ML20056G609
| ML20056G609 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Issue date: | 05/28/1993 |
| From: | Acker D NRC OFFICE OF INSPECTION & ENFORCEMENT (IE REGION V) |
| To: | Faulkenberry B NRC |
| Shared Package | |
| ML20056G560 | List: |
| References | |
| NUDOCS 9309030324 | |
| Download: ML20056G609 (3) | |
Text
..
.. ~...
i.
l 4
l 1
6 5
MMf 28,1993 l
[
l MEN 3%NDEM FGt:
B. H. FAIEJGHBERRY F5EM:
D)22 AC3GR SUE 7ET:
REVIDI or 'DE: DRAFT RD3ICH V REALICROGNP SItDt
)
Attached are wf ccaments to the study. I also plan to write to the t
h4=ioners ocreerning the ZDo's ground ruims for the stutf, sinos that is my main conomen.
l
-i I
i e c. A&ar l
ico V Reactor IrWw f
f t
4 h
i 5
I i
t i
(
i 4
i t
1 i
t
,A d e
[
f- (w^)
\\,
ogs
!\\ J i
e (fj,,\\, G
\\
i.i i
c,
~
9309030324 930812 CDP 4Pgs tJRCC 101 PDR CORRESPDPEENCE PDR TOTR. P.04 l
l
~
stasy..... _-h 1.
Pegs 28, last' paragraph di=m-the benefits of a larger inspection staff in a larger regicn. While the listed benefits appear true, it is also true (but not stated) that the individual inspa m 's cwerall knowledge of each site's unagemnt, design and operation will be.e.
- in a large regicn with rcre sitas. Roo:rrend so noting.
2.
Pago 29, first o:rplete paragraph, last senterce. I dcn't see this as a benafit unlesa Regions IV ard V have a histcry of nerH;capmation.
i 3.
Page 35, this' analysis seens wrorg. Flight tires for a charter plane fren Dallas to Lincoln, Nebr. plus drive tire to cooper is certainly less than the flight / drive to Diablo Canyon or WrP2 frtn Dallas. Unlaan we intend to pay someone to unintain a stardby jet in Dallas, Irmpme tasms frtn Dallas will not mke the 6 hour6.944444e-5 days <br />0.00167 hours <br />9.920635e-6 weeks <br />2.283e-6 months <br /> t no....and the airgw.'us near DC are oftan fogged in (occasionally at RP2). Khy doesn't the study say honestly that you my not mke the 6 hour6.944444e-5 days <br />0.00167 hours <br />9.920635e-6 weeks <br />2.283e-6 months <br /> time lirdt frcn Dallas and let the M *= ion daal with it?
Also this secticn says the staff would call upcn the residents frcrn the other West Cbast sites for immediate limited respcess to any site that had a mjar problam. Please add that WW2 is excitried frcen this sta+
=nt, sitce there will be no nearby residents.
4.
Page 37, encord paragraph. 7his, in my mind, is entirely ir - Kt..
In an Edy=.ucy the entire 180 staff would (and should) respco$. I disagree that regicnal Ecundaries would block any cxrbined re.,cnse. The overall loss of 70 people in regions IV/V is stat will have a negative irpact on mmgen:y response, try reducing the everall pool of talented people.
The ary.rmnt that 180 people in Dallas can rwd to a west osaat eamvurcy better than 80 people in HC ard 100 in Dallas says that Regions IV ard V rany.cc would let Regional Ecundaries interfare with an c.c ercy ruspanse. With separate Regions, initial pECpl4 would get v
there earlier, ard the pool of ba::kup people is still thers, as r==4=1 Raqaest this p agraph be reworded.
5.
Page 44.
Does the travel costs incluie the extra trips inspectcrs will have to mke trun Dallas to West Coast plants to mintain the same inspection effort"t To get 600 hcurs of DIE, a typical inspectar crzrdng to West coast plants from >11= will have to rake two rcre trips than he/she would have had to rake frcn HC.
That aro.mts to 2 tors ruuM trip air farms, car rentals and 10 days per diem. This cost will occur. I Please insure tycur study ircitdes it.
6.
Page 45.
(Qaestion Cnly) sirca tha cost of travel to uc frun HDC is only 60 dollars rec e for a rcr.rd trip, and per diem about 40 dollars a day rcre, the avefage IQ enployee c: ring to RV on site specific business, will cost around 200 dollars rcre for a short stay,100 of these trips would be 20,0$0.
Trips taken to RV on regional business would cost ateut 800 dollars rare fer shart trips.
150 cf these trips would be 120,000 dollars.
102
m 4
lO
- ;& ~6
/f \\\\\\
t s '* # 6 S dg,#,
\\//o '('{ 1q'fff' h t#
IMAGE EVALUATION jjk 4
TEST TARGET (MT-3) 7 Jg~%,fte Ys &gg, Q4 4
,.o w w a IM $2.2 lemu t-ru E C'" llim.0 112 l-l E
=
L l l 1.8 u_
l.25 1.4 1.6 4
150mm 6"
4 4
z,@
gr e>of, 7,,
d!)
s$ "
e sp, gg ss
- ,y,
, &7-o m
4p p p
+,
p.-,.-
\\
'/
I, g%**
UL.
< e..'
,,-.._r,
f f'2 t.1 '.._., _ _.. _,_jrj.. _1_____.___.__ _gj_;:".sdjyypis!d h ; _
l ll(g c%
Q, o',e'
'a %m
[A 6W #4, n
9' :, +
t "g' IMAGE EVAL.U ATION
</
\\g// '('~ QIf TEST TARGET (MT-3)
J, g,
((/
(' @, diff
[
//
$'%f/
k l.0
": "" "4 v nn u
!k;:Ee t-F 2.0 s
j,l e
M
[ 1.25 l
1.4
'i!=1.6 i..
!l:
=
4---
150mm 4___.--
6" ch.%~,kjp s s /,A h
4 O/sgv
~ e n"4 v ;a,
,/
r y*
o
^
a c
o*4
'4fi,'9' 7
oy
(
3y n
x
... "11
+s
,O
..y, p.
'['j/j//
[ Y, dT4,
<'s O
IMAGE EVALUATION
////
TEST TARGET (MT-3)
/
'^
p 4Q
[V 1.0 p22
% 2.0 l l,l b EE:
I;!!! l.8 i
lbs
'!! l.25 l!!H I.4 91.6 IMeme bmsz f
isomm I _-
4
..____.._____._.--6" l
'le 4lh
- f4
$$p gge Alf :% yyc
'h Q > //f\\
3 o,
p 6d jj
- ~~
i
.a a
Do we really have that many visits / reviews per year?
7.
Option 4.
Nok math? Region V TY95 staffing sh:vs 6 materials irWwe... the Region IV Cption 4 staffing shcus an f x:rease of 11 i
positibas in tRSS, an increase of 1 in Qin fco-the state aWAd.
positien, and'an increase of 1 in E3% to swL the new peopla. 'Jhe sta2y indicates that i a:kiitional inspectar will be required, das to travel tias....so if you t:cansfer 6 positicris arti add 1 icu abenild have an increams of 7 positiens, not 11.
I don't urxlerstand where the other 4 positionscampfrom. Plan =a resolve.
I e.
0:xzent. If 6ptions 2 or 3 were to be chosen, the h4==ir=1, cruid allow a&iitic6al reactor inspectors to work out of the WC office, inspectire We6t Coast plants and rvr==ionally plants closer to Dallas.
i
'this would be no scre sg-sive than flyirg pocple frca Dallas, ew=4N "no additional cost" office space is available in WC. 'Jhis would be only
)
for existing $2alified inspectors arri enly until they retized, were pseted ca free office space hacw e unavailable. 'Ihis option would be especially irportant to Bill Wagner, with his wife's medical conditicn.
I'd appreciate it if you cx:uld put this option in the stufy, as it could save the M== ion mwing expenses, preclude ps.h hardships, and potentially cost nothing.
9.
Oorsnent. 'Ihate are several places in the study which d4='$m= the limited i
cuerview that inspectors in a arall Regicn V would have, das to a small sacple of sitp to inw. 'Ihis could be easily taken care of through mare exdiarge inspe:ticns with other Regions ani dcmin't appear to take acving to Dallas to resolve. Smygest report noted that more excharryes could ocner withcut mvirg.
j i
e 1
i t
103