ML20043A410

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Forwards Security Insp Repts 50-528/90-14,50-529/90-14 & 50-530/90-14 on 900404-30.Weaknesses Identified in Personnel Training & Contingency Plan Implementation.Encl Withheld (Ref 10CFR2.790 & 73.21)
ML20043A410
Person / Time
Site: Palo Verde  Arizona Public Service icon.png
Issue date: 05/15/1990
From: Pate R
NRC OFFICE OF INSPECTION & ENFORCEMENT (IE REGION V)
To: Conway W
ARIZONA PUBLIC SERVICE CO. (FORMERLY ARIZONA NUCLEAR
Shared Package
ML20043A411 List:
References
NUDOCS 9005220046
Download: ML20043A410 (4)


See also: IR 05000528/1990014

Text

.

_ . _ _

.

. _

_ _ _ . _ _ _ _ __

. _.

7

,}I O; % I

k

o. y

.g;s,cq39yggs n.yom.Ma iOh

x

,

MAY 2 5 n

,

f

,.

a

~ Dockets No. 50-528, 50-529 and 50-530

l

'

,

ArizonaNuclearPowerProject

P.D. Box 52034

-

Phoenix,'-Arizona 85072-2034

Attention: -

Mr. William F. Conway

'

Executive Vice President

-

,

Nuclear

.

.-

j

.

a

Gentlemen:.

(

This letter refers'to an announced, special security (team inspection of your

.-

3

activities at Palo' Verde Nuclear Generating Station PVNGS) as authorized.

under NRC Licenses No. NPF-41 NPF-51', and NPF-74.

The insp,ection was

conducted by M. D. Schuster, l.. R. Norderhaug, D. W. Schaefer and A. D.

McQueen of this office on April 4, 1990, through April'30, 1990. Assisting in.

the inspection were R. .Hsu and M." Warren of the NRC Office of Nuclear Reactor

. Regulation ~and J. Cashion and J. ' Moore from the U. S. Army.

This letter also

.

- refers to the discussions-of our preliminary inspection findings held by R. A.

Scarano -Director, Division of Radiological Safety and Safeguards,-with you,

P.Caudlliandother'membersofyourstaffonApril 11, 1990.

It also-

~ documents telephone conversations with F. Larkin of your staff on April 30,_

1990..

-

Areas examined during this inspection included activities related.to physical

"

protection'as described in the enclosed inspection report. Within these

areas, the inspection consisted of selective examinations of procedures and

representative records, interviews with facility and contractor personnel, and

observations by the inspector.

..

.This special team inspection identified several observed strengths. However,

?

program weaknesses warranting management attention were also identified.

'Among the more significant weaknesses are personnel training and contingency

1

. plan implementation. . Also, it appears that certain of your activities were

'

a

not conducted in full compliance with NRC requirements, as set forth in

paragraph 2.f of the inspection report enclosed with this letter. Based uaon

u

the inspectors' review of your planned corrective actions, we have no furtier

l-

questions at this time.

In accordance with 10 CFR 2

paragraph A, a, Notice of Violation has not been issue,. Appendix C, Section-V,

y

L

d.

,

1

In accordance with'Section 2.790(d) of the NRC's " Rules of Practice," Part 2,

p

Title 10. Code of Federal Regulations, documentation of the findings of your

safeguards and security procedures are exempt from public disclosure; ic

E

!

therefore, the enclosure to this letter will not be

Document Room and will receive limited distribution.placed in the Publ

-We have determined that the enclosure to this letter so designated, contains

Safeguards Information and are subject to the controis of 10 CFR 73.21.

NCLOSUnE CoNTAINS

/_{4{LQ

  • Amunes inromnm.

SAFEGUARDS INFOm.1/i.T105

'

-

-

um srnanza ms

9oos22co46 9aosis

'

3 ncz szec m zu,,

gDR

ADock osooos2e

q

E

PDC

. . . .

.

..

..

.

.

~'

--

-

s. ..-

!

, y

.

,

,

<

_.;,~.

gzy3313))

I

-2-

,

.

,

\\

.

l

Should you have any' questions concerning this letter, we would be pleased to

discuss them with you.

E

Sincerely,

'

Robert'J.- Pate, Chief

Nuclear Material Safety and Safeguards.

Branch

.

~

.

Enclosure:

Inspection Report Nos.

50-528/90-14

4

.

50-529/90-14

,

50-530/90-14- (IE-V-921)

cc w/ enclosure:

T. R. Bradish,L ANPP

J. N. Bailey, ANPP '

'*

,

'

B. E. Ballard, Sr. , ANPP

A. Gutterman, Esq. , Newman & Holtzinger, P. C.

J. M. Levine, ANPP

W. F. Quinn, ANPP-

R. Dube, NRR

cc w/o enclosure-

0.-M. DeMichele, APS

E. C. Simpson, ANPP

R. W. Page, ANPP

..A. C. Gehr, Esq., Snell & Wilmer

,

-

.;-

e

t-

t

J.

l

.

.

.

- -

- - - - - - -

_ _

_

_ .

.

- - . _ - - . - .

... - .

. . _ .

.

..

.

- -

r, '

v*

. ,,;

_

.*

e

.

,

!

-3-

MAY 2 ; . ;y;g

- -

{

, .

^

'

bec w/enclos'ure:

'

docket file'

s

B. Faulkenberry-.

J. Martin

i

bec w/o enclosure:

G. : Cook

ProjectInspector

. Resident Inspector

ProjectManager,NRR

'

M. Smith-

,

J.-Zollicoffer

REGION V/

See E ^^

oCr

..

LNorderhaug

AMcQueen

DSchaefer

'MWarren

F MSchuster

,

05/f'/9 g

05

05g90

05/ /90

05/

/

7 90

j

YES ')/, NOi T COPY J REQUEST " Y]3

REQU.

@L92/UEST COPY ] REQUEST COPY ] T

T / NO

R MUEST COPY ]

] YES ~/ NO

] LY

NO

] YES / NO

]/

]

HWwonf90-

v

-

RPate M .

AJoh on

05/T 90

05/f

05/d/90

'

c,m

s.**

0

5

- v

)END TO PUR

'

YES) / NO

C-evc.r-fehreu/3wm"f

w J a ,e t - f g

.

e

i

.

.-

W

i

.

-.

--

m

- .

- -

.

1 MAY[89 ? W 13i23 ~

~ ~

NRC LINERICKT11

iP81 ~

~

~

~

~

^

gy

=

1,;

.

M.9$

415 943 3889

.

85/97/1990 89837- U5:Pt Region U 1RC

'415 90 3988 P.02

';c

/

~

MAY2s1933

I

bec w/ enclosure:

i

~'

docket file

8. Faulkenberry

J. Martin

,

.

.

bec w/o enclosure:-

,

G. Cook'-

-

ProjectInspector.

~

!

,

Resident Inspector

-ProjectManager,NRR

'

'i

M. with

J. Zo111 coffer

REG 10N'V/

(

.*

,

LNor,derhaug

AMcQueen '

Dschaefer

Warren

MSchuster

.

05/7/9g

05g0

05g90

05/g 90

05/-/90

'

YES'y/,NDCOPY ,

Mtyuts1

Y-[

styu

JIgutsI UDPY j/ YEA / N0M ut3T GUPY ,

-Rtquts1 corY-]

AJohn{on

. YES / ND

. 0'ED / NO

]

YES / NO~ ]

6

~

V

HWwonf90

RPate

05/Tlf90

05/

05/ /90

1:

RtQUt51 pry J RLQUE51 UUPT , MtqUtsI GUPY '

YES ///N02 ) YES / NO-

YES /- NO

,

w

.

n

.5tND 10 PDR

-

'

h

-

YES / N0 ~ !

L

~

}

  1. i:

t

!

.

e

t

!.

.

.

.

- - - - - -

-

' "~'- ~

'