+08 24476.
11.71 ACCEPTABLE 350.0 8.941E*08 24500.
11.72 ACCEPTABLE 25.0 8.856E*08 24269.
11.61 ACCEPTABLE 355.0 8.959E+08 24551.
11.74 ACCEPTABLE 30.0 8.729E+08 23921.
11.45 ACCEPTABLE 35.0 0.536E+08 23391.
11.20 ACCEPTABLE g
40.0 8.277E+08 22683.
10.88 ACCEPTABLE ACCEPTABLEI MINIMUM SAFETY FACTOR -
7.69 AT 275.0 DEGREES.
45.0 7.887E*08
- 21614, 10.38 ACCEPTABLE 50.0 1.682E+08 21051.
10.12 ACCEPTABLE 55.0 7.423E+08 20340.
9.79 ACCEPTABLE 60.0 7.127E+08 19529.
9.42 ACCEPTABLE 65.0 6.777E+08 18570.
0.97 ACCEPTABLE 70.0 6.396E+08 17528.
8.49 ACCEPTABLE 75.0 6.124E+08 16781.
8.15 ACCEPTABLE 80.0 5.982E+08 16393.
7.97 ACCEPTABLE 85.0 5.930E+08 16251.
7.90 ACCEPTABLE 90.0 5.848E+08 16024.
7.79 ACCEPTABLE 95.0 5.855E+08 16043.
7.80 ACCEPTABLE 200.0 5.894E*08 16152.
7.85 ACCEPTABLE 105.0 6.047E+08 16569.
8.05 ACCEPTABLE 110.0 6.332E+08 17351.
8.41 ACCEPTABLE 115.0 6.748E+08 18491.
8.94 ACCEPTABLE "h""'
120.0 7.248Ee00 19863.
9.57 ACCEPTABLE 125.0 7.701E+08 21103.
10.15 ACCEPTABLE 130.0 8.095E+08 22182.
10.64 ACCEPTABLE O
135.0 8.434E+08 23112.
11.07 ACCEPTABLE g
140.0 8.769E+08 24030.
If.50 ACCEPTABLE Wu
10/27/1f96 12:57 Filen+me r U1H4F. CUT Pece 1
10/22/1996 12:57 Filenamet U1H4F. CUT Ptge 2
H4 Faulted (2000 days) High Flux Eones Fully Cracked 145.0 9.038E+08 24766.
11.54 ACCEPTABLE DLL: DISTRIBUTED LIGAMENT LENGTH EVALUATION (REVISION: 02/27/94) 150.0 9.238E+08 25314.
11.79 ACCEPTABLE DATE OF CURRENT ANALYSIS: 10/22/1996 155.0 9.367E+08
- 25659, 11.95 ACCEPTABLE 160.0 9.492E+08 26010.
12.10 ACCEPTABLE StM1ARY OF INPUTS:
165.0 9.561E+08 26199.
12.19 ACCEPTABLE 170.0 9.557E+08 26109.
12.18 ACG PTABLE Angle increment 1.0 deg. (CCARSE) 175.0 9.487E+08 25997.
12.10 ACCEPTABLE l
Membrane Stress. Pm 842. psi 180.0 9.470E*00 25950.
12.07 ACCEPTABLE Bending Stress. Pb 1177. pol 185.0 9.545E+08 26156.
12.17 ACCEPTABLE J
Safety Factor. SF 1.39 190.0 9.613E+08 26343.
12.25 ACCEPTABLE Mean Radius. Rm 88.00 inches
=
195.0 9.600E+08 26329.
12.24 ACCEPTABLE Wall Thickness, t
=
1.500 inches 200.0 9.530E*00 26116.
12.15 ACCEPTABLE Material 304 SS m
205.0 9.380E+08 25703.
11.96 ACCEPTABLE Stress Intensity. Sm = 16900. psi 210.0 9.201E*08 25213.
11.74 ACCEPTABLE (p)
Fluence 2.2E+19 n/cm*2 y
215.0 0.981E+08 24609.
11.47 ACCEPTABLE (Thus. LEFM evaluation not applicable) 220.0 8.692E*08
- 23818, 11.11 ACCEPTABLE 225.0 8.289Ee00 22714.
10.62 ACCOTABLE f
THETA 1 THETA 2 THICKNESS 230.0 8.056E+08 22075.
10.33 ACCEPTABLE REGION (deg.)
(deg.)
(inches) 235.0 7.713E+08 21137.
9.90 ACCEPTABLE Q
Q 240.0 7.312E+08 20037.
9.41 ACCEPTABLE 1
14.9 30.0 1.500 245.0 6.879E+08
- 18849, 8.07 ACCEPTABLE Q
a 2
60.0 68.7 1.500 250.0 6.525E+08 17881.
8.44 ACCEPTABLE O
3 73.1 118.9 1.500 255.0 6.253E+08 17134.
8.10 ACCEPTABLE 4
150.0 161.2 1.500 260.0 6.104E+08 16727.
7.92 ACCEPTABLE 3
5 204.9 210.0 1.500 265.0 5.943E+08 16285.
7.72 ACCEPTABLE S
6 240.0 254.5 1.500 270,0 5.804E*08 15906.
7.55 ACCEPTABLE 7
268.6 274.0 1.500 275.0 5.769E+08 15808.
7.50 ACCEPTABLE (p
8 281.2 300.0 1.500 280.0 5.787E+08 15858.
7.53 ACCEPTABLE 6*
9 334.4 336.5 1.500 i
285.0 5.939E+08 16275.
7.71 ACCEPTABLE
.}
290.0 6.224E+08 17056.
0.07 ACCEPTABLE LIMIT 14AD RESULTS:
295.0 6.633E+08 18177.
8.57 ACCEPTABLE
,o 300.0 7.034E+08 19276.
9.07 ACCEPTABLE 305.0 7.382E+08 20228.
9.50 ACCEPTABLE.
M I
310.0 7.673E+08 21027.
9.86 ACCEPTABLE ALPHA MOMENT Pb' SAFETY 315.0 7.952E+08 21791.
10.20 ACCEPTABLE S
(degl lin-lbs)
(psi)
FACTOR RESULT 320.0 0.191E+08 22444.
10.49 ACCEPTABLE O
325.0 8.366E*00 22926.
10.71 ACCEPTABLE 7
.0 0.949E+08 24522.
11.43 ACCEPTABLE 330.0 0.479E+08 23234.
10.85 ACCEPTABLE 3
5.0 9.017E+08 24710.
11.52 ACCEPTABLE 335.0 8.558E+08 23452.
10.95 ACCEPTABLE S
10.0 9.056E+08
- 24816, 11.56 ACCEPTABLE 340.0 0.699E+08 23839.
11.12 ACCEPTABLE k
15.0 9.026E+08
- 24733, 11.53 ACCEPTABLE 345.0 8.854E+08 24261.
11.31 ACCEPTABLE 20.0 8.932E+08 24476.
11.41 ACCEPTABLE 350.0 8.941E+08 24500.
11.42 ACCEPTABLE 25.0 8.856E+08 24269.
11.32 ACCEPTABLE 355.0 8.959E+08 24551.
11.44 ACCEPTABLE 30.0 8.729E+08 23921.
11.16 ACCEPTABLE 35.0 8.536E+08 23391.
10.92 ACCEPTABLE 40.0 8.277E+08 22683.
10.60 ACCEPTABLE ACCEPTABLEI MINIMUM SAFETY FACTOR.
7.50 AT 275.0 DEGREES.
45.0 7.887E+08
- 21614, 10.12 ACCEPTABLE 50.0 7.682E+08 21051.
9.87 ACCEPTABLE 55.0 7.423E+08 20340.
9.55 ACCEPTABLE i
60.0 7.127E+08 19529.
9.18 ACCEPTABLE t
65.0 6.777E+08 18570.
4.75 ACCEPTABLE 10.0 6.396E+08 17528.
8.28 ACCEPTABLE
=
75.0 6.124E+08 16781.
7.94 ACCEPTABLE 80.0 5.982E+08 1093.
7.77 ACCEPTABLE r
85.0 5.930E+08 16151.
7.70 ACCEPTABLE i
90.0 5.848E+08 16024 7.60 ACCEPTABLE 95.0 5.855E+08
- 16043, 7.61 ACCEPTABLE 100.0 5.894E*08 16152.
7.66 ACCEPTABLE 105.0 6.047E+C8 16569.
7.85 ACCEPTABLE 110.0 6.332E*08 17351.
8.20 ACCEPTABLE g
115.0 6.748E+08 18491.
8.71 ACCEPTABLE i
120.0 7.248E+08 19863.
9.33 ACCEPTABLE I
125.0 7.701E+08 21103.
9.89 ACCEPTABLE 130.0 8.095E*08 22182.
10.38 ACCEPTABLE 135.0 0.434E+08 23112.
10.79 ACCEPTABLE i
140.0 0.769E+08 24030.
11.21 ACCEPTABLE g
=
hm r
o Shioud Circumferential. Weld _ Structural Evaluetion UgementlenetttDetermination Shroud tn =
1.5 in Evel Peried =
2000 deve date rient ID. '
BNPL co-177.5 an Leste =
214 in tupeevneemt Propered e f 8pd/f(o weed ID:
HS Creek Growth Rote =
5E-05 inne traic =
202 in tesumed Date ID:
811116 Tetsi inspecean uncensinty =
0.00 in Lain = 218.8 in vedfied ey-I*"U-Q w
.I High Nu Zone inspect 6en Deve End of Evstuetten Usament Date End of Evel. Crack Tip input for DLL Analysen eput for Ott Anstyshi Ligament Astrnuth Asemuth Esisting Deys te Fuey Azimuth { Aatmuth Ugement j tegh Na Zone?
Asimuth Aalenuth Aatmutet Aalmuth Ligement Number Start,fdegl $gdegl. Lg Onl Cracke_d Start idegl Stop (dogLg_Dnl
__ Start
$ top Start Step Start Step tength ITV f
73.30 52.79 61.2 24237 14.8 51.2 56.4 No Yes 14 0 51.2
(/)
2
- 54. 7 f 7 f.49 26.0 9500
$6.3 89.9 fi f Yes No
$4.3 69 9' 3
3 13.40 74.68 2.0 Crocked Cracked 4
7did 80 #s e.e 15it 7s.i 79.3 1.8 No No O
5 82 87 84_09 2.0 Crocked.
Cracked This TableNot ApplicMe for 6
86.02 700.24 22.0 7926 87.6 98.7 17.2, No Yes 104.4 120.7 EvolustionPeriod Q
No No 07.8 98.7 Wald H5 dJring__2_000,dey Q
7 f 02.8f 730 24 42.5 16454 104.4 128.7 37.7 F34 09 F35. f 0 1.6 Crocked Cinched
=4 9
f 38 95
- 40. F 5 1.9 C ecked Crocked Q
o
- 0
- 4 77 i7 557 6 13.1 Uti 148.8 154.1 8.3 Yes No 140 0 154.1 O
ff 763.37 f 64. 65 2.0 Crea ted Cracked 72 20J 30 209.74 10 0 2936 204.8 208.2 5.2 No No 204.8 208.2 3
- 3 2f f.67 273.67 30 2) 213.2 212.1 Crocked Yes Yes S
74 2f 5.54 2 f 5.14 0.3 Crocked Cracked 1
- 5 2 f 7.68 2JO 87 20.3 7224 219.2 229 3 15.5 Yes Yes 219.2 229.3 rA rs 234 03 257.98 37.1 14200 7 35.0 255.4 32.3' Yes No 235.8 254.4 6*
- 7 268.30 27566 11.4 3500 269 8 274.1 S.O No No 269.8 274.1 3
78 293 37 296 94 5.5 1054 294 9 295.4 0.7 No No
,O 79 298 23 J#0.76 18.5 6450 2998 300 8 13.7 No Yes 2998 308.8 20 3f f.45 J f 4 03 4.0 415 313.0 312.5 Cracked Yes Yes
~
M 27 377.25 337.98 32.1 12129' 318.8 338.4 27.3 Yes No 318.8 336.4
~
N D
O7 i
3m 3c+
t feisemp tapement length fmf =
323.0 EOE Lig. Length gni.
243.9 Since EOtLilomenentLenetit2 Lmitta.deteRedSmitleed enelvolabtetfeguked.
NOTES (1)
Ugement Data from 8111R1 GE Enem6 notion Summery Sheets (2)
Crack growth le opplied et each end of ligament (2)
Days to FiJy Crocked = days te hgement length is more tectusty: uncertainty + ASME crack proximity rulel for each 5gement.
tal Weh Na Zone = plus or minus 15 degrees from animuthe 45,135,225 and 315 lie 3460 etc.)
(5)
Idog = 1.54898 in (6)
Uninspected regions assumed fusy cracked. A5 cracks assuned through-wee
_- required Egement length for kmit load concems reference Structural integnty report $16-04-029 fiev. O (7)
Lcolc =. _.
13 Lnun = Leelc + 2tCrock Growth in Evesuetion Periodt + Tetet enspection uncertainty
~(
O T1 10/30/96 un H5 BNPICRAK.WK4
~
10/27/1996 14:16 Filename: U1H5N. C'Jr P*qe 1
10/22/1996 14:16 Filen+mer U1H5N.OUT Pece 2
HS Normal / Upset (2000 days) 135.0 1.001E+09 27430.
13.67 ACCEPTABLE I
DLL: DISTRIBUTED LIGAMENT LENGTH EVALUATION (REVISION: 02/27/94) 140.0 1.032E+09 20260.
14.09 ACCEPTABLE i
DATE OF CURRENT ANALYSIS: 10/22/1996 145.0 1.058E+09 29003.
14.45 ACCEPTABLE 150.0 1.077E+09 29517.
14.71 ACCEPTABLE StM4ARY OF INPUTS:
155.0 1.088E+09 29807.
14.85 ACCEPTABLE j
160.0 1.092E*09
- 29917, 14.91 ACCEPTABLE Angle increment 1.0 deg. (COARSE) 165.0 1.100E*09 30147.
15.02 ACCEPTABLE
[
=
Membrane Stress. Pm 207. poi 170.0 1.106E*09
- 30306, 15.10 ACCEPTABLE
=
l Gending Stress. Pb 1914. ps!
175.0 1.103E*09 30234.
15.06 ACCEPTABLg
.s
=
Saf ety Factor. SF
=
2.77 100.0 1.102E*09 30195.
15.04 ACCEPTABLE Mean Radius. Rm 80.00 inches 185.0 1.102E+09 30191.
15.04 ACCEPTABLE
=
1:all Thickness, t 1.500 inches 190.0 1.093E*09 29957.
14.93 ACCEPTABLE m
(
=
Material 304 SS 195.0 1.076E+09 29495.
14.70 ACCEPTABLE
(/) -
{
=
Stress Intensity. Sm = 16900. ps!
200.0 1.051E+09 20000.
14.36 ACCEPTABLE 3
i Fluence
= 2.2E+19 n/ca"2 205.0 1.018E+09 27902.
13.91 ACCEPTABLE (Thus LEFM evaluation not applicable) 210.0 9.046E*00 26901.
13.45 ACCEPTABLE E
215.0 9.490E+08 26006.
12.97 ACCEPTABLE f
THETA 1 THETA 2 THICKNESS 220.0 9.168E+08
- 25122, 12.53 ACCEPTABLE Q
REGION
[deg.]
[deg.]
[incheel 225.0 8.954E+00 24537.
12.24 ACCEPTABLE Q
{
230.0 0.765E+08 24019.
11.99 ACCEPTABLE A
+
1 14.9 51.2 1.500 235.0 8.666E+08 23747.
11.85 ACCEPTABLE 0) 2 56.3 69.9 1.500 240.0 8.672E+08 23763.
11.06 ACCEPTABLE O
'I 3
87.6 98.7 1.500 245.0 0.691E*08 23816.
11.89 ACCEPTABLE 4
104.4 128.1 1.500 250.0 0.839E+00 24222.
12.09 ACCEPTABLE 2
[
5 140.8 154.1 1.500 255.0 9.061E*00 24830.
12.39 ACCEPTABLE S
i 6
204.9 208.2 1.500 260.0 9.219E+08 25262.
12.60 ACCEPTABLE 1
219.2 229.3 1.500 265.0 9.391E+00 25734.
12.84 ACCEPTABLE 44 8
235.6 256.4 1.500 270.0 9.491E+00 26009.
12.97 ACCEPTABLE 6*
9 269.9 274.1 1.500 275.0 9.584E+08 26263.
13.10 ACCEPTABLE l2 10 299.8 300.6 1.500 280.0 9.611E+C8 26337.
13.13 ACCEPTABLE 11 318.8 336.4 1.500 285.0 9.513E+C6 26069.
13.00 ACCEPTABLE
.O 290.0 9.515E+08 26075.
13.00 ACCEPTABLE 295.0 9.659E+00 26468.
13.20 ACCEPTABLE LIMIT 14AD RESULTS:
300.0 9.705E*00
- 26595, 13.26 ACCEPTABLE N
305.0 9.671E+00 26501.
13.22 ACCEPTABLE E
h 310.0 9.792E+08 26833.
13.38 ACCEPTABLE ALPHA MOMENT Pb' SAFETY 315.0 1.001E+09 27430.
13.67 ACCEPTABLE (degl (in-lbe)
[psil FAC70R RESULT 320.0 1.030E+09 28446.
14.18 ACCEPTABLE b
325.0 1.067E+09 29227.
14.56 ACCEPTABLE 8
.0 1.102E+09 30195.
15.04 ACCEPTABLE 330.0 1.087E+09 23786.
14.84 ACCEPTABLE k
5.0 1.109E+09 30398.
15.14 ACCEPTABLE 335.0 1.099E+09 30110.
15.00 ACCEPTABLE 10.0 1.099E+09 30117.
15.00 ACCEPTABLE 340.0 1.092E+09 29917.
14.91 ACCEPTABLE 15.0 1.080E*09 29607.
14.75 ACCEPTABLE 345.0 1.112E+09 30474.
15.18 ACCEPTABLE 20.0 1.054E+09 20072.
14.39 ACCEPTABLE 350.0 1.116E+09 30592.
15.24 ACCEPTABLE 25.0 1.019E+09 27917.
13.92 ACCEPTABLE 355.0 1.103E+09 30234.
15.06 ACCEPTABLE 30.0 9.846E+08 26981.
13.45 ACCEPTABLE 35.0 9.454E+08 25900.
12.92 ACCEPTABLE 40.0 9.132E+08 25024.
12.48 ACCEPTABLE ACCEPTABLEl MINIMUM SAFETY FAC1VR = 11.78 AT 55.0 DEGREES.
45.0 8.934E+08 24403.
12.22 ACCEPTABLE 50.0 8.708E+08 23862.
11.91 ACCEPTABLE 55.0 8.609E+08 23591.
11.78 ACCEPTABLE 60.0 8.640E+08 23699.
11.83 ACCEPTABLE 65.0 8.691E+08 23816.
11.09 ACCEPTABLE 70.0 8.839E+08 24222.
12.09 ACCEPTABLE 75.0 9.027E*08 24737.
12.34 ACCEPTABLE 80.0 9.133E+08 25020.
12.49 ACCEPTABLE 85.0 9.364E*08 25660.
12.80 ACCEPTABLE
[
90.0 9.482E+08 25904.
12.96 ACCEPTABLE 95.0 9.561E+08 26199.
13.07 ACCEPTABLE 100.0 9.570E+00 26224.
13.08 ACCEPTABLE 105.0 9.513E+08 26069.
13.00 ACCEPTABLE 110.0 9.515E+08 26075.
13.00 ACCEPTABLE
.J 115.0 9.597E*08 26299.
13.12 ACCEPTABLE 120.0 9.640E+08 26417.
13.17 ACCEPTABLE D
125.0 9.671E*08 26501.
13.22 ACCEPTABLE 130.0 9.792E*08 26833.
13.38 ACCEPTABLE y
NW
~
.. -- n.
~ -,
e
- + - -
10/25/1976 17:03 F11*n*me r U1 HSE.0tTT Page 1
10/25/1996 17:03 Filenamer U1H5E.0LTT Page 2
H5 Emergency (2000 days) 135.0 1.013E+09 27759.
B.05 ACCEPTABLE DLL: DISTRIBUTED LIGAMENT LENGTH EVALUATION (REVISION: 02/27/941 140.0 1.044E+09
- 20616, 9.11 ACCEPTABLE DATE OP CURREtrr ANALYSIS: 10/25/1996 145.0 1.074E+09 29443.
9.37 ACCEPTABLE 150.0 1.096E+09 30046.
5.55 ACCEPTABLE I
StP94ARY OF INPtTIS:
155.0 1.110E+09 30420.
9.67 ACCEPTABLE 160.0 1.116E+09 30579.
9.12 ACCEPTABLE Angle increment 1.0 deg. (COA *SE) 165.0 1.124E+09
- 30793, 9.79 ACCEPTABLE
=
Membrane Strees Pm 795. poi 170.0 1.126E+09 30869.
9.81 ACCEPTABLE
=
Bending Stress. Pb
=
2433. pei 175.0 1.121E+09 30728.
9.77 ACCEPTABLE J
Safety Factor, SF 1.50 100.0 1.120E+09 30609.
9.75 ACCEPTABLE
=
Mean Radius, Rm 38.00 inches 105.0 1.116E+09 30595.
9.72 ACCEPTABLE i
Wall Thickness, t 1.500 inches 190.0 1.105E+09-30267.
9.62 ACCEPTABLE f71
=
teaterial 304 SS 195.0 1.004E+09 29710.
9.45 ACCEPTABLE M
Etress Intensity, Se = 16900. psi 200.0 1.056E+09 20926.
9.21 ACCEPTABLE 2
Fluence
= 2.2E+19 n/cm*2 205.0 1.019E*09 27922.
0.90 ACCEPTABLE (Thus. LEFM evaluation not applicable) 210.0 9.841E+08 26966.
B.60 ACCEPTABLE gg 215.0 9.454E+08 25900.
8.27 ACCEPTABLE THETA 1 THETA 2 THICKNESS 220.0 9.132E+08 25024 8.00 ACCEPTABLE O
+
REGION (deg.)
[deg.)
(inches) 225.0 0.911E+00 24419.
7.81 ACCEPTABLE O
t 230.0 8.709E+0e 23462.
7.64 ACCEPTABLE d
1 14.9 51.2 1.500 235.0 S.609E+08 23591.
1.55 ACCEPTABLE O
2 56.3 69.9 1.500 240.0 0.621E*08 23625.
7.57 ACCEPTABLE
,o 3
47.6 98.7 1.500 245.0 e.640Esos 23699.
7.59 ACCEPTABLE 4
104.4 128.7 1.500 250.0 8.796E*08 24104 1.71 ACCEPTABLE 2
5 148.0 154.1 1.500 255.0 0.990E+08 24534.
7.88 ACCEPTABLE O
[
6 204.9 200.2 1.500 260.0 9.133E+08 25028.
8.00 ACCEPTABLE 6.
7 219.2 229.3 1.500 265.0 9.334E*0s 25577.
8.17 ACCEPTABLE f
8 235.6 256.4 1.500 270.0 9.470E+08 25950.
8.29 ACCEPTABLE O
9 269.9 274.1 1.500 275.0 9.534E*00 26126.
8.34 ACCEPTABLE 3
to 299.8 300.6 1.500 200.0 9.525E+0s
- 26102, 8.33 ACCEPTABLE t
11 310.0 336.4 1.500 205.0 9.4 00E+ 00 25758.
3.23 ACCEPTABLE
.O s
290.0 9.402E+08 25764.
8.23 ACCEPTABLE I
p 295.0 9.532E+08 26120.
8.34 ACCEPTABLE LIMIT 1 DAD RESULTS:
300.0 9.572E+0e 26229.
0.37 ACCEPTABLE N
t
..................=
(
305.0 9.544E+00 26153.
0.35 ACCEPTABLE 310.0 9.665E+08 26485.
8.45 ACCEPTABLE 3-l ALPHA MOMEff?
Pb' SAFETY 315.0 9.803E+08 27002.
0.64 ACCEPTABLE g
[
[deg)
[in-lbs)
[psil FACTOR RESULT 320.0 1.025E+09 29000.
0.95 ACCEPTABLE g
325.0 1.050E+09 28769.
9.16 ACCEPTABLE
.0 1.003E+09 29684.
3.44 ACCEPTABLE 330.0 1.067E+09 29240.
9.30 ACCEPTABLE ro 3
5.0 1.094E+09 29975.
9.53 ACCEPTABLE 335.0 1.076E+09 29408.
9.30 ACCEPTABLE I
10.0 1.007E*09 29708.
9.47 ACCEPTABLE 340.0 1.067E*09 29239.
5.30 ACCEPTABLE I
'15.0 1.072E*09 29373.
9.35 ACCEPTABLE 345.0 1.075E+09 29469.
9.38 ACCEPTABLE 20.0 1.049E+09 20735.
9.15 ACCEPTABLE 350.0 1.095E+09 30011.
9.54 ACCEPTABLE N
25.0 1.017E+09 27878.
8.88 ACCEPTABLE 355.0 1.094E+09 29902.
9.53 ACCEPTABLE l
30.0 9.832E+08 26941.
0.59 ACCEPTABLE
[
35.0 9.506E+08 26050.
8.32 ACCEPTABLE
[
40.0 9.168E+08 25122.
0.03 ACCEPTABLE ACCEPTABLEl MINIMLN SAFETY FACTOR =
7.55 AT 235.0 DEGREES.
l 45,0 0.954E*08 24537 7.85 ACCEPTABLE 50.0 8.765E*00 24019.
7.69 ACCEPTABLE F
i 55.0 8.666E+08 23747.
7.60 ACCEPTABLE 60.0 e.691E+09 23017.
1.62 ACCEPTABLE 65.0 8.727E+08 23915.
7.65 ACCEPTABLE 70.0 0.875E+08 24320.
7.78 ACCEPTABLE 15.0 9.092E*08 24913.
7.96 ACCEPTABLE 00.0 9.219E+08 25262.
3.07 ACCEPTABLE
[L 85.0 9.414E+00 25797.
E.24 ACCEPTABLE 90.0 9.491E*00 26009.
8.30 ACCEPTABLE 95.0 9.604E+00 26317 0.40 ACCEPTABLE 100.0 9.640E*0s 26439.
e.44 ACCEPTABLE 105.0 9.620E+08 26361.
0.41 ACCEPTABLE 110.0 9.622E+08 26367.
8.41 ACCEPTABLE j
115.0 9.704E+08 26590.
8.48 ACCEPTABLE D
120.0 9.760E+08 26746.
8.53 ACCEPTABLE
- II
[
125.0 9.791E+00 26830.
0.56 ACCEPTABLE 130.0 9.912E+00 27163.
0.66 ACCEPTABLE
_G8 b
r
- - - - - - - -, - - - ~
~-n, n,nm
~ - -. - - ~ ~,
-e-e
10/22/1996 14:10 Filen"ser U1H5 F. C17T Paae 1
10/22/1996 14:10 Filenamet U1H5 F. Otfr Page 2
HS Faulted (2000 days) 215.0 1.013E+09 27759.
8.46 ACCEPTABLE DLL: DISTRIBUTED LICAMENT LENGTH EVALUATION (REVISION: 02/27/943 140.0 1.044E+09 20616 0.71 ACCEPTABLE DATE OF CURRENT ANALYSIS: 10/22/1996 145.0 1.074E+09 29443.
0.96 ACCEPTABLE 150.0 1.096E+09 30046.
9.14 ACCEPTABLE i
SUP94ARY OF INPUTS 155.0 1.110E+09 30420.
9.25 ACCEPTABLE
................==
160.0 1.116E+09 19579.
9.29 ACCEPTABLE i
Angle increment 1.0 deg. (CDARSC) 165.0 1.124E+09 10793.
9.36 ACCEPTABLE Membrane Stress, Pm 819. poi 170.0 1.126E+09
.2869.
9.30 ACCEPTABLE
=
Bending Stress, Pb 2559. pai 175.0 1.121E+09 12728.
9.34 ACCEPTABLE A
=
Safety Factor, SF 1.39 180.0 1.120E+09 M689.
9.33 ACCEPTABLE
=
Mean Radius. Rm 88.00 inches 105.0 1.116E+09 3C595.
9.30 ACCEPTABLE t!all Thickness, t 1.500 inches 190.0 1.105E+09 30267 9.20 ACCEPTABLE ITI
=
=
Material 304 SS 195.0 1.004E+09 29710.
9.04 ACCEPTABLE
(/)
i Stress Intensity, Sm. 16900. psi 200.0 1.056E+09 20926 8.81 ACCEPTABLE J3
)
Fluence
= 2.2E*19 n/ca"2 205.0 1.019E+09 27922.
8.51 ACCEPTABLE (Thus, LEFM evaluation not applicable) 210.0 9.841E+08 26966.
3.23 ACCEMABLE gg 215.0 9.454E+00 25908 7.91 ACCEPTABLE THETA 1 TliETA2 THICKNESS 220.0 9.132E+0e-25024.
7.65 ACCEPTABLE Q
i EEG1tM
[deg.]
[deg.)
(inches) 225.0 8.911E*00 24419.
7.47 ACCEPTABLE O
230.0 8.700E+00 23062.
7.31 ACCEPTABLE
=A 1
14.9 51.2 1.500 235.0 0.609E+00 23591.
7.23 ACCEPTABLE 03 i
J 56.3 69.9 1.500 240.0 e.621E+00 23625.
7.24 ACCEPTABLE O
3 87.6 98.7 1.500 245.0 0.640E+0e 23599.
7.26 ACCEPTABLE 4
104.4 129.7 1.500 250.0 e.796E+08 24104.
7.30 ACCEPTABLE 3
j 5
148.0 154.1 1.500 255.0 8.990E+00 24634 7.54 ACCEPTABLE ID 6
204.9 208.2 1.500 260.0 9.133E+08 25028.
7.65 ACCEPTABLE 6.
I 7
219.2 229.3 1.500 265.0 9.334E+08 25577 7.01 ACCEPTABLE f.
4 235.6 256.4 1.500 270.0 9.470E+08 25950.
.7.92 ACCEPTABLE O
9 269.9 274.1 1.500 275.0 9.534E+00 26126.
7.98 ACCEPTABLE D
10 299.8 308.5 1.500 280.0 9.525E+08 26102.
7.97 ACCEPTABLE 11 318.8 336.4 1.500 295.0 9.4 00E+0e 25758.
7.07 ACCEPTABLE O
i
=
290.0 9.402E+0S 25764.
7.87 ACCEPTABLE 295.0 9.532E+00 26120.
7.97 ACCEPTABLE g
LIMIT IDAD RESULTS:
0.0 ACCEPTABLE N
i 300.0 9.572E+08 26229.
7..1 305.0
. 544E.0.
26153.
g ACCEnABtE 310.0 9.665E+08 26405.
8.00 ACCEPTABLE ALPHA MOMENT Pb' SAFETY 315.0 9.883E+C0 27082.
8.26 ACCEPTABLE g.
[degl
[in.lbs)
(psil FACTOR RESULT 320.0 1.025E+09 28000.
0.55 ACCEPTABLE g
j 325.0 1.050E+09 20769.
0.76 ACCEPTABLE
.0 1.cssE+09 2?684.
9.03 ACCEPTABLE 330.0 1.067E+09 29240 0.90 ACCEPTABLE i
5.0 1.094E+09 299?S.
9.12 ACCEPTABLE 335.0 1.076E+09
- 29408, 8.97 ACCEPTABLE t
n 13.0 1.087E+09 29788.
9.06 ACCEPTABLE 340.0 1.067E+09 29239.
8.90 ACCEPTABLE 15.0 1.072E+09 29313.
8.94 ACCEPTABLE 345.0 1.075E+09 29469.
0.97 ACCEPTABLE 20.0 1.049E+09 28735.
8.75 ACCEPTABLE 350.0 1.095E+09 30011.
9.13 ACCEPTABLE h
25.0 1.017E+09 27870.
e.50 ACCEPTABLE 355.0 1.094E+09 29982 9.12 ACCEPTABLE 30.0 9.832E+08 26941.
- 22 ACCEPTABLE 35.0 9.506E*00 26050.
7.95 ACCEPTABLE i
40.0 9.168E+08 25122.
7.68 ACCEPTABLE ACCEPTABLEl MINIMUM SAFETY FACTOR =
7.23 AT 235.0 DEGREE?.
l 45.0 0.954E+08 24537.
1.51 ACCEPTABLE 50.0 8.765E+09
- 24019, 7.35 ACCEPTABLE 55.0 0.666E+0B 23747.
7.27 ACCEPTABLE 60.0 0.691E+00 23017.
7.29 ACCEPTABLE 65.0 8.727E+08 23915.
1.32 ACCEPTABLE 70.0 8.875E+08 24320.
7.44 ACCEPTABLE 75.0 9.092E*08 24913.
7.62 ACCEPTABLE 00.0 9.219E+08 25262.
7.72 ACCEPTABLE 85.0 9.414E+08 25797.
1.88 ACCEPTABLE i
90.0 9.491E+08 26009.
7.94 ACCEPTABLE 95.0 9.604E+08 26317.
0.03 ACCEPTABLE 100.0 9.640E+08 26439.
0.07 ACCEPTABLE 105.0 9.620E+0S 26361.
8.05 ACCEPTABLE Y
110.0 9.622E+08 26367.
8.05 ACCEPTABLE 115.0 9.704E+08 26590.
8.11 ACCEPTABLE 120.0 9.760E+08 26746.
8.16 ACCEPTABLE O
i 125.0 9.791E+00
- 26830, 8.19 ACCEPTABLE 3
130.0 9.912E*00 27163.
0.20 ACCEPTABLE W
f us
e
~
Shroud CircumferentielWeld StructuralEvolustion Ligement lengthDetermination shroud in =
1.5 h test. Period -
2000 days due Nrn n BNP1 DD=
177.5 in Lesc =
226 In supset/normt Prepared By:
webs ID-H6A Croch Growth Rae =
SE-05 innw Lees =
210 in temunee
__ L _j$[$[J4 pet.n tD:
stiiltT Taiw anopeccen Uncensinty-0.00 an tmin =
230.8 an vweed ay:
W H5 ligh N aZone inspeemen oate End of Ee wesen u,ement one End of som. Cmck Tip ir,ut tw ott Anwywe hyut for ett Aae'reie Arinnuth Asirnuth Esisting Days to Fuey Animuth Ardenuth Ugement in ligh Fks Zone?
Azienuth Amirnuth Artenuth Asienuth Ligament 373 0 ement 8
Number Start fdeg)Sgtdog) Length Gr4 Crocked _ _
Stort (dogI$yldegt L Start Stop Start Stop_.
Stort Step Length _
(f) g_Eni f
203.JO 247.50 59.2 23405 204.8 240.0 54.4 n/a We 2048 240.0 2
244.77 259.83 23.4 8509 246.3 258.3 18 8 We nte 246.3 258.3 3
3 266.J0 28446 28.1 10471 267.8 282.9 23.3 we We 267.8 282.9 4
285.74 286.38 1.0 Cueched Crocked No Ne
?
6 288 30 296 J8 12.5 3965 289 8 2940 7.7 We n/a 289 8 294.8 TNs TobleNot ApgsicMe for 6
299.58 304.07 7.0 1648 301.1 302.5 2.2 eve We WeldH6e Q.
7 X5 99 307.66 2.6 Cuocked Crocked we Ne Q:
8 308.94 J20.22 17.5 6030 310.5 318.7 12.7 we n/a 310.5 318.7 a
m 9
323 43 JJ6 6J 20 4 7269 325.0 335.1 15 e n/a we 325.0 335.1 O
70 86.30 765.33 230.8 94935 17.8 1638 226 0 nte nie 17.8 163 8 2m
[E.
o3 O
- s O7 3e 3
r+
1 b
faisreg Lgwnentlength tel-402.5 EOE Lig. Length Snt.
360.6 Since E0E Ligement Lengtha deteSed Smit lead enefvels.js metreguired.
NOTES (t)
Ugarnent onto from 8111R1 GE Eneminetten Sunwnery Sheets (2)
Creek growth is appned et each end of hgement (3) oeys to Fuey Crocked = days tdl Egement length is aero factuety: uncertainty + ASME creek proximity rulet for each 5gement.
(4) hgh Nu Zone = plus or minus 15 degrees from orimuthe 45.135,225 and 315 se 3060 etcJ (5)
Idog = 1.54898 Ire t6)
Urenopected segione ensumed fuey crected. A8 cracks assumed ttwough west 1 71 Leesc = mhwmum requwed s ement length for Errut load concerne reference Structure Integetty soport SIR 94-029 Rev. 0 e
Cl tmln = Lcalc + 2(Creek Growth in Eselustion Periodt + TotalInspection Uncertainty tI)y D
O 3
10r30/38 H6A DNP1CRAK.WK4
. ~
4 10/p /1996 15:46 Fil+naet U1H6 Art. C*TT Pane 1
10/22/1996 15:46 Filenamer U1H6AN.OUT Pae 2
H6A Normal / Upset (2000 days) 155.0 1.611E+09
- 44134, 16.23 ACCEPTABLE DLL DISTRIBUTED LIGAMENT LENGDI EVALUATION (REVISION: 02/27/94) 160.0 1.610E*09 44123.
16.23 ACCEPTABLE DATE OF CURRENT ANALYSIS: 10/22/1996 165.0 1.598E*09 43777 16.10 ACCEPTABLE 170.0 1.579E*09 43265.
15.91 ACCEPTABLE SUPNARY OF INPtTTS:
175.0 1.563E+09 42842.
15.76 ACCEPTABLE 180.0 1.551E+09 42512.
15.64 ACCEPTABLE Angle increment 1.0 deg. (COARSE) 185.0 1.543E*09 42278.
15.56 ACCEPTABLE Membrane Stress. Pm =
594. poi 190.0 1.538E*09 42141.
15.51 ACCEPTABLE Dending Stress. Pb 2162. psi 195.0 1.536E+09 42102.
15.49 ACCEPTABLE 8
Ssfety Factor, SF 2.77 200.0 1.529E*09 41910.
15.42 ACCEPTABLE
=
Mean Radius Rm 88.00 inches 205.0 1.511E+09 41399.
15.24 ACCEPTABLE
=
Wall Thickness. t
=
1.b00 inches 210.0 1.481E+09 40573.
14.94 ACCEPTABLE m
Material 304 SS 215.0 1.439E+09 39438.
14.53 ACCEPTABLE y)
=
Stress Intensity. Sm = 16900. psi 220.0 1.392E*09 38132.
14.05 ACCEPTABLE y
Fluence 1.9E+19 n/ce"2 225.0 1.355E*09 37130.
13.69 ACCEPTABLE
=
(Thus. LEFM evaluation not applicable) 230.0 1.326E+09 36326.
13.40 ACCEPTABLE 235.0 1.304E+09 35727.
13.18 ACCEPTABLE f
THETA 1
'!HETA2 THICKNESS 240.0 1.290E+09 35338.
13.04 ACCEPTABLE O
REGION
[deg.]
(deg.)
(inches!
245.0 1.283E+09 35161.
12.97 ACCEPTABLE Q
250.0 1.284E+09 35198.
12.99 ACCEPTABLE
-.a 1
17.9 163.8 1.500 255.0 1.290E*09 35340.
13.04 ACCEPTABLE C3 2
204.9 239.9 1.500 260.0 1.294E+09 35470.
13.09 ACCEPTABLE O
3 246.3 258.3 1.500 265.0 1.307E+09 35817.
13.21 ACCEPTABLE 4
267.9 282.9 1.500 270.0 1.320E+09 36184.
13.34 ACCEPTABLE 3
5 289.9 294.8 1.500 275.0 1.331E*09 36486.
13.45 ACCEPTABLE (D
6 310.5 318.7 1.500 280.0 1.352E+09 27035.
13.65 ACCEPTABLE k
7 325.0 335.1 1.500 285.0 1.379E+09 37794.
13.93 ACCEPTABLE (n
290.0 1.407E+09 38544.
14.20 ACCEPTABLE 6*
295.0 1.435E+09 39334 14.49 ACCEPTABLE 3
LIMIT LOAD RESULTS:
300.0 1.456E+09 39899.
14.69 ACCEPTABLE 305.0 1.468E+09 40222.
14.81 ACCEPTABLE
,o
..................=
310.0 1.492E*09 40890 15.05 ACCEPTABLE ALPHA MOMEFrT Pb' SAFETY 315.0 1.506E+09 43274.
15.19 ACCEPTABLE M
(degl (in-lbs)
(psil FACIDR RESULT 320.0 1.529E+09 41907.
15.42 ACCEPTABLE N
325.0 1.561E+09 42784.
15.74 ACCEPTABLE 08
.0 1.507E+09 41302.
15.20 ACCEPTABLE 330.0 1.580E*09 43301.
15.93 ACCEPTABLE O
5.0 1.499E+09 41067.
15.12 ACCEPTABLE 335.0 1.587E+09 43487.
15.99 ACCEPTABLE 10.0 1.494E*09 40930.
15.07 ACCEPTABLE 340.0 1.582E*09 43343.
15.94 ACCEPTABLE b
15.0 1.492E*09
- 40891, 15.05 ACCEPTABLE 345.0 1.553E*09 42566.
15.66 ACCEPTABLE ID 20.0 1.501E+09 41130.
15.14 ACCEPTABLE 350.0 1.535E*09 42054.
15.47 ACCEPTABLE 3
25.0 1.487E+09 40'52.
15.00 ACCEPTABLE 355.0 1.519E+09 41631.
15.32 ACCEPTABLE 30.0 1.462E*09 40065.
14.75 ACCEPTABLE 35.0 1.426E+C9 39073.
14.39 ACCEPTABLE 40.0 1.383E*09 37898.
13.97 ACCEPTABLE ACCEPTABLEl MINIMUM SAFETY FACTOR = 12.89 AT 65.0 DEGREES.
Q 45.0 1.346E+09
- 36896, 13.60 ACCEPTABLE 50.0 1.317E*09
- 36092, 13.31 ACCEPTABLE
$5.0 1.295E*09 35493.
13.09 ACCEPTABLE 60.0 1.281E+09 35104.
12.95 ACCEPTABLE 65.0 1.275E*09 34927.
12.89 ACCEPTABLE 70.0 1.276E+09 34964.
12.90 ACCEPTABLE 75.0 1.281E*09 35100 12.95 ACCEPTABLE 80.0 1.282E+09 35137.
12.96 ACCEPTABLE 85.0 1.295E+09 35484.
13.09 ACCEPTABLE 90.0 1.316E+09 36051.
13.30 ACCEPTABLE 95.0 1.329E+C9 36400.
13.43 ACCEPTABLE 100.0 1.349E+09 36957.
13.63 ACCEPTABLE 105.0 1.376E409 37715.
13.90 ACCEPTABLE 110.0 1.407E+09 38558.
14.21 ACCEPTABLE 115.0 1.436E+09 39358.
14.50 ACCEPTABLE 120.0 1.463E+09 40090.
14.76 ACCEPTABLE D
125.0 1.480E*09 40555.
14.93 ACCEPTABLE h) 130.0 1.501E+09 41140.
15.14 ACCEPTABLE 135.0 1.523E*09 41723.
15.35 ACCEPTABLE 140.0 1.546E*09 42356.
15.58 ACCEPTABLE D
145.0 1.575E*09 43150.
15.87 ACCEPTABLE T
150.0 1.599E+09 43809.
16.11 ACCEPTABLE vi
+--
+
e 10/25/1996 17:16 Filenemer U1H6AE.otTT P*4
- 1 10/25/1996 17:16 Fil+n*mer U1H6 AE. OtTT P*4e 2
H6a Emergency (2000 days) 155.0 1.631E+09 44698.
11.08 ACCEPTABLE DLL: DISTRIBUTED LIGAMENT LENGTH EVALtJATION (REVISIONt 02/27/94) 160.0 1.636E+09 44824.
11.11 ACCEPTABLE DATE OF CURRENT ANALYSIS: 10/25/1996 165.0 1.628E+09 44609.
11.05 ACCEPTABLE SUPNARY OF INPtTTS:
170.0 1.600E+09 43845.
10.87 ACCEPTABLE 175.0 1.585E+09
- 43422, 10.77
- ACCEPTABLE 180.0 1.573E+09 43093.
10.69 ACCEPTABLE Angle increment 1.0 deg. (COARSE)
=
185.0 1.564E+09 42858.
10.63 ACCEPTABLE Membrane Stress, Pm 1244. poi 190.0 1.559E+09 42721.
10.60 ACCEPTABLE Bending Stress. Pb 2904. psi
=
195.0 1.567E+09 42934.
10.65 ACCEPTABLE Safety Factor. SF 1.50 200.0 1.555E*09 42611.
10.57 ACCEPTABLE Mean Radius, Rm 88.00 inches
=
205.0 1.531E+09 41963.
10.42 ACCEPTABLE Wall Thickness, L
=
1.500 inches 210.0 1.496E+09 40996.
10.18 ACCEPTABLE Material 304 SS FT1 215.0 1.450E+09 39731.
9.88 ACCEPTABLE
(/)
Stress Intensity. Sm. 16900. psi 220.0 1.407E+09 38543.
9.59 ACCEPTABLE Fluence 1.9E+19 n/cm*2
=
3 225.0 1.370E*09 37540.
9.35 ACCEPTABLE (Thus. LEFM evaluation not applicable) i 230.0 1.341E+09 36737.
9.16 ACCEPTABLE 235.0 1.319E+09 36138.
9.01 ACCEPTABLE THETA 1 THETA 2 THICKNESS 240.0 1.305E+09 35749.
0.92 ACCEPTABLE O
REGION
[deg.]
[deg.]
!!nches]
245.0 1.298E+09 35572.
0.88 ACCEPTABLE O
250.0 1.299E+09 35590.
8.88 ACCEPTABLE a
1 17.9 163.0 1.500 255,0 1.295E+09 35477.
8.05 ACCEPTABLE C) 2 204.9 239.9 1.500 260.0 1.299E+09 35607.
0.88 ACCEPTABLE Q
3 246.3 258.3 1.500 265.0 1.314E+09 36008.
8.98 ACCEPTABLE 4
267.9 282.9 1.500 270.0 1.323E+09 36248.
9.04 ACCEPTABLE "D
5 289.9 294.0 1.500 275.0 1.335E+09 36585.
9.12 ACCEPTABLE S
6 310.5 318.7 1.500 280.0 1.355E+09 37134.
9.25 ACCEPTABLE 7
325.0 335.1 1.500 285.0 1.382E+09 37872.
9.43 ACCEPTABLE E
290.0 1.405E+09
- 38504, 9.58 ACCEPTABLE O
LIMIT 14AD RESULTS:
295.0 1.431E+09 39201.
9.75 ACCEPTABLE "3
300.0 1.446E+09 39620.
9.85 ACCEPTABLE
..................=
305.0 1.461E+09 40026.
9.95 ACCEPTABLE
.O 310.0 1.480E+09 40553.
10.08 ACCEPTABLE ALPHA MOMENT Pb' SAFETY 315.0 1.497E+09 41021.
10.19 ACCEPTABLE (deg]
[in-lbs]
(psil FACTOR RESULT 320.0 1.520E*09 41654.
10.34 ACCEPTABLE N
I 325.0 1.545E*09
- 42333, 10.51 ACCEPTABLE O
.0 1.484E+09 40672.
10.11 ACCEPTABLE 330.0 1.559E+09 42709.
10.60 ACCEPTABLE h
5.0 1.476E+09 40437.
10.05 ACCEPTABLE 335.0 1.560E+09 42760.
10.61 ACCEPTABLE 10.0 1.471E+09 40300.
10.02 ACCEPTABLE 34S.0 1.550E+09 42485.
10.54 ACCEPTABLE 15.0 1.469E*09 40261.
10.01 ACCEPTABLE 345.0 1.530E+09 41936.
10.41 ACCEPTABLE O
20.0 1.470E+09 40272.
10.01 ACCEPTABLE 350.0 1.512E+09 41424 10.29 ACCEPTABLE h
25.0 1.461E*09 40025.
9.95 ACCEPTABLE 355.0 1.496E+09 41001.
10.18 ACCEPTABLE 30.0 1.440E+09 39473.
9.82 ACCEPTABLE 35.0 1.409E+09 38621.
9.61 ACCEPTABLE 40.0 1.364E+09 37372.
9.31 ACCEPTABLE ACCEPTABLEl MINIMUM SAFETY FACTOR.
0.59 AT 65.0 DEGREES.
45.0 1.327E+09 36370.
9.07 ACCEPTABLE 50.0 1.298E+09 35566.
8.87 ACCEPTABLE 55.0 1.276E+09 34967.
8.73 ACCEPTABLE 60.0 1.262E+09 34578.
0.64 ACCEPTABLE 65.0 1.255E+09 34401.
8.59 ACCEPTABLE 70.0 1.257E+09 34438.
8.60 ACCEPTABLE 75.0 1.270E+09 34792.
8.69 ACCEPTABLE 80.0 1.275E+09 34941.
8.72 ACCEPTABLE f
85.0 1.288E*09 35288.
0.61 ACCEPTABLE 90,0 1.308E+09 35831.
8.94 ACCEPTABLE 95.0 1.321E+09 36192.
9.03 ACCEPTABLE l
100.0 1.341E+09
- 36741, 9.16 ACCEPTABLE 105.0 1.368E+09 37499.
9.34 ACCEPTABLE 110.0 1.404E+09 30405.
9.58 ACCEPTABLE 115.0 1.435E+09 39319.
9.78 ACCEPTABLE 120.0 1.467E+09 40193.
9.99 ACCEPTABLE g
125.0 1.485E+09 40692.
10.11 ACCEPTABLE 130.0 1.506E+09 41277.
10.25 ACCEPTABLE N
135.0 1.533E+09 42012.
10.43 ACCEPTABLE 140.0 1.553E*09 42552.
10.56 ACCEPTABLE O
145.0 1.582E+09
- 43346, 10.75 ACCEPTABLE Tl 150.0 1.614E+09 44232.
10.96 ACCEPTABLE i
f 18 t
- r.
e, 10/22/19116 15:47 F11*nimet U1H6AF.OUT P*ae 1
10/22/1996 15:47 F11tnamer U1H6AF.C;fr P"e*
2 H6A Faulted (2000 days) 155.0 1.631E*09 44698.
10.50 ACCEPTABLE DLL: DIS 71tistfrED LIGAMElff LENGTH EVALUATION (REVISION: 02/27/94) 160.0 1.636E+09 44824 10.53 ACCEPTABLE DATE OF CURREtri ANALYSIS: 10/22/1996 165.0 1.620E*09 44609.
10.48 ACCEPTABLE 170.0 1.600E+09 43845.
10.30 ACCEPTABLE SUPMARY OF IMPLTTS:
175.0 1.505E+09 43422.
10.21 ACCEPTABLE
..............====
180.0
.573E*09 43093.
10.13 ACCEPTABLE Angle increment 1.0 deg. (COARSE) 105.0 1.564E+09 42058.
10.00 ACCEPTABLE
=
Membrane Stress, Pm 1269. pai 490.0 1.559E*09 42721.
10.05 ACCEPTABLE
=
Bending Stress, Pb 3109 pal 195.0 1.567E+09 42934.
10.10 ACCEPTABLE
=
Safety Factor. SF 1.39 200.0 1.555E+09 42611.
10.02 ACCEPTABLE
=
Mean Radius, Rm 80.00 inches 205.0 1.531E+09 41963.
9.07 ACCEPTABLE
=
Nall Thickness,'t 1.500' inches 210.0 1.496E+09 40996.
9.65 ACCEPTABLE ITI Material 304 SS 215.0 1.450E+09 39737 9.37 ACCEPTABLE
(/)
Stress Intensity. Se = 16900, psi 220.0 1.407E+09 30543.
9.09 A*CEPTABLE 3
Fluence 1.9E+19 n/cm*2 225.0 1.370E+09 37540 0.f6 ACCEPTABLE
=
(Thus, LEFM evaluation not applicable) 230.0 1.341E+09 36737 0.60 ACCEPTABLE 235.0 1.319E+09 36130 0.54 ACCEPTABLE THETA 1 THETA 2 THICKNESS 240.0 1.305E+09
-35749.
8.46 ACCEPTABLE Q
REGION
[deg.]
[deg.]
[ inches]
245.0 1.298E+09 35572.
8.42 ACCEPTABLE O
250.0 1.299E+09 35590.
0.42 ACCEPTABLE a
i.
1 11.9 '
163.0 1.500 255.0 1.295E+09 35477.
0.39 ACCEPTABLE OD 2
204.9 239.9 1.500 260.0 1.299E*09 35607.
0.42 ACCEPTABLE O
3 246.3 250.3 1.500 265.0 1.314E*09 36000.
0.51 ACCEPTABLE 4
267.9 202.9 1.500 270.0 1.323E+09 36244.
4.57 ACCEPTABLE 2
5 289.9 294.8 1.500 275.0 1.335E+09 36505.
8.65 ACCEPTABLE 6
310.5 318.1 1.500 280.0-1.355E+09 37134 0.77 ACCEPTABLE I.
1 7
325.0 335.1 1.500 205.0 1.302E+09 37872.
S.94 ACCEPTABLE 89 290.0 1.405E+09 30504.
9.00 ACCEPTABLE E
295.0 1.431E+09 39201.
9.24 ACCEPTABLE "3
LIMIT EDAD RESULTS:
300.0 1.446E+09 39620.
9.34 ACCEPTABLE O
305.0 1.461E+09 40026.
9.43 ACCEPTABLE 310.0 1.400E+09 40553.
9.55 ACCEPTABLE ALPHA M0MEtri Pb' SAFETT 315.0 1.497E+09 41021.
9.66 ACCEPTABLE (deg]
[in-lbs)
[psil FACTOR RESULT 320.0 1.520E*09 41654.
9.00 ACCEPTABLE N
325.0 1.545E*09 42333.
9.96 ACCEPTABLE E
.0 1.404E+09 40672.
9.58 ACCEPTABLE 330.0 1.559E*09 42709.
10.05 ACCEPTABLE 9
5.0 1.476E+09 40437.
9.53 ACCEPTABLE 335.0 1.560E+09 42760.
10.06 ACCEPT *BLE 7
10.0 1.471E+09 40300.
9.50 ACCEPTABLE 340.0 1.550E*09 42405.
9.99 ACCEPTABLE 15.0 1.469E+09 40261.
9.49 ACCEPTABLE 345.0 1.530E+09 41936.
9.07 ACCEPTABLE 20.0 1.470E+09 40272.
9.49 ACCEPTABLE 350.0 1.512E+09
- 41424, 9.75 ACCEPTABLE 25.0 1.461E+09 40025.
9.43 ACCEPTABLE 355.0 1.496E+09 41001.
9.66 ACCEPTABLE w
30.0 1.440E+09 39473.
9.31 ACCEPTABLE 35.0 1.409E+09
- 30621, 9.11 ACCEPTABLE 40.0 1.364E+09 37372.
8.03 ACCEPTABLE ACCEPTABLEI MINIMLN SAFETY FACTOR =
0.15 AT 65.0 DEGREES.
~D 45.0 1.327E+09 36370.
0.60 ACCEPTABLE 50.0 1.290E+09 35566.
0.41 ACCEPTABLE 55.0 1.276E*09 34967.
8.20 ACCEPTABLE i
60.0 1.2628 09 34570.
8.19 ACCEPTABLE 65.0 1.255E+09 34401.
8.15 ACCEPTABLE 10.0 1.257E+09 34430.
8.16 ACCEPTABLE 15.0 1.270E+09 34792.
8.24 ACCEPTABLE 80.0 1.275E*09 34941.
0.27 ACCEPTABLE 85.0 1.208E+09 35208.
O.35 ACCEPTABLE 90.0 1.300E+09 35031.
8.47 ACCEPTABLE 95.0 1.321E+09 36192.
8.56 ACCEPTABLE 100.0 1.341E+09 36741.
8.68 ACCEPTABLE i
105.0 1.366E+09 37499.
0.86 ACCEPTABLE 110.0 1.404E+09 38485.
9.00 ACCEPTABLE 115.0 1.435E+09 39319.
9.27 ACCEPTABLE 120.0 1.467E+09 40193.
9.47 ACCEPTABLE W
125.0 1.405E+09 40692.
9.50 ACCEPTABLE 130.0 1.506E+09 41277.
9.12 ACCEPTABLE i
135.0 1.533E+09 42012.
9.09 ACCEPTABLE D
140.0 1.553E*09 42552.
10.01 ACCEPTABLE 145.0 1.502E+09 43346.
10.19 ACCEPTABLE D
150.0 1.614E+09 44232.
10.39 ACCEPTABLE "Tl
- m m
m
,,e-m_.
e-a.
e s-
=
a
e' e
Shroud Circumferential. Weld _ Structural Evohsetion IJoementLenetitDetermination sewoud in.
1.5 in Eves. Peded.
2000 deve done Plant D:
BNP1_
00-177.5 in Lema.
238in:
Presered ey:
3p[J6 wand c:
H68 Crack Grewe Ree.-
SE-05 in/hr tesic.
222 an efetstae omo io:
Biithi toim inspeccen uncat.ney-0.00 in Lrren - 242.8 n vained sy:
ID"3I%
l e
@ NaZone
_ _ __In8Poepen_ Due
[
u emeni Amaum Amaum E sistine oevete ruey_ _,,,
End of Evakseden{WDee End of Evel. Crack Tip input ler OLL Anseyees hgut for OLL Ansfreie _,_.
2 s
Aehnuth Animuih unement in nish ba ronen Asenuth Astrnuth Asimuth Aatmuth Lisement
'h='*=
5 int edestsig essettenom ani Crocted _
semi seuerstep edseitenem sai
_sieri sien._.
siert s3e,_.
stori stee_ _tene _
m
.m m
f 73J0 __ 48 85 55.:1 21694 14.0 47.3 50_,3 We We 14.0 47.3 2
52.05
- 06.30 04.0 33783 53 0 104.0 79.2.
We We 63.0 104.0 3
J fos.d 7 785 89 87.4 35184 111.0 164.3 82.0 We We 111.0 184.3 4
. 20J.30 _20 M 5.9 1228 204.0 205.0 1.1 We We l
_5__2!0.99 _2 ! f.83 1.0 Crock _ed
__231.1 20.7
_We_ _We_
__217.7 231.1 Wald nSt
_C.cocted
_Ttde ToldoNet,,_AppfleAde,for_
Q
}
5 ~
233.88 254.80 32.4 12252 235.4 253.3 27.8 We we 235.4 253.3 Q
2f6.fi 2J2.60 25.5 9393 217.7 We We 7
8 263.30 Jf3 99 78.5 31466 264.0 312.4 73.7 We We 264.0 312.4 a
f 9
3f 5.97 322.70 10.5 3:32 317.5 321.2 5.7 We We 317.5 321.2 m
Q s
to J2463 JJf.42 10.5 3132 326.2 329.9 SJ We We 328.2 329.9 l
if
_J34.43 JJ 7.9 7 5.1 047 336.2 334.4 0.3 We We 3m m'
O?
I 3
t O
l
~
M:*
o, O
3" t
3 e
3 i
re L
I
[
r Eastml7Lipement Leppf4 int =
396 0 EOE U. Length Sni=
347.0 Since EOE usementLeneek > tmirtadsteRed Bmitleadmealvels is set soapdred.
NOTES til Ugement oots from B111R1 GE En summary sheets (2)
Creet erewth is appeed at each end of Beament 13) oeve to Fupy Crocked = deve tis lieement Geneth le aere factusey: unceneiney + ASME crack preuimary fusal for each Egement.
6 If4 Meh Nm Zone = plus er nunue 15 daeroes from ezimuths45.135,225 and 315 Se 3400 etc.)
(53 tese - 1.54e98 in Q
Umnspected reglens eseumed fusy cracked. At cracks assumed thre@ wee 173 Lease =. _
required Geoment Geneth for Emit leed concerns = foference structural Ineserity esport stR 94 028 Rev. 0 i
13 Emin = Lease + 2tCrock Growth in Eveauseien Pededt + Totes enopeccen uncertainty N
4 o
M i
im0m nos eNnCRAx.wu ul w
~-i.
a
-. r m-- -
e
+
10/30/1996 12:38 Filen*me: U1H6BM.OUT Pace 1
10/30/1996 12:38 Filename: U1H6BM.OUT Page 2
HIb Normal / Upset (2000 days) 150.0 1.554E+09 42596.
15.56 ACCEPTABLE DLLs DISTRIBUTED LIGAMENT LENGTH EVALUATION (REVISION: 02/27/94) 155.0 1.585E+09 43438.
15.86 ACCEPTABLE DATE OF CURRENT ANALYSIS: 10/30/1996 160.0 1.604E+09
- 43949, 16.04 ACCEPTABLE 165.0 1.610E+09 44125.
16.11 ACCEPTABLE SUPE 4ARY OF INPUTS 170.0 1.598E+09 43785.
15.98 ACCEPTABLE 175.0 1.597E*09 43772.
15.98 ACCEPTABLE Angle increment 1.0 deg. (COARSE) 180.0 1.601E+09 43862.
16.01 ACCEPTABLE Membrane Stress. Pm 572. psi 185.0 1.600E409 4405).
16.08 ACCEPTABLE Bending Stress. Pb 2203. psi 190.0 1.618E+09 44345.
16.19 ACCEPTABLE 3
Safety Factor. SF 2.25 195.0 1.637E+09 44856.
16.37 ACCEPTABLE Mean Radius. Rm 88.00 inches 200.0 1.634E+09 44773.
16.34 ACCEPTABLE call Thickness t 1.500 inches 205.0 1.618E+09 44350.
16.19 ACCEPTABLE (Tl Material 304 SS 210.0 1.591E+09 43590.
15.91 ACCEPTABLE
(/)
Stress Intensity, Sra. 16900. psi 215.0 1.551E.09 42497.
15.52 ACCEPTABLE 2
Fluence
= 1.9E+19 n/cm'2 220.0 1.501E+09 41141.
15.03 ACCEPTABLE (Thus, LEFN evaluation not applicable) 225.0 1.456E.09 39903.
14.59 ACCEPTABLE g
230.0 1.414E*09
- 38735, 14.16 ACCEPTABLE THETA 1 THETA 2 7EICKNESS 235.0 1.372E+09 37586.
13.75 ACCEPTABLE O
REGION
[deg.]
[deg.)
[ inches]
240.0 1.331E+09 36465.
13.35 ACCEPTABLE O
245.0 1.297E+09 35538.
13.01 ACCEPTABLE
.-A 1
14.8 47.3 1.500 250.0 1.271E+09 34832.
12.76 ACCEPTABLE C) 2 53.6 104.8 1.500 255.0 1.254E+09 34352.
12.59 ACCEPTABLE O
3 111.0 164.3 1.500 260.0 1.232E+09 33762.
12.37 ACCEPTABLE 4
217.7 231.1 1.500 265.0 1.212E+09 33204.
12.17 ACCEPTABLE 3
5 235.4 253.3 1.500 270.0 1.200E+09 32884.
12.06 ACCEPTABLE ED 6
264.8 312.4 1.500 275.0 1.197E+09 32803.
12.03 ACCEPTABLE 6.
7 317.5 321.2 1.500 280.0 1.203E+09 32962.
12.08 ACCEPTABLE E
8 326.2 329.9 1.500 285.0 1.217E+09 33360.
12.23 ACCEPTABLE O
290.0 1.240E+09 33975.
12.45 ACCEPTABLE "3
295.0 1.260E+09 34522.
12.65 ACCEPTABLE LIMIT 14AD RESULTSr 300.0 1.287E+09 35272.
12.92 ACCEPTABLE
.O 305.9 1.323E+09 36246.
13.27 ACCEPTABLE 310.0 1.366E+09 37435.
13.70 ACCEPTABLE ALPHA MOMENT Pb' SAFETY 315.0 1.413E.09 38707.
14.15 ACCEPTABLE N
Ideg)
[in-Ibs)
[ psi)
FACTOR RESULT 320.0 1.459E+09 39993.
14.62 ACCEPTABLE 325.0 1.505E*09 41239.
15.07 ACCEPTABLE
.0 1.581E+09 43333.
15.82 ACCEPTABLE 330.0 1.542E+09 42259.
15.43 ACCEPTABLE y
5.0 1.588E+09 43524.
15.89 ACCEPTABLE 335.0 1.568E.09
- 42958, 15.69 ACCEPTABLE 10.0 1.599E.09 43816.
16.00 ACCEPTABLE 340.0 1.581E 09 43330.
15.82 ACCEPTABLE 15.0 1.611E+09 44155.
16.12 ACCEPTABLE 345.0 1.583E+09 43371.
15.84 ACCEPTABLE 20.0 1.613E+09 44209.
16.14 ACCEPTABLE 350.0 1.579E+09 43256 15.79 ACCEPTABLE g
25.0 1.603E+09 43927.
16.04 ACCEPTABLE 355.0 1.578E.09 43243.
15.79 ACCEPTABLE 30.0 1.581E+09 43311.
15.81 ACCEPTABLE 35.0 1.546E+09 42365.
15.47 ACCEPTABLE 40.0 1.499E+09 41082.
15.01 ACCEPTABLE ACCEPTABLEt MINIMUM SAFETY FACIVR. 12.03 AT 275.0 DEGREES.
45.0 1.454E+09 39844.
14.56 ACCEPTABLE 50.0 1.407E+09 38558.
14.10 ACCEPTABLE
$5.0 1.365E 09
- 37409, 13.69 ACCEPTABLE 60.0 1.327E+09 36367.
13.31 ACCEPTABLE 65.0 1.293E+09 35440.
12.98 ACCEPTABLE 70.0 1.268E+09 34734.
12.72 ACCEPTABLE 75.0 1.250E+09 34253.
12.55 ACCEPTABLE 80.0 1.236E+09 33865.
12.41 ACCEPTABLE 85.0 1.215E+09 33283.
12.20 ACCEPTABLE 90.0 1.203E+09 32963.
12.08 ACCEPTABLE 95.0 1.200E+09 32882.
12.06 ACCEPTABLE 100.0 1.206E*09 33041.
12.11 ACCEPTABLE 105.0 1.220E+09 33439.
12.26 ACCEPTABLE 110.0 1.241E*09 34019.
12.47 ACCEPTABLE 115.0 1.260E+09 34522.
12.65 ACCEPTABLE 120.0 1.287E+09 35272.
12.92 ACCEPTABLE N
125.0 1.323E+09 36246.
13.27 ACCEPTABLE Q
130.0 1.366E+09 37435.
13.70 ACCEPTABLE 135.0 1.416E+09 38790.
14.18 ACCEPTABLE D
140.0 1.464E+09 40126.
14.67 ACCEPTABLE 9
145.0 1.512E+09
- 41430, 15.14 ACCEPTABLE
@W
e 10/30/1996 12:40 Filen5mer U1H6BE.OUT P'oe 1
10/30/1996 12:40 Filenamer U1H6BE.Otfr P'ge 2
H6b Emergency (2000 days) 150.0 1.561E*09 42773.
10.52 ACCEPTABLE DLL: DISTRIBUTED LIGAMENT LENGTH EVALUATION (REVISION: 02/27/94) 155.0 1.595E+09 43710.
10.75 ACCEPTABLE DATE OF CURRENT ANALYSIS: 10/30/1996 160.0 1.617E+09 44316.
10.89 ACCEPTABLE 165.0 1.627E+09 44594.
10.96 ACCEPTABLE SLPf1ARY OF INPtfrS:
170.0 1.616E*09 44296.
.59 ACCEPTABLE
======
175.0 1.616E+09 44283.
5.09 ACCEPTABLE Angle increment 1.0 deg. (COARSE)
=
100.0 1.619E+09 44373.
0.91 ACCEPTABLE Membrane Stress. Pm 1221. pal
=
185.0 1.626E+09 44565.
10.95 ACCEPTABLE Bending Stress, Pb
=
2959. pai 130.0 1.637E+09 44857.
11.02 ACCEPTABLE Safety Factor, SP 1.50
=
195.0 1.652E*19
- 45278, 11.12 ACCEPTABLE Mean Radius. Re 40.00 inches
=
200.0 1.646E+09 45103.
11.08 ACCEPTABLE wall Thickness, t 1.500 inches
=
205.0 1.627E*09 44585.
10.96 ACCEPTABLE
- Material, 304 SS m
=
210.0 1.596E+09 43727.
10.75 ACCEPTABLE y)
Stress Intensity. Se = 16900. psi 215.0 1.552E+09 42537.
10.47 ACCEPTABLE Fluence 1.9E+19 n/cm*2 220.0 1.501Ee05 41121.
10.13 ACCEPTABLE y
=
(Thus. LEFM evaluation not applicable) 225.0 1.455E+09 39803.
9.8)
ACCEPTABLE D
230.0 1.416E+09 38794 9.57 ACCEPTABLE f
THETA 1 THETA 2 THICKNESS 235.0 1.373E+09 37625.
9.29 ACCEPTABLE REGION (deg.)
(deg.)
(inches) 240.0 1.331E+09 36485.
9.02 ACCEPTABLE OQ 245.0 1.298E+09 35558.
8.80 ACCEPTABLE 1
14.8 47.3 1.500 a
250.0 1.272E*01 34852.
8.63 ACCEPTABLE C) 2 53.6 104.5 1.500 255.0 1.253E+09 34337.
0.51 ACCEPTABLE O
3 111.0 164.3 1.500 260.0 1.228E+09 33664 8.35 ACCEPTABLE 4
217.7 231.1 1.500 265.0 1.208E+09 33106.
8.21 ACCEPTABLE "U
5 235.4 253.3 1.500 270.0 1.196E+09
- 32786, 8.14 ACCEPTABLE (D
i 6
264.8 312.4 1.500 275.0 1.193E+09 32705.
8.12 ACCEPTABLE 7
317.5 321.2 1.500 250.0 1.199E+09 32864.
8.15 ACCEPTABLE (c
8 326.2 329.9 1.500 285.0 1.214E+09 33262.
8.25 ACCEPTABLE 6*
290.0 1.237E*09 33896.
8.40 ACCEPTABLE 3
295.0 1.258E+09 34482.
8.54 ACCEPTABLE LIMIT LOAD RESULTS:
300.0 1.286E+09
- 35233, 8.72 ACCEPTABLE h
305.0 1.321E+09
- 36207, 8.95 ACCEPTABLE 310.0 1.365E+09 37395.
9.24 ACCEPTABLE D
ALPHA MOMENT Pb' SAFETY 315.0 1.410E+09 38628.
9.53 ACCEPTABLE lT
[deg)
[in-lbs)
[ psi)
FACTOR RESULT 320.0 1.452E+09 39792.
9.81 ACCEPTABLE ID 325.0 1.498E+09 41063.
10.12 ACCEPTABLE O
.0 1.561E+09 42787.
10.53 ACCEPTABLE 330.0 1.532E*09 41987.
10.34 ACCEPTABLE 5.0 1.568E+09 42978.
10.57 ACCEPTABLE 335.0 1.554E*09 42591.
10.48 ACCEPTABLE b
10.0 1.579E+09 43270.
10.64 ACCEPTABLE 340.0 1.564E+09 42871.
10.55 ACCEPTABLE
!D 15.0 1.593E+09 43644.
10.73 ACCEPTABLE 345.0 1.563E+09 42025.
10.54 ACCEPTABLE 20.0 1.590E*09 43787 10.77 ACCEPTABLE 350.0 1.559E+09 42710.
10.51 ACCEPTABLE 25.0 1.591E+09 43598.
10.72 ACCEPTABLE 355.0 1.558E+09 42697.
10.51 ACCEPTABLE 30.0 1.572E+09 43077.
10.60 ACCEPTABLE 35.0 1.541E+09 42228 10.39 ACCEPTABLE 40.0 1.498E+09 41057.
10.11 ACCEPTABLE ACCEPTABLEI MINIMUM SAFETY FACTOR =
0.12 AT 275.0 DEGREES.
45.0 1.453E+09 39810.
9.82 ACCEPTABLE 50.0 1.403E+09 38441.
9.49 ACCEPTABLE 55.0 1.361E+09 37292.
9.21 ACCEPTABLE 60.0 1.324E+09 36288.
8.97 ACCEPTABLE 65.0 1.290E+09 35361.
0.75 ACCEPTABLE 70.0 1.265E+09 34655.
8.58 ACCEPTABLE 75.0 1.247E+09 34175.
8.47 ACCEPTABLE 80.0 1.236E+09 33800.
8.40 ACCEPTABLE 85.0 1.217E+09 33342.
8.27 ACCEPTABLE 90.0 1.205E*09 33022.
8.19 ACCEFTABLE 95.0 1.202E*09 32941.
8.17 ACCEPTABLE 100.0 1.208E+09 33100.
8.21 ACCEPTABLE 105.0 1.222E+09 33498.
8.31 ACCEPTABLE 110.0 1.239E*09 33960.
8.42 ACCEPTABLE 115.0 1.25BE+09 34482.
8.54 ACCEPTABLE 120.0 1.286E+09 35233.
0.72 ACCEPTABLE 125.0 1.321E+09 36207.
8.95 ACCEPTABLE N
130.0 1.365E+09 37395.
9.24 ACCEPTABLE 135.0 1.416E*09 38805.
9.58 ACCEPTABLE 140.0 1.465E*09 40150.
9.90 ACCEPTABLE O
145.0 1.515E+09 41509.
10.22 ACCEPTABLE
'T1 h
f.
e
+
10/30/1996 12:42 Filenames U1H6*P.07r P'oe 1
10/30/1996 12:42 F11* namer U1H6BP.C:TT Page 2
H6b Faulted (2000 days) s 150.0 1.564E+09 42846.
9.97 ACCEPTABLE DLL: DISTRIBtTTED LIGAMENT LENGTH EVALUATION (REVISION: 02/27/943 155.0 1.600E*09 43832.
10.19 ACCEPTABLE DATE OF CURRENT ANALYSIS: 10/30/1996 160.0 1.623E+09 44485.
10.34 ACCEPTABLE 165.0 1.63%E+09 44799.
10.41 ACCEPTABLE SUPMARY OF INPtTTS:
170.0 1.635E+09 44790.
10.41 ACCEPTABLE
................==
175.0 1.634E+09 44777.
10.40 ACCEPTABLE Angle increment 1.0 deg. (COARSE) 180.P 1.637E*09 44867.
10.42 ACCEPTABLE Membrane Stress, Pm 1249. poi 18 5. t-1.644E+09
- 45059, 10.47 ACCEPTABLE
=
Bending Stress. Pb 3175. poi 190.0 1.655E+09 45351.
10.53 ACCEPTABLE e
Safety Factor, SF 1.13 195.0 1.660E+09 45475.
10.56 ACCEPTABLE
=
Mean Radius. Rm 88.00 inches 200.0 1.651E*09 45253.
10.51 ACCEPTABLE rall Thickness, t 1.500 inches 205.0 1.631E+09 44607.
10.38 ACCEPTABLE ITl Material 104 SS 210.0 1.598E*09 43781.
10.18 ACCEPTABLE (f)
Stress Intensity, Sm. 16900. psi 215.0 1.552E*09 42542.
9.90 ACCEPTABLE 3
Fluence 1.9E.19 n/cm"2 220.0 1.501E+09 41121.
9.58 ACCEPTABLE (Thus. LEFM evaluation not applicable) 225.0 1.455E*09 39883.
9.30 ACCEPTABLE O
230.0 1.416E+09 38809.
9.05 ACCEPTABLE f
THETA 1 THETA 2 THICKNESS 235.0 1.373E+09 37630.
8.79 ACCEPTABLE O
REGION Ideg.)
Ideg.)
linches]
240.0 1.331E*09 36485.
8.53 ACCEPTABLE Q
245.0 1.298E+09 35558.
8.32 ACCEPTABLE a
1 14.8 47.3 1.500 250.0 1.272E+09 34852.
8.16 ACCEPTABLE C) 2 53.6 104.0 1.500 255.0 1.252E+09 34312.
8.04 ACCEPTABLE Q
3 111.0 164.3 1.500 260.0 1.224E+09 33546.
7.87 ACCEPTABLE 4
211.7 231.1 1.500 265.0 1.204E+09 32989.
7.74 ACCEPTABLE 3
5 235.4 253.3 1.500 270.0 1.192E+09 32668.
1.67 ACCEPTABLE (D
6 264.8 312.4 1.500 275.0 1.189E+09 32587.
7.65 ACCEPTABLE
{
7 317.5 321.2 1.500 280.0 1.195E+09 32746.
7.68 ACCEPTABLE to 8
326.2 329.9 1.500 285.0 1.210E+09
- 33144, 7.77 ACCEPTABLE 6*
290.0 1.233E+09 33778.
7.92 ACCEPTABLE 3
295.0 1.258E+09 34482.
8.08 ACCEPTABLE LIMIT IDAD RESULTS:
300.0 1.286E+09 35233.
8.25 ACCEPTABLE
,o 305.0 1.321E+09 36207.
B.47 ACCEPTABLE 310.0 1.365E+09 37395.
8.74 ACCEPTABLE M
ALPHA MOMENT Pb' SAFETY 315.0 1.406E*09 38530.
0.99 ACCEPTABLE N
[deg]
lin-1bs]
[ psi]
FACTOR RESULT 320.0 1.452E+09 39792.
9.28 ACCEPTABLE 03 325.0 1.493E+09 40960.
9.54 ACCEPTABLE O
.0 1.541E+09 42223.
9.83 ACCEPTABLE 330.0 1.527E+09
- 41836, 9.74 ACCEPTABLE 5.0 1.548E+09 42415.
9.07 ACCEPTABLE 335.0 1.547E+09
- 42394, 9.87 ACCEPTABLE b
10.0 1.558E+09 42707.
9.94 ACCEPTABLE 340.0 1.556E+09 42629.
P.92 ACCEPTABLE O
15.0 1.583E*09 41375.
10.09 ACCEPTABLE 345.0 1.542E+09 42262.
9.04 ACCEPTABLE d
20.0 1.590E+09 43563.
10.13 ACCEPTABLE 350.0 1.530E+09 42146.
9.01 ACCEPTABLE 25.0 1.584E+09 43419.
10.10 ACCEPTABLE 355.0 1.530E+09 42133.
9.81 ACCEPTABLE 30.0 1.567E+09 42945.
9.99 ACCEPTABLE 35.0 1.538E*09 42144 9.81 ACCEPTABLE h-40.0 1.497E+09 41023.
9.56 ACCEPTABLE ACCEPTABLEt MINIMUM SAFETY FACTOR =
7.65 AT 275.0 DEGREES.
45.0 1.451E+09 39765.
9.27 ACCEPTABLE 50.0 1.403E+09 38441.
8.97 ACCEPTABLE 55.0 1.361E+09 37292.
8.71 ACCEPTABLE 60.0 1.324E*09 36288.
8.48 ACCEPTABLE 65.0 1.290E*09 35361.
8.28 ACCEPTABLE 70.0 1.265E*09 34655.
8.12 ACCEPTABLE 75.0 1.247E+09 34175.
8.01 ACCEPTABLE 80.0 1.236E 09 33865.
7.94 ACCEPTABLE 85.0 1.218E+09 33381.
7.83 ACCEPTABLE 90.0 1.206E*09 33061.
7.76 ACCEPTABLE 95.0 1.204E+09 32980.
7.74 ACCEPTABLE 100.0 1.209E+09 33139.
7.77 ACCEPTABLE 105.0 1.224E+09
- 33537, 7.86 ACCEPTABLE 110.0 1.239E+09 33960.
7.96 ACCEPTABLE 115.0 1.258E+09 34482.
8.08 ACCEPTABLE 120.0 1.286E+09 35233.
8.25 ACCEPTABLE y
125.0 1.321E+09 36207.
8.47 ACCEPTABLE 130.0 1.365E+09 37395.
8.74 ACCEPTABLE N
135.0 1.416E+09 38790.
9.05 ACCEPTABLE 140.0 1.46fE+09 40170.
9.36 ACCEPTABLE 145.0 1.515E+09 41509.
9.67 ACCEPTABLE hw
1 Stwood Circumferential Wold Structural Evolustion Ugementlength_Determinetton sewous en=
1.25 tri E,d. Peried =
2000 days dee.
rienn io-BleP1 00 171 h tede =
246 h euseettnennt evolmed ste Jd/ff weed 10:
H7 Creet Growth Rose.
5E-05 innw tease =
225 in steuhee Dets ith MT1W Tete inspect 6en uncertairey =
0.00 in tmin = 250.8 in vmined at:.
DIM
.e Hgh NeZone
__ inspecoon Does End of Evesuseen tJgement Date Endof Evet. Crack Tip Dgut1DLL Analysis Input tw DLL Analyste
_u ernene Aaenuth l Arenuth Emisting Days to Fuey Amenuth Astenuati ugement In High Na Fore?
Aatmutti Arenuth Azenut4 Asemuth Ligament s
heter __SJ*1!d%Slw idee 8L*3r'h_'ai crected_
seeri edese$1ede,iLenge one Start
- see, start Ste, _
start
- ste, toneeh_
m (Tg 8
FAdo _ yy!O 46 8 18354 15.2 43.2 _ 4Q ewe nie 15 2 43.2
- 2 48 00
- 65 03 174.6 74724 49 6 163.4 189.0 We we 49.8 163.4 3
3 20360 257.69 80 6 32520 205.2 256 0 75.O We We 205.2 256.0 4
266 60 2 f f. 72 74 0 30122 268.2 315.1 70.0 We We 268.2 315.1 h
5 Jf 8 00 JJ7.59 29.2 11139 319.s 336.0 24.4 We nre 319.6 336 0 Ties Totteleet Appacese for Q
t Wold HT Q
=A
@o 2e-1 a.t.
o3 t\\
o
=
I r
e 1
O I
7 3
e i
.3 re
[
fakens (spement Leapth int =
405.8 EOE Lig. Lorgth tng =
301.0 Since EOE Ugement Longet2 isnht a detamed ende lead onosysin le sistseguired.
t f40TES t
til Ugement Data frorn 8111R1 GE Esemination Summary Sheets (2)
Crect growth is appeed at each end of Egement l
13i Days *e Fuey Cracted = deve te agement length to more tactusey: uncertain y + AsME crect prealmity sulel for each agement.
i 14)
Hoh Flue Zone = plus er minus 15 degrees from emirnuthe 45.135. 225 and 315 se 3400 secJ i
158 1 dog = 1.49228 tri Uninspected regione assumed fully croched. As erects assumed etwoughwae (71 Lease = unironwn required Egement length for Smit W eencoms - reference Structurd sneegrity report SIR-94-029 Rev. O (0) tmin = teele + 2tCrack Growthin Evolustion Pertoe + TotalInspection Uncertainty D
19)
See Note 6 to Table 7.4 trage 16)
N DL o
Y r
h 10(30/96 H7 SNP1 craft.WK4 f
e e
10/29/1996 12:16 Filename: U1H7N.CtTT PMe 1
1C/29/1996 12:16 Filsnamer U1H7N.0UT Pace 2
H7 Normal / Upset (2000 days) 165.0 1.461E+09 51785.
12.44 ACCEPTABLE DLL: DISTRIBtTTED LIGAMENT LENGTH EVALUATION (REVISION: 02/27/94) 170.0 1.474E+09 52269.
12.55 ACCEPTABLE
+
DATE OF CURRENT ANALYSIS: 10/29/1996 175.0 1.472E+09 52175.
12.53 ACCEPTABLE 100.0 1.474E+89 52272.
12.55 ACCEPTABLE SUHARY OF INPtTTS:
185.0 1.479E+09 52425.
12.59 ACCEPTABLE 190.0 1.484E+09 52620.
12.64 ACCEPTABLE Angle increment 1.0 deg. [ COARSE) 195.0
- 1. 4 72 E* 09 52199.
12.54 ACCEPTAB12
=
Membrane Stress. Pm 695. pst 200.0 1.449E*09 51302.
12.34 ACCEPTABLE Bending Stress. Pb 3524. pst 205.0 1.415E+09 50173.
12.06 ACCEPTABLE A
=
Safety Factor. SF 2.25 210.0 1.374E+09 48724.
11.71 ACCEPTABLE
=
Mean Radius Rm 84.75 inches 215.0 1.337E+09 47401.
11.40 ACCEPTABLE
=
9 tall Thickness, t 1.250 inches 220.0 1.303E+09 46209.
11.12 ACCEPTABLE f71 Materini 304 SS 225.0 1.272E+09 45002.
10.05 ACCEPTABLE
(/)
=
Stress Intensity, Sm. 16900. psi 230.0 1.236E+09 43037.
10.56 ACCEPTABLE 2
Fluence
= 1.9E+19 n/ca"2 235.0 1.207E+09 42793.
10.31 ACCEPTABLE g
(
(Thus LEFM evaluation not applicable) 240.0 1.182E+09 41913.
10.10 ACCEPTABLE g
i 245.0 1.162E+09 41203.
9.93 ACCEPTABLE THETA 1 THETA 2 THIC10tESS 250.0 1.147E+09 40670.
9.00 ACCEPTABLE Q
REGION
[deg.]
[deg.)
[ inches]
255.0 1.137E+09 40317.
9.72 ACCEPTABLE O
260.0 1.133E+09 40101.
9.69 ACCEPTABLE
=a 1
15.2 43.2 1.250 265.0 1.123E+09 39028.
9.60 ACCEPTABLE 03 2
49.6 163.4 1.250 270.0 1.110E+09 39358.
9.49 ACCEPTABLE O
3 205.2 256.0 1.250 275.0 1.103E+09 39113.
9.44 ACCEPTABLE 4
268.2 315.1 1.250 200.0 1.102E+09 39060.
9.42 ACCEPTABLE 3
5 319.6 336.0 1.250 205.0 1.106E+09 39201.
9.46 ACCEPTABLE O
290.0 1.115E+09 39534.
9.54 ACCEPTABLE I.
295.0 1.130E+09 40056.
9.66 ACCEPTABLE E
LIMIT 14AD RESULTS:
300.0 1.150E+09 40764.
9.83 ACCEPTABLE Q
...............====
305.0 1.175E+09
- 41652, 10.04 ACCEPTABLE 3
310.0 1.205E+09 42713.
10.29 ACCEPTABIE ALPHA MOMENT Fb' SAFETY 315.0 1.237E*09 43042.
10.56 ACCEPTABLE
.O i
[deg)
(in-lbs)
(psil FACTOR RESULT 320.0 1.270E+09 45020.
10.04 ACCEPTABLE t
325.0 1.308E+09 46360.
11.15 ACCEPTABLE
.0 1.436E+09 50897 12.23 ACCEPTABLE 330.0 1.349E+09 47829.
11.50 ACCEPTABLE N
5.0 1.440E+09
- 51050, 12.26 ACCEPTABLE 335.0 1.309E+09 49231.
11.83 ACCEPTABLE E
10.0 1.452E+09 51465.
12.36 ACCEPTABLE 340.0 1.416E+09 50206.
12.06 ACCEPTABLE h
15.0 1.440E+09 51325.
12.33 ACCEPTABLE 345.0 1.433E+09 50798.
12.20 ACCEPTABLE 20.0 1.433E+09 50795.
12.20 ACCEPTABLE 350.0 1.439E+09 51003.
12.25 ACCEPTABLE 25.0 1.407E+09
- 49074, 11.99 ACCEPTABLE 355.0 1.433E*09 50000.
12.21 ACCEPTABLE 30.0 1.369E+09 48548.
11.67 ACCEPTABLE 35.0 1.332E+09 47225.
11.36 ACCEPTABLE ee 40.0 1.299E+09 46066.
11.08 ACCEPTABLE ACCEPTABLEI MINIMUM SAFETY FACTOR =
9.42 AT 280.0 DEGREES.
45.0 1.260E+09 44684.
10.76 ACCEPTABLE 50.0 1.227E*09 43484.
10.47 ACCEPTABLE 55.0 1.197E+09 42440.
10.22 ACCEPTABLE 60.0 1.172E+09 41559.
10.02 ACCEPTABLE 65.0 1.152E+09 40850.
9.85 ACCEPTABLE 10.0 1.137E+09 40317.
9.72 ACCEPTABLE 75.0 1.127E+09 39964 9.64 ACCEPTABLE I
80.0 1.122E+09 39794.
9.60 ACCEPTABLE 85.0 1.122E+09 39793.
9.60 ACCEPTABLE 90.0 1.113E+09 39476.
9.52 ACCEPTABLE 95.0 1.107E+09 39231.
3.46 ACCEPTABLE i
^
100.0 1.105E+09 39178.
9.45 ACCEPTABLE 105.0 1.109E+09 39319.
9.48 ACCEPTABLE 110.0 1.110E+09 39652.
9.56 ACCEPTABLE 115.0 1.133E+09 40174.
9.69 ACCEPTABLE 120.0 1.153E+09 40882.
9.85 ACCEPTABLE 125.0 1.178E*09 41770.
10.07 ACCEPTABLE h
130.0 1.208E*09
- 42831, 10.32 ACCEPTABLE N
135.0 1.243E+09 44050.
10.61 ACCEPTABLE 140.0 1.277E+09 45264 10.09 ACCEPTABLE g
145.0 1.314E+09 46596.
11.21 ACCEPTABLE 150.0 1.356E*09 48064.
11.56 ACCEPTABLE O
155.0 1.400E+09 49643.
11.93 ACCEPTABLE N
160.0 1.436E+09 50909.
12.23 ACCEPTABLE G
- ~ - ~
+e.~,
-, _. _ _ _.. _ _... +.
.m.
_, - _..... _. ~ - -,,
e
+
10/29/1996 12:19 Filenamer UIM7E.OUT Page 1
10/29/1996 12:13 Filenamer U1M7E.OUT Page 2
L i
H7 Emergency (2000 days) 165.0 1.471E+09 52151.
0.55 ACCEPTABLE DLL: DISTRIBt/TED LIGAMENT LENGTH EVALUATION (REVISION: 02/27/94) 170.0
- 1. 4 9 9E+ 09 52777.
S.65 ACCEPTABLE DATE OF CURRENT ANALYSISr 10/29/1996 175.0 1.495E*09
- 53001, 0.69 ACCEPTABLE 100.0 1.490E+09 53090.
8.70 ACCEPTABLE f
St9%ARY OF IMPUTS:
185.0 1.501E+09 53232.
0.72 ACCEPTABLE f
190.0 1.497E*09 53072.
0.70 ACCEPTABLE Angle increment 1.0 deg. ECOARSE) 195.0 1.481E+09 52507 0.61 ACCEPTABLE
=
Membrane Stress, Pm 1502. poi 200.0 1.454E+09 51544.
8.45 ACCEPTABLE 1
=
Bending Stress, Pb 4772. poi 205.0 1.415E+09 50160.
B.24 ACCEPTABLE 4
Safety Factor, SF 1.50 210.0 1.374E+09 48724.
0.01 ACCEPTABLE
=
Mean Radius. Rm 84.75 inches 215.0 1.337E+09 47401.
7.79 ACCEPTABLE SBs11 Thickness, t 1.250 inches 220.0 1.303E+09
- 46209, 7.60 ACCEPTABLE 373
=
Material 304 SS 225.0 1.274E+09 45156.
7.44 ACCEPTABLE (p)
=
Stress Intensity, Sm = 16900 poi 230.0 1.240E+09 43975.
7.25 ACCEPTABLE y
Fluence 1.9E+19 n/cm*2 235.0 1.211E+09 42930.
7.00 ACCEPTABLE IThus. LEFM evaluation not applicable) 240.0 1.186E+09 42050.
6.94 ACCEPTABLE t
f 245.0 1.166E+09 41341.
6.83 ACCEPTABLE I
THETA 1 1HETA2 THICKNESS 250.0 1.151E+09 40007.
6.74 ACCEPTABLE Q
REGION
[deg.]
[deg.)
[ inches) 255.0 1.141E+09 40454.
6.69 ACCEPTABLE Q
260.0 1.135E+09 40225.
6.65 ACCEPTABLE n
1 15.2 43.2 1.250 265.0 1.120E+09 39715.
6.57 ACCEPTABLE 2
49.6 163.4 1.250 270.0 1.100E+09 39279.
6.50 ACCEPTABLE O
3 205.2 256.0 1.250 275.0 1.101E+09 39034 6.46 ACCEPTABLE L
4 268.2 315.1 1.250 200.0 1.100E+09 38982.
6.45 ACCEPTABLE 2
5 319.6 336.0 1.250 205.0 1.103E+09 39123.
6.45 ACCEPTABLE g
t 290.0 1.113E+09 39455.
6.53 ACCEPTABLE i
r 295.0 1.128E+09 39978.
6.61 ACCEPTABLE 05 LIMIT I4AD RESULTS:
300.0 1.140E+09 40686.
6.72 ACCEPTABLE 6
l 305.0 1.173E+09 41573.
6.07 ACCEPTABLE 3
[
310.0 1.203E+09 42635.
7.03 ACCEPTABLE ALPHA MOMENT Pb' SAFETY 315.0 1.233E*05 43724 7.21 ACCEPTABLE h
idegl (in-1bs]
fps!)
FACTOR RESULT 320.0 1.267E+09 44910.
7.40 ACCEPTABLE c
325.0 1.304E+09 46242.
7.61 ACCEPTABLE k
.0 1.422E+09 50403.
8.27 ACCEPTABLE 330.0 1.345E+09 47691.
7.84 ACCEPTABLE N
t 5.0 1.426E+09 50556.
0.30 ACCEPTABLE 335.0 1.379E+09 40895.
0.03 ACCEPTABLE 08 10.0 1.432E+09 50764.
3.33 ACCEPTABLE 340.0 1.4 03 E+ 09 49726.
8.17 ACCEPTABLE O
[
15.0 1.432E+09 50761.
8.33 ACCEPTABLE 345.0 1.415E+09 50170.
8.24 ACCEPTABLE 20.0 1.421E+09 50372.
8.27 ACCEPTABLE 350.0 1.418E+09 50267.
S.25 ACCEPTABLE b
25.0 1.399E+09 49599.
8.14 ACCEPTABLE 355.0 1.419E+09 50307.
s.26 ACCEPTABLE O
[
30.0 1.367E+09 48449.
1.96 ACCEPTABLE h
35.0 1.329E+09 47126.
7.75 ACCEPTABLE
(
40.0 1.294E+09 45875.
7.55 ACCEPTABLE ACCEPTABLEI MINIMUM SAFETY FACTOR =
6.45 AT 280.0 DEGREES.
45.0 1.256E+09 44520.
7.34 ACCEPTABLB 50.0 1.222E+09 43327.
7.15 ACCEPTABLE 55.0 1.193E*09 42283.
6.98 ACCEPTABLE 60.0 1.168E+09 41403.
6.84 ACCEPTABLE 65.0 1.148E+49 40693.
6.73 ACCEPTABLE 70.0 1.133E+b9 40160.
6.64 ACCEPTABIE 75.0 1.123E*09 39807.
6.58 ACCEPTABLE i
80.0 1.118E+09 39637.
6.56 ACCEPTABLE L'
85.0 1.118E+09 39631.
6.56 ACCEPTABLE 90.0 1.112E+09 39441.
6.53 ACCEPTABLE 95.0 1.105E*09 39172.
6.48 ACCEPTABLE 100.0 1.103E+09 39a19.
6.47 ACCEPTABLE l
105.0 1.107E+09 39260.
6.50 ACCEPTABLE 110.0 1.117E+09 39593.
6.55 ACCEPTABLE 115.0 1.131E+09 40115.
6.63 ACCEPTABLE 120.0 1.151E+09 40823.
6.75 ACCEPTABLE 125.0 1.176E+09 41711.
6.09 ACCEPTABLE 130.0 1.206E+09 42772.
7.06 ACCEPTABLE 135.0 1.241E+C9 43999.
7.25 ACCEPTABLE 140.0 1.27eE+09 45323.
7.46 ACCEPTABLE D
145.0 1.316E*09 46655.
7.68 ACCEPTABLE 150.0 1.357E+09 48123.
7.91 ACCEPTABLE O
155.0 1.402E*09 49711.
8.16 ACCEPTABLE T1 160.0 1.442E*09 51129.
0.39 ACCEPTABLE h
I v1
,---n
,. ~,
.. ~.., - _ - - -, - ---
e e
10/29/3996 1.7:20 Filen*e U1H7F.OUT P*o*
1 10/29/1996 12:20 Filenamer U1H7F.Otfr P.u*
2 6
M7 Faulted (2000 days) t 165.0 1.411E+09 52151.
7.85 ACCEPTABLE i
DLL DISTRIBttrED LIGAMENT LENGTH EVALUATION (REVISION: 02/27/94) 170.0 1.499E+09 52777 7.94 ACCEPTABLE DAW OF CURRENT ANALYSIS: 10/29/1996 175.0 1.495E+09 53001.
7.97 ACCEPTABLE 100.0 1.490E+09 53098.
7.99 ACCEPTABLE i
SUP91ARY OF INPtTTSs 105.0 1.501E+09 53232.
8.01 ACCEPTABLE 190.0 1.497E+09 53072.
7.99 ACCEPTABLE I
Angle increment 1.0 deg. (COARSE) 195.0 1.481E*09 52507.
7.90 ACCEPTABLE
=
Membrane Stress, Pm 1536. poi 200.0 1.454E*09 51544.
7.75 ACCEPTABLE
=
Eending Stress, Pb 5301. ps!
205.0 1.415E+09 50168.
7.56 ACCEPTABLE A
-j
=
Safety Factor. SF 1.13
=
210.0 1.374E+09 48724.
1.35 ACCEPTABLE Mean Radius, Rm 04.75 inches 215.0 1.337E+09 47401.
7.16 ACCEPTABLE
=
Eall Thickness, t 1.250 inches 220.0 1.303E*09 46209.
6.Se ACCEPTABLE m
=
Material 304 SS
=
225.0 1.2748+09 45156.
6.03 ACCEPTABLE (O
Stress Intensity, Sm = 16900. poi 230.0 -
1.240E+09 43975.'
6.65 ACCEPTABLE 3
Fluence
= 1.9E+19 n/cm*2 235.0 1.211E+09 42930.
6.50 ACCEPTABLE (Thus. LEFM evaluation not applicable) 240.0 1.106E+09 42050.
6.37 ACCEPTABLE j
245.0 1.166E+09
- 41341, 6.27 ACCEPTABLE THETA 1 THETA 2 THICKNESS 250.0 1.151E+09 40007.
6.19 ACCEPTABLE Q
REGION (deg.]
(deg.)
(inches) 255.0 1.141E+09 40454.
6.14 ACCEPTABLE Q
260.0 1.135E+09 40225.
6.11 ACCEPTABLE a
+
1 15.2 43.2 1.250 265.0 1.120E+09 39715.
6.03 ACCEPTABLE C) 2 49.6 163.4 1.250 270.0 1.100E+09 39279.
5.97 ACCEPTABLE O
i 1
205.2 256.0 1.250 275.0 1.101E+09 39034.
5.93 ACCEPTABLE j
4 268.2 315.1 1.250 200.0 1.100E+09 30992.
5.92 ACCEPTABLE J3 t
5 319.6 336.0 1.250 205.0 1.103E+09 39123.
5.95 ACCEPTABLE S
290.0 1.113E+09
- 39455, 5.99 ACCEFTABLE 1
295.0 1.120E+09 39978.
6.07 ACCEPTABLE 44 LIMIT IDAD RESULTS:
300.0 1.140E+09 40606.
6.17 ACCEPTABLE O
~
305.0 1.173E+09 41573.
6.30 ACCEPTABLE 3
i 310.0 1.203E+09 42635.
6.45 ACCEPTABLE ALPHA MOMENT Pb' SAFETY 315.0 1.233E+09 43724.
6.62 ACCEPTABLE
,o (degl lin-lbs)
(psil FACTOR RESULT 320.0 1.267E+09 44910.
6.79 ACCEPTABLE v
325.0 1.304E*09 46242.
6.99 ACCEPTABLE M
.0 1.422E+09 50403.
1.59 ACCEPTABLE 330.0 1.345E+09 47691.
7.20 ACCEPTABLE M
5.0 1.426E+09 50556.
1.62 ACCEPTABLE 335.0 1.379E 09 40095.
7.37 ACCEPTABLE 8
10.0 1.432E+09 50764.
7.65 ACCEPTABLE 340.0 1.403E+09 49726.
7.50 ACCEPTABLE 15.0 1.432E+09 50761.
7.65 ACCEPTABLE 345.0 1.415E+09 50170.
7.56 ACCEPTABLE
(
20.0 1.421E+09 50312.
1.59 ACCEPTABLE 350.0 1.410E+09 50267.
7.57 ACCEPTABLE f
25.0 1.399E+09 49599.
1.4e ACCEPTABLE 355.0 1.419E+09 50307.
1.50 ACCEPTABLE O
30.0 1.367E+09 48449.
7.31 ACCEPTABLE k
35.0 1.329E+09 47126.
7.12 ACCEPTABLE t
40.0 1.294E*09 45875.
6.93 ACCEPTABLE ACCEPTABLEt MINIMUM 'AFETY FACTVR =
5.92 AT 280.0 DEGREES.
45.0 1.256E*09 44528.
6.74 ACCEPTABLE 50.0 1.222E*09 43327.
6.56 ACCEPTABLE f
55.0 1.193E+09 42283.
6.41 ACCEPTABLE 60.0 1.160E*09 41403.
6.28 ACCEPTABLE g
65.0 1.148E+09 40693.
6.10 ACCEPTABLE 70.0 1.133E+09 40160.
6.10 ACCEPTABLE l
75.0 1.123E+09 39007.
6.05 ACCEPTABLE
[
80.0 1.118E+09 39637.
6.02 ACCEPTABLE 85.0 1.118E+09 39631.
6.02 ACCEPTABLE 90.0 1.112E+09 39441.
5.99 ACCEPTABLE h
95.0 1.105E+09 39172.
5.95 ACCEPTABLE 100.0 1.103E+09 39119.
5.94 ACCEPTABLE l
105.0 1.107E+09 39260.
5.97 ACCEPTABLE 110.0 1.117E*09 39593.
6.01 ACCEPTABLE h
i 115.0 1.131E+09
- 40115, 6.09 ACCEPTABLE 120.0 1.151E+09
- 40823, 6.19 ACCEPTABLE f
125.0 1.176E+09 41711.
6.32 ACCEPTABLE 130.0 1.206E+09 42772.
6.45 ACCEFTABLE h
135.0 1.241E*09 43999.
6.66 ACCEPTABLE 140.0 1.27BE+09 45323.
6.95 ACCEPTABLE 145.0 1.316E+09 46655.
7.05 ACCEPTABLE 150.0 1.357E+09 48123.
7.26 ACCEPTABLE I
155.0 1.402E+09
- 49717, 7.49 ACCEPTABLE D
E 160.0 1.442E+09 51129.
7.10 ACCEPTABLE II i
f
..m
. - -. - - - -. - -.~~.-
-m-,e n-e.-
_m.,,_~.cw
t BrunswiclLCora_ShrouiSummary_oLLoada aniStransesAtEacitliorizontaLWeliLocation pensrunces (f) siwt Core sfreint nebeson toed omensen 0:4ssene*, st-4p42, mov. o
_ Inputs Symbols:
Vertical OBE(2/3 Horir. OBE) =
0.0535 g
D = Dood Loads VerticalSSE(2/3 Horir. SSE) =
0.1070 g
B = Buoyancy Forces Density Wofer =
0.036 lblin 3 P = Intemel Pressure Differenhal a
Density Shroud =
0.290 lbiln^3 Pn= NormalPressure
.i Shroud Head Area =
27317.92 in.^2 Pu = Upset Pressure Acoustic load =
60.00 Kips P1 = LOCA Pressure (max of MS and RR LOCA)
Acoustic Undorm =
0.195 K/In.
MSLOCA = Mein Steam LOCA Norme/ Head DP =
10 Psi RRLOCA = Reactor Recyculation LOCA 33 Upsef HeadDP =
11.8 Psi OBE = Operating Basis Earthquake CD Feuffed Head DP =
30 Psi SSE = Safe Shutdown Earthquake m
NormalCore Pfefe DP =
25.9 Psi Pm = Pnrnary Membrane Stresses 6
Upsef Core Pfefe DP =
29.3 Psi Pb = Primary Bending Stresses o
s Fauffed Core Piefe DP =
34 Psi DP = Differential Pressure Numbero/ Drive Tubes =
137 Tension = (-) Negative values indicate upwerd load - opposite gravity Drive Tube Diameter =
10.075 in.
Compression = ( + ) Positive values indicate downward load - with gravty Core Pfefe Effective Area =
11190.24 In.^2 N
see Note e to TeMe 7.4 concomhe sadnese er = at weW H7 h
[
PROPERTIES N1 N2 N3 N4 NS N8e K86 NT N8 5
Weld Elevation sea ssa ase ses 353ss3 317 ss3 21s713 1e3 7t3 17s.4s3 127.400 111 s00 6*
Shroud Outside Radius (in) se rso s47so se 7so ra.7so es.7so so.7so so.7so es.sco es soo 3
Shroud inside Radius tin) e3 250 s3.250 er.2so e7.2so e7.250 e7.2so e72so e4 2so es soo o
Shroud Thickness (in) 1.500 t.sco 1.s00 1.sco 1.500 1.500 1.500 1.25o 2.000 Shroud Wat Area (sq in) ees s3 ses 93 e2s 3e e2s se e2s se s2s.3e ers.3e seee1 1osIIes_ _
i, Centertine Section Modulus 41s41 41s41 3sess seems seems 3sess 3sess 2oast 44e70 h
LOADINGS N1 N2 N3 H4 MS N00 N9b NT NE C3 Shroud %ht (kips) 12eo 137.1 1de e t57 e te2 e 1e2 0 213 e 227.1 227.1 7-I Buoyant Force (kips)
-15 s4
-17 02
-te es te se
-22 ee
-23 e3
-2s se
-2s.to
-2s te h
OBE Moment (in-kips) +/-
20:00 assoo 2esco as700
-i es2co 7ee00 80400 99700 105000 s
{
OBE Shear 1 kips) +/-
tot 2ss 2ss ses are 414 414 414 4t4 OBE Vertical (kips) +/-
e.74 7.33 7 es e.44 s 7e 10.27 11.44 12.15 12.t5
~ 5E Moment (in-kips) +/-
2s500 34eco 34eco assa eseco toeoco toscoo 135o00 142000 S
'h SSE Shear (kips) +/-
3e2 sia sit s72 ese ere are oas ers SSE Vertical Uplift (kips) +/-
13 4e 14 er 15.so to se is se 20.54 22.es 24.30 24 30 RRIOCA Blowdown (in-kips) +/-
73 53 ase to 42sao ser so 4ses.57 74se se 7eseet 14s7s so 167 RRT6CA Accoustic (in-kips) +/-
212 se so3 e4 eso e1 134se2 4540 e3 steo 27 e3eo de 9250 so to d o?
,Y.
1Nembrarse (Pm) Stresses N1 N2 N3 N4 MS M8e N96 MT NE Mist Pressure (psi)
-30s
-sco
-32s
-22e
-32s
-es2
-es2
-est
-541 Upset Pressure (psi)
-sed
-see
-see
-3ee
-ses
-re4
-7e4
.s7s
-oh
[
LOCA Pressure (psi)
-s2s
-s2s
-see
-see
-see
-1447
-1447
-teco
-113o _
j Deadloadp) 142 155 17e too 22o 231 258 341 214 Buoyancyjpsi)
-te
-to
-22
-24
-27
-2e
-32
-42
-27 i
OBE Vertical (psi) +/-
e e
to to 12 12 14 to tt l
SSE Vertical (psi) +/-
1s 17 1s ao 24 25 2e as 23
- 7. ^ _, .
,, (Pb) Stresses N1
,N2 H2 N4 MS Nga N66 NT No OBE jpsi) 4e3 est 721 scos seis 21s2 2203 3s24 2340 SSEjpsi) ese est see 134o 2433 reos asse 4772 stes O
RR_ t.OCA_ Blowdown {psl}
2 e
12 27 12e 204 215 s2s 3eo RR LOCA Accoustic (psi) s 15 to 37 124 1ce 17s 327 227 i
D
-rs STRESNEF VA4 Pese 1 er2 tor 309e b
Io m
~ -.
4 Brunswick _ Cote _ Shroud _ Summary _ofl oads_and_SttesamaAt_EachJiorizontaLWeld_ Location L
~ ~MIf 3iresses-NormaFUjpsef Nf I
H3 l
IN I
N5 i
N8e i
Nob l
St~ f- 'He l
Co
~
Nombrane tension ( -) Pu+D+ B-OBEv
-247
-237
-241
-232
-207
-594
-572 ess
-43e compression ( + ) Pu+D+B+0BEv o
o o
o o
o o
o
,o_. _
Beneng
_s
(+/-) OBE 4s3 l
e32 l
721 l
1eos I
te14 l
21e2 l
2203 1
3524 l
2340 Nombrane + Beneng
?,
tension ( -) Pu+D+B-OBE
-730
-ses
-se2
-123e
-2021
-275e
-2775
-4219
-2777 compression ( + ) Pu+D+B+0BE 251 412 ese 7e4 teso 15e3 itse 2ess te27 33 h
Combined Strwsses-Emergency Hf l
H3 l
N4 l
N5 l
M8e l
N86 l
N7 i
Nt Membrane b
tension (- ) Pu+D+B-SSEv
-255
-245
-251
-242
-21e
-sos
-ses
-713
-44e O
compression ( + ) Pu+D+B+SSEv o
o o
o o
o o
o o
h
[
tension (-) Pl+D+B
.soo
-7eo
-est
-e21
-795
-1244
-1221
-1502
-e43 compression ( + ) Pl+D+B o
o o
o o
o o
o o
Bendng
'KE i
(+/-) SSE ese est see 1340 2433 2ood 2ose 4772 3165
e 12 27 12e 204 215 529 390 Gi'
15 10 37 124 1st 175 327 227 6'
Nombrane + Bendng 3
b Tension ( -) Pu+D+B-SSE
-es t
-to7s
-11ee
-15e2
-2e52
-3510
-3545
-5485
-3sts O
I Compression ( + ) Pu+D+B+SSE 412 ete 735 t13e 22s1 234e 242e 4131 27e3
(
M Tension ( -) Pl+D+B-Blowdown
-802
-7ee
-843
-e4e
-e21
-144e
-143e
-2031
-1333 Compression ( + ) Pl+D+B+ Blowdown 0
o o
o o
o o
o o,
h Tension (-) Pl+D+B-Accoustk
-sos
-e04
-849
-ess
-e20
-1413
-13ee
-ters
-tiro o
Compressio's ( + ) Pl+D+ B+Accoustk o
o o
o o
o o
o o
{
e Combined Stresses-Feu/ fee Hf I
H3 i
H5 i
N6e l
H6b i
HT I
Hs 3
i Nombre w tension (- ) Pl+D+B-SSEv
-e t e
-sos
-eso
-e42
-sis
-tree
-1249
-153e
-ess Benena D
I compression ( + ) Pl+D+B+SSEv o
o o
o e
o o
o o
l
(+/-) SSE + RR Blowdown ese eso eso 13es 255e stos 3175 5301 3555
{
(+/-) SSE + RR Accoustk e42 e45 ese 1377 255e 3074 3134 50se 33e2
^^ MN + Beneng Tension ( + ) Pl+D+ B-SSE-Blowdown
-1454
-toes
-teio
,220s
-337e
-437e
-4423
-se40
-4521
{
Compression ( + ) Pl+D+B+SSE+ Blowdown o
e7 14e ses tres teso test sese 2e35 Tension (- ) Pl+D+B-SSE-Accoustk
-1457
-test
-tete
-221e
-337e
-4343
-43e3 es37
-435e Compression ( + ) Pl+D+B+SSE+Accoustk o
72 154 57e 17ee lose 1941 se34 2472 t
l b
N O
'P (A)
STRESNEF M 4 Pese 2 of2 tor 504e l
o.
0 SafetyIactors BNP (1)
ASME (2)
Ratio Normal /Upsef =
2.25 2.77 1.23 (1) From Section 3.9.5.2.1 of FSAR Ememency =
1.50 1.39 0 93 (2) From Section XI Appendix C Feu#ed =
1.13 1.39 1.24 DLL INPUTS N1 N2 N3 N4 H5 M8e N86 NT M8 Normal / Upset Membrane =
247 237 241 232 207 see 572 eos 43s
.s Normal / Upset Bending =
4e3 e32 721 teos te14 21s2 2203 3s24 2340 -
f75 Emergency Membrane =
soo 7so est ett 795 1244 1221 1s02 e43, __ _
m (O
Emergency Bending =
ese est see 13eo 2433 reos 2sse 4772
_ 3165, _
g On FauRed Membrane = l sts aos eso e42 sie 12ee tres tsse r
. ses _]_-
6 l
FauRed Bending = !
e42 ses ses 1377 255e 31oe 3175 5301 3555 o
memtrene (normat. emerg. fouted ecreen) emergency emergency emergency emergener emergency emergency emergency _
o bendtrig (nermel, emerg. foused stroen) normal normal.
normal normal
._..J fiormal
,_..J
. -.. J 2
memtrene (emergencyNeuned screen) a
. -, - ~,
. _, ~,
emergency emergency
..m_,
. 7_g _
g bondhg ;.
,..~,.1_" f acreen)
.___.-r emergency emergency emergency emergency emergency emergency _
O "3
O i
M s
O l
- 7
=
3e "3
ee i
i b
Pw o
73 i
O STRESNEF.WK4 Page 1 of2 w
1(y3(wee i
~
w
~. - -'